She Stopped for Someone She Knew: The Disappearance of Nicole Sheridan

Missing Persons Mysteries · Aug 31, 2026 · 15m

She Stopped for Someone She Knew: The Disappearance of Nicole Sheridan

Steam curled from a paper cup of coffee left on the step rail of a running Kenworth at 5:40 AM; Nicole Sheridan’s wallet, coat, and overnight bag were inside the cab, but she was gone and her phone had pinged a tower 11 miles away just minutes after she was seen talking to a man at the fuel pumps. Who did Nicole know well enough to touch his forearm and then disappear without her coat on a January night?

In this episode, you will hear the timeline from Nicole’s last logged stop to the first discoveries at the rest area…