Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline LIVE From the WV Capitol Rotunda for Thursday, March 7, 2024
Transcript
- 0:00H Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network,
- 0:28podcasting live from the AARP location at the NCOVA Insurance Studios at the upper Rotunda
- 0:34of the State Capitol. We are underway to change the station. You are
- 0:42surrounded. Turn from the studios of w v RC Media and the Metro News
- 0:54Radio Network of Voice of West Virginia comes the most powerful radio show in West
- 1:00Virginia. For this this is Metro News Talk Live with Hoppy Kerchible. So
- 1:07it's network controls from Charleston to Morgan. Standby cue Hoppy. You're on Metro
- 1:14News talk Line with Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you by in COVID Insurance,
- 1:18encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting covid dot
- 1:23com to learn more. Good morning, Welcome Talkline on Metro News here at
- 1:26the upper roadtime to the West Virginia State Capitol, and we are day fifty
- 1:30eight, fifty nine, fifty eight fifty eight, day fifty eight of the
- 1:34session. It's scheduled to end at midnight Saturday. It may it may not,
- 1:38and that has to do with a lot of things. So today on
- 1:42the show, we have some complicated issues. I wish it were simple.
- 1:48I wish it was just like, oh, that's easy to understand. It's
- 1:49either one way or another. And it's not that way. I wish it
- 1:53were, because it'd be easier talk radio, probably be more interesting talk radio.
- 1:57But it just isn't. So I feel compelled to delve into these things
- 2:01that are in fact complicated but very relevant, like pay raises, like the
- 2:07budget, like unemployment, like also healthcare and and uh, you know,
- 2:14billing and paying an insurance for healthcare. A lot of stuff going on.
- 2:20Yeah, let me bring in. Brad Macliny has reporters brought to you by
- 2:22AARP, your rally for real Possibilities in the Mountain State. Connect on social
- 2:25media at AARP West Virginia learn more, AARP dot org, splash WV.
- 2:30Was that enough to turn everybody off or not? I mean, just like,
- 2:32oh my gosh, this is we're gonna mix in some jokes. Wow,
- 2:37that's even worse considering it's us. Brad, let's start with this.
- 2:40The Senate Finance Committee. The House has passed a budget that has pay raises
- 2:45in there for public employees, much talked about average five percent. The Senate
- 2:47Finance Committee has passed a pay raise bill, but as you right, but
- 2:52with a twist. Please explain the twist that we can all understand. Oh
- 2:55my gosh, Well, this is the fly in the ointment, as you
- 2:59mentioned, and it's day fifty eight. This is the end, beautiful friend,
- 3:05the end, God. So we got to get out of here.
- 3:07Theoretically midnight Saturday. Theoretically, the moment is upon us to pass a budget.
- 3:14That's the thing we are constitutionally obligated to do. Everyone agrees at this
- 3:21point that there are two key elements of that budget. Pay raises that the
- 3:24governor promised eight weeks ago or more five percent average pay raises for public employees.
- 3:30And then one of the governor's targets for this legislative session was to eliminate
- 3:38the remainder of the state taxes on social security benefits. The House has largely
- 3:45been on board with that and passed out a budget that includes those two elements.
- 3:49The social security aspect was a three year phase out. A little bit
- 3:53different, but you can wrap your mind around it. The Senate, now,
- 3:58particularly Senate Finance Chairman tar has has hooked first the social security tax cut
- 4:04to the trigger that's based on economic factors and sprinkles of magic dust that might
- 4:11the state might hit in August, hook that now to the Social Security elimination
- 4:17elimination, and then yesterday now has also hooked the pay raise to it.
- 4:24A four percent pay raise. I will try to simplify this for your audience
- 4:28without singing. But if if the state hits the personal income tax trigger in
- 4:34August, if the state hits it, and if the citizens of West Virginia
- 4:39you get a further personal income tax cut, then under this people in line
- 4:46for pay raises wouldn't get those pay raises. So wait, let me stop
- 4:48you there. So if a trigger is met to further reduce the state income
- 4:54tax rates, then there's no pay raise. Yep. Okay. So it's
- 5:00an if this then that okay, okay, and so But the other side
- 5:04also holds true. If the state does not hit the trigger for a personal
- 5:11income tax cut, then people in line for a pay raise would get them.
- 5:15One more little factor here, if you're keeping track on your white board
- 5:17at home, that the Senate has reduced that pay raise not five percent,
- 5:21but they've got four percent. Okay. The fly in the ointment part is
- 5:26the governor doesn't want that format. He called on the Senate yesterday to undercomplicate
- 5:30things, to quit guming up the works. And then that's not what the
- 5:34House wants either, and time is running short to try to figure this out
- 5:39and actually get this those two key elements into the budget before we leave here
- 5:44on Saturday, Brad, So, what is the rationale what's the thinking here
- 5:47that, again, if you do get the tax cut, you don't get
- 5:50the pay raise. If you don't get the tax cut, you do get
- 5:54the pay raise. What's the rationale behind that thinking? Yeah, I talked
- 5:57to Senator tar for just a moment after yesterd today's finance meeting, and his
- 6:01view is that there are financial pressures on the state that are introducing all kinds
- 6:06of uncertainty, and that that the calculations are there's only so much give on
- 6:14the money available for stuff, and that you can almost do either or you
- 6:19can you can take the next trigger and lower those personal income taxes for a
- 6:25couple hundred million dollars potentially, or you can do the pay raises or give
- 6:30the Social Security tax break. So you know, he's he's I'm envisioning a
- 6:34ceiling that he's seeing, okay, And he believes there's only so much give
- 6:39to do one or the other, to hit that trigger and dive in for
- 6:44more personal income tax reductions or do the pay raises in the Social Security break.
- 6:48Wow, So what now? I don't know. I mean I was
- 6:54mingling in the House and they are astounded. On the House side, they're
- 6:58you know, include some members of the Finance Committee who were like, what
- 7:01are they doing over there? That's not what we want to do, That's
- 7:04not what we sent them. So you know, you said if in your
- 7:08in your intro, it'll all end midnight Saturday, or you you had some
- 7:13element of doubt, and I have heard that element of doubt. You know
- 7:16that it may take may take longer than midnight to iron these things, these
- 7:21situations out. The ball is in the Senate's court right now, and I
- 7:26don't know what they do with the ball. I mean, they I suppose
- 7:29amend into the budget what they've done with the Social Security tax break and the
- 7:33pay raises, but I just don't think the House is in the mood to
- 7:39accept that at this point. So then what if the House doesn't I mean,
- 7:44if the House doesn't want to do it. It was speculated to me
- 7:47that we could be back next week, which we not make any of us
- 7:51happy. There there is already talk of a May special session, and that
- 7:57was supposed to be just to do budgets or plus items, the back of
- 8:01the budget things, and then you know the final possibility. I'm I'm understanding
- 8:07in real time. But an aspect of what Senator Tar told me was that
- 8:13this all depends on August economic calculations. And so theoretically, even in August,
- 8:22the legislature could come back and if if the target is not hit on
- 8:28the on the income tax cut, the personal income tax cut, and you
- 8:33then are proceeding with the pay raises and the Social Security tax break, right,
- 8:39you could come in even in special session at that point and backload those
- 8:45things into the budget calculations. Wow, apologies to all if I've mis explained.
- 8:48No, and your story at wv metronews dot com explains it very well.
- 8:52And we like to sit here and say, ah, it's simple raise,
- 8:56no rais, and it just isn't. But what we're telling you is
- 8:58this is what it is. And well, I think that's the political calculation,
- 9:03you know. So AARP sponsor of this location has has been pushing hard
- 9:09for that social security tax break and the governors was easy to understand, even
- 9:13the House break it into three years. You're gonn wrap your mind around that,
- 9:18but you're gonna get it. If the state hits a relatively unrelated economic
- 9:22target in August. That's tough to explain to people. Then the next level
- 9:26of explaining is, well, what is the trigger, how does that work?
- 9:30How does that work? And where do these see? I think too,
- 9:33I want to I want to fixed income. Yeah, And the next
- 9:37thing is going to be, well, wait a minute, where do these
- 9:39numbers come from? You know, what do they mean? You know,
- 9:43they're just numbers. Eh and okay, And the same thing I mean people
- 9:50are counting on the pay raise is they've been told since day one, since
- 9:52last fall, even before that, the governor said, you know we're gonna
- 9:56make up for your insurance right right, additionally insurance costs. We know that
- 10:01you're paying more for eggs and gasoline. You're doing a good job. We
- 10:05want to give you a pay raise. That was all part of a State
- 10:07of the State speech. The House has done it, and now it depends
- 10:13on day fifty eight. It depends on the trigger. It's tough for I
- 10:18think it's tough for lawmakers who are every member of the House of Delegates except
- 10:24for those opting out of running again. They're on the ballot in May,
- 10:26and they're going to take the pay raise issue back to their voters and say
- 10:31you might get one, you might not. That's a heck of a campaign,
- 10:33Brad mclhenny, and there are other things, but I got to move
- 10:37on. We're going to touch on these other things during the show. Brad
- 10:39macklinney Metro New State White correspond it. If you're confused, join the club.
- 10:45That's very rational. Yeah, but it is, Brad. Your story
- 10:48at we Metro news dot com does a good job of explaining it. And
- 10:52now we still have this process to go to for the next couple of days.
- 10:54Best of luck to all of us. Good job, Thank you,
- 10:56Brad. When we come back on Metro News talk Line, I'm sorry,
- 11:00another complicated story, but a story that has the potential to effect tens of
- 11:03thousands, hundreds of thousands of West Virginia individuals and businesses concerning a bill that
- 11:11hasn't been talked about that much. When Talkloin continues from the AARP broadcast location.
- 11:16Right after this, Metro News talkline with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to you
- 11:28by Encovia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what do you care about
- 11:33most? Visiting Coca dot com to learn more. Batter being Code Insurance Studios
- 11:37at the AARP broadcast location, Upper Rotunda the Capital, Jeff Jenkins tells me
- 11:43breaking news, as they say in the industry. The governors just issued a
- 11:46proclamation to extend the session into a March tenths to work on the budget only,
- 11:52so that tells you they don't have agreement on the budget and they're going
- 11:54to need a couple extra days to try to work it out. And the
- 11:58pay raise is tied into all that text. Hoppy, the only thing I'm
- 12:03hearing is my PI rates are going up, and neither pay raise nor tax
- 12:07cut will cover the rays increase. Also, I'll get less from the tax
- 12:11cut than a pay raise. What can we expect when we elect clowns and
- 12:13the circus ensues? Not happy, folks. Brian Dayton joins us from the
- 12:18West Virginia Chamber of Commerce. Brian, good see, how are you?
- 12:20I'm great, Hoppy. It's a day fifty eight two more to go,
- 12:24and well apparently just a little bit more, as we just found out,
- 12:26and they can extend a session just to work on the budget. So there's
- 12:28that. So let's go to another complicated story. And I don't think the
- 12:33story has been written about and talked about, but not as much as I
- 12:35think it deserves. Because this is something that potentially affects literally hundreds of thousands
- 12:41of West Virginians and tens of thousands of businesses. Has to do with unemployment
- 12:45West Virginia. Let me just run through this right now. Laid off workers
- 12:48can qualify from up to twenty six weeks of unemployment at a rate of fifty
- 12:52five percent of their average weekly wage, a microphone benefit of seventeen thousand dollars.
- 12:58There's a bill that passed the same and now under consideration in the House
- 13:01Amendment station today, it would change from twenty six weeks to twenty four weeks.
- 13:05Also, under the bill, benefits would be scaled from a high of
- 13:09seventy percent of the average weekly wage in the first four weeks and then declining
- 13:13by five percentage points every four weeks down to a low of forty five percent
- 13:16in the final weeks. With the macro from benefit of fourteen thousand dollars,
- 13:20so a little bit less money current on the employer's self. Currently, employers
- 13:26are taxed at ninety five hundred of employee wages. The bill would cap that
- 13:30taxable amount to ten thousand dollars. So yesterday we heard from a labor perspective,
- 13:35a business perspective from Brian Dayton. Brian, this is complicated, but
- 13:39is very relevant to employers and employees generally. Do you all think this is
- 13:43a good bill? So hoppy, this is an important bill, And let
- 13:46me give a little bit of backstory, I think to just help people understand
- 13:50what is basically going on. And back in two thousand and nine, as
- 13:54we hit the Great Recession, the deal was struck on unemployment and it set
- 13:58the wage base at twelve one thousand dollars. Just to describe that, that
- 14:01means every employer in the state will play pay unemployment taxes on the first twelve
- 14:07thousand dollars of every employee's wage, and it froze those weekly benefits for people
- 14:11receiving unemployment and that was frozen until the unemployment Compensation Fund hit two hundred and
- 14:16twenty million dollars. Well with the influx of COVID cash a couple of years
- 14:20ago. We have gone past it. We're now at about three hundred and
- 14:24eighty million dollars. So what it did is it lowered the wage base to
- 14:28nine thousand, and it unlocked the benefits basically for people. It will allow
- 14:33higher wage categories to be added in, but it's now untethered and so we've
- 14:37with the inflation going on right now, the adjustments are being made based on
- 14:43the average annual wage, So we have a bit of a runaway freight train
- 14:46if we do nothing. What employers are looking for is that right now they're
- 14:50paying about nine thousand, five hundred and twenty one dollars on a wage base,
- 14:54and it is projected to go to roughly ten thousand, five hundred or
- 14:56ten thousand, six hundred next year, more beyond that, likely beyond that
- 15:01the next year. That's really problematic. Not so much for big businesses they
- 15:05can absorb that more, but for your smaller business. Okay, so there's
- 15:09about one hundred and ten thousand smaller businesses in West Virginia. So you're saying
- 15:11that your members and other businesses are concerned. They have to pay. Everybody
- 15:16has to pay the tax the unemployment tax, and right now they're taxed on
- 15:20the first ninety five hundred dollars of the wages, and they're worried under the
- 15:22current law that that amount will continue to rise, therefore their cost paying an
- 15:28unemployment will continue to rise. Is that what you're saying? Yes, And
- 15:31again I want to drive home this. If you're a larger business, then
- 15:35you're you're paying people, you know, ninety thousand, one hundred thousand dollars,
- 15:37that's a much smaller percentage of their total wages you're paying that tax on.
- 15:41If you're a small business where you're maybe paying your employees twenty thirty thousand
- 15:45dollars part time, that's a much higher percentage. So it is really a
- 15:50problem, especially for your smaller businesses. And another thing I want to point
- 15:52out, three hundred and eighty million dollars in the unemployment fund is a ton
- 15:58of money. That is a very healthy fund. We believe that's way more
- 16:02than is necessary. And I think even the estimates are that at about ten
- 16:07percent unemployment, which we haven't seen ten percent uneployment for a long time,
- 16:10it would take ninety one weeks to deplete that fund. So it's very,
- 16:12very healthy. Our concern is allowing that wage base to continue going up.
- 16:18This bill would lock it in at ten thousand dollars. Now, we could
- 16:21argue could be a little bit lower, but this bill at least locks it
- 16:23and would prevent it from continuing to climb. Brian Dayton's with this Chamber of
- 16:26Commerce. But labors are arguing, among other things, they're saying, look
- 16:30as wages go up, As wages go up and costs go up, why
- 16:36shouldn't the benefit go up and accompany that? Because look, if the amount
- 16:41they receive a unemployment stays the same, but it cost more to go to
- 16:44the grocery store and buy gas and pay mortgage all those things, and why
- 16:47shouldn't the benefit go up? Isn't that a reasonable argument? Well, what
- 16:51I would say to that is that there's a good reason that we come back
- 16:53every sixty or every year for six or six days to have a legislative session.
- 16:57You can make those adjustments as anstiscessaries. So there would be nothing that
- 17:00would preclude next year's legislature or the one after that from reopening the statute and
- 17:04making adjustments as appropriate. Right now, we're like, again, it's a
- 17:10runaway freight train that we've got. What I would also point out though,
- 17:12under this bill, the first four weeks of benefits you're at seventy percent compared
- 17:18to fifty five. Now, if you were on unemployment for sixteen weeks,
- 17:22under this bill, you are going to be ahead of where you would be
- 17:25under the current law up until fifty three thousand dollars. So that's one thing
- 17:30we see as a positive. It would also allow people to work part time
- 17:33up until their weekly benefit without losing those benefits. That is, by the
- 17:37way, that's a great point. That's a great point is that is that
- 17:40because right now you cannot get you can you can't be on part time employment
- 17:44because you would lose your benefit. But there is a provision of the build
- 17:47that says you could work part time and make as much as you would getting
- 17:52unemployment and still get unemployment without losing it, without losing unaplotment. That is
- 17:55a good provision, and so that's something that we think that's been put in
- 17:57there. That's a good And most people are off unemployment in the first eleven
- 18:03twelve weeks, I mean that's about the average people go on and then they're
- 18:06coming back off. So all in all, I mean, would you know,
- 18:10we don't have a magic one. There may be some things we do
- 18:11slightly differently, but all in all, I think what the Senate has put
- 18:14forth is a plan that would really protect massive tax increases going forward on smaller
- 18:19businesses and something that would be airworkable for those receiving unemployment medics right sixty seconds
- 18:26and you and I and I talked to the labor guys yesterday. We spent
- 18:27a lot of time yesterday just trying to understand this bill, and I wrote
- 18:32about it. You have legislators who are looking at hundreds of bills, and
- 18:36you've been around for a while. In all candor, do you think that
- 18:38people who are going to vote on this bill understand the ramifications of this bill,
- 18:44can foresee the unintended consequences of this bill? Do they know what they're
- 18:48voting on? Well, that's a great point. This is a very convoluted
- 18:53and complex issue. And so that's why I think you have both sides or
- 18:56educating people right now to try to get them the under standing of this is
- 19:00what was the current law is, this is what the new law would be.
- 19:03But again, the benefit of the way we do things in West Virginia
- 19:07is next year we're going to be back for sixty days, and the next
- 19:10year after that we'll be back for sixty days. So there's always that ability
- 19:14to come in and make tweaks as necessary. It's one of the great things
- 19:17about this process. Some would say great, some would say what use other
- 19:22words? But it depends on how you feel near the end of it.
- 19:23Yeah, I understand this, all right. I did write about this today
- 19:26and got a lot of facts from the labor side, from the chamber side,
- 19:30and so you can learn more today at wv metro news dot com and
- 19:33by commentary Brian Daton, Vice President, Chamber of Commerce. Brian's good to
- 19:37see you. Thank you to sing too, all right, thank you.
- 19:38We'll take a break and come back on Metro News talk Line. When we
- 19:41come back, we'll get reaction from an education leader on this where things are
- 19:47with pay raises. This is talklent on Metro News, the Voice of West
- 19:49Virginia. All righty bodcasting Lave from the COVA Insurance studios at the AARP Broadcast
- 20:07location. You know the weather, it wasn't like it. Yesterday's nasty yesterday,
- 20:11but before you know what, the weather's going to be Nice's gonna be
- 20:12time to get outside. And if you're interested in boating this summer, then
- 20:17you need to shop now because by the time you start thinking about it,
- 20:19when it's seventy five or eighty degrees, it's going to be too late because
- 20:23the supply is going to be picked over. So it's a good time to
- 20:26check out. The boat's available at lou Window Marine Sales lou Windol Marine.
- 20:30Check them out. Check their inventory out at lou Windowmarine sales dot com.
- 20:34They have the best in pontoon boating and after this session, everybody could use
- 20:41a nice cruise on a pontoon boat, including this gentleman. Food Albert,
- 20:45president of AFT West Virginia. Morning foot, how are you sorry? Good
- 20:47morning, Hoppy. I'm well, how are you doing? And see you're
- 20:48relaxing on a pontoon boat right now, Like, oh my god, that
- 20:52sounds really nice. What do you think of the pay raise proposal that's come
- 20:56out that's moving in the Senate? Well, Hoppy, I'm glad you're asked
- 21:00that question, because actually, you know, we hear this legislative body speak
- 21:03all the time about stabilizing our companies in West Virginia. Our businesses, and
- 21:10we're all for that. We need to stabilize our workforce within the teaching ranks,
- 21:15and our service personnel, our public employees, our troopers, they need
- 21:18to be stabilized also. And to be honest with you, I like much
- 21:23better and our members like much better the House bills. It was House Bill
- 21:27forty seven sixty seven and House Bill forty two oh two that gave better,
- 21:33bigger pay raises. And I think that we're facing a situation here where we
- 21:38have over seventeen hundred vacancies in our teaching ranks. We've got to do something,
- 21:44and what has been proposed now in the Senate bill, I don't think
- 21:48reaches the point that we need to reach to stabilize our teaching for US.
- 21:53Fred alberts With is president of AFT West Virginia, and what does your take.
- 21:57Obviously don't you like the House version, which is an average five percent
- 22:02across the board. Teacher service workers, state workers would also get a five
- 22:06percent. But as we talked about earlier, this Senate bill is tied to
- 22:10a trigger and the short version is and that has to do with revenue collections
- 22:15in the state. And the short version is that if there is enough for
- 22:19a tax. If there's enough, if the trigger is met for the reduction
- 22:23in income tax rates, there would be no raise, that's right. But
- 22:27if the state does not reach the trigger amount for the income tax rate reduction,
- 22:33then you would get a raise, right, but we won't know that
- 22:36until August the fifteenth. From what I heard yesterday in Senate Finance, that
- 22:40decision won't be made until August of fifteenth by the Secretary of Revenue or the
- 22:45Secretary of Commerce. So that presents another problem. If there is not a
- 22:51reduction in the income tax personal income tax, then the pay a four percent
- 22:56pay raise would be granted to public employees, teachers, service personnel, troopers.
- 23:02But so that's not what the governor recommended in his State of the State
- 23:07address. The House versions the House bills were higher than a five percent.
- 23:12It was almost a five thousand dollars pay increase for our teachers and about a
- 23:17sixty seven hundred dollars pay increase for our service personnel. That's much needed,
- 23:22but on the Senate bill, So from what I heard yesterday in Centate finance,
- 23:27we wouldn't know that until August fifteenth. If there would be a four
- 23:30percent pay raise granted, then it would be retroactive to July one. That's
- 23:36going to create a real problem for the payroll departments of our schools and other
- 23:41payroll departments to go back and figure that out. How do you how do
- 23:45you explain this to members? I mean, how do you explain to people
- 23:48like, well, if this, then this, but if not this,
- 23:49then that. But it's very confusing. Here's the other thing we all would
- 23:55like. I think we all would like a reduction in our personal income tax.
- 24:00But when and Senator Oliverio spoke to this and Senate Education and Senate Financisity
- 24:06for our school employees, what would that mean? Compare that to a pay
- 24:11raise that would be about what was promised or what was suggested by the governor
- 24:17a five percent pay raise. You're talking about a couple of hundred dollars to
- 24:21a couple of thousand dollars difference. So you know, does this move the
- 24:25needle? Does this stabilize our teachers? So you're saying the teachers, the
- 24:30staff, state workers who would put a pencil to it, would say they're
- 24:34going to look at it and go, okay, an income tax reduction of
- 24:37whatever percent, maybe up to ten percent on the rates, and they're gonna
- 24:41do the math and awaitment. I say this much, right, but that's
- 24:45not nearly And I got Pia right, but that's not ten and a half
- 24:48percent next so that's not as much as well what a pay raise would be.
- 24:53That's exactly right. Now. Who will benefit from that from a personal
- 24:57income tax reduction? Those who may a lot more money so well, they
- 25:02pay a higher rate too, well, so they do, of course,
- 25:03But you know, it's just it's very troubling when we talked about and here
- 25:08we are two days left after today in this session and the pay raised bill
- 25:14is still out there. By the way, the governor did announce that they're
- 25:17extending the session next week to work on the budget. He just announced that.
- 25:19Okay, so three extra days next week to work on the budget and
- 25:22the budget. Let me ask you why you hear about a couple of other
- 25:26things, sure, and that is it looks like what we called what Jeff
- 25:30Jenko's called the travel bill is dead. And that's the bill that would have
- 25:33allowed high school athletes to participate in travel on travel teams. At the same
- 25:38time, looks like that's dead. What's your reaction to that? Well,
- 25:41I haven't heard a lot about that. I do know that there were you
- 25:45know, we have members on both sides of that. That was not something
- 25:49that we were in the battle for or against. So Okay, I'm sure
- 25:55we'll come back at some point. Yeah, it probably will. Student Discipline
- 25:59bill was moving in the House. This is a bill that came out of
- 26:00the Senate. Is that according to Senator Amy Grady, who pushed this bill
- 26:06Chair of Senate ed she says, look, this further empowers teachers to deal
- 26:10with discipline problems in the elementary school level. That looks like that's moving.
- 26:15Do you think that'll make a difference. I think it will, you know,
- 26:17I know, and we have people on both sides of that. I've
- 26:19been contacted all week long, all morning long, not so much by my
- 26:23members but by other people who feel that this is maybe not what we want.
- 26:29But we have been asking for some help because there is a problem in
- 26:33our elementary schools that we've never seen before. So we do need help.
- 26:38Is this the perfect answer. Probably not. It needs to be looked at
- 26:44and tweaked, but it's a start. Our members do need help in the
- 26:48classroom with discipline, with discipline issues that we've never seen before. We need
- 26:53help with more school counselors with we need to help these students. I don't
- 26:59think the answer is just suspension, and that's the fear. I think that
- 27:03we will continue traveling down a path where we suspend low socio economic students more
- 27:10than other students. So that that's something that needs to be looked at.
- 27:12Well, some look, some kids just cannot be in the classroom. I
- 27:17agree. But also if you just as a disciplinary matter, if you just
- 27:21suspend a student, he or she just gets farther behind and guess what exactly
- 27:25and where are you suspending them to to to you know, is it an
- 27:27unsafe situation at home or on the street, So that we need to find
- 27:33help. We need to find a way to change behaviors. Fred Albert,
- 27:37President of AFT West Virginia. Thank you, Fred, Thank you Hart.
- 27:38It's always good to see you. Thank you, good to see you.
- 27:41Talk like continues will return to the ARP broadcast location in just a minute.
- 27:48At WU Medicine Children's we know that orthopedic care for growing children is different than
- 27:53adults. Trust their team for the most advanced care for injuries and conditions affecting
- 27:59your child's muscles, pans and joints. Visit WU kids dot com WU kids
- 28:03dot com. We'll be right back on Talklientes. Stay with us. Metronews.
- 28:15Talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to you by Incovia Insurance, encircling
- 28:19you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit in Covia dot
- 28:25com to learn more. Talk line from the Incova Insurance studios at the ARP
- 28:30broadcast location here at the state Capitol. Let's go to Jeff Jenkins in the
- 28:34Metro News newsroom. Governor Justice has addressed a couple of these issues, particularly
- 28:40concerning the budget and the pay raise. Jeff, what's the governor saying about
- 28:42all this? And as you had the breaking news too, the governor's extending
- 28:45the session to work on the budget. So god, yeah, well,
- 28:48let me get you straight on that, Hoby, because because that's not as
- 28:52a big deal as it might appear. Okay, the governor is constitutionally required
- 28:57if there's no budget within the final three days of the session, if they
- 29:00haven't passed the budget, to extend it one day. And that's what he
- 29:03did. Does this every year, This is done every year. Okay,
- 29:07Now, could the governor further extend it for three days or up to a
- 29:11week like used to happen routinely when the Democrats were in charge. They would
- 29:15do that every year. They would extend a week see how bills passed,
- 29:18impacted the budget, then passed the budget the following Sunday. He could do
- 29:22that, but what he has the proclamation that was read this morning in the
- 29:26House floor session to begin the House floor session is something that's done every year.
- 29:32If they don't, so the intent I think is still to finish a
- 29:34budget by midnight Saturday night. But as you and Brad spoke, I mean
- 29:38that may not happen, and so they they indeed may heame after further extend
- 29:42it. So I think that remains to be seen. Okay, all right,
- 29:45good point. I appreciate that. Now go to some of the governor's
- 29:48comments about the budget, and again the big issue here is the pay raise.
- 29:52Okay, So I think you know this is what the governor said this
- 29:56yesterday during his briefing. I think this is pretty telling because I think he's
- 30:00responding just like some of us are responding, saying the trigger. Okay,
- 30:03what does that mean? And so here's what he had to say, I
- 30:07hope the Senate, I hope they they can some way, somehow get through
- 30:11this, all this muckety muck and and and and making things just so complicated
- 30:18and so difficult and everything, and just absolutely get on board with uh,
- 30:25with what I presented, and and and with what the House is doing,
- 30:27and and we can, uh, we can move on and and really help
- 30:33a bunch of folks in West Virginia. How do you describe muckety muck,
- 30:37muckety muck. That's one way to say it. Yeah, And then he
- 30:45further he made further comment and and brought in Okay, well, let's just
- 30:51hear what he says, because he kind of leans toward okay, well,
- 30:53maybe they will have to come back in May and finish this all up.
- 30:57And he almost sounds like he'd be open to it if that's what they want
- 31:00to do. I think everybody wants to kind of lay the stuff aside,
- 31:04come back in May. You know, see where we're really staying. I
- 31:08mean, I think I know where we're going to stand and and everything.
- 31:11But if if we want to come back in May with one time dollars,
- 31:15with surplus dollars, and I guess that'll be fine. Okay, so okay,
- 31:23okay, so you know, but but then but that that still wouldn't
- 31:29that's still want to answer the trigger question, quite honestly, because that when
- 31:33we want to know, we wouldn't know that until August. Right, you're
- 31:36right. So so, I mean the legislature has to pass the budget,
- 31:40and they have to do it by June thirtieth. I mean they don't have
- 31:42to I mean right, I mean that's when they have to do it.
- 31:45Remember, just when Justice first got into office, they didn't get a budget
- 31:48passed in his first session. Remember that's right, that's right. He took
- 31:52a while to it took a while to get it to get that done.
- 31:56Look, so the governor wants the average five percent pay raise. It might
- 32:01even be a little bit more net once what the House did. The House
- 32:05is on board pretty much. The Senate is not. The Senate has a
- 32:08different approach and led by a Center financi committee, Sirman Eric tar and I
- 32:12believe that the Center president is with him on this, said, well,
- 32:15we got to watch out about the state's finances, and what we really want
- 32:16to do is is, you know, lower income tax rates for West Virginians,
- 32:22and that can only be done if you meet a certain financial threshold.
- 32:24But if you do that, if you meet the financial threshold and there's an
- 32:28income tax free reduction, then that means less revenue coming into the state and
- 32:31there might not be enough money for a pay raise. So that that's why,
- 32:36in my opinion, Jeff helped me. If I'm wrong, that's why
- 32:39the Senate is saying. Senate leadership is saying, if you do if you
- 32:45do get a tax cut, that means there's less revenue coming in, so
- 32:47we can't afford this pay raise. But if there's not an if you don't
- 32:52meet a threshold and there's not a reduction in income tax collections, then there
- 32:58would be enough money for a pay raise. How about that? Yeah,
- 33:00And I think there's there's different thoughts on the on the federal money for you
- 33:07know, from education, because the Governor's office, you know, the Governor's
- 33:10office believes that you know, we're taking care of this, we're talking to
- 33:14the federal government, we're doing these other spending things. It shows in good
- 33:16faith and we're going to get a waiver. But the Senate, which which
- 33:21isn't you know, Eric Tarr isn't keen on spending a lot of money anyway.
- 33:24And I'm not I'm not saying this is convenient for him. I'm not
- 33:28saying that at all, but it kind of plays into his scenario. Yeah,
- 33:31well we gotta you know, we've got to be more to watch out,
- 33:35you got to watch out more conservative. We don't know what the federal
- 33:37want to accept this, We don't know, so that kind of plays into
- 33:40what his approach actually has been for the entire session. Yeah, let's let
- 33:45me skip over to the Jimmy Wriston story. Everybody knows that. So what's
- 33:49he saying about what's the latest on the Jimmy Riston situation. Well, the
- 33:52governor saying what we've kind of been saying. And after we got that,
- 33:57you know, the latest information from Charleston police, you know last week that
- 34:01they were actually that there's this investigation is on going into the emergency call itself,
- 34:07uh, and information is going to be turned over to Kannak County prosecutors.
- 34:10And now they kind of even urged prosecutors to charge the person who called
- 34:15in, you know, called in the information that that said that Ristin was
- 34:19driving, said this driver on Charston's de sm was driving erratically. Charleston police
- 34:22say they've seen video and they don't see no evidence of driving erradically. Uh.
- 34:28And so the governor just came out yesterday and said, you know,
- 34:30kind of what we reported last week, that he does think this is a
- 34:34setup. He don't know why, but believes it's the setup. They're just
- 34:37there are just some folks out there that are doing things you know that you
- 34:40know or have have different vendettas and everything, that are doing stuff to people
- 34:45that just didn't faire in a lot of ways. Yeah, and then he
- 34:50went on he went on to say that he believes that Jimmy Ristin, you
- 34:52know, that Jimmy Ristin was set up for whatever reason. There are certain
- 34:58things that have happened here that nobody discerners and and that's why the disappointment is
- 35:05is huge on my side. So let's just see how all of the fans
- 35:08out. Okay, So we're still waiting for the for the Charlestal Police to
- 35:14come out and say or conclude their investigation about who set up Riston and why.
- 35:19I mean, there's been a name out there about an individual who called
- 35:21in what apparently was a false report about him driving radically. That's one thing.
- 35:24But again there's also been confirmation Jeff, that that Ristin had at some
- 35:29point consumed alcohol, but the breathalyzer test was inconclusive or did not show him
- 35:35impaired. Is that correct? And and he passed to phill sobriety tests right
- 35:38right, yeah, And he passed to fill sobriety tests, and they they
- 35:43you know, they let him go to They're still looking into officers' actions,
- 35:45especially with the use of body cam. Bodycam policies were followed, but I
- 35:52think the focus is also going to be on this this possible criminal investigator or
- 35:57this possible what Knaw County prosecutors may do. All right, Jeff Jenkins,
- 36:00Thanks. Talk Line continues. We'll be right back. Talk Line from the
- 36:21AARP broadcast location of the en COVID Insurance studios here at the upper rotunda of
- 36:25the state Capitol. Text hopy, the governor calling the budget muckety muck leads
- 36:30me to believe he does not understand just how truly complicated a government budget is.
- 36:34A last the surprise on the four hundred and sixty five million dollar match
- 36:37the rule we've known about for the last two years, but This man is
- 36:42a businessman who can't pay his bills, says the texture. By the way,
- 36:45someone asked this morning, what's up with the helicopter repossession? Is that
- 36:50right? Repo? Don't know, don't know about that. We'll check.
- 36:53Not sure if we'd be in a court filings, but we'll see if we
- 36:57can find out. Right now, pretty busy with the legislatives. Back in
- 37:00six minutes. This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West
- 37:02Virginia. Ready, welcome back, hour number two talk Line on the Metro
- 37:32News radio network all across the great state of West Virginia. Broadcasting from the
- 37:37AARP broadcast location, the encolp Insurance Studios in the upper rotunda of the State
- 37:43Capitol. Let's talk vaccinations, and right now, vaccinations are required for our
- 37:50public school students in West Virginia and for our school students in West Virginia,
- 37:53whole battery of vaccinations. There are There is a to exempt for a medical
- 38:02justification. It's pretty narrow, but there is a way. But the House
- 38:07has passed a bill. Just give me a minute here to explain this.
- 38:09The House passed a bill that would expand the exemptions for children to those enrolled
- 38:17in virtual public schools and also private and parochial schools could set their own standards
- 38:25for the vaccinations. And the way the bill passed the House, it would
- 38:29also allow for parents to opt out of vaccinations for their children citing a religious
- 38:35objection. It didn't get more specific in that just said religious objection. The
- 38:38bill was taken up and sentate Health yesterday and they took out that provision of
- 38:44religious objection, which was very broad and would have greatly expanded and the number
- 38:49of parents who could opt out of those vaccinations for their children. So right
- 38:53now, the way the bill stands, it provides for exemptions for children enrolled
- 38:57in virtual public schools. It in parochial schools can set their own standards for
- 39:02these vaccinations. Joining us on Metro News talk Line is doctor Lisa Costello,
- 39:07a pediatric hospitalist in Morgantown, past president West Virginia State Medical Association in the
- 39:14West Virginia Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics. She joins us by phone
- 39:19on Metro News Talkline. Doctor, good morning, thank you for joining us.
- 39:22Let me start with this. I think I covered part of it,
- 39:24but what are the rules now for school immunizations. Well, thank you so
- 39:30much, Hope for having me. And right now, West Virginia is a
- 39:35national leader when it comes to routine childhood immunizations, and that we have the
- 39:39gold standard, evidence based policy set forth by the American Academy of Pediatrics,
- 39:45and that we only allow medical exemptions as a condition for school entry when it
- 39:51comes to our immunization requirements. So, right now, West Virginia is a
- 39:54leader. We have been. This policy has been in place for decades and
- 40:00as a result, we're seen as a national leader when it comes to routine
- 40:02childhood immunizations by only allowing medical exemptions as a condition for school entry. Doctor
- 40:08Costello, how concerned are you with the bill that passed the Senate Health Committee
- 40:15yesterday? And we'll go to the floor, given that they took out that
- 40:19broad religious exemption. Happy, I'm still very concerned, both as a pediatrician
- 40:23and I was on your program a few years ago. I was pregnant with
- 40:27my first child. I'm happy to report she's a healthy two year old and
- 40:30she's about to start Catholics pre K this fall, and so both as a
- 40:36pediatrician and a mom, I'm very concerned about this bill. Currently even in
- 40:43the amended version, because removing immunization requirements for students in private and parochial schools,
- 40:50and you know, we would not know what the schools would require if
- 40:54they opt out, we're really placing at risk those children and our larger community
- 41:01because we know when immunization rates fall in a community, it increases the risk
- 41:07not only for that child, but for those around us, so the elderly,
- 41:13pregnant people, individuals with weakened immune system. This is why it's really
- 41:17important to keep the immunization rates high so that we can keep diseases out of
- 41:22our communities. And we've been successful with that in West Virginia. Every surrounding
- 41:27state right now is seeing an outbreak of measles. We've yet to have a
- 41:30case in West Virginia. We haven't had a case of measles in West Virginia
- 41:34since two thousand and nine, and a lot of that is because of the
- 41:37strong policies we had. If this bill makes it across the finish line and
- 41:42we remove those requirements or allow private and parochial schools to opt out, and
- 41:49we would anticipate that some would that is going to lead to a decrease in
- 41:52our immunization rates and measles does not care hoppy if you go to private or
- 41:58public school. It's that's a virus that's going to come into our communities and
- 42:01doesn't matter if it's a private or public school. And as a pediatrician and
- 42:06a parent of a child who's about to start a parochial school, I think
- 42:09our private and parochial school children deserve the protections that the public school children would
- 42:15receive as well. And that's why we're concerned about this bill. Doctor Costello
- 42:21is with us. She's a pediatric hospitalistic Morgantown, past president West Virginia State
- 42:24Medical Association. Doctor, I would imagine that you have conversations all the time
- 42:30with parents about their children's health. And I would imagine, again I'm making
- 42:35some of this up, but I imagine that in those conversations and many times
- 42:38where you present the information to the parents and say to them, you have
- 42:43some decisions you have to make here. You're the parents. I want to
- 42:45give you the best information now. Correct. First of all, correct me
- 42:49if I'm wrong about that, and second of all, if I'm not wrong,
- 42:52Why wouldn't you want parents to be able to make some of these decisions?
- 42:55About vaccinations like they make about other medical procedures. Hoppy. I have
- 43:00conversations with parents all the time, both in my professional setting and then you
- 43:06know, parents talk amongst ourselves and discuss decisions that we're making for our children,
- 43:10whether it's Hey, what carcie do you use? You know, what
- 43:15sound machine did you like the best? And so there are certain lead decisions
- 43:20that people make every day, and as a parent myself, I appreciate that
- 43:23and the decisions that are made in the context of that loved one and why
- 43:29you're making that decision. When it comes to routine childhood immunization, I encourage
- 43:32parents to reach out to their healthcare provider to get the facts. There's a
- 43:37lot of misinformation and disinformation out there when it comes to routine childhood immunization.
- 43:43So talk it over with your healthcare provider and know that the decision that you're
- 43:49making not only impacts your child, but also those around you. And we
- 43:53have seen through years of study, hundreds of evidence based, peer reviewed clinical
- 44:01trials that immunizations are safe, they're effective, and they save lives. So
- 44:07we want to have those conversations with parents and give them the information that they
- 44:10need and help them make a decision that's best for their child and know that
- 44:15the decision they're making also impacts those around them. That's why when it comes
- 44:20to our school immunization requirements, I'm proud that the Democratic and Republican leadership over
- 44:27the past twenty years have kept this policy strong because they're saying, in a
- 44:31school setting where we're going to be around other children, the government had said
- 44:37we're going to keep kids as safe as possible by keeping our school immunization policy
- 44:42strong. This bill puts that in jeopardy. Doctor Gosseeloz again, the religious
- 44:46exemption has been taken out, I think, and maybe alluded to it earlier.
- 44:51I think West Virginia might be only one of only five states that does
- 44:54not allow for some form of religious exemption. So does that make us an
- 45:00outlier with so many other states? Happy that makes us a leader, and
- 45:06as a West Virginia I'm proud to say when we can be on top and
- 45:08when we can lead, I think you wrote about it recently. Usually,
- 45:12West Virginia is unfortunately not at the top when it comes to many health statistics.
- 45:16When it comes to routine childhood immunization, we've been seen as a leader,
- 45:21and for a long time, even a decade ago, there were only
- 45:23two states that had a strong policy like ours. So we've actually seen more
- 45:28states become more like West Virginia and follow our lead than the other way.
- 45:34If this bill makes it across the finish line, unfortunately, West Virginia is
- 45:37no longer going to be seen as a leader when it comes to our immunization
- 45:42policy, and we're really going to be placing our children and our community at
- 45:46risk. Doctor Lisa Costello, pediatric hospitalist in Morgantown, past President West Virginia
- 45:52State Medical Association in the West Virginia Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics.
- 45:58On this vaccination bill passed the House, got changed in the Senate, and
- 46:01now is up consideration in the Senate. Doctor, good to speak with you
- 46:05again. Thank you for coming on. I appreciate it. Thank you so
- 46:07much. Happy oh R you take good care. Text three or four Talks
- 46:09three or four Hoppy. Even if Jimmy Riston was set up, he was
- 46:14still drinking and driving a staged vehicle. Doesn't really matter how you got caught,
- 46:17just asked Bob Huggins. He consumed alcohol still drove a stage vehicle,
- 46:22yeah, there is a code. Not maybe not a code. Maybe it's
- 46:25just a rule that you cannot consume alcohol and drive a stage vehicle. There,
- 46:34from what we know in the investigation, he had consumed alcohol, but
- 46:36he he passed the sobriety checks. So I don't know how that fits together,
- 46:43right, I mean, okay, so you're not supposed to consume alcohol,
- 46:45but you did at some point, but you passed the sobriety checkpoint not
- 46:50checkpoint. You passed the sobriety test, so you weren't legally intoxicated. So
- 46:54that is another one of these unresolved issues on that story. Text copy,
- 47:01all these blue collar workers getting the shaft by the people. The Republicans they
- 47:07elected will continue to vote Republican. Why do working people vote against their own
- 47:10interests? Ask the texture Let's see three O four talk three O four.
- 47:17Trying to catch up on a lot of texts here, Happy call it what
- 47:22it is. Senator tar hates Governor Justice and is willing to tank the state
- 47:25budget just to be a thorn in justice aside, says the texture Happy.
- 47:32I'm pretty sure the state vehicle handbook says you cannot drink and drive. That
- 47:36is true. It does say that I even have the code section here somewhere.
- 47:45I respect teachers for having the patients to care for kids daily. However,
- 47:47they need to realize that it's a job like everyone else has a job,
- 47:51and they need to pay for their benefits like everyone else does, whether
- 47:54it's a minimum wage job or a high paying job. We all pay for
- 47:59our benefits, but not all of us get a summer break, spring break,
- 48:01Christmas break, all holidays off in seven hour days. Teachers, be
- 48:06fair to everyone. Pay your share for what you get, says the texture.
- 48:08We'll continue. Talk line resumes from the AARP broadcast location at the Capitol
- 48:14right after This Metro News talkline with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by Encovia
- 48:29Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what do you care about most?
- 48:32Visiting Covia dot com to learn more. Facting COVID Church Studios at the AARP
- 48:38broadcast location at the upper Rotunda of the State Capitol. State of the Union,
- 48:42addressed tonight by President Joe Biden and for John Decker with Gray Television and
- 48:47you see him in West Virginia on WSAZWTAPWDTV and WVVA for John Dekrombe's twenty second,
- 48:55twenty third, twenty fourth State of the Union. What, Johnny,
- 49:00So you short changed me there, Hobby. I'm sorry, so excited.
- 49:05Always a thrill, always a privilege to be in the House Chamber. The
- 49:09State of Union address an annual ritual for me and obviously a ritual for our
- 49:15country. And it's a big speech for President Biden in that this is an
- 49:19opportunity for him to have his largest audience, likely of the entire campaign,
- 49:23nationally televised nine pm Eastern Time, and it's an opportunity to reach out to
- 49:30his own dem you know who wins the twenty twenty or presidential election. Yeah,
- 49:37we have a bad connection. I hope it improves. If not,
- 49:40we'll reconnect John before I get to the speech tonight. Again, all these
- 49:45State of the Union speeches you've covered, they can probably run together. But
- 49:49do any does what stands out to you? Give me one or two instances
- 49:53where a State of the Union really stood out to you. Well, there
- 49:58are a fews. Certainly, the State the Union address that President George W.
- 50:01Bush delivered following nine to eleven sticks out to me first and foremost,
- 50:07because the country believe it or not was actually unified at that time, unified
- 50:10in a purpose in terms of turning back terrorism and then other State of Union
- 50:16addresses also stick out in my mind, and that's when presidents have delivered them
- 50:21as they were going through the process of impeachment. So Bill Clinton had to
- 50:24do that back in the late nineties. Donald Trump had to do that during
- 50:30his first impeachment as well. Those stick out of my mind, and of
- 50:34course times that surprised us when members of the opposite partied and the president heckl
- 50:39the president. We've seen that on occasion as well, including last year.
- 50:44So that's something I think is the new norm essentially, where presidents have to
- 50:47prepare for that possibility. Yeah, and I remember too when Nancy Pelosi tour
- 50:52of Donald Trump's spech and regardless of what you think of Trump, I thought
- 50:53that was really I thought that was beyond the pale. Frankly, I agree
- 50:58with you, Yes, that was. You know, I don't usually have
- 51:00my mouth to gate at events that happened inside the Capitol, but that was
- 51:06one of the moments when the House Speaker, Nancy Pelosi did just that.
- 51:09Yeah. John Decker's with is he'll be covering save the Union addressed, and
- 51:13I and John clearly there will be issues. I mean that the president has
- 51:17to has to run through kind of a laundry list of things, and he'll
- 51:21want to put everything in the best possible light. But candidly, John,
- 51:23I think everybody's going to be watching to see also or uniquely how he does,
- 51:30how he does and how he handles himself for like an hour and a
- 51:34half hour and twenty minutes. Yeah, presentation is a big part of this
- 51:38for Joe Biden's order to begin with. And then of course he's made a
- 51:44lot of gas over the course of his time as president, so people will
- 51:47be tuning into that for sure. That's one reason, Hockey why he's really
- 51:52worked on this speech quite a bit over the past few weeks, and in
- 51:55earnest over the last few days of Camp David with his team going through the
- 52:00speech line by line, making certain that the President is intimately familiar with it
- 52:06as he delivers it. This evening, right, John Decker, with great
- 52:08television he'll be covering the State of the Union address tonight, John, Always
- 52:14a pleasure, appreciate you coming on. Good to talk to you, Good
- 52:15luck tonight, Thank you, thank you, text copy on the bill that
- 52:22would cut unemployment benefits. The politicians who say it keeps the fund solvent,
- 52:27yet it has four hundred million dollars in the fund. I believe the real
- 52:30reason they want to cut benefits is to hurt the middle class. The thinking
- 52:34is, you'll go back to work faster, even if it's a lower paying
- 52:37job. I feel we should cut the pay of all the senators and delegates
- 52:40twenty percent and take that savings to bolster the unemployment fund. That is,
- 52:46and that's somebody who's against the bill, obviously, but that is one of
- 52:51the arguments in favor of the bill, that if you start unemployment payment at
- 53:00seventy percent of the average wage of the individual's average wage started at seventy percent,
- 53:07that okay, it's shocking to get be unemployed, to get laid off,
- 53:10and you're going to be pretty good for the first four weeks, the
- 53:15first eight weeks. But the argument goes I'm not making the argument, I'm
- 53:20pointing out what the argument is by those who support the bill that as time
- 53:23goes on and the amount you receive goes down, that theoretically, at least
- 53:29the motivation to get a job would go up. You know at one point
- 53:36that even though I wrote in detail about this bill for this morning, I
- 53:40did not include this point, which I do think is relevant, That it
- 53:45allows for individuals while they are unemployment to also work part time. Work part
- 53:51time might not be the job you're looking for, but to work part time
- 53:53and to earn an amount up to an equal to what you're getting on unemployments,
- 53:59so you could both because right now you can't do that right now if
- 54:02you're on unemployment, you want unemployment and you can't work part time at least
- 54:06you know, on the books and get paid. But I think these questions
- 54:12and others are very very relevant, And I said in the commentary today,
- 54:16I don't know if this is a good bill or bad bill. I've been
- 54:19presenting both sides of this for a couple of days and will continue to do
- 54:22that. I don't know if it's a good thing or bad thing. I
- 54:23really don't. But and I don't think I'm alone. I think there are
- 54:29a lot of lawmakers, and I spent a lot of time yesterday trying to
- 54:32understand this bill, and even now I don't understand every aspect of it,
- 54:37and lawmakers today are voting on dozens and dozens of bills. So when this
- 54:42very important bill that has the potential to affect five hundred thousand private employees in
- 54:47West Virginia. I say private because public employees typically don't get laid off,
- 54:52but you know a few might. But so private employees, one hundred thousand
- 55:00small businesses in West Virginia as well as a number of large businesses. That's
- 55:02who will be will be affected or potentially affected by this bill. And again
- 55:09I don't know if it's, you know, a good thing or bad thing,
- 55:12but I would say, make sure you understand this. Make sure you
- 55:15understand this bill before you vote on it. Happy, my children are vaccinated,
- 55:22why should I care if the child's sitting next to me is not.
- 55:24If vaccination's truly affected that my children are safe, that sounds like control,
- 55:30says the texture. Well, the more the fewer people who are vaccinated,
- 55:37the more likelihood it is, like, Okay, your child's protected. But
- 55:39if you know twenty percent of the children aren't vaccinated or ten percent or whatever,
- 55:45and somebody does get the meal measles, then what if the child sitting
- 55:49next to the child with the measles isn't vaccinated? So It's good your child
- 55:53is protected. But the more children, the fewer children, the more children
- 55:58who are not vaccinated, the more people then the more children who are at
- 56:02risk of getting one of these diseases. Hoppy, I'm for all normal vaccinations,
- 56:15but not COVID. Well currently when you go to school, COVID vaccine
- 56:20not required. Happy great info from doctor Costello say. In fact, folks
- 56:25like Marjorie Taylor Green have a louder and more far reaching megaphone says. The
- 56:30texture will take a break and come back a major medical story across the country.
- 56:35How's it impacting West Virginia? This is talk line on Metro News from
- 56:38the state Capitol. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia. It's already
- 57:00back here at the upper rotund of the Capitol and it's the day fifty eight,
- 57:04fifty eight of the Legislative Session. Broadcasting from the AARP location at the
- 57:08Encode Insurance Studios in the upper rotund of Jackpots in the milliontore in West Virginia.
- 57:13Who doesn't want to be a millionaire? Getting the Powerbell drawings Mondays,
- 57:15Wednesdays and Saturdays and the Mega Million's drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you
- 57:20be the next big Winter Play? Today? The Powerball jackpot is five hundred
- 57:23and twenty one million dollars, the Mega Megus jackpot six hundred and eighty seven
- 57:27million dollars. Okay, bear with me on this story. Trust me on
- 57:32this that this is a very important story that is affecting or has the potential
- 57:39to effect a lot of people in West Virginia. Here's the background. US
- 57:45health officials are urging insurance companies to take immediate steps to ease a digital log
- 57:52jam after a massive data hack that has snarled administrative functions for hospitals, doctors,
- 58:00pharmacies, and millions of patients. And some of you've probably already experienced
- 58:05this. The Department of Health and Human Resources asking insurers to waive prior authorizations
- 58:10and medicare contractors to accept paper bills from doctors and hospitals. These temporary measures
- 58:15to try to deal with a hack of Change Healthcare. Change Healthcare Now,
- 58:24what happened is this company processes about fifteen billion health related transactions every year.
- 58:34Change Healthcare operates a digital digital clearinghouse that connects doctors, hospitals, and other
- 58:38healthcare providers with insurance companies that pay for medical care and authorize medical services.
- 58:45So you can imagine what has happened because hospitals and providers they just I mean,
- 58:53they work through this intermediary to process you know, insurance, whether it's
- 59:00private or Medicare and Medicaid, and since this company has been hacked, they're
- 59:07not able to do that. So a lot of this billing and also approval
- 59:10for medical procedures, prescriptions, all this stuff is getting held up because of
- 59:17this. Now with that backdrop, let me go, let me bring in
- 59:22again. Melanie Dempsey, vice president of the financial policy at the West Virginia
- 59:27Hospital Association, talked to her earlier this week, but let's get an update.
- 59:30Melanie, Thanks for coming back with us. I gave my explanation.
- 59:34Tell us more, give us the direct impact in West Virginia and healthcare providers.
- 59:37Sure, good morning, happy, thanks for having me. So.
- 59:40The Change Healthcare platform, as you mentioned, is used by a variety of
- 59:45providers across the state. They have come to a near standstill in processing many
- 59:51of their claims. So this outage has prevented them from submitting claims to insurance
- 59:57companies, stop payments coming back into the facilities. It's also impacting patient's ability
- 1:00:02to receive prior authorizations for timely care and pick up prescriptions in many cases at
- 1:00:08their local pharmacies. Melonie, I talked to an individual yesterday whose wife is
- 1:00:15a pediatrician. She has a small private office, has a couple of employees,
- 1:00:20and she didn't have the bank full of money and she can't get paid,
- 1:00:23and she's got bills coming in, she has people she needs to pay.
- 1:00:29I think that's probably repeated many times across West Virginia. Would you agree?
- 1:00:34Sure? This is impacting everyone from the large hospital down to the private
- 1:00:38provider, And in West Virginia, we know these healthcare providers do not have
- 1:00:45large reserves of cash flow. This outage has been going on over two weeks
- 1:00:49at this point with limited cash coming in, and we know that obligations to
- 1:00:53meet payroll, payper supplies, medicine operations, those don't stop. So yes,
- 1:00:59it's becoming increasingly difficult to continue in the face of this financial vulnerability.
- 1:01:06Melanie Dempsey's with his vice president of financial policy at the West Virginia Hospital Association.
- 1:01:09So, Melanie, you've you've given a general overview, have bet Let's
- 1:01:15let's drill down a little bit more. Does that mean that that I go
- 1:01:17into the doctor today and I go see my family doctor and they say,
- 1:01:22look, you're going to have to pay cash. Or is the family doctor's
- 1:01:24office going to say, you know, we can see you, but you
- 1:01:29know, we're running low on cash and we'll figure it out later. Or
- 1:01:31that does the operator that private clinic say, you know, I got to
- 1:01:36go to the bank today and see if I can get a small business loan
- 1:01:37to carry me through. Or do I go to the pharmacy and have problems
- 1:01:42they are getting my prescription? Are these kinds of things happening? So I
- 1:01:45want to reiterate that providing the safe, efficient care to our patients remains the
- 1:01:50top priority in any touch point in healthcare. I don't think that any patient
- 1:01:55confidently will be turned away for their service, but the providers are going to
- 1:02:00start having trouble making those obligations now. Will say that In the past few
- 1:02:07days, HHS and CMS, the centers for Medicare and Medicaid have started to
- 1:02:13open up loan programs that these providers can apply for, and they're starting to
- 1:02:17be some congressional pressure on insurance companies to waive some of these manual processes that
- 1:02:23are taking more time for providers to take care of and give patients that care.
- 1:02:30In West Virginia, that's huge too, because in West Virginia, the
- 1:02:35patrio mix is probably more than half Medicare Medicaid. Right. Absolutely, we've
- 1:02:38got about seventy five percent Medicare Medicaid PEA, those governor governmental programs here in
- 1:02:45the state. Melanie Dempsey's with his vice president of financial policy the West Virginia
- 1:02:50Hospital Association. So would you say at this point, and again, I
- 1:02:52guess everybody's doing it a little bit differently that hospitals and providers, doctors' offices,
- 1:02:58pharmacies that they're fit bring out what to do in the introim or as
- 1:03:01you said, there's some maybe some immediate help on the way, or they're
- 1:03:05just hanging on until this hack gets cleared and they can get back to having
- 1:03:10these claims processed and get the reimbursements. Healthcare providers, whether it be a
- 1:03:16hospital, positions office or pharmacy, they're working to mitigate any barriers to the
- 1:03:22patient. Would see, however, there are going to be some real world
- 1:03:25effects. Let me give you an example. If a patient goes into a
- 1:03:30pharmacy, and the pharmacy uses this change healthcare platform, they're not going to
- 1:03:35be able to immediately run eligibility for the drugs process a discount card if they
- 1:03:42have it applicable to their deductibles. So a patient could encounter a situation where
- 1:03:46they try to pick up their prescription. They may have to pay higher out
- 1:03:51of pocket costs at the time of purchase until the pharmacies are able to come
- 1:03:58back and reconcile that with the insurance company. So while we're trying to mitigate
- 1:04:01it, patients very well may see some pain touch points in receiving their care.
- 1:04:08Speaking of pain touch points, let me try to put another face on
- 1:04:11this. Let's say I'm, you know, at the doctor's office and the
- 1:04:15hospital and they say, okay, we're going to do your shoulder surgery or
- 1:04:17whatever because you fail and you have to have the surgery whatever, whatever it
- 1:04:21is, make it up, And I say, well, you know have
- 1:04:26insurance. Insurance would pay for this, and say, well, okay,
- 1:04:28we got to see if insurance is going to pay for that. Can that
- 1:04:30process work normally or might there be a hold up in that too? Well,
- 1:04:34there could be holdups and we're working to mitigate that. Typically a hospital
- 1:04:39would have to get a prior authorization to perform that surgery or whatever service it
- 1:04:44is on a patient, and we're having to do a lot of those processes
- 1:04:46manually. However, that is one of the touch points that HHS and others
- 1:04:53are working to mitigate so that we can bypass those procedures. That's to not
- 1:04:58hold up patient care and still be able to submit those claims and be assured
- 1:05:02of payment after those procedures are taken care of. We want this to we
- 1:05:06want to minimize any effects seen on patient care. Melanie, what is your
- 1:05:13thought about the fact that one entity and I don't know, I know it
- 1:05:19was some it was a hacker or a few people that do this hack,
- 1:05:24or whoever does this hack. I don't know if anybody knows where it came
- 1:05:27from or how exactly it got into to help to this organization. But to
- 1:05:35think that one hack could cause this much chaos, and of course it's ransomware,
- 1:05:41and I don't know whether they've paid or not. There was some report
- 1:05:43that maybe they've paid twenty million dollars in bitcoin or something. But to think
- 1:05:46that something like this could cause this muchruption. Disruption is chilling. That's chilling
- 1:05:53to me. Do you absolutely change? Healthcare provides a very robut platform,
- 1:06:00but many insurances use to process their claims, and unfortunately, healthcare providers have
- 1:06:06become a very high value target for cyber attacks because there's so much demographic,
- 1:06:12medical, and financial information kept in those systems. So as we digitize more
- 1:06:17and more of our workflows and healthcare, it's a balancing act to make sure
- 1:06:21we keep that information protected and also work to improve patient experiences and care delivery.
- 1:06:28Finally, Melanie, do you have any idea how many of your members
- 1:06:30at the Hospital Association have been impacted? And then outside of that a best
- 1:06:34estimate of number of other providers, physicians, physicians offices, pharmacies that have
- 1:06:39been impacted. We've been in contact with our members. Many of our members
- 1:06:45are impacted. I would say some more so than others just because of their
- 1:06:48insurance mix. But every healthcare facility is touched by this outage in some way,
- 1:06:55and it's the same across the country. When you have a group that
- 1:06:59touches is almost fifteen billion healthcare transactions, no one is exempt from an effect
- 1:07:05from that fallout. Melanie Dempsey vice president of Financial Policy the West Virginia Hospital
- 1:07:11Association. Troubling story, good insights. Thank you for coming on. I
- 1:07:15appreciate it. Thanks Hoppy. All right, we'll take a break and come
- 1:07:18back. Talk line continues. The travel bill, as Jeff Jenkins named it,
- 1:07:24appears to be dead. That story when we return. Metro News talk
- 1:07:36Line with Hoppy Kirchibal is brought to you by Incovia Insurance, encircling you with
- 1:07:42coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting Covia dot com to learn
- 1:07:45more. Talk Line from the cob Insurance studios at the ARP location here at
- 1:07:50the Upper Road ton of the Capitol. So the travel team Bill is dead.
- 1:07:55That's the bill that would have allowed athlete tis school athletes to travel team
- 1:08:00at the same time as that sport at their school. We've talked about basketball,
- 1:08:04so you could be on the school basketball team and also be on a
- 1:08:06basketball travel team. But now that has died. Let me bring in Dave
- 1:08:11Price, who is the executive director of the West Virginia SSAC, who's at
- 1:08:15the Charleston Coliseum, the convention center where the girls state tournaments underway. So
- 1:08:19it might be a bit noisy, but Dave, what is your reaction to
- 1:08:21the fact that that bill died? Well happy, you know, it's it's
- 1:08:26been something that we've been discussing with both the Senate and the House since it
- 1:08:29was introduced, and you know, under the version that they introduced, obviously,
- 1:08:33the Coaches Association, you know, we took a stand on it.
- 1:08:36We weren't for that, and Coaches Association, Athletic Directors Association, and others
- 1:08:42got involved as well, and you know, I think they were very very
- 1:08:45vocal by some concerns they had with the bill as well, you know,
- 1:08:49as it was presented. We haven't had some flaws in it and stuff,
- 1:08:55but I think that at some point, you know, we'll be looking at
- 1:08:59some of the things that our rule books to see how we can modify things
- 1:09:02a little bit, to maybe come to a consensus on how this looks.
- 1:09:04Make sure we're supporting our kids in the right way. You know, David,
- 1:09:09let me let me interrupt you there, because that's a good point because
- 1:09:12some of the things that that I heard were like, look, right now,
- 1:09:17a student and we'll use basketball. They're on the school basketball team,
- 1:09:20but they can't have any interaction with the travel team at all. Like a
- 1:09:24photo shoot or tryouts or anything. I mean, are the rules now too
- 1:09:29strict and they need to be modified and are you all going to do that?
- 1:09:31Well, yeah, you know, we're looking at some things there to
- 1:09:33make sure that we're doing the right thing, and yeah, I think there's
- 1:09:38some applications that can be made to that. You know, I think the
- 1:09:40biggest concern is being able to participate on two teams at the same time in
- 1:09:45the same sport. It get's difficult on a student athlete, and there's a
- 1:09:47lot of concerns about that actually in the team sport. Individual sport and team
- 1:09:51sports are really different when it comes to that, and we get that under
- 1:09:56We understand that. But I think there are some things that are our rules
- 1:10:00that we need to look at, and we'll be discussing with our border control
- 1:10:04and again they make the final decision. You know, we were at the
- 1:10:09SSAC the four of us Ashley. We're the group that has to enforce everything.
- 1:10:14Our principals bank the rules. They decide on what happened. So be
- 1:10:18presenting some of this student border control and we'll see how it goes with them,
- 1:10:24all right, Dave Price and Dave we're gonna limit this interview because you're
- 1:10:27there and there's not a great Seales signal, and you also have business to
- 1:10:30attend to. But we get to drift. Dave Price, executive director of
- 1:10:33the West Virginia SSAC Travel Team Bill dead, but SSAC pledging to try to
- 1:10:39make some changes in some of these rules to try to be more accommodating to
- 1:10:43travel to students who participate in sports at their school and also on our travel
- 1:10:45team. Dave, thank you very much. We appreciate that. Thanks Hoppy,
- 1:10:50Thank you, Hoppy. This is a texture textas says I for one
- 1:10:55hope it comes back up. That is the travel team bill in the future
- 1:10:57of My daughter graduate from Glenville State Universe last spring went there on a softball
- 1:11:01in academic scholarship. She would have never gotten this opportunity if it weren't for
- 1:11:04travel ball. I was one of her coaches on the travel team, and
- 1:11:08we never scheduled any games during the school ball season. I have a suggestion
- 1:11:13four that got some suggestions here, but I think that that you know,
- 1:11:18I get it. I get what many see as the value in travel teams.
- 1:11:21And there's a perfect example. But the argument was that okay, maybe
- 1:11:26you would keep it in the off season, but would there be travel teams,
- 1:11:30AAU events or you know, scheduled tournaments at the same time as the
- 1:11:36season, and therefore students might be in conflict. Are they going to try
- 1:11:42to participate in both? Would there be a load management issue as to how
- 1:11:45much they participate? Would they miss some games with one organization not with another.
- 1:11:51There were a lot of complications there that gave coaches. They gave coaches
- 1:11:56a lot of a lot of heartburn. And also, I weight in on
- 1:12:00this at this level, isn't that something and there are legitimate issues that the
- 1:12:05SSAC clearly needs to deal with because the rules were so restrictive that a student
- 1:12:11athlete couldn't have any contact with the travel team. And you heard Dave Price
- 1:12:15say, well, they probably need to deal with some of those things.
- 1:12:16So that that, to me, is how it should work. These are
- 1:12:19concerns, these are issues. Can you fix that without changing everything? And
- 1:12:27that to me seems more like a more logical approach than passing a law.
- 1:12:32I mean, do you really need the West Virginia legislature to pass a law
- 1:12:36on something like this or can you just bring pressure on the SSAC and say,
- 1:12:41look, you got to make some changes here and then go from there.
- 1:12:44Talk line continues, will return to the AARP broadcast location in just a
- 1:12:47minute. Networks security is serious business, and sitting that is serious about protecting
- 1:12:51your business and your employees from today's constant barage of cybersecurity threats. We know
- 1:12:57about one. It's affected healthcare providers and West Virginia. Let sitting net be
- 1:13:00your cybersecurity hero when it comes to technology, sitting that connects, protects,
- 1:13:04and perfect. We'll be right back already back at the upper rotunda the West
- 1:13:23Virginia State Capital, the AARP broadcast location of the in COVID Insurance Studios.
- 1:13:28Text Happy, These teachers continue wanting raises, but the people of West Virginia
- 1:13:31want to see results. Once we start seeing positive results, then that's when
- 1:13:36we need to be concerned about raises, says the texter Happy. Somehow we've
- 1:13:43lost our way and everything is backward in my world of small business, we
- 1:13:46must produce results before we get paid. Do you agree on that? Thanks
- 1:13:49for your time, says the texture text team With the argument about the state
- 1:13:57mandatory vaccinations, why the state man undated traffic laws about drinking and driving.
- 1:14:01Those people have to wear seatbelts. Right, let me see here, let
- 1:14:15me see happy. Yelling you lie to the president is not beyond Yeah,
- 1:14:21it is. I just mentioned that about Pelosi. But I still believe in
- 1:14:28manners and decorum, and I think the President of the United States, regardless
- 1:14:31of who the president is, that you owe them some respect. You owe
- 1:14:38the office of respect. I mean, Pelosi shouldn't tear up the speech,
- 1:14:40and somebody sitting in the audience shouldn't yell out you lie. You want to
- 1:14:43say that, wait till afterward and say to the press whatever, send out
- 1:14:46a news release, but you should. All that kind of stuff to me
- 1:14:49just continues to break down civility. And I don't care who does it.
- 1:14:55It is. It reduces civility and ultimately is bad. All right, se
- 1:15:00tomorrow, We'll be here live tomorrow from the Capitol. This has been talk
- 1:15:01Line on Metro News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia.