Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 137: Pleasure in Paris with Glynnis MacNicol
Transcript
- 0:06You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:08I'm your host, Lindsay Trermuda. For many people, the year
- 0:12following strict pandemic lockdowns felt like coming out
- 0:14of hibernation. As the proverbial chains came
- 0:17off, some went wild. Others were more.
- 0:20Cautious and set new priorities for their lives.
- 0:23Some did a mix of both, like the writer Glenys Mcnichol.
- 0:27After enduring nearly a year of isolation and a punishing lack
- 0:31of human touch, Mcnichol boarded a plane for Paris in August 2021
- 0:35to sublet a friend's apartment for the month.
- 0:38She was 47 years old and on a very specific mission. 100%
- 0:43enjoyment. An exploration of pleasure.
- 0:47Her memoir about this time, called I'm Mostly Here to Enjoy
- 0:50Myself, came out a few months ago, and I was delighted to
- 0:53interview her in Paris last week at the Red Wheelbarrow
- 0:56Bookstore. This episode is a.
- 0:58Recording of that conversation. I hope you enjoy it and don't
- 1:02forget to check the show description for a link to order
- 1:05a copy of the book. By this point, everyone has seen
- 1:11this cover, right? I think even if you don't know
- 1:14what the book is about, maybe you've seen it across your
- 1:16feeds. Although Instagram has tried
- 1:18really diligently to block it from everyone's feeds, citing
- 1:22pornography. So it's been quite difficult
- 1:25actually in a lot of ways to promote on social media where
- 1:29everyone conceivably discovers book for that reason.
- 1:33But you've also been writing on these themes in the New York
- 1:35Times, in the op eds this summer.
- 1:38And it's quite exciting, I think, to have you here because
- 1:41you've just done these events in the US, but your story takes
- 1:44place in Paris, and now you're back.
- 1:45And now I'm back. I know one other person in the
- 1:48audience asked this question. I think it's Sophie, who I was
- 1:51exchanging with earlier. And it was the first thing that
- 1:53I kind of wondered as well when I was reading, which is could
- 1:57any other destination have delivered what you needed in
- 2:01that very particular post COVID isolation moment?
- 2:05Right. A couple people have asked me
- 2:07that. So for those of you who haven't
- 2:08read, the book takes place in Paris in August of 2021 after I
- 2:13was very alone for a year in my very small New York City studio
- 2:18apartment on the top floor, smaller than this bookstore.
- 2:21And I landed in Paris and had five very enjoyable weeks, so
- 2:26could have taken place anywhere else.
- 2:28I didn't come with the intention of writing the book.
- 2:31And so it wasn't sort of conceit.
- 2:34Like it wasn't a desk, it wasn't a travelogue.
- 2:35It wasn't like I planned it. And I knew I wanted to write
- 2:38about Paris. I was in Paris because I'd spent
- 2:40summers here for a few years prior at a friend group.
- 2:44We were in the audience that were here and I knew the city
- 2:48and I missed it so much because I've been coming here so
- 2:50regularly and to have not been here for, you know, a year and a
- 2:54half or two years or whatever it was.
- 2:56So I don't know. I I don't claim to like no Paris
- 3:01the way creations do, or people who've lived here for such a
- 3:04long time, but I knew it well enough.
- 3:07They felt comfortable writing about it.
- 3:08I think if I'd gone somewhere else, it would have been a
- 3:10travelogue very directly because it would have been in a brand
- 3:15new place in that that sense of exploring something that you
- 3:17don't know anything about. Whereas coming here, I can bike
- 3:21Paris without a map. I have some, I have like regular
- 3:24haunts and friends and rituals routines which were all a little
- 3:27off that summer, obviously for all of us.
- 3:29But I don't know. But I also think in addition to
- 3:31that, the French, particularly compared to Americans, Please
- 3:36keep in mind I've lived in New York City for my adult life.
- 3:39Prioritize pleasure in a different way, and it does come
- 3:43with a degree of enjoyment, particularly when you don't live
- 3:46here full time and only brush up against the bureaucracy as
- 3:49opposed to like get plunged into it.
- 3:52So I think that there's like that added aspect to it.
- 3:55But the book genuinely came about months later when I was
- 4:00going back and reading my journalism.
- 4:02I was really enjoying my own journalism.
- 4:03So you keep it. You keep a a.
- 4:05Pretty I've been keeping a journal since I was six years
- 4:07old. And in my first year I pulled it
- 4:11up for a podcast I was doing on a different subject and the
- 4:13journal entry said, and I want to be a writer.
- 4:16I don't know what kind of writer, but I want to like
- 4:18that's one of my early journal entries.
- 4:19So from age 6, from age 6 in my scratchy, illegible handwriting.
- 4:23So I was rereading my journal entries months later and I
- 4:25thought, oh, this is so wonderful, knew I could come
- 4:29back into lockdown and I was really missing it.
- 4:31And I thought I want I wonder if I can capture some elements of
- 4:35this on the page, which was sort of the motivation for the book.
- 4:38But also, do you associate in all of the summers that you
- 4:41spent here, had you associated Paris with pleasure in the way
- 4:44so many people? Do certainly, yeah.
- 4:46So that. Played some sort of a role.
- 4:47Do you also feel that this is another question that I think
- 4:51has come up for people is that you had somewhat of another
- 4:55identity when you were here? I think yes, I, I think that's
- 4:59probably true of anyone. Like I've lived in New York for
- 5:02a long time, but I'm also Canadian and I grew up in
- 5:04Toronto and I also spend enough time here.
- 5:06I think whenever you're out of your full time life, then you,
- 5:11it releases you from like the grooves of my life in New York
- 5:15at this point are so deep. And in my grooves of my life in
- 5:18Paris, I have grooves here, but they're not nearly as deep.
- 5:21So you get to be a slightly different person and one that I
- 5:24sometimes think that when we talk about relationships or long
- 5:26term relationships, at least in my life, I match myself with
- 5:28cities more than people. Like the the person Paris allows
- 5:34me to be is that matches best in the city is different than the
- 5:38person that New York allows me to be.
- 5:40And I enjoy both people and I wouldn't give either up.
- 5:44But yes, absolutely, it's a different city.
- 5:47It brings out different parts of you.
- 5:48It's a different way of life. And so the language perhaps as
- 5:51well, because you can sort of navigate without feeling the
- 5:54same burdens perhaps. You don't.
- 5:56It allows you to tune out a little bit.
- 5:58So I have, I am Canadian and I I can read French better than I
- 6:02can do everything better than speak French.
- 6:03I can understand it better and read it better.
- 6:06I can speak it a tiny bit, but I think when you're in a place
- 6:09where you're not fluent in the language, it serves as a white
- 6:12noise, which is really wonderful because it like releases you
- 6:15from your environment a little bit and eavesdropping in a weird
- 6:20way, which is somewhat delightful in New York
- 6:21sometimes, but like you're sort of a little bit in your own
- 6:25world, which is. Which is what you were seeking
- 6:27also. Absolutely, Yeah.
- 6:29I mean, it wasn't seeking silence so much, but yeah, it
- 6:32allows you to. The opposite of silence.
- 6:35It allows you to move differently, like sort of like a
- 6:39different water way to move through.
- 6:41For sure. Yeah, less and less the more
- 6:43time I spent. Like it's a different.
- 6:44My relationship with the city changes so dramatically each
- 6:46time I'm here because it becomes more familiar and the language
- 6:51becomes more familiar. But just like the cultural
- 6:53expectations and mores of Paris like become not too exotic
- 6:58anymore, you know, which is the same if any relationship, I
- 7:00think people or city or what, whatever.
- 7:03No, but it's interesting because there's this idea that you sort
- 7:05of can have an adventure in another city that you can't
- 7:08allow yourself to have in your whole city, or your adopted city
- 7:11in your case, and that there's something we can tap into by
- 7:16simply changing the environment. I think it's a combination of
- 7:21the way, how would I phrase this?
- 7:24I don't like speaking in broad terms, but I would say there are
- 7:27some New Yorkers here making back me up on this.
- 7:31I think New York is a very power driven city and that that
- 7:35influences dating to a degree that is hard, like it's
- 7:43suffocating and aggressive and competitive and all of those
- 7:49things. And I don't think Paris is a
- 7:50power driven city and those goals, you know, the joke is
- 7:54American women come here and, and go out on one date.
- 7:57And especially when you're from New York and like French men can
- 8:00get serious very quickly. And whereas that's not the same
- 8:03in America, but I don't think that's entirely true.
- 8:05But there's just like a different mentality here around
- 8:08it. So it's a combination of both
- 8:09those things. You you're both tapping into a
- 8:11different part of yourself, and you're in a place that views all
- 8:14of these interactions differently.
- 8:17What would would the French power then be?
- 8:19Pleasure. And I think so.
- 8:21Right. But Speaking of that.
- 8:24Well, so Paris is an international city and I think
- 8:26increasingly international. I wouldn't have said this
- 8:28necessarily 10 years ago, but my impression having spent regular
- 8:32time here over the last decade is that it's increasingly has an
- 8:35international feeling to it. Like you're just encountering
- 8:39French people, you're encountering, you know,
- 8:41Europeans, people from Africa, people from all over in a way
- 8:46that I think was not necessarily the case, at least in my
- 8:48experience. I'm certainly not an expert.
- 8:51Like I'm, I'm always careful when I thought something.
- 8:53Not for Eastern, no. But I'm only giving, I'm giving
- 8:56my like half in, half out impressions of things.
- 8:58Well, certainly it has embraced its international population in
- 9:02a way that it hadn't. Yes.
- 9:04And there's a younger, there's a younger feeling here, like it
- 9:06has a different energy right now than it did.
- 9:08Well, it was always a global capital.
- 9:10It just didn't like to claim itself to right.
- 9:13But it it is very much so you talk about so talking about
- 9:17pleasure, right. A lot of the coverage of around
- 9:20the book has been very much focused even before it's
- 9:23released around sex, the desire for it and the having it, which
- 9:28you do write about. But that and.
- 9:31Do. And do still conceivably have,
- 9:36but it is not the only source of enjoyment in the book.
- 9:40And, and, and, you know, the message goes far beyond that.
- 9:44And it goes pretty deep on friendship.
- 9:46And you also challenge the idea that to have a compelling story
- 9:49as an older single woman without children, the journey must lead
- 9:54to love. How do you interpret this
- 9:56coverage around the book? And you know, is it just
- 10:00because, well, sex fails and so it's sensationalism, or does it
- 10:03really go into something much deeper?
- 10:05It's a big question. It was interesting, I think when
- 10:10I went back and looked at the flap copy of the book to make
- 10:12sure that I cuz I wrote the flap copy more or less to make sure
- 10:17that it was like, here's what you can expect.
- 10:19You can expect friendship. And you can, as I say in all my
- 10:22interviews, although sometimes interviewers are less interested
- 10:24in hearing and I'm like poor to my life are my friendships.
- 10:29And I joke, not really joke, but when I did CBS Mornings with
- 10:32Gayle King, it was lovely and it was a lovely interview.
- 10:35She came in before Hannah was asking me, you know, about the
- 10:38book and questions and the things she wants to talk about.
- 10:41She says there anything that I'm missing.
- 10:43And I said, well, my friendships are really core to my life and I
- 10:45and I want to make sure we touch on that.
- 10:47She goes, forget about it. We're just talking about the
- 10:49sex. And I was like, fair.
- 10:52But what happened was so much of the early coverage, I really
- 10:56wanted this book just to backtrack a bit to capture how
- 11:00women, and I can't speak for all women, but how I experienced
- 11:05many people in my life experience pleasure in their
- 11:07lives and how it is very detached from the narrative of
- 11:13satisfaction for women, which is almost always, you know, fall in
- 11:17love, marriage, possibly children.
- 11:19And I wanted to say like, we are accessing pleasure in or I am
- 11:22accessing pleasure in such a wide variety of ways that I
- 11:25don't see reflected back to me. And I want to try it.
- 11:27And that summer seemed to capture it for me.
- 11:28And I wanted to try and capture it in the book.
- 11:31But in the early coverage, all of the coverage was about the
- 11:35sex in the book, which I work in media.
- 11:38So I understand the headline, like I got it.
- 11:41But at the same time, what ended up happening was people who are
- 11:45coming to the book after the fact were expecting it to be a
- 11:48book about sex. And so a lot of the criticism I
- 11:53got from readers about a month in was there's not enough sex in
- 11:57this book. Why isn't there more sex in the
- 12:00book? And I was like, oh, I felt like
- 12:02it was a sufficient amount of me being naked in this book, but I
- 12:06wasn't actually writing porn. I get that maybe that is a
- 12:09market that people should be tapping into though, based on
- 12:11responses to the book. But there was a there was a sort
- 12:14of discrepancy between how it was promoted in major news
- 12:19outlets and what was actually in the book.
- 12:20And also what I would always be saying to people, which is I'd
- 12:23like to talk about a number of other things as well.
- 12:26And I think and speaking like this summer, you know, All Fours
- 12:29by Miranda July has really taken off too.
- 12:31And a number of other books. I think that there is an absence
- 12:35in culture of any good storytelling around women and
- 12:41sex after a certain age. And I would argue about women
- 12:43and sex in general, but just the absolute hunger that I felt from
- 12:49women over 40 to see any depiction of enjoyable,
- 12:55appealing, attractive sex was really telling to me that we're
- 13:00not we're not getting it. We might be get we're getting it
- 13:04in real life and we're not getting it in culture.
- 13:06And that is condemnation of the culture less than I feel like
- 13:11what's missing in the book. But I'm sorry if you felt like
- 13:12there should be more socks. To me.
- 13:16It's interesting though, too, because in some ways, you know,
- 13:18a friend who read it early was like, no, the food is the porn
- 13:21in the book. And some.
- 13:23Yeah. And some people, I think this
- 13:25book is a love letter to my bike personally.
- 13:27And some people feel like we love the biking scene.
- 13:31And someone woman wrote me a letter.
- 13:32It stuck in my head so much, she said.
- 13:34The most erotic part of this book is where you just sit in
- 13:37the park by yourself in the quiet reading a book.
- 13:40And I thought, well, that's very American, but also that's a big
- 13:44tell too. I I think she also said that
- 13:46she's married with children, which is also.
- 13:48That was her idea. Absolutely.
- 13:50And I thought, you're right. Like if I had small kids at
- 13:53home, I also would be more interested than anything to be
- 13:57in a park by myself, reading a book and not having anybody
- 14:00bother me. Give a little bit more about why
- 14:03that was so crucial to your experience here.
- 14:07Because obviously you have friends in New York, you have
- 14:11friends in. Canada.
- 14:13But what was it that was so special about the this, that
- 14:15month of August with them as much as it was about exploring
- 14:19sort of this reconnection with touch?
- 14:23Yeah, we hug. I mean, I think in general, I'm
- 14:27very, I feel very strongly that we convey on friendships, on
- 14:34long term friendships, the same seriousness that we convey on
- 14:38romantic relationships because they are for me anyway, and for
- 14:42many people I know, just as long they're just as serious, they
- 14:46are just as supportive. They provide the infrastructure
- 14:49for your life. And that we don't have as the
- 14:50ritual or the language to convey the respect that that deserves
- 14:55is I think frustrating for a lot of people.
- 14:57But something when I'm writing, I'm always just trying to, you
- 15:00know, flesh out what that looks like in my life as a way to, you
- 15:05know, offers. And I'm far from alone in that.
- 15:07There's many books on this. So my friendship's in Paris and
- 15:10all of my friends are here right now.
- 15:12Anybody who wants to pipe up pan, but started out with what I
- 15:16say was the best fine date I've ever been set up on with a woman
- 15:21who's become a very close friend.
- 15:23And we are all not married and no one has kids and just felt I
- 15:31think making friends gotten this question from No One Tells You
- 15:35This, which is my last book. And this was like, how do you
- 15:37make friends when you're older? Which I think is a struggle for
- 15:41some people. And I think particularly people
- 15:43who've been in long term marriages are coming out of kids
- 15:45who are going to school. But I think making friends when
- 15:48you're older is like, there's something so magical about it
- 15:51'cause you're so fully yourselves and just looking at
- 15:55them, but you're so like you are, you have a full sense of
- 15:59yourself and you can bring that to the table.
- 16:02And like I have friends that I've known for decades who I
- 16:05grew up with and you sort of you keep on with each other, but
- 16:08you're really choosing each other at this stage.
- 16:10Like, like you really recognize in one another, like a
- 16:13similarity and a strength. And and I think friendship is
- 16:18something it requires work. Sometimes I hear married people
- 16:22say like it requires work. I'm like, it really sounds
- 16:24unpleasant, but but like requires like, like you hold on
- 16:29to each other and you make space for each other.
- 16:31And and that was the case that I missed my friends.
- 16:33And I think I say in the book too, that I have many very close
- 16:36friends who are married. And I joke that like the joy of
- 16:40other people's husbands, Like I, I'm close with my friends
- 16:42husbands, but there's something wonderful in not having to
- 16:44translate your life to anybody and not having to justify it or
- 16:48say, but this. And just like it's it's its own
- 16:52language when we talk about, you know, having something, being
- 16:55fluent and something. So there's like, there's such a
- 16:57strength in that And and I'm so grateful for it.
- 17:02But also, that means when you pick this up, there's going to
- 17:05be a lot of. Friendship in there.
- 17:06There's a lot of friendship in here.
- 17:07But there's also something else which I really enjoyed, which I
- 17:10didn't expect going into. It was sort of how at some point
- 17:13with some of these friends, you trace historical women that have
- 17:17spent time in different neighborhoods, different places
- 17:20that they became attached to in some way.
- 17:25You know, we know that women have always come to to Paris, as
- 17:28have men. But, you know, women, women, we
- 17:31don't care about them right now. Sorry.
- 17:33Sorry, Sir. It's a friendly space.
- 17:38Thank you for coming. We like you too, but women.
- 17:41But women have come of all ages, you know, seeking pleasure here.
- 17:46But why do you think Paris is especially appealing to older
- 17:50women? Older with.
- 17:52Yes, elders. Well, my friend Ellie, who's
- 17:56here put together one Saturday afternoon like a little tour
- 18:00around Paris of women writers that I sort of followed her
- 18:05around on. And what struck me, there's a
- 18:08couple answers to this question, which is in terms of that tour,
- 18:11what struck me was so many of these women, you know, Simone
- 18:15Dubois, Edith Wharton, I talked about a little bit about Lee
- 18:19Miller in the book who there's just a movie that came out about
- 18:21her, which is interesting. Were in their mid to late 40s
- 18:25and that that aspect of their life is something that they were
- 18:28all having these, you know, affairs with younger men and
- 18:31they'd all sought Paris as a refuge from certain parts of
- 18:34their life. Obviously lives here, but and so
- 18:38that elements of it was interesting and Colette clearly
- 18:41Colette, you know being the pinnacle of this.
- 18:43But what I find frustrating is when we talk about women in
- 18:47isolation and not in community. So we when we talk about Edith
- 18:52Wharton, we don't ever talk about her in community with sort
- 18:55of I don't know if she ever met Gertrude Stein, although I would
- 18:58have liked to have been there for that or like Colette or that
- 19:01they all are existing or Josephine Baker, like they're
- 19:03all existing in a similar place at a similar time, but we only
- 19:06know them as econoclast and not in community with one another.
- 19:11And I always want to know in part of the that tour and that
- 19:16chapter was being like they live in geographically close to each
- 19:20other. What would it have looked like
- 19:21if we understood them the way we understood Hemingway and
- 19:23Fitzgerald or the way that we understood the way that men
- 19:28particular in that 1920s literary scene, the way that men
- 19:31all supported one another was sort of like the Gertrude Stein,
- 19:33as you know, Smurfette in that situation.
- 19:37But but and so that was part of it was just being like, well,
- 19:41how do we think of women as a community?
- 19:43And then part of it, I think too, is.
- 19:46And then this is a broad strokes answer, which I'm don't love,
- 19:50but I think culturally in America, women tend to fall off
- 19:55the cultural map right around 40, you know, in television, in
- 19:59movies, do not you sort of cease to hear from them?
- 20:03And I think, and I'm not a Parisian, but I think Paris,
- 20:09France possibly allows women to age in the culture differently
- 20:13and remain visible and that the combination of that.
- 20:18With an element of pleasure, that's someone said to me, and
- 20:21I've repeated this in many interviews, which is in America
- 20:24you have to earn your pleasure, like literally monetarily work
- 20:29to have a holiday. And here it is considered a
- 20:33right, right. And I think that is the
- 20:36difference. And so at an age when you're
- 20:38becoming invisible in America and in a culture where you're
- 20:43constantly having to justify any pleasure, compared to a country
- 20:47where women as they age remain visible and argue about how they
- 20:52remain visible, they definitely remain visible in a country that
- 20:55prioritizes pleasure in a different way.
- 20:56I think the combination of those two things allows women to enjoy
- 21:02what I consider the most powerful years of your life in a
- 21:05place that supports that. Well, this was also the home for
- 21:09sexual liberation, you know, a long time ago.
- 21:12And I think, you know, at least that generation has never left.
- 21:17Yes, I also think. Healthcare is part, I think
- 21:20there's no way to remove healthcare from any of these for
- 21:22someone who lives in America like I, I can't remove the
- 21:25healthcare part of this from any conversation, which is the
- 21:29finances of it being so punishing too.
- 21:31And I know it's more complicated than that here.
- 21:32But so I think it's it's a combination of those two things
- 21:35is like you're reaching a point in the States where you're sort
- 21:37of falling off the map and you're feeling very powerful and
- 21:41pleasure's accessible and you don't fall off the map here in
- 21:43the same way culturally. So it's pretty appealing.
- 21:46Well, maybe there's a chance for certain women to make a comeback
- 21:51in America since we are now uniting against JD Vance.
- 21:56I only bring him up because your book seems to have come out as
- 22:00sort of an A really opportunity moment just before not.
- 22:05That I would ever say thank you. No, no, no, no, we won't.
- 22:07Go we won't go that far, but but you know, you came out with this
- 22:11and you're able to then comment in, you know, essays that were
- 22:16published widely on his childless cat lady criticisms.
- 22:21And I feel like that's a very interesting tie in to what
- 22:24you're sort of arguing here. What do you think is behind
- 22:28words like his? And you know, they're not just
- 22:29his. There are plenty of other men in
- 22:32the world, including in France, be fair, who believe that you
- 22:36know the way that you're you're proposing to live your life or
- 22:40that you are living your life is somehow unhealthy, abnormal,
- 22:46scary, or OK. Scary is the word you're going
- 22:48to use. OK.
- 22:49No, I just. Scaring to go on.
- 22:51No, and just whenever I do these interviews, not just on that
- 22:53particular topic, but I think I'm careful when I do interviews
- 22:56in the States to be like France is not an like an idyllic Oasis
- 23:01of perfection. There's not that anyone needs to
- 23:04hear anything that. But like there's a lot.
- 23:05I'm always like careful to do that 'cause I think right now
- 23:08it's been America. There is this like Get Me Out of
- 23:11here. What do you mean that you can go
- 23:13to the doctor, you know, sense of wow, jeez.
- 23:18When I wrote an op-ed in May before the book came out, what
- 23:21they put a crazy headline on, but I think it's old books.
- 23:24So God bless them. It was something like men fear
- 23:27me, society shames me, but I love my life and the premise of
- 23:31it was sat on the home page first followed 48 hours and I
- 23:36was like, RIP my inbox. But actually I didn't get that
- 23:39much hate mail, so it was nice. The premise of it was I just
- 23:42turned 52 weeks ago and I was born the year after Roe was
- 23:49passed of the same year women in America were allowed to have
- 23:52credit cards and bank accounts in their own name for the first
- 23:54time. And possibly I don't know what
- 23:57the laws were in France, but I know it's.
- 23:58Pretty delayed as. Well, yeah, the same in Canada
- 24:01was exactly the same year. And that the life I'm leading
- 24:04with financial and physical agency is, you know, a result of
- 24:09both of those things. And that we're seeing so many
- 24:13women make these similar choices is not disconnected from the
- 24:19violent rollback of women's rights in America.
- 24:22That it's this, oh, no, the women are doing OK without us.
- 24:29How do we get them back under our control and.
- 24:33Insulting us is a good way to start.
- 24:35Yeah, but I mean like even the overturning of, you know, Roe
- 24:39and and they're, you know, the attempt to overturn no fault
- 24:43divorce and a lot of other laws that are in the works, you can
- 24:46feel this absolute, you know, hatred and the rise of child
- 24:51wives etcetera, etcetera. And so I wrote that.
- 24:54And between that and the aspect, no one tells you this.
- 24:56People would say to me, don't you think that we're past this,
- 24:59that you're sort of imagining that there's a social stigma,
- 25:01that people have a problem with you not being married and not
- 25:04having kids? And I'm like, I don't think
- 25:06that, but maybe. And then JD Vance comes out six
- 25:10weeks later with Childless Cat Lady.
- 25:11And I was like, it's not my imagination.
- 25:14This is literally what is happening.
- 25:17And what's been astounding to me, not astounding, but what's
- 25:22been pleasantly surprising to me is the degree of pushback
- 25:26against him 'cause I think in 2016, plenty.
- 25:30And I covered, you know, I was a politics reporter for a while
- 25:33and I covered the 2008 election with Hillary.
- 25:36And obviously 2016, it was like there was plenty of insults
- 25:41along these lines being hurled at Hillary, right?
- 25:43Like the ball crusher, the this, this and that, like awful things
- 25:45said to her that sort of made waves but didn't.
- 25:48So when he said that, my first inclination was like, oh, this
- 25:51is just another sort of dumb insulting thing that is coming
- 25:55from the usual sources and the absolute push back against it
- 26:00from all corners. And you know, Taylor Swift's
- 26:03endorsement, all of it has been incredible to me in terms of
- 26:09reflecting the degree, the amount of women living lives
- 26:13like this who are like, not just offend, like, like deeply
- 26:19offended not, and like, not offended, like person like Judy
- 26:22Vance thinks that, but offended the idea that this could be a
- 26:25political platform, that there's offended at the idea that
- 26:28there's something to feel shame about, I guess is more what it's
- 26:31about. Like, why would this be?
- 26:34Why wouldn't I want the cat? What is it about the behavior of
- 26:37men in America right now that suggests that I wouldn't prefer
- 26:40the cat with like the whole that's.
- 26:41That's exactly. It the bare meme that was going
- 26:43around to wow, you know, earlier this summer of like, would you
- 26:46rather meet a man or a bear in the woods or whatever it is?
- 26:48So that's been incredible to me actually.
- 26:50And that it aligns with like themes in the book.
- 26:54Just I was on occasion made me want to write my publisher and
- 26:57say I told you that, well that. There, there, there was a
- 27:01question, actually I had a couple of, I put out a sort of
- 27:05call on Instagram if people had any questions they wanted to ask
- 27:08you. And actually, I think most of
- 27:10those people are are here, including someone who asked to
- 27:14your point about writing to your publisher.
- 27:18I do love my my I'm the most amazing editor so I shouldn't.
- 27:21I so maybe this maybe that plays into why they were so keen to
- 27:24have your your proposal from the from the beginning, but how was
- 27:27it received by your, your agent and your publishers?
- 27:30You know, were they open to tapping into this theme or were
- 27:35they nervous that this was maybe sensitive terrain?
- 27:39So my last. Book No one tells you this,
- 27:40which is about turning 40 and not being married and not having
- 27:43kids and it both being great and also being the prime caretaker
- 27:47for my mother who was dying at the time, and a bunch of other
- 27:48family stuff. When I went to sell that, it was
- 27:50against the wall of total disbelief that anyone would
- 27:53consider this an appealing story.
- 27:55So when that book did reasonably well, I was a little bit like,
- 27:58and subsequently people read that and go, I don't understand
- 28:02what's the big deal? And I'm like, that's how quickly
- 28:03things change. When I went to sell this book,
- 28:06so I'd already published a book, my agent bought it pretty
- 28:10immediately. As in understood we were trying
- 28:13to do yes. OK, when we went out with it, we
- 28:18went out. I don't get into like the
- 28:20sausage, Howard sausage, it's made of publishing.
- 28:22But we went out to like, I think like 25 editors with this
- 28:28proposal. And I want to say like 18 of
- 28:32them turned it down, which is not abnormal, right?
- 28:35It's not, that's not an abnormal experience.
- 28:37But it was the manner in which they turned it down, like a
- 28:39normal rejection from an editor would be like dear Lucy, who's
- 28:43my agent's name? Dear Lucy, thanks so much for
- 28:45thinking of this, of thinking of us for this.
- 28:49It's not for us right now. Hope you're well and would love
- 28:51to have coffee soon and hear what else you're working on.
- 28:53Like a very polite three line. Totally fine.
- 28:55That's what you expect. Of the 17 rejections, we got
- 28:59something like 14 of them were like paragraphs long rejections
- 29:04where they were like, Dear Lucy, I kept them all because I worked
- 29:08some of them into the flap copy. Like I was like, if you're going
- 29:11to write this all out, I'm absolutely using it for my own
- 29:14benefit. But they were very kind.
- 29:15But it was a lot of like, I read this book, I read this proposal
- 29:19and I changed my plans for this weekend and I re and I tried to
- 29:25do what Glynis did and, and like prioritize pleasure, but
- 29:30actually we're just not sure how to sell this book.
- 29:32So we can't. So like, it was a lot of like,
- 29:34and it was making Lucy insane because she said there's
- 29:37nothing. A lot of times when people take
- 29:38that much time to say no, they'll tell you what they
- 29:40think's wrong with it. She was like, there's no
- 29:41feedback here that we can work with to like re reconfigure this
- 29:46proposal. And I said, I'm not surprised,
- 29:48but so there was a lot of that. But that told me that we're
- 29:51hitting a nerve and that publishing sometimes is not
- 29:55ready, adventurous, overly concerned.
- 29:59But the editor we got, we, it went to auction with like 3
- 30:01editors and they all got it, which was a good place to be.
- 30:04But it was a lot of like people not quite knowing what to do
- 30:10with it even though they liked it.
- 30:12And I think part of that wasn't just pleasure.
- 30:13Part of it is it doesn't have like a traditional narrative
- 30:16art, which I addressed very directly in the book, just
- 30:21because the reviewer was like, there's no instigating action.
- 30:25And I was like, I literally say that in.
- 30:29The opening although is that. Is that entirely true?
- 30:31I mean, you had a. Year of your.
- 30:34House without being touched. I feel like that's.
- 30:36Quite a that's instigating, yeah, it's very instigating.
- 30:41So there was a lot of that. It was a lot of like, it was
- 30:42clear it was hitting a nerve, but no one quite knew what to do
- 30:45with it. And and then we landed with the
- 30:47right person. As as any agent will tell you,
- 30:50you only need one editor to say yes.
- 30:51But when you're in the process of being so it said no to 25
- 30:54times in a row, you're like. Pretty demoralizing.
- 30:56Where's that editor? Somewhat just say yes.
- 31:00Exactly. But I got the best at it.
- 31:02I mean, I really was happy with with everything, so I was well,
- 31:05but. Also, that means the universe
- 31:06was sort of, yes, heading in the direction.
- 31:09For this to have air, Yeah, I was.
- 31:11It was in the air. I don't know, like it doesn't
- 31:13always happen. No, no.
- 31:15But like, now when people are talking about how Kamala Harris
- 31:17is, you know, running the Joy campaign, I'm like son of a
- 31:21spot. Joy is next to player right?
- 31:25It is a it's yeah, sensual yourself, Kamala, enjoy
- 31:29yourself. But it's definitely, I think a
- 31:31lot of women in particular came out of COVID and women with
- 31:35children. I mean, many of my friends are
- 31:36children. I would say that in the
- 31:37beginning of the book or just like hate everybody and then
- 31:42they feel guilty and I'm like, you're the 10th person to tell
- 31:44me that this week. So you're not alone.
- 31:46But I think there was a lot of like a Why are we working so
- 31:48hard? But I think it's a very
- 31:50interesting moment. You've captured also the
- 31:52starting point. You also speak about freelance
- 31:55writing. And as a fellow freelance
- 31:57writer, it's lots of feelings involved in that.
- 32:02And I wanted to. Then this connects to the last
- 32:04question, which comes from Kim. Is Kim here?
- 32:08Is there Kim? Yeah, maybe.
- 32:10Hey, Kim, you asked me this question, right?
- 32:13OK. All right.
- 32:14So she, she's sort of curious. Beside the besides the success
- 32:20of your books, what do you think is the most satisfying part of
- 32:24the writing process, whether it's for books or your your
- 32:28essays? And what is your least favorite
- 32:31part? Because this is more of a
- 32:34process question that I think is very interesting because you do
- 32:36all sorts of type, you know, all sorts of writing.
- 32:39I think this answer would have been different 5 or 10 years
- 32:44ago, and I'll tell you what. But for me, the most satisfying
- 32:46part is not the first draft, which feels terrible from
- 32:52beginning to end. In my experience.
- 32:54It's just like an act of faith where you're like, oh, I'm the
- 32:56worst writer in the entire world.
- 32:58Everyone's going to find out. It's the like the revision part
- 33:02where everything falls together and you get that sense of, I
- 33:06mean, I'm not a musician, but that sense of like hitting the
- 33:08tuning fork in the piano note matches it exactly.
- 33:10Like I've matched exactly what I was thinking and wanted to say
- 33:14with the words on the page. Like I am clearly articulating
- 33:17my idea and maybe have even come up with like a better version of
- 33:21it by writing it down. So that for me is the most
- 33:23satisfying part. Like the most satisfying part of
- 33:25this was when I sort of handed in that final, somewhat final
- 33:29draft. Like the there's so many errors
- 33:31in the galley that you have like, but mostly it was mostly
- 33:34where I wanted to be and I felt really happy about that.
- 33:37I think five years ago I would have said having it go out in
- 33:41the world and having other people resonate, which is
- 33:43incredibly pleasurable. I'm so grateful when when people
- 33:47tell me that, you know, they recognize themselves in it or
- 33:50they this, you know, this was so important to them.
- 33:54But publishing a book these days in the environment we're in,
- 33:59with the absence of of budgets and publishing houses where so
- 34:02much of the work falls on the writer to like Colin Favors and
- 34:04do your own publicity has become exhausting to a degree that it's
- 34:08removed somewhat of the pleasure of putting a book out in the
- 34:10world. The hustle train, the hustle,
- 34:12the hustling of your own book. And when you're hustling a
- 34:14memoir, it's sort of like, I'm sure hustling for everyone is
- 34:16terrible, but it's just, it's a lot of asking people to do
- 34:22things for you, which can become just exhausting.
- 34:25And that sort of removes, at least in that initial sort of
- 34:29month, the first month the book is that removes sort of the
- 34:31pleasure of having it resonate so much because you're just in
- 34:35this narrow, you know, six months later, I think it becomes
- 34:38enjoyable again. But for me, it's the right like,
- 34:40not the again, the first draft is awful.
- 34:42If anyone's in a first draft being like, this is terrible,
- 34:44I'm like, it's terrible for everyone.
- 34:45No one likes the first draft. And that's true for articles.
- 34:48It's not just true for books. It's, you know, you put words.
- 34:51On when I write articles, I make myself put a first draft down,
- 34:54even if it doesn't make sense, just so I have something there
- 34:56that I can come back to and work with.
- 34:58First drafts are torturous. Well, it just makes you doubt.
- 35:02Yourself. Yeah.
- 35:03Like why don't I work for a corporation?
- 35:07It's not something I think often, but definitely like and
- 35:10like one paragraph into the first draft of something.
- 35:12I'm like, this was a bad life decision.
- 35:15But clearly not no at the. End of the day, it's not.
- 35:18You have enjoyed yourself. And you're still enjoying.
- 35:20Yourselves and you're all here. Can we give?
- 35:22Before we go to questions, let's give a.
- 35:25No applause for goodness. That's the show for today.
- 35:33Thanks for listening. As always, if you're streaming
- 35:36this on Spotify, be sure to check out a little poll that
- 35:39awaits. You pertaining to this
- 35:40discussion. Just Scroll down on the episode
- 35:43page within the app and vote. And if you enjoy the show, I'd
- 35:47love it if you'd subscribe, share with a friend, and pick up
- 35:50the books that inspired it. The new Paris and the new
- 35:53Parisien. Until next time, Abiento.