Latest / Film And Whiskey / Whiplash / Sazerac Rye 18 Years Old
Transcript
- 0:00In 2014, director Damien Chazelle and star JK Simmons
- 0:05gave the world an emotionally devastating exploration of what
- 0:09it takes to achieve greatness. In 2024 we try a rye that could
- 0:15be in class with Miles Teller. The film is.
- 0:18Whiplash. The whiskey is Sazerac Rye.
- 0:23And we'll review them both. This is the film and Whiskey.
- 0:27Podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:48podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:51glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:53I'm Brad Gee. And Brad, it is week #5 of
- 0:57season #9 here on Film and Whiskey.
- 1:00This season, what we're doing is we're looking at films from the
- 1:03last 20 years, and we're considering whether or not they
- 1:06deserve to be called modern classics.
- 1:09These are films that have either shown up on the IMDb Top 250,
- 1:13the Letterbox Top 250, have grossed $100 million at the US
- 1:17box office or have been nominated for best picture or
- 1:21some combination of of those categories.
- 1:24And I believe our movie for today, Whiplash, which is just
- 1:27celebrating its 10th anniversary, checks three of
- 1:32those boxes. It didn't.
- 1:34It didn't check the box office box but I think it's in all the
- 1:38other 3. I I was gonna say, I think it's
- 1:40pronounced whiplash. Whiplash.
- 1:43Yeah, that's that's correct. I forgot that.
- 1:46I forgot the emphasis over the H.
- 1:48Yeah, if the if the marketing team had done a better job, it
- 1:50probably would have made more money.
- 1:52If it was known as its proper pronunciation, yeah, sure.
- 1:55But Bob, I am not in awe that this didn't make a lot of money.
- 2:00Like when you look at the lineup of best picture nominees for
- 2:04this year, it's a wild time it. I mean, it's going up against
- 2:08juggernauts like American Sniper.
- 2:11What? What were a few of the other
- 2:13ones 'cause I like as I was looking at it.
- 2:16I thought for two seconds that you'd actually done your
- 2:19research and you were like, I listened to this list and then
- 2:21you named one movie and said, what are the other?
- 2:26Ones I I trust you Bob, to know the other.
- 2:28Nominees. Oh, man.
- 2:29OK, let's see. Giving you a chance to shine.
- 2:32Let's see, off the top of my head, the winner of Best Picture
- 2:34this year was Birdman, which means it was also up against the
- 2:38movie Boyhood. It was up against this movie.
- 2:40It was up against American Sniper.
- 2:43Maybe The Imitation Game was this year.
- 2:47No, the theory of everything was must have been this year.
- 2:49I don't freaking know. Yeah.
- 2:51Yeah. Anyway, this was a good year for
- 2:53movies, and Whiplash may be the best one.
- 2:57Question mark. Far and away the best one you
- 3:00think better. Better than Birdman, better than
- 3:01American Sniper. I I love both of those movies.
- 3:05Bob, this is a better film. You know what's really cool
- 3:09about this movie, Brad? And and we'll get into other
- 3:12things we need to get into in a second here, but they literally
- 3:15right after we announced the lineup of movies for this
- 3:18season, I pulled up my Regal app one night because I wanted to go
- 3:22see a movie and I want to see what was playing.
- 3:24And they were doing a whiplash 10th anniversary re release.
- 3:28And I was like, hell yes, I went right that night and watched
- 3:32this movie in theaters. This thing still plays like
- 3:35gangbusters, dude it and I'm so glad I saw it in the theater
- 3:38again. It was freaking awesome.
- 3:40Yeah, and this is not quite. It is almost in the halls of the
- 3:47storied 90 minute movie. I mean it's like barely an hour
- 3:52and 40 minutes, which like I'll give it credit if a if a movie
- 3:55ends at 1:39, I'll call it a 90 minute movie.
- 4:00Not quite there but man oh man this film moves so fast and has
- 4:070 fat on it and just I want to see it in theaters so.
- 4:11Badly, Bob, Every time I return to this movie.
- 4:15And so over the last week or so since I went to the theater and
- 4:17saw it, I've been thinking about what I want to say on this
- 4:21episode. And I keep thinking I need to go
- 4:23back and listen to the first time we recorded this because
- 4:26surely this is a revisit episode for us.
- 4:30Somehow we made it to Season 9 without talking about Whiplash,
- 4:33Brad. So it's it's kind of crazy, but
- 4:35it makes me feel kind of nostalgic and puts me in that
- 4:40like Season 1 mode of film and whiskey.
- 4:43And what's even crazier is that you told a story about your
- 4:48first time seeing this movie, and it included a name that
- 4:51listeners of this show have not heard since season 1.
- 4:54Brad, why don't you clue us in a little bit to who our guest is
- 4:57today? Bob, today we are bringing the
- 5:00absolutely illustrious. One of my greatest friends in
- 5:04the world has seen me through thick and thin.
- 5:08Jordan Andrew McCain. Jordan.
- 5:12Wow, wow, wow, wow, wow. How?
- 5:13You doing man? Doing good.
- 5:15I thought this was a podcast for Drumline.
- 5:18That's what I watched to get ready.
- 5:20Is that not? That's not correct.
- 5:24That would be a perfect. Let's make it a double though.
- 5:27That it sure will. OK.
- 5:28That's the one. Nick or drumline?
- 5:31Nick Cannon is good. Nick Cannon's good Nick Cannon
- 5:34probably had kids in in Miles Teller's class in this movie
- 5:38too. So there you go.
- 5:40Oh man, it's all connected somewhere.
- 5:41Yeah, not comment. Jordan, we literally have not
- 5:44seen or heard from for mucin season 1.
- 5:46So I'm glad that the missing persons report we filed worked.
- 5:50You're you're home safe. Everything's going well.
- 5:52Here's the here's the back story of Jordan being in season 1.
- 5:56Brad and I decided to start a podcast and we said, hey, let's
- 5:59record some episodes together. And this was in the pre using
- 6:03Zoom as a socially acceptable means of recording days I.
- 6:07Think we recorded on like a a speakerphone like we did.
- 6:13A conference call microphone. That's all we.
- 6:15Have to record on call, Mike. The 1st 4 episodes of film and
- 6:18whiskey were filmed were recorded in a church basement
- 6:21and Brad showed up on the day with Jordan and was just like
- 6:25hey Jordan's coming he's just gonna hang out and work while we
- 6:29do 8 hours of recording today I'm.
- 6:32None of us had kids. No, Yeah, that's true.
- 6:37I would say I'm pretty sure I let you know that that Jordan
- 6:39was going to record with us. I might not have.
- 6:41No, what you said was Jordan is coming, but he's totally cool
- 6:45with just working while we record.
- 6:47And so we were like I said, dude, we absolutely not.
- 6:49I'm just going to, I'm not going to make him sit over in the
- 6:51corner and listen to us ramble about four movies.
- 6:54So Jordan was our first guest host on two of the 1st 4
- 6:58episodes, I believe it was 12 Angry Men and Inglorious
- 7:02Basterds. So dude, you are like 3 for
- 7:06three on picking great movies to join us for.
- 7:08These are three of my, I mean, these are a lot of my favorite
- 7:11movies. I just say, Brad, you're
- 7:13bringing me along, assuming I'm just going to do this.
- 7:15It's a very Terrence Fletcher, Fletcher move.
- 7:18It's just like, oh, we're I'm going to make it happen.
- 7:20We're going to make greatness happen.
- 7:22Yeah, I will say Jordan and I's relationship over the years has
- 7:27been tumultuous at times and so I thought it appropriate that he
- 7:31come join us for Whiplash. If if you recall Jordan, you
- 7:37were a massive fan of Whiplash, absolutely love the movie and
- 7:42every time our friend group in seminary would get together to
- 7:44to watch a film, you would suggest Whiplash.
- 7:48And what was my response generally?
- 7:51Oh, you mean the movie with JK Rowling?
- 7:55JK Rowling, It's, you know, what's crazy, though, is I think
- 8:01that JK Rowling has verbatim tweeted some of the things that
- 8:05JK Simmons says in this movie. So it really does all connect,
- 8:08yeah. I will if you like a pig.
- 8:11Yeah, something about something along those lines.
- 8:15All right, guys, let's dive into talking about the movie itself.
- 8:18And in order to get that conversation going, it's time
- 8:21for our first segment of the day, which we call, Brad
- 8:24Explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 8:26movie plots with only 60 seconds ticking on the clock, so let's
- 8:29go ahead and do your take with this little segment that we
- 8:33call, Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 8:35show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 8:38just seen, often for the first time.
- 8:41Brad, what's the watch counter at on Whiplash for you?
- 8:46Probably this was my fifth or sixth time.
- 8:49Oh man, this is like at the upper reaches the upper limits
- 8:54of the bell curve for you A. 100% yeah.
- 8:56And honestly, like Jordan had tried to get me to watch it for
- 9:00probably 2 years before I finally sat down and watched it.
- 9:05Jordan, I don't remember. Jordan is the first time I
- 9:07watched it. Was it with you or did I watch
- 9:09it on my own? I think you watched it on your
- 9:12own. Oh man, I'm sorry dude, I should
- 9:14have watched it with you. Wow, riveting stuff, guys.
- 9:16OK, so Brad explains. Brad, you have 60 seconds to
- 9:21breakdown the plot of this film. This is going to be full of
- 9:24spoilers, folks. So if you've not seen Whiplash,
- 9:27first of all, we've already given you our recommendation.
- 9:29You need to hit pause here. Go watch the movie and then
- 9:32rejoin us, Brad. One minute and go.
- 9:35Whiplash, also known as Whiplash, is a film about a
- 9:40young drummer named Andrew Niemann who is at a prestigious
- 9:44music Academy in New York City. His drug is being great and JK
- 9:50Simmons plays his teacher Terrence Fletcher, who is his
- 9:53drug dealer. That's it, huh?
- 9:58That's what we're going to. Bro, if you haven't seen
- 10:01Whiplash, go watch it. It's really good.
- 10:04Like it's an hour and 40 minutes.
- 10:06People, I just want you to watch this movie.
- 10:09So the director of this film, Damien Chazelle, kind of bursts
- 10:13on the scene with this movie. Chazelle is a trained jazz
- 10:17musician and filmmaker, and he carved out his little niche in
- 10:21filmmaking by making a short film version of Whiplash that
- 10:25was kind of his proof of concept.
- 10:27He submitted it to a bunch of film festivals as a way of
- 10:30trying to to secure funding for the full length film.
- 10:33They actually got JK Simmons to be in the short film version of
- 10:37Whiplash. It's pretty cool if you've if
- 10:39you've never seen the short film, it's essentially that
- 10:42first extended sequence of Are you going to be on My Time?
- 10:46And that's like, that's the movie really, really great.
- 10:49Little short film builds a lot of tension and Chazelle pretty
- 10:53quickly establishes himself as a young master of the craft.
- 10:58He then goes on to make La La Land because they gave him a
- 11:00bunch of money. After La La Land, he makes his
- 11:03Neil Armstrong biopic First Man, and then he makes Babylon, which
- 11:07was a colossal flop. And people are in interesting
- 11:10places on Chazelle now. I think that they they still
- 11:12look at him as a guy with tremendous talent and the
- 11:16ability to take a big swing. But I'm going to be honest, I
- 11:19don't know if he's ever topped this movie.
- 11:22Like this is such an economical movie, both in like how they
- 11:26spend the budget and in how there's no fat on this thing at
- 11:30all that it's it's kind of hard to find a way to one up this
- 11:35movie, even one of the with a movie like La La Land, that goes
- 11:38for excess. I don't know if it beats
- 11:41Whiplash for me, Brad. Yeah, there is.
- 11:45I don't know if we've ever watched a movie on this podcast
- 11:49that has a more clear through line throughout the film.
- 11:56Yeah, like I like, I just, I really can't think of many
- 12:00movies that are more dedicated to the main story, the main
- 12:05thrust of the film, and just never, ever strays from what the
- 12:11movie is all about, which makes sense because that is what the
- 12:14main character is doing throughout this movie.
- 12:17Yeah. I mean, trying to think of a
- 12:20movie that is as focused. Yeah, I it would be 1.
- 12:24I mean, it's in my top 10. It's one of those that really
- 12:27epitomizes a perfect story structure.
- 12:31And even although I will say for me, because of the things that
- 12:35brings up in me when I was even trying to draw the story
- 12:39structure of like what is the climax of this movie?
- 12:41I'm not 100% certain that it's not supposed to be the end.
- 12:46But if you talk about the scenes that are like the best in this
- 12:48movie, you're like, is there anything other than the ending
- 12:52of this movie that is one of the greatest moments?
- 12:55Like instant. It is just so intense and then
- 12:58it pop. Yeah, I mean, you're right.
- 12:59It's just hard to believe. It's a perfectly structured
- 13:02story, but it doesn't follow like the three act structure.
- 13:04It doesn't have like the rise and fall kind of denouement at
- 13:07the end of the movie. It's more like a freight train
- 13:10that gets moving and then can't stop.
- 13:12And Chazelle even commented on how he wanted to make the
- 13:16original short film kind of echo a sense of dread that he had by
- 13:21being in this kind of high stakes jazz band, which is a
- 13:24hilarious sentence to say I was in the high stakes jazz band.
- 13:27You don't understand, man. But but dread is what this movie
- 13:32does really well. I watched this movie in theaters
- 13:34back in 2014 and I walked out of it.
- 13:36And I remember posting like, this is the most terrifying
- 13:39movie I've seen in a long time. Like it was, it's it's scary to
- 13:44watch how this movie brings up that sense of tension, of
- 13:48suspense, of dread within you, and it doesn't let up.
- 13:52And then, depending on your interpretation of the ending,
- 13:54gets even more horrifying at the end of the film.
- 13:58Also, the idea of posting like, like grandpa.
- 14:01Tell us about what it was like to post on Facebook in 2014.
- 14:05Do you? Remember when Facebook statuses
- 14:09used to like come with the word is pre programmed, be like Brad
- 14:12G is and then you were supposed to finish the sentence.
- 14:17A book is afraid of JK Simmons. 100% man, still to this day.
- 14:23OK, let's let's start talking about the film itself.
- 14:27I want to start with Miles Teller, who prior to this movie
- 14:31had really only made maybe one film that people had seen and
- 14:35started hyping him up for. It was a small indie movie
- 14:37called The Spectacular. Now, he was really good in that
- 14:40movie, and then he comes out with this and I remember walking
- 14:43out of this movie and thinking like that dude is going to be a
- 14:45movie star. And I think some.
- 14:49Then he was in the Fantastic Four fan.
- 14:51Four stick. Yeah, it it did not go well for
- 14:54him, I think partially because he has a low key reputation for
- 14:59being kind of difficult. But then also he made a a couple
- 15:04movies that just did not work. And his big return to form was
- 15:08supposed to be Top Gun Maverick, which was supposed to come out
- 15:11in I think 2019 and then got delayed by almost three years.
- 15:15So by the time Top Gun Maverick comes out, we really hadn't
- 15:18heard from Miles Teller on a major scale in a couple years.
- 15:22I would really like to see him kind of continue the momentum of
- 15:26Top Gun Maverick and and find his footing again, because I do
- 15:30think that he's one of those young actors, similar to when we
- 15:33talked about Shia LaBeouf, Brad, that like he had the raw kind of
- 15:39rage within him that he could channel really, really well.
- 15:42And now that he's older, I want to start seeing him fine tune
- 15:45it. And I think he deserves to be a
- 15:48star. I just don't know where do you
- 15:50guys kind of consider him in the Hollywood star tier ranking now?
- 15:57Would you consider him like an A Lister or where would where
- 16:00would he fall in that kind of ranking?
- 16:03Yeah, I, I would love to hear your reflections walking out
- 16:07that made you feel that way. I he is not the I mean, as bad
- 16:10as it sounds, he's not the person I think about his acting
- 16:14when I walk out of this movie. Like I think he's good.
- 16:17And in some ways he is the moon reflecting the sun.
- 16:20Like he does a good job punching a drum and being very upset.
- 16:26And he even says that he's upset at a certain point.
- 16:28But I, I did not walk out thinking like, man, that guy is
- 16:33going to make it someday. It's just like, wow, this was a
- 16:36really good role for him. But wow, JK Simmons is a really
- 16:40good actor. That's all I could ever think
- 16:42about when I watch this movie. Yeah, I was going to say, I
- 16:46think I'm kind of with Jordan on this one.
- 16:48Like Miles Teller is very good in this movie.
- 16:51I think that he has a brooding intensity about him that like
- 16:56ramps up throughout the film until you get to the car crash
- 17:01sequence, which is almost feels reminiscent of our very first
- 17:05episode, the the Goodfellas drug sequence.
- 17:09And I think, I think Teller really knocks it out of the park
- 17:12here. But I, I am just going to say
- 17:16there's no better way to describe it.
- 17:18He is the moon reflecting the sun.
- 17:20That is JK Simmons. Yeah, I, I'm with both of you.
- 17:23I I also think that watching a film of an up and Comer 10 years
- 17:28ago and being able to identify like he's got it, this isn't
- 17:32this isn't it yet, but he's got it within him is very different
- 17:36than now. Revisiting it after seeing him
- 17:38in more movies and kind of just improving his craft.
- 17:42I'm I'm with you that there's a few scenes where I'm like, oh,
- 17:45he's still young. Like he's, he's still not quite
- 17:48there on JK Simmons level. Even even the I'm upset line
- 17:54where when he's screaming and it's like, oh, this is not
- 17:55believable. But aside from that, he has to
- 17:59be in every single scene of this movie.
- 18:01Like there is no scene in the film that he is not in.
- 18:04Everything is told from his perspective.
- 18:06And I think for being on screen for the entirety of the film, he
- 18:10anchors it down pretty well because if he was going to be as
- 18:13big and over the top as JK Simmons is, this movie would not
- 18:17work. It would just be a shouting
- 18:19match. Yeah, I I think that he he has a
- 18:23talent for holding back until the very end there.
- 18:27There's just little moments that you want him to be a better
- 18:31actor. But I, I guess when you look at
- 18:35his overall career, because that's where this conversation
- 18:38kind of started, Bob, I don't know if I've ever thought of
- 18:41Miles Teller as a great actor. Like I've other than Whiplash,
- 18:46I've never seen him in something and gone man, that guy's going
- 18:51to be a movie star. And if I'm being blunt with you,
- 18:53Bob, it's because he's like an above average actor with below
- 18:57average looks. And that like, if that's a
- 19:01recipe for success in Hollywood, then I, I don't know what we've
- 19:04been watching for 100 years. It is pretty funny the bar that
- 19:07we set for people's looks in Hollywood though, 'cause I think
- 19:10he is a generally good looking guy.
- 19:13He's just not movie star Hans, He's not Glenn Powell, you know
- 19:17what I mean? Like you put him next to Glenn
- 19:19Powell. Sure.
- 19:20I would say he's no Jordan McCain.
- 19:23We'll, we'll just put it that way.
- 19:24He is. Whiplash.
- 19:26With Glenn Powell, that could be something that could be a crazy
- 19:30remake. Glenn Powell could have been
- 19:31like the the Irish guy that is that's like the third up on the
- 19:35drums that he makes fun of that would that would have been a.
- 19:37Perfect Glenn Powell role. I love the line 'cause it
- 19:40reveals like a lack of self-awareness for Fletcher JK
- 19:45Simmons character but I love the line when he goes.
- 19:49Connelly was just a a tactic to get you motivated.
- 19:52It's like, yeah, man, we, we all, we all got it.
- 19:56We we were there. We saw.
- 19:59So I think that this could really quickly devolve into all
- 20:02of us just saying how good JK Simmons is over and over and
- 20:05over. And it would be deserved if we
- 20:08did that for him. But I think I just kind of want
- 20:12to talk around the character for a little bit.
- 20:15This is a character that I don't think we should reduce down to
- 20:18He is a villain or he does bad things or whatever, because
- 20:23there are there are elements of his character that are
- 20:25legitimately like some of the insults he says are the funniest
- 20:30things I've ever heard anybody say.
- 20:31Like he is clearly inflicting emotional abuse upon so many
- 20:36people. But then you're like, God, man,
- 20:38this guy is so good at insulting people.
- 20:41Like when he when the the fat trombonist is looking down at
- 20:44the ground and he's like, what? What do you there's not a
- 20:47fucking Mars bar down there? Like it's the best line in the
- 20:50movie. I love it.
- 20:51I I think the thing that I am most fascinated by is the
- 20:56philosophy that he puts forth and so clearly believes in and
- 21:02the like the charisma that he utilizes to enforce that
- 21:07philosophy is like fascinating. And, and the more I thought
- 21:10about Jordan joining on this episode, the more I was like, I
- 21:15feel like he is the perfect person to talk about how
- 21:19dangerous and flawed having a philosophy such as Terence
- 21:25Fletcher's, that the only way to get greatness is to ridicule it
- 21:31into existence, to demand it into existence, to violently
- 21:36right like. You're you're challenging it,
- 21:38you're trying to coax it out of someone by needling them into
- 21:43showing it, essentially. Yeah, and I just, I, Jordan, I'm
- 21:46going to throw you either under the bus or maybe up on top of it
- 21:49like a champion. I think you should talk about
- 21:52that because I, I think that, yeah, your wisdom in the area of
- 21:57Terence Fletcher's philosophy on greatness would be great,
- 22:01greatly appreciated. I mean, I'm from Indiana and
- 22:04Bobby Knights are hero, so that's the only way to go in my
- 22:08opinion is that's how you create great people.
- 22:10Listen, the results speak for themselves, man. 100 percent,
- 22:14100% no. I mean, that is the thing about
- 22:19trials and tribulations, or however you want to put it.
- 22:21Trauma really is what it is. Like I'm, you know, we're all
- 22:25from the Midwest. And so I remember I have no
- 22:29experience with jazz. And as 3 white men, we can all
- 22:32just acknowledge that that's maybe isn't our area of
- 22:34expertise. But I remember watching this for
- 22:38the first time and being like, hey, somebody goes, this is a
- 22:42jazz drumming movie, you should watch it.
- 22:43And I'm like, sweet. So they're in this beautiful
- 22:45stately practice area. And then JK Simmons begins
- 22:50saying things I've heard, like in my football locker room,
- 22:56right? Like, just like tearing these
- 22:59people apart. And I remember it brought me
- 23:03back very viscerally to moments of like, what's going to happen
- 23:08at the end of this pump up speech?
- 23:12Like, are these 1819 year olds who are getting ready for the
- 23:18game, are they going to respond and yell and like go out there
- 23:21and kick butt? Or are they going to realize
- 23:24they're being verbally abused and roll over?
- 23:27And, and it's, it's a fine line because if you respond well to
- 23:31it, the ends will always seem to justify the means.
- 23:34And I think it's very accepted and normal.
- 23:36I think that that gets old pretty quick, but it actually
- 23:39is. It can be work really well when
- 23:41you're young and you just want it that badly.
- 23:44I think we all lose our tolerance for that as we age
- 23:47would be my guess. I don't know your guys
- 23:49experiences have been. I mean, I remember viscerally
- 23:549th grade basketball, we lost to, I think it was North
- 23:59Ridgeville, a team that we never should have lost to.
- 24:03And Coach Siciliano, this like 5 feet.
- 24:09He said he said, raging Italian man.
- 24:11He said you. Lose at the game, you know, get
- 24:14at a pizza. That's what he said, right?
- 24:16He he was very Italian. He had do you do you know those
- 24:21like the mini water bottles that have like 4 ounces in them?
- 24:25He whipped one of those suckers against the chalkboard and it
- 24:30stuck in the chalkboard. He he like hit it with the cap
- 24:37and it stuck in the chalkboard and he kept screaming.
- 24:39And then he said. And then he said, did you know
- 24:41that Charlie Parker got a symbol thrown at his head?
- 24:44This water bottle will bring out the greatness in you.
- 24:48Exactly. Yeah.
- 24:49So 100%, man. I think the fascinating thing
- 24:54that this movie does is that it sets the backdrop of this older
- 24:59student who had been abused by JK Simmons against the story of
- 25:05Andrew Niemann. And so even as the film ends, I
- 25:09like I this didn't happen to me the first time or even the
- 25:11second time. But the last few times I've
- 25:13watched this movie, as soon as the movie ends and Whiplash hits
- 25:17the screen, I think about that student who killed himself 5-6
- 25:22years later and I'm like, oh, Neiman is headed down that same
- 25:26track. Oh, 100%.
- 25:27And so this is actually where I think the movie succeeds the
- 25:31most is not in the scenes where he is humiliating people
- 25:35publicly. It's when he's kind of like
- 25:38working the back channels in between things and he's trying
- 25:41to be buddy buddy with Andrew and asking about his mom and
- 25:44dad. And then you come to find out
- 25:45five minutes later, he only cares about the mom and dad so
- 25:48that he can have ammunition to use.
- 25:50But that final scene that they have in the bar after Andrew has
- 25:55already, you know, ratted him out, basically, there's such a
- 26:00weird combination of things he's saying to Andrew that are
- 26:04complete lies and things that are complete truths about
- 26:07himself. That's that's the scene where
- 26:09you get his philosophy about himself and his teaching style.
- 26:12And it's also the scene where he starts kind of stroking Andrew's
- 26:16ego again to get him to accept this invitation to play at the
- 26:19end of the film, which is all an elaborate ruse to sabotage
- 26:24Andrew one last time. It's freaking crazy.
- 26:26This guy is an absolute psychopath.
- 26:28But you buy into the world that they've created.
- 26:32And I think that this is kind of where I want to go for the next
- 26:35little segment, guys, 10 years on from the movie, I'm, I'm
- 26:40wondering like, as I'm watching it, how is this aging?
- 26:44Like, is it a little? Does it feel a little dated in
- 26:47an era where we're like, post me too now and Me too hadn't even
- 26:52happened when this movie came out.
- 26:54I just don't think anyone in this day and age would like Gen.
- 26:56Z would get away with like, slapping a student repeatedly in
- 27:01class. And so you you kind of have to
- 27:04take off your 2024 goggles in those early scenes and either
- 27:09get on board with the world of this movie, which is slightly
- 27:13exaggerated, or it's not going to work for you.
- 27:16And I will say that like, once I got on board with, you know
- 27:19what, whether this would happen in the real world, I think that
- 27:23they do a plausible enough job with like, hey, everyone knows
- 27:28it's happening, but nobody will say anything.
- 27:30And once they kind of established that, I was bought
- 27:32in again. And I'm just kind of wondering
- 27:34like, did you guys have that layer of disconnect from the
- 27:37movie this time around or are you like all the way bought in
- 27:40from the beginning? I don't know, man.
- 27:43I, I have heard enough stories now, and not just the Bobby
- 27:48Knights of the world that are big and famous.
- 27:51I, I, I've heard enough stories and I've seen enough people like
- 27:54this. I've listened to the rise and
- 27:56fall of Mars Hill. I I don't think this exaggerates
- 27:59anything like not not to like completely contradict.
- 28:04Your point, Bob I no, you're right.
- 28:05You're right. Like, I think stuff like this
- 28:07happens way too often when you get these insular, insulated
- 28:13worlds where a narcissistic personality is allowed free
- 28:20reign because he does bring about greatness and he brings
- 28:23home trophies from these competitions and he produces
- 28:27some great musicians. It's like, OK, well, we're just,
- 28:30you know, it's just Fletcher being Fletcher.
- 28:32I like, I don't know, I, I never once thought that this was, like
- 28:36an exaggerated world. It it felt eerily too similar to
- 28:42a real world, for me at least. I see both.
- 28:46I think I would agree with Brad that I imagine it's happening.
- 28:52I don't know if anything changes more than it just shifts in
- 28:57where it's located or what happened.
- 28:59So maybe it's not happening in this version of Juilliard or
- 29:02whatever their school is, but it's probably happening in small
- 29:06town, whatever Ohio, right, Like probably happening there.
- 29:11What I think is interesting that I think is different in 2024 is
- 29:16the thing I hear most consistently from people working
- 29:19with young folks when it comes to coaching or teaching, is the
- 29:24level of like emotional resilience in young people is on
- 29:29such a decline that like, I don't know if how many students
- 29:33would even show up for this jazz club team, whatever it is, but
- 29:37jazz band, that's how much I know about jazz.
- 29:41I don't know what it's called, but I don't know how many would
- 29:44show up after three sessions because they would be so
- 29:47discouraged so quickly that they would just quit.
- 29:50Now, again, that's also contextual, situational, but
- 29:53that's like the most consistent thing I hear, even at college
- 29:57levels is like, kid strikes out, he goes to the dugout and he
- 30:00thinks he's the worst baseball player who's ever lived as
- 30:04opposed to just like, yeah, dude, you just struck out like
- 30:07you. That's how that's what baseball
- 30:09is, you know? And it's just really hard to get
- 30:11them through those low points. I think actually the resilience
- 30:16for me feels crazy. I'm going to be honest, man, it
- 30:20kind of sounds like you're making JK Simmons point for him
- 30:23a little bit that like, hey, if we're ever going to find the
- 30:26next bird, you got to throw some symbols.
- 30:30These kids, these. Kids, I don't think that's
- 30:32that's not how you build resilience.
- 30:33You don't build resilience that way.
- 30:36He JK Simmons is taking advantage of resilience that
- 30:38already exists. You know this, you're not
- 30:40arguing for it, but you know, but he is taking advantage of
- 30:46whatever level of emotional maturity they have and then
- 30:49trying to strip it down and own it.
- 30:52And I just don't know how much of that even exists unless
- 30:55you're a pretty emotionally healthy family in this day and
- 30:58age. You should see how many symbols
- 31:01Jordan throws at our church. It's just.
- 31:05We, we go through so many, the budget for symbols each year is
- 31:09astronomical. So guys, before we go to break,
- 31:12I want to talk a little bit about Andrew's kind of downward
- 31:15trajectory. And this time around, you know,
- 31:18it's it's always been there in the movie and it's told like a
- 31:21Horror Story and it's told to Brad's point, like an addiction
- 31:24story. Like you could pair this movie
- 31:26up with something like Requiem for a Dream and it would make a
- 31:29super depressing but not at all dissimilar experience.
- 31:33And this time around, though, what I really found fascinating
- 31:37was how Andrew's, for lack of a better term, like
- 31:42assholeishness. I don't want to call it
- 31:44sociopathy, but his inability to get in contact with his own
- 31:49emotions and feelings and ability to process what's going
- 31:53on with him and his decision to push people away.
- 31:57It's there in the early scenes of the movie, even before you
- 32:01kind of get into the downward descent.
- 32:03So that by the time he breaks up with his girlfriend, it's just,
- 32:06it's so callous. But he does it in a way that for
- 32:09him is just, it's like, yeah, I'm going to lay out the facts.
- 32:12I'm super obsessed with this. And I can't pull myself out of
- 32:15its its clutches. And so, like, we should not be
- 32:17together anymore. And what she responds to is
- 32:20like, what's wrong with you, dude?
- 32:23How can you talk like that and not feel anything?
- 32:26And I think the movie does such a good job of establishing, yes,
- 32:30Fletcher is horrible and manipulative, but Andrew's also
- 32:35the kind of guy that here's this philosophy and is like, oh, that
- 32:39makes total sense. That's me.
- 32:40I need to do that. Yeah, I, I mean, for me, Andrew
- 32:44is like one giant trauma response.
- 32:47Like, like they said it from the start.
- 32:50His mother left them when he was a child.
- 32:53And everything from the movie flows from that.
- 32:56Like he has zero empathy for others.
- 32:59He has zero compassion for others and the only times he
- 33:05really gets emotional in the film are when he is getting the
- 33:10hit of the drug of like fighting for his dreams of greatness.
- 33:15And so the the this time through I especially noticed it.
- 33:20He plays everything so deadpan outside of his drumming career
- 33:26that the only time he gets passionate is when he's at the
- 33:29dinner table with his family who doesn't understand him and they
- 33:33are belittling him and don't don't understand his desires.
- 33:37That's when he gets passionate. When JK Simmons is like talking
- 33:41to him about his philosophy, he doesn't even get excited.
- 33:44He's still completely deadpan. It's not until he has the offer
- 33:48of drumming again that he starts to show emotion.
- 33:52And so for me, like this is a very, very classic trauma story
- 33:57of a young man who has gone through a horrific, terrible
- 34:03thing of losing a mother and the results that happened from that.
- 34:08They also do such a good job though of at multiple points in
- 34:11the movie, giving Andrew these kind of inflection points where
- 34:15for the audience, depending on how you want to read his
- 34:19character, his moments are either heroic or they're signs
- 34:23of his continuing decline into like madness.
- 34:27And that dinner table scene is such a good example because they
- 34:29set it up by his dad who dotes on him, who gives him
- 34:33everything, getting made fun of himself by his brother or
- 34:38brother-in-law. And they say he overcooked
- 34:40something and he doesn't say anything.
- 34:42And he's real meek and mild mannered.
- 34:44And then the kid says something to Andrew and Andrew's like,
- 34:48absolutely not. I'm going to, I'm going to, I'm
- 34:50going to belittle you. I'm going to tell you that
- 34:52you're at AD 3 school, that you will never play in the NFL.
- 34:56And. Tell me that's not a great line
- 34:58though, just the way he quietly goes.
- 35:00It's Division Three. It's AD 3.
- 35:02School, yeah, But it's see, as an audience member, you're like,
- 35:07yeah, he's sticking up for himself.
- 35:09He's sticking up for his dad. But what's really happening
- 35:11there is he's a like, just taking it out on the poor guy.
- 35:15But also he's just reflecting the exact type of challenge to
- 35:22that guy's greatness that he's been receiving from JK Simmons.
- 35:26And it's just really scary to see how that philosophy is being
- 35:28perpetuated. And you see that when the chord
- 35:32drummer and how he treats him as he loses the sheet music.
- 35:36Are you talking about immediately?
- 35:38Are you talking about great value, Ted Mosby?
- 35:41Yes, yeah. OK.
- 35:42Just just making sure. That's funny.
- 35:46That, that is a perfect description.
- 35:48I think his name is Tanner in the movie.
- 35:50The way he belittles Andrew is exactly what JK Simmons does.
- 35:57And so, yeah, I love those moments where you're like, oh,
- 35:59this philosophy is completely permutating the little world
- 36:04that Fletcher has created at what the Shaffer Conservatory, I
- 36:09think it's called. You notice too, that you know
- 36:13the way that Holtz work is they attempt to make you cut off all
- 36:19interaction with anyone outside of the group.
- 36:23And if you follow like the synergy of the conversation is,
- 36:28JK Simmons slowly but surely makes fun of and mocks every
- 36:33outside relationship that Andrew has, including his dad and his
- 36:36mom, right. He learns just a little bit
- 36:38about his dad and then uses that to prove he's not good enough.
- 36:43And then if you actually track, it's funny you say that Bob,
- 36:46that his dad dotes on him. Because if you track their
- 36:49conversations, every single one ends with his dad disagreeing
- 36:53with Andrew's choices. For sure.
- 36:55Which makes for an interesting like, OK, so my dad doesn't
- 36:59understand me even though he's nice about it.
- 37:01So who is going to understand me and understand what I care
- 37:04about? It's going to be this guy.
- 37:07So normally there would be a triangle for Andrew to get out
- 37:10of this or to get some anxiety out of the system.
- 37:12But instead it always goes back to parents every time.
- 37:16It just keeps going back to him and it they were like,
- 37:19inevitably drawn towards each other because of their focus.
- 37:24And it kind of creates this weird synergistic, emotional.
- 37:29What do you call it? It's codependency.
- 37:31Yeah. I mean in a lot of ways.
- 37:33And the very end of the movie, my favorite shot in the whole
- 37:36movie, is, is might not be what you expect, but he's been
- 37:40embarrassed by Fletcher on stage.
- 37:42And his dad gives him a hug and he's like, come on, let's go
- 37:44home. And then Andrew breaks away and
- 37:46goes back and again as an audience member, at first you're
- 37:49like, yeah, he's going to go stick it to that guy.
- 37:51He's going to prove him wrong. And as Andrew gets into his solo
- 37:56and become something like otherworldly and not human
- 38:00anymore, like truly monstrous on stage, they cut back to his dad
- 38:04looking through the door and like literally like shrinking
- 38:08away in horror at what his son has become.
- 38:12And it's this great because the whole movie they've been
- 38:16painting this triangle of like, is he going to go with his dad
- 38:18or is he going to go with his other perverted father figure in
- 38:22Fletcher? And this is him fully embracing
- 38:25Fletcher. And then you get the end of the
- 38:27film where he he hits the snare and looks up and it's this like
- 38:32hopeful, like, please accept me dad look.
- 38:35And then you get that like demonic smile from Simmons.
- 38:38And that's the end of the movie. And it's like, holy crap, dude.
- 38:42It's, I mean, it is dealing with so many parasocial
- 38:45relationships, codependent relationships in a way that is
- 38:48just absolutely terrifying. Am I right in calling this a
- 38:51horror film of sorts? Oh dude, 100%.
- 38:56And I think the reason Simmons wins an Academy Award here is
- 39:01not just for all the bombastic, ridiculous things that he does.
- 39:07It's for the moment that he picks up the symbol that Neiman
- 39:12has dropped, has knocked over. Dude.
- 39:16The way he picks that up and looks at Neiman, it's as if.
- 39:21It's completely, it's like, it's like he has locked in on this
- 39:24guy as a peer and then they're just like bro and out together
- 39:27and it's almost creepier to see him being friends with this guy.
- 39:33It's a completely different character than you've seen in
- 39:34the whole movie. Well, it, it feels like almost
- 39:38like a maternal mothering, like like here you go, here's your
- 39:42toy. I'm going to take care of you.
- 39:44I'm here to nurture you. I like, I can't communicate the
- 39:48ickiness that I felt watching him put that symbol back up.
- 39:53And like, it's moments like that why you hire JK Simmons and why
- 39:59he wins an Oscar. Yeah, also if you need pictures
- 40:01of Spider Man, you can hire him too.
- 40:03Like those are really the two reasons you hire the guy.
- 40:07You know who I think of it. It hit me as we've been talking
- 40:11about him, I think of JK Simmons and Willem Dafoe in a very
- 40:16similar category of like some of the absolute best actors that we
- 40:21have that don't give an absolute RIP about Academy Awards, about
- 40:26making money. They just love the craft of
- 40:30acting. Well guys, on that note, I think
- 40:32it's a good time for us to hit pause.
- 40:34Brad and I have to go drink some very pricey whiskey and then
- 40:38after we're done doing that. The the horrors.
- 40:41I'll tell you what the things we do for you, film and Whiskey
- 40:44Nation. After that we'll come back and
- 40:46I'm going to give my let's make it a double way early because I
- 40:49want to talk about it with you guys.
- 40:51Brad, what do you say we drink some whiskey?
- 40:52I am ready, Robert. Let's get to it.
- 41:00All right. Today we are continuing our trip
- 41:03through last year's Buffalo Trace Antique Collection.
- 41:06We've now done three of them, which means we have two left.
- 41:09And the fourth one in our list is Sazerac Rye.
- 41:13Now, Brad, we have tried the much cheaper alternative to this
- 41:17Sazerac rye, which is known as colloquially as Baby Saz.
- 41:22That's the one you can get for like 30 bucks.
- 41:24But because it's made by Buffalo Trace, even that is sometimes
- 41:28hard to find. We did that way back in like
- 41:30like season 2 or 3. So this is not that.
- 41:33This is the Sazerac 18 year whiskey and this particular
- 41:36bottle is coming in at 18 years and five months old.
- 41:41Brad is. So it was bottled.
- 41:44I'm sorry it was barreled in like May of 2005.
- 41:51Dang, think about the world in 2005, Bob.
- 41:54I was finishing up my freshman year of high school.
- 41:56Sure was. Yeah, Iraq going on kind of a
- 42:00big deal. Like, it's not the Iraq war,
- 42:04it's just Iraq. Iraq was happening, you know, it
- 42:07was the nation of Iraq. Have you ever tried Sazerac ride
- 42:13before, Brad? Like the the big boy here.
- 42:15I don't think I have I I think this is my first time in and I'm
- 42:18curious about this 90 proof point.
- 42:21Yeah, they water it all the way down to 90 proof.
- 42:23It's something to do every year and that's probably because when
- 42:28you look at the fact sheet on this, because it's so old, 74%
- 42:32of the initial volume has been lost to evaporation.
- 42:35So only 1/4 of the barrel is remaining.
- 42:38They frankly, they could probably sell this for more than
- 42:41they do given how old it is. It was 135 proof off the still
- 42:45barrel entry proof was 125. So I have to imagine what was
- 42:49left in the barrel was like hazmat level, so they would have
- 42:52had to water it down anyway. But 90 proof, that's what we're
- 42:55working with here today, man. Yeah.
- 42:57And I, you know, based on what they do with the stag and what
- 43:03did, what did we have last week, the Weller, Like, I don't know,
- 43:07I think he probably could have kept it at 135 proof and I
- 43:10would've been fascinated at what that whiskey tastes like.
- 43:13All right man, let's dive in. I'm really excited.
- 43:15I literally just poured this out and as I'm pouring it into my
- 43:18glencairn, I got a whiff from 2 feet away of honeydew and
- 43:24cantaloupe. This is super melon heavy.
- 43:27I'm going to let it kind of calm down a little bit in my glass
- 43:30while you give your nosing notes, Brad.
- 43:32I think once it settles down, it actually mellows out into this
- 43:36really nice. There's brown sugar, there's
- 43:40cinnamon, there's like a freshness of the rye and mint
- 43:45flavors coming through, and it really just kind of reminded me
- 43:48of like a nice cinnamony Raisin bread with a little bit of that
- 43:52fruitiness coming in. I think this is an absolutely
- 43:57stellar nose. I'm going to give it a nine and
- 43:59a half. I like this a lot.
- 44:01There is something like it's really complex and there is a
- 44:05significantly more aroma than I would expect from a 90 proof rye
- 44:09and that is obviously due to it being 18 years old.
- 44:12There's a note in here that I can't quite put my finger on.
- 44:15It's that sort of yeastiness that we get on younger rise, not
- 44:21even like too young, like a one or two year old, but like a four
- 44:24year rye. And some of that is still
- 44:25hanging around here, which is really interesting to me because
- 44:28I would have expected this to be a much more kind of concentrated
- 44:33potent nose. And everything you're saying is
- 44:37here. But then there's just this one
- 44:38little whiff of like, huh, this tastes like, or this smells like
- 44:42an 18 year old rye with just a hint of like a four year old rye
- 44:46in it. So I'm a little bit lower than
- 44:48you. I'm going to give it an 8 1/2 on
- 44:49the nose. Yeah, and I think the palate,
- 44:53there is a lot of really nice flavors here.
- 44:56I think that youth comes out in a little bit of a straw flavor,
- 45:00but the the mint comes through nice and strong.
- 45:03The rye is all there. It's a little bit Clovy, some
- 45:07vanilla really punches through and it and it kind of reminded
- 45:10me of like like a cream cheese icing that you put on a cinnamon
- 45:14roll that like there are some really nice, beautiful fit
- 45:18flavors here. And it just confirms to me again
- 45:21that the best Ryze out there are a mixture of the really nice,
- 45:27beautiful minty rye notes with a depth of and richness of flavor
- 45:35with that that cream cheese icing and vanilla and a little
- 45:39bit of brown sugar. I think this is a stellar
- 45:42palette that I'm going to give a nine out of 10 to.
- 45:45All right, dude, Are you ready for this?
- 45:46I think, I think I'm going to have my first really spicy take
- 45:50on VTAC. I'm let down by this like a lot.
- 45:56So I keep a little bottle of whiskey next to our kind of
- 45:59recording station here that I use kind of as my baseline.
- 46:03Like if I, if I don't feel like my palate's quite ready to start
- 46:05tasting whiskey, I'll have just a, a little sip of that to kind
- 46:10of set a baseline expectation for what whiskey does on my
- 46:13palate. And I drank that and then I
- 46:16started drinking the B tack. And this is, this is much more
- 46:19sour. Obviously it's rye.
- 46:21So like I'm expecting it to have a little bit of those sort of
- 46:24like mint and dill notes. But the youthfulness that I
- 46:28picked up on the nose, which does not make sense.
- 46:31Like this is 18 years old. It is not young.
- 46:33It carried through to the palate for me.
- 46:35It's a little bit too sour. It's a little bit too grassy and
- 46:40I think what, what'd you say? Straw?
- 46:42Straw's a good note here, but it doesn't bring any sort of
- 46:46caramel notes. It doesn't bring even, it
- 46:49doesn't even tip into like dill or mint.
- 46:51It just kind of has a really strong earthy tone.
- 46:54And I feel like the rye grain is swallowed up in this kind of
- 46:58sourness. Now.
- 47:00There was a slight hint of those like grandma strawberry candies
- 47:05that I got. And I was like oh interesting,
- 47:072nd sip it was gone again. I'm really really disappointed
- 47:11in this man. I'm just going to give this a 7
- 47:12out of 10. Yeah, you are way off from where
- 47:16I'm at because I I think that there are some really beautiful
- 47:20flavors here. I think as I got into the
- 47:22finish, the rye really finishes things out nicely.
- 47:26It turns a little bit vegetable. The leather starts to come
- 47:29through with the age. It has a little bit of an
- 47:31apricot kind of fruity type of flavor that lingered for a long
- 47:36time. It is a really long, mellow
- 47:40finish that I am all about. I like I'm sticking in this 9
- 47:45zone Baba. I'm at a nine and a half on the
- 47:47finish. Yeah, man, we have had a lot of
- 47:49really great rise on this show, and this is just not one of them
- 47:53for me. I mean, it's it is fine, but
- 47:56it's surprisingly one note. And that note is just kind of
- 48:01grassy. So if you're into an earthy
- 48:03flavor, it does kind of remind me of like an entry level Scotch
- 48:09in that regard. Like it, it has that sort of
- 48:12earthy barley flavor to it. It just doesn't remind me of a
- 48:15good rye. And it's a little bit bitter, a
- 48:17little bit sour. It has kind of that toasted oak
- 48:20note that I don't like sometimes where the toast on the instead
- 48:25of the char, the toast on the barrel can impart a kind of sour
- 48:27flavor. This is not doing it for me.
- 48:29Man. B.Tech, what the hell?
- 48:327 out of 10. Jeez, yeah, I think balance
- 48:36wise, we're at a nine out of 10. I think there's a decent amount
- 48:40of complexity here. It is not the most complex of
- 48:43the B tax. I I would say that so far this
- 48:46is the least complex and that's why I'm only at a nine.
- 48:50But I think the flavors you do get are awesome.
- 48:55Awesome is a very generous term and I'm, I'm going to say, for
- 48:59me at least, decidedly not awesome.
- 49:02I'm going to go ahead and give this just a 7 out of 10.
- 49:04Again, I like, I don't want to tip into value yet my value
- 49:08score is going to be horrifically low on this.
- 49:11Brad, I I mean, can we at least agree that this is a step down
- 49:17from the last two weeks? Yeah, I I do think that, I think
- 49:22that if this was in the hundred 110 proof range, it would be
- 49:27much, much better. I'm going to give it.
- 49:31I'm going to give it one more sip.
- 49:32This is your last chance, Sazerac, Because there's
- 49:34something within me that's like, I cannot, I can't give a $1500
- 49:38whiskey this low of a score. But I'm I'm pretty sure I'm
- 49:40going to. Well, while you're doing that,
- 49:43I'm going to go into value I I think that this is not as good
- 49:47as the rest of the lineup. It's just too expensive for
- 49:53something that's proofed down to 90.
- 49:55Like I said, I don't mind that they proof it down.
- 49:57Like you lost a lot in evaporation.
- 50:00Add a little water, take it from 1:30 down to 115, one O 5, but
- 50:05all the way down to 90. I think that it restricts the
- 50:09amount of notes that you can have on it.
- 50:12There's not quite enough complexity.
- 50:14I'm going to give it a 6 1/2 on value, like in the category of
- 50:19luxury whiskey. I think this is an OK value, but
- 50:23not something that's going to knock your socks off.
- 50:26Yeah, my, my suspicions are confirmed here.
- 50:28This just has kind of a generically almost mass produced
- 50:33vodka kind of flavor profile on the front of the palate where
- 50:37you can tell that there's ethanol and then some sort of
- 50:40not very well done grain mixture.
- 50:44And then on the back of the palate it gets really bitter and
- 50:48herbal. And that's fine for some things,
- 50:51but it kind of, it almost had the effect of like when you and
- 50:55I have met up with our buddy Chris Blattner and done malort
- 50:58shots with him. Like there's, there's that sort
- 51:01of not even quite black licorice annis, but the Super bitter
- 51:05herbs on the back end of a malort are on the back of my
- 51:08palate right now. This is not great.
- 51:10And I have been giving B.Tech a baseline score of five out of 10
- 51:16on value because I just don't think that I can go any lower or
- 51:19higher on any of them. This one has proved me wrong.
- 51:22I can go lower than five. I'm going to give this a three
- 51:25out of 10 on value, which is bringing my final score to a
- 51:2832.5. Brad, where are you?
- 51:32I am 11 points higher than you. I'm at a 43.5.
- 51:37I don't know if we've ever had a season where you and I have been
- 51:41so divergent. Yeah, yeah, this is a massive
- 51:45difference in opinion. I mean, I like, I love Ryze.
- 51:48I think that this offers so much of what rye can do.
- 51:52It just needs to be like 15 proof points higher and I would
- 51:56be in that upper echelon 45 plus.
- 51:59I was going to say our our last two weeks have been approaching
- 52:02the 90 mark, which is just an excellent whiskey, not just
- 52:06great, but truly excels. And this week we're at a 38 out
- 52:10of 50 due to my low score. Now I will say like I think that
- 52:15score does represent that both of us agree that this is a step
- 52:19down from the last two weeks. Whether you think it's a good
- 52:21whiskey or not, I don't know that this belongs in the price
- 52:26echelon of the other B.Tech offerings.
- 52:30Like I'd probably be a little less harsh on this if this sold
- 52:33for MSRP and not for 10 times MSRP.
- 52:37But this kind of seems like the the odd one out of the line up
- 52:41so far. Here, I'm going to be honest
- 52:43with you, Bob, I'm looking back at my scores.
- 52:45I gave the WL Weller a 40 out of 50.
- 52:49So I like, while like just memory serving me, I feel like I
- 52:53liked the Weller more. I scored it 3 1/2 points lower
- 52:57than the rye. So I I do like this rye a lot.
- 53:00I think it's a really good whiskey.
- 53:03You know what is good, Brad? What's that?
- 53:05This the 2014 film Whiplash. What a film.
- 53:10What a freaking movie. We should have used JK Simmons
- 53:14little one liners as as notes on our.
- 53:19Oh that would have been perfect. Man.
- 53:21I Is he like the greatest villain of all time?
- 53:24He's, I mean, he's certainly the most villainous villain.
- 53:28He's so good. All right, man, let's get back
- 53:30into talking with our friend Jordan about whiplash.
- 53:33What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 53:40All right, everybody. That was Sazerac Rye from the
- 53:432023 batch, a whiskey that hits the spot.
- 53:47But man, that's a lot of money, Bob.
- 53:50It's a lot of money, man. Didn't quite do it for me.
- 53:52Not quite my tempo, Brad. No, not, not not quite my tempo.
- 53:57He doesn't he doesn't so good to the first like 6 times.
- 54:00Not, not not quite my. Tempo and it's it's the fact
- 54:03that he does it like 6 times, just completely calm, completely
- 54:07loving. To the point where you, well,
- 54:09and you can tell by like the third time he's screwed with
- 54:11him. And then it's like right before
- 54:14he jumps up to were you rushing or were you dragging anyway?
- 54:21Well, hey man, Speaking of being right on tempo, your boy is
- 54:25four. And oh, this season at our next
- 54:28game, which we call 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 54:32He's going to try to stump you. Ball 2 are right and what is
- 54:37wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 54:42and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 54:44with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 54:48which is a complete lie and I have to guess which one that is.
- 54:52Now I have a ringer on hand today.
- 54:55Jordan McCain, expert in parasocial relationships.
- 54:58So hopefully all the questions are about that sort of thing and
- 55:01not actually about the making of the movie.
- 55:04They're all about family systems theories.
- 55:06Who knew? What does the DSM five say about
- 55:10dot dot dot? If you asked me a question about
- 55:13why the DSM 4 was better than the DSM 5:00, I could go on
- 55:16about that all day. I saw a meme on Instagram the
- 55:20other day that was like, girl, you're the you're the kind of
- 55:23girl that they write books about.
- 55:25Then the next page was a picture of the DSM 5.
- 55:31Jordan, has it been explained to you how this process works?
- 55:36I think so. I think I get it.
- 55:37I'm not going to say anything unless you ask.
- 55:40Yeah, yeah. So Brad is a stickler with this.
- 55:42When we have a guest on the show, I can seek your counsel.
- 55:46But once I seek your counsel, even if I choose a different
- 55:50answer than what you gave me, he considers that I have received
- 55:53your counsel. So if I get the question
- 55:56correct, I get one victory, but if I get it wrong, I get 2
- 56:00losses for having been LED astray by our guest.
- 56:03Yeah, it, it's kind of like the the game show the the three
- 56:08doors theory where if I, if I show you the open door and you
- 56:12switch, you have a higher chance of winning.
- 56:13I if you seek advice, you have a higher chance of winning.
- 56:16So it there should be some stakes here.
- 56:19All right. Well, Brad, hit me with your two
- 56:21facts and a falsehood. Fact #1 Director Damien Chazelle
- 56:26took some jazz drumming lessons for six months to better
- 56:30understand the intricacies of jazz drumming as he had already
- 56:34been trained on piano and bass guitar.
- 56:38Fact #2 Though a visual double was used for certain sequences.
- 56:43All of Andrew's drumming was performed by Miles Teller
- 56:45himself to pre recorded tracks. Approximately 40% of Teller's
- 56:50actual drumming made it into the final soundtrack.
- 56:54Fact #3 JK Simmons brought a personal connection to his role
- 56:58in Whiplash, having his own musical background.
- 57:01His mother was a middle school music teacher, and his father
- 57:04served as the director of the music department at the
- 57:06University of Montana, where JK himself earned a degree in
- 57:10music, lending authenticity to his portrayal of his role as
- 57:15Terrence Fletcher. I'm not sure about #3 #2 sounds
- 57:20kind of true, Jordan, and I'm just saying, Jordan, because I
- 57:23want to bounce ideas off of you as I watch your facial reactions
- 57:26to what I'm saying. I'm pretty sure that counts as
- 57:29asking for no. Come on.
- 57:31I'm not. I haven't asked anything.
- 57:34Let the record reflect. I haven't asked for a thing yet.
- 57:37I am pretty sure that Chazelle was a drummer, not a pianist.
- 57:45And so I'm kind of thinking Brad tried to pull one over on us a
- 57:48little bit. And I'm a little bit tempted to
- 57:51say #1 is the falsehood? Because I'm like 95% sure
- 57:56Chazelle tried to do jazz drumming, was not very good at
- 58:00it, and then gave it up to become a film maker.
- 58:03That's why I needed lessons. Come on, dude, have you seen La
- 58:07La Land? You see how much piano is in
- 58:09that movie? You're telling me Chazelle is a
- 58:12jazz drummer? Honestly, here's the thing guys,
- 58:15I have never not sought the counsel of the guest.
- 58:18Mostly because it makes for horrible audio to just talk at
- 58:21the guest and then never allow them to respond.
- 58:24So Jordan, you're in this with me now.
- 58:27Aside from #1, did anything else stand out to you as a potential
- 58:30falsehood? I would agree with you.
- 58:34AK Simmons does have a degree in music and I did know that Miles
- 58:40Teller, I knew he had been drumming.
- 58:44So I I think a lot of his stuff was used.
- 58:46I don't know, number one would strike me as the thing I know
- 58:49the least about. That seems the most suspicious
- 58:52to me. All right, then I think we're
- 58:53going to lock it in, Brad. I'm I'm staking my reputation,
- 58:56my four. No record on this.
- 58:58Number one is the falsehood. Jordan, you were correct.
- 59:03Miles Teller has been drumming since he was 15 years old, so a
- 59:09lot of his stuff was in fact used.
- 59:11And Bob, you were also correct about fact #1 being the
- 59:16falsehood. I don't know if he was a jazz
- 59:18drummer. I know that he was a jazz
- 59:19musician based on my research. Well, let's pull it up here and
- 59:24see, see if it's on his Wikipedia.
- 59:26As I do that, let's get back into talking about the movie,
- 59:29guys. And I said that I was going to
- 59:31spoil my let's make it a double film really early.
- 59:35And I think it's because it is so pertinent to the conversation
- 59:38that we've been having. I'm going to pair this movie
- 59:41with the 8 hour excessively long documentary The Last Dance that
- 59:47came out a couple years ago about Michael Jordan and the
- 59:50Chicago Bulls. Because Brad, I've been telling
- 59:53you ever since that documentary came out, first of all, it's an
- 59:55absolute glazed job on Michael Jordan.
- 59:58Like there it was like not objective at all.
- 1:00:01However. I think it did such a good job
- 1:00:05of unintentionally giving you an insight into what that mentality
- 1:00:11does to a person. Jordan just comes across as the
- 1:00:15most bitter, unforgiving, maladjusted old man who cannot
- 1:00:21let go of past slights that were either real or invented.
- 1:00:26And that kind of Mamba mentality that is so often praised among
- 1:00:32the greats in a sport. You know, Kobe had it, Michael
- 1:00:35had it. They always say LeBron doesn't
- 1:00:36have that mentality. And I always look at that and I
- 1:00:39say, well, like, it kind of seems like some of these guys
- 1:00:43just have their priorities in line.
- 1:00:45Like you could be great at something and not be a horrible
- 1:00:50person in every other facet of life.
- 1:00:52And I guess I kind of just want to explore with you guys.
- 1:00:54Why is it that you think or what is it do you think is so
- 1:00:58appealing to consumers, to fans, especially in the area of sports
- 1:01:04where this obsessive consumed mentality is lauded in a person?
- 1:01:11And you know, why do we continue to celebrate it?
- 1:01:15I think it's simplicity man. Like humans crave simplicity in
- 1:01:21life and it's so easy to say, well, they're great because they
- 1:01:27cut everything else out and they spend all their time in the gym
- 1:01:32and they, they don't lose track of what will make them great.
- 1:01:35They they have that killer instinct.
- 1:01:37And it's just this simple answer that like massages the part of
- 1:01:42our brain that wants everything to be obvious.
- 1:01:46And I like, I think it's way more than that.
- 1:01:49And I also think that we celebrate greatness in one area
- 1:01:56at the expense of a million other areas.
- 1:02:00Yeah, I was going to say in the first half, but Bob, it's so
- 1:02:05funny you call this a horror film because I love that you
- 1:02:09emphasize that. Because every time I watch this
- 1:02:12movie, all I can think of is Andrew did it like he did the
- 1:02:17thing, like he lived up to the expectation.
- 1:02:21And that's what my this will tell you all the viewers and you
- 1:02:23guys, everything you need to know about me.
- 1:02:26All I can think of is like, he did it, he got to Nirvana or
- 1:02:31whatever like that idea is. And I think it's because
- 1:02:37competency is authority and authority authoritarian
- 1:02:41structures, bigot authoritarian structures, bigot authoritarian
- 1:02:44structures. So like, I watched The Last
- 1:02:47Dance too. Michael Jordan does not come
- 1:02:49across as a in a personal way, as a good person.
- 1:02:54But there is not a single basketball player who will ever
- 1:02:57be like, yeah, but we don't like him or like he has.
- 1:03:01No, he has no say on the game. They're like, no, he's kind of
- 1:03:05still the king. And that's what they're going to
- 1:03:09say about Andrew, is he was formed in an authoritarian
- 1:03:13structure that made him as competent as humanly possible.
- 1:03:17And someday, if he doesn't kill himself, he will be the king of
- 1:03:21jazz drumming that some other budding musicians going to
- 1:03:26listen to. And his and his headphones,
- 1:03:29right? Just like he was like, I want to
- 1:03:31be like a bird, right? Like, I want to do it.
- 1:03:35I just think that that's so appealing depending on how your
- 1:03:37brain works. And I just when I think about
- 1:03:40this movie, I think about how hard it is for young people to
- 1:03:48see that life is more than a few moments.
- 1:03:52Like at the end of the day, this movie shows Andrew sacrifice
- 1:03:58family relationships and future, you know, relational, you know,
- 1:04:04getting a wife relationships. Like he has sacrificed 2 of the
- 1:04:09primary things that our society has said.
- 1:04:13These are paths towards a well lived life, right?
- 1:04:16Having a healthy family, finding a good spouse who loves us and
- 1:04:20cares for us. Like he sacrifices all those on
- 1:04:24a on a path to greatness. And at the end of the day, we
- 1:04:28saw what might have been his greatest moment ever as a
- 1:04:33musician. And to chase those singular
- 1:04:37moments of greatness is to sacrifice a lifetime of
- 1:04:43well-being and a journey towards health and healing and all these
- 1:04:46things. And you sacrifice all that for
- 1:04:49this one moment of greatness where this demon looks on at you
- 1:04:54with a motherly love. And, like, that's freaking
- 1:04:58terrifying. Yeah.
- 1:04:59Well, I keep calling it a horror movie.
- 1:05:01It's probably not an accident that this movie was produced by
- 1:05:04Blum House Pictures. I don't know if you guys saw
- 1:05:06that on the credits, but Blum House known for making low
- 1:05:09budget horror movies, they have become like the horror studio
- 1:05:12over the last 10 years. And it's partially because they
- 1:05:15just find low budget movies that they believe in and they end up
- 1:05:20being super profitable for them. But this movie cost $3.3 million
- 1:05:24to make. It made $50 million at the
- 1:05:26domestic box office. Not bad and I think watching it
- 1:05:30this time I'm so impressed with Chazelle both in like the
- 1:05:34kinetic camera work of his filmmaking in this movie, but
- 1:05:38also as a writer. And I think the the huge success
- 1:05:43of this film is that it does not spoon feed you exactly what to
- 1:05:46think about the people in this movie.
- 1:05:48JK Simmons is an obvious villain.
- 1:05:50Like he is one of the most demonic and quite quite frankly
- 1:05:54like scene chewing villains in the history of villainy.
- 1:05:57However, like, you can still have that moment of Andrew did
- 1:06:02it at the end of the movie like he's on the mountaintop.
- 1:06:06And it makes me feel even ickier as an audience member that I am
- 1:06:10rooting for the demise of someone's soul in real time.
- 1:06:16And Chazelle does such a good job of allowing you to feel the
- 1:06:22tension of both of those things without telling you which is
- 1:06:25right to feel and which is wrong to feel.
- 1:06:28Fred, I'm just wondering, like from a film making perspective,
- 1:06:31what were some of the techniques that you noticed this time
- 1:06:33around? Like what?
- 1:06:34What was Chazelle doing that signaled to the world that he
- 1:06:39was like a a young force to be reckoned with here?
- 1:06:43I think it's his ability to a hone in on people's faces.
- 1:06:49Like anytime a director can draw a beautiful performance out of
- 1:06:55his actors with super close-ups is always impressive to me, and
- 1:07:02it's his. I think it's his sound design,
- 1:07:04like the ability he has to give you these wildly, violently loud
- 1:07:10moments of musical expression paired with so many quiet
- 1:07:17moments throughout the film of Andrew having quiet
- 1:07:20conversations with Melissa, what's her last Benoit, I think,
- 1:07:27or with his dad put, you know, Paul Reiser.
- 1:07:30I like, I think that there's just so many small moments
- 1:07:34throughout the film that allow the big moments to shine that I
- 1:07:38like. I think Chazelle is on to
- 1:07:41something here. And like I said at the start, he
- 1:07:44never allows anything to distract the camera, the sound
- 1:07:48design, the acting, the script, like nothing distracts from this
- 1:07:54manic thrust towards the finish line.
- 1:07:58There's only a few things in the movie too.
- 1:08:00If we're talking about the way the movie shot it's, it works
- 1:08:03really well because it's low budget and they do a good job of
- 1:08:06capturing like the griminess of New York City.
- 1:08:08But everything has that sickly green hue to it of neon and
- 1:08:14streetlights. And there's only a couple
- 1:08:16locations in the whole film that have a different color palette.
- 1:08:20You see it really early on in the concession stand where his
- 1:08:25future and then former girlfriend works.
- 1:08:28And it's because it's like the object of Andrew's desire.
- 1:08:31It's where he feels the most sense of comfort and longing.
- 1:08:34And like, that's where he finds, for lack of a better term, like
- 1:08:37belonging. Like, he wants that girl.
- 1:08:41And then you find it in the classroom of JK Simmons.
- 1:08:45Like, there is a weird warm tone to that classroom that doesn't
- 1:08:49exist anywhere else. And then you finally get it on
- 1:08:53stage at the end of the movie when he starts his solo and the
- 1:08:56lighting changes there. And it's like a very obvious use
- 1:08:59of color. But it also does such a good job
- 1:09:02at getting into the psychology of this character and how he
- 1:09:05doesn't feel comfortable anywhere else.
- 1:09:07He doesn't feel like he belongs anywhere else.
- 1:09:09He clearly doesn't want to be anywhere else than just in those
- 1:09:12few places because he is like putting all of his identity eggs
- 1:09:17in that basket. All right guys, I've I've been
- 1:09:22going on Jordan's over here falling asleep.
- 1:09:25We got to get to Jordan here. And I think in order to do that,
- 1:09:27it's time for our last segment of the day, which we call let's
- 1:09:31make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:09:33episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 1:09:37Let's have another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:09:39struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 1:09:41day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:09:43Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:09:46movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 1:09:49feature. Jordan, I've already called you
- 1:09:51out, so we're putting you on the spot here.
- 1:09:54I've given my Let's make it a Double.
- 1:09:55What would you pair Whiplash with?
- 1:09:58There are only three movies where at the end of the movie as
- 1:10:01soon as the credits roll, I have thought to myself I would really
- 1:10:05like to watch that again immediately.
- 1:10:07They are Whiplash, Inception and then the movie.
- 1:10:13I would suggest for the double feature if you want a more
- 1:10:15positive tone is La La Land. I would pick La La Land.
- 1:10:18Very similar feel. I love musicals.
- 1:10:22It'll very much get you into a better headspace.
- 1:10:24Still like a little bit depressing but far less of like
- 1:10:28the manipulation. If I can add a second since you
- 1:10:31added the last dance because this popped into my head
- 1:10:33immediately. If you want to feel just as bad
- 1:10:36or worse about excellence, I would watch FXS the Bear.
- 1:10:44If you watch the Bear, it has a very similar philosophy to
- 1:10:49pursuing Exodus or excellence, pursuing excellence at the
- 1:10:53expense of yourself. And it is just as intense and it
- 1:10:58feels just as icky at times. But then there are still those
- 1:11:02moments of like, these are the greatest chefs ever and they're
- 1:11:07going to do it like they're going to nail it and it's going
- 1:11:10to be amazing. It's just a really fun way to
- 1:11:13watch it. So I would go in either of those
- 1:11:14directions, just depending on how you're.
- 1:11:16Feeling all right, Brad? The gauntlet has been thrown
- 1:11:20down. Those were some good picks.
- 1:11:21I didn't know where else to put this in Bob, but do you want to
- 1:11:24know when I knew that Andrew Neiman?
- 1:11:26Neiman was like the real protagonist of the movie.
- 1:11:30I do not. It's the moment when he looked
- 1:11:34at his father and said, I don't want the Raisinets, I'll just
- 1:11:38see you around them. I was like, take that Bob,
- 1:11:43Raisinets suck. Dude raisinets are really good.
- 1:11:47The fact that you haven't even tried them to form your opinion
- 1:11:50is what's most frustrating about it.
- 1:11:53You're like they suck and I am basing that on nothing but
- 1:11:56vibes. Yes. 100% that That is what our
- 1:12:00country runs on, Bob. If I were to pair this with
- 1:12:05another film, it is going to be depressing, it is going to be
- 1:12:09manipulative, it is going to be 1 Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest.
- 1:12:14Oh, interesting. What's your what's your
- 1:12:16reasoning there? Nurse Ratched?
- 1:12:21Oh, yeah. Good one.
- 1:12:22OK. I was thinking the Jack
- 1:12:23Nicholson route. I was like, yeah, I don't think,
- 1:12:26I don't think anybody in this movie gets lobotomized, do they?
- 1:12:28But yeah, great pick. All right, so we've got some
- 1:12:34really good explorations of the human psyche.
- 1:12:37We've got one floor of the Cuckoo's Nest.
- 1:12:39We've got The Last Dance, La La Land and the Bear for your Let's
- 1:12:44make it a double options. Let's make it a quintuple.
- 1:12:47Yeah, right. Today's Let's Make It a Double
- 1:12:50was brought to you by Blackwood Distilling Company, Kentucky's
- 1:12:53distillery specializing in toasted barrel bourbon and rye.
- 1:12:57No matter what movie you pick, you can always make it a double
- 1:13:00with Blackwood Distilling Co Brad, let's get into final
- 1:13:04scores here. I like there are tiny, tiny
- 1:13:09flaws in this film. There were like maybe one or two
- 1:13:12scenes where I thought, oh, maybe they could have taken a
- 1:13:15different line reading from Miles Teller or maybe we
- 1:13:18shouldn't have had him get hit by a semi truck.
- 1:13:20But even the semi truck thing, which I thought would be a hang
- 1:13:23up for me in the context of watching it this time, I was
- 1:13:26like no, that's like the next logical step on his quest to
- 1:13:29make it to the thing on time. This is a 10 out of 10 dude.
- 1:13:34This is a perfect movie. Like you said, No 10 out of 10
- 1:13:40movie we have ever scored that that way is actually a perfect
- 1:13:44movie because there is no such thing as a truly perfect movie.
- 1:13:49But when you look at the story that this is telling, the
- 1:13:54underlying philosophy that it's examining the economy of film
- 1:13:59usage, to get this in in under an hour and 40 minutes at like,
- 1:14:05this is a hell of a movie, Bob. And it's easily a 10 out of 10
- 1:14:09for me. Watch Jordan just come in here
- 1:14:12and be like, yeah, it's a 6 1/2 I.
- 1:14:15Don't know, I'd give it like a solid 3.
- 1:14:19No. No, it's been in my top five,
- 1:14:21top ten. I don't know whatever ranking
- 1:14:24systems we all use, but I go back to it frequently.
- 1:14:28It's one of those when you really want to get back in touch
- 1:14:30with good storytelling, you just kind of tap it on the shoulder
- 1:14:33and learn and good character development.
- 1:14:36You know, there's some movies with great cinematography, great
- 1:14:39story, maybe not the best characters, but this is a very
- 1:14:42much a character driven drama that just really hits you where
- 1:14:46it counts. Wait, did you give it a score?
- 1:14:50I'd give it a 10 out of 10. Solid 10 out?
- 1:14:52Sure. I heard I heard the
- 1:14:53descriptiveness but I need a number man this this is a
- 1:14:57quantitative podcast. I don't.
- 1:14:59I don't believe in numbers. Yes.
- 1:15:03I'd give it a caravan out of Claire de Lynch.
- 1:15:08Yep. How many times have you guys
- 1:15:11like been in the shower since watching this movie though and
- 1:15:14just started being like, it's so freaking good.
- 1:15:20It's like it's. I'll tell you a shameful fact is
- 1:15:23after the last time I watched this movie with Brad and some
- 1:15:27other guys, I bought an electric drum set and I have been, I'm an
- 1:15:31amateur drummer ever since because I was just like, it just
- 1:15:34makes something happen for me to be able to do it.
- 1:15:37So I I cannot play any of those riffs or anything, but it is a
- 1:15:41magical feeling. I so want to watch a cut of this
- 1:15:44movie where they just CGI in an electric drum set instead of a
- 1:15:48like a real kit. And so you just hear like,
- 1:15:54that's all you hear the whole slapping sound.
- 1:15:57Yeah. It would be a lot of slapping.
- 1:16:00There'd just be a slapping sound.
- 1:16:03Guys, this has been whiplash. We want to say thank you again
- 1:16:05to our friend Jordan McCain. Jordan, don't stay away for five
- 1:16:08years next time. Man, this was wonderful.
- 1:16:10It's good to see you. You let me know, I'm always
- 1:16:12available. We always offer this other
- 1:16:14guess. Is there anything big coming
- 1:16:16down the line for you? Where can we find you, Jordan?
- 1:16:20Another another kid on the way. What's going on?
- 1:16:22I'm barely present on social media.
- 1:16:25Don't look for me. This is the most exposure I've
- 1:16:28had in a long time. Well, Brad, we are going to
- 1:16:31continue a small run of movies with one word in the title next
- 1:16:35week with the 2019 Best Picture winner.
- 1:16:38We're talking about Bong Joon Ho's Parasite, so join us for
- 1:16:43Parasite next week if you want to let us know what you think of
- 1:16:45Whiplash. By the way, you can find us on
- 1:16:47any of our social medias, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
- 1:16:51Tiktok, YouTube at Film Whiskey. Or you can join the conversation
- 1:16:56on Discord, a platform where the conversations stay private and
- 1:17:01we have an opportunity to talk about things that we all love
- 1:17:03and care about, like movies, whiskey, and almost anything
- 1:17:06else. So if you want to join the
- 1:17:08conversation, you can find a link at the end of any single
- 1:17:12one of our show notes. Join us for Parasite next week.
- 1:17:15Happy Halloween, everybody, and until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:17:19I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.