Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA in 2025: What to Expect & How It Affects You
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today I am flying solo and I am calling this podcast something like
- 0:10what I expect from NCUA in 2025.
- 0:13In preparing for today's show, I took some notes going back and looking at NCUA's
- 0:22Agenda from their board action taken in 2025 and am gleaning based on the Trump
- 0:30administration and the Helpman leadership.
- 0:33What may or what may not happen in 2025 compared to 2024.
- 0:40When you go back and look at 2025.
- 0:43They had canceled two board meetings.
- 0:46So that was one takeaway.
- 0:48They canceled the March, 2024 board meeting, which was the first time in
- 0:53a long time that that had happened.
- 0:55And they canceled the June, 2024 meeting.
- 0:58So this was under then chairman Todd Harper, who is now a board member at
- 1:02large, although he came close to being named vice chair, and you can check out
- 1:07some of my past podcasts for discussions on why that may have blown up anyway.
- 1:12It things continue to blow up at the board level, but I'll get to that here shortly.
- 1:17All right.
- 1:18They canceled 2 board meetings and they held for N.
- 1:22C.
- 1:22U.
- 1:23S.
- 1:23I.
- 1:23F.
- 1:23share insurance fund briefings.
- 1:25I report on those quite a bit here and on linked in because that's 1 of the few
- 1:30windows to generic camel code ratings.
- 1:34You can see when camel code ratings go up and they did 4 of those.
- 1:39in 2024.
- 1:40I'm expecting they'll do four of those in 2025.
- 1:44They did one cyber security update briefing and they did a new charter
- 1:50update and briefing and tip to what I might say in the future.
- 1:54I think there will be more briefings because I don't think the board
- 1:57will be acting on much because I don't think the board is currently
- 2:00getting along because of the kerfuffle on NSF and overdraft fees.
- 2:07All right.
- 2:07So other things they did they did a proposed succession planning rule
- 2:12and a final succession planning rule.
- 2:15They did an incentive based compensation proposal, which I
- 2:18think will go nowhere in 2025.
- 2:21That was put out there because Biden's administration required it from all.
- 2:25Banking agencies and under the Trump administration there will
- 2:29be less or zero regulation.
- 2:30And I don't see them wanting to put proposals in on incentives.
- 2:35If you'd know what I mean.
- 2:37In July, there was a loan rate ceiling approval to.
- 2:41re approve utilization of the 18 percent rate.
- 2:44That's what they do every time.
- 2:46The trade associations come out saying you should allow that to go up or you
- 2:50should make it based on variability.
- 2:53If NCOA was ever going to raise it, it would have been last
- 2:57year and or the year before.
- 2:59They didn't seize that opportunity because they thought it would have
- 3:02been egregiously harmful to credit unions and credit union members.
- 3:06I disagree with that, but they will vote on that again because they have
- 3:09to vote on it and they will likely just do what they've done umpteen years in
- 3:14a row, which is reaffirmed the 18%.
- 3:16I expect that to happen in July again.
- 3:20All right.
- 3:20What else is going to be happening?
- 3:22Potentially, they did have a board appeal in August.
- 3:24By the way, they typically don't have open board meetings in August.
- 3:27That was a closed a closed item where a credit union appealed something without
- 3:33revealing what I know relative to that.
- 3:35That was a field of membership appeal.
- 3:38There was a fair hiring and banking proposal, which
- 3:41doesn't need to repeat in 2025.
- 3:45They simplified the insurance rules.
- 3:49And then when you get close to the end of the year, what happens at the end of
- 3:52the year and CUA approves their budget.
- 3:55But before they approve their budget, they do a budget briefing.
- 3:59A little bit of history on the budget briefings.
- 4:02The budget briefing started when I was the deputy executive director and
- 4:07they were started by Dennis Dollar.
- 4:10And I remember saying to that executive director, Len Skiles, if
- 4:14you do this, Make sure you want to do it and it was for transparency.
- 4:19But once you start something, it's very difficult to stop it.
- 4:22And I'll get to that and why I'm making that point.
- 4:25I'll get to it now, but I'll refer to it again.
- 4:27So NCOA did stop it.
- 4:29I believe it was under the Matt's administration and the trade
- 4:32associations got upset because that was their opportunity.
- 4:36One of their opportunities to show value saying your budget's too high.
- 4:40Here's why we think it's too high.
- 4:42And through assistance from Senator Mark Warner in Virginia, they were able to get
- 4:47the Federal Credit Union Act proposed, requiring NCUA to do a budget briefing.
- 4:53They are required to do a budget briefing.
- 4:55I believe they will do a budget briefing.
- 4:57I'm not so sure they will do a budget.
- 4:59They're not required to do a budget, and they are required to do a budget briefing.
- 5:03They're not required to do a budget, and that's because there is a two year budget.
- 5:06So I'll get to that and why I think that they may not do a budget
- 5:10when we walk through what I think will happen in totality in 2025.
- 5:15The NCOA approved their annual performance plan, which is linked to
- 5:19their strategic plan, already in January.
- 5:22That was one of the last things they did prior to Hauptmann taking over.
- 5:26So they don't need to do that annual plan, but they do need to do another strategic
- 5:30plan, and that would be due by the end of 2025 for the years 2026 through 2030.
- 5:38Will they do that?
- 5:39We will see.
- 5:41All right.
- 5:41So when you look at what is going to happen and what I predict
- 5:45will happen in 2024, that's a little bit about what happened.
- 5:49What I'm predicting in 2024 is that the theme of canceling
- 5:53board meetings will continue.
- 5:55They, as I mentioned, they canceled March and June.
- 5:59I'm expecting that they may cancel April or May.
- 6:03Or June or July, I don't believe they're going to have enough
- 6:09briefings to keep an agenda full.
- 6:12I don't believe they're going to agree on enough things because of the arguments
- 6:15they're having about about NSF fees and overdraft fees being reported by
- 6:23over a billion dollar credit unions.
- 6:24There's two approaches here.
- 6:26Kyle Hauptman canceled and changed the.
- 6:29Way that billion dollar plus credit unions were going were reporting for three
- 6:33quarters on NSFs and overdrafts saying that it's overkill and it's onerous on
- 6:40the credit unions, et cetera, et cetera, and that they would be looking at that
- 6:45during part of the examinations and then after he announced that at GAC and then.
- 6:53Board member Harper and board member Otsuka came out with their own press
- 6:57releases, and I understand they did a full court press on Capitol Hill
- 7:01on the topic and came out saying that what's wrong with transparency?
- 7:06There should be transparency here.
- 7:08Why are you stopping something that was started and that credit unions had been
- 7:13providing and that's bad for members?
- 7:15So that's the nexus I wanted to say where I mentioned with Dennis Dollar that
- 7:20when he started the budget briefings, I thought they would never be stopped.
- 7:24And it's hard to stop something when you do.
- 7:27What happened?
- 7:27Debbie Matt stopped the budget briefings, and then lo and behold,
- 7:30the Federal Credit Union Act was changed and INSU 8 was required.
- 7:34to do that.
- 7:34So at some point, whether it's when the next time there's a D in the
- 7:39White House or there's a D in running the Dems have control of Congress.
- 7:45And the White House, you're going to see more on the fee situation.
- 7:50You're going to see NCOA go back to collecting this data.
- 7:53Will it be in 4 years?
- 7:56Will it be in 8 years?
- 7:57Will it be sometime sooner than that?
- 8:00My guess is not before the four year period.
- 8:02I can't see how it went flip flopping on this, but it's hard to go back.
- 8:07Once you have that transparency and you take it away, that pendulum will swing.
- 8:11It's just a matter of when it will swing.
- 8:14By the way, on this topic of transparency, it's a little bit.
- 8:19I don't want to say disingenuous.
- 8:21It's a little bit flawed to complain about this transparency and requiring
- 8:27credit unions to be transparent when NCUA has its own transparency issues.
- 8:32I've talked about it on here on occasion, and that is that their
- 8:38redaction of things on their website.
- 8:40Or there are errors of things on websites that are just deadlinks.
- 8:44If you assume that the deadlinks in the NSPM, National Supervision Policy Manual
- 8:50two attachments, which, attachments which they have said publicly will be available.
- 8:54For example, the attachments on how NCUA evaluates bank purchases, which
- 8:59was discussed in a proposed rule that they were going to be adding things to
- 9:03the National Supervision Policy Manual.
- 9:06If you click to that there are dead links.
- 9:08Now it's either that NCUA has gotten lazy in following up on these or
- 9:13it's a concerted effort to hide more things from the industry.
- 9:17It's a concerted effort to to redact.
- 9:21More things, and I don't think it's a situation where they've actually
- 9:24gone through and decided legally.
- 9:26We can redact this.
- 9:27I think it's most likely errors, but to take the moral high ground of
- 9:33credit unions need to be transparent.
- 9:35When NCUA's transparency has gotten worse and worse.
- 9:38Over years and years about what's on their website.
- 9:41It is a little bit like throwing stones at glass houses.
- 9:44I'll leave that at that.
- 9:45I've talked about that occasionally here.
- 9:47I've talked about doing FOIAs to get information that I
- 9:50know they need to release.
- 9:51And I just I haven't done that yet.
- 9:53At some juncture, I may pursue that.
- 9:55I did have conversations with NCOA.
- 9:58And first was told, Hey, you might be able to just get this by asking.
- 10:01And then I was told, no, if you want to get it, you need to FOIA.
- 10:04And I basically left it at that.
- 10:07There is a bit of a black box on the NCUA exam program compared to the FDIC
- 10:12and OCC at some juncture, maybe that pendulum will swing back, I'll try and
- 10:15push the pendulum sometime down the road, it's just not something that I've,
- 10:20have the time and energy to pursue, because especially when NCUA is going
- 10:25through reorganizations, most likely, probably, or will, it's going to be more
- 10:31difficult getting time assigned to that because their footprint is going to be
- 10:34shrinking and things will get elongated, including exams, et cetera, et cetera.
- 10:39So back to the board meeting.
- 10:41I think they will cancel a few board meetings or they will
- 10:45go to quarterly board meetings and maybe they'll only do one.
- 10:47They'll do one each quarter.
- 10:49I could see that being something that they come up with.
- 10:51I know staff after I left proposed that and the tiptoeing towards canceling
- 10:56meetings is something that may mean that's something that's going to happen.
- 10:59But under the Trump administration, if they're not going to be acting
- 11:02on things, what's the point of having a monthly board meeting?
- 11:05And it puts more power with the, yeah.
- 11:07With the chair when there aren't actions being voted on because he can influence
- 11:12the the staff as chair, although they tweak the delegations and the executive
- 11:18director now reports to the full board or supervised by the full board, as opposed
- 11:22to just being supervised by the chair.
- 11:25But.
- 11:25I digress on that.
- 11:27I think they will have three more NCUSAF briefings.
- 11:30I think in May, they will brief on Q1.
- 11:33I think in September, they will brief on Q2.
- 11:35And I think in November, they will be brief on Q3.
- 11:39All right, to the budget.
- 11:41Why do I think they will have a budget briefing?
- 11:43I think they will have a budget briefing because they can call it the staff budget.
- 11:49They can say staff is proposing this budget.
- 11:51Now the reality is it's not the staff budget.
- 11:54It is partially the staff budget.
- 11:56It's the staff and the chair's budget.
- 11:58So this will be an opportunity for the chair to get out and
- 12:01say, here's what we want to do.
- 12:04We want to cut X, Y, and Z consistent with the Trump administration.
- 12:07That's my.
- 12:09anticipation of what might be done in that budget.
- 12:12I don't think he's going to be able to get a second vote, or he may not
- 12:16be able to get a second vote unless somebody on the board resigns.
- 12:19Because again, remember, there are two Democrats.
- 12:22Harper and Otsuka are Democrats, and their terms are longer,
- 12:25ironically, than the chairman Houtman, whose term is up in August.
- 12:30So I believe he will have a forum to propose the budget.
- 12:35They are required to do a budget briefing is if there is going to be a budget.
- 12:39But back when I was executive director, we turned back on something that had been
- 12:43done in the past and in the past had done 2 year budgets when they approved budgets.
- 12:50There were two year budgets the current year and the out year that stopped, but
- 12:54when we were down to two board members, we realized, this could end up in a
- 12:58draw how you get to January of a year.
- 13:01And you don't have a budget.
- 13:02You really can't even pay people because NC way is self funded.
- 13:05And so we went back to doing a 2 year budget.
- 13:08So I am anticipating 1 of the very likely possible or probable.
- 13:15Outcomes of this is they will have a budget briefing, but they
- 13:18will not have a budget approval.
- 13:21Why?
- 13:22Because Harper and Otsuka won't want to cut things that Hauptman wants to,
- 13:27or the other alternative is that they do, and Hauptman has to acquiesce
- 13:33more to what Harper and Otsuka want.
- 13:35Neither one of those things is a good strategy for Hauptman wanting
- 13:40to go out and find another job in the Trump administration, in my opinion,
- 13:43because again, his term is up in August, so he's in the hot seat here.
- 13:47Not having the votes, but having to carry the water of the Trump administration.
- 13:51And I think because of that, there will be less board meetings.
- 13:54There will be less votes because he's not going to be able to get the votes.
- 13:57And hypothetically, possibly, probably, maybe there won't even be a budget
- 14:02that is approved because they have the out year budget which is a good
- 14:05thing to have because again, then staff can can take what's in that budget.
- 14:10And do what needs to be done to keep the trains running, to keep the
- 14:15exams going, and to keep the credit union industry safe and sound from
- 14:21an NCUA examination perspective.
- 14:24So as far as briefings, I talked about the NCUSIFs.
- 14:27I believe one of the things they'll do is more briefings.
- 14:30I'm anticipating that maybe Hauptman will want to have a fintech briefing.
- 14:34He's big on fintech, he's big on blockchain, he's big on all of those
- 14:38Coin related things, and I'm expecting based on his speaking engagements,
- 14:42he might have a fintech briefing.
- 14:44He might have a fintech symposium.
- 14:46I know he's done some of those things and meetings at G.
- 14:49A.
- 14:50C.
- 14:50Recently he did that.
- 14:52I predict there will be at least one, maybe two cyber briefings again.
- 14:55Why?
- 14:56It's something that they can talk about, and they do it at least annually.
- 15:00They're not required to do those things.
- 15:02And by the way, Transcribed The briefing started again back
- 15:05when Dennis Dollar was chair.
- 15:06There was a time period where he was the only board member and the general
- 15:10counsel opined you cannot have a 1 0 vote or you could but it could be challenged
- 15:15and they wanted to have meetings.
- 15:18So what did they do?
- 15:18They invented the NSU SIF quarterly briefing.
- 15:21It was a good invention because They reveal the state of the insurance
- 15:25fund, and they reveal the state of the CAMEL ratings, and they can put
- 15:30some soundbites out relative to that.
- 15:33So other things I am expecting will or won't happen.
- 15:37I'm expecting that NCUA staff footprint will go down.
- 15:40If you listened to my emergency podcast last week, NCUA out of the blue dropped
- 15:46a closed board meeting last Thursday.
- 15:49And I recorded an instant podcast on that before I had chatted with
- 15:54anybody at NCWA anticipating that they were putting their RIF plan together
- 15:58and getting the board approval.
- 15:59I understand they had a very long meeting and that there may be a
- 16:04future vote on what was presented and that it it was a very long meeting.
- 16:08I'll just put it at that.
- 16:10And there will be some kind of reorg.
- 16:12What does that reorg mean?
- 16:14Means the footprint is not going to get bigger.
- 16:16It's going to get smaller.
- 16:18It means.
- 16:19Exams will take longer for NCOA to get done when I was there each region
- 16:25had a division of supervision and analysts that worked for that director
- 16:30of supervision, and they had, we put a deputy in to help the workload
- 16:34since I left, they went to three DOS.
- 16:36DOS directors in each division because of the magnitude of
- 16:40the weight of reviewing exams.
- 16:42And as you know better than I, exams are slow.
- 16:45Expect exams to get slower because the footprint in the offices, the footprint of
- 16:49the examiners who take the buyouts, either the Trump buyout or the one that NCUA may
- 16:54be proposing to its staff of voluntary early retirement, or just encouraging
- 16:59people who are eligible to retire.
- 17:01You'd expect that to elongate.
- 17:03The plus is if you're a billion billion dollar plus or more code one or code two,
- 17:08but less than one's 15 billion, you may see NCULS less frequently because they
- 17:14extended the exam cycle that allowed.
- 17:18Non they extended the exam cycle, not requiring a calendar touch each year
- 17:23for those billion dollar credit unions.
- 17:24So if you're in good shape, haven't had a management
- 17:26change, you might see them less.
- 17:28That's what a smaller footprint can do.
- 17:30If you're really well run, they're going to do triage just like in mash, right?
- 17:33You do triage, which places don't we need to go?
- 17:37And if you're on that good list, you will see them less frequently.
- 17:41You can expect things that you're asking for field of membership to
- 17:44take longer mergers to take longer bank acquisitions to take longer.
- 17:49If you're doing a bank acquisition and a merger that's really going to take longer.
- 17:53So again, expect less customer service, longer exams to get done and longer.
- 18:00Any other service you're looking for from N.
- 18:02C.
- 18:02U.
- 18:03A.
- 18:03Is going to get worse in the short term.
- 18:05Not better as far as turnaround time.
- 18:07Because what do they do when they triage?
- 18:10They've got to get their exams done.
- 18:11That's job one.
- 18:12The other things move to the back burner.
- 18:15I talked about the debate on the NSF.
- 18:17You can argue either way.
- 18:19Again, the transparency argument is a good one, except NCUA, look in the mirror.
- 18:23That's all I ask.
- 18:24Look in the mirror, see what's on your exam website that isn't there, that
- 18:27should be there, that isn't there, that is on FDICs, that is on OCCs.
- 18:32And it's it's really lack of transparency in what's out there
- 18:35with the deadlinks and the excessive.
- 18:37Redactions.
- 18:38All right.
- 18:39What else?
- 18:39I think that's it for today.
- 18:41I appreciate you listening.
- 18:43I know that later this week, I'll have a recording with Todd Miller and Steve Farr
- 18:49on the trends at the end of the year.
- 18:51That podcast will go out next week.
- 18:54I had a great time at GAC seeing good friends, colleagues.
- 18:59Credit union clients credit unions I used to supervise, potential clients, etc.
- 19:04etc.
- 19:05That's a wonderful event.
- 19:06I think America's Credit Unions did a really good job with that event, and I
- 19:10appreciate the opportunity to attend that.
- 19:13As always, listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 19:16I really appreciate that, and I hope you will listen again soon.
- 19:20This is Mark Treichel, signing off with Flying Colors.