Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Dec 20th-Terrforming Mars
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin. We look the best games of all time
- 0:17according to Board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar. Ah love this
- 0:37market, Steve. So we came to a different one today. Yeah,
- 0:40it's got different music, it's got it's great. It's got elephants in the
- 0:44background. Why not. Yeah, So this is the one that's out by
- 0:48the danks, Kirsha, the memorial. That's it's right by the key.
- 0:52One that's right by the zoo. That's why you can hear the elephants exactly,
- 0:54and the giraffes. There's a couple of minds over there in the background.
- 0:58Yeah, great, loving there all right? What other animals bend?
- 1:02You say? Uh? Willhelm scream? Anyway? So I want you to
- 1:15I want you to define a word forms because I think people doggerol. No,
- 1:19No, I'm going to give you the word oh, because I think
- 1:22people with bibulous. I like that word. You're bibulous. What's that mean?
- 1:26Like you like you like a drink? Oh, I'm certainly bibulous.
- 1:30So I'm gonna give you a word. And I think people often don't understand
- 1:34the true meaning of this word. They assume it in a far more negative
- 1:38connotation than actually it is so overrated. People think overrated means bad, they
- 1:47do, but what it actually means is could be good, but not as
- 1:51good as people think exactly. So why do you so you imagine yourself as
- 1:57overrated? No? No, no, I'm certainly rated as at least they
- 2:00fucking underrated. Well well, well indeed. But so we're talking to terraforming
- 2:06marks, and so if I were to say Terraforming Mars is overrated, people
- 2:10may be up in arms about this because they will say, well, it's
- 2:14fucking brilliant. I'm not saying it's not brilliant. But at the same time,
- 2:22so what do you think? Do you think Terraforming Mars is tremendously overrated?
- 2:25I mean, to be honest, it's this is two, three,
- 2:30four or five the sixth best board game. How many ratings? Like I
- 2:35don't know, I'll look at the phone. I've got lovely, I've got
- 2:38a lovely mechanical keyboard on the phone, And then how many ratings does like
- 2:44any other game whatsoever have? Because I bet Terraforming Mars has quite a few
- 2:50more ratings than like Dune Imperium In a second, so ninety four thousand writings
- 3:00STUF ninety four thousand, compared to Dune Imperial June Imperium. Yeah, just
- 3:07to have a data point. June Imperium forty thousand ratings, so more than
- 3:14twice as many. Yeah, Terrformming Mars like this is this is just one
- 3:20one game where I don't think my opinion matters. When this game came out,
- 3:23I have not seen a game since then that has captured the gaming world's
- 3:29imagination like Terraform Mamirs just like and the hobbyist game gaming War. So people
- 3:34to fucking go home and play this every single day. So it's it's interesting
- 3:38because sometimes games just grabbed our group the Berlin scene scide, it's just us.
- 3:45No, it isn't. It isn't, but I think it's indicative.
- 3:46You can talk to me about size. So Scythe, let me started on
- 3:51Scythe. I would get a rude is when Scythe came out and it was
- 3:53playing being played on three different types, same with code names, same with
- 3:58Evidel. Everdell was very popular briefly and Terraforming Mars was another one of these
- 4:03and it but Terraforming Mars was different in the way that it. It developed
- 4:11a kind of obsession cult with the game that was surprising to the cults.
- 4:16And I think it's a great game. I really enjoyed Terraforming Mars. I
- 4:21didn't even like know it was coming. I went to Berlin Bretspielkhan in twenty
- 4:27seventeen. Yeah, and Jacob Strixelius, which it's Jigo Yakob Yakob Frixelius.
- 4:34I don't know. He's twenty seventeen. It came out in twenty six stay
- 4:38nine state. Yeah. Yeah, but he was there with the game demoing
- 4:42it. Yeah. I had no idea about the game. I had no
- 4:44idea about him. It's just like this, like big bearded Swedish guy.
- 4:47He taught us the game and we played it like this, this game is
- 4:50great. We got to play the whole thing right there. I had no
- 4:54idea that it was going to become as popular as it did. So why
- 4:57do you own it then? Well? Because you especially then, probably because
- 5:00I bought it for a friend and I figured I could just play hers.
- 5:03Who did you buy Becca, Joe? She was there. It was me
- 5:08Sam Becca. Okay. She fell in love with the game, so I
- 5:12bought her a copy. At Essen had Jacob sign it with the Venus Next
- 5:17expansion, whichever year that was. I think we played it once with you
- 5:21actually at her place. Yeah, yeah we did. Yeah, that might
- 5:25have been the last time I played it. Yeah, because I just don't
- 5:28play the same game over and over again that many times. There's no need
- 5:31for me to own Terraforming Mars because everybody else owns it. I don't,
- 5:35and I'm not desperate to play it all the time. No, So it's
- 5:41fascinating because I played it maybe three or four times Terraforming Marts, and I
- 5:44haven't played it for a long time since, and I remember enjoying it,
- 5:46and I remember being absolutely fucking pulled by the type black cops that they were,
- 5:51just they seemed like such an unnecessary bolt on to a game that was
- 5:59brilliantly designed. I guess you could remove them. And at the Schpielders Yarras
- 6:02Awards ceremony must have been twenty seventeen when when Terraforming Mars was nominated, I
- 6:08spoke to Jacob Rixelius about this. It was nominated for the Ken even pretty
- 6:13heavy for that, I agree, And did it win? No, no,
- 6:15no, no, yes, maybe I can't remember anyway, So he
- 6:21said that he wanted to bring an element of sort of corporate espionage into the
- 6:28game, right, And I think it raises an interesting question about theme.
- 6:32Right. So in my interview with Jamie Keegee recently, he was talking about
- 6:39Star Wars Star Trek ascendancy. People say it's great, and he was saying
- 6:44that Gaelfas nine, who we spoke about previously, Gaelfer's nine, if they
- 6:49have a choice whether to go down a route where they're making a decision on
- 6:55a game, whether the mechanism adds to a better game design or makes the
- 7:00game more thematic, and it's a sort of zero summi thing, they will
- 7:02always go down the more thematic route that it may make the game less tight
- 7:10as a design. And and so I guess it raises a question. I
- 7:15don't dislike that decision. Well, it raises a question. Can theme into
- 7:23fear with the quality of a game design? Do you think? Absolutely?
- 7:28The thing is, I believe you can have it both ways. If you're
- 7:30doing a good design, have your cake and eat it. I mean,
- 7:33so it could exist in two places. We're the ring, I think,
- 7:38I mean, I'm not doing a fucking sophisticated analysis here. I mean that
- 7:41game may be broken in all sorts of ways I just don't appreciate because I
- 7:44haven't played it enough. But you get to like put the Witch King of
- 7:47Angmar into the games king. You get to put the witch King of Angmar,
- 7:50which which is in the game, the witch King which King of Angmar.
- 7:56Yeah, the joke doesn't work if you put the Agmar on the earth
- 7:58stave, it's gonna end of the point. Then, so you put the
- 8:01Witch King of Angmar, the Witch King of Angmart. You put the Witch
- 8:05King of Angmar into the game, and it works in the context of the
- 8:09game, and in fact, like the point of it is kind of to
- 8:13break the game in a sense, because it's not like a game like chess,
- 8:16where you're like you have rules and they never change. You're introducing like
- 8:20new rules into the game, right disrupt what's happening. But you also get
- 8:24to have the feeling like, fuck, I'm putting the Witch King of Angmar
- 8:26into the game. You fucking slam that mini down, and then like scythe
- 8:30the fucking Witch King of Angmar actually does something that makes sense, that makes
- 8:33you feel like you're part of a world that you've bought into, that you
- 8:35wanted to fucking play a game in instead of some fucking bullshit right, so
- 8:39apocalyptic son science fiction fantasy world. Steve puts the fucking witch King of Angmar
- 8:46down. Look at the doll. Look at the doll, Stevie, you're
- 8:48looking at the doll. I'm looking point on the doll where Scythe touched you,
- 8:52Steve. It's the problem is it didn't touch me. That's I mean,
- 8:56that is true anyway. So yeah, and the thing is though,
- 9:00so but the thing is, if you if you had to choose between the
- 9:03two of them, yeah, Like I don't know how Star Trek Ascendency plays,
- 9:05but like, do I want to get like a fucking do? I
- 9:07want to get Borg feels when the Borg do something? Yes? And I
- 9:13will be disappointed if I don't. I agree with If you give me a
- 9:16choice, like tighter rules or more thematic feeling, I want to have both,
- 9:20but I'd probably rather have the Borg feels. So the reason I love
- 9:24eurogames and the reason I am more and more annoyed by silver age eurogames.
- 9:35You're getting older, You're more and more annoyed by everything. It's is I
- 9:39don't know. I've led a life of being fairly fucking annoyed, to be
- 9:41honest, But so is what I love about eurogames. And I think what
- 9:46really grabbed me about eurogames is the they are set it and forget it right
- 9:52once you played around, the engine is humming and you don't need to tweak
- 9:58the engine. I'm by tweaking the engine, I mean constantly looking in the
- 10:01fucking rule book for exceptions and edge cases and all that sort of stuff.
- 10:05Right, I love that about eurogames. It's why when when apps came along
- 10:13that allow me to navigate, I loved it because I don't like looking at
- 10:18the map and checking my I don't like the problem solving. I like the
- 10:24problem solving within the game. I don't like the learning all the rules and
- 10:26then constantly having to learn the rules. That's why I don't think i'd be
- 10:30into tabletop miniatures games, because it's constantly playing tabletop miniatures games is looking into
- 10:35fucking rule books checking exceptions. Right if you have to have a table tap
- 10:37me lifestyle, because then you don't check the rules all the time. So
- 10:41the point is that the reason I theme bothers me is often theme As you
- 10:48say, is an exception to the rule, an edge case, and if
- 10:54that theme results in you having to consistently check it up and rubles, that's
- 11:01annoying. Spo wore the ring is so is so brilliantly wedded to its thing.
- 11:09I think that it makes sense. I think that the thematic elements have
- 11:13the potential and maybe it's a risk to introduce a lot of delight to the
- 11:16game, especially when you're invested in like the intellectual property. Right. There
- 11:22are loads of generic you know, Medieval, Renaissance, science fiction, colonial
- 11:28eurogames that they have a theme, but they don't have IP, so they
- 11:33can be thematic, but maybe not in a way that you find especially appealing.
- 11:37But there are cases in which theme and mechanism can like it's like form
- 11:43and content I guess, can can wed together so well, and maybe it's
- 11:46so rare that's why it's delightful when it actually works. And things you have
- 11:50Holler TWN for example, where the game models crop rotation and it doesn't break
- 11:56the game, and it's thematic and it actually works, and I find it
- 12:00like, I find it delightful. I don't know. I'm always going on
- 12:03and on about crop rotation, but like that works for me. That kind
- 12:05of theme mechanic interaction is great, and there's nothing in that game that's like
- 12:11this sort of you know, giant fucking mini that the fucking giant like farmer
- 12:16Mini that you put down right, or the fucking the Lord of the manor
- 12:20who takes away your fueld at the end of the game for no reason.
- 12:22The thing is brilliant theme. Brilliant theme has the power to delight to you,
- 12:30not only because it immerses you within the story, but there's also an
- 12:33element of thinking, bloody hell, that's clever. You've managed to model that
- 12:35in a plausible manner, and I see that it is. It's not the
- 12:41same, it's an abstraction, but wow, it really feels like that.
- 12:43So my definition. Do you think it's a difference between thematic games and IP
- 12:48games. That's an important well. I think there's a different expectation. I
- 12:54think IP games. IP games have to feel like the IP but often often
- 13:03theme to me is various gradiations of dice roll and I don't think that's thematic
- 13:09at all. People say, oh, wargames are super thematic because when you
- 13:11attack with the tank you have to roll for the angle of the turret you
- 13:16have to roll for where it hits on the opponents. That doesn't strike me
- 13:20as thematic at all. That it strikes me as just granular dice roll.
- 13:22Yeah. But when you when you play that fucking ugirl ha ha haa card
- 13:28in Arkham Horror and it's got like thirty seven thousand hit points and you have
- 13:31like a single pistol with one bullet in it to kill the thing, you
- 13:37love it? Yeah, I mean when it makes sense thematically. So I
- 13:41think Through the Ages is one of the most beautifully thematic games ever maked,
- 13:45right, I mean you think it's like the most beautiful every single category game
- 13:48ever in this is true. But like you play the Kremlin cut and the
- 13:52Kremlin card increases your military output but reduces your net happy. Not only is
- 14:00that sort of thematically, not only does Kremlin or communism, Kremlin Communism does
- 14:05something similar, right, you know, I might be getting this wrong.
- 14:09It don't come at me bro. So not only does that thematically resonate it
- 14:16seems plausible, but it does something else as well. It gives you an
- 14:22insight into the author's view of that particular political system, which is wonderful brings
- 14:28us back to terrorforming Mars, because this gives us an insight into the designers
- 14:33the way the designer imagines the potential colonization and terraforming ma Mars may play out.
- 14:39Okay, so a question for you then, So my initial view on
- 14:45those take that cards work. These feel like Bolton's. They feel unfairly mean,
- 14:52and they don't mesh with the rest of you. Can we sacrifice the
- 14:58integrity of the game system for thematic inclusion. I think the game remains like
- 15:05perfectly thematic without Take that cards. I mean, it's still essentially a fucking
- 15:11libertarian future like dystopian vision of how we're going to colonize. I don't think
- 15:16it is dystopian vision. I just came up with this argument now. I
- 15:18think it's perfectly perfectly utopian. In fact, no, no, the the
- 15:22idea that Mars will not be colonized by a collective endeavor of humankind, but
- 15:28that various corporations will simply like basically extend capitalism to include I think Ja is
- 15:35behind that. Yeah, I think he's pro that. Yeah, I know
- 15:37that's what I'm saying. I think this he sincerely believes that this is a
- 15:41good thing. I'm just saying it's like a libertarian dystopia. And also this
- 15:46is this is fascinating. I never thought of that until now, so it
- 15:48kind of is. We were talking about a few days ago, the bourgeoisification
- 15:52of games, right, yeah, like two days ago, I think,
- 15:56yeah. And there is this idea that has really become pro that you must
- 16:00agree with something to appreciate it. So in art, you must agree with
- 16:07the political trust that the art is making to like it. And I think
- 16:11that's utterly facile as a form of art criticism. One of my favorite writers
- 16:18is one of the was one of the artist fucking tories in the world.
- 16:25And yet evil war, evil in war. Yet his output is so wonderful.
- 16:30I mean, I love Bride every visiting, and I even love the
- 16:33section where him and his tough mates during the general strike become strike breakers.
- 16:38This is the antithesis of my view on the general strike of the nineteen twenties
- 16:44in Britain. Yet he is such a compelling writer. The he gives you
- 16:48such an affection for these characters that you're able for the time when you're reading
- 16:53the book to completely immerse yourself in that world. I don't agree with it,
- 16:57and I understand I don't agree, but appreciating. I mean, this
- 17:00is how I feel about the d nuncia, the speech in Coriolanus in which
- 17:06Caius Marsius denounces the plubs right as being this sort of like riotous, fickle
- 17:11mass that they have no idea what they really think. They're brave and then
- 17:15they're fearful. They back this one and then that one, hang the lot
- 17:18of them, which I've just finished reading nineteen eighty four again, and that
- 17:23is Orwell's view of the Prolls too. Or Well was not as left wing
- 17:27as people as here. Yeah, and you know, similarly, you know,
- 17:30I'm thinking about comparing this game to Daybreak, because I think Daybreak is
- 17:33meant to be this like I haven't played it, so I don't know,
- 17:36but the cooperative, collaborative vision about how we're going to somehow rescue the future
- 17:41for human civilization, Whereas, like I said, I think Terraforming Mars is
- 17:45clearly this like libertarian corporatist view of how we're gonna colonize other worlds. I
- 17:52mean, they're both fine, they're both interesting. I think the contrast is
- 17:53what's exciting about the hobby. Not every game needs to be like like any
- 17:56piece of art, a reflection of my view of the world, which is
- 18:00itself like unfinished, unstable, incomplete, not coherent. Then watch out for
- 18:06that zebra. Thank you for listening. You can support the show at Patreon
- 18:14dot com, forward slash five GFID, and join the discord by going to
- 18:18five gfd dot com. Have a very merry Christmas.