Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Siege of Jerusalem 1187 Negotiation and Surrender
Transcript
- Lucas: So, we've talked a lot about Saladin's big victories — Hattin, the capture of Acre, the various sieges — but one of the most dramatic moments, I think, was the siege of Jerusalem in the autumn of 1187. After Hattin, the city was basically cut off, but it wasn't a foregone conclusion. Luna: Right, because Jerusalem had strong walls and a lot of refugees from the countryside. What happened when Saladin showed up? Lucas: He arrived in mid-September with his army. The city was defended by a small garrison under Balian of Ibelin — he was a Frankish noble who'd managed to escape from Hattin and made his way to Tyre, then got Saladin's permission to go to Jerusalem to retrieve his wife. But once inside, he broke his oath and took command of the defense. Luna: Wait, Saladin let him go and he betrayed that trust? Lucas: Sort of — Saladin had given him a safe conduct to enter and leave, but when Balian saw the desperation inside, he decided to stay and organize the resistance. Saladin was furious, but he also had a huge army and siege engines. He began attacking the northern wall near the Damascus Gate. The fighting was intense — the Franj even managed to burn some of Saladin's siege towers. But by late September, the walls were breached in several places. Luna: So why didn't he just storm the city? He had the numbers. Lucas: That's the key question. According to Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, Saladin's chronicler, the Sultan was reluctant to take the city by storm because he knew the defenders would fight to the death, and the city might be destroyed. He preferred to negotiate a surrender — partly for religious reasons, partly to avoid a massacre that would inflame crusader sentiment even more. Plus, he wanted to secure the city intact. Luna: So Balian came out to negotiate? What were the terms? Lucas: Balian actually went to Saladin's camp under a flag of truce. He warned Saladin that if the city was taken by force, the defenders would kill their own families and destroy the holy places rather than let them fall into Muslim hands. Saladin understood the threat — a desecrated al-Quds would be a propaganda disaster. So he offered generous terms: the city would be surrendered peacefully, and every Frank could buy his freedom for a ransom — ten dinars for a man, five for a woman, and one for a child. Those who couldn't pay would become slaves. Lucas: Balian and the patriarch Heraclius argued for better terms, especially for the poor, but Saladin held firm. On October 2, the city gates were opened. Saladin entered and immediately ordered that the Christian holy places be protected. The Church of the Holy Sepulchre was closed for three days but then reopened, though the Franj were allowed to leave with their belongings. Lucas: And then there's the story of Queen Sibylla — she was the sister of the leper king Baldwin IV and the wife of Guy of Lusignan. After the surrender, she was allowed to leave with her court. Baha ad-Din notes that she was given gifts and safe conduct. The whole evacuation took about a month, with many Franj sailing away from the coast. Luna: What about the True Cross? The relic that was captured at Hattin? Lucas: Yes — the True Cross was still in Frankish hands? Actually no, it had been captured at Hattin and taken to Damascus. So it wasn't in Jerusalem during the siege. But there were other relics. Saladin allowed the Franj to take some of them, but many were ransomed later. The fate of the True Cross itself is a whole other story — it was eventually sent to Baghdad and then disappeared from history. Luna: That's fascinating. It's interesting that Saladin was so concerned with how he'd be seen — both by the Muslim world and by the crusaders. He wanted to come across as merciful but also in control. Lucas: Exactly. And speaking of perception, you know, one of the reasons we can do episodes like this — digging into the details of primary sources — is that this show is entirely listener-supported. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many of these. It's a small group, but it makes a big difference. Luna: Yeah, it's really nice that we can talk about Saladin without any ads or sponsors. It keeps the focus on the history. Lucas: Absolutely. So anyway, back to the aftermath — after the surrender, Saladin set about restoring the city as a Muslim center. He had the Dome of the Rock purified, and the cross removed from the top. The great Friday prayer was held there, which we covered in an earlier episode. But the siege itself shows his strategic mind: he knew when to offer terms and when to press the attack. Luna: And he had Balian to thank for forcing the negotiations, in a way. If Balian hadn't threatened to destroy the holy places, Saladin might have stormed it anyway. Lucas: True. The sources differ on exactly how much Saladin already planned to negotiate, but Baha ad-Din emphasizes that the Sultan was always looking for a peaceful solution. Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, his secretary, also wrote that Saladin was concerned about his reputation among Muslim rulers. He couldn't be seen as too soft, but also didn't want to be a butcher. The ransom terms were actually quite moderate by medieval standards. Luna: How many Franj actually left? And how many became slaves? Lucas: Estimates vary. Baha ad-Din says about 7,000 men paid the ransom, but many women and children were ransomed later. The patriarch Heraclius and others tried to use church funds to free the poor, but Saladin insisted on the ransom. In the end, around 15,000 people may have been evacuated. Those who couldn't pay, maybe 5,000 to 8,000, were enslaved. It was a common fate in those wars. Luna: And then the Third Crusade was just a few years away. Did Saladin regret not holding the city more securely? Lucas: There's no evidence he regretted it. He fortified the city and left a strong garrison. But the fall of Jerusalem did galvanize the West to launch the Third Crusade, led by Richard the Lionheart and Philip Augustus. Saladin probably knew that was coming. But he had achieved his lifelong goal: he had taken back the holy city. The rest was about holding it. Luna: And he did hold it, right? The crusaders never retook Jerusalem after that. Lucas: Correct. Despite Richard's victories at Arsuf and Jaffa, he never marched on Jerusalem. The city stayed under Muslim control until the modern era, except for a brief period during the Sixth Crusade under Frederick II, but that was a negotiated handover, not a conquest. So Saladin's legacy as the liberator of Jerusalem is well-earned. Luna: It's amazing how much of that story comes down to one negotiation — Balian's threat and Saladin's choice. Lucas: Exactly. And we actually have the accounts from both sides — the Arabic chronicles and the Latin ones, like the 'Itinerarium Regis Ricardi', though that one is a bit later. They agree on the basics: the city was starving, the walls were breached, but Saladin chose mercy over massacre. It's a moment that defined his reputation in both east and west. Luna: So next time we can maybe talk about what happened to the Franj who left — where they went and how they started the Third Crusade. Lucas: Great idea — but that'll have to wait for another episode. For now, I think this gives us a real sense of Saladin's character. He was a pragmatist, a diplomat, and a warrior, all in one. Luna: And also someone who knew when to show mercy. Lucas: Yeah. That's the Saladin that history remembers.