Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Pygmalion Effect in Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: There's a famous study from 1963 — Harvard psychologist Robert Rosenthal does an experiment in a California elementary school. He tells the teachers, 'We've identified a group of students who are about to bloom academically. These kids are late bloomers — expect big things from them.' Luna: And those kids actually do bloom? Or was it just a placebo? Lucas: They bloom — significantly. By the end of the year, the 'bloomers' had gained an average of 12 IQ points more than the control group. Here's the catch: the students Rosenthal flagged were chosen completely at random. There was no actual difference between them and the other kids. Luna: So the teachers' expectations literally rewired the students' performance. That's wild. Lucas: Exactly. That's the Pygmalion Effect — named after the Greek myth where a sculptor's statue comes to life because he believed so strongly it would. When someone in authority expects more of you, you tend to deliver more. And when they expect less... you shrink to meet that expectation too. That second part is called the Golem Effect. Luna: Okay, so how do we use this in office politics without being manipulative? Because I can already picture someone listening thinking, 'Great, now I have to fake high expectations of my boss?' Lucas: Before we go there — and this is only going to sound like a tangent for a second — a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these shows going. If you've gotten something out of this podcast, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's the smallest thing and it keeps us ad-free. Luna: Yeah, honestly, it makes a real difference. And the fact that you're listening at all — we appreciate that. Lucas: Right. So back to the Pygmalion Effect at work. The most practical application isn't about manipulating your boss — it's about managing the expectations that key people have of you. And the first step is understanding that expectations are contagious. Luna: Contagious how? Lucas: If your direct manager thinks you're going to ace a project, she gives you more interesting work, she gives you more airtime in meetings, she subconsciously smiles more when you speak. That signals to everyone else in the room that you're a high-performer. And then they start treating you that way too. It's a cascade. Luna: So the real lever is to get one key person to upgrade their expectation of you. Then the system kind of amplifies it for you. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a specific tactic for this — I call it 'the soft ask.' The idea is to plant a seed of high expectation without directly bragging. So instead of saying, 'I'm really good at data analysis,' you say, 'I've been diving into the Q2 metrics on my own time, and I noticed something interesting about the churn rate — want me to walk through it with the team?' Luna: That's not bragging, that's just... doing the work and being useful. But it signals competence. Lucas: Exactly. And because you're offering something specific, the other person starts to see you as someone who takes initiative. Their expectation shifts. And then — because of the Pygmalion Effect — they give you more opportunities, which makes you actually perform better. Luna: So it's a virtuous cycle. But there's also the flip side — the Golem Effect. What do you do if your boss has already decided you're average? Lucas: That's tougher. But you can sometimes reset expectations by creating a sudden, visible win in a domain your boss cares about. The key word is 'visible.' Not just doing good work — making sure it's seen by the person whose expectation you want to change. Luna: Right, because if they don't see it, their expectation doesn't update. They just assume you're still the same person. Lucas: Exactly. One way to do that is to ask for feedback on something you've already done well. You say, 'Hey, I put together the client deck for tomorrow — could you take 30 seconds to glance at the summary slide? I want to make sure it's hitting the right note.' That does two things: it shows you're diligent, and it forces them to see your work. Luna: And once they see it's good, their expectation creeps up. Then you get the Pygmalion boost from there. Lucas: Exactly. And here's something else — the Pygmalion Effect works in peer relationships too. If you treat a colleague like they're capable and valuable, they tend to become more capable and valuable in your interactions. That's useful for building alliances. Luna: That reminds me of the Ben Franklin Effect we talked about in an earlier episode — when you ask someone for a small favor, they start to like you more. This feels similar: when you show someone you expect them to be good, they meet that expectation. Lucas: Yes. And there's research backing that up. In one study, managers who were told their new hires were 'high potential' — even though the designation was random — gave those hires more coaching and more challenging assignments. The hires then outperformed the control group. The managers' belief created the reality. Luna: So the practical takeaway for someone listening today is: pick one person whose opinion matters — your boss, a senior stakeholder, a key collaborator — and think about what expectation they currently have of you. Then do one soft ask to nudge it upward. Lucas: Exactly. One specific action, this week. And then watch how their behavior shifts. Because once they expect more, they'll give you more — and you'll rise to meet it. Luna: I love that. It's almost like you're hacking the system from the inside out. Lucas: It is. And it's entirely ethical — you're not lying, you're just strategically revealing your competence in a way that shapes perception. That's office politics at its best. Luna: Alright, I'm going to try this with my skip-level this week. Let's see if I can get a Pygmalion boost. Lucas: Do it. And let us know how it goes. For now, that's it for episode 82. We'll be back with another angle on office politics next time.