Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Episode 287 / Tom Fenwick-Smith / Three UK / Senior In House Creative
Transcript
- 0:00Tom Fenwick-Smith: You have to stand up, you have to try again,
- 0:02you have to keep going. And I think that that mindset is super
- 0:04important in terms of building resilience.
- 0:12Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie? Then defy snacks
- 0:15is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:18combined with functional ingredients, giving you as much
- 0:20as 26 grams of protein per bag, so you can be both a little bit
- 0:24bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:28brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:31owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:34defy with an eye snacks.com and follow us on social at defy
- 0:39Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:39snacks.
- 0:48My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of automated creative,
- 0:51the creative effectiveness ad tech platform. And this is a
- 0:54regular podcast about the future of data driven marketing. And
- 0:57it's my absolute joy, privilege and pleasure to interview
- 1:01someone new and exciting and interesting and talented from
- 1:04the industry. And this week is absolutely no different. I'm on
- 1:08a call with Tom Fenwick Smith, who is senior in house creative
- 1:13at three UK. Tom, for anyone who doesn't know who you are and
- 1:16what you do, could you give us a brief background?
- 1:18Tom Fenwick-Smith: Oh, yeah, it's great to be here. Tom,
- 1:20thank you so much for asking me. Currently I'm working with Three
- 1:24and we've been helping for the last three years to build their
- 1:28in house creative agency, although I'm sure it's no secret
- 1:31to a lot of people out there, we are currently going to be going
- 1:35through a merger with Vodafone. But the in house space is super
- 1:39interesting at the moment, and it's been a real, you know, it's
- 1:43been a real learning and a real change from the agency, I like,
- 1:47I often talk about how in agencies, it's kind of like a
- 1:50collection of pirates. You know, you're all kind of bandits,
- 1:54cutthroats, eccentrics, but you're all seeking the same
- 1:57treasure. My experience with in house is that you kind of have
- 2:01to get, get rid of some of that, that roughness, and kind of be a
- 2:05bit more skilled up. So it's a bit more like working for a
- 2:08political party. You have to kind of understand and get to
- 2:12know other people's ambitions, where they're coming from, and
- 2:16what is important to them in order to make the creative ideas
- 2:19succeed. So it's been a real learning for the last three
- 2:23years. My route into the industry has been a little bit
- 2:26varied. I kind of, I didn't get here in a very lineal fashion. I
- 2:30kind of originally, I started in the film industry because I was
- 2:34totally obsessed with storytelling and wanting to tell
- 2:37stories, even from very young. I kind of love mythology and
- 2:41everything that came with it. And so at 18, I kind of packed
- 2:44my bags and went off to go and join whatever film industry
- 2:48element I could. And ended up being a runner in Soho, as many,
- 2:52many of us did, getting people's lunches, working in Edit houses,
- 2:56doing all sorts of stuff before finally landing on the floor of
- 3:00feature films, music videos, commercials, where I did about
- 3:0335 features, over 100 music videos and over 100 commercials,
- 3:07and in that really hone the craft of being able to tell
- 3:10stories. And I got to work with some incredible people from Sir
- 3:14Christopher Nolan, as of today, Ridley Scott, all kinds of
- 3:18different people from that kind of era, and watch them very
- 3:21closely as they put stories together. But the route I was
- 3:25going down there was an assistant director, and it was
- 3:28kind of, I was slowly being morphed into a sergeant major
- 3:31who was kind of.... my enemy was time and my creative output
- 3:35wasn't, was the creativity of being able to manipulate that
- 3:39time in order to get the best results, which is a handy skill
- 3:42to have, but not necessarily very creative. And then I
- 3:46retrained at the SCA, the School of Communication Arts, 2.0 I'm
- 3:50forever grateful to Mark and his team over at the SCA, because
- 3:53were the second I walked in the door, I fell at home, and I kind
- 3:57of knew I'd found my tribe of people and was able to really
- 4:01connect with being a creative and what it meant, and the kind
- 4:05of excitement that comes with being a creative, and the fact
- 4:08that you're kind of looking for these great insights that you
- 4:12can dig out yourself or find through data or anything to
- 4:15create a human insight, and then build great creative ideas off
- 4:19the back of that. And it was super exciting, like, it was a
- 4:23real light switch moment for me. And then from there went on
- 4:27spend some time at RGA, little bit of time at Google, some time
- 4:30at Havas, before landing at Poke, which then became
- 4:33publicist Pope, or Pope, Poke was absolutely incredible. Like,
- 4:37it was a place of real creativity, and it was right on
- 4:41the cusp of understanding digital work in a way which I
- 4:44don't think many people at the time were really like in the
- 4:48industry. Kind of could get and like how you could connect APIs
- 4:51and how you could build certain things, and all these social
- 4:55media platforms are being born, and the ways in which we could
- 4:59creatively manipulate them to tell stories. And everyone that
- 5:03worked there was an incredibly talented, like very specialized
- 5:06person. And it was a real melting pot of ideas, of people,
- 5:10of points of view. It was fantastic. And then from there
- 5:13Jack Morton, which was a fantastic experiential agency,
- 5:17and Rewind, where I did AR VR, all kinds of new tech and
- 5:20innovation learning to tell these kind of new stories in a
- 5:24new way. Before COVID happened, everything kind of dropped out
- 5:27and then ended up going to Three to help build their in house
- 5:31agency. Sorry, that's a very long answer. Tom, is that all right?
- 5:35Tom Ollerton: Yeah, you didn't read the brief though, did you?
- 5:37Brief answer? But it was an interesting way, and it's funny,
- 5:43you mentioned Mark Lewis. He was a relatively early guest on the
- 5:47podcast. And when someone says, like, what was your favorite
- 5:50episode? Actually, it was probably Mark's in some ways,
- 5:53principally because he showed up with a Buddhist monk. He was
- 5:56like, Can Can this Buddhist monk come on the podcast? And I was
- 6:00like, yeah, yeah, sure. So, and that was back in the day, where
- 6:03you go for a few pints and then do the recording when I was sort
- 6:05of less confident, so sort of helped me. But he was talking
- 6:08about how he put creativity into a spreadsheet, right? So it's
- 6:11like, when you come up with an idea that's good or gets a good
- 6:14reaction, score the reaction out of 10, and then try and
- 6:17remember, what was the process of you arriving at that idea:
- 6:20Was it in the morning, were you in the bath? were you going for
- 6:22a run? Did you be watching a movie? Were you high, whatever,
- 6:24and to start to get your own data on where your your best
- 6:27ideas might come from? And I was just like, What? What is this?
- 6:30And then with this, think it was Ben the Buddhist, or something
- 6:33that came along with him, because it was all very surreal,
- 6:35but, and that was like, five, six years ago, or something, so
- 6:39that that says, lays testament to him as a character, and
- 6:43clearly the profound impact he had on you.
- 6:45Tom Fenwick-Smith: Yeah. I mean, funnily enough, I remember Ben
- 6:47the Buddhist. He was like, I think when, when you first join
- 6:50you have like, I mean, lectures, is the wrong, the wrong? Like,
- 6:54people come and just talk to you, and they kind of give these
- 6:57great presentations. And the second I started that learning
- 6:59Unknown: So we've gone so wildly off piece with this podcast, I'm
- 7:00model, because it's so different, and being someone
- 7:03who's who's, like, dyslexic, and couple other neurological bits
- 7:06thrown in as well. The traditional learning model
- 7:08going to try and struggle it into it. Into its normal format.
- 7:09didn't work, and the way Mark managed to change it, it became
- 7:12so engaging and so fascinating. And Ben was, like, probably week
- 7:16three, Ben came in, and I remember his talk was just, it
- 7:18So the question I want to ask you is, like you've had this
- 7:19was, like, fascinating. And that was the great thing about the
- 7:22SCA it wasn't just learning a syllabus and going block by
- 7:25block, it was learning about exciting things in the world and
- 7:28really interesting career. I mean, in some ways, Tom it's got
- 7:28how you connect them to what you're trying to achieve. So
- 7:31we'd have like people, you know, legends from the industry coming
- 7:35in, and then you'd have people like Ben the Buddhist, and then
- 7:38a lot worse. You're making music videos and feature films and now
- 7:38you'd have like, neuroscientists, and you'd have
- 7:41just this incredible melting pot of just brilliant people which
- 7:44were at your fingertips to be able to discuss stuff with. And
- 7:47out of that kind of mix comes the creativity. You know, it
- 7:49you're an in house creative but I understand your path, and I
- 7:50pops up later in in any kind of different way, whether you're
- 7:54trying to crack a brief or just having conversations. It's just,
- 7:57it was fantastic. I loved it.
- 7:59respect that. I'm just teasing, but in that journey, what has
- 8:09been the best investment of your own time, energy or money, your
- 8:19own your own stuff in that career? What, what's been good?
- 8:29Tom Fenwick-Smith: I think I alluded to a little bit in my
- 8:31previous answer, but I think the the best investment I've made
- 8:36is, is my time with other people as much as possible, and any
- 8:41time I can spend with people who either know more than me, or
- 8:46come from a different background, or come from a
- 8:48different, you know, working background as well, anything to
- 8:53just to be able to discuss with them. And that can come in, like
- 8:56many ways, like I love constantly just listening to
- 8:59people and ask them about their chosen skill, their talent,
- 9:02their obsession. I love knowing people's obsessions, because
- 9:05you'll find if you ask someone about what their obsession is,
- 9:08they will be an utter expert in it. And even if it's a subject I
- 9:12would normally find quite boring, they will make it
- 9:15interesting for me to listen to 99% of the time.
- 9:17Tom Ollerton: To me, that's one of our go to interview questions
- 9:21when you've sort of done the dance of asking all the things
- 9:23that you should I always say, what is your kind of crazy
- 9:25passion point? But then always gets, you always get that funny
- 9:28look on people's faces. And then, and then, like, should I
- 9:31tell them about this thing? But then, and then you see the real
- 9:34person you know. Then then you see how articulate they are.
- 9:36Then you see how creative or interested, or, you know, all
- 9:38that kind of stuff. So what's yours? What is your subject that
- 9:42you know most about outside of work?
- 9:43Tom Fenwick-Smith: Currently, currently my, and this is the
- 9:45thing, I fall into obsessions. There's probably a new one every
- 9:49couple of years. My new one is, is Muay Thai kickboxing, and I'm
- 9:53a couple of years into that, and I sort of discovered it by
- 9:56accident after doing a white collar boxing fight, because I
- 9:59thought it was super important to do something that scared me,
- 10:03and I'd never been in a fight or whatever, and I realized how
- 10:03I'm now going to ask you about data driven marketing, because I
- 10:06underprepared I was for such a meteoric event, because it is,
- 10:10it's quite a big deal. It takes a lot to be able to do it. It's
- 10:14quite scary. So I found a fellow in my local boxing gym who had
- 10:17the most crooked nose, and trained with him, and then he
- 10:20turned out to be a world champion Muay Thai and k1
- 10:23fighter. And I was lucky enough to train with him once a week
- 10:27for the last three years, and it's been unbelievable. And it
- 10:30kind of not only just working with someone like that, who's
- 10:34got a mindset I've never seen, you know of a proper world
- 10:37champion like totally determined to go towards a goal. And it was
- 10:41fascinating just working with him and talking with him, and
- 10:44then he kind of led me into the passion I have for Muay Thai. So
- 10:48now I'm starting to learn all the fighters you know, all the
- 10:51fights I know when they're on. I'm very excited about One's
- 10:55partnership with Sky at the moment, because One is the
- 10:58biggest Fighting Championship in the world. But we don't really
- 11:01watch it here. We're more of a UFC kind of peeps, but if anyone
- 11:05watches One, it is stunning. And so, yeah, it's kind of become my
- 11:09obsession. It's not one for everyone. I totally get that.
- 11:12Some people look at me and they think I'm totally mad. But for
- 11:16me, it's been something that I've lent towards, especially to
- 11:19grow resilience as well. It's something I practice. I try my
- 11:23best, and I often go, and when you spar with a world champion
- 11:26once a week, you're going to lose, but you have to stand up,
- 11:30you have to try again. You have to keep going. And I think that
- 11:33that mindset is super important in terms of building resilience.
- 11:47think that is the kind of intellectual equivalent of
- 11:50throwing you a punch you're not expecting, but it is that
- 11:54podcast. So what is your best bit of advice to become a better
- 11:58data driven marketer?
- 11:59I'd love to think that this was a gem which was fully unique to
- 12:03me, but it's the blend of data insights with storytelling and
- 12:07empathy. There is nothing I like more than finding a really
- 12:12juicy, incredible problem, which is, which comes from data. The
- 12:16birth of those problems is, is, is the thing as a creative which
- 12:20makes me excited. But what I see time and time again is people
- 12:26hang the creative on the data, rather than the human element
- 12:30that's that's developed towards it and how it's got there
- 12:35there's a project, and it's often about bringing because
- 12:37when you understand that human element, there's often something
- 12:40on the other side of the fence that you can grab onto, which
- 12:42then creates something really, really special. There was one
- 12:45project I did kind of as a interesting solo piece, and it
- 12:50was based on a bit of data, which I saw around Alzheimer's
- 12:53in the UK being one of the fastest growing conditions in
- 12:56people over the age of 50 in the last 10 years, and the spike of
- 13:01it is is increasing immeasurably. And I was talking
- 13:04to someone at a conference who was studying the proteins which
- 13:08lead to the plaquing of the brain, which which then helps to
- 13:13start certain forms of Alzheimer's. After this, I then
- 13:18was discussing something else with someone around how music
- 13:22triggers memory. And this led me to kind of connect these two
- 13:26kind of thoughts together and be able to build something which
- 13:29was a small project which we did called Meet Betty. And Betty was
- 13:33a digital box which anyone could use. And it was very, very
- 13:37simple, and all you had to do was put your date of birth into
- 13:39Betty, and Betty would bring back the songs that were most
- 13:43relevant from your age between the ages of 15 and 25 with the
- 13:48consideration and thought that those songs would be able to
- 13:51trigger some memories from some very core points in your youth,
- 13:55ie, your first kiss, first dance, the first girl you loved,
- 13:58etc, etc, etc. And we managed to build a prototype and test this
- 14:02with a few people, and kind of lean towards how we would kind
- 14:07of manufacture it. I really wanted to take it to M&S, who
- 14:09apparently have a great back catalog of fabrics and all sorts
- 14:14of interesting things. It's like real heritage stuff. So you
- 14:17could design a box, personalize it for any of your relatives,
- 14:21and we didn't quite get the project off the ground, but that
- 14:24sort of thing, that's what I mean. When you find these kind
- 14:27of data insights, and you can bring them back to a human
- 14:29perspective, I think you can find some real magic in being
- 14:33able to build things.
- 14:34Tom Ollerton: Yeah, it reminds me of there's yet another
- 14:38Beatles documentary on Disney, would you believe. And there's
- 14:42an interview with Smokey Robinson of Miracles fame, and
- 14:45he was, and this quote really stayed with me, is that
- 14:48actually, except phrase, I think it's like music, it's medicine,
- 14:54right? That you when you hear a song, it can really heal you. I
- 14:58mean, if you stick your headphones in and listen to.
- 15:00Kind of like focus music on Spotify all day. You're unlikely
- 15:02to feel like that, but like music is unique in its power to
- 15:06to heal us, you know, heartache or exhaustion or be
- 15:09misunderstood, or all of that stuff you know. And that really
- 15:13struck me that that comment so when, when you said that, it's
- 15:16like, yes, a song. I think music, certainly, for me is, is
- 15:21the most effective time machine, like, you know, I'd listen to,
- 15:25you know, an early Oasis album. I'm 18. Instantly again, you
- 15:29know what I mean, I can see the clothes I'm wearing. I can see
- 15:31the street I'm walking down. I can see myself sat outside a pub
- 15:34smoking a fag, thinking I was cool, but not being cool, you
- 15:37know, I mean, it's, where is he? Yeah, whereas if you showed me a
- 15:40pair of jeans, I wouldn't have that response. Or I read a read
- 15:44an article in the newspaper from that day, I'd be like hmmm...
- 15:47but music, it fires off so many different parts of your brain
- 15:49and takes us to different places and heals us.
- 15:52Tom Fenwick-Smith: 100% I think, you know, smell does a similar
- 15:54thing, and we were looking at ways in which we can interact
- 15:57with that as well, but it didn't quite pull it wasn't quite as
- 16:00easy to access a database of smells, but with sound, it's so
- 16:05the memory that it connects to is so visceral as you as you
- 16:09touched on, like there are definitely certain songs I can I
- 16:12can remember where I was, I can remember what I was doing. I can
- 16:14remember how old I was, how I felt. You know what the feeling
- 16:17was behind that song in the moment. And it's very rare to be
- 16:21able to find something else that can do that and really connect.
- 16:23And it's not unique to an individual. Sometimes, you know,
- 16:27if you think of people that experience big festival
- 16:29experiences, you know certain tracks will really kick off
- 16:33emotional responses for them and genuinely connect their brain
- 16:38and make their body feel something. It's very powerful.
- 16:47Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 16:51brought to you in partnership with madfest. Whether it's live
- 16:54in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 16:57you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 17:00fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 17:03unconventional entertainment from madfest events. You'll find
- 17:06me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 17:09podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 17:13people in marketing. Check it out at www dot madfest
- 17:17london.com.
- 17:24Once again, we're miles, miles and miles off track. So I feel
- 17:28like this. You know, the grown up here, which is rare for me.
- 17:32So we're gonna, we're now gonna talk about your shiny new
- 17:34object, not for as long as I'd hoped. But anyway, let's get
- 17:37into it. So your shiny new object is the human element of
- 17:40AI, what is that? And why is it your shiny new object, and if
- 17:43you can, let's try and keep it vaguely on marketing?
- 17:46Tom Fenwick-Smith: Yeah, well, I think because I've been around
- 17:50for a little bit, and I've been lucky enough to live in a
- 17:52timeframe where I've seen the development of various bits of
- 17:57new technology, from like social platforms to things like Spotify
- 18:00and all these kind of new things that we kind of take for
- 18:02granted, and there's always a bit of a user cycle with them,
- 18:06of how people use them. With AI, it's become slightly different
- 18:11because the guardrails surrounding it are asking us to
- 18:15use it in a certain way, and I think it's there's a lot of
- 18:19concern around AI, and it's taking jobs and all those sort
- 18:23of things. And the thing I'm looking forward to within that
- 18:27is how human beings can reclaim the use of AI and how we can
- 18:34still own the storytelling. I think that I came into this
- 18:38business because I wanted to kind of make people feel
- 18:40something and similar, you know, that's always what I was trying
- 18:43to do with a lot of my creative work, and any kind of films I've
- 18:46ever made, and all that kind of stuff. And I think we're at a
- 18:49really interesting place now where we can explore how we can
- 18:52still make people feel things, given the power that we're going
- 18:55to have behind us with AI and we're going to have see such an
- 18:59explosion in projects development, all this kind of
- 19:02stuff, and it's going to be the cream that rises to the top. And
- 19:06I think that cream will be based on people that have been able to
- 19:09hack or understand how to make people feel, even having all
- 19:14this innovation around them, still, so human, the feeling of
- 19:17human and those things that come with them will become the
- 19:20premium. If that makes sense, that's my belief. That's kind of
- 19:25what I think.
- 19:25Tom Ollerton: Yeah, I mean, it's not a million miles from from my
- 19:27thinking just came off doing being interviewed on someone
- 19:30else's podcast, and they're like, you know, how do you
- 19:33Automated Creative use AI? And our thing is that you should use
- 19:36generative AI to do things you couldn't do before, not to do
- 19:39the things you're doing before, faster and cheaper. Because
- 19:42everyone is everyone is going to use it to do what they're
- 19:45currently doing faster and cheaper, right? That's the sort
- 19:48of a base level of intelligence as goes into it. So like, right?
- 19:51We need to crank out a ton of banners in all these different
- 19:54languages for all of these different platforms in all of
- 19:57these different markets. Right? You can automate that stuff,
- 20:00right? You can use AI, you can crank that out, right? But then
- 20:03so can your competitors like, and the analogy I use is email,
- 20:06right? At some point, not very many people used email, and then
- 20:10there would have been a an innovator who goes, Do you know
- 20:13what I'm going to use email in my office? And when you know
- 20:16we're not going to like have meetings as much, we're not
- 20:18going to type stuff out, we're not going to send letters, we're
- 20:22going to use email. And someone would have been on stage at a
- 20:25conference saying this and be like, well, that will never
- 20:27stick, and all this kind of stuff. So eventually it catches
- 20:30on, and it was, it was a competitive advantage to begin
- 20:33with, but then as soon as everyone's doing it, there isn't
- 20:36an advantage, it's a zero sum game, right? So, and I think the
- 20:39same will be, the same will be true with with AI for average
- 20:42ideas and an average production, right? Everyone will save a
- 20:45certain amount of time and money in producing the thing that they
- 20:49were currently doing. However, our clients, the way that
- 20:51they're using it, in a very progressive way, is go, Well,
- 20:54what can we do with Gen AI that we couldn't do before? Right? So
- 20:58you've got brands who are going, Well, normally what we do is we
- 21:01put our shot in the foreground of a scene, like on a beach or
- 21:04in a bar or in a bathroom or in a wherever, and we could afford
- 21:07to do one, like four of those shoots a year, or one of those
- 21:10shoots, whereas now you can, you can do as many as you want. But
- 21:13what you can do with automation is you can test all of those
- 21:16different scenarios. You can set right, okay, so we're going to
- 21:19run all of those scenarios with our products in it, so all the
- 21:23audience, and then we can learn from the audience. How do they
- 21:26want to be communicated with? You couldn't do that before
- 21:29without Gen AI, because it would just be financially unfeasible.
- 21:32Whereas now what you can do is you can unlock new insights by
- 21:35using Gen AI to create ads at scale. Whereas I think
- 21:38everyone's thinking, right, brilliant, well, we'll we'll
- 21:40just get chat GPT to write our copy, but then everyone else is
- 21:43going to do that. Everything's going to sound the same. Then
- 21:46your, your job as a marketer is to stand out, not to fit in.
- 21:50Tom Fenwick-Smith: And this is why when when building a team
- 21:52and when working with creators, I'm so I'm a massive proponent
- 21:55of neurological diversity and just different ways of thinking,
- 22:01because creativity is individual. It comes from lived
- 22:04experience so much of the time. And I think, as you say, you can
- 22:08have this base level of AI that can churn out a creative option.
- 22:12You know, you can do hundreds of different AB tests with very
- 22:16basic creative and I'm sure you can see results, but you won't
- 22:18have anything that truly connects and lives rent free in
- 22:21someone's psyche, because it hasn't connected, connected with
- 22:25them at a human level at the moment. And I think, you know,
- 22:28Coca Cola? Did you know they just redid their their ads using
- 22:32full AI? And I think it was a great technical achievement, but
- 22:35it did leave me not feeling much, right?
- 22:36Tom Ollerton: Oh, no. I don't think it's a technical
- 22:38achievement at all. I thought it was like, like, I mean, as a
- 22:41Brit, I don't, we have people all over the world listen to
- 22:45this podcast, but as a Brit, like the Coca Cola advert, it
- 22:48was one of those kind of, like, it's the, it's a great it's a
- 22:52green shoot of Christmas. The first time you hear Mariah or
- 22:55Slade or have a mulled wine, it's like, it's the, it's one of
- 22:59the gate posts to the to the Christmas experience, right? But
- 23:02I saw the advert, and I just was going, Oh, Ah, I didn't feel
- 23:06Christmassy. Like, number one job of a Coke advert, like, if
- 23:09it was like, I don't know, some kind of thing with 3d
- 23:12influencers, and they'd really broke, broken the mould, fine,
- 23:16but what they tried to do was just like, deliver the same old
- 23:19right? But they, the insight I have for from a source who
- 23:23remain nameless, is that, apparently Coke have invested
- 23:26like a billion into Microsoft AI tech. So actually, that campaign
- 23:29was a B to B campaign from Microsoft, which gives a which
- 23:33gives it a very It wasn't, but it was.
- 23:35Tom Fenwick-Smith: Yeah, I mean, it really comes back to this
- 23:38uncanny valley theory, which I know a lot of lot of the guys,
- 23:41if you probably got lots of listeners that kind of work in
- 23:43the virtual reality, mixed reality space. But there's
- 23:45something that those, those guys have been juggling with for a
- 23:48long time, and it's just, it's a built in human part of our
- 23:52brain, which just is un comfortable with something that
- 23:57doesn't feel human. It, and it's built into our evolutionary
- 24:01tracks, right? And nothing's been able to beat that yet.
- 24:04Tom Ollerton: You'll go to a conference, marketing
- 24:06conference, and there'll be two tracks, right? For argument, say
- 24:09there's the AI track and then there's the influencer track,
- 24:12right? And the word everyone's gonna say over and over with
- 24:15influencers as they should, is authenticity, right? It's about
- 24:18having an authentic influencer relationship, and it's authentic
- 24:22activation. So when that person says this product's ace, it
- 24:24sounds like they actually mean it, right? If you remove the
- 24:27authenticity, you remove the effectiveness. But yeah, on the
- 24:30other hand, we're like, right? Well, yeah, we're going to use,
- 24:31like, Gen AI to completely synthetically make people,
- 24:34because it's cheaper, it's mad. It's the same industry. But we
- 24:37said, with like, pulling these in completely different
- 24:40directions, whilst putting ourselves on the back about how
- 24:43clever we are.
- 24:44Tom Fenwick-Smith: Well, as someone who works with creators
- 24:46an awful lot, you know, their authenticity is really what
- 24:49makes our engagement and our you know, it sells our products in
- 24:55whatever way, right? And if you take that away, it just Yeah, it
- 24:59doesn't. It doesn't feel right. I find it really interesting
- 25:02that the explosion of creators has happened at the same time as
- 25:05the kind of the growth of AI right? As you say, it's pulling
- 25:09in two different directions, and it'll be interesting to see
- 25:13where it goes. It kind of it leads back to what I was saying
- 25:15earlier. I really do think that human will become premium.
- 25:18Tom Ollerton: Yeah, I absolutely agree. Because once everyone's
- 25:20AI production, then what's gonna be the differentiator is an
- 25:24idea. And if everyone's using AI to produce the same ideas, then
- 25:29it's the it's the human that can think tangentially, which will
- 25:32be the competitive advantage. I think, is your point. I mean, I
- 25:35saw a brilliant tweet on LinkedIn saying his guy was on a
- 25:39flight to New York or somewhere, and he said he watched an exec
- 25:42from one of the big four accounting firms use chatgpt to
- 25:46write every word of a 50 page report for their clients. It
- 25:52might not even be true. It might not be even be true, right? But
- 25:55it feels like it probably, you know, like there's some there's
- 25:58some truth in there. Maybe it's just a brilliant LinkedIn post.
- 26:00Tom Fenwick-Smith: I don't know. You know, never let facts in the
- 26:03way of a good story. You know. Well, that's, that's it.
- 26:05Tom Ollerton: Oh, never let AI get in the way of good story.
- 26:09Probably, probably a good place to leave it Tom, I've enjoyed
- 26:12this so much, man, and I feel we've, we've definitely not
- 26:15necessarily delivered on the promise of the podcast, but it's
- 26:18been a fascinating conversation. I really appreciate it.
- 26:20Tom Fenwick-Smith: No, no worries. Thanks for your time.
- 26:22Tom Ollerton: And if someone wants to get in touch with you,
- 26:24where is the best place to do that and what makes them what
- 26:27makes a message you actually bother replying to?
- 26:29Tom Fenwick-Smith: You can definitely reach out to me in
- 26:31LinkedIn and just, yeah, tell me your obsession. I know that
- 26:35sounds a bit weird, doesn't it?
- 26:36Tom Ollerton: but sounds quite sexy.
- 26:38Tom Fenwick-Smith: It does doesn't it. Now I've said it out
- 26:40loud, it sounds a bit weird, but generally, obsessions are the
- 26:44way to pique my interest.
- 26:47Tom Ollerton: Let's leave it there. Thank you so much.
- 26:49Tom Fenwick-Smith: Thanks. Tom.
- 26:56Tom Ollerton: hi just before you go, I'd really appreciate it if
- 27:00you could take the time to write a review of the shiny new object
- 27:04podcast on Apple podcasts or iTunes, or whatever it's called
- 27:07these days, or whichever podcast provider you use, we're in a new
- 27:11podcast. So it would go a long way for us if you could just
- 27:14share the Word and give us a bit of a support on those channels.
- 27:18That'd just be fantastic. If you haven't got time. That's also
- 27:20cool. And yeah, if you could tell your colleagues about the
- 27:23podcast, and also, if possible, don't forget to subscribe. And
- 27:27I'd love to hear your feedback. If you'd like to speak on the
- 27:30podcast, I'll be a guest, or you think I'm asking the wrong
- 27:33questions. Anything, I'd be super interested to hear what
- 27:35you think. So please email me Tom at automated creative.net,
- 27:42that's Tom at I'm not gonna bother spelling it anyway.
- 27:46You'll work it out. Thanks so much.