Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Progressive Design-Build: Rethinking Risk, Teamwork, and the Off‑Ramp
Transcript
- 0:00A big thank you to Autodesk, the sponsor of Engineering Influence at this year's convention.
- 0:06Autodesk partners with the AEC industry and its leaders to shape a more connected,
- 0:11data-driven future empowering engineers to work more intelligently and to make
- 0:16confident decisions to drive meaningful impact.
- 0:19This enables firms to evolve, stay competitive, and deliver stronger business
- 0:24outcomes, all while designing a better world.
- 0:27So thank you again to Autodesk.
- 0:34Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Engineering Influence podcast by
- 0:38the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:40We're coming to you live from the ACC Annual Convention and Legislative Summit,
- 0:43and this podcast is sponsored by Autodesk.
- 0:46I'm Shreya Jin, and I'll be your host for today, and I have with me Dr.
- 0:49Keith Molinar, who is the Dean of the College of Engineering and Applied Science
- 0:52at the University of Colorado Boulder.
- 0:54Keith, thank you so much for being here, and welcome to the podcast.
- 0:57It is my pleasure, Shreya.
- 0:58So we are going to be talking about progressive design build today.
- 1:01So can you start off by telling us a little bit about Progressive Design Build and what it is. Sure.
- 1:05So I've been doing research in project delivery methods for about the last 30 years.
- 1:11And really, Design Build started
- 1:13to be used in the public sector and more broadly back in the late 1990s.
- 1:18Progressive Design Build is the latest progression or the latest version of Design Build.
- 1:24And I think it really addresses what we found in our study, is it truly addresses
- 1:28some of the challenges around cost, risk, and some of the other elements that
- 1:33we've found through other types of design build, such as
- 1:37lump sum best value or low bid design build.
- 1:41So you talked about other types of design build. What is it that makes progressive
- 1:45design build unique? Yeah, so progressive design build starts through qualifications-based
- 1:51selection. And I think that's the most unique factor.
- 1:54It's really hiring based on qualifications an ability to do teamwork and to
- 2:02come up with collaborative solutions.
- 2:04So where a lump sum best value is done through a competition with an RFP.
- 2:11And a scored competitive competition, progressive design build begins with qualifications-based
- 2:17selection, just like you would do with a consultant, an engineer, or an architect.
- 2:22From there, you work towards a firm fixed price or a guaranteed maximum price
- 2:28through the pre-construction and preliminary design phase so that, you know, the.
- 2:34Main differences are qualifications-based selection and a truly two-phased process
- 2:39working towards a price and then getting through design and construction.
- 2:43Yeah, absolutely. And you talked a little bit about qualifications-based selection.
- 2:47Can you expand on that a little bit and restate its importance to the engineering industry?
- 2:52Yeah, for sure. You know, progressive design build is used when there's uncertainty
- 2:57in scope or an owner wants really, really...
- 3:01Early constructability and
- 3:03knowledge from a construction company in partnership with a design firm.
- 3:09So really, truly the best way to do that is to have a rigorous qualifications-based selection.
- 3:15You're hearing many owners do that not only through just scoring of
- 3:20past projects or scoring of qualifications, but having even day-long sessions
- 3:26to see how design builders work through problems, how they would be working with their team.
- 3:31So you've seen the qualifications-based selection process really evolve as well over the last few years.
- 3:37And, you know, some of these projects are multiple years. So you really want
- 3:41to do a rigorous QBS process when getting into a long-term relationship like this.
- 3:47You want to have the best person for the job, right? Absolutely.
- 3:49Yes. Not just the best firms, but actually the best people as well.
- 3:53For sure. Absolutely. The people are the ones who make up the firms.
- 3:56Exactly. So, you know, in that same vein of picking the best people and everything,
- 4:01you said that progressive design build is working as intended when certain firms
- 4:06or companies choose to drop or, you know, back out of the contract that they originally agreed to.
- 4:12What do you mean by that? How is it working as intended? Well,
- 4:15I think you're referring to our kind of second or later part of the report that
- 4:20we just published, and that is around off-ramping.
- 4:23Is that what you're referring to? Yes, yes, off-ramping. So I think the unique
- 4:27piece of progressive design build is truly two contracts.
- 4:32One that does the preliminary design, pre-construction, and makes sure that
- 4:35a project can be done within the budget and achieving the scope and goals of an owner.
- 4:41And then the second part is the, you know, construction phase.
- 4:45It's still got more design. It's a design overlap with construction,
- 4:48but you're working under a fixed price there.
- 4:51I think a truly surprising finding from our study was that when that off-ramp
- 4:56is exercised, and that means you couldn't get to agreement on a price or external
- 5:02variables changed and you didn't.
- 5:04The project didn't progress to a place where you could sign that contract for the second phase.
- 5:11The projects we studied and the people we interviewed really didn't see that
- 5:15as a project failure, but they saw that as a natural and planned portion of the process.
- 5:22So they entered into that first agreement. They went through rigorous design,
- 5:26risk analysis, vetting of the project, and then discovered that it couldn't
- 5:31be completed as intended.
- 5:33And it wasn't necessarily due to, you know, somebody being at fault or a firm
- 5:39not being qualified, but it was more just the process functioning as intended.
- 5:43Kind of a no-fault divorce. Yeah, somewhat. Yeah, somewhat. Again,
- 5:47we work on really, really complex projects with so many stakeholders and so many variables.
- 5:53I think, again, a surprising part was, you know, we have a lot of successful
- 5:58projects that we studied, but those ones that were off-ramp weren't really seen
- 6:02as a failure. And that was an interesting finding. That is really interesting, yeah.
- 6:07You know, shifting gears a little bit more towards that adoption of progressive
- 6:10design build, you've been very careful to say that although a lot of firms have
- 6:13adopted progressive design build,
- 6:15You've said that adoption is uneven. Yeah. Why do you say that?
- 6:18Yeah. Well, if you read the report, you'll see that about 90% of the firms saw
- 6:25that their portfolio progressive design bill was increasing over the last five years.
- 6:31So it's unavoidable, right? Firms are going to be doing this. Yeah.
- 6:36It's the delivery method now becoming of choice, working towards the future.
- 6:41However, it is a shift. If your firm hasn't done traditional design build,
- 6:46if you've only worked on detailed design engineering or, you know,
- 6:49worked directly for the owner, not with a design builder or contractor.
- 6:55Then it still is uneven.
- 6:56So a lot of firms, as they move into this, have specialized groups,
- 7:01specialized employees or a group within their firm that moves them towards design
- 7:07build and progressive design build.
- 7:09And then as that portion of the firm grows, it can be expanded to be more wide
- 7:15cast across the entire firm.
- 7:17And that actually parallels owners as well. Not all owners are ready for a design
- 7:22build or especially a progressive design build.
- 7:25You're bringing so many people back from construction into the design process
- 7:30and then trying to have the owner and designer work on detailed contracts,
- 7:36schedule and cost decisions very early.
- 7:39It's a set of muscles or a set of skills that you truly need to build.
- 7:43It's not something that just everyone can jump into. For sure. Yeah. Absolutely.
- 7:49And like talking a little bit more about that adoption process,
- 7:51how do you think this study that was released is going to help firms make that
- 7:56decision of whether or not they want to move to that system and that model and
- 7:59they want to develop those skills that it takes to build those labor intensive contracts? Sure.
- 8:04Well, I think just the data that we're providing, the first phase had over 500 responses.
- 8:10The second phase, we studied well over 200 projects, and then into those just
- 8:15a few more than 10 of the off-ramp projects.
- 8:19This study is making the data available. The fact that so many firms are participating,
- 8:26that if you're not participating, you're really somewhat behind the curve.
- 8:30Another really surprising finding was that eight out of the 10 of the participants
- 8:36who completed projects found them to be successful.
- 8:39You know, of course, we'd love 100 percent, but again, we all work on such complex
- 8:44projects. And these are just such anomalies.
- 8:47Yes, they will. Right. And, you know, earlier studies I've done of other delivery
- 8:52methods, sometimes those results are closer to 50%. Of course,
- 8:56you want better than a coin flip. Yes.
- 8:58But I think that's why we're going to see it grow. And I do think that the study
- 9:03has the data that shows that it's growing.
- 9:05Absolutely. Yeah. And how do you think AEC firms can create that collaborative
- 9:10environment that drives this project success? Yeah.
- 9:13Well, phase one of these projects, pre-construction, preliminary design,
- 9:19or many folks call it the validation phase, really takes a discipline.
- 9:23You have to have people ready to make decisions.
- 9:26You have to be able to make decisions at the same pace across the team,
- 9:30whether that's the owner, the designer, or the contractor.
- 9:34You have to have key gates or milestones that you're making these decisions
- 9:38on in case you have to exercise that off-ramp. It's.
- 9:44It can't be as fluid as a preliminary design when a contractor is not on board
- 9:49or a preliminary design when you're developing an RFP.
- 9:52These are much more collaborative projects that have to set up that environment
- 9:58for collaboration, but within a discipline of decision making.
- 10:02And then the other thing I'd add is really bringing in key upper execs from
- 10:08the design firm, from the contracting firm and the owner at those key milestones.
- 10:13So, again, both the successful and unsuccessful projects that we've studied
- 10:18really looked at that discipline and how rigorous it needs to be in that first phase. Absolutely.
- 10:25Well, we've covered a lot of ground here talking about progressive design build,
- 10:28the study, what it can do for firms, and why the process is so unique.
- 10:32Do you have any final thoughts you'd like to leave everyone with?
- 10:35Yeah. You know, as a dean of the college here, I have almost 11,000 students,
- 10:41and I think about where they're going.
- 10:43Our civil engineers, our electrical engineers, our architectural engineers.
- 10:48And after doing this study, I really am convinced that progressive design build
- 10:55is so much more collaborative.
- 10:57It's such a unique problem-solving environment that I'm really excited to see
- 11:01the growth because seeing our students get involved in this type of collaborative
- 11:06decision-making, collaborative problem-solving, and.
- 11:11Project-based work is really exciting for me.
- 11:14So I'm thrilled to see the industry moving in this direction.
- 11:18Absolutely. I would encourage everyone to check out the Progressive Design Build
- 11:22Study that was released by the ACC Research Institute.
- 11:25And this was the engineering influence podcast brought to you by the american
- 11:28council of engineering companies make sure to like and subscribe and we'll see
- 11:32you next time thank you thank you for your time yeah thank you.