Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Engineering Workforce Playbook: Rebranding the "E"
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to the Engineering Influence Podcast from the American Council of Engineering
- 0:08Companies coming to you from our 2025 Fall Conference in beautiful San Diego, California.
- 0:14And one thing that this has been, it's been a conference that's focused on two
- 0:19things, technology and people.
- 0:22And you can't have one without the other. Really in this fast-paced world that
- 0:27we live in, technology is driving the industry, but you need the people to actually
- 0:30put that technology to good use.
- 0:32And to really focus in on that, I'm very, very pleased to be joined by Eric Renzel.
- 0:37He is a member of the workforce committee. He is also, you are on the ground floor of the EWC as well.
- 0:43I was, yeah. I was part of the original group signing the MOU.
- 0:47So the Engineering Workforce Consortium, if you're not completely knowledgeable
- 0:52of that, that is really a group effort here.
- 0:57We're doing it with ASCE, APWA, kind of as the steering committee,
- 1:00but then we have a group from really private, public education,
- 1:05everybody trying to come together and tackle the workforce issue itself.
- 1:09Not exactly a small challenge. You know, we were talking to Joe Bage from the
- 1:13Institute not too long ago, and the workforce study that's coming out from their
- 1:17firm, The Future Project, workforce
- 1:19is going to be a challenge that is not going anywhere anytime fast.
- 1:24You know, give us a little bit of update what's happening on the workforce committee,
- 1:27the work that you guys are doing, and, you know, really just how we're tackling
- 1:32this both through the committee and the consortium.
- 1:35Yeah, well, first, Jeff, thanks for having me on the podcast.
- 1:37I really appreciate the opportunity to be here.
- 1:39It's great to contribute to something that I think is an absolutely critical
- 1:43national dialogue that we have.
- 1:45And I've been really encouraged about what I've seen here during the annual
- 1:48convention in terms of focus on workforce development.
- 1:52Particularly yesterday, the workforce committee had, I think,
- 1:56a really good discussion about the topic.
- 1:59I was proud to participate in the conversation. In addition to my role as a
- 2:04member organization of ACEC, I also represent the Institute of Transportation
- 2:10Engineers, or ITE, for external workforce development issues.
- 2:14We'll talk about that in the context of EWC in a minute.
- 2:17But here, as far as the ACEC goes, I'll tell you what I've seen overall is a
- 2:21lot of dedicated people to making a difference. Yeah.
- 2:23And, you know, when you get a lot of really intelligent, motivated people together, you
- 2:29kicking ideas around, you're bound to come up with something that really makes a difference.
- 2:33And so I would say overall, I'm really encouraged about what I've seen here.
- 2:37It's definitely one of our key focus areas.
- 2:39Getting the EWC started was a big focus for our CEO, but then just investing
- 2:46in the workforce committee, building that out.
- 2:48Creating the playbook that we announced over the conference,
- 2:52maybe speak to that a little bit and how that's going to inform some of the
- 2:56work to arm some of our member organizations with the tools necessary to kind
- 3:00of take this to the States.
- 3:01What I'm really impressed about is the depth of the content in the playbook.
- 3:06You know, it covers everything really from, you know, the beginning of an idea
- 3:11that you might want to go on to be an engineer to being somebody who's ready
- 3:14to retire and pass on that legacy.
- 3:17But that doesn't mean it's light on content. I think it has a lot of great ideas, proven strategies.
- 3:23And that's the thing that sets it apart from some other things that I've seen
- 3:26is that proven strategies that member organizations can take today and implement at their company.
- 3:33So very thoughtful, but also tactical.
- 3:36One of the challenges we had early on, you know, we identified early was the
- 3:41fact that, you know, there's no central repository for a lot of this information.
- 3:45Firms are going and trying to do their own recruitment in their own way,
- 3:49and everybody's kind of doing their things, but nobody's actually collected all that information.
- 3:54And the one thing I think the playbook does well is take best practices from
- 3:59different organizations among the states and then also different organizations outside of ACDC.
- 4:04As well as tried and true, you know, guidance and bring it together to make
- 4:09it accessible for everybody.
- 4:10You know, I think that's talking to me that speaks to leadership, right?
- 4:14And I think that ACEC in really spearheading the formation of the Engineering
- 4:20Workforce Consortium, if I could broaden the term playbook beyond the document
- 4:24that was just released, that's part of the playbook too is coalition building.
- 4:27And I think it's this recognition, whether you're, you know,
- 4:31an ACEC private or ACEC member organization, whether you're a public agency, right?
- 4:37There are things that we want to do to, you know, be part of our brand and recruit
- 4:43people to want to work for our organization.
- 4:45But I think informing the EWC and what's in the playbook, it recognizes that, sure.
- 4:53Drawing people into our individual organizations is important,
- 4:56but there's a higher order need, and that's to draw people into our industry. Sure. Yeah.
- 5:02And I think that's the big change in mindset, right?
- 5:05Of course, association membership is critically important. We want people to
- 5:09join into our organizations.
- 5:11But at the same time, you know, we've actually taken an industry look now.
- 5:15We're actually focused on how do we actually get people into our industries,
- 5:19whether it's the consulting industry or whether it's the public utilities industry.
- 5:22And how do we, you know, rising tide lifts all boats mindset,
- 5:26which I think is the most important thing to really address the workforce shortage.
- 5:31Yeah, you know, that was what compelled ITE to join the Engineering Workforce
- 5:36Consortium, frankly, because, of course, being a transportation organization,
- 5:40we talk about on-ramps for people to get into our industry, right?
- 5:44Whether you know when you're in junior high school that that's what you want
- 5:48to do, or maybe you didn't figure that out until you were 30 years old.
- 5:51We want you in to our industry and we want you to be a contributor, right?
- 5:56Because we all know the value that engineers, in the case of IT,
- 6:01transportation professionals bring to the built environment.
- 6:05But we don't always get that word out there the right way or as strongly as
- 6:09we could. And it's just that visibility.
- 6:12You know, I was thinking and talking to a previous guest that,
- 6:15you know, who's really engaged with mentoring and mentorship,
- 6:17that unlike other professions, you know, you don't turn on the television.
- 6:22You're going to turn on the television, you're going to see a legal drama.
- 6:25You're going to see some kind of a medical drama.
- 6:27You're going to see something of another profession that's really highly promoted.
- 6:32But you don't turn on the television and see a show about engineers.
- 6:36So the exposure is not really there. And it's incumbent upon industry and associations
- 6:42like ours to get that message out that engineering,
- 6:47public works, the things that actually make society run, it's a noble profession.
- 6:52Yeah. You know, that was one of the things that came up first in our workforce
- 6:55committee yesterday was about rebranding.
- 6:58Yeah. Right. And as I said, the comment I made is that even when I started in
- 7:03this field, you know, it was not ethical to put the name of your company on
- 7:07the side of a vehicle. Yeah. Right.
- 7:09And we were trained in school that, you know, when you're supporting a public
- 7:13agency, you know, when an elected official steps forward to,
- 7:17you know, celebrate something that's being done, you step back.
- 7:21Yeah. Right. That's really what the message.
- 7:22And that's been baked in. It's that, you know, in the life cycle of a project,
- 7:27the work that the engineer does is so early.
- 7:30It's before anything really goes vertical. Right.
- 7:34But it enables that entire project and that small, you know,
- 7:38the spend at the beginning influences the entire project life cycle. But it's not seen.
- 7:44Yeah. You know, if it's done well, it's never seen. And it's hard to show the investment.
- 7:50Yeah, you know, the only time you're typically going to see an engineer on TV
- 7:54is when there's a crisis. Exactly.
- 7:56And that's something we have to change. And I think that the playbook,
- 7:59I think the work that's being done by ACEC to the Workforce Development Committee
- 8:04and the Engineering Workforce Consortium, there's a concerted effort to change that mindset.
- 8:09Yeah, and we're trying to do that. I mean, tied in with the EWC is the Engineering
- 8:13Public Works Roadshow, trying to get out there and demonstrate the value of good public works.
- 8:19The events that we've held with students, you can kind of see them light up
- 8:24and kind of the, you know, it connects in their minds what that work means.
- 8:29The other part is just, you know, getting out there and just explaining the
- 8:33essentiality of the, and I think this is something that is found with the workforce
- 8:37study that we're going to be coming out with is the idea that,
- 8:40you know, people who are coming in to the industry or the future next generation,
- 8:46they want to have that value behind the work that they do. They want to have a benefit.
- 8:51They want to contribute more than just to the economy, but to society.
- 8:56It's a perfect profession for doing that. I agree. And you can look at that
- 9:00from a couple of different ways.
- 9:01First, of course, in childhood education, many member organizations and engineers
- 9:07across industry are proud of engagement with STEM activity. And we should keep doing that.
- 9:12But we shouldn't be shy about highlighting the value of the E in STEM.
- 9:17And I think that we've diluted the message somewhat and haven't done ourself
- 9:24enough justice to really emphasize the E among science, technology, and math.
- 9:32And the way you can get in, where you start salary-wise, career opportunities later.
- 9:38And then I think in the mid-career, it's kind of about fighting a stereotype,
- 9:44which is if you didn't initially go to college and get that four-year engineering
- 9:49degree when you were 20, 23 years old, that you can never get in. Exactly.
- 9:53And that's just not the answer. That's not the truth. Yeah, especially these days.
- 9:56I mean, especially now with the rapid advancement of technologies.
- 10:00You know, the fact is the firm of 10 years from now is not going to look like anything we have now.
- 10:05The computer fields, the software fields, the AI, of course,
- 10:09but then drone operators, the people who are using the applying the technologies
- 10:13to support licensed engineers.
- 10:15There's a whole realm of field open to people who don't have a traditional engineering
- 10:21degree to be part of the industry and contribute to it and be compensated very well for doing it.
- 10:28But, you know, Jeff, we have a pattern for this. Some folks like to pretend
- 10:31like we've never done this before. Or, you know, when I was coming out of school
- 10:35was when CAD was really becoming the normal.
- 10:38Prior to my generation, I graduated in 2000, okay? Yep, fantastic.
- 10:43Prior to me, you know, at the large firm that I worked at, there was an army of draftsmen, right?
- 10:50And that slowly changed. And what we saw was an adaptation to train people on
- 10:55computer skills, to be able to take what the knowledge that they had is really
- 11:00assistant engineers and apply that through the CAD.
- 11:03Right. And so we're an industry that's about adaptation.
- 11:08We've done it for the entire existence of engineering. There's no reason to
- 11:12think that we are not ready for the challenge now. Yeah.
- 11:14And if you're out there and you're studying, you know, computer science or you're a data person,
- 11:20you know, one of the things I talked to a firm about not too long ago was how
- 11:25they're structuring their firm to have, you know, these project teams that you
- 11:30have your licensed engineers,
- 11:31you have your sole technical people who are doing the engineering work.
- 11:36But then you have this backfill of data specialists and people who are managing
- 11:39the data because data is going to be king and whoever owns and manages that
- 11:44data appropriately is going to win.
- 11:46So they have this entire structure of non-engineers who are there specifically
- 11:50to support all of the data stuff and using all the AI tools and manipulating
- 11:54all that stuff so that the firm works in a new way.
- 11:59So if you're out there and you're
- 12:01working in this stuff, it's a perfect opportunity to join the industry.
- 12:04I can speak to that from my personal experience, Jeff, because two and a half
- 12:09years ago, I transitioned from a large firm to starting my own company.
- 12:13And, you know, the first year was all about getting my feet under me and getting organized.
- 12:17And, you know, Jeff, when it came time to hire my first employee, do you know what I hired?
- 12:23Somebody with a master's degree in information systems and undergraduate in
- 12:26computer science. You know why?
- 12:27Because no matter what project I work on, it comes down to data stored in disparate
- 12:33systems that need to be brought together to get new insights.
- 12:36So I know as I'm starting my small business, I have almost 30 years of engineering experience.
- 12:45I need somebody who's just as powerful in data integration. Yeah,
- 12:49exactly. And that's going to become more important.
- 12:51And while data, AI, all that's going to create efficiencies,
- 12:55you're going to need the workforce to actually apply that technology.
- 12:58And that's just one of many avenues that's open to us. I mean,
- 13:02we do need as an industry to take advantage of that and evangelize.
- 13:06To your point, we need a step from that shadow.
- 13:09We have to need a step from the background into the light.
- 13:12You know, it's interesting whenever we do these roadshow events
- 13:16and we have the engineers who worked
- 13:19on the projects and we actually have had situations where
- 13:22engineers on significant projects
- 13:25you know bridges in miami
- 13:29we have we have important infrastructure
- 13:32and they come to us after and they say this is the first time
- 13:35i've been publicly recognized for my work stuff that is going to support billions
- 13:42of dollars of economic activity support the safety and welfare of sometimes
- 13:48millions of people and they don't get the recognition that they should and it's
- 13:52not going to come naturally.
- 13:55You got to step forward and actually take it.
- 13:57You know, I mentioned a few minutes ago that throughout the course of the history
- 14:01of engineering, we've shown our ability to adapt.
- 14:04We've also shown at times that we will resist that change until the last possible minute.
- 14:09I think what's important for us to recognize at this time is that that rate
- 14:14of acceptance, the curve, if you will, it's shortening and it's sharpening.
- 14:19And I think that it's not a time to resist that change. It's time to step forward
- 14:25and lead because engineers also show that we lead things. Yeah, absolutely.
- 14:29And just one more point to what you said there is that that's where I think
- 14:34the workforce issue overall ties into a lot of other topical areas that ACEC is focused on.
- 14:40Because, you know, whether we're talking about, you know,
- 14:43value and a value agenda and protecting quality based selection and things like
- 14:49that, we want to be able to bring our creativity and our ingenuity to solve engineering problems.
- 14:56Yes, we might have new tools in the toolbox to do that, but that doesn't mean
- 15:00that the creativity of the people working on our industry is any less.
- 15:03Oh, no. If not, it's more.
- 15:05It's more, and to your point, to extend on that, it's value not just in QBS,
- 15:12it's not just value in selection, but it's also value in pricing.
- 15:16Absolutely. Which is critically important because the threat is always when
- 15:19you have a tool like AI come out, the threat is commoditization, right?
- 15:25And we have to fight against that because the value that engineers bring has
- 15:28always been the intellectual power of their talent, but then also the ability
- 15:33to apply innovative solutions to very complex challenges that a machine cannot do.
- 15:39And that value has to be seen throughout their marketing through the project
- 15:45selection and how they position themselves.
- 15:47It is a trusted advisor relationship.
- 15:50And we can't dilute that.
- 15:53I spoke to somebody here during the show that said, you know,
- 15:56they were working for a client that said, oh, well, you're probably using AI
- 15:58now. So you're going to reduce my fee, right?
- 16:01What we want the question to be is how much more creativity are you going to
- 16:04be able to bring to my project?
- 16:06It's anticipating things. It's actually, you know, no, it's not a question of
- 16:10lowering your fee, but we'll lower your overall project costs because we're
- 16:14going to create efficiencies along the way.
- 16:15Or improve your value. Or improve your value or find a solution that you weren't
- 16:19thinking of or address an issue that you weren't considering in the first master plan.
- 16:23And we just need to stay with that. That's right. I agree with you. Yeah, absolutely.
- 16:28You know, great event, great conference, workforce, big part of it.
- 16:32What do you have next on the workforce committee?
- 16:35What are we looking forward to? So, you know, we're looking,
- 16:37we're going to be looking forward to the next engineering workforce consortium
- 16:41summit, which will be held again next April with the member organizations of that.
- 16:45And there's some work to do. You know, you come out of a conference like this
- 16:49and other chances you get to interact with things and, you know, you're full of ideas.
- 16:55There's so many great conversations that take place that video calls can't really
- 16:59replace, you know, from an in-person standpoint, but you got to come away,
- 17:03you got to filter those down to the...
- 17:05Salient points i think you know clearly on the
- 17:08workforce front there's a lot of momentum i've seen
- 17:11a lot of great you know products and things being created
- 17:14by acc member organizations across the
- 17:17country i think it's bringing some of those to the national spotlight and letting
- 17:22them shine i think it's also about you know there's a thread there about what
- 17:27do we do for mid-career professionals how do we keep them from leaving once
- 17:30we let them in right so there's that and And, you know, I think there's some
- 17:34other opportunities there.
- 17:35So we're going to build towards that next summit and, you know,
- 17:38really try to get ourselves in a spot where we're ready to take action. Fantastic.
- 17:42Well, there's going to be a lot to do. The work does not stop on this issue.
- 17:46So, Eric, I do appreciate the time that you've taken with us and look forward
- 17:49to working for you with you in the months to come because I'll be busy.
- 17:54Absolutely, Jeff. Again, thanks for having me here. Absolutely.
- 17:57And again, this has been Engineering Influence Podcast from the American Council
- 18:01of Engineering companies. See you next time.