Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Kentucky Ballot Amendment 2
Transcript
- 0:05[♪♪]
- 0:10GOOD EVENING. WELCOME TO
- 0:11KENTUCKY TONIGHT. I'M RENEE
- 0:12SHAW. THANKS FOR JOINING US. OUR
- 0:14TOPIC TONIGHT: KENTUCKY BALLOT
- 0:16AMENDMENT TWO, THE SO-CALLED
- 0:18“SCHOOL CHOICE” AMENDMENT. THE
- 0:20MOST TALKED-ABOUT KENTUCKY RACE
- 0:21THIS YEAR DOESN’T INVOLVE
- 0:23CANDIDATES. IT’S A
- 0:24CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT THAT,
- 0:25IF PASSED, WOULD LET THE
- 0:27KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 0:28CONSIDER SPENDING PUBLIC MONEY
- 0:31ON NON-PUBLIC EDUCATION. BACKERS
- 0:32SAY IT WILL GIVE PARENTS MORE
- 0:33OPTIONS FOR THEIR CHILDREN’S
- 0:35EDUCATION. CRITICS SAY IT WILL
- 0:37DRAIN RESOURCES FROM PUBLIC
- 0:39SCHOOLS, AND HURT MOST KENTUCKY
- 0:40STUDENTS.
- 0:41WE’LL TALK ABOUT ALL THIS, IN
- 0:44OUR LEXINGTON STUDIO, WITH THESE
- 0:46FOUR GUESTS:
- 0:46JIM WATERS, PRESIDENT OF THE
- 0:48BLUEGRASS INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC
- 0:48POLICY SOLUTIONS;
- 0:51TOM SHELTON, CHAIR OF THE
- 0:52PROTECT OUR SCHOOLS CAMPAIGN AND
- 0:55A FORMER SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENT;
- 0:57HEATHER LEMIRE, KENTUCKY STATE
- 0:58DIRECTOR OF AMERICANS FOR
- 0:59PROSPERITY;
- 1:01AND JESSICA HILER, PRESIDENT OF
- 1:03THE FAYETTE COUNTY EDUCATION
- 1:04ASSOCIATION.
- 1:05WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU. YOU
- 1:07CAN SEND YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:09COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 1:11-- AT PUB AFFAIRS KET. SEND AN
- 1:14EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT K-E-T
- 1:15DOT O-R-G. OR USE THE WEB FORM
- 1:18AT K-E-T DOT O-R-G SLASH K-Y
- 1:20TONIGHT. OR YOU CAN CALL
- 1:211-800-494-7605. WELCOME TO ALL
- 1:23OUR GUESTS.
- 1:28SOME OF YOU ARE REPEAT FREQUENT
- 1:30FLYERS AS WE LIKE TO SAY.
- 1:32AND WE HAVE A COUPLE NEW FACES
- 1:35SINCE THE LAST TIME WE HAD THIS
- 1:39DISCUSSION SINCE OCTOBER.
- 1:40YOU CAN WATCH PART ONE AND THIS
- 1:41WILL BE THE FINAL INSTALLMENT
- 1:44BEFORE NOVEMBER 5.
- 1:45WE WILL TALK ABOUT IT MORE ON
- 1:47KENTUCKY EDITION.
- 1:48THIS IS THE LONGER VERSION.
- 1:50I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THIS
- 1:51AMENDMENT THAT WOULD ALLOW WE
- 1:53WANT TO CLARIFY AS WE DO EVERY
- 1:55TIME Mr. WATERS WHAT THE
- 1:57AMENDMENT WOULD ALLOW LAWMAKERS
- 1:59TO DO.
- 2:00TELL US YOUR PERSPECTIVE IF
- 2:03KENTUCKY VOTERS APPROVE.
- 2:04>> THANKS.
- 2:06I'M DISAPPOINTED I WANTED TO DO
- 2:08ONE MORE SHOW.
- 2:10I'M KIDDING.
- 2:10NO, THE AMENDMENT 2 IF IT
- 2:13PASSES, WILL ALLOW OUR
- 2:14LEGISLATURE TO FOCUS LESS ON
- 2:16WHAT THE COURTS ARE SAYING AND
- 2:18MORE ON WHAT FAMILIES WANT AND
- 2:21STUDENTS NEED.
- 2:22IT DOESN'T CREATE SCHOOL CHOICE
- 2:25POLICY IT'S CALLED THE SCHOOL
- 2:26CHOICE AMENDMENT.
- 2:27BUT IT CLEARS THE WAY FOR THE
- 2:30LEGISLATURE TO CREATE POLICIES
- 2:32SIMILAR TO WHAT WE'VE SEEN
- 2:33AROUND THE NATION THAT HAVE
- 2:35WORKED TO BOTH PROVIDE STUDENTS
- 2:36WHO NEED A DIFFERENT OPTION TO
- 2:39PROVIDE THAT CHOICE FOR
- 2:40FAMILIES.
- 2:41AND THEN ALSO TO BRING PRESSURE
- 2:42TO BEAR ON OUR PUBLIC SYSTEM, AN
- 2:45APPROPRIATE KIND OF PRESSURE, TO
- 2:47IMPROVE.
- 2:48THE KENTUCKY ASSESSMENT WAS
- 2:50RELEASED SINCE WE HAD OUR LAST
- 2:54CHAIR IN THAT REPORT A MAJORITY
- 2:55OF OUR STUDENTS ARE STILL NOT
- 2:58PROFICIENT IN MATH AND READING.
- 2:59IF YOU LOOK AT THE NATIONAL
- 3:01TESTING, IT'S SHOWING AN EVEN
- 3:03BLEECKER PICTURE OF THAT.
- 3:04AND ESPECIALLY FOR OUR LOW
- 3:06INCOME MINORITY STUDENTS.
- 3:07SO WE'RE FINDING THAT SCHOOL
- 3:09CHOICE POLICIES AROUND THE
- 3:11COUNTRY ARE DOING A LOT TO HELP
- 3:14PARTICULARLY THAT DEMOGRAPHIC
- 3:14AND THAT GROUP.
- 3:15BUT I THINK THERE IS A LOT OF
- 3:18NEED AND WANT.
- 3:18AND I THINK THERE WOULD BE A LOT
- 3:20OF HELP FOR FAMILIES PROVIDED IF
- 3:22THE LEGISLATURE HAS AN
- 3:24OPPORTUNITY TO AT LEAST TALK
- 3:26ABOUT WHAT CAN WE DO HERE IN
- 3:27KENTUCKY AND THEY CAN'T DO THAT
- 3:29IF THIS AMENDMENT DOESN'T PASS.
- 3:34>> Renee: Mr. SHELTON WHEN YOU
- 3:35LOOK AT THE ASSESSMENT SCORES
- 3:37AND IT DOESN'T SHOW MUCH
- 3:38PROGRESS AND FOR THIS SIDE OF
- 3:40THE TABLE IT MAKES THE CASE
- 3:42STRONGER FOR WHY MORE PARENTS
- 3:44SHOULD HAVE OPTIONS PARTICULARLY
- 3:45THOSE WHO COME FROM
- 3:47DISADVANTAGED HOUSEHOLDS.
- 3:48WHAT WOULD YOU SAY IS THE REASON
- 3:50THEY SHOULD REJECT AMENDMENT 2.
- 3:52>> FIRST OF ALL, WE DON'T HAVE
- 3:54ANY PROBLEM WITH SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 3:57SCHOOL CHOICE AS I'VE SAID
- 3:59BEFORE, HAS BEEN AROUND FOR A
- 4:01LONGTIME.
- 4:02THIS AMENDMENT DOESN'T CREATE
- 4:04SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 4:06ALTHOUGH AS Mr. WATERS SAID
- 4:07IT'S CALLED BY A LOT OF PEOPLE
- 4:09THE SCHOOL CHOICE AMENDMENT.
- 4:11IT DOESN'T CREATE CHOICE.
- 4:13THE CHOICE IS ALREADY THERE.
- 4:14SO WE DON'T OPPOSE SCHOOL
- 4:16CHOICE.
- 4:17THE ISSUES AND THE REASONS WE
- 4:19OPPOSE THIS AMENDMENT IS BECAUSE
- 4:20IT TAKES PUBLIC DOLLARS TO FUND
- 4:23THAT SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 4:25AND WE ALREADY HAVE UNDERFUNDED
- 4:28PUBLIC SCHOOLS WHERE 90% OF OUR
- 4:30STUDENTS ATTEND TAKING MONEY
- 4:32AWAY IS NOT THE ANSWER TO
- 4:34IMPROVING STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT.
- 4:37>> Renee: HEATHER LEMIRE THANK
- 4:38YOU FOR BEING WITH US.
- 4:39AND WE JUST GOT THIS VIEWER
- 4:43QUESTION OR COMMENT SAYS QUOTE
- 4:46THE BALLOT LANGUAGE REFERS TO
- 4:47THE CHOICES OF PARENTS BUT THE
- 4:49AMENDMENT LANGUAGE GIVES CHOICES
- 4:50TO THE LEGISLATURE.
- 4:51THE AMENDMENT DOES NOT GUARANTEE
- 4:53PARENTS' CHOICES NOR REQUIRED
- 4:55ANY FUTURE BILL THE LEGISLATURE
- 4:56MAY PASS.
- 4:57WHY WAS THIS MISLEADING LANGUAGE
- 5:00INCLUDED ON THE BALLOT?
- 5:02IS THE LANGUAGE ON THE BALLOT
- 5:04MISLEADING OR CONFUSING?
- 5:05>> I HOPE IT'S NOT CONFUSING.
- 5:08I THINK THE LEGISLATURE TRIED TO
- 5:10MAKE IT AS CLEAR AS POSSIBLE SO
- 5:12PEOPLE WOULD UNDERSTAND IT.
- 5:13AND WE HAVE BEEN TRYING TO
- 5:15EDUCATE PEOPLE ABOUT WHAT THE
- 5:16AMENDMENT IS AND WHAT IT'S NOT.
- 5:19I HOPE THAT PARENTS KNOW THAT,
- 5:22YOU KNOW, THE AMENDMENT ITSELF
- 5:24IS NOT GOING TO BE A SCHOOL
- 5:27CHOICE ANY SPECIFIC PROGRAM OF
- 5:29SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 5:30BUT THAT IS JUST GOING TO GIVE
- 5:33THE LEGISLATURE AN OPPORTUNITY
- 5:34TO COME BACK IF IT PASSES IN
- 5:36JANUARY AND REALLY LOOK AT
- 5:38DIFFERENT OPTIONS.
- 5:39AND THE PUBLIC WILL HAVE AN
- 5:40OPPORTUNITY TO REACH OUT TO
- 5:42THEIR LEGISLATOR AND TELL THEM
- 5:44WHAT THEY WANT.
- 5:46>> Renee: AREN'T THERE
- 5:47DISCUSSIONS WHAT THAT COULD LOOK
- 5:49LIKE CONSIDERING THAT THE
- 5:51LEGISLATURE STARTS SIX, SEVEN
- 5:52WEEKS AFTER THE ELECTION IF THEY
- 5:54WANT TO PASS SOMETHING IN 2025?
- 5:56>> I THINK THERE'S BEEN
- 5:58DISCUSSION ALREADY AROUND
- 6:00CHARTER SCHOOLS SPECIFICALLY.
- 6:01AS SOMETHING THAT WOULD
- 6:03IMMEDIATELY BENEFIT LOWER INCOME
- 6:05FAMILIES.
- 6:06SO THAT'S BEEN SOMETHING THAT I
- 6:07KNOW HAS BEEN DISCUSSED.
- 6:09SO THAT'S PROBABLY SOMETHING
- 6:10THAT THEY WOULD ADDRESS.
- 6:12BUT I MEAN I'M NOT GOING TO
- 6:14SPECULATE.
- 6:14I DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY WILL LOOK
- 6:16AT.
- 6:21>> Renee: SOME PUNISHED ITS
- 6:23WOULD SAY THOSE WHO ARE OPPOSED
- 6:25TO AMENDMENT 2 HAVE AN EASIER
- 6:26TIME OF SELLING IT IT WILL TAKE
- 6:29AWAY MONEY FROM PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 6:30AND ONUS IS IN THE COURT OF
- 6:33THOSE WHO ARE FOR IT TO MAKE THE
- 6:35CASE FOR IT.
- 6:35GIVE US MORE WHY THIS IS A BAD
- 6:37IDEA AND WOULD BE BAD FOR
- 6:39KENTUCKY IN YOUR VIEW?
- 6:40>> WELL, OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE
- 6:42ALREADY CHRONICALLY UNDERFUNDED.
- 6:45WE NEED SMALLER CLASS SIZES AND
- 6:47WE NEED MONEY FOR THAT.
- 6:49WE NEED MORE HEALTH SERVICES FOR
- 6:51KIDS, WE NEED MONEY FOR THAT.
- 6:52WE HAVE A TEACHER SHORTAGE AND
- 6:54WE NEED MONEY AND SERVICES FOR
- 6:56THAT.
- 6:57TAKE A PIE THAT IS SHRINKING
- 6:59EVERY YEAR BECAUSE OUR
- 7:00LEGISLATURE IS NOT KEEPING UP
- 7:01WITH INFLATION WHEN THEY ARE
- 7:02LOOKING AT THE SEEK FUNDING, TO
- 7:04TAKE THAT AND TO START DIVIDING
- 7:06IT TO SCHOOLS THAT ARE NOT
- 7:09PUBLIC SCHOOLS THAT ARE NOT
- 7:11ACCOUNTABLE TO THE PUBLIC, LIKE
- 7:13PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE, REALLY MAKES
- 7:15NO SENSE.
- 7:16I'M NOT ONLY A PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 7:18EDUCATOR BUT A PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 7:19PARENT.
- 7:20AS A PARENT, I HAVE A CHOICE
- 7:21WHERE I WANT MY CHILD TO GO TO
- 7:23SCHOOL.
- 7:24DO I WANT HIM TO GO TO PUBLIC
- 7:26SCHOOL OR PRIVATE I'VE ALWAYS
- 7:27HAD THAT CHOICE.
- 7:29I CHOSE PUBLIC SCHOOLS BECAUSE I
- 7:31KNOW THE SCHOOLS WRAP AROUND OUR
- 7:32COMMUNITY AND PROVIDE THE
- 7:33SERVICES THAT OUR COMMUNITIES
- 7:35NEED TO THRIVE.
- 7:36I'M VERY CONCERNED WHAT IT WOULD
- 7:38DO TO FAYETTE COUNTY PUBLIC
- 7:40SCHOOLS BUT TO OUR RURAL
- 7:41COMMUNITIES.
- 7:42THE AMOUNT OF DOLLARS IT WOULD
- 7:43TAKE AWAY FROM THEM IS
- 7:45CONCERNING TO SEND IT TO URBAN
- 7:47AREAS.
- 7:47WHERE THE MAJORITY OF OUR
- 7:49PRIVATE SCHOOLS ARE LOCATED MOST
- 7:52RURAL COMMUNITIES IN KENTUCKY
- 7:54DON'T HAVE A PRIVATE SCHOOL TO
- 7:55SEND A CHILD TO.
- 7:56>> Renee: AND THAT IS THE POINT
- 7:57YOU MADE LAST TIME YOU WERE ON
- 7:59THE PROGRAM IS THAT 80% OF THE
- 8:04POPULATION MIGHT BENEFIT PERHAPS
- 8:07OR NOT BENEFIT FROM THIS.
- 8:08BECAUSE THEY LIVE IN AREAS WHERE
- 8:10THIS WOULD NOT BE ATTAINABLE?
- 8:12>> RIGHT.
- 8:13THE MAJORITY OF OUR PRIVATE
- 8:15SCHOOLS ARE IN THREE COUNTIES BY
- 8:17FAR.
- 8:17THEY ARE IN JEFFERSON COUNTY,
- 8:19FAYETTE COUNTY AND KENT COUNTY.
- 8:22AND AS YOU MENTIONED, 80% OF OUR
- 8:25PRIVATE SCHOOLS ARE IN EIGHT OF
- 8:27OUR ZIP CODES.
- 8:29SO TWO-THIRDS OF OUR COUNTIES
- 8:31DON'T EVEN HAVE PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 8:33OPTION.
- 8:33SO WE'RE NOT CREATING MORE
- 8:36CHOICE.
- 8:38WE'RE SIMPLY GOING TO BE
- 8:38SHIFTING FUNDS MAINLY FROM THE
- 8:41RURAL AREAS TO THE PRIVATE
- 8:43SCHOOLS FOR THE SPECIFIC AREAS.
- 8:46YOU KNOW, THE BIGGEST ISSUE
- 8:48ABOUT THAT IS, IS THIS IS SUCH
- 8:51AN OPEN ENDED AMENDMENT THE WAY
- 8:55IT'S WRITTEN.
- 8:56THE LANGUAGE IS SO BROAD.
- 8:59IT'S NOT DEFINED.
- 9:00THAT IS PART OF THE PROBLEM TO
- 9:03BEGIN WITH.
- 9:05IT'S ALREADY BEEN SAID WE CAN'T
- 9:07HAVE THE CONVERSATION.
- 9:09WELL, IF WE'RE GOING TO HAVE THE
- 9:10CONVERSATION IT NEEDS TO BE A
- 9:12LITTLE MORE SPECIFIC.
- 9:14HOWEVER, WHAT I WOULD SAY IS
- 9:16THAT AS I MENTIONED LAST TIME,
- 9:19THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS ALREADY
- 9:21SHOWN US WHAT THEY WANT TO DO
- 9:22WITH THIS.
- 9:23THEY FILED HOUSE BILL 563 WHICH
- 9:27THE COUNSEL SUED ON AND WE WON
- 9:29UNANIMOUSLY AT THE SUPREME COURT
- 9:31LEVEL.
- 9:31THEY FILED HB9 AMENDING THE
- 9:34CHARTER SCHOOL LAW ALREADY ON
- 9:35THE BOOKS AND CREATED PRIVATE
- 9:38CHARTER SCHOOLS REQUIRED CHARTER
- 9:40SCHOOLS IN SPECIFIC AREAS OF THE
- 9:41STATE.
- 9:43AND TOOK PUBLIC MONIES FROM
- 9:44LOCAL COMMUNITIES AND SENT IT TO
- 9:47THOSE PRIVATE CHARTER SCHOOLS.
- 9:48SO WE SUED ON THAT ONE AND WON
- 9:52AND IT'S ON ITS WAY TO THE
- 9:54SUPREME COURT.
- 9:54WHEN PEOPLE SAY THAT THERE'S NO
- 9:57BEEN NO DECISION OR NO
- 9:59CONVERSATION ABOUT WHAT IS GOING
- 10:00TO HAPPEN, I DISPUTE THAT.
- 10:02BECAUSE I THINK WE ALREADY KIND
- 10:04OF KNOW BASED ON WHAT'S HAPPENED
- 10:06BEFORE.
- 10:06>> Renee: IF YOU LOOK AT THE
- 10:07PLIGHT OF OUR TRADITIONAL PUBLIC
- 10:10SCHOOLS, I THINK WE TOUCHED ON
- 10:11THIS A LITTLE BIT LAST TIME
- 10:13ABOUT CHRONIC ABSENTEEISM AND WE
- 10:15KNOW KENTUCKY DEFINES THIS AND
- 10:18INFORMATION FROM THE KENTUCKY
- 10:19DEPARTMENT OFD ED IT IS DEFINED
- 10:21AS MISSING 10% OF THE ACADEMIC
- 10:25YEAR FOR ANY REASON.
- 10:27A STUDENT MISSING TWO DAYS A
- 10:29MONTH RESULTS IN BEING CALLED
- 10:31CHRONICALLY ABSENT.
- 10:32AND THAT KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF
- 10:34ED FOUND ACROSS KENTUCKY 30% OF
- 10:38ALL STUDENTS WERE CHRONICALLY
- 10:40ABSENT DURING THE 2022-2023
- 10:46SCHOOL YEAR.
- 10:4930% IN FOSTER CARE.
- 10:53WHEN WE THINK ABOUT WHY THEY ARE
- 10:55NOT GOING TO SCHOOL, SOMETHING'S
- 10:57NOT WORKING IN THE TRADITIONAL
- 10:59PUBLIC SCHOOL SETTING COULD NOT
- 11:01SCHOOL CHOICE OPTIONS THAT ARE
- 11:03MADE AVAILABLE TO THEM HELP
- 11:08UPEND THE NUMBERS?
- 11:09>> AS I MENTIONED SOME WOULD SAY
- 11:12THE SCHOOL CHOICE OPTIONS ARE
- 11:14NOT OPEN FOR THE DEMOGRAPHIC
- 11:15THAT YOU MENTIONED.
- 11:16I WOULD SAY THAT THERE'S NO
- 11:19GUARANTEE THAT WITH THIS
- 11:20AMENDMENT THAT THEY WOULD BE
- 11:21ANYWAY.
- 11:22BECAUSE IT'S NOT PARENT CHOICE
- 11:24THAT WE'RE CREATING HERE.
- 11:26THE SCHOOLS STILL HAVE THE
- 11:27CHOICE.
- 11:27PRIVATE SCHOOLS WILL STILL
- 11:29CHOOSE WHO THEY TAKE.
- 11:31AND IN ADDITION TO THAT, ANY
- 11:33LEVEL OF VOUCHER OR SUPPORT IS
- 11:34NOT GOING TO FULLY COVER THE
- 11:36COST OF A PRIVATE SCHOOL,
- 11:37ESPECIALLY IN THE AREAS THAT I
- 11:39MENTIONED IN LOUISVILLE,
- 11:41LEXINGTON AND NORTHERN KENTUCKY.
- 11:42AND SO WE'RE NOT CREATING AN
- 11:46OPTION FOR OUR MOST
- 11:47DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS TO GO TO
- 11:48A PRIVATE SCHOOL.
- 11:50IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT'S HAPPENED
- 11:52IN OUR OTHER STATES THAT HAVE A
- 11:55POLICIES LIKE THIS, THE MAJORITY
- 11:56OF THE FUNDS INITIALLY ABOUT 90%
- 11:59IT LEVELS OFF AT 70% AFTER A
- 12:02NUMBER OF YEARS, THE MONEY GOES
- 12:04TO KIDS ALREADY THERE IN PRIVATE
- 12:06SCHOOLS.
- 12:07IT'S NOT REALLY CREATING
- 12:09ADDITIONAL CHOICE AND GIVING
- 12:10OPTIONS FOR OUR MOST
- 12:12DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS.
- 12:13INSTEAD IT'S TAKING MONEY AWAY
- 12:15FROM OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS WHO NEED
- 12:17MONEY TO SUPPORT THOSE
- 12:19DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS.
- 12:20>> Renee: FROM THE DISCUSSIONS
- 12:22YOU ARE HEARING PERHAPS AND
- 12:23MAYBE YOUR OPINION SHOULD
- 12:25EDUCATIONAL CHOICE POLICIES BE
- 12:26OPEN TO ALL STUDENTS?
- 12:28OR TARGETED AND SHOULD IT REALLY
- 12:30CATER TO THOSE ACADEMIC
- 12:33DISADVANTAGED AND PERHAPS AT THE
- 12:35LOWER WRUNG OF THE SOCIOECONOMIC
- 12:37LADDER?
- 12:37>> AMERICANS FOR PROSPERITY
- 12:39BELIEVES IN UNIVERSAL CHOICE.
- 12:41WE BELIEVE THAT EVERY PARENT
- 12:43REGARDLESS OF SOCIOECONOMIC
- 12:47STATUS SHOULD HAVE THAT OPTION.
- 12:50AND.
- 12:50>> Renee: REGARDLESS OF WEALTH?
- 12:51>> RIGHT.
- 12:52I DISAGREE WITH THE STATEMENT
- 12:54BECAUSE I FEEL LIKE NOT EVERY
- 12:56FAMILY HAS THAT CHOICE RIGHT
- 12:58NOW.
- 12:58I THINK THAT WE'VE BEEN TALKING
- 13:01TO FAMILIES ON THE WEST END OF
- 13:03LOUISVILLE WHO DO NOT FEEL LIKE
- 13:05THEY HAVE THAT CHOICE RIGHT NOW.
- 13:06THEY FEEL VERY STUCK IN THE
- 13:09SCHOOL SYSTEM THAT THEY ARE IN.
- 13:11AND THEY FEEL VERY FRUSTRATED.
- 13:14AND THEY FEEL LIKE THEIR CHILD
- 13:17IS FAILING.
- 13:18AND WE'VE HEARD THAT STORY OVER
- 13:20AND OVER AGAIN FROM PARENTS FROM
- 13:23THE WEST END OF LOUISVILLE.
- 13:25AND THERE IS SUCH INNOVATION IN
- 13:27PLACES LIKE DREAM CENTER ACADEMY
- 13:29THAT ARE REALLY CHANGING
- 13:31CHILDREN'S LIVES IF THE WEST
- 13:32END.
- 13:33I KNOW THEY ARE PLANNING ON
- 13:35STARTING A SECOND SCHOOL.
- 13:37AND THIS TYPE OF FUNDING COULD
- 13:39HELP FUND THESE TYPES OF SCHOOLS
- 13:41AND CAN REALLY CHANGE THESE
- 13:43CHILDREN'S LIFE.
- 13:44>> Renee: DO WE KNOW THAT IS
- 13:45WHAT HAPPENS THAT THOSE WHO ARE
- 13:47IN MORE ECONOMICALLY
- 13:49DISADVANTAGED AREAS ARE
- 13:50BENEFITING?
- 13:51OR IS IT JUST THE WEALTHY WHO
- 13:52ARE GETTING THE BENEFIT?
- 13:54>> WELL, I MEAN THAT OPPORTUNITY
- 13:56WOULD BE AVAILABLE TO THEM.
- 13:57AND I DON'T THINK THAT EVERY
- 13:59PRIVATE SCHOOL IS OUT OF REACH
- 14:02EVEN WITH SCHOOL CHOICE IT WOULD
- 14:04BE TOO EXPENSIVE FOR AN ESA
- 14:06PROGRAM TO APPLY.
- 14:10>> Renee: EDUCATIONAL SAVINGS
- 14:11ACCOUNTS.
- 14:12>> YES.
- 14:13I TAUGHT AT A PRIVATE SCHOOL IN
- 14:15SPENCER COUNTY, KENTUCKY RURAL
- 14:19AREA, AND MOST OF THE PARENTS
- 14:21THERE WERE DEFINITELY NOT
- 14:23WEALTHY.
- 14:23THEY WERE REALLY MAKING A
- 14:25SACRIFICE TO SEND THEIR KIDS TO
- 14:26THE SCHOOL.
- 14:28AND THIS TYPE OF PROGRAM WOULD
- 14:32GREATLY HELP THEM.
- 14:33AND I THINK THERE IS A NUMBER OF
- 14:36SMALLER SCHOOLS LIKE THAT ALL
- 14:37ACROSS THE STATE.
- 14:39THERE'S MICRO SCHOOLS.
- 14:40AND REALLY THE POSSIBILITIES ARE
- 14:42ENDLESS.
- 14:43I THINK THAT RIGHT NOW TEACHERS
- 14:44DON'T FEEL LIKE THEY CAN
- 14:46INNOVATE AND THIS WOULD ALLOW
- 14:48TEACHERS TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT.
- 14:50>> Renee: WHAT IS A MICRO
- 14:51SCHOOL?
- 14:52>> I THINK WE SAW A LOT OF THEM
- 14:54START TO POP-UP DURING COVID.
- 14:56PARENTS WERE KIND OF JOINING
- 14:58TOGETHER THERE'S MICRO SCHOOLS
- 15:00THEY ARE SMALLER ALMOST LIKE A
- 15:04ONE-ROOM SCHOOLHOUSE TYPE
- 15:05SETTING.
- 15:06>> Renee: Mr. WATERS YOU WANT
- 15:08TO CHIME IN?
- 15:09>> BY THE WAY GREAT STORIES OF
- 15:12PARENTS HIRING TEACHERS THAT
- 15:13WERE AVAILABLE BECAUSE OF COVID
- 15:14AND WHO WERE WILLING TO DO THAT.
- 15:17I WILL START WITH AGREEMENT.
- 15:18I AGREE WITH THE OTHER SIDE OF
- 15:20THE ROOM HERE ON THE FACT WE DO
- 15:22HAVE SCHOOL CHOICE IN KENTUCKY.
- 15:24IF YOU ARE WEALTHY YOU HAVE
- 15:26CHOICE.
- 15:26AND WE HAVE WEALTHY FOLKS WHO
- 15:28EXERCISE THAT CHOICE EVERYDAY.
- 15:30THEY WRITE A CHECK TO A PRIVATE
- 15:31SCHOOL TO TOUGHER TUITION.
- 15:34AND THEY MOVE TO A BETTER SCHOOL
- 15:36DISTRICT THERE ARE CHOICES FOR
- 15:37THOSE FOLKS.
- 15:38BUT A LOT OF PEOPLE COULD USE
- 15:41THAT HELP TO GET A BETTER
- 15:43EDUCATION FOR THEIR CHILDREN.
- 15:44AND THEY TALKED ABOUT OTHER
- 15:46STATES WHERE A LOT OF VOUCHERS
- 15:49ARE SCHOLARSHIPS ARE GOING TO
- 15:51FAMILIES WHO ALREADY HAVE
- 15:52CHILDREN IN PRIVATE SCHOOL.
- 15:54BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE
- 15:55WEALTHY.
- 15:55IT DOESN'T MEAN THEY HAVE NOT
- 15:57SACRIFICED EVERYTHING TO GIVE
- 15:58THEIR CHILDREN A BETTER
- 15:59EDUCATION.
- 16:00SO THEY WOULD BENEFIT, TOO.
- 16:02I THINK THE QUESTION ABOUT RURAL
- 16:04AREAS, WE DO HAVE PRIVATE AND
- 16:07NONPUBLIC SCHOOLS IN RURAL AREAS
- 16:09BUT WE WOULD SEE MORE IF THERE
- 16:11WERE OPPORTUNITIES LIKE A
- 16:13SCHOLARSHIP THAT WE'RE CREATED.
- 16:16MORE PARENTS WOULD TAKE
- 16:18ADVANTAGE OF THAT AND I THINK
- 16:19THERE WOULD BE MORE DEMAND FOR
- 16:21THAT.
- 16:21I THINK IT IS A ELITIST ATTITUDE
- 16:24TO SAY YEAH, WE HAVE CHOICE BUT
- 16:26WE'RE NOT GOING TO HELP YOU.
- 16:28WE'RE NOT GOING TO PROVIDE ANY
- 16:30FINANCIAL BENEFIT OR HELP SO
- 16:33THAT YOU CAN PUT YOUR CHILD INTO
- 16:34A SCHOOL BECAUSE OF YOUR INCOME
- 16:37OR BECAUSE WHERE YOU HAPPEN TO
- 16:39LIVE.
- 16:39AND WE'VE HEARD SOME OF THAT
- 16:42FROM OPPONENTS OF THIS.
- 16:43SO I THINK THAT'S WRONG.
- 16:47WE'RE TALKING ABOUT PARENTS
- 16:48BEING ABLE NOT ONLY TO HAVE THE
- 16:50CHOICE BUT TO HAVE THE FUNDS TO
- 16:53MAKE THAT CHOICE.
- 16:54AND JESSICA MENTIONED
- 16:56ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 16:56AND I AGREE.
- 16:57I THINK WHEN YOU LOOK AT OUR
- 16:59PUBLIC SYSTEM, I WANT TO KNOW
- 17:01WHERE THE ACCOUNTABILITY IS FOR
- 17:02A MAJORITY OF OUR STUDENTS
- 17:04FAILING TO REACH PROFICIENCY IN
- 17:07KEY ACADEMIC AREAS AND HAVING
- 17:08THE SUPERINTENDENT OF OUR
- 17:10LARGEST COUNTY REALLY JUST TURN
- 17:12AROUND AND GO BRAVO FOR A 90%
- 17:15GRADUATION RATE.
- 17:16I WONDER WHAT THOSE DIPLOMAS
- 17:18MEAN FOR THOSE STUDENTS WHO ARE
- 17:20WALKING THE STAGE, ESPECIALLY
- 17:22FOR LOW INCOME MINORITY STUDENTS
- 17:23WHO ARE REALLY NOT BENEFITING AS
- 17:26MUCH FROM OUR PUBLIC EDUCATION
- 17:28SYSTEM.
- 17:29THE FACT IS IN SCHOOL CHOICE
- 17:31PROGRAMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND
- 17:32THE DATA BEARS THIS OUT, A
- 17:34MAJORITY OF STUDENTS IN MANY OF
- 17:35THOSE PROGRAMS ARE LOW INCOME
- 17:37MINORITY STUDENTS.
- 17:3858% OF CHARTER SCHOOL STUDENTS
- 17:40IN AMERICA ARE FROM LOW INCOME
- 17:42MINORITY HOMES.
- 17:44THIS IDEA THAT ESPECIALLY WITH
- 17:46CHARTER SCHOOLS THIS IS FILLED
- 17:48WITH RICH FOLKS WHO DON'T NEED
- 17:50THE HELP.
- 17:51IT'S JUST NOT FACTUAL IT'S JUST
- 17:54NOT TRUE.
- 17:54>> I WANTED TO ADDRESS THE POINT
- 17:57ABOUT INNOVATION.
- 17:58SO IN A SCHOOL DISTRICT LIKE
- 18:01FAYETTE COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS WE
- 18:02HAVE A LOT OF INNOVATIVE
- 18:03PROGRAMS WITHIN OUR PUBLIC
- 18:05SCHOOLS.
- 18:05WE HAVE LOCUST TRACE AGRISCIENCE
- 18:10FARM.
- 18:11AND STEM ACADEMY FOR GIRLS.
- 18:12WE HAVE ALL OF THESE OPTIONS FOR
- 18:15OUR STUDENTS IN FAYETTE COUNTY
- 18:17PUBLIC SCHOOLS THEY CAN CHOOSE
- 18:19WHERE THEY WANT TO GO TO SCHOOL.
- 18:20AND SO TO SAY THERE'S NOT
- 18:22INNOVATION IN OUR PUBLIC
- 18:24SCHOOLS, I THINK IS WRONG TO SAY
- 18:25THAT.
- 18:26BECAUSE WE HAVE THESE
- 18:27OPPORTUNITIES.
- 18:27DO OTHER COUNTIES HAVE THAT?
- 18:29THEY DON'T.
- 18:30YOU KNOW WHY?
- 18:31BECAUSE THERE'S NOT THE FUNDING.
- 18:32AND THAT'S WHAT WE NEED WE NEED
- 18:35MORE FUNDING TO OUR PUBLIC
- 18:37SCHOOLS SO WE CAN BE MORE
- 18:38INNOVATIVE AND CREATIVE.
- 18:41Dr. SHELTON WAS SUPERINTENDENT
- 18:42OF FAY EQUITY COUNTY PUBLIC
- 18:44SCHOOLS WHEN SOME OF THE
- 18:45PROGRAMS WERE CREATED.
- 18:46>> SO WHY THE PROBLEM WITH MORE
- 18:48PROGRAMS IF YOU ARE BRAGGING
- 18:50ABOUT ALL THE PROGRAMS WE HAVE,
- 18:51WHAT IS THE HARM IN ALLOWING
- 18:53MORE OPTIONS?
- 18:54>> OUR PROGRAMS IN FAYETTE
- 18:56COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 18:57SPECIFICALLY BECAUSE THAT IS MY
- 18:58LENS THEY HAVE ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 19:00THEY HAVE OVERSIGHT BY OUR
- 19:02SCHOOL BOARD AND OUR
- 19:04SUPERINTENDENT.
- 19:04>> WHY OPPOSE ADDITIONAL
- 19:07PROGRAMS THAT MIGHT BE OUTSIDE
- 19:08OF THAT PARTICULAR --
- 19:11WHY OPPOSE THAT?
- 19:12IF PARENTS ARE HAPPY WITH WHAT
- 19:14IS GOING ON THEY WILL CHOOSE THE
- 19:16RIGHT THING FOR THEIR CHILDREN
- 19:18UNLESS WE DON'T HAVE CONFIDENCE
- 19:19IN PARENTS THAT THEY WILL DO
- 19:20THAT.
- 19:21>> I THINK I HAVE CONFIDENCE IN
- 19:22PARENTS TO DO WHAT IS BEST FOR
- 19:24THEIR KIDS AND THEY ARE CHOOSING
- 19:25THAT NOW WITH 90% OF OUR KIDS IN
- 19:28PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 19:29>> MAKE THAT DECISION AND GIVE
- 19:30THE PARENTS THE HELP.
- 19:33WE'VE INCREASED SPENDING ON
- 19:33PUBLIC EDUCATION IN KENTUCKY
- 19:35MORE THAN DOUBLED IT SINCE
- 19:40KIERA.
- 19:40INFLATION ADJUSTED.
- 19:41I DON'T THINK FUNDING IS THE
- 19:43ONLY ISSUE THE TEST SCORES AND
- 19:46THE EDUCATIONAL OUTPUTS HAVE NOT
- 19:48REFLECTED THE INCREASES IN
- 19:50FUNDING.
- 19:51FAYETTE COUNTY, A MAJORITY OF
- 19:53STUDENTS FAILING TO REACH
- 19:55PROFICIENCY IN THE ACADEMIC
- 19:58AREAS.
- 19:58>> Renee: SHOULD PROFICIENCY BE
- 19:59THE BENCHMARK IT MEANS WHAT?
- 20:02AND IS IT A REALISTIC
- 20:04EXPECTATION THAT MORE THAN HALF
- 20:05CAN REACH THAT LEVEL?
- 20:07AT ANY PLACE?
- 20:08>> WELL, THE FIRST THING THAT I
- 20:09HAVE TO SAY ABOUT THAT, IS THAT
- 20:12IF YOU THINK ABOUT PRIVATE
- 20:13SCHOOLS THEY DON'T TAKE THE SAME
- 20:16ASSESSMENT ACCOUNTABILITY THAT
- 20:17PUBLIC SCHOOLS DO.
- 20:20TO CRITICIZE PUBLIC SCHOOLS FOR
- 20:23THE ACCOUNTABILITY THEY DO HAVE
- 20:26IS COMPLETELY UNFAIR FIRST OF
- 20:27ALL.
- 20:28BECAUSE PRIVATE SCHOOLS SELECTS
- 20:30THEIR STUDENTS, DECIDES WHO THEY
- 20:32ARE GOING TO TEACH, DECIDES WHAT
- 20:34THEY ARE GOING TO ASSESS, DECIDE
- 20:36WHAT IS THEY ARE GOING TO
- 20:37REPORT.
- 20:37THEY DON'T HAVE OPEN MEETINGS.
- 20:39THEY DON'T HAVE OPEN RECORDS.
- 20:41AND ARE WHERE PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 20:43HAVE ALL OF THAT OPEN
- 20:45ACCOUNTABILITY THAT IS THERE.
- 20:46THE SECOND THING THAT I THINK
- 20:48HAS TO BE CONSIDERED IS WHEN
- 20:50HOUSE BILL 563 WAS PASSED
- 20:53INITIALLY THERE WERE TWO PARTS
- 20:54OF IT.
- 20:54WE CHALLENGED THE SECOND PART
- 20:56WHICH WAS THE PRIVATE SCHOOL TAX
- 20:58CREDITS BUT THE FIRST PART WAS
- 20:59OPEN BORDERS REQUIREMENTS WHICH
- 21:02ALLOWS STUDENTS TO GO TO OTHER
- 21:04PUBLIC SCHOOLS IN OTHER
- 21:06DISTRICTS.
- 21:07THERE ARE REQUIREMENTS THAT HAVE
- 21:09TO BE MET.
- 21:10BUT THEY CAN DO THAT.
- 21:11THE OTHER THING, THOUGH, IS THAT
- 21:13IF WE TALK ABOUT CREATING A
- 21:16VOUCHER SYSTEM, I WILL HIGHLIGHT
- 21:19JEFFERSON COUNTY I TALKED ABOUT
- 21:21THAT LAST TIME.
- 21:22JEFFERSON COUNTY IF YOU LOOK AT
- 21:23THE AMOUNT OF STATE FUNDING THAT
- 21:25THE STATE PROVIDES FOR PUPIL IS
- 21:29$2700 A YEAR.
- 21:29THE REST OF IT IS ALL LOCAL.
- 21:34$2700 A YEAR WOULD BE THE MOST
- 21:36AMOUNT THAT ANY VOUCHER COULD BE
- 21:38IN JEFFERSON COUNTY.
- 21:39BECAUSE YOU CAN'T GET MORE MONEY
- 21:41TO A PRIVATE SCHOOL PARENT GOING
- 21:42TO TAKE THEIR KIDS THAN YOU
- 21:45COULD BE FUNDING FOR THE PUBLIC
- 21:46SCHOOLS BECAUSE THAT IS
- 21:48DEFINITELY, READY FOR
- 21:48LITIGATION.
- 21:49IF YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT $2700,
- 21:53WHEN MOST PRIVATE SCHOOLS IN
- 21:57LOUISVILLE XAVIER IS $16,000 A
- 22:00YEAR, SACRED HEART $17,000 A
- 22:03YEAR.
- 22:03WE ARE NOT CREATING OPTIONS FOR
- 22:05THE PARENTS WHO HAVE LOW INCOME.
- 22:07WHEN YOU GIVE THEM A $2700
- 22:10VOUCHER NOW YOU HAVE TO COME UP
- 22:13WITH 14, 15,000 TO SEND YOUR
- 22:15KIDS IT IS A MISNOMER TO SAY WE
- 22:20ARE CREATING CHOICE.
- 22:23>> OUR CONSTITUTION STILL
- 22:34REQUIRES OUR LEGISLATURE TO FUND
- 22:36THE PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM AND
- 22:37WOULD NOT ALLOW DOLLARS USED FOR
- 22:41K-12 FUNDING TO BE APPLIED TO A
- 22:43SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM.
- 22:44THEY WOULD HAVE TO CREATE A
- 22:46SEPARATE PROGRAM.
- 22:46SO WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT
- 22:49AMOUNT WOULD BE.
- 22:50>> Renee: IT COULD BE MORE THAN
- 22:51$2700?
- 22:52>> IN THE COUNTRY IT'S 6-8,000
- 22:55DOLLARS ON AVERAGE.
- 22:56AND IT'S AMAZING I KNOW Mr.
- 22:59SHELTON TALKS ABOUT THE PRIVATE
- 23:01SCHOOLS THAT ARE AT THE TOP END
- 23:03OF THE COST BUT THERE ARE MANY
- 23:05PRIVATE SCHOOLS THAT WILL
- 23:06EDUCATE KIDS FOR THEY WILL FIND
- 23:08A WAY TO DO IT.
- 23:09FOR THEM IT'S ABOUT EDUCATING
- 23:10THE STUDENTS IT'S NOT ABOUT A
- 23:13SYSTEM, NOT ABOUT CREATING A
- 23:14SYSTEM OR PROPPING UP A SYSTEM
- 23:17IT'S ABOUT EDUCATING THE
- 23:18STUDENTS.
- 23:19I KEEP ASKING ABOUT THAT AND
- 23:21ALSO, I HEAR WHAT YOU ARE SAYING
- 23:23ABOUT PRIVATE SCHOOLS BUT WHAT
- 23:25ABOUT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS?
- 23:27WHY THE OPPOSITION TO PUBLIC
- 23:28CHARTER SCHOOLS?
- 23:29WE HAVE 45 CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 23:32AROUND THE COUNTRY AND EVERYONE
- 23:33OF THEM REQUIRES CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 23:35TO TAKE FIRST-COME-FIRST-SERVE
- 23:38STUDENTS INCLUDING LEARNING
- 23:40DISABLED SCHOOLS AND CHARTER
- 23:42SCHOOLS ARE DOING GREAT THINGS.
- 23:46THERE WASN'T A FUNDING MECHANISM
- 23:48WITH IT.
- 23:49AND TOM'S GROUP SUED TO STOP US
- 23:53FROM US BEING ABLE TO FUND A FEW
- 23:56CHARTER SCHOOLS IN THE STATE.
- 23:57THAT IS INACCURATE.
- 23:58FIRST OF ALL OUR GROUP, THE
- 24:01KENTUCKY ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL
- 24:02SUPERINTENDENTS THAT I WAS
- 24:03LEADING IN 2017 WHEN THE PUBLIC
- 24:06CHARTER SCHOOL LAW WAS PASSED I
- 24:09HELPED CRAFT THE LAW WITH THEN
- 24:12REPRESENTATIVE CARNEY WHO WAS
- 24:14CHAIR OF THE HOUSE EDUCATION
- 24:15COMMITTEE AND SEVERAL OTHERS.
- 24:17WE WORKED TOGETHER TO CREATE
- 24:18PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS.
- 24:21THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY CHANGED
- 24:22THAT WITH HOUSE BILL 9.
- 24:24THEY CREATED PRIVATE CHARTER
- 24:26SCHOOLS AND REQUIRED CHARTER
- 24:28SCHOOLS TO BE IN CERTAIN AREAS
- 24:29OF OUR STATE.
- 24:30THEY REQUIRED THERE TO BE
- 24:33CHARTER SCHOOLS IN JEFFERSON
- 24:35COUNTY AND NORTHERN KENTUCKY.
- 24:36THEY TOOK AWAY THE LOCAL BOARD
- 24:38OF EDUCATION'S OPTIONS ON
- 24:40CONTROLLING AND REGULATING
- 24:42SCHOOLS CHARTER SCHOOLS IN ANY
- 24:44DISTRICT THAT WAS 7500 STUDENTS
- 24:46OR MORE.
- 24:46THEY TOOK PUBLIC FROM LOCAL
- 24:49FUNDS TO FUND THOSE CHARTER
- 24:51SCHOOLS.
- 24:52NOT JUST THE STATE MONEY.
- 24:53THAT IS WHAT WE SUED OVER.
- 24:55WE DID NOT SUE OVER THE PUBLIC
- 24:57CHARTER SCHOOLS.
- 24:58WE SUED OVER THE PRIVATE CHARTER
- 25:00SCHOOLS AND OVER THE FUNDING
- 25:02MODEL.
- 25:02AND SO IF WE WOULD HAVE PUBLIC
- 25:05CHARTER SCHOOLS THAT OUR LOCAL
- 25:07BOARDS OF EDUCATION HAVE THE
- 25:10OPTIONS TO CHARTER, AND THEY
- 25:11COULD BE FUNDED BY STRUCTURES
- 25:14AND MECHANISMS WITHIN THE SEEK
- 25:16FORMULA AND WITH LOCAL
- 25:18PARTNERSHIPS, THERE WOULD HAVE
- 25:19BEEN NO OPPOSITION.
- 25:20>> Renee: LET'S TALK ABOUT
- 25:22ARIZONA.
- 25:22>> THAT IS THE FIRST I'VE HEARD
- 25:24THAT.
- 25:24>> PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS.
- 25:26>> CHARTER SCHOOLS ARE PUBLIC
- 25:30SCHOOLS.
- 25:30>> Renee: LET'S PUT A PIN IN IT
- 25:33WE'VE HEARD ABOUT ARIZONA THEY
- 25:34HAD THE EDUCATION SAVINGS
- 25:36ACCOUNTS AND YOU MAY HAVE PICKED
- 25:37UP THE COURIER JOURNAL AND COME
- 25:41ACROSS AN OP-ED BY A WOMAN IN
- 25:43ARIZONA WHO HAS CONNECTIONS IN
- 25:45LOUISVILLE.
- 25:46SHE WAS SCHOOLED AT THE SEMINARY
- 25:47FOR FOUR YEARS AND WROTE A PIECE
- 25:50TRYING TO CONVINCE KENTUCKIANS
- 25:52TO VOTE FOR AMENDMENT 2 AND HERE
- 25:53IS OUR INTERVIEW FROM LAST WEEK.
- 25:55>> WELL, I KEPT SEEING
- 25:58INFORMATION ABOUT ARIZONA'S
- 25:59PROGRAM IN THE NEWS IN KENTUCKY
- 26:01FROM DIFFERENT POLICY
- 26:02ORGANIZATIONS.
- 26:03AND I FELT COMPELLED TO CORRECT
- 26:05THE RECORD.
- 26:07I SAW A LOT OF THE LIES HOW
- 26:10ARIZONA'S EDUCATION SAVINGS
- 26:12ACCOUNT WHERE SCHOOL CHOICE
- 26:13PROGRAM WAS ACTUALLY WORKING.
- 26:15AND THAT IS WHY I WROTE THE
- 26:17OP-ED.
- 26:18I WANTED KENTUCKY FAMILIES TO
- 26:19KNOW ARIZONA'S BUDGET IS JUST
- 26:21FINE AND THAT KIDS AND FAMILIES
- 26:23IN ARIZONA HAVE MORE OPTIONS
- 26:25BECAUSE OF ESA'S.
- 26:27>> Renee: TALK ABOUT YOUR
- 26:28PERSONAL EXPERIENCE AND
- 26:29CONNECTION TO THE ISSUE IT'S NOT
- 26:31JUST RESPONDING TO POLICY
- 26:32QUESTIONS AND REBUTTING WHAT MAY
- 26:34HAVE BEEN PUT OUT IN A POSITION
- 26:35PAPER.
- 26:36BUT YOU HAVE PERSONAL EXPERIENCE
- 26:38WITH HOW THIS HAS HAPPENED
- 26:41YOUR --
- 26:42HELPED YOUR KIDS THRIVE IN A
- 26:44BETTER EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT.
- 26:44>> YES, MA'AM, THAT IS RIGHT.
- 26:46I HAVE FIVE CHILDREN THREE BOYS
- 26:48AND TWO GIRLS.
- 26:49AND I WAS HOME SCHOOLING MY
- 26:51OLDEST BOYS WHEN THEY WERE SIX
- 26:52AND EIGHT.
- 26:53AND WE DISCOVERED THAT THEY WERE
- 26:55STRUGGLING TO READ.
- 26:56WE GOT THEM EVALUATED AT THE
- 26:59LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICT.
- 27:01AND HAD SEVERE DYSLEXIA AND
- 27:04THERE WERE NO PROGRAMS OFFERED
- 27:06TO ME IN ONE OF THE BEST SCHOOL
- 27:08DISTRICTS IN MY STATE TO HELP MY
- 27:12DYSLEXIC CHILDREN.
- 27:12ONE IN FIVE KIDS HAVE DEX
- 27:16ALEXANDRIA, WE ENDED UP ON OUR
- 27:19STATE'S EDUCATION SAVINGS
- 27:20PROGRAM.
- 27:21IT TRANSFORMED OUR LIVES.
- 27:22WE WERE ABLE TO AFFORD THE BEST
- 27:24THERAPIES AND PROGRAM ANDS AND
- 27:27TUTORS AND MY KIDS ARE ON AN ESA
- 27:30BECAUSE OUR PROGRAM IS UNIVERSAL
- 27:32IT IS NO LONGER JUST FOR SPECIAL
- 27:34NEEDS STUDENTS.
- 27:35I WANT FAMILIES TO KNOW THAT
- 27:36THESE PROGRAMS ARE REALLY LIFE
- 27:39CHANGING FOR STUDENTS WITH
- 27:42DISABILITIES.
- 27:42>> Renee: YOU COULDN'T FIND
- 27:43THOSE SERVICES TO HELP YOUR
- 27:44CHILDREN IN A TRADITIONAL PUBLIC
- 27:47SCHOOL ENVIRONMENT?
- 27:48>> YES, THAT'S RIGHT.
- 27:50SO TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 27:52CAN WRITE IEP'S OR 504 PLANS AND
- 27:57ANY PARENT KNOWS THAT IT'S A
- 27:59DIFFICULT VERY EMOTIONAL
- 28:00PROCESS.
- 28:01NOT JUST TO GET YOUR KID
- 28:03IDENTIFIED, BUT TO GET THEM THE
- 28:05SERVICES THAT YOU FEEL LIKE THEY
- 28:07NEED.
- 28:08AND MOST PARENTS IF YOU WERE TO
- 28:10ASK THEM TODAY FEEL LIKE THEY
- 28:11ARE NOT GETTING THE HIGH QUALITY
- 28:13SERVICES THEY NEED NO MATTER
- 28:15WHAT STATE YOU ARE IN.
- 28:16BECAUSE OF ALL SORTS OF
- 28:17DIFFERENT REASONS.
- 28:18BUT WITH AN ESA WE WERE ABLE TO
- 28:21QUICKLY OPT-OUT OF THAT OR GET
- 28:23OUR KIDS SERVICES IMMEDIATELY.
- 28:25THERE WAS NO WAIT, THERE WAS NO
- 28:27DELAY.
- 28:27WE WERE ABLE TO LEAVE THAT
- 28:30OPTION AND QUICKLY GET ON TO AN
- 28:32EDUCATION SAVINGS ACCOUNT.
- 28:33>> Renee: SO THAT IS WHERE I
- 28:34WANTED TO PICK UP YOU SAID ESA
- 28:37TO CLUE OUR VIEWERS IN EDUCATION
- 28:39SAVINGS ACCOUNT.
- 28:40CAN YOU DEFINE MORE OF WHAT THAT
- 28:42IS AND HOW IT WORKS IN ARIZONA?
- 28:44>> SO AN EDUCATION SAVINGS
- 28:46ACCOUNT IS A SCHOLARSHIP THAT
- 28:48ALLOWS FAMILIES TO TAKE A
- 28:49PORTION OF THE FUNDS HERE IN
- 28:52ARIZONA 90% TO BE EXACT SO THERE
- 28:54IS A TAXPAYER SAVINGS AND WE ARE
- 28:56AALLOWED TO USE THAT FUNDING FOR
- 28:59TUTORS, THERAPISTS, HOME
- 29:00EDUCATION OR A PRIVATE SCHOOL OF
- 29:02OUR CHOOSING.
- 29:04NOW, THOSE FUNDS WE RECEIVE THEM
- 29:05EVERY YEAR.
- 29:06THEY ROLLOVER.
- 29:07AND THEY ALLOW PARENTS TO BE IN
- 29:10CONTROL OF WHERE THEIR CHILD
- 29:11GOES.
- 29:12WE ARE NO LONGER LIMITED IN
- 29:13ARIZONA BY OUR FAMILY INCOME OR
- 29:16BY OUR ZIP CODE WHEN IT COMES TO
- 29:18GIVING OUR KIDS A GREAT
- 29:19EDUCATION.
- 29:20AND WE HAVE HAD ESA'S IN ARIZONA
- 29:25APPROACHING 12 YEARS.
- 29:26OUR PROGRAM JUST WENT UNIVERSAL
- 29:29FOR ALL FAMILIES TWO YEARS AGO
- 29:30AND NOT A SINGLE PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 29:33HAS CLOSED IN ARIZONA.
- 29:35IN FACT IT'S BEEN THE OPPOSITE.
- 29:36MORE KIDS HAVE OPTIONS AND MORE
- 29:39TEACHERS HAVE OPTIONS BECAUSE WE
- 29:41HAVE NEW SCHOOLS OPENING ALL THE
- 29:42TIME HERE IN OUR STATE.
- 29:45>> Renee: SO WHAT IS THE ACTUAL
- 29:47FINANCIAL BENEFIT YOU GET AS A
- 29:49PARENT?
- 29:49WHAT IS A YEARLY CAP, I GUESS,
- 29:51FOR THE TYPES OF SERVICES THAT
- 29:52YOU ARE LOOKING FOR FOR YOUR
- 29:55CHILDREN?
- 29:55>> THE AVERAGE ESA IN ARIZONA IS
- 30:00$7500 PER STUDENT.
- 30:01THE AVERAGE PER PUPIL SPENDING
- 30:03IN ARIZONA IS $12,000.
- 30:07SO WE DO RECEIVE LESS DOLLARS
- 30:09THAN A PUBLIC SCHOOL WOULD
- 30:11RECEIVE.
- 30:11IN ARIZONA OUR PROGRAM IS UNIQUE
- 30:13BECAUSE IF YOU ARE A FAMILY WITH
- 30:15A STUDENT WITH A DISABILITY OURS
- 30:17IS FORMULA FUNDED.
- 30:18IN THE PUBLIC SYSTEM A STUDENT
- 30:22WITH AUTISM RECEIVES $40,000 A
- 30:25YEAR AND ESA THEY RECEIVE
- 30:27$30,000.
- 30:28THOSE ARE A RANGE IN ARIZONA
- 30:29WHEN IT COMES TO OUR ESA PROGRAM
- 30:32WHY IT'S SO AMAZING AND
- 30:34POWERFUL.
- 30:35ONE IN 33 KIDS HAVE AUTISM.
- 30:37AND IN ARIZONA THE PERCENTAGE OF
- 30:40STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES ON
- 30:41OUR ESA ARE STUDENTS WITH
- 30:44AUTISM.
- 30:4518% OF OUR 81,000 KIDS PRESENT
- 30:48LEFT HAND OUR OUR ESA ARE
- 30:50STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES.
- 30:52AGAIN, VERY LIFE CHANGING FOR
- 30:54STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES IN
- 30:56ARIZONA.
- 30:56>> Renee: SO THE CASE YOU ARE
- 30:57MAKING FOR KENTUCKY VOTERS WHO
- 30:59WILL DECIDE THIS ISSUE THAT
- 31:00COULD CHART A PATH FORWARD FOR
- 31:02STATE LAWMAKERS TO CRAFT
- 31:04LEGISLATION LIKE WHAT YOU HAVE
- 31:06OUT IN ARIZONA.
- 31:07WHAT WOULD YOU SAY IS THE FINAL
- 31:09ELEVATEDDER PITCH TO CONVINCE
- 31:12KENTUCKIANS TO VOTE YES ON
- 31:13AMENDMENT 2?
- 31:14>> WELL, EDUCATION IS ALL ABOUT
- 31:17STUDENTS.
- 31:18AND I BELIEVE THAT WE SHOULD
- 31:20SHOULD BE PUTTING STUDENTS
- 31:22FIRST, A PUBLIC SCHOOL, A
- 31:23PRIVATE SCHOOL, A HOME
- 31:24EDUCATION.
- 31:25FAMILIES DESERVE TO HAVE ACCESS
- 31:26TO THEIR EDUCATION FUNDING SO
- 31:28THEY CAN MAKE THE BEST CHOICE
- 31:30FOR THEIR STUDENT.
- 31:32>> Renee: THANK YOU.
- 31:33JENNY CLARK FOR YOUR TIME.
- 31:34WE APPRECIATE IT.
- 31:36>> THANK YOU, RENEE.
- 31:39>> Renee: SO Dr. SHELTON TALK
- 31:40ABOUT NUMBERS.
- 31:41SHE SAID 7500 IS THE ANNUAL
- 31:45STIPEND OR THAT THEY RECEIVE.
- 31:47THAT THERE IS A TAXPAYER SAVINGS
- 31:49WHERE 12,000 WOULD NORMALLY GO
- 31:51THERE.
- 31:51TALK TO US ABOUT HOW YOU
- 31:53INTERPRET THOSE NUMBERS AND IF
- 31:54THERE IS A REAL TAXPAYER SAVINGS
- 31:56BY WHAT SHE DESCRIBED?
- 31:58>> FIRST OF ALL, ARIZONA'S
- 32:01FUNDING IS MUCH GREATER THAN
- 32:04KENTUCKY'S FOR THEIR PUBLIC
- 32:05SCHOOLS.
- 32:06WE DON'T RECEIVE ANYTHING NEAR
- 32:08THAT FOR THE AVERAGE PUBLIC
- 32:09SCHOOL STUDENT.
- 32:12KENTUCKY'S SEEK FORMULA AS IT'S
- 32:16KNOWN, SUPPORT EDUCATION
- 32:17EXCELLENCE IN KENTUCKY IS NOT A
- 32:19FUNDING FORMULA IT IS AN
- 32:22ALLOCATION FORMULA.
- 32:23IT TAKES THE MONEY THE
- 32:25LEGISLATURE PUTS INTO EDUCATION
- 32:27AND ALLOCATES IT ACCORDING TO A
- 32:30FORMULA TO THE DISTRICTS.
- 32:31THE DISTRICTS THAT HAVE THE
- 32:32STUDENTS WITH THE GREATEST
- 32:33AMOUNT OF NEED RECEIVE THE MOST
- 32:35AMOUNT OF FUNDING.
- 32:36THE DISTRICTS ARE THE LOWEST
- 32:38LEVEL OF PROPERTY VALUES RECEIVE
- 32:40THE GREATEST AMOUNT OF FUNDING.
- 32:42AS MY EXAMPLE THAT I GAVE
- 32:45EARLIER WITH JEFFERSON COUNTY,
- 32:48JEFFERSON COUNTY HAS A STRONG
- 32:51PROPERTY TAX BASE AS FAYETTE
- 32:52COUNTY DOES, THE MAJORITY OF THE
- 32:54MONEY IS FUNDED LOCALLY THROUGH
- 32:55PROPERTY TAXES.
- 33:02THE STATE MAY FUND 6-7,000 FOR A
- 33:06STUDENT IN METCALF COUNTY, OR
- 33:10McCLAIN COUNTY BUT THEY DON'T
- 33:12IN OUR LARGER AREAS OF THE STATE
- 33:13IN OUR MORE POPULATED AREAS OF
- 33:15THE STATE.
- 33:17THE SECOND THING THAT HAS TO BE
- 33:19CONSIDERED IS THE FACT THAT
- 33:20BECAUSE WE HAVE AN EQUALIZED
- 33:23FUNDING FORMULA ALLOCATION
- 33:25FORMULA THAT ANY LOSS OF FUNDING
- 33:27FROM THE STATE BECAUSE THAT WILL
- 33:29NOT BE A TRUE SAVES TO A LOCAL
- 33:32SCHOOL DISTRICT FOR MANY STUDENT
- 33:33THAT LEAVES BECAUSE IT IS NOT A
- 33:35DOLLAR FOR DOLLAR WHEN YOU LOSE
- 33:37ONE STUDENT YOU DON'T SAVE THAT
- 33:39AMOUNT OF MONEY BECAUSE OF ALL
- 33:41THE FIXED COST THAT A SCHOOL
- 33:42DISTRICT HAS.
- 33:43MOST SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE GOING
- 33:44TO HAVE TO LOOK AT RAISING LOCAL
- 33:46PROPERTY TAXES AND FUNDING EVEN
- 33:49MORE OF THE COST OF THE PUBLIC
- 33:51EDUCATION LOCALLY FOR THE KIDS
- 33:52WHO ARE GOING TO REMAIN IN THE
- 33:55PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 33:55SO NO MATTER WHAT THE LEVEL OF
- 33:58FUNDING THAT IS GIVEN TO A
- 34:00PARENT IN A VOUCHER SITUATION
- 34:01BECAUSE THAT IS WHAT AN
- 34:04EDUCATION SAVINGS ACCOUNT IS AND
- 34:05A PRIVATE SCHOOL TAX CREDIT THEY
- 34:07ARE VOUCHERS BY ANOTHER NAME,
- 34:09ANY AMOUNT OF FUNDING THAT IS
- 34:10GIVEN TO THEM IS NOT GOING TO BE
- 34:15OFFSET BY ANYTHING THAT THE
- 34:16STATE DOES T WILL HAVE TO BE
- 34:18MADE UP AT THE LEVEL LEVEL --
- 34:21LOCAL LEFT.
- 34:23>> Renee: I SMALLER GOVERNMENT,
- 34:25LOWER TAXES WHEN YOU HEAR WHAT
- 34:27Dr. SHELTON DESCRIBED IS THE
- 34:28LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WOULD HAVE TO
- 34:30LEVY HIGHER TAXES TO MAKEUP THAT
- 34:34DEFICIT OR THE GAP FROM THE
- 34:35STATE FUNDING, HOW DO YOU
- 34:37RESPOND?
- 34:37>> I WANT TO POINT OUT THAT
- 34:40KENTUCKY IS NOT UNIQUE.
- 34:42AND I THINK A LOT OF TIMES I
- 34:45HEAR THE SAME IN THE LEGISLATURE
- 34:47THAT KENTUCKY IS UNIQUE TO OTHER
- 34:49STATES.
- 34:49THERE ARE LOTS OF STATES WITH
- 34:52URBAN AND RURAL AREAS.
- 34:55SIMILAR MAKEUP TO THE STATE OF
- 34:57KENTUCKY.
- 34:59WITH HIGH POVERTY AREAS THAT
- 35:01HAVE IMPLEMENTED SCHOOL CHOICE
- 35:04AND IT'S BEEN VERY SUCCESSFUL.
- 35:06AND I THINK THAT THERE'S THIS
- 35:11MISNOMER IS SOMEHOW UNIQUE AND
- 35:14THAT THE SKY WILL FALL IF WE
- 35:16IMPLEMENT THIS.
- 35:17AND OUR PUBLIC SCHOOL ALSO SHUT
- 35:18DOWN.
- 35:19AND IT'S JUST NOT THE CASE.
- 35:20AND I THINK WE HAVE YEARS OF
- 35:22DATA AND WE HAVE YEARS OF
- 35:25EXAMPLES OF HOW THIS IS WORKING
- 35:26IN OTHER STATES.
- 35:28AND KENTUCKY IS JUST FALLING
- 35:30BEHIND.
- 35:31AND I THINK THAT, YOU KNOW, WE
- 35:34HAVE HEARD OVER AND OVER WE HAVE
- 35:36BEEN TO NOW CLOSE TO 200,000
- 35:39DOORS ACROSS THE STATE OF
- 35:40KENTUCKY.
- 35:41AND HAD OVER 50 TOWN HALLS.
- 35:45AND WE HEAR OVER AND OVER JUST
- 35:49HEARTBREAKING STORIES OF PARENTS
- 35:50WHO TRULY FEEL LIKE THEY HAVE NO
- 35:53OPTIONS.
- 35:53AND I WILL SAY THAT I WAS ONE OF
- 35:55THOSE PARENTS.
- 35:56I WAS A SINGLE MOM WORKING THREE
- 35:59JOBS AT THE TIME.
- 36:00MY SON WAS IN MIDDLE SCHOOL.
- 36:03AND HE WAS BEING BULLIED REALLY
- 36:06BADLY IN SCHOOL.
- 36:07WAS REALLY STRUGGLING.
- 36:09HAD ADHD AND WAS REALLY
- 36:11STRUGGLING TO SIT STILL IN THE
- 36:12CLASSROOM.
- 36:13HE WAS CAUSING PROBLEMS IN THE
- 36:14CLASSROOM.
- 36:15AND I KNEW THAT SOMETHING WAS
- 36:18REALLY WRONG.
- 36:19AND I FELT LIKE THERE WAS NO
- 36:21SUPPORT FROM THE PRINCIPAL.
- 36:22I FELT LIKE THERE WAS NO SUPPORT
- 36:25FROM THE ADMINISTRATION.
- 36:27AND I FELT POWERLESSLESS AND
- 36:30THAT IS A HORRIBLE FEELING TO
- 36:32FEEL LIKE YOU CANNOT HELP YOUR
- 36:34OWN CHILD WHO IS STRUGGLING.
- 36:36I WAS ABLE TO GET HIM INVOLVED
- 36:38IN SPORTS AND THROUGH HAVING A
- 36:40COACH WHO REALLY MENTORED HIM IT
- 36:43CHANGED HIS LIFE.
- 36:44BUT I WAS TOLD HE COULDN'T GO TO
- 36:46A DIFFERENT SCHOOL.
- 36:47HE COULDN'T GO TO A DIFFERENT
- 36:50PUBLIC MIDDLE SCHOOL.
- 36:50THAT IS A CHOICE THAT I FEEL
- 36:53LIKE PARENTS SHOULD HAVE FOR
- 36:56WHATEVER REASON THEIR CHILD MAY
- 36:58NOT BE DOING WELL IN THAT
- 36:59SETTING.
- 37:00MY GIRLS WERE DOING GREAT IN
- 37:02PUBLIC SCHOOL BUT MY SON WAS
- 37:04STRUGGLING.
- 37:05AND SO I JUST THERE NEEDS TO BE
- 37:08OPTIONS FOR PARENTS.
- 37:09>> Renee: WE HAVE A COUPLE OF --
- 37:10YOU WANT TO CHIME IN HERE?
- 37:13>> WHEN WE ARE TALKING ABOUT
- 37:14OPTIONS AND PUBLIC SCHOOLS I
- 37:15THINK WE SHOULD BE LISTENING TO
- 37:17PARENTS AS A PARENT, I AM A
- 37:19PARENT LISTEN TO PARENTS AND
- 37:20WHAT THEY NEED.
- 37:21BUT WE ALSO SHOULD BE LISTENING
- 37:23TO EDUCATORS AND WE DO NOT DO
- 37:26ENOUGH OF THAT.
- 37:27WE DO NOT LISTEN TEACHERS WHAT
- 37:29THEY NEED TO MAKE THEIR STUDENTS
- 37:31SUCCESSFUL AND THAT COULD BE THE
- 37:33MISSING PIECE.
- 37:34IN THIS SITUATION, I'VE BEEN ALL
- 37:35OVER THE STATE.
- 37:37WE'VE BEEN HAVE A GROUP OF
- 37:38PEOPLE ALL OVER THE STATE IN THE
- 37:40LAST COUPLE WEEKS TALKING TO
- 37:42TEACHERS ABOUT AMENDMENT 2 AND
- 37:43THE OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF
- 37:44TEACHERS ARE OPPOSED TO
- 37:46AMENDMENT 2 BECAUSE THEY BELIEVE
- 37:47IN THEIR PUBLIC SCHOOLS MANY THE
- 37:49OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF PUBLIC
- 37:51SCHOOLTEACHERS SEND THEIR KIDS
- 37:52TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS BECAUSE WE
- 37:54BELIEVE IN WHAT IT DOES FOR THE
- 37:55COMMUNITIES AND FOR OUR
- 37:57FAMILIES.
- 37:57>> WONDERFUL THIS IS NOT GOING
- 37:58TO CHANGE ANYTHING.
- 37:59IT WILL ALLOW THE FAMILIES THAT
- 38:01NEED SOMETHING DIFFERENT TO HAVE
- 38:03THAT OPTION.
- 38:03WHAT IS WRONG WITH THAT?
- 38:04I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY SUCH A
- 38:06FIGHT.
- 38:07AND THE FUNDING ISSUE, SCHOOL
- 38:09DISTRICTS GET MORE THAN JUST THE
- 38:11SEEK FUNDING FOR STUDENTS.
- 38:13THEY GET LOCAL PROPERTY TAX
- 38:15REVENUE.
- 38:16THEY GET FEDERAL DOLLARS.
- 38:17OUR LEGISLATURE IN THE PAST
- 38:19COUPLE OF BUDGETS INCREASED
- 38:22FUNDING TO DISTRICTS ON TOP OF
- 38:23THE SEEK FUNDING IN ORDER TO
- 38:25GIVE TEACHERS RAISES OR MEET
- 38:27OTHER NEEDS IN DISTRICTS AND
- 38:29THAT HASN'T BEEN RECOGNIZED.
- 38:31BUT STUDENTS DISTRICTS AREN'T
- 38:34JUST LIMITED HERE TO THE 45 OR
- 38:374800 OF THE SEEK AVERAGE SEEK
- 38:39FUNDING.
- 38:40THEY GET A LOT MORE THEY ARE
- 38:42GETTING $20,000 WHEN YOU TAKE
- 38:43ALL OF THE REVENUE SOURCES
- 38:45TOGETHER THAT DISTRICTS ARE
- 38:47GETTING.
- 38:47>> Renee: THIS COMMENT FROM MIKE
- 38:49IN KENTON COUNTY, ONLY WEALTHY
- 38:51KIDS HAVE THIS OPPORTUNITY WHEN
- 38:53I WAS GROWING UP I WAS ONE OF
- 38:55SEVEN KIDS AND WE ALL WENT TO
- 38:57CATHOLIC SCHOOLS.
- 38:57WE WEREN'T RICH THEY NEED TO GET
- 39:00RID OF THE IDEA THAT ONLY
- 39:02WEALTHY KIDS GO TO CATHOLIC OR
- 39:04PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 39:05CARE TO COMMENT THIS SIDE?
- 39:07>> AGAIN, WE DON'T HAVE ANY
- 39:09PROBLEM WITH SCHOOL CHOICE YOU
- 39:11WON'T FIND ANY PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 39:14EDUCATOR THAT OPPOSES SCHOOL
- 39:16CHOICE.
- 39:16IT IS THE ISSUE OF FOLLOWING THE
- 39:19DOLLARS.
- 39:19THE ISSUE OF THE LACK OF FUNDING
- 39:21FOR PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 39:22IT'S THE ISSUE THAT, YOU KNOW,
- 39:25THE CONCEPT OF PARENT CHOICE IS
- 39:27FALSE.
- 39:28IT'S MISLEADING.
- 39:29IT RARELY HAPPENS ESPECIALLY FOR
- 39:31SPECIAL EDUCATION STUDENTS AND
- 39:32STUDENTS IN POVERTY.
- 39:34THOSE STUDENTS WILL END UP
- 39:35REMAINING IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 39:37AND WILL BE UNDERFUNDED.
- 39:40AND SO IF YOU LOOK AT THE REAL
- 39:43DATA AND I BROUGHT LOTS OF DATA
- 39:45I KNOW WE DON'T HAVE TIME TO
- 39:47DELVE INTO IT ON THIS SHOW BUT I
- 39:49HEAR ABOUT THE SO-CALLED DATA
- 39:51FROM THE OTHER SIDE AND I'VE
- 39:52NEVER SEEN ANY OF IT.
- 39:53I HAVE 40 PAGES OF FOOTNOTES OF
- 39:56DATA THAT SHOW THAT VOUCHERS AND
- 40:01PRIVATIZATION OF PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 40:02DOES NOT WORK.
- 40:03>> Renee: FROM THE BOOK THE
- 40:06PRIVATEERS.
- 40:06>> ONE PLACE.
- 40:08AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE RESEARCH
- 40:09OF A VERY WELL-KNOWN EDUCATIONAL
- 40:13RESEARCHER JOHN HADY WHERE THERE
- 40:15IS SCHOOL CHOICE, SCHOOL CHOICE
- 40:17DOES NOT IMPACT STUDENT
- 40:19ACHIEVEMENT.
- 40:19>> SEE, THAT'S JUST NOT TRUE.
- 40:23IF YOU TAKE WHAT HAPPENED IN
- 40:24FLORIDA WHEN CARA WAS PASSED
- 40:26HERE IN KENTUCKY AND IN FLORIDA
- 40:29AT THAT TIME THEIR PUBLIC
- 40:30EDUCATION PERFORMANCE TRAILED
- 40:32KENTUCKY IN MANY KEY AREAS.
- 40:34IN THE INTERVENING YEARS IT'S
- 40:37BEEN 34 YEARS OF THIS REFORM OUT
- 40:39OUTCOMES REMAINED LARGELY
- 40:42STAGNANT WITH SOME INCREASE.
- 40:44BUT NOT NEARLY WHAT WE'VE SEEN
- 40:46IN A STATE LIKE FLORIDA WHICH
- 40:48HAS INCREASED TO THE POINT THEIR
- 40:50PUBLIC EDUCATION SYSTEM IS
- 40:51PERFORMING NEAR THE TOP OF THE
- 40:53COUNTRY AND THEY'VE INCREASED
- 40:55SPENDING LESS PER IN RELATION TO
- 40:58THEIR POPULATION.
- 40:59THEY HAVE HALF A MILLION
- 41:01CHILDREN ON SCHOOL CHOICE
- 41:02PROGRAMS TODAY.
- 41:04AND THEIR PUBLIC DISIM HAS
- 41:06IMPROVED GREATLY.
- 41:07WHAT IS THE MAJOR DIFFERENCE IN
- 41:08FLORIDA AND KENTUCKY?
- 41:09IT'S NOT SPENDING MORE BECAUSE
- 41:12WE HAVE INCREASED SPENDING MORE
- 41:14BUT THEY'VE OFFERED PARENTS A
- 41:15NUMBER OF CHOICES.
- 41:17THAT DYNAMIC OF CHOICE HAS AN
- 41:19IMPACT ON THE PUBLIC SYSTEM.
- 41:21AND I THINK IF YOU ARE FOR
- 41:23PUBLIC EDUCATION WHICH I AM AND
- 41:24A PRODUCT OF THAT, BUT I WANT TO
- 41:26SEE IT DO WELL BECAUSE MOST OF
- 41:28OUR STUDENTS ARE GOING TO BE IN
- 41:29PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 41:31ESPECIALLY LOW INCOME MINORITY
- 41:33STUDENTS BEING IMPACTED.
- 41:33>> AND IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT
- 41:35ALL OF THAT FLORIDA DATA WHICH
- 41:38CONTINUES TO BE CITED IS THEIR
- 41:39OWN GENERATED DATA.
- 41:41THEY HAVE NEVER HAD AN
- 41:42INDEPENDENT VERIFIED RESEARCH
- 41:44BASED STUDY.
- 41:45>> WE KNOW THERE'S SCHOOL CHOICE
- 41:49PROGRAM FROM THE FLORIDA
- 41:50DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION WE KNOW
- 41:51WHAT THEY ARE SPENDING.
- 41:52>> IT'S THEIR OWN NUMBERS, JIM.
- 41:54>> THE KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF
- 41:55EDUCATION PUTS OUT THE SPENDING
- 41:57NUMBERS HERE.
- 41:59>> Renee: THIS QUESTION FROM
- 42:01HARDEN COUNTY AND HARKENS BACK
- 42:03TO YOUR COMMENTS ABOUT TESTING
- 42:05AND THIS VIEWER SAYS WHY DO WE
- 42:07BASE OUR EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS ON
- 42:09ONE SINGLE TEST DURING THE
- 42:11SCHOOL YEAR INSTEAD OF TAKING A
- 42:13HOLISTIC APPROACH WHY DON'T
- 42:15THINK THEY CONSIDER THIS WHEN
- 42:17TESTING STUDENTS.
- 42:17>> I WOULD COMPLETELY AGREE WITH
- 42:20THEM.
- 42:21OUR OPPONENTS USE THAT TO BASH
- 42:23OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 42:24WHEN MOST OF YOUR PUBLIC
- 42:26EDUCATORS WOULD TELL YOU THAT IF
- 42:28THEY HAD THEIR CHOICE, WE WOULD
- 42:29DO AWAY WITH SUCH ASSESSMENTS.
- 42:33THOSE ARE NOT LOCAL DECISIONS
- 42:34THOSE ARE STATE AND FEDERAL
- 42:37DECISIONS.
- 42:38AND LOOKING AT ONE LEVEL OF
- 42:40ASSESS MANY AND DECIDING WHETHER
- 42:42OR NOT A SCHOOL IS SUCCESSFUL OR
- 42:43NOT, IS NOT A GOOD MEASURE.
- 42:46>> Renee: SO IF SCHOOL CHOICE IS
- 42:48ALLOWED VOTERS RATIFY THAT ON
- 42:50NOVEMBER FIFTH AND THE
- 42:51LEGISLATURE DECIDES TO TAKE IT
- 42:53UP, SHOULD IT BE CRAFTED THAT
- 42:55PRIVATE SCHOOLS WHO TAKE SCHOOL
- 42:58VOUCHERS OR EDUCATIONAL SAVINGS
- 43:00ACCOUNTS HAVE TO USE THE SAME
- 43:02TESTING MECHANISMS AS
- 43:04TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND
- 43:05THE SAME ASSESSMENTS AND WHY
- 43:06NOT?
- 43:07>> THE ANSWER TO THE QUESTION,
- 43:10CERTAINLY EVERY TEST HAS ITS
- 43:12MARGIN OF ERROR.
- 43:14BUT WHEN A MAJORITY OF YOUR
- 43:16STUDENTS ARE FAILING TO REACH
- 43:18PROFICIENCY ON THE STATE
- 43:20ASSESSMENT AND THE NATIONAL
- 43:22ASSESSMENT HAS 85% OF OUR
- 43:24MINORITY STUDENTS FAILING TO
- 43:26REACH PROFICIENCY THE PROBLEM IS
- 43:27NOT THE TEST.
- 43:28THAT IS NOT THE PROBLEM.
- 43:29AND HERE'S THE DIFFERENCE --
- 43:32>> Renee: WOULD YOU REQUIRE THE
- 43:33SAME TEST TO BE TAKEN?
- 43:34>> THE DIFFERENCE THAT OUR
- 43:36OPPONENTS DON'T ACCOUNT FOR IS
- 43:39THE INVOLVEMENT OF PARENTS AND
- 43:40THEIR DECISION.
- 43:42SO THERE ARE MYRIAD REASONS WHY
- 43:44PEOPLE CHOOSE A DIFFERENT SCHOOL
- 43:45FOR THEIR CHILD.
- 43:47IF THEY ARE SATISFIED AND THEY
- 43:48ARE HAPPY THAT THEIR CHILD IS
- 43:51GETTING THE EDUCATION THEY NEED
- 43:53WHATEVER TEST THAT PRIVATE
- 43:54SCHOOL MAY USE OR SCHOOL OF
- 43:56CHOICE THAT IS THE DETERMINING
- 43:57FACTOR.
- 43:59IT'S ABOUT WHETHER THE STUDENT
- 43:59IS GETTING WHAT THE PARENT WANTS
- 44:02THEM TO GET.
- 44:03IT'S NOT ABOUT FORCING SOME KIND
- 44:05OF TESTING SYSTEM ON A PRIVATE
- 44:07SCHOOL.
- 44:07BUT IN THE PUBLIC --
- 44:09>> Renee: WHEN YOU ARE COMPARING
- 44:11APPLES TO ORANGES HOW DO YOU
- 44:13KNOW THAT CHILDREN IS GETTING A
- 44:15EQUITABLE EDUCATION?
- 44:15>> GREAT QUESTION.
- 44:16IF THEY ARE NOT, THE PARENTS
- 44:18WILL CHOOSE TO SEND THEIR CHILD
- 44:20SOMEWHERE ELSE IF THE SCHOOL IS
- 44:22NOT SEAING THAT --
- 44:23SATISFYING THAT REQUIREMENT OF
- 44:25THE PARENT.
- 44:26IN THE PUBLIC SYSTEM WE SEE WITH
- 44:27THE TESTING THAT IT'S NOT JUST
- 44:30ONE TEST.
- 44:31WE'VE SEEN THE STATE TEST AND
- 44:32THE NATIONAL ASSESSMENT AND IT'S
- 44:34NOT JUST BEEN FOR A COUPLE YEARS
- 44:36IT'S BEEN FOR DECADES WE'VE HAD
- 44:39THIS.
- 44:39I'M NOT SAYING TESTING IS THE
- 44:41COMPLETE OF OUR EDUCATION.
- 44:42BUT IT CERTAINLY INDICATES THAT
- 44:45WE HAVE SOME ISSUES TO SOLVE.
- 44:47AND THE OPPONENTS NEVER WANT TO
- 44:49TALK ABOUT THE PERFORMANCE OF
- 44:50OUR SYSTEM.
- 44:51AND THEY NEVER HAVE ANY
- 44:52SOLUTIONS OTHER THAN ALL I'M
- 44:54HEAR SOMETHING MORE FUNDING AND
- 44:56WE'VE INCREASED FUNDING
- 44:57TREMENDOUSLY.
- 44:58>> Renee: THIS QUESTION FROM
- 45:00HARDEN COUNTY HOW WILL AMENDMENT
- 45:012 IMPACT HOME SCHOOLERS?
- 45:03>> SO I ENCOURAGE EVERYONE TO GO
- 45:07TO BIPPS.ORG WE POSTED ABOUT
- 45:11THAT.
- 45:12WHY HOME SCHOOLING FAMILIES
- 45:15SHOULD SUPPORT SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 45:16THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF CONCERN
- 45:18AMONG HOME SCHOOLERS THAT IF
- 45:19THERE IS A SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM
- 45:21THAT INCLUDES HOME SCHOOLING
- 45:23WHICH SOME SEVERAL STATES HAVE
- 45:26DONE, THAT THAT WOULD MEAN THAT
- 45:28THE GOVERNMENT OR THE PUBLIC
- 45:29SYSTEM COULD DICTATE TO THEM
- 45:31WHAT THEY TEACH AND HOW THEY
- 45:33TEACH.
- 45:33WE HAVE NOT SEEN THAT HAPPEN IN
- 45:34ANY STATE.
- 45:35AND I DON'T THINK IT'S GOING TO
- 45:37BE AN ISSUE.
- 45:39OUR HOME SCHOOLERS CAN TALK
- 45:40ABOUT THIS.
- 45:41OUR HOME SCHOOLING ASSOCIATIONS
- 45:44HERE ARE VERY STRONG.
- 45:45AND BY THE WAY, I WANT TO
- 45:47COMPLIMENT OUR PUBLIC SYSTEM.
- 45:49BECAUSE THEY HAVE RECOGNIZED
- 45:50WITH LEARNING DISABLED CHILDREN
- 45:53THEY HAVE RECOGNIZED IN MANY
- 45:54CASES THEY CAN'T PROVIDE WHAT
- 45:56THAT CHILD NEEDS AND RECOMMENDED
- 45:58ANOTHER SCHOOL THAT WILL FIT
- 46:01THAT NEED FOR THERAPY OR
- 46:02SERVICES.
- 46:03SO WE HAVE PUBLIC SCHOOLS DOING
- 46:05THAT.
- 46:06THE PROBLEM WITH THE PREVIOUS
- 46:09SCHOOL CHOICE LAWS AND THE
- 46:10REASON THE LEGISLATURE GOT
- 46:13INVOLVED IN THAT IN THAT WAY WAS
- 46:15WE HAD SUPERINTENDENTS FOR
- 46:16EXAMPLE, THE E TOWN
- 46:19SUPERINTENDENT AT THE TIME CAME
- 46:20OUT AND HAD HIS BOARD PASS A
- 46:22RESOLUTION THAT THEY OPPOSE EVEN
- 46:24THE IDEA OF CHARTER SCHOOLS EVEN
- 46:26BEFORE LEGISLATION WAS PASSED.
- 46:29WHAT CHANCE DOES A CHARTER
- 46:31SCHOOL APPLICANT HAVE IN A
- 46:32DISTRICT THAT IT'S ONLY THE
- 46:34PUBLIC SCHOOLS THAT BOARD THAT
- 46:37CAN AUTHORIZE THAT AND THEY WERE
- 46:38TRYING TO ADDRESS THAT.
- 46:40I'M NOT SAYING IT WAS PERFECT OR
- 46:42GREAT, BUT THAT'S WHAT THEY WERE
- 46:43TRYING TO DO.
- 46:44I THINK IT'S ONLY FAIR TO TALK
- 46:46ABOUT THAT.
- 46:48>> Renee: AN X POST, FORMERLY
- 46:50KNOWN AS TWITTER, DAVID W SAID
- 46:52MY FAMILY MEMBERS IN RURAL IOWA
- 46:54LOVE THE CHOICE AFFORDED TO THEM
- 46:56BY THEIR EDUCATION SAVINGS
- 46:58ACCOUNT PROGRAM AND IT HASN'T
- 46:59HURT THEIR PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 47:00I AM A YES ON NUMBER 2.
- 47:03THE KENTUCKY LEGISLATURE CAN
- 47:04EXPLORE OPTIONS FOR FAMILIES AND
- 47:06ALSO PROMOTING STRONG PUBLIC
- 47:08SCHOOLS.
- 47:09ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE ISSUE
- 47:11WE BROUGHT YOU JENNY CLARK FROM
- 47:13ARIZONA WHO MADE THE CASE FOR
- 47:14AMENDMENT 2 AND LAST WEEK THERE
- 47:17WERE GROUPS COALESCING AROUND
- 47:19DEFEATING AMENDMENT 2 AND
- 47:20CLAYTON DALTON SHARES THIS WITH
- 47:22US.
- 47:23>> WHY IS THIS A HEALTH ISSUE,
- 47:25YOU MIGHT ASK?
- 47:27WELL, BECAUSE EDUCATION IS ONE
- 47:27OF THE MOST SIGNIFICANT
- 47:31PREDICTORS OF HEALTH OUTCOMES.
- 47:35PEOPLE WITH MORE EDUCATION LIVE
- 47:38LONGER, HEALIER LIVES.
- 47:39THEY ARE MORE LIKELY TO ACCESS
- 47:42HEALTHCARE, SECURE WELL PAYING
- 47:43JOBS AND AFFORDS THEM THE
- 47:45OPPORTUNITY TO LIVE IN HEALTHIER
- 47:47ENVIRONMENTS.
- 47:48THIS IS WHY IT'S CRITICAL THAT
- 47:51EVERY CHILD IS ABLE TO RECEIVE A
- 47:53QUALITY EDUCATION.
- 47:54AND A PROPERLY FUNDED PUBLIC
- 47:57SCHOOL SYSTEM IS THE ONLY WAY TO
- 47:59GUARANTEE THIS ACCESS FOR ALL
- 48:01KIDS AND NOT JUST A FEW.
- 48:03>> SINCE PRIVATE SCHOOLS ARE NOT
- 48:05REQUIRED TO FOLLOW STATE AND
- 48:07FEDERAL ANTIDISCRIMINATION
- 48:09REGULATIONS THAT PROTECT
- 48:10STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES,
- 48:12THESE SCHOOLS CAN CHERRY PICK
- 48:13STUDENTS THAT THEY CHOOSE TO
- 48:15ENROLL.
- 48:16IN STATES WITH VOUCHERS, PARENTS
- 48:18REPORT THAT THEIR CHILDREN WITH
- 48:20DISABILITIES WERE OFTEN DENIED
- 48:22ADMISSION TO PRIVATE SCHOOLS OR
- 48:23WERE NOT RETAINED IN CLASS FOR
- 48:25THE ENTIRE SCHOOL YEAR.
- 48:27SO THEY WERE ACCEPTED INITIALLY
- 48:29AND THEN DROPPED BECAUSE OF
- 48:31THEIR BEHAVIOR LACK OF PROGRESS.
- 48:34PARENTS ALSO REPORTED THAT SOME
- 48:36PRIVATE SCHOOLS CHARGE THEM FOR
- 48:37THERAPY SERVICES THAT WERE IN
- 48:39THE CHILD'S IEP.
- 48:41SOMETHING THEY HAD NEVER
- 48:42ENCOUNTERED IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 48:43>> RESEARCH SHOWS THAT SCHOOL
- 48:46MEALS IMPROVE STUDENT HEALTH
- 48:47INCLUDING OBESITY RATES AND
- 48:49MENTAL HEALTH OUTCOMES.
- 48:51SCHOOL MEALS IMPROVE ACADEMIC
- 48:55PERFORMANCE REDUCED TARDINESS,
- 48:57FEWER OFFICE REFERRALS AND
- 48:59IMPROVE MATH AND READING TEST
- 49:02SCORES.
- 49:03SIPHONING MONEY AWAY FROM PUBLIC
- 49:04SCHOOLS TO PROVIDE VOUCHER
- 49:06PROGRAMS FOR PRIVATE EDUCATION
- 49:08CREATES A TWO-TIERED EDUCATION
- 49:10SYSTEM AND WIDENS THE HUNGER GAP
- 49:12THAT WE FACE AS A COMMONWEALTH
- 49:14FOR TOO LONG.
- 49:15LET'S KEEP KIDS HEALTHY AND FED
- 49:18SAYING NO TO AMENDMENT 2 THIS
- 49:19NOVEMBER.
- 49:19>> WHAT WOULD IT MEAN FOR THE
- 49:21SCHOOLS IN YOUR DISTRICT SPENT
- 49:24DECADES DOING MORE WITH LESS TO
- 49:25HAVE THEIR BUDGETS CUT FURTHER?
- 49:28IT WOULD MEAN CUTS TO HEALTH
- 49:29SERVICES SUCH AS SCHOOL NURSES.
- 49:31HEALTH SCREENINGS, COUNSELING
- 49:33AND MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES.
- 49:34IT WOULD MEAN THE ELIMINATION OF
- 49:36WELLNESS AND NUTRITION PROGRAMS.
- 49:38IT WOULD MEAN INCREASED CLASS
- 49:39SIZE AND LIMITED RESOURCES FOR
- 49:41SPECIAL NEEDS MAKING IT
- 49:42CHALLENGES FOR OUR TEACHERS AND
- 49:44STAFF TO DELIVER INDIVIDUALIZED
- 49:47DETENTION.
- 49:47THESE CUTS WOULD GO BEYOND
- 49:49IMPACTING STUDENTS' ABILITY TO
- 49:51SUCCEED ACADEMICALLY AND
- 49:53SOCIALLY THEY COULD CREATE
- 49:54NEGATIVE CONSEQUENCES FOR THEIR
- 49:56PHYSICAL AND EMOTIONAL HEALTH
- 49:57INTO THEIR ADULT LIVES.
- 49:58>> WE NEED TO BE CLEAR, THE
- 50:00IMPACT OF THIS AMENDMENT WOULD
- 50:02NOT BE FELT EQUALLY.
- 50:04THE LOSS OF FUNDS COULD FORCE
- 50:06PUBLIC SCHOOLS TO CUT OR SCALE
- 50:09BACK HEALTH SCREENINGS,
- 50:12TRANSPORTATION, AND OTHER
- 50:13SERVICES AND PROGRAMMING THAT
- 50:15ARE ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT FOR OUR
- 50:18VULNERABLE POPULATIONS.
- 50:20KENTUCKY'S PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE
- 50:21THE BACKBONE OF OUR COMMUNITIES.
- 50:23AND THEY PROVIDE CRITICAL ACCESS
- 50:26TO EDUCATION FOR ALL CHILDREN.
- 50:29>> Renee: SO I WANT TO COME TO
- 50:30THIS SIDE OF THE TABLE AND HAVE
- 50:32YOU ALL RESPOND THAT THERE ARE
- 50:34NOT RULES AGAINST
- 50:36ANTIDISCRIMINATION WHAT WE HEARD
- 50:38IN THE PIECE I'M REQUOTING THAT.
- 50:41SOME SPECIAL NEEDS OF STUDENTS
- 50:42WITH DISABILITIES DENIED
- 50:44ADMISSION.
- 50:45HEALTH SCREENINGS AND
- 50:46TRANSPORTATION WOULD BE ISSUES.
- 50:50RESPOND TO WHAT YOU HEARD FROM
- 50:51THE OPPONENTS?
- 50:51>> SO, WE ALREADY HAVE LAWS
- 50:54CIVIL RIGHTS LAWS THAT
- 50:56REQUIRE --
- 50:57THAT MAKE DISCRIMINATION ILLEGAL
- 50:59ACROSS THE BOARD WHETHER YOU ARE
- 51:00TALKING ABOUT EDUCATION OR ANY
- 51:03OTHER PART OF OUR SOCIETY.
- 51:07THIS IDEA THAT PRIVATE SCHOOLS
- 51:09CHERRY PICK THEIR STUDENTS THAT
- 51:11TOTALLY IS WRONG.
- 51:13BECAUSE THE PROGRAMS ARE EVEN
- 51:14THE ONE SETUP HERE, IT WOULD
- 51:16HAVE BEEN THE PARENTS DECIDING
- 51:18WHERE THESE EDUCATION SAVINGS
- 51:20ACCOUNT DOLLARS WOULD GO.
- 51:24AND HE TALKED ABOUT SIPHONING
- 51:26OFF FUNDS WE DON'T HEAR THAT
- 51:28WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT OTHER PUBLIC
- 51:30GOODS PROVIDED BY PUBLIC
- 51:31DOLLARS.
- 51:32EXAMPLE, MEDICARE ALLOWS THE
- 51:34PATIENT TO DECIDE WHICH DOCTOR
- 51:35THEY GO TO OR WHICH PROVIDER
- 51:37THEY GO TO.
- 51:38THE GI BILL ALLOWS VETERANS TO
- 51:41DECIDE WHERE THEY GET THEIR
- 51:42EDUCATION INCLUDING A RELIGIOUS
- 51:44SCHOOL.
- 51:45SECTION EIGHT HOUSING ALLOWS FOR
- 51:47HOUSING CHOICES.
- 51:49THE W.I.C. PROGRAM ALLOWS THE
- 51:51INDIVIDUAL TO DECIDE WHERE THEY
- 51:53PURCHASE THEIR FOOD.
- 51:54WHY?
- 51:54BECAUSE THE DOLLARS DO NOT
- 51:56BELONG TO THE PROGRAM OR THE
- 51:57DOCTOR OR THE HOSPITAL, THEY
- 51:59BELONG FOR A PUBLIC GOOD AND
- 52:01THEY BELONG TO TAXPAYERS AND
- 52:03THEY BELONG TO THAT INDIVIDUAL
- 52:04TO DO WHAT IS BEST FOR THEM.
- 52:06SO WE DON'T TALK ABOUT DIVERTING
- 52:08FUNDS AWAY FROM THAT.
- 52:10WHY IS THAT --
- 52:11I MEAN THESE DOLLARS DO NOT
- 52:13BELONG TO SCHOOL OR THE SYSTEM.
- 52:15THEY ARE THERE TO EDUCATE
- 52:16STUDENTS.
- 52:17IF A STUDENT TAKES A VOUCHER OR
- 52:19SCHOLARSHIP AND THEY GET
- 52:21EDUCATED AT A PUBLIC SCHOOL, A
- 52:22CHARTER SCHOOL OR A PRIVATE
- 52:24SCHOOL AND GET THE EDUCATION
- 52:25THEY NEED THEY WILL BE HEALTHY
- 52:26AND STRONG.
- 52:27THAT'S WHAT WE WANT TO SEE THEM
- 52:29SETUP FOR LIFE AND THAT MEANS
- 52:31THE MONEY HAS BEEN PROPERLY
- 52:34USED.
- 52:35>> Renee: THIS SIDE.
- 52:35>> SO THE FIRST THING I THINK WE
- 52:37HAVE TO GO BACK AND LOOK AT THE
- 52:41REASON THAT VOUCHERS WERE
- 52:42CREATED TO BEGIN WITH.
- 52:43I MEAN IF YOU LOOK AT THE
- 52:46HISTORY OF VOUCHERS AND WHERE
- 52:47THEY STARTED IN MILWAUKEE.
- 52:49THERE'S SOME IN TEXAS AND OTHER
- 52:51DISTRICTS THEY WERE CREATED TO
- 52:53GO BACK AND SEGREGATE SCHOOLS.
- 52:55THEY WERE CREATED TO ALLOW WHITE
- 52:59WEALTHIER FAMILIES TO LEAVE THE
- 53:02SCHOOLS AFTER THE BROWN VERSUS
- 53:04BOARD OF EDUCATION DECISION.
- 53:06SO WHAT ENDS UP HAPPENING OUR
- 53:09STUDENTS OF COLOR ARE GENERALLY
- 53:11MORE DISADVANTAGED.
- 53:12IT IS UNFORTUNATE, BUT THERE ARE
- 53:14MORE STUDENTS OF COLOR WHO LIVE
- 53:16IN POVERTY THAN THERE ARE WHITE
- 53:18STUDENTS.
- 53:19AND THAT'S TRUE IN MOST ANY
- 53:21AREA.
- 53:23AND SO THAT'S THE FIRST THING
- 53:24WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE HISTORY OF
- 53:27VOUCHERS.
- 53:27SO WHY WOULD WE SUPPORT A
- 53:29PROGRAM THAT IS CREATED TO TAKE
- 53:33AND GIVE STUDENTS THAT HAVE MORE
- 53:35WEALTH AND MORE RESOURCES
- 53:38OPPORTUNITIES THAT OTHERS DON'T
- 53:40HAVE?
- 53:40SO THIS IDEA THIS THOUGHT THAT
- 53:43WE'RE CREATING SOMETHING THAT IS
- 53:44GOING TO BENEFIT THOSE STUDENTS,
- 53:46HAS NOT PROVEN OUT.
- 53:50IN ANY OF THE DATA.
- 53:51>> WHY IS A MAJORITY OF STUDENTS
- 53:54IN CHARTER SCHOOLS, AND IN THESE
- 53:57SCHOOLS OF CHOICE PROGRAM WERE
- 53:59ARE THEY LOW INCOME MINORITY
- 54:01STUDENTS?
- 54:01WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE PERFORMANCE
- 54:03OF THE PUBLIC SYSTEM, IT IS THE
- 54:05LOW INCOME MINORITY STUDENTS WHO
- 54:07ARE MOST LIKELY TO BE LEFT
- 54:08BEHIND.
- 54:09MOST LIKELY TO BE CAUGHT IN
- 54:11FAILING TRAPPED IN A FAILING
- 54:13SCHOOL THAT SOUNDS LIKE A REAL
- 54:16PROBLEM WITH MAKING SURE THAT
- 54:19ALL PEOPLE OF COLOR, PEOPLE LOW
- 54:22INCOME, KENTUCKIANS HAVE AN
- 54:24OPTION HAVE ACCESS TO A GREAT
- 54:26EDUCATION.
- 54:26>> Renee: DO YOU DISPUTE THE
- 54:29FOUNDING PRINCIPLES WHY VOUCHERS
- 54:30TOOK ROOT THAT HE CITED?
- 54:33>> I DON'T THINK WE'RE SEEING
- 54:34ANY OF THAT.
- 54:35WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE MAJORITY OF
- 54:38STUDENTS.
- 54:38>> Renee: DO YOU AGREE ON THE
- 54:40PREMISES WHICH THEY WERE
- 54:41FOUNDED?
- 54:41>> SOME PEOPLE MAY HAVE USE TO
- 54:43DO FOR THAT REASON I'M NOT GOING
- 54:45TO DENY THAT 150 YEARS AGO.
- 54:47BUT THAT IS THE PROBLEM WITH OUR
- 54:48EDUCATION SYSTEM IT NEEDS TO
- 54:50CATCH UP TO 2024.
- 54:52AND WE SEE AROUND THE COUNTRY
- 54:53ALL OF THESE STATES WHERE
- 54:57VUCHERS --
- 54:57VOUCHERS ARE BEING USED TO HELP
- 54:58THE FOLKS YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT.
- 55:00>> SCHOOL CHOICE EXPLODED AFTER
- 55:02COVID.
- 55:04PARENTS STARTED SEEING THINGS
- 55:06THAT WERE GOING ON IN EDUCATING
- 55:10THEIR CHILDREN AND THEY HAD A
- 55:12FRONT ROW SEAT TO IT.
- 55:13AND A LOT OF PARENTS WERE
- 55:14UNHAPPY WITH IT FOR VARIOUS
- 55:16REASONS.
- 55:18AND SO THE DEMAND FOR OTHER
- 55:22CHOICES STARTED AFTER COVID AND
- 55:30WE SAW STATE AFTER STATE AFTER
- 55:33STAY IMPLEMENT SCHOOL CHOICE
- 55:34PROGRAMS.
- 55:34I GUESS I'M NOT UNDERSTANDING
- 55:37WHY THERE IS THIS PASSIONATE
- 55:40VOICE AGAINST THIS.
- 55:41BECAUSE I FEEL LIKE IT HAS BEEN
- 55:44PROVEN OVER AND OVER AGAIN THAT
- 55:45IN EVERY STATE WHERE SCHOOL
- 55:49CHOICE PASSES, OR SOME TYPE OF
- 55:51SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM IS
- 55:53IMPLEMENTED, THAT PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 55:57IMPROVE ANYTIME THERE'S
- 55:59COMPETITION IN A FREE MARKET,
- 56:00YOU KNOW, YOU WILL RISE TO THE
- 56:03OCCASION OR IF YOU ARE GOING TO
- 56:05FAIL YOU ARE GOING TO FAIL.
- 56:06>> Renee: WE HAVE TO LEAVE IT
- 56:08THERE WE HAVE 20 SECONDS LEFT.
- 56:09THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
- 56:11WE HOPE YOU GOT SOMETHING OUT OF
- 56:12THIS DISCUSSION.
- 56:13YOU CAN SEE PART ONE ON OUR
- 56:17WEBSITE AT KET.ORG WE WILL BE
- 56:19BACK MONDAY TO TALK ABOUT THE
- 56:212024 ELECTION.
- 56:22AND I WILL SEE YOU TOMORROW
- 56:24NIGHT ON KENTUCKY EDITION AT
- 56:266:30 EASTERN, 5:30 CENTRAL.
- 56:28THANK YOU FOR WATCHING.
- 56:30I'M RENEE SHAW TAKE GOOD CARE.
- 56:31SO LONG.