Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / A Judge’s Perspective on Personal-Injury Damages with Hon. Margaret Oldendorf (Ret.)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to a judge's perspective on personal
- 0:08injury damages. I'm Philip Vondra, co -chair
- 0:11of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's personal
- 0:14injury law section. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:16today's speaker, the honorable Margaret Oldendorf,
- 0:20retired. Judge Margaret Oldendorf is a mediator,
- 0:24arbitrator, and referee at ADR Services, Inc.
- 0:27She joined the panel in 2024 after nearly 20
- 0:30years on the Los Angeles County Superior Court.
- 0:34where she spent the last nine years presiding
- 0:36over civil trial and independent calendar courts.
- 0:39Known for her fairness, efficiency, and deep
- 0:42legal knowledge, Judge Oldendorf has earned numerous
- 0:46accolades, including Judicial Civility Award
- 0:50from ABOTA and Trial Judge of the Year from CALA.
- 0:53And now, let's get started. Bill, thank you very
- 0:57much, and good afternoon to everybody. Thank
- 1:01you very much for attending, whether you're going
- 1:03to be seeing this live or you're going to be
- 1:05listening to it later. This is a program on personal
- 1:09injury damages. We're going to go over both some
- 1:12black letter law and then also some strategy
- 1:17issues. Suzanne is going to run the PowerPoint
- 1:20for me. Suzanne, if you can go to the next slide.
- 1:29Let's just review some of the issues that I'm
- 1:31hoping to review with you guys today, and then
- 1:35hopefully have five or 10 minutes at the end
- 1:37for questions, which you'll put in the Q &A.
- 1:41We're going to talk about creating your approach.
- 1:45We're going to review some black letter law,
- 1:47especially in the area of economic and non -economic
- 1:50damages. Talk a little more then toward the end
- 1:54about strategy. And then the difference of dealing
- 1:58with damages issues in mediation and arbitration
- 2:03if time permits. Next slide. Do the next slide
- 2:12there. This one isn't no specific content other
- 2:17than there you go. Your approach to damages,
- 2:22I would just want to first really encourage everyone
- 2:26to take the time, do the preparation at the beginning
- 2:29to identify unique issues in your case. Are non
- 2:36-economic damages going to really be a big driver
- 2:38in your case? Are the medical damages going to
- 2:42be a big issue, loss of earnings? Do you have
- 2:45someone who's got pre -existing conditions? Practically
- 2:48everybody does. and how these things affect the
- 2:52case. Let me just mention here, I'm gonna be
- 2:54trying to look at this from both the plaintiff
- 2:57attorney perspective as well as the defense perspective.
- 3:00Some of this is a little bit more plaintiff oriented
- 3:05because of course we start with the black letter
- 3:08law on the plaintiff side, but all of these things
- 3:12I think apply equally to both the plaintiff side
- 3:16and the defense side. I have found personally
- 3:22as a lawyer and also as a judge that our Casey
- 3:25instructions are probably one of the best resources
- 3:28that you all have to review the black letter
- 3:31law in the area of damages. When I was on the
- 3:36bench, I did a lot of personal injury trials.
- 3:40I would, if I had the time, actually go through
- 3:44the entire 3900 series of Casey. and just review
- 3:48them, get a sense of which ones may be applying
- 3:51to my case. They've also got just excellent resources
- 3:56in the use notes, directions for use, the authority
- 4:03section. I spent a short period of time on the,
- 4:08a couple years, on the judicial council committee
- 4:13on jury instructions, civil. And I found that
- 4:18very informative. One of the things that I learned
- 4:21as a participant on that committee is how hard
- 4:24that committee works to vet, to identify, and
- 4:28to articulate in the use notes the applicable
- 4:31law on a particular area. You can rely on that
- 4:35information. It's a fabulous resource. So I really,
- 4:38really want to commend you to that. Don't make
- 4:43your discovery necessarily real cookie cutter.
- 4:46Try to tailor it to the specific issues in your
- 4:49case. Don't be too shotgun. You try to focus
- 4:52on what's going on. And then I think one really
- 4:55important thing you can do is get a little bit
- 4:57of scoop on your judge. Go to you if you've got
- 5:01listserv available. If you've got other. group
- 5:06blogs or resources available, ask around in your
- 5:09office, try to figure out, do you have somebody
- 5:11who's a micromanager? Do you have somebody who's
- 5:15pretty relaxed and easygoing? Either way, just
- 5:21remember, your judge is never going to want to
- 5:24commit reversible error on anything. You want
- 5:29to educate your judge if you think it's an area
- 5:31that they may not be aware of. This is my own
- 5:37opinion, but having been on the other side of
- 5:39it as a judge, just because you might be able
- 5:43to get away with maybe a borderline or a risky
- 5:47argument doesn't necessarily mean that you want
- 5:50to go ahead and do it. Because if your judge
- 5:53has made a mistake and it goes up on appeal,
- 5:57it could be coming right back down. And of course,
- 6:00that doesn't do your client any good. So I think
- 6:03that that kind of investigation is very helpful.
- 6:08We can go to the next slide, Suzanne. I just
- 6:13told Suzanne and Phil when we were prepping.
- 6:16Let's see, we've got a slide that says, where's
- 6:20the blackboard? That's what damages look like
- 6:24to a judge. sometimes when we're trying to learn
- 6:28about your case. Thanks, next slide. Just a little
- 6:33background, we're just going to try and go through
- 6:36this hopefully pretty quickly. In the damages
- 6:40area, we all are aware of the collateral source
- 6:43rule. There's no offset entitled by the defense
- 6:49for compensation that a plaintiff may receive.
- 6:52from an independent source. That's the general
- 6:54rule. There are some exceptions. This would include
- 6:59payments from the plaintiff's insurer, even maybe
- 7:04gratuitous payments by employer or family, other
- 7:08sources. There are some exceptions that may apply.
- 7:12It's going to be unique to your case, subrogation
- 7:15cases. Those of you who do med mal, you're aware
- 7:19of Civil Code section, I think it's 33, 33 .2,
- 7:26which may allow information on payments. This
- 7:30Stokes versus Muszynski case, a fairly recent
- 7:34case out of the second district involving one
- 7:37of our L .A. Superior Court judges at trial.
- 7:41It's a case that's interesting because it. It
- 7:45discusses what happens during trial when information
- 7:51relating to collateral sources, Medicare, social
- 8:00security eligibility, insurance through Kaiser.
- 8:07The gist of the case is that passing references
- 8:12to this information in and of itself is not going
- 8:16to violate the collateral source rule and won't
- 8:20be prejudicial. In fact, as we may discuss a
- 8:24little bit later on here, it could actually be
- 8:27information that's relevant to the jury determining
- 8:31the reasonable value of a particular service.
- 8:37We can go to the next slide now. Past meds, basically
- 8:44four elements to the general rule. A plaintiff
- 8:48is entitled to get reasonable expenses for medical
- 8:53services that have been actually rendered. They
- 8:56do have to be reasonably necessary. And of course,
- 9:00it has to be something that was causally connected,
- 9:04caused by the particular accident or incident.
- 9:09KC 3903A is your basic rule on that. Typically,
- 9:15most of this is gonna require you to present
- 9:18it through or challenge it from the defense side
- 9:23through competent expert testimony. Your plaintiff
- 9:27probably can testify about a specific service
- 9:29they received. Yes, my arm was, my broken arm
- 9:33was set or something like that. But everything
- 9:37else really is going to wind up having to come
- 9:39through expert testimony. Next slide. So what's
- 9:45a reasonable medical expense? Here we get into
- 9:48the Howell case and its progeny. Reasonable payments
- 9:54for past meds cannot exceed the amount that was
- 9:59either actually paid or incurred. So Howell.
- 10:04General rule, a plaintiff may recover the lesser
- 10:07of the amount paid or incurred and the reasonable
- 10:12value of that service. Next slide. What does
- 10:19that mean? If the plaintiff has medical insurance,
- 10:24then if the provider has billed for that service,
- 10:30gotten paid, and there's some kind of a discount,
- 10:34and the provider, the doctor, the hospital, whatever,
- 10:38has accepted that payment, even if, arguably,
- 10:44the reasonable value might be more than that,
- 10:49you can't recover any more than the actual payment
- 10:52because the plaintiff can't recover any more
- 10:55than the actual loss. So that's what we mean
- 11:00when we talk about reasonable value less than
- 11:04the ordinary rate. These amounts are often easy
- 11:08to identify. And many of you are aware, if you
- 11:13practice in this area, we refer to these as the
- 11:17so -called Howell numbers. Frequently, counsel
- 11:20reach stipulations on these numbers. And your
- 11:23judge is going to want to kind of try to get
- 11:25you to do that so you don't have a big fight
- 11:28during trial getting bogged down on information
- 11:32that's probably pretty easy to determine. Harder
- 11:36area, if an expense hasn't yet been paid, Then
- 11:40you've got to get into the detail a little bit
- 11:44more. You've got to determine whether the service
- 11:47represented the reasonable value. What was billed
- 11:51is the reasonable value. This is the case whether
- 11:54there was insurance or not. In these cases, Bermudez,
- 11:58Pebley, you're all probably pretty familiar with
- 12:02it. This is more of a battleground every year
- 12:08in my experience because we see more and more
- 12:11every year treatment on so -called medical liens.
- 12:16People who voluntarily choose not to go through
- 12:21their medical insurance and instead seek treatment
- 12:26on a lien for various reasons. So this is an
- 12:34area where you're going to see some case law
- 12:38developing, I think, and it's important for you
- 12:41to review it and kind of be up on it. We can
- 12:44go to the next slide. Future meds, basically
- 12:50a three -part test. Again, you can get the reasonable
- 12:56value of medical service that the plaintiff is
- 13:01reasonably certain is going to be necessary in
- 13:04the future. And again, it's got to be attributable
- 13:07to the accident. One of the best cases dealing
- 13:10with future meds is this corn bomb case. And
- 13:13again, we're looking at KC 3903A. You can go
- 13:18to the next slide. Here's kind of an evidentiary
- 13:24way to look at some of these issues. If I were
- 13:29a plaintiff's lawyer or a defense lawyer, stay
- 13:33away from using the term medical insurance per
- 13:38se. The focus is on what's the reasonable value
- 13:42of a service. The cases over the last few years,
- 13:51including the Bermuda's case, which I cited on
- 13:54one of the prior pages, makes it clearer every
- 13:57year this develops. The courts are going to be
- 14:01willing to permit what they term a, quote unquote,
- 14:05wide -ranging inquiry into what's a reasonable
- 14:09service. If you look at KC 3903A, it talks about
- 14:15the cost of a service. This is the inquiry that
- 14:23the court is going to allow the parties to engage
- 14:26in so the jury can evaluate. Things like patient
- 14:37payment, a cash payment for a service, although
- 14:44that kind of implicates the absence of insurance,
- 14:52evidence that a patient personally paid for a
- 14:56service, depending on the circumstances of your
- 14:59case, might be allowable and relevant by the
- 15:03judge. Some cases, especially if you've got life
- 15:09care planners and they're looking at future meds,
- 15:13your life care planner may talk about the market
- 15:18value of a service. There are some cases that
- 15:22deal with testimony concerning the quote unquote
- 15:24exchange value of a service. These inquiries
- 15:31may be permissible. Even a life care planner
- 15:36who uses as a benchmark Medicare reimbursement
- 15:40rates, even if the individual isn't Medicare
- 15:42eligible, that might be relevant. This case that
- 15:47I've got here on this slide, Audish versus Macias,
- 15:50is a recent case out of the fourth district.
- 15:53It involved testimony by the plaintiff's life
- 15:57care planner on future meds. This was the life
- 16:03care planner for the plaintiff, but on cross,
- 16:07she was asked some questions about future meds,
- 16:10and there was some testimony about the plaintiff's.
- 16:13future eligibility for Medicare and how that
- 16:17might relate to the value of a particular service.
- 16:22The court found that it was not a violation of
- 16:24the collateral source rule to have that testimony,
- 16:28that it was relevant to reasonable value. Again,
- 16:32you can see this area is very fluid right now.
- 16:37It's fertile ground. It's something that may
- 16:41be important in your cases. We talked a little
- 16:45bit about medical service on a lean basis. Evidence
- 16:50concerning lean treatment may be permissible.
- 16:54I allowed it in many cases, particularly if the
- 17:00medical provider, the doctor, was on the stand.
- 17:05and on cross -examination, it was developed that
- 17:09he or she provided that treatment on a lean basis.
- 17:14My feeling was that it can be relevant to bias.
- 17:18It may actually even be relevant to reasonable
- 17:21value. It could also be relevant to what the
- 17:25plaintiff incurred. For example, it may be that
- 17:29it's appropriate to ask the treater, do you build
- 17:33for that, but do you actually expect to be paid
- 17:35for that? Those may be fair game, those questions.
- 17:41In the area of lien treatment, you may be bumping
- 17:44up against some attorney -client issues. The
- 17:48Khadir case, I just realized when I proved this
- 17:50this morning, I'm sorry, there's an extra U in
- 17:53that name, it's QAA. Khadir versus Figueroa 2021
- 17:59case, one of our judges in LA dealt with that
- 18:03case. The Court of Appeal ruled that whether
- 18:07or not an attorney referred a patient, a plaintiff,
- 18:13to a so -called lean physician was relevant to
- 18:18bias, also may be reasonable value. This is an
- 18:24area that can be a little bit dicey because of
- 18:27attorney -client communication. Is the date the
- 18:31attorney actually was retained in comparison
- 18:37to when that plaintiff went to that lien provider
- 18:41doctor? Is that relevant? Maybe. As a judge,
- 18:47I think my perspective is the actual date an
- 18:51attorney was retained. is not an attorney -client
- 18:54communication. It's probably just a fact, as
- 18:59opposed to a communicative act. But I've had
- 19:02that discussion with lawyers and cases before.
- 19:07These are areas for you to be sensitive to and
- 19:09to prepare for. They may come up in your motions
- 19:15in limine. Sometimes they come up right during
- 19:18trial, so you want to be ready for them. Okay,
- 19:21Suzanne, we can go to the next slide. Past and
- 19:26future lost earnings. This sometimes is a big
- 19:33issue in personal injury cases. Sometimes it's
- 19:38not. Your Casey instruction 3903C deals with
- 19:45lost earnings. as opposed to lost earning capacity.
- 19:51We'll get to that in just a minute. But the focus
- 19:56in 3903C is what is the plaintiff lost to date
- 20:03and what are they reasonably certain to lose
- 20:05in the future. We've now got our instruction
- 20:093906 that makes it clear if it wasn't already.
- 20:14that criteria such as race, gender, ethnicity
- 20:17cannot be used in any way, shape, or form as
- 20:23a basis for any reduction in someone's lost earnings.
- 20:30We can go to the next slide. Lost earning capacity.
- 20:36Slightly different. This is 3903D. So it's the
- 20:41difference in what your capacity was before and
- 20:45what it is after a traffic collision the plaintiff
- 20:51is a professional violin player serious injury
- 20:56to neck and arm You know a promising violinist
- 21:05not going to be able to have that vocation after
- 21:12the accident. So what's the difference? And maybe
- 21:16can be a teacher now, but can't be a professional
- 21:19musician. What's the difference between those
- 21:23two things? This is a decision for the fact finder,
- 21:30the jury or the judge. This Lewis versus Ukraine
- 21:36case makes it clear that you don't necessarily
- 21:41need expert testimony in this area. It may be
- 21:44that the plaintiff can testify. It may be that
- 21:51you've got some comparative evidence, proof of
- 21:57the plaintiff's prior earnings, pre -incident
- 22:01versus post -accident might be available as a
- 22:09comparison. Okay, we can go to the next slide.
- 22:17Then one of the other big areas, of course, is
- 22:20non -economic damages, and this is set forth
- 22:23in KC 3905A. As you all know who practice in
- 22:29this area, I remember saying it to juries, During
- 22:32for dire when the issue of damages came up in
- 22:38questioning of a jury and of course I would read
- 22:40this instruction. There is no fixed standard
- 22:43for dessert determining the amount of non economic
- 22:46damages. The jury is told that they must review
- 22:50the evidence and use their common sense. The
- 22:56bottom line is. the test, what is a plaintiff
- 23:01reasonably certain to suffer? In 3905A, there
- 23:05are various enumerations of examples, emotional
- 23:11distress, humiliation, pain, suffering, the loss
- 23:15of enjoyment of life. And you want to tailor
- 23:21that jury instruction to the specific facts of
- 23:24your case, remove the inapplicable examples.
- 23:31You run the risk of confusing the jury. You could
- 23:37alienate the jury if you included things that
- 23:41just clearly don't apply in your case. And keep
- 23:47your focus on those things that are specifically
- 23:51created by the particular facts of your case.
- 23:59One interesting area that I saw and some of you
- 24:07may have seen is whether or not you would be
- 24:16allowed to include as an item of non -economic
- 24:23damage a diminishment or a loss in life expectancy.
- 24:32We have our instructions and, of course, the
- 24:37actuarial tables on life expectancy. And in many
- 24:41cases, those are specifically read to the jury.
- 24:49But this is a little bit different. Are you entitled
- 24:54to argue that you suffer a non -economic damage,
- 25:02a form of emotional distress basically, if you've
- 25:06now are aware that your life expectancy has been
- 25:12shortened? I don't know the answer to this. So
- 25:18far, this has not. something that has been included
- 25:22in the Casey instruction on non economic damages.
- 25:27That probably tells you a little bit about where
- 25:31the committee is in terms of its comfort level
- 25:35about including it. And so it may be something
- 25:39that you might. Depending again on the facts
- 25:43of your case, have an argument with your particular
- 25:45trial judge on. And so I raise it as maybe a
- 25:51potential developing area on non -economic damages.
- 25:58Okay, let's go to the next slide. Let's talk
- 26:03now about strategy. Let me emphasize, these are
- 26:12my opinions as a retired judge. having done a
- 26:17lot of personal injury cases. I don't speak for
- 26:21the court, for EDR, any other entity. But these
- 26:29are my views based on what I saw, what I saw
- 26:35juries doing. Many of you may disagree with some
- 26:43of these thoughts. and you may be receiving some
- 26:50training that might challenge some of these perspectives.
- 26:56It's all fair. Take all of it. Find out what
- 27:00works for you based on your personal experience,
- 27:05your personality, your comfort level, and then,
- 27:09of course, do what you're comfortable with. I
- 27:15think two of the most important things you can
- 27:17do as an attorney in a personal injury case,
- 27:21whether you're the defense or the plaintiff,
- 27:25try to establish that trust. Whether it's your
- 27:30fact finder is the jury or the judge or both,
- 27:37there's just no replacement for that. Juries
- 27:47are sophisticated, this is my view, and they're
- 27:52also very cynical. And they take everything with
- 28:01a pretty healthy grain of salt. And if you're
- 28:08way, way, way over the top, and really, really
- 28:14kind of out there from the beginning, they are
- 28:19gonna dial it back and not place a lot of trust
- 28:24in you. And so you wanna build your ask, I guess,
- 28:34with building blocks, slowly. You don't want
- 28:42to over promise things especially at the beginning
- 28:45You don't want to improperly inflate your case
- 28:49too much with flowery language Huge numbers Outrageous
- 29:00claims They will start to tune you out and When
- 29:10you lose them, it's really hard to get them back.
- 29:15So I think if I would have any kind of advice
- 29:19to someone going into practicing in the personal
- 29:23injury area, that would probably be my strongest
- 29:29admonishment. During the vordier process, which
- 29:36as we know is your first time to have contact
- 29:39with the jury. There are some challenges in dealing
- 29:43with damages. Probably one of the biggest ones
- 29:48is whether or not you as a plaintiff's lawyer
- 29:55are going to try to introduce specific dollar
- 30:01amounts to the jury. about what you think the
- 30:07evidence is gonna show and how your client suffered
- 30:12X thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands,
- 30:17millions of dollars in damage. My approach in
- 30:24this area as a judge was I would not allow attorneys
- 30:33to mention specific dollar figures, especially
- 30:41dealing with non -economic damage. But they would
- 30:47be permitted to indicate to the jury that they
- 30:54expected the evidence to show that their client
- 30:58incurred Substantial, significant, extreme, pick
- 31:09your descriptor, amounts of damage. I thought
- 31:17that was fair in order for attorneys to figure
- 31:26out whether or not that particular juror or that
- 31:32veneer group of jurors, are going to be open
- 31:36-minded about damages. I also encouraged attorneys
- 31:43when I would start a personal injury trial to
- 31:49be very thoughtful about how they raised the
- 31:52issue of damages during voir dire. I would sometimes
- 32:00give a little bit of a spiel before the attorney
- 32:03started questioning jurors and explained to the
- 32:07jury that if you're selected to be on this jury,
- 32:13you're going to be asked to do two basic things.
- 32:17You're going to be asked to determine liability.
- 32:21Was there negligence in this case? Is the defendant
- 32:25responsible for the claimed injuries? Then if
- 32:30there's liability, you're going to be asked to
- 32:32determine what amount of damages, if any, is
- 32:36appropriate. Then I talk a little bit about damages
- 32:40and say within damages, they're typically going
- 32:43to be both economic damages, which are sometimes
- 32:46a little easier to determine like medical bills.
- 32:50Then there may be lost earnings, then there may
- 32:53be non -economic damages. Then I would talk about
- 32:56the - the general standard on non -economic.
- 33:00And I would try to describe this kind of universe
- 33:03to the jury and then say something to them like,
- 33:07does everybody generally understand those concepts
- 33:11that I've just described for you? And usually
- 33:14everybody, you know, kind of nods their head.
- 33:16And then you've introduced the concept and then
- 33:20the lawyers can go and voir dire and kind of
- 33:23build on that. In comparison, I've seen problems
- 33:30develop where a lawyer, it could be either a
- 33:36plaintiff's attorney or a defense attorney, would
- 33:40get up and they would say, so how does everybody
- 33:45feel about pain and suffering? Frequently, jurors
- 33:54They're not quite sure what you're asking them,
- 33:56but then somebody on the jury says, oh, well,
- 33:59I don't believe in that. And then you get in
- 34:04this weird kind of dialogue with the jury about
- 34:08trying to explain that whether or not they award
- 34:12pain and suffering damages, which is a subset
- 34:15of non -economic damages we know, is going to
- 34:19depend on the evidence in the case. you've got
- 34:24some constraints on talking about specific items
- 34:26of evidence in the case, and then you've got
- 34:29yourself talking to this juror about why it would
- 34:32be important to be open -minded, you've backed
- 34:36yourself a little bit into a corner. Vordier
- 34:40is really critical, I think, on how you introduce
- 34:44these concepts, how far you go. I think that
- 34:51There's a bit of a red flag. If you try to ask
- 34:55for specific dollar figures or mention them in
- 34:58voir dire because your judge is going to be sensitive
- 35:02to that, you may elicit an objection. It may
- 35:05be something that gets dealt with in a motion
- 35:08in lemonade because the defense side is going
- 35:12to want to have you avoid what we call anchoring.
- 35:22Be sensitive in this area, really give it some
- 35:25thought. Get your jury generally willing to stay
- 35:32open -minded about the evidence in your case,
- 35:36but do question enough so that you can weed out
- 35:41those people who are going to be resistant to
- 35:44listening to the evidence, I guess. That's from
- 35:47the plaintiff perspective and from the defense
- 35:50perspective. Of course, you want to examine in
- 35:55that area as well with your goals in mind. Then
- 36:00of course, after you've done that work and you've
- 36:02got your jury, you get into your opening statement.
- 36:06How do you handle damages here? Again, the extent
- 36:12to which you are going to be able to identify
- 36:17and say that you think that the evidence is going
- 36:21to show that your client experienced X amount
- 36:26in medical bills is going to depend a little
- 36:30bit on the comfort level of your judge. If you
- 36:35have questions, I always advocate for people
- 36:42asking ahead of time and trying to work these
- 36:44things out so that you don't have last -minute
- 36:46surprises or objections. Again, with non -economic
- 36:51damages, I think you're going to want to stay
- 36:55more broad -brush. If you've got a case where
- 37:02causation is a really big issue, for example,
- 37:06you've got a client who has a significant pre
- 37:09-existing condition, And there are so many cases
- 37:12like this. Again, my viewpoint, try to deal with
- 37:20it upfront. Don't try to hope that it won't develop
- 37:25and you won't have to deal with it that much.
- 37:29You're going to have to probably, at some point,
- 37:34confront the concept of pre -existing condition
- 37:38Your medical experts are going to have to deal
- 37:41with it. Your other experts may have to deal
- 37:44with it. Look at KC 3927 and 3928. Those are
- 37:54the instructions on 3927 is pre -existing condition,
- 38:01aggravation of pre -existing condition. 3928
- 38:03is the so -called eggshell plaintiff. instruction,
- 38:09those may come into play in your case. And so
- 38:15you're going to, if you're the plaintiff and
- 38:21there is a preexisting condition, you're very
- 38:25likely going to be able to get that 3927 instruction,
- 38:30possibly 3928. Sometimes the defense wants 3928.
- 38:40and think through how, for example, a pre -existing
- 38:50back injury is going to impact a rear end accident
- 38:57and a back injury on the new case that you're
- 39:03handling. you're going to have to have to have
- 39:05your doctors be willing to deal with this. So
- 39:10getting it out front, you don't have to make
- 39:15a huge big deal out of it out front, but being
- 39:19able to acknowledge it, I think it just helps
- 39:23you once again build that trust with the jury
- 39:27so they don't think you're trying to avoid something.
- 39:31Something that I have felt is really important
- 39:34is this concept of keeping an eye on the jury.
- 39:38I know you're doing a million different things,
- 39:40but some of the best personal injury lawyers
- 39:45I've seen, I mean, they don't make it super obvious,
- 39:49but they're always watching the jury because
- 39:52you'll get reactions from your jury and you'll
- 39:56know if something's landing with a thud or they're
- 40:00really or they're really into it with you and
- 40:04if you've just got too much going on get somebody
- 40:08else on your team even if they're sitting in
- 40:10the audience watching that jury see how they're
- 40:14reacting to what you're saying which jurors reacting
- 40:18to what and it's going to help you understand
- 40:22whether your message is resonating or whether
- 40:26you're not you know being received well I think
- 40:30it's really, really critical. One other thing
- 40:35in this area where you're talking about voir
- 40:37dire opening, be thoughtful and careful about
- 40:42your word choices. The way that you present your
- 40:48case is a huge part of the chances of success.
- 41:01And this, of course, plays into how critical
- 41:04preparation can be. OK, we can go to the next
- 41:08slide, Suzanne. Here's another, I think, important
- 41:13concept. As the lawyer, don't get in the way
- 41:16of your evidence. Let it come from the witness.
- 41:21This is especially important as the plaintiff's
- 41:23lawyer, but it's also very important as the defense
- 41:25lawyer if you're cross -examining. or you're
- 41:29questioning your own witnesses. Here is where
- 41:36preparation, witness prep planning is so incredibly
- 41:40important. Avoid long convoluted questions where
- 41:50all the witness has to do a leading question.
- 41:55where all the witness has to do is say, yes,
- 41:57that's right. Not only will you probably elicit
- 42:02an objection or if it was somebody like me, if
- 42:06it's really bad, I might actually interrupt and
- 42:08say, please stop doing that. You don't really
- 42:12learn anything from your witness that way. The
- 42:15jury doesn't learn anything. So you want to prep
- 42:20your witness. Tell that witness where you're
- 42:23going. Tell them what you're trying to accomplish.
- 42:28Don't have your witness be over the top, exaggerated,
- 42:37flowery. I always feel like low -key is always
- 42:43better, but have them be descriptive. They may
- 42:50be shy, they may be nervous, certainly. You may
- 42:55be able to lead the witness a little bit if as
- 42:59they get into things, they're having difficulty
- 43:02maybe articulating what they're trying to say.
- 43:05That's okay. In fact, I think that's very human
- 43:08and that's actually, you can kind of endear the
- 43:13witness to the jury a little bit. Set up a question
- 43:19and let the witness answer in their own words.
- 43:23I think you'll get better evidence that way.
- 43:27Tailor the questioning to the case. By this,
- 43:31I guess I mean you want to build your particular
- 43:36story. I think of a case that I had with a really
- 43:42good plaintiff's attorney who had a young plaintiff
- 43:48who had suffered some severe injuries. The attorney
- 44:01broke the description basically down into pieces.
- 44:09Although the medical treatment had pretty much
- 44:13been over, was really very compelling that this
- 44:18individual had gone through so many different
- 44:21treatments, surgeries, time in the hospital,
- 44:29rehab. Rather than lump it all together, he broke
- 44:36it down and the witness talked about every stage
- 44:40of it, not repeating, what she was saying, but
- 44:46going over it and it really kind of built to
- 44:53sort of a crescendo. If you have a case like
- 44:57that, work on breaking it down a little bit,
- 45:00focusing your questions. Again, this is an area
- 45:05where your witness prep is just gonna be so important.
- 45:10Or if you're on the defense side and you're doing
- 45:13cross -examination of the plaintiff, prep those
- 45:16cross -examination questions to get the exact
- 45:19answer, of course, that you want to get, that
- 45:24you think the evidence is going to give you.
- 45:28Let's go to the next slide. Closing argument.
- 45:35I think that it is very important Again for juror
- 45:41trust enhancing your outcome Don't skip an issue
- 45:46go over every issue that's important now You
- 45:53know your jury can only retain so much information
- 45:59you want to be You know judicious about how you
- 46:02do it, but for every important point hit that
- 46:06point be able to explain why it should be the
- 46:10way that you're arguing, why that item of damage
- 46:13should be awarded. If there is, for example,
- 46:21a big pre -existing condition issue and you're
- 46:26worried about it as a plaintiff's attorney, don't
- 46:29skip the issue. Deal with it, even if maybe If
- 46:35there's a particular issue, even if you feel
- 46:37like it's a red herring, you can say something
- 46:43like that. This is a diversion, this is a red
- 46:45herring, and I really don't think that it's something
- 46:49you need to be concerned with, and here's why.
- 46:53If you've got some kind of a losing issue, consider
- 46:58just conceding on it. Don't try to make, don't
- 47:03twist yourself into nods. Try to explain something
- 47:06that is just not gonna come out right because
- 47:10you'll lose credibility with your jury if you
- 47:14try to do that. Have a backup plan. Okay, you
- 47:20know what, I'm gonna concede that issue. It turned
- 47:24out that my client, you know, didn't say that
- 47:30he hit his head when he was in the emergency
- 47:32room, you're right. It doesn't show up in the
- 47:36medical records. However, I don't think that
- 47:38that's an issue and it shouldn't be something
- 47:41you should concern yourself with because when
- 47:44he went and he saw the neurologist a week later,
- 47:47this is what was developed, something like that.
- 47:51Be agile, be willing to deal with it. and rather
- 47:57than try and kind of take an extreme or an outrageous
- 48:01position, I really, really feel that being disrespectful
- 48:09to the other side, to the attorney, to the witness,
- 48:14to the party, juries hate it, judges certainly
- 48:19hate it, really avoid it. There are civil, respectful,
- 48:26appropriate ways to respond to somebody's argument,
- 48:34to put somebody in their place, so to speak.
- 48:37Find those ways. Don't take a cheap shot. Makes
- 48:45you feel good for about two seconds, but it usually
- 48:49backfires. Don't be overly extreme in your demeanor,
- 49:01in your presentation. I had a lawyer one time
- 49:07in closing, get in front of the jury, right in
- 49:12front of the box. I didn't know he was going
- 49:14to do it. And he fell over. And he was trying
- 49:18to give as an example what happened to his client.
- 49:22Well, it was just completely ineffective and
- 49:28it was a little embarrassing for him. It wound
- 49:32up a lot of the jurors laughed. They were very
- 49:35turned off. Be very careful when you do things
- 49:40like that. Game out how it's going to look before
- 49:46you decide to do something dramatic in the courtroom.
- 49:51It's always great to give your jury alternatives.
- 49:55If you're the plaintiff's attorney, you're asking
- 49:57for a certain amount of damages, consider giving
- 50:02them a range. Consider giving them different
- 50:06ways to calculate, for example, non -economic
- 50:09damages rather than just giving them a number.
- 50:15Letting them be involved in the process is empowering.
- 50:20to the jury, it shows respect for the jury. And
- 50:25it becomes a little bit more of a team effort,
- 50:31if you will, between the lawyer and the jury.
- 50:34And so I think that it's very, very helpful if
- 50:38you do something like that. You can tell, my
- 50:42last point, this is sort of my perspective. Less
- 50:46is frequently more. And I think sometimes you
- 50:54get more out of your jury when you downplay certain
- 50:58things. And then emphasize the really important
- 51:02stuff. Save your energy and your fire for those
- 51:08really important things. OK, Suzanne, we can
- 51:11go to the next slide. Just a little time before
- 51:15questions to talk about. The difference in mediation
- 51:18and arbitration. You've obviously got a different
- 51:24audience. You're not going to be dealing with
- 51:26a jury. You're going to be dealing with a neutral
- 51:29who's got some experience in your area, hopefully.
- 51:33You're going to have people on the other side
- 51:34who are very experienced, hopefully. You can
- 51:38be a lot more kind of cut to the chase, a little
- 51:44more realistic. If you're trying to settle a
- 51:48case in mediation and you're either arguing for
- 51:54a high number on settlement as the plaintiff
- 51:57or a lower number as defense, have facts at hand.
- 52:07If it's one thing that I've learned doing this
- 52:09now for about a year is mediation is very interesting.
- 52:12It's really dynamic. And it can be hard sometimes
- 52:17to figure out what might impact the other side
- 52:21in a particular back and forth. And so there
- 52:24may be times during a mediation where you want
- 52:28to throw out an important piece of information
- 52:30that maybe you haven't felt like the mediator
- 52:33of the other side has had time to focus on yet.
- 52:37You got to know that stuff. You've got to have
- 52:40that in your brain. So you need to know about
- 52:42your case, you've got to have these facts available,
- 52:46and you need to be able to be willing to provide
- 52:48it to the other side. Give your mediator tools,
- 52:54ammunition, ideas. Judge, this may be something
- 52:59that it might be a good idea to raise at this
- 53:01stage of things. Make sure they know that this
- 53:06person has a really significant social media
- 53:10presence and we've looked at that stuff and it
- 53:15could affect how your party comes across. Think
- 53:20about these things. Think about how to use them
- 53:23during your mediation. In your arbitration, you're
- 53:26going to have one arbitrator or three arbitrators.
- 53:30You're not going to be able to go nuclear really
- 53:32in an arbitration. If you're trying to, you're
- 53:36going to have to be able to explain it. Again,
- 53:42you've got to give that detail and methodically
- 53:49lay that out for your arbitrator. Again, I think
- 53:55that this is another area where Being more low
- 54:01key, less out in the stratosphere is more likely
- 54:06to establish that trust, which goes a long way
- 54:11toward accomplishing what your goals are. So
- 54:18that is my two cents on, we can go to the next
- 54:24slide, on damages. I wanted to just highlight
- 54:30a few resources that I think are very, very helpful.
- 54:35Of course, I've already mentioned the Casey instructions.
- 54:39A couple of the Rudder Guide books are really,
- 54:42really good on personal injury and personal injury
- 54:45damages. The PI Rudder Guide, the Civil Trials
- 54:50and Evidence. Another book that I love, I don't
- 54:55really use it in mediation so much, but I used
- 54:57it a lot on the bench. Is this Simon's Evidence
- 55:01Manual? I think there's a 2024 edition, might
- 55:05even be 25 out now. This is a really good evidence
- 55:10book, and it's also got good case discussions,
- 55:14so you might want to look at that as well. Next
- 55:19slide. Thank you everybody so much. I hope you
- 55:24have found this helpful. Please call me. If you
- 55:29want to run an issue by me, if you have an arbitration
- 55:33with me, please don't call me. That would be
- 55:35an expert communication. But if you want to talk
- 55:39about something, I'm happy to try to help in
- 55:42any way that I can. I think we've got a couple
- 55:45of questions. I'm going to go down here, Suzanne.
- 55:50and look at this. Let's see. Here's a question.
- 55:58If you did not allow specific numbers by a plaintiff
- 56:03rate damages, did you allow the defense to say
- 56:07zero or nothing? That's a great question. I think
- 56:15if The plaintiff is going to say something like,
- 56:22I think there's going to be a substantial, you're
- 56:25going to see the evidence is going to show that
- 56:27there's going to be a, you're going to be compelled
- 56:31to give a substantial award in this case. And
- 56:36I think it's going to be okay to allow the defense
- 56:40to say, I think after all the evidence comes
- 56:45in, you're going to conclude, that the award
- 56:50is gonna be nothing because there's no liability
- 56:54here. So I guess the answer is yes, I think it
- 56:59might be possible to allow the defense to do
- 57:03that. I've been asked, who are some of your favorite
- 57:08plaintiff attorneys in trial? I'm gonna take
- 57:11the fifth on that one. I will say this, if you're
- 57:15getting ready to go to trial, and you haven't
- 57:18maybe had a trial in a while or a lot of trial
- 57:21experience, try to find out what's going on.
- 57:23If you've got the time, try to make the time,
- 57:26especially if it's in front of the judge you're
- 57:29going to have. Go down, observe, see what's going
- 57:33on. We've got a couple more here. What techniques
- 57:37have you seen be successful for framing? lean
- 57:43slash attorney coordinated treatment to the jury
- 57:49for plaintiff. So let's say that somebody has
- 58:04decided to go to an attorney excuse me, to a
- 58:12doctor and the treatment is on a lien and let's
- 58:22say that it possibly comes into evidence that
- 58:25that plaintiff had Medicare or was a Kaiser patient
- 58:34or something like that and they didn't go to
- 58:36a Kaiser doctor. I've seen plaintiffs' attorneys
- 58:41ask, why did you go to ex -doctor? Well, I felt,
- 58:52it has to be genuine, but I felt that that person
- 58:56had a lot of experience with the particular kind
- 59:00of fracture that I had suffered. And I thought
- 59:04that it would be wise for me to get that care.
- 59:09I wanted the best care that I could get. Why
- 59:13did you go to the doctor that your lawyer referred
- 59:18you to if that came out? I've seen people say,
- 59:24I didn't know what to do. I needed help. I needed
- 59:29help by consulting a lawyer and they helped me
- 59:32through the process, things like that. You know,
- 59:35those are kind of genuine answers. And then the
- 59:39jury decides what they're going to do with the
- 59:42lean treatment issue. Let's see. Is there a formula
- 59:49for pain and suffering that's most credible in
- 59:52your view or more credible than not? Per diem?
- 59:57Per hour? How is it postured? I think this is
- 1:00:00a great question. You know, This is where alternatives
- 1:00:05help a lot, giving people alternatives. Maybe
- 1:00:10you want to look at it on a per diem, for example,
- 1:00:13X. Maybe you're an hourly employee and it's a
- 1:00:20value to you to look at it this way. I'm going
- 1:00:25to suggest to you that you should consider for
- 1:00:29the difficulty that my client has experienced.
- 1:00:33an award of X. Just giving them, this is my own
- 1:00:39opinion, just giving a jury like a per diem or
- 1:00:43an hourly rate is kind of artificial. And if
- 1:00:49that's the only thing that you do, I don't know.
- 1:00:53I don't know how helpful that is for juries.
- 1:00:57I like it when I thought it was successful rather
- 1:01:02when attorneys gave the jury alternatives. Let's
- 1:01:07see. I think we might have one last question
- 1:01:09and then that's it. I'm pre -reading this. Wow.
- 1:01:20In a pregnancy discrimination case where the
- 1:01:23plaintiff was trying to get pregnant, and that
- 1:01:25ability to get pregnant is arguably diminished
- 1:01:28by the stress of the discriminatory conduct.
- 1:01:31Is it too speculative to ask for non -economic
- 1:01:34damages related to diminished fertility? Wow.
- 1:01:40Here's a good judge answer. I think the answer
- 1:01:43is it depends. Because if you're probably going
- 1:01:47to have an expert, it's probably going to be
- 1:01:49a gynecologist, maybe a fertility expert. and
- 1:01:54that person can testify that stress is a huge
- 1:02:00factor or a factor, an important, a significant
- 1:02:07factor in someone's ability to get pregnant.
- 1:02:19then you've got the support for making that kind
- 1:02:24of an argument. You may need to tie it into some
- 1:02:27expert testimony, however. And that's where if
- 1:02:33you can't do that, then your judge might be a
- 1:02:36little bit concerned about that being too speculative.
- 1:02:40The alternative to that? You just talk broadly
- 1:02:44about the kind of stress that the client was
- 1:02:46under and how life changed, things got difficult.
- 1:02:51Maybe that's a way to do it. You guys, I think
- 1:02:56that's all the questions. Thank you so very much
- 1:03:01and I wish everybody the very best of luck. I
- 1:03:04miss Jerry trials, but mediations are fun too.
- 1:03:08Call if you want to talk. Thanks. Bye. You may
- 1:03:12be eligible for CLE credit in your state. Visit
- 1:03:15bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.