Latest / The imuRgency Room / The Rise Of 'The West Village Girl' Has Made NYC Basic
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to the Big Fat Apple, where MRTS are the
- 0:02dirtiest, but our ingredients are the cleanest.
- 0:04I'll be your server roomie. What can I get started for you?
- 0:06Hi. I think I'll do the, let me
- 0:07guess, like Hugo Spritz. Oh, and you're probably going to
- 0:09want our super snatch Caesar, too, with the dressing on the
- 0:12side. Did I get that right?
- 0:13Actually, no. I was going to get your
- 0:15signature chicken apple club with the water.
- 0:18Why would you assume that? I Oh, yeah, no, sorry.
- 0:20It's just like 90% of the people that come to this West Village
- 0:23location all order the same exact thing and wear the same
- 0:25thing. So I just figured you'd be like
- 0:26that. Yeah, no, we're not doing that.
- 0:29Hey guys, it's up to emergency and welcome, welcome back to my
- 0:31channel. Today.
- 0:31The intros are making a strong comeback, so shout out to that.
- 0:35But today we're going to be talking about something that I
- 0:36have recently seen be a topic of conversation online, which does
- 0:40brought not to a larger conversation, which I think is
- 0:42interesting around the concept of digital gentrification.
- 0:45Of this whole phenomenon that we've been seeing of different
- 0:47cities and neighborhoods being picked up by social media
- 0:50romanticize on Lambo at every different aesthetic appeals to
- 0:53that location and having people move there in mass, essentially
- 0:56changing the culture that had already existed in those areas.
- 0:59For the sake of this video, we're mostly talking about this
- 1:01happening with New York, but it's happened in the past with
- 1:03cities like LA, Boston had a moment or is having a moment and
- 1:07more. Now this video is mostly
- 1:08inspired by the recent New York Mag article that came out titled
- 1:11It must be nice to be a West Village girl.
- 1:13And of course, with a title like that, the article did spark up a
- 1:15bunch of discourse and conversation.
- 1:18And in the discourse around the article, there were a lot of
- 1:20valid points made, like having the article be a fun read and
- 1:23sort of capturing the complaints that a lot of native New Yorkers
- 1:25have around the state of New York, specifically around the
- 1:28West Village, with a lot of transplants moving into the city
- 1:31and adopting a similar sort of aesthetic persona, changing the
- 1:34entire culture of the area. And there are also comments in
- 1:36the discourse talking about how there could have been more of a
- 1:38poignant point being made in the article, which is valid.
- 1:41But on the topic of gentrification, this is not a
- 1:43new topic. Like even according to the
- 1:45native New York as themselves, OK, the West Village in New York
- 1:48has been gentrified even before the white tank top, cowboy boot
- 1:52wearing, Pilates loving 20 somethings that are inhabiting
- 1:56the area right now. But what I think is really
- 1:58interesting about the article and the concept of what's going
- 2:00on right now is the intersection that we've been seeing of social
- 2:03media, our digital space, and how it influences our physical
- 2:06spaces. For taking this video and for
- 2:08the sake of this conversation, neighborhoods and the concept of
- 2:11social media influencing a whole culture shift of an entire
- 2:14neighborhood is actually wild. And I'm actually really excited
- 2:17to talk about it. Let's start by framing exactly
- 2:19what we're talking about here. If you didn't know and aren't
- 2:21from New York, and I'm not, but I've heard of it over the past
- 2:24couple years, there's been a big culture shift in multiple areas
- 2:27in New York as New York has become the destination spot for
- 2:30a lot of young people to move to.
- 2:31Like I don't know if you remember, but there was like a
- 2:33huge push for like NYC content like post lockdown.
- 2:37And I don't think it's necessarily slowed up since like
- 2:39it seemed like everyone and their mom was moving to New York
- 2:42for like 2021 onwards. With the influx of day in my
- 2:44life and NYC content flourishing on TikTok, YouTube and the likes
- 2:48with young 20 somethings either just graduating college, high
- 2:50school, or starting a new job. We're just looking for a new
- 2:53place to move, flocking to New York City and jumping on the
- 2:56hype and buzz around the city. Now this isn't to say that New
- 2:58York has not always been the city.
- 3:00Like it is arguably the most recognizable, if not the second
- 3:03most recognizable city in the United States.
- 3:06Like those are the 2 main cities when you think of like America
- 3:09on a macro scale. But it is to say that this
- 3:11shifted interest was different than previously before because
- 3:15it's almost entirely driven by social media and people's
- 3:18assumptions around what the city is like based on what they've
- 3:21seen other people enjoy. In a quote from the Cut article,
- 3:23If the city washed out the last of the neighborhood's bohemians
- 3:262 decades ago and turned the West Village into a celebrity
- 3:29playground where real adults with real income live, the
- 3:31pandemic turned it into something else entirely.
- 3:33A bustling sorority house essentially getting out.
- 3:36How most people that move to New York and choose to live in West
- 3:38Village all kind of look the same and act the same under
- 3:41interested in the same things. My one critique of this article
- 3:43is that it really does harp on just the women and make it seem
- 3:47like it's just the girls that do this sort of thing, when in
- 3:49reality it's both the girlies and the guys.
- 3:50Like while the West Village girl is very much into things like
- 3:54Pilates, Cartier bracelets, Blank St.
- 3:56Hugo, Spritz's Reformation, Taylor Swift, etcetera,
- 3:59etcetera. I thought the male equivalent is
- 4:00like the Friday finance or tech bro.
- 4:02Like more than likely is interested in day trading, can't
- 4:05dress for his life, artsy for the aesthetic, emotionally
- 4:07manipulative by trade, and so on and so on.
- 4:09But the paint more of a fuller picture.
- 4:11The article goes on to describe the West Village girl saying
- 4:13that they moved through the neighborhood in packs wearing
- 4:16the local uniform, a white tank, light washed jeans and sambas
- 4:19and ice matcha latte in hand and hair slip back into a tight
- 4:22ponytail. Very much the clean girl
- 4:24aesthetic that we've seen popular on tech talk on this
- 4:26channel. We're a big proponent for
- 4:27letting the girlies have fun. OK, but this goes to bring up
- 4:30the question like which girlies are having fun?
- 4:33When you look up images of like the West Village girl or just
- 4:35look at the images in the article, most not all the women
- 4:37depicted are white, thin blonde women wearing similar outfits,
- 4:40all dating the same variation of the same man.
- 4:42And that's coming straight from the Girly's from West Village
- 4:44themselves in the article saying they typically go for the
- 4:47Freddie finance type guys, essentially showing like 1
- 4:50brand, one type 1 flavor of New York girl.
- 4:53And I think when you see things like this and you see the
- 4:55content that all these people are trying to emulate, it's
- 4:59clear to see that like influencers have definitely done
- 5:01their job. Like, yes, the job of an
- 5:04influencer is to, you know, influence people.
- 5:07But seeing how that whole archetype and aesthetic has like
- 5:09dominated a whole neighborhood to fit into this very specific
- 5:12aesthetic is very interesting to say the least.
- 5:15And this goes into the whole conversation as to the role of
- 5:18social media as being a driver for gentrification or at least
- 5:21cultural change in an area. Now like I've been saying, I
- 5:24don't, I live in New York and I have never lived in New York.
- 5:26But from what I understand, there are more eminently
- 5:28gentrified areas in New York that are and have been
- 5:31displacing low income people, especially low income black and
- 5:34brown people. But when it comes to the
- 5:36gentrification of the West Village, we can't attribute that
- 5:38solely, if not at all really to 20 something tik tokers that
- 5:42we've been talking about. This has been going on for a
- 5:44while and truly started long before the 80s and 90s.
- 5:47It's time for a little history lesson my friends.
- 5:49If you didn't happen to know the lore of the West Village because
- 5:52I don't know why the average person who doesn't live in New
- 5:54York would. Up until around the 1890's.
- 5:57The West Village used to be pretty black up until around the
- 6:001890s, with the area actually starting the first professional
- 6:02black theater in the country called the African Grove.
- 6:06But that only lasted until around the turn of the century
- 6:08where black and brown people's houses were replaced with
- 6:10tenement buildings to make room for the newly arriving Italian
- 6:13immigrants. This is around the same time
- 6:14where the first Bohemians started really taking root in
- 6:16that area, with Walt Whitman being one of them.
- 6:18And it wasn't until after this and after that time, the
- 6:22neighborhood was home to Irish, Italian and Puerto Rican
- 6:24immigrants, dockworkers, schmex workers, artists, writers, gay,
- 6:28lesbian and transgender people. And around this time, the West
- 6:31Village is really seen as a place for artists, writers,
- 6:33creatives, basically anyone looking for somewhere to live
- 6:36cheaply. But that quickly changed as more
- 6:38wealthy people started moving into the area and changing up
- 6:40how that area looks and went about culture.
- 6:42And I think that this goes to show that despite the culture
- 6:45changing yet again nowadays, this has been something that has
- 6:48been years, decades in the making.
- 6:49People often talk about the loss of like bohemian culture in the
- 6:52West Village, and a lot of that is because many times
- 6:54gentrification will commodify culture and make it more
- 6:57palatable to potential higher income residents through things
- 7:00like public art and art washing. And as mentioned in the New York
- 7:02Mag article, after the bohemian and artsy culture came the holes
- 7:06in the city type of crowd, making the West Village into a
- 7:08celebrity playground for people working in fashion, publicist,
- 7:12marketing, etcetera, etcetera. And none of this is to say that
- 7:14like places need to remain the same forever and that places
- 7:17like the West Village can't change.
- 7:19Just like how in LA the culture in silver like has been
- 7:21gentrified for a long time. Like yes it's heartbreaking for
- 7:23a long time residents and yes there are real repercussions and
- 7:26it sucks when it happens and it doesn't really seem like
- 7:29anything is going to change. Like the residents of those
- 7:31communities specifically with the West Village will be fine.
- 7:34Like for the West Village specifically, yes these women
- 7:36are aiding and gentrification. But unfortunately this is not
- 7:40new. The area's already been
- 7:41gentrified in the West Village situation aside, I think it's
- 7:44less interesting that like a previously gentrified area is
- 7:47being re gentrified again. I think the more pressing point
- 7:50or interesting point is seeing how social media is directly
- 7:54playing a factor into how gentrification is happening in
- 7:57modern day, especially with how social media is driving this
- 8:00homogeneous or samey culture of like the white T-shirt and
- 8:03jeans, the Pilates, like this area collecting all these people
- 8:06with very similar interests that maybe did not have those
- 8:09interests before, but saw these interests be romanticized on
- 8:12social media and coming to this one place to embody that
- 8:15identity with others. And on a high level, you think
- 8:17like, oh, wow, that's a pretty interesting thing
- 8:19sociologically. But like the the outcome is just
- 8:21not, it's not giving because what we're getting out of this
- 8:24is like a single noted characterization that's creating
- 8:27an almost shallow culture with little to no diversity.
- 8:31Like, again, see the pictures in the article.
- 8:33Like, I think this is one of the first times we're seeing through
- 8:35TikTok of these places becoming memeable or like influencing
- 8:38people to move to a neighborhood or adopt an entirely different
- 8:41identity based on the neighborhood that they live in
- 8:43and what they've seen on social media.
- 8:44And I guess the question I present here is like, isn't this
- 8:47to its own form of tensification or at least a takeover of the
- 8:51previous culture? I saw a comment on a TikTok that
- 8:53actually was pretty interesting here where the poster says yes,
- 8:56the West Village has long been overpriced and gentrifying.
- 8:59But my gripe is that these people don't seem to have
- 9:01respect for the neighborhood or an interest in being part of the
- 9:03community or caring about the artistic path of the
- 9:05neighborhood. Like it's truly like the whole
- 9:07concept. Like taking an image of an
- 9:08image. Like what are you losing?
- 9:09Like what aspect of culture, authenticity, whatever would
- 9:12have you are you losing when you continuously gentrify or rebrand
- 9:16the culture? Like, at what point do you
- 9:17completely lose sight of what was originally there entirely?
- 9:21And I think that this is really interesting because in like
- 9:23traditional forms of gentrification or at least like
- 9:25population or like demographic terraforming, it usually things
- 9:28like companies or like corporations buying up a bunch
- 9:31of land, apartments, spaces, whatever would have you and like
- 9:34funneling a bunch of their employees or a bunch of people
- 9:36that they feel like would fit like their aesthetic into
- 9:39certain areas. Like think of like the tech
- 9:40towns like Amazon, Meta, Apple, whatever would have you out in
- 9:43like Silicon Valley or like the West Coast, like buyout or build
- 9:46these entire towns specifically for their employees and for
- 9:49their ecosystem. So like everyone's kind of the
- 9:51same. We're seeing that now, but like
- 9:53for free. Like instead of being paid to
- 9:55move and gentrify, these people are pegging to go and gentrify
- 9:59based on what they've seen on social media.
- 10:00Like we don't need to sell jobs to people anymore.
- 10:02We just need to sell vibes and people move in mass.
- 10:05And as a byproduct of this, we're starting to see cultural
- 10:07monikers or like metropolitan city based in jokes, both in
- 10:11real life with like people that live in specific locations and
- 10:13getting specific attributes. Like one comment said, like what
- 10:16about Murray Hill boys? Like what does that mean?
- 10:19Like they're monikers that are really only relevant to people
- 10:21that live there and really build like that in Group community of
- 10:24people that live there. Like in LA, there's things like
- 10:26the Silver Lake mustache man or Venice cowboy.
- 10:29Like it's just really interesting to see how social
- 10:30media is truly influencing these neighborhoods.
- 10:33But I have to say, like, while this is different, this isn't
- 10:35necessarily the first time we've seen social media take hold of
- 10:39landscapes like of actual spaces, not necessarily in a
- 10:41gentrifying way, but more so like social media taking up
- 10:44physical spaces. Like maybe not to the same level
- 10:47of New York, but I remember back in like 2014 and 2016 LA had its
- 10:51like LA was like the place where a lot of people would like move
- 10:54for the aesthetic for the vibe before New York really took off.
- 10:57But like one example, tell me this is Tunish but like do y'all
- 11:02remember like the original hype house?
- 11:04Like not the hype house like tik tokers.
- 11:06I'm talking about like 1600 Vine, which essentially if you
- 11:10did not know was like the original like hype house for
- 11:14Viners. Like all of the biggest Viners
- 11:16all lived in this one apartment building up the intersection of
- 11:19Vine in Hollywood in LA. Like it was crazy.
- 11:22Like, let me set the scene. It's 2014.
- 11:24Yes, that 2014 Vine has been out for two years and has created a
- 11:29gaggle of popular creators on the app, people like Logan and
- 11:32Jake Paul, Amanda Cerny, Juan Pazarita, Lele Pons, Gabby Henna
- 11:36and King Batch. And all of these creators
- 11:38collectively moved to an apartment complex off Vine in
- 11:41Hollywood. But this is just something that
- 11:42was truly iconic at the time, just in terms of like Internet
- 11:45and pop culture. Because again, this is like one
- 11:47of the first times that you see a bunch of creators, like being
- 11:49a creator, or at least like a popular.
- 11:51Their creator was still relatively new at that time, but
- 11:53like there weren't a ton of big influencers and they have them
- 11:55all in one centralized area, all making contact with each other
- 11:58crazy. And even then, eventually more
- 12:00Viners and Youtubers moved into that same building, like
- 12:02transforming that space. It was so iconic that it even
- 12:04got a mention in the New York Times article back in 2017
- 12:07saying that 1600 Vine offers a peek into the booming ecosystem
- 12:10of these social media stars. As in any cauldron of attention
- 12:13seekers who live and work together in the same building.
- 12:16It's an atmosphere rife with clichedness, jealousy,
- 12:18insecurity, and the social hierarchy of high school.
- 12:20Except everyone knows precisely how popular or unpopular you
- 12:23are, and it's amplified by the fact that influencers could
- 12:25become millionaires with the following on par with any movie
- 12:28stars. Harsh.
- 12:31It seems like they didn't really love influencers too much in
- 12:332017. How far we've come and as you
- 12:37may or may not remember or imagine when you put a bunch of
- 12:40influencers known for making crazy content, crazy stunts,
- 12:44loud screaming videos. The apartment management
- 12:46building had to put in some new regulations as they were
- 12:49receiving complaints from other residents.
- 12:51So they instated some no filming in or by the pools and no large
- 12:55cameras in common areas regulations which then later
- 12:59evolved into no filming in common areas period.
- 13:02And because of limitations like this, people began moving out or
- 13:05getting evicted. I agree, pay study for this is
- 13:07Logan Paul and a quote. His escalating stunts in March
- 13:09alone included dangling a $20 bill from his balcony, including
- 13:13a fishing rod to tempt passers by, rigging a zip line over
- 13:17Hollywood Blvd. to send gifts to fans camped outside, and
- 13:20pretending to be shot as fans watched in war outside his
- 13:24window. I actually did not know that
- 13:25most of this stuff happened. He used to do a lot.
- 13:27And of course all of this led to him not getting his lease
- 13:30renewed. Apparently he recorded that
- 13:32conversation with him not getting his lease renewed in his
- 13:34vlog. He moved across the street and
- 13:36he was asked to leave there too. So whether you're a fan of them
- 13:38or not, it's undeniable that most of the influencers that
- 13:40were a part of this culture move to 1600.
- 13:42Vines still have huge platforms and their success is transferred
- 13:45over to other platforms. But like one question I've like
- 13:47always been wondering is like, did they all collectively decide
- 13:50to move to that one apartment? Or was it like they saw more and
- 13:52more people moving there so they decided they needed to move
- 13:54there too? Like I want to know how that all
- 13:56happened because the fact that a bunch of Viners took over an
- 14:00apartment building is crazy. And to clarify for this whole
- 14:03point, this isn't said like the OG Viners gentrified Hollywood,
- 14:06but it's undeniable that it shifted something culturally and
- 14:08dynamic wise in the neighborhood.
- 14:10Like again, think back to romanticize 2014 to 2016 LA.
- 14:14It was romanticized to a level that it is still currently to
- 14:17this day thought back on as like nostalgic content.
- 14:20Like we missed that era like the King Kylie era, the flower crown
- 14:22era, the Earth Cafe pink wall of it all.
- 14:25Like this truly is not new. The romanticization of like
- 14:28everyone wanting to move and live in this one area and embody
- 14:31this certain life style has not been new in the social media
- 14:35sense, but it's just so interesting to see how social
- 14:37media influences people's living moving habits and how it
- 14:40transforms areas now. Now we've been throwing around
- 14:43this word or what? And it's a cornerstone of like
- 14:45this article, but gentrification.
- 14:47I think it's important to contextualize what we're talking
- 14:49about when we're talking about gentrification.
- 14:50So here's the definition. According to the Urban
- 14:52Displacement Project, gentrification is defined as a
- 14:55process of neighborhood change that includes economic change
- 14:57and in a historically disinvested neighborhood by
- 15:00means of real estate investment and new hiring income residents
- 15:03moving in, as well as a demographic change, not only in
- 15:06terms of income level, but also in terms of changes in education
- 15:08level or racial makeup of residents.
- 15:10And while this doesn't 100% apply to the West Village
- 15:14because in most of our lifetimes and in recent history, it's been
- 15:16gentrified for a while as we've been talking about making it, in
- 15:19my opinion, less impactful gentrification than if it was
- 15:22disenfranchising or pushing out like current low income
- 15:25neighborhoods, which is happening across the country.
- 15:27It undoubtedly brings like a cultural shift to the city.
- 15:30And I think one thing that I want to talk about and honestly
- 15:32is like the more harmful part for cases like West Village,
- 15:36where like it's not necessarily people that are already
- 15:39disenfranchised becoming more so disenfranchised, but more so a
- 15:43age demographic shift. Is like oftentimes for things
- 15:47like this, where there is like a rise in gentrification or there
- 15:50is a population shift or like a city becomes super hot and
- 15:53trendy, is that people from outside the city or outside the
- 15:55neighborhood will flock to the city or neighborhood, want to
- 15:58change everything about the city or neighborhood to like fit
- 16:00their needs, their interests, disregard or closing down any
- 16:03previous businesses, shops and tractions or whatever that
- 16:07existed before the boom. And then eventually and
- 16:10inevitably in a couple of years, when the trend or the excitement
- 16:14or the hype around the city dies off and most people move out of
- 16:16that city, they leave the city or neighborhood of shell of
- 16:18itself, completely devoid of the culture that it had before.
- 16:21And I think that that is a huge issue.
- 16:22Like you can see it very visibly in cities like San Francisco.
- 16:25There's a movie called The Last Black Man in San Francisco, and
- 16:28there's a scene that really shows the difference between
- 16:29like a gentrifier mentality and a local mentality and the scene
- 16:32and essentially depicts like an older wave of gentrifiers.
- 16:35That being the hipsters of San Francisco being upset with the
- 16:37new wave of gentrifiers in San Francisco being like the tech
- 16:40Bros and startup people and the hipsters essentially abandoning
- 16:42the city, no loyalty to it or adding value to the culture.
- 16:45And I think that that really is the cornerstone to a lot of
- 16:48frustrations that locals have, or at least the transplants that
- 16:51have actually done the part to integrate into a city.
- 16:54Because for a lot of transplants or gentrifiers, whatever you
- 16:57want to call them, they view a new treading city as like this
- 16:59playground in place for their own personal character
- 17:02development for this area in their life and then take off and
- 17:04leave somewhere else. Somewhere safer to like settle
- 17:07down once the city no longer suits them.
- 17:08Which again, isn't necessarily a bad thing in and of itself.
- 17:11But when it's happening in mass and you see like this exodus of
- 17:13people after again quickly and drastically reshaping the
- 17:16culture demographics, an economy of a certain location just up
- 17:20and leaving does have impacts for people that do choose to
- 17:22stay there or have no option to leave who are there in the 1st
- 17:25place. Like, I imagine it's so
- 17:26frustrating to have a whole culture of an area stripped,
- 17:29stripped and extracted and then replaced just for those same
- 17:31people to go and abandon it. And I guess my last point for
- 17:34all this is to say like, yeah, no, moving to a new place, it
- 17:37doesn't make you inherently a bad person.
- 17:39Like if you're not a bad person or a crazy gentrifier, to move
- 17:42to New York, to move to LA, to move to whatever city you want
- 17:44and to live your life. And I do think there are more
- 17:47ethical ways to go about moving or gentrifying or taking up
- 17:51space as a new person in a new community for you.
- 17:53Things like integrating yourself more into the already existing
- 17:56culture and community of the neighborhood or city that you're
- 17:58living in, getting involved, give back to the communities
- 18:01that you're living in. And stop saying things like
- 18:03you've discovered a new hidden gem that you're obsessed with
- 18:05and it's so cheap and local. And then go on to list a place
- 18:08that has existed in that neighborhood for years and is a
- 18:10staple of the neighborhood and everyone knows about.
- 18:11Like, research neighborhoods you plan on moving in, get to know
- 18:14them. And more importantly, join
- 18:15existing places and programs and help support and build them.
- 18:19Because we said this in all the more sociocultural side of the
- 18:22times videos that we do on the channel.
- 18:24But like, getting involved in community really does help a
- 18:27lot. Lovely things that we have going
- 18:29on right now. But yeah, y'all, that's gonna be
- 18:31it for this video. I guess question to leave y'all
- 18:33off on is if this is a thing, if the whole Tik Tokification of
- 18:38physical places is a thing and continues to go on taking over
- 18:41places like the West Village, San Francisco, whatever would
- 18:44have you? What place do you think is next?
- 18:46In what shape do you think it's going to take?
- 18:48Let me know all your thoughts in the comments section below.
- 18:50Thank you so, so much for watching again.
- 18:51If you're new to the channel, then definitely don't forget to
- 18:53subscribe with the like and follow me on my social medias at
- 18:55emergency on Instagram, TikTok and Twitter.
- 18:58Other than that, y'all, I have an emergency and I will see you
- 19:00in the next video please.