Latest / The Vegan Report / Are Psychedelics the Cure to Speciesism? | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, this is Ryan and you are listening
- 0:03to The Vegan Report. I hope you are enjoying
- 0:07the Wednesday's Science of Activism episodes.
- 0:11Today I wanted to re -upload one of my favorite
- 0:14episodes of the show, a conversation I had with
- 0:18the researcher called Ellen Polanin who co -authored
- 0:22the only study exploring the link between the
- 0:25use of psychedelics and how we treat animals.
- 0:30I mean, what other vegan podcast is covering
- 0:33this? This is why I love doing this show. Anyway,
- 0:38you are in for a treat. Enjoy, share the episode
- 0:42with the vegans you know, and don't forget to
- 0:45subscribe and follow the show for more science
- 0:48of activism episodes. Thank you. Each time I
- 0:53would get high, I experienced more and more connectedness
- 0:57to life. I experienced empathy in deeper ways
- 1:01than I ever had, and this followed through even
- 1:04to when I was sober. It culminated in an arguably
- 1:08bad trip, where I experienced the life of a factory
- 1:11-caged creature who never saw sunlight or socialized
- 1:15for its whole life. That experience played a
- 1:18large part in going vegan for me, which happened
- 1:21the next week. I stopped eating meat while on
- 1:23a mushroom trip. I was eating chicken and it
- 1:26tasted like ash and death and I felt an omniscient
- 1:30presence that wanted me to stop and so I decided
- 1:33that moment to stop eating meat. That was 14
- 1:36years ago. I became vegan a few months later
- 1:39just as a logical next step. I was confronted
- 1:42with my guilt for eating animals during a psychedelic
- 1:45experience. I didn't immediately go vegan though.
- 1:49I continued to consume animal products until
- 1:52about five months later when I came across Earthling
- 1:55Ed on YouTube and I decided to go vegan overnight.
- 1:59While my decision did come a while after having
- 2:02that psychedelic experience, I do think it played
- 2:05a major role. I don't know when or if I would
- 2:09have gone vegan had I not had that experience.
- 2:11I watched the Unity documentary on LSD in 2020.
- 2:16The part where it says, when you look in an animal's
- 2:20eyes, you can see that they love their life.
- 2:23They love their life to the same degree that
- 2:25you love your own. I started crying with how
- 2:29beautiful it was. Ever since then, I was vegan.
- 2:34I found the hopeful message of Unity to be more
- 2:36personally inspiring than Earthlings had been.
- 2:44It helped me not only stay vegan for the rest
- 2:47of my life, but also to be even more active to
- 2:50help nature and animals. So yeah, the feeling
- 2:53of compassion is real. I mean, LSD was banned
- 2:56for a reason in the 60s and 70s. It got banned
- 2:59because people started taking LSD and stopped
- 3:02supporting the Vietnam War. Of course there were
- 3:05more reasons, but you know. So I'd say LSD and
- 3:09psychedelics will make you rethink your actions,
- 3:11as well as make you feel compassion. which then
- 3:13leads you to be more open to veganism or at least
- 3:16against any kind of violence. Welcome to The
- 3:19Vegan Report. My name is Ryan and today we are
- 3:23going to talk about psychedelics and connecting
- 3:26with nature. For years I have been hearing stories
- 3:29of people taking psychedelics and being transformed
- 3:33by the experience. overcoming depression or an
- 3:37addiction, overcoming PTSD, stimulating their
- 3:41creativity, and more to the point of this podcast,
- 3:45gaining a sense of connectiveness with nature,
- 3:47a higher level of empathy towards others, including
- 3:52animals, and even a willingness to become vegan.
- 3:56When I hear such stories, I cannot help but think
- 4:01maybe psychedelics are the powerful ally that
- 4:05the vegan movement needs. Maybe we should fight
- 4:08for them to become legal and more readily available
- 4:12as they might provoke the cultural reset we need
- 4:16to overcome speciesism. To discuss this topic,
- 4:20I have with me Ellen Polanan. She is the co -author.
- 4:24of one of the only studies out there examining
- 4:27the link between the use of psychedelics and
- 4:30how we treat animals. The study is titled Classic
- 4:35psychedelics and human -animal relations and
- 4:38you can find a link to the study in the description
- 4:40below. But Ellen is more than a researcher, many
- 4:44of you know her as Kelly, a talented musician
- 4:48and singer In the background of the real -life
- 4:51testimonies you heard in the introduction of
- 4:54the episode was playing Crane's, one of her songs.
- 4:58Again, visit the description below to access
- 5:01all of Kelly's music. Ellen, welcome to the show.
- 5:05Thank you so much for being here. Thank you so
- 5:07much for having me. So I actually don't know
- 5:10much about psychedelics. I never had a psychedelic
- 5:14experience. So my first question for you is what
- 5:17are psychedelics? I must just say before we start
- 5:22that if you would if you would have said to me
- 5:25like 10 years ago that I would be on a podcast
- 5:28talking about psychedelics, I would have laughed
- 5:30in your face because I am not an expert on psychedelics.
- 5:35I am an expert on what I call being annoying,
- 5:41which means that I tend to place myself in rooms
- 5:45and ask questions, shouldn't we look at this?
- 5:48And that is what happened also with my colleagues
- 5:51who are very knowledgeable in psychedelics and
- 5:56that were so kindly inviting me to the discussion
- 6:00and created this study with me where we looked
- 6:04at human relations and psychedelics. So what
- 6:07I really did in this study was to kind of post
- 6:11that question. We knew that previous studies
- 6:15have looked at psychedelics and nature -relatedness,
- 6:19and there was really a gap there. Why? Because
- 6:23of the testimonies that you shared before. we
- 6:27kind of talk about it, but it hadn't really been
- 6:30studied before. So that was kind of an insight
- 6:33that we should probably look at this as well,
- 6:35because as many of us know, human relationships
- 6:41with animals has fundamentally changed the surface
- 6:45of our planet in a negative way due to how we
- 6:50treat them and how we imprison billions of them.
- 6:55a kind of important thing to ask ourselves is
- 6:58how do we change this and what kind of interventions
- 7:02could we use? And that's where psychedelics come
- 7:05in. So psychedelics, I today, when I kind of
- 7:12historically emailed my colleague, I'm going
- 7:15to talk about psychedelics today. What should
- 7:17I say? I don't know if I remember anything. No,
- 7:21but then he he kind of reminded me, like, you
- 7:28know, you wrote this article, so you know, but
- 7:31if you want to know a fun fact, the the word
- 7:36psychedelic psychedelics come from a Greek has
- 7:41Greek roots. And that stems from kind of being
- 7:45something mind revealing. And that is something
- 7:48that we associate with psychedelics kind of being
- 7:51mind revealing. It's it's from what I've come
- 7:57to learn, what is included in the word psychedelics
- 8:04is still debatable within the scientific community.
- 8:08But in our article, we refer to kind of classic
- 8:11psychedelics, which is a group of psychoactive
- 8:14drugs that can produce changes in perception,
- 8:19mood and cognitive processes in different ways.
- 8:23in daily terms, that can mean, you know, magic
- 8:27mushrooms or GMT, which is the primary ingredient
- 8:31in ayahuasca. So kind of the ingredients that
- 8:36we know alter our perceptions of reality and
- 8:40our place in reality. So I would say that that
- 8:46is what psychedelics mean. And we can talk about,
- 8:48and that is probably what we're going to talk
- 8:50about in this context, those those famous psychoactive
- 8:55ingredients that can alter the way we experience
- 8:59life. I like the fact that you bring the animal
- 9:04rights agenda to your work and use your perspective
- 9:09to ask pertinent questions about important topics.
- 9:15What have you studied in university? What are
- 9:19your your expertise in terms of, you know, your
- 9:24place in that study and your role. I think I've
- 9:27been quite of a hedonist when it comes to studying.
- 9:30I've made my own programs. First I did a bachelor's
- 9:35program in political science, but I kind of shaped
- 9:39my own program and the courses. I can say like
- 9:43this, that everything I have studied on university
- 9:47has always been with the kind of animal perspectives
- 9:51in the back of my mind. Like how could I use
- 9:54these tools, these research tools or methods
- 9:58or mindsets to carry forth the importance of
- 10:04altering our relationship to animals for the
- 10:07better in a positive way and show the positive
- 10:10consequences that come from that positive transition.
- 10:15So for instance, when I studied public science,
- 10:19I saw the need to kind of, okay, how could we
- 10:23see animals as members of society? Even if, for
- 10:28instance, political parties that are based on
- 10:31animal rights often get ridiculed. You can't
- 10:33get kittens to vote. I mean, duh. But how could
- 10:39we make sure that animals are included in the
- 10:46decision -making processes? in a rightful way
- 10:49when the decisions really impact their lives.
- 10:53So more about, you know, really the rights side
- 10:57of it. So how can we make decisions that really
- 11:01impact animals' lives and not really try to even
- 11:06have them present in the room or have somebody
- 11:08that speaks for them in the room? And how could
- 11:11that... be called a democratic process if we
- 11:14do not do so. So those kind of questions and
- 11:17also I studied environmental law and philosophy
- 11:23and noticed how how easily you know those classical
- 11:26moral philosophers divide between body and mind
- 11:32and logic and and feeling and you know those
- 11:36kind of things that are just you know kind of
- 11:39boring and untrue. So I kind of had that as a
- 11:46perspective with me all along and it made it
- 11:48quite fun as well because even if I studied the
- 11:52most really not my cup of tea courses with, you
- 11:57know, whatever that might be, I could always
- 12:02think about how could I use this. to carry forth
- 12:09animal rights or that kind of perspective. So
- 12:13it kind of helped me as well to go through different
- 12:18phases in life. And I also wrote my bachelor
- 12:22thesis on a kind of, I did a discourse analysis
- 12:27of meat consumption in relation to climate change
- 12:31and how that was discussed in the. in the Swedish,
- 12:34in Swedish politics. And that was over 10 years
- 12:37ago. And unfortunately I don't see a lot of changes
- 12:40in that area. So, and then I studied public health
- 12:45and learned about quantitative methods, which
- 12:50was horrific because it was a bit scary to sit
- 12:55there with a computer and doing all these kinds
- 12:57of statistical analysis. But I... That was really
- 13:02insightful as well, to be able to look at research
- 13:08and say, okay, how could I criticize this? Or
- 13:10how could this be a sane argument? Because there
- 13:18are so much misinformation out there as well.
- 13:20And it's really important to try to get the tools,
- 13:25as much tools as possible to kind of scrutinize
- 13:30the research out there. in its biases. And I
- 13:33tried to do that with my own research as well.
- 13:37What in this could not be true or closer to truth
- 13:41or whatever, we all know there are a lot of research
- 13:45out there saying this and that about plant -based
- 13:48diets and this and that about everything. So
- 13:51just learning about these different methods and
- 13:55the different ways that we calculate what is
- 13:57closest to truth can be very fruitful in realizing,
- 14:01aha, this is what research means, and this is
- 14:04how research can be used in different ways. And
- 14:10in those public health classes, I learned a lot
- 14:14about what was not being said. That is usually
- 14:16the thing that has taught me the most in every
- 14:19academic setting I've been in, and also in every
- 14:21research setting I've been in. But there's also
- 14:25something that we learn from what is not being
- 14:27said. So in the public health class it was we
- 14:30never talked about plant -based diets. We didn't
- 14:34talk about the relationship between climate change
- 14:37and environmental destruction, animal exploitation,
- 14:40and human health. We didn't talk about pandemics.
- 14:45I read that on the site because I found that
- 14:49very important and a very important argument
- 14:52to transition from the way we are living now
- 14:57to a way that at least minimizes the risk of
- 15:01future pandemics and epidemics. So really in
- 15:06the heart of everything that I've done academically
- 15:08has always been just a wish to learn more about
- 15:16the world and how I can see it in different ways
- 15:20and how I can learn from that. and to bring that
- 15:25into the conversations I have. And yeah, and
- 15:30I think animal rights have been a very central
- 15:32part in that, in the decisions I've made. And
- 15:34it's been joyful. It's been joyful. We usually
- 15:37talk about the things we have to give up when
- 15:40we talk about animal rights, but I do think it's
- 15:42been just joyful to have that as perspective.
- 15:44It's really helped me to kind of find the passion
- 15:47and motivation to go through those big books.
- 15:52I want to go back to your study and some of the
- 15:56words that you have used in that study that maybe
- 16:01most listeners would not be familiar with. And
- 16:04I want to take the time to maybe define them.
- 16:08So talking about psychedelics, you talk about
- 16:12something called ego dissolution. So what is
- 16:17ego dissolution? It has been found. in studies
- 16:21on psychedelic use. And it can really be said
- 16:25to be a loss of self -identity, your boundaries,
- 16:29the boundaries between yourself and your surroundings
- 16:33is decreased or absent. It's a feeling of being
- 16:38that is different from the ones that we might
- 16:42know now as the ego, that here is where I begin,
- 16:46there is where my surroundings begin. So it's
- 16:50really about dissolving that boundary, a feeling
- 16:53of that boundary being dissolved. And it's a
- 16:56really interesting term. I found it interesting
- 17:02because it made me think about how human exceptionalism
- 17:12is such a common theme in our culture and especially
- 17:17in Western culture. Sorry, Ellen, can you define
- 17:22that? Because in vegan circles, we hear about
- 17:26speciesism, but we don't hear about human exceptionalism
- 17:31that often. Well, it's really linking terms because
- 17:35you can't really have speciesism without human
- 17:37exceptionalism in a way. Speciesism is really
- 17:42pushing your species in front of other species
- 17:44and thinking that you're superior. And that could
- 17:47not really be done without human exceptionalism,
- 17:50believing that, well, we are the exception. And
- 17:55I've been in very, very, well, very, no, that's
- 18:00not really an exaggeration. I've been in many
- 18:02rooms, scientific rooms as well, with brilliant
- 18:07minds. when it comes to human -animal relations
- 18:14or the way we relate to each other, there is
- 18:18almost an ideological feeling in the room that,
- 18:24well, this is established. The human exceptionalism
- 18:27is established. Animals don't have culture. Animals
- 18:30don't have languages. Animals don't have this.
- 18:34And usually it is used in a way to describe humanity.
- 18:39and the way we humans work. And in many instances,
- 18:44it's very, very wrong, according to the research
- 18:48that we know. So human exceptionalism is a really
- 18:52sociocultural phenomenon that we construct to
- 18:57make it easier to place ourselves above other
- 19:01species. Well, another question I'm dying to
- 19:05ask. Why is the research that we have currently
- 19:09on animals describing them as having personalities
- 19:13and feelings and complex creatures. Why is it
- 19:18not making any impact on the way we think about
- 19:22them? And I will go as far as to talk about,
- 19:28you know, Darwin, why Darwin's discovery of natural
- 19:33selection have not completely and radically changed
- 19:38our interactions with the natural world, with
- 19:42the rest of the animal kingdom. He's the one
- 19:45who said, and I think you quote him or paraphrase
- 19:50him in the study or in one of your interviews,
- 19:54but he's the one who said the difference between
- 19:56humans and animals is a difference of degrees
- 20:00and not of kind or nature. why is it not making
- 20:05an impact on the way we think about the world?
- 20:09Wow, if we knew that. I believe that in our,
- 20:21and I think we will come back to this, but I
- 20:25think that the way that we currently, I think
- 20:28that the way I feel and I think many others feel
- 20:31like that who who fights for animal rights or
- 20:35who is part of the ongoing battle, so to say,
- 20:39is trying to see how could I reach this individual
- 20:45or how could I change this and that. And I think
- 20:47in that insight in, wow, how much we could change
- 20:51with just changing the way people eat, for instance,
- 20:56what a tremendous effect and impact that might
- 20:59have. So we focus on the individual and reaching
- 21:03that individual. But I think that is a very important
- 21:07effort. But I do think that sometimes we forget
- 21:09that the powerful and resourceful industries
- 21:14that are behind these habits that make up our
- 21:21lives and the enormous amounts of propaganda
- 21:24that has been fed to us and is continuously being
- 21:28fed and that A lot of the decisions that have
- 21:34made a horrendous impact on Earth and on public
- 21:38health and on animal health, those decisions
- 21:41have been made in rooms that are closed and that
- 21:45are not made by politicians, but in boards, in
- 21:49economic institutions and businesses. While I
- 21:56think that a lot of frustration comes from, oh,
- 21:59we could do so much by just changing how individuals
- 22:02think about this and that, I think that we should
- 22:06also remember that the frustration that some
- 22:10of us carry might also be directed to the people
- 22:14in power. Why didn't you have our interest in
- 22:17mind? Because many, and we're talking about we're
- 22:24normalizing talking about this when it comes
- 22:26to the tobacco industry. But we should normalize
- 22:30talking about this when it comes to all industries
- 22:33because too many free cards have been handed
- 22:37out at the expense of our planet and public health.
- 22:42And I think that is important to remember. And
- 22:47I think When we talk about, for instance, climate
- 22:51change and environmental exploitation, the tendency
- 22:58and the daily rhetoric is that it's an external
- 23:02problem that can be fixed through technology.
- 23:04But I do think that many of us who knows the
- 23:08consequences of technology, which means that
- 23:10the industries are more efficient, which creates
- 23:15a lot of suffering. So we understand the kind
- 23:17of negative sides of technological innovations
- 23:20if it doesn't come with inner dimensions of change.
- 23:25So I think when we talk about climate change,
- 23:28when we talk about animal rights, when we talk
- 23:30about human rights, when we talk about everything
- 23:32that has to do with rights, we're talking about
- 23:36attitudes, we're talking about our internal lives
- 23:40that we manifest on a daily basis. And that can
- 23:45be really hard to change. But we are social animals,
- 23:50we are. And I think that one small transition
- 23:53can create, can do something, can create a domino
- 23:59effect. So I do think that there is a place for
- 24:01hope, but I do think that we also need to remind
- 24:03ourselves that years and years of misinformation
- 24:09and propaganda is behind these daily habits of
- 24:13individuals. we need interventions and we need
- 24:19people who want this to change and who wants
- 24:23to put our health before profit. And that is
- 24:29also a way to go about it to kind of win people
- 24:32over because when we cause the suffering of billions
- 24:36of animals, we are not putting human health first.
- 24:41Our health is always interconnected. We saw that
- 24:45in the pandemic. So we need to alter that perception.
- 24:51And ego dissolution, it can be a way to do that
- 24:53because it can remind people that the boundaries
- 24:58that we have socially and culturally created
- 25:01towards the outside world is not really the way
- 25:04the world works. It's not really the way the
- 25:06world works. And the pandemic was a harsh reminder,
- 25:11but other things can be a harsh reminder as well.
- 25:14when the climate starts to change around us or
- 25:17as in my personal experience, the forest in my
- 25:22home village is being turned into clear cuts
- 25:25and I'm very personally affected by this. We
- 25:31are reminded that we know this. We know that
- 25:36we are interconnected with the world around us.
- 25:39Even if we are fed with the idea that there is
- 25:43a separation going on. Pets can remind us about
- 25:48this. There are so many reminders. And I think
- 25:53we also write about that in the article about
- 25:56these kind of reminders in our daily lives and
- 26:00in the context where we are that can remind us
- 26:03about this interconnection. It can also feed
- 26:06us with separation. I think one important thing
- 26:11to hold on to is to find these moments of interconnection
- 26:14to guide us forward. Because I think that is
- 26:17the closest to reality that will ever come as
- 26:20humans. So if I understand well, ego dissolution
- 26:25is about finding back that connection with your
- 26:32environment. Basically, that sense that you are
- 26:36separate from the world disappears. I think that
- 26:43ego dissolution is a phenomenon where you feel
- 26:46that that boundary is dissolving. And it has
- 26:51been linked to different measurements, if I'm
- 26:54not wrong. I think they have seen that it has
- 26:58been associated with well -being, for instance,
- 27:00and positive outcomes. But I'm hesitant to say
- 27:04that ego dissolution is the way to go. But I
- 27:08think it's an interesting phenomenon. And particularly
- 27:16because we are so trained to rather feel the
- 27:20opposite, to feel a separation. So that was what
- 27:26kind of sucked me into the concept. Ooh, that's
- 27:28intriguing. It's something, I love breaking barriers.
- 27:33So when I heard that, I was like, ooh, you have
- 27:36my attention, ego dissolution. But yeah, so.
- 27:43Yeah. Well, that's why I think that psychedelics
- 27:47are an interesting prospect for activists, because
- 27:51I'm not sure you can reach that goal of connecting
- 27:56people with nature just by the Socratic method
- 28:00of stopping people in the streets and debating
- 28:03them about veganism, like we see it with the
- 28:07cube of truth. I think there are as many ways
- 28:11as there are people. I think you can reach people
- 28:14in many, many different ways. I think, and we
- 28:17can all do it in our own way just by being who
- 28:19we are in the context that we are. I think one
- 28:22of the most important insights that I got from
- 28:24the psychedelic study was that context is so
- 28:27important, context and mindset. It would also
- 28:33be a bit risky to say that psychedelics idyllic
- 28:38would act as a kind of quick fix because I know
- 28:40that we are we humans we tend to in our also
- 28:43in our culture we tend to look at oh quick fix
- 28:48how can I quick fix this and that is also a risk
- 28:53that we culturally appropriate that we exploit
- 28:57just to to get to that lesson that we need to
- 29:01learn to move forward. I think we need to also
- 29:05sit in the discomfort. of what has been done
- 29:09and how can we do better and create contexts
- 29:16that really help us see the positive impacts
- 29:19of human -animal nature relations. And for instance,
- 29:24after psychedelic experience, people are very
- 29:26vulnerable to stimuli. What happens if you go
- 29:30on a spiritual... ego dissolving journey or whatever
- 29:35we should call it and then you come back into
- 29:37your daily life and you're still met with the
- 29:41you know the the individualized pieces of products
- 29:46that animals represent in the store for instance
- 29:48what happens when you're constantly fed with
- 29:51with that kind of division again and that kind
- 29:56of culture again it's it's yeah it's it's really
- 30:00about context i believe and And if you're open
- 30:03to it in the beginning, or if you have a community
- 30:07where that kind of way of looking at animals
- 30:11is more accessible and possible. So I do think
- 30:19context is really the key in this study as well,
- 30:22that just enabling for other relationships with
- 30:27animals that are more positive and less de -individualized
- 30:30and more nuanced could really do something. And
- 30:35if you add psychedelics in there, wow, the results
- 30:39might be very fascinating and very effective.
- 30:43But also if you add music in there, or if you
- 30:46add whatever ingredient in that context, who
- 30:50knows? We could have made ourselves a transformative
- 30:55community just by creating those kind of ingredients.
- 30:59Of course, I'm thinking about the 1960s and 70s
- 31:03and how psychedelics were used and what was the
- 31:08impact on the society of that time. I mean, it's
- 31:11fascinating. There was an explosion of culture
- 31:14and art and music. Some of the best singers we
- 31:24can think of were born from that era. And also
- 31:29we get stories of scientists who have used psychedelics
- 31:35from that time to make breakthroughs. So we have
- 31:41a model of what would society look like with
- 31:46a more accessible use of psychedelics. Yeah,
- 31:53that's super interesting. That was the introduction
- 31:58of a, of an article I read. I remember when I
- 32:01was writing the article that it was about that
- 32:04and the music and the pro environmentalism that
- 32:08was occurring at the same time was kind of the,
- 32:11the psychedelic movement and the environmental
- 32:13movement kind of went alongside the beginning.
- 32:16That's really interesting for sure. Yes. I have
- 32:20the image of hippies in mind, you know, and I
- 32:26want to quickly go back to that, to the hostile
- 32:30forces, to those ideas. When you said that you
- 32:35studied environmental science, I think, environmental
- 32:38law, and in the context of your studies, there
- 32:44was no mention of pandemics. I thought about
- 32:49the risk that factory farming poses on public
- 32:52health in terms of zoonotic diseases. And then
- 32:56I thought, okay, do you believe that academic
- 33:04institutions that you visited, from which you
- 33:11got your education, were in a way captured by
- 33:17the agriculture industry or big corporation or
- 33:21I don't want to get, you know, conspirational
- 33:23here, but I want to ask you that question still.
- 33:31I'm going to answer that by saying something
- 33:34that has nothing to do with it. No, I'm going
- 33:36to, when I graduated from upper secondary school,
- 33:40which also was a political science kind of focused
- 33:47program, I said to my teacher that I wanted to
- 33:51focus on animal rights in my, in going forward
- 33:55to the university. She was like, oh, that's such
- 33:58a shame. You were so good at human rights. And
- 34:02I think that that is still the way that most
- 34:09people live their lives because that is the way
- 34:13that we are we are being taught from day one
- 34:18to make that separation. But really what many,
- 34:22many researchers before me has been saying for
- 34:25a long time and not just researchers, but poets
- 34:28and artists is that that is really not true.
- 34:35That is not the way we live our lives. But it's
- 34:38still very present because I think that what
- 34:42what happens in academia and I don't think it's
- 34:45a it's a it's a willful ignorance. I don't think
- 34:48so. I think it's just because we have we have
- 34:53created academia in a way that makes it you know
- 34:57very accessible in a way that we we make these
- 35:00boxes and this is what we should learn and this
- 35:02is how reality looks like and that is that is
- 35:05one one purpose of research to make it easier
- 35:07to categorize and to do all these things. But
- 35:13I do think that issues that have to do with animal
- 35:17rights have been drowned a bit. It has been hard
- 35:21to reach the surface for many different reasons.
- 35:27But I can't really, I do think it's just cultural.
- 35:31I do think that we are trained to say, ah, we
- 35:34will deal with that later. We haven't. we haven't
- 35:39figured this thing out yet, so we will deal with
- 35:41that later. Or it's not as relevant as talking
- 35:44about tobacco and alcohol, for instance, when
- 35:46it came to the public health program, which in
- 35:50a way is really important to talk about. But
- 35:52it's also important to talk about diets and the
- 35:57way that animal exploitation is really harmful
- 36:00to all of us, and especially for the often marginalized
- 36:04communities living close by or for the people
- 36:09working within these horrible institutions that
- 36:12suffer, many suffer from PTSD, for instance.
- 36:16So I think it's still seen as a bit of a marginalized
- 36:21or very, very specific subject, animal rights
- 36:24or things that has to do with animals when it
- 36:26really is just ingrained in our lives. In most
- 36:29things that we talk about, a lot of things we
- 36:32have in our homes are made from animals. We don't
- 36:35even think about it or people who We can think
- 36:38about it, but normally we don't stop and go,
- 36:41wait, this candle, is that? And I've worked because
- 36:49I was also part of a research project that looked
- 36:54at the pandemic and its consequences. And I was
- 36:58part of a team where I again said, But what about
- 37:04the way we treat animals and the reason why we
- 37:07have a pandemic? Why aren't we talking about
- 37:09that? And my colleague said, here, here, that
- 37:11is what we want to look at. So we did that. And
- 37:14we collaborated with one of the founders of One
- 37:18Health in Sweden. And One Health is a concept
- 37:21that looks at the interconnectedness and health
- 37:23between humans, animals, and the environment.
- 37:28And he told me that years before the COVID -19
- 37:32pandemic. I don't remember if it was one year
- 37:37or if it was a time before the pandemic arrived
- 37:41to Sweden that he wanted to have a seminar to
- 37:45politicians talking about the risks of a pandemic
- 37:48happening linked to the way we treat animals.
- 37:52And he has been... specializing in bird flus
- 37:58and things like that, but he really wanted to
- 38:01have a seminar to kind of inform politicians
- 38:03about the risks of future pandemics, which he
- 38:06found to be bound to happen due to the way that
- 38:12the world is functioning right now. And there
- 38:16was not a lot of interests. And he even had a
- 38:20book about pandemics that was, you know, completely
- 38:26covered in dust there on the bookshelf and then
- 38:29the pandemic happened and the interest just,
- 38:32you know, skyrocketed and he, and that is kind
- 38:36of an example of how I think these voices have
- 38:39always, the voices of resistance have always
- 38:43been there. It's just very hard for them to be
- 38:46heard because there are so many other things
- 38:49that are pushed forward to be prioritized. and
- 38:53especially in a world where we are trained to
- 38:56not see that connection, it's not seen as the
- 38:59most important subjects to look at because, well,
- 39:04I do think it's not a willful act. I do just
- 39:11think that it is just the way the world works
- 39:15because of how we've been trained to think. Sadly,
- 39:21in institutions where great minds are, we all
- 39:24have blind spots. I have my blind spots, we all
- 39:28have them. And they are more easy to have when
- 39:32we're trained to walk with a cognitive dissonance
- 39:35all day long. You make the point in, I think,
- 39:42the introduction of the study that people who
- 39:45have a sensitivity towards animals who care about
- 39:50animal rights are also people who are less likely
- 39:56to be criminals, to be intolerant, to be abusive.
- 40:04And the opposite is true. When we think about
- 40:07animal abusers, there's this, you know, image
- 40:11cliche of the murder, you know, the serial killer
- 40:17then. was torturing animals during his childhood.
- 40:22And when we talk about sexism, who are the first
- 40:27to kill and abuse animals? Well, men and so many,
- 40:33for instance, dogs in shelters will be afraid
- 40:38of human men and will only interact with human
- 40:45females. I feel like it's just, it's there. People
- 40:52are conscious of it, but they're just not making
- 40:55the connection. They're not able to step beyond
- 41:00that cognitive dissonance you're talking about.
- 41:05The last push is not there. So yeah. In that
- 41:14type of research, I think I've... I've read a
- 41:19lot of Aisha Akhtar's work and I must say that
- 41:21I really recommend everyone reading her work
- 41:23because she talks a lot about, especially from
- 41:28a public health view, how human rights is connected
- 41:32to animal rights and those relations that you
- 41:37were talking about, for instance, through abuse
- 41:40and violence. And how I've come to think of it
- 41:46is that The key element in all this, I think,
- 41:51is the role of dehumanization or the de -individualization.
- 41:56If you animalize someone, which we do with animals,
- 42:00but we also do with other groups of people, it's
- 42:04easier to not see how these individuals can,
- 42:10how you can inflict pain in these individuals
- 42:12or how they're, you know, if... if something
- 42:18happens to their bodies or violence or whatever,
- 42:20you kind of discredit or you ignore the sensations
- 42:25that these individuals can have. So I think the
- 42:27key element in this is dehumanization and how
- 42:32those processes work. And cognitive dissonance
- 42:37is also a kind of coping mechanism. So if your
- 42:46values and your actions, they conflict. What
- 42:51to do? And parts of that answer can be that,
- 42:59well, if that individual that I'm doing this
- 43:04to is not really an individual, then this gap
- 43:07doesn't exist anymore. So we kind of. In our
- 43:11very high human intelligence, we have a lot of
- 43:14ways to rationalize bad behavior or rationalize
- 43:18things to ourselves to make us feel better. And
- 43:22I do think an important part of moving forward
- 43:25is to get the tools to look at ourselves and
- 43:32sit in that discomfort and just be, okay, what
- 43:37have I been taught and what have I learned? do
- 43:40I have dehumanizing tendencies or do I have blind
- 43:43spots or whatever? And I do think that doing
- 43:46that as a society and as a community could be
- 43:48really healing and could be really transformative.
- 43:55Continuing on, by the way, the term de -individualizing,
- 44:01I love it. One of my new favorite terms now.
- 44:07Another term you used in this study and that
- 44:11I want you to define is something you call the
- 44:15biophilia hypothesis. So what is that about?
- 44:22Well, that is really a term that emphasizes the
- 44:28human innate need to connect with the natural
- 44:31world. been suggested, inspired by that term,
- 44:40that nature connectedness, to feel connected
- 44:42with nature is a human need even. So it's really
- 44:46a term that wants to say that we have a need
- 44:55to connect with the natural world. And this need
- 44:57might not only be physical, but also spiritual.
- 45:03And it can have many it can have nuances to it.
- 45:08So it can also be a very spiritual term and kind
- 45:12of psychological term as well. And as we've talked
- 45:19about, I do think that there's something that
- 45:23we experience, even though I know you said that
- 45:26we've kind of built away a lot of nature and
- 45:29we kind of created a human world in a sense.
- 45:34I think just going on the subway in town can
- 45:38be a really good reminder that you cannot build
- 45:42away nature in a way. Nature is always there.
- 45:45You can just alter the way nature looks like.
- 45:51we never live in human worlds. We always live
- 45:54in interconnected worlds with a multi -species
- 45:57world with nature and just like standing on the
- 45:59subway and the pigeon walks in and you're like,
- 46:01okay, there you are. How nice, how lovely of
- 46:05you to join us. And then the pigeon, the group
- 46:08of pigeons stand there for a couple of stops
- 46:09and then they just walk out. And I think those
- 46:12instances are lovely reminders of that we can
- 46:17try with humans. And I don't think That is a
- 46:20goal. I think that is a horrible goal, but we
- 46:22can try to kind of, you know, build our human
- 46:25world. But the world would just remind us like,
- 46:29hello, here I am. And I find that just wonderful.
- 46:36And I think during the pandemic, the biophilia
- 46:41hypothesis was probably experienced by a lot
- 46:44of people. So for instance, people who couldn't,
- 46:47in Sweden we had the fortune to not be as restricted
- 46:50in our movements. So we could go outside for
- 46:52instance. And a lot of us went to the forest
- 46:56to reflect and to help us distress and to mirror
- 47:01ourselves in another kind of a more, a reality
- 47:05that is more still and peaceful. And also for
- 47:10the people who had to be inside research. has
- 47:13shown that if they had a tree they could look
- 47:15at, it helped them to kind of establish this
- 47:19connection to the natural world anyway and feel
- 47:21less isolated. And all those research studies
- 47:26showing that if you have a tree outside of your
- 47:30hospital window, it helps you feel faster. And
- 47:33all of these things, I think, really just pinpoint
- 47:37what that hypothesis is trying to say that we
- 47:41have this innate need, even if we have created
- 47:45somewhat a culture that is based upon this human
- 47:50exceptionalism and based on this kind of separation
- 47:53of nature and culture and animals and humans,
- 47:58that we have this need. And when we really realize
- 48:03that, I think we need to. in this these times
- 48:09we need to realize that the time to really act
- 48:14on this need is now because we are we are doing
- 48:19so much to this planet that we will regret and
- 48:22that will have consequences for also our health
- 48:24for instance deforestation and and environmental
- 48:28degradation and all of these things. I just I
- 48:36think I've read a Danish interview or what it
- 48:39was that inspired me to write my lyrics for O
- 48:42and it was that he had been biking with his son
- 48:45and he had not been experiencing the insects
- 48:50in the same way that he had summers before. That
- 48:53just these minor changes in the way we experience
- 48:56life when these change, we will miss the interactions
- 48:59we had with other animals. We will miss it because
- 49:02it is information that we receive and that make
- 49:05up our lives, but we take them for granted. So
- 49:08when the birds, you know silence people know
- 49:12and we will miss it So I do think that it's time
- 49:16to act on this kind of thesis now more than ever
- 49:23By the way, oh my favorite song of yours I'm
- 49:57just realizing in how much of a mess we are talking
- 50:01with you In the sense of how chaotic and nonsensical
- 50:13our situation is. Because yes, I agree that we
- 50:20feel a need to connect with nature. I absolutely
- 50:23agree with the biophilia hypothesis, the premise
- 50:31of that theory. You know, you talked about the
- 50:36pandemic and how people went hiking a lot. And
- 50:41that is something we also experience in Canada.
- 50:45People, instead of going to Southern America,
- 50:48where they usually go for vacation, went and
- 50:53visited our national parks. But then there was
- 50:58like a big scandal about how the National Park
- 51:05were getting lots of garbage and nature was getting
- 51:09destroyed and trees were being cut and it started
- 51:16lots of fires. And from an individual perspective,
- 51:23we want to live near a forest or near a park
- 51:29or a garden and our houses that are near green
- 51:33zones are worth more on the market. But if we
- 51:39see a spider in the kitchen or, you know, we
- 51:44get all crazy and we want to kill it and we don't
- 51:50like mosquitoes and we're intolerant of any kind
- 51:57of, you know, Like if it's too sunny we complain
- 52:05if it's true. There's too much rain. We start
- 52:08to complain. We're always complaining about nature
- 52:12and so there there is that and and then there's
- 52:18the whole aspect of You know, like you mentioned
- 52:22like we talked before We understand that there
- 52:28is a link between us and the natural world that
- 52:32we are part of the animal kingdom. We have so
- 52:36much data and studies backing up the fact that
- 52:39animals are sentient. But then we have this big
- 52:43cognitive dissonance and we're not able to take
- 52:48the leap. And so I find myself being in wonder
- 52:55of how much, again, nonsensical our attitude
- 53:01and behaviors are. Yeah, that they are that it's
- 53:07it's it's so interesting what you're saying,
- 53:10because that is one of the things that I think
- 53:12you realize when you read, you know, human human
- 53:16animal studies, or, you know, attitudes to animals
- 53:19that they can be so contra intuitive or and and
- 53:25just conflict them conflicting in themselves
- 53:27that they can be very ambivalent and you know
- 53:31why do we that animal not this and very culturally
- 53:34linked just to habit or class or status or whatever
- 53:40and it's so interesting what you said with the
- 53:45kind of opposite to having a need for nature
- 53:49that the kind of the a fear of nature which is
- 53:52really interesting now when we talk about the
- 53:54pandemic because that was that was one of the
- 53:56risks that we saw when we did um that we did
- 53:59explore the you know the consequences of the
- 54:02pandemic in relation to human animal nature relations
- 54:05is that you know in the word that we use or not
- 54:09we but you know the governments use or or doctors
- 54:12use or whatever uh animals and nature can be
- 54:18seen as threats to human health. And how does
- 54:23that alter our willingness to protect animals
- 54:25and nature if they are a threat to us? And that
- 54:29is a problem because usually when an animal poses
- 54:33a threat to us, for instance, if a bat population
- 54:36has a disease that can be transmitted to humans,
- 54:42the standard is, oh, we should kill all the bats.
- 54:48But maybe the problem why the infection was easily
- 54:53transmitted to us in the first place was because
- 54:55we destroyed the habitat of the bats. So what
- 55:00we really should do is that we should protect
- 55:02bats. And in today's world, that can be very
- 55:06counterintuitive also because of the relations
- 55:08that we created with animals that are very based
- 55:11on anthropocentric means and what is good for
- 55:15us humans and animals being a function to us
- 55:18humans, why should we protect something that
- 55:20wants to kill us? So I really see an importance
- 55:25here in getting the message out to people. And
- 55:31a more nuanced way of seeing our relationship
- 55:35to animals means, OK, the risk exists, but why?
- 55:40And And if we think about the animal perspective
- 55:45and the animal life, a suitable measure should
- 55:49not be to kill all the individuals. It might
- 55:52be to protect its habitat and make sure that
- 55:55they have a space where they can be. So we tend
- 55:59to see, when we talk about fear and we talk about
- 56:02those kinds of things, and it's a valid fear
- 56:05because infectious diseases are increasing in
- 56:08this world, we usually tend to double punish
- 56:13the animals that have these infections and not
- 56:15maybe think about ourselves as the problem. Usually
- 56:18we are the problem because we've built away their
- 56:22natural environments and that means that they
- 56:25live closer to us. So I do think that it's really
- 56:29important especially after the pandemic where
- 56:32there is a risk that we can talk about animals
- 56:35as a risk to human health and also nature's risks
- 56:38to human health. to really understand that we
- 56:47can create a kind of movement that shows politicians
- 56:53or decision makers that we are not okay with
- 56:58calling as an option for treating this problem
- 57:02because we as a community or whatever, we need
- 57:07to create buffer, we want to create buffer zones.
- 57:11that decreases the risk of transmission. And
- 57:14that can mean keeping that forest intact, for
- 57:17instance, or maybe not building houses where
- 57:21bats live, for instance. So I think the fear
- 57:25that we feel towards animals, especially here
- 57:29in the Western world, especially in Sweden, where
- 57:33we have been quite fortunate with diseases and
- 57:38things like that. is that it has, oh, they can't
- 57:42come here. We've had the problem with wild boars.
- 57:45And in Norway, they just killed everyone off.
- 57:49And here in Sweden, they try to restrict the
- 57:51area in which the disease is. But also here,
- 57:58we have a very active forest industry that clear
- 58:02cuts a lot of natural areas where the animals
- 58:06live. So I do think that that fear that animals
- 58:12live where we live and that fear might guide
- 58:17us to something. It might guide us to yes, because
- 58:21we are not letting them have their space. I think
- 58:28just creating a more positive relationship with
- 58:30animals also come with, like in every healthy
- 58:33relationship, it comes with knowing When do I
- 58:37have to give you space? When do I, how can I
- 58:40create a safe space for you and I to function?
- 58:43I do think we need to see it more as a personal
- 58:46relationship to understand, but it kind of, it
- 58:52takes of us to transform. So it was really interesting
- 58:57what you said because that is a lot of what I've
- 59:00been reading recently is about that. fear messaging
- 59:05or risk messaging and the negative consequences
- 59:08that might come from that. Yeah. Thanks. Well,
- 59:15also, I would be remiss not to mention how in
- 59:21the vegan community, but also everywhere, the
- 59:25word nature and natural comes with a positive
- 59:31perception. So we want natural products and it's
- 59:37not very scientific because in a way, you know,
- 59:40everything is natural. What do you mean by this
- 59:43is natural? What do you make of the use or misuse
- 59:51of the term natural to sell products to cast
- 59:58a positive light on something. It has become
- 1:00:05kind of an accessory for capitalism and for big
- 1:00:10corporations. For sure. It is kind of a rabbit
- 1:00:17hole, isn't it? Or a nostril. It throws you out
- 1:00:21in a... When you phrased that question, I was
- 1:00:25like, wow, that could be an endless or just like
- 1:00:29a 24 -hour discussion just about the world's
- 1:00:32natural and how it's so ingrained in so many
- 1:00:35things. Well, I was also thinking of that ad.
- 1:00:38I don't know if you watched that ad of Apple
- 1:00:41inviting Mother Nature to their headquarters.
- 1:00:47Tim Cook, who's the CEO of Apple, talking with
- 1:00:52Mother Nature about how Apple is great and has
- 1:00:56a great relationship with nature and is environmentally
- 1:01:00friendly. And Mother Nature, you know, congratulates
- 1:01:05them for being wonderful, environmentally friendly.
- 1:01:12company, which they are not, they are absolutely
- 1:01:14not. That sounds super surrealistic. I don't,
- 1:01:17that sounds so surreal. I've never, I haven't
- 1:01:20heard of it. I just think about, because now
- 1:01:24I'm very, I'm very active in the kind of the
- 1:01:29forest movement here in Sweden, trying to come
- 1:01:31by clear cuts. And so I'm very into that area
- 1:01:34right now. So that might be why I'm constantly
- 1:01:37moving in that direction. But the word natural,
- 1:01:40is a very problematic term there as well, because
- 1:01:44a forest is seen as something that is renewable,
- 1:01:49which in a sense, okay, understandable, you can
- 1:01:51cut down a tree and it grows up again, but then
- 1:01:53you tend to miss the fact that a forest comes
- 1:01:58with an ecosystem, comes with something that
- 1:02:02has been growing and living and developing there
- 1:02:06for hundreds and hundreds of years, and that
- 1:02:09is now renewable. So, and there's a really ongoing
- 1:02:15trend here in Sweden, I think all over the world
- 1:02:17that, you know, Sweden wants to post itself as
- 1:02:19a very, very environmentally friendly country
- 1:02:21with, you know, we have these solutions for this.
- 1:02:25Like we, there is a commercial on TV that you
- 1:02:27can replace everything with, with, with trees,
- 1:02:31with wood. They just walk around with, you know,
- 1:02:34everything is, everything is, is, is you know
- 1:02:37made from a tree and then you just think okay
- 1:02:39there the old growth forest went like this because
- 1:02:43we barely have anything left what's left is fields
- 1:02:46of trees of production which is not a forest
- 1:02:53it's and it's the typical way that um we are
- 1:02:59trained to think as um consumers or and as citizens
- 1:03:03that we we are I'm going to use one of your new
- 1:03:07favorite terms now, de -individualizing. We are
- 1:03:10also de -spiritualizing places and individuals
- 1:03:15and not seeing the forest for its arrays of relationships
- 1:03:21and networks and things that we have barely started
- 1:03:25to care about and explore that are being destroyed
- 1:03:30due to the forest industry. we are just learning
- 1:03:34to see the trees. There's one tree, there's a
- 1:03:37second tree, and we're not really being trained
- 1:03:40to see the relationship these trees have with
- 1:03:42each other and all the species that live there
- 1:03:45and everything that has been growing and et cetera,
- 1:03:49et cetera. So this is another example of when
- 1:03:51we are trained to just commodify life into product.
- 1:03:58And when we look at a product and we see, oh,
- 1:04:00natural, it's made out of trees from blah, blah,
- 1:04:03blah, it's certified. I mean, the more I learn,
- 1:04:07the more disappointed I get in these labels.
- 1:04:13I get sad because I wish they were true. I wish
- 1:04:17that the certifying sustainable forestry, this
- 1:04:23this notepad was made from a certified sustainable
- 1:04:27forestry. And I know what that means. I've seen
- 1:04:30the clear cuts. It's not sustainable. And it
- 1:04:36really needs to happen something. And I think
- 1:04:38we need to demand as consumers. Unfortunately,
- 1:04:42that's the way the economy works. We need to
- 1:04:44demand that for more transparency within the
- 1:04:47industry. I mean, to use natural but to use harvested
- 1:04:52meat like harvest just to use these terms you
- 1:04:55know that makes us forget that these animals
- 1:04:58were born raised and killed in these industries
- 1:05:02for instance it's a very very you know it can
- 1:05:09be an efficient way to make us forget where things
- 1:05:13come from and that products that resources were
- 1:05:19taken to create something. Even if it's natural
- 1:05:25or more sustainable, it still took something
- 1:05:28for that product to end up there. And it's not
- 1:05:34a very popular view, especially not in a capitalist
- 1:05:40society, but to use less perhaps. I don't think
- 1:05:46we will save the world by driving electric cars.
- 1:05:49I'm sorry. I don't think so. But I think that
- 1:05:56is what is more profitable for the system that
- 1:06:01we live in, but it's not better for us. Absolutely
- 1:06:05not. But yeah, the word natural can be a very
- 1:06:13efficient label, for sure. Clean also, clean,
- 1:06:18green. What else? Non -devo, whatever, everything,
- 1:06:24every label is. It's hard to be a consumer these
- 1:06:28days. It's really hard. That's why we need to
- 1:06:30put pressure on governments and companies because
- 1:06:35individuals can do a lot of work, but it's impossible
- 1:06:38to do all the work. I guess they are literally
- 1:06:42capitalizing on our biofilia, our needs to be
- 1:06:47close to nature. They have recognized that and
- 1:06:50instead of making reforms in culture, they instead
- 1:06:55wanted to use it to make profits for their company.
- 1:06:59Instead of doing better and instead of doing
- 1:07:01things that actually is positive for that term,
- 1:07:07they just say, we know you care about this, but
- 1:07:10you should also not care about it. Yes, it's
- 1:07:16a bit psychopathic. If I had to go to the essence
- 1:07:22of your study, I get the sense that you consider
- 1:07:27psychedelics as maybe a way to get clarity in
- 1:07:35the middle of this confusion and those lies and
- 1:07:40this senselessness. clarity about our place in
- 1:07:43the world and about who we are. And it goes against
- 1:07:49cultural norms and understandings of psychedelics
- 1:07:53because we believe psychedelics, I think most
- 1:07:57people, to be something akin to alcohol. It makes
- 1:08:01you confused and it makes you you lose your mind,
- 1:08:10uh, from taking, uh, and you're not a serious
- 1:08:13person if you take psychedelics. Um, but instead
- 1:08:18you're making the point that no, this is, this
- 1:08:21will bring us clarity or this might bring us
- 1:08:24clarity. Hmm. Yeah. I would perhaps say that
- 1:08:32psychedelics can be or should be further explored
- 1:08:37because this is just the beginning. We don't
- 1:08:39know enough to really say anything else then
- 1:08:43that, ha, we found an association. This might
- 1:08:46be worthy of further investigation, really, if
- 1:08:49it might be an intervention to alter perceptions
- 1:08:55and alter human -animal relations also in a long
- 1:08:59-lasting way because we don't have any longitudinal
- 1:09:03data, we don't have any long term data. So we
- 1:09:05don't really know, we just know what the participants
- 1:09:09recall. So it can be also, you know, a bit of
- 1:09:15a self reporting bias there that people want
- 1:09:17to feel connected. And it's, we really need to
- 1:09:20see more studies that show, you know, okay, so
- 1:09:25people feel an increased connection, but does
- 1:09:28that, does that translate into the way they live
- 1:09:31their lives? in long term and how they behave
- 1:09:34after a while. So we don't really know, but we
- 1:09:38did see, well, we did see some associations with
- 1:09:44animal solidarity and also with, what was it,
- 1:09:51speciesism, lower speciesism or negative effects
- 1:09:54with speciesism. So we did see associations that
- 1:09:58showed that, okay, it can alter human animal
- 1:10:01relations. can. But again, what my colleagues
- 1:10:07really want to emphasize as well, and I know
- 1:10:08they want to, so I have to emphasize it again,
- 1:10:11is that, and I believe this as well, it is it
- 1:10:14is really context dependent. So and previous
- 1:10:20studies have seen that, for instance, if people
- 1:10:22do psychedelics in nature, that can increase
- 1:10:24the relatedness to nature, because it's made
- 1:10:27in nature, nature setting, etc, etc. In a more
- 1:10:31wild or non -human setting. Nature is everywhere.
- 1:10:38So I think the core of the article is really,
- 1:10:46again, I think a lot can be seen in what we can
- 1:10:51say. I think it's really interesting that we
- 1:10:53don't have enough answers about this, even despite
- 1:11:00the fact that it is so important to change these
- 1:11:04relations that we have with animals because they
- 1:11:06do really alter the world and health and everything
- 1:11:16and a lot of things. So how can we not to this
- 1:11:22day have more studies on interventions that can
- 1:11:25alter these relations? How can we not no more
- 1:11:31how we can efficiently try to transform these
- 1:11:34relationships into a more positive one. So I
- 1:11:36think that is the most fundamental question in
- 1:11:40all of this and that the psychedelic study, I
- 1:11:45love discussions and articles. I do love the
- 1:11:48discussions and I do like the discussion in this
- 1:11:51article because there we can talk about, okay,
- 1:11:54ego dissolution but not lifetime classic psychedelic
- 1:11:57use. was positively associated with the desire
- 1:12:00to help animals. What can that mean? Okay, that
- 1:12:04might mean that it has something to do with that
- 1:12:10our coping or defense mechanisms, for instance,
- 1:12:14cognitive dissonance is decreased because our
- 1:12:19ego, our egos, our boundaries are dissolving
- 1:12:22and we are not as inclined to have these win
- 1:12:26and lose mentality. and this kind of notion of
- 1:12:30human exceptionalism, we don't lose our humanness
- 1:12:35by seeing that animals have their own lives,
- 1:12:38for instance, and their own personalities, for
- 1:12:40instance. So we can re -individualize animals
- 1:12:43again, because it doesn't make us less of who
- 1:12:46we are. Maybe, we don't know, but that is one
- 1:12:51of the things that we talk about in the discussion
- 1:12:52that I really like. is how can psychedelics as
- 1:12:57one of many interventions help us to instead
- 1:13:02see the win -win situations in improving our
- 1:13:06relationship with animals and having enriched
- 1:13:09and respectful relationship with animals and
- 1:13:11nature. And another thing that I find really
- 1:13:17puzzling with the study and just by studying
- 1:13:21human behavior and attitudes is that our connection
- 1:13:26with nature, what does that mean? It can mean
- 1:13:32a lot of things. So we haven't really pinpointed
- 1:13:35what that means to every individual who has answered
- 1:13:38the survey. So it can mean to feel connected,
- 1:13:43but what does it mean, as I said, with how you
- 1:13:47live your life or in some ways connection can
- 1:13:50be experienced as as also a separation, like
- 1:13:55I feel a connection with nature, but I'm not
- 1:13:58part of nature. How is that, how does that work?
- 1:14:02I'm very fascinated with these kind of mindsets
- 1:14:05that we carry and how they translate into the
- 1:14:08world and how interventions such as psychedelics
- 1:14:12can help us get insight into these cognitive
- 1:14:16processes that we all carry, because it's very
- 1:14:18fascinating. They seem complex. So yeah, that
- 1:14:26is my takeaway from the article. And I do hope
- 1:14:30that more research will show more long -term
- 1:14:38answers. Blogitudinal studies would be amazing.
- 1:14:41And also looking at other interventions other
- 1:14:43than psychedelics, maybe just community -based
- 1:14:47also interventions will be amazing just because
- 1:14:52we do think that the context and setting is so
- 1:14:55important. So what happens when we mix all these
- 1:14:59ingredients? Could that alter people's mindsets?
- 1:15:03Could that make people feel like the threshold
- 1:15:06to change their behaviors is lower, is easier,
- 1:15:10more accessible? So that is really the question
- 1:15:14that I had and I carry forth in this article,
- 1:15:19those kind of questions. And I'm happy you're
- 1:15:21making that point because just from anecdotes,
- 1:15:27I know that there are plenty of people out there
- 1:15:30who are big fans of psychedelics and psychedelics
- 1:15:35have made a great impact, transformative impact
- 1:15:40in their lives. But they are the opposite of
- 1:15:44a vegan or an environmentalist in a way. And
- 1:15:48I'm thinking here about Joe Rogan. We're recording
- 1:15:54a podcast. The king of podcasting is of course
- 1:15:58Joe Rogan and he is infamous for being against
- 1:16:03vegans and against eating a plant -based diet.
- 1:16:08He thinks it's unhealthy and he's all about hunting.
- 1:16:13Yet at the same time, he talks a lot about psychedelics
- 1:16:18and how that transformed him and made him more
- 1:16:23receptive to the world, more empathic. And he
- 1:16:28goes on and on about the importance of psychedelics
- 1:16:32in his life. And he talks about it as something
- 1:16:36spiritual. And it's hard to understand how can
- 1:16:44someone go through such a profound experience
- 1:16:49and still finds pleasure, sadistic pleasure in
- 1:16:55hunting, killing, and eating animals. Yeah, and
- 1:17:01that is something that we did discuss. I mean,
- 1:17:09also some research suggests that You can also
- 1:17:15strengthen the connections already existing or
- 1:17:17your mindset is very important when you go through
- 1:17:20this experience. So even if you're You can you
- 1:17:24can feel a sense of you know, dissolving of boundaries
- 1:17:26again, the context seems to be very important
- 1:17:29and also the mindset that you already carry and
- 1:17:33I think as you as you said Maybe he had different
- 1:17:39different goals. And sometimes I think that that
- 1:17:43is just typical of the way we handle things in
- 1:17:46our society. I think one, I read an interesting
- 1:17:51article that talked about mindfulness, how we
- 1:17:54kind of integrated yoga into the Western culture.
- 1:18:00And that has also been created some kind of,
- 1:18:04or mindfulness practices as some kind of quick
- 1:18:06fix. There are so many you know, instances for
- 1:18:11you here in places or whatever, like, I meditate
- 1:18:1420 minutes a day to get the optimal results of
- 1:18:18this. And so it's still in the this kind of context
- 1:18:23of production and capitalism and hustle culture
- 1:18:27and whatever. So it feels like the context is
- 1:18:31really important. And it's a whole, I mean, stereotypes
- 1:18:40and prejudice and they come with harmful things
- 1:18:48also for the people who are seen as having more
- 1:18:52power. I mean, it feels like the goals that you
- 1:18:57set when you have that role as a, I don't know,
- 1:19:03people call them alpha males or like a toxic
- 1:19:06masculinity or you should be this and do that
- 1:19:10and it's very restrictive as well. So I wish
- 1:19:18that his experiences might have been, oh, I can
- 1:19:23be the interconnectedness of liberation and if
- 1:19:29I'm free and they're free and we're all free
- 1:19:31and you know, but no. it's, it's, I did this
- 1:19:37and I feel more open now so I can do these and
- 1:19:39these goals. It feels like a way of, of, of using
- 1:19:43something to move forward. And it, it doesn't
- 1:19:48have to mean inner work. Um, it doesn't. So,
- 1:19:52so that's, that might also be a really important
- 1:19:54point that maybe the reason why you consume psychedelics
- 1:19:59is important in the first place, just also with,
- 1:20:02with the context. Um, I mean, there are people
- 1:20:07from Western culture traveling to these small
- 1:20:13villages where they have practices. I've been
- 1:20:15doing these practices, for instance, Ayahuasca
- 1:20:16for many, many, many years, hundreds of years.
- 1:20:20And they have that rooted in their culture and
- 1:20:23their community. And individuals consume it individually
- 1:20:29and might might not focus on the experience of
- 1:20:35the community, for instance, that might be the
- 1:20:37case locally, traditionally. And so what does
- 1:20:43that do with us when we still have that individual
- 1:20:47anthropocentric way of consuming something? Can
- 1:20:52that really then alter our minds? Or is the context
- 1:20:57so important that we need to kind of invest in
- 1:21:00the community first? to create a safe space.
- 1:21:04So those are questions I don't have the answer
- 1:21:06to, but I do think that they are very important.
- 1:21:09And I do think that when we talk about psychedelics,
- 1:21:12that cultural misappropriation and also exploitation
- 1:21:15of these cultures are important to talk about
- 1:21:20because it's a risk due to the history of colonialism
- 1:21:26and due to the ongoing colonialism that we are
- 1:21:29seeing. There are many, many, many things that
- 1:21:36we could talk about in terms of this article.
- 1:21:39This has, you know, your explanation has truly
- 1:21:43helped me to understand why he behaves that way
- 1:21:47because I, uh, the, the mindfulness analogy speaks
- 1:21:52to me as a Buddhist. I see the difference between
- 1:21:57the meditation that is taught by uh, monks who
- 1:22:02have to meditate for 10 years before having the
- 1:22:06privilege to teach meditation to students versus,
- 1:22:10um, people here in the West who go through a
- 1:22:15six months certification program to be able to,
- 1:22:19um, host, you know, uh, meditation, uh, class
- 1:22:24classes, uh, for anyone who wants to, uh, events
- 1:22:29that have better mental health or something like
- 1:22:32that. And the meditation I have learned from
- 1:22:35monks is much more profound and in its purpose,
- 1:22:41in its intention, in its goals than the meditation
- 1:22:46we find on apps. And so it truly speaks to me
- 1:22:51that difference. It's weird how meditation is
- 1:22:59also a practice of ego dissolution, or at least
- 1:23:04the way I see meditation. It's all about disappearing.
- 1:23:12And I find the link between that and also psychedelics
- 1:23:16interesting. And it can be really hard for individuals
- 1:23:26to, I think it's hard in this society because
- 1:23:32our value, it's easy to think that our value
- 1:23:38is just related to our productivity, right? So
- 1:23:41the transformative processes that we do, like
- 1:23:44meditation, whatever, when the end goal is just
- 1:23:48to increase our productivity, what happens with
- 1:23:53the practice, what happens to our experience
- 1:23:54of ourselves and things like that. It's really
- 1:24:00context dependent. And it can be hard to lose
- 1:24:05those shackles of the capitalists put on us that
- 1:24:11we are just worthy when we're productive. I mean,
- 1:24:14also in these age of social media, when the doing
- 1:24:18is unfocused, it can be really hard. So it's
- 1:24:22not easy. Well, there was a monk who once said,
- 1:24:26I remember he said, you can be a mindful assassin.
- 1:24:33It's possible. If you're not taking the practice
- 1:24:37as a whole doesn't make sense. But yeah, here
- 1:24:42we go. Another practice that might promote a
- 1:24:50connection with nature is music. And when I think
- 1:24:55about the history of music, I think of, for instance,
- 1:25:00the muse. And I had the experience of visiting
- 1:25:03Greece and the Greek ruins and temples. And at
- 1:25:10some point we visited like a cave. in at the
- 1:25:14top of the mountain, and it was surrounded with
- 1:25:17forests. And we were told that, yeah, this is
- 1:25:21where this is the cave of the muse and the muse
- 1:25:27inhabits, you know, the the forests surrounding
- 1:25:31us and or something like that, if I remember
- 1:25:36correctly. But I remember very clearly being.
- 1:25:41a bit surprised by, because for me music was
- 1:25:46synonymous with civilization and culture. And
- 1:25:50so I was not expecting for arts and anything
- 1:25:56that has to do with it to inhabit a wild forest
- 1:26:02and to be about a cave. What's the link between
- 1:26:06a cave and music or poetry, or whatever the I
- 1:26:14don't know how many muses there are. But yeah,
- 1:26:19they're all like saint patrons of different art
- 1:26:24form. So I find it truly interesting. And I wanted
- 1:26:30to ask you as a musician, has it helped you make
- 1:26:35that connection with nature? How do you experience
- 1:26:38your art, basically? Hmm, I love this question.
- 1:26:44I do think growing up with music because I'm
- 1:26:46brought up in a family where music was very present
- 1:26:49and where we sang together and my mother is a
- 1:26:52music maker and my sister also sings and dances
- 1:26:56and my dad loved to listen to music. So he was
- 1:27:01a great appreciator of music. I do think that
- 1:27:06I hope it also helped of course, in combination
- 1:27:09with living on the countryside and living with
- 1:27:12animals. But I do think that music helped me
- 1:27:14because my first language was communicating through
- 1:27:21music. That was my first language, was music,
- 1:27:23to sing or to create sounds. I did sing before
- 1:27:29I spoke. So I do think that just having that
- 1:27:34relationship with with a non -verbal way of communicating
- 1:27:38really showed me that, you know, our human words
- 1:27:42are not everything that is embedded in the word
- 1:27:49communication. It comes with a lot of things.
- 1:27:51It comes with, and just growing up performing,
- 1:27:54it's also about body language. And communication
- 1:27:56means so many different things. So I think music
- 1:28:00really helped me to see that and just appreciate
- 1:28:05the music of nature of other animals and just
- 1:28:09birds singing. I could listen for hours. I remember
- 1:28:13when I was a kid, I was thinking, wow, that is
- 1:28:15so beautiful how they communicate. And learning
- 1:28:19more about that helped me to dissolve the barriers
- 1:28:23between cultural and biological diversity because
- 1:28:26I do not think that that separation is correct.
- 1:28:31I think that whenever we are erasing biological
- 1:28:34diversity, very actual now with the mass extinction
- 1:28:39of animals, we are also losing cultural diversity
- 1:28:44and cultural practices that we have barely started
- 1:28:47to know more about because we have been quite
- 1:28:51into our human exceptional ideas of culture.
- 1:28:56There's whale singing and there's so many different
- 1:29:02ways of art. And I think culture is also a biological
- 1:29:09function. It's just navigating through life.
- 1:29:11Music has helped me navigate through life. It
- 1:29:14helps me to integrate the feelings that I have
- 1:29:17felt and the experiences that I have and to create
- 1:29:21something with it and to share it with other
- 1:29:23people. And it can have like a soothing effect
- 1:29:26for people that might be able to reflect themselves
- 1:29:29in music. I think it's a way of navigating through
- 1:29:32life. And I do think that most, if not all, other
- 1:29:35animals do need to navigate through life. And
- 1:29:38then, of course, I can experience music in the
- 1:29:45natural, less human -made environments as well.
- 1:29:49Like, for instance, with trees. scratching and
- 1:29:54things like that. And sounds rather. And sometimes
- 1:30:00I sampled them and I hear the music in them.
- 1:30:03I think music is just a collection of sounds.
- 1:30:06And I love seeing music that way because that
- 1:30:09makes me appreciate the kind of unpolished sounds
- 1:30:12that infiltrate my compositions no matter if
- 1:30:15I want them to or not. Oh, the squeaky thing
- 1:30:17that came into the recording and then I really
- 1:30:21love that squeaky sound because it's life. Sounds
- 1:30:24just infiltrate your life. And as a musician,
- 1:30:28I love that. So yeah, I think that music really
- 1:30:35helped me to gain that perspective from early
- 1:30:37on. And when I make music or when I perform,
- 1:30:45I feel very integrated. And also when I play
- 1:30:49music, I feel a kind of That the boundaries are
- 1:30:53also dissolving like the way you talk about meditation
- 1:30:56that I Think I said when people asked me what
- 1:31:00I wanted to be when I grew up as a kid I would
- 1:31:03say that I wanted to be music because it was
- 1:31:06a state of being To become music in a way that
- 1:31:10you're so integrated with all of the parts that
- 1:31:12you are one So I sometimes I feel that and I'm
- 1:31:18very lucky to experience that feeling I felt
- 1:31:20that yesterday when I was rehearsing for a gig,
- 1:31:23when I was playing violin, I was like, oh, I
- 1:31:26felt it afterwards that, oh, I had that experience
- 1:31:28again when I was just completely integrated into
- 1:31:33the being. That's a beautiful answer. And it's
- 1:31:38not a surprising one because when we, when I
- 1:31:41listened to your music, it's very immersive.
- 1:31:45I feel like I'm transported by, uh, the music
- 1:31:50and the lyrics. Do you have that goal in mind?
- 1:31:56Do you think of the people who are going to listen
- 1:31:59to your songs when you make music, or do you
- 1:32:04just let yourself be guided by your creativity,
- 1:32:09by your muse? Like, will I sound like a terrible
- 1:32:12person if I just say no? I don't think of other
- 1:32:14people. I do think about other people when I
- 1:32:18get cold feet before releasing music, like, oh
- 1:32:21my God, will they even find this as music or
- 1:32:25is it noise? So interesting, that process as
- 1:32:30well from the creative stage of being into the,
- 1:32:34you know, scrutinizing yourself and thinking
- 1:32:37about, you know, the thing that is so personal
- 1:32:40to you is a very interesting process in this
- 1:32:43day, modern day. But no, it just comes to me,
- 1:32:53really. I sit in front of an instrument and I
- 1:32:58think it's something that has been happening
- 1:32:59in my subconscious and then it just comes out
- 1:33:02and then sometimes I do have a feeling, for instance,
- 1:33:06that something I've been thinking about or something
- 1:33:08I've been trying to embody and then I have walked
- 1:33:12around with it and then when I sit down it usually
- 1:33:15just comes and then I after a while I realize
- 1:33:17oh okay this song is about this because now I'm
- 1:33:20experiencing this and then I try to finish it
- 1:33:24with that kind of emotion or I say in a lot of
- 1:33:32interviews And I think it is because I want to
- 1:33:37kind of give credit to my roots that I have Swedish
- 1:33:42roots. I also have Finnish Karelian roots. And
- 1:33:44Karelia is an endangered culture. And there's
- 1:33:50a practice in Karelia culture that is limitation.
- 1:33:53And limitation is, you know, it practices all
- 1:33:55over the world. But in Karelia, it is a female
- 1:33:59-led tradition. And historically, it was often
- 1:34:02an older woman who who was present at different
- 1:34:09occasions. It could be happy occasions, like
- 1:34:13a wedding, or it could be like a funeral. And
- 1:34:17the mission of the Lamenter was to help people
- 1:34:23to channel all their emotions in a transition.
- 1:34:27And that is something that has really inspired
- 1:34:29me in my personal life, but also in my artistry
- 1:34:33that I I think that music has that role in our
- 1:34:38lives. Again, navigating through life, but also
- 1:34:41helping us to feel all the emotions at the same
- 1:34:43time. Because usually it's like, is it a happy
- 1:34:46song? Is this a sad song? It's usually a sad
- 1:34:52song will be into happy song or both. It's usually
- 1:34:56many feelings at the same time. When I'm writing,
- 1:34:58I'm usually carrying all of these feelings and
- 1:35:00I need to give myself space to explore these
- 1:35:03different emotions. in different languages or
- 1:35:06with different instruments and sounds. And of
- 1:35:10course, when I'm doing it, I'm just trying to
- 1:35:12be as present as I can and to really just also
- 1:35:17find the joy and playfulness in it. But of course,
- 1:35:22I wish that my role could be a little bit like
- 1:35:27the lamentator in the way that I can help people
- 1:35:31process different emotions and and to help them
- 1:35:35kind of not deny themselves the safe space where
- 1:35:41all of these feelings can be felt at the same
- 1:35:43time. So I really wish that I create a space
- 1:35:49where people can express themselves in different
- 1:35:52ways and just to just feel all the emotions.
- 1:35:54That is my wish. And I do think that The way
- 1:36:02I can facilitate this is by just making sure
- 1:36:06that I'm being the most honest version of myself
- 1:36:09as I can when I create the music. And I don't
- 1:36:12think about the end result and how that can be,
- 1:36:15you know, met in with different, you know. just
- 1:36:25positive or negative or whatever. I just think
- 1:36:27about being as present as I can in that moment
- 1:36:29and giving myself that space. And then I can
- 1:36:32invite other people in that safe space. And yeah,
- 1:36:36I hope, yeah. I haven't asked you yet, but have
- 1:36:41you ever tried psychedelics? No. But my... I'm
- 1:36:49intrigued what would happen because when I talk
- 1:36:51about my experiences, one of the co -authors
- 1:36:55of the study and the specialist in psychedelics,
- 1:36:59he's like, but sometimes you sound like you're
- 1:37:01already on psychedelics. So I don't really know
- 1:37:04how you would react because I talk with trees
- 1:37:10and I'm the typical tree hugging stereotype in
- 1:37:16that way, but I'm a proud tree hugger. I think
- 1:37:19it's a very, it's my innate need and I accept
- 1:37:24it. Same. I mean, I had a chat with Emma who's
- 1:37:30known as Whispers Red on YouTube. She makes ASMR
- 1:37:34videos and she describes herself as being hypersensitive
- 1:37:39and that sense of being receptive to the world
- 1:37:44and to its sounds. Um, she reflected that, you
- 1:37:48know, she talked about it. She also talked about
- 1:37:50it in the conversation we had. And I do think
- 1:37:55there is a link between being hypersensitive
- 1:37:59and being creative, but also caring for animals
- 1:38:06and having this different relation with animals.
- 1:38:12Yeah, there might be something there. And I think
- 1:38:15some studies that, or, you know, just, just argumentations
- 1:38:22that, you know, why would you want to care about,
- 1:38:24you know, animals or be, you know, vegan or whatever,
- 1:38:27because it, you know, it just makes you depressed
- 1:38:30and you feel bad. I do think that it is hard
- 1:38:34to feel good. When all the time and be shippy
- 1:38:40happy when you know that there is an ongoing
- 1:38:48industry that creates suffering. I think that
- 1:38:54it is the same with terms such as eco or climate
- 1:38:58anxiety. I do think that they are healthy responses
- 1:39:01to an unhealthy way of living life and an unhealthy
- 1:39:06way of treating the planet. And so I do think
- 1:39:09that some of the negative consequences of caring
- 1:39:13is healthy responses to something that is sick.
- 1:39:20So I think that sometimes maybe, I don't know,
- 1:39:25but maybe it can be, you want to show the positive
- 1:39:29things about being an animal rights activist
- 1:39:32or caring about different causes, but it's also
- 1:39:35a struggle. We feel sad sometimes and overwhelmed
- 1:39:39and really powerless and and Just being against
- 1:39:43these powerful powerful industries and trying
- 1:39:46to do what we can. It can be it can be really
- 1:39:49hard and I just recently I mean I've experienced
- 1:39:54burned out and I do and I and I and I think that
- 1:39:59you know We always carry the the feeling of the
- 1:40:03week. We have to do more and that what we do
- 1:40:06is not enough, et cetera, but it is really important
- 1:40:10to find the best we can in an unsustainable world,
- 1:40:15but to try to find sustainable ways in our activism
- 1:40:18and in our lives where we can still care, but
- 1:40:23we take care of ourselves and not stigmatizing
- 1:40:28that we feel bad because I think it's a very
- 1:40:32normal and healthy response. to something. I
- 1:40:35mean, just knowing what happens is hard. Well,
- 1:40:43to be really plain, it sucks. It sucks, but yeah,
- 1:40:49and it can be really hard. So self -compassion
- 1:40:52is also important. Yeah. Well, my message and
- 1:40:58the message of the podcast is that action is
- 1:41:04a way to overcome those feelings, to find strength
- 1:41:09in your situation. And because what you're describing
- 1:41:16is a sense of being overpowered. Well, claim
- 1:41:20back your power. Find the action you can do and
- 1:41:26go outside and do something and connect with
- 1:41:29people and make a difference. That will make
- 1:41:32you feel better. Yeah. So what is your message
- 1:41:36for the people who are dealing with that, with
- 1:41:39those emotions, but who stay passive? They're
- 1:41:44not prepared. It depends. I mean, I can understand
- 1:41:47that if you feel like it's really hard to do
- 1:41:51something because of the environment that you're
- 1:41:53in or whatever, that you might be in a strong
- 1:41:57opposition or I think just finding ways of finding
- 1:42:06rooms where you can express yourself maybe might
- 1:42:09be a start to find the rooms where you where
- 1:42:11you can dive into more topics or learn more or
- 1:42:16also I think that animal rights is not it can
- 1:42:24be treated as a as a as a marginalized you know
- 1:42:28like subtopic but it's it's really interlinked
- 1:42:31with other forms of oppression. And if it is
- 1:42:35hard where you're at to kind of do something
- 1:42:38for animal rights, it's also important just be
- 1:42:41an ally for other causes because they're interlinked.
- 1:42:43So if you just do something to decrease the risk
- 1:42:46of dehumanization of any being, it is really,
- 1:42:51I do think that it helps the world. And I do
- 1:42:55also think that For us, they're active in the
- 1:42:58animal rights movement to also be good allies
- 1:43:00to other movements because we do have the same
- 1:43:03movement. We are part of the same social justice
- 1:43:05movement. Animals are included in the social
- 1:43:08justice movement. And we're kind of one movement
- 1:43:12against, again, the commodification and just
- 1:43:16the individualization of different bodies. And
- 1:43:22maybe I think just For me, I think just being,
- 1:43:30I've come to learn with all the years now that
- 1:43:33I've been advocating for animal rights. When
- 1:43:37I've just been myself in different rooms, no
- 1:43:40matter if it's with relatives that were like,
- 1:43:41oh, this is such a trend. I'm like, okay, like
- 1:43:4515 years later. No, but I think that is a trend
- 1:43:49or whatever. Just being who you are, consistent
- 1:43:52and being, just standing up for what you believe
- 1:43:55in. what you buy or, or just asking a question
- 1:44:01like, Oh, you think that I'm also like that?
- 1:44:03Why do you think that? Because I know the studies
- 1:44:05have shown this, just being somebody in the room
- 1:44:07that asks a question that might just a little
- 1:44:14bit combat the human exceptionalism in the room,
- 1:44:16maybe can do can can start something. And years
- 1:44:20later, a relative might come to you and say,
- 1:44:22Do you know what I've just I'm only eating plant
- 1:44:26-based now. And that was the relative that were
- 1:44:30freely thought that you were going through a
- 1:44:33phase. And after a while saw, oh, that is a way
- 1:44:36that you can live your life. Okay, I'm gonna
- 1:44:38try. And then all of a sudden you've made the
- 1:44:43lifestyle that you've chosen more accessible
- 1:44:45to other people just by showing another person
- 1:44:49how to live that life. Other ways that you said,
- 1:44:53I think is really important. I mean, just organizing
- 1:44:56with other people and finding your groups and
- 1:45:01maybe finding the group locally. I think locally
- 1:45:06is a really good way to start. If everyone would
- 1:45:09organize themselves in local groups, you could
- 1:45:11do a lot of things. Just a personal example of
- 1:45:16deforestation and here in Sweden, It's so easy
- 1:45:21to just have anxiety over all the reports on
- 1:45:25planned clear cuts that are coming in. And I
- 1:45:28just feel like, oh my God, just an ongoing amputation
- 1:45:31just happening and the really tangible anxiety
- 1:45:35that I feel in those moments. And when I try
- 1:45:39to avoid looking at them, that doesn't help because
- 1:45:42I still know that they're happening. So persistence
- 1:45:45can really be an act of hope. an act of envisioning
- 1:45:49another future and together that is really powerful.
- 1:45:52So I've organized with other local people in
- 1:45:56my hometown, just writing emails, talking to
- 1:46:00professional biologists and getting help on the
- 1:46:03way, finding allies. That is just like you say,
- 1:46:08that is really a strategy for not getting stuck
- 1:46:12in that anxiety. And of course, finding ways
- 1:46:19how to express yourself that works to help you
- 1:46:25become resilient in a world that can really break
- 1:46:29you down because of the way it is. So for me,
- 1:46:31it's music or sometimes it's dancing or whatever,
- 1:46:35just finding those expressions that help you
- 1:46:37to also grieve. It's really... important, I think,
- 1:46:46to grieve because it's so much loss. It's so
- 1:46:51sad. And when we give ourselves permission to
- 1:46:55grieve, we also help ourselves to feel that powerful
- 1:47:01joy in experiencing life the way we do with,
- 1:47:05you know, interaction with animals or other humans
- 1:47:08that have that wants to do what we want to do
- 1:47:13with goals or to combat whatever issue. So I
- 1:47:18do think I agree with you finding ways to organize
- 1:47:22yourself and but also finding ways to rest and
- 1:47:25express yourself individually and collectively
- 1:47:29in ways where you where you see that there's
- 1:47:34a lot of emotions that come with trans transformation
- 1:47:36and struggle and trying to create something resilient.
- 1:47:43Who wins when we break down and we can't do anything?
- 1:47:48Well, status quo. So it's important. And I mean,
- 1:47:56I've myself experienced burnout. So I'm not an
- 1:48:01expert at all. I don't live as I learn. I haven't
- 1:48:04always, but that's also how I know that it's
- 1:48:09hard. Yeah. I never heard about grieving the
- 1:48:19loss of animals before. And I truly admire that,
- 1:48:29that you went and thought about that because
- 1:48:32I definitely thought that we should have something
- 1:48:36like a monument remembering all of these all
- 1:48:41of those animals, the billions of them. And we
- 1:48:45can't even wrap our mind around that number.
- 1:48:50And we should at least have some kind of monument
- 1:48:53to their memory. But you might be on something
- 1:48:59here when you say, when you talk about grieving,
- 1:49:02because maybe lots of vegans are not so much
- 1:49:06experiencing, you know, being powerless, but
- 1:49:11being in grief of all of that lost that nobody
- 1:49:16sees. So truly, it's powerful stuff here. Yeah,
- 1:49:25I am. I personally experienced grief. Like I
- 1:49:33lost my dad a couple of years ago and just seeing
- 1:49:41how society, due to his illness and his age and
- 1:49:46other isms that you could, you know, attach to
- 1:49:49him, how I felt that my grief wasn't as, you
- 1:49:55know, acute or like, you know, I really understood
- 1:50:03what I've learned throughout the years when it
- 1:50:05comes to processes of dehumanization and I'm
- 1:50:09really grateful for that knowledge because it
- 1:50:12helped me to kind of be prepared for those personal
- 1:50:17experiences of grief and experience that kind
- 1:50:22of grief with your family member and then experiencing
- 1:50:25grief on a collective level and also grief of
- 1:50:31seeing how your natural surrounding who was one
- 1:50:34of your like safety nets in keeping yourself
- 1:50:37sane during this period of time was destroyed
- 1:50:40really made me realize the importance of what
- 1:50:43you're saying that our grief is seen and how
- 1:50:48it is how we are given the space to grieve and
- 1:50:53in society we might not be given that time. to
- 1:51:00grieve for that space. And depending on what
- 1:51:05we grieve or who we grieve, society might be
- 1:51:07more or less willing to acknowledge that grief.
- 1:51:11So it's very important to, I think, to create
- 1:51:14communities and have people around you that identifies
- 1:51:18and sees your grief and says, I understand that
- 1:51:21you are grieving. And if you don't have that,
- 1:51:25well, at least to give yourself the permission
- 1:51:30to grieve and finding ways how to connect with
- 1:51:35your grieving body through different ways of
- 1:51:40experiencing yourself through dance or whatever
- 1:51:43has really helped me. And I do think we talk
- 1:51:49too little. I do think we need to have a conversation
- 1:51:53about grief. When it comes to climate change,
- 1:51:56for instance, I do think that, I mean, I'm working
- 1:52:00on instrumental album right now that is really
- 1:52:05about that, that is about, you know, instrumental
- 1:52:08music, about grieving processes related to climate
- 1:52:12change. And just how are we supposed to deal
- 1:52:22with the transformation that that we are facing,
- 1:52:25that we're having to prepare ourselves for. It
- 1:52:29can be also a positive transformation, just like
- 1:52:32when we talked about lamentation and how we need
- 1:52:36to get help to process different emotions in
- 1:52:39transformation. It doesn't matter if the transformation
- 1:52:41is a good one. We will still probably need to
- 1:52:46grieve. So for instance, if we transform our
- 1:52:49relationship with animals to a more positive
- 1:52:50one, we will still have to grieve. what we lost,
- 1:52:56all the relationships that we lost because we
- 1:52:58didn't acknowledge the relationships that were
- 1:53:01relationships. We just thought they were business
- 1:53:04trades or whatever. We just thought they were
- 1:53:06objects. So I do think that we need tools as
- 1:53:12communities, as societies, as individuals to
- 1:53:15kind of process all these emotions and culture
- 1:53:17and music can be one tool, but also just creating
- 1:53:22cultures and politics that acknowledge that when
- 1:53:27our surroundings change, or when something happens
- 1:53:30in our lives, we need to grieve and we need to
- 1:53:33have the contexts where we can process these
- 1:53:38emotions. And if these are destroyed, or disrespected
- 1:53:45in a way, of course that hurts us. So I am so
- 1:53:51happy that you jumped on the grief train because
- 1:53:54that is a train that I've been on for a lot of
- 1:53:57years now. And I'm like, and I'm always, I'm,
- 1:54:02I, I, yeah, I really, I appreciate that you were
- 1:54:06the one bringing this up in a way because yeah,
- 1:54:09we went there. Amazing. And thank you for sharing
- 1:54:15your insights. This discussion reminds me of
- 1:54:20a concept that I truly love. It's about spirituality
- 1:54:26because we're talking, you know, that's the underlying
- 1:54:30theme of what we're talking about here, spirituality.
- 1:54:34And it says that spirituality doesn't have to
- 1:54:37be vertical, you know, about a pantheon of gods
- 1:54:41and angels and stuff like that. It can also be
- 1:54:46horizontal. We can have a horizontal spirituality
- 1:54:50in the sense of building, again, connections
- 1:54:54and relationships with our community, but also
- 1:54:58here with nature and animals. And I truly love
- 1:55:04that reference image of like horizontal versus
- 1:55:09vertical spirituality. Yeah. I want to ask, feel
- 1:55:19free to answer however you want, but do you find
- 1:55:22that there is any vertical spirituality to our
- 1:55:31understanding of nature and our relationships
- 1:55:34with animals? As I interpret your question, you
- 1:55:40can let me know. if I didn't understand you correctly.
- 1:55:52But in many ways, the way we look at animals
- 1:55:56is really based on power dynamics. And it really
- 1:56:03stems from the agricultural and domestication
- 1:56:06of the agricultural, kind of the early agricultural
- 1:56:10revolution when it comes to domestication of
- 1:56:12animals kind of happened the same time as the
- 1:56:14major religions came in. from from what I understand
- 1:56:17it. So I do believe that religion was a way of
- 1:56:21rationalizing how to treat animals and how to
- 1:56:26domesticate animals and how to create like an
- 1:56:28animal industry. And I do think that seeing humans
- 1:56:34as as godlike can also be a way of of encouraging
- 1:56:39human exceptionalism in a way. And I mean, I
- 1:56:42am is personally speaking, I've never, I'd heard
- 1:56:49to a certain religion brought up in a household
- 1:56:53quite the contrary, where my mother has been
- 1:56:57studying theology. It's called theologi in Swedish.
- 1:57:00I don't know if it's the right word in English,
- 1:57:03but you know, the history of goddesses and those
- 1:57:08kind of things. And we have a famous poet in
- 1:57:16Finland called Eva Kilpi who has written, she's
- 1:57:2097 or something now, I think. And she wrote a
- 1:57:24whole book with the theme of nature and animals
- 1:57:28called Animalia. And if I remember correctly,
- 1:57:32yeah. And she wrote that if you look into an
- 1:57:35animal's eye, you will see God or the Almighty.
- 1:57:38And that was very controversial for that time.
- 1:57:44But I do agree with her in a way, even though
- 1:57:47I don't, you know, I talk with the God or whatever.
- 1:57:50I do think that the way I see it is that we live
- 1:57:56in a world where we're striving towards monoculture,
- 1:58:00where everything is, you know, you see trees
- 1:58:03in line as a monoculture. The way we've created
- 1:58:07our agricultural productions the way we've done,
- 1:58:11the way we've created our religions is now very
- 1:58:14monocultural and for me I think a multi, more
- 1:58:19variety or many gods or many practices or would
- 1:58:27be quite nice. I don't know the horizontal view
- 1:58:33that you said, I like that because that reminded
- 1:58:35me of the Eva Kilpi poem, it reminded me that
- 1:58:39at least you can believe in God, but also be
- 1:58:43part of it somehow. It's the connection thing
- 1:58:45again. Do you feel connected to something and
- 1:58:47still separated from it? What is that connection?
- 1:58:51Instead of connection, I would like to say relationship
- 1:58:55because that requires us to place ourselves like
- 1:58:57in the room or in something that is an active
- 1:59:00ongoing thing where we have to be. even if it's
- 1:59:04a negative relationship or positive. We place
- 1:59:06ourselves easier in the room when we talk about
- 1:59:08the word relationship. Connection can be something
- 1:59:11that we kind of connect into server, logging
- 1:59:14out. Our relationship requires something from
- 1:59:18us and can also give us something more. So I
- 1:59:22like the term relationship and relations and
- 1:59:25how we can just experience life through relationships
- 1:59:31and And having role models or having an awe,
- 1:59:36an awe for something can be, doesn't have to
- 1:59:41come with power and balances and things like
- 1:59:49that. I like the horizontal view, but I'm biased
- 1:59:53because I'm brought up that way. I do understand
- 1:59:56the role of religious communities and I'm absolutely
- 2:00:02not again, I understand. I have pretty much the
- 2:00:05same sentiment for some kind of universe and
- 2:00:09interconnection and interrelations. I have that
- 2:00:14notion. But I mean, sure, we're talking about
- 2:00:17spirituality. Once again, it's maybe the term
- 2:00:19is spirituality. Yeah, I like the way you put
- 2:00:25it more. You should just erase my answer. Just
- 2:00:31put your question as also the answer. Can we
- 2:00:38do that? Your answer was great. I don't know
- 2:00:42why you say that. It was so poignant. It was
- 2:00:46there. But yeah, I agree. I should have just
- 2:00:50said I agree. No, it was good. I truly like the
- 2:00:57thing you said about seeing God in the eyes of
- 2:01:01animals. I think this will be shocking to hear
- 2:01:09for a listener who is not vegan and for whom
- 2:01:14animals have no presence and absolutely no personhood.
- 2:01:21But I think if you accept that animals are more
- 2:01:25than what we have been brought up to believe
- 2:01:29they are, I think, why not? Why not consider
- 2:01:34them and integrate them in our religious practices
- 2:01:38and our spirituality? Yeah. And maybe just like
- 2:01:45making a full circle, maybe that is what we have
- 2:01:49done and humans have done and all thinkers from,
- 2:01:52you know, thousands of years ago said, that you
- 2:01:58could see the God in the animal eyes. But as
- 2:02:02a culture, we have just not highlighted those
- 2:02:05people because I know that we know that there
- 2:02:07have been acts of resistance towards the way
- 2:02:09animals are being treated throughout history.
- 2:02:12And we talked about it before with the academia
- 2:02:14and why animals are not as highlighted or a marginalized
- 2:02:19subject in different fields and et cetera. it's
- 2:02:25where we place our focus and how we tell the
- 2:02:28story of humankind. And it's good if we've raised
- 2:02:35more positive examples of what it might mean
- 2:02:39to take the animal perspective, if you say like
- 2:02:41that, and how many of us, how many have been
- 2:02:46before us and how we're part of something bigger.
- 2:02:50We tend to also maybe do the human exceptionalism
- 2:02:54or the exceptionalism with ourselves, like I
- 2:02:56am the exception. And in some way, sure, we are
- 2:03:00because, I mean, we are marginalized in the way
- 2:03:06that we see and want to treat animals, but in
- 2:03:10other way, we're not exceptional. We're just
- 2:03:12part of a bigger movement, a resistance movement,
- 2:03:17also a larger social justice movement with other
- 2:03:21related issues. So I think that that can be empowering
- 2:03:24as well to remember that throughout history there
- 2:03:28have been voices that have said things that were
- 2:03:30talked about things that maybe you and I are
- 2:03:32talking about right now and that we should highlight
- 2:03:34them because we humans are like continuously
- 2:03:37writing our own history and who gets to write
- 2:03:43that history and that is also like an act of
- 2:03:45resistance and trying to to combat the way that
- 2:03:48that is being written. is being written humans
- 2:03:52as superior and whatever. So I think that that
- 2:03:56can also be a fun conversation to find the role
- 2:04:01models of today and yesterday and thousand years
- 2:04:06before that. And yeah, at the beginning of the
- 2:04:09conversation, you talked about how this was liberating
- 2:04:13for you to discover the animal rights fight.
- 2:04:18And this is what psychedelics are about, liberating
- 2:04:25your mind. And I think it could be the theme
- 2:04:29of our conversation, liberating ourselves from
- 2:04:34all of those dogmas, cultural beliefs and things
- 2:04:40that are just burdening us and working to harm
- 2:04:45us. So, Ellen, I have been talking with you for
- 2:04:52about two hours now. I think it's the longest
- 2:04:55podcast episode I ever recorded. Have a fun time
- 2:05:01in the post -production. Well, I think most of
- 2:05:05it was incredible. I don't think that I will
- 2:05:09have to edit lots of things in what was said.
- 2:05:16I hope listeners think the same way. Like, Oh
- 2:05:21my God, it's stopping. No, but, but thank you.
- 2:05:26It was a really interesting discussion and you,
- 2:05:28and you said some things that you said, can I
- 2:05:31just ask you something before we go? Here's an
- 2:05:34half an hour more. No, I'm kidding. No, but you
- 2:05:38said something about how you've experienced that
- 2:05:41some terms are being used within like the movement
- 2:05:44or. uh when it comes to speciesism and those
- 2:05:47kind of things and I to be fair I have not been
- 2:05:52because I've moved a bit away from research and
- 2:05:54human animal studies towards more you know culture
- 2:05:57and the music now and focusing on on the forest
- 2:06:01uh issue here in Sweden so I feel a bit unpolished
- 2:06:06on that area now so could you kind of develop
- 2:06:09um a bit more what you meant with those kind
- 2:06:13of terms that you have experienced and those
- 2:06:15kind of things. Because that stuck with me. What
- 2:06:19terms? I'm not... We're talking about like how
- 2:06:22speciesism is used and how it's kind of a shallow
- 2:06:27way of seeing things. Or you were talking about
- 2:06:30kind of going deeper into certain things and
- 2:06:33kind of nuancing in different terms and... Yes,
- 2:06:37I think we had that conversation before I started
- 2:06:40the recording. But I developed that now because
- 2:06:44I do want to know. Well, I was thinking about
- 2:06:48how. We often. In the public discourse around
- 2:06:55veganism, we tend to take a kind of a more superficial
- 2:07:02way, but more. simplistic way. I think that this
- 2:07:09vegan movement and the ideas we're putting forth
- 2:07:12are radical in many ways, going against centuries
- 2:07:19of traditions. But we are not maybe fully conscious
- 2:07:28of the the implications of this philosophy. Or
- 2:07:35maybe we simplify veganism because we are on
- 2:07:40this activism mode all of the time, always speaking
- 2:07:44to non -vegans instead of speaking to vegans.
- 2:07:49So maybe less conversations between ourselves
- 2:07:53and more conversations directed to non -vegans.
- 2:08:01If I had to give maybe concrete examples of that,
- 2:08:06I would say we say we use veganism and we often
- 2:08:10mean plant -based diet. So we reduce sometimes
- 2:08:17veganism to a diet and we concentrate on the
- 2:08:20health and lifestyle aspect. So yeah, I'm a bit
- 2:08:24vague right now. I don't know if I'm clear or...
- 2:08:28Yeah. I see what you mean and of course there's
- 2:08:33a value in simplifying depending on the kind
- 2:08:37of you know target group or messaging and trying
- 2:08:40to make it simple for people to you know understand
- 2:08:44or what can I do to do this or for this result
- 2:08:49and blah blah but as you say it as we talked
- 2:08:53about before with kind of like internal or external
- 2:08:56solutions to problems uh when it comes to like
- 2:08:59climate change or whatever that a lot of these
- 2:09:02things happen inside of us these processes uh
- 2:09:06and we manifest them in our lives and they but
- 2:09:09we're not born with them they come from somewhere
- 2:09:12we are being fed by these kind of social cultural
- 2:09:15ideas of for instance human animal relations
- 2:09:19and how they should look like and they are and
- 2:09:22the and the foundation of that is really questions
- 2:09:28like who has worth, why, who is part of nature,
- 2:09:34who's part of culture, who is a body, who's a
- 2:09:37mind, who is worth, those kind of questions.
- 2:09:40And that is why I liked research in the first
- 2:09:43place because I can just ask a lot of questions.
- 2:09:47But that is also why I like just being, having
- 2:09:52conversations because you Usually the questions,
- 2:09:57I think now is the time for questions. How can
- 2:10:00we create interventions that help us transform
- 2:10:06the way we treat animals and like our surroundings
- 2:10:11in a positive way? How can we connect these oppressive
- 2:10:21mechanisms in through words, for example, like
- 2:10:26dehumanization, and how can we see our blind
- 2:10:30spots? I think just by asking ourselves questions,
- 2:10:35we have done something. And that's why research
- 2:10:40love questions, because we have realized that
- 2:10:42we might not know everything, but we can just
- 2:10:45move on from there and try to gather as much
- 2:10:48information as possible, and most importantly,
- 2:10:51embody. what that means to ask these questions
- 2:10:55and embody the answers that we find. I completely
- 2:11:01agree. I think we have realized so much, but
- 2:11:06we're still reacting to those realizations, not
- 2:11:11having fully appreciated the depth of those realizations
- 2:11:15and what they mean for our cultures and for ourselves.
- 2:11:21Yeah, and we have all of these technical means
- 2:11:24to kind of quickly answer some questions that
- 2:11:30are more external. Fix this and fix that and
- 2:11:33how can we do this? But as we've talked about,
- 2:11:36we've seen the consequences of technology in
- 2:11:39its worst light. I mean, one solution to decreasing
- 2:11:44the risk of pandemics is to just keep animals
- 2:11:47more compact in a really uh closed space is that
- 2:11:52is but is that a solution that we want is that
- 2:11:56something that we would we would face and say
- 2:11:59oh sounds sounds appropriate um or would our
- 2:12:05cognitive dissonance be like we need to say that
- 2:12:09they're harvested and it's a nice environment
- 2:12:11with like a with a big TV where they can see
- 2:12:16other animals. I don't know how we would rationalize
- 2:12:18that, but you know what I mean. And these other
- 2:12:22questions that have to do with who we are, I
- 2:12:26think are the most important now in moving forward.
- 2:12:30And it's, again, as you said, it's also part
- 2:12:34of spirituality. Who am I? What do I find important?
- 2:12:42How can I support other people? What can I do
- 2:12:46to create the world that I envision and create
- 2:12:52the spaces that we need to dare ourselves to
- 2:12:55envision that another world is possible? It's
- 2:13:00very important to not restrict ourselves and
- 2:13:03our potential. And I want to give an example.
- 2:13:11that is close to my heart of one of those questions
- 2:13:16that you're referring to. The very first episode
- 2:13:21of this podcast was a conversation with Dr. Jens
- 2:13:24Vogt, who is a primate communication expert.
- 2:13:29And the very first question I asked her was,
- 2:13:33do chimpanzees truly understand human language
- 2:13:37when they communicate with sign language. You
- 2:13:40know, we have seen those famous videos of Japanese
- 2:13:42using sign language. Yeah. Or is it just like
- 2:13:46a conditioning trick, like a parrot repeating
- 2:13:49phrases and words? And she said, no, we, we know
- 2:13:53that they understand the sense, the meaning of
- 2:13:56the word and that they're truly using human language.
- 2:14:01And then she said, it is It's interesting. It
- 2:14:04remains so controversial because it rattles the
- 2:14:07foundation of who we are as a species. Yeah.
- 2:14:11I mean, we have the information, but we don't
- 2:14:13know what to do with it. Exactly. We don't want
- 2:14:16to embody it. Yes. Chimpanzees can use human
- 2:14:19language. Now what? That's why I love the Hitchhiker's
- 2:14:23Guide to the Galaxy and just also using... like
- 2:14:28humor to help us humans, you know, see ourselves
- 2:14:31from the outside and see the pride that we might
- 2:14:35have the way we see ourselves, because it really
- 2:14:38helps. I mean, just taking that example, for
- 2:14:40instance, as, you know, aliens coming or coming
- 2:14:45and just looking at us and how we are doing things
- 2:14:49and just, you know, they're super smart or AI,
- 2:14:51whatever, you know, the beings might be. And
- 2:14:55just seeing ourselves from the outside, just
- 2:14:58like in the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy,
- 2:15:01where the animals are like, no, we knew what
- 2:15:02was going on. I love that so much. I think it
- 2:15:08does something with us. I think that's why I
- 2:15:10do think that culture has a huge role to play
- 2:15:12in this, because it helps us in our imagination
- 2:15:16to also envision another world, and a world that
- 2:15:21is very much here already, because we live in
- 2:15:23an interconnected world. our role might be different
- 2:15:26in this new envisioned world or our feelings
- 2:15:30or our mindsets but just like helping us envision
- 2:15:33these worlds and help us envision it's just like
- 2:15:38how how humans might be perceived by other animals
- 2:15:42it's like are we to quote like Franz de Waal
- 2:15:46are we smart enough to know how smart animals
- 2:15:48are are are we or maybe we are smart enough but
- 2:15:52maybe we we just don't as you say, we're not
- 2:15:55ready. Because it would just, again, then our
- 2:16:02human exceptionalistic argumentations would not
- 2:16:05work anymore. And wouldn't that be a bliss? I
- 2:16:09look forward to the day. Well, I think it's a
- 2:16:15great way to end the conversation. Ellen, thank
- 2:16:19you so much for having accepted my invitation
- 2:16:21and for having answered my question. What an
- 2:16:25interesting and fascinating and inspiring conversation
- 2:16:27we had. I will certainly be thinking about it
- 2:16:31in the coming days. So, Ellen, thank you again.
- 2:16:36Thank you so much. It was great. Thank you everyone
- 2:16:40for listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 2:16:43podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 2:16:46more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 2:16:50so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday
- 2:16:53for a new episode.