Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / BC Conservative Justice Plans, Defending Chickens from a Dog, and Easement Stairs
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment, joined as always by barrister and solicitor with Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, legally speaking on CFAX 1070.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Morning, Michael.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: Hey, good morning.
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:11Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: Some interesting topics for the show this week Up first I'm reading provincial criminal justice reform proposals Workable or not.
- 0:19Adam Stirling: We've heard a number of them pitched as part of the election campaign recently.
- 0:25Michael Mulligan: Yeah, I thought this would be a good time to talk about these.
- 0:26Michael Mulligan: We've now seen some of the early poll results following the leaders debate in BC the other night.
- 0:33Adam Stirling: Yes.
- 0:34Michael Mulligan: And with the Conservatives, now appears to be having a growing but small lead over the NDP, and the prediction predictions appear to be, again with a small lead likelihood that they'll wind up with the most seats, and so I thought it would be a good time to talk about some of the proposals they've made with respect to the criminal justice system and public safety.
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: That's been a significant issue in the campaign, and so I reread with interest what their proposals were in that regard, and I must say there's a mixture, as with many of these things, right, some of the proposals seem like ones that are likely to be workable and to advance things, and some less so, so I thought I'd start with some of the things that they've proposed that would appear to be helpful and would have, I think, a chance of improving things in the criminal justice system.
- 1:29Michael Mulligan: One of the things which they've listed here is a proposal to hire more sheriffs and judges to clear the court backlog.
- 1:36Michael Mulligan: That's a good idea, although it is important to remember there are various elements we require for a criminal trial to proceed.
- 1:45Michael Mulligan: Certainly, the judge is obviously pretty important, right?
- 1:48Michael Mulligan: We also, however, need a sheriff, and we've had a shortage of sheriffs in BC, a chronic one, and it's a result of, frankly, not paying the sheriffs enough, and so you wind up with people that are interested in law enforcement.
- 2:01Michael Mulligan: They get training as a sheriff, and then they're often peeled away to join police forces because they could make significantly more money doing that, and so we do need more sheriffs, and ultimately, it's a funding issue.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: But judges and sheriffs aren't enough.
- 2:16Michael Mulligan: You also need Crown counsel, right?
- 2:18Michael Mulligan: You can't have a trial without Crown.
- 2:20Adam Stirling: You need a court clerk right.
- 2:22Michael Mulligan: Without a court clerk, nobody's writing down what the judge is saying.
- 2:25Michael Mulligan: That's not much good.
- 2:26Michael Mulligan: We need that.
- 2:26Michael Mulligan: You also need a physical courtroom and finally, you need defense counsel, and the reality is that many criminal accused have no money, right?
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: The people that are laying face down on the pavement do not have money to hire a lawyer, and so that really means for many of the accused, that means legal aid funding.
- 2:44Michael Mulligan: Have money to hire a lawyer, and so that really means for many of the accused, that means legal aid funding.
- 2:48Michael Mulligan: So you need all of those things to make your criminal trial proceed promptly.
- 2:52Michael Mulligan: And what has happened for many years I've seen this for all five years in the criminal justice system is it often gets dealt with as a crisis for one of those areas Like, oh my goodness, we don't have enough judges.
- 3:04Michael Mulligan: Hire some, right, or the sheriffs have all quit, and then they hire some more sheriffs, right, and we saw a couple of years ago hire a bunch of Crown Council.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: Okay, well, that's fine, but you need all of those things.
- 3:16Michael Mulligan: And so that's a good proposal right, the hiring sheriffs and judges, but we need to also hire more court clerks.
- 3:24Michael Mulligan: We need to build or reopen physical courtrooms.
- 3:27Michael Mulligan: A number of years ago, a whole bunch of provincial courts were closed all over the province.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: We're still dealing with the effects of that and you need proper legal aid funding.
- 3:36Michael Mulligan: So you need to have all of those things there if you want trials to proceed.
- 3:39Michael Mulligan: So a good idea, but we need to make sure all those things are kept in balance.
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: But we need to make sure all those things are kept in balance.
- 3:49Michael Mulligan: They've also made a proposal saying to create a new statutory court to hold trials for small criminal offenses within one week of arrest instead of 12 to 18 months at present.
- 3:56Michael Mulligan: So there are a few things to break down there.
- 3:59Michael Mulligan: I should say it's not ordinarily the case that criminal trials are 12 to 18 month mark.
- 4:05Michael Mulligan: 18 months is the, in fact, the constitutional maximum where charges will presumptively be stayed for not having been conducted within a reasonable period of time, and we are seeing cases that are falling over that 18 month mark and being stayed as a result of delay, and that's not acceptable for anyone in the criminal justice system.
- 4:23Michael Mulligan: Most trials are not going to be at the 18-month mark, although the way the system is currently set up is.
- 4:31Michael Mulligan: The thing just runs right on the edge right.
- 4:34Michael Mulligan: We have just enough courtrooms and court clerks to sort of keep things together usually, but if anything small goes awry, you know, whatever sheriffs are sick that day or a witness doesn't attend or whatever cases just can readily fall over the maximum and wind up being stayed for delay.
- 4:54Michael Mulligan: But the other thing to know about that one week may be an unrealistic, a laudable goal.
- 5:01Michael Mulligan: I should say that we don't necessarily need a new statutory court.
- 5:05Michael Mulligan: We have the provincial court where the overwhelming number of criminal cases are tried, and in fact there's a number of pilot projects including one in Victoria which is an interesting one that may want to be increased or expanded elsewhere if there are the resources to do it where the trial coordinators will schedule trials that are like relatively simple matters, like sort of shoplifting or breach of probation or things of that sort, and they will schedule them all on one day of the week and many more than will possibly proceed in the same courtroom, and the theory of that is that many of those cases they're very unlikely to proceed right.
- 5:46Michael Mulligan: It's sort of you know, the person was caught red-handed with the cheese in their pants or whatever at the store that's very unlikely to actually proceed to a trial right.
- 5:56Michael Mulligan: Many of those things just turn into guilty pleas and so they've scheduled these days where they just stack up a whole bunch of these things like cordwood, and then they often get sorted out on that day and if you had additional resources you could have trials scheduled in that way for that kind of minor offense much more quickly and that actually would have an impact.
- 6:17Michael Mulligan: We've talked before about bail and whether that's really the fundamental problem.
- 6:21Michael Mulligan: It's not in my view.
- 6:23Michael Mulligan: But when you have minor offenses, one of the issues is this let's say you've got somebody who's been charged, you know for the third time, with theft of cheese or batteries or condoms or something right.
- 6:34Michael Mulligan: That's the profile.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: And if the judge knows that if they detain the person they're going to spend nine months, say, in jail waiting for their trial, spend nine months, say, in jail waiting for their trial, a judge may be very reluctant to do that because it's unlikely the person is going to receive a nine-month sentence for the cheese theft even if they're convicted.
- 6:51Michael Mulligan: But if you had enough resources court clerks, sheriffs, judges and so forth that the trial.
- 6:57Michael Mulligan: Maybe we can't do it in one week, but let's say the trial would be in three weeks or a month.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: Right, you may very well have a different analysis and say look, I'm terribly sorry, sir, we've let you out three times and you've once again stolen cheese or batteries.
- 7:10Michael Mulligan: I appreciate that's not in itself particularly significant, but you're not following your conditions of release.
- 7:14Michael Mulligan: We have resources to have a trial, you know, two weeks from now, and so I'm terribly sorry, but you're being detained and you would likely have a different outcome on that kind of a bail hearing if you had resources to do those things.
- 7:27Michael Mulligan: It doesn't necessarily require a separate court, but it does require more of all of those factors that we just talked about in order to allow things like that sort of summary trial court to be expanded and operate efficiently.
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: And so there's a core of a good idea there.
- 7:42Michael Mulligan: I don't know that it requires a separate court and one week may be optimistic, but I think if we had the resources to get that time down significantly, it would have a real impact for the sort of public disorder offenses I could call it that you know, breaching their conditions by having drug paraphernalia, or the person who's you know doing things of that sort missing the appointment with their bail supervisor.
- 8:11Michael Mulligan: That's sort of minor offenses, but cumulatively they wind up you know, mischief, things like that, right, and cumulatively those do have an impact on people.
- 8:17Michael Mulligan: So there's a core of a good idea there, with a slight modification.
- 8:21Michael Mulligan: Another interesting proposal that the BC Conservatives have made is an idea to make audio recordings of all court proceedings available online.
- 8:29Michael Mulligan: That's an interesting one, I should say.
- 8:32Michael Mulligan: Technologically that's easily done.
- 8:34Michael Mulligan: All court proceedings are digitally recorded and in fact they are available online through a very secure system for lawyers and judges involved with the case.
- 8:42Michael Mulligan: They're also made available to accredited members of the media, so a reporter can get a copy of a court recording to listen to it, to make sure they're accurately reporting on what's going on.
- 8:53Michael Mulligan: Yes, but they're not broadly available to the public and lawyers or judges or reporters are not permitted to just post the thing on Facebook or, you know, play it on the radio, right?
- 9:02Michael Mulligan: No, it's to allow reporting on it.
- 9:04Michael Mulligan: Yes, now I think generally more light is good on the criminal justice system and I don't think you get too much pushback from people who are participants in the criminal justice system.
- 9:14Michael Mulligan: There is likely to be some pushback from complainants or witnesses.
- 9:17Michael Mulligan: Sometimes people have concerns about being publicly identified or concerns about reprisals, things of that sort, and there are some categories of cases, like sexual assault cases, where there are prohibitions on identifying the complainant, for example, and so I think there's a good inclination there and the technology is there, but it would need to be managed to take into account those other considerations.
- 9:41Michael Mulligan: So all of those are in the categories of good ideas, perhaps with some modification.
- 9:45Michael Mulligan: A couple of the proposals, however, that have been made, I don't think would be effective.
- 9:49Michael Mulligan: The proposals, whoever that have been made, I don't think would be effective.
- 9:53Michael Mulligan: One of the proposals that would be on the less workable end is to suggest that there'd be a crackdown by toughening charge approval by Crown.
- 9:59Michael Mulligan: That's to suggest that currently the Crown needs to be persuaded there's a substantial likelihood of conviction before they approve a charge.
- 10:08Michael Mulligan: If there isn't, they won't approve it.
- 10:09Michael Mulligan: Lowering that would not be a wise idea.
- 10:12Michael Mulligan: It would just produce a bunch of charges for which there was no substantial likelihood the person would be convicted and you would simply clog the criminal justice system and further delay trials with cases where the lawyer who's looked at the report and evidence the police have gathered have just said no, it's just not likely this person's being convicted.
- 10:29Michael Mulligan: I don't think we advance things by having trials of that kind.
- 10:33Michael Mulligan: It would just slow things down and there are big implications for charging somebody where there's no substantial likelihood they're going to be convicted.
- 10:41Michael Mulligan: So I don't know that that would be a good one, even though it might feel satisfying for some.
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: And the final one that I don't know that has much merit is the idea that the province should quote fight for mandatory minimum sentences for violent offenders to put them behind bars.
- 10:56Michael Mulligan: That sounds satisfying, but criminal sentencing is federal.
- 11:01Michael Mulligan: The province has no control over it and, as well, mandatory minimum sentences are shown to be ineffective.
- 11:07Michael Mulligan: They don't actually deter crime.
- 11:09Michael Mulligan: There isn't an underlying problem with judges not sentencing people properly who are convicted.
- 11:14Michael Mulligan: If there is a problem with an individual case, we have a remedy for that.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: It's called an appeal.
- 11:19Michael Mulligan: And so the other impact of mandatory minimum sentences.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: They don't take account fact patterns.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: Just nobody thought of right.
- 11:27Michael Mulligan: Like you know, we used to have a mandatory minimum for having a handgun with readily accessible ammunition.
- 11:32Michael Mulligan: It was like two years in prison and everyone had in mind yeah, that's for gang members in downtown Toronto.
- 11:37Michael Mulligan: But I remember in Victoria a fellow who was like a World War II veteran, 80-something years of age, coming in with a cane and all his medals on, and somehow they found a police had found a Luger with some bullets from the Second World War He'd taken off a German officer and he was charged with that and repeatedly coming into court with his cane, facing this two-year jail sentence, which would be ridiculous and so mandatory.
- 12:00Michael Mulligan: Minimum sentences don't account for human realities, which are not always what we have in mind when we come up with them.
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: And then the other effect of it is they just produce trials because there's no incentive for somebody to plead guilty, right, if you tell that veteran, well, it's two years.
- 12:13Michael Mulligan: If you plead guilty to that offense, guess what's happening?
- 12:16Michael Mulligan: Not guilty, I guess right.
- 12:17Michael Mulligan: And so you just have a trial when one otherwise shouldn't have occurred.
- 12:21Michael Mulligan: Yeah, he probably shouldn't have had the Luger from 1943, but does he need to go to prison for two years?
- 12:27Michael Mulligan: Probably not.
- 12:28Michael Mulligan: Maybe we can just sort that out and take the gun away, right, and so that one is in the category of not so good.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: So there's lots to be seen there.
- 12:36Michael Mulligan: I think there really is some opportunity to improve things and I think it's going to be very interesting to see what happens over the next few days.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: Voting starts today, and so we'll see whether these things are turned into legislative proposals, perhaps before too long.
- 12:51Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest on criminal justice proposals from the Conservative Party.
- 12:55Adam Stirling: Legally speaking on CFAX 1070 with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 12:59Adam Stirling: We'll continue right after this.
- 13:00Adam Stirling: All right, we're back on the air here at CFAX 1070, legally speaking, as we continue with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 13:07Adam Stirling: Michael, after we did a scan of the various proposals that are on tap in the bc election, uh, the next story is sort of interesting.
- 13:15Adam Stirling: It asks a curious hypothetical that I've never actually had to consider personally and yet I'm sure at least somewhere in the vast, endless array of and diversity of human affairs, someone has asked to ask themselves can you shoot a dog to protect your chickens?
- 13:30Michael Mulligan: sometimes, okay answer it depends.
- 13:33Michael Mulligan: There's actually it depends, I guess, with most things, and so there was a case dealing with exactly this fact pattern and the circumstance involved a couple of neighbors who had had a dispute for a number of years, and much of the friction appeared to involve the one of them kept a bunch of chickens and the other had some dogs, and the dog-owning household apparently had four dogs, two described as Burmese mountain dogs, crossed with wolves, not sure what those look like and then, on the complete other end of the dog continuum, two small chihuahuas, and so that's what you had on one side of the fence small chihuahuas, and so that's what you had on one side of the fence.
- 14:13Michael Mulligan: And on the other side of the fence you had a person who was keeping 60 chickens for eggs, and there had been apparently disputes over the years as dogs had gotten at the chickens, allegedly.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: But on the particular day in question what happened is the neighbor with the dogs had built a better fence to try to contain the dogs, but nonetheless a hole got chewed through the fence and one of the two chihuahuas went through the hole.
- 14:41Michael Mulligan: The chihuahua, unlike the Burmese mountain dog-wolf combo, was described as being four pounds in size, so not very big, and the neighbor with the chickens heard a ruckus and ultimately wound up taking a .22 rifle and shooting the chihuahua, and so he was charged with doing that and the case proceeded on the basis of was that
- 15:11Michael Mulligan: allowed?
- 15:12Michael Mulligan: Now, yes, the man who shot the Chihuahua thought he could rely on an act, a BC act called the Livestock Act, and the Livestock Act in fact deals expressly with the issue of dogs and livestock, and it says this section 11.1, sub 2.
- 15:30Michael Mulligan: A person may kill a dog if the person finds the dog A running at large and B attacking or viciously pursuing livestock period.
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: And you might also ask yourself the question well, can you shoot a dog?
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: What about the gun?
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: And indeed, in BC we have another act called the Farm Practices Protection Act, the Right to Farm.
- 15:53Adam Stirling: Act.
- 15:54Michael Mulligan: And one of the things that act does is it provides that farmers somebody who's a farmer, that's defined in the act they are exempt from sections of the community charter that do things, including put restrictions on the use of firearms.
- 16:08Michael Mulligan: And so even if you're a farmer and even if your municipality says you couldn't use a firearm to defend your livestock for example, let's imagine your sheep's being attacked by a wolf you'd be able to use a firearm to protect your sheep from the wolf.
- 16:21Michael Mulligan: Now the problem for the man in the case that Chihuahua had the chickens, is that that term, livestock, is defined in that act, and it's defined this way Livestock means cattle, goats, horses, sheep, swine and game.
- 16:37Michael Mulligan: Livestock means cattle, goats, horses, sheep, swine and game and other animals designated by regulation.
- 16:43Michael Mulligan: The problem is the chicken is not designated and is none of the above, and so because of that, that act does not apply.
- 16:49Michael Mulligan: And so the man who shot the Chihuahua whose name, by the way, was Bear his next defense was protection of property, and you do have a common law right to use force to protect your property, and that's preserved in the criminal code.
- 17:12Michael Mulligan: Yes, and so the issue then became was that what he was doing?
- 17:17Michael Mulligan: And that particular question turned on this man's evidence, and I should say the man who shot the dog apparently had some cognitive difficulties.
- 17:27Michael Mulligan: He'd suffered from a couple of strokes which he testified impacted his memory, and so, for example, in his direct examination he alleged that he fired two warning shots before shooting Bear, but then, in cross-examination, stated that he shot three times at Bear and hit Bear on the third try.
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: And then as well there was some inconsistency.
- 17:50Michael Mulligan: He had originally said that Bear had feathers in his I think mouth, but then admitted that that was a prior occasion when one of the chihuahuas had feathers in the mouth, and on this occasion there were no feathers in Bear's mouth.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: Furthermore, eventually, after cross-examination, it became clear that Bear was retreating by the point the .22 rifle was brought out, and then the man had made a comment in cross-examination that he had shot Bear because he had quote had enough, and so ultimately the judge concluded that the Livestock Act didn't apply because it's chickens, and furthermore the defense of property didn't apply here because at the time the man shot the Chihuahua, the chihuahua did not have feathers in its mouth and it was going the other way, apparently back towards the hole in the fence, and the judge pointed out, there were other things the man could have done.
- 18:47Michael Mulligan: He could have thrown something at the chihuahua or yelled to scare the chihuahua off,
- 18:51Michael Mulligan: whatever.
- 18:52Michael Mulligan: And so the answer to the question is sometimes and it would depend on what exactly is going on there may well have been a different answer in this case, had the chihuahua had the chicken in its mouth or something, but here the dog was retreating.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: You would also have a different answer if you had a different sort of animal you were protecting.
- 19:11Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, we've created a hierarchy of animals, some of whom I suppose are deserving of more protection.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: Hierarchy of animals some of whom I suppose are deserving of more protection.
- 19:17Michael Mulligan: I guess we just have a higher degree of need to protect swine as opposed to chickens.
- 19:23Michael Mulligan: But there we are.
- 19:24Michael Mulligan: That's what the legislation says.
- 19:26Michael Mulligan: So in this case, bear could not be shot, but that does not mean that in every case the answer would be the same.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: It's going to turn on why something happened and why and when it occurred.
- 19:37Michael Mulligan: So that's whether you can use a gun to protect your chickens.
- 19:40Adam Stirling: We have two and a half minutes left.
- 19:42Adam Stirling: I'm reading does an easement to access the beach allow stairs to be built for this purpose?
- 19:46Adam Stirling: And it's a case from North Saanich.
- 19:49Michael Mulligan: Yes, so interesting case.
- 19:50Michael Mulligan: It's a case that involves exactly what you said an easement, two properties, one waterfront, the other right behind the waterfront property, and the owners.
- 19:59Michael Mulligan: For many years the two properties were friends and before the owners for the property on the ocean sold their property, they granted an easement to the owners who were their friends in the property behind, for the sum total of $1.
- 20:13Michael Mulligan: And the easement authorized access to the beach along a strip of land of the waterfront property.
- 20:20Michael Mulligan: What then happened?
- 20:22Michael Mulligan: Properties changed hands, the property on the water changed hands and previously, when the two owners were friends, the back property owners would walk along and use stairs owned by the waterfront property owner.
- 20:34Michael Mulligan: That was no longer permitted, and the property owner in the rear built a set of wooden stairs to get down to the beach, upsetting the owner of the waterfront property.
- 20:46Michael Mulligan: He said well, you had this easement, but that didn't mean you could build stairs.
- 20:48Michael Mulligan: And they also thought it was then improper for the municipality of North Saanich to have retroactively granted a permit for the stairs.
- 20:57Michael Mulligan: Right, they didn't ask for a permit, but later got one, and so the waterfront property owner was suing both the rear property owner and the municipality, arguing they didn't have any right to do what they had done.
- 21:09Michael Mulligan: It required the judge to interpret.
- 21:10Michael Mulligan: What does this easement mean?
- 21:12Michael Mulligan: It doesn't expressly say you could build stairs.
- 21:15Michael Mulligan: It says that the easement is so that you can, on foot, access the waterfront from the rear property.
- 21:21Michael Mulligan: But the judge pointed out that an easement needs to be interpreted like a contract, which is to say, to try to determine well, what does this mean?
- 21:30Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 21:30Michael Mulligan: And the judge concluded that, even though it didn't expressly say you could build stairs, because the slope down to the water was so steep nobody could safely access it without stairs.
- 21:42Michael Mulligan: The judge concluded that the clear purpose of the agreement in granting the easement, the purpose of it was to allow the rear property owners to get down to the beach, not to have a hollow right to go to a cliff edge and be unable to get down there, and so, even though it wasn't specified, the judge found that there was authority to do that.
- 22:00Michael Mulligan: Furthermore, even though the relevant bylaws don't deal with the issue of whether an easement owner is an owner to get a permit, the judge concluded that the North Saanich had reasonably interpreted the community charter to include that Otherwise there would be no way for the easement owner to get a permit to build the stairs.
- 22:21Michael Mulligan: And finally, the judge pointed out that even though the property owners, who still own the property for where there's an easement, they were concerned that well, there'd be liability for the stairs.
- 22:30Michael Mulligan: The judge concluded no, the law is that if the beneficial owner of the easement constructs something like that, doesn't maintain it, and there's like a law somebody slips down the stairs, they're on the hook, not the property owner.
- 22:42Michael Mulligan: So the result is the easement, even though it didn't say you could build something, allowed for it, on the basis that that's what was intended.
- 22:49Michael Mulligan: That's the latest from the stairs in North Saanich.
- 22:51Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan during the second half of our second hour, legally speaking on CFAX 1070 every Thursday.
- 22:56Adam Stirling: Michael, pleasure as always.