Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Board Focus: Staff Morale & Safety of Credit Union Deposits
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with some breaking news, uh, from the
- 0:04NCUA board , the NCUA board held their first board meeting since Kyle Hauptman
- 0:10was named chairman by President Trump.
- 0:13And they can't act on much because regulations are frozen, right?
- 0:19So they originally had two items on their agenda, the NCUSIF.
- 0:24Briefing, which is where they release camel data, and that was kind of ho hum.
- 0:29There was pretty much no change there, although the board did,
- 0:32say we have to remain vigilant.
- 0:34Harper made some comments about Code 3s becoming Code 4s in complex
- 0:40credit unions, over 500 million.
- 0:44Which was interesting, but the big focus was two things, NCOA staff
- 0:50morale, and the insurance fund, , and the fact that there have been no losses
- 0:55on insured credit union deposits.
- 0:57Why are these two things, , paramount to NCOA right now?
- 1:00Because of, , the many Donald Trump President Donald Trump, presidential
- 1:06orders that are impacting federal agencies, the hiring freeze, the
- 1:10buyout, the lack of independence for independent agencies, which I've
- 1:15discussed here with the discussions about the possibility of the banking
- 1:19regulators being merged, including NCUA.
- 1:22By the way, I did a podcast yesterday with John Ney about, the real and
- 1:26imagined fears as it relates to that.
- 1:28And time will tell how that works out.
- 1:30But there's the fear of reorganization, the fear of losing your job, et cetera,
- 1:35et cetera, which reminds me before I go any further, there's a quote that I
- 1:40used to refer to about reorganizations a lot because reorganizations.
- 1:44Cause chaos, and they've been causing chaos since, uh, at least 2010 BC
- 1:50when Petronius the Arbiter said, we trained hard, but every time we formed
- 1:54up teams, we would be reorganized.
- 1:57I was to learn that we meet any new situation by reorganizing and a wonderful
- 2:02method it can be for creating the illusion of progress while producing confusion,
- 2:07inefficiency, and demoralization.
- 2:10There's also another quote that relates to that I am reminded of and this is,
- 2:17it is, it must be remembered that there is nothing more difficult to plan, more
- 2:22doubtful of success, nor more dangerous to manage than the creation of a new system.
- 2:28For the initiator.
- 2:30That would be Trump, and Musk, has the enmity, FYI, enmity means hatred, of all
- 2:37who would profit by the preservation of the old institutions and merely lukewarm
- 2:41defenders and those who would gain by the new ones, and that's, Niccolo Machiavelli.
- 2:46There's a lot of concern from NCOA staff about reorganization, there's a
- 2:50lot of concern about, is my job safe?
- 2:54And think about this, you've got probationary employees
- 2:56who are relatively, generally speaking, brand new to government.
- 3:00And when they see these things in the press, they don't know the truth.
- 3:04They don't know the falsehoods.
- 3:06They don't know what is going to do.
- 3:08Some agencies are getting rid of all their.
- 3:10, probationary employees.
- 3:11Some agencies are accepting everybody who applies, to the eight month buyout.
- 3:16And there's chaos at NCA right now.
- 3:18And you can tell that there's chaos because they focused on staff morale
- 3:22because they made reference to the executive director saying that he
- 3:25heard that it was great to see the operating fee schedule come out.
- 3:29From credit unions, , from the, from, excuse me, from the NCUA board.
- 3:33And why?
- 3:34Because it's mundane.
- 3:35The NCUA staff are getting deluged with press about, the inadequacies of federal
- 3:41government, about fraud, waste, and abuse, which I think is very minimal at NCUA.
- 3:45, I think the IG there does an amazing job, , editorial comment.
- 3:48And the reality is, there is chaos, there is concern, and N.
- 3:54C.
- 3:54U.
- 3:55A.
- 3:55Staff, , being pleased to see something mundane as opposed to be getting messages
- 4:00saying, you need to tell us, tell me the 5 things you achieved this week.
- 4:04There's chaos there, and it's clear that, N.
- 4:07C.
- 4:07U.
- 4:07A.
- 4:07Board is is.
- 4:09Showing leadership, by making statements that they have open
- 4:13door policies to remain calm.
- 4:15The other side of remaining calm is they don't want, , a run to happen
- 4:19at credit unions, just like the banks don't want runs to happen at banks.
- 4:23And there is a podcast I want to refer you to in that regard.
- 4:28It's the banking with interest podcast had an episode today called what the hell is
- 4:34going on part two merging OCC and FDIC.
- 4:37So they talk about the mergers but they talk about all the weird messages that
- 4:42the host and the guests are getting as it relates to the insurance fund of the DIF.
- 4:47Kyle Houtman made reference to that, that he was on Reddit looking
- 4:51up things about NCUA, although I couldn't find them when I looked.
- 4:55I'm sure they're out there, but they're getting messages about the safety of
- 4:58the insurance fund and the fund is safe.
- 5:00Have less than 250, 000 at a bank or at a credit union.
- 5:04You're going to get your money back.
- 5:05So remain calm as it relates to that, but it's clear they want staff.
- 5:09Um, to find some solace in the fact that the board, , isn't going to
- 5:14overreact any more than they might have to related to these things.
- 5:17But, , it remains to be seen how many people do leave N.
- 5:20C.
- 5:20U.
- 5:20A.
- 5:20I've spoke to the fact that I think exam cycles are going to get elongated.
- 5:25I think staff turnover will go up.
- 5:27There'll be people.
- 5:29What happens in these instances is people who can leave and have other
- 5:32alternatives, just go pursue them.
- 5:33A lot of people will be leaving NCUA because of that.
- 5:36There'll be people leaving because of the fact they don't want to take it anymore.
- 5:40They'll be leaving because, hey, I was going to retire in June, so
- 5:43just give me my six months anyway.
- 5:45And then what remains to be seen is how NCUA will respond as it
- 5:49relates to probationary employees.
- 5:52The other takeaway I want to mention here is originally there were two items on the
- 5:56NCUA agenda, the NCUSAF briefing and an item to make somebody presumably Almost
- 6:03certainly, Harper, vice chair at NCUA.
- 6:08Now there's no requirement to have a vice chair, but Hauptmann had decided to do it.
- 6:13Then it mysteriously disappeared from the agenda.
- 6:15They didn't talk about it.
- 6:17I put a post on right before the board meeting, when I realized
- 6:20this, that NCUA had pulled it.
- 6:22And by the way, I don't believe they complied with.
- 6:24The sunshine rules relative to that, if something gets pulled, they're supposed
- 6:29to say, Hey, we had to pull it because of matters that we can't get into.
- 6:34And we didn't have time to notify the public, but we've
- 6:36pulled that from the agenda.
- 6:38I think there was a conscious decision not to do that because
- 6:42I'm sure that the general council would have advised them to do that.
- 6:45It's interesting they chose not to do it or that there was an
- 6:48error and they didn't do that.
- 6:49But I had, posited that.
- 6:52They could have voted by notation vote and then talked about the fact they did it.
- 6:57But since there was no reference to how Harper being the vice chair,
- 7:01there was no reference to the fact that they were contemplating it.
- 7:04I believe Hauptmann decided it wasn't wise to make a Democrat the vice chair
- 7:10right now because of the state of politics, or somebody told him that
- 7:14he shouldn't do it and they pulled it.
- 7:16, And I'm not exactly sure when that fell off.
- 7:18I noticed it this morning.
- 7:20, and that is very, very curious.
- 7:23All right.
- 7:23So here's about 10 minutes of the NCUA board talking about the safety
- 7:27of the insurance fund, talking about the importance of staff morale,
- 7:31all good news for NCUA staff.
- 7:32It was a feel good meeting from that perspective.
- 7:35Lastly, if you're going to be at GAC and you want to chat, let me know.
- 7:40I will see you there.
- 7:41I'll be there Monday and Tuesday and we'll be recording some short
- 7:45snippets for the podcast and reporting that here via the podcast.
- 7:51All right, without further ado, here is the NCUA board.
- 7:56Hauptman: Morning everyone.
- 7:57I call this meeting of the SRA Board to order.
- 7:59, this is my first board meeting.
- 8:00I'm the chairman.
- 8:01It's an honor.
- 8:02I serve as the 13th chairman of NCUA and advance the priorities for
- 8:06growth, opportunity, and innovation in the credit union system.
- 8:09I want to thank the president for his trust in me.
- 8:11I also want to thank my colleague Todd Harper for his service through
- 8:13some challenging times for NCUA and the credit union system.
- 8:16So as the last few weeks, there have been a flurry of executive
- 8:19orders, uh, affecting the federal workforce, including us.
- 8:23Some of those directives may bring changes to NCUA.
- 8:27All of us at this table understand that change and uncertainty can be
- 8:32challenging for a number of parties.
- 8:33The credit union system, stakeholders, and most definitely NCUA employees.
- 8:39All of us at NCUA, including the board, are diligently assessing
- 8:42how these announcements may affect NCUA, our operations, regulatory
- 8:46structures, and our workforce.
- 8:48To my colleagues at NCUA who may be watching, the work each of you does every
- 8:55day keeps our credit union system thriving and keeps our credit union members strong.
- 9:00There's also loads of misinformation and rumor out there.
- 9:02I've spent some time recently reading forums on Reddit that touch
- 9:06on NCUA or federal employees, and there is some crazy stuff out there.
- 9:10There's people moving their money out of banks and credit unions and
- 9:14buying treasury bonds or gold because they think, they hear that federal
- 9:17deposit insurance is going away.
- 9:19And that's not even one of the crazy rumors.
- 9:22Let's continue to stay focused on our mission and we, the board, will
- 9:25continue to support your work as we navigate any changes together.
- 9:30Thank you for your patience and your dedication to NCUA.
- 9:33One thing that struck me last week, our executive director mentioned how much NCUA
- 9:39staff liked seeing an email about this year's fee schedule for credit unions.
- 9:44And I was curious why a fairly routine, mundane topic would
- 9:48generate a positive reaction.
- 9:50But it was precisely because it was mundane, and now it made sense to me,
- 9:56it was a sign that the big picture hasn't changed, NCUA business continues.
- 10:00The normalcy of it was positive and reassuring.
- 10:05Uh, when I asked any of my 1, 200 colleagues here at NCUA to reach
- 10:08out to me anytime, by phone, teams, email, Uh, well, we on the board
- 10:13don't have any more info on White House directives than anyone else.
- 10:17I'm happy to talk to you about problems and possible solutions.
- 10:19I'll tell you what I know and don't know.
- 10:22And to the people we work for, the 142 million Americans who pay into
- 10:25the Share Insurance Fund, know that NCWA's mission is unchanged.
- 10:29There are still 4, 500 credit units to examine, and most importantly, 20 million
- 10:34or so Share Insurance Fund that is the true north for each of us on the board.
- 10:38Our deposit insurance is unchanged.
- 10:40The exams are continuing just like the rest of the work here.
- 10:43Be assured we have not taken our eye off the ball.
- 10:46We're aware that uncertainty, uh, surrounding one's employer and job
- 10:51isn't new for credit union members.
- 10:52Many credit unions were founded by employee groups of
- 10:55companies that no longer exist.
- 10:57Also, just in the four years I've been on the board, we've lost a thousand
- 11:00credit unions in this country.
- 11:02We're aware that most Americans, the people who pay my salary,
- 11:05live a daily reality of uncertainty that we're creating.
- 11:08situation.
- 11:10Uh, in a normal year, like this year, about 10 million Americans
- 11:13lose their job in the normal churn.
- 11:15Four years ago, 21 million job, 21 million Americans lost their job in one month.
- 11:19So just, I want to send a message that we at NCA, we understand the way the
- 11:23real world works and the people who pay us, we understand their reality.
- 11:27So maybe just grant us a bit of grace as we adjust to work
- 11:31through these changes here at NCA.
- 11:33And again, your money is safe.
- 11:34In the NCA insurance fund and it's safe at NCA insured Credit unions.
- 11:38Our NCA staff are professionals and they, and credit union members should know.
- 11:42The management around here has worked around the clock to ensure we still
- 11:45meet the needs of America's credit union members and my outstanding NCA coworkers.
- 11:51And finally, I know as chairman, I could steer some priorities to the agency,
- 11:56but any concrete actions require board approval and that requires some measure
- 11:59of compromise on the part of all parties.
- 12:01Discussions among my colleagues.
- 12:04I've always been in good faith and the spirit of cooperation
- 12:06during my tenure on the board.
- 12:08Through plenty of give and take, none of us gets everything we want, but all
- 12:13of us get usually something we wanted.
- 12:15I look forward to continuing that collaboration with my board
- 12:18colleagues now that I'm chair.
- 12:20That concludes my remarks.
- 12:21I now recognize board member Harper.
- 12:23Harper: uh, Mr.
- 12:24Chairman, uh, and again, let me offer my sincerest congratulations
- 12:29um, on your, uh, progress.
- 12:32new position.
- 12:33I will also say this.
- 12:35Um, as you and I discussed the other day, there are many burdens of being chairman.
- 12:40You really don't have an idea until you sit in the seat.
- 12:44And again, I offer to you Um, my hand to help guide you just as past NCUA
- 12:51chairman have helped guide me, uh, as part of the kitchen cabinet over the years.
- 12:57Um, second, I want to echo, um, our NCUA team of professionals is
- 13:02our greatest asset and resource.
- 13:06They protect people, they protect deposits, and they protect taxpayers
- 13:12from losses at the shared insurance fund.
- 13:14We need to keep that in mind.
- 13:16And we need to continue to demonstrate the compassion that we
- 13:21have worked to build at this agency.
- 13:24And I'm very proud that we've worked to build at this agency
- 13:27over the last several years.
- 13:30Um, as a servant leader, my job, again, is to listen, to learn, and to
- 13:36find ways to lead that bring us to, back to where the chairman suggested.
- 13:42And that is consensus and compromise.
- 13:45I do value all of the work of our NCUA team.
- 13:50I also do want to remind everybody, as the chairman said, that your deposits at
- 13:56federally insured credit unions are safe.
- 13:59Up to at least 250, 000.
- 14:04That hasn't changed.
- 14:05That's not going to change.
- 14:07And that's we're not going to take our eyes off of that at any point in time.
- 14:12With that, I'll end my comments here with what I always send
- 14:15my emails to staff with.
- 14:16And that is be safe.
- 14:18Be well, be kind.
- 14:20Well said.
- 14:20Board Member Oskar, you're recognized.
- 14:23Hauptman: Thank you.
- 14:23Um, excuse me.
- 14:25Uh, I also want to congratulate, uh, Chair Hoffman on his new role.
- 14:30Um, and think, uh, board member Harper, former chair Harper for his leadership.
- 14:35Um, you know, I I do appreciate the board's ability to continue
- 14:39to work together on tough issues.
- 14:41We did so last year, and I think we will continue to do that this
- 14:45year and in the coming years.
- 14:47Um, and I want to, you know, echo some of the comments that have
- 14:51already been made, but Um, you know, I have been deeply troubled by the
- 14:56attacks on the federal workforce who are here to serve the American
- 14:59people and speaking directly to my N.
- 15:02C.
- 15:02U.
- 15:02A.
- 15:02colleagues.
- 15:04I want you to know that as a former career public servant myself, I have
- 15:08the utmost respect and admiration for the work that you do at the N.
- 15:12C.
- 15:12U.
- 15:12A.
- 15:13A lot of you have been in federal service for your entire careers.
- 15:18Many of you are veterans.
- 15:20Many of you have private sector experience as well.
- 15:23Um, so I just want to reiterate my, um, reverence for the work that you do and
- 15:30the dedication with which you do it.
- 15:32Without you all, we would not have a strong examination program.
- 15:36Questions from credit unions and consumers alike would go unanswered.
- 15:40We wouldn't be able to charter new credit unions or process
- 15:43field membership applications or provide technical assistance.
- 15:47Or issued guidance to the credit union industry and the list goes on.
- 15:52Um, so thank you for what you do day in and day out.
- 15:55Um, you are extremely important to the agency as my
- 15:58colleagues have, uh, also said.
- 16:01And I think the continuity of staff and our ability to stay, uh, keep our
- 16:06eyes on the prize, keep our eyes on the mission is extremely important.
- 16:10Um, I also wanna reiterate my open door policy.
- 16:13When I joined the board last year, um.
- 16:15Um, I, I, I noted that and, um, I want to reiterate it, uh, right now.
- 16:21So as you and your teams navigate changes here at NCUA, as you, uh, you know, as
- 16:27you navigate new issues that we may come across from a substantive standpoint,
- 16:31really with anything, please feel free to reach out to me and my staff.
- 16:35Um, I really do have an open door policy.
- 16:38And again, thank you for all the work that you do.
- 16:41Thank you.
- 16:42Thank you.
- 16:43Thank you.
- 16:43Yeah, um.
- 16:43I think we agree.
- 16:44One thing about this, this isn't the Pentagon, the giant 2 million employee
- 16:49thing where like almost no one ever even sees the Secretary of Defense.
- 16:54This isn't the Federal Reserve where it's kind of hard to get an audience
- 16:57with the Federal Reserve chair, even if you're pretty senior at the Fed.
- 17:01We're pretty easy to reach and talk to, and I think that's a good thing.
- 17:05Okay, that's it from , Hollywood, Florida, the NCOA board reporting
- 17:10that staff morale is important.
- 17:12Staff is the number one resources.
- 17:14Your deposits are safe.
- 17:16And one last quote, , Winston Churchill, one of my favorite quotes and one
- 17:21of my daughter's favorite quotes.
- 17:23I said it so much when she was a runner back in high school and
- 17:26college, she got a tattoo of this Winston Churchill quote, which is
- 17:31when going through hell, keep going.
- 17:35That's it.
- 17:36That's a wrap.
- 17:37Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 17:39If you're at GAC and see me, let's chat.
- 17:43Talk to you soon.