Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Why Does Church Music Still Matter in Worship Today? A Conversation with Rick Seaton
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, I finally, after
- 0:04six years of running this podcast, sat down and had a
- 0:08conversation with Rick Seaton, the director of music here at
- 0:11Bethany. He's awesome.
- 0:13We had so much to talk about in terms of our thoughts about
- 0:15worship and about Lutheran worship and Lutheran musical
- 0:19history, and it was super fun. You're going to enjoy it.
- 0:22Here we go. Welcome to the Together for Good
- 0:24Podcast, a podcast created by Bethany Lutheran Church in
- 0:28Cherry Hills Village, Co and hosted by me, Pastor Nate
- 0:32Pricinger and Together for Good. Our goal is to provide
- 0:35practical, engaging content that supports you without
- 0:38expectations. Whether you're feeling
- 0:41disconnected from traditional religion or simply exploring
- 0:44what faith means in your life, we are here to walk alongside
- 0:47you. No matter where you are on your
- 0:50journey of faith, we're glad you're here.
- 0:52Welcome to Together for Good. Welcome everybody to the
- 0:56Together for Good podcast. I'm seated in the sanctuary with
- 1:00the one and only Rick Seaton. Hello, Rick.
- 1:02Thanks for coming on. Thanks, Nate.
- 1:04It has been way too long. I apologize that it's taken five
- 1:07years to finally get you on the podcast.
- 1:09That's on me, not on you. But we're sitting in your
- 1:11favorite spot between the organ and the piano, which you play so
- 1:15well. And I have so many questions for
- 1:17you. We're we're going to really get
- 1:19into that. First and foremost, I just want
- 1:21to hear, and people might not know, how long have you been
- 1:23doing this whole organ? Director of music thing at
- 1:26Bethany. I've been here since July of
- 1:282010. OK, so I guess I'm coming up on
- 1:3216 years. That's a holy.
- 1:33God, that is a long time. But you've been playing organ
- 1:36long before that. Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 1:37I mean, I started playing the piano at age 6, started learning
- 1:40the organ at about 17 and, you know, got a couple music degrees
- 1:46in addition in addition to an MBA, so.
- 1:49Yeah, and I mean, that's the interesting thing too.
- 1:51Before coming to Bethany, you weren't like a a different
- 1:54church as the Yeah. Or were you?
- 1:56I was the organist at Central Presbyterian for about 6 years
- 2:00and at that time my major source of income was piano teaching.
- 2:04Gotcha. Before that, I was in the
- 2:06corporate world for about 12 years.
- 2:08Yeah, in corporate you were. I was in finance.
- 2:11And financing, that's what I thought, yeah.
- 2:13OK. And did you, I mean, growing up,
- 2:16did you have a sense that you wanted to like make music kind
- 2:20of a full time gig if possible or I mean, if you brought in the
- 2:24accounting thing, you must have gone away from that for a while.
- 2:26Just kind of curious the process.
- 2:28I sort of chickened out on music for a while, but yeah.
- 2:30It's not easy. No, it it's not to find a full
- 2:33time job. I mean, a lot of musicians have
- 2:36to just string together a lot of.
- 2:39I mean, I know a lot of people in our choir do that, where I
- 2:41talked to him, like the assistant director, Matthew
- 2:43Ashman, He's like, I have 7 jobs right now and he's always here
- 2:46teaching lessons as one of us. Like, Oh my gosh.
- 2:49Yeah. Just exhausting.
- 2:51But you were fortunate enough you were at Central
- 2:53Presbyterian. But then you grew up Lutheran,
- 2:56correct? Yeah, I grew up.
- 2:58Prince of Peace Lutheran down the street, I grew up like 5
- 3:01minutes from here, you know, just north of the church.
- 3:04So I'd like to brag I'm the most not only a native Coloradan, but
- 3:08I grew up like right next to the church so.
- 3:11Absolutely. And I mean, let's just set the
- 3:13record straight right now. If you were to only choose your
- 3:18faith-based on the breadth of musical accomplishments, like,
- 3:24it would be the Lutheran's like, we have the best music by far
- 3:28and, and like the greatest history of musicianship.
- 3:31I had a friend in college who was Catholic and he's like,
- 3:35yeah, like if it was only about the music, I'd convert to
- 3:37Lutheranism tomorrow. And that's always stuck with me.
- 3:41He had, he had other factors in mind.
- 3:43But like, I mean, just give us what makes you affirm that
- 3:48statement that I'm making because I don't think people
- 3:50recognize and realize just how rich the Lutheran history is,
- 3:54musically speaking. Yeah, Yeah.
- 3:56Well, you could start off with this guy.
- 3:59Maybe you've heard of him. JS Bach.
- 4:01You know. Widely regarded even by secular
- 4:03people as the greatest composer in the history of music you
- 4:08know, and so much of his output was dedicated towards producing
- 4:11music for. The church, correct?
- 4:13So, you know, you have Bach, you have handle, you have
- 4:18Mendelssohn, you have this, you know, this whole line of, of
- 4:22composers going back to well, even before the time of Bach.
- 4:25You know, a lot of those great German composers from, you know,
- 4:29pre Bach times are, are, are also Lutheran.
- 4:31So so yeah, there's no single denomination that that really
- 4:36compares, you know, other than than the Catholic faith.
- 4:39And you know they have a very. They're pretty good too.
- 4:41Yeah, they have a very rich musical tradition as well, which
- 4:43I think they're they're trying to rediscover as well, which is
- 4:46which is wonderful. Yeah, I mean, and that's it's a
- 4:49part that that I lament a lot of the time too, is that I don't
- 4:52think your everyday Lutheran understands just how much this
- 4:57is a part of our DNA and and how deep back it goes.
- 5:01And like you, you mentioned Bach, I mean, the the man was
- 5:04prolific and I don't know how you can create that much music
- 5:07nonetheless, that much musical genius when you really look at
- 5:11it like it's all mathematically based, it seems, in which I
- 5:14can't even fully comprehend. And and he basically wrote music
- 5:19for every Sunday of the church here.
- 5:20Is that fair? Like, I mean, how many works are
- 5:22there? Do you even know?
- 5:24There in the the catalog of Bach works, there's like over 1000
- 5:28things, but some of those are, you know, multi movement works
- 5:32that last a really a long time. So I mean, and then there are as
- 5:35many works we know of that are lost.
- 5:37So it's, it's, it's just it, it, it, you know, it's well over
- 5:411000 if you count individual movements of pieces, it's
- 5:45thousands, You know, it's. It's so crazy and and and again,
- 5:48and each one is just so intricate and carefully put
- 5:52together with Bach. And I know you're not a Bach
- 5:55scholar, but I've always kind of been curious myself how, I mean,
- 5:59he was he writing these just for his congregation.
- 6:04And that was kind of the idea is that he just had a very talented
- 6:07group that he worked with and so would put out these musical
- 6:09pieces on a regular basis for that local church.
- 6:13Or was it always intended to be wider audience, like kind of
- 6:17concert style? I'm just kind of curious about
- 6:19the logistics of it if you know. He would never have expected to
- 6:22be like it performed in a concert.
- 6:24Yes, it was for his local church.
- 6:26Yeah. You know, Leipzig, the last
- 6:28place that he works, you know, being, you know, not a small
- 6:31town but not like the biggest of the big city.
- 6:34Some people consider that a bit of a cultural backwater.
- 6:37So, yeah, he was producing mainly for his own church.
- 6:41And yeah, I mean it, this was a normal thing though, at that
- 6:45time that you would have, you'd have a choir.
- 6:47I mean, he taught at the school. He had, you know, boys from the
- 6:51school as his soprano and Alto voices.
- 6:54And then he had, you know, tenor and bass voices and he had
- 6:57soloists and he had instrumentalists.
- 6:59So, you know, there was a budget for for all this music.
- 7:04But yeah, for it to be the the Kapel Meister at that time, that
- 7:07was expected that you would produce a fair number of, you
- 7:11know, custom, you know, custom works just for the church.
- 7:15And it's, I mean, it's obviously Bach is like a singular talent
- 7:19in all of history. And it doesn't feel like that's
- 7:23how churches tend to work much anymore.
- 7:26It's one of the things I love about Bethany is that, I mean,
- 7:28you and I have worked together on that Advent liturgy that we
- 7:31came up with. And I know you come up with
- 7:33pieces every now and then as well for the choir or your post
- 7:37ludes or or preludes, things like that.
- 7:40But why do, why do you think is it just like a, a talent and a
- 7:43time commitment or is do you feel like we've lost something
- 7:47in terms of how we relate to church and church music?
- 7:51That's that's where this has just become not common at all
- 7:54for people to create works for their local congregation.
- 7:57Right. And yeah, if we as part of
- 8:00reclaiming our historical tradition, that should be
- 8:02considered normal. Absolutely not.
- 8:04Not that you would expect in this day and age, your, you
- 8:07know, music director to write a new cantata.
- 8:10Every single week. But but.
- 8:12Yeah, why aren't you doing that? Slacking off, But yeah, that it
- 8:20should be considered normal. And there are other Lutheran
- 8:22music directors that do a fair amount of that.
- 8:24So either you're creating new stuff or you're finding new
- 8:28things. You know, we talked about the
- 8:30liturgy. That was never, never should be
- 8:35considered normal, that it's like you just sing the same
- 8:37liturgy setting every single day, forever and ever and ever.
- 8:41People might resist having to learn new settings, but it's
- 8:44like that's what it's, you know, reformation or pre reformation.
- 8:50That's not what it's supposed to be like.
- 8:51You're you're supposed to have different settings that you.
- 8:53Yeah, I mean, I mean why? Why are you?
- 8:56Well, hang on. First off, a fun story.
- 8:58At my first church where I was the pastor, if you dropped the
- 9:01hymnal, it would automatically open to LBW setting too, because
- 9:05that was all that they ever used since since Moses time.
- 9:12And it was really fun to like you take any handle, you just
- 9:14drop it and it automatically open there.
- 9:16But why do you think it is so important to be exploring other
- 9:21settings and and having, I mean, if possible, writing music for
- 9:25the sake of the local congregation?
- 9:27Like what? What makes you so strongly
- 9:29committed to that? That's what makes worship
- 9:32interesting, you know, with the framework that the liturgy gives
- 9:35us, a framework, a structure, a skeleton.
- 9:38But then we have the opportunity to, you know, decorate that, if
- 9:42you will. In a good.
- 9:43Way in an interesting way, you know, the line from the Psalms
- 9:47sing to the Lord a new song. So we have these the liturgical
- 9:53traditions goes back. You know, some of these things
- 9:55could be traced back to like early, like the first few
- 9:59centuries, right? And so it's a valuable thing to
- 10:03stay with them. But it's not like we do the
- 10:05exact same thing every week. It's we have different music,
- 10:09different liturgy settings. And the other really cool thing
- 10:13about that is that so much of this music, you know, whether
- 10:17it's hymns or choir anthems, is tailored very, very specifically
- 10:23to, you know, a particular lesson, a particular season,
- 10:28which, you know, a lot of today's question of using
- 10:31doesn't do that. It's just very general and
- 10:33repetitive. It's like, yeah, you have.
- 10:36I mean, it just doesn't matter what liturgical season is or
- 10:39the, the, the lectionary. There are pieces written and
- 10:44hymns written very specifically to fit that theme.
- 10:47To the no, I'm so glad you bring it up because I mean, I think, I
- 10:50think the liturgical seasons give us a window into how to
- 10:53think about this and why it's important, right?
- 10:55Like over the course of a year, because of the liturgical
- 10:58seasons, we confront different stories and different aspects of
- 11:03the Bible and different aspects of the life of faith.
- 11:07And like I always say, people, people complain about Pentecost
- 11:09being so long and I'm like, no, like, I think it's good because
- 11:12part of the life of faith is that you get bored.
- 11:14I think there's something actually wise about us having a
- 11:18really long season where it's like, is it over yet?
- 11:20Is it over yet? Because it's not always about
- 11:22novelty in the life of faith. And and that's just one example,
- 11:25right? If we didn't have Lent, would we
- 11:27go that like self reflective and repentant on our own?
- 11:30I don't think we would, right, right.
- 11:32Like it forces you into these spaces and into the like, just
- 11:36to think about different things that you wouldn't otherwise.
- 11:40And to your point, writing new music, right, you stick within
- 11:43the forms of the liturgy, so it has this ancient rootedness, but
- 11:48then you also get to start exploring it in different ways
- 11:53so that the words don't just become white noise.
- 11:56It's like, like, I never. Is that really what the Curie is
- 11:58about? That's what we're doing here,
- 12:00right? Like, whereas if you just sing
- 12:01the same version every time, it would probably become white
- 12:05noise pretty quickly. Yeah.
- 12:07So. So with all this, I mean, you're
- 12:09hinting at it too, but let's let's talk because there's
- 12:11always so much going on in our Lutheran churches, especially
- 12:16about this like contemporary traditional debate of things.
- 12:20And 1st off, what do you, where do you think that comes from?
- 12:24Like, why? Why are we so concerned with
- 12:27wanting, And I'm, I don't mean Bethany, but I mean like writ
- 12:30large, why is there such an appeal for contemporary worship
- 12:35or historically has there been? Yeah.
- 12:37Well, if you look at sort of the history of the last 30 years of
- 12:43the, you know, sort of the the evangelical non denominational
- 12:48churches, you know, what we saw was like 30 years of just
- 12:53unbridled growth. You know, it's just nothing but
- 12:55explosive growth, you know, for several decades.
- 12:59And so I think people got it into their minds like, well,
- 13:02this is just the future. This is where things are.
- 13:04This is just the way it's. Going to be.
- 13:05From now on. And so now what we're finding in
- 13:09the last, you know, five years at least is like, no, that, that
- 13:14that sort of thing has reached its its peak and is now on the
- 13:19decline. And we have a significant number
- 13:22of people interested in, you know, more traditional things
- 13:25and most notably, a lot of young people.
- 13:28Exactly. And that's what's so encouraging
- 13:30for us is that we're. Well positioned.
- 13:33Yeah. Well, positions to to fill that
- 13:35need. I totally agree.
- 13:36I had people send me articles all the time about anything
- 13:40that's happening in church, which I really appreciate, so
- 13:42please keep doing it. But yeah, there was a Washington
- 13:45Post article about the Catholic Church this Easter performing
- 13:51more conversions and baptisms than like the then in the last
- 13:5520 years. And it's not just one diocese.
- 13:58It was like they listed so many different diocese across the
- 14:03United States. And some of that they're saying,
- 14:05like, is this because of the American Pope?
- 14:07Like, OK, maybe that's a little piece of it.
- 14:10But I also think, I mean, my, my hypothesis is that we have been
- 14:15so saturated with entertainment for so long now and that I think
- 14:20people are just like, I need to, I need something different.
- 14:23Like, I like, I want, I want like quiet and I want structured
- 14:27and I want ancient because I'm so tired of being tied to my
- 14:32phone and being constantly entertained by the next six
- 14:35second clip. And and yeah, like, and so the
- 14:38traditional churches are well suited for this.
- 14:41The other article I saw was about Greek Orthodox seeing a
- 14:45huge explosion in young men returning to church, and they're
- 14:48theorizing maybe for some similar reasons, I don't know.
- 14:51Do you have any thoughts about what is causing the resurgence?
- 14:55I, I think it's just people becoming aware to, you know,
- 15:00the, the frankly, the superficiality of a lot of that
- 15:03type of thing where, yeah, like you said, church is like a show
- 15:08and it's, and it's lights and it's fog machines and it's,
- 15:13it's, it's loud music and it's sitting and consuming something
- 15:18rather than being actively involved in the worship, you
- 15:21know, So in, in our liturgical worship, you know, you sit, you
- 15:24stand, you, you, you say prayers, you sing, you remain
- 15:29engaged. And you don't just sit there and
- 15:31listen to a band for 20 minutes, then listen to somebody speak
- 15:34for 40 minutes. It's.
- 15:35Yeah, nobody needs to listen to me speak for 40 minutes.
- 15:39I would listen to you for 40 minutes.
- 15:41I. Thank you for listening to the
- 15:43Together for Good podcast. But.
- 15:46Yeah, I think that that's a big part of it.
- 15:49I. Think you.
- 15:50Know young people sort of discovering, you know this is
- 15:56this is 30 years later from when this movement started and we're
- 16:01a different generation and this is not you know and of course it
- 16:05doesn't that doesn't speak for all young.
- 16:07People. No.
- 16:07There's a wide variety. Totally of.
- 16:10Opinions. But there is a significant
- 16:11movement within that is like, this is not our, this is not our
- 16:15music. This is not our vibe.
- 16:17And we're looking for something, you know, deeper from church and
- 16:21more rooted in the historic Christian.
- 16:24Faith. Well, and I think too, it's
- 16:25just, it can't be about like, taste because, yeah, people have
- 16:31a variety of different musical tastes.
- 16:33And yeah, I mean, maybe at classical music concerts, it
- 16:37tends to be older individuals who attend those than you know,
- 16:40and the younger ones are at Red Rocks.
- 16:43I'm seeing some sort of band, but that's not entirely true.
- 16:46And the I, I I just believe like that that's the wrong question
- 16:50for church to be asking. Right, Right.
- 16:52Like we're, we're not trying to to entertain you and wow you
- 16:57like we're trying to share with you something a much, much
- 17:00deeper than the surface level tastes, right.
- 17:04And that's just, I think it's how you present whatever it is
- 17:07that you have to offer, right? Like in a church, a Lutheran
- 17:11Church, given our deep DNA and roots in these like incredible
- 17:17pieces of music, like how do how do we just talk about that?
- 17:21Like, hey, come experience this thing that's given like joy in
- 17:25life to people for hundreds of years.
- 17:29That's connected to these like really big eternal theological
- 17:33promises, right? Like that's more of an no
- 17:36common. Like the music's really good and
- 17:38you'll be entertained in the fog machine makes a really cool
- 17:41setting. I just don't think that's the
- 17:43game church should ever be playing, especially a Lutheran
- 17:46Church. I don't know, Yeah, thoughts on
- 17:48that are pushback and. And it's not that music
- 17:51shouldn't be good. I think in today's church
- 17:53environment where we're, you know, we're really struggling to
- 17:56to, you know, keep people, not just young people, just people
- 18:00in general. I think one of the big mistakes
- 18:04of the mainline Protestant church over the, you know, many
- 18:07decades is just starting too many itty bitty little churches.
- 18:11And so none of them have the capacity to do music really
- 18:15well. It doesn't matter what kind of
- 18:16music they're doing. Yeah, it's.
- 18:18And I know that sounds kind of maybe judgmental or something,
- 18:21but I mean, all these musicians at these little churches,
- 18:24they're doing the best they can. Absolutely.
- 18:26But they don't have the resources to hire people to do,
- 18:29you know, you know, traditional music absolutely that we do.
- 18:33Or, you know, you know, contemporary music at the level
- 18:36that the big you know. Yeah, cathedrals or whatever the
- 18:39big. You know, mega churches do and I
- 18:43just think there's fewer and fewer people in today's church
- 18:46environment that want to come here.
- 18:49But frankly, yeah, mediocre, bad music.
- 18:51So we it's kind of for most churches, not all churches, but
- 18:55for most churches just mediocre, really amateur in music is just
- 19:01not. A viable strategy.
- 19:04It's such a great point and it's, I mean people, I know a
- 19:08lot of folks come here and they're like, I, I came to your
- 19:10church because of the Oregon because and it's, it makes us
- 19:13very unique. Like First off, someone of your
- 19:16talent makes us very unique. But even just us having an
- 19:19instrument like this is not common in churches anymore.
- 19:24They're like, because they're expensive and you need to be
- 19:27very specially trained in how to play it.
- 19:29It's not just like, oh, I can play piano so I can play organ.
- 19:32It doesn't quite work like that. And, and not a lot of people are
- 19:36going to organ school or like or majoring in organ or even
- 19:40learning how to play the organ anymore.
- 19:42Well, there's a surprising number of young people, you
- 19:44know, organist, you get, you watch a few YouTube videos, you
- 19:48know, by some of these young organists, you'll, you know,
- 19:50like anything else, you'll get a flood of, you know, suggestions
- 19:53and oh, there's, there's tons of very talented young organists
- 19:56out there. So, you know, there's a lot more
- 20:00organ opportunities in cities other than that.
- 20:04Colorado is not a Mecca for lots and lots of I mean more in the
- 20:08East and the Midwest, but. Yeah, When I went to, I went to
- 20:12a music school, like a school that had a really strong music
- 20:14program. And so I knew there were a lot
- 20:17of organ majors there. But I also knew that my
- 20:20institution was a very peculiar place and that they were.
- 20:24Yeah, that this is not necessarily the norm anymore,
- 20:27but it was fun. We would always, we had daily
- 20:31Chapel and I would go most of the time.
- 20:33And that's when the Oregon students would play and that
- 20:36varying degree, like sometimes you were late for class because
- 20:39Jimmy was playing so slow. Pick it up, man.
- 20:44We got 5 verses of this and I got to get to class well.
- 20:46For example, Saint Olaf, they're.
- 20:48Still very. That's where I went.
- 20:49Very strong organ program by alma mater Indiana.
- 20:53Very strong. Go Hoosiers.
- 20:56Eastman you know, schools like that Michigan still very strong
- 21:00organ programs. Yeah.
- 21:02And I mean, to your point, though, there's just so many
- 21:05churches, so many Protestant churches that it can be very
- 21:09hard to fill that particular position.
- 21:13Yeah, I think about like my first congregation, I remember
- 21:16we were doing the budget and I was like, hey, I'd really like
- 21:20in the budget for next year, $200.00 so that I can buy the
- 21:25youth group pizza like once a month.
- 21:27Like if we could just put it, if we could find a way to work in
- 21:29200 bucks. And that was my youth ministry
- 21:32budget, right? Like just to show you, I'm like,
- 21:36gosh, that is that is very hard to do ministry like and is a
- 21:40wonderful church and really like faithful, caring people.
- 21:43And because it had dwindled to such a size and the finances
- 21:48were so sparse, it made ministry really, really difficult.
- 21:51Yeah. You know, and I understand, I
- 21:53think there's a, I've also heard there's a big movement towards,
- 21:56you know, really small, like house churches or churches that
- 21:59don't have professional clergy and just small groups of people
- 22:02that meet and, and that's great. You know, if that's the type of
- 22:07church environment that some people want, I think that's
- 22:10wonderful. But if you want to operate a
- 22:12church like this in this day and age, you know, kind of like
- 22:15we've been talking about, I think we just have to do a
- 22:19better job at everything that we do.
- 22:21And we need to concentrate our forces, you know, together
- 22:26rather than, you know, dissipate across, you know, way too many
- 22:32and it's congregations. And it's not just across
- 22:34congregations. Like I also think there's an
- 22:36aspect to what you're talking about just within churches, even
- 22:39large ones, where you are trying to be so many things to so many
- 22:43people. And I wonder if, you know, you
- 22:45could just try to focus in and say, we're going to do these
- 22:48these four things really, really well.
- 22:51I feel like that would move the needle so much more because
- 22:53really. Right.
- 22:54Like, what is church about at the end of the day?
- 22:56What I learned in seminary is it's the place where the people
- 22:58get together and the sacraments are administered and the word is
- 23:01preached. Like, that's our baseline of
- 23:04what we're trying to do here. And the rest of it is important
- 23:06and serves that wider purpose. But also, like, these are the
- 23:10core things that a church needs to be doing.
- 23:13And so if that's all it is, like, yeah, how can we do all of
- 23:17those really, really well? And it would be interesting to
- 23:21see how many churches are big. Oh, like if that's what we're
- 23:23trying to do, maybe we don't need to do this and this and
- 23:25this and and all these other pieces around the edges to kind
- 23:29of focus in. Yeah, I completely agree.
- 23:32This this business of trying to be all things to all people, or
- 23:35at least too many things to too many people.
- 23:37That's that's not a good. If you're running a business,
- 23:40you're going to go out of business pretty quickly if you
- 23:43don't have an identity and focus and you just you know, today
- 23:46we're a little of this and you know, next week we're a little
- 23:49of that. And you know, you mix these
- 23:52three things together and you know, it's a little something to
- 23:55make everybody happy. It's like that's not a very,
- 23:59that's only sound strategy. No, right.
- 24:01Like it works like in like 3 if you're Walmart, I guess, Yeah,
- 24:05But then you have to just be so massive.
- 24:08Yeah, right. That's the only way it's
- 24:09possible. Kind of to your original point
- 24:11too. It's like, yeah, if you could
- 24:11just become this massive, massive place, then you can be
- 24:14all things to all people. But until then, no, like just
- 24:18be, just be the bakery, right? Like just be the Candlestick
- 24:21maker, whatever. What's wrong with that?
- 24:23Yeah, right. What's wrong with that?
- 24:25So from a from a worship standpoint, though, what I mean,
- 24:29how are you thinking about your work here, right?
- 24:33Like what? What are you hoping to
- 24:36accomplish or offer as you direct music at Bethany to use
- 24:41your official title? Oh wow, that's a that's a pretty
- 24:46broad question. I know.
- 24:47And you can take it whatever angle you want, but I I figured
- 24:49you'd have some kind of interesting insights.
- 24:51And it's like a peek behind the curtain because people just show
- 24:54up and they're like, oh, like, I like this hymn.
- 24:55I didn't like that hymn. The choir anthem was awesome,
- 24:58but I know it's so much more intentional than that.
- 25:00Yeah, I mean it, it's very gratifying when people express
- 25:04appreciation or clap for, you know, for me or for the choir.
- 25:07But, you know, that's obviously that's not what it's all about.
- 25:10It's like, I don't, I don't care whether people remember my name
- 25:14or my face or my bald head or anything like that.
- 25:16I just care about do people feel the Spirit of God moving in this
- 25:23space when they, when they come here?
- 25:27And that is getting back to sort of the professionalism.
- 25:30It's not, you know, being professional to be competitive
- 25:35or puff yourself up. It's because it requires a very
- 25:38high level of skill to truly. You just have to get truly moves
- 25:43people as opposed to just oh, that, that was nice.
- 25:46You know, and that. And I think that's, that's what
- 25:49we're called to do the, our, our, our various musical
- 25:53ensembles, you know, that practice every week and the
- 25:56organ music and just everything we, that we do to plan worship.
- 26:00It's, it's, it's, it's not to satisfy our own egos or, you
- 26:05know, performance desire, but to, you know, provide a
- 26:11spiritual experience that people feel inside.
- 26:15And of course, to just serve the message, you know, the texts,
- 26:20the what, what you're preaching that day, that that sort of a
- 26:22thing. I think about that a lot, or I
- 26:24have been thinking about that a lot just in the last week.
- 26:27We just got out of Holy Week and I mean, I'm just like so
- 26:34overwhelmed and appreciative of what we are able to offer the
- 26:38community here. Like I'm just so proud of it
- 26:41from starting from Palm Sunday all the way through.
- 26:44And, and I think in particular about the Good Friday 7 Last
- 26:48Words of Christ, Dubois Peace that the choir put together with
- 26:52and we had the orchestra as well.
- 26:54And it was just like, it's, it's so unbelievable and, and it gets
- 26:58me so excited too of like, Oh my gosh, like, look at what's
- 27:01possible here, like what we are able to offer.
- 27:05And it's, it's so unique and it's so powerful.
- 27:09And, and what I love about the Dubois piece in particular,
- 27:12because it, I feel like that one really gets at what you're
- 27:14talking about. We didn't applaud, right?
- 27:17Like it it wasn't the emotional space of the evening for there
- 27:21to allow for applause. And it was just so rooted in
- 27:27telling the story. That's all it's trying to do is
- 27:29just like, hey, this story has been around 2000 years.
- 27:32You probably know it, but have you ever heard it like this
- 27:35before? And that's what it does.
- 27:38And there's just something very profound about that insight of,
- 27:41yeah, like we can kind of get out of the way too.
- 27:43Like, it isn't about being like, showy and fancy and clever
- 27:48necessarily. Like, sometimes just portraying
- 27:51the message in a new way is in of itself so powerful, right?
- 27:58Like, and that's not to diminish, obviously.
- 28:01Like, there was so much work and talent and beauty in what the
- 28:05choir and the orchestra offered, and it was just the story.
- 28:10I don't know, there's something about that that I'm still
- 28:12struggling to get my words around.
- 28:15But that was very profound in its simplicity and its beauty
- 28:19all at the same time. And it's not like that was a
- 28:21simple piece whatsoever. But I don't know.
- 28:23Do you have any? I rambled a lot there, and I
- 28:26would love to hear your kind of reaction to that.
- 28:28Well. Yeah, I just started circling
- 28:29back to what we talked about before.
- 28:31You know, you've got these in the in the tenebray.
- 28:34You've got these 7 passages, the seven last things that that
- 28:38Jesus said from the cross, and maybe few words besides that.
- 28:42And so we read each one in sequence, and then there's a
- 28:45incredibly specifically tailored piece of music that amplifies
- 28:49that, you know, just tailored to that one little slice.
- 28:53That little phrase, Yeah. And.
- 28:54So that's just, that's just so incredibly powerful.
- 28:57It's unbelievable, yeah. And it's, it shows the magic of
- 29:03that type of musicality, I think, right it's.
- 29:09A lot of work, you know, it's, it's a, you know, it's something
- 29:12that we have to, I guess contrive in a way, but it's, but
- 29:16it's, you know, like I said, sing to the Lord, a new song.
- 29:18It's something that we that we do.
- 29:21Do you know of any other pieces of music like that one?
- 29:24Not necessarily for Good Friday, but I was just curious too as
- 29:26like are there other points in the year where there's beautiful
- 29:29music that's been written that's like amplifying a core little
- 29:33message or anything? Well.
- 29:34One of the big ones is, you know, all these Requiem
- 29:36settings, you know, it's the text of the, of the traditional
- 29:39Requiem Mass that we typically do that.
- 29:41We used to do those on Good Friday.
- 29:43Liturgically it's it's not really appropriate.
- 29:45We do it on All Saints. So, you know, the requiems by
- 29:49composers like Foray and Duraflay, you know which which
- 29:52we have done also and of which have also had a similar reaction
- 29:56to the the Dubois piece. You know, where people just
- 29:59especially on an emotional day like All Saints, where you, you,
- 30:02you, you know, we remember those who have died, you know, and
- 30:04people have a really emotional reaction to those pieces
- 30:08sometimes. And that's, I mean, that's what
- 30:10music can do, right? Like, like we should talk about
- 30:13that as well as that music offers, I think.
- 30:16I mean, since the beginning of religion, not not just
- 30:20Christianity, but just kind of any tribal religion, music has
- 30:24been intimately connected with religion just because it,
- 30:29there's something about singing or, or making music that seems
- 30:33to connect us with a higher power, right?
- 30:36There's it's just expressing ideas and words and emotions in
- 30:40ways that are more mystical beyond not to get to woo woo,
- 30:44but. And so with that, you're right.
- 30:47Like when there's these deeply emotional days, music can be one
- 30:51of the most powerful, important things that we do.
- 30:54Yeah. Just because it's able to
- 30:55finally give expression to what we couldn't quite figure out or
- 30:59articulate ourselves. Yeah.
- 31:00Yeah. So here's Let's play Stump the
- 31:02pastor. What is the first reference in
- 31:04the Bible to anything musical? Wow, this is a great question.
- 31:12Yeah. He's thinking.
- 31:17I don't know. It it goes all the way back to
- 31:20the 4th chapter of Genesis where Jubal is mentioned, you know, as
- 31:24being a player of the Liar and the pipes.
- 31:28Liar and the pipes in the OK. I was trying to go through the
- 31:31days of creation. I didn't hear anything in there.
- 31:33No, but that's Genesis 4. That's really early.
- 31:36It is, and it's very interesting that instrumental music is
- 31:40mentioned before, even vocal music.
- 31:42I think the first reference to vocal music is Exodus 15.
- 31:46Is that when Miriam sings and dances?
- 31:48Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then of course, we have in
- 31:51the Psalms, you know, that that's all about singing.
- 31:53That's totally their hymn book and it mentions singing and it
- 31:55mentions all these different instruments.
- 31:57Yeah. Here's another stump the.
- 31:59Past Oh gosh, it's embarrassing. Did you know that there that the
- 32:04Bible has evidence of professional musicians in the
- 32:08temple, you know, in old temple? Really.
- 32:10Yeah, in the in Nehemiah and Chronicles.
- 32:13It mentioned. Yeah, just sort of as an aside,
- 32:15there's like a mention of the temple musicians and how they're
- 32:17to be paid. It sort of implies that they
- 32:20were like like full time employees if you will of of the
- 32:24of the temple. Of the temple in order to offer
- 32:26those gifts, yeah. So, so music, at least at the
- 32:28Big Temple in Jerusalem, was. Yeah, kind of a fancy and an
- 32:32important piece of it. Yeah, yeah.
- 32:34And I mean, and like we were saying too, and it, and it
- 32:37always has been. And it's, yeah, there's just
- 32:41something different that happens when.
- 32:45Well, I, I talk about this a lot too with the, with the
- 32:47confirmation class singing together is group meditation
- 32:53because you are, you are breathing at the same time.
- 32:55And it they've like studies have shown, like your heartbeats
- 32:58start to align with those around you when you, when you sing in
- 33:01unison and right, happy birthday, Take Me Out to the
- 33:06ball game and church are the places where people sing
- 33:09together like that. That's it.
- 33:11Like it's no longer a a a normal part of our culture,
- 33:13unfortunately. It would be a shame to lose
- 33:15that. It would be a shame to lose
- 33:17that. The only other places where
- 33:19large numbers of people sing together is, you know, in the
- 33:22schools, the middle schools, the high schools, you know it where.
- 33:26Music once or choirs or Yeah yeah.
- 33:28Many, many young people that I mean, this is sort of where the
- 33:32epicenter of of singing together is, is in our schools today even
- 33:36more than our churches. Yeah, even.
- 33:38And it is interesting how I understand, like some people
- 33:40just don't like to sing and I feel like you're missing out.
- 33:44But it's, you know, it's embarrassing and it's vulnerable
- 33:47and you don't have a good voice, so you don't want to be seen as,
- 33:50you know, imperfect or whatever. But I don't know, it's just so
- 33:55much better when people sing together.
- 33:57And we're going to have the big Synod assembly here.
- 34:00I'm very excited about that. I know you've been working hard
- 34:04with Kirk and Pastor Gary and people from the Synod on
- 34:07designing that worship, but that's a cool experience because
- 34:11these are people from all these different, a lot of the times
- 34:14much, much smaller churches around the Denver area.
- 34:17For us to be able to offer that all together and to get them an
- 34:19experience that, can you give us any little sneak previews or
- 34:21anything? Gosh, I mean, we're gonna have
- 34:24the Denver Brass Quintet. Are we really?
- 34:27Yeah. As we do on Christmas, so.
- 34:29That'll be fun. The choir is doing a couple of
- 34:32fun anthems. There's some sort of a guest
- 34:35musician that's, I guess he's Indonesia and he's gonna sing a
- 34:39song. Cool, OK at.
- 34:41Communion. So yeah, it's gonna be kind of
- 34:44just a big festival. Festival worship service.
- 34:47Kind of a thing. And then there's another worship
- 34:48service on Saturday that I think some of our Sounds of Praise
- 34:53folks are. Gonna cool, they're playing in
- 34:55OK. Yeah, we still haven't finalized
- 34:57what that service is gonna look like, but.
- 34:59Plenty of time. That'll be a different thing
- 35:00from the Thursday 1. No, thanks for putting all that
- 35:03together. I think that's that's really
- 35:05powerful, especially for folks coming from smaller places where
- 35:09this will be the largest workshop service of the year
- 35:11that they get to participate in. Yeah, OK.
- 35:14Final question, looking ahead, what what should we be working
- 35:18on? Rick?
- 35:19You, you and me, me, you and the rest of the Bethany staff.
- 35:23As we look forward to the future for worship at Bethany, what
- 35:26kinds of things would you hope we'd be putting our time and
- 35:29energy into? Well, you and I should write
- 35:31another liturgy setting. We should.
- 35:33I love it. Folks don't know, like he's
- 35:35Hammerstein, I'm Rodgers and we've done.
- 35:39We've done a couple, I think at least.
- 35:41Because you wrote the that that Bethany Unity liturgy you wrote
- 35:45the words to. That I did.
- 35:46And yeah, and you wrote the words to the Advent liturgy and
- 35:50I, I think he wrote some words like that hymn that we sang on.
- 35:54On Monday, Thursday, I did you. You wrote extra words.
- 35:57That was awesome. I have to tell you about that
- 35:58too, part of that. So my grandfather was a Lutheran
- 36:01pastor and he was a very good musician.
- 36:04And he, when he when he passed, my dad gave me this collection
- 36:09of hymns that he had written new lyrics for.
- 36:12And so that has been like an inspiration of mine of like a
- 36:15way to kind of honor grandpa of like, yeah, that's just a fun
- 36:19thing. I can't do the musical side of
- 36:20things, but I can figure out words once in a while.
- 36:23And I I know enough music that I don't get in too much trouble.
- 36:26Yeah. Yeah.
- 36:27It's it's been fun. So yeah, more music.
- 36:30We can do that. That'd be fun.
- 36:32There's, you know, there's just this unbelievable wealth of
- 36:36tradition, you know, that that's bequeathed to us that we haven't
- 36:40even scratched the surface of, right.
- 36:42So we do that and at the same time we write new music, you
- 36:46know, and that's, you know, like sort of like we started the
- 36:48conversation out. That's the beauty of the
- 36:50liturgical structure is that we have just this unbelievable
- 36:55wealth of stuff that's been handed down to us, and we create
- 37:00new things to go with it. You know?
- 37:03Yeah. And that's sort of, it's sort of
- 37:05echoing, you know, we get to be creators, you know, the way God
- 37:09created the earth, you know, Right.
- 37:10In some small way, we echo that. And he, I think he God intended
- 37:15it that way. I think you're right too, is
- 37:17that that the creative process is a part of of worship, right?
- 37:22Like that's the way we honor God is by living out those creative
- 37:27pieces, right? Yeah.
- 37:28I really, I really like the way you put it, is that God has
- 37:30created the world and we're made in God's image.
- 37:33So we then can create as well in our own ways.
- 37:36And that got the lights in that. Yeah.
- 37:39Rick, thanks. We should do this again.
- 37:41Not in five years time. I'm so sorry it's taken so long,
- 37:44but I appreciate all your you're just such a wealth of knowledge
- 37:48and really fun to talk to. And I feel like we think
- 37:50similarly about a lot of this stuff, which is also encouraging
- 37:53and affirming. Yeah.
- 37:54I enjoyed our talk very much, so yeah, let's do it again.
- 37:56Soon, let's do it again. Soon.
- 37:57One last thing, Rick has a concert coming up on May 1st and
- 38:03he's going to be doing a whole bunch of different post ludes.
- 38:06Laura Tribby, who's one of our vocalists and one of the youth
- 38:09choir director, she's going to be singing in it as well.
- 38:11Rick, anything else they need to know about this?
- 38:14The title of the concert is Get Out of Here.
- 38:17Subtitled favorite post Ludes for the church here.
- 38:21So it's sort of like, you know, people that I try to do fun, you
- 38:25know, you know, not entertaining, but, you know,
- 38:27fun, exciting post loose. So it's sort of like a dinner
- 38:30full of desserts, you know? That's a great way to put it.
- 38:34OK. But yeah, just a wide variety of
- 38:36stuff, you know, none of the pieces is long, so it's not like
- 38:38I'm doing a 40 minute Symphony by Vidor or anything like that.
- 38:43It's just it's a lot of short pieces at a very wide variety.
- 38:46What's the the fabulous Laura Tribbey, of course.
- 38:48Will she'll? She'll be singing with it.
- 38:50Sing on somebody. Yeah, sure.
- 38:51Her voice is incredible. She's amazing.
- 38:52Yeah, she's awesome. So are you going to do that
- 38:54really long long post loop that you've done at Easter from
- 38:57sometimes? I'm going to do the same post
- 38:59loop that I did for Easter. That, that one's awesome, yeah.
- 39:01That's that's one of the organs. Great greatest hits, so that
- 39:04that'll be on the program. And Phantom of the Opera or no,
- 39:07no, OK. Because it's not a post loop,
- 39:10but I have another piece that's like has a Halloween scariness
- 39:13to it similar to that. But yeah, I just couldn't do
- 39:15tecotting fugue because it's it's just, it's just not a post.
- 39:18Loop, OK, you've, yeah, you've done that for you.
- 39:20Did that this year I think on Halloween, right?
- 39:22I think so or. Close to it.
- 39:23Yeah, I think you did. It's the best for the for the
- 39:26prelude, right? Right.
- 39:28Anyways, So yeah, check it out May 1st get out of here post
- 39:31foods. Friday, May 1st, 7:00. 7:00
- 39:34Awesome. Be there, be square.
- 39:36Hey, and you, dear listener, thank you for listening.
- 39:38Feel free to share this conversation with family and
- 39:40friends and let us know what you're thinking about worship
- 39:44here at Bethany and in the wider audience as well.
- 39:47And as always, friends, stay in peace.
- 39:49Thank you for listening to the Together for Good podcast.
- 39:52If you'd like more resources for your walk of faith, please visit
- 39:55our website bethany-denver.org or download our mobile app by
- 40:00searching Bethany Connect in your phones App Store.