Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Rates Down/Payments Up, Scout DTC “Exactly What Customers Want”?, Apple’s AI Ads
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, Kyle. Do you know what is in Lafayette, Indiana? Bob Roermann Toyota. I was gonna say we are. We are. [laughs] It is October 29th. It's Tues- Is it Tuesday today? It's Wednesday. It's Tuesday.
- 0:13It's Tuesday, October 29th. We're in Lafayette, Indiana at Bob Roermann Toyota to shoot, uh, a season two episode of More Than Cars. Oh my goodness. But first, we have some things to talk about. We got some things.
- 0:23I don't know if there was music playing or not. We... All right, we're good. We got music. We got these global rigs. We got people producing things and all that. We have the- We're rolling heavy.
- 0:31We got, like, 10 people here. You can see in the back. Uh, we're starting to set up. We have a full day. We actually have a, a family lunch in this episode- Uh-huh... which we're super excited about.
- 0:40It's gonna be a blast. Yeah. Um, if you haven't seen any of the episodes leading up to this, you can just go to morethancars.tv or you can go on Amazon Prime now and see it. Hey.
- 0:49Um, but, uh, basically we're going around the country telling the good stories, the real truth about car dealers, and, uh, this is gonna be one of those, so we hope you can do that.
- 0:57We're also premiering episode four of season one on November 13th, so we're just about at the two-week mark- Real close... two weeks from tomorrow. Go to LinkedIn. Make sure you sign up so that you get the notification.
- 1:09Join it. Uh, th- Bring the whole team for lunch. Watch the, watch episode four. Oh, so much fun. Yeah. Uh, it works great in the conference room. Although- It really does...
- 1:16uh, although we don't get the view count to show Amazon that people love it. It's fine. But we'll, we'll live. We'll live.
- 1:21Uh, we are gonna be on the road again next week at the, uh, we're gonna be speaking to all the communications- Oh my goodness, yeah... directors for all of the state associations. It's great.
- 1:30We're gonna be the opening keynote, so we're excited to do that, um, and be with the people who's job is every single day to connect the dealers with the communities and with the states.
- 1:40So, uh, that'll be a fun one, too. Uh, you probably won't be at that one. Or maybe you will. If you're gonna be at that one, shoot us an email and let us know, because we wanna make sure we say hi.
- 1:48But I think we'll get to meet everybody, 'cause there's only 50. There's only 50 people. [laughs] So it'll be a good one. One per state. There you go.
- 1:54Oh, are we still- It doesn't mean we're not gonna talk about news today.
- 1:57So JD Power's preliminary October data revealing that while auto loan interest rates have dipped, monthly payments on new vehicles continue to climb, driven by largely reduced trade-in values.
- 2:08The average inter- interest rate for a new vehicle is 6.7%, down from 7.4% a year ago. So we're moving a little bit, not even a whole point.
- 2:16With monthly payments, though, reaching still $738 on average, which is still a 14% increase year over year. Wow.
- 2:25Um, the average new vehicle transaction price is down a little bit to $44,904, with used vehicles averaging still so high, $28,472 is the average- Wow... used vehicle. Trade-in equity, here's the kicker.
- 2:38Trade-in equity has plummeted 10%, all the way down to $7,900. Uh, cars are spending an average of 50 days on lot. Uh-oh. That's more than double what they were last year. Um, leasing is up to 23%.
- 2:53We've been talking about that, um, driven by increased incentives. Now 6.3% of sticker price is the average incentive. Wow. That's coming back up. I think we have a quote here.
- 3:03Thomas King, JD Power, said, quote, "This holiday season may require innovative strategies to entice customers into acquiring a new vehicle."
- 3:10Well, here's the key notes for me on this one, is a 50 days, uh, um, a average of 50 days on lots for used vehicles. Like, we know- Yeah... what type of impact that has for profitability- Yeah...
- 3:21what type of impact it has on floor plan interest. Um, and so staying keen on the used car inventory is extremely key.
- 3:28The other interesting one for this for, for me is that, uh, I was talking to someone in the financial sector the other day, uh, specifically about mortgage rates, and we're actually seeing over the last, uh, 60 days mortga- mortgage rates climb again, while we're seeing auto rates getting reduced.
- 3:46Hmm. So it's just something- Why, why do you think that is? Uh, I think it's, it's- I, I know mortgage rates aren't, like, lockstep tied- Right...
- 3:52'cause they build into pricing what they think the fed interest rate's gonna do. We didn't get into that ton.
- 3:55It was more about, like, hey, look, even though the federal, fed interest rate came down, the interest rates on, on 30-year mortgages is going back up, but we're seeing the continued decline, um, in, in new car interest rates.
- 4:07So it's something to talk about.
- 4:08Uh, there's, uh, you know, obviously, uh, a week from today there'll be a lot of speculation about what rates will do in Q1, Q2, so there'll be, you know- What's going on in a week from today? Shh.
- 4:18Don't talk about it too much, okay? [laughs] Um, but, but still just heavy level of consideration on spending power, on ability to purchase, on how incentives tie into, uh, trade-in equity or inequity. Hmm.
- 4:32And so that con- consumer education up front still has to be super top of mind. Oh, man. Speaking of top of mind, do we have a segue? Stop. Segue. We got it. Very good. It's always good when you got that coordination.
- 4:43I feel like we're a band today. Yes. Uh, we've been talking about this one a little. A little bit of a different nuance.
- 4:47We know Scout Motors, backed by Volkswagen, is embracing this direct-to-consumer model, obviously sidestepping dealers, looking for this seamless digital-first process.
- 4:56However, um, dealers are always, already pushing back with legal threats. So what, why we're covering this, and the link in the article today, is from, um, something we... It's like a, it's a... What is it?
- 5:06It's, like, a tech consumer- Yeah-... consumer-... tech consumer media aggregator that's similar to us but for outside of auto.
- 5:12It's called The Verge, and really the angle of this is pretty much what you would expect from a consumer-first perspective media saying- Yeah... like, "Scout is aiming to get rid of dealers. No one's upset about it.
- 5:23Nobody wants the dealers anyway." It's a very familiar tune, but basically Scott Keogh is promising a, quote, "Transparent, super fast, and super easy buying experience." They have an in-house digital platform.
- 5:33Do you know who's powering that? No clue. Are they doing that, Stan? I don't- Let's find out. We're gonna find that out. Scout bypasses the, the, the dealership model, obviously.
- 5:38They're looking to open 25 what they are calling, quote, "Workshops for service and test drives and Scout Studios for sale." You can call it whatever you want. That's what Tesla did. That's a car dealership.
- 5:48[laughs] Looks like a car dealership. Um, only through direct sales model can Scout go, give a full 360 view of the cus- customer, says VP Cody Thacker. See, that, that one's interesting to me.
- 5:59It's like, oh look, that's the only way we're actually gonna get a complete view of what the, what the customer is doing.
- 6:04And I know for a fact that there are multiple companies across, uh, a- across auto looking at, like, how do we tie the tier three to the tier one and the data story?
- 6:15Um, but the, the bigger thing about this to me is the unique data points that they're trying to pull out about the buying experience.
- 6:22You know, Scout saying, "Oh look, the shopping or the buying experience takes over 13 hours," which we know from inside the industry-Yeah, here it is. Yeah. Uh, here's, here's from the article.
- 6:33Um, "The clean sheet approach is trying to remake buying. According to research compiled by Scout, uh, the company buying experience consumes an average of 13 hours, 31 minutes.
- 6:42Just 8% of consumers have high or very high trust in dealers, resulting in more than 180,000 dealer-related complaints every year." So- Yeah... they're saying that customers are spending 13 hours buying a car.
- 6:54This is, this is the struggle for me- That's good research... right? Like, Scott Keogh came from VW. Um, and we know that VW still needs to see, uh, the, the dealer as a, as a winner for them.
- 7:03And so it's interesting to me that they, that as a brand they're kind of, like, calling this out.
- 7:08But what's, what's- the bigger story here, and the one that I wanna focus on today, is the fact that The Verge, a very widely used consumer-facing brand of media, is calling this out as w- seeing dealers- Mm-hmm...
- 7:21combat this in legal process alone. Yeah. Right? And, and that's the perception of the consumer.
- 7:29Um, you know, we were actually talking to someone this morning at the hotel that was like, "Oh look, I never even knew about this Scout brand, and now it's like I can't get away from it the last few days." Yeah.
- 7:39Um, and so- They did a good job on the brand market. Exactly. They did, they get, they did a great job and the PR game has been amazing.
- 7:44But that also means that as dealers, like, our perception is again on the line because of the way that Scout is going to market, and we- and combating that by legal process alone is just never gonna win in the court of public opinion.
- 7:59So Scott Keogh and Volkswagen are in this tricky boat because, you know, uh, where's this quote?
- 8:04And, uh, you know, Scott says, "Scout is 100% separate brand, separate entity, separate structure, separate everything," except for the fact, Scott- [laughs]... where did you work last? Right.
- 8:17And who tapped you on the shoulder and said, "We have this idea to do this thing"? It was a Volkswagen employee- Right... or executive. So even though you have the legal entity, like, dealers don't see it that way.
- 8:27We'll see if consumers actually see it that way. Right. But, but the reality is, totally agree, the consumer wants the best way to buy a car.
- 8:35We've seen now Tesla, and Rivian, and Fisker, um, even I'll, I'll throw Carvana in there- Yeah... trying to deliver a different experience.
- 8:43And what actual, what the actual data shows is that people like dealing with a salesperson. They always talk about them. When you review people, what's the best part of your buying? The, the salesperson. Every time.
- 8:53Regardless of that. And we've seen the service issues that come up, what happens when there's a problem with the delivery.
- 8:59It, it's a challenging thing that they're trying to do, and we have examples now to say, like, it doesn't go like everyone thinks it's going to go. Yep. Yep.
- 9:08Still, I mean, obviously we have our opinions on this and, and we're calling out, like, the facts are the facts- Yeah...
- 9:13but, like, as dealers, we still have the responsibility to give the best possible experience at every turn so that the OEM and the consumer has no choice but to go with the dealer, uh, experience. For sure.
- 9:25Scott's very well-loved in the industry, and he's- True... seems like an amazing leader. And look, when you're, you're in a track meet or you're in a f- Like, what do you want?
- 9:32You want a real athlete competing against you. Yep. Right? 'Cause that makes you run faster, pay more attention. So, um, I love the vehicles, by the way. Yeah. They're so dope looking. They're dope.
- 9:40[laughs] I'd wanna sell 'em too if I- I'd, I would absolutely wanna sell- All day... them if I was a dealer. Speaking of things that are dope- Yeah...
- 9:47I don't know, we're gonna watch a commer- We're gonna watch an Apple commercial. They're usually dope. [upbeat music] [laughs] All right. Uh, if you haven't seen it, you gotta go check it out. Link's in our show notes.
- 9:55Uh, but this week Apple has launched two new ads promoting its Apple intelligence tools. Um, interestingly enough- Are we gonna watch one of these?
- 10:03We, we gotta watch it, but, but what you wanna watch out for is that the ad kind of, like, calls out- Yeah... the general person for maybe not being as on top of their game as they should be. [laughs] All right.
- 10:17Let's check it out. Let, let's run the ad. [object clatters] B- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- b- [camera clicks] Oh, wow.
- 10:38"Hey, Jay. This project might need a bit of zhuzhing, but you're the big enchilada. Holla back, Warren."
- 10:54[sighs] "The most capable individual to undertake this task. Please let me know your thoughts. Best regards, Warren?" Huh. I am genius.
- 11:12Oh, gen- So basically what you saw there is this, like, kind of, like, sloppy-looking guy at a desk- [laughs]...
- 11:20and he's, like, talking about how he's typing a text message to his boss or an email on his phone, and then he hits the professional button for the AI to rewrite it, and the boss looks up and looks back over at this guy, like, you know, like, spinning in his office chair.
- 11:31[laughs] And he's like, "You wrote that?" This is, it's, it's really interesting because I think, uh, you know, the con- like, consumers are now getting a more widely adopted AI integrated into their everyday technology.
- 11:46Mm-hmm. Like, I...
- 11:47You know, in business I think a lot of people have been utilizing it, but it's not something that people have adopted on, like, a moment-by-moment basis to enhance their, their, their s- their speed of work.
- 11:57And so to kind of, like, position AI as the way to be smarter, um, is a really interesting move.
- 12:05Uh, a- and actually, this article, uh, by Fast Company, uh, the, the, the observers noted, like, so far Apple Intelligence is showing us how to construct a false impression of ourselves, essentially.
- 12:17[laughs] I mean, that is exactly what it does, and it says, "Critics say Apple's ads subtly suggest that AI is a, quote, cure for the dumb and lazy." Wow.
- 12:27But what's really interesting is, like, great use of AI actually requires a lot of skill, a lot of understanding. Um, and so, like, my encouragement here is don't just use AI to be dumb and lazy. Be s- No, don't- Right?
- 12:40I think it's, it's different than that, I would say. I would say it's don't use AI to be somebody else. That's right. And I think that that's where everyone very quickly is gonna figure out, like, "Oh, that's not real."
- 12:51That's not real. Yeah. "That's not real," when they read, like, your social media posts. Like, you didn't write that, right? Ah, yeah.
- 12:56So I think- And that's what this is, is, like, I'm gonna be somebody, but the, the bottom line is, like, that guy is not gonna make it because he's not paying attention. He's not thinking critically.
- 13:04He's not working hard. Yeah. And then everyone is gonna elevate to this level. Like, we hi- we do hiring. Yep. You read resumes and you're like- Uh... something has changed. Yes. You're right.
- 13:13Everyone is not writing at this level anymore. And then actually, it makes it even more important that you look for the differentiating factor- Yep... the personality factor.
- 13:21Those are gonna bubble to- The creativity is gonna bubble to the top.
- 13:24The concepts, if you're in marketing, creative concept's gonna bubble to the top because all the stuff's gonna look and feel- It'll look and feel the same. Nice.
- 13:30And so you gotta look for that, that level of personality, that le- level of in- injection of who that person actually is. Roll the outro music- Roll it...
- 13:37which is- We are here in person in Lafayette, Indiana, at Wurman Toyota to produce more of the cars, to talk to people, do some things. I heard there's gonna be a costume thing going on. Wow. We'll find out soon.
- 13:48[laughs] [upbeat music]