Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Lindsey mystery man, Findlay at Hunting, and ScottishPower's pivot
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week we discussed Lindsay's
- 0:14mystery man and Scottish powers moved to grid Focus.
- 0:20Also, we've got Russell Finlay from the Scottish Tories
- 0:24chatting to us in the middle of the show.
- 0:26I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, and joining me this week
- 0:29is renewables reporter Michael Baer.
- 0:31How are you doing this week, Michael?
- 0:32Not bad. It's another fine day for
- 0:35discussing energy news, so I am excited and raring to go.
- 0:38And a returning fan favorite editor of E Forward, Mr. Ed
- 0:44Reed, how are you doing? Hello.
- 0:45Hello. I'm very well.
- 0:46Thank you. Very well.
- 0:47And I mean as, as, I mean, I just feel like I need to match
- 0:49Michael's enthusiasm for energy news and just, you know, really
- 0:53digging into the details, which I'm sure we're going to do in
- 0:55this first section. Certainly it's it's been an
- 0:57interesting, interesting old time for Lindsay and I feel like
- 1:01Michael, you're probably best placed to to chat us through
- 1:04this because you've been on our early shift.
- 1:07You've been Johnny on the spot this week, getting up at half
- 1:10six in the morning to organize our newsletters.
- 1:12To me, it feels like the situation we're talking about
- 1:15almost feels like almost feels like what happened with Prax,
- 1:20but even further, an even bigger extreme right.
- 1:24Praxe was like this little company that had run some petrol
- 1:27stations. Then they wanted to open
- 1:29refineries and rare run North Sea installations.
- 1:32This time it's it's some bloke that used to sell Swiss watches.
- 1:35Is that right? It's.
- 1:37I mean, it's a shame that our, our man Floyd is not here.
- 1:40Sadly, he is not feeling completely well.
- 1:43So I mean, let's give the the listener a little peek behind
- 1:47the, the energy voice curtain. Because as you see, the, the
- 1:49newsletter shift is, you know, if you're subscribing to our
- 1:52newsletter and I'd advise you to do it comes at 8:15.
- 1:55So we have an early shift where we need to, to get some of the
- 1:59stories out. And one of them was from earlier
- 2:01in the month was this, I don't know if we could call a
- 2:06speculative pitch from this unspecified gentleman by the
- 2:11name of Mark Cameron suggesting that, hey, how's about I have a,
- 2:16an investment consortium. I can run the, the, the Lindsay
- 2:20refinery. It was, the government owns it.
- 2:22And being, you know, the, you know, we're pressed for time.
- 2:24It's kind of just the hour to go before the newsletter comes out.
- 2:27I, I covered it, but I didn't really have time to, to dig too
- 2:31deep into who this Mark Ameron guy is.
- 2:33And from the little bit that I did as I looked to kind of, you
- 2:37know, Fact Check my own story, I was like, there's not a lot on
- 2:40this guy. So as I said, Floyd, our
- 2:44colleague in the, the Northwest, he has been really digging into
- 2:48to who exactly Mark Ameron is. And the truth is we've been
- 2:55we've been struggling to really get a quite a few details I feel
- 2:58like that would would anyone disagree on?
- 3:00That no, I, I, I also tried to do a bit of reading this morning
- 3:04just in case, you know, there was something that Floyd might
- 3:06have missed or something. But in the age of social media,
- 3:10it's very strange to not be able to find someone's entire life
- 3:14story within, say, 15 minutes on Google.
- 3:19I mean, that may just be the voice of youth, right?
- 3:21It may just be. Nice.
- 3:22I mean, I feel like, you know, like there are there are people,
- 3:25but I mean it it yeah, I mean, as you say, it is it is strange
- 3:29that he he doesn't seem to have any history, should we say, in
- 3:33the in the energy industry. But he's got, you know, it
- 3:36seems, other, other, other. Well see this is the thing
- 3:38right? So the, the two 2 Swiss
- 3:41organisations, that's Swiss Luxury Investments and the Swiss
- 3:44Luxury brands were both incorporated in, in 2017 and
- 3:49they dissolved just over a year after they incorporated a
- 3:53company's house in November 2018.
- 3:56So I don't know, like, I mean, I suppose it's the question as
- 3:59well as like, we don't even really know this guy's track
- 4:01record. I'd never heard of Swiss Luxury
- 4:03Investments, but I mean, maybe, maybe he made a lot of customers
- 4:06very happy. But the, the interesting thing I
- 4:10found was the, the fact that sort of growing political party
- 4:14reform UK sort of threw their hat in with them and kind of
- 4:18went, oh, we back. And we think he's a we think
- 4:20he's a credible, credible Ave. to go down.
- 4:25And like I sort of said, the, the start of the segment, it's
- 4:27quite an interesting sort of situation where total energies
- 4:32sold the the Lindsay refinery to Prax.
- 4:35Prax had previously sources managed petrol stations.
- 4:39They got into refining and then clearly got in way over their
- 4:44heads. And we're in the financial
- 4:47situation we're in now. Loads of jobs are at risk.
- 4:52There's like, you know, big sort of cries from unions to to
- 4:55support and you know, then this this guy who seems to not have
- 5:01any experience in the field, less experienced than practice
- 5:04even dead. At least they sold the stuff
- 5:06that the refinery put out. You know, it kind of just, it
- 5:09feels a bit strange. It definitely when I I, you
- 5:14know, covered it, you know, I got a quick story up on it.
- 5:16It definitely felt a bit specs because let's be fair, any of us
- 5:19could come in and say, oh, I've got an idea.
- 5:23Yeah, let me, let me run it like, you know, we could set up
- 5:25the the EV consortium and be like.
- 5:27I mean, so I think, I think the, the, the great thing about it is
- 5:31obviously it's just so clear that he's like, I, I want none
- 5:35of the downsides and just all of the upsides, right?
- 5:38He's like, I don't want to take on the liability of the actual
- 5:41ownership of the plant, which might have a decommissioning,
- 5:44you know, Bill of something like, you know, I think like a
- 5:46billion pounds. I think that was one of the sort
- 5:48of numbers that's been kind of kicked around, right?
- 5:49Obviously it's a lot of work would go into kind of, you know,
- 5:52remediating that site, but he just wants to to to to run the
- 5:57operations and be able to sell, you know, the products and
- 5:59you're like, well, I don't understand how that would work.
- 6:02Like why? Who would who would agree to
- 6:05that? I mean, it feels just like a
- 6:07sorry, Ron, you're going to. Tell me.
- 6:09Well, I was going to say he hopes that Desna has all agreed
- 6:12to that deal. I think that was a great deal
- 6:13because that's kind of his ideas, like a private, private
- 6:16public partnership. Yeah.
- 6:19I mean, I just feel like if I was Ed Miliband and then, you
- 6:23know, I would be extremely skeptical of something that gave
- 6:26me no upside at all, but but would land me with a massive
- 6:30decommissioning bill at some unspecified point in the future
- 6:34after how many years, right. Maybe.
- 6:36I mean, I don't know how practice end it for what, three
- 6:39years? Four years.
- 6:39Yeah, totally. Was it even?
- 6:41That would it be another three years and then and then as they
- 6:43go through the the whole process again, I don't know.
- 6:45Right, Mark, if you're listening to this, let's amend this idea
- 6:49to a public private parasite partnership.
- 6:53The EV consortium is going to come in.
- 6:55We'll do none of the operating well or none of it.
- 6:58We'll invest no money, but you give us 50% of the profits.
- 7:01This sounds like a great deal to me.
- 7:03I really like. This, you know, I think there's
- 7:05also a political ramifications angle to consider here as well,
- 7:09isn't there? Because, you know, they're
- 7:11they're wanting to are Disney's to foot some of the bill take
- 7:15take over some of the ownership as he sort of takes over part
- 7:18ownership of this this site. But you could argue that even if
- 7:23they did say yes to this, and even if they did think that this
- 7:25was a good deal and all of this, this is going to save the jobs
- 7:28that we're trying to save and yada, yada, Then they get a kick
- 7:31in from Scottish politicians, right?
- 7:33Because the SNP earlier in the year were saying, you know, that
- 7:38British Steel was bought over, you know, nationalized.
- 7:41And like Stephen Flynn, my local MP, said in the Commons, you
- 7:46know, Starmer was willing to move a quote, heaven and earth,
- 7:50you know, to save those jobs. But Grangemouth didn't get that
- 7:55same, same treatment. If Lindsay were to then get get
- 8:00this treatment, I feel like there's also a sort of political
- 8:03being that they're the Labour might end up taking, which
- 8:05they'll also be considering as well, right?
- 8:08I mean, I think look, overall, I, I think I feel like The thing
- 8:11is that it, it, it feels pretty clear to me.
- 8:13And I'm, you know, obviously never make predictions, but it
- 8:16feels to me that, that, that the, the Amram, you know, thing
- 8:19is not actually going to move, right?
- 8:20I don't, I don't see any way in which the government is going to
- 8:23let it go. But you've got to, you know,
- 8:25think about, you know, what comes next.
- 8:27It just feels like actually, it's like a, like an indictment
- 8:30of as you say, right, Like how we think about refineries and
- 8:33those jobs. And it's it, it, I mean, I, I
- 8:37mean, I, I think, I suspect Stephen Flynn was maybe sticking
- 8:40that sort of, you know, Scottish angle of the Grangemouth.
- 8:42But I feel like, you know, the kind of the workers around
- 8:44Lindsay will be, you know, asking sort of similar questions
- 8:47and saying, like, look, why aren't you betting this out?
- 8:51And the fact that reformers latched onto it obviously kind
- 8:54of turns it again into another sort of a local political issue.
- 8:57Yeah, I think it's an interesting situation.
- 8:59We haven't even come on to, you know, the the man that's been
- 9:02appointed to do the due diligence.
- 9:04I've been looking up him because at least I've found a social
- 9:06media account for James Ascott, who's going to be sort of a
- 9:10representative for this consortium.
- 9:12And, and he seems to have joined as our common common Sense
- 9:19Politics Facebook group on the 19th of October, I believe same
- 9:25day that they'd sent out this press release saying, hey, we're
- 9:28going to do do this. And he shared it on this on this
- 9:31account. And I don't again, he's also
- 9:36someone that's like this. I feel like this question marks
- 9:38around and I know Floyd got in touch with him because at least
- 9:41we've got somewhere to to go for these sort of questions with
- 9:45with him. But I don't think he got back to
- 9:46us. It's it seems like every time
- 9:49you sort of take another step in this, in this series of events,
- 9:54you just end up with more questions than you do answers.
- 9:59Now, as, as Michael said, you know, if, if James or Mark feel
- 10:04like they're being hard done by here, then you're more than
- 10:06welcome to reach out and get, you know, come on the show and
- 10:10tell us why you think this is a good deal for the government.
- 10:13Because yeah, I think we're all in agreement that right now I we
- 10:18don't see how it is. Agreed.
- 10:20Agreed. But yeah, as you, as you say, I
- 10:22mean, you know, James and Mark, I'm sure you're keen listeners
- 10:24to the show. So drop us an e-mail.
- 10:26We'll, you know, get in touch. Let's let's let's take this
- 10:29conversation forward. There we are right from the
- 10:32voice of E forward. We're going to move things
- 10:34forward. How fitting is that?
- 10:36Join us after this break because the Tory party leader up here in
- 10:40Scotland has been speaking to us at Hunting's base in
- 10:44Aberdeenshire. So Russell Finley, the leader of
- 11:38the Scottish Tories, was up here in the northeast of Scotland and
- 11:42he, I met up with him at the hunting base in Port Lethon in
- 11:46Aberdeenshire as just soon after the the farm announced that it
- 11:50was moving some of his manufacturing capability from as
- 11:53bad and toy facility out to its new Dubai facility.
- 11:58So we obviously touched on this, but he'd also just come from a
- 12:02meeting from the Aberdeen and Grampian Chamber of Commerce
- 12:05where he was hearing from local energy firms and their their
- 12:09concerns about the current business climate.
- 12:11Let's hear what you had to say. There were many.
- 12:14I mean, primarily it's about the lack of certainty in respect of
- 12:20oil and gas production in the United Kingdom.
- 12:24You've companies who have, who want to invest, who want to
- 12:28expand, who want to stay in Scotland because this is where
- 12:31they have begun their journey often or where they have a big
- 12:35footprint and they employ many, many people.
- 12:38But increasingly, due to this chilling effect of decisions
- 12:42taken by the SNP government in Edinburgh and the Labour
- 12:46government in London, they're making decisions, long term
- 12:49decisions where they'll go elsewhere, they'll go where they
- 12:52feel welcome, where there's a regulatory regime that doesn't
- 12:56punish them for wanting to expand and to hire people.
- 13:00I mean, if you look at the North Sea and I believe and our party
- 13:04believes firmly that we should make the most of the resources
- 13:07that we are blessed to have on our own doorstep.
- 13:11Both governments right now, their position is that this
- 13:15should be left in the ground and that renewables are the only
- 13:19show in town. But it really isn't a question
- 13:22of either or it's a question of both.
- 13:24Because the same companies who are experts, world leading
- 13:27experts in oil and gas are the same ones who will be pioneering
- 13:32and building the renewables industry of the future.
- 13:34And if we scare people off, if we just deter them, if we if, if
- 13:38you've got an anti business sentiment coming from Edinburgh
- 13:42and London, then then these companies will not hang about.
- 13:45And that's a, it's a great risk that that they're facing.
- 13:49Did your party support the oil and gas sector or your
- 13:53colleagues then in Westminster? Westminster support the oil and
- 13:56gas sector when they implemented the windfall tax that's been
- 13:59much bemoaned by industry and then later expanded the
- 14:02deadline. So the energy profit levy to
- 14:06which you're referring that that was introduced under a previous
- 14:10Conservative government at a time when the, the, the, the
- 14:14money being made by energy companies had risen dramatically
- 14:18due to the events in Ukraine. Now we're back in a much more
- 14:22difficult business environment. What we have said is this should
- 14:28be stopped. What the Labour government have
- 14:31done, instead of listening to the the concerns of the energy
- 14:34industry, they've increased the the levy, they've extended the
- 14:39levy and they've even removed the incentives for investment
- 14:43around that's money. So what we would do is fully
- 14:47support oil and gas. That was then, this is now.
- 14:50We understand why industry was aggrieved at the time, but it
- 14:53was the right thing to do in those circumstances.
- 14:56However, many colleagues within within our party argued against
- 15:00it at the time, they felt it was the wrong thing to do.
- 15:03So we are now clearly firmly against it because we understand
- 15:08that what we want to do is support oil and gas because
- 15:11Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom is going to rely
- 15:13on it for decades to come, you know.
- 15:16The the Conservative Party often bills itself as the party of
- 15:20business and Kimi Badenoch has recently spoken about how if she
- 15:25were to form the next UK government, she would roll back
- 15:28on climate commitments. We're speaking about renewables
- 15:31there and the the opportunities offered to to firms in that
- 15:35space. Doesn't rolling back climate
- 15:38commitments and shifting the goal posts not create further
- 15:41uncertainty for. No, no, far from it.
- 15:44I was in a meeting today arranged by Aberdeen and
- 15:46Champion Chamber of Commerce, and I asked the assembled
- 15:50business people in the room who covered virtually every type of
- 15:53sector, but especially oil and gas and energy and renewables
- 15:56more generally, and asked them if any of them believed that the
- 16:002045 net zero target, the Scottish Government, was in any
- 16:03way achievable. Not a single hand went up
- 16:06because they know that in order to meet that target, the way in
- 16:10which every one of us would have to fundamentally change the way
- 16:13in which we live, that's the price you'd have to pay and not.
- 16:16So it's not just the financial cost that would be expected to
- 16:19to land on the shoulders of consumers and taxpayers, but the
- 16:23the change in lifestyle. So we are being honest with
- 16:26people and it's that honesty that will actually give business
- 16:29and householders greater certainty than this pretend
- 16:33dance the SNP and Labour are both doing that they're going to
- 16:36somehow magically achieve this net zero target when they've not
- 16:40met a single one of the interim targets in all the in all the
- 16:44previous years. Isn't there a concern though,
- 16:46when you're speaking to oil and gas companies about their
- 16:48renewables, that maybe it's a case of Turkey's not voting for
- 16:51Christmas? No, because I think the oil and
- 16:54gas companies, many of them are spending huge sums of money on
- 17:01research and exploration, exploitation of renewable
- 17:06opportunities. It's the same businesses very
- 17:09often the same businesses who serviced oil and gas have seen
- 17:12for example, one Business Today, the ratio used to be 20% of
- 17:15their business was with renewables.
- 17:17It's now 5050 with renewables and oil and gas.
- 17:20So the, the these same businesses are on this, they're
- 17:24in the same space and, and it's not a question of oil and gas.
- 17:29Not voting for Christmas as well.
- 17:30Making the most of this world leading energy apparatus we have
- 17:36in our doorstep. Not scaring them off and knowing
- 17:40that they will put their money where their mouth is.
- 17:42They will fund the the renewable revolution that's coming our
- 17:45way. Now with headlines last week
- 17:47about Hunting looking to move its manual, some of its
- 17:49manufacturing capabilities right from right here in Baden Toy out
- 17:53to its new facility in Dubai. It's apartment to speak about
- 17:58job losses in in the North East of Scotland in particular.
- 18:03You know where you're going to have a tour of hunting
- 18:05facilities where they are shipping out and there's still
- 18:08at the 10 leads to descend out to the Middle East.
- 18:11Now what's what's your take away from speaking with the
- 18:17community, up in the business community up in Aberdeen, but
- 18:19also touring, hunting today? So these companies are making
- 18:23these decisions for commercial reasons.
- 18:25They're making these decisions partly because of the regulatory
- 18:29reality that they face from both governments where they don't
- 18:32feel welcome, where taxations too high, regulations too high.
- 18:36And even before you get to those practicalities that are
- 18:39considered in boardrooms, you've got an anti business sentiment
- 18:44being expressed very often and very much an anti oil and gas
- 18:48sentiment being expressed. And that's why we are so keen to
- 18:52support them. Goodbye to the point you asked.
- 18:54So there was another point I was going to make.
- 18:57Around the the shipping of manufacturing.
- 18:59Yeah, yeah. So the the the one of the the
- 19:02more recent times I was in Aberdeen, it was the same week
- 19:05in which a huge American oil and gas company just completely
- 19:10closed its doors and realized there was no more point in being
- 19:13here. We just drove past in the way
- 19:16here, the former site of Shell, which has now been raised to the
- 19:19ground and no trace of it is left.
- 19:22And I think it's absolutely tragic.
- 19:24I think most people in Scotland and certainly most people in the
- 19:28rest of the United Kingdom don't really truly appreciate how
- 19:31economically important Aberdeen in the Northeast, how
- 19:36fantastically successful and beneficial has been to the
- 19:40entire country to have oil and gas on our own doorstep.
- 19:44And it's a complete folly. I think most people will look
- 19:46back at this period where so many zealots and the
- 19:50environmental side of things, the Green Party being an
- 19:53example, live in cloud tuition land.
- 19:55They believe that they don't. They can just turn off the taps
- 19:58and we will not need oil and gas, when in fact we're going to
- 20:01need it for decades to come no matter what happens with the net
- 20:050 targets. Dwindling investment in oil and
- 20:09gas isn't an overnight thing. We mentioned the EPL was brought
- 20:12in by the Tories. 14 years in government ended in oil and gas
- 20:18investment being reduced. Should the oil and gas industry
- 20:22be listening to what you have to say and saying, well, the Tories
- 20:25are the way forward? Well, I think if you're taking
- 20:29the EPL factor, putting, putting that to one side, I think it's
- 20:34crystal clear that we are the only party who have stood by oil
- 20:38and gas throughout the past few decades and will continue to do
- 20:43so. We're the only part to be honest
- 20:45with the public about what net 0 means about the affordability of
- 20:49that. And we're the only party that is
- 20:51unequivocal in saying that we should extract the resources
- 20:55that we have from the North Sea and make most of them, both for
- 20:59the economic reasons and indeed for the environmental reasons.
- 21:03The same left wing politicians who harp on about, you know,
- 21:07stop turning off the taps can never explain why they think
- 21:11it's sensible to then rely on imports which are a more costly
- 21:16and be more environmentally damaging.
- 21:19It makes no sense whatsoever. I I often often hear politicians
- 21:23speak about the term turn off the taps.
- 21:24Could you tell me who specifically is tell is telling
- 21:28the UK industry that it needs to turn off?
- 21:31Well, if you look at what the SNP government, famously the
- 21:34SNP's, rallying cry used to be, it's Scotland's oil.
- 21:38Now they've got they, they're effectively against further
- 21:43extraction. You know, they keep dancing in
- 21:45the head of a pin in the language they used.
- 21:47But the Green Party is an example of one party which is at
- 21:51least as opposed to give them some credit, unlike the SNP who
- 21:55are being honest in that regard. They would absolutely turn off
- 21:59the taps and I don't think they've been any secret of that.
- 22:02And and labour their stance, do you see them as turning off the?
- 22:06Ed, Ed Miliband, You know, the oil and gas sector, I think the
- 22:11best thing that could happen would be for Ed Miliband to no
- 22:14longer be in his job. He's a zealot.
- 22:17He's no different to the SNP and Green politicians who are
- 22:20referred to earlier. But you know, we've got a
- 22:23government that perhaps might appreciate oil and gas industry,
- 22:27but we've got an individual politician in Ed Miliband who is
- 22:31determined to throw oil and gas overboard in pursuit of a net
- 22:38zero goal that is unachievable. And that's before we even get to
- 22:42the offshoring of of our carbon emissions.
- 22:47And you know, I suppose the the last party to to ask your stance
- 22:51on would be your right wing, growing right wing opponents
- 22:55Reform UK. They they've shown support for
- 22:58the oil and gas sector and they haven't got a history in
- 23:00government that resulted in the decline in.
- 23:03Investment. I mean the one thing I know
- 23:05about reform is that a vote for reform in Scotland is only going
- 23:10to benefit the SNP. As to what else they stand for.
- 23:13You say they're pro oil and gas, I don't know if they are.
- 23:16They say they're pro union, I don't know if they are.
- 23:18I don't know very many unionist parties that field pro
- 23:21independence candidates. So I think once people start
- 23:24looking at reform and this idea that they can be all things to
- 23:29all people, perhaps because they don't have any form of baggage,
- 23:33I think that will soon fall apart under scrutiny.
- 23:35We mentioned a lot of politicking in the the start of
- 23:38the show and that end of the ending of that segment just
- 23:41continued it. But this the next segment seems
- 23:44to be more grid focused than it is politically focused.
- 23:48Who knows, Ed might throw a spanner in the works.
- 24:38So Ed, before the before the show we were having a lot of
- 24:42chat about Scottish Power and they're pivot to sort of
- 24:45focusing more on grid and less on East Anglia 2.
- 24:49You've been writing about this and E forward this week.
- 24:51Can you tell us a little bit about that?
- 24:53Yeah. So, you know, news broke last
- 24:56week that even Drolla, the owner of Scottish Power, was looking
- 25:01to sell a 49% stake in East Anglia 2, which is about 960
- 25:05megawatts of offshore wind as the name.
- 25:09So just off off E Anglia, a sort of a fairly normal sort of
- 25:13transaction. It follows in many ways Scottish
- 25:16powers deal with Mazda with a sole a similar sort of stake in
- 25:21East Anglia 3, which, you know, obviously kind of, you know,
- 25:25part of the course. But I think the thing that stuck
- 25:27out for me was the sort of the thinking behind it.
- 25:30So there was sort of mentioned in the, in the, in the, in the
- 25:34news, the, that, that the thinking behind the sort of the
- 25:38sale was around sort of reducing political risk, right?
- 25:40And obviously we're sort of seeing these kind of challenges
- 25:43growing to, to, to, to offshore wind projects.
- 25:47We've seen Austin cancelling Hornsey 4, so it's kind of very
- 25:52much in the wind. But I think the thing that sort
- 25:53of stood out for me around sort of the kind of EBITDA Scottish
- 25:57Power kind of angle was that they're kind of moving
- 26:00essentially from those kind of big, you know, large scale
- 26:02ambitious, you know, hundreds of sort of turbines in the middle
- 26:05of the of the sea and all those sort of changes around that into
- 26:09more of sort of focus on delivering grids and networks,
- 26:13right? So they're essentially moving
- 26:17something in the sort of, you know, the billions of EUR into
- 26:21this sort of focus, particularly in the UK, in the US And the
- 26:26thing and it's, it seems to be again, a move away from those
- 26:30kind of riskier kind of contracts around offshore wind.
- 26:34And there's sort of those challenges, which obviously
- 26:37we've seen playing out, particularly in the US and into
- 26:40this sort of, you know, essentially like a regulated
- 26:42asset base, right, where, you know, you just build the grid
- 26:44and you get paid a sort of a, a, a, a kind of a guaranteed
- 26:47return. And it feels, you know, kind of
- 26:50quite striking that obviously, you know, as a country, you
- 26:53know, the UK needs a lot more grids, you know, thinking about
- 26:55these kind of constraint payments that we're seeing, you
- 26:58know, particularly sort of Scotland, England connections is
- 27:01obviously kind of one of those kind of big issues.
- 27:04But but not just in the UK, right?
- 27:05The the US also has been talking a lot about how to, you know,
- 27:09sort of, you know, strengthen its gradient, talking about
- 27:12energy security. And so it feels like quite a a
- 27:16kind of a notable point of change to move away from that
- 27:20sort of generation and into networks.
- 27:21And it feels it may actually this is probably quite, it's not
- 27:25the only thing we need, but actually it's possibly the kind
- 27:27of the piece that we've been missing so far in our sort of
- 27:29transition discussion. Do you know, I was going to ask
- 27:31about that because it's not to sound like a EBITDA columns
- 27:36persons are spending a line out of this strategics or shift.
- 27:42But if you've been in the sort of, you know, turbine
- 27:46operatorship kind of side of the market, you would you'll know
- 27:51about the long time for grid connections.
- 27:54And so you know, the constraints, the grids going
- 27:56through. And if you've got that sort of
- 27:59Ave. to pep it and like you say, it's maybe a slightly more solid
- 28:04footing for Better Business as well.
- 28:06You know, you're not you're not constrained by sort of weather
- 28:08conditions and having to turn off the power generation when
- 28:11the wind gets too strong or when it's not blowing enough.
- 28:14You're just getting paid a flat rate.
- 28:17So do you think that this this sort of, however, will will
- 28:22serve to, to benefit projects that are stolen that are going
- 28:27well? We could build turbines, we
- 28:29could put them in the North Sea, but how are we getting power to
- 28:32or how are we connecting them to homes?
- 28:33Or do you think this is purely but cynical?
- 28:35Like we need money, so we're going to shift now.
- 28:38I mean, I don't know if that's cynical to say we need money.
- 28:40I feel that's, you know, you know, some would argue these the
- 28:42sole, the sole, the sole business of a company is to
- 28:45generate a profit. I mean, look, I, I, I think it,
- 28:48it makes lots of sense. I feel like looking at those
- 28:51kind of challenges around offshore wind, around those kind
- 28:54of challenges around, you know, installation and the kind of,
- 28:57you know, the kind of the squeeze that we're sort of
- 28:59seeing and, you know, sort of vessel availability, you know,
- 29:02those sorts of challenges. You can see why you might be
- 29:04like, oh, actually, maybe there are other ways of doing it.
- 29:06I think the thing that stood out for me is obviously, you know,
- 29:09like God, like grid is also hard, like looking at the
- 29:14challenges of people trying to build, you know, this say, for
- 29:17instance, the kind of the the cross-border connection they're
- 29:20talking about at the moment between Scotland and England.
- 29:23You know, more of these obviously, you know, the the
- 29:25sort of the onshore links are facing such entrenched kind of
- 29:30community opposition, right. And I feel like to say, you
- 29:34know, like, oh, you know, offshore wind is hard does not
- 29:37mean the building grid is easy, right?
- 29:40It's, it's like, it's like, it's like a different set of
- 29:42problems, but it's still a set of problems.
- 29:44Yeah. I mean, it's something that
- 29:46onshore wind developers deal with and it's yeah, like you
- 29:49say, so those that are erecting pylons also deal with where I
- 29:54I've definitely heard sort of hearsay and like sort of
- 29:56anecdotes on, you know, conference show floor is about,
- 30:00Oh yeah, our public consultation people are often often stressed
- 30:05or stressed leave or whatever after sort of doing sort of
- 30:08weeks of consultation and communities because it's weeks
- 30:11of just having abuse hurled at you, you know.
- 30:13And so, yeah, I get, I get where you're coming from from that
- 30:16perspective, but I guess this probably is a cynical take, but
- 30:22and the guys making that, those decisions, the people, you know,
- 30:26the people saying we're going to pivot to that aren't the people
- 30:28that have to deal with the the townsfolk of a local area that
- 30:34are going to rally against rally against a new development.
- 30:39They can kind of just stand back and go, well, we signed the
- 30:41contract and we're going to get the money for that.
- 30:44So there's it's, it's easier for this or the upper echelons of a
- 30:49company to, to agree to that, right?
- 30:51Because if if you're not producing as much power as you
- 30:54thought you would due to weather conditions or whatever, or your
- 30:57projects being delayed because it can connect to the grid and
- 31:00you know, inflation costs and all the other things that we
- 31:02speak about in relation to offshore wind that impacts the
- 31:07bottom line and it continues to hurt the company.
- 31:10And if you're observed the CFO, you're going to look bad for for
- 31:13that, right. Whereas you've seen the contract
- 31:16and you got the money. Yes, it's, it's tough from a
- 31:19community management standpoint and like public outreach
- 31:22standpoint. But the the guys in the senior
- 31:26leadership team, do they have to deal with that?
- 31:27Yeah. I mean, I think, I think, you
- 31:32know, yes, absolutely the, the, the sharp end, you know, the,
- 31:35the sort of the, the EBITDA and the management team will not
- 31:38see. But I think what they would be
- 31:39seeing is, you know, those kind of questions around trying to,
- 31:43you know, like planning and consenting, right?
- 31:46And I mean, I think that's obviously, you know, something
- 31:49that, you know, in this country we're trying to solve.
- 31:51But the, you know, the planning infrastructure bill is I think
- 31:54in the House of Lords at the moment, but it's, you know,
- 31:57obviously very much kind of front and centre around actually
- 32:00how we sort of deliver the electrification that the, the
- 32:04government says that, you know, we're, we're aiming for.
- 32:06So I think, look, there are, there are certainly challenges
- 32:08there. And I think, you know, certainly
- 32:11in the, in the, in the, in the, in the US as well.
- 32:13I think the, I think the other thing that's kind of striking is
- 32:15obviously, you know, if you cast your mind back to April of this
- 32:18year and the, the Iberian blackout, it feels interesting
- 32:22that, you know, Ibadruella was not focusing so much on building
- 32:26out the Spanish grid, which obviously looking at the, the
- 32:29analysis of that blackout that we saw.
- 32:32You know, obviously the, the kind of the first take was kind
- 32:34of blaming kind of, you know, essentially sort of, you know,
- 32:37solar power. But a lot of reports have come
- 32:39out and it seems to be that actually it was kind of a grid
- 32:42capacity question and some sort of, you know, the kind of grid
- 32:46forming measures that were that had seen under investment.
- 32:50And yeah, it seems that that, you know, you would roll is not
- 32:53not not stepping on that. I mean, it would be it would be
- 32:55fascinating to dig into more why the UK is an interesting place
- 33:01for Ibadrolla than than Spain when you're thinking about grid
- 33:04investments. But one for another time,
- 33:07perhaps. Perhaps I don't know nearly
- 33:09enough about Spanish, Spanish investment incentives or
- 33:12whatever. I can talk to you a little bit
- 33:14about Chris Stark if you want, but that's probably as good as
- 33:17we can get. No comparison.
- 33:19Is there a Chris Stark equivalent in Spain?
- 33:22This is the, this is the week of call outs.
- 33:23If you're the Chris Stark of Spain, please get in touch.
- 33:27Well, I think that wraps up this segment so well.
- 33:30Thank you very much for sharing that with his Ed.
- 33:33That was a really interesting conversation and I'm sure one
- 33:35that our listeners will continue to speak about on LinkedIn and
- 33:41you know, get in touch about it. Please, please do.
- 33:42If you've got some interesting insights to share, we love to
- 33:45hear them. That does it for this weeks
- 33:47episode. If you'd like to catch us again,
- 33:49we'll we'll be in the same time. It will be here at the same
- 33:52time, same place next week. Thank you, Ed.
- 33:54Thank you, Michael, and we'll see you next time.