Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 5)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to get right
- 0:06back to the Alexacosta interview with the OIG investigators. Question,
- 0:12all right, so did you have any doubt that you'd
- 0:14get a waiver if you applied for one? Answer? So
- 0:17I'm now speculating. I don't recall, but I'm not sure
- 0:21I would have said, is there a doubt that I'd
- 0:23get a waiver? As opposed to is this something I
- 0:25feel comfortable doing or not? Question? And this being the
- 0:29prosecution or this being the applying for a waiver? Answer
- 0:34applying for a waiver. And so you know, either Main
- 0:36Justice gives it or doesn't give it, that doesn't mean
- 0:39you don't apply for it if you think that it's
- 0:41the right thing to do. So. For example, in the
- 0:44UBS case, which was one of our big tax you know, prosecutions,
- 0:48we asked for a Bank of Nova Scotia authorization to
- 0:52the Bank of Nova Scotia. And I didn't think Main
- 0:55Justice would you know. I push really hard and I
- 0:57got into the weeds in that case that purpose, but
- 1:01I still thought, let's go for it, and we did,
- 1:03and Maine Justice didn't give into it and that's okay,
- 1:06that's how it works. Question. Okay, so they denied that request. Answer,
- 1:11they denied that request. And I say that as an
- 1:14example as a typical matter. I don't think that's what
- 1:17Maine Justice is going to say. As opposed to how
- 1:20should we approach this matter? Question? I don't understand about
- 1:24what you mean by how should we approach this matter? Answer?
- 1:27So honestly, how do I explain this? So? I think
- 1:31there's a difference in saying, let me predict how Maine
- 1:34Justice will come out and follow that prediction, versus folks,
- 1:37what do you all think? Okay, if we're comfortable with this,
- 1:40let's write it up and let's see what Main Justice does.
- 1:44One is trying to predict what folks in this building
- 1:46are going to think. Another one is trying to predict
- 1:49another one is just saying, what do we do in Miami?
- 1:53What do we think? And let Maine Justice figure it out?
- 1:56Question in which is the approach you typically took? Answer?
- 2:00And my point is the approach that I typically took
- 2:02is what do we think? And let Maine Justice give
- 2:05it a thumbs up or a thumbs down? Question? All right?
- 2:09And in this case, did you do that with regard
- 2:11to the petite policy answer? So in this case, we
- 2:14didn't get that far in that we didn't have to
- 2:17submit to DOJ, but we were approaching it not based
- 2:21on what main justice was going to think. But do
- 2:24we feel is this the right outcome in this office? Question? So,
- 2:29as I understand, the bottom line is that you didn't.
- 2:31As I hear you, I believe you're saying that you
- 2:33didn't stand down or in any way sees your limit
- 2:37pursuing this case on batit policy grounds. Answer. So we
- 2:43went forward with the matter although there were petit policy
- 2:46concerns in the background. So you're setting this up as
- 2:49a binary as a did was it as a binary?
- 2:53You did not limit yourself on petite policy grounds? And
- 2:56I'm pushing back a little bit because I don't think
- 2:59that it's part as opposed to when you look at
- 3:02the case, there are all sorts of factors, and it's
- 3:05a factor in you know, how you think of a
- 3:07matter going forward? Question? If you had those petit policy concerns,
- 3:11you or your members or staff answer, I would say
- 3:15a combination of me and my management staff. Question who answer,
- 3:22I can't recreate gets cut off by the person asking
- 3:25the questions. But who are you dealing with on this case? Answer?
- 3:30Primarily it would be my first assistant and criminal chief.
- 3:33As I typically so there is, as you know, to
- 3:36sort of put it in main justice terms, you know,
- 3:38a line attorney and a deputy section chief, and a
- 3:41DAG and an AAG, and the AAG usually deals with
- 3:46the section chief or the DAG. And so I was
- 3:48dealing with my first assistant and my crim chief. Question right,
- 3:53and they were in Miami. Answer And they were in Miami.
- 3:57Question and by the way, redacted first line supervisor was redacted?
- 4:01Answer correct? Question. Do you know why she was not
- 4:05actively participating in the chain of command? Answer? I noticed
- 4:09that in the correspondence, and I couldn't speak to that question,
- 4:13all right, But it goes to the point that if
- 4:16you look at the she reported to or redacted, who
- 4:20are reported to redacted? Who are reported or redacted? Who
- 4:22are reported to redacted? And so, as a typical matter,
- 4:26I tried to empower my first assistant and my criminal
- 4:29chief and my office heads and work through them, not
- 4:32bypass them. Question in this particular case, with regard either
- 4:36to petite policy or any other aspect, was there anyone
- 4:39other than the group of five, if you will, in
- 4:42that chain from you down to or redacted through redacted
- 4:46and redacted that you were dealing with. Answer? I can't recall.
- 4:50I can say, as a general matter, it would not
- 4:52be unusual for me to walk down walk down the
- 4:55hall and talk to someone that I trust and say, hey,
- 4:58I've got this fact pattern. What do you think? Question?
- 5:01Do you recall ever doing that in connection with this case? Answer?
- 5:05I don't recall the specific briefings or who I talk to.
- 5:08I'm just saying as a general matter that there are
- 5:10folks on the eighth floor that were in management that
- 5:13I would often just walk down the hall. Question, but
- 5:17do you recall doing that in this case? Answer? I
- 5:20don't recall. Question Okay, So we shared with you in
- 5:23Exhibit three a pretty lively exchange between redacted and redacted.
- 5:28We have no reason to believe you saw this before,
- 5:31but it makes some representations about you, and that's why
- 5:34we brought it to your attention. Question our answer, okay,
- 5:38Question do you recall this EML ex change? Answer? I
- 5:41don't recall the email ex change. Question I mean, didn't
- 5:47you see it? Then? Do you recall having read it
- 5:49before today. Answer, I recall reviewing it, yes, question, all right, okay,
- 5:54So starting from the end redacted using redacted to BlackBerry,
- 5:57which is a little confusing to begin with, I reacted
- 6:00that a particular conversation he had with one of the
- 6:04defense attorneys. At this point, what I want to do
- 6:07is draw your attention to the comment and his response.
- 6:11And we're looking at page three. So in the third paragraph,
- 6:14it was made clear to you by the US Attorney
- 6:17and the first assistant from the time when you were
- 6:20first authorized to investigate mister Epstein that the office had
- 6:23concerns about taking the case because of batite policy and
- 6:27a number of legal issues. And then later he says
- 6:30that you were never given authority or authorization by anyone
- 6:33to seek an indictment in the case. And then on
- 6:36the first page, redacted presents her version of that original
- 6:40contact with you, meeting with you at the bottom of
- 6:42the page. Halfway through the last paragraph, she says, my
- 6:45recollection of the original meeting with Alex and redacted is
- 6:49quite different than your summary. In that meeting, I summarized
- 6:53the case and the state Attorney's office handling of it.
- 6:56I acknowledge that we needed to do work to collect
- 6:59the evidence of staff wishing a federal nexus, and I
- 7:01noted the time and month that I'm sorry, I noted
- 7:04the time and money that would be required for an investigation.
- 7:08I said, I was willing to invest time, and the
- 7:11FBI was willing to invest the money, but I didn't
- 7:14want to get to the end of it, to the
- 7:16end and then have the office be intimidated by the
- 7:18high powered lawyers. I was assured that would not happen.
- 7:22Can you tell us which version of that initial version
- 7:26is correct? Answer? So, again, I don't remember the initial briefing,
- 7:30so I can't tell you which version is correct. I
- 7:32would also say that it's possible neither version is correct,
- 7:36and that there's a little bit of truth. Now I'm
- 7:38just speculating that there's a little bit of truth in
- 7:41either one, because it's certainly possible to say, I hear
- 7:43you righteous case, go forward and investigate work on the
- 7:47federal nexus, which is what Exhibit three is saying, go
- 7:51work on the federal nexus and find evidence for the
- 7:53federal nexus. But we have concerns about patitit policy and
- 7:57legal matters, so there's a lot of work to be done. Question, So,
- 8:02what kind of direction does that amount to for the
- 8:04line AUSA, what's her job? Then? Answer? So the job
- 8:08would then be to go back and investigate, develop facts,
- 8:12and report back. Question and if she developed enough facts
- 8:15and support of law to present proposed prosecution? Answer right,
- 8:20and so a lot of times in this he said
- 8:24she said, there's a little bit of truth on both
- 8:26sides of the discussion. I'm just saying, as a general matter,
- 8:30your questions are sometimes either or, and sometimes it can
- 8:33be a combination of both. Answer, all right, but in
- 8:38fact you don't recall. Answer I'm speculating. Question, all right,
- 8:42is there anything in either of those that two accounts,
- 8:45two versions that you didn't say happened couldn't happen? Answer?
- 8:48I can't, because I don't recall. I can't speak to that.
- 8:52I would speculate that there's probably a little bit of
- 8:54truth on both sides that if you read it closely,
- 8:57you'll see that redacted acknowledges the need to work on
- 9:00a federal nexus. So that goes to you know where
- 9:04or mister redacted. I'm sorry, I'm using first names. Question,
- 9:08it's all right question. This is an informal interview answer,
- 9:12I'm going to just start using first names. I don't
- 9:15mean that disrespectfully. Where you know, Redacted says, you know,
- 9:18because of petit policy and legal issues, and Redacted is
- 9:21acknowledging the legal issue because she's saying that they needed
- 9:25work to do to collect the evidence establishing the federal nexus. Question.
- 9:29All right. Back in two thousand and six, in this
- 9:34exhibit number one, Redacted tells you in his email that
- 9:38the indictment target date is August twenty fifth, two thousand
- 9:41and six, In other words, very shortly thereafter, within a
- 9:45month or so. Do you know why the line ausa
- 9:47Redacted was keen on getting the federal case against Epstein
- 9:51brought on a fairly on a quick basis answer. So
- 9:55I can't speak to that, and I can I can
- 9:57ask based on your record, well, was that the state
- 10:01indictment target date? Answer? Epstein had already been indicted and
- 10:08arraigned on the indictment, So that's federal question. That's talking
- 10:13about a federal indictment answer, all right. The point is
- 10:18early on the investigative team, the FBI and Redacted were
- 10:22hot to trot to get this case moving from a
- 10:24federal standpoint that may well have been quite unrealistic, giving
- 10:29all the issues that we've been discussing. But the question
- 10:31is do you know why there was some urgency? Answer?
- 10:35I haven't the slightest idea. When was it initially brought
- 10:39to the office? Question? It was brought to the office
- 10:42in May of two thousand and six. Answer that would
- 10:46be a really really fast timeline question, right, So the
- 10:49question is aspirational though it may have been there was
- 10:53hope to get it done quickly. So the question is
- 10:56can you think of factors that would have led a
- 10:58prosecutor to want to pursue this quickly? Answer? I don't recall.
- 11:04I can speculate that redacted was very hard charging and
- 11:07wanted to do a lot. Question what was your experience
- 11:10of her? Answer? So based on this, I see you
- 11:13know so exhibit too. He gets interrupted? Excuse me? Would
- 11:19but just from your memory? Is that your recollection of
- 11:21how redacted operated hard charging? Answer? Yeah, I'd say so.
- 11:26A lot of really good prosecutors are hard charging. That's
- 11:29part of the job description. Question. Okay, did so in
- 11:34the child sex offender context, are you familiar with the
- 11:37belief on the part of the people who do that
- 11:40kind of case, as did it redacted and redacted and
- 11:43others in your office, that those offenders typically don't stop
- 11:46offending even after somebody's onto them, so that there was
- 11:49a concern that he that in this case, Jeffrey Epstein
- 11:53might be continuing to offend and therefore getting them off
- 11:56the streets was a priority answer. I have heard that
- 12:00discussed recently in the media. I don't recollect that back
- 12:04in well, part of the discussion back in two thousand
- 12:06and six. All right, folks, we're gonna wrap up right here,
- 12:09and then the next episode dealing with the topic, we're
- 12:11gonna pick up where we left off. All of the
- 12:14information that goes with this episode can be found in
- 12:17the description box.