Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Criminal Law 101: How the Canadian Legal System Decides Guilt, Innocence & Punishment
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. So if you
- 0:03are sitting there stressing about the forensic
- 0:05psych module. Do not panic. Yeah. Grab a coffee,
- 0:09pull up a chair. You're basically our third study
- 0:12buddy today. Right. We are cramming for this
- 0:14just like you are. Exactly. I mean, we've got
- 0:16this massive stack of notes, textbook chapters,
- 0:19case law. All the dense, heavy stuff. Right.
- 0:21And today's mission is to break down the Canadian
- 0:24legal system and how forensic psychology actually
- 0:27fits into it. Because honestly, trying to understand
- 0:30how a psychologist operates in a courtroom is,
- 0:33well, it's super confusing. It really is. Like,
- 0:35usually in psych - we treat the brain like an
- 0:37engine, right? We diagnose the broken part and
- 0:40try to fix it. But when you step into the legal
- 0:42arena, suddenly that engine is on trial. We're
- 0:45dealing with guilt and innocence and all these
- 0:47arbitrary rules. Right, which brings us to the
- 0:49first big concept we need to memorize, the arena
- 0:52itself. So to understand our system, we have
- 0:55to compare the adversarial system with the inquisitorial
- 0:58system. Oh, yeah. This part is crucial. So the
- 1:01inquisitorial system, which they use a lot in
- 1:04Europe, is codified. Like everything is written
- 1:07down systematically. So the judge is super active,
- 1:09right? Exactly. The judge is like a director.
- 1:12They investigate. They call the witnesses. They
- 1:14ask the questions. The lawyers are really just
- 1:16there to... assist the court in finding the actual
- 1:20truth. Okay, so the memory trick I'm using for
- 1:22this one is that the inquisitorial system is
- 1:24like an inquisition, or better yet, a group of
- 1:27scientists. They're all working on a science
- 1:29project together to find the truth. I love that.
- 1:32But then our system in North America, the adversarial
- 1:35system, is totally different. It's not a science
- 1:37project, it's... Well, my memory trick is adversaries
- 1:40in a boxing ring. Yes, or like two used car salespeople.
- 1:45Right. Salespeople. Yeah, think about it. The
- 1:47prosecution and defense are just trying to sell
- 1:50their version of events. They only highlight
- 1:52the good facts for their side and they try to
- 1:55hide the bad ones. Oh, right. And the judge is
- 1:57just the referee in the boxing ring. They don't
- 1:59investigate anything. They just make sure nobody
- 2:01hits below the belt. Exactly. But it brings up
- 2:04this huge moral question. If our goal is justice,
- 2:08Why do we want salespeople instead of scientists?
- 2:11Yeah, that's what that Anderson and Otto study
- 2:12from 2003 was about, right? Yeah, the textbook
- 2:15mentions it. It's so fascinating. They compared
- 2:17Americans who use the adversarial system with
- 2:20people in the Netherlands who use the inquisitorial
- 2:22one. And the Americans thought the boxing match
- 2:24was fairer, which is, I mean, that's wild. Why
- 2:27would fighting be fair? Because of human psychology.
- 2:30The Americans felt that having a lawyer whose
- 2:33only job is to advocate for you, like a personal
- 2:35champion, gave them more agency. So it feels
- 2:39fair because you get to throw your own punches.
- 2:41But morally, are we actually finding the absolute
- 2:43truth or is it just about who can afford the
- 2:45better lawyer to argue for them? Right. And it
- 2:48even affects the experts. The research shows
- 2:50that court -appointed experts in Europe are actually
- 2:53less biased. Because they aren't hired by one
- 2:55side to help win a fight. Exactly. When you get
- 2:57paid by the defense in North America, there's
- 3:00this subconscious pressure to, you know, play
- 3:02for your team. That makes total sense. OK, so
- 3:05we've got the boxing ring. But if we're studying
- 3:07for this exam, we need to know who builds the
- 3:10ring. Who makes the rules? Right, the division
- 3:12of powers. We have to go back to the Constitution
- 3:14Act of 1867. Formerly the BNA Act, right? Yep.
- 3:18So it strictly divides what the federal government
- 3:19does and what the provinces do. Section 91 is
- 3:22federal that covers national issues. And for
- 3:25our forensic psych class, the big federal issue
- 3:27is criminal law. So a murder in Vancouver is
- 3:30the exact same legal crime as a murder in Halifax.
- 3:33Exactly. But Section 92 is provincial power.
- 3:36And the huge one there is mental health law.
- 3:38Oh, right. So if the federal government tries
- 3:41to pass a law telling a provincial psychiatric
- 3:43hospital how to run things, the courts step in.
- 3:46Yeah, they strike it down as ultra -virus. Ultra
- 3:48-virus, outside jurisdiction, got it. But wait,
- 3:51we need to talk about Insight 2 .1 from the textbook
- 3:53because it blew my mind. The bodily autonomy
- 3:55stuff. Yes. Because mental health is provincial
- 3:59under Section 92, your actual moral rights change
- 4:02at the border. Like in BC, psychiatric institutions
- 4:06can force involuntarily committed patients to
- 4:08take medication against their will. Right. They
- 4:11prioritize treating the illness. But if that
- 4:13exact same patient moves to Ontario, they almost
- 4:16never force treatment. You can be involuntarily
- 4:19committed, but still refuse the meds. It is wild.
- 4:22Your fundamental human rights literally depend
- 4:25on your postal kit. Super wild. Which is a perfect
- 4:28pivot to the biggest rule book we have. The Canadian
- 4:31Charter of Rights and Freedoms, 1982. The supreme
- 4:35law of the land. But, and this is a huge trap
- 4:38on the exam, the Charter only protects you from
- 4:41government actors. Right, so police, government
- 4:43agencies. Not private people. Exactly. If the
- 4:47cops search your house without a warrant, that's
- 4:49a charter violation. But if your private landlord
- 4:51discriminates against you, you can't use the
- 4:53charter. You'd have to use a human rights tribunal
- 4:55or something. Yeah, exactly. But even against
- 4:57the government, the charter isn't like a perfect
- 4:59shield. Oh, Section 1, the reasonable limits
- 5:01clause? Yes. Section 1 says the government can
- 5:05actually infringe on your rights if it's a reasonable
- 5:08limit in a free and democratic society. Which...
- 5:11I mean, morally, that sounds like a massive loophole.
- 5:14The government writes the supreme law to protect
- 5:17us from them, but then gives themselves a pass
- 5:19to break it. It totally sounds like a loophole,
- 5:21but they have to really justify it. The classic
- 5:24example they always test on is roadside DUI checks.
- 5:27Oh, right. Because normally, if you're detained,
- 5:30you have the right to a lawyer immediately. Right.
- 5:32But at a check stop, the cop makes you blow into
- 5:35a breathalyzer before you can call a lawyer.
- 5:38That is a clear violation of your charter rights.
- 5:40But the Supreme Court basically said the societal
- 5:43harm of drunk driving is so horrific and letting
- 5:45everyone call a lawyer would cause such a massive
- 5:48traffic jam that it's a reasonable limit. Exactly.
- 5:51Public safety outweighs your temporary right
- 5:53to a lawyer on the side of the highway. Okay,
- 5:55but what if the government does go too far? Like,
- 5:58what are the remedies? Well, courts can read
- 6:00down a law, which means crossing out the bad
- 6:03part. They can read in new words. Or they can
- 6:06strike the law down completely. Oh, and Section
- 6:0824. If the police break the rules to get evidence,
- 6:12the court can throw that evidence out so it doesn't
- 6:14bring the administration of justice into disrepute.
- 6:17Nailed it. And the textbook gives a crazy example
- 6:20of striking a law down completely. R .V. Vailen
- 6:25Court. Oh, constructive murder. This is such
- 6:28a good morality, Link. Right. So constructive
- 6:30murder used to mean that if you committed a crime
- 6:32like an armed robbery and someone died, you were
- 6:36automatically guilty of murder. Even if your
- 6:38gun went off by accident or you never ever intended
- 6:41to kill anyone. Yes. The outcome determined your
- 6:44guilt. but the Supreme Court struck it down using
- 6:47the charter. They said it violates fundamental
- 6:49justice to brand someone a murderer if they never
- 6:52intended to kill. Which feels so aligned with
- 6:55how we view, like, personal morality. You shouldn't
- 6:57be punished for an accidental outcome to that
- 6:59extreme degree. Exactly. And that flows perfectly
- 7:02into the next major concept, the anatomy of an
- 7:05offense. Like, how does the state actually prove
- 7:07you committed a crime? Okay, I have a good memory
- 7:09trick for this. So there are two elements, right?
- 7:11Actus reus and mens rea. So I just memorize,
- 7:14actus equals actual action. It's the physical
- 7:17part. And mens equals mental state, the guilty
- 7:21mind. That's perfect. Actus reus is the physical
- 7:24deed. Mens rea is the intent. But, and this is
- 7:27another exam trap motive, is not mens rea. Oh,
- 7:31right. You can have the intent to kill someone
- 7:33without having any logical motive for doing it.
- 7:36Exactly. And it's so interesting philosophically,
- 7:38like in religion, sometimes just having an evil
- 7:40thought sending in your heart is enough to condemn
- 7:42you. Yeah, but the law says, no, we need both.
- 7:45You can think about robbing a bank all day, but
- 7:47until you actually do the actus reus, the physical
- 7:49act, you haven't committed a crime. Generally,
- 7:51yeah. Though there are weird exceptions. Like
- 7:54if you murder a police officer, it's automatically
- 7:57first degree murder. Wait, even without the mens
- 7:59rea of planning and deliberation. Exactly. The
- 8:02state protects its own, so they elevate the crime
- 8:04based mostly on the actus reus of who the victim
- 8:07was. That's super intense. OK, so we've got the
- 8:09action in the mind. Now we need to know the four
- 8:11categories of crimes. Right. Summary, indictable,
- 8:15hybrid. and electable. Summary is minor, right?
- 8:18Like a small fine, maybe six months in jail,
- 8:20and there's a six month time limit to lay charges.
- 8:24Yep. And indictable is the big stuff. Murder,
- 8:27no time limits, severe penalties. So what's a
- 8:30hybrid offense? That's when the Crown gets to
- 8:32choose. Assault is a good example. If you just
- 8:35shove someone in a bar, the Crown can treat it
- 8:37as a minor summary offense. But if you brutally
- 8:40beat someone up, they can choose to prosecute
- 8:43it as an indictable offense. Exactly. It's a
- 8:46pressure release valve, so the big courts don't
- 8:48get clogged with minor bar shoves. Makes sense.
- 8:51And electable. That's when the accused person
- 8:53gets to choose where they are tried. Like for
- 8:56manslaughter, you can elect to have a provincial
- 8:58judge or go to superior course with a judge and
- 9:01jury. Okay. Got it. So let's talk about defenses,
- 9:04because this is where forensic psychology really
- 9:06shines. The textbook outlines a few ways to defend
- 9:09yourself. First, you can negate the actus reus.
- 9:13So that's saying my body did the actual action,
- 9:15but it was involuntary, like sleepwalking or
- 9:18having a seizure. Yes. Or you can negate the
- 9:21mens rea. This is the psychologist's bread and
- 9:23butter. I did the act, but my mental state was
- 9:26broken. So. Severe mental disorder or being wildly
- 9:30intoxicated exactly you couldn't form the guilty
- 9:32intent But then they're the last two and you
- 9:35have to know the difference between justification
- 9:37and excuse. Okay. Let me see if I have this right
- 9:40a Justification is like self -defense. I'm saying
- 9:42I did the act I meant to do it, but honestly,
- 9:45it was the morally right thing to do to save
- 9:47my life Society supports my choice spot on But
- 9:52an excuse is different. Say a cartel kidnaps
- 9:55your family and forces you to smuggle drugs.
- 9:57That's duress. Right. With an excuse, you're
- 9:59saying, I did it. I know it was legally and morally
- 10:02wrong, but I shouldn't be punished because I
- 10:04had literally no other choice. So justification
- 10:06means I was right. Excuse means I was wrong but
- 10:08couldn't help it. Exactly. Awesome. OK. Moving
- 10:11on to the actual courtroom. Proving it. We need
- 10:14to know the court hierarchy. It goes Provincial
- 10:16Courts at the bottom. They handle most things.
- 10:18Then Provincial Superior Courts. than Provincial
- 10:21Courts of Appeal. And the boss at the top is
- 10:23the Supreme Court of Canada. Right. And what
- 10:27glues this whole hierarchy together is stare
- 10:30decisis. Oh, my memory trick for that is staring
- 10:33at past decisions. It means lower courts have
- 10:36to follow the precedence of the higher courts.
- 10:38Yeah, let the decision stand. Because without
- 10:40it, a judge could just decide things based on
- 10:43what they had for breakfast. It gives us stability.
- 10:46Thank goodness. Now. What about criminal versus
- 10:49civil law? Huge difference in the burden of proof.
- 10:53In criminal law, the state is trying to put you
- 10:55in a cage. Liberty is on the line. So they have
- 10:58to prove it beyond a reasonable doubt. Yes. But
- 11:01in civil law, it's just two citizens fighting
- 11:04over money. So the standard is much lower. The
- 11:06balance of probabilities. Yeah. Which just means
- 11:09tipping the scale to 51 percent, right? Exactly.
- 11:11It just has to be slightly more likely than not.
- 11:13OK. And during a trial, there's a trier of law
- 11:16and a trier of fact. The judge is always the
- 11:18trier of law. They interpret the rules. But the
- 11:21jury or the judge in a bench trial is the trier
- 11:24of fact. They decide what actually happened.
- 11:26And that brings up the rules of evidence. There's
- 11:28a big difference between admissibility and weight.
- 11:31Oh, yeah. Admissibility is just whether the evidence
- 11:34is legally allowed in the door. So a judge might
- 11:37say a traumatized three -year -old is allowed
- 11:39to testify. It's admissible. Right. But the jury,
- 11:44the trier of fact, decides the weight. They might
- 11:47hear the toddler and say, yeah, we can't base
- 11:50a conviction on a three -year -old's memory and
- 11:52give it zero weight. Admissibility gets you in.
- 11:55Weight is how much the jury cares. Precisely.
- 11:58And speaking of getting in, we have to talk about
- 12:00hearsay. Oh, man. Hearsay is presumptively inadmissible.
- 12:04Because the courts hate gossip. You can't cross
- 12:06-examine gossip. Exactly. But it completely depends
- 12:09on why you are introducing this statement. Remember
- 12:12the Helen example. Right. So if Helen calls me
- 12:14from England and says, it's raining, and a lawyer
- 12:17asks me to repeat that in court to prove it was
- 12:19actually raining, that's hearsay. Because Helen
- 12:22isn't there. You can't ask her if she was looking
- 12:24at a sprinkler. But wait. If the lawyer just
- 12:26wants to prove that Helen was alive on Friday.
- 12:29Yes. Then her saying, it's raining, has nothing
- 12:32to do with the weather. Oh, wow. It's just proof
- 12:34that she could speak, so it's not hearsay. Exactly.
- 12:37You aren't proving the truth of the contents.
- 12:39That is such a trick question waiting to happen.
- 12:42OK, last big topic for the study session, expert
- 12:45evidence. Because normally, witnesses can't give
- 12:48opinions, right? Right. You can say the car was
- 12:50red, but you can't say the crash was his fault.
- 12:54But Experts get a special privilege to give opinions.
- 12:57And to stop junk science, the Supreme Court made
- 13:00the Mohan criteria, RV Mohan, four hurdles. Let's
- 13:04run through them. First, it must be necessary,
- 13:07meaning it's outside the everyday experience
- 13:10of a normal juror. Like the textbook example
- 13:12of delayed reporting and child abuse, a normal
- 13:15juror might think, if they were abused, why wait
- 13:1710 years to tell someone they must be lying?
- 13:19Right. So a forensic psychologist is necessary
- 13:21to explain trauma and shame to the jury. Got
- 13:24it. Second hurdle, it must be relevant to a material
- 13:27issue, like no lectures on sleepwalking if the
- 13:30crime happened while they were awake at noon.
- 13:31Exactly. Third, the expert must be properly qualified,
- 13:35which doesn't always mean a PhD. Sometimes it's
- 13:39just years of specific field experience. And
- 13:41the fourth hurdle, no exclusionary rules. You
- 13:45can't use an expert to sneak in banned evidence
- 13:48like a defendant's bad past character. Yes, they
- 13:50have to play by the rules of the arena. Man,
- 13:52OK. We covered so much ground today. We went
- 13:56from the boxing match of the adversarial system
- 13:58to the division of powers to bodily autonomy
- 14:03shifting at the border. We covered the charter
- 14:05protecting us from the state. Actus Reus, and
- 14:08mens rea, and the strict Mohan rules for psychologists
- 14:12testifying. I honestly feel way better about
- 14:14this module now. Same. But before we wrap up,
- 14:17I want to drop one final really provocative thought
- 14:19from the source text so we didn't touch on much.
- 14:22Oh, hit me. So we talked about the Charter being
- 14:23the supreme law, right? But the framers intentionally
- 14:26wrote it using really broad, interpretable language.
- 14:29Well, okay. Why? Because they didn't want it
- 14:31to stagnate. They wanted courts to reinterpret
- 14:33it as society's values evolved. Like, what was
- 14:36a reasonable limit in 1982 might be totally unacceptable
- 14:40today. Oh, so it's a living document. Yeah. But
- 14:43think about the philosophical implication of
- 14:45that. If our supreme law is designed to constantly
- 14:48shift with the cultural mood, Does the law actually
- 14:53reflect objective morality? Or is justice just
- 14:57a mirror reflecting whatever random consensus
- 14:59society happens to believe right now? Wait, that's
- 15:02incredibly deep. Are we searching for a universal
- 15:04truth or just enforcing a popularity contest
- 15:06of modern morals? Exactly. Something to chew
- 15:08on while you review your notes. Wow. Okay, I'm
- 15:11definitely going to be thinking about that during
- 15:12the exam. Thanks for starting with us everyone.
- 15:15We will catch you on the next deep dive here
- 15:17on The Psychology Undergrad. Good luck.