Latest / The Vegan Report / Vegan by Default, Baby Jessica Effect & China | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00This is Rakefet for The Vegan Report. Today we're
- 0:03exploring the question, what if a simple intervention
- 0:07like defaults, a vegan filter and a story of
- 0:10an individual cow can help save the animals?
- 0:15Connect with me, my email and social links are
- 0:19in the episode notes. You can find new episodes
- 0:23every Wednesday on this podcast. Please share
- 0:27this episode with your community. I am a research
- 0:31manager at the China Vegan Society. I am also
- 0:35doing a PhD in social psychology, in which I
- 0:38study sustainable defaults, and today we will
- 0:41explore a hot topic in social psychology, the
- 0:45power of defaults, and how sustainable defaults
- 0:49can be a powerful tool for driving change in
- 0:52institutions. Defaults have an outside impact
- 0:57on behavior, more so than information campaigns,
- 1:01reminders or incentives. Sustainable defaults
- 1:07allow us to transform institutions in a way that
- 1:10preserves choice rather than limiting it. This
- 1:14approach has been proven effective and we will
- 1:18discuss some real world examples of how sustainable
- 1:21defaults have driven positive change. The key
- 1:26is leveraging the power of defaults to make the
- 1:29sustainable choice the easy choice. By making
- 1:33sustainable options the default, we can shift
- 1:36nodes and drive meaningful progress without restricting
- 1:40individual freedom. So why sustainable food matters?
- 1:47First, the environmental impact. Campus dining
- 1:51halls serve millions of meals annually. Shifting
- 1:56to sustainable defaults can dramatically reduce
- 2:00carbon emissions, water usage, and land degradation.
- 2:06Secondly, health benefits. Diets based on vegetables
- 2:11Reduce risk for chronic diseases including heart
- 2:15disease, diabetes and certain cancers. Promoting
- 2:20healthier student communities. Third, social
- 2:25justice. Making sustainable meets the default
- 2:28increases accessibility and inclusivity for students
- 2:31with diverse dietary, religious and ethical preferences.
- 2:38The problem is that many people don't want us
- 2:41to decide for them what to eat. The solution?
- 2:45To keep all the options, but to encourage them
- 2:49to eat sustainable food with the default effect,
- 2:52the pre -selected option that you get if you
- 2:55don't choose otherwise. Defaults are powerful
- 2:58because it's not only that we are too lazy to
- 3:03choose the non -default option, But we also trust
- 3:08that if an option is the default, it must be
- 3:11so because it's the better one, feeling like
- 3:15this is what is expected of us. And we don't
- 3:19have to take any option away. You get effective
- 3:22results without removing any option. Changing
- 3:26defaults can shape decisions at a large scale
- 3:30while still keeping freedom of choice. This might
- 3:35be why defaults have been shown to yield two
- 3:38to four times higher acceptance compared to other
- 3:41psychological approaches. Behavioral science
- 3:45shows that default options profoundly influence
- 3:49our decisions. When sustainable meals are presented
- 3:54as the standard choice, students naturally gravitate
- 3:58toward them without feeling restricted. Studies
- 4:03from universities that have implemented sustainable
- 4:06default options show consumption increases by
- 4:1040 -80 % compared to traditional opt -in approaches.
- 4:16This isn't about taking away choice, it's about
- 4:20making the sustainable choice the easy choice.
- 4:23Opting out of the default is much easier for
- 4:26people than actively choosing the desired behavior.
- 4:30This opt -out approach leads to a substantial
- 4:3353 -87 % increase in sustainable meat selections,
- 4:38as demonstrated by Greener by default. Defaults
- 4:43leverage our tendency towards inertia and the
- 4:46status quo. People are more likely to stick with
- 4:49the default, making it a highly effective tool
- 4:52for promoting sustainable behaviors. And defaults
- 4:56are a huge success. On average, There is a 60
- 5:00% increase in sustainable meal selection when
- 5:04implementing a sustainable default. For example,
- 5:07hospitals in New York saw an impact of over 800
- 5:12,000 additional sustainable meals served annually.
- 5:16After making the switch, sustainable selection
- 5:21rates jumped to 81 .5 % on default days, compared
- 5:27to just 30 .8 % on control days. This has a significant
- 5:33carbon reduction impact, with the potential to
- 5:37save 350 ,000 kg of CO2 annually for large institutions.
- 5:44For example, and one among many successful implementations
- 5:49of the default effect, according to Hansen, Schilling
- 5:53and Malthusen, These are the results from three
- 5:57different experiments, A, B and C, conducted
- 6:01at various conferences with two groups in each
- 6:05experiment. Group 1 received a registration form
- 6:10with a non -sustainable lunch as the default
- 6:13option, but with the ability to choose a sustainable
- 6:16option. Group 2 received a registration form
- 6:21with a sustainable lunch as the default option.
- 6:25but with the ability to choose a non -sustainable
- 6:28option. The main results. In Experiment 3, sustainable
- 6:33choice increased from 2 % to 87%, an increase
- 6:39of 85%. In Experiment 2, sustainable choice increased
- 6:44from 6 % to 86%, an increase of 80%. And in Experiment
- 6:523, Sustainable choice increased from 12 .5 %
- 6:57to 89%, an increase of 76 .5%. By the way, when
- 7:06the participants were informed eventually that
- 7:09they had been part of an experiment, they didn't
- 7:13mind. They were asked whether they approved of
- 7:17the nudge or not, and 90 % of the people who
- 7:21were exposed to the nudge actually approved it
- 7:24oh for example toulon and lay universities achieved
- 7:28an impressive 81 .5 sustainable meals on sustainable
- 7:34default days showing strong institutional commitment
- 7:38surveys indicated high satisfaction and minimal
- 7:44resistance from students and professors demonstrating
- 7:48broad acceptance of the program. The financial
- 7:52impact was cost neutral or even generated savings
- 7:56for the institutions, making it a sustainable
- 8:00model. These examples showcase how universities
- 8:04can effectively transition to more sustainable
- 8:08dining options, benefiting students, the environment
- 8:12and the bottom line. Another study led by Zhang
- 8:172014 examined six different university events
- 8:22across four academic institutions. At these events,
- 8:27attendees pre -selected their meals on one of
- 8:31two randomly assigned RSVP forms. One form had
- 8:37a meat -based default option, the other one had
- 8:41a sustainable default. The results showed a 43
- 8:45% increase in sustainable choices when the sustainable
- 8:49option was the default. This led to a significant
- 8:53environmental impact with over 100 ,000 kg of
- 8:58CO2 reduced from just these six small events.
- 9:03Another study by Gene and Sparkman from 2024
- 9:08looks at how three different university cafeterias
- 9:14changed their offerings over three months in
- 9:18one condition the sustainable dish and the meat
- 9:21-based dish were displayed behind the glass and
- 9:25in the other condition only the sustainable dish
- 9:28was displayed behind the glass and you could
- 9:31have gotten meat only if you specifically asked
- 9:35for it this led to a 58 .3 % increase in sustainable
- 9:41choices, and 57 .2 % decrease in meat -based
- 9:47choices. The data also shows that students were
- 9:51very receptive to the expanded sustainable offerings,
- 9:55and prefer them over meat -based options. And
- 9:59there are different types of sustainable defaults
- 10:02that organizations can implement. Here I can
- 10:05mention four of them. The first one is menu default.
- 10:09We set sustainable options as the standard with
- 10:14animal products available only by request. The
- 10:18second one is bulk serving. We provide a sustainable
- 10:22buffet with an option for animal protein sites.
- 10:26The third one is event or catering. We default
- 10:31to sustainable event registration forms. with
- 10:35alternatives available only by special selection.
- 10:38And the last one is cafeteria design. We prioritize
- 10:43sustainable options visually and by organizing
- 10:46the space. The key is to shift the default so
- 10:50that sustainable food is the standard and no
- 10:53sustainable food is the exception that requires
- 10:56extra effort. This helps normalize sustainable
- 11:01eating and makes it the easy, convenient choice
- 11:05for most people. There are three concrete examples
- 11:08of how we can implement sustainable options in
- 11:11different settings, including a hospital, a university
- 11:15and a school. For hospitals, the standard meal
- 11:20trays should be sustainable, but patients can
- 11:24request meat options through a simple form. For
- 11:28university events, the RSVP form defaults to
- 11:32sustainable meals and attendees must actively
- 11:37opt out to request a non -sustainable option.
- 11:40In school lunch programs, the daily lunch is
- 11:44sustainable by default and parents must submit
- 11:47a special form to request a non -sustainable
- 11:50option for their children. And to summarize the
- 11:53benefits to the cafeterias, sustainable food
- 11:57is not only better for the planet it's also better
- 12:01for the budgets health outcomes and overall satisfaction
- 12:06as for the second intervention we were working
- 12:09on let me ask you a question can we encourage
- 12:12people who are not vegetarian nor vegan to take
- 12:16an action for the animals and the answer is yes
- 12:20we can using the identifiable victim effect Originally,
- 12:25the identifiable victim effect was seen when
- 12:28a girl named Jessica fell into a well. It's horrible,
- 12:32but she received more media coverage than Wanda
- 12:35and her foe together. People felt for her because
- 12:40she was an identified victim with a name and
- 12:43a face. A study by Markovitch, 2013, found the
- 12:49identifiable victim effect for animals, but only
- 12:53for non -environmentalists this led us to think
- 12:58that non -vegetarians would help a single identifiable
- 13:01animal victim more than a group of unidentified
- 13:05victims we conducted three experiments to test
- 13:10that in experiment one we gave participants a
- 13:14true story in which in which the cow lucky with
- 13:18a picture or several anonymous cows without a
- 13:22picture managed to escape from a live market.
- 13:26The participants reported their willingness to
- 13:29sign and share a petition to bring Lucky or the
- 13:32several cows to a farm sanctuary. And we have
- 13:36found that people were more willing to sign and
- 13:40share the petition for the cow when he was identified.
- 13:44But would people sign an actual petition? Let's
- 13:49find out. In experiment 2, We showed the same
- 13:53story, only this time with an actual petition.
- 13:57We found that a cow with a name and a picture
- 14:00got more people to sign and support an actual
- 14:03petition. But we didn't separate identifiability,
- 14:07the effect of a victim having a name and a face,
- 14:11from singularity, the effect of a single victim
- 14:14yet. To do this, we ran experiment 3, in which
- 14:20we had each person in one of four groups single
- 14:25identified single unidentified plural identified
- 14:29and plural unidentified victims we found that
- 14:34a single identified victim raised more donations
- 14:37than the three other groups ambivalence towards
- 14:41meat which was the inner conflict explained it
- 14:46and finally the vegan filter project Look, we
- 14:50know that a big problem is that vegan shopping
- 14:54is inconvenient. According to Phonolitics 2016
- 14:59and again in 2024, vegetarian and vegan dropout
- 15:05rate is as high as 84%. Convenience seems like
- 15:11the number one reason flexitarians don't go vegan.
- 15:17So, What could possibly be the solution? The
- 15:22solution is to turn the whole online supermarket
- 15:25vegan with just a click of a button. The project
- 15:30we are trying to promote is a simple button that
- 15:35will filter all the vegan products in the supermarket
- 15:39instantly showing only the vegan items. It will
- 15:44include all the plant -based products in the
- 15:47store. These are products that online websites
- 15:51sometimes for some reasons don't include. For
- 15:55example, if it's obvious that they are vegan.
- 15:59However, we still want to buy them. Our goal
- 16:03is to reduce friction, especially for new vegans.
- 16:07New vegans go vegan and find out that they have
- 16:13to go through the ingredient list and then they
- 16:17still don't find enough products. This might
- 16:21be part of the reason why, again according to
- 16:24phonolitics, 5 out of 6 new vegetarians or vegans
- 16:29quit. We want to change that. This is an example
- 16:33for what we call nudges at the point of sale.
- 16:38And we think we should use them more often, right
- 16:42when the decision is made. According to a study
- 16:45by Qatar and Zhao, with over 3 ,000 total views,
- 16:51sustainable filters increase vegan product sales
- 16:55by 25 -37%. And we want to focus on China. Actually,
- 17:03there are more humans and farmed animals living
- 17:07inside the area surrounding India and China than
- 17:10in the rest of the world combined. It means that
- 17:15according to Asia for Animals, the AFA, that
- 17:19it is 75 % of the farmed animals, 90 % of the
- 17:27fish, and 5 billion people, who are 60 % of the
- 17:34world's population. And China receives only 8
- 17:39% of the pro -animal funding. Also, a project
- 17:45in China is expected to be cost -efficient. We
- 17:49expect that confirming that the products are
- 17:54vegan in the vegan filter will cost three times
- 17:59less than in the US. China is also very supportive
- 18:04with its 14 five -year plan stating that alternative
- 18:10proteins are a national priority so we want to
- 18:14include an ai -based vegan filter button inside
- 18:18the supermarket app and we will double check
- 18:23the ingredients with actual consumers we also
- 18:27want to conduct surveys to track the impact so
- 18:31just to summarize it all here are three key points
- 18:37Plant -based defaults have been found to be the
- 18:41most effective institutional approach for dietary
- 18:45change. Implementing plant -based defaults offer
- 18:48many benefits, enabling us to save costs, reduce
- 18:53emissions, and increase inclusivity for all diners.
- 18:57Plant -based defaults seem like the most effective
- 19:01leverage point for us to drive large -scale plant
- 19:06-based adoption. As for the identifiable victim
- 19:10effect, the effect of a single individual with
- 19:13a name and a picture, the take -home message
- 19:17is give lucky a name and a face. Finally, we
- 19:20encourage you to advocate for a vegan filter
- 19:23button to reduce one of the biggest barriers
- 19:25for new vegans, which is convenience. So what
- 19:30can we do starting from today? Talk to someone
- 19:34in leadership or food services about the idea
- 19:38of a vegan default, the identifiable victim,
- 19:42or the vegan filter. Or if you are in leadership,
- 19:46collaborate with businesses and restaurants.
- 19:50Share what you have learned today with others.
- 19:54Write a message, have a meeting, post on social
- 19:58media. Start a small pilot. such as one event,
- 20:03one meeting or one meal with a vegan default
- 20:07option, tell the story of a single animal with
- 20:11a picture and a name, pitch the idea of removing
- 20:14barriers online and generally share your success
- 20:18to inspire others to take similar actions. The
- 20:24change we want is already happening and we have
- 20:27the privilege to take a part. Thank you so much
- 20:31for listening. I appreciate your interest and
- 20:34support.