Latest / Ego and Other Things / Happiness Is The Exception | Vlogs
Transcript
- William: Alright, today I just wanted to record a quick vlog video for you guys. I'm gonna be going away on a trip to Ohio for the next few days, which is gonna kinda interrupt my my regular workflow. So I just wanna do something that was while I was a little bit light, a little bit easy. And one of the things I I had in my mind recently was this whole idea of especially in modern Western kind of societies, there is this expectation of happiness, meaning that there is this feeling that we should be happy and that That life ought to be happy. And I've never really thought about it before, but that kind of idea or that kind of expectation Seems a little bit odd when you start to think about it and when you start to think about it in terms of our history. And this really came up for me because I I've been in the process of writing a book and and one of the sections of the books deals with of the book deals with There this tension between the needs of survival and the sort of purpose of human life, meaning and joy and happiness, and really just the ability to act for the sake of what we authentically value. Meaning this tension of the fact that though we have to spend so much time and energy and resources and labor devoted to our own survival, human beings Are not really satisfied by survival. They're they're trying to produce something more, something better. And survival, more often than not, is a means to an end rather than an end in itself. It's survival is something that we have to submit to, something that we have to sacrifice to in order to have the time or the resources or the energy to be able to pursue the kinds of things that we really want. And In general, there's a tension between them. Meaning that the the tools and the epistemology and the perspective of the world that you have to have in order to survive on a day-to-day basis can be significantly different from the pursuit of authentic values. And one of the things I highlight in that chapter is the social needs of survival. We're often having to conform ourselves to the culture around us, whether it's rational or not, whether it actually produces any value to us or not. In order simply to get along enough to survive, and how historically if you really went against your culture, or you really questioned the sort of rationality of the religion, of the myths, of the traditions that were expected of you, that this could actually threaten your survival and therefore threaten your ability to act for the sake of what you authentically value. And so for a long time we had to sort of submit ourselves to a certain kind of self delusioned irrationality, which has persisted in degrees psychoevolutionarily in degrees over the generations. And now that the needs of survival are not so pressing, we have a lot more time to be independent. We have a lot greater ability to step outside of the irrational parts of culture and simply act for the sake of what we truly value. And there is kind of this growing expansion of social freedom, right? And so there's this whole That's the entire basically the idea of the chapter and kind of what implications that has for philosophy and for ethics, for the concept of the self, for the historical reality of childhood and how that all plays together, right? But part of that writing is, you know, diving deep into our history. And what I've noticed, or at least what stood out to me in in the in that study of you know pre-civilized history or even pre industrial history is How much of their the people's mindset or any given individuals mindset was not focused on the idea of happiness or individual fulfillment at all. In fact, the needs of survival were were so pressing, even 500 years ago for the vast majority of people, that they wouldn't have even had the idea. or the conception of personal fulfillment or happiness as something that they could really achieve, as something that they had any kind of control over. Meaning that for them, if happiness came about, if joy or pleasure or or whatnot came about in their life, it was entirely separate from what they could do to produce it, entirely separate from them having any kind of control or or choice to pursue it. Whereas in the modern day, we have We seem to have at the very least choice and freedom, right? We we we think of our lives in terms of, you know, how can I arrange things or how can I set up my life so that I can do the things that I really want, right? Whether that's artistic pursuits, whether that's playing video games, whether that's spending time with our family, whether that's some sort of business we're producing, whether that's you know, again, some sort of creative hobby, whatever. actually gives us fulfillment and joy, the way that we look at our lives often is, okay, well, you know, I I've gotta get I've gotta get certain things done, right? I've gotta get enough money and have a home and and have the basic necessities and maybe some some luxuries over here. But once I get those set in place, then I have a certain amount of hours within the day that I'm gonna spend on the things that actually, you know, bring me bring me joy or fulfillment or or pleasure or whatever. And so we and we do this not only in our day-to-day lives, but we do it kind of in the structure of our lives. So a lot of standard advice given to young people is, you know, when you're young, you know, you try try to try to sacrifice and build up a foundation for yourself so that when you're in your thirties and forties, you're gonna have a lot more freedom and time to pursue the things that are of of real value to you, of real meaning to you, right? You don't want to Act impulsively when you're young and then have to pay for it when when you're later, because it's harder to make up for that the older you get than it is for when you're younger. And so both in our day-to-day lives and even in the way that we we think about planning for our lives, we try to structure things in a way where at some point we're gonna be able to do the things that that make us happy, right? And the more you go back in history, the more you realize that. they knew never even had the chance to conceive of having autonomy, conceive of having choice, conceive of acting individually for the sake of their own happiness. their primary and constant concern was always, okay, what do I need to do in order to to live for the next day or for the next few months? What do I need to do in order to protect or feed or clothe or help my my family and my community survive. And the few moments or the few days within a given year that they really had any kind of deliberate free time or structured leisure were these kinds of festivals that were placed around Times of abundant harvest like the first fruits of spring or or the har the fall harvest. And so it was only that really a couple of days or maybe a a few days strung together where the people could largely let their their pressing needs of survival, let the their guard down and actually, you know, have some some some pleasure for that day. There was no expectation. and no mindset that that I I get to choose my life, I get to choose my role within society, I get to choose my path, and That I get to be happy. And again, one of the things that stands out to me about modern culture is that that is how we structure our lives. We we're structuring after the pursuit of happiness and meaning and purpose, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. I mean, I think it's a great improvement that we actually have enough time and leisure and power and resources that you know, lots of people can actually have some free time. In their life to think about those things and pursue them. But one of the things I think that stands out negative about the modern mindset is this expectation of happiness. This sense in which if I don't feel happy or fulfilled or like I'm moving towards my my purpose in life. That I individually have have failed in some way. That I have failed to live up to what is expected of me. I think a lot of people almost view you know stress, anxiety, sadness, even stretches of depression as the as out of the norm, as out of the norm of human experience, as out of the norm of of how life as a human being you know should or ought to be. But when we go back in time and we look at the people of the past, there wasn't any expectation to be happy. I mean, they thought of life as basically a a near constant struggle that was every once in a while permeated by by moments of happiness or by by days of specifically ritual leisure or you know happiness and joy and meaning and purpose was almost entirely consumed by The pursuit of survival itself, and then broke in in moments of free time and leisure that happened to come upon them that they had no control or purpose over. The actual natural state so to speak, or at least the historical state, is one of suffering, struggle, pain, boredom, Punctuated by moments of of happiness that are completely outside of one's control. And yet again, in in the modern day, we expect to be happy most of the time. We expect, in one sense, to be pursuing our purpose most of the time. We expect to feel fulfilled most of the time. And I don't know. I mean I I really don't know Maybe where that that new tension comes about, besides the fact that we have we actually have the free time. But I wonder if that mindset of the expectation of happiness in the modern day does does more harm than good, and and triggers that kind of comparison narrative that we go in ahead in our brain and doesn't really allow us to be to be grateful for. how much or how often we get to be happy in our lives compared to to our to our ancestors. It's almost adjacent to the kind of stoical or or or Buddhist mindset of This sense of of recognizing that life Is not inherently a place of of happiness, joy, meaning, purpose, love, I mean any of these kinds of things, sort of recognizing that that the actual base case of survival and humanity and society is is kind of one of suffering or boredom. Almost you know, sort of like Schopenhauer said, right? The pendulum between suffering and boredom. That that that life is really at its base, or at least in its natural state, something that is Actually quite quite unfulfilling and painful. And that that's natural. And that in the modern in the modern age, you know, when you when you when you are experiencing pain, when you're experiencing loss, when you are experiencing struggle, when you are experiencing anxiety, when you're experiencing depression, that those experiences in the world are not actually odd. They're not out of place. They're not even mistaken. they are responding to something that is actually true and real about the world. And that it's actually more odd for people to be happy, it's more odd for people to have joy, it's more odd for people to feel fulfilled and meaningful and like they have a purpose, than the opposite way. And it's not that it makes any of these negative experiences you know. in and of themselves better by recognizing that that that tends to be the natural case of Existing as a human being, but that it kind of gives this sense of I'm not the odd one, right? I'm not the odd one if I'm suffering. I'm not the odd one if I'm anxious. I'm not the odd one if I'm depressed. I'm not the odd one if I feel out of place, if I feel as though I don't have a purpose or a meaning. that that that when you're experiencing that, you're actually in really good company historically. and that even the people in the modern day who who suffer from who suffer from you know those those feelings or states or periods, then oftentimes those periods of suffering or boredom or or whatnot are still comparatively less than what the vast majority of the people in in our history actually experienced. I almost wish that we could continually bring the mindset that happiness is the exception and not the rule. Happiness is should not be an expectation. Purpose should not be an expectation, but rather always to treat it as the the exception when we take in the the context of the whole of our history. And by understanding that, by by understanding that joy and purpose and meaning that that these kinds of things are actually the exception, then when they happen to us, right, or when we get the opportunity to do something that's that's actually meaningful and fulfilling to us, we can recognize how significantly rare that is, or significantly different that is, rather than treating it like, you know, I've finally gotten to the place where I should be, right? I finally gotten to the place where I ought to be, rather recognizing I've gotten to a place that is genuinely rare and exceptional and wonderful because of that. And then the same way when we do go through the suffering and the boredom and the sense of listlessness, recognizing like, yeah, that's that's kind of the base case of life. That's kind of the base case of you know what human life is like. And I don't know, maybe that's maybe that would be depressing for some people, or maybe they would ask themselves, you know, why, you know, why endure that at all? And Again, for me anyway, I mean I I I'm I'm a Christian, so e even if life in and of itself is kind of just suffering and boredom for the most part, even if I the rest of my life I could never do anything that was meaningful or experience any more kind of happiness, you know, I myself would consider that to be you know, the the result of a fallen world and and know that that know with with a certain faith that someday I'm going to be with my creator in heaven, where there is no suffering and all tears are wiped away. But even just looking at the history of of the past and and looking at how did our ancestors deal with this perpetual this this base case of suffering and and boredom beyond the religion and beyond the myths of their of their time, how do they deal with it? And I think there there are many well, there are a couple distinct ways that they dealt with it. One was really just this idea of hope. there's this I the idea in general that that people were building something out of which they would never experience themselves, but which they knew their their children or their grandchildren, their great grandchildren, or generations even further down the line would benefit. And even if their the majority of their life was, you know, suffering and boredom, they got purpose and meaning out of using that, using, being a part of that. and and viewing it as the growth of the tribe or the civilization or the nation around them and sort of enthusiastically in one sense building for that kind of future and And also the the punctuated moments of structured, you know, leisure celebration or whatnot, I think really helped them to endure through it because it would be months and months of this you know, constantly just doing whatever you needed to do in order to survive and and laboring and laboring. And then you would get these sort of punctuated moments of celebration. And oftentimes those moments of celebration, because they were so d distinct in in pleasure and leisure and and whatnot, n they were they were heightened to this kind of psychological and sen extent that that helped them to anticipate it, so to speak. And y you know, in one sense giving our giving ourselves celebrations I think can be can be helpful. But the third part really was that was this community aspect to it, right? Where you Even while you were laboring, right, you even while you were you're struggling with other people to to survive on a day-to-day basis, there was a sense of of unity with other people. You were struggling alongside your tribe members and and the and the people of your community. You were str you were struggling alongside them. And Out of that struggle, people would create stories that they would tell each other. They would create poems that they would that they would talk with one another about. they were constantly socially communicating with each other face to face next to each other while they're they're laboring and and people would you know they'd they'd come together to to eat at the end of the day as a as a group, not just sort of. you know, isolated families or isolated individuals, but as a group they would sort of so socially connect with one another. In this way that I think even throughout the day you you could kinda get through the the majority of of the suffering and the boredom because, you know, hey, you get to go talk to to use a modern name, you get to go talk to Tom later, right? Or you get to to to see your wife later, or you get to sit around with the people of of your tribe or community, and and catch up with them about the day and you know, maybe maybe Josh has a new story for us or or Bob has a new joke to tell, I don't know, something like that, right? there is this anticipation of of the social connection that acted as almost a perpetual reward for the kind of innate suffering, pain, loss, and boredom that was the natural state of of people. And I know that in the modern day, for a number of reasons, structurally this becomes even more and more difficult. And so in in one sense the the suffering and the and the pain is the suffering and the loss and and boredom is is more difficult to endure today than it might have been in the past. it's hard to really know because it's such a subjective evaluation. But I don't know. I was just sort of as writing a as writing that chapter, I was just sort of lingering on this idea of the modern expectation of of happiness and and wondering whether or not Is that expectation realistic, right? You know, just i i i it often goes uncommunicated. It often goes people don't talk about it explicitly, but there is this kind of expectation that that we need to be happy, right? We need to be in pursuit of what's meaningful to us. We need to be living a meaningful and joyful life. And you know, you go up to somebody and you ask them how you're doing, and they say, I'm doing good. You know, and and there's this sense of in which If somebody is not happy or me or joy f or if someone is not happy or joyful or or s or full of meaning that we think there is something wrong, right? We think there's something wrong, something has gone wrong, you know, either with them or with something happening around them. And that's just not historically the case, right? I mean historically again, happiness, joy meaning that was the exception. That was the complete rare exception that one had no no control over. And and I wonder I wonder to what degree that recognizing that explicitly and trying to remind oneself that happiness is an exception to life and not the rule would enable one to actually feel estranged in the world and appreciate the moments that they do have of of genuine joy and meaning. So Anyway, I think that's where we're gonna end the end the vlog today. the next video I'm doing, going to be doing is going to be part two on the meta philosophy, talking about the what it means to to be a philosopher and the structure of philosophy and sort of who counts as a philosopher and who doesn't, sort of critiques of of academic philosophy. so that's what we'll be headed next. But you know, in this question of the tension between happiness and survival, I mean, do you see that tension In your own life, and do you expect to be happy in your day-to-day life? Or do you kind of take the the more historically realistic expectation that life is full of suffering and boredom? And how do you think these expectations play in your day-to-day life? Let me know. Put your answers down in the comments. I would love to have a conversation with you guys about that and really just talk our different perspectives. But if you like this video, please give it a like. If you think this video would be interesting to somebody else, then please share it with them. And if you want more videos like this, then please hit subscribe. And as always, thank you guys for watching.