Latest / Bloomberg Law / Did Hunter Biden Get a Sweetheart Deal?
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: It made him a very good deal and he shucked
- 0:14Speaker 2: it up like a hoover belocked.
- 0:15Speaker 3: Senator John Kennedy was just one of the Republicans saying
- 0:19Speaker 3: Hunter Biden got a sweetheart deal that will likely allow
- 0:22Speaker 3: him to avoid time behind bars on tax and gun charges.
- 0:27Speaker 3: Although Attorney General Merrick Garland maintains that he kept his
- 0:30Speaker 3: promise not to interfere with US Attorney David Weisse's investigation
- 0:35Speaker 3: and charging decision for the president's son.
- 0:39Speaker 1: So as I said from the moment of my appointment
- 0:43Speaker 1: as Attorney General, I would leave this matter in the
- 0:46Speaker 1: hands of the United States Attorney who was appointed by
- 0:50Speaker 1: the previous president and assigned to this matter by the
- 0:53Speaker 1: previous administration, that he would be given full authority to
- 0:58Speaker 1: decide the matter as he decided that was appropriate.
- 1:01Speaker 3: After a five year investigation. The deal calls for Hunter
- 1:04Speaker 3: Biden's son to plead guilty to two misdemeanor counts of
- 1:08Speaker 3: failing to pay taxes and accept court imposed conditions that
- 1:12Speaker 3: will allow him to avoid prosecution on a felony gun charge.
- 1:17Speaker 3: Joining me is former federal prosecutor Robert Mintz, a partner
- 1:20Speaker 3: at Macarter and English Weiss's office, said the tax charges
- 1:24Speaker 3: each come with a maximum sentence of twelve months and
- 1:28Speaker 3: that the gun charge carries up to ten years incarceration.
- 1:32Speaker 3: So Republicans have lasted the agreement, saying he's getting away
- 1:36Speaker 3: with this slap on the wrist.
- 1:38Speaker 4: What do you think, Well, the investigation here has been
- 1:42Speaker 4: conducted by David Weiss, who was the US Attorney for
- 1:46Speaker 4: the state of Delaware appointed by President Trump, and President
- 1:51Speaker 4: Biden allowed him to continue over into his administration, specifically
- 1:55Speaker 4: so that he can continue this investigation into the president's son.
- 2:00Speaker 4: And according to the Attorney General Merrick Garland, who testified
- 2:03Speaker 4: before Congress about this ongoing investigation, he said that he
- 2:07Speaker 4: gave mister Weiss full authority and independence to decide whether
- 2:11Speaker 4: to bring charges against mister Biden's son on which charges
- 2:14Speaker 4: to bring. So there is at least an appearance of
- 2:16Speaker 4: independence by this US attorney in these charging decisions. But
- 2:21Speaker 4: as you point out, the investigation really boiled down to
- 2:24Speaker 4: two issues at the end of the day. Here. One
- 2:27Speaker 4: was whether to indict Hunter Biden in connection with his
- 2:29Speaker 4: failure to meet filing deadlines for his twenty seventeen at
- 2:33Speaker 4: twenty eighteen taxes and whether he didn't properly claimed about
- 2:37Speaker 4: thirty thousand dollars in deductions for business expenses. Mister Weiss
- 2:41Speaker 4: said that mister Biden had earned more than one point
- 2:44Speaker 4: five million in each of those years, but failed to
- 2:46Speaker 4: pay income taxes during those years, which amotters to about
- 2:49Speaker 4: one hundred thousand dollars each year. Mister Biden subsequently paid
- 2:53Speaker 4: that overdue bill in twenty twenty one. The second issue
- 2:56Speaker 4: was one having to do with the purchase of a gun.
- 2:59Speaker 2: At the time.
- 3:00Speaker 4: Biden had filled out a government format every individual has
- 3:03Speaker 4: to when purchasing a handgun, stating that he was not
- 3:06Speaker 4: using drugs, and it was a parent from his erratic
- 3:09Speaker 4: activity that mister Biden did have a drug issue at
- 3:11Speaker 4: the time he purchased that weapon. So those are the
- 3:14Speaker 4: two issues that ultimately this investigation came down to. But
- 3:18Speaker 4: let's bear in mind that the investigation started off with
- 3:22Speaker 4: a much broader mandate. Mister Weiss was given authority to
- 3:25Speaker 4: investigate mister Biden's activities regarding an array of issues, including
- 3:30Speaker 4: his dealings with Chinese investors, his work with Barisma, a
- 3:34Speaker 4: Ukrainian energy company on whose board he served while his
- 3:38Speaker 4: father was Vice president, and at that time Vice President
- 3:41Speaker 4: Biden was overseeing the Obama administration's policy towards Ukraine. So
- 3:45Speaker 4: these are large issues that have been within the ambit
- 3:48Speaker 4: of mister Weiss's investigation, but at least to date, no
- 3:51Speaker 4: charges have been brought in connection with any of those issues,
- 3:54Speaker 4: and now we're facing only these two relatively minor issues
- 3:58Speaker 4: involving taxes and involving the purchase of a handgun.
- 4:02Speaker 3: Some legal experts said that the use of a diversion
- 4:05Speaker 3: agreement to resolve the gun charge was creative and fairly unusual,
- 4:12Speaker 3: and Republican Senator Mike Lee retweeted criticisms of the agreement
- 4:17Speaker 3: and said that pre trial diversion programs normally exclude offenses
- 4:21Speaker 3: involving the brandishing of a firearm. Is that diversion agreement unusual?
- 4:27Speaker 4: Well, it is unusual for federal prostituts to use diversion
- 4:30Speaker 4: agreements at all, and it also is unusual for federal
- 4:33Speaker 4: prosecutors to charge misdemeanors. When I was a federal prosecutor
- 4:37Speaker 4: for almost ten years, I could probably tell you on
- 4:40Speaker 4: a single hand how many times misdemeanors were charged. Generally,
- 4:44Speaker 4: if it doesn't amount to a felony, prosecutors on the
- 4:47Speaker 4: federal level are not going to bother pursuing it, given
- 4:49Speaker 4: the limited resources that they have. But this is a
- 4:52Speaker 4: very high profile case that was being watched very closely
- 4:56Speaker 4: by the American public and by politicians on Capitol Hill,
- 4:59Speaker 4: and so I think there was a lot of pressure
- 5:01Speaker 4: for the US Attorney here to bring charges if there
- 5:04Speaker 4: were provable charges, and here there definitely were provable charges.
- 5:09Speaker 4: The facts regarding the failure to pay taxes were really
- 5:12Speaker 4: never in dispute, and the misstatement and the purchase of
- 5:14Speaker 4: the handgun was also something that was not disputed. But
- 5:18Speaker 4: these are charges that prosecutors will rarely bring because they're frankly,
- 5:22Speaker 4: just not that serious, and generally prosecutors are not going
- 5:25Speaker 4: to devote resources to something that doesn't amount to at
- 5:29Speaker 4: least one felony charge.
- 5:30Speaker 3: Now, a judge, you'll have the final say on any sentence.
- 5:34Speaker 3: In April, an IRS supervisor who'd been overseeing the Hunter
- 5:39Speaker 3: Biden investigation went to Congress and alleged political favoritism in
- 5:44Speaker 3: how the investigation was handled. We know that Congressional Republicans
- 5:48Speaker 3: are still investigating Hunter Biden, So could the judge wait
- 5:54Speaker 3: to decide whether or not to accept the deal until
- 5:57Speaker 3: some of these investigations are well.
- 6:01Speaker 4: It's possible the judge can really do whatever he or
- 6:04Speaker 4: she wants to do here. But typically if the Department
- 6:07Speaker 4: of Justice is recommending a particular plea deal, it's rare
- 6:11Speaker 4: for judges not to accept it. I will tell you
- 6:14Speaker 4: that it does happen. It has happened a handful of
- 6:16Speaker 4: times if a judge believes that the government is essentially
- 6:20Speaker 4: giving away the store, or there's something improper about the
- 6:24Speaker 4: deal that the government has struck with a defendant. But generally,
- 6:27Speaker 4: judges rely on the discretion of prosecutors to make the
- 6:31Speaker 4: right decision, and there's lots of factors that can ultimately
- 6:33Speaker 4: go into a decision about how to charge a particular
- 6:37Speaker 4: case or whether to bring charges at all in the
- 6:39Speaker 4: first place. So this is going to be something that
- 6:42Speaker 4: I think everybody's going to watch carefully to see what
- 6:44Speaker 4: the judge does. But I think it's unlikely that the
- 6:47Speaker 4: judge is not going to agree to it, particularly since
- 6:50Speaker 4: it is being recommended by mister Weiss, who was a
- 6:53Speaker 4: Trump appointed US attorney and who by all accounts, had
- 6:57Speaker 4: complete independence in terms of whether or not to bring
- 6:59Speaker 4: these charges on ultimately what charges to bring.
- 7:02Speaker 3: No doubt this is going to continue to be a
- 7:05Speaker 3: political issue as the campaigns progress. But do you think
- 7:10Speaker 3: it's sort of been a litmus test for the Justice
- 7:12Speaker 3: Department about how it would handle this kind of politically
- 7:16Speaker 3: explosive case.
- 7:18Speaker 4: Well, these kinds of cases historically have been very difficult
- 7:21Speaker 4: for the Department of Justice to handle because of the
- 7:24Speaker 4: post familiar relationship between the defendant and the president of
- 7:28Speaker 4: the United States. We can think back on other presidents
- 7:30Speaker 4: who had family members who were subject to criminal prosecutions,
- 7:34Speaker 4: and it always is awkward because no matter what you do,
- 7:37Speaker 4: it seems like there's something improper. If they give a
- 7:39Speaker 4: deal that seems to be too lenient, people are complaining
- 7:42Speaker 4: that the president or the White House and political operatives
- 7:46Speaker 4: interfered with the Department of Justice decisions.
- 7:48Speaker 2: If the Department of Justice.
- 7:50Speaker 4: Is aggressive, other people will say that is being done
- 7:52Speaker 4: in order to make a political statement. So it's a
- 7:55Speaker 4: tough line for prosecutors to walk in this case. But
- 7:58Speaker 4: at the end, they have to look at the fact,
- 8:00Speaker 4: they have to look at the circumstances that are unique
- 8:02Speaker 4: to each case and decide what they think is an
- 8:05Speaker 4: appropriate resolution. This was a case that was being negotiated
- 8:08Speaker 4: between mister Biden's lawyer and the Department of Justice for many,
- 8:11Speaker 4: many months, and there, no doubt was a lot of
- 8:13Speaker 4: back and forth here between the Department of Justice and
- 8:16Speaker 4: mister Biden's lawyers as to whether or not there should
- 8:19Speaker 4: be criminal charges at all, and if so, which ones
- 8:21Speaker 4: he should ultimately have to be flead guilty to Bob.
- 8:23Speaker 3: I want to turn for a moment to the upcoming
- 8:25Speaker 3: criminal trial of former President Donald Trump on the Classified
- 8:29Speaker 3: Documents charges. Judge Eileen Cannon issued an order for the
- 8:33Speaker 3: trial to begin on August fourteenth. What are the chances
- 8:37Speaker 3: it will actually start.
- 8:39Speaker 4: On that day, Well, it's unlikely that it will start
- 8:41Speaker 4: that day. Typically, judges will set a date that is
- 8:45Speaker 4: within what's called the Speedy Trial Act, and that means
- 8:48Speaker 4: that once a defendant is indicted, the defendant has a
- 8:51Speaker 4: right to a trial within seventy days. In other words,
- 8:55Speaker 4: the Department of Justice and the federal prosecutors have to
- 8:58Speaker 4: be ready to go once they pull the trigger on
- 9:01Speaker 4: an indictment. They can indicted, defend it and then say, oh,
- 9:04Speaker 4: we need a year a year and a half to
- 9:05Speaker 4: continue to investigate this case before we're ready to go
- 9:08Speaker 4: to trial. So the Speedy Trial Act is there to
- 9:10Speaker 4: protect defendants right to a speedy trial in the event
- 9:14Speaker 4: they want the government to go to trial as soon
- 9:16Speaker 4: as possible. But what happens typically and what's undoubtedly going
- 9:19Speaker 4: to happen in this case, is that the defense does
- 9:21Speaker 4: not want a speedy trial, and the defense wants to
- 9:24Speaker 4: delay and draw out the trial. And in this case,
- 9:27Speaker 4: there's an ample number of issues that I think we're
- 9:29Speaker 4: going to see that will result in a delay of
- 9:32Speaker 4: that trial date, perhaps months, perhaps even longer before this
- 9:35Speaker 4: case actually.
- 9:36Speaker 2: Goes to trial.
- 9:37Speaker 3: So the special counsel Jack Smith, appears to be trying
- 9:41Speaker 3: to keep to a speedy trial schedule. He started turning
- 9:45Speaker 3: over evidence to Trump's legal team, including grand jury testimony
- 9:49Speaker 3: of witnesses. How much more complicated is this case because
- 9:55Speaker 3: of the classified documents?
- 9:57Speaker 4: The fact that there's classified documents in this case does
- 10:01Speaker 4: make it more complicated than the vast majority of cases
- 10:03Speaker 4: that go to trial in federal court, and for starters,
- 10:07Speaker 4: there's going to be delayed built into this trial because
- 10:10Speaker 4: although the government is beginning to turn over evidence as
- 10:14Speaker 4: it has to in discovery to the Defense Council. The
- 10:17Speaker 4: defense lawyers here have to obtain security clearance in order
- 10:21Speaker 4: to look at much of this classified evidence, which means
- 10:24Speaker 4: they have to undergo a background check, a process to
- 10:27Speaker 4: obtain clearances in order to look at these documents. And
- 10:30Speaker 4: that's a slow process that easily can take months before
- 10:34Speaker 4: the defense lawyers can even begin to look at the
- 10:36Speaker 4: classified documents that are evidenced in this trial. So that's
- 10:40Speaker 4: one reason this case is going to be delayed second
- 10:42Speaker 4: reason it's going to be delayed further is also related
- 10:46Speaker 4: to the classified evidence that's at the heart of this case,
- 10:48Speaker 4: because there's going to be, in parallel to what we
- 10:51Speaker 4: see in open court the public proceedings, there's going to
- 10:54Speaker 4: be a secret litigation that goes on in this case
- 10:57Speaker 4: where the defense lawyers, the prosecutors, and the judge, out
- 11:01Speaker 4: of the public view, are going to discuss how the
- 11:04Speaker 4: classified documents are going to be handled a trial. That's
- 11:07Speaker 4: going to be something that's handled under what's called the
- 11:09Speaker 4: Classified Information Procedures Act, and that is an act which
- 11:13Speaker 4: controls how classified information may be given out into the
- 11:16Speaker 4: general public, and that's going to be an ongoing negotiation
- 11:20Speaker 4: with prosecutors, with the defense counsel, and with the judge.
- 11:23Speaker 4: And ultimately, if prosecutors are unhappy with any of the
- 11:26Speaker 4: rulings that Judge Canon may hand down in connection with
- 11:30Speaker 4: these classified documents, they have the right to appeal that
- 11:33Speaker 4: immediately to the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh
- 11:36Speaker 4: Circuit in Atlanta. So if they decide that they want
- 11:39Speaker 4: to appeal one of these rulings, they have the right
- 11:42Speaker 4: to do it. But that's going to delay the trial
- 11:44Speaker 4: even further.
- 11:45Speaker 3: Bob. Why do the defense attorneys have to examine all
- 11:49Speaker 3: these documents? Why isn't it enough to know that they're
- 11:52Speaker 3: MAREK classified mark top secret? I mean, why do they
- 11:56Speaker 3: have to go into what's in them?
- 11:59Speaker 4: Well, it's just it's the bedrock principle of our judicial
- 12:02Speaker 4: system that if the government is going to rely on documents,
- 12:06Speaker 4: the defense has a chance to look at them. Now,
- 12:08Speaker 4: the government is going to argue, no doubt to the
- 12:11Speaker 4: trial judge that those documents can be redacted, so essentially
- 12:15Speaker 4: certain classified portions of them can be blocked out because
- 12:19Speaker 4: they're going to make the very argument that you just
- 12:21Speaker 4: alluded to which is to say, there's enough information in
- 12:24Speaker 4: these documents to prove that they're classified. We don't necessarily
- 12:28Speaker 4: have to show every detail in open court. But on
- 12:31Speaker 4: the other hand, in order to make this a compelling case,
- 12:34Speaker 4: prosecutors are going to want the public to know and
- 12:37Speaker 4: specifically the jury to know the general type of information
- 12:42Speaker 4: that they are alleging was maintained at former presidents Trump's
- 12:47Speaker 4: club at Mara a Lago, and they are already alluded to,
- 12:51Speaker 4: generally the type of information that is very sensitive to
- 12:54Speaker 4: national security. They've alluded to documents that had to do
- 12:57Speaker 4: with Iran, They've alluded to documents that had to do
- 13:00Speaker 4: with some of our chief allies in the world, and
- 13:03Speaker 4: they be alluded to documents that have to do with
- 13:05Speaker 4: steps that the US military would take in the event
- 13:08Speaker 4: of an attack from somebody outside the country. So this
- 13:11Speaker 4: is the kind of stuff that's very important to the
- 13:13Speaker 4: prosecution because they have to show jurors that not only
- 13:17Speaker 4: did former President Trump willfully violate the law with regard
- 13:21Speaker 4: to this classified information, but they also have to convince
- 13:24Speaker 4: them why it matters. They have to show them that
- 13:27Speaker 4: not only was this information something that he should not
- 13:29Speaker 4: have taken out of the White House, that he should
- 13:31Speaker 4: have returned when the government asked that he return it,
- 13:34Speaker 4: but by not doing so, he placed the national security
- 13:37Speaker 4: of the country at risk at risk.
- 13:41Speaker 3: What other kinds of motions do you think we'll see,
- 13:45Speaker 3: selective prosecution, prosecutorial misconduct, anything like that.
- 13:50Speaker 4: Yeah, We're going to see an array of motions coming
- 13:52Speaker 4: from the defense, and these are pre trial motions, so
- 13:55Speaker 4: these are motions that the judge will have to decide
- 13:58Speaker 4: before the trial even began. And we can expect to
- 14:01Speaker 4: see some type of motions regarding alleged prosecutoral misconduct where
- 14:05Speaker 4: they're going to say prosecutors acted improperly in front of
- 14:09Speaker 4: the Grand jurian some way. We're going to certainly see
- 14:12Speaker 4: an argument that performer President Trump is the victim of
- 14:16Speaker 4: what's called selective prosecution. That essentially is an argument that
- 14:21Speaker 4: I'm being prosecuted for conduct that others who committed the
- 14:24Speaker 4: very same conduct are not being prosecuted for. This is
- 14:27Speaker 4: going to be raised, most likely in connection with the
- 14:30Speaker 4: failure of the Department of Justice to prosecute former Secretary
- 14:34Speaker 4: of State Hillary Clinton when she had classified information found
- 14:37Speaker 4: on a server in her home. That's something that will
- 14:40Speaker 4: be raised. It's unlikely, frankly, to succeed. Generally, in order
- 14:44Speaker 4: to prevail on a selective prosecution argument, you have to
- 14:48Speaker 4: show that you are being singled out for some kind
- 14:51Speaker 4: of improper reason. Typically it's because of your race, or
- 14:55Speaker 4: your religion, or some kind of protected class, but it
- 14:58Speaker 4: will certainly be raised by the defense. I think one
- 15:02Speaker 4: of the issues that will be raised that perhaps has
- 15:04Speaker 4: the most likelihood of gaining some kind of traction has
- 15:08Speaker 4: to do with a motion that the government made before
- 15:12Speaker 4: this case was ever indicted, in front of a judge
- 15:15Speaker 4: in the District of Columbia to get documents and to
- 15:18Speaker 4: get keep recordings made by one of former President's arms
- 15:22Speaker 4: prior lawyers. Typically, conversations between a defendant and their lawyer
- 15:27Speaker 4: are covered by the attorney client privilege. That that's so
- 15:30Speaker 4: that defense lawyers and their clients can discuss their case
- 15:33Speaker 4: freely and not fear that those conversations will ultimately be
- 15:37Speaker 4: used against a defendant. But there's something called the crime
- 15:40Speaker 4: fraud exception, which is something that allows prosecutors to get
- 15:44Speaker 4: at those very conversations if they can convince a judge
- 15:48Speaker 4: that those conversations were not about defending past conduct but
- 15:52Speaker 4: perpetrating a future crime, and they were successful in convincing
- 15:57Speaker 4: the district court judge that that is exactly what happening.
- 16:00Speaker 4: And so those tapes and those conversations were turned over
- 16:04Speaker 4: to prosecutors and now form one of the critical basies
- 16:08Speaker 4: for the obstruction charge in the indictment against former President Trump.
- 16:12Speaker 4: So I think we're going to see that issue raised again,
- 16:15Speaker 4: and the judge in Florida will have a chance to
- 16:17Speaker 4: look at that issue and make her own decision about
- 16:20Speaker 4: whether or not the crime fraud exception was appropriate and
- 16:23Speaker 4: whether prosecutor should have gotten access to those conversations between
- 16:27Speaker 4: former President Trump and his former attorney.
- 16:30Speaker 3: So, former President Trump gave a lengthy interview with Fox
- 16:35Speaker 3: that was broadcast on Monday, and he suggested that he'd
- 16:39Speaker 3: been too busy and that he wanted to be sure
- 16:42Speaker 3: he retrieved his personal belongings before complying with the federal
- 16:46Speaker 3: government's repeated demands and even a subpoena. He said these
- 16:50Speaker 3: boxes were interspersed with all sorts of things, golf shirts, clothing, pants, shoes.
- 16:56Speaker 3: Isn't he making an admission that he deliberately kept the
- 17:01Speaker 3: papers from the government, Well.
- 17:03Speaker 4: It's a little hard to understand exactly what the defense
- 17:06Speaker 4: that former President Trump was trying to assert during that interview,
- 17:10Speaker 4: And it's hard to believe that his lawyers agreed for
- 17:14Speaker 4: him to go on and make those statements, because typically,
- 17:16Speaker 4: as a defense lawyer, you do not want your client
- 17:19Speaker 4: making public statements about the case because prosecutors are watching
- 17:23Speaker 4: those statements and all of that can be used against
- 17:25Speaker 4: your client at a trial down the road. So it's
- 17:28Speaker 4: likely that the decision to appear at that interview was
- 17:31Speaker 4: not something that was sanctioned or encouraged by former President
- 17:35Speaker 4: Trump's lawyers. On the other hand, we are going to
- 17:38Speaker 4: see this case played out on two fronts, inside the
- 17:41Speaker 4: courtroom and also in the court of public opinion. And
- 17:43Speaker 4: former President Trump was no doubt playing to the court
- 17:46Speaker 4: of public opinion. He knows that people are watching this
- 17:50Speaker 4: case very carefully and they are listening to every statement
- 17:54Speaker 4: he makes regarding his conduct. And of course he has
- 17:56Speaker 4: attacked both the special counsel and the indictment as being
- 18:00Speaker 4: politically motivated, and I think those interviews are just a
- 18:03Speaker 4: further attempt to try to delegitimize both the prosecutor and
- 18:08Speaker 4: the prosecution itself. To the extent that he ultimately reaches
- 18:11Speaker 4: individuals who might find their way into a jury pool
- 18:15Speaker 4: for this case, that could ultimately be a successful defense
- 18:19Speaker 4: in the sense that his lawyers may ultimately convince even
- 18:23Speaker 4: one juror not to convict on the basis of jury nullification.
- 18:27Speaker 4: In other words, if a jury is convinced that, even
- 18:29Speaker 4: if everything the prosecution says is true, this is a
- 18:33Speaker 4: case that never should have been brought, they may vote
- 18:36Speaker 4: against the conviction even though the government may have proven
- 18:40Speaker 4: their case beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 18:41Speaker 3: Yeah, because he continued to insist that he had every
- 18:44Speaker 3: right to have those boxes and that he declassified everything
- 18:48Speaker 3: that he had. And I don't think that his defense
- 18:52Speaker 3: lawyers have ever used any of those in a courtroom.
- 18:56Speaker 3: So do you think that they might still bring it
- 18:59Speaker 3: up a try I'll and just try to throw everything
- 19:01Speaker 3: out there.
- 19:02Speaker 4: Well, you know, one of the big questions for this
- 19:05Speaker 4: trial is going to be whether or not former President
- 19:08Speaker 4: Trump takes the stand in his own defense. If he does,
- 19:11Speaker 4: he certainly will be cross examined by prosecutors as to
- 19:15Speaker 4: all of these public statements, and I think it's going
- 19:18Speaker 4: to be difficult for him to defend his position and
- 19:21Speaker 4: so I think what he's doing is trying to sway
- 19:24Speaker 4: public opinion and trying to appeal to the jury pool
- 19:28Speaker 4: in South Florida specifically in the hopes that he may
- 19:31Speaker 4: convince one or more jurors that this prosecution should never
- 19:34Speaker 4: have been brought in the first place, and that's going
- 19:36Speaker 4: to make it much more difficult for prosecutors to ultimately
- 19:38Speaker 4: get a conviction here. I do think that some of
- 19:41Speaker 4: the statements that form President Trump has made publicly and
- 19:44Speaker 4: in interviews after his indictment may ultimately be damaging to
- 19:48Speaker 4: his case said trial, because remember, this is not a
- 19:51Speaker 4: case about which documents former President Trump took with him
- 19:55Speaker 4: from the White House. Prosecutors are going to instead focus
- 19:59Speaker 4: the jury on the quest of what former President Trump
- 20:02Speaker 4: did after prosecutors and after the government demanded the return
- 20:06Speaker 4: of those documents. And that's really something that I think
- 20:10Speaker 4: is different than the question of whether it's classified or
- 20:12Speaker 4: not classified, because regardless of whether it's classified or not,
- 20:16Speaker 4: if federal prosecutors issue a subpoena and demand that you
- 20:20Speaker 4: return every document that has the classified label affixed to it,
- 20:25Speaker 4: you have to return it, regardless of ultimately whether that
- 20:27Speaker 4: information was classified.
- 20:29Speaker 2: Or not.
- 20:29Speaker 4: And so I think former President Trump is trying to
- 20:31Speaker 4: convince the public that he did nothing wrong, that he
- 20:33Speaker 4: was entitled to keep these documents. The battle lines will
- 20:36Speaker 4: be drawn when prosecutors try to refocus the jury not
- 20:39Speaker 4: on the question of whether this information was classified or not,
- 20:42Speaker 4: not on the question so much as to whether or
- 20:44Speaker 4: not President Trump was even committed a crime by removing
- 20:48Speaker 4: those documents from the White House in the first place,
- 20:51Speaker 4: but whether or not once he was requested to return
- 20:54Speaker 4: those documents, he obstructed justice. He got others to lie
- 20:58Speaker 4: on his behalf about those documents and whether he actively
- 21:02Speaker 4: misled federal prosecutors about the fact that he continued to
- 21:05Speaker 4: retain classified and national security sensitive documents at his club
- 21:10Speaker 4: in mar A Lago and after a prosecutors first requested
- 21:13Speaker 4: it through the National Archives, then requested it through a
- 21:16Speaker 4: federal grand jury subpoena, and ultimately resorted to a search
- 21:19Speaker 4: word in order to try to recover those documents.
- 21:22Speaker 3: Thanks so much for your insides, Bob. That's former federal
- 21:25Speaker 3: prosecutor Robert Mens, our partner McCarter and English.
- 21:29Speaker 2: Call to me, kalt me.
- 21:36Speaker 4: Else have far as to protect dwarfs their minds men
- 21:40Speaker 4: their fields of grain, but we harfoots of.
- 21:44Speaker 1: Each other, dodness will lot of facius.
- 21:54Speaker 2: It would be easy and not just as all people.
- 22:06Speaker 3: The sequel The Lord of the Rings, The Rings of
- 22:08Speaker 3: Power brought back the Middle Earth of fantasy novelist J. R. R. Tolkien,
- 22:14Speaker 3: with its elves, dwarfs, harfoots, and humans to Amazon viewers.
- 22:18Speaker 3: It was the most expensive television show ever made, with
- 22:22Speaker 3: close to a half a billion dollar budget. But it's
- 22:25Speaker 3: now the subject of dueling lawsuits. Joining me to untangled
- 22:29Speaker 3: the lawsuits is intellectual property litigator Terence Ross, a partner
- 22:33Speaker 3: at catin Yuchen Rosenman. So Terry. This started, and it's
- 22:37Speaker 3: sort of amazing to me, But it started with a writer,
- 22:40Speaker 3: Demetrius Polychron, suing the Tolkien Estate and Amazon for their
- 22:45Speaker 3: production of the Rings of Power, saying they had infringed
- 22:50Speaker 3: his sequel to Lord of the Rings, called The Fellowship
- 22:53Speaker 3: of the King.
- 22:55Speaker 2: He filed a lawsuit back in April of this year
- 23:00Speaker 2: after a period of time in which he was exchanging
- 23:03Speaker 2: correspondence with the TOLKIENA State and apparently didn't like what
- 23:08Speaker 2: he was hearing back from the TOLKIENA State, so he
- 23:11Speaker 2: went out and filed his own lawsuit, and a couple
- 23:13Speaker 2: months later, after additional attempts on the part of the
- 23:17Speaker 2: Tolkiena State to settle the matter, they filed on June first,
- 23:21Speaker 2: a copyright lawsuit in the same court against mister Polychrome.
- 23:27Speaker 3: Tolkien's estate says it has a policy of not licensing
- 23:31Speaker 3: writers to create sequels, so it refused permission. Where does
- 23:36Speaker 3: that policy stand in this dispute?
- 23:40Speaker 2: So to understand the dispute, you have to understand that
- 23:43Speaker 2: the Copyright Act gives authors of work multiple rights. So
- 23:48Speaker 2: it's not just the right to sell their book or
- 23:51Speaker 2: to display their artwork to the public, or to broadcast
- 23:57Speaker 2: their music. It includes the right to derivative works. And
- 24:01Speaker 2: derivative works are works that follow on the original work.
- 24:07Speaker 2: So Star Trek was followed by Star Trek the Next Generation,
- 24:12Speaker 2: and Star Trek the Next Generation would be considered and
- 24:16Speaker 2: was a derivative work of the original Star Trek, not
- 24:19Speaker 2: to send characters, but sort of the same universe in
- 24:22Speaker 2: setting that was used by the original Star Trek. And
- 24:25Speaker 2: so the author of Star Trek, Gene ron Berry, had
- 24:29Speaker 2: the exclusive right to prepare such a derivative work, and
- 24:33Speaker 2: no one could come along and do that if you
- 24:35Speaker 2: want to call it a sequel without his permission. So
- 24:38Speaker 2: that's where we are here. JR. R. Tolkien's trilogy of
- 24:42Speaker 2: Fellowship of the Rings gave him an exclusive right to
- 24:46Speaker 2: prepare derivative works, which would certainly include any sequel to
- 24:50Speaker 2: the Fellowship of the Rings. And apparently that's exactly what
- 24:54Speaker 2: the work issue here is a sequel.
- 24:57Speaker 3: The Tolkien estate alleges that Pollichron used a lot of
- 25:02Speaker 3: copyrighted protected elements, such as fifteen poems or other passages,
- 25:07Speaker 3: copied verbatim, hundreds of the original characters, and recycling of
- 25:11Speaker 3: the entire plot premise of the trilogy. So it sounds
- 25:14Speaker 3: like the estate has a good case. What would be
- 25:17Speaker 3: the writer's defense here.
- 25:18Speaker 2: I'm not sure what the defense of the writer would be.
- 25:20Speaker 2: I think the Tolkien state has an excellent case, and
- 25:23Speaker 2: may be it excellent in part by the communications from
- 25:26Speaker 2: mister Polychron to the estate in the years leading up
- 25:29Speaker 2: to litiation. He has repeatedly said that this was a
- 25:33Speaker 2: sequel and that it was intended to here as closely
- 25:36Speaker 2: as possible to the Fellowship of the Ring and to
- 25:39Speaker 2: use similar characters and settings so that readers and fans
- 25:43Speaker 2: of Fellowship of the Rings would recognize it and believe it.
- 25:48Speaker 2: He at one point referred to it as a loving
- 25:51Speaker 2: homage to Professor Tolkien. So he has said a lot
- 25:55Speaker 2: of things that sort of undermine any of the usual
- 25:58Speaker 2: defenses such is fair use. At one level, you could
- 26:01Speaker 2: think of his work as a theme of good trying
- 26:05Speaker 2: thing over evil, and at the most general, at the
- 26:08Speaker 2: broadest possible level, that's what there are Tolkien's Fellowship the Rings.
- 26:11Speaker 2: It's not good trying thing over evil, and certainly no
- 26:14Speaker 2: one can copyright that a theme that has come down
- 26:18Speaker 2: through history and simply can't be monopolized by anyone writer.
- 26:22Speaker 2: The problem is this work was set in the exact
- 26:25Speaker 2: same fictional universe of Middle Earth that Lord of the
- 26:30Speaker 2: Rings was set in. It used a very similar plot,
- 26:33Speaker 2: a fellowship of hobbits and humans who come together, form friendships,
- 26:38Speaker 2: go on a quest, and then overcome evil, which is
- 26:41Speaker 2: strikingly similar to the Fellowship of the Rings. It's gotten
- 26:45Speaker 2: lots of the same scenes and settings. The key character
- 26:48Speaker 2: in this new work by mister Polypromp is sam wise Ganji,
- 26:53Speaker 2: who was the companion of Rono during the Fellowship of
- 26:57Speaker 2: the Rings. He's taking the exact same character, set it
- 26:59Speaker 2: in exact same place, the shire, and uses many of
- 27:03Speaker 2: the same places on the journey Rivendelle the Prancing Pony
- 27:06Speaker 2: in all these places reappear. And on top of that,
- 27:10Speaker 2: there are numerous passages that are just taken verbatim from Tolkien's.
- 27:15Speaker 3: Work, And it's sort of stunning that he had enough
- 27:19Speaker 3: nerve to sue Amazon for the Rings of Power series
- 27:24Speaker 3: for stealing his plot lines and characters from his book.
- 27:28Speaker 2: Now, the stunning thing about it is that the lead
- 27:32Speaker 2: defendant in that lawsuit is Jeff Bee's hope it just
- 27:35Speaker 2: happens to own the Amazon Studios. I mean, it's exactly
- 27:39Speaker 2: the sort of overreach that you see with lawsuits that
- 27:42Speaker 2: have limited validity. I mean, names profession Tolkien's grandson merely
- 27:49Speaker 2: because he's the executor of the Tolkien estate. I mean,
- 27:52Speaker 2: this is just inappropriate in many ways. And the ask
- 27:56Speaker 2: in that lawsuit is two hundred and fifty million dollars.
- 28:00Speaker 2: Two hundred and fifty million dollars. This is just extraordinary.
- 28:04Speaker 2: The foots by the fellow, that's the word.
- 28:07Speaker 3: So the trust said that he plans to release up
- 28:11Speaker 3: to six additional books, all based on Tolkien's characters. They're
- 28:15Speaker 3: demanding that his books be taken off the shelves of stores.
- 28:20Speaker 3: Would a court go that far?
- 28:22Speaker 2: Oh? Absolutely, But first, they're not being sold on the
- 28:26Speaker 2: shelves of any bookstores. They're being sold by him online.
- 28:30Speaker 2: This is a self published work, which probably tells you
- 28:33Speaker 2: something about it right off for that, and the lawsuit
- 28:36Speaker 2: by the Tolkien estate goes to great length to point
- 28:39Speaker 2: out how bad the writing is compared to Professor Tolkien's writing.
- 28:43Speaker 2: So what the lawsuit wants is to have the court
- 28:47Speaker 2: enter an injunction stopping him from any future sales by
- 28:51Speaker 2: himself online, as well as stopping any future works, all
- 28:56Speaker 2: on the basis that these are derivative works and the
- 29:00Speaker 2: Keen of State has the exclusive right to prepare directive works.
- 29:03Speaker 3: And Jerry, we've seen these fan fiction lawsuits before, so.
- 29:08Speaker 2: Dun you know. We've seen this sort of fan fiction
- 29:10Speaker 2: before with the Bridgerton lawsuit that was filed last summer
- 29:14Speaker 2: against these two young ladies in New York who had
- 29:17Speaker 2: prepared a Bridgerton the Musical using the same characters, of
- 29:21Speaker 2: the same settings, but adding music to the Netflix original series.
- 29:26Speaker 2: That lawsuit was debbled within months of coming out. But
- 29:29Speaker 2: fan fiction is this notion that people who are so
- 29:33Speaker 2: wrapped up in a fictional work, whether it be a
- 29:38Speaker 2: literary work such as here with the Fellowship of the
- 29:40Speaker 2: Races in that case the television series, certain fans get
- 29:43Speaker 2: so wrapped up and have some talent that they start
- 29:46Speaker 2: preparing works that feed off of the original, and they
- 29:50Speaker 2: always portray it, just as mister polychron has here as
- 29:53Speaker 2: sort of homage to the original. And the problem, as
- 29:57Speaker 2: we've discussed before, is that, yes, for the most part,
- 30:01Speaker 2: authors and the owners of intellectual property in that case
- 30:04Speaker 2: Netflix once word of mouth. They want their theories, their books,
- 30:08Speaker 2: their movies, They want them talked up, they want them
- 30:10Speaker 2: to have a buzz about them. They want a really
- 30:13Speaker 2: positive vibe. And that's done by sort of sub rosa
- 30:16Speaker 2: encouraging bands to do things like that. It's always drawing
- 30:20Speaker 2: a line, though what constant is going too far, And
- 30:23Speaker 2: in the bridget In case, preparing a musical full body
- 30:26Speaker 2: of musical and putting it on at Kennedy Center here
- 30:28Speaker 2: in DC was just too much and Netflix had to
- 30:31Speaker 2: bring them a suit to stop that. Here, the Tolkien
- 30:35Speaker 2: universe has never needed that sort of fan buzz word
- 30:40Speaker 2: of mouth. This series came out in fifty four and
- 30:44Speaker 2: was instantaneously best sellers and became iconic. I mean we
- 30:49Speaker 2: all had to read them in high school. I mean
- 30:52Speaker 2: because they were considered more than just science fiction. They
- 30:55Speaker 2: were considered works of literary art that needed to study.
- 30:59Speaker 2: And there have been so many academic pieces rated on this.
- 31:02Speaker 2: And then the movies came out two thousand and three,
- 31:04Speaker 2: I believe, which just took them to new heights. So
- 31:06Speaker 2: there was never any need on the part of the
- 31:08Speaker 2: owners of the intellectual property and fashion theories to have
- 31:12Speaker 2: fan fiction. They had all the buzz they needed. They
- 31:15Speaker 2: had a really great five beyond buzz. I mean, these
- 31:18Speaker 2: are considered some of the greatest novels in English history
- 31:23Speaker 2: by academics whose you know what they're talking about, and
- 31:25Speaker 2: so you just didn't need it. And that's why they've
- 31:28Speaker 2: never encouraged the store of fan fiction and tried to
- 31:31Speaker 2: shut this guy down as soon as he poked his
- 31:34Speaker 2: head up unsuccessfully and now finally had to take the
- 31:38Speaker 2: last step of final lawsuits to shut him down.
- 31:41Speaker 3: Well, we'll see how long it takes. Do is that
- 31:42Speaker 3: all this one? Thanks Cherry. That's Terrence Ross of Catain
- 31:46Speaker 3: Euchen Rosenman, and that's it for this edition of The
- 31:48Speaker 3: Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get the latest
- 31:51Speaker 3: legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find
- 31:54Speaker 3: them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot Bloomberg
- 31:59Speaker 3: dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, And remember to tune
- 32:03Speaker 3: into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten pm
- 32:06Speaker 3: Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to
- 32:10Speaker 3: Bloomberg