Latest / Bloomberg Law / Justices Skeptical of Allowing Emergency Abortions
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: The Supreme Court justice is clashed today over the limits
- 0:13Speaker 2: on a state's power to ban abortions when a woman's
- 0:16Speaker 2: health is in jeopardy. It indicates a deep divide over
- 0:20Speaker 2: the Biden administration's attempt to protect access to abortion in
- 0:25Speaker 2: medical emergencies, even in states like Idaho with near total
- 0:29Speaker 2: bans on abortion. During the tense arguments, the court's three
- 0:33Speaker 2: liberal justices agreed with the administration's view that a forty
- 0:37Speaker 2: year old federal law MTALLA requires hospitals to provide abortions
- 0:42Speaker 2: when necessary to prevent major health consequences for the woman.
- 0:46Speaker 2: Here's Justice Elena Kagan, where.
- 0:49Speaker 3: The woman is her life is not imperiled, but she's
- 0:52Speaker 3: going to lose her reproductive organs. She's going to lose
- 0:55Speaker 3: the ability to have children in the future unless an
- 0:58Speaker 3: abortion takes place. Now, that's the category of cases in
- 1:02Speaker 3: which I'm talis, says, my gosh. Of course the abortion
- 1:07Speaker 3: is necessary to assure that no material deterioration occurs. And
- 1:12Speaker 3: yet Idaho says, sorry, no abortion here. And the result
- 1:17Speaker 3: is that these patients are now helicoptered out of state.
- 1:22Speaker 2: But the court's most conservative justice is like Samuel Alito,
- 1:27Speaker 2: questioned the administration's reading of the law.
- 1:30Speaker 1: How can you impose restrictions on what Idaho can criminalize
- 1:35Speaker 1: simply because hospitals in Idaho have chosen to participate in Medicare.
- 1:39Speaker 1: I don't understand how this swears with the whole theory
- 1:42Speaker 1: of the spending clause.
- 1:44Speaker 2: It's the first time the Court has reviewed a state
- 1:46Speaker 2: abortion ban since it overturned the right to abortion in
- 1:49Speaker 2: twenty twenty two. Joining me is Elizabeth Zepper, a professor
- 1:53Speaker 2: at the University of Texas Law School. Liz, there was
- 1:55Speaker 2: a lot going on under the surface of these arguments,
- 1:58Speaker 2: but tell us about the main issue.
- 2:00Speaker 4: The main issue is whether emergency department physicians in Idaho
- 2:06Speaker 4: have to comply with the Federal Emergency Medical Treatment and
- 2:09Speaker 4: Labor Act or if the state law that only allows
- 2:13Speaker 4: them to provide abortion if someone's life is at risk
- 2:17Speaker 4: is what governs their provision of emergency medical care.
- 2:21Speaker 2: So the Biden administration maintains that Idaho's law it collides
- 2:26Speaker 2: with the federal law m TALA and so should override
- 2:31Speaker 2: Idaho's ban. That's federal preemption. Why doesn't that answer the
- 2:35Speaker 2: question here.
- 2:37Speaker 4: Yeah, that should answer the question. The US Constitution has
- 2:41Speaker 4: a supremacy clause that says federal law is supreme and
- 2:46Speaker 4: m TALA is federal law. There are questions about the
- 2:50Speaker 4: degree of conflict between Idaho's abortion ban with its very
- 2:55Speaker 4: narrow life saving exception and m TALA. Idaho a multiple
- 3:00Speaker 4: points tried to claim that there actually was no conflict
- 3:03Speaker 4: between state law and federal law at all.
- 3:07Speaker 2: That was surprising to me, and I think it was
- 3:09Speaker 2: surprising to some of the justices as well. They asked, well,
- 3:13Speaker 2: why are you here if there's no conflict?
- 3:17Speaker 4: Right, It would seem that if there is no conflict,
- 3:20Speaker 4: we should both see emergency department doctors able to provide
- 3:25Speaker 4: the same emergency abortion care they were providing pre state
- 3:30Speaker 4: law ban on abortion. And also it would seem like
- 3:33Speaker 4: the state shouldn't be at the Supreme Court on this question.
- 3:37Speaker 4: I think Justice Jackson, though, really put her finger on
- 3:40Speaker 4: the issue. The State of Idaho was trying to argue
- 3:44Speaker 4: there wasn't a conflict with federal law by saying that
- 3:48Speaker 4: the federal law essentially defers to state law on the
- 3:52Speaker 4: question of what medically appropriate care is in an emergency
- 3:57Speaker 4: and so that if someone complies with a state law,
- 4:00Speaker 4: they are automatically complying with the federal m TALA. And
- 4:04Speaker 4: she pushed the assistant Solicitor General from Idaho's whether it
- 4:09Speaker 4: would be true that if a doctor complied with m
- 4:11Speaker 4: TALA that there would be no conflict with Idaho law.
- 4:16Speaker 2: And what was his response.
- 4:18Speaker 4: I don't think that he could really respond in a
- 4:20Speaker 4: satisfying way, right, She said, Well, if there would be
- 4:23Speaker 4: no conflict, why not let doctors comply with m tala
- 4:26Speaker 4: and the state law presumably allows them to do so
- 4:30Speaker 4: if there truly is no conflict.
- 4:32Speaker 2: Particularly, the Solicitor General pointed out what's happening on the ground,
- 4:37Speaker 2: so to speak, saying that Idaho's abortion ban has already
- 4:41Speaker 2: affected emergency care, that women are being flown to other states.
- 4:46Speaker 4: Yeah, I think the Solicitor General really focused the court
- 4:50Speaker 4: on what is going on in Idaho. It's one thing
- 4:52Speaker 4: to claim that you could read the statutes as having
- 4:56Speaker 4: identical requirements for emergency care. It's quite another to look
- 4:59Speaker 4: at IDOL and see what has happened under the abortion ban.
- 5:02Speaker 4: And what has happened is there are hospital closures, There
- 5:06Speaker 4: is near impossibility in recruiting obgins come to the state,
- 5:11Speaker 4: and people who become pregnant are told to purchase insurance
- 5:16Speaker 4: for metavac flights because what physicians know is if they
- 5:20Speaker 4: experience complications in pregnancy, those pregnant patients are going to
- 5:25Speaker 4: need to be dumped on another state Entirely.
- 5:29Speaker 2: Under Idaho's law, abortions are only allowed when necessary to
- 5:33Speaker 2: prevent the death of the pregnant woman. So Justice Sotomayor
- 5:37Speaker 2: asked Idaho's lawyer if it were true that the state's
- 5:41Speaker 2: ban would prevent abortion in situations where a woman would
- 5:44Speaker 2: otherwise lose an organ or have serious medical complications. Justice
- 5:49Speaker 2: Kagan brought this up as well, and when pushed and pushed,
- 5:53Speaker 2: Idaho's lawyers said, yes, abortions are in that case are
- 5:57Speaker 2: not allowed.
- 5:59Speaker 4: Yeah, there some slipperiness, though, I think it seemed and
- 6:03Speaker 4: the answers to I think really concrete clinical cases that
- 6:07Speaker 4: the justices were presenting to Idaho's Assistant Solicitor General, and
- 6:13Speaker 4: you know many times what he would come back to is, well,
- 6:16Speaker 4: if there's good faith medical judgment, and they had to
- 6:19Speaker 4: keep pushing him on good faith medical judgment of what
- 6:23Speaker 4: and the answer under Idaho law has to be that
- 6:27Speaker 4: death is likely to occur.
- 6:30Speaker 2: Did he ever admit that, you know it would have
- 6:33Speaker 2: to be that radical for an abortion to take place.
- 6:37Speaker 4: No, we got the same sort of grimerle that we
- 6:40Speaker 4: get whenever health and life exceptions come up, where the
- 6:45Speaker 4: defenses of these really narrow exceptions tend to pass the
- 6:49Speaker 4: book to physicians to say, well, they can go ahead
- 6:53Speaker 4: and exercise their medical judgment, and surely there doesn't need
- 6:57Speaker 4: to be imminence here. It could be something that could
- 7:00Speaker 4: occur the next day or within the week. It doesn't
- 7:03Speaker 4: have to be imminent. The Solicitor General said, Look, it
- 7:06Speaker 4: says necessary, right, Even if there's not an imminence, this
- 7:10Speaker 4: will occur within minutes. The necessary to prevent death does
- 7:15Speaker 4: tell you something about the connection between performing an abortion
- 7:19Speaker 4: and avoidance of death that you have to be able
- 7:21Speaker 4: to establish that it was necessary. And if a doctor
- 7:25Speaker 4: does perform an abortion under these circumstances, they always face
- 7:29Speaker 4: the possibility that an enterprising prosecutor could come along and
- 7:32Speaker 4: second guess their medical judgment.
- 7:35Speaker 2: And under this law, performing an abortion outside of these
- 7:38Speaker 2: limited exceptions is a felony punishable by up to five
- 7:41Speaker 2: years in prison. So a tough penalty. So the three
- 7:44Speaker 2: liberal justices seem to be firmly on the Biden administration side.
- 7:49Speaker 2: So let's turn down to the conservatives of starting with
- 7:52Speaker 2: Justice Samuel Alito, who wrote the majority decision overturning Row,
- 7:56Speaker 2: and he seemed to be most invested in supports arding
- 8:00Speaker 2: Idaho's law. He grilled a Solicitor general about whether mental
- 8:04Speaker 2: health is a condition that would require abortions. He also
- 8:08Speaker 2: pointed to language in Mtala that refers to unborn child.
- 8:13Speaker 1: So in that situation, the hospital must stabilize the threat
- 8:18Speaker 1: to the unborn child.
- 8:19Speaker 4: Yes, it was relatively unsurprising that Justice Alito was the
- 8:24Speaker 4: one to latch on to the language of unborn child
- 8:28Speaker 4: within m TALA. Now, we've been told that everyone is
- 8:31Speaker 4: now a textualist, that we look at the statute text
- 8:34Speaker 4: and that pretty much ends the discussion about what it requires.
- 8:38Speaker 4: And Pala's text is actually quite clear only in an
- 8:42Speaker 4: individual can have an emergency medical condition, and an individual
- 8:46Speaker 4: has to be someone who is born, and so a
- 8:49Speaker 4: fetus is not someone who is born. Now, there was
- 8:53Speaker 4: language related to unborn child added to Amtala to reflect
- 8:57Speaker 4: the fact that for a pregnant person that individual could
- 9:02Speaker 4: be in an emergency scenario if her own health were
- 9:07Speaker 4: in jeopardy or if the fetus's health was in jeopardy,
- 9:11Speaker 4: really affirming that emergency departments need to screen pregnant people
- 9:15Speaker 4: not only for the stability of their own health, but
- 9:18Speaker 4: to make sure the fetus isn't in distress.
- 9:21Speaker 2: Which of the Conservatives were like a leado, seeming to
- 9:27Speaker 2: be supporting Idaho's law.
- 9:30Speaker 4: Justice Gorsuch spoke out quite a bit in ways that
- 9:34Speaker 4: indicated affinity for Idaho's position. Justice Kavanaugh had an extended
- 9:40Speaker 4: exchange with Idaho over the question of whether there was
- 9:44Speaker 4: a conflict at all between Idaho law and federal law,
- 9:48Speaker 4: seemingly leaning very strongly towards the view that there was
- 9:51Speaker 4: no conflict between the two. Justice Barrett asked the sort
- 9:55Speaker 4: of wide range of questions I've read a number of
- 9:59Speaker 4: commentators now who suggests that her vote could be in question,
- 10:03Speaker 4: or perhaps that she was sympathetic to the position of
- 10:06Speaker 4: the United States. I think that's highly unlikely, just given
- 10:10Speaker 4: the reality of who Justice Fair is, and I think
- 10:13Speaker 4: often her questions in oral argument are not particularly indicative
- 10:17Speaker 4: of what her vote will ultimately be in the case.
- 10:21Speaker 2: So that makes five votes in favor of Idaho's ban
- 10:25Speaker 2: on abortion. Because we know where Justice Clarence Thomas stands.
- 10:30Speaker 4: It's hard for me to imagine that was my view
- 10:32Speaker 4: going in that the Supreme Court doesn't want to get
- 10:35Speaker 4: into five. I think there are really open questions after
- 10:40Speaker 4: the oral argument as to how it would get to
- 10:42Speaker 4: five on what particular facet or facets of this litigation.
- 10:47Speaker 4: You know, we though at least three justices sort of
- 10:50Speaker 4: play with the notion that maybe spending clause legislation can't
- 10:58Speaker 4: impose these kind of sub intensive obligations, which would be
- 11:03Speaker 4: sort of a bar reaching, de regulatory sort of analysis.
- 11:07Speaker 4: We saw Justice Thomas start off with that argument, and
- 11:11Speaker 4: then of course we have you know, Justice Kavanaugh really
- 11:13Speaker 4: pressing the idea that there might not be a conflict
- 11:16Speaker 4: between Idaho law and TALA, but presumably buying into Idaho's
- 11:21Speaker 4: argument that as long as you comply with state criminal law,
- 11:25Speaker 4: m TALA won't require you to do more. That there's
- 11:28Speaker 4: baked into the federal law the incorporation of state criminal law.
- 11:32Speaker 2: Could you tell where the Chief Justice was?
- 11:35Speaker 4: The Chief Justice said very little in the oral argument,
- 11:38Speaker 4: so I don't think he revealed much about where he
- 11:41Speaker 4: was coming.
- 11:42Speaker 2: Up next on the Bloomberg Law Show. I'll continue this
- 11:44Speaker 2: conversation with Professor Elizabeth Sepper of the University of Texas
- 11:48Speaker 2: Law School. Just how tense were they arguments? It seemed
- 11:52Speaker 2: like even the patients of the Solicitor General was tested.
- 11:55Speaker 2: I'm June Gross when you're listening to Bloomberg. A case
- 11:59Speaker 2: at the Supreme Court today pitts Idaho's near total ban
- 12:02Speaker 2: on abortion against a federal law that requires hospitals to
- 12:06Speaker 2: provide emergency healthcare. Ahead of the arguments, abortion rights advocates
- 12:11Speaker 2: were concerned that the case might be used to advance
- 12:15Speaker 2: the fight for fetal personhood, the idea that a fetus
- 12:18Speaker 2: would have the same rights as the pregnant woman. And
- 12:22Speaker 2: Justice Samuel Alito, who wrote the decision overturning the right
- 12:26Speaker 2: to abortion, sharply questioned the Solicitor General, Elizabeth Prelager about
- 12:31Speaker 2: his interpretation that the federal law imposes an equal duty
- 12:35Speaker 2: on the hospital to both the pregnant woman and the fetus,
- 12:38Speaker 2: whom he referred to as the unborn child. But the
- 12:41Speaker 2: Solicitor General pushed back forcefully.
- 12:45Speaker 1: So in that situation, the hospital must stabilize the threat
- 12:49Speaker 1: to the unborn child. And it seems that the plain
- 12:52Speaker 1: meaning is that the hospital must try to eliminate any
- 12:56Speaker 1: immediate threat to the child, but performing an abortion is
- 12:59Speaker 1: antithetic to that duty.
- 13:02Speaker 5: That stabilization obligation equally runs to her and makes clear
- 13:05Speaker 5: that the hospital has to give her necessary stabilizing treatment.
- 13:09Speaker 5: And in many of the cases you're thinking about, there
- 13:11Speaker 5: is no possible way to stabilize the unborn child because
- 13:14Speaker 5: the fetus is sufficiently before viability that it's inevitable that
- 13:17Speaker 5: the pregnancy is going to be lost. But Idaho would
- 13:20Speaker 5: deny women treatment in that circumstance, even though it's senseless.
- 13:24Speaker 2: I've been talking to Professor Elizabeth Sepper of the University
- 13:27Speaker 2: of Texas Law School. So did it seem as if
- 13:31Speaker 2: the Solicitor General, who is the consummate professional and excellent
- 13:36Speaker 2: in handling questions at these arguments, that she seemed to
- 13:39Speaker 2: be losing patients or frustrated a few times with the conservatives' questions,
- 13:44Speaker 2: particularly Justice Alito.
- 13:46Speaker 4: I mean, I think an important thing to note about
- 13:48Speaker 4: or argument. This is not just an opportunity to convince
- 13:51Speaker 4: the justices. It's an opportunity to speak to the American people,
- 13:56Speaker 4: and I think we saw the those that are general
- 13:58Speaker 4: doing that in multiple I think how she began her
- 14:02Speaker 4: argument by bringing the justices and the conversation back to
- 14:06Speaker 4: the experience of people on the ground in Idaho who
- 14:09Speaker 4: are being denied health saving pregnancy and abortion care was
- 14:13Speaker 4: one moment. But I think another moment was her interchange
- 14:16Speaker 4: with Justice Alito at the end, where he really was
- 14:20Speaker 4: suggesting that physicians need to save the unborn child and
- 14:25Speaker 4: that's what federal law requires, and she really pushed back
- 14:28Speaker 4: that the individual in Mtala is the woman and that
- 14:32Speaker 4: in some scenarios we're really talking about, and the very
- 14:34Speaker 4: premise of his question, he said, is that the pregnant
- 14:38Speaker 4: person does not get treatment to save her health, her organs,
- 14:42Speaker 4: her life. And I thought that was, you know, meant
- 14:45Speaker 4: more for us than it was to persuade Justice Alito,
- 14:48Speaker 4: who the Biden administration knows is unpersuadable in this case
- 14:52Speaker 4: and many others.
- 14:53Speaker 2: When you hear what the situation is in Idaho, now
- 14:58Speaker 2: what's happening and in other states that have these near
- 15:00Speaker 2: total bands, it's hard to imagine the Supreme Court doing
- 15:04Speaker 2: what it's likely to do, which is uphold this Idaho
- 15:07Speaker 2: law when you know, women's health is in jeopardy here.
- 15:12Speaker 4: Yeah, and m TALA matters quite a bit to a
- 15:15Speaker 4: narrow range of situations, to crisis situations. But those situations,
- 15:21Speaker 4: of course, are really life or health on the one side,
- 15:25Speaker 4: or people who are experiencing them. And I think in
- 15:27Speaker 4: red states or states that have abortion bands in place,
- 15:31Speaker 4: and TALA is what is less of protections for miscarriage
- 15:37Speaker 4: management and for abortion care in these crisis scenarios where
- 15:41Speaker 4: someone's being made quite sick from their pregnancies. So it
- 15:45Speaker 4: matters quite a bit under abortion bands, not just about Idaho.
- 15:48Speaker 4: It's about every state that has an abortion ban that
- 15:51Speaker 4: prohibits emergency abortion care in scenarios where MTALA would require
- 15:58Speaker 4: that care be offered to pregnant person. You know, it
- 16:01Speaker 4: might matter to states that have more liberal abortion policies
- 16:05Speaker 4: as well. And this is a real concern. How the
- 16:07Speaker 4: Court decides this case could have real implications beyond states
- 16:12Speaker 4: with abortion bands. You know, if you read the amicus briefs,
- 16:16Speaker 4: if you read the brief from the State of Idaho,
- 16:19Speaker 4: there's actually an argument being made that fetuses have equal
- 16:23Speaker 4: rights to pregnant people under federal law. And if that's right,
- 16:27Speaker 4: and a number of amicist briefs go this far, then
- 16:30Speaker 4: it is actually prohibited by ANTALA for a hospital to
- 16:35Speaker 4: perform an abortion, and that's federal law. That would be
- 16:39Speaker 4: the rule everywhere New York, California, Rhode Island.
- 16:42Speaker 2: Do you think that conservative justices would go so far
- 16:45Speaker 2: as to embrace this idea of fetal personhood.
- 16:49Speaker 4: It would not surprise me to see a concurrence that
- 16:52Speaker 4: makes the argument for statutory fetal personhood. That is that
- 16:57Speaker 4: with this nineteen eighty nine amendment to that added the
- 17:00Speaker 4: language of an unborn child in order to emphasize the
- 17:05Speaker 4: dual obligation to the pregnant person, that in fact m
- 17:09Speaker 4: Tala creates an obligation to the fetus that's equal to
- 17:12Speaker 4: the obligation to the pregnant person. I don't think that
- 17:15Speaker 4: we're going to have a majority of the court that
- 17:18Speaker 4: would be willing to go along with that, probably, but
- 17:21Speaker 4: we could easily see a concurrence that begins to build
- 17:25Speaker 4: fetal rights under federal statute.
- 17:28Speaker 2: So the decision here will it have definite implications for
- 17:32Speaker 2: states that have enacted these near total bands on abortion.
- 17:36Speaker 4: Yes, absolutely, So the court could side with the Biden administration.
- 17:40Speaker 4: If it sides with the Biden administration, then m TALA
- 17:43Speaker 4: preempts conflicting state laws. So to the extent a state
- 17:48Speaker 4: abortion band conflicts with m TALA, m TALA applies an
- 17:52Speaker 4: emergency department physicians would be free to provide abortion care
- 17:57Speaker 4: consistent with MTALA. If the court sides with the State
- 18:01Speaker 4: of Idaho, under virtually any rationale, it might decide the
- 18:05Speaker 4: opinion that will also affect other state laws. Because the
- 18:09Speaker 4: Idaho law is quite extreme, has a very narrow exception
- 18:13Speaker 4: only for life. So if there's no conflict between the
- 18:16Speaker 4: Idaho law and the federal and TALA, then there's no
- 18:19Speaker 4: conflict between MTALA and Texas law, for example, which has
- 18:24Speaker 4: a life as well as the substantial impairment of a
- 18:28Speaker 4: major bodily function exemption. Or perhaps even more worryingly, if
- 18:33Speaker 4: the idea is that IMPALA incorporates state law by reference,
- 18:38Speaker 4: so the standard of care is set by state law
- 18:41Speaker 4: rather than national medical practice, then I think that application
- 18:45Speaker 4: could apply beyond abortion to other sort of hot areas
- 18:50Speaker 4: where in particular Republican legislatures are trying to regulate medical
- 18:56Speaker 4: care and restrict medical care.
- 18:58Speaker 2: Let's say there are five votes to support Idaho's abortion ban.
- 19:02Speaker 2: Does the Court then tell the Biden administration you can't
- 19:06Speaker 2: enforce IPALA this way.
- 19:08Speaker 4: Because the idea would be simply that ATALA doesn't apply
- 19:12Speaker 4: as the Biden administration has said it applies, right, So
- 19:16Speaker 4: the rationale could be that MTALA only requires stabilizing treatment
- 19:22Speaker 4: consistent with state criminal law or state law period. That's
- 19:27Speaker 4: one of the lines that Idaho is pushing. So if
- 19:31Speaker 4: that's the notion, then state law is really the baseline,
- 19:35Speaker 4: not so much in TALA.
- 19:37Speaker 2: What does it indicate that the Supreme Court allowed the
- 19:41Speaker 2: Idaho law to take effect while they're hearing the case,
- 19:45Speaker 2: and also that they took the step unusual of bypassing
- 19:50Speaker 2: the federal appeals court level and you know, deciding to
- 19:53Speaker 2: directly review a federal trial court's ruling.
- 19:58Speaker 4: Yeah, I mean, it's a sign of where they are
- 20:01Speaker 4: headed and where they want to head past. And you know,
- 20:04Speaker 4: they're abundantly aware too that they have a cert petition
- 20:07Speaker 4: currently pending from the Biden administration involving a very similar
- 20:11Speaker 4: case out of Texas. It really raises that question squarely
- 20:15Speaker 4: about the interaction between state law and the federal and.
- 20:18Speaker 2: TALA does it seem clear that the Justices and particularly
- 20:24Speaker 2: Samuel Alito, who wrote the decision overturning Row, were wrong
- 20:28Speaker 2: and thinking that they were done dealing with abortion cases
- 20:31Speaker 2: by putting it in the hands of the states.
- 20:35Speaker 4: Yeah, the Corps has two abortion cases less than two
- 20:39Speaker 4: years after they overturn Roe v. Wade. And this is
- 20:42Speaker 4: clearly an issue that the Justices are going to see
- 20:47Speaker 4: over and over again with regard to AMTALA, with regard
- 20:51Speaker 4: to FDA, with regard to constitutional arguments related to the
- 20:56Speaker 4: right to travel, and so they I think they will
- 20:59Speaker 4: be regularly adjudicating cases involving abortion. And that's really a
- 21:04Speaker 4: legal landscape that the Supreme Court creative itself.
- 21:07Speaker 2: And will you explain the arguments around federal conscience protections.
- 21:14Speaker 4: One theme in the oral argument on Amtala were federal
- 21:18Speaker 4: conscience protections and these came up with regard to the
- 21:21Speaker 4: abortion pills oral arguments as well, And I think we
- 21:24Speaker 4: see some concerning developments here with regard to conscience protection.
- 21:28Speaker 4: So conscience protections are just the idea reflected in federal
- 21:32Speaker 4: and state law usually that people with religious or moral
- 21:35Speaker 4: objections to performing abortions can't be discriminated against usually can't
- 21:40Speaker 4: be required to perform abortions. This was fair enough. The
- 21:44Speaker 4: issue here, though, involves the interaction between emergency medicine and
- 21:49Speaker 4: conscience protections, and we got some very very disturbing statements,
- 21:54Speaker 4: I think, from the US government as to the position
- 21:57Speaker 4: of the US government on these laws. The US government
- 22:00Speaker 4: is now arguing that federal conscience protections allow not just
- 22:05Speaker 4: individual doctors, but entire institutions not to provide emergency abortion care.
- 22:11Speaker 4: This is shocking. This is shocking because with the Affordable
- 22:16Speaker 4: Care Act, there were lots of debates over this issue.
- 22:19Speaker 4: It was the position of everyone. The United States government
- 22:22Speaker 4: included that in emergency scenarios, there was no right to say,
- 22:28Speaker 4: my moral feelings would be hurt by this, and as
- 22:32Speaker 4: a result, you get to lose your kidney. This was
- 22:35Speaker 4: not a viable argument. How do I know that's true
- 22:38Speaker 4: because multiple times Republicans in Congress tried to amend the
- 22:43Speaker 4: law to allow exactly this to happen, to create a
- 22:46Speaker 4: conscience exemption related to MTALA. They failed each time. And
- 22:51Speaker 4: now we see the US government showing up in the
- 22:53Speaker 4: Supreme Court and in two arguments claiming that this right
- 22:57Speaker 4: exists it's a real problem because I think it opens
- 23:01Speaker 4: the door to religious institutions, and there are many in
- 23:05Speaker 4: healthcare to denying emergency abortion care, including in states where
- 23:10Speaker 4: abortions are legal and readily available, And that is really
- 23:16Speaker 4: seriously concerning because it goes much farther than even what say,
- 23:21Speaker 4: the US Conference of Catholic Bishops were arguing some twenty
- 23:25Speaker 4: years ago. It goes farther than what the Catholic Health
- 23:27Speaker 4: Association has that is required. And so I think we're
- 23:30Speaker 4: in a brave new world with regard to the invocation
- 23:33Speaker 4: of conscience constantly, regardless of the costs for human health
- 23:38Speaker 4: or human life.
- 23:39Speaker 2: And that's something you don't here talked about as much
- 23:42Speaker 2: as apparently we should be talking about it. Thanks so much, Liz.
- 23:46Speaker 2: That's Professor Elizabeth Zepper of the University of Texas Law School,
- 23:50Speaker 2: coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show. The Chamber
- 23:53Speaker 2: of Commerce is already suing to block the FTC's newly
- 23:58Speaker 2: announced non compete ban. I'm June Grasso, and you're listening
- 24:01Speaker 2: to Bloomberg. Business groups, led by the US Chamber of
- 24:06Speaker 2: Commerce sued the Federal Trade Commission today to try to
- 24:10Speaker 2: block a rule finalized this week that would outlaw non competes.
- 24:15Speaker 2: Those are provisions that prohibit workers from switching jobs within
- 24:19Speaker 2: an industry. The Chamber argued that the FTC lacks the
- 24:23Speaker 2: authority to issue rules that define unfair methods of competition.
- 24:27Speaker 2: The regulator has argued that its legal authority is crystal
- 24:31Speaker 2: clear in the FTC Act. Joining me is Bloomberg reporter
- 24:34Speaker 2: Leeaan Nylan Leah. Let's start with the FTC's ban on
- 24:38Speaker 2: non competes. Tell us about it.
- 24:41Speaker 6: Yeah, so the FTFP voted to adopt what's a nearly
- 24:45Speaker 6: complete ban on non competes going forward. So after the
- 24:50Speaker 6: rule takes into sorry, after the rule goes into effect,
- 24:54Speaker 6: there will be no more non competes, which are essentially
- 24:58Speaker 6: just clauses in employee contras that forbid them from switching
- 25:01Speaker 6: jobs within an industry. There's a couple tiny carve out.
- 25:06Speaker 1: One.
- 25:07Speaker 6: If you are an executive who is currently subject to
- 25:10Speaker 6: a noncompete, and they define an executive as somebody who
- 25:12Speaker 6: makes more than one hundred and fifty thousand dollars per
- 25:15Speaker 6: year and has a policy position within your organization, you
- 25:20Speaker 6: can still be subject to your current noncompete, but executives
- 25:24Speaker 6: going forward, cannot enter into new ones. And the other
- 25:27Speaker 6: sort of tiny caveat they made is if you are
- 25:29Speaker 6: selling a business, you can be subject to a noncompete
- 25:33Speaker 6: because they're trying to prevent essentially, you know a thing
- 25:37Speaker 6: where somebody who is a startup founder or something sells
- 25:39Speaker 6: their business to someone and then goes out the next
- 25:42Speaker 6: day and starts the same business under a different name.
- 25:44Speaker 6: You know, businesses do want a little bit of comfort
- 25:47Speaker 6: that when they buy something they are getting all of
- 25:51Speaker 6: the assets and sort of knowledge there.
- 25:54Speaker 2: Many people still think of non competes as being for
- 25:57Speaker 2: executives people with trade CDs, but nowadays they even applied
- 26:02Speaker 2: to blue collar workers and minimum wage workers.
- 26:06Speaker 6: Yes, the FTC started this initiative a couple of years ago.
- 26:10Speaker 6: They started it with a workshop in which they had
- 26:13Speaker 6: academics who had studied this come in, and they also
- 26:16Speaker 6: had some state lawmakers because before now non commutes were
- 26:20Speaker 6: largely regulated at the state industry and there was It
- 26:23Speaker 6: was actually a pretty interesting workout workshop that happened during
- 26:26Speaker 6: the Coup administration. The attorneys general from Illinois and a
- 26:30Speaker 6: couple other states had come and talked about how they
- 26:33Speaker 6: had found that there were like a weird proliferation of
- 26:37Speaker 6: these in a lot of as you mentioned, like minimum
- 26:40Speaker 6: wage jobs. Like there ended up being a pretty famous
- 26:43Speaker 6: one involving the sandwich Shane Jimmy Jones and which it
- 26:47Speaker 6: was trying to prevent it's sandwich makers from going anywhere
- 26:50Speaker 6: else that made sandwiches. They had a pretty detailed list
- 26:54Speaker 6: of things that they couldn't do, including like making pedas
- 26:57Speaker 6: or making hogies. All of these types of sandwiches you
- 27:01Speaker 6: couldn't go somewhere else that made them. They found out
- 27:04Speaker 6: in Washington State people were doing it at coffee shops,
- 27:07Speaker 6: you know. They didn't want baristas moving around. It's fairly
- 27:11Speaker 6: common among hairdressers, so yes, well, it's sort of associated
- 27:16Speaker 6: with executives in very like well compensated employees. It had
- 27:22Speaker 6: really like proliferated around the economy to a lot of
- 27:25Speaker 6: lower wage jobs, and even some that you might be
- 27:30Speaker 6: surprised by, like doctors and nurses were often being asked
- 27:34Speaker 6: to sign non compete.
- 27:35Speaker 2: Well, sandwich makers also surprises me. Getting a band like this.
- 27:40Speaker 2: President Biden directed the FTC to get a band like
- 27:44Speaker 2: this more than two years ago, so high priority for
- 27:46Speaker 2: the administration.
- 27:49Speaker 6: Yes, Joe Biden signed this executive order his first year,
- 27:51Speaker 6: the Executive Order on competition, And he actually says in
- 27:54Speaker 6: some of his public speaking that's the thing that first
- 27:56Speaker 6: made him very interested in the issue of competition was
- 27:59Speaker 6: when he was on the campaign trail during the last
- 28:02Speaker 6: election and hearing from a number of workers who had
- 28:05Speaker 6: mentioned to him non competes and that really sort of
- 28:08Speaker 6: struck him as wrong. You know, like non competes are
- 28:10Speaker 6: very a fundamental restraint of trade, as people say, you know,
- 28:14Speaker 6: it is literally preventing a worker from going out and
- 28:16Speaker 6: trying to get a better job that pays them, pays
- 28:19Speaker 6: them well. And particularly when you have you know, people
- 28:25Speaker 6: who have skills that require some kind of licensing within
- 28:27Speaker 6: a state, even like medical, medical or even hairdressers. You know,
- 28:32Speaker 6: when you move, if you try and move out of
- 28:34Speaker 6: state to get another job, you have to go through
- 28:36Speaker 6: the process of getting your recertification. It's very expensive. So
- 28:39Speaker 6: these non competes can have a pretty serious impact on
- 28:42Speaker 6: people's everyday lives when you really can't go and work
- 28:45Speaker 6: for a competitor.
- 28:47Speaker 2: So, but this was a narrow three to two vote.
- 28:50Speaker 2: It went down party lines.
- 28:52Speaker 1: Yes.
- 28:53Speaker 5: So the SEC is a.
- 28:55Speaker 6: Five member body. It has three Democrats right now, because
- 28:58Speaker 6: the Democrats are in the major and then two Republicans,
- 29:02Speaker 6: and they did vote along party lines. Both of the
- 29:04Speaker 6: Republicans in their votes. They gave public statements about them
- 29:09Speaker 6: during the Open Commission meeting earlier this week, and they
- 29:12Speaker 6: said that while they sort of agree in principles that
- 29:15Speaker 6: noncompetes are problematic, they are concerned that the FTC does
- 29:20Speaker 6: not have the authority to issue this type of rule,
- 29:23Speaker 6: and that is what various lawsuits that have now been
- 29:26Speaker 6: filed a challenging the rule have also said because there
- 29:29Speaker 6: is a little bit of a question about whether the
- 29:31Speaker 6: FTC Statute as written would allow them to have this rule.
- 29:34Speaker 2: So the Chamber of Commerce, the nation's largest business lobby,
- 29:38Speaker 2: is one of those suing. Is that what they're alleging
- 29:42Speaker 2: that the FDC just doesn't have the authority here.
- 29:45Speaker 6: Yes, they have two major arguments, but first being the
- 29:47Speaker 6: FTC does not have the authority to issue this type
- 29:49Speaker 6: of rule. So the SEC says it does because the
- 29:53Speaker 6: FTC Act allows them to prohibit what are known as
- 29:56Speaker 6: unfair methods of competition, and so in the rule they said,
- 30:00Speaker 6: this is an unfair method of competition, and the SEC
- 30:03Speaker 6: Act also has another section that says that they are
- 30:05Speaker 6: allowed to issue rules and regulations to help enforce the law.
- 30:09Speaker 6: So to the Democrats on the FTC, they think that
- 30:12Speaker 6: makes it pretty clear that they are allowed to issue
- 30:14Speaker 6: a rule of this type. The Republicans say, you know,
- 30:18Speaker 6: historically the FTC has prohibited unfair methods of competition by
- 30:22Speaker 6: individual enforcement actions, and very rarely has that actually gone
- 30:27Speaker 6: through with a rule making. The last time they had
- 30:31Speaker 6: a rule making that used this unfair methods of competition
- 30:35Speaker 6: statute on its own to make a rule with something
- 30:38Speaker 6: like the nineteen seventies, and generally they make rules under
- 30:43Speaker 6: some of their other authorities. So that is like one
- 30:47Speaker 6: half of the Chamber of Commerce's lawsuits. The other half is,
- 30:50Speaker 6: you know, the Supreme Court in a case recently said
- 30:54Speaker 6: that they have concerns when agencies act on major questions,
- 30:59Speaker 6: and so the Chamber of Commerce is also sort of
- 31:02Speaker 6: challenging the FTC's on compete van under this major questions doctrine.
- 31:07Speaker 6: You know, that's the idea that if Congress really did
- 31:09Speaker 6: want you to solve this major question, they would have
- 31:11Speaker 6: been very very explicit in the statute that this was
- 31:15Speaker 6: the sort of action that the agency could take.
- 31:18Speaker 2: And also the Supreme Court. The conservative members of the
- 31:21Speaker 2: Supreme Court are on sort of a mission against the
- 31:24Speaker 2: administrative state, and there are several cases involving the reach
- 31:29Speaker 2: of agency powers. So do people you've talked to think
- 31:33Speaker 2: that the Chamber has a good case here?
- 31:36Speaker 6: It's pretty much right now, following along party lines, you know,
- 31:41Speaker 6: the STC did have a challenge to its authority to
- 31:43Speaker 6: make rules back in the nineteen seventies that took place
- 31:47Speaker 6: here in the DC Circuit. That's part of the reason
- 31:49Speaker 6: why the Chamber opted to do in Texas, which is
- 31:52Speaker 6: in the more conservative Fifth Circuit, because if they had
- 31:55Speaker 6: filed here, you know, they would probably refer back to
- 31:58Speaker 6: this nineteen seventies case that says, yes, we think the
- 32:00Speaker 6: FTC has this authority. But by filing in a new circuit,
- 32:05Speaker 6: you know, they can sort of have that circuit take
- 32:07Speaker 6: the question up a new potentially creating a circuit split
- 32:11Speaker 6: that they could then take up to the Supreme Court.
- 32:13Speaker 2: And what other groups are suing besides the Chamber, So the.
- 32:16Speaker 6: Chair of Commerce and the Business round Table are too,
- 32:19Speaker 6: alongside some local chambers of commerce in Texas. That's how
- 32:22Speaker 6: they got venues in Texas. There was also a tax
- 32:26Speaker 6: firm that filed its own lawsuit, and yeah, we've been
- 32:33Speaker 6: We've been getting a couple others since the day has
- 32:35Speaker 6: gone on of various people who are filing. When the
- 32:39Speaker 6: SEC announced this, there were a bunch of business groups
- 32:41Speaker 6: that came out against it, including HR professionals, associations, a
- 32:46Speaker 6: lot of professional associations like actuaries, things like that came
- 32:50Speaker 6: out sort of against the idea of banning non competes.
- 32:53Speaker 2: It's going in hundreds of millions of dollars to workers wages.
- 32:56Speaker 2: Is that why business groups are mostly against it? Or
- 32:59Speaker 2: are there are other reasons besides money money money.
- 33:02Speaker 6: The business groups say that noncompete are useful for sort
- 33:07Speaker 6: of protecting business information. So you know, you don't really
- 33:10Speaker 6: want to hire an employee and then have them the
- 33:13Speaker 6: next day go across the street to your biggest rival
- 33:15Speaker 6: and tell them all of your customers or your business
- 33:18Speaker 6: plans and strategy. The SEC says in response, you know,
- 33:23Speaker 6: there are all sources of other laws that you could,
- 33:26Speaker 6: you know, use to address that trade secret law, non
- 33:31Speaker 6: solicitation clauses, things like that, so you don't really need
- 33:34Speaker 6: a non compete which effectively bars them from taking another job.
- 33:39Speaker 6: The other aspects of the STC left open in the
- 33:42Speaker 6: rule is that you could offer an employee garden leave
- 33:45Speaker 6: is sort of what it's known as, which is where
- 33:48Speaker 6: you are requiring them not to take another job for
- 33:52Speaker 6: a certain period of time, but you are continuing to
- 33:54Speaker 6: pay them either a salary or some sort of compensation
- 33:57Speaker 6: to make up for the fact that they can't take
- 34:01Speaker 6: this other job. That way, when they go to a
- 34:03Speaker 6: new employer, like the information they have about your company
- 34:06Speaker 6: is at least a little bit dated.
- 34:08Speaker 2: With the proposed rule making, there was a solicitation of
- 34:11Speaker 2: public comments. What did they say about the comments that
- 34:14Speaker 2: they got.
- 34:16Speaker 6: Yes, so the FEC got twenty six thousand comments, which
- 34:19Speaker 6: is a lot for the FPC. Oftentimes they put out
- 34:23Speaker 6: for public comments and onnly get a couple hundred. So
- 34:26Speaker 6: they were pleasantly surprised that they got twenty six thousand.
- 34:29Speaker 6: Of the twenty six twenty five thousand were actually in
- 34:32Speaker 6: support of the rule, which is one of the things
- 34:35Speaker 6: that they cited for a reason why they felt comfortable
- 34:39Speaker 6: and we're moving forward with this. And in the rule
- 34:42Speaker 6: itself they cited a bunch of them from individuals who
- 34:44Speaker 6: talked about how non competes had significantly impacted their lives,
- 34:49Speaker 6: preventing them from taking, you know, other jobs, or when
- 34:52Speaker 6: they did try and take another job, they got sued.
- 34:54Speaker 6: As I mentioned before, a lot of non competes before
- 34:57Speaker 6: this rule were really handled an estate by state basin,
- 35:00Speaker 6: and because of that, you know, you would often have
- 35:03Speaker 6: to go to court to see if a noncompete was
- 35:06Speaker 6: enforceable or not. And the average person doesn't have a
- 35:08Speaker 6: lot of experience with courts or suing over contracts, and
- 35:12Speaker 6: so when you know an employer might threaten to see them,
- 35:15Speaker 6: that was sometimes enough to keep them from trying to
- 35:18Speaker 6: change stobs because they don't really want to have to
- 35:20Speaker 6: deal with that.
- 35:21Speaker 2: Does the FTC or the Biden administration expect this to have,
- 35:25Speaker 2: you know, a broad effect on the workplace or the workforce.
- 35:30Speaker 6: Yes, So the SEC did some of its own calculations
- 35:34Speaker 6: on how broad this might be. They estimated that it
- 35:37Speaker 6: would impact wages to the two no four hundred billion
- 35:41Speaker 6: billion dollars over the next ten years. They also, however,
- 35:45Speaker 6: said that they think that it may help with small
- 35:47Speaker 6: business formation because when people are no longer subject to
- 35:51Speaker 6: a noncompete, they can go out and start their own
- 35:53Speaker 6: businesses in the same industry. And so they had some
- 35:56Speaker 6: research that they did showing that it would increase new
- 36:00Speaker 6: business formation by as much as two point seven percent
- 36:02Speaker 6: a year. So their findings were largely that this would
- 36:05Speaker 6: have a positive impact on the economy.
- 36:07Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Leah. That's Leah Nylan, Bloomberg Antitrust Reporter.
- 36:12Speaker 2: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 36:15Speaker 2: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 36:17Speaker 2: subscribing and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 36:21Speaker 2: and at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, Slash Law. I'm
- 36:25Speaker 2: June Grosso and this is Bloomberg