Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Rebel Ridge (2024): An Action Movie About De-escalation
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:32We're sitting here in my attic room. There are
- 0:36craft supplies all over the floor. A large packet
- 0:39of thin markers. A stack of colored papers. The
- 0:44paper confetti and kid scissors that mark a good
- 0:47project. My kids were up here with me today.
- 0:52Being a parent, being around kids all day, every
- 0:57day, means having the same conversations over
- 1:01and over again. It's important that you treat
- 1:05each other with respect, as if the other person
- 1:07is someone who matters. If someone is annoying
- 1:11you, ask them to please stop. Ask them calmly
- 1:16first, then quietly but firmly, and then you
- 1:20come get a grown -up. But you need to talk to
- 1:23them first before you come to me. And did that
- 1:28choice make the fight bigger or smaller? It can
- 1:33be pretty exhausting. But then I'm often reminded
- 1:37of... How few grown -ups ever learned these things,
- 1:40either because a grown -up never taught them
- 1:43or because they refused to listen. And I have
- 1:48to believe that it will be worth it, that my
- 1:51kids will hopefully learn conflict management
- 1:54and how to live at peace with others, so far
- 1:57as it depends on them. Today, I'm going to be
- 2:03talking about a film that debuted on Netflix
- 2:06last year, Rebel Ridge, directed by Jeremy Saulnier,
- 2:11a very skilled filmmaker with a particular reputation,
- 2:15one that actually kept me away from this movie
- 2:18for a few months. I watch a lot of movies, of
- 2:22all kinds. I read about even more. And I've started
- 2:27to identify certain words, certain descriptors
- 2:31that indicate when a movie is not my cup of tea.
- 2:35One of those is bleak. Bleak movies stick to
- 2:41me. I find I can't shake them for days after,
- 2:45and it's a real struggle to go about my life.
- 2:48It often affects my mood and even my mental health.
- 2:53This isn't to say I avoid movies that deal with
- 2:56tough topics. Far from it. I actually really
- 3:00love movies that are honest about the realities
- 3:03of suffering in the world, of pain and difficulty.
- 3:08But I need a crack of hope. I need a breath of
- 3:12catharsis. I need a sense of purpose in my pain.
- 3:19Jeremy Saulnier is known for making high -quality,
- 3:23bleak thrillers. His biggest hit was a movie
- 3:27called Green Room, one that contains reportedly
- 3:30phenomenal performances from Patrick Stewart
- 3:32and the late Anton Yelchin, and is an incredibly
- 3:36tense, bleak film straddling the horror -thriller
- 3:40line. It's one of those stories where People
- 3:44are horrifying, and the terrible things they
- 3:46will do to each other are the nightmare that
- 3:49traps the protagonist and his unlucky punk band.
- 3:53I have heard only praise about this film. I've
- 3:57read reviews, I've watched video essays, and
- 4:01I know that actually watching the movie would
- 4:04be very bad for me. So I didn't watch Rebel Ridge
- 4:08when it came out. I kept hearing very good things
- 4:12as it made a little splash on Netflix, building
- 4:15week after week as one of the most watched films
- 4:18on the platform. But I kept reminding myself
- 4:22that Jeremy Saulnier does not write movies that
- 4:26are good for my mental health. What changed my
- 4:30mind was this pitch. What if Rambo... in first
- 4:37blood, was committed to non -lethal tactics.
- 4:43I love action movies. If you visited me back
- 4:47in March, you'll have heard me wax eloquent about
- 4:50my love for Raiders of the Lost Ark, an action
- 4:54-adventure movie. I'm also one of those people
- 4:57who thinks Die Hard is a Christmas movie, and
- 5:00it's part of my yearly tradition. Action is a
- 5:03cozy genre for me. If I'm having a bad day, there's
- 5:08nothing better than curling up with a movie where
- 5:11a dude is going to solve his problems by shooting
- 5:15or punching another dude in a particularly skilled
- 5:18or inventive way. It's probably the catharsis
- 5:22talking. But I'm highly aware that there's a
- 5:25level of personal cognitive dissonance here.
- 5:29John McClane, from Die Hard, is the kind of cop
- 5:33that should not be. a cop. Like, he genuinely
- 5:38should have been fired years ago. He is way too
- 5:42quick to pull his gun. He literally kills first,
- 5:46asks questions later. I might have a lot of fun
- 5:50watching him solve problems, think on his feet,
- 5:54and blow up a whole floor of a building in order
- 5:57to get the police to take his situation seriously,
- 5:59but I have to acknowledge that he's reckless
- 6:02in a way that would make me very concerned in
- 6:05real life. While I do not believe action movies
- 6:09cause violence, I do have to wonder at how desensitized
- 6:16we are to violence. and violent images, and I
- 6:20also have to question how they shape the capacity
- 6:23of our imaginations for how to solve problems.
- 6:28So, what if we could take the catharsis of an
- 6:33action movie, of watching a skilled individual
- 6:36solve problems in an inventive way, but use it
- 6:40to challenge our imagination. What if we could
- 6:45use the language of a film genre to simultaneously
- 6:49satisfy the desires of its audience and question
- 6:53the very pillars of that genre? Here's the setup
- 6:58for Rebel Ridge. In the first scene, we are introduced
- 7:03to Terry Richmond, a Black man traveling down
- 7:07a rural Louisiana highway on a bicycle. He is
- 7:11listening to rock music on headphones. This is
- 7:14considered a safety hazard by most cycling experts,
- 7:18but as he isn't wearing a helmet, he's not exactly
- 7:21doing the safety thing. Behind him is a police
- 7:25cruiser flashing his lights. It isn't clear if
- 7:29the siren is on, nor how long the cruiser has
- 7:32been following him, but Terry is purposefully
- 7:36clipped by the vehicle and sent sprawling. The
- 7:39cop emerges with his gun drawn and demands that
- 7:43Terry lay flat on the ground, hands spread wide.
- 7:47According to the cop, he'd been following Terry
- 7:49for two miles, and Terry is considered to be
- 7:52fleeing an arrest, despite Terry's insistence
- 7:55that he hadn't heard the sirens or seen the lights.
- 7:59Terry is at first defensive, then drops his tone
- 8:03to be calm and clear. Another cop shows up in
- 8:07his car. and threatens to tase Terry. According
- 8:11to the cops, they had a report of a stolen bike,
- 8:14which is their stated reason for pulling him
- 8:17over. Terry asks to see the report of the bike.
- 8:21The cops deflect, insisting it doesn't matter
- 8:24since he fled. They proceed to search his backpack,
- 8:28all the while harassing him, trying to prompt
- 8:32a reaction from him. They find a plastic bag
- 8:36inside which Terry at first denies permission
- 8:38for them to examine, then agrees when he realized
- 8:42he would be delayed for several hours otherwise.
- 8:46Inside is $36 ,000 in cash. Terry explains it
- 8:53is to post bail for his cousin and buy a pickup
- 8:55truck so they can work together. He admits his
- 8:59cousin is in prison on a drug charge, and the
- 9:02cops declare that since the money is affiliated
- 9:04with drugs, they are confiscating it via civil
- 9:07forfeiture. We have our hero who, while reckless
- 9:11in his bike driving, is quiet, polite, clear,
- 9:16Direct and level -headed in a very tense interaction
- 9:20and is clearly being held up unjustly by some
- 9:24cops who are very happy to inflict as much pain
- 9:27and misery on him as they can, looking for every
- 9:30excuse to make his life miserable. We don't know
- 9:36exactly what's going on. We know that it smells.
- 9:42As a film audience, We understand what this setup
- 9:46means. This is the beginning of tension that
- 9:49will find its release in violence. We are given
- 9:53a promise. These guys messed with the wrong dude,
- 9:58and he will get back at them. We have been taught
- 10:01this in so many films. We have seen this scenario
- 10:05before. Quite literally. As I mentioned earlier,
- 10:11Rebel Ridge is very much in conversation with
- 10:141982's First Blood, the original appearance of
- 10:18John Rambo. It's funny, Rambo is a character
- 10:22with a specific reputation, the star of intensely
- 10:26violent and jingoistic films about the slaughtering
- 10:29of faceless commie bad guys from all over the
- 10:32world by the ultimate killing machine. But his
- 10:36first film is entirely different. a more grounded
- 10:39story of a troubled Vietnam vet going against
- 10:42a bunch of good old boy cops in a small Oregon
- 10:45town. In the beginning of First Blood, we get
- 10:49a scene of context of Rambo trying to meet up
- 10:52with an old war buddy, only to find out he died
- 10:56of cancer as a result of being exposed to Agent
- 10:59Orange. And then we meet him walking into town.
- 11:03He's spotted by the local sheriff who seems to
- 11:06know everyone by name. The sheriff picks him
- 11:09up in his car and offers to drive him through
- 11:12to the other side of town. Rambo is at first
- 11:15pleased with the gesture. He asks if they could
- 11:18stop to get a bite to eat. The sheriff refuses,
- 11:22saying drifters aren't welcome here and Rambo
- 11:26needs to walk 31 miles up the road. He drops
- 11:30him at the edge of town and tells him to keep
- 11:32going. And then Rambo turns back around, pops
- 11:38his collar, and begins to walk back into town,
- 11:41accompanied by the swell of intensely defiant
- 11:44music. And in First Blood, this scene is a promise
- 11:50that there will be retribution. That this smarmy
- 11:54cop will not get away with disrespecting a former
- 11:57Green Beret. And he doesn't. In that film, they
- 12:02keep pushing and pushing him until he ends up
- 12:05taking them down one at a time in the forest,
- 12:08using guns and knives, a spike trap, a garrotte,
- 12:12and a well -thrown rock. I heard one person describe
- 12:16that scene as him becoming Batman. Which is funny,
- 12:20because Batman as a character is theoretically
- 12:23committed to not killing others. Of course, in
- 12:26most of his film depictions, the people would
- 12:29definitely be dying offscreen. Burton's Batman
- 12:33drops goons from tall buildings, Nolan's flips
- 12:36cars, Snyder's brands his enemies, knowing this
- 12:40will get them killed in prison. Pattinson's Batman
- 12:44goes through a journey of questioning his methods,
- 12:47of whether violence really makes anyone a hero,
- 12:51but he's only gotten one movie so far, and it's
- 12:54not exactly sure how his character will progress.
- 12:57What is certain is that we assume Terry Richmond
- 13:01will be another John Rambo. He's a veteran, a
- 13:07Marine who is clear, confident, and unshaken
- 13:10in a completely unjust circumstance. We want
- 13:15him to teach these power -tripping, possibly
- 13:19racist cops an amazing lesson. And he does. It's
- 13:25just in a different way than we were expecting.
- 13:29First, Terry always tries to talk through the
- 13:33conflict. His voice is low and quiet. He sometimes
- 13:39gets defensive. He is human and he is definitely
- 13:42being put through the ringer, but he always takes
- 13:45a beat after to calm down. He speaks very directly.
- 13:51and reasonably laying out as much of the information
- 13:54as is necessary to get things done. When one
- 13:58plan falls through, he plans an alternate, a
- 14:01different way of solving his problem. When that
- 14:04fails, he searches for a contingency, another,
- 14:08albeit more complicated, way to accomplish his
- 14:11goals. And only when that falls through does
- 14:15he fight back. Terry is skilled in martial arts.
- 14:20His service in the Marines was specifically to
- 14:23train his fellow men in martial arts techniques
- 14:27for close quarters combat. But when he begins
- 14:30to fight, he does so only to disarm. He takes
- 14:35a gun by the barrel, twists it away and empties
- 14:39it before his antagonist, another good old boy
- 14:43sheriff, can even blink. He is not interested
- 14:47in wounding. He is interested. in disarming.
- 14:51And it rules. My husband was in the room working
- 14:55on something else when this scene played, and
- 14:57he dropped everything to watch Terry Richmond
- 15:00skillfully and inventively disarm and dismantle
- 15:05every threat against him. It is perfect, fist
- 15:09-pumping, enthusiastic, yelling action movie
- 15:12catharsis. And everybody is alive at the end
- 15:16of this scene. Everybody's still breathing. Nobody
- 15:20even has to go to the hospital. But Terry has
- 15:23given them the opportunity to understand exactly
- 15:27who he is and what he is capable of. This physical
- 15:32encounter is not the last. The plot has many
- 15:35places to twist and turn before the story ends,
- 15:38including the ridge of the title. But in all
- 15:42of his conflicts, Terry remains committed to
- 15:46making the fight smaller and not bigger. He always
- 15:50tries to talk first, disarm second, and give
- 15:54an opportunity for conflict resolution before
- 15:57jumping to violence. And as that violence escalates,
- 16:02which it does, he remains committed to non -lethal
- 16:06methods. Clever, inventive, useful ones. Using
- 16:11a threat instead of a gunshot. Beanbag rounds
- 16:15instead of a shotgun. There is variety here in
- 16:18the action, in the conflicts, in a way that is
- 16:21never boring and is always badass. And I think
- 16:26that's really important. De -escalation, non
- 16:30-violent methods, and non -lethal efforts are
- 16:34seen in our culture as boring and deeply uncool,
- 16:38as well as ineffectual. I remember when the idea
- 16:43of having a separate mental health intervention
- 16:46hotline became a cultural talking point, as well
- 16:50as de -escalation training for cops, and how
- 16:53quickly it became a joke, particularly a viral
- 16:56meme of two cops laughing as a social worker
- 16:59tries to talk down someone having a mental health
- 17:02crisis. De -escalation, the idea goes, is what
- 17:07idiots do. It's what cowards do. Heroes solve
- 17:12the problem quickly and forcibly. And that word
- 17:18hero is important. That's what many cops want
- 17:23to be. And a very specific kind of hero. An action
- 17:28hero. John McClane. Rambo. One of the 500 law
- 17:34enforcement officers played by Arnold Schwarzenegger
- 17:37over his long film career. We have the dash cam
- 17:40and body cam footage to prove it. Cops starting
- 17:44car chases, they don't need to. In one video
- 17:47I've seen, a cop heard a car backfire and did
- 17:51an action movie ground roll before shooting at
- 17:53the vehicle in which a suspect was handcuffed,
- 17:56laying on his back like so many action heroes
- 17:59had done before him. So I think it's really,
- 18:04really important to tell a different kind of
- 18:08story. To have Terry Richmond solving his problems
- 18:11with as little pain and as little bloodshed as
- 18:15possible, but with all the awesomeness and filmic
- 18:19catharsis of the best action movies. In 1982,
- 18:24Sylvester Stallone set the tone of 80s action
- 18:28movies as an ultra -violent killing machine who
- 18:31went from challenging good ol' boy cops to slaughtering
- 18:35whatever brand of communist bad guy made the
- 18:37most sense. We got an ultra -violent hero who
- 18:42solved his problems with skilled and clever violence.
- 18:46And now we have this amazing opportunity for
- 18:50something else. To set the tone of action movies
- 18:54where heroes try to solve the problem with words
- 18:57and then targeted non -lethal action. And it
- 19:04really seems like that might happen. I mentioned
- 19:10earlier how live action depictions of Batman
- 19:12talk a good deal about not killing people, while
- 19:16people are definitely dying off -screen because
- 19:19of his actions, and how it's possible that Pattinson's
- 19:22Batman may wrestle with this. While I don't know
- 19:26if Rebel Ridge will have a specific impact on
- 19:29Batman, it is going to impact superhero action
- 19:33films. One month after this movie's debut on
- 19:37Netflix, Aaron Pierre, the actor who fully brings
- 19:41to life Terry Richman's quiet, calm, direct manner
- 19:45of problem -solving, was cast as Green Lantern.
- 19:50It's clearly too soon to say that Pierre's Jon
- 19:53Stewart will follow the non -lethal methods of
- 19:56Terry Richman, but it's a possibility. And I
- 20:02can't help but be excited about a new kind of
- 20:05action catharsis, where heroes treat their opponents
- 20:08with respect, as if they are people who matter.
- 20:12Where they use their words to communicate boundaries
- 20:16quietly, but firmly. And where they use their
- 20:20skills to cleverly make all of their fights smaller,
- 20:24not bigger. Thanks for coming.