Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The South Carolina Witness: A Follow-Up on Epstein, Trump, and the Questions That Never Went Away (4/21/26)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. Previously, we were talking about the accuser from
- 0:07South Carolina who said that Donald Trump assaulted her after
- 0:13she was introduced to him by Jeffrey Epstein. And we've
- 0:16had a couple of episodes following this story. And in
- 0:20this episode, we're going to follow up once again with
- 0:22another article from The Post and Courier, connecting a few
- 0:26more pieces. And to say that it's interesting is quite
- 0:30the understatement. Like I said, This article was published by
- 0:33The Post and Courier and the headline protect Source Inside
- 0:37the case of an alleged Epstein victim from Hilton Head.
- 0:41This article was authored by Marilyn W. Thompson and Mitchell Black.
- 0:46From the beginning FBI agent's flag for Special Care their
- 0:49interviews with a woman who claimed that she was sexually
- 0:52assaulted by financier Jeffrey Epstein while she was a teenager
- 0:56living on hilton Head Island as type protect source at
- 1:01the top of a formal interview report and confidential was
- 1:04stamped across the bottom, alerting colleagues to their sensitivity. Her
- 1:09four interviews during the flurry of FBI activity around Epstein's
- 1:13twenty nineteen sex trafficking arrest are the only witness interviews
- 1:17labeled with both clear internal warnings, according to a Post
- 1:21and Courier review of records published by the US Justice Department.
- 1:26And of course that's very interesting, right. You don't write
- 1:30protect source if you don't think that there's something there,
- 1:34if you don't think that there's something that's viable, something
- 1:36that's worth protecting. And not only that, but the FBI
- 1:40thought that she was credible enough to speak with her
- 1:43four times. So in my mind, that tells me that
- 1:47they feel like she's a credible witness and she has
- 1:50something to offer. And if that's the case, there's a
- 1:52whole lot of questions that need to be answered, like
- 1:56why wasn't it progressed up the chain, or if it was,
- 1:59who killed it? Why was there no real investigation, Why
- 2:02wasn't it robust? How come these documents were hidden when
- 2:06these files were released, And in my mind, it's all
- 2:10part of the cover up. And of course that cover
- 2:12up is being overseen by Donald Trump and his dj
- 2:18And if you want tangible evidence of something that is criminal,
- 2:21in my opinion, that's where it is. The woman told
- 2:27agents that she believed she was being followed and felt
- 2:30intimidated by harassing phone calls, including one to her mother
- 2:33at a West Coast assisted living facility. What are you ralthy,
- 2:37Siferretto calling Paulia Walnuts's mom. Who does that? What's wrong
- 2:42with people? Oh? Yeah, I know what I'll do. I'll
- 2:45call this lady's mom who's in an assisted care facility,
- 2:47and I'll break her chops. People like that need to
- 2:51take slap right out of their mouth, and we'll call
- 2:53that a life lesson. But the woman's allegation soon took
- 2:56an unorthodox path, after veering from Epstein to an unproven
- 3:00accusation against Donald Trump, who was serving his first term
- 3:03as president when he spoke with it. When she spoke
- 3:06with agents, she was one of two alleged Epstein victims
- 3:09to directly accuse him of sexual misbehavior before he became president,
- 3:14claim strongly denied by the White House. So at this point,
- 3:18how can anyone call for anything besides a special investigator? Like,
- 3:23what are we doing here? We're just gonna keep spinning
- 3:26our wheels, keep going in circles, keep having the same
- 3:29people who told us that everything was fine tell us
- 3:33it's fine again, I'm sorry, but I don't accept it,
- 3:37and I don't accept the people that are investigating this
- 3:40right now or saying they're investigating it, are doing their
- 3:43job correctly. So the only thing we can possibly do
- 3:48to make sure that there's accountability is to put a
- 3:51special counsel in place. And I'm not going to shut
- 3:55up about it until it happens. Despite the sensitivity of
- 4:02folder containing the woman's case, evidence including handwritten agent notes
- 4:06and three photographs, was never forwarded for review or discussed
- 4:10in writing with the US Attorney's office. According to documents
- 4:14and interviews. No public records show that the agents contacted
- 4:18any potential witnesses that she named, so they did no investigation.
- 4:22They just wrote it off. That is completely and utterly unacceptable.
- 4:31They interview this lady four different times, they right protect
- 4:34the source on the interview, and then they don't progress
- 4:37it to the prosecutors. They never send it up the chain.
- 4:41Well either they made that decision on their own, which
- 4:43I doubt so. That leaves us with the brass at FBI.
- 4:47And we all know that we can trust Bill barr
- 4:49Over at the DOJ. Right, that's a man whose character
- 4:54can never be impugned. He's never lied to the American public.
- 5:00The FBI interviewed four times, then the conversations ended. The
- 5:05posting courier used a tool called source based AI and
- 5:09the DOJS online Epstein Library to do targeted searches for
- 5:13some three and a half million pages of records. Reporters
- 5:17also interviewed six former FBI agents, prosecutors, and federal judges
- 5:22to give their insights on why the agency could have
- 5:25devoted so much time in late twenty nineteen to the
- 5:28woman but ultimately did not pursue her case. The former
- 5:32officials requested anonymity so they could discuss the sensitive case. Well,
- 5:38of course they don't want to deal with blowback when
- 5:40you're dealing with this case, especially, you know blowbacks coming
- 5:43you bring up the wrong person, bring up the wrong topic,
- 5:46forget it. But for me, the thing that really sticks
- 5:48out is that nobody pursued anything. Nobody talked to witnesses,
- 5:52nobody pursued evidence, Nobody decided it would be a good
- 5:56idea to send it to the prosecutors. And this is
- 6:01what I've been telling you from the beginning, folks. There
- 6:03has never been a real investigation. There's never been a
- 6:09robust investigation, where every single door is kicked in, where
- 6:13every bush is shaken, where every single rock is overturned.
- 6:19It's never happened, and anybody telling you that it has
- 6:22is lying to you. And if they're telling you that
- 6:24under oath, they're committing perjury. The review offers a partial
- 6:29picture because it captures no phone calls or in person
- 6:32communication among the players in the Epstein investigation, a choice
- 6:36that agent said, keeps such conversations from being used as
- 6:40evidence by defense attorneys and future prosecutions. I think they
- 6:44could come and bite you in the ass. If you're
- 6:46putting on paper where you're documenting your opinion of someone's credibility,
- 6:50one agent said, a defense attorney could come back and
- 6:54use it against you. Well, that's true, that part right
- 6:57there is definitely true. Keep that close to the vest.
- 7:01That's something you say to the prosecutor. You don't put
- 7:03that on the paperwork, right, not if you're looking to
- 7:06pursue a conviction. But this isn't that. This is something
- 7:09completely different. There was no investigation at all, and that's
- 7:15where the problem lies. The newspapers analysis raises questions about
- 7:20how federal officials evaluated the accuser's credibility, the seriousness given
- 7:24to her allegations about Trump, and the sensitivity they applied
- 7:28to her case. Look, that's all very disturbing, and it
- 7:31makes me wonder just exactly what is Donald Trump trying
- 7:34to hide. It also helps explain why members of Congress,
- 7:39including South Carolina Representative Nancy Mace, have insisted that fired
- 7:43Attorney General Pambondi testify under oath before the House Oversight
- 7:47Committee to answer questions about the case and the DOJ's
- 7:51fumbled release of the documents. Bondi did not comply with
- 7:54the committee subpoena to appear on April fourteenth. Can you
- 7:58imagine the absolute raised in disrespect for the survivors, the
- 8:03American people, the Constitution, and everything in between. In my opinion,
- 8:07Pam Bondi should be arrested for a perjury. She lied
- 8:09while she was under oath about Jeffrey Epstein about what
- 8:12was going on, and now she's evading the subpoena. Here's
- 8:18an idea, Why don't you try that and then report
- 8:20back to me how it works out. First, Lady Milania
- 8:23Trump recently called for Congress to hear from victims who
- 8:27have mobilized to protest their treatment by the US justice system.
- 8:31The Post and Courier has not named the former Hilton
- 8:34Head resident in keeping with the papers general policy regarding
- 8:38potential sex crimes victims. She has not responded to interview requests.
- 8:42In a recent comment, Trump referred to women involved in
- 8:45the Epstein case as victims or whatever, and said they
- 8:48have refused to go under oath, which is a little surprising.
- 8:52What about the ones that have one under oath, mister President,
- 8:55Glenn Dubin, Bill Richardson, George Mitchell, Marvin Minsky, the list
- 9:00goes on. These are all people that were credibly accused
- 9:05and never investigated. So please stop your bullshit. The onus
- 9:10is on you, not the survivors, and you're not going
- 9:12to change the narrative and try and put it on them.
- 9:15And anybody trying to change that narrative, you're going to
- 9:17be in for a long fucking day because that nonsense
- 9:20is going to be challenged every step of the way.
- 9:22Records related to the former Hilton Head residence case were
- 9:25inexplicably withheld from two massive document dumps of Epstein files
- 9:30and were later released only after public pressure, leading to
- 9:34concerns that the DOJ was shielding the president. Acting Attorney
- 9:38General Todd Blanche, one of Trump's former personal attorneys, said
- 9:42the departments done releasing documents. Although it continues to hold
- 9:46about two and a half million pages of records, it's
- 9:49deemed duplicative or non responsive. Does anyone trust that? Honestly?
- 9:56Does anyone trust that they've released everything and there's nothing
- 9:59left for the public to say? The Post and Courier
- 10:03reviewed dozens of these unreleased files and found a number
- 10:06of details in them that either appear to be redacted
- 10:08from or omitted from what has been publicly released. Yeah, no, shit,
- 10:13we're being lied to. I know, it's hard to believe.
- 10:16You're being dog walked again. Though. US Representative Rocanna, a Democrat,
- 10:22who authored the bill forcing the document's release, demanded answers,
- 10:26and in April fifteenth letter to Blanche. Until the DOJ
- 10:30makes the full body of records available as required by law,
- 10:33compliance will be impossible to measure, he said. The Post
- 10:38and Courier found several reasons why the woman's case might
- 10:41have been set aside for no further action. Agents may
- 10:44have privately decided they didn't believe her, or have found
- 10:47no way to pursue the decades old and vague assault
- 10:50allegations because they involved many jurisdictions and were difficult to reconstruct.
- 10:55So because it's difficult, you shouldn't pursue it. I thought
- 10:58the FBI was the greatest investigator body in the world.
- 11:01Guess not, huh. Two of the men that she implicated
- 11:04had died. Her accusations also could have been lost in
- 11:07an agency embroiled in political turmoil. By late twenty nineteen,
- 11:12when agents did their fourth brief interview with the woman,
- 11:15Epstein had died of an apparent suicide in his prison cell.
- 11:19Investigators then switched their attention to prosecuting his associate, Glene Maxwell.
- 11:24The South Carolina accuser did not mention Maxwell, Epstein's ex girlfriend,
- 11:28who later helped them recruit under age teenagers for sexual encounters.
- 11:32You mean, fellow scumbag, fellow child abuser, general, all around
- 11:36scuzbag and biputal serpent, Right, that's what you mean. The
- 11:41FBI was also under increasing criticism from an inspector general
- 11:45and GOP leaders, led by South Carolina Senator Lindsay Graham,
- 11:49for improperly handling investigations of Trump as he finished his
- 11:53first term. In office. So you have a special investigator
- 11:56for that, but not this special investigator for Russia Gate,
- 12:01but not this, and nobody's even talking about it. Ask
- 12:07yourself why the alleged victim ultimately settled with Epstein's estate,
- 12:13according to her lawyer, but questions remained about how the
- 12:16Justice Department has released her case files. A former federal
- 12:20prosecutor set reporters should scrutinize the government's official explanation of
- 12:25her case. You guys are absolutely right not to trust
- 12:28what the government's producing or their explanations for things as
- 12:32clerical errors, given all the sensitivity to this and how
- 12:35much Trump wants not to talk about it, he said.
- 12:38And look, my sources have said the same thing. I mean,
- 12:41remember what Agent X told us. They have worked over
- 12:48time to bury this shit. The FBI had a heads
- 12:54up that the former Hilton Head woman might have explosive charges.
- 12:57On July eighth, twenty nineteen, a call all came into
- 13:00a tip line the FBI had set up after arresting
- 13:03Epstein on sex trafficking charges. William F. Sweeney Junior, then
- 13:08the Assistant director in charge of the FBI's New York
- 13:11Field office, had urged a woman who believed they were
- 13:14Epstein victims to call. One person reported she had knowledge
- 13:18of a friend who claimed to have been sexually assaulted
- 13:21by both Epstein and Trump as a teenager after randomly
- 13:24meeting Epstein on Hilton Head. The tipster's call was logged
- 13:29into FBI files, and records of it were later made
- 13:32public in such a way that the caller's identity was exposed.
- 13:36An FBI internal memo circulated last year included notes that
- 13:40used the caller's first name and indicated that she had
- 13:43been charged in a criminal case in South Carolina. The
- 13:46Post and Courier discovered her full name by reviewing the
- 13:49archive case, which had been dismissed. She has declined to
- 13:53speak to the Post and Courier. I don't blame her
- 13:56for a minute. I wouldn't be speaking to anybody either,
- 14:00especially now. What's it going to do? What's it going
- 14:03to prove? Just make her life miserable. The DOJ has
- 14:08said it corrected any errors as soon as it learned
- 14:11of them, and eventually redacted the caller's name. The alleged
- 14:15victim then called the hotline two days later. July tenth,
- 14:19twenty nineteen, record show an FBI employee recorded her initial
- 14:24tip and sent a file to the Seattle field office,
- 14:26asking agents there to interview the woman. Referring cases to
- 14:30field offices was common, as calls poured in, saving time
- 14:34and money from having agents fly around the country, according
- 14:37to former FBI agents, and that's pretty common. So if
- 14:41the FBI has an issue with somebody, say they're in Montana,
- 14:44they'll have the local field office go out, get the
- 14:47initial interview, and then they'll go from there. But of
- 14:49course there's always a downside, and the downside was that
- 14:53field agents were not as familiar with the Epstein investigation,
- 14:56which was based in New York and involved a dedicated
- 14:59team of prosecutors and FBI agents. Investigators there had interviewed
- 15:04dozens of potential witnesses and resurrected files from Epstein's state
- 15:08conviction in Florida in two thousand and eight for solicitation
- 15:13of prostitution of a minor prostitution of a minor again,
- 15:16which is just code word for molesting a kid. Considering
- 15:20children cannot consent, the employee referring to the case to
- 15:24Seattle asked agents to contact the Epstein team before arranging
- 15:28a sit down interview. It's unclear if they did so.
- 15:32Seattle agents conducted their first interview on July twenty fourth,
- 15:36twenty nineteen. The alleged victim discussed how Epstein lured her
- 15:40to a villa at Sea Pines Resort for a babysitting
- 15:43gig and then plied her with drugs and alcohol before
- 15:46repeatedly abusing her. The victim ended the interview without describing
- 15:51her alleged encounter with Trump. Within the coming weeks, agents
- 15:55formalized handwritten notes into an interview summary, as is standard practice.
- 16:01That report offered no opinions about her credibility. Seattle agents
- 16:06noted in the interview summaries the words protect source an
- 16:09effort to safeguard her identity and future witness interviews or
- 16:12during potential criminal cases. They referred to her by her
- 16:16initials throughout the file. They conducted three additional interviews over
- 16:20the next three months, including sessions in which she accused
- 16:24Trump of forcing her to perform oral sex in the
- 16:27New York area in the mid eighties. A fourth conversation,
- 16:31weeks after Epstein's death, was brief and without the woman's lawyer.
- 16:35The woman told agents she was about to join a
- 16:38victim's lawsuit against Epstein's estate, which she eventually dropped after
- 16:42receiving a settlement of an unknown amount. Agents pressed her
- 16:45on her alleged interaction with Trump. What's the point, she asked.
- 16:51Agents responded that all victims of crime should have the
- 16:53opportunity to tell their stories. She was disillusioned, as fuck
- 16:58I bet and can you blame her? And as far
- 17:00as credibility goes, the estate found her credible enough to
- 17:03give her a settlement, So that should tell you a
- 17:06little something. The Justice Department records don't show further FBI
- 17:11interaction with the woman. Her attorney called agents in October
- 17:14of twenty nineteen after the woman told him about a
- 17:17suspicious contact at work and sternly requested that she be
- 17:21approached only through her lawyers. One former prosecutor said it's
- 17:26possible that the FBI higher ups decided not to send
- 17:29the case file to the US attorney. Prosecutors dropped the
- 17:32Epstein charges after his death and arranged for some victims
- 17:36to fly to New York and speak out a court hearing.
- 17:38By then, prosecutors were focused only on Epstein victims who
- 17:43had evidence against Maxwell, who was convicted of sex trafficking
- 17:46and serving twenty years in prison. Only certain FBI and
- 17:50Justice Department officials can answer questions about the final disposition
- 17:54of the alleged victim from Hilton Head. Both agencies have
- 17:59declined to give an official statement. I would say that
- 18:02the plot is certainly thickening, and it's obvious that a
- 18:05real investigation was never initiated. And all that talk about
- 18:09President Trump being exonerated, well, in the words, a leak
- 18:12courso not so fast, my friend. All right, folks, that's
- 18:16going to do it for this one. And when the
- 18:18Post and Courier has another article in their series, we'll
- 18:21definitely get that added to the catalog as well. But
- 18:24until then, all the information that goes with this episode
- 18:27can be found in the description box.