Latest / Home After 50™ / Respecting Aging Parent Decisions in Multi-Generational Homes
Transcript
- Juli: If you are the adult child of an aging parent, this is a must read. It is so helpful for contextualizing this conversation of safety versus or safety integrated with autonomy and independence. And I think it can help us all do a better job of supporting our aging parents. Welcome to Home After 50. I'm Julie Ford. And this is a show about reimagining what life can look like in this next chapter. Here we explore home, family, reinvention, and the evolving ways that women after 50 are shaping lives that are meaningful, grounded, and true. I'm so glad you're here. Welcome back to Home After 50. This week I want to talk with you about something that I'm not sure I've really spent much time at all talking about on the podcast. And that is this issue of the independence and decision-making abilities of our aging parents and more specifically respecting those things. I'm going to talk about this from a perspective of living multi-generationally, but Honestly, this applies whether you are living in the same home or on the same property with your parents or not. If you have aging parents, this episode is for you. And if you are an aging parent, of course, we're all aging, but if you're an older adult, if you're experiencing some of the challenges of aging and you're navigating conversations around your decisions, your abilities, and your lifestyle with your family, this may also be for you as well. So I want to preface this conversation by saying that for the most part, I would say 99.9% of the time, I have the most incredible social media community. And what I mean by that is I am consistently impressed and pleased that the people who come into my comments follow my content that I share on social media and engage in conversation with me are so wise, kind, thoughtful, and emotionally intelligent. I see this over and over again in my community and I'm so appreciative of it. However, it is social media. And so occasionally somebody comes into the comments and even if they didn't mean to, says something that is a little bit off of what I like the tone of my my accounts to to take. So That that happened this week and that actually sparked me thinking about this episode. But actually, I I think I have to thank that person because I am going to be able to bring you some enhanced perspective on this issue of respecting our aging parents' decisions in a way that I probably wouldn't have if this person's somewhat negative comment hadn't made me go down a deeper rabbit hole around this. I'm not working from home alone today. I can hear my husband making noise in the background. I hope you cannot hear. Hear him too. So here we go. So I have been posting a few educational posts and stories on social media around respecting our parents' ability to continue to make their own decisions as they age. And specifically, I've been talking about this in the context of as long as there's not a diagnosis of dementia, Alzheimer's, cognitive decline that really legitimately Challenges their ability to make decisions for themselves that we, even if we disagree, really have to respect that our parents are adults and and they are perfectly capable of making their own decisions, even if we don't like those decisions. One of the posts that I put up was an example of something I've been navigating with my mom. And I'll just be upfront: this has not created a lot of tension between me and my mom, but it is just something we've sort of been navigating as her mobility has become more challenged. I shared in a social media post that I brought up the idea of the possibility of installing a chairlift between her part of the house and ours twice to my mom. And twice she has declined the the idea of it. So you may have heard me talk about our setup before my mom has a fully independent in-law apartment in our home, but it is one level away. She's in a walk-out basement. She has her own exterior. entrances and exits and we also have a staircase between us. What's happened is over the past few years, as her health and her mobility have declined somewhat, it's harder for her to come up and down stairs. An interim solution that we did, I don't know, it was like a year or two ago, was we installed an a second hand drilling on that staircase and that helped. So she can support herself with two hands coming up and down the stairs. But now we're at the point where she doesn't come up and down the stairs unless one of us is there. with her in case she needs help. And that's a solution. But what I was thinking about it was that it's kind of limiting her from just popping up, saying hi, just feeling more free to come up and down. And that is why I suggested the idea of a cheerlift. Not that she absolutely needs it. It's not that she can't climb the stairs, but she for safety reasons doesn't do it without one of us around. So I know that that limits the number of times she comes up and down because she doesn't Always want to have to bother us for help, you know, before she would she would pop up and say hello occasionally. And I just felt like that was allowed for more social interaction for her and more freedom and flexibility. So in the social media post where I was talking about this, I was sharing that even though my mom and I had different perspectives on the idea of what a chairlift might do for her. I had to respect her decision and I actually know it's coming from a place of her wanting to preserve her independence, wanting to preserve her mobility, because because let's face it, when you're when you're going up and downstairs, you're using muscles, right? If you stop doing that, you are potentially reducing your activity even more. And the less we move, usually the less we can move. So I know that from her perspective, there are really good reasons to not want to take that step towards a chairlift. And what came across to me, you know, the idea of it came across to me as feeling like it would give her more freedom. For her, it actually feels like less. And and I deeply respect that. And my mom also is perfectly capable of making her own decisions. Also, I want to point out, and we'll talk about this a little more later when I share something with you that I'm really excited to tell you about. She is still keeping her own safety in mind because she has decided that she doesn't feel safe enough to walk up and down the stairs by herself right now. So she won't do it unless one of us is there. So it's not like my mom is putting herself at unnecessary risk. She's just making choices for herself. Someone came into the comments on that post and said this. And I'll just read it to you because you'll probably see when I read it why I didn't receive it. Very well. So this person, I'm not gonna name them, said, I don't respect the no, referring to the parents no of a decision that they're making that the adult child doesn't agree with. I don't respect the no because it's selfish. Your mother would rather fall, it's stupid. Well, you can imagine. I didn't receive that very well. My mom is not stupid and she would not rather fall. She's just making different choices. So I addressed that. I told her I thought it came across as unkind. I'll just actually I'll read my reply. So I said, Of course my mother would not would not rather fall. She is not taking unnecessary chances. I said that she doesn't climb the stairs without one of us present. This is about her holding on to some hope that she may improve and also retaining an activity level that could help her retain her strength. And that's her choice. My mom is also one of the least selfish people I know. Of course I felt I needed to defend my mom. I respect differences of opinions here and welcome thoughtful discussion, but the way you worded this comment came across as unkind. And and then she replied to me and she said, I I don't mean to come across as rude. I just think it's risky and not worth it. It will give her independence while she works on getting strength back and it can be removed, which, you know, that is perfectly true. But the whole point of the the post was to talk about the need for us as adult children of aging parents who do not have a cognitive diagnosis. That we have to respect their decisions, that we have to respect that they are still adults in charge of their own life. Now, for sure, when we're helping each other as family members, there may be some compromises and agreements that we all come to because our decisions affect other people. And I completely understand that. And we talk about that in our family a lot. But it doesn't negate the fact that I still think we need to raise this conversation because I do think. And I don't even want to say I think. I know that ageism in the world and honestly in our country in the US specifically, I'm sure it exists other places as well. Ageism is a real thing. So I thought it might be helpful if I did a little deeper research to help me talk with you about this. And I found something that I was really excited to share with you. In March of 2025, there was a journal article. Published in the publication The Gerontologist. And it is called the Safety Autonomy Grid, a flexible framework for navigating protection and independence for older adults. And I think it is wonderful. I will link to it in the show notes. I think that if you are the adult child of an aging parent, this is a must-read. It is so helpful for contextualizing. this conversation of safety versus or safety integrated with autonomy and independence. And I think it can help us all do a better job of supporting our aging parents. It was published by Kelly Martfeld and Kate Wilbur. And I hope that I'm going to be able to link directly to the the grid itself, the image of the grid itself in the show notes because I think it's so helpful to look at. So What they've done is they have created a quadr a four quadrant grid called the safety autonomy grid. And on the horizontal line are concerns for safety, and on the vertical line are concerns for autonomy or independence. And so the ideal placement in this grid. If I'm fancy this week, maybe I'll even pop this grid up on the video if I can do that for you so you can see it while I'm talking about it. I'll try. The ideal placement is to be in balanced independence, where you have high safety and high autonomy, high independence. And of course, the not ideal place to be is low safety and low independence. And then the other quadrants of the scale are you could have high safety but low independence. Which could mean that that person is in a physically very safe environment, but they're not allowed autonomy and independence for one reason or another. Or you could have high independence but low safety, which means that they're completely in charge of their own life, but it is very risky the way that they're living. So the goal for all of us is to find ways to support our parents in getting to the place of having high safety and high autonomy. So I just want to use this example of my mom one more time and say, She has declined the chairlift for now, but she's still functioning. So that's her high autonomy, right? That's her independence, that's her choice. However, she is still functioning with high safety for two reasons. One, we have the extra handrails there, but two, and more importantly, in her particular situation right now, she has decided that she will not climb the stairs alone. She will not go up and down without one of us with her. So that's her safety choice that keeps her independence. and her autonomy high. You know, for me, I was worried, hey, that's restricting your freedom because now you don't feel as free to come up and down whenever you want. But for her, the trade-offs are worth it. So she's maintaining safety and maintaining autonomy. So I love the way that this grid explains that. Also, I'll dig into the quadrants a little bit more with you here. And again, I'm going to link this in the show notes so you can you can read it yourself. But quadrant one, the ideal quadrant is Balanced independence. This is what they call it. Person-centric protection. And they say this quadrant represents the ideal of modern elder care models where safety and autonomy coexist within a person-centered care approach. Here, conditions need to be created where caregivers have access and knowledge to be able to take advantage of tools such as adaptive technologies. That second hand reel is a very simple example of that. Individualized care plans and collaborative decision making, ensuring that older adults can maintain as much independence as possible while minimizing risks. So now they're talking about this in both a home environment and a more institutional environment as well. So this covers, you know, any living situation. Now, quadrant two is what they call independence at all costs, safety forsaken. And they describe that this way. This quadrant prioritizes autonomy above all else, even when significant risks are present. Consider an older adult with moderate cognitive impairment who insists on living independently but refuses needed help. Their fierce commitment to independence can create deep emotional stress for family members and caregivers. Family history and dynamics can also make these situations undeniably challenging, and I think that that is so important that they pointed that out. Perhaps this individual has always been strong-willed, or perhaps promises were made that they could remain in their own home, making it difficult to challenge their choices. Quadrant three is what they call neglected independence or unconsidered care. In this quadrant, neither safety nor autonomy is prioritized. It represents scenarios where older adults are left to fend for themselves without adequate support, including situations of self-neglect and social isolation. This level of disregard for both safety and autonomy can occur in family caregiving situations, within institutional environments, and in society at large. In some situations, older adults may desire assistance but are unable to access it due to isolation or limited caregiver capacity. Additionally, self-neglect may stem from a lack of insight or fear. That seeking help could lead to pressured safety interventions, such as placements in a care facility. You can certainly understand that fear. And finally, the last quadrant, which I think speaks a little bit to what I was perceiving, the commenter on my post was the place that they were coming from, is quadrant four, safety at all costs. This is autonomy revoked. This quadrant represents an overemphasis on safety, often resulting in the complete loss of autonomy. Common examples include full guardianship, restrictive or premature institutional care, or caregiving that limits personal decision making. This overemphasis can occur at both individual and institutional levels, leading to significant restrictions on personal choice and independence. This is really what I think the the conflict was between the message that I was trying to share about respecting our aging parents' decisions when they are cognitively capable and overstepping and making decisions for them that we're not respecting their independence and autonomy out of our own fear of what may happen. The other thing that they address in this journal article, by the way, it's it's a journal article, but it's I I'm finding it very readable. It's not so academic. that it's challenging to read. But one of the things that they address are all of the barriers and limitations to adopting this grid and this framework. And one of those are cultural biases and ageism. And this is really what I wanted to talk about: is age it ageism. They say here the grid challenges ingrained cultural biases, particularly the assumption that older adults are inherently frail. Or cognitively impaired simply due to age. Ageism often leads to overprotective decisions, even when the older adult may still have the capacity to make autonomous choices. Overcoming these assumptions is critical for it to be effectively implemented. Effective it being the grid for the grid to be effectively implemented, this framework of autonomy and safety. Shifting the narrative away from blanket protections towards a more person-centered approach. While not insurmountable is a significant barrier. And so this is really what I think about a lot as I navigate this aging journey with my mom, as I've worked with hundreds of over older adults over the past several years. And what I find is that the families who are supporting their aging parents most successfully, living with aging parents in multi-generational homes most successfully, and by successfully, I also mean happily. Are the people who are able to respect their aging parents, independence, and decision making, and the aging parents who are able to make independent choices for their own emotional, mental, and physical well-being, but also then maybe make some compromises with their family in some areas that help their family feel a little more safe. So I'll give you an example. My mom is about to get one of those. life alert bracelets that will send out an alert if she has fallen because she's fallen two or three times three times actually this year and she's been okay each time and each time she has had her phone nearby but I was starting to get concerned that it was honestly just luck that her phone has been within reach the three times that she has fallen. And she wasn't really excited about getting the the life alert bracelet. She wasn't entirely opposed to it, but she was She was, I think, kind of putting it off. It was a little bit annoying to deal with getting it. And luckily my brother stepped in. By the way, that's a whole other conversation of having family members who are helping and not just defaulting to, you know, the the adult child who lives in the multi-generational home with the parent to doing everything. My brother's been great about stepping in and taking care of this. But it was really me that said to my mom, I I think it's time. I I I really would feel better if you got the bracelet simply because When are you gonna fall and not have your phone? We d we just don't know when you might have another fall. And we know there are probably going to be other falls. There are issues with her mobility. and I won't, you know, get into my mom's h private health information, but there are some issues that make the likelihood of a fall pretty high. And I told her, I'm just I'm worried that you're gonna have a fall and not have the phone. Like maybe it will fall out of your reach, or maybe you'll just happen to not have it on you when that happens. And she understood that and she agreed to that. So I didn't feel I was overstepping, but I was expressing honestly, let's face it, it was my own need. It was my own fear of something happening and her not being able to contact me, my brother, 911, anyone to help her. And she made a compromise in what she preferred to help us feel more secure about her safety. So that's what I mean by. There is a navigating of relationship and respect and support for one another while still maintaining autonomy, independence, and safety. That's all I have for you this week. This is a conversation that I think we could talk a lot more about. I hope that introducing this safety autonomy grid was helpful to you. I am definitely going to include links in the show notes. I'll put it in my newsletter this week as well. Because I think that this is a tool that so many families could benefit from. So if you liked this conversation, if you'd like to hear more about it, I'd love to hear from you. You can always leave comments on the show wherever you listen to your podcasts, or you can send me an email at Julie at Julie4.com. I'd love to know what you thought, what you potentially got out of it, if you have experienced. The navigation of safety and autonomy with your aging parents or as an aging parent with your young adult or older adult kids supporting you. Yeah, how's it going? Please let me know. I would love to know what you'd like to see more of here so I can continue to make content that feels helpful to you in your aging and multi-generational journey. Thanks so much for being here. I'll see you next time. Thanks so much for joining me for this week's episode of Home After 50. If this episode resonated with you, please make sure you're following and subscribing so you never miss a thing. And you can find more resources at my website, julieford.com. See you next time.