Latest / Backfire Guns Podcast / No Advantage To Modern Hunting Cartridges? With Ron Spomer
Transcript
- Jim Harmer: What's up everybody? Welcome back to the Backfire Guns Podcast. Today we have one of our favorite people in the gun industry. We have Mr. Ron Spoer. Hey Ron. Hey, how you doing, Jim? I'm doing very well. It's an honor to get to talk to you. Hey, it's an honor to be talked to. Well, I have a bunch of questions that I have been interested in as I I you know always watch your content and since our last last conversations. Tell me this. What is your ideal? Of a hunting rifle. Not necessarily brands or anything, but if you're you're choosing every little part of that, from cartridge to everything, what does it probably look like? boy. You know, Jim, this is a problem I have, and I suspect others you probably do too. There are so many great options on these hunting rifles. It's tough to pick just one. And that's why I have more than one, and most serious hunters do. But I hear what you're saying. It's like, well, if you had to have that one rifle. What's the perfect one? Take the amal amalgamation of all of them, put them all together, what do come up with? But there's something else that kicks in for me at least, and that is changing attitudes, physicality and behavior. When I was younger, of course I could carry more, go farther, have more energy, you get older. Not only do you physically change your ideas of what works well for you, but there's just some kind of a spiritual thing going on. And that's just gonna get us to a rifle I'm gonna bring up as my current favorite. It'll probably end up being my all-time favorite, which is not the most practical rifle, not the bestest rifle for most accurate shooting at long range or anything like that. But it's got everything in it that I want right now for the way I hunt, which is a deeper connection with the entire experience. I don't want to just go out, see something, shoot it, say, hot dog, I got a good one. Now we wait for next year. I want to suck the marrow out of that experience. I want to smell the lay of the rotting leaves in the woods and the sagebrush and I want to hear the birds singing and I want to see and identify everything. I just soak it all in. Because as most people are going to recognize that in our current urban suburban lifestyles, we are so far removed from nature that when we have an opportunity to go hunting, that is Immersing ourselves back into what essentially created us in the first place. you know, I think God created us as an integral part of the environment, not as archangels set apart from the rest of the world that we circle above it and look down and say, those poor sweet little animals. We have to live with those animals and use them the same way that they use one another in this cycle of life. And it becomes almost a holy and sacred act being a hunter. You are out to interact with the animals, get your food by eating them the same as they do by eating one another and you and vegetation and all the rest of it. So the closer I can get to that, the less my equipment is getting in the way, I think, the better I like it. And that's where I'm coming down on my current rifle. I've always been pretty much a minimalist when it comes to my equipment. I didn't like a lot of extras and doodads and features and stuff. So I've gone with maximum point blank range sighting system and a simple scope. Three to nine, two and a half to eight. maybe three to fifteen at the top end, but I've stayed away from dials pretty much and just went with maximum point blank range, which required a fairly fast flat shooting cartridge. Two seventy Winchester was a big one years ago. You to get the right bullet with a high BC, shoot it as fast as you can, and your drops at three hundred yards. If you're sighted about two and a half high at a hundred, you're probably three inches low at three hundred. That's ninety some percent of my shooting opportunities. Part of that, of course, is I want to be a effective hunter. I want to stalk close, work the wind and all the rest of it in the cover and get in close. And this is my tool, this is what it's capable of doing. When I bow hunted, I understood I needed to have a bow in my hand and get within forty yards if I wanted to get anything. That's just part of the game we're playing. So these days, having slowed down quite a bit, I really appreciate the gunmaker's art and what a fine firearm should look like and how it should perform. I have come down to the Park West Arms SD 10 single shot falling block rifle. It's most people are gonna roll their eyes and go, what who would wanna wanna go out hunting with a single shot rifle? But this thing is so slim, trim, elegant, I would say, and balanced. It just fits and feels so good. So when I'm carrying it, even if I don't have game, just having that rifle in my hands actually augments my experience. It becomes becomes part of what I'm doing and why I'm doing it. And I can look at that rifle and I just go. I love this thing. I love the way it looks. I love the way it feels. And when I do shoot it, it's remarkably accurate. And I mean, I was in Africa with it, got six one shot kills. Landon borrowed it and got two one shot kills. Came back here and I got a coyote with one shot. I mean it just doesn't miss, most of the time. Maybe I do. Except for when it does. Yeah. Yeah. Except for those times. You know, that is. But All all of that ties together. So and it's chamber for the seven fifty seven. I currently have I I could even tell you what loophole scope I have on it. I think it's a three to twelve or somewhere in that vicinity. Forty, maybe forty two millimeter lens on it. I don't even look at it anymore. I just know it works and how it works. And it's I'm actually thinking of going a little smaller with the scope right now. No big deal, you know, but just a little tweak maybe. But that's it. It's a a walnut stock blued traditional rifle. As I said, falling block, which is really different. Most people have probably never seen one, but it's slick and smooth and just I don't know. I just love that little rifle. So it's not probably the most sensible rifle to get to be the most effective shooter, because you're gonna have a heck of a time getting that follow up shot off in a hurry, 'cause you gotta reach in your pocket and pull another round out. So I make it a point to make that first shot count. That's awesome. I I mean certainly nobody's gonna fault you on that. Everybody wants to love their rifle. And I think that is what you know, in addition to the tradition, one thing that's really missing in current rifles today is the uniqueness. there you know, everyone looks exactly like every other one coming off the line. and it just doesn't have the the uniqueness of each different piece of wood and things like that. So I I I certainly hear you there. I kind of have a follow up question to that. so obviously it sounds like you're more you care more about the feel of the rifle and the look and all that kind of stuff. you know, connecting with the rifle. But I think everyone has kind of their accuracy threshold. You know, a rifle could look super awesome, but if it shoots four inches, nobody's gonna want to shoot that, you know? So or at least take it hunting. so what's your like accuracy threshold? Like if if a rifle shoots over this, I'm not taking it hunting. That's a question. Yeah, yeah, that's a good really good question. I would say if I love the rifle enough, inch and a half. Okay. Yeah. One and a half MOA. I've gone hunting with a rifle that did closer to one and three quarter. And I w twelve sh fourteen shots I got twelve animals on a safari in Africa. What with what I would consider an inaccurate rifle. But we hunted well, we got close and it didn't matter. And it But generally my rifles are MOA. If I get down to MOA, I don't really waste a lot more time and ammunition working up hand loads to get better than that because I know I don't need it. I'm not shooting at eight hundred yards or even six hundred yards. It's rare that I shoot past four hundred. Most of my shots are inside of three. So I would say, yeah, that's that's my limit. If I've got this absolute killer rifle I love and it only groups one and a half, I can live with that. I'll just get a little closer. But the good news is, of course, my current SD 10 757 Mauser is shooting half MOA with handloads. Well, there you go. Can't complain about that. You could also argue it's a single shot, so everything is just a pinhole group. That's right. They're all one hole. That's right. Yeah, I accuracy is interesting. you obviously obviously know this, but as it's interesting in the industry, it's almost meaningless to even talk about MOA with people. because you know, half MOA, one MOA, one and a half, two, whatever. because it means so many different things to different people. sometimes that means I shot seven groups. And one of them was half and so that must be the one that I did my part on and so this is a half MOA rifle. There you go. It's it's interesting as we have people come to our range and this isn't you know, not not in any means making fun or anything, but just to highlight the differences. I mean very often we we'll have everybody cite in and just kind of see what they do, look at the target. Very often somebody'll say, you know, we have a group of six shots, whatever And they're like, look at those two right next to each other. This is a super accurate rifle when I do my part. And I think that's how a lot of people really look at their their accuracy is they think, you know, the gun is really good. Anything that's off that point must be me. And while it certainly could be, I mean, every gun just has its natural dispersion. If you shoot a twenty shot group with any rifle and you do absolute perfect, there is going to be some natural dispersion to it. And I think that's the one thing that that riflemen just don't want to admit because we all want to love our rifles. Yeah. Well, as a handloader, you know this. You've got to work at getting such precision and consistency. Your cases have to weigh the same. They should have the same internal volume. And then what about your primers? How consistent are those primers? You should get some match grade primers probably. Then is your bullet perfectly balanced? You might need to get a match grade bullet or get a balancer and throw out the the off ones. And then Are you within a tenth of a grain on your powders and on and on it goes? And then, as you've said in other conversations we've had, what's the temperature that day? How does that affect your barrel steel, your bedding system? And on and on and on it goes. And as you know from all the rifle testing you guys have done, you get the same exact rifle coming off the line, one right behind the other, and one could shoot sub MOA and the next one can shoot a two inch group. Same stuff, same everything. Why? What's going on? Rifles like people are individuals. And then there's the factory ammunition. I think a lot of the people we're talking about are fans and our friends and our other hunters, and to a large degree, we do the same thing. You just grab the rifle, it shoots well with a factory load that you happen to find that shot pretty well. But a factory load is probably run down the line and the powder measure opens and closes and dumps a certain amount in and it might be off. You might have, well gosh, I've shot ammunition at varied by a hundred feet per second from shot to shot out of the same box. That makes a big difference once you get past about two, three hundred yards, you're gonna have a heck of a difference in your drops. Now people don't necessarily understand that if you shoot a hundred yard group and you get this flyer, you just kinda wanna discount it and say, well I I I must have pulled it or something, but we won't count that one. We'll just count the two that are touching. Now then you get the argument about, well, three shot group isn't even close to telling you what your rifle's really going to do. You need to do a five. No, you need to do ten. No, you need to really have a twenty shot group. I'm not taking my single shot rifle and putting twenty rounds down it to see what sort of a group I got. I'm sorry. You'll be there all day. Now, Ron, you've hunted everything under the sun. What big game animal animal would you consider the experience of hunting to be a little overrated? Mmm. Boy, I hate to say anything's overrated, but golly. It would be insulting to all of the animals that outwitted me. Right. To name any one of them as overrated. To me, it's not so much the animal as it is the the habitat and area, the terrain, that whole experience that you get makes it so much more special. For instance, you can never say that a whitetail is overrated, given what they've done over the years to thwart a hunter, drive you crazy. Same with black tails over in Oregon. my gosh, I've had some of those guys run circles around me. Frustrating. But you know, it might be sheep. Really? Yeah, it might be because I've never found them to be particularly I don't know if a guy could say savvy or smart. You know, so many times we say, that buck is really smart. I think they're smart the way we know of as smart. They're just extremely alert. and wary and they know when to get the heck out of dodge. But sheep I think get away with being fairly dumb because of where they live and what they can see. They've got such incredible eyesight and there's usually a band of three to ten rams together and their eyeballs looking in every direction and the ears and all the rest of it. So they've got plenty of tools to detect danger. And then they're perched way up in the mountain and it's The challenge of sheep hunting is getting there. Getting there, glassing the sheep before they glass you, and then planning your route. But I've always found that once we've found that particular ram, it wasn't that difficult to get within about three hundred or four hundred yards of him. That's an interesting point. Yeah, broken terrain and all. You just have to get the wind right and then stay out of sight until you crawl within a good shooting position. And as I said, it's usually somewhere in that Four hundred and less. I think I've only shot one ram at four. All the rest have been under, but most of them are around three, three fifty. Mm-hmm. So but people rate them as like, what a trophy animal, because they are. They're a magnificent representative of the wilderness, the pristine wild high country, you know. It's the this is this is as good as it gets. This is the beginning. This is what God made. unpolluted by man and his roads and his developments. It's just pure wild nature. And you're up there as a part of it. And there's this sheep that's living there day after day in the s the snow and the rain and the heat and the cold and whatever nature throws at and they're just munching away at the Forbes up there, making a life, growing those massive antlers and packing thirty five, forty pounds of horn on her heads all day. Could you imagine wearing that on your head? Got to respect that animal. Wow, what an animal. What an animal. But I don't think they're the most challenging to hunt. But they can appreciate our enjoy. Yeah. Now on the on the opposite side, not necessarily the animal, but this time talking about the hunting experience. If you were to take somebody who is newer to hunting but capable, and you just said, Okay, I I'm gonna take on this one experience that I just absolutely know is gonna hook you for the rest of your life into hunting, where would you take them? It would either be a spring gobbler calling it in or a fall September elk calling. Okay. Yeah. Yeah, yeah if you can throw the calls in, that adds so much. You don't get that as much with mule deer or white tail or but or even a moose. But yeah, I think it'd be easier obviously to take kid turkey hunting or any newcomer and hear that gobbler and then sit there with the intensity that comes with that. Getting closer and closer, and he's there you can see his head peeking up and then he's gone, and then you see the edge of his fan coming over the bushes. boy, that gets you hooked. I just did that with an older gentleman, a good friend of mine, had never shot a turkey, 75 years old. And I took him up and called this gobbler in. And fortunately it went just the way it was supposed to. I had the spot and I said, I can't guarantee it, but I've always been successful calling gobblers up to this. I call it gobbler's knob. We'll go to Gobbler's Knob, sit up the same place where I've shot my last three gobblers, and he should come from over here. And it all happened just the way I predicted. And Steve was just he was just going crazy. He was just quivering, sitting there, and then he finally got the shot on his gobbler and dropped it. He was exhausted. It was just, my gosh, he was on and on and on about what a great experience it was. the gobbling, and he was strutting right in front of me and on and on. Yeah, so that was a big thrill. A little more challenging to find a place to get an elk easily like that, you know, it's a lot harder. But boy, if you can put a new shooter in on an elk that's bugling and he comes in, calling in a bull elk within bow range, ho yeah. You're definitely gonna be hooked on that if you you probably have to wash your shorts out, but you're gonna be hooked. I I can agree with you on both points, but especially the turkey. Well, I didn't start hunting until I was sixteen years old or something like that. Just wasn't from a a hunting family at all. And I just I we had moved from Texas to Idaho and you know, just seeing the mountains and stuff was just so interesting to me. And so I I we started hunting but had nobody to mentor us, nobody to show us, you know, what we were doing. We just had to kinda figure it out from books at the library. figure figure out how to go hunting. And anyway I I went with a friend when I was very first starting and he called in a turkey. It wasn't even turkey season. We weren't hunting it. You just just watch this, you know? And I it it was the most magnificent thing I had ever seen in my life until that point. I it was just incredible. You know, just sitting there hiding and the sound and the excitement as it slowly worked its way in. It's it's amazing. Yeah, guys really get hooked on that. Jim, is it okay with you if I put a plug in for my course. Yeah, please do, especially for somebody who's new to hunting like I was. Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. to just what you said about not having anybody, no mentors, and you had to go get some books to figure it out for yourself. I've realized that this is a big problem these days 'cause so many young people, especially they grow up in the cities or in the suburbs and they don't get exposed to nature the way I did as a boy out in the farm. It was easy to just grab a rifle and go out and figure it out. So I thought somebody needs to tell these people what they need to know to sift through it, especially when you start thinking about the language we use as riflemen. This cartridge, this versus a caliber and and a bold action and a push feed and a control run feed and why a short barrel, why a long barrel, on and on it goes. New shooters will come to me and say, I I'm confused. I I just don't get it. This what is all this stuff? It's so complicated. And I got to thinking, I wonder how many of just don't even try because of that complication. So I was talking with Betsy and she said, Well, why don't you teach them? It's like I'm not gonna have a school out here and bring people in and all that I'm too old for that stuff, you know. She's well do a video course. So she talked me into doing this video course. We called it the complete rifleman, and it does this, it explains all this stuff. In my usual style, if anybody watches my YouTube videos, they'll either appreciate the way I present or they won't. But they'll love it. We tr we try to make it s so it's understandable and it g flows. You know, like this is the rifle, this is stock, this is the barrel, this is the action, but this is a different kind of action. Why is it? This is how it works, close-ups and all this stuff. So if anyone out there is listening and you're thinking, I would love to get into hunting, but it's confusing, this course might be a way for you to really get into it and understand it. Without all the conflicting data you get from different YouTube channels and different websites and everything, 'cause everyone's saying their equipment is the best. Of course. I try to I try to give just the straight scoop. I don't care what the brand name is, that's nothing to do with it. It's just this is how this thing works, this is how that one works, this is how a scope works. I show the insides of a scope that we've sliced in half. I show the inside of a f a rifle we sliced in half and just as much detail as we could get in. Fourteen hours worth of videos. And we're adding to it. If they buy the course, we will be adding or we're gonna be doing something on getting your meat put up here shortly. That's a good one. But with deer season on, you know, so field dressing, caping your animal out, getting the cuts of meat, what to do with it. So anything and everything we just keep adding to it and we ask people who buy the course, what didn't you learn that you wanna learn? We'll make another video and give once you're That meat care is important too. I I can remember those first couple deer we shot, it it turned me off from hunting because it tasted so foul. I thought, God wow, how you how you how do you even use this meat? And in hindsight, I looked at how we cared for that meat and I thought, Well, no wonder it tasted so bad. We did everything the opposite of what we should have done. So that's wonderful. I'm glad that you have that resource for people. You know, and I think if if a lot of us are are honest about it. We we all have lots of holes, even if you have been a gun around guns your whole life, there's so much knowledge to be had. Yeah. Yeah. So if the did you go to Ronspoomer Outdoors dot com. It's our website and they can find it on there. Check it out. Okay, so in those in that course, everybody's gonna ask you these two questions that just have to be asked. What's the best deer cartridge and what's the best elk cartridge? If you had to pick one for each, what would you say? Yeah, that's a great question. And of course the answer is variable. There is no one absolute best, but you really cannot fault a three eight Winchester, much as I make fun of them because everybody thinks it's so great. What what what am I hearing here, Ron? Ron's recommending the three eight Winchester? Start over, something's wrong here. We got a disconnection. Yeah, bad, bad. No, yeah, seriously. Think of the three eight and what it does. You you've got it. You you're covered. It's not the flattest shooting. It doesn't have the best wind bucking ability. People like to call it buck in the wind. I think that's a silly way to describe it, but wind deflection is not the best in the world of it. But it's good enough for anything and everything. You could say the thirty aught six. That's always been the standard. Like you can shoot three eight bullets and weights from a hundred grains up to two hundred and twenty grains. Well the three eight's the same, it's just shorter, less powder, so it's slower. So it's not the best, but it'll certainly do the job for you. And it's good enough for elk, good enough for deer, good enough for pretty much anything and everything. I personally wouldn't go there, as you probably guessed. I would say you could go to a 708 or a 270. I think a 270 is still the great option because it'll work just fine in the tighter cover back east for whitetail hunting, and it's outstanding for mule deer out west, and it's Big enough with a hundred fifty grain bullet especially to take elk and even moose and even big brown bears. So that's a really good option. Of course, these days with the new cartridges coming out, I would guess a lot of kids would say, Well, I'd rather get a six point eight Western as my two seventy. Same bullets, but a short fat case and all the latest features and hey, that's a great option too. You really can't fault the six five Creed more much as people like to, hate it. It really is the six five by fifty-five Swede that everybody loves is actually more powerful, shoots faster and flatter, less wind deflection, but people love to hate it because so many people think it's the the greatest thing ever. But it's a great little cartridge. Is the six five Creedmore an elk cartridge for you? You know, I haven't used it on elk, but my buddy does. He just shot a beautiful three eighty bull the other day. he got I helped him pack out a six by six about five years ago. He took it from four hundred and sixty yards with a hundred forty-three grain of hornady one shot kill. And that mean that thing the inside the chest when we opened it up, devastating performance. Really? Yeah, it can do it. Would I say it's my favorite? Would it just do the best? No. I always go for the three thirty-eight Winchester Magnum. And a lot of people are saying that cartridge is old and really doesn't do anything you need it to do anymore. The 300s will do it. And that's true. But there's just something about that 338 wind mag that puts you that one step above the 300 mags with that little bit bigger, heavier bullet. There's just something about it that's been proven over and over again to be an elk hammer. I've only ever used it once on an elk, but but it's just so popular and it's got such an excellent reputation. I would say that that's probably your best option for elk. But I wouldn't complain if you sh preferred a 300 Wind Mag or any of the 300 Magnums. 300 WSM, just as good. Now, you've seen so many changes in the industry over time, and particularly with cartridges. It feels like I maybe it was with the six five Creedmore, but there there kind of became this this point in history where every cartridge became a little bit shorter, a little bit fatter. We went to thirty five degree shoulders, tight chamber tolerances, and faster twist. And so that includes a whole class of cartridges from the six five Creed to the twenty-two creed to the twenty-five creed to the six five PRC to the seven PRC to the si to the six eight western to all of this new this new category of cartridges. So you seeing, you know, the the cartridge that they quote unquote replaced or c or came to improve upon from those to this in a practical sense, what is somebody really gonna see? What benefit did we really get from doing that? Is it something noticeable? Somebody that picks the six five PRC over a two seventy. what can they really anticipate expect to see the real significant gain is from those high B C bullets so the faster twist barrels on these new cartridges that allow you to shoot the longer, heavier More efficient bullets, aerodynamic efficiency. As you know, when you launch a bullet, boy, muzzle velocity, that's all we talked about in the twentieth century. We gotta get it faster, faster, faster. We never thought about the bloody bullet. That's what's doing all the work. It's flying down range. You can send it off at 2,000 feet per second or 3,000, but eventually that 3,000 foot per second bullet's gonna go 2,000 if he gets down there far enough. So if you want to help it maintain its velocity to keep going. You've got to improve its aerodynamic efficiency. So that's BC. Well, to do that, you have to have a long bullet, and to stabilize a long bullet, you have to have fast rifling twist. And that I think is the real advantage. It's not so much that the case has got a short, fat powder supply versus a longer, skinnier one. There's a little bit of benefit in efficiency and accuracy, perhaps, but not in a hunting situation. There's plenty of 30 aught sixes, you build it right, and you can get a half MOA 30 aught 6, but nobody thinks of the 306s being a particularly accurate cartridge. Cartridges aren't accurate, I maintain. Rifles are. You can build a more accurate cartridge of anyone as long as you pay attention to all of the little measurements, make sure everything's consistent. But whether it's a 308 or a 300 Magnum of some kind, i they've all got the basic ability to to be wonderfully accurate. Has it translated like when you see your average hunter with the with their rifle today, is it really more capable? The rifle is, but I'm not sure the hunter is. They would like to be, and they could be, but what you're going to gain, I don't think really starts to matter until probably 400 yards. The 270 will keep up with the 6.5 PRC to 400. After that, that slight advantage in BC you get with the 6'5 bullet is going to take over. But in my hunting career, all the hunting I've done, it's so seldom that I needed to shoot anything at 600 yards. I could probably count on one hand, if I really dug deep into the memory banks, the number of animals I've shot past 450 yards. There's probably not even five of those, which tells me at least that. A either I didn't get my game because I wasn't capable of shooting a six hundred yard shot, or I didn't need to take a six hundred yard shot because I could get closer. And that is what I remember about my hunting over these years is that I would fit find my game and just get close. And it wasn't very often that I couldn't get inside of four hundred, usually three hundred yards. So it to me it wouldn't make that much difference. But again, these days with folks living Apart from nature, it's difficult to get out of town, to get out into an area where you can hunt, public land most likely, unless you've got a lot of money to get on a private, and then you're gonna compete with everyone else for your shooting opportunity. And if you're on the mountainside after an exhausting climb and you see a buck out there that you want to stalk, but then you see some people over that might just interrupt everything and beat you to him and all that sort of stuff, you start to take these long shots. And I d y you've probably heard the story about a a young man a few years ago who did that and another young woman was doing the same thing and they were both taking shots too far away and they got into a who's is it, who hit it first, who hit it best, and there was all kinds of who wants to ruin your your annual hunt with a situation like that? Yeah. But I it it is very unfortunate. And the mountains, it it's interesting that there are far fewer hunters today in most states than there there used to be. You know, in in Utah about a quarter of the number of people are going into the woods each fall than when I was a kid. Things have changed dramatically. But the mountains still feel full when you get up there. I and in a lot of these general season hunts I it's it's fewer people but they're packing into tighter windows, one week hunts in some units And so it feels like World War Three more than ever. Whereas when I was a kid, you know, I'd go hunt up in just north of Boise in McCall, Idaho, and the way we'd hunt is you know, Friday night you'd get out of school, you'd go buy the what I think it was called the sportsman's package for a hundred dollars, and you'd get a mountain lion tag, a bear tag, a deer tag, an elk tag, and it was a hundred dollars, you'd get all of The hunting season dates were All the same, you could hunt all of those species pretty much if it's on four on four feet, you can kill it. and that's that's what the hunt hunt looked like. Not so much today. There are very, very few places that you can d that you can do something like that. See the thing that's I cannot figure this out, Jim. If there are fewer and fewer hunters and their populations of elk are kind of peaked now, they've they've come back to the Top number since the eighteen hundreds. why is it that it you can't draw a tag? I can't draw an elk tag. I can't draw yeah. It's like it's it seems like there's twice as many hunters in half the game. I d I don't understand it. I'm with you, and I have put significant effort into trying to understand it. And I I just have not felt like I've gotten straight answers on it. You know, why are there a quarter the number of hunters and then You know, you look at fish and game agencies in many different states that I've looked at their budgets from when I was a kid until today, adjusting for inflation, and it's still they're often spending four and five times the budget of what they used to, even adjusted for inflation, to manage a quarter of the number of hunters. It feels like we should have incredible hunting opportunity and it's just not there. Is it just the urban sprawl? Is it I don't know What is happening? But I don't feel like I've had straight answers that convince me on what the actual root cause of the problem is. See, I would go with the urban sprawl right away, I think, because I see it. It's like more houses. Where where's the game gonna live? The mountains. Okay. Well they come off the mountains for the winter and there's a housing dairy there. They're not gonna be f and they eat a few bushes around the houses and they're done, you know, then people want to chase them off. So but then again, they claim that there are fewer hunters, so even if you're losing habitat and you're losing game numbers, if you're half the hunters you used to have, wouldn't it be f kind of even at least? Or slightly an advantage? I don't know. my issues are I see the decline in habitat. You get up in the national forest and it's grazed. There you've got their cattle and sheep are running up in the mountains. And they have to compete. Elk, deer, everything has to compete with those cattle. Then the winter comes, they move the livestock down to the valley bottoms, and here come the elk and the deer, and they're competing with them again. Well, if you got a thousand cattle down there, you can't have a thousand elk. If there's enough forage there for the cattle or the sheep, you can't have that many deer and elk. So we're losing potential game numbers that way. I think we have to have a better balance of how much livestock gets to be in those places. But is that enough to make the difference? Because surely they were running huge numbers of livestock back thirty, forty years ago, a hundred years ago. And I started hunting in the sixties. and just prior to that, mule deer was in incredible. They mean the best mule deer hunting was in the forties, fifties, into the sixties. And by the late sixties it started to fall off. But it used to be you'd get two tags for two monster bucks and everybody was shooting big ones and they were everywhere. And back in those days there were cattle, poor management, overgrazing, and yet we had all these mule deer. And now it what's going on? Where's the mule deer? Mm-hmm. Yeah, I You're supposed to have the answer. I I wish I did. I I understand the you know, the many factors. I can certainly see the the loss of habitat in some areas and things and then I I go to some areas where I used to hunt and I hunt again and you know, it's still a wild place, but the animals just aren't quite there. And so I I dun I don't know. I don't know that I have have the answer. I I've asked a lot of people and I've certainly you know, I I think it's a nuanced answer, certainly. It depends on which particular spot we're talking about and things. But but when I zoom out and look at it as a whole I think, boy, why are we spending so much more with so many f fewer hunters and we can't get tags anymore? I I worry about hunting in the future because teenagers today are just do not have the culture of hunting even from when I was a teenager and I'm certainly a big step down in the culture from when you were a teenager. but y you know, my kids, I'm grateful I can take them on on lots of different hunts but It's also really difficult to leave school. We used to get a week off when it was the fall deer hunt. that's g that's all kind of gone away. So Yeah, yeah. No, d the culture is definitely a big, big issue. It's so much easier for kids to sit by the computer and play all these exciting games and get involved in sports with school and it's it's like my grandkids. I don't know that there's ever an hour in the day when they don't have some kind of a scheduled activity. They're either going to classes or they've got a soccer game or a piano recital is just one thing after another. Almost never is it we're taking the rifles or the boas out back and we're gonna shoot some cottontails. So that cultural aspect I think is is really getting short shrift these days. What does Garrett think about that? Well I don't know. I w well it's it's tough for me to kind of weigh in on this particular conversation just because I my family grew up hunting but I was never really big into it until four years ago. and so I haven't really seen the differences. It's kind of just what it is today is kind of how I've is how I've known it, you know? Yeah. And so I I hear the everyone else's perspective and you know how you know conservation. I mean it's crazy spending with conservation, you know, like Jim was saying, four or five times more than it used to be back when he was hunting. And It's crazy to me that that there's not increased opportunity even with the whole urban sprawl. because you would think with extra effort and less hunters there would be more opportunities, or at least the same. kind of like what you were saying. But yeah, it just seems like that's just not the case. Well, what you're missing, Garrett, is the history of conservation and hunting going back. And this even goes further back than I do, believe it or not. But around the turn of the nineteen hundreds, w that's when conservation really started to come on strong. And the result of that was for the next forty, fifty years we did all these nascent conservation practices, reintroducing game, preserving wetlands, trying to get habitat back at good quality, reducing the numbers of livestock on public lands, managing the forests a little bit better, ju various programs that they came up with that would improve habitat. understanding wildlife better, migrations, putting collars on them to study the wildlife and what they needed and did and all on and on and on it went. Did a great job because we went from, I think the population of pronghorn in the entire world was something like twenty thousand. And they got that back up to a million or two million, whatever, just huge numbers. Similar with elk. When I was a kid, an elk, my gosh, you got to go way back in the mountain wilderness to find an elk. Now they've got them practically running around our old farm in South Dakota, 40 miles away from our farm. So they've expanded beautifully and they had all these reintroductions. We're moving this animal here, turkeys. my gosh, turkeys all over. Snow geese. When I was a kid, you saw a snow goose and it was like, wow, look at that. And now it's like, geez, look at all these snow geese. There's too many of them. They're eating themselves out of house and home. You know, on and on it goes. But In the last ten years or so, I've started to see it slip back to the old way. Where we seem to be declining populations. When I was a in my twenties, I could go to Montana or Wyoming especially, walk in the store, give me a pronghorn tag, and go hunting. Well, now you gotta have two year preference points, maybe and get lucky, try to win a draw. Same with mule deer, elk, all the rest of it. It's just tougher and tougher. So I don't know what the answer is, but I wish. More young people or even middle aged people that really haven't paid that much attention to the history of conservation. How much work our predecessors put into getting the game up to the levels that we've been enjoying. I just really hit the jackpot, but started to come on when I was able to finally hunt, the game populations were up enough to make it easy for me. I could get eight deer tags in the state of South Dakota when I was in my twenties. There are still places that you can get tags much easier than where we live in Idaho and Utah. You know, go go to Tennessee, you can shoot a whole pile of does and a couple bucks during the year. Yeah. But not not so much out west. Yeah. If I could pinpoint a problem from my perspective, just from conversations I've had with people, I think I think conservation maybe puts too much effort into protecting animals that aren't suitable for its own environment that is currently living. Like for example, there's a pretty small population size of sheep in Utah. It's not that big. but they put so much effort into protecting them that, you know, if me and Jim have talked about this, like, what if, you know, Oddad were brought into Utah? They would thrive in Utah. It'd be the perfect environment for But they never would because it would cause diseases and it would kill off all the sheep. Tiny population of bighorn sheep, you know, around around Lake Powell and stuff. Tiny population of bighorn sheep, but we could have Thousands and thousands of people hunting odd ad ones. It would just it would increase. It's a tough it's a tough question. I I don't know what the right answers are there. You certainly don't want to lose those bighorn sheep. No. But it also does result in less hunting overall. I I think it's like, you know, there there's bighorn sheep in other places though. So maybe, you know, a relocation is maybe the answer. I don't know. I don't know what the answer would be, but I think part of the problem is is trying to preserve animals that maybe aren't even really suited for their own environment that they're currently in. just from conversations I've had with people. Yeah, I I hear what you're saying and it sounds reasonable. It's like w if audad do so well here, why don't we just bring in the audad? Right. I think we're looking at it from the purely from the hunter's perspective. We want a game animal we can go hunting. Yeah. Whereas the non-hunters who really have the same stake in this one, you know, wildlife in this country belongs to everybody equally, and you've got to manage for the resource first and then the using of that resource later. And odd at our foreign animal. They don't belong here. It's an invasive species. Yeah. And Texas is having issues with that. Ultimately, the best move would be to have ten times more bighorn sheep. But that's an extreme challenge because we've introduced domestic sheep. pneumonia and all these different diseases they've brought in. It's too late now. The cat's out of the bag. They've got this issue. How do we get our bighorn populations to improve with that kind of competition? So you've got to consider the grazing of the habitat, what's available for sheep. I think the biggest problem we have is that we we don't make the priority the native game. Elk, moose, sheep, pronghorn, you name it, they should get they need specific habitat on which to live. Livestock can make it on all sorts of alternate things. You you can have your cattle down on man-made grass fields that you've stripped the sagebrush off and you planted all the grass, sh they'll do fine. You can't feed mule deer on grass. They've got to have the Forbes that are out there or alfalfa or some other commercial crop like that. But then the farmer goes, Well, they're eating my alfalfa. I don't want them eating my alfalfa. If I'm trying to make a living growing alfalfa, I can't have four hundred deer out there eating on it. All of these issues come into play. So deciding how can we have more game to hunt, I think we really need to say, what do we do to maximize the population of our native wildlife without stepping on too many toes of people who are trying to make a living on the land? Yeah. I I I want more farmers and ranchers who are living with the land rather than converting it as something like housing or recreation complexes and all these things. It's gotta produce something. Right. And and the other part of sprawl that we don't think about very often is if you get another housing development with hundred ho new houses on it, you've lost that land to wildlife. But you've also then have more people living there and they've got to have water, they've got to have energy, they have to have food, so you're farming more areas, and then you're using water in the desert to grow the crops to feed the people who moved in, et cetera, et cetera. So it's more than just the people taking up space, it's their demand for natural resources that takes away from wildlife habitat. And as a young man, you've not seen how empty the West was. When I was a kid, you could come out west and it's just like, wow, it's the wild, wide open West. Right. And I'm sure a generation before me would have said, Wow, wow, wow, wow, it's the wide, wide, wide open West. It's always you come from a perspective of this is the way it's always been. When you come of age, it's like it must have been like this forever, right? No? Before you showed up, this was all one big wild covered up with pronghorn and an elk and mule dare. Yep. Garrett, you might want to read Lewis and Clark's journals or an abbreviated version of it. They got into South Dakota, about in the middle of the state near what's now Chamberlain. They crawled out of the valley of the Missouri River to get up on top to look around. I used to hunt this country. Beautiful, beautiful place. They got up on top and they described it as the American Serengeti. In one view, They saw mule deer, whitetail, pronghorn, and elk and bison. Five big game animals right out in front of them in one view in South Dakota. Wow That's what this country used to be like. That is awesome. And it's it's it's the conservation, it's a tough topic to to cover just because like at the at the same time of wanting to increase the hunting, you know, and the wildlife populations and all that and the hunting opportunities, like the human population is growing, right? And so there's gotta be places for people to live. And so how do you kind of walk that line? So it really is a tough conversation to have. But yeah, yeah, kind of going away from the c conservation, I I'm curious, like okay, s a younger guy like me, if if if you were if you met yourself at my age, you know, around twenty years old, you know, and you could take him hunting for one day, what would you teach him? gosh, Garrett That's a tough one. And then a very important question too. Yeah. Because that's the that is the big responsibility that we older hunters have is to teach young folks like you the most important lessons. And I think the critical one is s respect for the resource, respect for yourself, and respect for the hunting tradition. Mm-hmm. You ri and this is a difficult one I think for most people because We just want to get out and have fun. We want to get our game. We want to get the big buck. But we don't want to be going on like, this I'm on a spiritual quest and I'm gonna become the best person I can become and all that. But that really is at the core of what we're doing. It's so easy when you're younger to overlook that stuff. When you get a little older, you look back and say, you know, I was really a jerk that time that I went and shot that buck out from under my buddy, you know, I it it was really his, but I sh I shot 'cause I just wanted to get it before he did and little things like that. They add up. But if you can develop an attitude of I want to be the best person I can be so that other people respect me. At the same time, I want to respect the resource, the wildlife that I'm hunting, and honor them for what they are, what they have to put up with to survive, and then to appreciate all what we've got. Just think about how many people in this world don't get to get the guns that you do. don't get to go elk hunting, have never seen an elk, et cetera, et cetera. So you really need to be j respectful of it, but also thankful for the opportunities that we have. Because I think what your questions probably was hinting at was some useful hunting technique or tactic that I could maybe impart and help you to understand. You're like, always work the wind. As long as you don't have the wind behind you, you're gonna have your best chance. A little basic stuff like that. But the real heart of it is appreciating who you are, what you have, and how you're utilizing it. Mm-hmm. And I see too many old hunters as well as young who disrespect nature. You know, they'll say things like, I I'll see a a songbird and I'm a birder so I can identify it. That's a white throated sparrow. That's cool. And the guy's what? that's just a dicky bird. That's just a useless brown dickey bird. You know, the only good coyote's a dead coyote and crazy stuff like that. Come on, guys. This is the This is a world of nature that we love, and we should love it for what it is, and be grateful that we have the opportunity to be involved with it and get to shoot some of it, to eat it, and enjoy it that way too. I call it sustainable use. I think the only way we can continue to enjoy hunting and wildlife and have a wild planet is sustainable use of natural resources. Too many people think you take wildlife, you put it into a national park, put a fence around it, and that's your that's your wildlife. That's your park. The rest of it we're gonna turn into canals and racetracks and boating lakes and housing and shopping malls and ball fields and all the rest of this stuff. It's for people. You've got to live with the natural resource and that means you have to eat some of it. Yeah. You can't displace it all and say, We're just gonna eat cows and chickens. Right. Maybe a maybe a pig every once in a while. and then the wildlife will be fine. No it won't because those cows and chickens and pigs have to have the same food off the same land and if you just do devote all your land domestic crop production, you don't have wildlife. So there's gotta be this balance. And if we can utilize deer and elk and all the rest of it for some of our meat instead of us strictly using the domestics, we can sustain that population. Yeah, I I totally agree with you about the you know, the the most important part of, you know, when you're teaching people how to hunt and the the the whole experience, you know, about teaching them the you know, the spirituality side, you know? Bec I mean, the very first hunt I ever went on, I was really young and it's kind of what I wouldn't say put me off of hunting, but kind of led me sort of away from hunting. Just I was I love animals and love nature and stuff. The very first hunt I went on, I was eight or nine years old, something like that. my dad shot the deer, and I started crying because I was like, We just killed an animal, you know? Yeah. and it was sad. But he was the very first thing I I can ever remember at him like teaching me about hunting, it didn't have anything to do with a gun or, you know, cartridge or caliber selection or anything like that. It was, you know, respect the animal. When you shoot it, you know, the first thing we're gonna do is we're gonna go we're gonna go get it and we're gonna, you know, pray and thank God that we we got the animal and we got this harvest, you know, and we're gonna make sure we cut it up cleanly and all that kind of stuff. Make sure we get all the meat. And that's the first thing I can ever remember that about, you know, being taught about hunting was was that side of it. And I I do think that's the most important part because if you don't respect it then you have people hunting for sport and poaching and all this kind of stuff and it's just that that's just not good for for hunting or for the world as a whole. And so I totally agree with you that that's that's kind of the most important part. Yeah, excellent. Yeah. Well done. Well, thank you, Ron. That was It's great to have you. That's I've worked with Jim for several years, but that's my first time actually talking to you. So that was fun for me. Yeah. Pleasure to to meet you. I've seen you on some videos from time to time, but I've I think I bumped into you at one of the shows, a shot show or two. Yeah, shot show we've probably run into each other. But yeah. Well thank for coming on. Yeah, we need to get hunt going. I would like to have Yeah, that would be awesome. I yeah, that would yeah, I would not be hard to convince me of that. So I wouldn't I wouldn't even need to bring a rifle. Just to sit around the campfire and talk to about stuff like this would be really fun. huh. Yeah, that would be awesome. It would not be hard to convince me of that. So yeah. Cool. Well awesome. Thank you, Ron, for coming. And for all the backfire listeners, we will see you on the third, thirteenth, and twenty third of every month.