Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / AI Meets IP: Navigating Legal Minefields in the Age of Artificial Intelligence with Sky Moore
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everybody. My name is Keith Cooper. I
- 0:04am the secretary of the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 0:08Entertainment Law Section. And I am very pleased
- 0:12to introduce our speaker today. His name is Skye
- 0:14Moore. And that's short. That's his nickname,
- 0:18I guess. But Skye is a partner at Greenberg Lusker,
- 0:22LLP, and is a leading authority in entertainment,
- 0:25corporate, and tax law. He's represented a lot
- 0:28of major players in Hollywood financing and authored
- 0:31widely used including The Biz. He's recognized
- 0:35as a legal legend by The Hollywood Reporter and
- 0:39is consistently ranked among the most influential
- 0:42lawyers in media and entertainment. This is my
- 0:45kind of guy, so we welcome you to today's section
- 0:50meeting and take it away, Scott. Thank you so
- 0:53much. Thank you very much, Keith. And thank you
- 0:56all for everybody that's attending. I'm deeply
- 0:59honored to have... Anybody listen to me prattle
- 1:02on about AI? And there's a lot going on. So let's
- 1:07start with what AI can do. And I would summarize
- 1:11by saying AI could put on this very seminar with
- 1:15me as the speaker and with my voice and inflection
- 1:19and everything. They could do it. So probably
- 1:21within a year or two, I'll push a button and
- 1:24it will be. me doing this AI seminar. So AI can
- 1:28do, and it can do text. You can type in stuff
- 1:33and it will turn it into speech. You can type
- 1:36in stuff and it will turn it into video. It can
- 1:40do perfect music. It can replicate. It can create
- 1:43new music. And in time, and not in long time
- 1:47at all, it will be doing full feature length
- 1:51films from start to finish, including the script,
- 1:56the choreography, the characters. It will have
- 1:58AI actors. And it will be, and I'm sorry to say
- 2:02this to all the creative group out there, it
- 2:05will be as good as people can create because
- 2:08fundamentally we are neuron connections and computers
- 2:13have more neuron connections than we do. And
- 2:16so they will beat us. And all of this remarkable
- 2:22ability triggers just an avalanche of legal issues.
- 2:26It's a brand new world and so buckle up. The
- 2:33best part to be is be litigators because there's
- 2:35going to be so much litigation on this forever
- 2:39and I'll be touching on a lot of the issues.
- 2:44The one thing I do want to mention is AI submitted
- 2:48material is winning awards. when people aren't
- 2:52aware that it is AI -submitted material. That
- 2:54is how good it is. It's winning music awards,
- 2:56art awards, and short film awards. And then it's
- 3:00to the chagrin of the award -aurs that give it,
- 3:03that say, oh, my God, it was AI, and they want
- 3:05to revoke it. So that's how good it's gotten.
- 3:09And short film so far. Not yet the long film,
- 3:11but boy, that's coming. So lawsuits. And let's
- 3:15start with copyright, which is probably the biggest.
- 3:19First issue. Uploading. The AI is, what it's
- 3:23doing is it's sucking up everything in the world,
- 3:26and anybody who has any ownership of copyright
- 3:29to anything in the world is suing all the AI
- 3:32companies for that uploading itself. And they're
- 3:35claiming that that's copyright infringement,
- 3:38which it is, and the issue all boils down to
- 3:43fair use. Is that uploading, which is copying,
- 3:48And therefore it's on prima facie copyright infringement.
- 3:51Is it protected by fair use? And there's now
- 3:53been a slew of cases on this question. And fair
- 3:57use ultimately boils down to, do you think it's
- 4:01fair? And it's really a rule with your heart
- 4:04question. And the two competing arguments that's
- 4:07going on right now is you've got the... kind
- 4:11of the old Google versus the Association of Library
- 4:15authors that where the Second Circuit said it
- 4:18was Google was allowed to upload all the books
- 4:21because isn't this a wonderful thing and they're
- 4:23only going to show snippets and it advances humankind
- 4:26and it's just a wonderful thing. The counter
- 4:30side is really the Andy Warhol Supreme Court
- 4:35decision where fundamentally it said that copyright
- 4:40infringement is not fair use if the owner of
- 4:43the copyrighted material would expect to get
- 4:45paid for whatever was done with the work. And
- 4:49if you apply that analysis to what's going on,
- 4:53the answer is pretty obviously the people that
- 4:55create the copyright, who own the copyrighted
- 4:58material, expect to get paid because they're
- 5:01all suing to get paid. So it kind of answers
- 5:04the question. Now, where the cases come out?
- 5:06There's three important cases this year, 2025.
- 5:10You've got the Thomas Reuters versus Ross decision
- 5:12earlier this year that on pretty extreme facts
- 5:17held that uploading was not fair use. It was
- 5:20copyright infringement and all the copyright
- 5:22owners went, yay, yay, okay, we're gonna win.
- 5:25And then, unfortunately, this summer, two horrific
- 5:28cases came out that... held that it was fair
- 5:31use. And the first one was the Anthropic case.
- 5:34Second was the Meta case. And both of those cases
- 5:39held that the uploading was fair use. They fundamentally
- 5:43relied on this prior Google versus Library Association
- 5:47case. And they basically said, oh, isn't this
- 5:50a wonderful thing? We're advancing humankind,
- 5:54blah, blah, blah. And therefore, it's fair use.
- 5:59To me, the flaw with both of those decisions
- 6:02is they focused on the... One of the factors
- 6:07in fair use is the impact on the market. And
- 6:10both of those cases looked at the market as being
- 6:14the output side of AI. That is, what does the
- 6:17AI do with this material? Does it spit out books?
- 6:20Does it spit out music? Whatever it does, does
- 6:24that output compete with the uploaded material?
- 6:29To me, that is the wrong analysis that the uploading
- 6:33itself is the market. There is absolutely now
- 6:36a very vibrant commercial market for uploading.
- 6:42And that is the impact on the market, of course,
- 6:45is that the AI companies, by scooping up all
- 6:48this stuff, is bypass, is wiping out the market
- 6:52for uploading. And there's a pending case by
- 6:55the New York Times. They're very aware of this
- 6:56issue. 100 % focused on it. And I'm rooting for
- 7:00them that they will get the court to recognize
- 7:03that the market is the uploading. It's not the
- 7:07output. So let's all, for those that own copyright,
- 7:11let's root for the New York Times because they
- 7:14definitely are on to this question. There was
- 7:21a proposed settlement that a court rejected by
- 7:23Anthropic for $1 .4 billion that you'll see.
- 7:28And people are misinterpreting that as being
- 7:30that Anthropic was liable somehow for this uploading.
- 7:34That was a different issue. What Anthropic had
- 7:37done is they had sucked up all these books. They
- 7:41had saved to their library books that were stolen
- 7:45and that were online. billion for settlement
- 7:51is for a different aspect of that case. So right
- 7:54now that you have two horrific cases that uploading
- 7:56is fair use. I just want it not to be diverted
- 8:00by that anthropic settlement because that's really
- 8:02a different issue. What else on this topic? The
- 8:07Copyright Office issued a report that said that
- 8:11uploading might be infringement. And the day
- 8:16after they issued that report, the head of the
- 8:19Copyright Office was promptly fired. And no doubt
- 8:23that it was fired because Trump, and this may
- 8:25be the most important legal development of all,
- 8:27oddly, is Trump has now announced his position
- 8:30loudly and clearly that uploading should be allowed.
- 8:35And given the Supreme Court's predilection to
- 8:38go along with whatever Trump wants, I would not
- 8:41be surprised that based on where the trend is
- 8:44going, meta -anthropic, Trump's announcement
- 8:47that when this gets to the Supreme Court, I would
- 8:50not be surprised if the holding is that uploading
- 8:53is fair use. That is going to be my, that is
- 8:56my current vote. I was previously going to vote
- 8:58in favor that it would not be fair use based
- 9:01on the Andy Warhol case because I, to me the
- 9:03market is the uploading and that is clearly has
- 9:06an impact on, you know, stealing the books and
- 9:09the cop and the films and everything to me is
- 9:12absolutely destroying the market for the uploading.
- 9:15But So be it. So keep your eyes on what does
- 9:19the Supreme Court do? This will all obviously
- 9:21have to be resolved by the Supreme Court. Next,
- 9:27one thing to think about on this uploading question,
- 9:30which is to me fascinating, but no one's done.
- 9:33If I was an AI company and I was uploading, boy,
- 9:36I would be doing it out in the middle of the
- 9:38Atlantic, or I would be doing it in Zimbabwe,
- 9:40or someplace where there's not copyright infringement.
- 9:43enforcement because the copying is a jurisdictional
- 9:47issue and it depends on where the copying occurs.
- 9:51There was an interesting UK case where they brought
- 9:54a copyright infringement case in the UK, but
- 9:56the AI company said, I didn't do it in the UK
- 9:59and the UK had to throw out that aspect of the
- 10:01case because it depends where the copying occurs.
- 10:05It's interesting that AI companies have not focused
- 10:08on that and been a little smarter on where they
- 10:11do the uploading. Now, it brings us to the output
- 10:16side. Now the AI sucked up everything in the
- 10:18world, and now it starts spitting out stuff.
- 10:21And everybody's suing over that as well. So anybody
- 10:24who got uploaded is now suing on the output side.
- 10:28And this is a different issue. The first step,
- 10:34one of the claims is, hey, you uploaded my stuff,
- 10:38so I must be in that output somewhere. I must
- 10:41be in there somewhere. And therefore, that output
- 10:44is copyright infringement. Those claims are all
- 10:47losing as they should because all art is based
- 10:53on prior art. And even when anybody is a musician
- 10:57or an artist, they are impacted by what they
- 10:59previously saw, read, heard. And so to some extent,
- 11:03what they previously saw, read, heard is reflected
- 11:05in what they do. So that the I'm in there somewhere
- 11:08claim is losing. The claim that is winning is,
- 11:12wait a minute, that is too similar to my work.
- 11:15And this is a classic copyright claim, and it's
- 11:19a two -step analysis. The first step is, is it
- 11:22a derivative work? And that is, as with fair
- 11:27use, it's a rule with your heart question. You
- 11:29look at the old, you look at the new, and you
- 11:31say to yourself, are they too similar? And if
- 11:34you think they're too similar, then you go, ah,
- 11:36it's a derivative work. It's based upon the original.
- 11:38It's substantially similar. You put a bunch of
- 11:40words on the opinion, and you rule that it's
- 11:43a derivative work. If you think they're far enough
- 11:45apart, then you say, oh, it's not derivative.
- 11:48It's not based upon. It's not substantially similar.
- 11:50You put a lot of words in the opinion, and you
- 11:52come to the opposite conclusion. Once you have
- 11:56a derivative work, your next question is, OK.
- 12:02who did it. And this is an interesting one, because
- 12:06the AI companies are often saying, we didn't
- 12:10do it, our customers did it. All we are is, we're
- 12:15just a service and our customers came and did
- 12:17all this stuff. And, oh, by the way, if you have
- 12:21a lawsuit, go sue the customers. And then, oh,
- 12:26by the way, if they post it back on our service,
- 12:28which like, let's take... which is what's happening,
- 12:33then the claim is, oh, we're protected by the
- 12:40Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Send us a takedown
- 12:43notice, and we'll take it down. But we aren't
- 12:46liable. This is the safe harbor under the DMCA,
- 12:50and so you can't go after us. Where this is coming
- 12:55up in spades is the Disney, Universal, and Warner
- 12:59now suing Mid -Journey. And Mid -Journey is precisely
- 13:04what's happening. You know, Mid -Journey's uploading
- 13:09everything. Customers are downloading. They're
- 13:11creating all the same images using the uploaded
- 13:14stuff. Then they're posting it on Mid -Journey.
- 13:16And Mid -Journey no doubt is going to say, hey,
- 13:19we didn't do it. And oh, by the way, just send
- 13:21us a takedown notice. The counter to that, and
- 13:26where I think this is going to go, is the argument
- 13:30between Betamax, the old Betamax case, and Grokster
- 13:35and Napster on the other side. And the question
- 13:37will ultimately be, was there intentional promotion
- 13:41of infringement? And my god, if Mid -Journey
- 13:44did not intentionally promote infringement, nobody
- 13:48did. I'm betting against Mid Journey on this
- 13:51one. They are no question that they are intentionally,
- 13:56with malice aforethought, encouraging people
- 13:59to rip off copyrighted material from all the
- 14:03studios and create their own Star Wars, you know,
- 14:07Batman, whatever, and now post it up on Mid Journey.
- 14:10So to me, this is just a slam dunk against Mid
- 14:12Journey under Napster versus in Grokster theory.
- 14:17But interestingly, It's not a copyright. It's
- 14:22not a direct copyright infringement. It's more
- 14:24like a aiding and abetting and encouragement.
- 14:31Step three in this analysis, OK, so now you've
- 14:33got it is a derivative work, and whoever it is
- 14:37is liable for it. And then the question is fair
- 14:39use. And fair use, back again, is rule with your
- 14:43heart. Do you think it's fair? The one important
- 14:49change in the analysis here is Andy Warhol case.
- 14:53It used to be the case that transformative was
- 15:00a defense under fair use for copyright. And transformative
- 15:04was interpreted as you did something creative
- 15:07with the original work. You morphed it. You changed
- 15:10it. You colorized it. And that was the Andy Warhol
- 15:13case. And the Supreme Court said, nah. That's
- 15:16not what we mean by transformative. So whether
- 15:19you modify it or transform it or do something,
- 15:21that is not transformative. And that's, to me,
- 15:25this is very important. So AI can't rely on the
- 15:28fact that it changed the original work in some
- 15:31way and say, aha, that's transformative. In most
- 15:37cases, if you get past these two things, you've
- 15:40got a derivative work and you've got the right
- 15:43defendant. I don't think that fair use will apply,
- 15:47because you now clearly have a derivative work
- 15:50that looks like the original or close enough
- 15:53that it's a derivative work. And I think that's
- 15:56going to be liability. Footnote for everybody.
- 16:02I should have said this earlier. I will take
- 16:04questions at the end. I should have said this
- 16:07earlier. My apologies. If you write out the questions,
- 16:11I'm going to take questions at the end. till
- 16:13the cows come home, please make them short. I
- 16:17would like them to be like not more than a sentence
- 16:19or two, three lines or less, and so that I can
- 16:23catch up with them. And then we'll do all questions
- 16:27at the end. And my apologies for not saying that
- 16:29earlier. Onward. The copyright office in that
- 16:37report that I mentioned earlier also said that
- 16:40the output could be infringing and might not
- 16:44be protected by fair use. But once again, the
- 16:49person that wrote that report was fired the next
- 16:51day. But I really think the objection was the
- 16:56uploading, not the output. I would be surprised
- 16:58if anybody, even Trump, thought that it was fair
- 17:02to just go and rip off and do Star Wars imitations
- 17:05and Batman imitations. I would be very surprised
- 17:09if that was with the intent. Next big issue,
- 17:15and this is a very big issue with copyright,
- 17:17is that AI -created material itself is not protected
- 17:22by copyright. And this was the issue. The Copyright
- 17:27Office has said it loud and clear. The cases
- 17:30have all supported that. I don't see any change
- 17:33in that. I don't think that's going to change
- 17:35on appeal or anywhere else, but people are still
- 17:38fighting it. But what that means is that if you
- 17:42can't protect it under copyright, that because
- 17:44of copyright preemption, it means that you can't
- 17:47protect it under state law either, and therefore
- 17:50you can't protect it at all. You can't do a takedown
- 17:53notice if it pops up on YouTube, because takedown
- 17:56notice only applies for copyrighted material.
- 18:00And so you have no protection. Footnote is that
- 18:06You may have read Disney just fired an animator
- 18:10that was using AI for their animation. And I'm
- 18:14going to guess that it was for two reasons. One
- 18:17of which is that animation that is created by
- 18:20AI cannot be protected by copyright. And so Disney
- 18:23would lose the copyright to, would just not be
- 18:26able to protect any animation that is created
- 18:29by AI. So that's a very obvious reason for not
- 18:33using AI to create particularly animation. So
- 18:41now, what do you do if you can't protect it?
- 18:46People are pushing the boundaries of this in
- 18:49all different ways. Some people are saying, I
- 18:54told the computer what to do. My prompt was so
- 18:56creative that you've got to protect my prompt.
- 19:00And therefore, whatever the computer did was
- 19:02a derivative work of my brilliant prompt. Some
- 19:05people are saying, you know, look, it's like
- 19:08Photoshop, and I did some, I amended, I modified
- 19:11the output, or I told it to do some changes.
- 19:15And you're really, there'll be a lot of litigation
- 19:18on the boundaries between if you did something
- 19:21after, if you did something before, what's it
- 19:24take? But clearly, My analysis is whatever the
- 19:29human did is protected, but whatever additional
- 19:31elements that the AI created is just not protected.
- 19:35And so you can parse it out. If the humans did
- 19:39some part of it, you're going to have to parse
- 19:41it out. And in fact, when you go to the copyright
- 19:43office, you are supposed to identify the parts
- 19:46that are created by AI and the parts that were
- 19:48created by a human, which brings me to the great
- 19:51defense that I am sure that most of the people
- 19:53are going to use, which is the great I forgot
- 19:56defense. And I guarantee you, I promise you that
- 20:00everybody is going to go register their work
- 20:01in the copyright office, and they are going to
- 20:04forget that it was created by AI. And they're
- 20:08just going to register it as the author and gun
- 20:11it. And good luck for other people trying to
- 20:15figure out if it was or was not created by AI,
- 20:19because it's not. easy to tell, and it's getting
- 20:22harder and harder to tell. And so that is obviously
- 20:27what people are going to do just as a practical
- 20:29matter. What are the legal solutions? Putting
- 20:33aside the I forgot defense, what solutions can
- 20:37you adopt if you're a studio, whatever you're
- 20:40doing that's using AI to protect the work? I
- 20:44give two suggestions to my clients. Suggestion
- 20:48one is have a human with flesh and blood write
- 20:51the original treatment and go record that in
- 20:55the copyright office. And that becomes the basis
- 20:59for your copyright claim. And then you can have
- 21:01the script written by AI and the film written
- 21:04by AI. And everything that follows from that,
- 21:08as long as it's based upon that original treatment,
- 21:11will be a derivative work of the treatment that
- 21:13can be separately protected. at least as to the
- 21:17fundamental story. You won't be able to protect
- 21:21the AI -created visual elements or additional
- 21:24elements, but nobody will be able to take that
- 21:27film that results and go and just copy it and
- 21:30run with it, because it will be a derivative
- 21:33work based on the treatment, and you'll be able
- 21:34to sue on that. So that's plan one for how to
- 21:39solve the problem. Plan two is you let the AI
- 21:43do everything, just have at it. And at the end,
- 21:47have some human go through and do stuff to the
- 21:50final visuals, colorization, add a few special
- 21:53effects, personally have somebody do it. And
- 21:57then bury enough in it that there are copyright
- 22:01elements that if somebody goes and tries to rip
- 22:03it off, you'll be able to point to like fingerprints
- 22:06on it, like what they do with Google on a map.
- 22:08There'll be some. fingerprints that you can point
- 22:11to and say, aha, those are human -created copyright
- 22:13elements, and you stole it. So those are the
- 22:20two suggestions that I've got beyond the I forgot
- 22:24defense. Now, let's look at the Disney, Universal,
- 22:30and Warner versus Mid Journey. Let's put all
- 22:32this in context now. So where did Mid Journey
- 22:38do the copying? Interestingly, I haven't seen
- 22:42anything that said it. But if they were smart,
- 22:44they would have done it outside the US. And the
- 22:46first defense they would have said is no jurisdiction
- 22:49in the US because I copied it outside the US.
- 22:51I haven't seen. I don't know if they've even
- 22:53filed an answer yet, but that would be a fun
- 22:57answer. The second answer you know is coming
- 23:01is, hey, this is fair use. Go read Anthropic
- 23:05and Meta. And all we did is upload all this stuff.
- 23:08And so the uploading, you can't tag us. And that's
- 23:14bad. That may be, under current law, based on
- 23:17Anthropic and Meta, the uploading itself may
- 23:20not be alone. How about the downloading? Well,
- 23:24you know there clearly were derivative works.
- 23:26You've got Star Wars. You've got Batman. You've
- 23:28got everybody. It's, you know, they're identical.
- 23:30There's no question that it's a derivative work.
- 23:33But, but Anthropics, sorry, Metta's defense.
- 23:37Mid -Journey's defense is going to be, we didn't
- 23:39do it. Our customers did it. And, oh, they posted
- 23:43it on our website. Oh, too bad. You know, DMCA
- 23:47send us a takedown notice and we'll take it down.
- 23:49That'll obviously be their defense. And, and
- 23:54the studio is not going to sue the customers
- 23:56for infringement. And so that's what Mid Journey
- 24:01is obviously hoping is they won't sue the customers.
- 24:04They can't sue us because all they can do is
- 24:08send a takedown notice. And where I think they
- 24:11get nailed again is the Grokster versus Napster.
- 24:15And I read the Disney and Universal complaint,
- 24:19and they clearly are all over it, which is this
- 24:21was intentional. encouragement, for infringement,
- 24:25if there wasn't, I mean, if there's ever a case
- 24:27for aiding and abetting, and beyond aiding and
- 24:29abetting. I mean, this is absolutely, this is
- 24:33it. So again, I'm going to hope that that is
- 24:38the outcome on that. Warning, warning, warning
- 24:43to people that use AI services. You've got to
- 24:46read the terms of use because on some of them,
- 24:50including Mid Journey, if you upload stuff that
- 24:53you own, the terms of use say that it effectively
- 24:58becomes public domain. It effectively says that
- 25:01Mid Journey owns it. Whatever you upload, like
- 25:05if you say, oh, here's Disney, I can intentionally
- 25:09upload it, Mickey Mouse, they'll never do this,
- 25:12but to Mid Journey, and said, please make the
- 25:15ears yellow. boom, under the mid -journey terms
- 25:18of use, Mid -Journey now owns Mickey Mouse, and
- 25:23they can give it to any other customers and let
- 25:25anybody use it. So you've got to be... And this
- 25:28may be another reason that Disney fired that
- 25:30animator. God knows what the animator uploaded
- 25:32or what... I don't know what AI service they
- 25:34used, but heaven forbid they used Mid -Journey.
- 25:38And a lot of the AI services, some of them have
- 25:41very good terms of use, some of them don't. You've
- 25:43got to read the terms of use. before you upload
- 25:46anything to AI. Warning, warning. Done with copyright.
- 25:54Let's move on to trademark. Okay, just as a general,
- 25:59first I'm gonna just give a general background
- 26:02of trademark before we do the AI implications.
- 26:06Trademark is aimed, it's different than copyright.
- 26:09It is aimed at consumer confusion as to the source
- 26:12of the goods. As long as there's no consumer
- 26:15confusion as to the source of the goods, you
- 26:17can use trademark. So if you're watching a film
- 26:19and you see a car, a Mercedes drive by with the
- 26:23Mercedes emblem, or you see McDonald's golden
- 26:26arches, that is not trademark infringement because
- 26:29a reasonable consumer would not think that McDonald's
- 26:32or Mercedes produced that film. And so there's
- 26:36a, you know, people sue over this all the time
- 26:38and they lose all the time. You know, Pepperdine
- 26:42just sued over this. sued Netflix over the waves
- 26:46trademark, but it was clearly not being used
- 26:49to identify the source of the goods. So you get
- 26:52this all the time. Now, which brings us to AI.
- 26:56My favorite one on this is that stable diffusion
- 27:00uploaded all the Getty images, claiming that
- 27:06it was fair use, of course, and then spit out
- 27:10photos that were not did not look like the Getty
- 27:13photos, but with humor from the legal side, the
- 27:20photo said Getty images on the output. And so
- 27:25a reasonable person looking at that photo saying
- 27:28Getty Images, even though it wasn't an original
- 27:30Getty image, would think Getty Images created
- 27:33that. And Getty immediately sued for trademark
- 27:36infringement. And they're right. So they didn't
- 27:38have to sue for copyright. Forget the uploading.
- 27:41Forget the output. This is just a trademark claim.
- 27:44What are you doing using our trademark to identify
- 27:47your goods? You can imagine that if I did a film
- 27:50and I said, please put presented by Disney, Or
- 27:56if the AI just happened to spit out, it thought
- 27:59it was a wonderful idea. Boy, the film would
- 28:01be much better received if it says presented
- 28:03by Disney. You can imagine Disney being a bit
- 28:07annoyed on the trademark side and with good cause.
- 28:11So AI can cause trademark infringement. Or you
- 28:20can imagine, I tell it. You can also, I mean,
- 28:23you can imagine, please make a film called Galaxy
- 28:26Wars. And Galaxy Wars, you know, and the question
- 28:31is, is that a trademark infringement for Star
- 28:34Wars? And again, the litigators can have fun
- 28:37arguing it. Where this is going to get really
- 28:42fun is AI -curated actors. And AI -curated actors
- 28:48are already there in the social media space.
- 28:52There are influencers that are completely created
- 28:55by AI, and they are having a wonderful time living
- 28:58the life of the rich and famous. They've got
- 29:01cars and pools and everybody. And they actually
- 29:03have hundreds of thousands of followers. And
- 29:06the people that are creating those AI -created
- 29:09influencers are making a bucket of money every
- 29:12month using that image. Now, given that it's
- 29:18created by AI, you can't protect it by copyright.
- 29:23So how do you protect your, and this is what's
- 29:26going to happen with the studios, I guarantee
- 29:27it, is they're going to have AI -created actors
- 29:29that will star in film after film, and they might
- 29:33even have their own off -screen quote persona,
- 29:37because people buy it. Like, go figure. Public
- 29:42buys it. And so how will the studios and how
- 29:48do the influencers protect these characters.
- 29:53And the only way you can protect it is with trademark.
- 29:55And so what I have suggested is you use an AI
- 30:01character that doesn't look like anybody obvious.
- 30:04You make the image very distinctive. You identify
- 30:08the image with the source of a particular good.
- 30:12So for example, you put the actor's name. in
- 30:16the front of where the film is presented by.
- 30:20And you have the actor's name and their image.
- 30:23And you use it in multiple films and you file
- 30:27a trademark registration using it and you put
- 30:31it in ads and you protect it with trademark.
- 30:34And that's what I think is going to happen, because
- 30:36you won't be able to protect it with copyright.
- 30:39So I think that that's the way that people are
- 30:42going to be able to do it. Next, big fight, right
- 30:48of publicity. All right, so this is where AI
- 30:52gets really fun. Pardon me. Okay, summary of
- 31:01right of publicity before we get into the AI
- 31:03elements is that you have a prima facie claim
- 31:08any time anybody uses somebody's voice. name
- 31:14or image for any purpose. That's kind of a prima
- 31:18facie case. And then you have a bunch of defenses
- 31:20that apply. And the problem right now is that
- 31:26it is a state -by -state question of the defenses.
- 31:29There's no federal right of publicity. And the
- 31:32states are all over the board. Some states base
- 31:37jurisdiction and choice of law based on where
- 31:41the exploitation occurred. Some states look to
- 31:44the residence of the plaintiff. And so point
- 31:49of exploitation versus residence is a big split.
- 31:52And then some states have different defenses.
- 31:55Some states say all expressive works are protected.
- 32:00Some states say only transformative works are
- 32:04protected. And when they use the word transformative,
- 32:07they are using the prior, the pre -Andy Warhol
- 32:11copyright. description of transformative, you've
- 32:14modified it in some way. Like this is the California
- 32:17case of the Winter Brothers that were turned
- 32:19into half worms and was held to be protected
- 32:22because they were transformed, even though it
- 32:24was obviously the Winter Brothers. And my hope
- 32:27is that the Andy Warhol decision bleeds into
- 32:31the right of publicity and stops that kind of
- 32:33analysis. But some states apply that. Some states
- 32:37say, well, if the work is protected by copyright,
- 32:40then copyright preempts a right of publicity
- 32:42claim. I think that is nuts, but a lot of cases
- 32:45are doing that. And then some states, like California,
- 32:51allow the protection to apply to the estates
- 32:55of celebrities so that estates can enforce it.
- 32:58Importantly, California as of 2025 passed legislation
- 33:03that closed up a loophole that permits the use
- 33:08of deceased celebrities for an entertainment
- 33:12or dramatic work. And that got closed off from,
- 33:16at least as to digital replicas, is no longer
- 33:20allowed starting in 2025. So you can't use the
- 33:24deceased celebrity as a digital replica in an
- 33:28entertainment or dramatic work. Also starting
- 33:31in 2025, California purported to not permit people
- 33:38to waive their right of publicity in a contract
- 33:43to permit third parties to create digital replicas
- 33:48of the person. So an actor can't, under California
- 33:51law, can't sign a contract that says, go have
- 33:55at it and use my image to making digital replicas.
- 33:59Those contracts, in theory, are no longer valid
- 34:02as a violation of public policy. However, they
- 34:06are riddled with exceptions that this supposed
- 34:12prohibition is so easy to get around. So if you
- 34:16run into this, it doesn't apply to SAG actors
- 34:19because they're separately protected, which we'll
- 34:21talk about later. It doesn't apply if the person
- 34:25was represented by a lawyer. It doesn't apply
- 34:29if the use of the image is done to do something
- 34:36that the individual would not otherwise do, which
- 34:40is pretty simple to me. Or if they give a reasonably
- 34:44specific description of what it is they're going
- 34:47to do, I'm going to turn you into a dinosaur,
- 34:50whatever they're going to do, all you have to
- 34:52do is say it. So this alleged prohibition is
- 34:56kind of riddled with exceptions. Now, what do
- 35:02you do with an AI service that allows consumers
- 35:09to upload an image of a person and convert that
- 35:14person into another picture, a film, a something.
- 35:20And this is what AI companies easily let people
- 35:23do. And the AI companies are saying, hey, I didn't
- 35:30do it. I just work here. Somebody else, they
- 35:33uploaded a picture, and often there's a terms
- 35:35of use that says you have to supposedly check
- 35:38a box that says that you have authority to use
- 35:39this person's picture, which everybody checks
- 35:42the box, but nobody has authority. So what do
- 35:46you do in this situation? Or the voice. This
- 35:48is also coming up. We have clients whose voices
- 35:51are being used by a text to speech companies,
- 35:55and they are, you know, and we're... their customers
- 36:00are clearly infringing the voice of our celebrity
- 36:02clients. So what do you do? I think this is a
- 36:05Betamax versus Grokster and Napster case. I think,
- 36:09again, that if the service is intentionally encouraging
- 36:14the use of kind of infringement of people's right
- 36:19of publicity, that just like you could bring
- 36:21a copyright claim, you should be able to bring
- 36:24a right of publicity claim. You're aiding and
- 36:25abetting the tort of of violation of the person's
- 36:30right of publicity, and you can sue them. This
- 36:34is going to be a hot issue going forward. And
- 36:39we have clients where this is a significant issue.
- 36:44What do you do if the service allows you to put
- 36:47the resulting picture up on their site? And there's
- 36:54a picture of your celebrity up on the site of
- 36:56Mid Journey or whatever it is. And you can't
- 37:00do a takedown because the takedown procedures
- 37:03and that safe harbor only applies to copyright.
- 37:07It doesn't apply to write a publicity. And there's
- 37:10a circuit split as to whether the services are
- 37:13protected by Section 230 of the Communications
- 37:17Decency Act. And the Ninth Circuit says that
- 37:21they are protected by Section 230. And the Third
- 37:26Circuit says that they're not. So right now you
- 37:28have a split. If a service is violating somebody's
- 37:35right of publicity, whether or not you can sue
- 37:37them or whether they have this Section 230 protection.
- 37:44More fun on right of publicity. In June, New
- 37:49York passed legislation that required any advertisement
- 37:54that uses a digital image, what they call a synthetic
- 37:57performer, someone created by AI, has to disclose
- 38:01that fact on the advertisement. It has to say,
- 38:05this ad includes somebody that is a synthetic
- 38:07performer. And unless it's an ad for a film that
- 38:16that person appears in, basically. So that synthetic
- 38:20performer performs in. Federal legislation. There
- 38:24is a crying need for federal legislation on this
- 38:28issue. It is absolute. You've got copyright,
- 38:31trademark, patent. Right of publicity is an enormously
- 38:35valuable intellectual property right. Why isn't
- 38:38there a federal legislation? Well, There kind
- 38:42of is, and there kind of isn't. They actually
- 38:45managed to pass an act earlier this year called
- 38:48the Take It Down Act, which would have been the
- 38:52perfect vehicle to really lock up a federal legislation
- 38:56on right publicity. Unfortunately, it was limited
- 38:59to nude pictures. So either it was aimed at the
- 39:06Taylor Swift situation. So either you've digitally
- 39:09created somebody to look like they're a nude,
- 39:12or it's revenge pornography, one of the two.
- 39:17But unfortunately, it was limited just to nudes.
- 39:20And there was a second act that is pending that
- 39:23is called the No Fakes Act that is a broad right
- 39:27of publicity statute. It's being pushed by the
- 39:30guilds. It's pushed by celebrities. And unfortunately,
- 39:35it is going nowhere fast. So that act has been
- 39:38pending for a couple of years, and I don't see
- 39:41it passing, unfortunately. I think they did the
- 39:45take it down act, and then patted themselves
- 39:47on the back, and then moved on. Next. Defamation.
- 39:58I love this, because I predicted the outcome
- 40:01of this, and the outcome happened. Summary of
- 40:07defamation, general rule is you're not allowed
- 40:12to say false, defamatory facts about somebody
- 40:15that gives rise to potential liability. If they
- 40:19are a public figure or it is a matter of public
- 40:22interest, then there's this actual malice standard,
- 40:28which has nothing to do with malice and it's
- 40:32a rather ridiculous term. The standard is whether
- 40:38the person saying it had an honest belief as
- 40:43to the truth of the whatever they said. As long
- 40:48as the person saying if you're dealing with a
- 40:51public figure or you're dealing with a matter
- 40:53of public interest, as long as the person saying
- 40:57the defamatory thing believed it, honestly believed
- 40:59it, that is a defense. to, I'm going to quote
- 41:03the Supreme Court on this one, there also has
- 41:06to be is that the defendant actually, the only
- 41:09way you can find liability is if the defendant,
- 41:11quote, actually had a high degree of awareness
- 41:15of probable falsity. So earlier this year, CHAT
- 41:20GPT was sued, or OpenAI was sued, by something
- 41:26CHAT GPT said, which was defamatory, of a public
- 41:29figure. And the court said two critically important
- 41:33things. One is, it said, a computer can't have
- 41:37actual malice because a computer doesn't have
- 41:41any intention. And therefore, under that standard,
- 41:49an AI company cannot defame a public celebrity
- 41:56or a matter of public interest because, or it
- 42:00won't be held liable for it because it has no
- 42:03intention at all. It's just rambling hallucination.
- 42:09The second thing it said, which was even worse,
- 42:12is that reasonable people should know that chat
- 42:17GBT hallucinates. And therefore, you can't trust
- 42:21anything it says, and therefore, It's not defamatory
- 42:26because no reasonable person should believe it.
- 42:30Now that means that you can't, what that does
- 42:33is a per se defense for all AI companies for
- 42:38defamation, whether it's a public figure or not.
- 42:42Public figures can't sue because AI service doesn't
- 42:48have intent and non -public figures can't sue
- 42:52because everyone should know that whatever it
- 42:55says nasty, no one should believe. Now, what's
- 42:59ridiculous about that is people absolutely believe
- 43:03what ChatGBT says. And if there was ever any
- 43:06better proof of it, it is that every single day,
- 43:10lawyers are including what ChatGBT says in their
- 43:14briefs, most of which is wrong. And they're getting
- 43:18sanctioned for it, which I'll talk about later.
- 43:20But people clearly believe what AI companies
- 43:24say. They ask it all. I get clients sending me
- 43:27stuff all the time. Hey, ChatGBT said this, and
- 43:30ChatBT said that. Are you kidding me? But they
- 43:34believe it. So defamation. Can't sue them. Next,
- 43:43another claim. False advertising or unfair business
- 43:48practice. So. Where this is coming up is, we
- 43:55had an associate in our firm that actually brought
- 43:57this all the way up to the California Supreme
- 43:59Court. They sued Sony for releasing a record
- 44:03that was supposedly sung by Michael Jackson,
- 44:08and they released it after his death. They said
- 44:10it was Michael Jackson pre -death recorded tracks.
- 44:14It was not true. They had created it using AI,
- 44:18and digital. They'd actually created it using
- 44:20digital techniques equivalent of AI. That was
- 44:25held to be an unfair business practice. And so
- 44:29that is with us. You can always think of a claim
- 44:34when you see an AI created something. And we'll
- 44:37talk about some examples. Was there misrepresentation
- 44:43as to the source and the original of what this
- 44:46is? Because if they're passing it off as being
- 44:51true and real, and it's not, it was created by
- 44:54AI, then there's potential liability. Okay, let's
- 44:59now you're at your studio, and somebody has given
- 45:03you a script, a movie, a something, something,
- 45:07and they say, and it's wonderful, please buy
- 45:10it. What do you do? How do you know that it wasn't
- 45:15created by AI? And what are your remedies? So
- 45:20the practical attempted solution is that there
- 45:26is now AI detecting software that you can run
- 45:31the whatever through, the film, the script, the
- 45:33whatever, that supposedly will tell you if it's
- 45:35created by AI. But it's an arms race. And I will
- 45:40tell you that AI is winning this race and that
- 45:43the detection software is losing. because AI
- 45:46is getting better and better, and it's getting
- 45:47harder and harder to detect. Second thing you
- 45:50can do if you're a studio is obviously get reps
- 45:53and warranties. And you really care about this
- 45:57because the AI elements are not protected. So
- 46:00if that film was created by AI and anybody can
- 46:06take it, you're in trouble. You're in deep trouble.
- 46:09Now, this is no doubt why Disney fired the animator.
- 46:13that was using AI because that whatever is created
- 46:16wouldn't be protected. And even the protected
- 46:23elements, like even if that person ran those
- 46:29protected elements through an AI service that
- 46:33had bad terms of use, terms of service, like
- 46:37mid -journey. then even the protected elements
- 46:41may now become effectively public domain. So
- 46:45how do you protect? I mean, the answer is, I
- 46:48don't know how you protect yourself. AI detecting
- 46:52software doesn't really work. What, indemnity
- 46:54from a penniless producer? You better have a
- 46:59deep pocket that you can sue because the studio's
- 47:04really are at risk unless they create it from
- 47:07scratch and know every step of the way, and nobody
- 47:10was dumb enough to run it through an AI machine.
- 47:15Okay. If you do have a claim, you have a whether
- 47:19or whether, right, a publicity, defamation, unfair
- 47:22prison, who do you sue? Who do you sue? Do you
- 47:27sue the consumer, which is in most cases who's
- 47:30doing it? Do you sue the owner of the content
- 47:36in many cases, you can imagine a studio picking
- 47:40up something that was created that they didn't
- 47:44know that was a violation of something. Or do
- 47:47you sue the service that created it, the open
- 47:50AIs of the world, the stable diffusions? And
- 47:54so there's a lot of litigation on who is liable
- 47:58for whatever the claim is. And then you're going
- 48:01to have all the defenses, whether it's the Safe
- 48:05Harbor takedown notice, or is it the Section
- 48:08230? So for the litigators out there, you're
- 48:12going to have a party. Absolutely a party. Guild
- 48:17issues. Buckle up, boys, because next year, it's
- 48:22going to be chaos as the guild agreements all
- 48:24come due, because they expire next year. And
- 48:29it's going to get wild. It's already got wild
- 48:33in the last one. If you think it was wild the
- 48:35last one, it's going to get wilder. Here's where
- 48:36it stands right now. The DGA kicked the can down
- 48:41the road for three years, and their agreement
- 48:46says that the studios cannot use AI to replace
- 48:51someone that was a DGA member. So that effectively
- 48:53stops studios that are signatures to the DGA.
- 48:58from using AI to create a film because, of course,
- 49:01that would replace a DGA member. But they have
- 49:07affiliates and they do negative pickups and they
- 49:09do all kinds of things where they can side with
- 49:12that. The WGA got a provision that said AI -created
- 49:18material is not... does not count as literary
- 49:23material for purposes of compensation and credit.
- 49:25That was widely misinterpreted as that studios
- 49:28couldn't use AI to create literary material.
- 49:30That is not correct. Studios can use AI, but
- 49:36whoever touches it, any WGA member that touches
- 49:40it becomes the deemed author of it for compensation
- 49:42and credit. So if they have AI create a screenplay,
- 49:47and they ask a writer to do a few polish, to
- 49:49do a quick polish, that WGA member will become
- 49:54the author of the screenplay for purposes of
- 49:57compensation and credit. The real question will
- 50:00be, what happens if the studios just bypass writers
- 50:03completely and have AI create it from ground
- 50:06zero? They obviously won't do that because The
- 50:14screenplay won't be protected by copyright. But
- 50:17what they might do is have a non -WGA writer
- 50:20write a treatment, pick it up from somebody that's
- 50:27not WGA, or have an affiliate that's not WGA,
- 50:30and then have AI take it from there. And that's,
- 50:34I think, going to be part of the discussion next
- 50:36year as to what the WGA does about that. SAG.
- 50:44has SAG got protection for their members that
- 50:49basically requires very extensive contract provisions,
- 50:57has to be clear and conspicuous, has to be signed
- 50:59in a separate writing, has a very clear description
- 51:02of what's used, of what the intended use was.
- 51:05And if they use the actor's physical participation
- 51:08at all, they have to pay them residuals. Actors
- 51:13are like, why not? If I was an actor, I'd say,
- 51:16fine, use my image, but as long as you pay me.
- 51:20The real question will be synthetic performers.
- 51:23And one of the questions will be whether SAG
- 51:26has any jurisdiction over the use of synthetic,
- 51:30completely made up performers by AI. And will
- 51:33SAG have any jurisdiction on that at all? And
- 51:38in the agreement, it says, that if the studios
- 51:42create a synthetic performer, that they have
- 51:47to give notice to SAG and an opportunity to bargain
- 51:51in good faith over, quote, appropriate consideration,
- 51:54if any. Now, I guarantee you the studios are
- 51:58going to say the appropriate consideration is
- 52:00zero because SAG has no jurisdiction over special
- 52:05effects, which they will treat this as. And so
- 52:08that will be a fun issue if litigated, and it
- 52:11will be a more fun issue when this comes up next
- 52:14year, because it's getting closer and closer
- 52:16to the studios doing exactly this. As just a
- 52:22warning shot across the bow, SAG brought charges
- 52:27against Fortnite earlier this year for using
- 52:31Darth Vader's voice with permission of the estate.
- 52:37The person that did his voice, they got the permission
- 52:40of the estate, but SAG said, you failed to bargain
- 52:43in good faith to use guild members to do this.
- 52:49And shortly after that, they settled and entered
- 52:52into a new agreement for video games. But SAG
- 52:56has laid down at least where it plans to go with
- 52:59this. If people are going to use synthetic performers,
- 53:02they're going to say that's a failure to bargain
- 53:04in good faith and it's an unfair labor practice.
- 53:12Let's look at a lot of this now. One of the early
- 53:18ones that came out on this was Heart on My Sleeve
- 53:22by Drake and Weekend. It came out a couple of
- 53:25years ago. It was what really started the flurry
- 53:29of attention to this. Just for the fun of it,
- 53:32let's go down the analysis. Let's look at copyright.
- 53:37all the issues we've discussed, trademark right
- 53:39of publicity. So copyright. The song itself had
- 53:45no copyright protection because it was created
- 53:48by AI, so anybody could copy it and use it. There
- 53:54would have been no takedown right of Universal
- 53:57to take it down, other than the happy fact for
- 54:00Universal that there was a short clip of a Universal
- 54:04song that they could use to flag and take it
- 54:07down as a copyright. There just happened to be
- 54:10one clip. But for that clip, they would not have
- 54:13been able to do that. How about copyright infringement
- 54:18based on existing songs? Was it too close to
- 54:22an existing song? And I don't think it was. I
- 54:24think that, yes, the genre and the general feeling
- 54:29was, yeah, you understood that it was Drake and
- 54:32Weekend, but it wasn't so similar to an existing
- 54:34song that you would say, hey, that was a derivative
- 54:37work of an existing song, and therefore copyright
- 54:39infringement. How about trademark? You clearly
- 54:42saw the name of Drake and Weekend, but there
- 54:45was a disclaimer that said it was created by
- 54:48AI, and therefore that would have defeated a
- 54:52reasonable consumer's belief as to the source
- 54:55of the goods. And so I don't think that there
- 54:57was trademark infringement because of that disclaimer.
- 55:02Similarly, I don't think that there was false
- 55:06advertising or an unfair business practice because,
- 55:10again, they said it was created by AI, and that
- 55:13should have been sufficient a disclaimer to avoid
- 55:15a claim on that basis. What about Drake and Weekend
- 55:20saying, hey, you're violating my right of publicity?
- 55:23And I frankly think, yeah, I think it was. It
- 55:27had their names. It was clearly their style.
- 55:32And now you get to the state law problem. Where
- 55:35do you sue? Are you suing a point of exploitation,
- 55:38or are you suing based on residence? And now
- 55:41let's look at the defenses. Some courts say,
- 55:43hey, that's an expressive work, and therefore
- 55:45it's protected. You can't sue. No, you can't
- 55:47bring a right of publicity claim against an expressive
- 55:49work. God bless the First Amendment for some
- 55:51reason. Or some cases would say, hey, that's
- 55:54transformative. The very fact that it wasn't
- 55:58actually Drake and Weekend was therefore it was
- 56:01a mutation of them, and therefore it's transformative.
- 56:05Note, again, this is no longer a defense for
- 56:07copyright, because under Andy Warhol, that is
- 56:09no longer a valid defense in copyright. But for
- 56:12right of publicity, it still exists. How about
- 56:16you suing YouTube? Can they sue YouTube for violating
- 56:20their right of publicity? And this goes to what
- 56:22circuit you sue in. Because does YouTube have
- 56:28section 230 protection of the communication?
- 56:31Decency Act. And the Ninth Circuit would say,
- 56:34yes, that that is protected. And in the Third
- 56:37Circuit, they would say, yeah, you can sue. So
- 56:39it really is a function of where you sue. And
- 56:47last, but not least on AI is a warning to all
- 56:51my lawyer friends out there. Three years ago,
- 56:56there was a case that a lawyer got nailed for
- 56:58using AI in a brief. And I thought, oh, boy,
- 57:01that was ridiculous. And it did fake citations.
- 57:07And the guy didn't check. And I thought, well,
- 57:09that'll never happen again. Everyone's obviously
- 57:11read that article. And then it started happening
- 57:14every month. And then it started happening every
- 57:17week. And now it happens every day. And in fact,
- 57:22a judge got popped for it. So it is so unbelievable
- 57:26that people who are using this And relying on
- 57:31it, which shows that they believe it, by the
- 57:33way, for if you get back to the defamation thing.
- 57:36And it's just phenomenal that people are relying
- 57:41so heavily on this. And it literally is every
- 57:45day. So please don't rely on AI. Check what it
- 57:48says. I look at it all the time. I use it for
- 57:51research and stuff. But you have to check every
- 57:53single time because half the time it's wrong.
- 57:55It gets you close. Sometimes it gives you a good
- 57:58citation that you can go read, but you just can't
- 58:00rely on it. And now the promotional part of the
- 58:05program. If you want to be added to my newsletter,
- 58:11I send out a newsletter every month, just pop
- 58:13me an email with the word add at the top. My
- 58:16email is smore, M -O -O -R -E, at ggfirm .com.
- 58:22That's really easy, smore at ggfirm .com. And
- 58:28I will add you to my newsletter list I send out
- 58:30every month. And if I have an entire course on
- 58:34YouTube that I used to teach at UCLA. I taught
- 58:37at UCLA Law School for many years. And I taught
- 58:40at USC. I taught at the business school at UCLA.
- 58:44And I recorded the course, basically, and put
- 58:47it on YouTube. So if you search Sky Moore Attorney
- 58:50altogether, Sky Moore Attorney, you will find
- 58:53my course on YouTube. And I have a bunch of articles
- 58:58on Forbes that you can read any time. And I have
- 59:04a, hold on, a book that is called The Biz. And
- 59:09I've lost, I think I've lost you. Am I still
- 59:12there? Sorry, I think I - No, you're still here.
- 59:14Okay. And so I want, what I want to do is hold
- 59:17on one second with, I want to pull up with luck.
- 59:21a copy of The Biz. And if you don't have, is
- 59:24that on my screen? Yes. And if you don't have
- 59:28it, you should get this. It's a great overview
- 59:30of the industry. It's in its sixth edition. It's
- 59:32a very popular book. A lot of people have it,
- 59:35and I strongly recommend that it's on Amazon.
- 59:39And it's just a good over, and everything we've
- 59:40talked about today is in there, plus a lot more.
- 59:44And with that, I am standing by to take any questions
- 59:48if you would be so kind as to read them. and
- 59:52I would be glad to stay as long as people want
- 59:54and I can bore people to death answering questions.
- 59:58Great. What is your interpretation of transformative
- 1:00:01post -war hall? My interpretation in copyright
- 1:00:06is that it is transformative means you have to
- 1:00:09be using it for a very different purpose. It's
- 1:00:11not just changing it in some little way. You
- 1:00:14have to be using something from like for education.
- 1:00:19or for news that that is quote transformative
- 1:00:22it's the different use not different modification
- 1:00:26all right let's see um has the 2025 california
- 1:00:33laws read digital replica has been challenged
- 1:00:35on our first amendment basis no not yet not yet
- 1:00:40all right and What if an artist will slash trust
- 1:00:45allows the estate or heirs to create post -mortem
- 1:00:48digital replicas and license them to make movies?
- 1:00:51Say that again. Sorry, say it again. So what
- 1:00:54if an artist will slash trust allows the estate
- 1:00:58to create post -mortem digital replicas and license
- 1:01:01them to make movies? Yeah, that should be allowed.
- 1:01:04That should be enforceable. Yeah. Right, let's
- 1:01:08see, what else do we have here? And as you stated,
- 1:01:12all human art is derivative in some form of prior
- 1:01:14work. So how is Mid Journey's inspiration illegally
- 1:01:17derivative? Because it is an identical copy of
- 1:01:22the original. You know, it's Star Wars, it's
- 1:01:25the Star Troopers, it's Batman. This is not some
- 1:01:28different version. They are doing absolute identical
- 1:01:31replicas of original copyrighted works. It is
- 1:01:34not even close to being, you know, something
- 1:01:38else. All right, let's see. So regarding the
- 1:01:48need for federal legislation to unify on rate
- 1:01:50of publicity, do you think there's a greater
- 1:01:52chance that federal law would remove all restrictions
- 1:01:55on AI? No, no way. It will remove all restrictions
- 1:02:02on AI. Well, I hear the question because that
- 1:02:06was proposed in the recent big, beautiful bill
- 1:02:09that got dropped out. I don't think that'll happen.
- 1:02:12There was too much flack against it. So no, short
- 1:02:15answer is I don't think that will happen. All
- 1:02:18right. Let's see what we have here. Let's see.
- 1:02:30Can you give more examples? regarding trademarks
- 1:02:34in AI? It'll all come down, trademarking in AI,
- 1:02:39it'll all come down to consumer confusion as
- 1:02:40the source of the good. So it is, again, I love
- 1:02:44the Getty images showing up in the stable diffusion
- 1:02:46photographs. Again, if I did a film that said
- 1:02:52presented by Disney, it'll all come down to that.
- 1:02:56So AI is not capable of avoiding the problem,
- 1:02:59that's for sure. and so they may walk into it,
- 1:03:02you know, headlong. Is the Andy Warhol SCOTUS
- 1:03:11ruling really broader than that particular type
- 1:03:13of infringement or more towards really visual
- 1:03:19works with near identical new works? I think
- 1:03:24Andy Warhol completely changed the analysis of
- 1:03:26fair use. I think it changed it to the question
- 1:03:28of Does the owner of the original copyrighted
- 1:03:32work expect to get paid for whatever was done
- 1:03:35with their work? I believe that is the new test.
- 1:03:38And that is why I think that this uploading should
- 1:03:41be infringement because the market is the uploading
- 1:03:44and to do it for free is clearly just trampling
- 1:03:48on the expectation of payment of the copyright
- 1:03:51owners, as you can see, because they're all suing.
- 1:03:53So I'm shocked at the meta and anthropic decision.
- 1:03:57I'm shocked at it. All right, so is the grounds
- 1:04:02of protection for AB 1836 that the decedent be
- 1:04:05domiciled in California at the time of death
- 1:04:07be a resident in California or that no company
- 1:04:10can engage in the use of digital? California
- 1:04:12is based on domicile at the time of death. All
- 1:04:16right, let's see what else we have. Yeah, they're
- 1:04:21a residence test and California applies a residence
- 1:04:24including domicile at the time of death. Okay,
- 1:04:28and another question. Just to be clear, as of
- 1:04:302025 in California, an expressive film utilizing
- 1:04:33replicas of James Dean or Marilyn Monroe is prohibited
- 1:04:36without a license from the estate. If it's a
- 1:04:44digital replica, it is prohibited without, unless
- 1:04:48the time, I forget how long the period is, but
- 1:04:50unless that time is expired, it is prohibited
- 1:04:53if it's a digital replica. By the way, they could
- 1:04:56use an actress that looks like Marilyn Monroe,
- 1:04:59though, and still get away with it without using
- 1:05:02a digital replica. Great. I believe that about
- 1:05:08wraps up Q &A. OK. So we're done. And I'm deeply
- 1:05:12honored to have everybody who attended today.
- 1:05:14And thank you very much. And you'll get CLE credit
- 1:05:17for this. Thank you.