Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 6 – Jed and Andy Are Fragile Vessels
Transcript
- 0:00Jed: Hey Andy.
- 0:01Andy: Hey Jed.
- 0:02How are you?
- 0:03Jed: I'm doing terrific.
- 0:04How are things?
- 0:05Andy: They're good.
- 0:05They're good.
- 0:06We're easing into summer.
- 0:07I think we've like relaxed our dress code it looks like a little
- 0:09bit because it is summertime.
- 0:12Jed: I like it.
- 0:13Well we sure have a lot of stuff to tackle.
- 0:16There's so many things that are going on, but I suppose we remind people what the
- 0:20heck WonkyFolk is and who we are and, you want to take a swing at it to get started?
- 0:27Andy: Well, yeah, you're listening to the Wonky Folk podcast.
- 0:29That's me, Andy Rotherham.
- 0:32I'm a co-founder and partner at Bellwether and Jed, who is an education
- 0:36consultant, led the California Charter Schools Association for a long time,
- 0:39long time leader in our space and was a school operator himself, when
- 0:44I first got to know him down in San Diego and we generally it's us.
- 0:49We had our first guest last week.
- 0:51We had Macke Raymond from CREDO on to talk about the new CREDO charter study
- 0:55and that data and that body of work.
- 0:57And so we'll have some guests in the future too, we are going to
- 1:00make that sort of a regular thing.
- 1:05Jed: Good intro.
- 1:06I like all that.
- 1:07Andy: Decidedly amateur because we are amateur podcasters.
- 1:11We're not yet professionals.
- 1:13Jed: And we're excited to know about some of the guests that may come on here
- 1:15shortly, so that, that'll all be fun.
- 1:17But hey, let me just get started because right as we go to
- 1:20recording, we have this announcement coming out of the Supreme Court.
- 1:24I didn't foresee this happening and here it is happening literally an hour
- 1:29ago or two hours ago, where the Supreme Court announced that they are not
- 1:33going to take up the Peltier charter school skirt case in North Carolina.
- 1:39This is a very big deal.
- 1:41I've been writing about it at CharterFolk.
- 1:42I know you're aware of the case, generally, Andy.
- 1:46But I wanted to just dive into, and I also, I've done some
- 1:49texts with some lawyers on this case already, I'm not a lawyer.
- 1:54Within a week, or even a few days, there will be a lot of
- 1:57lawyers with deep analysis of the implications of this decision.
- 2:04Andy: So the issue was this dress code lawsuit and whether or not it
- 2:09turned on whether or not charters are going to be considered under the law,
- 2:12public schools or private schools.
- 2:13But why don't you talk about the implications and what it means,
- 2:16like what does it even mean right now that they passed on this?
- 2:19So what is the law existing law going to look like?
- 2:23Jed: Yeah, so there was a charter school day in North Carolina that was making
- 2:29the argument that their dress code requiring boys to dress in a certain
- 2:34way and girls to dress in another way, specifically to wear skirts, was something
- 2:38that they were in empowered to enforce because they were not state actors.
- 2:44And so the United States Constitution protections for public school students
- 2:49did not apply to a charter school and the school was very upfront about
- 2:54its arguments along these lines.
- 2:56They said that the reason that they wanted girls to wear skirts is because
- 3:00they believe that girls are quote unquote "fragile vessels" and they want
- 3:05to teach the boys that they needed to protect the girls along these lines.
- 3:09Andy: You don't need the Supreme Court for this.
- 3:11They could spend a couple hours with my girls and I could debate some of the
- 3:14idea that girls are fragile vessels.
- 3:16There's no reason to bring in our well-traveled Supreme Court into this.
- 3:21Jed: So there was a court in North Carolina that made a decision that
- 3:25had a lot of people alarmed, which was that the charter school would be in
- 3:31fact able to use its dress code arguing that the United States Supreme Court
- 3:38protections don't apply to the school.
- 3:41The school then a appealed up to the, I'm sorry.
- 3:47The authorizer then appealed up to the appellate level.
- 3:51And the appellate level, thankfully found that in fact the United States
- 3:56Constitution does apply to this school and you cannot discriminate
- 4:01against the girls on that basis.
- 4:03So what happened is the school decided to seek an appeal from the United
- 4:08States Supreme Court, and so many people were worried that the United States
- 4:12Supreme Court might take this case.
- 4:15And if they took it and deemed that charter schools are not state actors
- 4:20and thus don't have the constitutional protections applicable to them, it could
- 4:25have rippled through and had damaging effect across the entire charter school
- 4:28movement because it could have undermined decades of jurisprudence about what
- 4:35a charter school is and nevermind the political repercussions in all these
- 4:39different contexts when people would learn that charter schools would supposedly have
- 4:43some ability to discriminate against kids.
- 4:45So today we learned that the United States...
- 4:47Andy: yeah, it seems like it would've been a gift to charter critics, right?
- 4:49They would've been incredible talking.
- 4:51Jed: It would've been horrible for us.
- 4:52And so for the United States Supreme Court to say: "No,
- 4:55we're not touching that case".
- 4:57For purposes of whether or not charter schools are state actors
- 5:00and whether or not the United States Constitution protections are applicable
- 5:03to their students and to their employees, they're staying out of it.
- 5:06So this is a very big decision.
- 5:08It's both good as in terms of relief in the short term, but it also has
- 5:13some implications for potentially religious charter schools that are
- 5:17decisions that are coming down the pike.
- 5:19Andy: Yeah.
- 5:19Is there any reason to believe maybe that in Supreme Court jurisprudence,
- 5:23they call it a clean vehicle, so a case with like really a clean fact pattern
- 5:28so it can be a very clear kind of precedent, they like clean vehicles.
- 5:33Is there any chance they passed on this one just because it's not a clean vehicle
- 5:36and we're going to see a different case come along and this all the concern about
- 5:40this will start right back up again?
- 5:42Jed: I've heard some religious scholar and lawyers argue, we shouldn't have
- 5:49brought a case that had the term fragile vessel in it, isn't there a
- 5:53better one that we could have brought?
- 5:55But I don't know, I'm not the legal mind here, I don't know if there's a different
- 5:58angle you can now take to charter schools not being state actors, it seems
- 6:03fairly definitive what's happened right now, but clearly we're in a time when
- 6:09religious freedom advocates and lawyers are looking at the charter school space
- 6:14as an opportunity to advance things and we'll see if they continue to do so.
- 6:18But if I can just throw in the additional implication here.
- 6:21We have this religious charter school that's been approved in Oklahoma and
- 6:24it's now being conducted in court.
- 6:26And it seems as though if the United States Supreme Court says that charter
- 6:30schools are in fact state actors for purposes of the applicability of the
- 6:34United States Constitution and they cannot discriminate against kids on
- 6:38various bases, it's going to be very difficult for religious charter schools
- 6:42to remain in the space or to be able to operate as they might otherwise as a
- 6:46private school and again, we would see that to be a very positive development.
- 6:51I don't think anybody in our world should be counting chickens or thinking that
- 6:54this is dispositive, but it's a very good day for charter schools right now.
- 6:58Andy: But it seems like kind of confused, I mean, I'm watching like,
- 7:01so Peter Doshi, who used to be a democratic member of Congress, he's
- 7:05opening religious charter schools now.
- 7:07And I think there's a tendency to see this as we see lots of things
- 7:12to sort of a left right or liberal conservative kind of valence.
- 7:16And it seems like it's actually more the politics on the ground are a
- 7:20little bit more confused and unsettled.
- 7:22And so like something you said just a second ago, so I think we
- 7:25haven't seen the last of this.
- 7:26It seems like we're having a set of conversations.
- 7:29We'll talk more about some of them later, I think, on other issues where we're
- 7:32sort of figuring out new definitions and redefining boundaries for things.
- 7:37Jed: Yeah, there are things that I tend to be one to defend or support
- 7:41the idea that charter schools should be given a great deal, more latitude, a
- 7:44great more freedom and all that stuff.
- 7:46There are certain things, Andy, that are just beyond where I think we can
- 7:50go and the idea that US Constitution protections, kids could be kicked out
- 7:55for some identity they may have or sort of some belief that they may have
- 7:59or certain employees may no longer be able to work there, their beliefs.
- 8:03This is just a bridge way, way, way too far.
- 8:07Andy: It seems like it erases what is public about charters and in some
- 8:12important ways, not only politically, but just substantively in terms
- 8:16of the experience of what happens in to people in inside a charter.
- 8:20So it certainly seems important that way.
- 8:23Jed: What do you think about these other cases that the Supreme Court
- 8:25is just about ready to act upon?
- 8:28What about affirmative action?
- 8:29What about some of the other implications of these recent decisions?
- 8:32Andy: Yeah, I mean, look, the affirmative action case is going to
- 8:35be interesting, and I do think we'll actually have an a, a sort of tangential
- 8:38impact on charters and impact on K-12.
- 8:42Look, we're recording this in the beginning of the week and we're
- 8:45expecting a decision on that any day and so this, what I'm about
- 8:47to say may not age well, right.?
- 8:50But, like, it seems like the court just given that they wanted to take
- 8:56the case in the first place, the composition of the court, it seems like
- 9:00the smart money is that they're going to strike down affirmative action.
- 9:03And so again, everything I'm about to say may be irrelevant
- 9:07if something peculiar happens.
- 9:08But that seems like the smart money bet.
- 9:11A couple of things, It's going to reinvigorate a debate in K-12 about,
- 9:18okay what kinds of things are going to affect depending how they write
- 9:22it, it could actually impact certain K-12 admissions schemes and so forth.
- 9:27Second, what's the role?
- 9:28I mean, we do always do have to remember when we're talking about affirmative
- 9:31action at the higher Ed level.
- 9:32We're talking to some extent about redressing problems that
- 9:36we could have dealt with in K-12.
- 9:38So when you have these fights, whether it's eighth grade for high school
- 9:41spots or at the end of high school for college spots, and the pipelines
- 9:45aren't robust like we would want them to be, you have to ask why, and a
- 9:48lot of that comes back down to K-12.
- 9:50And then third, and I think this will be the unpleasant aspect of it.
- 9:54Like, it's going to be just be really toxic, I think, and the interesting thing
- 10:00about this one, I will say, this will be a chance to, to sort of, for people.
- 10:04There is nuance here.
- 10:06I mean, you live in a state where affirmative action was on the ballot.
- 10:08It was defeated quite handily.
- 10:10There's not support for it in public opinion, so whether or not you agree
- 10:14with what the court if assuming the court strikes it down, whether or
- 10:17not you agree with it, this is not like a counter majoritarian ruling.
- 10:21There are things the court does that kind of go against majority opinion.
- 10:25We've sort of seen the fallout of that with the Dobbs with the abortion case.
- 10:28This one is not, people, people sort of value diversity.
- 10:33They think it's a really important value.
- 10:34You ask 'em that.
- 10:35They say yes, but then when you ask them specifically about using
- 10:39race and admissions, they're not real comfortable with it.
- 10:41When you ask them specifically about affirmative action programs,
- 10:44they're not real comfortable with it.
- 10:45And then every time it's on the ballot, lately it, it is struggled, particularly
- 10:49again in California of all places.
- 10:52And if there's any good news there, it's that maybe when the dust settles,
- 10:56we can have a conversation about, okay, if you really do care about diversity
- 11:01in higher education and you care about higher education as being an engine of
- 11:05social mobility, which when you look at some of these schools, it's hard
- 11:08to argue that it is, that it's not just sort of reinforcing, you know,
- 11:12existing class and social structures.
- 11:16So if we actually believe it should play a more disruptive role in ensuring social
- 11:21mobility, a level playing field, that will start to have a new conversation on, okay,
- 11:25"what other kinds of remedies can you do there that would pass Constitutional
- 11:28muster and still achieve those goals?"
- 11:30And that could actually be a really fruitful conversation.
- 11:33And again, with a big role for k12.
- 11:36But I worry that a lot of people are going to just feed this into this narrative that
- 11:40everything the court does is illegitimate.
- 11:43Which it doesn't even make sense because you know, just last week they handed
- 11:47down a really important ruling on rights for Native Americans, and I didn't hear
- 11:51anybody saying that was illegitimate.
- 11:52People, the only illegitimate rulings are the ones that, that you don't like.
- 11:57But hopefully we won't just get caught up in that vortex so we can
- 12:00instead be like, "okay, what now?
- 12:02And what does this look like?"
- 12:06Jed: Well, I think it'll be a very big decision if they decide that
- 12:10private entities aren't able to do this, and I'm really interested in
- 12:14what the ripple through effect will be on perhaps organizations that they
- 12:18weren't first thinking about, "What does this mean for HBCUs?", for example?
- 12:22What does it mean for other schools that have been set up specifically
- 12:25to compensate for the fact that historically we haven't had the
- 12:28same number of kids in,college from various races and backgrounds?
- 12:33Um, are they no longer gonna be able to do these things?
- 12:35But I also feel like the California Prop 29 experience is probably a wise one for
- 12:42us to stay focused on, because if you look at what happened right after Prop 29, it
- 12:48was startling the number of the drop in the number of African-American and Latino
- 12:52students in California public schools and the UC system was really sobering.
- 12:59And I think I remember seeing that at the UCLA law school, it might
- 13:04have dropped to just a couple of black students being admitted.
- 13:08And then the schools started to look at different criteria, not race
- 13:13specific, but experience specific.
- 13:16And it was really around had these applicants shown resiliency, had they
- 13:22overcome this kind of thing or that kind of experience or whatever it may be.
- 13:26And we've seen a rebound in the number of African-American and Latino students
- 13:30that are being admitted to UCs.
- 13:32I don't think it's achieved parity or gotten back to the point where
- 13:35it was before Prop 29 came along, but it's also proven to be something
- 13:41that was addressable via other means.
- 13:44And it's very possible that we would see private schools do some
- 13:48something similar if in fact the Supreme Court decides in this way.
- 13:52Andy: Yeah, I mean, well there's two plausible scenarios there.
- 13:55One is that they just evade it because it will be very hard.
- 13:58You can just say, "Okay, we're not going to use objective measures anymore."
- 14:01Like there's a way like college admissions are opaque and so there's
- 14:05a way that opaqueness that this.
- 14:07So one scenario is this ruling actually has less impact than
- 14:10people think because the schools just kind of go do other stuff.
- 14:13And like the real loser in the case is like the college board and you
- 14:16know, it becomes like, cause people are just like, yeah so we're not going
- 14:19to have any measure that can be used to compare students who're just going
- 14:23to make these decisions as one-offs.
- 14:25Yeah, that's that.
- 14:26And then there'll be litigation if you see sort of disparate impact, but it'll
- 14:29be very, that'll be very hard to prove.
- 14:31And then the other scenario though is kind of what you're talking,
- 14:33again, this could be a moment, let's separate the sheep from the goats.
- 14:36You've got of people saying they care about diversity in higher ed, they
- 14:39just don't like affirmative action.
- 14:41We're going to be able to put that to the test.
- 14:44"Okay.
- 14:45How do we continue to, in a meaningful way, ensure that you do have,
- 14:49have really meaningful diversity in higher ed these schools?"
- 14:52Like how do you bring people together and that like again, will separate the
- 14:55sheep from the goats, the people who are just they were saying that because
- 14:58they were going after affirmative action and then the people who
- 15:00really actually do care about that.
- 15:02Obviously in our sector, a really noteworthy person that would be like a
- 15:05Rick Kahlenberg who, you know, Rick has written books about this, he's a huge
- 15:10proponent of economic, affirmative action.
- 15:13He's a huge proponent of economic . He and I have actually butted heads
- 15:17on that cause I think he oversells what's possible with that in, in K-12.
- 15:21But he's got a very principled position on this, and in fact, he
- 15:25testified for the plaintiffs in the case, and it like cost him dearly, but
- 15:29he just thinks economic is the way.
- 15:31And I feel like we can start to, whether you agree with him on that
- 15:34or not, if we can start to have conversations about other remedies and
- 15:38other things that, you know, and then you figure out who's actually going
- 15:41to show up for those conversations.
- 15:42And again, like, I think I got someone like Rick, like he shows up for that.
- 15:45He cares deeply about diversity.
- 15:48He also cares deeply about like effective policy wouldn't
- 15:51his view as effective policy.
- 15:54Jed: Well, one of the things that's important to keep in mind as you point
- 15:59out, is what has been the experience of kids in the K 12 system such that
- 16:03they're perhaps not able to gain admission without the use of affirmative action.
- 16:11And what does it do to improve the K-12 system?
- 16:13I want to go to the science of Reading thing.
- 16:19Are there any other Supreme Court cases you wanted to highlight?
- 16:23Andy: No, I mean, yeah, one other set of cases that are coming that aren't
- 16:27here yet we should talk about just, but what you just said is so important.
- 16:30We treat talented minority kids as a scarce commodity and we treat really
- 16:37good schools as a scarce commodity and it leads to these really, really
- 16:41screwed up politics like it when everybody's fighting over seats at
- 16:46one really competitive school, you have to ask, why don't we have more?
- 16:48And obviously charters are one way you can have enabling legislation states.
- 16:52There's other stuff you can do, but it's said, it turns into this Holy War
- 16:54over who gets to go and you see this is the story of San Francisco, Boston, New
- 16:59York, Northern Virginia, and it's crazy.
- 17:03And no other system where you're like, "oh, this thing's really popular, let's
- 17:05make sure we don't have more of it."
- 17:07And then we treat the pipeline the same way that these kids are, like
- 17:11this scarce, rare thing rather than why don't we have more of them?
- 17:14And what are the things we need to do to create more?
- 17:16Which is, you know, there's a whole set of policy things there and
- 17:20structure things in terms of schools.
- 17:22And so it's sort of, the debate is kind of infuriating and then leads to
- 17:26these really toxic politics, but the other cases you wanted to talk about.
- 17:30Yeah.
- 17:30Jed: Well, I mean, let me just throw in on the scarcity thing
- 17:32because I agree with you.
- 17:33I think that scarcity, especially around education supply,
- 17:37should be our collective enemy.
- 17:40There's no reason for it.
- 17:41And there are things that we could be doing to, if schools have a certain
- 17:44number of kids that are applying beyond, the spaces that are available, school
- 17:49districts and states and whatever should be obligated to provide that
- 17:53school with the additional facilities, the other support it needs to grow.
- 17:57And the idea that we just do not do everything we can to grow those things
- 18:02that are clearly successful already, that is a scandal and it's something
- 18:05that we could address really quickly.
- 18:08Andy: Well, it shows how potent the sort of special interest politics here
- 18:12in the politics around this issue are, because in any other field you'd be
- 18:16unleashing that energy, not bottling it up, but here it becomes politically,
- 18:20you can bottle it up and it's just a very revealing situation in terms of the
- 18:26politics and the power in the sector.
- 18:29But these other cases, yeah.
- 18:31I just have this feeling, and again, this is another one maybe it won't
- 18:33age well in 10 years when people go through the Wonky Folk archives and
- 18:38excavate them they'll laugh at me for this, but it seems like we're seeing
- 18:43a whole set of student and teacher expression cases, free expression cases.
- 18:49A lot of them focused on LGBT issues moving through the court.
- 18:53So there's a case in Massachusetts about whether or not a kid could wear a shirt
- 18:58that says there are two genders which sort of, obviously outside of school would be
- 19:04just a very clear first Amendment issue, inside of school, it's more complicated.
- 19:10You're seeing cases with a number of cases with teachers and pronouns and names that
- 19:15kids have changed and pronouns that don't correspond with biologic sex, a bunch
- 19:19of cases on that, where teachers are saying, "Hey, we don't have to do that".
- 19:22"I have a right not to do that."
- 19:24Now, traditionally compelled speech by teachers, it's been kind of a
- 19:27cornerstone of how public schools operate, that's why you can't teach
- 19:30the world is flat or whatever.
- 19:32But we're seeing a bunch of these cases and so it just feels
- 19:35like, again, this idea that like, we're sort of renegotiating
- 19:40boundaries and things like that.
- 19:42We, some of these cases, and I think there's gonna be some, potentially some
- 19:45interesting cases around student rights and compelled speech and teacher rights
- 19:49and compelled speech and potentially momentous cases, because everybody's
- 19:53like, "Oh, what's the big deal?
- 19:54It's just pronouns".
- 19:55But if we start deciding that teachers have, you know, either right
- 19:59of conscious or faith exemptions from certain school policies.
- 20:03As soon as you get outside of the real narrow thing around religion and like
- 20:08what you can wear and so forth, that is a Pandora's box that we will not close.
- 20:16And we talk about redefining public schools and what does it mean?
- 20:20Like that would be a huge one if teachers get, I feel like people on all sides
- 20:25of these issues, regardless of what you think of them, need to realize
- 20:28the precedence that this is laying bare and the potential consequences.
- 20:32And again, it seems like in the next few years we're going to
- 20:34see more and more of these cases.
- 20:39Jed: The individual rights of the kids and then of the teachers, there's also
- 20:44really the institutional rights to have a point of view on historical conditions
- 20:53of the country or whatever it may be.
- 20:55I think it's really fascinating.
- 20:57Last year the Texas State Board of Education turned down four out of five
- 21:02new charter school applications and almost everybody was of the opinion that almost
- 21:07all five should have been approved, but it was just rejected for whatever reason.
- 21:12This last week, there's been an election, the Texas Charter School Association has
- 21:16been doing very effective advocacy and political work, and we have now a stronger
- 21:21state board in support of charter schools.
- 21:23So one year later, four out of five charters are approved, but the fifth
- 21:28school, the one that was denied, is another school that almost everybody
- 21:33believes is a strong applicant.
- 21:37The reason cited by the state board for denying it was that they didn't like
- 21:41the woke curriculum that supposedly they were going to be teaching.
- 21:46And so it became a decision, not so specific to rights that you're
- 21:49bringing up Andy, but it's a long, a very similar fault line there.
- 21:53What degree of entitlement do institutions and individuals have
- 21:59to take their own point of view on foundational matters such as these?
- 22:03And my own point of view is that we should be receiving, we should be more receptive.
- 22:08We have to allow a greater range here but it's obviously we're in a time where we're
- 22:14narrowing more than we're broadening.
- 22:16Andy: I think so, although, I do have to say there's an idea that's out
- 22:21there in the school choice community that school choice is a solution
- 22:24to this, that we can just sort of, everybody gets their choice and so you
- 22:27don't have to have these big fights.
- 22:29And I think at some level there's some merit to that in the sense of like,
- 22:33why fight over whether we're going to have Montessori or other pedagogies.
- 22:38Why fight over if we should have schools that like, are very arts focused versus
- 22:42like pre-law, you know, STEM focused, whatever, like that, those seem like
- 22:46dumb fights, and we should let you know, the parents can sort of let their
- 22:51preferences be known, but I don't think you can be like, oh, we're just going
- 22:54to choose which version of history we teach and we're just going to choose
- 22:58about like, how we think about like seminal events in American history.
- 23:03I feel like a healthy society, you have to have some kind of a consensus on some
- 23:07of that stuff, and then you move forward.
- 23:08Sometimes that consensus changes, but you can't have to choose
- 23:13your own adventure on everything.
- 23:15And so that's why, again, in public schools, like you can't teach certain
- 23:20things in let's say, a biology class or a geology class or a history class, right?
- 23:25You can't be, well, maybe the Holocaust didn't happen, guy in teaching high
- 23:31school history, you teach a curriculum that teaches about the Holocaust in
- 23:34all 50 states and I feel like it's fraught if we're not careful, and some
- 23:40of this is just the hard conversations societies have to make decisions and
- 23:45none of us will like all the decisions, but you have to live with them.
- 23:49Jed: I hear you.
- 23:50I also think there are certain foundational issues that are super
- 23:54complicated and one can take a, there can be a variety of legitimate points of view
- 23:59taken on something as broad as well, how do we, how are we going to teach slavery?
- 24:03How are we going to teach the history of racial discrimination in our country.
- 24:06There's just so many different orientations you could have toward that.
- 24:09And I personally think a lot of them should be welcomed.
- 24:13And I've seen just in too many contexts, like in textbook adoption like the
- 24:19Armenian issue, I mean that the Armenian portrayal in textbooks was enough to
- 24:25slow down the entire state Board of Education in California for nine months.
- 24:29They couldn't make an adoption on the textbook cause they kept
- 24:31having to come back on this.
- 24:33So I just, you know, I hear you.
- 24:36But I also feel like, and there are some things that are
- 24:39outside the bound for sure.
- 24:41But a lot of it I think also is, "Hey, we're going to have a wide
- 24:44variety of opinion on these issues within society, and we need to have a
- 24:48wide range of opinions that are, are welcomed within public education as
- 24:52well as a foundational starting point".
- 24:54Andy: Sure.
- 24:55But you just said it, some stuff's outside the bounds and I feel
- 24:58like we have to like, and the bounds will over time will change.
- 25:03But you have to have those conversations.
- 25:09And then personally, I feel like I balance like an appreciation for school
- 25:13choice, let parents choose all of that with like a healthy society does
- 25:18have consensus around certain things.
- 25:21And again, at broad strokes, we're not indoctrinating people down to every
- 25:28little detail, but at broad strokes, you have to have some kind of a broad
- 25:34consensus around, just around how certain things happen and things like that.
- 25:37You can't, people could take away their own meaning from it and all that, but
- 25:41I don't know, it strikes me, we are on dangers ground, we start deciding there's
- 25:46just all these different ways that you do have questions of societal cohesion there.
- 25:51Jed: Yeah.
- 25:52Well, something to come back to.
- 25:53Andy: Yeah, absolutely.
- 25:54I think we're going to.
- 25:55I think the one thing, the last couple things we've talked about have in common
- 25:58again, is it seems like we're in a time, it is a very fluid time in terms of
- 26:04redefining things, changing boundaries, and that's interesting and things will
- 26:08probably look different in 10 years.
- 26:12Jed: As a teacher, we talked about this, I mentioned this before, my theory was
- 26:16could I give multiple perspectives to the students and have them grapple with
- 26:21them and challenge themselves to change their thinking and to recognize their
- 26:25own patterns of thinking over time?
- 26:27And it's really difficult to do.
- 26:29It's really difficult to teach multiple perspectives as a teacher and I
- 26:33think I got it wrong several times.
- 26:35Andy: It is hard.
- 26:36Yeah.
- 26:36And we have to support teachers part of the problem is we don't support them,
- 26:40so we're like, Hey, go teach about these like, really contentious issues and
- 26:43just sort of figure out how to do it ,rather than like, here's really high
- 26:46quality training and how to think about this and how to teach these questions.
- 26:52Jed: So one of the things I wanted to bring up was this article or this op-ed
- 26:57that Eva Moskowitz wrote about phonics and finally the establishment that has
- 27:06resisted phonics for so long finally kind of getting its comeuppance and I think
- 27:11it's just brought up this whole question.
- 27:12Andy: There's a lot of words to say, "I told you so."
- 27:15It was like 800 words.
- 27:17Jed: Well, I mean, if there's anybody that's compelling a lot delivering
- 27:20a message like that, it's Eva too.
- 27:21Right?
- 27:22But I think that it's brought up this whole issue of science of reading
- 27:28that I've wanted to come to return to.
- 27:31I mean we had Calkin, what's her first name?
- 27:36Andy: Lucy Calkins.
- 27:37The reading guru -- the guru in quotes.
- 27:41Jed: Yeah.
- 27:41Of whole language.
- 27:43And I've got my teaching credential right when she was coming into ascendancy.
- 27:49I mean, when I got my district intern credential through Los Angeles Unified.
- 27:54It was just 100% whole language, whole language, whole language.
- 27:58Fortunately, I had a mother who specialized in reading, teaching reading
- 28:02to kids, and I had just gone and raided her closets and I had all of her stuff.
- 28:07And plus I just had experience with my parents.
- 28:09So I think I had very fairly good barriers going into the classroom.
- 28:12I listened to all the stuff around whole language.
- 28:14I was like, maybe it actually works.
- 28:16I tried it for a few weeks.
- 28:17I was like, oh, forget it.
- 28:18And LA Unified was just so discombobulated, the
- 28:22management was so ineffective.
- 28:24No one knew what was going on in my classroom anyway, and so I taught
- 28:27how I thought that I needed to teach.
- 28:29But you know, the thing that we failed to recognize is this whole debate around
- 28:35whole language and phonics, it happened within a political context where if you
- 28:41chose one thing or the other, you were not choosing instructional practice.
- 28:46You were not choosing pedagogical specificity.
- 28:50You were choosing sides in a culture war.
- 28:54There were people that believed that the old way of us teaching education with
- 28:58phonics and with books that went back to the 1950s with kids of certain races,
- 29:04all that and the way that we set up our classrooms and rows there, that was a
- 29:09conservative way of operating a school.
- 29:14And then there was the whole language folks that were like trying to discount
- 29:17that the phonics mattered, but also we needed a bunch of new books and by the
- 29:21way, these books are going to teach a whole bunch of different kinds of lessons.
- 29:25And by the way, we're going to have a different kind of experience
- 29:27that we want for our kids.
- 29:28And so after the fact, we now start to like just parse to separate
- 29:33out the pedagogical expertise from the cultural context.
- 29:37And I think that's just a grave, grave mistake.
- 29:40We should always be remembering maybe, I mean, clearly we made a
- 29:44terrible mistake in deemphasizing phonics, and everybody can go back
- 29:48and say, "Our schools of education let us down and somehow or another we
- 29:52like failed to recognize the proper pedagogy", that's not what happened.
- 29:56Its pedagogy got set up in a broader culture war and we made wrong decisions
- 30:02in that highly contentious experience.
- 30:04Andy: Let ourselves people check their brains and became partisan.
- 30:08I mean, people would come in from outside the sector and be like, it seems like
- 30:12there's a republican way to teach reading and a democratic way to teach reading.
- 30:15And you were like, yes, it would.
- 30:17I mean it, it totally would appear that way.
- 30:19And that's deranged and has huge consequences.
- 30:22People, this is what happens.
- 30:24And I think like it's a lesson that should carry forward to
- 30:26a lot of the debates today.
- 30:27When you check your brain, for partisanship, like watch out and
- 30:33you can see, and especially now when everything's so reactionary, and so
- 30:36you've got people, you know, on both the right and the left, just taking
- 30:40sort of really out there, reactionary positions just because of the other side.
- 30:46There's a huge lesson there.
- 30:47And to me, the frustrating thing about it, like going back to like project follow
- 30:51through and all that, there's been like lots of evidence on this for a long time.
- 30:55So this is, I think if it, if it helps it go down easier politically
- 30:59be like, "oh, this is all this new information and new research, we
- 31:01need to adapt to the new research".
- 31:03If that's the narrative that's...
- 31:05I get it.
- 31:05That's the political narrative.
- 31:07But like the fact is there was lots of evidence.
- 31:10It was widely ignored.
- 31:11There was a billion dollar reading program during the Bush years and
- 31:14it fell prey to politics,right?
- 31:17And we've had just over the years, we've had efforts around this and they just
- 31:23get killed in this political crossfire, but I did write about this last week, I
- 31:28think it was, or week before at EduWonk.
- 31:30I do think we need the science of reading, people need to be careful.
- 31:33Eva deserves her victory lap.
- 31:34She deserves a lot of victory lap.
- 31:36And now she was treated in New York, and people are like, well,
- 31:39you can do a better job, go show us.
- 31:41And she's shown them like, she's entitled to a lot of
- 31:44victory, a lot of victory laps.
- 31:46But the science of reading people want to be careful, and I worry they're now
- 31:53like salting the earth behind them a little bit, if you will, and being a
- 31:57little bit like, you know, and they need to be a little careful for two reasons:
- 32:01* One, they were excluded from intellectual debate and they
- 32:05were cast out and all that.
- 32:07So why replicate that?
- 32:08Because it just creates a backlash.
- 32:10* And then second, just substantively, if we over index on phonics, there
- 32:16will be a backlash from teachers, this will be common core all over again.
- 32:19So you have to get this right.
- 32:21You've to support teachers and you've got to allow people to have debate
- 32:26because there will be mistakes.
- 32:28Not every state that's implementing a science or reading laws
- 32:30are going to be great laws.
- 32:31It can be implemented well, and you need that kind of debate
- 32:34and, that's how we learn, right?
- 32:36You,see what's going well, we debate it, you try to learn from it.
- 32:40And so I'm a little concerned there could be an overcorrection here.
- 32:47There should be an examination for sure.
- 32:49And I do think, like all these people who they see profit under every stone, were
- 32:56like, Lucy Caulkin made an awful lot of money teaching kids to read the wrong way.
- 33:01So, and it was, and all over.
- 33:03So it's a poor reflection on the sector, but people should be very
- 33:08careful how we move forward because there's backfire potential there.
- 33:12And I am concerned about that.
- 33:16Jed: Yeah.
- 33:17We just failed.
- 33:17We can look back and see how nonsensical it was outside our own context, but
- 33:23then what's happening in the current moment, we can't see its applicability.
- 33:28And I just think so many things around pedagogy and instructional
- 33:31practice are being warped by our experience around the pandemic, by
- 33:37the political wars that we have, by the pushback of the public education
- 33:42establishment to reform generally and.
- 33:46Very little, very little focuses on instructional practice.
- 33:50Very little actually focuses on what generates student learning.
- 33:55And I think we should all be sobered by that and to find some, to try to find some
- 34:01anchors in these very difficult context.
- 34:05Andy: Yeah, I think that's right.
- 34:07I think that's spot on and so much of this.
- 34:11I wrote a piece a few years ago called The Wild One, like the Wild One
- 34:15Movement or everyone was about sort of some of the stuff that was going on.
- 34:17It was from that Marlon Brando film, what are you rebelling against?
- 34:20What do you got?
- 34:21And I feel like that sort of really is like kind of where we are.
- 34:25People are frustrated and there's data on this, like across both parties,
- 34:29Republican or Democrat if people are upset about school closures, they're
- 34:32more likely to be upset about a whole host of culture war and other issues.
- 34:36People are just, They're angry and they're frustrated.
- 34:38And they feel like they feel like they weren't taken seriously and that no
- 34:41one's taken accountability for that.
- 34:43It's why like people are like, why is everybody still
- 34:45upset with Randy Weingarten?
- 34:47It's because people feel like there hasn't been accountability.
- 34:49There's a whole bunch of people who want, they want someone to acknowledge,
- 34:53"Hey, that some bad stuff happened here".
- 34:54And the fact that there are kids and no one's doing that.
- 34:57And I feel like that is informing a very reactionary politics.
- 35:01That will then get in the way of getting stuff done.
- 35:04Because I think, I'm a sort of a congenital moderate, but like my view,
- 35:12like you step back, you see stuff both parties are doing and you're like, what?
- 35:16This doesn't make any sense.
- 35:18Doesn't even make any sense with your prior commitments, right?
- 35:20Yeah.
- 35:20This is like stuff that you just thought up, you know, a week ago?
- 35:24But it's because of how spun up everything is and there'll be some collateral
- 35:28damage from that in our sector for sure.
- 35:30Jed: I wasn't tracing the science of reading phenomenon early enough
- 35:35to see when exactly they started it.
- 35:37My guess is that it would've been pre pandemic and they would've chosen
- 35:42science as some trustworthy foundation that we could go to, and of course we
- 35:48get through the pandemic and everything around vaccines and all that stuff,
- 35:52science has now been politicized.
- 35:54There's nothing.
- 35:56Andy: We all believe in science.
- 35:58You can't swing a dead cat where I live without hitting one of these signs on
- 36:01how in this house we believe in science.
- 36:06Jed: But it's just crazy.
- 36:09And we had Macke on last time and it's just amazing how she brings
- 36:16this information to policymakers and to the general public.
- 36:19There's not that much interest in it.
- 36:21And if anything, people are taking away from her the data that she
- 36:25will need to continue to have these kinds of studies in the future.
- 36:30Andy: And her data has changed.
- 36:34The most stunning thing about that study is the results have changed.
- 36:37We talked about this at the last podcast, like people treat it like frozen and
- 36:40amber from 2009, but it's because science is now this like ... science.
- 36:47Science is not settled.
- 36:48Science is like an investigative process of learning and refining and so forth,
- 36:53but we have decided to weaponize.
- 36:55And so the science is always settled and you remember like, who the hell knows,
- 37:00like the origin of Covid, but it sure seems like maybe it could have come from
- 37:05a lab that seemed plausible in 2020 too.
- 37:07Right?
- 37:08But back then, that was like against the science and you were basically, you know,
- 37:12you were like a tin tinfoil hat person.
- 37:14Right?
- 37:14Like it'll soon if you thought that might be the case, you also believe
- 37:19all this other stuff and like the science and the evidence has changed.
- 37:24Right?
- 37:24And that debate has now changed and us intelligence agencies
- 37:27are split on that question.
- 37:28And like that should like humble everybody a little bit.
- 37:31And that's my point on like the science of reading.
- 37:34There's definitely some stuff we should do the evidence points in a
- 37:37direction we should train teachers based on the best available evidence.
- 37:41But we should not then become like crazy illiberal and being like, this is
- 37:45now settled and this is the way, and I worry some science of reading advocates
- 37:49because I've heard people say things, you know, we have to make sure there's
- 37:52no one in an Ed school who doesn't believe in the science of reading.
- 37:56And like, that's just, I don't know.
- 37:57I'm not there on that.
- 37:58I think like, that's, to me that sounds like on something like
- 38:03that, you want to know, "well where's the limiting principle?
- 38:05What other things should we not allow?"
- 38:07So it's a good time on a lot of issues people just sort of take a deep breath.
- 38:14Jed: Well, and often it's determined by a small number of very impassioned people
- 38:20who show up at a school board meeting.
- 38:22And just it attempt to impose their will.
- 38:26Andy: Yeah.
- 38:26We should talk about Moms for Liberty.
- 38:30But one other thing on this, someone we should mention before we get off the
- 38:33science of reading is Emily Hanford, the journalist who sort of started calling
- 38:37attention to this, did articles for American Public Media, did podcasts.
- 38:42Did that whole series, recently sold a story.
- 38:45I can remember a few different times over the years you'd get a journalist, usually
- 38:50not an education journalist, because they bathe in all this and so they're sort
- 38:56of caught up in it, like from outside the sector who would come in and write
- 38:59an article that basically like, not to put too fine a point on, was like, "Hey,
- 39:04reading instruction sure is fucked up".
- 39:06And everybody would be like, "Yeah, that's right.
- 39:08Like, look at that".
- 39:09And then like that article would like evaporate.
- 39:13Into the ether, right?
- 39:14It would just bounce off and then everyone would get back to business as usual.
- 39:18And Hanford, to her credit, I do think this is in like she didn't bounce off.
- 39:22She was able to get traction.
- 39:24I don't know if it was different modalities, if it was her just force
- 39:27of will, whatever, but for whatever reason she's gotten traction on this in
- 39:31a way that no one has a very long time.
- 39:34And is changing, it's changing policy, as a result.
- 39:39And that's just an enormous credit to her.
- 39:43Jed: Absolutely.
- 39:44We have to have somebody that can get through the noise and every once in
- 39:47a while you have a journalist that can get to the bottom of things.
- 39:50Andy: So yeah, she just, I don't know the skillset, the timing, whatever it
- 39:53is, like she just deserves an enormous so amount of credit, because many people
- 39:56have bounced off, before she got there.
- 39:59So though, you said you want to talk about parenting , I mean,
- 40:02I assume you're on your way to Philadelphia for the Moms for Liberty.
- 40:04You're just like waiting to finish our podcast, then you're
- 40:07going to head to the airport.
- 40:08Jed: Got my plane ticket for tomorrow.
- 40:10Andy: Nice.
- 40:11I heard a story about them.
- 40:13I did not know this apparently, and since this is a podcast, we don't
- 40:17have to check our facts, so it may not be true, but I think it's true.
- 40:19Somebody said they apparently give this award, it's called "The Sword
- 40:24of Liberty", and I guess they gave it to Ron DeSantis not too long ago.
- 40:28So there's a picture of him with like this sword.
- 40:30Did you know about this?
- 40:32Jed: It's Excalibur or something pulled out of the stone?
- 40:34Andy: That was my thought.
- 40:35Jed, we think alike.
- 40:36That's why I go, my thought was what, like some Moms for Liberty person,
- 40:40like pulled it out of a copy of gender queer or something and that's
- 40:43like how this like all started.
- 40:45That was exactly where I went.
- 40:49This is what I learned about this.
- 40:50Jed: Well, I mean it's barbaric, you know, strategies and tactics
- 40:59of attacking the fortress straight out of the Middle Ages that seems
- 41:04an appropriate comparison point, in terms of looking at some the tactics
- 41:08of some of these groups these days.
- 41:12Andy: I dare say they may have been more comfortable with appearing stuff in the
- 41:15Middle Ages than some people are now.
- 41:17But that's, neither nor there.
- 41:19Yeah.
- 41:20I mean, I'm struck, they're an interesting group.
- 41:23You can't avoid them.
- 41:25I think that you have to look at them along a couple of dimensions, like,
- 41:29are they helping, hurting, on different things and different people are
- 41:34going to agree or disagree on that.
- 41:36And then the Southern Poverty Law Center recently labeled them a hate group,
- 41:41which if I were them, I would probably be pretty psyched about, cause I'm
- 41:45sure that's been good for fundraising.
- 41:48I've got my issues with them to be sure.
- 41:50And going back to science and reading, I think, yeah, they're creating some
- 41:52real complications around science and reading and curriculum adoption, but
- 41:57I don't think they're a hate group.
- 42:00That's a pretty serious label and there are hate groups.
- 42:03And I think when you start labeling groups like Moms for Liberty, hate groups, you
- 42:07at once help their fundraising and you help all the other hate groups maybe
- 42:11sort of seem a little less nauseous.
- 42:15Right?
- 42:16Jed: I don't want to overstate my criticism too.
- 42:17I think that there's all sorts of legitimacy to many of the issues that
- 42:22they care a lot about and to their tactics and what they're trying to do.
- 42:26The thing I find troubling right now is that the venue within which public
- 42:32education decisions are made are these public board meetings where if a small
- 42:38splinter group comes in completely impassioned to take an extreme point
- 42:44of view, they're not necessarily going to get the board to adopt that extreme
- 42:48view, but they are going to be able to slow down the decision perhaps, you know,
- 42:55stop the decision, create so much tension and ill will between the board members,
- 43:01whatever it may be, that whatever they have to do to weather this challenge
- 43:06that's been happening on this particular case degrades the board's ability to make
- 43:10decisions on all sorts of other issues.
- 43:11And I think it's time for us really to be thinking about what is the
- 43:16ideal governance circumstance for a public education entity?
- 43:20I really, I do believe that there are venues where we need the public of
- 43:25whatever ilk to be able to come out.
- 43:27I believe that.
- 43:28I believe that's more at the authorizer level, not at the operator level.
- 43:32If we had our public hospitals, If their boards were public meetings where people
- 43:38were coming and basically insisting that the operation of the hospital, follow
- 43:43whatever their dictate is or whatever is.
- 43:46Our ports, our harbors, if they were governed in such a way that the operators
- 43:52were subject to whomever it was that would sign up, show up at the meeting.
- 43:57We would just simply have, imagine if our military, if our boards that are
- 44:02running the Navy we're subject to a school board meeting protocol, we simply
- 44:09wouldn't get the excellence that we need.
- 44:10So I think we need to find a way to allow the public to have, its, its,
- 44:15you know, its chance to engage with regulators, but less so with operators.
- 44:20And the regulators, if they see the operators doing something
- 44:23that's just not permissible, will they of course intervene.
- 44:26But we protect the operators from just this chatter and controversy
- 44:31that's clearly counterproductive.
- 44:36Andy: Yeah, I watched this as a state board member because like
- 44:39we, public comment's important.
- 44:40I think, it's a first Amendment activity.
- 44:44No, petition the government for redress of grievances, that's no small thing.
- 44:48Even when they're saying things that I don't agree with, I love
- 44:51that people can come and do that and they don't have to worry about like
- 44:53retribution and, all the things.
- 44:56If you've spent time elsewhere in the world and you've seen, you know, like
- 44:59you, you realize how precious this is.
- 45:01But at the same time, it can get in the way, it can become if it just becomes
- 45:06theater, it actually in some ways works against the public interest in the
- 45:10sense that people are just showing up cause they have something they want to
- 45:12talk about and they're very sincere.
- 45:15They get drowned out by whatever the sort of theater of the moment is.
- 45:18So I do think, yeah, we want think about how do you balance all of
- 45:23those things and lead to sort of both effective communication, so
- 45:28boards actually are hearing from the public and know what's going on.
- 45:31And also, when those rights are protected again obviously, but
- 45:35then also sort of, Operation.
- 45:37The other thing with this related to Moms for Liberty though, like that you
- 45:42said in terms of, of how they operate.
- 45:44I feel like I have a much better sense what they're
- 45:46against than what they're for.
- 45:48And I feel like that's what some of the, some of these new parent groups
- 45:51who like you, I'm sympathetic to some of the issues they raise, and people
- 45:57in our sector pretend like there hasn't been like an enormous leftward lurch
- 46:01of the schools in the last few years.
- 46:02Like it's obvious that they're every, it's one of these things like, you know, you're
- 46:06not supposed to say, but everybody kind of knows like, why don't we just say it?
- 46:09We have a healthier conversation.
- 46:11And I don't think that's all bad incidentally.
- 46:13I think some of that stuff's good, some of it is not, and we need to talk about that.
- 46:18But I don't know what they're for I get it.
- 46:23And they seem to be kind of all over the place.
- 46:25So when I see them going after like the Ruby Bridges book in Tennessee
- 46:32or, and also the other one there, which was a just a good book for young kids.
- 46:35It's just a book about Martin Luther King's life that I think as I recall,
- 46:39was keyed, like, at a second grade level.
- 46:41It's just a good biography for kids to read.
- 46:45You can obviously see where that would fit into to a curriculum,
- 46:49especially certain times of the year.
- 46:50And they're against that, and so I struggle with that because when
- 46:59they say, hey, school shouldn't be transitioning kids in secret,
- 47:02and that's happening a lot.
- 47:04They have a point and we should talk about that, that's another one of these ones.
- 47:06Nobody's like, don't talk about that, we should talk about that.
- 47:10But then when it's hard to then when the next thing is like people saying, let's
- 47:14get rid of teaching about Ruby Bridges, because it might make people feel bad.
- 47:18And I feel like they have, you know, we'll see how this, their conference
- 47:21is obviously they got a lot of juice.
- 47:22They got like, you know, Donald Trump's there for goodness sake.
- 47:25But yeah, how they translate that I think, is this the Tea Party?
- 47:32And so it's sort of going to dissipate or turn into something else, or
- 47:35can they build a actual lasting institutional dependent on how they
- 47:41answer those kinds of questions.
- 47:43Jed: Yeah.
- 47:43Well, I always love talking about these things with you and we got a couple weeks
- 47:50and it just seems like the volume of activity that's happening right now, just
- 47:55the seismic changes that are happening.
- 47:57I just find it challenge to stay on top of it.
- 48:00Andy: Yeah, I do try.
- 48:00Do you think it's because like the pandemic kept everybody so focused on
- 48:03one thing, which was the pandemic that we're seeing, like, you know, there's just
- 48:07a lot buildup and it's being released.
- 48:09What do you thinks causing that?
- 48:12We didn't even talk about the NA scores cause, at one level there's
- 48:14all this attention and then at another level, is there really enough
- 48:18attention to like these core things, like the catastrophic learning loss.
- 48:22Jed: Yeah, I mean, I think that what we're seeing is just an acceleration
- 48:26of the splintering of society.
- 48:28I mean, just Facebook and, you know, partisan this.
- 48:30And the consensus around how our schools operate is just
- 48:36disintegrating before our eyes.
- 48:38And so it's fine to say, oh, it's disintegrating, but that means as they
- 48:40separate, each one needs to like begin to make decisions for itself again, and the
- 48:46separation they can't help but criticize whomever they're separating from.
- 48:50And it's just creating this period of just intense, intense controversy.
- 48:56And I also think dumbing down of the discussion.
- 49:00We're just not getting to the most important stuff right now.
- 49:03And being at High Tech High or you know, a lot of charter school
- 49:08organizations, I think do an incredible job around the structural issues.
- 49:11It's very hard.
- 49:13It's very difficult to do this incredibly well, and we need our boards.
- 49:18In consultation with their staff members and with their parents or whatever in
- 49:21their community, really talking about the right things, and some of these things are
- 49:26going to be controversial and difficult.
- 49:28And I'm just not sure that, you know, that conversation happening in a setting
- 49:34where the next day you could find yourself on social media, the enemy of some right
- 49:40large number of people that don't believe that is how we get the excellence of the
- 49:45discussion that we need to go forward.
- 49:49Andy: Yeah.
- 49:49I think that's a good, and we didn't get to, we'll talk about another time,
- 49:54like the whole thing on charters, and this goes to the science of reading and
- 49:59they have control over their inputs.
- 50:00That's all that makes them special.
- 50:01They get to control who is doing the teaching and what is being taught.
- 50:06And in a business that is a teaching and learning business, it is what
- 50:10education is, that is no small thing and I feel like all the theatrics
- 50:16around charters sort of ignore that core thing and it probably more than
- 50:19anything else explains the improving results that Macke found, for instance.
- 50:24Jed: Yeah.
- 50:25I know we want to jump off here.
- 50:26I just, I think that when there are problems within the traditional
- 50:30public school system that become even more visible and more apparent.
- 50:35Charter schools are looked to anew.
- 50:37And we exist because there are those problems.
- 50:41And we also have a status quo that's trying to sweep a lot of
- 50:45those problems under the rug.
- 50:47And what we're seeing right now is rugs are disintegrating.
- 50:52Things are where they are and I think that charter schools will see a
- 50:55resurgence and momentum along these lines.
- 50:57But that's not all good because it's a sign of the fact that there're just
- 51:01all these other challenges in public education right now that are not
- 51:04being addressed as they need to be.
- 51:07Andy: Jed, I'll just leave you with this thought.
- 51:08If I were going to quit my job, which I don't plan to do cause I enjoy
- 51:12podcasting with you and other things.
- 51:13If I were, and I was going to become like a singer songwriter duo, like
- 51:17playing coffee shops, the name of my band would be Fragile Vessel.
- 51:23Jed: Well, could we bill ourselves as Click and Clack?
- 51:27Andy: Click and Clack.
- 51:29Jed: All right.
- 51:30Great seeing you, Andy.
- 51:31Take care.
- 51:31Andy: Hey, see you buddy.
- 51:32Have a good couple weeks.
- 51:33I'll see you soon.
- 51:33Jed: Okay, bye-bye.