Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Special Edition: Interviews Live From The NY Auto Forum
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] All right, we are here at the NADA J.D. Power Auto Forum at the New York Auto Show. Uh, standing here with John Bozzella and Mike Stanton.
- 0:11Gentlemen, thank you so much for joining me, uh, after already having had a chat on the stage. Obviously, you are both at the forefront of two major conversations, EVs and tariffs right now.
- 0:22I'd like to talk, Mike, a little bit ab- about tariffs with you because, uh, the conversation a lot right now is at the OEMs, but there, there's a lot of dealer concern around this.
- 0:33What's the conversation as you've been working with the staff and working with the members on how to approach this, what to take consideration with, and then how you're taking that back, uh, to The Hill?
- 0:43Yeah, a guy I used to work for, Finbar O'Neill at J.D. Power, uh, he had a saying. It was, "Speculation is for chumps." And I think when it comes to tariffs, speculation is for chumps.
- 0:52What the NADA is doing is we're telling the dealer story with the administration, with the Office of Trade Representative, members of Con- Congress, other agencies.
- 1:00We're telling the story about affordability and the concerns there, and then the potential impact to jobs. And as you know, dealerships run great businesses.
- 1:09You guys are great promoters of the jobs that, that they create.
- 1:13Good, good jobs, and those could be at risk if this is su- uh, sustained, and the administration needs to be aware of that as they're making their decisions.
- 1:21We seem to kind of have like a, a flip-flop state of, of the union, where every single day we could have new information about what is or isn't going to happen.
- 1:30Obviously, a May 3rd date kind of as the impending, uh, time of, of potential increased tariffs, specifically on auto parts. There's been kind of some relief on the manufacturers from the build.
- 1:41Um, you know, what are the conversations that you're hearing as to whether those things will come to place, and, and you know, what that impact could be on certain manufacturers?
- 1:52Well, John'll know better than me, but the manufacturers that I'm talking to, they're asking for more time. This is complicated. They don't know how to, how this, uh, how to figure it out just yet.
- 2:00So they need more time. We all need more time, uh, in general to, to deal with this.
- 2:05It's just been so sudden, and, and we've also been advocating for, you know, a, a path versus a, you know, an, an immediate- I love that.
- 2:12John, the other conversation, EVs, we got to have a little bit of this conversation back at Public Policy Day.
- 2:17But because EVs have kind of taken a backseat in the public, public eye, and, and there's been a little bit of waning interest, um, due to, uh, conversations moving away or the political atmosphere, um, one of the conversations that isn't in the forefront is these, I think it's six or seven states that have- Yeah...
- 2:37this 35% of the manufacturer's deliveries in that state having to be in the 20- uh, 26 model year as EVs, correct? Yes. 35% EV sales in model year 2026, which is this calendar year- Right...
- 2:552025, right now, in the state we're standing in, in New York, California, and four other states, right? So it is, it is... This would be the big story if it weren't [laughs] for the tariffs- Ah... and the challenges.
- 3:08The tariffs are, are, right? So you think that the, the hundreds of billions of dollars of risk with regard to tariffs, and I think Mike is right, you cannot change, uh, production and supply chains overnight.
- 3:19So you, like, and by the way, on, just while we're on tariffs for a minute, we do share the president's goal of making more in America. We wanna make more- For sure... we wanna make more cars in America.
- 3:28We wanna make more, w- have more production of cutting edge technologies that go into cars in America, but you can't make that happen overnight. So now you have that risk.
- 3:38And then on top of that risk is this, this idea that in the state of New York and in the state of California, where we sell millions of vehicles, that 35% of those vehicles have to be EVs right now.
- 3:52It, it would take a miracle for this to happen. Think about where we're at. In, in California, 23% of sales is EVs. Now, you say, "Well, that's not that far from 35%."
- 4:05Well, that includes Tesla sales, and they're effectively not regulated- Right... so back them out.
- 4:10And so now the full line manufacturers and their dealers have to figure out to- how to get from effectively each of them from 12% to 35%. New York, we're at- Wow... 9%. As an average. As an average.
- 4:23Including the m- the- 100%. Yeah. Including, including the pure play, uh, uh- EV manufacturers. Yeah... EV manufacturers. So, so something's gotta give. Congress is considering, um, uh, disapproving this rule- Right...
- 4:37uh, and is currently considering a vote on this in the next couple of weeks. I also think states have to consider whether this is right for them. 61% of New Yorkers think this is a bad idea. How do I know?
- 4:51'Cause we've done the polling. Sure. And so I wonder if, if the governor of New York recognizes that, and I think it's important that she does.
- 4:59What was interesting about this is in Maryland, a Democratic governor, Wes Moore, faced a similar question and decided to pause the program for two years, and what he said was, through an executive order, "You know what?Um, we need a timeout.
- 5:13We need to figure out whether this is achievable. By the way, he blamed the President of the United States, but that's politics. That's how it works. Like, uh, and by the way, the president handled it beautifully.
- 5:21He said, "Thank you." You're welcome. You're welcome. [laughs] So, uh, so I, I love that interplay. Like, I don't pick sides. I just, we gotta get... I, I, I'm in the car and truck party. Like, I'm not- That's right.
- 5:30Yeah. [laughs] Like, I don't, I don't, I don't get into that, that stuff. A better place to be.
- 5:33But the point of, the point of the exercise is states are now also starting to make decisions about whether this is right for them. Whether it's right, yeah. They thought it was a free pass. It's not. Yeah.
- 5:43It's not easy.
- 5:44And when you pair both of those things, you start to get into some of our largest states where our manufacturers are the most profitable, having potential issues with supply because, uh, as, as you had the conversation, we change the denominator so that you don't have as much supply that you have to battle against the numerator of the 35%.
- 6:02And then if we come into any supply chain issues with the tariffs and, and some manufacturers potentially backing down their manufacturing in order to reassess where they put manufacturing efforts- Mm-hmm...
- 6:14we get into massive supply chain issues. You s- you kind of said, hey, there might be kind of a pandemic blip in supply chain, especially for some m- manufacturers.
- 6:21And so I think that that's something where dealers can be watching out, um, not, not holding their inventory, uh, but definitely not letting it go for, uh, for too much of a discount, especially with some of the increased volume that we've seen in sales recently.
- 6:36Yeah, each dealer has got to take a look at their own situation.
- 6:39They do have to project, speculate a little bit, take a look at the EVs and the potential of this ta- tax credit going away, then look at the tariffs, what their inventory is now, what that looks like 60, 90 days.
- 6:49For some, they're in great shape. For some, they're not. And then figure out a way to maximize, you know, their, their ROI.
- 6:55Well, gentlemen, thanks for staying on the front lines informing, but also being active, uh, in the political ecosystem and with the manufacturers to make sure that dealers and consumers are treated fairly in all this.
- 7:05Well, well, thank you for having us. And, uh, I love our partnership with NADA, so Mike, thank you. Yeah. Yeah. Awesome. Thanks for all that you do, guys. For sure. You too, Kyle. Thanks, y'all. Perfect.
- 7:14[upbeat music] All right, I am here at the NADA J.D. Power Auto Forum at the New York Auto Show. Thanks again to LiftKit for powering all of our content today. I'm standing here with Stuart Stropp, who- Hi, Kyle.
- 7:29Uh, you, you have been a mainstay in conversations that we've had across these events for a long time.
- 7:34And we were just talking before we jumped on, uh, and, and I think one of the conversations that's not being had right now is that, is that it is so important when consumers are still asking us to be in person, we're-- they're wanting us to care for them in an in-person relationship, whether that be in service or sales.
- 7:53How are we thinking about that consumer interaction?
- 7:57And, and you were telling me like, "Hey, that's something that you all are considering right now," and how to leverage the big data that you have access to into actionable insights in- into the showroom.
- 8:08Talk to me a little bit about, like, where the impetus for that was, why you saw a need, and how you're fulfilling it. Yeah, absolutely.
- 8:15I mean, we're really focused right now on helping our clients, and this could be automakers, uh, dealer groups, uh, you know, and all the way down to the, the field teams, individual rooftops, pull together all these different data sets that we know are out there and that are, all, all of them are, are very valuable if you've got, you know, social review content out there.
- 8:37You've got content coming in from th- all the J.D. Power surveys that we put out, perspective there. You've got the surveys that are coming in, uh, from the individual automakers. Uh, you've got call center data.
- 8:49You've, you've got data all over the place. But generally, it kind of lives-- each one of those data sets live on their own- Yeah... almost in isolation. So it takes a lot of- Different dashboards, different places.
- 9:00You gotta log in. Yeah. Exactly. So the, it, it really takes a lot of work, as things stand right now, in most cases, to make sense of that data across all those different origins.
- 9:11So what we are working on actively right now is building out a platform and, and it's got, you know, dashboard functionality like we were talking about earlier.
- 9:20It's very easy to navigate, but it pulls all of that data together in a single location, and then we apply AI to it so that all that data, regardless of where it comes from, is categorized in the same way.
- 9:34And this is where we're really applying J.D. Power's, you know, decades worth of, of experience in the industry, categorizing data so that it makes sense. Yep.
- 9:44Like, you know, we've, we figured out how to categorize, uh, vehicle quality problems. Uh- Absolutely. We figured out- Exactly...
- 9:50right, with IQS, and same thing with the sales experience, service experience, and, and so on.
- 9:56Using all of that, that knowledge to help drive these AI engines to organize the data so that regardless of where it comes from, a user, whether it be a dealer, field manager, somebody at corporate, can make sense of that data and take action on it, uh, either through a dashboard-type interface, also, which is very common for AI, query tool functionality.
- 10:19Just conversation. Exactly. Like, "What do I do with this?" Yeah.
- 10:21So, I mean, you- Are you seeing any early signs as you're starting to aggregate data that might indicate like, "Hey, here's, here's some of the leads that we need to be thinking about from a consumer experience perspective," um, that broadly in the industry people are concerned with right now?
- 10:36Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you know, we just published the, uh, the twenty twenty-five Customer Service Index, uh, results or CSI. Yep.
- 10:46And what we see in that data, and we've seen this in, in recent years past as well-The brands that do really well, the retail networks that are doing really well in those types of studies
- 10:58ha- have figured out a way to build really strong connections with their dealers. A- a- and what I mean is, is create a lot of trust- Mm...
- 11:05with, with, uh, with, uh, the, across the dealership network, actually with the retail customers, uh, through good processes, through really kind of prioritizing, uh, points of communication, uh, throughout the service experience, uh, you know, providing some kind of reasonable estimate for when the vehicle's gonna be ready, obviously delivering on that, or if you, if you know you can't deliver it on time, proactively reaching out to that customer and letting them know, uh, and, and resetting those expectations.
- 11:36Also, leveraging technology. Like, we're talking about building these platforms to, to make sense of all the data. Even just using technology more effectively with customers through things like photo, video NPI. Mm.
- 11:49Uh, we see a really strong, positive correlation with, with using tech in those ways, particularly if it's on digital tablets, in customer satisfaction, in trust. We actually see higher trust metrics.
- 12:00I can, I can validate that. W- when I was at the dealership, we implemented photo and video NPI, and the, uh, the, like, over a year and a half after we, like, really implemented it, there were multiple things.
- 12:13CSI, like, real customer satisfaction scores. Yeah. The biggest one actually was retention. Absolutely. People wanted to come back to get that experience again. I'm sure you're saying absolutely.
- 12:24Like, that's a real measurable metric that over time you can look back and say, "If my NPI," right- Yeah... "process looks like that, people do come back to that particular experience." No doubt about it. Yeah.
- 12:36I mean, it's a very clear journey, if you will, between using technology like that to build trust. That results in high level of satisfaction for that customer.
- 12:48And to your point, every year [laughs] in the, in the data set, we correlate satisfaction with intended service loyalty. Are they gonna come back?
- 12:57How likely are they to come back to that same dealership for their service need next time? Incredibly strong correlation there every time. So, yeah.
- 13:06And, and I don't know if you have this data, but I'll, I'll call this out. Most dealers wanna know, but is it gonna make me more money, right? Yeah, exactly. Right. We saw a 40% increase in customer- Yeah...
- 13:17dollars per RO, customer paid dollars per RO- [laughs]... simply from installing video NPI in our service lanes. Amazing. So, yeah. Amazing. Well, hey, thanks for sharing some of the data.
- 13:27I'm encouraged of what you guys are doing, and thanks for spending a little time with us. Thank, thank you, Kyle- Absolutely... as always. All right. Great seeing you. [upbeat music] All right.
- 13:38It's a special edition of the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Daly. This is Kyle Mountsier, and we're here with the one and only Senator Bernie Moreno. Senator, thank you for giving us a few minutes today.
- 13:46Of course. You guys are killing it out there. It's great. Thank you for spreading the word about the auto industry. It's an industry that I love. I know it's an industry you guys love. Absolutely.
- 13:53And you're doing a great job. One of the things that, uh, have been, uh, has been very impactful is hearing you throughout the day talk about the people side of the business.
- 14:01A lot of conversation about tariffs and international trade.
- 14:04Um, however, uh, you have a lot of experience and insights on dealers who have to deal with these conversations with their own people and with consumers on the front line.
- 14:14So what would you say to dealers, um, about those conversations, not necessarily the global ones? Look, focus on the things that you can control.
- 14:22Uh, I remember during the '08 recession, I had a TV in my office right in the middle of the showroom. I literally turned the TV off. Uh, I can't control anything that's on there.
- 14:29I can control what's in front of me, uh, my people, uh, my clients, make sure I give them a better experience than they've ever imagined, and make sure that I take care of my people who also had stress.
- 14:38And so they, they're looking into me. Like, if I'm the one freaking out, they're gonna freak out even worse.
- 14:43So calm, get everybody focused on cutting cost, making sure you do a great job with used cars, make sure you're at, at, at the, uh, uh, that you're focused on making sure you got the right inventory, making sure you're doing well in finance, make sure you're doing well in fixed operations, that you're running a clean organization.
- 15:00Those are the things you can control. You can't control international trade and tariffs and, uh, global politics or what's China saying today. Stop reading so much, uh, news. Definitely turn off CNN.
- 15:11[laughs] But turn on ASTU, by the way- ASTU... to get the real scoop. Yeah. Sorry, baby. There we go. There we go.
- 15:15You know, one of the things that you also encouraged is obviously getting involved in the local politics, especially at the state level, and, and lobbying those state representatives that may not, that they may not be able to get in front of you or come to, to DC or anything like that.
- 15:29How, how can dealers be the best involved in some of the things that you're trying to pursue right now? Well, you know, dealers are always involved in the local communities.
- 15:38I mean, I don't think there's a group of businesspeople, uh, writ large of any industry, that takes care, better care of their local communities than car dealers do. Uh, so continue to do that.
- 15:48Uh, the, on the state side, those are where your franchise laws live, so make certain that you're in touch with your federal officials. In Ohio, we're blessed with an incredible auto dealer associations.
- 15:56I think a lot of states are. And then at a federal level, look, advocate for candidates that are supporting the industry. Advocate, uh, for bills like the one I've introduced, the Transportation Freedom Act.
- 16:06So if you're represented by a Democrat congressman or a Democrat senator, lobby them.
- 16:10Explain to them how important it is to give the industry certainty, to stop allowing states like California to dictate national standards that raise the cost of automobiles. Those are the things that you can do.
- 16:21Recently, uh, some data came out saying interest in EVs has been dropping now. Um, what is your perspective on EVs and dealers having them, selling them, consumer interest?
- 16:31Look, there's a new Taylor Swift song that's gonna be coming out. It's about the breakup between the Democrats and Elon. [laughs] It's a tragic, tragic breakup. As a result- Yes.
- 16:40[laughs] As a result, EV sales have gone down a lot. You know, Tesla's two-thirds of EV sales. Yeah. So when you take down Tesla- Mm-hmm...
- 16:47uh, you're taking down EVs, and then we're gonna eliminate the subsidies, the $7,500, uh, the lease loophole, and the $4,000. That will also bring down demand.
- 16:56So look, at the end of the day, car companies should make cars that people want, not, uh, cars that politicians want, and we're gonna fix that.
- 17:03I think it's gonna allow car companies to be more profitable and lower the price of carsWell, Bernie, as John said up there, thank you so much be- for being an advocate for the industry.
- 17:12Also, just challenging dealers to be better, not just rely on politics for everything, to continue serving communities and- Well, look, they gotta get eng- they gotta get engaged.
- 17:19Look, I'm the first auto dealer in the Senate. We've had a few in the House. Don't make me the last auto dealer in the Senate. There you go. Good. [laughs] All right, so...
- 17:26And by the way, if you remember the line from It's a Wonderful Life when, uh, George Bailey was gonna jump off the bridge, and the angel came and said, "What can I do for you?" He said, "Do you have any money?"
- 17:35And he goes, "No, we don't use money in heaven." He goes, "Well, it comes in pretty handy down here, Bob." [laughs] So, with that, go on teammarino.org. [laughs] There you go. I like it. I like it. Thank you.
- 17:43All right, thanks for spending some time. All right, thanks, guys. That's great. [laughs] Appreciate you. [upbeat music] All right, we are here at the NADA JD Power Auto Forum at the New York Auto Show.
- 17:55I'm standing here with Tom Castriota. Hi. Uh, thanks to LiftKit again for powering all of our content today. Really appreciate that. Tom- Yes, sir... you have been in the seat now officially since NADA- That's right...
- 18:06what, about three months, and, uh, there's been no shortage of activity- That's correct... in the auto world.
- 18:13What's been the messy stuff that you've had to get your hands dirty with as you've kind of gotten your, uh, your hands dirty in the seat?
- 18:19Well, let's start with the first rule is that we had the positive ruling by the appellate court in Texas- Right...
- 18:24who ruled in favor of the dealers, the Texas dealers, against the Federal Trade Commission in the CARS Rule. Then we rolled into- [laughs]...
- 18:32President Trump and the tariff, so that's been the real discussion point now for almost a month since- Right... the President announced that, and the turmoil it's causing between, uh...
- 18:41It's the uncertainty, as everybody knows already from the tariff. So from, you know, NADA's standpoint is we're like everybody else. We're monitoring. And,
- 18:50you know, with all our different franchises, some franchises are in a different, or OEMs, in a different position than another. Right. And, and so where's that balance?
- 18:59And that's what, what we're trying to find out or, or try to take that path to, to cover and be the voice of all the dealers with the same message.
- 19:07But right now the message is we're hoping that President Trump gets the tariff situation at least some consistency, and that maybe he gives us a bridge. When I say us, I'm talking the OEMs.
- 19:19That there's a bridge so the dealers have some consistency along with the OEMs as well as the consumer.
- 19:24Now, obviously, as a dealer, you're thinking about, "How do I make sure that my people are approaching the subject well?" Sure. Both internally and with their customers.
- 19:33How are you encouraging your store and the people on ground and, and every single day learning about, talking about, interacting with some of the news that's coming down the pipe?
- 19:42Because obviously the consumer's educated. Well, that, that's true, and two weeks ago, three weeks ago when it really started to hit the press, then the consumers comes, "Oh, my lease is up in three months.
- 19:51My lease is up in four months. Should I do it now?" And it is driving that, that, that sense of urgency. Mm-hmm. And, and it just isn't Chevrolet. It's just about every manufacturer is saying the same thing.
- 20:01Of course, as you know, the March sales were, were up, and a lot of that's contributed- Right... to the tariff. April s- most of the manufacturers are saying they're up.
- 20:09And there's, and there is a lot of inventory out there. Now, there's some shortage of other inventories. That's a real concern that some dealers have. But personally, you know, our story is we have inventory.
- 20:18We're not affected by the tariff. GM builds a lot of vehicles in the United States, and they build a lot as well in Mexico and Canada. So we're not affected today. Now, what happens in three or four months?
- 20:28I think we'll find out. Yeah. Uh, but right now we're not affected necessarily by the concern that GM's not hiking prices. They're not, they're not reflecting anything in of a tariff.
- 20:38There's, if there is a vehicle that might be affected- Yeah... they're not passing anything along. Amazing. And I think that's what our stability's gonna be for the next two or three months.
- 20:46Yeah, and I think we'll see that across the industry, so. Yes. Now, I, I love that you said you're monitoring it, right? Yes.
- 20:50And I think that's a way that a lot of people can get into this situation is like, "We're monitoring it. We're not pulling any crazy triggers." Correct. "We're not ma- taking any knee-jerk reactions, anything like that."
- 21:01Uh, now- Yeah... tell me. You've been in, listening to all the conversations- Yes... today. A lot of talk about tariffs, a lot of talk about EVs, a lot of interest, uh, around the conversations with the actual OEMs. Yes.
- 21:12Tell me a little bit about Jason Stein has kind of like prodded a couple OEMs on, on their plans. Talk a little bit about what you've heard there and what's interesting. Um, I, I like the candidness.
- 21:23I mean, we've had Hyundai with Randy Parker and, uh, Shahin from, um, Nissan. Yeah. And then, uh, uh, and Mike Contron from Volvo. Volvo, yeah.
- 21:32Uh, and I've met most of them, but they're being very candid with the situation is, "We're here to support our dealers. We're still here to support our customers."
- 21:42And none of them said that we're affecting right now, that we're gonna pass on to prices. Yeah. I mean, if you, like take Volvo for instance, you know, Volvo has, has a plant, I think they said they have two plants here.
- 21:52Well, they're ramping up production here. Nissan said, "We're ramping up production," on the US version of what they build here. Yeah.
- 21:59And, and so that's how they monitor, at least listening to them, is that they're not passing any kind of tariff extra cost to the consumer, and they're...
- 22:06So the two biggest issues I'm hearing is it's the customer, it's the dealer relationship. That's amazing. It is. And it's, it's, but it's interesting time. Yeah.
- 22:14And I think, again, from NADA's standpoint, that we have to monitor the effect of all our dealers that represent every OEM here in the country. For sure.
- 22:24And as we talked earlier, some of those OEMs are, it's questionable, I shouldn't say questionable, but they're in not a strong position as maybe some of the domestics are or some of the imports that have plants here.
- 22:35Yeah. For sure. And some of those, as we've talked about, they don't have plants here. So those are the ones that, you know, that's the effect.
- 22:43So and our point as dealers, they're part of our, they're part of NADA, so we still have to find that, that- That common ground, the balance. Yeah...
- 22:49balance between dealers that might be questionable on the franchise side, that have less inventory, and then those that dealers that their manufacturer's a much more s- uh, solid position on, uh, uh, on where they are in the tariff situation.
- 23:02Yeah. Well, Tom, thanks for taking a minute. Thanks. It's my pleasure. Always appreciate what you're doing- Appreciate it... and how you're caring for the dealers in the network. We'll, we'll do it. Thanks. Excellent.
- 23:08Glad you're here.All right, we're here at the J.D. Power Auto Forum. I have the one and only Alan Haag. Alan, thanks for catching up a little bit. It's fun to be here with you, Paul.
- 23:19Okay, so a lot of people are thinking and talking about what is happening with dealer valuations with all the tariff talks. A lot of retail uncertainty.
- 23:27Big question is, is that translating to dealer uncertainty about valuations moving forward? So far, it has not translated to any kind of decline in values.
- 23:35We signed four letters of intent in the last week, and the letters that we signed, the values for those stores were at or above our expectations when we started the process. That was well before the tariffs.
- 23:45So I think dealers are looking at these tariffs as some short-term noise that's a little bit confusing. But these dealers have got a long-term perspective.
- 23:54They want these assets not for the next six months or the next two years, but for the next 20 years. So if the right brand comes up in the right market, they're going forward aggressively.
- 24:04I think that's really interesting that more than you expected. Yeah.
- 24:07And when you went into, like, what your, you know, estimate or what you thought it might be worth, was that factoring in a tariff drop or a tariff dip, or was that just standard market and it beat that by 30%?
- 24:18Yeah, no, we weren't valuing any tariffs, uh, into our estimates of dealers before they hired us. So we-- I don't think people were expecting this 25%. Right. No.
- 24:27Um, so we were concerned when we went to market what the impact would be.
- 24:31So far, we haven't had a single client, uh, or any, any buyers back up on a deal, meaning they wanna get out of the deal or they wanna reduce the price.
- 24:40We're having a conversation on one deal that includes an Audi store, but other than that, all the other brands we're representing, people are leaning forward aggressively.
- 24:48I think that says a lot, actually, about how you all do business. 'Cause probably the, the, uh, just like a real estate agent or something, like, when, "What's my home worth," right?
- 24:57The, the temptation to overestimate it to get you excited about doing business with me. You gave, uh, obviously, a conservative estimate, and it even surprised you- Yeah... in, in the midst of that.
- 25:06So I think that says a lot about how you do business. Yeah, the valuations have been hard since t- uh, 2019. In 2019, we did some math.
- 25:14We were 99% accurate in terms of estimating a value to our client and what they received at the closing table in terms of blue sky. Mm.
- 25:22And then we, we got off base during the COVID era because the values went up so fast. Mm-hmm. We couldn't really keep up with the, with the value increasing.
- 25:31Now we're back to more normal times where people are looking at current profits as the best estimate of future profits. So our estimates have gotten more accurate.
- 25:39But what we still don't always have in our minds when we're doing the valuations are the level of confidence on behalf of the buyer. So we'll give you an estimate in January.
- 25:48We may not go to market until March or April or May. So when we get there, that's really what matters, how people are feeling- Right... about the future. At that moment.
- 25:54Yeah, and I think the dealers looked at the amount of money they made in '24, which was not as much as '23 or '22- Right... but still a fortune- Yeah... more than double their profits from 2019.
- 26:05So private buyers in particular have a lot of capital. They like the auto retail business. They haven't lost confidence in its future. They want more stores, especially if it's the right brands in the right markets.
- 26:15Are there any, uh, brands that are, are moving their way to the top in this current market, or is it really a grab bag of what fits for the market and for the potential-- or for the br- specific buyer?
- 26:26I think there's some brands that have been in motion and been strong for a long time, like Toyota, Lexus. They've done a great job navigating the, the transition of powertrains.
- 26:35They have not put their dealers in a tough spot by trying to force them to sell a lot of unprofitable EVs.
- 26:41The Toyota, Lexus are really the top of the food chain in terms of where every dealer would like to have a Toyota store- Of course... Lexus store.
- 26:47In terms of brands that haven't been, you know, the top five or six brands for a long time, I would say Mazda's been a brand that's come up a lot since the pandemic started.
- 26:56Their sales per dealership have gone up more than any other, uh, brand that we track. So that's a little bit of a sleeper, and we're encouraged with the profitability of those stores that we see as well.
- 27:06So, you know, Toyota, Honda, BMW, Mercedes, Lexus, Porsche, all those brands continue to be rock solid. But I would say that Mazda and also Kia's been another brand that dealers are really- Been strong...
- 27:16seeking to acquire. Uh, so what are you saying, last 30 seconds, what are you saying to, to a dealer who is maybe considering selling their store? Is it a good time, or is it a bad time? Which, what should I do?
- 27:26Should I wait a little more, or should I get in right now? It's still an excellent time to sell.
- 27:29I mean, we get the call once a week, couple times a week from people saying, "Hey, I don't own dealerships, but I'd like to have dealerships." [chuckles] Oh, wow.
- 27:36Or people that have dealerships saying, "I want more dealerships." Or a dealer receives an announcement of a store that we sold someplace, and they call us and said, "Why didn't you approach me on that business?"
- 27:44So there's no lack of demand for dealerships. There's some dealership brands that are challenged. You know, Infiniti and Nissan are having a particularly tough, uh, 24 months. Couple, couples.
- 27:54Stellantis has had a tough period, but we're actually seeing the rebound happening there. Oh, that's encouraging.
- 27:58So, so a couple of the letters of intent that we signed are for Stellantis or groups that include Stellantis brands.
- 28:03So I think we'll view, view that as a smart time now to buy Stellantis 'cause it's bottomed out, and it's on the road to recovery. Very good.
- 28:10Well, Alan, thanks for giving us a few minutes, and also, I mean, as always, thanks for serving the industry the way you do. Oh, it's our pleasure to be a part of it. Thanks, Paul. [upbeat music]