Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Nature Abhors a Vacuum & So Does the Rumor Mill
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03This is being recorded.
- 0:05The morning of April 14th for publication on April 15th, there
- 0:11is an NCA Board meeting on.
- 0:13Thursday, April 17th, which I'll get to here in a second.
- 0:18But first I want to start with a quote that is attributed to C North Coat
- 0:23Parkinson, which is that nature abhors a vacuum and so does the rumor mill.
- 0:31Now, the idea behind this is that absence clear information, people
- 0:35tend to fill the gap with speculation.
- 0:38Gossip or rumors.
- 0:40Now, I'm not here to talk about rumors.
- 0:42I'm not here to talk about gossip.
- 0:44I may have a little bit of speculation though, but it's educated,
- 0:47speculation, or educated guests also filled in by some triangulation of
- 0:52conversations I've had in the industry.
- 0:55Conversations I've had with some of my teammates, conversations I've had.
- 0:59With some other folks who used to work at NCUA and or may still work
- 1:03at NCUA relative to the anxiety if you will, that might be there because
- 1:09of NNC a's reorganization and the buyout offers that they have been
- 1:13making the last NCA board meeting.
- 1:16Most of their discussion was a morale based conversation.
- 1:20And so seeing that NCUA has an item to fill a vacuum of information or eliminate
- 1:26a vacuum of information on their agenda this week, I think is a good thing.
- 1:30They're doing a briefing on that.
- 1:31But first, before we get into that, I did a poll in that
- 1:35regard on NNC Wade's agenda.
- 1:38And by the way.
- 1:39I did a podcast recently, kinda walking through what I thought NCUA would do
- 1:43this year and wouldn't do this year.
- 1:45They won't be approving a lot of rules in my opinion, or based
- 1:48on my speculation educated guess they will be doing more briefings.
- 1:53And what happens is when there's nothing for the board to vote on, they
- 1:56go, Hey, what can I brief the world on to show that we are still engaged?
- 2:00And so they picked two good topics.
- 2:02Although one of them based on my poll, is not something that a lot of people
- 2:07are very interested in, but I think it's a good thing that they're doing.
- 2:09So at the board meeting coming up, they are doing a briefing on the inter-agency
- 2:14rule relative to regulatory relief on the California wildfire appraisal
- 2:20rules that NCUA put out along with all the other agencies in January.
- 2:25So they're doing a briefing on that and they're doing a briefing
- 2:28on NCA staff buyout program.
- 2:30I did a poll on this and the the results were as biased as
- 2:35any or were as polar as any.
- 2:40Poll result that I have done here on LinkedIn, but 90% of the people that
- 2:47voted were more interested in NCA staff buyout program, and 10% of the
- 2:52folks that voted were interested in the California wildfire appraisal relief.
- 2:57Now, in that regard I did a follow up.
- 3:01Poll and bear with me as I try and get it to come up here on LinkedIn.
- 3:05Sometimes LinkedIn can be a little wonky.
- 3:09And so the, to, to the poll that I did relative to NC.
- 3:18Staffing downsizing Red as this NCA is downsizing with 12% of
- 3:24staff already accepting buyouts.
- 3:26What percentage of total FTEs do you think will Ultimate NCA will ultimately choose?
- 3:35What's, what percentage of total FTEs do you think will
- 3:39ultimately choose to leave NCUA?
- 3:43How low will they go?
- 3:44The options were 14 to 16% reduction, which 15% of the folks I.
- 3:50Voted for.
- 3:51And by the way, this is probably my most popular poll ever.
- 3:56Next up, 16 to 18% reduction was 16%.
- 4:0118 to 20% reduction was 31%.
- 4:05Throw a lot of numbers at you.
- 4:06Some of you like that.
- 4:07Some of you'll go, ah, stop with the numbers.
- 4:0920% or more, 38%.
- 4:11So the bigger numbers, the bigger options.
- 4:1518 to 20 and the 20 and over were 31 plus 38, almost 70%, 69%.
- 4:22Of the, those who voted thought that it would be at least 18%, 38%
- 4:27thought that it would be at least 20%.
- 4:29So in regards to those numbers I've heard that again, probably along the
- 4:36lines of trying to fill the vacuum for staff and the anxiety that staff has.
- 4:40They are providing a frequent update to NCA staff of how many
- 4:45people have accepted the buyouts.
- 4:48And the last number I heard from last week and I heard it from several sources,
- 4:54was that 145 people had committed and once they commit, they can't un uncommit.
- 5:01And that's probably some things, some details they'll talk about.
- 5:03On Thursday, 145 people had committed to take the early departure.
- 5:08Now that's 12%.
- 5:10I also heard that the powers that be wanted roughly a number in the.
- 5:18Somewhere in the range of two 15 to two 20.
- 5:21And if you look at what that would be, two, two.
- 5:26So let's just pick two 17 for example.
- 5:29Number right in the middle of that range, two 17 divided by 1247 would be 17.4%.
- 5:37NCU a's budget had 1,247 approved FTEs.
- 5:44If someone is hoping for a top end goal of 217, that would leave
- 5:49you 30 bodies over a thousand.
- 5:52And people, people advertise that they'll.
- 5:56Sell a shirt for $9 and 99 cents not $10.
- 6:00One of the theories I've heard is that NCUA would like to get
- 6:03below a thousand employees.
- 6:04So if we assume that one of the rumors I heard was right,
- 6:09that 217 is a goal at the.
- 6:12Board level or very high up level, shall we say, 217 departures that
- 6:18would leave you at 1030 FTEs.
- 6:21How could that number make sense if someone was trying
- 6:23to get below a thousand?
- 6:25It could make sense if there were already 30 vacancies when they started the
- 6:29process and they're under a hiring freeze.
- 6:31So let's assume 1,247.
- 6:34Is the total of FTEs in the budget?
- 6:37Let's assume that there are 30 vacancies and who knows, maybe it's higher.
- 6:42And let's assume that n NCAA's top management is trying
- 6:46to achieve 217 departures.
- 6:48That would get you below a thousand, which is a good soundbite.
- 6:51Good soundbite for, Hey, you should leave us independent.
- 6:54Hey, we went along, so don't tax us.
- 6:57Hey, we're listening to the Trump mandate, that's all.
- 7:01Again, specula speculative me filling in some blanks on how I know NCR works,
- 7:08coupled with some triangulation of some numbers I've heard in the industry and as
- 7:12I said, from from elsewhere within NCUA.
- 7:15So it'll be interesting how the NCUA board approaches this briefing.
- 7:21I.
- 7:22Some of, I think one thing it will reveal will be, was this a unanimous vote
- 7:28to approve this, these buyout offers.
- 7:30If one of the Democrats is comes out, one of the Democrats come, may come out
- 7:36and say, and if I voted against it, I would say, Hey, I didn't vote for this.
- 7:39Here's why.
- 7:40If it passed, at least one of the board members voted for it.
- 7:44I would wanna have a narrative that explained.
- 7:47Why I voted for it.
- 7:49And if I was the chair, I would be wanting to show the Trump administration that I'm
- 7:54taking what they want me to do seriously.
- 7:56And my comments would be in that vein.
- 7:59Now, how do you balance all of those three things while also
- 8:03holding morale high at NCA?
- 8:05It's going to be tough.
- 8:06And who's gonna be at the table for NCA?
- 8:08Most likely Larry fao.
- 8:10Who?
- 8:11Is really good on his feet.
- 8:12It'll be interesting to see how and how Larry, if presuming it is Larry
- 8:17possibly to Tawanda Tawanda Brooks, who is in the acting or permanent
- 8:23deputy executive director position.
- 8:25And who knows, perhaps a few others will be at the table from general
- 8:28counsel, et cetera, et cetera.
- 8:30Alright, it's going to be a delicate balance because one of the things I will
- 8:33say this being a consultant as opposed to being at NCUA, I love the fact that I
- 8:38can say what my opinion is and not having to triangulate on what I think three
- 8:42board members' opinion is what I think the general counsel's opinion is, what I
- 8:45think my staff is, how I keep morale up.
- 8:48And it becomes very difficult to negotiate all those things in your
- 8:51brain when you're figuring out what to say at a public event like this.
- 8:54I'm.
- 8:54I'm going to be listening closely for hints of what
- 8:59this chosen words might mean.
- 9:01And, I've talked in the past about how NCA board meetings are scripted.
- 9:06Oftentimes NCA staff, most often under most board members NCA staff is alerted
- 9:12I'm going to be asked this question.
- 9:13Sometimes the board members will say, if I ask this question, I
- 9:16wanna know what your answer will be.
- 9:18Kyle Halman doesn't seem to operate that way based on what I've heard
- 9:22and based on what I've seen.
- 9:23Questions can come outta left field and have come outta left field.
- 9:27Where he puts people on the spot in some very unique situations.
- 9:31Some of those have been revealing.
- 9:33Some of those have just been awkward.
- 9:35I'm looking forward to see how this plays out and I will be doing a podcast
- 9:39postmortem of whatever they do, say.
- 9:42If it's urgent, I may do it Thursday after the meeting.
- 9:45Otherwise that one will follow next week.
- 9:48Alright, one other thing I wanted to talk about was a listener po tipped me off to
- 9:54an article that I want to walk through.
- 9:57The title is from writers written by David Lauder and Pete Schroeder Bessant
- 10:02says US Treasury to take stronger role in bank regulation easing undue burdens.
- 10:09US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessant.
- 10:11Said on Wednesday his department will play a greater role in banking
- 10:15regulations to better balance costs and benefits and ensure the lenders
- 10:18can finance growth in the US economy.
- 10:21In prepared remarks to an American Bankers Association conference.
- 10:24Bessant called for common sense principles and banking regulations
- 10:28to ease burdens, especially for community banks that have had to
- 10:31deal with rules tailored for larger.
- 10:34Organizations.
- 10:36Bessant said, Tre's, stronger involvement in crafting bank regulations would be
- 10:41achieved through the financial system.
- 10:43Stabi Financial Stability Oversight Council, FS OC, which meets regularly
- 10:48includes the heads of the Federal Reserve and other banking regulators, FYI.
- 10:52That includes NCUA.
- 10:53He also said he would use the president's working group on capital markets.
- 10:57A smaller committee that studies financial trends and has sometimes
- 11:01met during financial crises.
- 11:03Treasury engagement with individual regulators such as the OCC.
- 11:07FDIC is another tool for this.
- 11:10In the past, bank regulators have exercised vast powers on almost
- 11:14every aspect of daily life, but without meaningful accountability
- 11:18to the American people.
- 11:20Be essence said, most glaringly regulation through supervision has too often
- 11:24taken place behind a veil of secrecy that precludes scrutiny by the public.
- 11:29And their elected officials, Bestin remarks were short on specific proposed
- 11:35changes to banking regulations or capital requirements, but he said that the
- 11:38Trump administration would look at the capital buffer framework for large banks
- 11:42to ensure that it's consistent with law and acts as an appropriate backstop.
- 11:48He said that his princip principles for regulation should derive
- 11:51from clear statutory mandate.
- 11:53Including safety and soundness, mitigating risk and consumer protection.
- 11:58Second, regulation should be efficient.
- 12:01That means regulation should strike an appropriate balance
- 12:05between cost and benefit.
- 12:07Adding that regulators themselves needed efficiency in their budget and
- 12:10staffing just talked about how NCA is trying to theoretically achieve
- 12:14that more tailored regulation.
- 12:17Cent said the regulation should be fair and applied evenly across entities.
- 12:21The Treasury Department intends to drive a change in the culture of supervision
- 12:25through improvements to examination procedures, enhanced monitoring of
- 12:29examiner's compliance with those procedures, and more realistic processes
- 12:32for appealing supervisory findings.
- 12:35Perhaps the most consequential step would be to define unsafe and unsound
- 12:39by rule using more objective measures, root rooted in financial risk.
- 12:46He said he would be particularly focused on a more tailored regulation of community
- 12:50banks that have struggled with undue compliance burdens that require heavy
- 12:53investment in technology For the last four decades, wall Street has grown wealthier
- 12:58than ever before, and it can continue to.
- 13:01Grow and do well, peasant said, but for the next four years, its main
- 13:04street's turn to drive investment.
- 13:07Whatever that means.
- 13:08Besson also criticized the Basel Committee's endgame standards,
- 13:12saying that in his opinion, this was not the right starting point
- 13:15For US regulatory modernization, we need to take a different approach.
- 13:19We should not outsource decisions making for the United States
- 13:22to international bodies.
- 13:24Adding that the US should conduct an analysis tailored to its interest,
- 13:28and the US can borrow selectively from the Basel end game standards.
- 13:33All right couple things.
- 13:34NCA does have a table at FS o.
- 13:37What happens is the NCH chair is a member of fs o and a as a reminder
- 13:43in oh 8, 0 9 as a result of, the Great Recession Fsoc was created.
- 13:49One of the things that happened then under the Democratic leadership was that some
- 13:54institutions were named cfi, significantly important financial institutions.
- 13:59Some insurance companies were named that.
- 14:01Then when Republicans got in, they, they took some of those
- 14:04labels off the insurance companies.
- 14:06And that's also when NCOA decided to create ones and say that this was
- 14:11significant to the insurance fund.
- 14:13While we don't have anything significant to the.
- 14:15The economy of the us, if it failed, it would impact the insurance fund.
- 14:19And that's where one's was born.
- 14:21When NCA goes, this is how it used to work.
- 14:23Not sure if this is how it still works.
- 14:25When NCA would go to the FS OC, the would be the one per one board member,
- 14:31the chair, and someone typically from the Economi office would go with them.
- 14:36And, would prepare notes for them, should they be involved in any discussions.
- 14:42But it was very bank focused and it was, I'll say this as nicely as I can.
- 14:48NCA was invited to the table because they needed to be, but they really
- 14:51were much of an afterthought based on my conversations with staff.
- 14:55So they will be at those meetings besson when he refers
- 14:59to other banking regulators.
- 15:00NCOA will be there and will be expected to comply with whatever is done here.
- 15:05The second major point is, I talk a lot about safety and soundness.
- 15:09NCUA uses the hammer of safety and soundness and swings it around pretty
- 15:13aggressively and inconsistently depending on, on, on region, depending
- 15:18on supervisory examiner, depending on examiner, depending on specialist.
- 15:22It's really the wild west.
- 15:23So the be the biggest takeaway from this is that perhaps they could define.
- 15:28Safety and soundness.
- 15:29I think it's a noble goal.
- 15:31Will it happen?
- 15:31Besson has a lot going on right now since he's in charge of tariffs, so
- 15:35I'm not expecting anything here soon.
- 15:36But I like the concept of looking at safety and soundness, making it
- 15:40more defined, less regulation by by.
- 15:44Guidance, less regulation on best practice et cetera, et cetera.
- 15:48So I like what the administration is doing in that regard.
- 15:51It'll be interesting to see what, if anything, will actually come of it.
- 15:55All right.
- 15:55That's it.
- 15:56I appreciate as always, I appreciate you listening.
- 15:59I appreciate the listener who, pointed out be Essence's article here, and if
- 16:02there's something that you see in the press that you'd like me to talk about
- 16:06here on the podcast, shoot me a note and I will take it into consideration.
- 16:10I always like hearing from my listeners, and as always, I
- 16:14hope you'll listen again soon.
- 16:15I thank you for listening today.
- 16:17This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.