Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 27 - Navigating "The Lost Decade" with Steven Wilson
Transcript
- 0:02Hello,
- 0:02Jed.
- 0:03Hey,
- 0:03Andy.
- 0:04How
- 0:04you
- 0:04doing?
- 0:04Good.
- 0:05It's
- 0:05good
- 0:05to
- 0:05see
- 0:05you
- 0:05get
- 0:06to
- 0:06do
- 0:06another
- 0:06one
- 0:06of
- 0:06these
- 0:06in
- 0:07person.
- 0:07Yeah.
- 0:07In
- 0:07Florida,
- 0:08you
- 0:08know,
- 0:09not
- 0:09at
- 0:09a.
- 0:09Bar,
- 0:09but
- 0:10in
- 0:10Florida.
- 0:11It
- 0:11sounds
- 0:11like
- 0:11a
- 0:11bar.
- 0:13It
- 0:13does
- 0:13sound
- 0:13like
- 0:14a
- 0:14bar.
- 0:14Because
- 0:14we're
- 0:14at
- 0:15the
- 0:15national
- 0:16alliance
- 0:16for
- 0:16Public
- 0:17Charter
- 0:17Schools
- 0:17annual
- 0:18conference.
- 0:19And
- 0:19it
- 0:20is
- 0:20kind
- 0:20of
- 0:20an
- 0:21interesting
- 0:21sign
- 0:21of
- 0:21the
- 0:21times.
- 0:22I
- 0:22was
- 0:22walking
- 0:22through
- 0:22the
- 0:22exhibit
- 0:23hall,
- 0:24which
- 0:24is
- 0:24near
- 0:24where
- 0:24we're
- 0:25doing
- 0:25the
- 0:25podcast,
- 0:26and
- 0:26it
- 0:27reminded
- 0:27me
- 0:27of
- 0:27one
- 0:27of
- 0:28the
- 0:28big
- 0:28old
- 0:28line
- 0:29education
- 0:29conferences
- 0:30back
- 0:30in
- 0:31the
- 0:31day.
- 0:31Just
- 0:31the
- 0:31size
- 0:32of
- 0:32the
- 0:32exhibit
- 0:32hall,
- 0:32the
- 0:33volume,
- 0:34the
- 0:34number
- 0:34of
- 0:34vendors
- 0:35and
- 0:35different
- 0:35kinds
- 0:35of
- 0:35products
- 0:36and
- 0:36services
- 0:36for
- 0:36schools.
- 0:37And
- 0:37it's
- 0:37a
- 0:38charter
- 0:38school
- 0:38conference.
- 0:39And
- 0:39you
- 0:39probably
- 0:39wouldn't
- 0:39have
- 0:40predicted
- 0:40that
- 0:4120
- 0:41years
- 0:42ago
- 0:42that
- 0:42this
- 0:42is
- 0:42actually
- 0:43bigger
- 0:43than
- 0:43some
- 0:44of
- 0:44the
- 0:44old
- 0:44line
- 0:44education
- 0:45conferences
- 0:45now.
- 0:46Yeah,
- 0:46real
- 0:47sense
- 0:47of
- 0:47energy.
- 0:47It's
- 0:48really
- 0:48cool.
- 0:49And
- 0:49nice
- 0:49job
- 0:50moderating
- 0:50the
- 0:51panel
- 0:51this
- 0:52morning.
- 0:52You
- 0:52need
- 0:52to
- 0:52thank.
- 0:53Fantastic
- 0:53job.
- 0:54We
- 0:55will,
- 0:55you
- 0:55know,
- 0:55just
- 0:56remind
- 0:56people
- 0:56out
- 0:56of
- 0:56the
- 0:57gate.
- 0:57This
- 0:57is
- 0:57the
- 0:57Wonky
- 0:58Folk
- 0:58podcast
- 0:58with,
- 0:59with
- 0:59Andy
- 0:59Rothram
- 1:00and
- 1:00Jed
- 1:00Wallace.
- 1:01And
- 1:01today
- 1:01we
- 1:02are
- 1:02lucky
- 1:02that
- 1:03we've
- 1:03got
- 1:03Stephen
- 1:03Wilson,
- 1:04who
- 1:05has
- 1:05an
- 1:05amazing
- 1:06background
- 1:06in
- 1:06charter
- 1:07schools
- 1:07for
- 1:07a
- 1:07long
- 1:07time
- 1:07and
- 1:08has
- 1:08written
- 1:08a
- 1:08book,
- 1:09the
- 1:09Lost
- 1:09Decade,
- 1:10which
- 1:10is
- 1:10going
- 1:10to
- 1:10serve
- 1:11as
- 1:11the
- 1:11frame
- 1:11for
- 1:11a
- 1:11lot
- 1:12of
- 1:12our
- 1:12conversation
- 1:12today.
- 1:13Thanks
- 1:14for
- 1:14writing
- 1:14this
- 1:15book
- 1:15and
- 1:16thanks
- 1:16for
- 1:16being
- 1:16a
- 1:17part
- 1:17of
- 1:17this
- 1:17conversation
- 1:17today.
- 1:18Delighted
- 1:18to
- 1:19be
- 1:19with
- 1:19you
- 1:19both.
- 1:19Good
- 1:19to
- 1:20see
- 1:20you
- 1:20guys.
- 1:20Yeah,
- 1:21I
- 1:22was
- 1:22just
- 1:22thinking
- 1:22back.
- 1:23I
- 1:23remember
- 1:23you
- 1:24and
- 1:24I
- 1:24doing
- 1:24a
- 1:24consultancy
- 1:25discussion
- 1:25together
- 1:26that
- 1:26was
- 1:26right
- 1:26when
- 1:27we
- 1:27were
- 1:27in
- 1:27a
- 1:27moment
- 1:28of
- 1:28like,
- 1:29I
- 1:29think,
- 1:30big
- 1:30momentum
- 1:30and
- 1:31a
- 1:31sense
- 1:31of
- 1:31optimism
- 1:32and
- 1:32all
- 1:32that
- 1:32stuff.
- 1:32And
- 1:33so
- 1:33I
- 1:33hope
- 1:33we
- 1:33can
- 1:33dive
- 1:34back
- 1:34into
- 1:34that.
- 1:34It's
- 1:35like,
- 1:35you
- 1:35know,
- 1:35just
- 1:35remembering
- 1:36that
- 1:36moment
- 1:36when
- 1:37the
- 1:37charter
- 1:37school
- 1:38world
- 1:38really
- 1:38felt
- 1:38on
- 1:39stride
- 1:40and
- 1:40we
- 1:41can
- 1:41get
- 1:41back
- 1:41there.
- 1:42Do
- 1:42you
- 1:42want
- 1:42to
- 1:43get
- 1:43us
- 1:43started
- 1:43with
- 1:43our
- 1:43first
- 1:44question
- 1:44or
- 1:44something?
- 1:44Well,
- 1:44why
- 1:44don't
- 1:45we
- 1:45start?
- 1:45This
- 1:45is
- 1:45a
- 1:45question
- 1:46this
- 1:46morning
- 1:47I
- 1:47did.
- 1:47The
- 1:48keynote
- 1:48discussion
- 1:49was
- 1:49with
- 1:49Marlon
- 1:50from
- 1:50the
- 1:51Citi
- 1:51Fund
- 1:51and
- 1:51Nello
- 1:52from
- 1:52DSST
- 1:52in
- 1:53Colorado
- 1:53and
- 1:53Hannah
- 1:54from
- 1:55Daniels.
- 1:55And
- 1:56I
- 1:56asked
- 1:56them
- 1:56like,
- 1:57scale
- 1:571
- 1:57to
- 1:5710
- 1:58with
- 1:581
- 1:58being
- 1:59absolute
- 2:00pessimism
- 2:00and
- 2:0010
- 2:01being
- 2:01total
- 2:01optimism,
- 2:02like
- 2:02where
- 2:03they
- 2:03were
- 2:03on
- 2:03charters
- 2:04and
- 2:04charter
- 2:04schooling.
- 2:04So
- 2:05I'll
- 2:05ask
- 2:05you
- 2:05the
- 2:05same
- 2:05question,
- 2:05one
- 2:06to
- 2:0610,
- 2:06Stephen,
- 2:07like,
- 2:07where
- 2:07are
- 2:08you
- 2:08today?
- 2:08I
- 2:09would
- 2:09say
- 2:09I'm
- 2:09a
- 2:10five,
- 2:11I'm
- 2:11a
- 2:12die
- 2:12hard
- 2:13optimist,
- 2:14but
- 2:15I
- 2:15have
- 2:16a
- 2:16of
- 2:16lot,
- 2:16a
- 2:16lot
- 2:16of
- 2:16worry
- 2:17right
- 2:17now.
- 2:18I
- 2:18think
- 2:18we've
- 2:19lost
- 2:19our
- 2:19focus
- 2:20on
- 2:20instruction,
- 2:21on
- 2:21great
- 2:22teaching,
- 2:23and
- 2:23on
- 2:23academic
- 2:23achievement
- 2:24as
- 2:25the
- 2:25North
- 2:25Star
- 2:25as
- 2:26the
- 2:26raison
- 2:26d'.
- 2:26Etre.
- 2:27And
- 2:27I'm
- 2:28very
- 2:28worried
- 2:28about
- 2:29a
- 2:29scenario
- 2:30which
- 2:30we
- 2:31sink
- 2:32toward
- 2:32the
- 2:32mean
- 2:33and
- 2:33we
- 2:34revert
- 2:34to
- 2:34the
- 2:34mean.
- 2:35Our
- 2:35results
- 2:35are
- 2:35not
- 2:36sufficiently
- 2:36distinguished
- 2:38from
- 2:39the
- 2:39majority
- 2:40system.
- 2:40And
- 2:41at
- 2:41the
- 2:41same
- 2:41time,
- 2:41a
- 2:42lot
- 2:42of
- 2:42energy
- 2:43goes
- 2:43towards
- 2:44private
- 2:44school
- 2:45choice,
- 2:45ESAs
- 2:46and
- 2:46vouchers,
- 2:47and
- 2:47the
- 2:48charter
- 2:48movement
- 2:49is
- 2:49forgotten.
- 2:49Now,
- 2:50that's
- 2:50a
- 2:50dire
- 2:50scenario,
- 2:51but
- 2:51it's
- 2:51one
- 2:52that
- 2:52we
- 2:52should
- 2:52be
- 2:52alert
- 2:53to.
- 2:53I
- 2:53think
- 2:54there's
- 2:55another
- 2:55word.
- 2:57Oh,
- 2:58is
- 2:58that.
- 2:58I
- 2:58want
- 2:58to
- 2:58hear
- 2:59more.
- 2:59Jed
- 2:59and
- 2:59I
- 2:59have
- 2:59a
- 2:59disagreement
- 3:00about
- 3:00this.
- 3:00Yeah,
- 3:00I'm
- 3:01so
- 3:01curious
- 3:01to
- 3:01hear
- 3:01more.
- 3:02But
- 3:02of
- 3:02course,
- 3:02there's
- 3:02another
- 3:03scenario
- 3:04in
- 3:04which
- 3:04we
- 3:05bring
- 3:06the
- 3:06sector's
- 3:07traditional
- 3:09humility,
- 3:10drive
- 3:11assertion,
- 3:12and
- 3:12we
- 3:12say,
- 3:13okay,
- 3:13we
- 3:13made
- 3:13a
- 3:14wrong
- 3:14turn,
- 3:15but
- 3:15we
- 3:15can
- 3:15fix
- 3:16it.
- 3:16We're
- 3:17at
- 3:17mid
- 3:17decade,
- 3:18let's
- 3:18get
- 3:18to
- 3:19it.
- 3:19I
- 3:19just
- 3:19don't
- 3:20know
- 3:20which
- 3:20way
- 3:20we'll
- 3:20go.
- 3:21When
- 3:21you
- 3:22say
- 3:22you're
- 3:22at
- 3:22five,
- 3:23is
- 3:23that.
- 3:23Is
- 3:23that
- 3:23your
- 3:23nadir?
- 3:24Is
- 3:24that
- 3:24as
- 3:24low
- 3:25as
- 3:25it's
- 3:25been
- 3:25and
- 3:25it
- 3:25stayed
- 3:26there,
- 3:26or
- 3:26if
- 3:26you
- 3:26had
- 3:27moments
- 3:27where
- 3:27you
- 3:27felt
- 3:28even
- 3:28lower
- 3:28and
- 3:28there's
- 3:29no
- 3:29kind
- 3:29of
- 3:29rebound
- 3:30whatsoever?
- 3:30This
- 3:31is
- 3:31a
- 3:31low
- 3:31point.
- 3:32Yes.
- 3:32Okay.
- 3:32Yeah,
- 3:33yeah.
- 3:34And.
- 3:35And
- 3:35if
- 3:36you
- 3:36were
- 3:36to
- 3:36broaden
- 3:37the
- 3:38analysis
- 3:39out
- 3:39to
- 3:39where
- 3:40public
- 3:40education
- 3:40is
- 3:42right
- 3:42now,
- 3:43with
- 3:44the
- 3:44implosion
- 3:45after
- 3:45Covid
- 3:45with
- 3:46NAEP
- 3:46scores
- 3:46and
- 3:46the
- 3:47other
- 3:47problems
- 3:47that
- 3:47are
- 3:47out
- 3:48there,
- 3:49what
- 3:50would
- 3:50be
- 3:50your
- 3:50optimism
- 3:51assessment
- 3:52for
- 3:52public
- 3:52education?
- 3:53How
- 3:53low
- 3:53does
- 3:53the
- 3:54scale
- 3:54go?
- 3:54I
- 3:54don't
- 3:55know.
- 3:55I
- 3:55don't
- 3:55know.
- 3:55I
- 3:55mean,
- 3:55because
- 3:56it
- 3:56puts
- 3:56in
- 3:56context,
- 3:56hey,
- 3:57five,
- 3:58let's
- 3:58say
- 3:58a
- 3:58two.
- 3:59And
- 3:59there's
- 3:59a
- 3:59reason
- 4:00for
- 4:00that,
- 4:01which
- 4:01is
- 4:01that
- 4:02the
- 4:02response
- 4:03to
- 4:03the
- 4:03pandemic
- 4:03was
- 4:04very
- 4:04revealing
- 4:05about
- 4:05the
- 4:05majority
- 4:06system.
- 4:06We
- 4:07saw
- 4:07no
- 4:07sense
- 4:08of
- 4:08urgency.
- 4:08And
- 4:09you
- 4:09have
- 4:09to
- 4:09remember,
- 4:09right,
- 4:10the
- 4:10basics
- 4:10were
- 4:11schools
- 4:11closed
- 4:12in
- 4:12March,
- 4:13mid
- 4:13March,
- 4:14and
- 4:14there
- 4:14was
- 4:15very
- 4:15little
- 4:15return
- 4:15or
- 4:16effort
- 4:17to
- 4:17go
- 4:17towards
- 4:18live
- 4:18teaching.
- 4:19Some
- 4:19kids
- 4:19got
- 4:20none
- 4:20at
- 4:20all.
- 4:20You
- 4:20know,
- 4:20the
- 4:21whole
- 4:21story.
- 4:21And
- 4:22then
- 4:22there
- 4:22was
- 4:22big
- 4:23talk
- 4:23about
- 4:24making
- 4:24up
- 4:24learning
- 4:25gaps
- 4:25in
- 4:25lost
- 4:26ground.
- 4:27It
- 4:27was
- 4:27going
- 4:27to
- 4:28be
- 4:29extensive,
- 4:30high
- 4:31dosage
- 4:31tutoring,
- 4:32to
- 4:32use
- 4:32Mike
- 4:33Goldstein's
- 4:33term,
- 4:34et
- 4:34cetera,
- 4:34et
- 4:35cetera.
- 4:35None
- 4:35of
- 4:35those
- 4:36initiatives
- 4:37came
- 4:37to
- 4:37pass.
- 4:38So
- 4:39it
- 4:39really
- 4:39revealed
- 4:40how
- 4:40complacent
- 4:41the
- 4:41majority
- 4:42system
- 4:42is
- 4:43and
- 4:43how
- 4:44impossible
- 4:44it
- 4:45is
- 4:45for
- 4:45them
- 4:45to
- 4:45get
- 4:45out
- 4:46of
- 4:46their
- 4:46own
- 4:46way.
- 4:47So
- 4:47I'm
- 4:48not
- 4:48optimistic
- 4:49about
- 4:49the
- 4:49majority
- 4:49system.
- 4:50One
- 4:51of
- 4:51the
- 4:51things
- 4:51I
- 4:51love
- 4:51about
- 4:51the
- 4:52book
- 4:52is
- 4:52the
- 4:52first
- 4:53three
- 4:53chapters.
- 4:53You
- 4:54go
- 4:54deep
- 4:54on
- 4:55education
- 4:55history,
- 4:56and
- 4:58you
- 4:58also
- 4:58have
- 4:59focus
- 4:59on
- 5:00Massachusetts
- 5:01and
- 5:01places
- 5:01where,
- 5:01hey,
- 5:02maybe
- 5:02we
- 5:02made
- 5:02some
- 5:02progress
- 5:03and
- 5:03then
- 5:04we
- 5:04give
- 5:04up
- 5:04on
- 5:05things.
- 5:05I
- 5:05mean,
- 5:05if
- 5:05we
- 5:05look
- 5:06at
- 5:06NAEP
- 5:06scores,
- 5:07they
- 5:07were
- 5:07collapsing
- 5:08far
- 5:08earlier
- 5:09than
- 5:09Covid
- 5:10came
- 5:10along.
- 5:10By
- 5:102012,
- 5:1113
- 5:12or
- 5:12so,
- 5:13perhaps
- 5:13we
- 5:14had
- 5:15hit
- 5:16our
- 5:16apex.
- 5:18And
- 5:18I
- 5:18bet
- 5:18you
- 5:18we
- 5:19would
- 5:19look
- 5:19at
- 5:19the
- 5:20Massachusetts
- 5:20story
- 5:21as
- 5:21very
- 5:22aligned
- 5:22with
- 5:22that
- 5:23overall
- 5:23NAEP
- 5:24story.
- 5:25How
- 5:25do
- 5:25you,
- 5:26how
- 5:26are
- 5:26you
- 5:27characterizing
- 5:28kind
- 5:28of,
- 5:29you
- 5:29know,
- 5:29our
- 5:29historical
- 5:30efforts
- 5:31and
- 5:31you
- 5:32know,
- 5:32how
- 5:32are
- 5:32you
- 5:32putting,
- 5:33you
- 5:33know,
- 5:33the
- 5:34NAEP
- 5:34story
- 5:34and
- 5:35the
- 5:35other
- 5:35dysfunction
- 5:36in
- 5:36context
- 5:37of
- 5:37that
- 5:37broader
- 5:38history?
- 5:38Yeah,
- 5:39and
- 5:39I'll
- 5:39try
- 5:39to
- 5:39be
- 5:40very
- 5:40brief,
- 5:41which
- 5:41is
- 5:41the
- 5:41book
- 5:42begins
- 5:42with
- 5:43going
- 5:43way
- 5:44back
- 5:44to
- 5:44the
- 5:44turn
- 5:44of
- 5:45the
- 5:45previous
- 5:45century,
- 5:45the
- 5:461890s,
- 5:47a
- 5:48seminal
- 5:48report
- 5:49by
- 5:49the
- 5:49so
- 5:49called
- 5:50Committee
- 5:50of
- 5:50Ten
- 5:51which
- 5:51said,
- 5:52Whoa,
- 5:53every
- 5:53child
- 5:53should
- 5:54have
- 5:54a
- 5:54rich
- 5:55liberal
- 5:55arts
- 5:56education,
- 5:56the
- 5:56kind
- 5:57of
- 5:57education
- 5:57that
- 5:58the
- 5:58affluent
- 5:59have
- 5:59long
- 5:59had.
- 6:00And
- 6:01immediately
- 6:01this
- 6:02proposal
- 6:03was
- 6:03decried
- 6:04as
- 6:04ridiculous,
- 6:05a
- 6:05fantasy
- 6:06by
- 6:06the
- 6:07emerging
- 6:07education
- 6:08professoriate
- 6:09which
- 6:09was
- 6:09just
- 6:09coming
- 6:09into
- 6:10existence.
- 6:11And
- 6:11since
- 6:12then,
- 6:12and
- 6:13that
- 6:13idea
- 6:13was
- 6:13abandoned,
- 6:14just
- 6:14to
- 6:14be
- 6:14clear.
- 6:15And
- 6:15since
- 6:15then
- 6:16we've
- 6:16had
- 6:17a
- 6:17long
- 6:17and
- 6:17sorry
- 6:18procession
- 6:18of
- 6:18anti
- 6:19intellectual
- 6:20reforms
- 6:21that
- 6:21were
- 6:21always
- 6:21advanced
- 6:22in
- 6:22the
- 6:22name
- 6:22of
- 6:23democratizing
- 6:24education,
- 6:25but
- 6:25in
- 6:25fact
- 6:26had
- 6:26the
- 6:26reverse
- 6:26effect,
- 6:27dumbing
- 6:28down
- 6:28education,
- 6:29depriving
- 6:29most
- 6:30students
- 6:31of
- 6:31a
- 6:31rigorous
- 6:32education
- 6:33that
- 6:34as
- 6:34I
- 6:34said,
- 6:35the
- 6:35rich
- 6:36have
- 6:36always
- 6:36obtained.
- 6:37And
- 6:38my
- 6:38book
- 6:38argues
- 6:39that
- 6:39this
- 6:39latest
- 6:39turn
- 6:40of
- 6:40social
- 6:40justice
- 6:41education
- 6:41is
- 6:42merely
- 6:42the
- 6:42latest
- 6:43installment
- 6:44in
- 6:44that
- 6:44procession
- 6:45of
- 6:45anti
- 6:46academic
- 6:46progress
- 6:47reforms.
- 6:48So
- 6:48I
- 6:49think
- 6:49that
- 6:50this
- 6:51is
- 6:51important
- 6:51context.
- 6:52Of
- 6:52course,
- 6:53the
- 6:53brief
- 6:54exception
- 6:55was
- 6:56the
- 6:56educational
- 6:57excellence
- 6:57movement,
- 6:58beginning
- 6:59with
- 6:59the
- 7:00bombshell
- 7:00of
- 7:01the
- 7:01nation
- 7:01at
- 7:01risk
- 7:02and
- 7:02culminating
- 7:03in
- 7:03the
- 7:04federalization
- 7:04of
- 7:05the
- 7:05initiatives
- 7:05across
- 7:06the
- 7:06states
- 7:06to
- 7:06establish
- 7:07education
- 7:08standards
- 7:09and
- 7:09accountability.
- 7:10And
- 7:10I
- 7:11think
- 7:11that
- 7:11a
- 7:11fair
- 7:12reading
- 7:12of
- 7:12that
- 7:13is
- 7:13that
- 7:13we
- 7:14did
- 7:14make
- 7:14some
- 7:14progress,
- 7:15as
- 7:15you
- 7:15said,
- 7:16in
- 7:16the
- 7:16first
- 7:16decade
- 7:17and
- 7:17then
- 7:18we
- 7:18did
- 7:19not
- 7:19sustain
- 7:19it
- 7:20in
- 7:20the
- 7:20second.
- 7:21And
- 7:22people
- 7:22gave
- 7:23up
- 7:23on
- 7:23it,
- 7:24but
- 7:24for
- 7:24the
- 7:24wrong
- 7:24reasons
- 7:25and
- 7:25without
- 7:25the
- 7:26care.
- 7:28They
- 7:28didn't
- 7:28take
- 7:28it
- 7:28apart.
- 7:29They
- 7:29didn't
- 7:29realize
- 7:30how
- 7:30we
- 7:30could
- 7:30fix
- 7:31it.
- 7:31And
- 7:31so
- 7:31I
- 7:31think
- 7:31we've
- 7:32largely
- 7:32lost
- 7:33that
- 7:33as
- 7:34well.
- 7:34The
- 7:35accountability
- 7:35movement.
- 7:36Yeah,
- 7:37well,
- 7:37I
- 7:38mean
- 7:38last.
- 7:39And
- 7:39that's
- 7:39of
- 7:40course
- 7:40very
- 7:40dangerous,
- 7:40Jed,
- 7:41for
- 7:41charters.
- 7:41Right.
- 7:42Because
- 7:42if
- 7:43we
- 7:43don't
- 7:43have
- 7:44the
- 7:44spotlight
- 7:45on
- 7:45performance,
- 7:46schools
- 7:47will
- 7:47revert,
- 7:47including
- 7:48charters,
- 7:49to
- 7:49defining
- 7:50all
- 7:50kinds
- 7:50of
- 7:50other
- 7:51ends
- 7:51for
- 7:52education
- 7:52other
- 7:53than
- 7:53academic
- 7:54excellence.
- 7:54And
- 7:55I
- 7:55think
- 7:55that's
- 7:55what's
- 7:55happening
- 7:55now.
- 7:56And
- 7:56the
- 7:56charter
- 7:56movement
- 7:57early
- 7:57was
- 7:57centered
- 7:58around
- 7:58that
- 7:58idea.
- 7:59Absolutely,
- 7:59excellence.
- 8:00And
- 8:00you
- 8:00know,
- 8:01Matt
- 8:01Candler,
- 8:02famous
- 8:02at
- 8:03famously,
- 8:04I
- 8:04don't
- 8:04want
- 8:04to
- 8:04be
- 8:04part
- 8:04of
- 8:04a
- 8:05movement
- 8:05that,
- 8:06that
- 8:06his
- 8:06motto
- 8:06is
- 8:07we're
- 8:07just
- 8:07going
- 8:07to
- 8:07suck
- 8:07less.
- 8:08Yes.
- 8:08And
- 8:08it
- 8:09was
- 8:09like
- 8:09this,
- 8:09this
- 8:10what
- 8:10you're
- 8:10talking
- 8:10about
- 8:11with
- 8:11sort
- 8:11of
- 8:11the
- 8:11standards
- 8:12movement,
- 8:12Is
- 8:12focus
- 8:13on
- 8:13excellence
- 8:14really
- 8:14was
- 8:14the
- 8:14breeding
- 8:15ground
- 8:15for
- 8:15this
- 8:15first
- 8:16generation
- 8:17of
- 8:17charters
- 8:18that
- 8:18were,
- 8:18you
- 8:19know,
- 8:19just
- 8:19relentlessly
- 8:20focused
- 8:21on
- 8:21outcomes
- 8:22and
- 8:22getting
- 8:22kids.
- 8:23Max
- 8:23handler
- 8:23got
- 8:24up
- 8:24at
- 8:24a.
- 8:24At
- 8:24an
- 8:25event
- 8:25in
- 8:252007
- 8:26or
- 8:27whatever
- 8:27it
- 8:27was,
- 8:28as
- 8:28you
- 8:28say,
- 8:29much
- 8:29like
- 8:29this
- 8:30one,
- 8:30and
- 8:30said,
- 8:31we
- 8:32need
- 8:32to
- 8:32stop
- 8:32creating
- 8:33suck
- 8:33less
- 8:34schools.
- 8:35And
- 8:35that
- 8:35was
- 8:35a
- 8:35bombshell.
- 8:36He's
- 8:36absolutely
- 8:36right.
- 8:37And
- 8:37now
- 8:37I
- 8:37think
- 8:37we're
- 8:38back
- 8:38in
- 8:39that
- 8:39moment
- 8:40that
- 8:40we
- 8:40need
- 8:41to
- 8:41restore
- 8:42the
- 8:42focus
- 8:42on
- 8:43academic
- 8:44outcomes
- 8:44for
- 8:44kids.
- 8:45We're
- 8:45doing
- 8:45kids
- 8:45no
- 8:46favor
- 8:47by
- 8:47sending
- 8:48them
- 8:48to
- 8:48schools
- 8:48that
- 8:49are
- 8:49only
- 8:49incrementally
- 8:50better
- 8:50than
- 8:50the
- 8:51schools
- 8:51around
- 8:51them.
- 8:53I'm
- 8:53known
- 8:53for
- 8:54insufferably
- 8:54long
- 8:55charterfolk
- 8:56posts.
- 8:56I
- 8:56think
- 8:57the
- 8:57longest
- 8:57one
- 8:58I've
- 8:58written
- 8:58in,
- 8:59like,
- 8:59in
- 9:00five
- 9:00years
- 9:00of
- 9:00doing
- 9:00this
- 9:01was
- 9:01at
- 9:01last
- 9:01year's
- 9:02conference
- 9:02when
- 9:03I
- 9:03used
- 9:03the
- 9:03Boston
- 9:04story
- 9:04and
- 9:04I
- 9:05just
- 9:05told
- 9:05the
- 9:05history
- 9:06and
- 9:06I
- 9:06want
- 9:07to
- 9:07see
- 9:07that.
- 9:07And
- 9:08you
- 9:08know,
- 9:08I
- 9:08really,
- 9:08I
- 9:09said
- 9:09that
- 9:09one
- 9:09of
- 9:09the
- 9:09things
- 9:09that
- 9:10drives
- 9:10me
- 9:10crazy
- 9:10is
- 9:11that
- 9:11the
- 9:11charter
- 9:11school
- 9:11world
- 9:12doesn't
- 9:12really
- 9:12understand
- 9:13the
- 9:13D
- 9:14seg
- 9:14cases.
- 9:14And
- 9:15in
- 9:151974,
- 9:16you
- 9:16know,
- 9:17the.
- 9:18Basically
- 9:18the
- 9:19supreme
- 9:19court
- 9:19pulling
- 9:20back
- 9:20from
- 9:21Brown
- 9:21versus
- 9:21Boards
- 9:22separating
- 9:22out
- 9:23the
- 9:25suburban
- 9:25schools
- 9:26from
- 9:26D
- 9:26SEG
- 9:27in
- 9:27Boston
- 9:28and
- 9:28basically
- 9:29how
- 9:29there's
- 9:29been
- 9:29no
- 9:30progress
- 9:30made
- 9:30on
- 9:30reform
- 9:31in
- 9:31Boston
- 9:32schools
- 9:33forever
- 9:34until
- 9:34the
- 9:34charter
- 9:35school
- 9:35movement
- 9:35comes
- 9:35along.
- 9:35Yes.
- 9:36And
- 9:36then
- 9:36you
- 9:36can
- 9:36see
- 9:36in
- 9:37from
- 9:371999
- 9:38to
- 9:38like
- 9:382015,
- 9:3916,
- 9:40something
- 9:40like
- 9:40that,
- 9:41it's
- 9:41the
- 9:41most
- 9:42important
- 9:42thing
- 9:42that's
- 9:42happened
- 9:43in
- 9:43education
- 9:43in
- 9:44Boston,
- 9:45arguably.
- 9:45And
- 9:46please
- 9:46can
- 9:47we.
- 9:47Can
- 9:47we
- 9:47remember
- 9:48that
- 9:48the
- 9:49brookings
- 9:49institution,
- 9:50liberal
- 9:51lion
- 9:52of
- 9:52the
- 9:53think
- 9:53tanks,
- 9:54says
- 9:55the
- 9:55largest
- 9:56educational
- 9:56effects
- 9:57ever
- 9:57seen
- 9:58in
- 9:58the
- 9:59Boston
- 9:59charter
- 9:59schools.
- 10:00So
- 10:01absolutely.
- 10:01And
- 10:02by
- 10:02the
- 10:02way,
- 10:02that
- 10:02has
- 10:03unraveled.
- 10:03And
- 10:04we
- 10:04could
- 10:04talk
- 10:04about
- 10:04that
- 10:05too.
- 10:05And
- 10:05let's.
- 10:06We
- 10:06should
- 10:06talk
- 10:06about
- 10:06that
- 10:07because,
- 10:07I
- 10:07mean,
- 10:07that's
- 10:07the
- 10:07fascinating
- 10:08thing
- 10:08and
- 10:08not
- 10:08a
- 10:09really
- 10:09flattering
- 10:10sort
- 10:10of
- 10:10portrait
- 10:11for
- 10:11the
- 10:11sector.
- 10:12When
- 10:12you
- 10:12say
- 10:13that
- 10:13they're
- 10:13outperforming.
- 10:14We
- 10:14should
- 10:14quite
- 10:14quantify
- 10:15this.
- 10:15It
- 10:15was,
- 10:15you
- 10:15know,
- 10:16180
- 10:16extra
- 10:17days
- 10:17of
- 10:17learning
- 10:18where
- 10:18the
- 10:18effect
- 10:18sizes,
- 10:19which
- 10:19is
- 10:19basically
- 10:20we
- 10:20talk
- 10:20about
- 10:20extended
- 10:21learning
- 10:21time
- 10:22or
- 10:22extending
- 10:22the
- 10:22school
- 10:22year.
- 10:23They're
- 10:23basically
- 10:23doubling
- 10:24the
- 10:24school
- 10:24year.
- 10:24Kids
- 10:25there
- 10:25in
- 10:25the
- 10:25charters
- 10:25were
- 10:25getting
- 10:262
- 10:26for
- 10:261
- 10:27in
- 10:27terms
- 10:27of
- 10:27the
- 10:27amount
- 10:28of
- 10:28instruction
- 10:28that
- 10:28they
- 10:29were
- 10:29getting.
- 10:30And
- 10:30you
- 10:30would
- 10:31think
- 10:31in
- 10:31a
- 10:32situation
- 10:32like
- 10:32that
- 10:32that
- 10:33everybody
- 10:33around
- 10:33the
- 10:33country
- 10:34would
- 10:34descend
- 10:34on
- 10:35Boston
- 10:35to
- 10:36figure
- 10:36out,
- 10:36like,
- 10:36what's
- 10:37going
- 10:37on
- 10:37and
- 10:38that
- 10:38local
- 10:38leaders
- 10:38would
- 10:39be
- 10:39highlighting
- 10:39that.
- 10:40You
- 10:40think
- 10:40of
- 10:40so
- 10:41many
- 10:41other
- 10:41things
- 10:41if
- 10:41you
- 10:42had
- 10:42a
- 10:42cure
- 10:42for
- 10:42a
- 10:43disease
- 10:43or
- 10:44whatever
- 10:44else
- 10:44people
- 10:44would
- 10:45be
- 10:45clocking.
- 10:46And
- 10:46yet,
- 10:46like,
- 10:47not
- 10:47Only
- 10:47did
- 10:47it
- 10:47get
- 10:48no,
- 10:48you
- 10:48know,
- 10:49not
- 10:49a
- 10:49lot
- 10:49of
- 10:49attention
- 10:49outside
- 10:50of
- 10:50places
- 10:50like
- 10:51Brookings.
- 10:52Like,
- 10:52it
- 10:52is
- 10:53faded.
- 10:54It
- 10:55is
- 10:55more
- 10:55than
- 10:56faded.
- 10:56What.
- 10:57What
- 10:57I
- 10:57think
- 10:57people
- 10:58need
- 10:58to
- 10:58understand
- 10:59is
- 10:59that
- 10:59many
- 10:59of
- 10:59those
- 11:00high
- 11:00flying
- 11:01schools
- 11:02are
- 11:02no
- 11:02longer
- 11:03once.
- 11:04And
- 11:04there's
- 11:05a
- 11:05specific
- 11:06dynamic
- 11:06to
- 11:06this.
- 11:07When,
- 11:08when
- 11:09new
- 11:09young
- 11:10graduates
- 11:11came
- 11:12circa
- 11:122000
- 11:13or
- 11:13even
- 11:13earlier
- 11:14to
- 11:15these
- 11:15schools
- 11:15to
- 11:15teach
- 11:16and
- 11:17started
- 11:17calling
- 11:18the
- 11:18founders
- 11:18of
- 11:19the
- 11:19schools
- 11:20their
- 11:20bosses,
- 11:21their
- 11:21principals,
- 11:22white
- 11:23supremacists
- 11:23and
- 11:24racists,
- 11:25and
- 11:25saying
- 11:25that
- 11:26they
- 11:26were,
- 11:26quote,
- 11:26controlling
- 11:27black
- 11:27and
- 11:27brown
- 11:27bodies
- 11:28and
- 11:28all
- 11:28the
- 11:28other
- 11:28accusations
- 11:29that
- 11:29were
- 11:29made.
- 11:30Those
- 11:31founders
- 11:31were
- 11:31already
- 11:32exhausted
- 11:33people.
- 11:33They
- 11:33had
- 11:34given
- 11:34their
- 11:35entire
- 11:36soul
- 11:37every
- 11:37hour
- 11:38of
- 11:38their
- 11:39life
- 11:39to
- 11:40building
- 11:40those
- 11:40schools.
- 11:40And
- 11:41they
- 11:41just
- 11:41said,
- 11:41screw
- 11:42this.
- 11:42I
- 11:42don't
- 11:42know
- 11:42if
- 11:42I'm
- 11:43allowed
- 11:43to
- 11:43use
- 11:43more
- 11:43colorful
- 11:44language
- 11:44on
- 11:44your
- 11:44show.
- 11:44You
- 11:45are
- 11:45on
- 11:45Walking
- 11:45Folk.
- 11:46Anything
- 11:46goes.
- 11:47I'm
- 11:48out
- 11:48of
- 11:48here.
- 11:49And
- 11:49then
- 11:49what
- 11:49happened
- 11:50is
- 11:50that
- 11:50the
- 11:51successor
- 11:51leader.
- 11:52We
- 11:52all
- 11:53know
- 11:53how
- 11:53insanely
- 11:54fragile
- 11:55schools
- 11:55are
- 11:56to
- 11:56their
- 11:56leadership,
- 11:57right?
- 11:58And
- 11:58the
- 11:58successor
- 11:59leaders
- 11:59were
- 12:00either
- 12:00people
- 12:01who
- 12:01were
- 12:01true
- 12:01believers
- 12:02in
- 12:02social
- 12:03justice
- 12:03education
- 12:04and
- 12:04totally
- 12:05changed
- 12:06direction,
- 12:06the
- 12:07results
- 12:07tanked,
- 12:08or
- 12:08they
- 12:08were
- 12:09just
- 12:09looking
- 12:09for
- 12:09comity.
- 12:10They
- 12:10just
- 12:10wanted
- 12:10everyone
- 12:11to
- 12:11get
- 12:11along
- 12:11again.
- 12:13They
- 12:13fared
- 12:13no
- 12:13better.
- 12:14Right.
- 12:14Because
- 12:14you
- 12:14have
- 12:14to
- 12:14stand
- 12:15for
- 12:15something
- 12:15and
- 12:15you
- 12:15have
- 12:15to
- 12:16resolve
- 12:16this
- 12:16is
- 12:16a
- 12:16fundamental
- 12:17conflict
- 12:17over
- 12:18direction.
- 12:18Or
- 12:19in
- 12:19a
- 12:19very
- 12:19small
- 12:20number
- 12:20of
- 12:20cases,
- 12:21those
- 12:21leaders
- 12:22held
- 12:22firm
- 12:23and
- 12:23stayed.
- 12:24Like
- 12:24the
- 12:25Brooks
- 12:25schools.
- 12:26The
- 12:26Brooks
- 12:26schools
- 12:27continue
- 12:27to
- 12:27just
- 12:28kill
- 12:29the
- 12:29sector.
- 12:29They
- 12:29are
- 12:30fantastic
- 12:31because
- 12:31they
- 12:31never
- 12:32let
- 12:32this
- 12:32in
- 12:32the
- 12:32door.
- 12:33They
- 12:33said,
- 12:34we
- 12:34are
- 12:34all
- 12:34about
- 12:35rigorous,
- 12:36rich
- 12:37academics
- 12:37for
- 12:38every
- 12:38child.
- 12:39That's
- 12:39what
- 12:39caring
- 12:41and
- 12:41that's
- 12:41what
- 12:41justice
- 12:42looks
- 12:42like.
- 12:44One
- 12:44of
- 12:44the
- 12:44things
- 12:45that
- 12:45struck
- 12:45me
- 12:45about
- 12:45this,
- 12:46Stephen,
- 12:46I'm
- 12:46interested
- 12:46in,
- 12:47you
- 12:47have
- 12:47experience
- 12:47here.
- 12:48You
- 12:48were
- 12:48leading
- 12:48a
- 12:48school
- 12:49at
- 12:49this
- 12:49time.
- 12:49You
- 12:50have
- 12:50experience
- 12:50with
- 12:51this
- 12:51dynamic.
- 12:52It
- 12:52struck
- 12:53me
- 12:53as
- 12:53a
- 12:53very
- 12:54elite
- 12:54discourse.
- 12:55When
- 12:55you
- 12:55went
- 12:55into
- 12:56communities
- 12:56and
- 12:57you
- 12:57talked
- 12:57to
- 12:57parents,
- 12:58these
- 12:58were
- 12:58not
- 12:58things
- 12:59they
- 12:59were
- 13:00talking
- 13:00about.
- 13:02They
- 13:02liked
- 13:03schools
- 13:03that
- 13:03were
- 13:04orderly
- 13:04in
- 13:04schools
- 13:04that
- 13:05were
- 13:05safe.
- 13:05They
- 13:05liked
- 13:05the
- 13:05focus
- 13:06on
- 13:06academics.
- 13:07They
- 13:07thought
- 13:07getting
- 13:07their
- 13:08kids
- 13:08ready
- 13:08for
- 13:08college
- 13:09was
- 13:10why
- 13:10they
- 13:10had
- 13:10chosen
- 13:11these
- 13:11schools
- 13:12in
- 13:12the
- 13:12first
- 13:12place.
- 13:12Not
- 13:13that
- 13:13it
- 13:13was
- 13:13a
- 13:13system
- 13:13of
- 13:14oppression.
- 13:14They
- 13:14wanted
- 13:15schools
- 13:15are
- 13:15going
- 13:16to
- 13:16propel
- 13:17their
- 13:17kids
- 13:18into
- 13:18college.
- 13:18And
- 13:19so
- 13:19it
- 13:19struck
- 13:19me
- 13:19it
- 13:20was
- 13:20a
- 13:20very
- 13:20sort
- 13:20of
- 13:20elite
- 13:21discourse
- 13:22where
- 13:22it
- 13:23was
- 13:23being
- 13:23done
- 13:23in
- 13:23the
- 13:24name
- 13:24of
- 13:24communities,
- 13:24but
- 13:25it
- 13:25was
- 13:25really
- 13:25education
- 13:26reformers
- 13:27talking
- 13:27to
- 13:27other
- 13:27education
- 13:28reformers.
- 13:29Yes.
- 13:29And
- 13:29this
- 13:29is
- 13:30a
- 13:30point
- 13:30I
- 13:30wish
- 13:30I
- 13:30had
- 13:30made
- 13:31this
- 13:31morning
- 13:32with
- 13:32the
- 13:32network
- 13:33talk.
- 13:34This
- 13:34is
- 13:34exactly
- 13:35right.
- 13:35And
- 13:35of
- 13:36course,
- 13:36one
- 13:36crude
- 13:37measure
- 13:37of
- 13:37that
- 13:37is
- 13:38the
- 13:38parent
- 13:38surveys,
- 13:39which
- 13:39at
- 13:39all
- 13:39These
- 13:39networks
- 13:40were
- 13:4095%,
- 13:4297%
- 13:44approval
- 13:44of
- 13:45what
- 13:45their,
- 13:45their
- 13:45children
- 13:46were
- 13:46getting.
- 13:46Yes,
- 13:47this
- 13:47was
- 13:47always
- 13:48an
- 13:48elite
- 13:49imposition.
- 13:50Parents
- 13:50of
- 13:51these
- 13:51schools,
- 13:51as
- 13:51you
- 13:52said,
- 13:52I
- 13:52couldn't
- 13:52say
- 13:52it
- 13:52better,
- 13:53always
- 13:53wanted
- 13:53rigorous
- 13:54academics.
- 13:55They
- 13:55always
- 13:56wanted
- 13:56a
- 13:57chance
- 13:57to
- 13:57get
- 13:57their
- 13:58kids
- 13:58into
- 13:58college.
- 13:58And
- 13:59they
- 13:59knew
- 13:59that
- 13:59that
- 13:59would
- 13:59take
- 14:00a
- 14:00lot
- 14:00of
- 14:00hard
- 14:00work.
- 14:01So
- 14:01the
- 14:01KIPP
- 14:01slogan,
- 14:02be
- 14:02nice,
- 14:03work
- 14:03hard,
- 14:05that
- 14:05was
- 14:06correct
- 14:06to
- 14:06them.
- 14:07And
- 14:08by
- 14:08the
- 14:08way,
- 14:08it
- 14:08doesn't
- 14:08just
- 14:09start.
- 14:09This
- 14:09elite
- 14:10discourse
- 14:10doesn't
- 14:11just
- 14:11start
- 14:11there.
- 14:11I
- 14:11mean,
- 14:12if
- 14:12we
- 14:12go
- 14:12way
- 14:12back
- 14:13into
- 14:13the
- 14:14early
- 14:1419th
- 14:15century,
- 14:15we
- 14:16have
- 14:16the
- 14:16same
- 14:16thing
- 14:16in
- 14:16the
- 14:17south
- 14:17where
- 14:18black
- 14:18parents
- 14:19after
- 14:20the
- 14:20end
- 14:20of
- 14:21slavery
- 14:21were
- 14:22very
- 14:22clear
- 14:22that
- 14:23they
- 14:23want
- 14:23an
- 14:23academically
- 14:24rich,
- 14:26kind
- 14:26of
- 14:26actually
- 14:27high
- 14:28flying
- 14:29European,
- 14:30almost
- 14:30kind
- 14:31of
- 14:31education.
- 14:32And
- 14:32they
- 14:32were
- 14:32said,
- 14:32oh
- 14:33no,
- 14:33no,
- 14:33you
- 14:33have
- 14:33no
- 14:33use
- 14:34for
- 14:34that.
- 14:34We're
- 14:35going
- 14:35to
- 14:35focus
- 14:36on
- 14:36agricultural
- 14:37training.
- 14:37So
- 14:38there's
- 14:38a
- 14:38long
- 14:38history
- 14:39of
- 14:39denying
- 14:41what
- 14:41black
- 14:42families
- 14:42actually
- 14:43want
- 14:43from
- 14:43schools,
- 14:44which
- 14:45is
- 14:45rigor.
- 14:46So
- 14:47how
- 14:47much
- 14:48was
- 14:48that?
- 14:49A
- 14:49perfect
- 14:49storm.
- 14:50The
- 14:50organizations
- 14:51themselves
- 14:52are
- 14:53pivoting
- 14:53away
- 14:53from
- 14:54practices,
- 14:55values,
- 14:55norms
- 14:56that
- 14:56had
- 14:56gotten
- 14:57that
- 14:57generated
- 14:58these
- 14:58results.
- 14:59And
- 15:00you
- 15:00have
- 15:00Covid,
- 15:01which
- 15:01just
- 15:01simply
- 15:03diminished
- 15:04the
- 15:04amount
- 15:04of
- 15:04supports
- 15:05that
- 15:05we
- 15:05could
- 15:05offer
- 15:05to
- 15:05schools.
- 15:06Anyway,
- 15:06those
- 15:07two
- 15:07things
- 15:07come
- 15:07together
- 15:08and
- 15:08that
- 15:09gives
- 15:09us.
- 15:09Or
- 15:11would
- 15:11you
- 15:11nuance
- 15:12it
- 15:12different
- 15:12than
- 15:12that?
- 15:13It
- 15:13seems
- 15:13like
- 15:13it'd
- 15:13be.
- 15:13I
- 15:14don't
- 15:14think
- 15:14either
- 15:14of
- 15:14us
- 15:14agree
- 15:14with
- 15:15that.
- 15:15Yeah,
- 15:16I
- 15:16don't
- 15:16actually
- 15:17agree
- 15:17with
- 15:17that.
- 15:18No,
- 15:18that's
- 15:18fine.
- 15:19Right.
- 15:20I
- 15:20think
- 15:20in
- 15:21districts,
- 15:22I
- 15:22think
- 15:22Covid
- 15:22had
- 15:23a
- 15:23great
- 15:23deal
- 15:23to
- 15:24do
- 15:24with
- 15:24it.
- 15:24With
- 15:25the
- 15:25further
- 15:25decline.
- 15:26Absolutely.
- 15:28But
- 15:29because
- 15:29for
- 15:29one,
- 15:30they
- 15:30immediately
- 15:31turn
- 15:32to
- 15:32other
- 15:33things
- 15:34like
- 15:35putting
- 15:36in
- 15:36more
- 15:36air
- 15:36conditioning
- 15:37systems
- 15:37and
- 15:38spending
- 15:38obscene
- 15:39amounts
- 15:39of
- 15:39money
- 15:39on
- 15:39stuff
- 15:40like
- 15:40that,
- 15:41which
- 15:41was
- 15:41probably
- 15:41misguided
- 15:42in
- 15:42hindsight,
- 15:42now
- 15:43that
- 15:43we
- 15:43know
- 15:43more
- 15:43about
- 15:43the
- 15:44disease.
- 15:46But
- 15:46they
- 15:46certainly
- 15:47didn't
- 15:47do
- 15:47much
- 15:47about
- 15:47instruction.
- 15:48So
- 15:48I
- 15:48think
- 15:48it's
- 15:48a
- 15:48different
- 15:49story
- 15:49in
- 15:49charters.
- 15:52Covid,
- 15:52I
- 15:52think,
- 15:52was
- 15:53largely
- 15:53immaterial.
- 15:54These
- 15:54schools
- 15:54were
- 15:55already
- 15:56deeply
- 15:57losing
- 15:57their
- 15:57way.
- 15:59The
- 15:59key
- 16:00event
- 16:01on
- 16:01the
- 16:02charter
- 16:02side
- 16:03is
- 16:03George
- 16:04Floyd
- 16:04and
- 16:05the
- 16:05racial
- 16:05reckoning
- 16:06and
- 16:06how
- 16:07the
- 16:07schools
- 16:07responded
- 16:09to
- 16:09the
- 16:09racial
- 16:09reckoning
- 16:10rather
- 16:10than
- 16:10doubling
- 16:11down
- 16:12on
- 16:12what
- 16:12they
- 16:13stood
- 16:13for,
- 16:14which
- 16:14was
- 16:15rigorous
- 16:15academics
- 16:16in
- 16:17service
- 16:17of
- 16:18ending
- 16:18these
- 16:19inequalities
- 16:19that
- 16:20are
- 16:20so
- 16:20pervasive.
- 16:21Instead,
- 16:22they
- 16:22got
- 16:22sucked
- 16:23into
- 16:23a
- 16:23different
- 16:24ideology
- 16:24that
- 16:25proposed
- 16:25a
- 16:25different
- 16:28explanation
- 16:29and
- 16:29solution,
- 16:30which
- 16:30turned
- 16:31out
- 16:31to
- 16:31be
- 16:31incorrect.
- 16:32And
- 16:33I
- 16:33saw,
- 16:33I
- 16:34mean,
- 16:34also,
- 16:34I
- 16:34think
- 16:34this
- 16:34was
- 16:35like,
- 16:35I
- 16:35think
- 16:36it
- 16:36was
- 16:36like
- 16:36things
- 16:36happening
- 16:36on
- 16:37two
- 16:37tracks.
- 16:37There
- 16:37was
- 16:37the
- 16:38sort
- 16:38of
- 16:38erosion
- 16:39of
- 16:39accountability
- 16:39in
- 16:40the
- 16:40post
- 16:40NCLB
- 16:41era.
- 16:41Yes,
- 16:41that's
- 16:41very
- 16:42important.
- 16:42You
- 16:42were
- 16:42starting
- 16:42to
- 16:42see
- 16:42a
- 16:42decline
- 16:43that
- 16:43was
- 16:43happening.
- 16:44And
- 16:44then
- 16:44I
- 16:44think
- 16:45it
- 16:45was
- 16:45more
- 16:45like
- 16:46host
- 16:47Michael
- 16:47Brown
- 16:48even.
- 16:49And
- 16:49then,
- 16:49you
- 16:49know,
- 16:49obviously
- 16:49Trayvon
- 16:50Martin.
- 16:50This
- 16:50was
- 16:51when
- 16:51this
- 16:52got
- 16:52going
- 16:52and.
- 16:53Because
- 16:53people
- 16:53were
- 16:54justifiably
- 16:55horrified.
- 16:56And
- 16:56what
- 16:56was
- 16:56striking
- 16:57to
- 16:57me
- 16:57is
- 16:57you
- 16:57had
- 16:57a
- 16:57lot
- 16:58of
- 16:58people
- 16:58who
- 16:58seem
- 16:58not
- 16:58to
- 16:59have
- 16:59been
- 16:59aware
- 16:59of
- 16:59some
- 17:00of
- 17:00these
- 17:00issues
- 17:00previously,
- 17:01and
- 17:02this
- 17:02had
- 17:02thrust
- 17:02it
- 17:03into
- 17:03the
- 17:03limelight.
- 17:04And.
- 17:04And
- 17:05that's
- 17:05actually
- 17:05a
- 17:05good
- 17:05thing.
- 17:06If
- 17:06you
- 17:06want
- 17:06to,
- 17:06like,
- 17:07we
- 17:07can
- 17:07do
- 17:07chapter
- 17:07and
- 17:08verse
- 17:08on
- 17:08why
- 17:08social
- 17:08media
- 17:09is
- 17:09bad.
- 17:09But
- 17:09that
- 17:10was.
- 17:10That's
- 17:10like
- 17:10a
- 17:10good
- 17:10thing
- 17:11that
- 17:11like
- 17:11people
- 17:11were
- 17:11getting
- 17:12exposed
- 17:12to
- 17:12this.
- 17:12They're
- 17:12like,
- 17:13these
- 17:13things
- 17:13are
- 17:13horrible.
- 17:14And
- 17:14then
- 17:14along
- 17:14came
- 17:15Donald
- 17:15Trump
- 17:15and
- 17:16I
- 17:16sort
- 17:16of
- 17:16saw
- 17:16like
- 17:17after
- 17:17like
- 17:172016,
- 17:182017.
- 17:19That's
- 17:20correct.
- 17:20Is
- 17:20the
- 17:21focus
- 17:21became
- 17:22very
- 17:22political,
- 17:23very
- 17:24signaling
- 17:24to
- 17:25each
- 17:25other.
- 17:25And
- 17:25we
- 17:26could
- 17:26talk
- 17:26more
- 17:26about.
- 17:27Yeah,
- 17:27let
- 17:27me
- 17:27anecdotally
- 17:28just
- 17:28mention
- 17:29going
- 17:29back
- 17:29a
- 17:29few
- 17:30more
- 17:30years
- 17:30when,
- 17:31when
- 17:31my
- 17:31network
- 17:32started
- 17:32ascend
- 17:33in
- 17:332008.
- 17:34Obama
- 17:35was
- 17:35elected
- 17:37that
- 17:37fall,
- 17:37I
- 17:37think.
- 17:38And
- 17:40then
- 17:41what
- 17:41you
- 17:41saw
- 17:42in
- 17:42the
- 17:42first
- 17:43school,
- 17:43and
- 17:43it
- 17:43was
- 17:43just
- 17:44one
- 17:44school
- 17:44then
- 17:46in
- 17:46almost
- 17:46every
- 17:47classroom,
- 17:47was
- 17:47the
- 17:48official
- 17:48portrait
- 17:49of
- 17:50Barack
- 17:50Obama
- 17:51and
- 17:51his
- 17:51two
- 17:52very
- 17:52young
- 17:53girls,
- 17:54who
- 17:54happened
- 17:54to
- 17:54be
- 17:54exactly
- 17:55the
- 17:55same
- 17:55age
- 17:55as
- 17:55our
- 17:56students,
- 17:56which
- 17:56created
- 17:56additional
- 17:57residents.
- 17:58And
- 17:58there
- 17:58was
- 17:58such
- 17:59a
- 17:59strong
- 17:59sense
- 17:59of
- 18:00racial
- 18:00unity
- 18:01and
- 18:01that
- 18:01we
- 18:02were
- 18:02going
- 18:02to
- 18:02do
- 18:02this
- 18:02together
- 18:03as
- 18:03educators,
- 18:04white
- 18:04educators.
- 18:05Of
- 18:05course
- 18:05there
- 18:05was
- 18:05tension,
- 18:06there's
- 18:06always
- 18:06going
- 18:06to
- 18:06be
- 18:07tension
- 18:07around
- 18:08this
- 18:08topic
- 18:09in
- 18:09an
- 18:09urban
- 18:09community
- 18:10like
- 18:10Brownsville,
- 18:11where
- 18:11we
- 18:11were
- 18:11located.
- 18:12But
- 18:12there
- 18:12was
- 18:12a
- 18:12very
- 18:12strong
- 18:13sense
- 18:13of
- 18:13common
- 18:14purpose.
- 18:15When
- 18:15Trump
- 18:16was
- 18:16elected
- 18:17for
- 18:17his
- 18:17first
- 18:18term,
- 18:19this
- 18:19collapse,
- 18:20this
- 18:21fragile
- 18:22sense
- 18:23of
- 18:23optimism
- 18:23was
- 18:24lost.
- 18:25And
- 18:25then
- 18:25in
- 18:26stepped
- 18:27the
- 18:28thinkers
- 18:28of
- 18:29Ibram
- 18:29Kendi
- 18:30and
- 18:31Robin
- 18:31Diangelo,
- 18:33which
- 18:33were
- 18:33then
- 18:33vulgarized
- 18:34in
- 18:34the
- 18:34work
- 18:34of
- 18:35Timo
- 18:35Kuhn,
- 18:36who's
- 18:38basically
- 18:38one
- 18:39pager
- 18:39became
- 18:40the
- 18:40mainstay
- 18:41of
- 18:41all
- 18:42these
- 18:42trainings.
- 18:42And
- 18:43it.
- 18:43And
- 18:43these,
- 18:43you
- 18:44should
- 18:44probably
- 18:44say
- 18:44what
- 18:44that
- 18:44one
- 18:44pager
- 18:45is.
- 18:45I
- 18:45think
- 18:45you
- 18:46follow
- 18:46this,
- 18:46they're
- 18:47going
- 18:47to
- 18:47track.
- 18:47But
- 18:47for
- 18:48listeners.
- 18:48Yes,
- 18:48yes,
- 18:48yes,
- 18:49yes.
- 18:49So
- 18:49the
- 18:50one
- 18:50pager
- 18:50was
- 18:51a
- 18:51document
- 18:51that
- 18:51purported
- 18:52to
- 18:52identify
- 18:53the
- 18:53symptoms
- 18:53of
- 18:54white
- 18:54supremacist
- 18:55culture.
- 18:56And
- 18:57among
- 18:57them
- 18:57were
- 18:58things
- 18:58like
- 18:58objectivity,
- 19:00urgency,
- 19:03worship
- 19:03of
- 19:03the
- 19:03written
- 19:04word
- 19:04was
- 19:04another
- 19:05one.
- 19:05And
- 19:06so
- 19:06across
- 19:06the
- 19:07country,
- 19:07not
- 19:08just
- 19:08in
- 19:08charters,
- 19:08but
- 19:09equally
- 19:09in
- 19:09large
- 19:10districts,
- 19:11this
- 19:11became
- 19:12the
- 19:12mainstay
- 19:14of
- 19:15anti
- 19:15racist
- 19:16trainings.
- 19:17And
- 19:18so
- 19:18it
- 19:18created
- 19:19this
- 19:19very
- 19:19simplistic,
- 19:21derivative,
- 19:22reductive
- 19:23Manichean
- 19:25world
- 19:25in
- 19:26which
- 19:26you
- 19:26were
- 19:27partly,
- 19:28by
- 19:28the
- 19:28way,
- 19:28for
- 19:29social
- 19:29reasons,
- 19:30to
- 19:30obtain
- 19:30social
- 19:31standing
- 19:31in
- 19:32that
- 19:32world,
- 19:33you
- 19:33had
- 19:34to
- 19:35prove
- 19:35that
- 19:35you
- 19:36were
- 19:36more
- 19:36anti
- 19:37racist
- 19:37than
- 19:38your
- 19:38colleague,
- 19:39particularly
- 19:39Your
- 19:39white
- 19:40colleague.
- 19:40So
- 19:41there
- 19:41was
- 19:41this
- 19:41jockeying
- 19:42for
- 19:42social
- 19:43position
- 19:43to
- 19:44take
- 19:44ever
- 19:44more
- 19:45radical
- 19:46views
- 19:47of
- 19:48this
- 19:48idea.
- 19:49And
- 19:50where
- 19:50this
- 19:50perhaps
- 19:51first
- 19:51showed
- 19:51up
- 19:52was
- 19:52in
- 19:53an
- 19:53attack
- 19:53on
- 19:54the
- 19:54disciplinary
- 19:54systems
- 19:55of
- 19:55these
- 19:55schools.
- 19:55And
- 19:56this
- 19:56goes
- 19:56back
- 19:56to
- 19:56what
- 19:57you
- 19:57said
- 19:57earlier.
- 19:58By
- 19:58that
- 19:58point
- 19:59people
- 19:59had
- 19:59completely
- 20:00forgotten
- 20:00where
- 20:01charters
- 20:01began,
- 20:02circa
- 20:031995.
- 20:05There's
- 20:05a
- 20:05wonderful
- 20:05book
- 20:06that
- 20:06I
- 20:06like
- 20:06to
- 20:06hold
- 20:06up,
- 20:07totally
- 20:07obscure,
- 20:08but
- 20:08a
- 20:08former,
- 20:09I
- 20:09think
- 20:09a
- 20:09Daily
- 20:10News
- 20:10reporter,
- 20:11she
- 20:11spent
- 20:12on
- 20:12an
- 20:12education
- 20:13reporter.
- 20:13She
- 20:13spent
- 20:14a
- 20:14year
- 20:14in
- 20:14the
- 20:14New
- 20:14York
- 20:15City
- 20:15schools.
- 20:16And
- 20:16the
- 20:16title
- 20:17is
- 20:17Shut
- 20:17up
- 20:18and
- 20:18Let
- 20:18the
- 20:18Lady
- 20:19Teach.
- 20:19And
- 20:19it
- 20:20has
- 20:20some
- 20:20black
- 20:20and
- 20:20white
- 20:21photographs.
- 20:21And
- 20:22you
- 20:22know
- 20:22the
- 20:22old
- 20:22notion
- 20:23that
- 20:23a
- 20:23photograph
- 20:24says
- 20:24more
- 20:24than
- 20:24a
- 20:25thousand.
- 20:25You
- 20:25look
- 20:25at
- 20:25this
- 20:26picture,
- 20:26it
- 20:26is
- 20:27devastating.
- 20:28Just
- 20:28the
- 20:28physical
- 20:29decay,
- 20:30the
- 20:31broken
- 20:32pencils
- 20:32on
- 20:32the
- 20:33floor,
- 20:33the
- 20:33sense
- 20:34of
- 20:34we
- 20:35don't
- 20:35give
- 20:35a
- 20:35fuck
- 20:35is
- 20:36what
- 20:36it
- 20:36conveys
- 20:38on
- 20:38the
- 20:38part
- 20:39of
- 20:39the
- 20:39teachers
- 20:39is
- 20:40what
- 20:40I'm
- 20:40saying.
- 20:41And
- 20:41so
- 20:41this
- 20:42was
- 20:42the
- 20:42disorder.
- 20:43People
- 20:43think
- 20:44that
- 20:44charters
- 20:45were
- 20:45trying
- 20:45to
- 20:46create
- 20:46safety
- 20:46from
- 20:47gangs.
- 20:47No,
- 20:48they
- 20:48were
- 20:48really
- 20:48trying
- 20:48to
- 20:49address
- 20:49the
- 20:49low
- 20:50level
- 20:50disorders
- 20:51in
- 20:51the
- 20:52classroom
- 20:52that
- 20:53made
- 20:53it
- 20:53impossible
- 20:54to
- 20:54teach
- 20:55and
- 20:55impossible
- 20:55for
- 20:56kids
- 20:56to
- 20:56learn.
- 20:57So
- 20:57people
- 20:57have
- 20:57forgotten
- 20:58that.
- 20:58So
- 20:58what
- 20:58happened
- 20:59then?
- 20:59This
- 21:00attack
- 21:00on
- 21:00no
- 21:01excuses
- 21:01style,
- 21:01discipline.
- 21:02And
- 21:02by
- 21:03the
- 21:03way,
- 21:03the
- 21:03schools
- 21:03had
- 21:03already
- 21:04recognized
- 21:04their
- 21:05excesses
- 21:05at
- 21:05this
- 21:06point
- 21:06and
- 21:06begun
- 21:06to
- 21:07make
- 21:07very
- 21:07important
- 21:07changes
- 21:08in
- 21:09their
- 21:09disciplinary
- 21:09and
- 21:09cultural
- 21:10approaches.
- 21:10But
- 21:11nonetheless,
- 21:12many
- 21:12networks
- 21:13and
- 21:13schools
- 21:13just
- 21:13didn't
- 21:14have
- 21:14anything
- 21:14to
- 21:14replace
- 21:15those
- 21:15approaches
- 21:16with.
- 21:16So
- 21:16they
- 21:16tore
- 21:17out
- 21:17this.
- 21:18Yeah.
- 21:18And
- 21:18discipline
- 21:19completely
- 21:20collapsed.
- 21:21Schools
- 21:21became
- 21:22radically
- 21:23unsafe,
- 21:24like
- 21:24the
- 21:24noble
- 21:25schools,
- 21:25high
- 21:25schools
- 21:26in
- 21:26Chicago.
- 21:27And
- 21:29that
- 21:29was
- 21:29the
- 21:30beginning
- 21:30of
- 21:30the
- 21:30unraveling.
- 21:31Because
- 21:31if
- 21:31you
- 21:31don't
- 21:32have
- 21:32discipline,
- 21:32you
- 21:32can't
- 21:33do
- 21:33anything.
- 21:33Of
- 21:33course,
- 21:34I
- 21:35think
- 21:35that's
- 21:35right.
- 21:36We
- 21:36skipped
- 21:36over,
- 21:37I
- 21:37think
- 21:38probably
- 21:38a
- 21:38lot.
- 21:39But
- 21:39you
- 21:39said,
- 21:40you,
- 21:40you
- 21:40said
- 21:40like
- 21:40it
- 21:40started
- 21:41to
- 21:41become
- 21:41like
- 21:41positioning.
- 21:42And
- 21:42I
- 21:42think
- 21:42like
- 21:42what
- 21:42was
- 21:42happening
- 21:43at
- 21:43this
- 21:43point
- 21:43is
- 21:44like
- 21:44the
- 21:44sort
- 21:45of
- 21:45bipartisan
- 21:46education
- 21:46reform
- 21:46movement
- 21:47had
- 21:47fallen
- 21:47apart
- 21:47and
- 21:48so
- 21:48it
- 21:48was
- 21:49factionalized.
- 21:49This
- 21:50thing
- 21:50we've
- 21:50talked
- 21:50about
- 21:50before
- 21:51and
- 21:51whenever
- 21:51you
- 21:51have
- 21:51that
- 21:51situation,
- 21:52you're
- 21:53going
- 21:53to
- 21:53get
- 21:53your
- 21:53power
- 21:54by
- 21:54being
- 21:55intra
- 21:55factional,
- 21:56more
- 21:56intense.
- 21:57And
- 21:57you're
- 21:57seeing
- 21:58that
- 21:58now
- 21:58in
- 21:59present
- 21:59times
- 21:59with
- 22:00maga,
- 22:00right,
- 22:00where
- 22:00everybody's
- 22:01competing
- 22:01to
- 22:01be
- 22:01more
- 22:02maga.
- 22:02Yeah,
- 22:03Back
- 22:03then
- 22:03it
- 22:03was
- 22:03the
- 22:03Democrats,
- 22:04everybody
- 22:04competing
- 22:05to
- 22:05be
- 22:05more
- 22:06socially
- 22:07justice
- 22:07oriented.
- 22:08And
- 22:09I
- 22:09mean,
- 22:09I
- 22:09think
- 22:10there
- 22:10were
- 22:10some
- 22:10people
- 22:11who.
- 22:11Well,
- 22:12I
- 22:12mean,
- 22:12I
- 22:12think,
- 22:12I
- 22:12think
- 22:12there
- 22:13are
- 22:13people,
- 22:13particularly
- 22:13some
- 22:14white
- 22:14people
- 22:14who
- 22:14looked
- 22:15at
- 22:15that
- 22:15coon
- 22:16list
- 22:16and
- 22:16they
- 22:16credibly
- 22:17believed
- 22:17it.
- 22:17And
- 22:18it's
- 22:18because
- 22:18they
- 22:18had
- 22:18moved
- 22:19through
- 22:19life
- 22:19in
- 22:20a
- 22:20way
- 22:20that
- 22:20they'd
- 22:20never
- 22:21been
- 22:21confronted
- 22:22by
- 22:22this.
- 22:22I
- 22:22remember
- 22:22a
- 22:22conversation
- 22:23with
- 22:23somebody,
- 22:23they're
- 22:23like,
- 22:24perfectionism
- 22:24is
- 22:25a
- 22:25white
- 22:25trait.
- 22:25And
- 22:25I
- 22:25was
- 22:26like,
- 22:26have
- 22:26you
- 22:26ever
- 22:26met
- 22:27like
- 22:27a
- 22:27black
- 22:27United
- 22:27States
- 22:28Marine?
- 22:29And
- 22:29it
- 22:29quickly
- 22:29became
- 22:30clear
- 22:30that
- 22:31actually
- 22:31no,
- 22:31they
- 22:32had
- 22:32not.
- 22:32And
- 22:33you
- 22:33know,
- 22:34but
- 22:34then
- 22:34there
- 22:34was.
- 22:34Other
- 22:34people
- 22:35who
- 22:35were
- 22:35just
- 22:35very
- 22:35cynical
- 22:35about
- 22:36it,
- 22:36who
- 22:36to
- 22:36your
- 22:36point,
- 22:36that
- 22:37was
- 22:37how
- 22:37you're
- 22:37going
- 22:37to.
- 22:37I
- 22:37think
- 22:38we're
- 22:38going
- 22:38to
- 22:38look
- 22:38back
- 22:39on
- 22:39it
- 22:39and
- 22:39just,
- 22:40I
- 22:40mean,
- 22:40just
- 22:41be
- 22:41absolutely
- 22:41astounded
- 22:42that
- 22:42this
- 22:44moment
- 22:44of
- 22:45moral
- 22:45panic
- 22:46occurred
- 22:47and
- 22:47occurred
- 22:48the
- 22:48way
- 22:48it
- 22:48did.
- 22:49Because,
- 22:50you
- 22:51know,
- 22:51as,
- 22:53as
- 22:53people
- 22:53like
- 22:53John
- 22:53McWhorter
- 22:54have
- 22:54said,
- 22:55you
- 22:55know,
- 22:55who
- 22:55wrote
- 22:55the
- 22:55forge
- 22:56of
- 22:56my
- 22:56book,
- 22:57this
- 22:57is
- 22:58just
- 22:58profoundly
- 22:59condescending
- 23:00towards
- 23:01black
- 23:01people.
- 23:01You're
- 23:02taking
- 23:03traits
- 23:03which
- 23:04are
- 23:04considered
- 23:05to
- 23:05be
- 23:05noxious
- 23:06stereotypes
- 23:07of
- 23:07black
- 23:08people
- 23:09and
- 23:09you're
- 23:09turning
- 23:09them
- 23:09on
- 23:10their
- 23:10head.
- 23:11So,
- 23:11for
- 23:11example,
- 23:12punctuality
- 23:14is
- 23:14a
- 23:14white
- 23:15supremacist
- 23:15virtue.
- 23:17Perfection
- 23:17is
- 23:18a
- 23:18white.
- 23:18What,
- 23:19what's
- 23:19the
- 23:19converse
- 23:20of
- 23:20that?
- 23:20What
- 23:21are
- 23:21you
- 23:21saying?
- 23:21Right.
- 23:22And
- 23:23so
- 23:23it's,
- 23:24it's
- 23:24incredible.
- 23:24That
- 23:25put
- 23:25a
- 23:26little
- 23:26more
- 23:26crudely.
- 23:26Yeah,
- 23:27I'm
- 23:27trying
- 23:27not
- 23:27to
- 23:27be.
- 23:28David
- 23:28Duke
- 23:29showed
- 23:29up
- 23:29at
- 23:29your
- 23:30anti
- 23:30racist
- 23:30training
- 23:31and
- 23:31agreed
- 23:31with
- 23:32half
- 23:32of
- 23:32it.
- 23:32You
- 23:32should
- 23:33probably
- 23:33pause
- 23:34and
- 23:34rethink
- 23:35what.
- 23:35It
- 23:35is
- 23:35exactly
- 23:36that
- 23:36you're
- 23:36doing.
- 23:36It
- 23:37was
- 23:37condescending
- 23:38and
- 23:38somewhat.
- 23:39But
- 23:40there
- 23:41was
- 23:41a
- 23:41moral
- 23:41panic
- 23:42on.
- 23:42I
- 23:42agree.
- 23:43We're
- 23:43at
- 23:43a
- 23:43conference
- 23:44of
- 23:44leaders.
- 23:44Steven,
- 23:45I'd
- 23:45be
- 23:45interested
- 23:45in
- 23:45your
- 23:45take.
- 23:46Like,
- 23:46why
- 23:46was
- 23:47this
- 23:47such
- 23:47a
- 23:48failure
- 23:49of
- 23:50leadership?
- 23:51Well,
- 23:51I
- 23:52think.
- 23:52In
- 23:52your
- 23:52view.
- 23:53Yeah,
- 23:53yes,
- 23:53I
- 23:53think
- 23:54that
- 23:54is
- 23:54the
- 23:55question.
- 23:57One
- 23:57is
- 23:57that
- 23:59we
- 23:59were
- 23:59caught
- 24:00up
- 24:01in
- 24:01a
- 24:01genuine
- 24:02and
- 24:02much
- 24:03needed
- 24:04reckoning.
- 24:05Right.
- 24:05I
- 24:05mean,
- 24:05the
- 24:06murder
- 24:06of
- 24:06George
- 24:07Floyd,
- 24:07as
- 24:07you
- 24:07said,
- 24:07coming
- 24:08on
- 24:08a
- 24:08long
- 24:09progression
- 24:11of
- 24:13police
- 24:14violence
- 24:16against
- 24:16black
- 24:17people
- 24:17created
- 24:18an
- 24:19urge,
- 24:20a
- 24:20very
- 24:21broad
- 24:21drive,
- 24:22the
- 24:22largest
- 24:22peaceful
- 24:23protest
- 24:23in
- 24:23American
- 24:24history
- 24:25to
- 24:25address
- 24:25racial
- 24:26injustice.
- 24:27And
- 24:27when
- 24:27something
- 24:28like
- 24:28that
- 24:28happens,
- 24:30the
- 24:30public
- 24:31and
- 24:31the
- 24:32intellectual
- 24:32leadership
- 24:33and
- 24:33the
- 24:33political
- 24:33leadership
- 24:35needs
- 24:35a
- 24:37dogma
- 24:38or
- 24:38a
- 24:38point
- 24:38of
- 24:39view
- 24:39or
- 24:39a
- 24:40prescription
- 24:41to
- 24:43move
- 24:43forward
- 24:43with.
- 24:44And
- 24:44in
- 24:44that
- 24:45void
- 24:46was
- 24:46found
- 24:47the
- 24:47ideas
- 24:48of
- 24:49d'.
- 24:49Angelo.
- 24:50And
- 24:50so
- 24:51that
- 24:51became
- 24:52the
- 24:52solution.
- 24:53Everyone
- 24:54jumped
- 24:54on
- 24:55that
- 24:56without
- 24:56realizing
- 24:56in
- 24:57the
- 24:57charter
- 24:57sector
- 24:58that
- 24:58it
- 24:59was
- 24:59profoundly
- 25:00anti
- 25:00intellectual,
- 25:01profoundly
- 25:02anti
- 25:02achievement
- 25:03and
- 25:03completely
- 25:04at
- 25:04odds
- 25:04with
- 25:04what
- 25:05the
- 25:05whole
- 25:05movement
- 25:06was
- 25:06based
- 25:06on,
- 25:06in
- 25:07my
- 25:07view.
- 25:08And
- 25:08I
- 25:08think
- 25:08we're
- 25:08only
- 25:09now
- 25:09and
- 25:10be
- 25:10realizing
- 25:12that
- 25:12that
- 25:13is
- 25:13what
- 25:13came
- 25:13to
- 25:13pass.
- 25:14I
- 25:14will
- 25:14say
- 25:14that
- 25:14I've
- 25:15only
- 25:15been
- 25:15here
- 25:15for
- 25:1612
- 25:16hours,
- 25:17but
- 25:17I
- 25:17think
- 25:18this,
- 25:18this
- 25:18sector
- 25:18is
- 25:19very
- 25:19dug
- 25:19in
- 25:20and
- 25:20people
- 25:20are
- 25:20very
- 25:21afraid
- 25:21to
- 25:22talk
- 25:22about
- 25:22this.
- 25:22I,
- 25:23I
- 25:24think
- 25:24it's
- 25:25still
- 25:25very
- 25:25present
- 25:26the
- 25:26fear
- 25:26factor
- 25:27is
- 25:27very.
- 25:27See,
- 25:27we
- 25:28haven't
- 25:28talked
- 25:28about
- 25:28the
- 25:29other
- 25:29dimension
- 25:29of
- 25:29this.
- 25:30That
- 25:30part
- 25:30of
- 25:30this.
- 25:31Of
- 25:31this
- 25:32newfound
- 25:32culture
- 25:33was
- 25:34to
- 25:35shame
- 25:35and
- 25:35ostracize
- 25:37and
- 25:37ultimately
- 25:38cancel
- 25:39those
- 25:40who
- 25:40disagreed.
- 25:41So
- 25:41it
- 25:42was
- 25:42an
- 25:42extremely
- 25:43intolerant
- 25:44movement,
- 25:45and
- 25:45that
- 25:46had
- 25:46a
- 25:46lot
- 25:46of
- 25:47people
- 25:47running
- 25:47scared.
- 25:48A
- 25:48lot
- 25:48of
- 25:48people,
- 25:48a
- 25:49lot
- 25:49of
- 25:49great
- 25:49talent
- 25:50just
- 25:50left
- 25:50the
- 25:51sector.
- 25:51We
- 25:51never
- 25:51talk
- 25:51about
- 25:52that.
- 25:52If
- 25:52you
- 25:52look
- 25:52at.
- 25:53We've
- 25:53lost
- 25:53a
- 25:53lot
- 25:54for
- 25:54sure.
- 25:54Talk
- 25:54about
- 25:55it
- 25:55all
- 25:55the
- 25:55time.
- 25:55We
- 25:56got
- 25:56all
- 25:56these,
- 25:56you
- 25:57know,
- 25:57people,
- 25:57their
- 25:58early
- 25:58to
- 25:58mid-50s,
- 26:00where
- 26:00they
- 26:00going.
- 26:00Where
- 26:00they
- 26:01going
- 26:01to
- 26:01spend
- 26:01the
- 26:01rest
- 26:01of
- 26:01their
- 26:01life?
- 26:01Well,
- 26:01they're
- 26:02now
- 26:02doing
- 26:02things
- 26:02like,
- 26:03you
- 26:03know,
- 26:03running
- 26:04a
- 26:04retail
- 26:04operation.
- 26:04I
- 26:05mean,
- 26:05they've
- 26:05just
- 26:05left
- 26:05education
- 26:06because
- 26:07they
- 26:08were
- 26:08shot
- 26:08out
- 26:09of
- 26:09the
- 26:09cannon.
- 26:10And
- 26:10I
- 26:10mean,
- 26:10if
- 26:10you
- 26:10look
- 26:10at
- 26:11network
- 26:11like
- 26:11af,
- 26:12they
- 26:12lost
- 26:13the
- 26:13whole
- 26:15two
- 26:15tiers
- 26:16of
- 26:16the.
- 26:17Of
- 26:17the
- 26:17network's
- 26:18management.
- 26:18And
- 26:18these
- 26:19are
- 26:19people
- 26:20who
- 26:20were
- 26:20stellar.
- 26:21I
- 26:22mean,
- 26:22they
- 26:22were
- 26:23incredibly
- 26:23accomplished
- 26:24and
- 26:24had
- 26:24driven
- 26:25much
- 26:25of
- 26:25the
- 26:25network
- 26:26success.
- 26:26They
- 26:26were
- 26:26just
- 26:27gone.
- 26:27Yeah.
- 26:28So,
- 26:28I
- 26:28mean,
- 26:29I
- 26:29may
- 26:29be
- 26:29worse.
- 26:30Though,
- 26:30than
- 26:30what,
- 26:30Stephen?
- 26:31I
- 26:31think
- 26:33an
- 26:33element
- 26:33of
- 26:33this.
- 26:34You
- 26:34keep
- 26:34talking
- 26:34about
- 26:35these
- 26:35books,
- 26:36and
- 26:36so
- 26:36you've
- 26:37got,
- 26:37you
- 26:37know,
- 26:38Okun
- 26:38coming
- 26:39along,
- 26:39but
- 26:39you've
- 26:39got
- 26:40Kendi
- 26:40and
- 26:40you've
- 26:40got
- 26:41d'.
- 26:41Angelo,
- 26:42and
- 26:42then
- 26:42in
- 26:42academia,
- 26:43you
- 26:44know,
- 26:44you
- 26:44have
- 26:44Crenshaw
- 26:44and
- 26:45Delgado.
- 26:45Yeah,
- 26:46I
- 26:46could
- 26:46actually
- 26:47understand
- 26:47this
- 26:48more
- 26:48if
- 26:48I
- 26:48felt
- 26:48like
- 26:48what
- 26:48we
- 26:49were
- 26:49having
- 26:49at
- 26:49the
- 26:49leadership
- 26:50level
- 26:50was
- 26:50like
- 26:50a
- 26:51vigorous
- 26:51debate
- 26:52about
- 26:52these
- 26:52claims
- 26:53and
- 26:53counterclaims.
- 26:54But
- 26:54I'm
- 26:54struck
- 26:55by
- 26:55how
- 26:56few
- 26:56people
- 26:56are
- 26:57even
- 26:57familiar
- 26:58with
- 26:58the
- 26:58claims
- 26:59in
- 26:59these
- 26:59books.
- 27:00And
- 27:00to
- 27:01some
- 27:01extent,
- 27:01Kendi
- 27:02doesn't
- 27:02agree
- 27:02with
- 27:03Crenshaw
- 27:03and
- 27:03Delgado.
- 27:04There's
- 27:04even
- 27:04disagreements
- 27:05amongst
- 27:05them.
- 27:05But
- 27:06people
- 27:06are
- 27:06not
- 27:06like,
- 27:07we're
- 27:07not
- 27:07having
- 27:08any
- 27:08kind
- 27:08of
- 27:08a
- 27:08debate
- 27:09about
- 27:10power
- 27:10and
- 27:10intolerance.
- 27:11And.
- 27:11And
- 27:12you
- 27:12talk
- 27:12to
- 27:12people
- 27:12who
- 27:13are
- 27:13very
- 27:13strident
- 27:14on
- 27:14this
- 27:14stuff,
- 27:14and
- 27:14you
- 27:14pretty
- 27:15quickly
- 27:15realize
- 27:15they
- 27:15haven't
- 27:16actually,
- 27:17like,
- 27:17read
- 27:18the
- 27:18things
- 27:18that
- 27:19they're
- 27:19claiming.
- 27:19They're
- 27:20telling
- 27:20the
- 27:20rest
- 27:20of
- 27:20us
- 27:21to
- 27:21read
- 27:21Kendi.
- 27:21But
- 27:21it's
- 27:22clear
- 27:22they.
- 27:22They
- 27:22haven't
- 27:23read
- 27:23it.
- 27:23They
- 27:23haven't,
- 27:24like,
- 27:24thought
- 27:24about
- 27:24CRT
- 27:25one
- 27:25way,
- 27:26whether
- 27:26you're
- 27:26for
- 27:26it
- 27:27or
- 27:27against
- 27:27it.
- 27:27They
- 27:27just
- 27:27haven't,
- 27:28like,
- 27:28thought
- 27:28about
- 27:28it.
- 27:28And
- 27:29so
- 27:29as
- 27:29a
- 27:29leadership
- 27:30issue,
- 27:30that's
- 27:31what's
- 27:31sort
- 27:31of
- 27:32striking,
- 27:32is
- 27:32how
- 27:32quickly
- 27:33everybody
- 27:33just
- 27:34got
- 27:34on
- 27:34board
- 27:34with
- 27:35something.
- 27:35I
- 27:35think
- 27:36there's
- 27:36also
- 27:36a
- 27:36lack,
- 27:37a
- 27:37lack
- 27:37of
- 27:38courage,
- 27:39a
- 27:39lack
- 27:39of
- 27:39fortitude
- 27:40among
- 27:41the
- 27:41boards
- 27:41of
- 27:41these
- 27:42organizations.
- 27:43I
- 27:43think
- 27:43that
- 27:43when
- 27:44the
- 27:45mob
- 27:45came,
- 27:45if
- 27:46you
- 27:46will,
- 27:48they
- 27:48didn't
- 27:49say,
- 27:49whoa,
- 27:50stop,
- 27:51let's
- 27:52talk
- 27:52about
- 27:53what
- 27:53our
- 27:54values
- 27:54are
- 27:54and
- 27:55why
- 27:55we're
- 27:55doing
- 27:55this.
- 27:56And
- 27:57part
- 27:57of
- 27:57it
- 27:57was,
- 27:57I
- 27:57mean,
- 27:58it
- 27:58was
- 27:58just
- 27:58like
- 27:58being
- 27:58hit
- 27:58by
- 27:59a
- 27:59tidal
- 27:59wave.
- 27:59I
- 27:59mean,
- 28:00it
- 28:00really
- 28:00was
- 28:00because
- 28:01part
- 28:01of
- 28:02the
- 28:02playbook,
- 28:03and
- 28:03of
- 28:03course
- 28:03this
- 28:03playbook
- 28:04originated
- 28:04on
- 28:05college
- 28:05campuses
- 28:05and
- 28:06then
- 28:06was
- 28:06appropriated
- 28:07in
- 28:07the
- 28:07sector.
- 28:08But
- 28:08part
- 28:08of
- 28:08the
- 28:09playbook
- 28:09was
- 28:09that
- 28:10if
- 28:10you
- 28:11engaged
- 28:11in
- 28:12a
- 28:12traditional
- 28:12form
- 28:13of
- 28:13discourse
- 28:14where
- 28:14you
- 28:14say,
- 28:15I
- 28:15hear
- 28:15you,
- 28:17can
- 28:17we
- 28:17talk
- 28:18about
- 28:18it?
- 28:19You
- 28:19might
- 28:19very
- 28:19well
- 28:20get
- 28:20the
- 28:20response
- 28:20that
- 28:21even
- 28:21you're
- 28:21asking
- 28:22to
- 28:22talk
- 28:22about.
- 28:23It
- 28:24is
- 28:24a
- 28:24form
- 28:25of
- 28:26white
- 28:26supremacist
- 28:27privilege.
- 28:29So
- 28:29if
- 28:29you
- 28:29no
- 28:30longer
- 28:30have
- 28:30civility,
- 28:31if
- 28:31you
- 28:31no
- 28:31longer
- 28:32have
- 28:32discussion,
- 28:34well,
- 28:34you
- 28:34know,
- 28:34then
- 28:35you're
- 28:35stuck.
- 28:36So
- 28:36I,
- 28:36I
- 28:36would
- 28:37place
- 28:37a
- 28:37lot
- 28:37of
- 28:37responsibility
- 28:38at
- 28:38the
- 28:38board
- 28:39and
- 28:39funder
- 28:39levels.
- 28:40They
- 28:40could
- 28:40have,
- 28:41they,
- 28:42they
- 28:42could
- 28:42have
- 28:43stood
- 28:44tall
- 28:44and
- 28:45said,
- 28:46we
- 28:46are
- 28:46committed
- 28:47to
- 28:47a
- 28:48liberal
- 28:48arts
- 28:48education.
- 28:49It
- 28:49involves
- 28:50being
- 28:50able
- 28:50to
- 28:51discuss
- 28:51opposing
- 28:52views
- 28:53with
- 28:53civility
- 28:54so
- 28:54that
- 28:55we
- 28:55can
- 28:55together
- 28:55find
- 28:56the
- 28:56truth.
- 28:56That's
- 28:56not
- 28:57what
- 28:57happened.
- 28:58They
- 28:58just
- 28:58ran
- 28:59for
- 28:59the
- 28:59hills.
- 28:59See,
- 29:00I'm
- 29:00not
- 29:00disputing
- 29:01in
- 29:01any
- 29:01way
- 29:02the
- 29:04general
- 29:05findings
- 29:05that
- 29:05you
- 29:05have.
- 29:06I'm
- 29:06just
- 29:06talking.
- 29:07I
- 29:07think
- 29:07there's
- 29:07a
- 29:07broader
- 29:08context
- 29:08that
- 29:09made
- 29:10the
- 29:10lack
- 29:10of
- 29:10courage
- 29:12possible
- 29:13or
- 29:13resulted
- 29:13in,
- 29:14I
- 29:14think,
- 29:14because
- 29:14the
- 29:15other
- 29:15pieces
- 29:15I
- 29:15would
- 29:15throw
- 29:15in,
- 29:16you
- 29:16talk
- 29:16about,
- 29:17hey,
- 29:17basically,
- 29:18NCLD
- 29:19waning
- 29:19loss
- 29:20of
- 29:21trust
- 29:21in
- 29:22data.
- 29:23So
- 29:23first
- 29:23of
- 29:23all,
- 29:24the
- 29:24story
- 29:25that
- 29:25we
- 29:25have,
- 29:25first
- 29:26of
- 29:26all,
- 29:26in
- 29:26the
- 29:26first,
- 29:26you
- 29:26know,
- 29:27in
- 29:27the
- 29:27first
- 29:27place,
- 29:27hey,
- 29:28our
- 29:28kids
- 29:28are
- 29:28actually
- 29:28doing
- 29:29better
- 29:29academically.
- 29:30We're
- 29:30already
- 29:30starting
- 29:31to
- 29:31recede
- 29:31on,
- 29:31on
- 29:32that,
- 29:32you
- 29:32know,
- 29:32from,
- 29:33from
- 29:33a,
- 29:33from
- 29:33a
- 29:33data
- 29:34perspective,
- 29:34then
- 29:35you've
- 29:35got
- 29:352016,
- 29:36you
- 29:37know,
- 29:37same
- 29:37day
- 29:37that
- 29:37Trump
- 29:38is
- 29:38elected,
- 29:38you
- 29:38have
- 29:39question
- 29:39two
- 29:39goes
- 29:40down
- 29:40in
- 29:40fricking
- 29:41flames,
- 29:42right?
- 29:42And,
- 29:43and,
- 29:43and
- 29:43the
- 29:43message
- 29:44that,
- 29:44you
- 29:44know,
- 29:44the,
- 29:45the
- 29:45unions
- 29:46brought
- 29:46there
- 29:46was
- 29:46it
- 29:46doesn't
- 29:47even
- 29:47matter
- 29:47if
- 29:47charter
- 29:47schools
- 29:48are
- 29:48better.
- 29:48The
- 29:49only
- 29:49thing
- 29:49that's
- 29:49better
- 29:50matters
- 29:50is
- 29:51the
- 29:51growth
- 29:51of
- 29:51charter
- 29:51school
- 29:52supposedly
- 29:53makes
- 29:53all
- 29:53other
- 29:53schools
- 29:54worse,
- 29:54right?
- 29:55And
- 29:55then
- 29:55in
- 29:552017,
- 29:56six,
- 29:56eight
- 29:57months
- 29:57later,
- 29:57for
- 29:58the
- 29:58first
- 29:58time
- 29:58in
- 29:5820
- 29:59something
- 29:59years,
- 30:00the
- 30:00NEA
- 30:00aft
- 30:01come
- 30:01out
- 30:01with
- 30:01their
- 30:01own,
- 30:02with
- 30:02their
- 30:02new
- 30:02charter
- 30:03school
- 30:03policy,
- 30:04which
- 30:04they
- 30:04believe
- 30:05is
- 30:05a
- 30:05new
- 30:05mechanism
- 30:06to
- 30:06attack,
- 30:07attack,
- 30:07attack.
- 30:08At
- 30:08the
- 30:08same
- 30:09time
- 30:09that
- 30:09the
- 30:09Trump
- 30:09thing
- 30:10comes
- 30:10in
- 30:10and
- 30:10all
- 30:11sorts
- 30:11of
- 30:11Trump
- 30:11charter
- 30:12school
- 30:12people
- 30:12are
- 30:12trying
- 30:12to
- 30:13project
- 30:13that
- 30:14they're
- 30:14in
- 30:14some
- 30:14way
- 30:14different
- 30:15from
- 30:15that,
- 30:16from
- 30:16that.
- 30:17And
- 30:17the
- 30:18charter
- 30:18school
- 30:18world
- 30:19hears
- 30:19from
- 30:20our
- 30:20political
- 30:20consultants
- 30:21and
- 30:21others
- 30:22don't
- 30:22say
- 30:22that
- 30:22there's
- 30:23anything
- 30:23different
- 30:23about
- 30:24you.
- 30:24And
- 30:25traditional
- 30:25public
- 30:25schools
- 30:26don't
- 30:26say
- 30:26anything
- 30:27negative
- 30:27about
- 30:28public
- 30:28schools
- 30:28whatsoever.
- 30:29And
- 30:29so
- 30:29we're
- 30:30losing
- 30:30our
- 30:30reason
- 30:31to
- 30:31exist.
- 30:31Yes.
- 30:32When
- 30:32we've
- 30:32lost
- 30:33our
- 30:33reason
- 30:33to
- 30:33exist,
- 30:34then
- 30:34you
- 30:34introduce
- 30:35the
- 30:35contagion
- 30:35that
- 30:36you're
- 30:36talking
- 30:36about.
- 30:37It
- 30:37can
- 30:37now
- 30:38pass
- 30:38through
- 30:38the
- 30:38body,
- 30:39you
- 30:39know,
- 30:39of
- 30:40the
- 30:40movement.
- 30:41We
- 30:41can't.
- 30:41I,
- 30:42and
- 30:42I'm
- 30:42very
- 30:42clear
- 30:42is
- 30:43what
- 30:43Andy
- 30:43thinks
- 30:43about
- 30:44this.
- 30:44I
- 30:44agree
- 30:44with
- 30:45you
- 30:45very
- 30:45strongly
- 30:45this
- 30:46particular
- 30:46point
- 30:47that
- 30:47we
- 30:48stop
- 30:48talking
- 30:48about
- 30:49why
- 30:49we
- 30:49exist
- 30:51with
- 30:51respect
- 30:52to
- 30:52the
- 30:52majority
- 30:53system.
- 30:53And
- 30:54if
- 30:54we
- 30:54stop
- 30:54talking
- 30:55about
- 30:55it
- 30:55and
- 30:55we
- 30:55just
- 30:55say
- 30:55nicey
- 30:56nice
- 30:56things.
- 30:56Right.
- 30:57Yeah.
- 30:57Which
- 30:57is
- 30:57what
- 30:57the
- 30:58PR
- 30:58consultants
- 30:58told
- 30:59everybody
- 30:59to
- 30:59do,
- 31:01we
- 31:01lose
- 31:02our
- 31:02reason
- 31:02for
- 31:03being.
- 31:03And
- 31:04I
- 31:04think
- 31:04that
- 31:04that
- 31:04was
- 31:05a
- 31:05very
- 31:05important
- 31:06mistake.
- 31:07I
- 31:07couldn't
- 31:08agree
- 31:08more.
- 31:08I
- 31:08think
- 31:09this
- 31:09is.
- 31:09We
- 31:09talked
- 31:09about
- 31:09this
- 31:10a
- 31:10little
- 31:10bit
- 31:10this
- 31:10morning,
- 31:10and
- 31:10you
- 31:10and
- 31:11I,
- 31:11I
- 31:11think
- 31:11this
- 31:12differentiation
- 31:13issue
- 31:13for
- 31:13charters
- 31:14is
- 31:14an
- 31:14enormous
- 31:15one.
- 31:15And
- 31:16it's
- 31:16differentiating
- 31:17both
- 31:17with
- 31:17school
- 31:18districts
- 31:18and
- 31:18differentiating
- 31:19with
- 31:19other
- 31:19choice
- 31:19options
- 31:20which
- 31:20are
- 31:20proliferating.
- 31:21And
- 31:21it
- 31:21was
- 31:22very
- 31:22clear
- 31:22early
- 31:22on
- 31:23our
- 31:23point
- 31:23of
- 31:24difference
- 31:24was
- 31:24we're
- 31:25actually
- 31:25going
- 31:25to
- 31:25educate
- 31:26kids
- 31:27demonstrably.
- 31:28We
- 31:29are
- 31:29pro
- 31:29accountability.
- 31:30We're
- 31:31at
- 31:31peace
- 31:31with
- 31:31testing.
- 31:32We
- 31:32know
- 31:32our
- 31:33kids
- 31:33can
- 31:33do
- 31:33it.
- 31:34The
- 31:34end
- 31:34goal
- 31:35is
- 31:35college
- 31:36with
- 31:36such
- 31:36clarity.
- 31:38And
- 31:38we
- 31:38lost
- 31:38all
- 31:39of
- 31:39that
- 31:39in
- 31:39part
- 31:40because
- 31:41as
- 31:41some
- 31:42of
- 31:42these
- 31:42places
- 31:43got
- 31:43larger,
- 31:44they
- 31:44hired
- 31:45mainline
- 31:46communication
- 31:47shops
- 31:48who
- 31:48told
- 31:48them,
- 31:49oh,
- 31:49never
- 31:49criticize
- 31:50the
- 31:50school
- 31:50district.
- 31:51Well,
- 31:51hello,
- 31:51we
- 31:51exist
- 31:52to
- 31:52criticize
- 31:53the
- 31:53school
- 31:53district.
- 31:53Exactly,
- 31:54exactly.
- 31:56And
- 31:56you
- 31:56have
- 31:56this,
- 31:56you
- 31:56know,
- 31:57you.
- 31:57Have
- 31:57the,
- 31:57if
- 31:58nothing's
- 31:58wrong
- 31:58with
- 31:58the
- 31:58school
- 31:59district,
- 31:59why
- 31:59would
- 32:00your
- 32:00kids
- 32:01come
- 32:01to
- 32:01our
- 32:01school?
- 32:02And
- 32:02the
- 32:02perverse
- 32:03irony
- 32:03is
- 32:03this
- 32:03was
- 32:04all
- 32:04being
- 32:04done
- 32:05in
- 32:05an
- 32:05effort.
- 32:05People
- 32:06looked
- 32:06and
- 32:06said,
- 32:07the
- 32:07outcomes
- 32:08of
- 32:08this
- 32:08system
- 32:09are
- 32:09terrible.
- 32:10They're
- 32:10highly
- 32:10inequitable.
- 32:11Opportunity
- 32:12in
- 32:12this
- 32:12country
- 32:12is
- 32:13being
- 32:13allocated
- 32:13by
- 32:13zip
- 32:14code
- 32:14and
- 32:14we
- 32:15can
- 32:15change
- 32:15that.
- 32:15And
- 32:16you
- 32:16had
- 32:16schools.
- 32:16So
- 32:16again,
- 32:17Massachusetts,
- 32:17you
- 32:17had
- 32:18schools
- 32:18opening
- 32:18up
- 32:18reverse
- 32:19achievement
- 32:19gaps
- 32:20where
- 32:20African
- 32:20American
- 32:20kids
- 32:21were
- 32:21outperforming
- 32:22the
- 32:22suburban
- 32:23white
- 32:23kids.
- 32:24And
- 32:24so
- 32:25the
- 32:25perverse
- 32:25irony
- 32:26is
- 32:26this
- 32:26was
- 32:26being
- 32:26done.
- 32:27Taking
- 32:27down
- 32:28a
- 32:28movement
- 32:28that
- 32:28was
- 32:28generating
- 32:29these
- 32:29kinds
- 32:29of
- 32:30results
- 32:30to
- 32:31improve
- 32:31system
- 32:31of.
- 32:32They
- 32:32figured
- 32:32out
- 32:32how
- 32:32to
- 32:33do
- 32:33it.
- 32:33You
- 32:33see,
- 32:33I
- 32:33think
- 32:34we're
- 32:34also
- 32:34losing
- 32:34institutional
- 32:35knowledge
- 32:35now
- 32:36because.
- 32:36Because
- 32:36that
- 32:37particular
- 32:37period
- 32:38from
- 32:38say,
- 32:382006
- 32:40to
- 32:412016
- 32:42was
- 32:43while
- 32:43there
- 32:43was
- 32:44an
- 32:44annoying
- 32:44triumphalist
- 32:46dimension
- 32:46to
- 32:47it,
- 32:47which,
- 32:47Jed,
- 32:47you
- 32:47alluded
- 32:48to
- 32:48earlier,
- 32:48but
- 32:49not
- 32:49by
- 32:49name,
- 32:50but,
- 32:50you
- 32:50know,
- 32:50waiting
- 32:50for
- 32:50Superman
- 32:51and
- 32:51all
- 32:51that,
- 32:52that
- 32:52was
- 32:52excessive.
- 32:53But
- 32:53there
- 32:53was
- 32:54reason
- 32:54to
- 32:54be
- 32:54very
- 32:55proud
- 32:55of
- 32:55what
- 32:56had
- 32:56happened,
- 32:56which
- 32:56is
- 32:57that
- 32:57we
- 32:57had
- 32:58figured
- 32:58out
- 32:58how
- 32:58to
- 32:59scale
- 33:00great
- 33:00schools
- 33:01that
- 33:01have
- 33:01great
- 33:02results.
- 33:02It
- 33:02wasn't
- 33:02just
- 33:02little
- 33:03boutiques
- 33:03anymore.
- 33:04It
- 33:04was
- 33:04at
- 33:05scale.
- 33:05And
- 33:05they
- 33:05were
- 33:06very
- 33:06specific
- 33:07things
- 33:08that
- 33:08the
- 33:09big
- 33:09networks
- 33:09learned
- 33:10how
- 33:10to
- 33:10do
- 33:10and
- 33:11they
- 33:11were
- 33:11deeply
- 33:11curious
- 33:12about
- 33:12each
- 33:12other.
- 33:13They
- 33:13were
- 33:13constantly
- 33:14visiting
- 33:14each
- 33:14other
- 33:15and
- 33:15stealing
- 33:15ideas
- 33:16from
- 33:16each
- 33:16other.
- 33:17And
- 33:17so
- 33:17it's
- 33:18sad
- 33:18because
- 33:18we
- 33:19actually
- 33:19now
- 33:19know,
- 33:19I
- 33:20would
- 33:20submit,
- 33:21how
- 33:21to
- 33:21operate
- 33:23a
- 33:23large
- 33:24system
- 33:24of
- 33:25charters
- 33:25that
- 33:25would
- 33:25produce
- 33:26stellar
- 33:27results.
- 33:27And
- 33:28one
- 33:28more
- 33:28sort
- 33:28of
- 33:29irony,
- 33:29and
- 33:29then
- 33:29we
- 33:29can
- 33:29get
- 33:30onto
- 33:30some
- 33:30of
- 33:30the
- 33:30counterfactuals
- 33:32that
- 33:32you
- 33:32just.
- 33:32I
- 33:32think
- 33:32we
- 33:33just
- 33:33have
- 33:33to
- 33:33call
- 33:33out.
- 33:34All
- 33:34this
- 33:34was
- 33:34happening
- 33:35at
- 33:35a
- 33:35time
- 33:36when
- 33:36non
- 33:36white
- 33:37people
- 33:37were
- 33:37moving
- 33:38towards
- 33:38the
- 33:38Republicans.
- 33:39So
- 33:40this
- 33:40was
- 33:40being
- 33:40done
- 33:40in
- 33:40our
- 33:41sector
- 33:41as
- 33:42we're
- 33:42speaking
- 33:42for
- 33:42the
- 33:42communities
- 33:43were
- 33:44of
- 33:44the
- 33:44street.
- 33:44And
- 33:45what
- 33:45was
- 33:45actually
- 33:45happening
- 33:46is
- 33:46this
- 33:46really
- 33:47profound
- 33:47and
- 33:48hugely
- 33:48consequential
- 33:49shift,
- 33:50electorally
- 33:50speaking,
- 33:51of
- 33:52pretty
- 33:52much
- 33:52everybody
- 33:53who
- 33:53was
- 33:53a
- 33:53non
- 33:53white
- 33:54voter.
- 33:54The.
- 33:55That
- 33:55was
- 33:55where
- 33:56Trump
- 33:56was
- 33:56making
- 33:57gains
- 33:57among
- 33:57all
- 33:58of
- 33:58those
- 33:59demographics.
- 33:59And
- 33:59so
- 34:00while
- 34:00everybody
- 34:01was
- 34:01turned
- 34:01inward
- 34:02in
- 34:02the
- 34:02education
- 34:02sector,
- 34:03ripping
- 34:03each
- 34:03other's
- 34:04faces
- 34:04off.
- 34:04Exactly.
- 34:05You
- 34:05had
- 34:05this
- 34:05big
- 34:06shift
- 34:06happening
- 34:07politically
- 34:07that
- 34:07again,
- 34:08I
- 34:08would
- 34:09say
- 34:09is
- 34:09going
- 34:09to
- 34:09be
- 34:09enormously
- 34:10consequential
- 34:11for
- 34:11the
- 34:11country.
- 34:11But
- 34:11I
- 34:11don't
- 34:12think
- 34:12that.
- 34:12I
- 34:12don't.
- 34:13I
- 34:13think
- 34:13that
- 34:13that
- 34:13shift
- 34:14is
- 34:14enormously
- 34:15consequential.
- 34:15I
- 34:16think
- 34:16there
- 34:16started
- 34:16to
- 34:16be
- 34:17obviously
- 34:17a
- 34:17lot
- 34:17of
- 34:18discussion
- 34:18and
- 34:19analysis
- 34:19of
- 34:20why
- 34:20it
- 34:20occurred.
- 34:21I
- 34:21don't
- 34:21see
- 34:21that
- 34:22happening
- 34:22in
- 34:22the
- 34:22charter
- 34:23sector.
- 34:23Yeah,
- 34:24I
- 34:24think,
- 34:24I
- 34:25mean,
- 34:25you
- 34:25make
- 34:25an
- 34:25argument.
- 34:26Yeah,
- 34:26sorry,
- 34:26go
- 34:26ahead.
- 34:27You
- 34:27can
- 34:27make
- 34:27an
- 34:27argument
- 34:27that
- 34:28the
- 34:28biggest
- 34:28accomplishment
- 34:29of
- 34:29the
- 34:29charter
- 34:29school
- 34:30movement
- 34:30in
- 34:30its
- 34:31first
- 34:3125
- 34:31years
- 34:32or
- 34:32wherever,
- 34:32you
- 34:32know,
- 34:32this
- 34:32receding
- 34:33started
- 34:33to
- 34:33occur
- 34:34was
- 34:34the
- 34:34amassing
- 34:35of
- 34:35people
- 34:37that,
- 34:37that
- 34:37believe
- 34:38this
- 34:38thing
- 34:38could
- 34:39be
- 34:39done.
- 34:39Yeah.
- 34:40And
- 34:40develop
- 34:40the
- 34:41chops
- 34:41to
- 34:41actually
- 34:42get
- 34:42it
- 34:42done.
- 34:43Yes,
- 34:43that's
- 34:43exactly
- 34:44right.
- 34:44We
- 34:44became,
- 34:45I
- 34:45believe,
- 34:45complacent
- 34:46about
- 34:47whether
- 34:47or
- 34:47not
- 34:47the
- 34:48movement
- 34:48is
- 34:48going
- 34:48to
- 34:49be
- 34:49able
- 34:49to
- 34:49keep
- 34:49attracting
- 34:51and
- 34:51keep
- 34:52growing.
- 34:52You
- 34:52know,
- 34:53just
- 34:53generally
- 34:54people's
- 34:55commitment
- 34:55and
- 34:56their
- 34:56expertise
- 34:56in
- 34:57this
- 34:57area.
- 34:57We
- 34:58became,
- 34:58we
- 34:58just
- 34:59became
- 35:00blase
- 35:01about
- 35:01how
- 35:01important
- 35:01Charterfolk
- 35:02was.
- 35:02The
- 35:03reason
- 35:03I
- 35:03made
- 35:03Charterfolk
- 35:04is
- 35:04because,
- 35:04you
- 35:04know,
- 35:04after
- 35:05I
- 35:05left,
- 35:05you
- 35:05know,
- 35:05ccsa
- 35:06and
- 35:06I
- 35:06left
- 35:06at
- 35:07CCSA
- 35:07because
- 35:08of
- 35:08political
- 35:09fights.
- 35:09You
- 35:10know,
- 35:10there
- 35:10is
- 35:11a
- 35:11nuance,
- 35:12but,
- 35:12you
- 35:13know,
- 35:13I
- 35:13had
- 35:13to
- 35:13get
- 35:13out
- 35:13of
- 35:14there
- 35:14for
- 35:14political
- 35:15reasons.
- 35:16And
- 35:16I
- 35:16went
- 35:17on
- 35:17a.
- 35:18A
- 35:18tour
- 35:19and
- 35:19I
- 35:19visited
- 35:1930
- 35:20states
- 35:20across
- 35:20the
- 35:20country
- 35:21and
- 35:23I
- 35:24came
- 35:24back
- 35:24sobered
- 35:25because
- 35:26I
- 35:26would
- 35:26ask
- 35:26people,
- 35:27you
- 35:27know,
- 35:27what
- 35:28is,
- 35:28what
- 35:28is
- 35:28the
- 35:28role
- 35:28of
- 35:29charter
- 35:29schools
- 35:29right
- 35:29now?
- 35:29And
- 35:30I,
- 35:30I
- 35:30came
- 35:30back
- 35:30from
- 35:31those
- 35:31conversations
- 35:31feeling
- 35:31like
- 35:32we
- 35:32had
- 35:32lost
- 35:32any
- 35:33sense
- 35:33of
- 35:33confidence
- 35:33that
- 35:34we
- 35:34were
- 35:34on
- 35:34the
- 35:34right.
- 35:34That
- 35:34is.
- 35:35That
- 35:35is
- 35:35absolutely
- 35:36remarkable.
- 35:36Contrast
- 35:37that
- 35:37with,
- 35:37I
- 35:37can't
- 35:37remember
- 35:38what
- 35:38year
- 35:38it
- 35:38Was.
- 35:38But
- 35:38if
- 35:38I
- 35:39were
- 35:39to
- 35:39guess
- 35:39it
- 35:39was
- 35:39roughly
- 35:402016,
- 35:42when
- 35:43Massachusetts,
- 35:44unable
- 35:45to
- 35:45again
- 35:45raise
- 35:46the
- 35:46cap
- 35:46from
- 35:47the
- 35:47very
- 35:47tiny
- 35:47cap
- 35:48that
- 35:48charters
- 35:48began
- 35:49with
- 35:49in
- 35:491993,
- 35:51instead
- 35:51pass
- 35:52legislation
- 35:53that
- 35:54allowed
- 35:55successful
- 35:56networks
- 35:56that
- 35:57had
- 35:57a
- 35:57strong
- 35:57track
- 35:58record
- 35:58academically
- 35:59to
- 35:59open
- 35:59additional
- 36:00campuses
- 36:02in
- 36:03Boston.
- 36:04And
- 36:04everyone
- 36:05that
- 36:05was
- 36:05invited
- 36:05to
- 36:06do
- 36:06so
- 36:06because
- 36:06of
- 36:06their
- 36:07academic
- 36:07record
- 36:08accepted
- 36:09and
- 36:09within
- 36:10a
- 36:10space
- 36:11of
- 36:12two
- 36:12years
- 36:12had
- 36:13opened
- 36:13additional
- 36:14campuses
- 36:14that
- 36:15were
- 36:15as
- 36:15high
- 36:16performing
- 36:16or
- 36:17higher
- 36:17performing
- 36:18than
- 36:19their
- 36:19original
- 36:19campus.
- 36:20So
- 36:20to
- 36:21me
- 36:21what
- 36:21this
- 36:21showed
- 36:21is
- 36:22that,
- 36:22ah,
- 36:22we
- 36:23can
- 36:23totally
- 36:23scale
- 36:24this.
- 36:24All
- 36:25students
- 36:25in
- 36:25Boston
- 36:26could
- 36:26go
- 36:26to
- 36:26a
- 36:26high
- 36:26performing
- 36:27charter
- 36:27if
- 36:28we
- 36:28had
- 36:28politically
- 36:29the
- 36:29will
- 36:29to
- 36:29do
- 36:29it.
- 36:30So
- 36:30it's
- 36:30not
- 36:31a,
- 36:31it
- 36:31was
- 36:31not
- 36:31a
- 36:32organic
- 36:33or
- 36:33native
- 36:33obstacle
- 36:34to
- 36:35results
- 36:35at
- 36:35scale.
- 36:36It
- 36:36was
- 36:36purely
- 36:36a,
- 36:38a
- 36:38political
- 36:38internal
- 36:39obstacle.
- 36:40So
- 36:40we've
- 36:40lost
- 36:41that.
- 36:41Can
- 36:41we
- 36:41pivot
- 36:42to
- 36:42like,
- 36:42you
- 36:42know,
- 36:42how
- 36:42we,
- 36:42how
- 36:43we
- 36:43dig
- 36:43our
- 36:43way
- 36:43out
- 36:43of
- 36:43this,
- 36:44or
- 36:44did
- 36:44you
- 36:44have
- 36:44another
- 36:44way?
- 36:44No,
- 36:45I
- 36:45think,
- 36:45because
- 36:45I
- 36:46think
- 36:46it's,
- 36:46I
- 36:46mean
- 36:46there's
- 36:46like
- 36:46so
- 36:47much
- 36:47energy
- 36:47at
- 36:47this
- 36:47conference.
- 36:48Like,
- 36:48and
- 36:48I
- 36:49mean
- 36:49again,
- 36:49one
- 36:49of
- 36:49the
- 36:49discouraging
- 36:50things
- 36:50to
- 36:50me
- 36:51is
- 36:51like
- 36:51most
- 36:52of
- 36:52these
- 36:52goals
- 36:52that
- 36:53the
- 36:53goal
- 36:53is,
- 36:53is
- 36:53equity
- 36:54in
- 36:54terms
- 36:54of
- 36:54making
- 36:54sure
- 36:55kids
- 36:55have
- 36:55equal
- 36:55opportunity
- 36:56and
- 36:56have
- 36:56the
- 36:56supports
- 36:57they
- 36:57need
- 36:57to
- 36:57be
- 36:57successful.
- 36:58There's
- 36:59broad
- 36:59support,
- 37:00sort
- 37:00of
- 37:01the
- 37:01value
- 37:01of
- 37:01diversity.
- 37:02This
- 37:02conference
- 37:03that
- 37:03we're
- 37:03at,
- 37:03like
- 37:03speak,
- 37:04speak
- 37:04to
- 37:04that,
- 37:04just
- 37:05the
- 37:05incredible
- 37:06diversity
- 37:06that's
- 37:07here
- 37:07of
- 37:07all
- 37:07kinds.
- 37:08And,
- 37:09and
- 37:09so
- 37:09there's
- 37:10all
- 37:10these
- 37:10shared
- 37:11goals.
- 37:12And
- 37:13yet
- 37:13to
- 37:14what
- 37:14you
- 37:14all
- 37:14said
- 37:14earlier,
- 37:15which
- 37:15I
- 37:15agree
- 37:15with,
- 37:16this
- 37:16sort
- 37:16of
- 37:16ideology
- 37:17has
- 37:18become
- 37:18like
- 37:18very
- 37:19baked
- 37:19in.
- 37:20Like,
- 37:20I
- 37:20don't
- 37:20think
- 37:20it's
- 37:21passed
- 37:21either.
- 37:21I
- 37:21think
- 37:21it's
- 37:22just
- 37:22kind
- 37:22of
- 37:22become
- 37:22baked
- 37:23into
- 37:23the
- 37:23price
- 37:23of
- 37:23things.
- 37:24And
- 37:24that,
- 37:25that's
- 37:25a,
- 37:25that's
- 37:25a
- 37:25troubling
- 37:26thing.
- 37:26So
- 37:26we
- 37:26should
- 37:26talk
- 37:27about
- 37:27like,
- 37:28I
- 37:28think
- 37:28some
- 37:28of
- 37:28the
- 37:28counterfactuals
- 37:29you.
- 37:30Because
- 37:30from
- 37:30that
- 37:30might
- 37:30come
- 37:31some
- 37:31of
- 37:31the
- 37:31lessons
- 37:31on
- 37:32like
- 37:32where
- 37:32to.
- 37:33Yes,
- 37:34yes.
- 37:34And
- 37:35by
- 37:35the
- 37:35way,
- 37:35I
- 37:35think
- 37:35what
- 37:35we'll
- 37:36see
- 37:36now
- 37:37is
- 37:37a
- 37:37lot
- 37:38of
- 37:40silence
- 37:40when
- 37:41these
- 37:41concerns
- 37:41are
- 37:42raised.
- 37:43Say
- 37:43if
- 37:44someone
- 37:44gives
- 37:44a
- 37:44talk,
- 37:44as
- 37:45I
- 37:45did
- 37:45this
- 37:45morning,
- 37:46but
- 37:46then
- 37:46afterwards
- 37:47they
- 37:47come
- 37:47up
- 37:48to
- 37:48you,
- 37:48I
- 37:48wanted
- 37:49just
- 37:49to
- 37:49let
- 37:49you
- 37:49know
- 37:49that
- 37:49I
- 37:50thought
- 37:50what
- 37:50you
- 37:50said
- 37:50was
- 37:50really
- 37:51important.
- 37:51There's
- 37:52a
- 37:52ton
- 37:52of
- 37:52that
- 37:52going.
- 37:55Five
- 37:55of
- 37:55those
- 37:56thank
- 37:57you
- 37:57for
- 37:57good.
- 37:57And
- 37:57not
- 37:57good
- 37:58thank
- 37:58you
- 37:58for
- 37:58saying
- 37:58thank
- 37:58you.
- 37:59But
- 37:59don't
- 37:59tell
- 37:59me
- 37:59when
- 38:00I
- 38:00said
- 38:00this.
- 38:00Yeah,
- 38:00but
- 38:00don't
- 38:00tell
- 38:01me.
- 38:01So
- 38:01I
- 38:01said
- 38:01to
- 38:02this
- 38:02one
- 38:02woman
- 38:02who
- 38:02came
- 38:02up
- 38:03to
- 38:03me
- 38:03after
- 38:03the
- 38:03conference,
- 38:04I
- 38:04mean,
- 38:05after
- 38:05I
- 38:05spoke,
- 38:06well,
- 38:06I
- 38:06wish
- 38:06that
- 38:06you
- 38:07had
- 38:07said
- 38:07that.
- 38:08From
- 38:08the
- 38:08microphone,
- 38:09she
- 38:09said,
- 38:10no,
- 38:10I
- 38:10can't.
- 38:11So
- 38:11it's
- 38:11like,
- 38:11this
- 38:12is
- 38:12where
- 38:12we're
- 38:12at,
- 38:12and
- 38:12this
- 38:13is
- 38:13where
- 38:13we
- 38:13were
- 38:13at
- 38:14five
- 38:14years
- 38:14ago.
- 38:15So
- 38:15I'm
- 38:15not
- 38:15sure
- 38:15we're
- 38:16making
- 38:16any
- 38:16progress
- 38:17on
- 38:17that
- 38:17front,
- 38:17by
- 38:18the
- 38:18way.
- 38:18But
- 38:18to
- 38:19the.
- 38:19To
- 38:19the
- 38:19counterfactual,
- 38:21do
- 38:22you
- 38:22want
- 38:22to
- 38:22introduce
- 38:22this
- 38:22or
- 38:23do
- 38:23you.
- 38:23I
- 38:23mean,
- 38:23I
- 38:23think
- 38:24it's
- 38:24a.
- 38:25Because,
- 38:25I
- 38:25mean,
- 38:25essentially,
- 38:26again,
- 38:26you
- 38:26don't
- 38:27find
- 38:27anyone
- 38:27in
- 38:28this
- 38:28movement,
- 38:30like,
- 38:30saying,
- 38:30like,
- 38:31you
- 38:31know,
- 38:31that,
- 38:32like,
- 38:32what
- 38:32happened
- 38:32to
- 38:32George
- 38:33Floyd
- 38:34was
- 38:34in
- 38:34any
- 38:34way
- 38:35okay,
- 38:36or
- 38:36that,
- 38:36you
- 38:37know,
- 38:37that
- 38:37he
- 38:37shouldn't
- 38:37have
- 38:38been
- 38:38alive
- 38:38the
- 38:39next
- 38:39day
- 38:39after
- 38:39he
- 38:40had
- 38:40interaction
- 38:41with
- 38:41the
- 38:41police.
- 38:41You
- 38:41don't
- 38:41find
- 38:41anybody
- 38:42defending,
- 38:42like
- 38:43people
- 38:43talk
- 38:43about,
- 38:43we're
- 38:44defending
- 38:44systems
- 38:44of
- 38:44oppression.
- 38:45But
- 38:45I
- 38:45think
- 38:45you
- 38:45have
- 38:45to
- 38:45look
- 38:46pretty
- 38:46hard
- 38:47to
- 38:47find
- 38:47anybody
- 38:47who
- 38:47wants
- 38:48to
- 38:48defend
- 38:49system
- 38:49of
- 38:49oppression
- 38:50in
- 38:50this.
- 38:50In
- 38:50this
- 38:50group
- 38:51of
- 38:51people.
- 38:52So
- 38:52the
- 38:53counterfactual
- 38:53is,
- 38:54given
- 38:55that
- 38:55and
- 38:55the
- 38:56basic
- 38:56tenor
- 38:57of
- 38:57this
- 38:57movement,
- 38:58what
- 38:58could
- 38:58have
- 38:59been
- 38:59done
- 38:59differently,
- 39:00wherever
- 39:00you
- 39:01want
- 39:01to
- 39:01date
- 39:01it,
- 39:02from
- 39:022014
- 39:03and
- 39:03Mike
- 39:04Brown
- 39:04or
- 39:04from
- 39:042017
- 39:05and
- 39:06Donald
- 39:06Trump
- 39:06or
- 39:06whatever,
- 39:07what
- 39:07could
- 39:07have
- 39:08been
- 39:08done
- 39:08differently
- 39:09to
- 39:09harness
- 39:09this
- 39:10energy?
- 39:11Different.
- 39:11Well,
- 39:11so
- 39:12I'll
- 39:12throw
- 39:13something
- 39:13out.
- 39:13I
- 39:14would
- 39:14say
- 39:14that
- 39:15in
- 39:152020,
- 39:16with
- 39:16the
- 39:16beginning
- 39:17of
- 39:17the
- 39:17racial
- 39:17reckoning,
- 39:18we
- 39:18could
- 39:18have
- 39:19all
- 39:19done
- 39:19what
- 39:20we
- 39:20did,
- 39:20which
- 39:20was
- 39:20to
- 39:21look
- 39:21at
- 39:21these
- 39:22yawning
- 39:23and
- 39:23persistent
- 39:24inequities
- 39:24across
- 39:25whatever
- 39:25measure
- 39:26you
- 39:26want,
- 39:26whether
- 39:27it
- 39:27be
- 39:27income,
- 39:27net
- 39:28worth,
- 39:28educational
- 39:29attainment,
- 39:29et
- 39:30cetera,
- 39:30et
- 39:30cetera,
- 39:31and
- 39:31say,
- 39:31this
- 39:31cannot
- 39:32stand.
- 39:32So
- 39:32that's
- 39:33what
- 39:33we
- 39:33did.
- 39:33That's
- 39:33good.
- 39:34That's
- 39:34the
- 39:34starting
- 39:34point.
- 39:35It
- 39:35was
- 39:35terribly
- 39:36necessary.
- 39:37And
- 39:37then
- 39:37in
- 39:38the
- 39:38school
- 39:38community,
- 39:38we
- 39:39could
- 39:39have
- 39:39said,
- 39:41we
- 39:41are
- 39:42going
- 39:42to
- 39:44turn
- 39:44to
- 39:46academic
- 39:46excellence.
- 39:47We're
- 39:47no
- 39:47longer
- 39:48going
- 39:48to
- 39:48tolerate
- 39:50that
- 39:50most
- 39:50students
- 39:51from
- 39:51poverty
- 39:52are
- 39:52sitting
- 39:53in
- 39:54ineffective
- 39:54classrooms
- 39:55and
- 39:55demonstrably
- 39:56not
- 39:57learning
- 39:57and
- 39:58come
- 39:58out
- 39:58of
- 39:5813
- 39:59years
- 40:00of
- 40:00formal
- 40:00education
- 40:01and
- 40:01can't
- 40:02write
- 40:02a
- 40:02coherent
- 40:03paragraph,
- 40:03because
- 40:04that's
- 40:04where
- 40:04we
- 40:04were
- 40:04then
- 40:05and
- 40:05that's
- 40:05where
- 40:05we
- 40:05are
- 40:06still
- 40:06are
- 40:06today.
- 40:07And
- 40:07that
- 40:08is
- 40:08why,
- 40:08of
- 40:08course,
- 40:08community
- 40:09colleges
- 40:09have
- 40:10to
- 40:10spend
- 40:10an
- 40:10enormous
- 40:11amount
- 40:11of
- 40:11effort
- 40:12simply
- 40:13getting
- 40:13students
- 40:13the
- 40:14remedial
- 40:15education
- 40:15to
- 40:16be
- 40:16able
- 40:16to
- 40:16function
- 40:16at
- 40:17a
- 40:17pseudo
- 40:17college
- 40:18level.
- 40:20So
- 40:21if
- 40:21we
- 40:21had,
- 40:21for
- 40:21example,
- 40:23paid
- 40:23attention
- 40:23to
- 40:24that
- 40:24magnificent
- 40:26TNTP
- 40:27report,
- 40:27whose
- 40:28name
- 40:28I
- 40:28will
- 40:28forget,
- 40:29which
- 40:29looked
- 40:30at
- 40:32the
- 40:32instructional
- 40:33tasks
- 40:34that
- 40:34are
- 40:34being
- 40:34put
- 40:35before
- 40:35kids,
- 40:35I
- 40:36think
- 40:36it's
- 40:36such
- 40:36a
- 40:36brilliant
- 40:36way
- 40:37of.
- 40:37At
- 40:37looking.
- 40:37Looking
- 40:37at
- 40:37it.
- 40:37You
- 40:38know,
- 40:38every
- 40:38class
- 40:39is
- 40:39basically,
- 40:40kids
- 40:40are
- 40:40being
- 40:40asked
- 40:40to
- 40:41do
- 40:41something.
- 40:42What
- 40:42are
- 40:42they
- 40:43being
- 40:43asked
- 40:43to
- 40:43do?
- 40:44And
- 40:45is
- 40:45it
- 40:45at
- 40:46grade
- 40:46level
- 40:47or
- 40:47is
- 40:47it
- 40:48markedly
- 40:48below
- 40:49grade
- 40:49level
- 40:49or
- 40:50above
- 40:50grade
- 40:50level.
- 40:51And
- 40:51what
- 40:51they
- 40:52found
- 40:52is
- 40:53that
- 40:53this
- 40:53is
- 40:53a
- 40:53problem
- 40:54of
- 40:54going
- 40:55back
- 40:55to
- 40:55the
- 40:56Bush
- 40:57expression.
- 40:59It
- 41:00is
- 41:00the
- 41:01soft
- 41:02bigotry
- 41:02of
- 41:02low
- 41:02expectation.
- 41:03Low
- 41:03expectations.
- 41:04The
- 41:04soft
- 41:04bigotry
- 41:05of
- 41:05low
- 41:05expectation.
- 41:06They
- 41:06were
- 41:06being
- 41:06given
- 41:07consistently
- 41:08tasks
- 41:09that
- 41:09are
- 41:09way
- 41:09below
- 41:10what
- 41:10they
- 41:11were
- 41:11capable
- 41:11of
- 41:12doing.
- 41:12So
- 41:13that
- 41:13was
- 41:13a
- 41:13diagnosis
- 41:14and
- 41:14at
- 41:14the
- 41:15same
- 41:15time
- 41:15a
- 41:15prescription.
- 41:16We
- 41:16need
- 41:17to
- 41:17ensure
- 41:17that
- 41:17every
- 41:18child
- 41:19has
- 41:19in
- 41:19front
- 41:19of
- 41:20them
- 41:20educationally
- 41:21well
- 41:22constructed
- 41:23tasks
- 41:23that
- 41:24are
- 41:24demonstrably
- 41:25educationally,
- 41:26instructionally
- 41:27effective
- 41:28and
- 41:29are
- 41:29pitched
- 41:30at
- 41:31the
- 41:31level
- 41:32that
- 41:32is
- 41:32challenging
- 41:33and
- 41:33respectful
- 41:34of
- 41:34where
- 41:35they
- 41:35are.
- 41:35And
- 41:36that's
- 41:36not
- 41:36what
- 41:36we
- 41:36did.
- 41:37Had
- 41:37we
- 41:37done
- 41:38that,
- 41:38had
- 41:38we
- 41:38been
- 41:39consumed
- 41:40with
- 41:40fixing
- 41:41instructional
- 41:42quality,
- 41:42we
- 41:43would
- 41:43have
- 41:43been
- 41:44way
- 41:45on
- 41:45the
- 41:45way
- 41:46towards
- 41:48educational
- 41:49equity
- 41:49and
- 41:50I
- 41:50would
- 41:50argue
- 41:50towards
- 41:51much
- 41:51larger
- 41:51forms
- 41:52of
- 41:52equity.
- 41:52But
- 41:53we
- 41:53didn't
- 41:53do
- 41:53that.
- 41:53And
- 41:54the
- 41:54interesting
- 41:54thing
- 41:54is
- 41:54that
- 41:55is,
- 41:55and
- 41:55it
- 41:55was
- 41:55actually,
- 41:56we
- 41:56should
- 41:56note,
- 41:56it
- 41:56was
- 41:57Dick
- 41:57Riley,
- 41:57who
- 41:58was
- 41:58Clinton
- 41:58Secretary
- 41:58of
- 41:59Education,
- 41:59came
- 42:00up
- 42:00with
- 42:00like
- 42:00the
- 42:00tyranny
- 42:01of
- 42:01low
- 42:01expectations
- 42:02or
- 42:02something.
- 42:02Bush
- 42:02flipped
- 42:03it
- 42:03to
- 42:03soft
- 42:04bigotry.
- 42:04Both
- 42:04are
- 42:05fantastic
- 42:05phrases
- 42:06to
- 42:06describe
- 42:07this,
- 42:07which
- 42:07I
- 42:07think,
- 42:07and
- 42:07you
- 42:08talk
- 42:08a
- 42:08little
- 42:08bit
- 42:08in
- 42:08the
- 42:08book,
- 42:09it's
- 42:09sort
- 42:09of
- 42:09a
- 42:09palliative
- 42:10approach
- 42:10to
- 42:11education
- 42:11rather
- 42:12than
- 42:12an
- 42:12academic
- 42:13one.
- 42:13Yes,
- 42:13but
- 42:14this
- 42:14is
- 42:14happening
- 42:15now.
- 42:15When
- 42:15you
- 42:15look
- 42:15at
- 42:15the
- 42:16NAEP
- 42:16data,
- 42:16I
- 42:16think
- 42:16one
- 42:17of
- 42:17the
- 42:17things
- 42:17everybody
- 42:17throws
- 42:17their
- 42:18hands
- 42:18up
- 42:18and
- 42:18says,
- 42:18well,
- 42:18the
- 42:19NAEP
- 42:19data
- 42:19is
- 42:19all
- 42:19terrible
- 42:20and
- 42:20it's
- 42:21not
- 42:21great,
- 42:21but
- 42:22it's
- 42:22also
- 42:22not
- 42:22even.
- 42:23There
- 42:23are
- 42:23states
- 42:23that
- 42:23are
- 42:24making
- 42:24progress
- 42:24and
- 42:24they're
- 42:25basically
- 42:25doing
- 42:26what
- 42:26you're
- 42:26talking
- 42:27about.
- 42:27They're
- 42:27using
- 42:28high
- 42:28quality
- 42:28instructional
- 42:29materials.
- 42:29They're
- 42:30really
- 42:30serious
- 42:30about
- 42:30reading
- 42:31and
- 42:31increasingly
- 42:31math.
- 42:32They're
- 42:32doing
- 42:32all
- 42:32these
- 42:33things.
- 42:33And,
- 42:34and
- 42:34let
- 42:34me
- 42:34just
- 42:34name
- 42:35two
- 42:35others.
- 42:35They're
- 42:36to
- 42:36your
- 42:36point,
- 42:37Andy,
- 42:37they're,
- 42:37they're
- 42:38putting
- 42:38in.
- 42:39We've
- 42:39at
- 42:39last
- 42:40won
- 42:40the
- 42:40war
- 42:41on
- 42:42phonics.
- 42:42Right.
- 42:43On
- 42:43science
- 42:44of
- 42:44reading.
- 42:45They're
- 42:45ensuring
- 42:45that
- 42:46all
- 42:46children
- 42:47are
- 42:47given
- 42:47a
- 42:48scientifically
- 42:48competent
- 42:49early
- 42:50phonics
- 42:50instruction
- 42:51so
- 42:51they
- 42:51can
- 42:51become
- 42:52decoders.
- 42:53That's
- 42:53great,
- 42:53but
- 42:53that's
- 42:54only
- 42:54the
- 42:54start.
- 42:55Now
- 42:55these
- 42:55states
- 42:56that
- 42:56you're
- 42:56describing
- 42:57recognize
- 42:58that
- 42:58knowledge
- 42:58is
- 42:59not
- 42:59a
- 42:59skill.
- 43:00I
- 43:00mean
- 43:00reading
- 43:01comprehension
- 43:01is
- 43:01not
- 43:01a
- 43:02skill.
- 43:02It's
- 43:02the
- 43:02accretion
- 43:04of
- 43:04exposure
- 43:04to
- 43:05knowledge.
- 43:05And
- 43:05they're
- 43:05trying
- 43:06to
- 43:06put
- 43:06in
- 43:06place
- 43:06knowledge
- 43:07rich
- 43:07curriculum.
- 43:08So
- 43:08they
- 43:08are
- 43:08bright
- 43:08spots.
- 43:09The
- 43:09other
- 43:10bright
- 43:10spot
- 43:10I
- 43:10would
- 43:10suggest
- 43:11are
- 43:12high
- 43:13performing
- 43:13charters
- 43:14that
- 43:15never
- 43:15made
- 43:16the
- 43:16move
- 43:16away
- 43:16from
- 43:16this
- 43:17stuff
- 43:17like
- 43:17Brook,
- 43:18like
- 43:18success,
- 43:18like
- 43:19classical.
- 43:20And
- 43:20I
- 43:20would
- 43:20also
- 43:20say
- 43:21today
- 43:22a
- 43:22lot
- 43:22of
- 43:22these
- 43:22classical
- 43:23focused
- 43:24charter
- 43:24schools
- 43:25that
- 43:25are
- 43:26unabashedly
- 43:27pro
- 43:29great
- 43:30literature,
- 43:31ambitious
- 43:31literature.
- 43:32These,
- 43:33these
- 43:33People
- 43:33are
- 43:33killing
- 43:34it.
- 43:34Yeah.
- 43:35I
- 43:35mean,
- 43:36like,
- 43:36yes.
- 43:36Is
- 43:37still
- 43:37nailing
- 43:37it.
- 43:37DSST
- 43:38looks
- 43:38pretty
- 43:39dang
- 43:39good.
- 43:39Harmony
- 43:40schools.
- 43:40I've
- 43:41been
- 43:41to
- 43:41a
- 43:41lot
- 43:41of
- 43:41Harmony
- 43:42schools.
- 43:42Every
- 43:42single
- 43:43one
- 43:43of
- 43:43them.
- 43:43Yeah.
- 43:44You
- 43:44know,
- 43:44they
- 43:44got
- 43:44a
- 43:44lot
- 43:44of
- 43:45good
- 43:45stuff
- 43:45going
- 43:45on.
- 43:45So
- 43:46there
- 43:46is.
- 43:46There
- 43:47is
- 43:47a
- 43:47base
- 43:47of
- 43:47schools
- 43:48that
- 43:48I
- 43:48think
- 43:49did
- 43:49not
- 43:49get
- 43:49completely
- 43:50knocked
- 43:50off
- 43:50their
- 43:50moorings.
- 43:51That's
- 43:51right.
- 43:51I
- 43:51mean,
- 43:51one
- 43:52other
- 43:52thing
- 43:52I
- 43:52would
- 43:52put
- 43:53out
- 43:53there
- 43:53as
- 43:53far
- 43:53as,
- 43:53you
- 43:54know,
- 43:54counterfactual.
- 43:55And
- 43:55I
- 43:55have
- 43:55this
- 43:55experience
- 43:56at
- 43:56CCSA
- 43:57when
- 43:57we
- 43:58hired
- 43:58a
- 43:58lot
- 43:58of
- 43:58young
- 43:59progressive
- 43:59people
- 44:00to
- 44:00be
- 44:00our
- 44:01parent
- 44:01organizers
- 44:02working
- 44:02to
- 44:03win
- 44:03Los
- 44:03Angeles
- 44:03Unified
- 44:04School
- 44:04Board
- 44:04races.
- 44:04And
- 44:04we
- 44:05won.
- 44:06But
- 44:06what
- 44:06I
- 44:07noticed
- 44:07when
- 44:07we
- 44:07brought
- 44:08these
- 44:08young
- 44:08people
- 44:08in
- 44:09is
- 44:09they
- 44:09were
- 44:10very
- 44:10progressive,
- 44:11very
- 44:11focused
- 44:11on
- 44:11social
- 44:11justice
- 44:12issues,
- 44:13and
- 44:13they
- 44:13immediately
- 44:14wanted
- 44:14to
- 44:15pivot
- 44:15to
- 44:16other
- 44:16issues
- 44:16outside
- 44:17of
- 44:17education.
- 44:17Let's
- 44:18get
- 44:18involved
- 44:18in
- 44:18criminal
- 44:19justice.
- 44:19Yes.
- 44:19You
- 44:19know,
- 44:20let's
- 44:20get
- 44:20involved
- 44:20in
- 44:20sentencing.
- 44:21What's
- 44:21going
- 44:21on
- 44:21with.
- 44:22Let's
- 44:22get
- 44:22healthcare
- 44:22or
- 44:22whatever
- 44:23it
- 44:23was.
- 44:23And.
- 44:23And
- 44:24I
- 44:24just
- 44:24spent
- 44:24a
- 44:24lot
- 44:25of
- 44:25time
- 44:25and
- 44:25I
- 44:25just
- 44:25realized
- 44:26our
- 44:27world
- 44:27just
- 44:27does
- 44:27not
- 44:28know
- 44:29how
- 44:29much
- 44:30unfairness
- 44:31is
- 44:31cooked
- 44:31into
- 44:31the
- 44:32DNA
- 44:33of
- 44:33public
- 44:33education.
- 44:34And
- 44:34when
- 44:34I
- 44:34was
- 44:34able
- 44:35to
- 44:35bring
- 44:35it
- 44:35back
- 44:35to
- 44:36them
- 44:36and
- 44:36talk
- 44:36about
- 44:37red
- 44:37lines
- 44:38and
- 44:38attendance
- 44:38boundaries,
- 44:39you
- 44:39know,
- 44:39when
- 44:39we
- 44:39were
- 44:40able
- 44:40to
- 44:40talk
- 44:40about
- 44:40fiscal
- 44:41practices
- 44:42that
- 44:42over
- 44:42and
- 44:43over
- 44:43again,
- 44:43Los
- 44:43Angeles
- 44:44Unified
- 44:44sucks
- 44:45money
- 44:45away
- 44:46from
- 44:46Watts
- 44:46and
- 44:47East
- 44:47LA
- 44:47to
- 44:48subsidize
- 44:48the
- 44:48schools
- 44:49on
- 44:49the
- 44:49west
- 44:49side.
- 44:49And
- 44:50when
- 44:50you
- 44:50can
- 44:50show
- 44:51this
- 44:51stuff
- 44:52now,
- 44:52we
- 44:52can
- 44:52anchor
- 44:53our
- 44:53people
- 44:53and
- 44:53stay
- 44:54focused
- 44:54on
- 44:54our
- 44:54stuff.
- 44:55But
- 44:55from
- 44:55an
- 44:55advocacy
- 44:56perspective,
- 44:56as
- 44:56far
- 44:57as
- 44:57I
- 44:57can
- 44:57tell,
- 44:58our
- 44:58world
- 44:59refused
- 44:59to
- 45:00take
- 45:00on
- 45:00that
- 45:00stuff
- 45:00because
- 45:00we
- 45:00would
- 45:01not
- 45:01criticize
- 45:01the
- 45:01public
- 45:01school
- 45:02system.
- 45:02And
- 45:02so
- 45:02when
- 45:03Trump
- 45:03came
- 45:03along,
- 45:03there
- 45:04was.
- 45:04Let
- 45:04me
- 45:04just
- 45:05finish.
- 45:05Yeah,
- 45:05sorry.
- 45:05When
- 45:05Trump
- 45:06came
- 45:06along,
- 45:06you
- 45:07know,
- 45:07our
- 45:08world
- 45:08is
- 45:08somewhat
- 45:08like,
- 45:09oh,
- 45:09how
- 45:09do
- 45:09we.
- 45:09How
- 45:10do
- 45:10we.
- 45:10Virtue
- 45:10project
- 45:11here.
- 45:11How
- 45:11do
- 45:11we
- 45:11Values
- 45:12project.
- 45:12We
- 45:13ended
- 45:13up
- 45:13values
- 45:14projecting
- 45:14on
- 45:14a
- 45:14bunch
- 45:14of
- 45:15stuff
- 45:15that
- 45:15had
- 45:15nothing
- 45:16to
- 45:16do
- 45:16with
- 45:16education,
- 45:16being
- 45:17Muslim,
- 45:17travel
- 45:18banned.
- 45:18The
- 45:19California
- 45:19Charter
- 45:19School
- 45:19association
- 45:20is
- 45:20making
- 45:20comments
- 45:21on
- 45:21that.
- 45:21What
- 45:21the
- 45:22heck?
- 45:22When.
- 45:23If
- 45:23we
- 45:23had
- 45:24inarguably
- 45:25been
- 45:25going
- 45:26forward
- 45:26with
- 45:26policy
- 45:26agendas,
- 45:27trying
- 45:27to,
- 45:28like,
- 45:28get
- 45:28rid
- 45:29of
- 45:29these
- 45:29things,
- 45:30our
- 45:30world
- 45:30would
- 45:30have
- 45:31known
- 45:31on
- 45:32some
- 45:32of
- 45:32these
- 45:32issues
- 45:33of
- 45:33fairness
- 45:33that
- 45:34people
- 45:34do
- 45:34still
- 45:34motivate
- 45:35for.
- 45:35We're
- 45:36doing
- 45:36our
- 45:36stuff
- 45:36on
- 45:36that.
- 45:37Meanwhile,
- 45:37keep
- 45:38our
- 45:38focus
- 45:38on.
- 45:38On
- 45:38academic
- 45:39rigor.
- 45:40Instead,
- 45:40we
- 45:40like,
- 45:41you
- 45:41know,
- 45:41in
- 45:41the
- 45:41convoluted
- 45:42mess
- 45:42of
- 45:42it,
- 45:43you
- 45:43know,
- 45:43basically
- 45:44let
- 45:44it
- 45:44all.
- 45:44All
- 45:45drop.
- 45:46Oh,
- 45:47I
- 45:47mean,
- 45:47I.
- 45:48To
- 45:48me,
- 45:48it
- 45:48creates
- 45:48a
- 45:48permission
- 45:49structure
- 45:50not
- 45:50to
- 45:50focus
- 45:51on
- 45:51results.
- 45:52There's
- 45:52lots
- 45:52of
- 45:52stuff
- 45:53that's
- 45:53bad.
- 45:53The
- 45:53Muslim
- 45:54travel
- 45:54ban
- 45:54is
- 45:54a
- 45:55good
- 45:55example
- 45:55of
- 45:55that.
- 45:56But
- 45:56there's
- 45:56168
- 45:57hours
- 45:57in
- 45:57the
- 45:58week.
- 45:58And
- 45:58so
- 45:58you
- 45:58got
- 45:58to
- 45:58figure
- 45:59out
- 45:59what
- 45:59are
- 46:00you
- 46:00going
- 46:00to
- 46:00focus
- 46:00on
- 46:01and
- 46:01what
- 46:01do
- 46:01you
- 46:02care
- 46:02about?
- 46:02And
- 46:02you
- 46:03can't
- 46:03fix
- 46:03all
- 46:03the
- 46:04world's
- 46:04ills.
- 46:04And
- 46:05very
- 46:05quickly,
- 46:05if
- 46:05you,
- 46:06and
- 46:06I
- 46:07think
- 46:07this
- 46:07is
- 46:07part
- 46:07of
- 46:07what's
- 46:07happened
- 46:08at
- 46:08a
- 46:08leadership
- 46:08level,
- 46:09if
- 46:09you
- 46:09care
- 46:09about
- 46:10everything,
- 46:10then
- 46:10you
- 46:11care
- 46:11about
- 46:11nothing,
- 46:12in
- 46:12effect.
- 46:12And
- 46:12so
- 46:13you
- 46:13have
- 46:13to
- 46:13pick
- 46:13your
- 46:13spots.
- 46:14We're
- 46:14education
- 46:14people
- 46:15and
- 46:15so
- 46:15we
- 46:16intersect
- 46:16with
- 46:16a
- 46:16few
- 46:17things
- 46:17like
- 46:17health
- 46:17care
- 46:17and
- 46:18housing
- 46:18and
- 46:18so
- 46:19forth.
- 46:19But
- 46:19there's
- 46:19a
- 46:19whole
- 46:19bunch
- 46:19of
- 46:20other
- 46:20stuff
- 46:20that's
- 46:21just
- 46:21way
- 46:22far.
- 46:23It
- 46:23doesn't
- 46:23mean
- 46:23it's
- 46:24not
- 46:24bad
- 46:24and
- 46:24not
- 46:24a
- 46:24problem
- 46:25and
- 46:25not
- 46:25inequitable.
- 46:26But
- 46:26you,
- 46:26you
- 46:26can't.
- 46:27Like
- 46:27you,
- 46:27you.
- 46:28If
- 46:28you're
- 46:28focused
- 46:29on
- 46:29that,
- 46:29then
- 46:29you're
- 46:29not
- 46:29focused
- 46:30on
- 46:30our
- 46:30core
- 46:30thing,
- 46:30which
- 46:31is
- 46:31teaching
- 46:31and
- 46:32learning,
- 46:32instruction
- 46:33and
- 46:33school
- 46:33improvement.
- 46:34Exactly,
- 46:35exactly.
- 46:35And
- 46:35so
- 46:36that's
- 46:36right,
- 46:36we
- 46:37lost.
- 46:37We
- 46:37lost
- 46:38the
- 46:38basic
- 46:39supposition
- 46:40that
- 46:41within
- 46:41these
- 46:41four
- 46:42walls,
- 46:42despite
- 46:43all
- 46:43of
- 46:43these
- 46:43other
- 46:44social
- 46:44injustices
- 46:45around
- 46:45us,
- 46:45despite
- 46:46racism,
- 46:46despite
- 46:47poverty,
- 46:47despite
- 46:48family
- 46:49issues,
- 46:50we
- 46:50have
- 46:51what
- 46:51it
- 46:51takes
- 46:51to
- 46:52educate
- 46:52students,
- 46:52students
- 46:53to
- 46:53a
- 46:53high
- 46:53level.
- 46:53That
- 46:54was
- 46:54the
- 46:54driving
- 46:57premise
- 46:58of
- 46:59early
- 46:59charters,
- 47:00and
- 47:01it's
- 47:01profoundly
- 47:03powerful.
- 47:05And
- 47:05going
- 47:05along
- 47:06with
- 47:06that,
- 47:06of
- 47:06course,
- 47:06was
- 47:07the
- 47:07idea
- 47:08of
- 47:08no
- 47:08excuses,
- 47:09not
- 47:09making.
- 47:10It's
- 47:10not
- 47:10about
- 47:10kids,
- 47:11people.
- 47:11So
- 47:11it's
- 47:12a
- 47:12terrible
- 47:12name
- 47:12for
- 47:12that
- 47:13reason.
- 47:13People
- 47:13think
- 47:13it's
- 47:13about
- 47:14not
- 47:15wailing
- 47:15on
- 47:15kids.
- 47:16It's
- 47:16not
- 47:16about
- 47:17that
- 47:17at
- 47:17all.
- 47:17It's
- 47:17about,
- 47:18it's
- 47:19about
- 47:19as
- 47:19adults
- 47:20in
- 47:20the
- 47:20building,
- 47:21we're
- 47:22going
- 47:22to
- 47:22stop
- 47:22blaming
- 47:23poverty,
- 47:23blaming
- 47:24all
- 47:24these
- 47:24other
- 47:24things
- 47:25and
- 47:25say,
- 47:25no,
- 47:26we're
- 47:26not
- 47:26going
- 47:27to
- 47:27do
- 47:27that
- 47:27anymore,
- 47:28because
- 47:28that's
- 47:28just
- 47:28excuse
- 47:29making.
- 47:29We
- 47:29actually
- 47:30can
- 47:30educate
- 47:31to
- 47:31a
- 47:31high
- 47:31level
- 47:32despite
- 47:33those
- 47:33problems.
- 47:34And
- 47:35that
- 47:35stopped
- 47:36the
- 47:36moment
- 47:36that
- 47:37we
- 47:37went
- 47:37all
- 47:37Kendi,
- 47:38because
- 47:39Kendi
- 47:39and
- 47:39others
- 47:40said,
- 47:41no,
- 47:41the
- 47:44derivation
- 47:45of
- 47:45all
- 47:45of
- 47:46these
- 47:46other
- 47:48inequities,
- 47:51racial
- 47:51inequities,
- 47:52is
- 47:52downstream
- 47:54of
- 47:56structural
- 47:57racism.
- 47:58And
- 47:58structural
- 47:58racism
- 47:59was
- 47:59never
- 48:00defined.
- 48:01Structural
- 48:01racism
- 48:02is
- 48:02really
- 48:02just
- 48:03a
- 48:03synonym
- 48:04for
- 48:04the
- 48:04inequities
- 48:05itself.
- 48:06So
- 48:06it
- 48:06didn't
- 48:07offer
- 48:07a
- 48:07solution.
- 48:08It
- 48:08didn't
- 48:08say
- 48:08what
- 48:09to
- 48:09do.
- 48:10Right.
- 48:12But
- 48:13to
- 48:13your
- 48:13point,
- 48:14Andy,
- 48:14it
- 48:14just
- 48:14took
- 48:15all
- 48:15the
- 48:15focus
- 48:16off
- 48:16of
- 48:17great
- 48:17instruction
- 48:18and
- 48:18off
- 48:18of
- 48:19the
- 48:19belief
- 48:19that,
- 48:19yes,
- 48:20you
- 48:20know
- 48:20what,
- 48:20we
- 48:20actually
- 48:20do
- 48:21have
- 48:21the
- 48:21means
- 48:21to
- 48:21do
- 48:22it.
- 48:22And
- 48:22it
- 48:22was
- 48:22peculiar
- 48:23as
- 48:23a
- 48:23book.
- 48:23His
- 48:24first
- 48:24book,
- 48:24you
- 48:24know,
- 48:25stamped
- 48:25the
- 48:26description
- 48:26of
- 48:26testing
- 48:27and
- 48:27how
- 48:27it
- 48:27works
- 48:27was
- 48:28like
- 48:28wildly
- 48:29bastardized.
- 48:29And
- 48:30so
- 48:30again,
- 48:30like
- 48:31you
- 48:31would
- 48:31think,
- 48:31the
- 48:31leadership
- 48:32of
- 48:32this
- 48:32Sector
- 48:33would
- 48:33say
- 48:34these
- 48:34are
- 48:34important
- 48:35issues
- 48:35to
- 48:36discuss
- 48:36and
- 48:36debate
- 48:37and
- 48:37we
- 48:37should
- 48:37engage
- 48:38with
- 48:38them.
- 48:38But
- 48:39let's
- 48:39engage
- 48:39with
- 48:40them
- 48:40with
- 48:41a
- 48:41book
- 48:41or
- 48:41an
- 48:42author
- 48:42that's
- 48:42actually
- 48:42approaching
- 48:43them.
- 48:43Well,
- 48:44there's
- 48:44the
- 48:44famous
- 48:44paragraph
- 48:45in
- 48:45the
- 48:46second
- 48:46Kendi
- 48:47book
- 48:47that
- 48:48attacks
- 48:48testing.
- 48:49And
- 48:50it
- 48:50is
- 48:50a
- 48:51total
- 48:51confusion
- 48:52from
- 48:52first
- 48:53word
- 48:53to
- 48:53last.
- 48:54It
- 48:54conflates.
- 48:55No,
- 48:55I
- 48:55mean,
- 48:55it's
- 48:55an
- 48:55astounding
- 48:56paragraph.
- 48:56You
- 48:57remember
- 48:57this
- 48:57paragraph?
- 48:57I
- 48:57mean,
- 48:58it's
- 48:58just
- 48:58astounding.
- 48:59It
- 48:59conflates
- 49:00IQ
- 49:00testing.
- 49:01Right.
- 49:02With
- 49:02achievement
- 49:02testing.
- 49:03I
- 49:03mean,
- 49:04and
- 49:04if
- 49:04you
- 49:04remember,
- 49:05we
- 49:05don't
- 49:05have
- 49:06to
- 49:06go
- 49:06back
- 49:06long
- 49:07during
- 49:07the
- 49:08peak
- 49:08of
- 49:08the
- 49:08opt
- 49:09out
- 49:09movement
- 49:09and
- 49:09testing.
- 49:10I
- 49:11need
- 49:11a
- 49:11date,
- 49:11guys.
- 49:11But
- 49:12you
- 49:12know
- 49:12that,
- 49:12right?
- 49:13It's
- 49:13a
- 49:13while
- 49:13when
- 49:13everybody.
- 49:14When
- 49:15we
- 49:15lost
- 49:15Park
- 49:15Slope.
- 49:15When
- 49:16we
- 49:16lost
- 49:16Park
- 49:16Slope,
- 49:17by
- 49:17the
- 49:17way,
- 49:17we
- 49:18never
- 49:18lost
- 49:18the
- 49:18black
- 49:19community
- 49:19at
- 49:19all.
- 49:19No,
- 49:20it
- 49:20was,
- 49:21it
- 49:21was
- 49:21after
- 49:22white
- 49:22parents
- 49:23who
- 49:23wanted
- 49:23out
- 49:23of
- 49:24testing.
- 49:24And
- 49:24it
- 49:24was
- 49:25a
- 49:25brief
- 49:25thing
- 49:25and
- 49:26it,
- 49:26and
- 49:26it
- 49:26died
- 49:26down
- 49:26fairly
- 49:27quickly.
- 49:27But
- 49:28at
- 49:28that
- 49:28moment,
- 49:30all
- 49:30of
- 49:30the
- 49:31leading
- 49:31national
- 49:32civil
- 49:32rights
- 49:32organizations
- 49:33from
- 49:34the
- 49:34aclu,
- 49:37the
- 49:38naacp,
- 49:39La
- 49:39Raza,
- 49:40all
- 49:40put
- 49:41out
- 49:41a
- 49:41joint
- 49:41statement
- 49:42saying
- 49:42no,
- 49:43testing
- 49:44is
- 49:44good.
- 49:45Testing
- 49:46is
- 49:46very
- 49:46important.
- 49:47Otherwise
- 49:47we
- 49:48will
- 49:48no
- 49:48longer
- 49:49illuminate
- 49:50these
- 49:50disparities
- 49:51and
- 49:52have
- 49:52a
- 49:52path
- 49:53for
- 49:53their
- 49:53solution.
- 49:54That
- 49:54statement
- 49:55is
- 49:55one
- 49:55of
- 49:55the
- 49:55best
- 49:55press
- 49:56releases.
- 49:56It
- 49:56was
- 49:57absolutely
- 49:58unequivocal
- 49:59in
- 49:59its
- 49:59embrace
- 50:00of
- 50:00accountability.
- 50:01So.
- 50:01But
- 50:01I'm,
- 50:01I'm
- 50:01with
- 50:02you
- 50:02guys.
- 50:02Maybe
- 50:02my,
- 50:02my
- 50:03seat
- 50:03on
- 50:03this
- 50:03is
- 50:04just
- 50:04different
- 50:04with,
- 50:05you
- 50:05know,
- 50:05California
- 50:05with
- 50:06a
- 50:06large,
- 50:06large
- 50:07number
- 50:07of
- 50:07schools,
- 50:08a
- 50:08large
- 50:08number
- 50:08of
- 50:08stakeholders.
- 50:09California
- 50:10is
- 50:10weird.
- 50:11And
- 50:11you've
- 50:12got
- 50:12CTA
- 50:12just
- 50:13spending
- 50:14millions,
- 50:15you're
- 50:15a
- 50:15billionaire
- 50:16plot,
- 50:17you
- 50:17know,
- 50:18people
- 50:18getting
- 50:19accosted
- 50:19in
- 50:20supermarkets.
- 50:21Why
- 50:21are
- 50:21you
- 50:22friends
- 50:22of
- 50:22charter
- 50:22school?
- 50:23You
- 50:23know?
- 50:23Yeah.
- 50:24And
- 50:25yes,
- 50:25we
- 50:26must
- 50:26keep
- 50:26a
- 50:27focus
- 50:27on
- 50:28instruction
- 50:28and
- 50:29academic
- 50:30excellence
- 50:30for
- 50:30sure.
- 50:31But
- 50:31I
- 50:31also
- 50:32think
- 50:32that
- 50:32our
- 50:33stakeholders
- 50:33need
- 50:33to
- 50:33feel
- 50:34as
- 50:34though
- 50:35the
- 50:35advocacy
- 50:35heft
- 50:36of
- 50:36the
- 50:36growing
- 50:36movement
- 50:37is
- 50:37being
- 50:38put
- 50:38toward
- 50:38these
- 50:38problems
- 50:39that
- 50:39aren't
- 50:39only
- 50:41self
- 50:41supporting
- 50:42for
- 50:42the
- 50:42sector
- 50:42itself.
- 50:43We
- 50:43want.
- 50:44Parents
- 50:45are
- 50:45getting
- 50:45screwed
- 50:45over
- 50:46and
- 50:46there
- 50:46are
- 50:47all
- 50:47sorts
- 50:47of
- 50:47ways
- 50:47for
- 50:47them
- 50:47to
- 50:47get
- 50:48something
- 50:48better.
- 50:48They
- 50:48can
- 50:49get
- 50:49access
- 50:49to
- 50:49other
- 50:49great
- 50:50schools
- 50:50or
- 50:51they
- 50:51can
- 50:51get
- 50:51access
- 50:51to
- 50:51our
- 50:52schools.
- 50:52But
- 50:52the
- 50:53lack
- 50:53of
- 50:54clear
- 50:55evidence
- 50:55in
- 50:55the
- 50:55landscape
- 50:56that
- 50:56the
- 50:56overall
- 50:57sector
- 50:57was
- 50:57pushing
- 50:58toward
- 50:58those
- 50:58kinds
- 50:59of
- 50:59policy
- 50:59ends,
- 51:00I
- 51:00think
- 51:00made
- 51:01our
- 51:01world
- 51:01much
- 51:02more
- 51:02difficult.
- 51:02But
- 51:03I
- 51:03think
- 51:03what
- 51:03you're
- 51:04getting
- 51:04at
- 51:04is,
- 51:05to
- 51:05me,
- 51:05the
- 51:05most
- 51:06dangerous
- 51:06thing
- 51:06about
- 51:06the
- 51:07charter
- 51:07movement,
- 51:07I
- 51:07mean,
- 51:07dangerous
- 51:08in
- 51:08a
- 51:08good
- 51:08way,
- 51:08dangerous
- 51:09for
- 51:09the
- 51:09status
- 51:09quo,
- 51:10was
- 51:10it
- 51:11showed
- 51:11it
- 51:11can
- 51:12be
- 51:12done
- 51:12as
- 51:13like
- 51:13what
- 51:13Stephen
- 51:14was
- 51:14saying
- 51:14earlier.
- 51:14It
- 51:15showed
- 51:15that
- 51:15even
- 51:16all
- 51:16else
- 51:16equal
- 51:16with
- 51:17all
- 51:17these
- 51:17problems,
- 51:17you
- 51:18can
- 51:18do
- 51:18a
- 51:18substantially
- 51:19better
- 51:19job.
- 51:19You
- 51:19can
- 51:19propel
- 51:20kids
- 51:20into
- 51:20lives
- 51:21of
- 51:21opportunity.
- 51:22And
- 51:22this
- 51:22is
- 51:22a
- 51:23sector
- 51:23where
- 51:23I
- 51:24was
- 51:24just
- 51:24talking
- 51:24with
- 51:24a
- 51:24friend
- 51:24today
- 51:25who's
- 51:25a
- 51:25school
- 51:25principal,
- 51:26was
- 51:26talking
- 51:26about
- 51:26how
- 51:27the
- 51:27strategy
- 51:27for
- 51:28improving
- 51:28the
- 51:28school
- 51:29was
- 51:29which
- 51:29kids
- 51:29they
- 51:30could
- 51:30move
- 51:30in
- 51:31through
- 51:31various
- 51:31kinds
- 51:32of
- 51:32transfers
- 51:32and
- 51:32changes,
- 51:33not
- 51:33how
- 51:33do
- 51:34you
- 51:34improve
- 51:34the
- 51:34school
- 51:34through
- 51:34better
- 51:35instruction.
- 51:35Right.
- 51:36And
- 51:36that's
- 51:37the
- 51:37ethos.
- 51:37Right.
- 51:38And
- 51:38if
- 51:38you
- 51:39want.
- 51:39So
- 51:40if
- 51:40you
- 51:40want
- 51:40Democrats
- 51:41to
- 51:41come
- 51:41on
- 51:41board,
- 51:41you
- 51:42have
- 51:42to
- 51:42really
- 51:43change
- 51:43this
- 51:43whole
- 51:43belief
- 51:44system
- 51:44system
- 51:44because
- 51:44there
- 51:44is
- 51:45a
- 51:45subtle
- 51:45racism
- 51:46out
- 51:46there
- 51:46of.
- 51:47And
- 51:47it's
- 51:47also
- 51:47classism
- 51:48of
- 51:48like
- 51:48you
- 51:49can't
- 51:49expect
- 51:49a
- 51:50lot
- 51:50from
- 51:50these
- 51:50kids.
- 51:51So
- 51:51we've
- 51:51got
- 51:51to
- 51:51have
- 51:52this
- 51:52palliative
- 51:52approach.
- 51:53And
- 51:53the
- 51:53charters,
- 51:54the,
- 51:54the
- 51:54best
- 51:54ones
- 51:55they
- 51:55just
- 51:55put
- 51:55on
- 51:55the
- 51:55table
- 51:56that.
- 51:56No,
- 51:56that's
- 51:56actually.
- 51:57And
- 51:58you
- 51:58can
- 51:58actually
- 51:58do
- 51:58all
- 51:59else
- 51:59equal
- 51:59to
- 51:59a
- 52:00much
- 52:00better
- 52:00job
- 52:00if
- 52:01all
- 52:01else
- 52:01wasn't
- 52:02equal.
- 52:02We
- 52:02actually
- 52:02address
- 52:03some
- 52:03of
- 52:03these
- 52:03other
- 52:03social
- 52:03issues.
- 52:04Just
- 52:04think
- 52:05what
- 52:05we
- 52:05could
- 52:05do.
- 52:05And
- 52:06I
- 52:06think
- 52:06that's
- 52:06what
- 52:07we
- 52:07need
- 52:07people
- 52:07to
- 52:08get
- 52:08back
- 52:08behind
- 52:08because
- 52:09people
- 52:09in
- 52:09this
- 52:09sector,
- 52:10particularly
- 52:11who
- 52:11are
- 52:11very
- 52:11social
- 52:11justice
- 52:12oriented,
- 52:12need
- 52:12to
- 52:13understand
- 52:13this
- 52:14was
- 52:14a
- 52:14social
- 52:14justice
- 52:15play
- 52:15for
- 52:16the
- 52:16campaign,
- 52:17if
- 52:17you
- 52:17define
- 52:17it
- 52:17in
- 52:17social
- 52:18media.
- 52:18And
- 52:18I
- 52:19think
- 52:19you're
- 52:19raising
- 52:19a
- 52:19very
- 52:20interesting
- 52:21nuance
- 52:21here,
- 52:21Andy,
- 52:22which
- 52:22is
- 52:23I
- 52:23think
- 52:23that
- 52:25many
- 52:25of
- 52:25the
- 52:26white
- 52:27advocates
- 52:28of
- 52:28the
- 52:28Kendi
- 52:29style
- 52:30social
- 52:30justice
- 52:31explanations
- 52:32actually
- 52:33themselves
- 52:35hold
- 52:36low
- 52:36beliefs
- 52:37about
- 52:38low
- 52:38income
- 52:39black
- 52:39and
- 52:39brown
- 52:39students
- 52:40can
- 52:40do.
- 52:41I
- 52:41really
- 52:41do
- 52:42believe
- 52:42that.
- 52:43And
- 52:43so
- 52:43as
- 52:43you,
- 52:44palliative
- 52:44was
- 52:44a
- 52:44very
- 52:45good
- 52:45word.
- 52:45So
- 52:45they're
- 52:46very
- 52:46drawn
- 52:46to
- 52:48things
- 52:48that
- 52:48I
- 52:48think
- 52:49we
- 52:49at
- 52:49this
- 52:49table
- 52:49would
- 52:50find
- 52:50very
- 52:50condescending,
- 52:51which
- 52:51is
- 52:51we
- 52:52should
- 52:52spend
- 52:52more
- 52:53time
- 52:53on
- 52:54addressing
- 52:54children's
- 52:55trauma
- 52:58and
- 52:58the
- 52:59trauma
- 52:59of
- 53:00their
- 53:00teachers.
- 53:01And
- 53:01so
- 53:02it
- 53:02becomes
- 53:02a
- 53:02very
- 53:02therapeutic
- 53:03kind
- 53:04of
- 53:04intervention.
- 53:05Academics
- 53:07is
- 53:07subordinated
- 53:08to
- 53:09a
- 53:09therapeutic
- 53:10intervention,
- 53:11which
- 53:11I
- 53:11talk
- 53:11about
- 53:11in
- 53:12the
- 53:12book.
- 53:12And
- 53:13I
- 53:13think
- 53:13that
- 53:13is
- 53:14one
- 53:14of
- 53:14the
- 53:14worst
- 53:15aspects
- 53:15of
- 53:15what
- 53:16is
- 53:16happening
- 53:16right
- 53:17now.
- 53:17Because
- 53:18the
- 53:18fact
- 53:18is
- 53:19many
- 53:19teachers
- 53:21would
- 53:21be
- 53:22very
- 53:22drawn
- 53:22to
- 53:22that
- 53:22because
- 53:23they
- 53:23enter
- 53:23teaching
- 53:24is
- 53:24a
- 53:24helping
- 53:24profession.
- 53:25They
- 53:25are
- 53:26deeply
- 53:26empathetic
- 53:27and
- 53:28compassionate
- 53:29human
- 53:29beings.
- 53:30And
- 53:30so
- 53:31if
- 53:31you
- 53:31as
- 53:31a
- 53:31school
- 53:32system
- 53:32say
- 53:33it's
- 53:33okay
- 53:34to
- 53:34focus
- 53:35mainly
- 53:36on
- 53:37therapy
- 53:37or
- 53:38social
- 53:38emotional
- 53:39learning,
- 53:39they
- 53:39will
- 53:40jump
- 53:40at
- 53:40that.
- 53:41That's
- 53:42very
- 53:42compelling
- 53:43to
- 53:43them.
- 53:44So
- 53:44there's
- 53:44a
- 53:45constant
- 53:45need
- 53:46to
- 53:46reassert
- 53:47that.
- 53:47No,
- 53:48actually
- 53:49if
- 53:49we
- 53:49really
- 53:50care
- 53:50about
- 53:50kids,
- 53:50we
- 53:51need
- 53:51to
- 53:51educate
- 53:51them.
- 53:52And
- 53:52if
- 53:53we
- 53:53educate
- 53:53them,
- 53:54they're
- 53:54going
- 53:54to
- 53:54hold
- 53:55a
- 53:55very
- 53:55high
- 53:56sense
- 53:57of
- 53:57self
- 53:58and
- 53:58sense
- 53:58of
- 53:58agency
- 54:00and
- 54:00sense
- 54:00of
- 54:00capacity.
- 54:02One
- 54:02of
- 54:02the
- 54:02biggest
- 54:03indictments
- 54:04of
- 54:04Social
- 54:04justice
- 54:05education
- 54:05is
- 54:05that
- 54:06it
- 54:06is
- 54:06capacity
- 54:07reducing.
- 54:08Children
- 54:09feel
- 54:10they
- 54:10do
- 54:10not
- 54:10have
- 54:11capacity
- 54:12to
- 54:12make
- 54:12their
- 54:12way
- 54:13in
- 54:13the
- 54:13world.
- 54:13And
- 54:13that's
- 54:13what
- 54:13makes
- 54:14me,
- 54:14I
- 54:14think,
- 54:14the
- 54:14most
- 54:14angry
- 54:15about
- 54:15it.
- 54:16And
- 54:16I
- 54:16think
- 54:16a
- 54:16great
- 54:17section
- 54:17of
- 54:17the
- 54:17book
- 54:18that
- 54:18was
- 54:18powerfully
- 54:19said
- 54:19is
- 54:19you
- 54:19have
- 54:20the
- 54:20sort
- 54:20of
- 54:20these
- 54:20five
- 54:20evasions
- 54:21that
- 54:21you
- 54:21talk
- 54:22about.
- 54:22And
- 54:23I
- 54:23almost
- 54:23think
- 54:23it's
- 54:24a
- 54:24great
- 54:24book
- 54:24and
- 54:24I
- 54:24encourage
- 54:24people
- 54:25to
- 54:25read
- 54:25it.
- 54:25But
- 54:25if
- 54:25you're
- 54:25only
- 54:25going
- 54:25to
- 54:25read
- 54:25one
- 54:26chapter
- 54:26because
- 54:26I
- 54:27like
- 54:27it
- 54:27just
- 54:27does
- 54:27a
- 54:28really
- 54:28good
- 54:28job.
- 54:29It
- 54:29reminds
- 54:29me
- 54:29very
- 54:30much
- 54:30of,
- 54:30like,
- 54:30A.O.
- 54:30hirschman's,
- 54:31like,
- 54:31rhetoric
- 54:32of
- 54:32reaction
- 54:32book.
- 54:33Like,
- 54:33you
- 54:33just
- 54:33lay
- 54:34out,
- 54:34here
- 54:34are
- 54:34the
- 54:34things
- 54:35you
- 54:35are
- 54:35going
- 54:35to
- 54:35hear
- 54:36about
- 54:36this
- 54:37and
- 54:37here's
- 54:37why
- 54:37they're
- 54:38mistaken.
- 54:38And
- 54:39I
- 54:39think
- 54:39that
- 54:39it's
- 54:39a
- 54:39very
- 54:40important.
- 54:42It's
- 54:43a
- 54:43very
- 54:43important
- 54:43section
- 54:43because
- 54:44there
- 54:44is.
- 54:44To
- 54:44what
- 54:44you're
- 54:45saying.
- 54:45There
- 54:45are
- 54:45these.
- 54:46These
- 54:46belief
- 54:46systems
- 54:47run
- 54:47deep
- 54:47and
- 54:48they
- 54:48are
- 54:48problematic.
- 54:48I
- 54:49also
- 54:49love
- 54:49the
- 54:49chapter
- 54:49just
- 54:50about,
- 54:50you
- 54:50know,
- 54:50why
- 54:51school
- 54:51Districts
- 54:51are
- 54:52ultimately
- 54:52not
- 54:53reformable.
- 54:55I
- 54:55mean,
- 54:55it's.
- 54:55Well,
- 54:55because,
- 54:56you
- 54:56know,
- 54:57I
- 54:57feel
- 54:57like
- 54:57it
- 54:58is
- 54:58an
- 54:58elephant
- 54:58in
- 54:58the
- 54:59room
- 54:59that
- 54:59people
- 54:59just
- 54:59will
- 55:00not
- 55:00take.
- 55:00And,
- 55:00but.
- 55:01And
- 55:01can
- 55:01I
- 55:01just
- 55:01say,
- 55:02we
- 55:02used
- 55:03to
- 55:03talk
- 55:03about
- 55:03that
- 55:04at
- 55:04the
- 55:04beginning
- 55:04of
- 55:05the,
- 55:05of
- 55:05the
- 55:05movement.
- 55:06We
- 55:06talked
- 55:06about
- 55:06it
- 55:06a
- 55:07lot.
- 55:07Yeah.
- 55:07I
- 55:08mean,
- 55:08I
- 55:08went
- 55:08back
- 55:08and
- 55:08read
- 55:09some
- 55:09Boston
- 55:09Globe
- 55:09articles
- 55:10from
- 55:101991
- 55:11because
- 55:11I
- 55:11was
- 55:11trying
- 55:12to
- 55:12write
- 55:12a
- 55:12chapter
- 55:12about,
- 55:13well,
- 55:13the
- 55:13chapter
- 55:13on
- 55:13Massachusetts.
- 55:14And
- 55:15I
- 55:15was
- 55:15struck
- 55:15by.
- 55:16By
- 55:16the
- 55:16tone
- 55:17of
- 55:18political
- 55:18leaders,
- 55:18including
- 55:19some
- 55:19superintendents,
- 55:21who
- 55:21were
- 55:21far
- 55:22more
- 55:23direct
- 55:24in
- 55:24describing
- 55:25the
- 55:25failures
- 55:26of
- 55:26their
- 55:27very
- 55:27own
- 55:27systems.
- 55:28The
- 55:28language
- 55:29was
- 55:29much
- 55:29more
- 55:29vivid.
- 55:30It
- 55:30wasn't
- 55:30all
- 55:30of
- 55:30this
- 55:31euphemized.
- 55:34I
- 55:34worked
- 55:34for
- 55:34one
- 55:34in
- 55:34San
- 55:35Diego.
- 55:35Alan
- 55:35Burson
- 55:36was
- 55:36one
- 55:36of
- 55:36them.
- 55:37That's
- 55:37a
- 55:37very
- 55:37good
- 55:37example.
- 55:38He
- 55:38just
- 55:38spoke
- 55:38very
- 55:39directly
- 55:39about
- 55:40our
- 55:40failure.
- 55:40So
- 55:40we
- 55:41don't
- 55:41hear
- 55:41that
- 55:41anymore.
- 55:42And
- 55:42then
- 55:42people
- 55:43just
- 55:43don't
- 55:43realize
- 55:44that
- 55:44what
- 55:44I
- 55:44call
- 55:45the
- 55:45operating
- 55:45system
- 55:46of
- 55:47large
- 55:48urban
- 55:48systems
- 55:49is
- 55:49fundamentally
- 55:50incompatible
- 55:51with
- 55:51high
- 55:51achievement.
- 55:52I
- 55:52mean,
- 55:52look
- 55:53at
- 55:53what
- 55:53the
- 55:53best
- 55:53charters
- 55:54are
- 55:54doing.
- 55:54As
- 55:54I
- 55:55said,
- 55:55they're
- 55:55doing
- 55:55things
- 55:56like
- 55:56the
- 55:57one
- 55:57month
- 55:57of
- 55:57professional
- 55:58development
- 55:59before
- 55:59the
- 55:59year
- 55:59starts.
- 56:00That's
- 56:00very
- 56:01time
- 56:01very
- 56:01well
- 56:02spent.
- 56:02When
- 56:02it's
- 56:03done
- 56:03well,
- 56:03you
- 56:04go
- 56:04deep
- 56:04into
- 56:04the
- 56:05maw
- 56:05of
- 56:05techniques
- 56:06or
- 56:06you
- 56:06go
- 56:06deep
- 56:06into
- 56:07your
- 56:07math
- 56:07curriculum.
- 56:08You
- 56:08have
- 56:08teachers
- 56:09practice
- 56:09it
- 56:09in
- 56:10a
- 56:10fishbowl
- 56:10setting,
- 56:11getting
- 56:11feedback.
- 56:11This
- 56:12stuff
- 56:12is
- 56:12incredibly
- 56:13powerful.
- 56:14But
- 56:14you
- 56:14could
- 56:14never
- 56:15do
- 56:15that
- 56:15in
- 56:15a
- 56:15unionized
- 56:16setting.
- 56:16You
- 56:16get
- 56:16one
- 56:17day
- 56:18to
- 56:18bring
- 56:18your
- 56:18teachers
- 56:19together
- 56:19before
- 56:19you
- 56:20teach.
- 56:20What
- 56:20contempt
- 56:21are
- 56:21we
- 56:21showing
- 56:22for
- 56:22children
- 56:23by
- 56:23those
- 56:23kinds
- 56:24of
- 56:24policies?
- 56:26So,
- 56:26no,
- 56:26I.
- 56:26And
- 56:27you
- 56:27know,
- 56:27look,
- 56:27at
- 56:27New
- 56:27York
- 56:28schools.
- 56:28Right.
- 56:28We've
- 56:29had
- 56:29what,
- 56:2915
- 56:30superintendents
- 56:31in
- 56:3125
- 56:32years.
- 56:32So
- 56:33if
- 56:33we
- 56:33think
- 56:33that
- 56:33some
- 56:34God
- 56:34is
- 56:34going
- 56:34to
- 56:35step
- 56:35up
- 56:35and
- 56:35suddenly
- 56:36make
- 56:36it
- 56:36work,
- 56:36the
- 56:36closest
- 56:37we
- 56:37got
- 56:37was
- 56:37under
- 56:38Bloomberg,
- 56:38of
- 56:38course,
- 56:39and
- 56:39it's
- 56:39even
- 56:40all
- 56:40of
- 56:40Bloomberg's
- 56:41reforms
- 56:42have
- 56:42been
- 56:42dismantled,
- 56:43save
- 56:44one.
- 56:44Urban
- 56:45charters.
- 56:45That's
- 56:45right.
- 56:46Well,
- 56:46we're
- 56:47going
- 56:47to
- 56:47have
- 56:47to
- 56:47wrap
- 56:47this
- 56:47up.
- 56:48I
- 56:48want
- 56:48to
- 56:48get
- 56:49to
- 56:49a
- 56:49little
- 56:49bit
- 56:49though.
- 56:49There's
- 56:50got
- 56:50to
- 56:50be
- 56:50some
- 56:50hope
- 56:51here
- 56:51like
- 56:51how
- 56:51we
- 56:52dig
- 56:52ourselves
- 56:52out
- 56:52of
- 56:52this
- 56:53thing
- 56:53and
- 56:54you
- 56:54know,
- 56:54we're
- 56:54not
- 56:54going
- 56:54to
- 56:54get
- 56:54out
- 56:55of
- 56:55there
- 56:55in
- 56:55one
- 56:55fell
- 56:55swoop
- 56:56or
- 56:56not
- 56:56getting
- 56:56out
- 56:56in
- 56:57one
- 56:57year.
- 56:57But
- 56:58you
- 56:58know,
- 56:58if
- 56:59we're,
- 56:59if
- 56:59we're
- 56:59here
- 57:00a
- 57:00couple
- 57:00of
- 57:00years
- 57:01from
- 57:01now
- 57:02and,
- 57:04and
- 57:04there's
- 57:04the
- 57:04kind
- 57:05of
- 57:05progress
- 57:06that
- 57:06you
- 57:06think
- 57:06we
- 57:07should
- 57:07be
- 57:07making,
- 57:08what
- 57:08are
- 57:08going
- 57:08to
- 57:08be
- 57:08indicators,
- 57:09you
- 57:09know,
- 57:10a
- 57:10year
- 57:10or
- 57:10two
- 57:10down
- 57:11the
- 57:11road
- 57:11that
- 57:11maybe
- 57:12we're
- 57:12getting
- 57:12our
- 57:12bearings
- 57:13again.
- 57:13I
- 57:13think
- 57:13honest
- 57:14conversation
- 57:14about
- 57:15the
- 57:15wrong
- 57:15turn
- 57:16will
- 57:16become
- 57:17permissible.
- 57:18We'll
- 57:19hear
- 57:19it.
- 57:20We'll
- 57:20have
- 57:20honest
- 57:20conversations
- 57:21with
- 57:21each
- 57:22other.
- 57:22We're
- 57:22not
- 57:22there
- 57:23yet.
- 57:23That
- 57:23hasn't
- 57:24started,
- 57:24I
- 57:24don't
- 57:24think.
- 57:25But
- 57:25you
- 57:25were
- 57:25invited
- 57:26to
- 57:26speak.
- 57:27Thank
- 57:27you.
- 57:27That's
- 57:28very
- 57:28true.
- 57:28And
- 57:28I'm
- 57:28extremely
- 57:29grateful
- 57:30to
- 57:30Starlee
- 57:31and
- 57:31to
- 57:31Andrea
- 57:32for
- 57:32that
- 57:33opportunity.
- 57:33You're
- 57:34absolutely
- 57:34right.
- 57:34I
- 57:34was
- 57:34invited
- 57:35to
- 57:35speak.
- 57:35That's
- 57:35a
- 57:36big
- 57:36deal.
- 57:36I
- 57:36think
- 57:36people
- 57:36realize
- 57:37this
- 57:37is
- 57:37an.
- 57:37Issue
- 57:38and
- 57:38you're,
- 57:38you're
- 57:39quite
- 57:39right.
- 57:39Some
- 57:40challenges
- 57:40that.
- 57:40The
- 57:41first
- 57:41reaction
- 57:41is
- 57:42probably
- 57:42going
- 57:42to
- 57:42be
- 57:42some
- 57:42silence
- 57:43and
- 57:43discomfort.
- 57:44Yeah,
- 57:44that's
- 57:44what
- 57:44I
- 57:44got
- 57:45to.
- 57:45If
- 57:46we
- 57:46don't,
- 57:46if
- 57:46we
- 57:46don't
- 57:46give
- 57:47up
- 57:47on
- 57:47it,
- 57:47though.
- 57:47Yeah.
- 57:48You
- 57:48know,
- 57:48I
- 57:48think.
- 57:48No,
- 57:49you're
- 57:49absolutely
- 57:49right.
- 57:49And
- 57:50I'm
- 57:50being,
- 57:50I'm
- 57:50being
- 57:50ungenerous
- 57:51because
- 57:51I,
- 57:52I
- 57:52was
- 57:52invited.
- 57:53That's
- 57:53a,
- 57:53that's
- 57:54a
- 57:54big
- 57:54risk
- 57:54to
- 57:54take
- 57:55and
- 57:55it's
- 57:56a
- 57:56great
- 57:56setting
- 57:56and
- 57:57so
- 57:57that's
- 57:58encouraging.
- 57:58And
- 57:59I
- 57:59think
- 57:59the
- 57:59other
- 57:59thing
- 57:59is
- 57:59I
- 58:00think
- 58:00we're
- 58:00going
- 58:00to
- 58:00hear
- 58:01a
- 58:01lot
- 58:01more
- 58:02about
- 58:02these
- 58:02very
- 58:03high
- 58:03performing
- 58:03networks
- 58:04that
- 58:05didn't
- 58:05change
- 58:06course
- 58:06and
- 58:07the
- 58:07results
- 58:07that
- 58:07we're
- 58:08getting.
- 58:08I
- 58:08think
- 58:08the
- 58:08classical
- 58:09schools
- 58:10movement
- 58:11is
- 58:11going
- 58:11to
- 58:11get
- 58:11a
- 58:11lot
- 58:12of
- 58:12airtime,
- 58:12as
- 58:12it
- 58:12should.
- 58:13So
- 58:14I
- 58:14think
- 58:14that.
- 58:15What
- 58:15do
- 58:15you
- 58:15think,
- 58:16what
- 58:16do
- 58:16you
- 58:16both
- 58:16think
- 58:16on
- 58:17this
- 58:17question
- 58:17that
- 58:17you're
- 58:17asking?
- 58:20What
- 58:20are
- 58:20the
- 58:20positive
- 58:21signs
- 58:21going
- 58:22forward?
- 58:24I
- 58:24mean,
- 58:24I
- 58:25feel
- 58:25like
- 58:25this
- 58:25is
- 58:25a
- 58:25people
- 58:25issue.
- 58:26I
- 58:26think
- 58:26this
- 58:27is
- 58:27a
- 58:27people
- 58:27issue.
- 58:29I
- 58:29have
- 58:30a
- 58:30secret
- 58:31hope
- 58:31that
- 58:31some
- 58:31of
- 58:31these
- 58:31people
- 58:32that
- 58:32exited,
- 58:33they're
- 58:33going
- 58:34to
- 58:34recognize
- 58:34that
- 58:34they're
- 58:35needed.
- 58:35And
- 58:35my
- 58:36own
- 58:36conversations
- 58:36with
- 58:37Many
- 58:37of
- 58:37them
- 58:38is.
- 58:39They
- 58:39know
- 58:39it,
- 58:39actually.
- 58:40I
- 58:40agree.
- 58:41I've
- 58:41had
- 58:41the
- 58:41same
- 58:41conversations,
- 58:43so.
- 58:43And
- 58:44I
- 58:44also
- 58:44feel
- 58:44like
- 58:44while
- 58:45they've
- 58:45gone
- 58:45on
- 58:45and
- 58:45they're
- 58:46doing
- 58:46some
- 58:46other
- 58:46things,
- 58:47while
- 58:48they
- 58:48feel
- 58:48at
- 58:48least
- 58:49batteries
- 58:49charged
- 58:50and
- 58:50not
- 58:50completely
- 58:51depleted,
- 58:51they're
- 58:52bored.
- 58:52Out
- 58:52of
- 58:52their
- 58:52minds.
- 58:53They're
- 58:53not.
- 58:53They.
- 58:53And
- 58:54they
- 58:54know,
- 58:54they're
- 58:55like,
- 58:55hey,
- 58:55Shelby
- 58:56did
- 58:56this
- 58:56until
- 58:56he
- 58:56was
- 58:5780.
- 58:57I
- 58:57mean,
- 58:57I
- 58:58got
- 58:58a
- 58:58lot
- 58:58more
- 58:58years
- 58:59left
- 58:59in
- 58:59me.
- 58:59I
- 58:59think
- 59:00we're
- 59:00going
- 59:00to
- 59:00get
- 59:00some
- 59:00of
- 59:00those.
- 59:01They're
- 59:01wrestling
- 59:01with
- 59:01what
- 59:02to
- 59:02do
- 59:02with
- 59:02their
- 59:02talents.
- 59:03And
- 59:04one
- 59:04guy,
- 59:04Douglas,
- 59:05look
- 59:05what
- 59:05that
- 59:05guy
- 59:05can
- 59:06do.
- 59:06Bring
- 59:06these
- 59:06people
- 59:07back
- 59:07and
- 59:07get
- 59:07them
- 59:08plugged
- 59:08into
- 59:08organization
- 59:09is
- 59:09another
- 59:10great
- 59:10one.
- 59:11Great
- 59:11one.
- 59:11But
- 59:11I
- 59:12also
- 59:12feel
- 59:12as
- 59:12though
- 59:13your
- 59:13point,
- 59:13you
- 59:14know,
- 59:14to
- 59:14realize
- 59:15that.
- 59:15That
- 59:16the
- 59:16newcomers
- 59:17that
- 59:17are
- 59:17coming
- 59:17in,
- 59:19you
- 59:19know,
- 59:19we've
- 59:20also
- 59:20got
- 59:20to
- 59:20be
- 59:20filtering
- 59:21for,
- 59:22you
- 59:23know,
- 59:23what
- 59:23is
- 59:24their
- 59:24reason
- 59:25for
- 59:25coming
- 59:25in.
- 59:25Yeah,
- 59:26if
- 59:26they're
- 59:26just
- 59:26looking
- 59:27for
- 59:27a
- 59:27job,
- 59:28that's
- 59:28just.
- 59:29We're
- 59:29gonna
- 59:30end
- 59:30up
- 59:30with
- 59:31our
- 59:31having
- 59:31a
- 59:32district
- 59:32orientation
- 59:33toward
- 59:33things.
- 59:34But
- 59:34I
- 59:35think
- 59:35that.
- 59:36I
- 59:36think
- 59:36we
- 59:36have
- 59:36the
- 59:37potential
- 59:37with
- 59:37a
- 59:37lot
- 59:38of
- 59:38focus
- 59:38on
- 59:38our
- 59:38newcomers,
- 59:39supported
- 59:40by
- 59:40some
- 59:40of
- 59:40these
- 59:41old
- 59:41timers
- 59:41that
- 59:41could,
- 59:42like,
- 59:42acquaint
- 59:42them.
- 59:43Another
- 59:43place
- 59:43where
- 59:43we
- 59:44may
- 59:44see
- 59:44some
- 59:45positive
- 59:46energy
- 59:47is
- 59:47if
- 59:48the.
- 59:48The
- 59:48philanthropic
- 59:49community.
- 59:49Philanthropic
- 59:50community
- 59:51may
- 59:51be
- 59:52able
- 59:52to
- 59:53recognize
- 59:54the
- 59:54wrong
- 59:54turn
- 59:55and
- 59:55speak
- 59:55out
- 59:56about
- 59:56it
- 59:56and
- 59:57push
- 59:57the
- 59:58sector
- 59:58back
- 59:58on
- 59:58track.
- 59:58Does
- 59:59that
- 59:59make
- 59:59sense?
- 59:59Is
- 59:59that
- 1:00:00possible?
- 1:00:00Well,
- 1:00:00it
- 1:00:00has
- 1:00:01to.
- 1:00:01Or
- 1:00:01we
- 1:00:01need
- 1:00:02philanthropists
- 1:00:03because,
- 1:00:03like,
- 1:00:04that
- 1:00:04is
- 1:00:05where
- 1:00:05the
- 1:00:05resources
- 1:00:06come
- 1:00:06from
- 1:00:07and
- 1:00:07to
- 1:00:07the
- 1:00:07end.
- 1:00:07And
- 1:00:07it's
- 1:00:08where
- 1:00:08people
- 1:00:08take
- 1:00:08their
- 1:00:08cues
- 1:00:09off
- 1:00:09of.
- 1:00:09And
- 1:00:09so,
- 1:00:10yeah,
- 1:00:10to
- 1:00:10the.
- 1:00:10Yeah,
- 1:00:11to
- 1:00:11the
- 1:00:11extent
- 1:00:12they
- 1:00:12make
- 1:00:12it
- 1:00:12safe
- 1:00:13for
- 1:00:13people
- 1:00:13to
- 1:00:14do
- 1:00:14the
- 1:00:14things
- 1:00:14you're
- 1:00:14talking
- 1:00:14about
- 1:00:15to
- 1:00:15lead,
- 1:00:16they
- 1:00:16make
- 1:00:16it
- 1:00:16safe
- 1:00:17for
- 1:00:17these
- 1:00:17networks.
- 1:00:17And
- 1:00:18to
- 1:00:18the
- 1:00:18extent
- 1:00:19they
- 1:00:19make
- 1:00:19it
- 1:00:20fraught,
- 1:00:20it'll
- 1:00:20go
- 1:00:20the
- 1:00:20other
- 1:00:21direction.
- 1:00:21Bloomberg
- 1:00:22foundation,
- 1:00:23of
- 1:00:24course,
- 1:00:24Kevin
- 1:00:25at
- 1:00:25the
- 1:00:25Charles
- 1:00:26Growth
- 1:00:26foundation,
- 1:00:26if
- 1:00:27those
- 1:00:27people
- 1:00:28were
- 1:00:28able
- 1:00:29to
- 1:00:30come
- 1:00:30forward
- 1:00:30and
- 1:00:31speak
- 1:00:31up
- 1:00:31and
- 1:00:32say,
- 1:00:32guys,
- 1:00:32we
- 1:00:32have
- 1:00:33a
- 1:00:33problem,
- 1:00:33we
- 1:00:34need
- 1:00:34to
- 1:00:34fix
- 1:00:34it,
- 1:00:34I
- 1:00:35think
- 1:00:35it
- 1:00:35would
- 1:00:35make
- 1:00:35an
- 1:00:35immense
- 1:00:36difference.
- 1:00:36Cal
- 1:00:37said
- 1:00:37something
- 1:00:37years
- 1:00:38ago
- 1:00:38that
- 1:00:38I
- 1:00:38think
- 1:00:39like,
- 1:00:39is.
- 1:00:40He
- 1:00:40said
- 1:00:40to
- 1:00:40me,
- 1:00:40it
- 1:00:41was
- 1:00:41very
- 1:00:41early
- 1:00:41days
- 1:00:41of
- 1:00:42the
- 1:00:42reform
- 1:00:42movement.
- 1:00:42He
- 1:00:43said,
- 1:00:43you
- 1:00:43look
- 1:00:43at
- 1:00:43the
- 1:00:43people,
- 1:00:43everyone's
- 1:00:44betting
- 1:00:44their
- 1:00:44careers
- 1:00:45on
- 1:00:45this
- 1:00:45and
- 1:00:46the
- 1:00:46risk
- 1:00:46they're
- 1:00:46taking,
- 1:00:47he's
- 1:00:47like,
- 1:00:47that's
- 1:00:47a
- 1:00:48signal
- 1:00:48that
- 1:00:48we're
- 1:00:49going
- 1:00:49to
- 1:00:50succeed.
- 1:00:51And
- 1:00:51we
- 1:00:52then
- 1:00:52did.
- 1:00:52And
- 1:00:52some
- 1:00:52of
- 1:00:52the
- 1:00:53things
- 1:00:53you're
- 1:00:53talking
- 1:00:53about,
- 1:00:53we
- 1:00:54saw
- 1:00:54these
- 1:00:54transformative
- 1:00:55schools
- 1:00:55that
- 1:00:55were
- 1:00:56changing
- 1:00:56lives
- 1:00:56and
- 1:00:56outcomes,
- 1:00:57and
- 1:00:58you
- 1:00:58had.
- 1:00:59It's
- 1:00:59sort
- 1:00:59of
- 1:00:59the
- 1:00:59average
- 1:01:00bear
- 1:01:00problem
- 1:01:00or
- 1:01:01the
- 1:01:01average
- 1:01:01bear
- 1:01:01sort
- 1:01:02of
- 1:01:02indicator
- 1:01:02you
- 1:01:02had
- 1:01:03suddenly
- 1:01:04people
- 1:01:04coming
- 1:01:04into
- 1:01:04this
- 1:01:04movement
- 1:01:05just
- 1:01:05because
- 1:01:05they
- 1:01:05thought
- 1:01:05it
- 1:01:05was
- 1:01:05the
- 1:01:05corporate
- 1:01:06cool
- 1:01:06thing
- 1:01:06to
- 1:01:06do.
- 1:01:06They
- 1:01:06weren't
- 1:01:06necessarily
- 1:01:07committed
- 1:01:07to
- 1:01:07education
- 1:01:08as
- 1:01:08an
- 1:01:08instrument
- 1:01:09of
- 1:01:09social
- 1:01:09change,
- 1:01:10but
- 1:01:10it
- 1:01:10was
- 1:01:10the
- 1:01:10cool
- 1:01:10place
- 1:01:10to
- 1:01:11be.
- 1:01:11You
- 1:01:11had
- 1:01:11politicians
- 1:01:12who
- 1:01:12were
- 1:01:12like
- 1:01:13I
- 1:01:13don't
- 1:01:13know
- 1:01:13what
- 1:01:13this
- 1:01:13is
- 1:01:13all
- 1:01:13about,
- 1:01:14but
- 1:01:14everyone's
- 1:01:15red
- 1:01:15reform.
- 1:01:15The
- 1:01:16average
- 1:01:16bears
- 1:01:16came
- 1:01:17over.
- 1:01:17So
- 1:01:17I
- 1:01:17think
- 1:01:17the
- 1:01:18indicator
- 1:01:18to
- 1:01:18answer
- 1:01:19your
- 1:01:19question
- 1:01:19that
- 1:01:19I
- 1:01:19would
- 1:01:19look
- 1:01:20for
- 1:01:20in
- 1:01:20a
- 1:01:20few
- 1:01:20years
- 1:01:21is
- 1:01:21are
- 1:01:21the
- 1:01:21average
- 1:01:21bears
- 1:01:22coming
- 1:01:22back?
- 1:01:22Right
- 1:01:23now
- 1:01:23you've
- 1:01:23got
- 1:01:23two
- 1:01:23kinds
- 1:01:24of
- 1:01:24people
- 1:01:24largely
- 1:01:24in
- 1:01:24the
- 1:01:25sector.
- 1:01:25You've
- 1:01:25got
- 1:01:25the
- 1:01:25true
- 1:01:25believers
- 1:01:26who
- 1:01:26genuinely
- 1:01:27believe
- 1:01:27the
- 1:01:27transformative
- 1:01:28power
- 1:01:28of
- 1:01:29education
- 1:01:29and
- 1:01:29that
- 1:01:30like
- 1:01:30it's
- 1:01:30not
- 1:01:30going
- 1:01:30to
- 1:01:31solve
- 1:01:31all
- 1:01:31of
- 1:01:31our
- 1:01:31problems.
- 1:01:32But
- 1:01:32it's
- 1:01:32hard
- 1:01:32to
- 1:01:32see
- 1:01:32see
- 1:01:33us
- 1:01:33having
- 1:01:33a
- 1:01:33more
- 1:01:33equitable
- 1:01:34just
- 1:01:34society
- 1:01:35without
- 1:01:35a
- 1:01:35better
- 1:01:36education
- 1:01:36system.
- 1:01:37And
- 1:01:37then
- 1:01:37you
- 1:01:37got
- 1:01:37the
- 1:01:37zealots
- 1:01:38and
- 1:01:39we'll
- 1:01:39know
- 1:01:39we're
- 1:01:40succeeding
- 1:01:40if
- 1:01:40you
- 1:01:40got
- 1:01:40the
- 1:01:41average
- 1:01:41bears
- 1:01:41coming
- 1:01:41back
- 1:01:42in
- 1:01:42who
- 1:01:42are
- 1:01:42like
- 1:01:42oh
- 1:01:42okay,
- 1:01:43this
- 1:01:43looks
- 1:01:43like
- 1:01:44a
- 1:01:44good
- 1:01:44place
- 1:01:44to
- 1:01:44be.
- 1:01:44There's
- 1:01:45cool
- 1:01:45stuff
- 1:01:45happening.
- 1:01:45And
- 1:01:46right
- 1:01:46now
- 1:01:46frankly
- 1:01:46those
- 1:01:46people
- 1:01:47are
- 1:01:47in
- 1:01:47climate
- 1:01:47and
- 1:01:48other
- 1:01:48things
- 1:01:48and
- 1:01:49like
- 1:01:49we'll
- 1:01:49know
- 1:01:50we're
- 1:01:50succeeding
- 1:01:50when
- 1:01:50they
- 1:01:51come
- 1:01:51back
- 1:01:51and
- 1:01:51politicians
- 1:01:52and
- 1:01:52philanthropists
- 1:01:53come
- 1:01:53back.
- 1:01:53But
- 1:01:53I
- 1:01:53think
- 1:01:54that
- 1:01:54core
- 1:01:54idea
- 1:01:55we
- 1:01:55shouldn't
- 1:01:56lose
- 1:01:56that.
- 1:01:56It
- 1:01:56is
- 1:01:57possible.
- 1:01:58So
- 1:01:58success
- 1:01:58with
- 1:01:58the
- 1:01:58thing.
- 1:01:59We're
- 1:01:59not
- 1:01:59trying
- 1:01:59to
- 1:01:59create
- 1:01:59something
- 1:02:00that
- 1:02:00nobody
- 1:02:00has
- 1:02:00seen.
- 1:02:01We're
- 1:02:01trying
- 1:02:01to
- 1:02:02recreate
- 1:02:02something
- 1:02:03that
- 1:02:04was
- 1:02:04a
- 1:02:05powerful
- 1:02:05moment.
- 1:02:06It
- 1:02:06doesn't
- 1:02:06wasn't
- 1:02:07without
- 1:02:07its
- 1:02:07problem.
- 1:02:08It
- 1:02:08wasn't
- 1:02:08without
- 1:02:08its
- 1:02:09problem.
- 1:02:09It
- 1:02:09wasn't
- 1:02:09without
- 1:02:09its
- 1:02:10problems.
- 1:02:10And
- 1:02:10we
- 1:02:10should
- 1:02:10acknowledge
- 1:02:11that
- 1:02:12they
- 1:02:12were
- 1:02:13changes
- 1:02:13that
- 1:02:13were
- 1:02:14made
- 1:02:14in
- 1:02:14response
- 1:02:15that
- 1:02:15were
- 1:02:15necessary.
- 1:02:17But
- 1:02:17yes,
- 1:02:17one
- 1:02:17of
- 1:02:17the
- 1:02:17things
- 1:02:17I'm
- 1:02:18worried
- 1:02:18about
- 1:02:18is
- 1:02:18that
- 1:02:18we're
- 1:02:19going
- 1:02:19to
- 1:02:19lose
- 1:02:19the
- 1:02:20institutional
- 1:02:20knowledge
- 1:02:21of
- 1:02:21what
- 1:02:22made
- 1:02:22those
- 1:02:22systems
- 1:02:23very
- 1:02:23hyper
- 1:02:23focused
- 1:02:24farming.
- 1:02:24So
- 1:02:24it's
- 1:02:24really
- 1:02:24important
- 1:02:25that
- 1:02:26we
- 1:02:26document
- 1:02:26the
- 1:02:26mechanisms
- 1:02:27by
- 1:02:27which
- 1:02:28that
- 1:02:28success
- 1:02:28was
- 1:02:29obtained
- 1:02:29because
- 1:02:30it
- 1:02:30we,
- 1:02:30we
- 1:02:30know
- 1:02:31what
- 1:02:31we
- 1:02:31did.
- 1:02:31I'm
- 1:02:32going
- 1:02:32to
- 1:02:32throw
- 1:02:32in
- 1:02:32one
- 1:02:32more
- 1:02:32as
- 1:02:33before
- 1:02:33we
- 1:02:33get
- 1:02:33to
- 1:02:33that.
- 1:02:34I
- 1:02:34agree.
- 1:02:34That's
- 1:02:34the
- 1:02:35technical
- 1:02:35problem.
- 1:02:35That's
- 1:02:36a
- 1:02:36technical
- 1:02:36problem.
- 1:02:36We
- 1:02:36also
- 1:02:37don't
- 1:02:37want
- 1:02:37to
- 1:02:37lose
- 1:02:38sort
- 1:02:38of
- 1:02:38the
- 1:02:38sort
- 1:02:39of
- 1:02:39aspirational
- 1:02:40that
- 1:02:40absolutely
- 1:02:41what
- 1:02:41is
- 1:02:41possible.
- 1:02:42I
- 1:02:42worry,
- 1:02:42I
- 1:02:42worry
- 1:02:43we
- 1:02:43potentially
- 1:02:43lose
- 1:02:44both.
- 1:02:44I'm
- 1:02:45going
- 1:02:45to
- 1:02:45throw
- 1:02:45in
- 1:02:45one
- 1:02:45more
- 1:02:46just
- 1:02:46from
- 1:02:46the
- 1:02:46authorizer
- 1:02:47advocate
- 1:02:47perspective
- 1:02:47too.
- 1:02:48I
- 1:02:48just
- 1:02:48feel
- 1:02:48as
- 1:02:48though
- 1:02:49having
- 1:02:49clear
- 1:02:50minimum
- 1:02:50performance
- 1:02:50performance
- 1:02:51expectations
- 1:02:51for
- 1:02:51schools
- 1:02:52and
- 1:02:52some
- 1:02:53schools
- 1:02:54being
- 1:02:54closed
- 1:02:54and
- 1:02:55a
- 1:02:55bar
- 1:02:55rising
- 1:02:56and
- 1:02:56our
- 1:02:56work
- 1:02:57totally
- 1:02:58embracing
- 1:02:58this
- 1:02:59is
- 1:02:59super
- 1:03:00important
- 1:03:00and
- 1:03:00we've
- 1:03:01let
- 1:03:01that
- 1:03:01go.
- 1:03:01But
- 1:03:01I
- 1:03:02actually
- 1:03:02feel
- 1:03:02like
- 1:03:03it's
- 1:03:03something
- 1:03:03would
- 1:03:03be
- 1:03:04fairly
- 1:03:04easy
- 1:03:04to
- 1:03:04reassemble
- 1:03:05and
- 1:03:06because
- 1:03:06It's.
- 1:03:06It's
- 1:03:07hard
- 1:03:07to
- 1:03:07define
- 1:03:07quality,
- 1:03:08but
- 1:03:08when
- 1:03:09you
- 1:03:09really
- 1:03:09get
- 1:03:09into
- 1:03:10the
- 1:03:10performance
- 1:03:10and
- 1:03:11see
- 1:03:11how
- 1:03:11low
- 1:03:12performance
- 1:03:12is
- 1:03:12as
- 1:03:13a
- 1:03:13result
- 1:03:13of
- 1:03:13some
- 1:03:13of
- 1:03:13the
- 1:03:14instructional
- 1:03:14practices
- 1:03:15you're
- 1:03:15talking
- 1:03:15about.
- 1:03:15Jed,
- 1:03:16you
- 1:03:16were
- 1:03:16so
- 1:03:17spot
- 1:03:17on.
- 1:03:17If
- 1:03:17there
- 1:03:18isn't
- 1:03:18an
- 1:03:18accountability
- 1:03:19system
- 1:03:20at
- 1:03:20the
- 1:03:21testing
- 1:03:21level,
- 1:03:22but
- 1:03:22also
- 1:03:22at
- 1:03:22the
- 1:03:23authorizer
- 1:03:23level,
- 1:03:24that
- 1:03:24is
- 1:03:25just
- 1:03:25crucially
- 1:03:26important.
- 1:03:27You
- 1:03:27know,
- 1:03:27the.
- 1:03:27The
- 1:03:28SUNY
- 1:03:29created
- 1:03:29great
- 1:03:29charters
- 1:03:30because
- 1:03:31it
- 1:03:31was
- 1:03:31willing
- 1:03:31to
- 1:03:31close
- 1:03:32bad
- 1:03:32ones.
- 1:03:33And
- 1:03:33it
- 1:03:33was
- 1:03:33very
- 1:03:33clear
- 1:03:34about
- 1:03:34that
- 1:03:35and
- 1:03:35it
- 1:03:35was
- 1:03:35very
- 1:03:35clear
- 1:03:36how
- 1:03:36excellence
- 1:03:37was
- 1:03:37defined.
- 1:03:38It
- 1:03:38had
- 1:03:38a
- 1:03:38very
- 1:03:39sophisticated
- 1:03:39evaluation.
- 1:03:40R.
- 1:03:41So
- 1:03:41if
- 1:03:41we
- 1:03:41lose
- 1:03:42those
- 1:03:42things,
- 1:03:43this
- 1:03:43is
- 1:03:43a
- 1:03:43big
- 1:03:43problem.
- 1:03:44Yeah,
- 1:03:44I
- 1:03:45will.
- 1:03:45I
- 1:03:45will
- 1:03:45take
- 1:03:45the
- 1:03:46prerogative
- 1:03:46of
- 1:03:46one
- 1:03:46of
- 1:03:47the
- 1:03:47hosts.
- 1:03:47Today's
- 1:03:48my
- 1:03:48last
- 1:03:48day
- 1:03:48on
- 1:03:48the
- 1:03:48Virginia
- 1:03:49Board
- 1:03:49of
- 1:03:49Education
- 1:03:49when
- 1:03:49we're.
- 1:03:50Yeah,
- 1:03:51congratulations.
- 1:03:53We
- 1:03:53got
- 1:03:53an
- 1:03:53accountability
- 1:03:54system
- 1:03:54in
- 1:03:54place.
- 1:03:54That
- 1:03:55was
- 1:03:55the
- 1:03:55reason
- 1:03:55I
- 1:03:55went
- 1:03:56back
- 1:03:56on
- 1:03:56the
- 1:03:56board.
- 1:03:57Congratulations.
- 1:03:58Couple
- 1:03:58of
- 1:03:58years.
- 1:03:58And
- 1:03:59this
- 1:03:59idea
- 1:03:59that
- 1:03:59you
- 1:03:59need
- 1:04:00to
- 1:04:00measure
- 1:04:00in
- 1:04:00a
- 1:04:00transparent
- 1:04:01way
- 1:04:01and
- 1:04:01report
- 1:04:02is
- 1:04:02absolutely
- 1:04:03instrumental
- 1:04:04to
- 1:04:04all
- 1:04:05of
- 1:04:05this.
- 1:04:05And
- 1:04:06there's
- 1:04:06so
- 1:04:06much
- 1:04:06pressure
- 1:04:07on
- 1:04:07measurement.
- 1:04:07But
- 1:04:08there's
- 1:04:08also
- 1:04:08some
- 1:04:08states
- 1:04:08that
- 1:04:08are
- 1:04:09trying
- 1:04:09to.
- 1:04:09I
- 1:04:09don't
- 1:04:09know
- 1:04:09what
- 1:04:09will
- 1:04:09happen
- 1:04:10with
- 1:04:10it
- 1:04:10over
- 1:04:10time.
- 1:04:10Time,
- 1:04:10but
- 1:04:10there's
- 1:04:11some
- 1:04:11states
- 1:04:11that
- 1:04:11are.
- 1:04:11Trying
- 1:04:11to
- 1:04:11move
- 1:04:12forward
- 1:04:13counterexample.
- 1:04:14Massachusetts,
- 1:04:14the
- 1:04:15highest
- 1:04:15performing
- 1:04:16state,
- 1:04:16now
- 1:04:16has
- 1:04:17the
- 1:04:17lowest
- 1:04:17graduation
- 1:04:18requirements
- 1:04:19from
- 1:04:19high
- 1:04:19school
- 1:04:20in
- 1:04:20the
- 1:04:20country.
- 1:04:20And,
- 1:04:21and
- 1:04:21the
- 1:04:21advocacy
- 1:04:22world
- 1:04:22from.
- 1:04:22Is
- 1:04:23getting
- 1:04:23strong
- 1:04:23enough
- 1:04:24in
- 1:04:24most
- 1:04:24situations.
- 1:04:25If
- 1:04:25we're
- 1:04:25going
- 1:04:25to
- 1:04:26keep,
- 1:04:26you
- 1:04:26know,
- 1:04:26an
- 1:04:27underperforming
- 1:04:27school
- 1:04:27alive,
- 1:04:28we're
- 1:04:29probably
- 1:04:29building
- 1:04:29enough
- 1:04:29advocacy
- 1:04:30strength
- 1:04:30to
- 1:04:31do
- 1:04:31it.
- 1:04:31The
- 1:04:31question
- 1:04:32is,
- 1:04:32are
- 1:04:32we
- 1:04:32going
- 1:04:32to
- 1:04:33put
- 1:04:33our
- 1:04:33advocacy
- 1:04:33strength
- 1:04:34toward
- 1:04:35accountability?
- 1:04:35Are
- 1:04:36we
- 1:04:36going
- 1:04:36to,
- 1:04:36like,
- 1:04:36actively
- 1:04:37want
- 1:04:37underperforming
- 1:04:38schools
- 1:04:38to
- 1:04:38close?
- 1:04:41I'm
- 1:04:41guardedly
- 1:04:41optimistic,
- 1:04:42but
- 1:04:42there's
- 1:04:42a
- 1:04:42lot
- 1:04:42more
- 1:04:43discussion
- 1:04:43to
- 1:04:43your
- 1:04:43point
- 1:04:44that
- 1:04:44even
- 1:04:44in
- 1:04:44the
- 1:04:44advocacy
- 1:04:45realm
- 1:04:45needs
- 1:04:45to
- 1:04:45happen.
- 1:04:46Well,
- 1:04:46plenty
- 1:04:46more
- 1:04:47to
- 1:04:47talk
- 1:04:47about,
- 1:04:47but
- 1:04:47we
- 1:04:48want
- 1:04:48to
- 1:04:48end
- 1:04:48just
- 1:04:48by
- 1:04:49thanking
- 1:04:49Stephen
- 1:04:49for
- 1:04:50taking
- 1:04:50time.
- 1:04:50The
- 1:04:51book
- 1:04:51is
- 1:04:51the
- 1:04:51Lost
- 1:04:52Decade.
- 1:04:52I
- 1:04:52would
- 1:04:52highly
- 1:04:53recommend
- 1:04:53it.
- 1:04:54Hey,
- 1:04:54you
- 1:04:54got
- 1:04:55Two
- 1:04:55Colors.
- 1:04:55He's
- 1:04:56got
- 1:04:56the.
- 1:04:56The
- 1:04:56pre
- 1:04:56press
- 1:04:57version.
- 1:04:57Oh,
- 1:04:58gee,
- 1:04:59now
- 1:04:59I
- 1:04:59know.
- 1:05:00Now
- 1:05:00I
- 1:05:01know
- 1:05:01who's
- 1:05:01loved
- 1:05:01around
- 1:05:01here.
- 1:05:02Jeez.
- 1:05:04It's
- 1:05:04a
- 1:05:06no.
- 1:05:06This
- 1:05:06one's
- 1:05:06better.
- 1:05:08That
- 1:05:08one
- 1:05:08doesn't
- 1:05:08have
- 1:05:08any
- 1:05:09misspelling.
- 1:05:09It's
- 1:05:10a
- 1:05:10fantastic
- 1:05:11and
- 1:05:11important
- 1:05:12book.
- 1:05:12And
- 1:05:12as
- 1:05:12Steven
- 1:05:12said,
- 1:05:13it's
- 1:05:13just
- 1:05:13an
- 1:05:13important
- 1:05:13con.
- 1:05:13Wherever
- 1:05:14you
- 1:05:14come
- 1:05:14down
- 1:05:14on
- 1:05:14this,
- 1:05:14it's
- 1:05:15just
- 1:05:15an
- 1:05:15important
- 1:05:15conversation
- 1:05:16that
- 1:05:16this
- 1:05:16sector
- 1:05:17needs
- 1:05:17to
- 1:05:18have.
- 1:05:18If
- 1:05:18we're
- 1:05:18going
- 1:05:18to
- 1:05:18have
- 1:05:19a
- 1:05:19healthy,
- 1:05:19robust
- 1:05:21sector,
- 1:05:21we
- 1:05:21need
- 1:05:22to
- 1:05:22be
- 1:05:22able
- 1:05:22to
- 1:05:22have
- 1:05:22conversations
- 1:05:23about
- 1:05:23these
- 1:05:24kinds
- 1:05:24of
- 1:05:24things
- 1:05:25and
- 1:05:25figure
- 1:05:25out
- 1:05:26where
- 1:05:26we've
- 1:05:26been
- 1:05:27and
- 1:05:27where
- 1:05:27we're
- 1:05:27going
- 1:05:27so,
- 1:05:28Stephen,
- 1:05:28thank
- 1:05:28you
- 1:05:28so
- 1:05:28much.
- 1:05:29Thank
- 1:05:29you
- 1:05:29for
- 1:05:29having
- 1:05:29me.
- 1:05:30Really
- 1:05:30a
- 1:05:30privilege.
- 1:05:30Thank
- 1:05:31you.
- 1:05:31Great.