Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / When Overachievers Burn Out Without Telling You
Transcript
- Lucas: You have a team member who always delivers. Never misses a deadline, never complains, always says 'I'm fine' when you check in. That person might be your biggest risk. Luna: That's a tough one. Because on paper, they're your dream employee. But inside, they might be running on empty. Lucas: Exactly. And the scary part is, they usually don't tell you until they crash. I've been reading some work from Adam Grant on what he calls 'chronic overfunctioning' — essentially, the habit of taking on more than your share and never signaling that you're struggling. Luna: Right — because they've built their identity around being the reliable one. Saying 'I need help' feels like a failure. Lucas: That's it. And the data backs this up. A study from the Harvard Business Review a couple years ago found that high performers are actually less likely to ask for support, even when their workload spikes. They internalize the pressure. Luna: So what are the signals you should be watching for? Because if they're not going to say anything, you have to see it. Lucas: I think there are three that most managers miss. First, a shift in communication style. The overachiever who used to write thoughtful, detailed messages starts sending short, transactional replies. They stop offering extra context or ideas. Luna: Yeah, I've seen that. It's like they're conserving energy. Lucas: Second, a drop in proactive suggestions. The person who used to say 'what if we tried X' stops volunteering ideas. They just execute. That's a huge red flag. Luna: And the third one? Lucas: The timing of their email. If you start seeing messages sent at 11 p.m. or 6 a.m. on a regular basis, that's not dedication — that's compensation. They're trying to keep up by burning the hours no one sees. Luna: Let's make this concrete. Do you have a real example? Lucas: Yeah. There's a story from a mid-size tech company called Tangent Labs. They had a top engineer — let's call him David — who had been a star for three years. Never missed a deadline, always volunteered for the hardest projects. His manager thought he was fine because he kept delivering. Luna: Classic. And then what happened? Lucas: He took two months of medical leave for anxiety and exhaustion. And when his manager did an exit interview — well, it wasn't an exit, he came back — but during that conversation, David said he had been overwhelmed for over a year but felt like admitting it would let everyone down. Luna: That's heartbreaking. And the manager probably thought they were doing a good job by not micromanaging him. Lucas: Exactly. The manager's instinct was to give him space because he was performing. But that's the opposite of what he needed. He needed someone to actively check in and say, 'I see you doing all this — what can I take off your plate?' Luna: So how do you do that check-in without making it sound like you think they're failing? Lucas: The key is to normalize the conversation. Instead of 'How are you doing?' — which invites a reflexive 'fine' — you can say something like, 'I've noticed you've been sending a lot of late emails this week. I'm not worried about the output, but I want to make sure the load is sustainable. What's one thing I could help you reprioritize?' Luna: That's good. It's specific, it's about the pattern, not the person. And it offers help without implying weakness. Lucas: Right. And you can back it up with a structural change. One team inside Spotify implemented a mandatory 'no-meeting Friday afternoons' policy specifically to give their high performers uninterrupted time. They found that unscheduled overtime — people working after hours just to catch up — dropped by 34 percent. Luna: Thirty-four percent is huge. And it shows that the problem wasn't the people, it was the system. Lucas: Exactly. Overachievers often absorb systemic inefficiencies. They'll work around a bad process instead of flagging it. So part of managing them is building processes that force everyone to work at a sustainable pace. Luna: That reminds me — if this conversation is useful to you, and you want more episodes like this without ads interrupting, listener support is what keeps this show going. You can find that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, completely agree. It's a small way to make sure we keep digging into these real management challenges. So back to the structural piece — what else can a manager do beyond setting boundaries on meetings? Luna: I think one thing is to explicitly tell your star performers that you expect them to delegate. Some high achievers hoard work because they think no one else can do it as well. Lucas: That's a great point. And you can make it part of their goals. At the beginning of a quarter, say, 'One of your objectives this quarter is to identify three tasks you can hand off to someone else and mentor them through it.' That reframes delegation as a leadership skill, not a loss of control. Luna: And it builds the team's capability at the same time. Win-win. Lucas: One more thing — don't just rely on your own observation. Ask peers. Sometimes the manager is the last person to know because the employee puts on their best face for you. But their peers might see the cracks. Luna: That's a good reminder. So to wrap this up — the quiet burnout of the overachiever is real, and it's preventable if you know what to look for. Lucas: And if you're a manager listening and you think 'I might have a David on my team,' the best time to have that conversation is today. Not after the leave request.