Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Direct Listings to Go Public
Transcript
- Lucas: So earlier this week, Coinbase was trading around one fifty-seven, down about four percent over the last five days. Not exactly a standout moment for crypto-adjacent stocks, but it got me thinking about how Coinbase actually got here — not through a traditional IPO, but via direct listing. Luna: Right, it was one of the first big tech names to go that route back in 2021. And it was a big deal because it sidestepped the whole underwriting machine. Lucas: Exactly. And I think that's worth unpacking because direct listings are still relatively rare, but they offer a fundamentally different mechanism for a company to become public. No bankers setting the opening price, no lockup period where insiders can't sell, no dilution from new shares issued. Instead, existing shareholders — employees, early investors — just sell their shares directly into the market on day one. Luna: If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, listener support is what keeps this show ad-free. You can help at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small way to keep this going. So back to direct listings — the big question is, why would a company choose this over a traditional IPO? For Coinbase, a lot of it came down to not needing to raise new capital. They were already profitable, or close to it, and they had plenty of cash. So they didn't need the IPO to raise money — they just wanted a liquid market for their shares. Luna: And that's the key distinction, right? A traditional IPO is primarily a capital-raising event. The company issues new shares, underwriters buy them, and then sell them to the public. In a direct listing, no new shares are created. It's just a secondary sale. Lucas: Right. And that means the price discovery is more market-driven from the get-go. In an IPO, the underwriters set a price based on investor feedback, but there's often a 'pop' on the first day as the market corrects. With a direct listing, that pop is theoretically baked in because the opening price is set by a direct match of buy and sell orders on the exchange. Luna: But not everyone loves it. Critics say it leaves money on the table for the company, because if the stock pops, that's value that could have gone to the company's coffers if they'd sold new shares at the higher price. Lucas: True, but the counterargument is that the pop is a signal of mispricing by the underwriters. If the market values the stock at fifty dollars on day one, but the IPO priced at forty, that's ten dollars per share that went to the underwriters' clients instead of the company. A direct listing avoids that entirely. Luna: And the SEC has been warming up to them. They updated the rules a few years ago to allow companies to raise capital in a direct listing, not just sell existing shares. So you could theoretically do a 'primary direct listing' — selling new shares without underwriters. Lucas: That's a big shift. And it opens the door for more companies, especially ones that don't need the hand-holding of traditional underwriters. But there are risks. Without a book-building process, you might get more volatility on day one. And institutional investors might be less inclined to buy if there's no one guaranteeing the price. Luna: So what about a company like Rivian? They went the traditional IPO route in 2021, and their stock has been volatile. They're up five percent in the last five days, trading around seventeen dollars. Could they have benefited from a direct listing? Lucas: Possibly. Rivian needed to raise capital at the time — they were burning cash fast. So a traditional IPO made sense. But if they'd been more mature, with a strong balance sheet, a direct listing might have saved them the hefty underwriting fees. Typically, investment banks charge around three to seven percent of the proceeds for an IPO. On a ten billion dollar raise, that's three hundred to seven hundred million dollars. Luna: That's a lot of money. And for a company that doesn't need the cash, it's hard to justify. Lucas: Exactly. But there's also the signaling aspect. Choosing a direct listing signals to the market that you don't need the banks' validation. It's a vote of confidence in your own valuation. And it aligns with the ethos of many tech companies that want to democratize access — retail investors get the same shot at the opening price as institutions. Luna: But not everyone is convinced. Some argue that the lack of underwriter support means less analyst coverage and less liquidity over the long term. Lucas: That's a fair point. Underwriters typically provide aftermarket support and coverage. Without that, a direct-listed stock might be more prone to being ignored by the Street. But then again, for a company like Coinbase, which was already a household name in crypto, that probably wasn't a concern. Luna: So what's the takeaway for our listeners? If you're an investor eyeing a direct listing, what should you watch for? Lucas: I'd say look at the company's capital needs. If they don't need to raise money, a direct listing can be a sign of strength. But also check the liquidity — are there enough shares being offered to create a stable market? And pay attention to the reference price set by the exchange. It's not the IPO price, but it gives you a sense of where the market expects to open. Luna: And for the companies themselves, the calculus seems to be shifting. With the SEC allowing capital raises in direct listings, we might see more unicorns choosing this route. It's cheaper, faster, and arguably more democratic. Lucas: I think so. The traditional IPO isn't going away, but direct listings are becoming a credible alternative. And as more companies prove the model works — like Coinbase, Spotify, Slack — the stigma around being a 'non-traditional' IPO fades. Luna: All right, so next time you hear about a company going public via direct listing, you'll know the trade-offs. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And for our listeners, we'll keep tracking these market shifts. See you next time.