Latest / Politics with Paul / Is Negative Campaigning Effective? | Politics with Paul #114
Transcript
- Paul Rader: Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of political science and civics. And I am your host, Paul Rader. Today we're going to be answering the question of whether negative campaigning is that effective, and do we really hate it as much as we say we do? Election season is in full swing, and with that, so are the campaign ads that feel inescapable, ubiquitous. And as is often the case, these are ads that mostly focus or entirely focus on attacking one of the candidates in a race, from assailing their records in office and quotes that they've made to impugning their moral character. Yet despite candidates often claiming that they want to run positive campaigns and voters claiming that they're sick of this quote unquote negative campaigning, these attack ads not only persist, but appear to be increasingly pervasive. And as a result, there are several questions we need to ask ourselves. Candidates, voters, everybody. Do we truly hate negative campaigning like we say we do? While it has undoubtedly contributed to increased cynicism, heightened tribalism and partisanship, and more disenchantment amongst many voters, Does negative campaigning still sometimes serve a good purpose? Is negative campaigning really that effective? And lastly, what can we do about it? Those are the questions we are diving into today. But we first need to talk about what even is negative campaigning. A common theme in this podcast is that definitions matter a great deal, and the meaning of terms and phrases may not be as obvious as they seem. And negative campaigning is the same way. And it's also known by other names such as swiftboating, which goes back to the 2004 presidential election between George W. Bush and John Kerry. Mudslinging, as it has been called for a very long time, smear campaigns. Negative campaigning is often lamented. But what exactly is it? The simplest definition might just seem like any ad that criticizes opposing candidates or even campaigns on a ballot measure. But that's Awfully broad. And we have public opinion data that suggests that the general public is divided on what exactly constitutes negative campaigning. So consider this. We have a poll that comes from Gallup back in 2000. Now 2000 is obviously a very long time ago. It doesn't appear that there is a more recent poll focusing comprehensively on opinions about negative campaigning and public opinion. You'll sometimes see Other polls that are not specifically about that, but they might ask what how people feel about negative campaigns, or they will just like generally ask, not in a scientific way, do you like or how how much do you oppose negative campaigns? So in this case, the best that we have is from the year 2000. But the point is to demonstrate how there is an agreement. On what is negative campaigning. And a lot of these numbers might not necessarily be that different 26 years later. But some of the findings in this poll about what constitutes negative campaigning, according to Americans. Over 70% of the people in the poll said that bringing up an opponent's extramarital relationships or use of illegal drugs before they held office was an example of negative campaigning. Forty-two percent said that mentioning an opponent's ties to special interest groups is negative, while fifty-four percent said that was not negative campaigning. One out of five people in that poll said that bringing up an opponent's stance on issues like education or military spending constituted negative campaigning. And then four fifths of the people in the poll said that criticizing an opponent for running negative ads is itself negative campaigning. So quite a few differences in opinion on there. And that's not even all the considerations you could come up with. Some other things to think about is does it matter if a negative critical comment about anybody was made quickly versus an ad that's being solely or mostly focused on criticism? So what if it just one sentence that said, let's fight against these other people and that was it versus Look at how terrible this person is. They did this, this, and this. One example I can think of is there's been an ad and just watching football the time, you're seeing all these ads for all these different places and including places I can't vote in. but James Tallerico running for US Senate in Texas. There is an there's an ad that he's pointing out trying to get more Campaign donations and said something about fighting back against billionaires and mega donors. So is that considered negative campaigning? Because he is criticizing a group, but he's not necessarily going that far into that criticism. Or does the opponent have to be specifically mentioned or can it be a more generalized quote unquote them like in that act? D do you have to specifically say I'm you know, t Ted Cr in his case, Ted Cruz or or if for any other candidate, do they specifically have to say the person that they're running against for it to be a negative campaign ad? Another thing to consider, are there levels to negative campaigning is bringing up an extramarital affair, fair game, but you know, talking about them taking Mental health breaks, is that going too far? We might consider one to not be negative just informative, while the other one is, whoa, that is going way too far. And if you say things like instead of negative campaigning, where a lot of times candidates will say, a smear campaign is being run against me, that sounds much worse than just saying, there's negative attack ads out there. And does it matter if we consider an attack unfair or just simply truthful? Because in politics the line is regularly blurred between informative and misleading or flat out false. And with artificial intelligence being increasingly used and increasingly used in everything, but it especially campaign ads, that line is only becoming further eroded. And erased. And I can go to one person, show them one campaign ad, and they say that that's informative. That's fair. That's truthful. Show it to another person, and they're gonna say that that's misinformative, that's unfair, they're lying. Who is right? Now, obviously, biases play a big role in that. If you're a Republican and you see an attack add against a Republican, you're more likely to think that it's unfair or untruthful. And if you're a Democrat who sees that ad, you're more likely to think that that is a totally fair ad to run, that that is just trying to inform people. But it's not always just because of partisan or ideological dispositions. And also with these ads, you only have so much time in an ad to condense information. You can't go on a long diatribe for five minutes about how terrible. This other candidate is. So you have to condense things. So almost by default, you have to take something out of context. Though sometimes, of course, it is much more out of context than in other times, or the context doesn't change the truth all that much. But in any case, you do have to make things more compact, oversimplified. And so H how much of that is the fault of the candidate and how much of it is the fault of the medium and how much of it is our attention spans? It's a little bit of everything. And also how much of this campaign ad is or these negative ads are aimed at mobilizing their bases versus actually trying to persuade people? And how much does that affect whether an ad is being informative or not? How does that affect the calculus of whether an ad is being informative or misleading or does it affect that calculus? How much you think an ad is being informative may also impact whether you think it's negative. You might not necessarily put two and two together and say, wow, this is a very negative campaign, but I am learning something. So is an ad that attacks an opponent just being overly negative and toxic, or is it simply telling the truth? Can both be true at the same time? But regardless of your definition of what a negative ad is, whether you think it's bringing up personal stuff is fair, whether you think just bringing up Their stances on specific issues. Forget all that for a second. Negative ads are clearly used a ton to attack opposition. We may not always agree on whether a specific ad is a negative ad, but clearly we see a ton of these negative ads. Much less campaign spending is being used for purely positive ads to help prop up their candidate. Most candidates, if not all candidates, are gonna use at least a little bit of a mix of Positive and negative ads, but for the most part, most candidates are going to employ a lot of negative campaign ads. And they're used so often because we often respond to it. And a lot of it is our negativity bias. Even people who are more optimistic can fall into this trap of negativity bias. We tend to better remember things that we have a negative reaction to. Things that make us angry, things that make us fearful. That's why fear is so often used in campaign acts. And we also tend to be more interested in conflicts like legislative fights in Congress or mean or offensive remarks from one political person made about another political person. Conflicts are negative. Now that's not to say that conflicts can't serve. a a purpose, but the problem is we have way too many conflicts and we try to find conflicts about everything. And things that are framed more negatively tend to be more persistent in our mind. We tend to take a glass half full mentality with a lot of these things when it comes to politics. And one example is whenever you see statistics, whether it's government statistics or any statistics that you see in a poll, whether we have a vested interest in pulling the Positive number or the negative number. For example, when we talk about employment in America, you always see it as unemployment rate. You never see employment rate. But if I were to paint something as we've got 93% employment, you're to hear that and go, wow, that's pretty good. The vast majority of people are working in America. They've got a job. That's great. But if you turn it into, well, that's 7% unemployment, now all of a sudden, Geez, that's really high. And that is really high. Seven percent unemployment is is a way too high of an unemployment rate. You usually want somewhere between three to five percent. Usually three to five percent is a healthy economy. Obviously you'd like to have zero percent unemployment, but that's just not feasible. Another negative frame or type of negative frame that's often remembered is whenever nicknames are used about people. They're succinct and they're oftentimes catchy. Whenever you hear any sort of derogatory nickname for somebody, prime example would be Richard Nixon. He was called Tricky Dick long before the Watergate scandal. He he was called that since the 1950s. And even though he would eventually win. Twice in the presidency he would resign during his second term, but even though he won quite a few elections, that tricky dick nickname followed him for pretty much the entire time, and especially when Watergate happened. Or you can turn to Donald Trump and his many nicknames for people. Now that I know people are gonna hear that and automatically think that that's just that making one declaration one way or another about him, but objectively. He has a lot of derogatory nicknames for people. So you hear those kinds of things, those are have a very negative connotation. So you're going to remember them a lot. And also with negativity bias, we are often focused on minimizing our pain and protecting ourselves from danger, or at least what we perceive as pain and danger. And a couple of ways you see that is we have a very high incumbency win rate. Because people are fearful of the unknown. They just t a lot of times will go with who they know. And of course, incumbents have more resources at this at their disposal, generally speaking, because they're already in office. But part of it is that people already know who the incumbent is. And unless they really don't like the incumbent, they're gonna be less likely to come out to vote. So it's just harder for challengers to win. And a lot of voters in general vote. against somebody rather than for somebody else. They see this person as bringing nothing but pain and danger to America. And so There's a lot there's not as much positively voting for somebody. It's much more negatively voting against somebody. And so we should ask ourselves, do we really actually hate negative campaigning? We talk about how much we wish ads were positive in that Gallup poll, for example. Of course, people say, we wish we had just positive ads, or we'd rather have no ads at all. Of course, we we want those things to happen. So it's not that we're lying when we say that we hate negative campaigning. A lot of us genuinely do, but we are often more responsive to negative campaigning than we want to admit. We don't even all agree on what constitutes negative campaigning. We just talked about it. Does just simply bringing up an opponent's stances on things count as negative campaigning. Is bringing up their legal troubles negative campaigning? And because we all have different thresholds for what is negative or goes too far, it's hard to sincerely have a blanket statement against all negative campaigning, to really say I hate all negative campaigning. We might say that, but do we really believe that one do we really believe when we say that we don't like any form of negative campaigning? And we get wrapped up in all these conflicts and politics because they tend to be more interesting than cooperation. And guess what? I'm guilty of it too. I'm not gonna pretend that I'm above all this because I'm not. None of us are. Conflicts and negativity tend to be more interesting. It's what we tend to gravitate to. Sometimes because we just find find it more interesting, and sometimes we're just trying to protect ourselves from something. And certain attacks that a lot of people would consider negative have become more acceptable in campaigning. There was a time where extramarital affairs were just not brought up at all. It's almost never talked about before Gary Hart got caught in. back in nineteen eighty seven. He was running for the Democratic nomination for president for the nineteen eighty eight election. And there were already rumors about him having an extramarital affair. And he dared the media to follow him and said, I'm not having an affair. And then they found out he was having an affair with a model named Donna Rice. Now that's if if that kind of thing is found out, that is obviously gonna be used. That is That is completely fair game now. And besides voters, candidates themselves often pledge that they will not go negative. A lot of them will also say, yeah, I I don't like the negativity in politics either. Even a lot of the most polarizing people in politics will say, well, yeah, I don't like negativity either. But then they claim that they must retaliate when their opponent goes negative and say, Well, they started it. I'm just having to respond and protect myself. But everybody's going to claim that. And yes, somebody has to start it, but Both sides will keep on doing it back and forth to each other. Republicans are gonna gonna do it, Democrats are gonna do it, independents will do it sometimes too. And so you one of the one of the phrases you often hear is when they go low, we go high. And now before you say anything, no, that is not directed at any candidate. Because that is what a lot of candidates claim they will do. They don't necessarily say those exact words, but they oftentimes claim that, well, we're gonna be the the bigger people here. We are going to be above the political fray. And they're not. A lot of the times they're not. If you have to make a big fuss about how you are above the political fray and your supporters are above the political fray, you might not actually be above the political fray. But there is that incentive for them to return fire lest they feel like, well, if I don't start attacking the other side, I'm going to fall behind. So I need to say something back. And of course, candidates are just going to claim that they're being informative, not being negative for the sake of being negative. But despite all that, that is not to say that negative campaigning always works, and that campaigns should only do that, because that is absolutely not true either. It's not even a consensus as to how much it works and when. Just like how there's not a consensus about what constitutes negative campaigning, there is not a consensus about how much it works, whether it works. Some political observers can be overly cynical and think, well, just everybody just responds to negative campaign ads. So of co people just just love the negativity. Yes, we have a negativity bias, but that's overly cynical. But on the other hand, people can also be v overly optimistic and be like, actually, negative campaigning doesn't work nearly as much as people think, and here's why. It can be very disingenuous to be totally one way or another. And it could be painted a lot more by what people want to be true. Where people want to be optimistic or they want to confirm their negativity bias. If negative campaigning weren't effective, it wouldn't be used in over two hundred years worth of American political campaigns. And a lot of times you get this there is this notion that negativity and in politics and nastiness is is this new front that's been opened, or relatively new front. How much it's in your face is new just because it's everywhere. Social media, you can get all this information at your fingertips right away. How quickly you get it is different. But we've had nastiness in in politics since politics was invented, and America is no exception. You had Adams versus Jefferson in the eighteen hundred election. That was particularly venomous. Two once stalwart friends that would not speak to each other for years afterwards until near the e end of their lives, they fortunately reconcile, but They got very nasty despite both of them being major contributors, major founding fathers. The coffin handbills in the eighteen twenty eight presidential election that John Quincy Adams used against Andrew Jackson, talking about people that he or John Quincy Adams saying that Andrew Jackson unjustly slaughtered people during his time as a military official. 1964, the Lyndon B. Johnson. Daisy ad against Barry Goldwater, where it was clearly implying that if you vote for Barry Goldwater, nuclear war is going to happen. So that's a slightly more contemporary example than the first two examples I use. But all that to say that we've had negative campaigning, regardless of our definitions of it, for hundreds of years. But at the same time, it is not a foolproof strategy. It might help only a little or not at all for the candidate that is trying to benefit, or it can have the exact opposite effect and backfire on that candidate. For all the negativity bias that we have, and for as much as we can respond to it, it does not always work. You have to look at the context of the race, including how competitive that race is projected to be, the partisan divide of the voters, if that's available, the campaign funds available, all sorts of things that you have to look at. To see whether or not negative campaigning is going to be effective. And if it is going to be effective, how much should you use? Because you shouldn't go a hundred percent into it either. And so we have some empirical studies findings to look to. Now, you also have to be careful with these and not just take them as blanket facts for every kind of race that you run. Because sometimes it might not work out this exact way. way. Just like how a blanket statement about negative campaigns always working is faulty, so is using these empirical studies findings ab against negative campaigning to say that, see, negative campaigning should not be used in these contexts ever. But that being said, some of the ways that negative campaigning can actually ha be ineffective or have the effect of backfiring on candidates. It can alienate more centrist and undecided voters who are already less likely to vote and make them sit home. And that can take your campaign if you need them to win. A lot of can campaigns need at least some of those voters to support them. negative campaigning is less effective when more people know the candidate because they can have more of a their Their opinion of the of the candidate is less malleable because they already have a preconceived notion of who that person is. Not to say that it can't ever work against people who are more well known, because it certainly can, but a lot of times it won't work as well. You can't mold people's opinion negatively against that candidate as easily because more people know who they are. negative campaigning is less impactful on races with wider margins. It's much more commonly used in close races and more impactful in those. A lot of times candidates who are falling behind will get desperate and try to use negative campaign ads, but a lot of times that's it's just not going to help them. If you're far enough ahead, there's not really much reason for you to run those ads. some people may get the sense voters may get the sense of That they are being deceived or that there is hypocrisy at play whenever there are certain negative campaigning tactics used. And so that negative campaigning can blow back on the candidate it's trying to help. And that's a lot of that is a very case by case basis, whether or not it's going to be something that people perceive as being deceptive, because once again, some people can look in an ad and say it's deceptive, and then some other people will look at that ad and say, no, that's just that's being truthful. But if a wide swath of people think they're being hoodwinked, then that negative campaigning can have a serious impact. There was a forget which one it was, I want to say it was a US Senate race. And Elizabeth Dole tried to lamb baste Kay Hagen as an atheist, as somebody who disbelieved in God. And that completely backfired on her. And also, lastly, negative campaigning from PECs, political action committees, tends to be less effective than coming from the candidate itself. When it comes more from the candidate, a lot of times it'll feel like, okay, this is more the source I un I have a better sense of, I guess is the way to put it. Not not that they necessarily Trust the source more per se, but there's more of a face that they could put to as to the source of these negative campaign ads as opposed to these packs, which people tend to have a negative opinion of in general. So that leaves us with one last question. Should we push back more against negative campaigning? I think it's pretty clear that there is too much negativity in politics, and I think most people would agree. But it's also unrealistic and silly to say that we just need to be positive all the time. And just saying, well, we should be more positive, that's not really. You you you need to be a little bit more specific than that. How do we be more positive? But you can't just be positive all the time because first of all, it is extraordinarily difficult to curb the amount of negative campaigning that we see, because there's often plenty of incentive to go low. So how many campaigns feel like they have to trade fire every single time they get attacked? And then when they go for the attack, then the other candidate feels like they have to attack again and it's just a vicious cycle. But besides the incentives that there are for these negative campaigning tactics, you have free speech concerns if you try to significantly curb it through law. The Citizens United case is A big example of why, which the ruling basically allows unlimited amounts of spending by super PACs for or against a candidate as long as that PAC does not coordinate with a campaign. That is very illegal. They cannot do that. But as long as they follow that guideline, they can raise and spend unlimited amounts of cash. Besides that part, it's How many people are going to say, well, I'm allowed to say this because this is a free country. I have First Amendment rights, and so I can say these negative things. And well, for the most part, they're right. You can't say anything you want to say, but for the most part, you are allowed to say those things. And so you would run into the First Amendment quite often if you tried to curb negative campaigning. But even if free speech wasn't what was Stopping any sort of laws, it would be incredibly challenging, if not impossible, to codify negative campaigning limitations into law because of how much disagreement there is on what constitutes negative campaigning. Is this ad a negative campaign ad? One person will say yes, second person will say no. Even if another person thinks it's negative campaigning, they might not agree that it's as negative as another person does. So you would have to get people to agree on what constitutes negative campaigning and therefore what kinds of campaigning you're allowed to curb. Are you not allowed to make personal attacks on people? Well, what constitutes a personal attack? If you bring up extramarital affairs or illegal drug use, is that getting too personal? Is or is are those exceptions that you could bring up? It's just So difficult to come up with ways to even if you pass the free speech test, getting people to agree on what negative campaigning tactics should be curb is very difficult to make happen because of incentives and legislative wheeling and dealing that you need to do. But negative campaigning does have a purpose. It can legitimately inform you. Even if it is biased, and of course the primary goal of these ads is not to inform you, it's to influence your vote. It's never primarily a public service, no matter how much the campaign that is supporting that ad will say it's trying to be a public service. But a lot of these ads can inform you, or it can bring up things that you never really considered before, and you can try to research those. But negative campaigning has gone overboard overall, and we can push back on it as voters, and candidates too, if they are willing. It always starts always starts with being more cognizant and self-aware of our susceptibility to negative ads. Regardless of whether these ads are valid or we think they're valid, we always need to be vigilant. Nobody's immune to it. We might think we are. A lot of people think that they're not capable of being manipulated, and most of the time, those are the people who are most easily manipulated. But No matter how much you agree with the ad, you need to stop a moment and simple and sincerely ask yourself how much an ad is trying to inform you and how much it is simply trying to sway your opinion so their side can win. It's always going to be the primary function of that ad is to sway your opinion. But is it actually trying to inform you? Is it something you need to look further into? And also be more proactive and reactive in researching elections and issues and everything else going on. Because negative ads are more impactful when you don't know as much about what is going on or who the people are because you haven't been able to form an opinion yet. And when you get negative ideas in your head first, it's hard to shake those. Not impossible to shake them, but it's hard to shake them. And so You want to start becoming more familiar ahead of time. And whatever you see, never take negative ads at face value. You look up what they are talking about every time to see if an ad is spinning the facts, if it's taking things out of context, if it's just straight up fabricating things. And certainly, definitely don't fall for simple partisan and ideological cues. Not saying this person's a conservative warrior, or this person's a progressive champion, or this one's a staunch Republican, staunch Democrat, or whatever it is. Don't just accept those things. Always be healthily skeptical. And a lot of times if it's just being overly partisan or ideological, you definitely need to be more careful and and aware of those ads. And if you truly hate negative campaign ads, and you do have more options on who to vote for, stand on business and hold these candidates accountable by not voting for them. Now, of course, you should research these other candidates first. I'm not just saying, well, if this person's running a bunch of negative ads, just vote for the other person. Not saying that. And a lot of times, those people will be running negative ads too. But the only way we get people to stop. Relying on negative ads to get candidates to stop relying on negative ads is to stop responding so much to them. Actually punish them at the ballot box if you think that they are being too negative. Or if you see a negative ad on TV, change the channel. You can mute it, and sometimes I do it too, but you're still get it's still getting a view, and so it's going to think, well, I'm going to the people who are propagating the ad are going to say, well then we need to just push this out more because people are seeing it. No. You're on a on a you see an ad on the computer, close that tab, go to a different tab. Mm might be too difficult to do that because every time you open up a tab, it might and go on a website, it might still show you that that ad. So I'm not going to pretend that it's a foolproof strategy, but deliberately find a way to Move away from that ad and try to research these things for yourself. Don't completely sallow yourself from politics as a result because then you're just letting people who are polarized have a greater, more outsized effect on the results, and that's going to lead to more negativity in politics because polarized people have a vested interest in being more negative. So you want to not just completely recuse yourself from politics, but try to deliberately find more positive content and more straight up informative content. Look up these things for yourself. And there are some other suggestions that have been made by researchers for candidates and campaigners. But be careful making blanket assumptions that these automatically work too. Just like with blanket statements about getting rid of negative ads, or you don't just make blanket assumptions that these are going to be more effective than negative ads. A lot of times academics take the results of their study, and even though they say that future research can build upon it. A lot of times they'll still think that their results are going to be inherently more applicable to more scenarios than it actually will be. But these are still things to think about. Few things here, th three things that you should consider if you're a candidate and you want to be more positive. Once you find an effective positive frame for yourself, you focus on it and repeat it over and over and over and over again. You know what's oftentimes even more effective than negativity? Repetition. Even if it's positive and you repeat it over and over, it'll get stuck on people's heads. Now of course, negativity repeated over and over again can too, but You find an effective positive frame, just because it's a positive frame doesn't mean it's going to be effective. But if you find one that works, hammer it home. And if you're a voter, find that those positive things and don't just get caught up in the negatives all the time. Not necessarily saying that you should get caught up in all the positives as well, because you need to take the good and the bad and balance them together, but don't get overly focused on finding negative stuff. Stay positive as long as you can out advertise your opponent. There's that's no small task. Obviously, you gotta have a lot of money to do that. You gotta be able to keep pace with spending, especially when you're running for one of these really big time elections like US Senate, for example, and especially president. And lastly, offer voters a new unfamiliar situation with the possibility of a major gain. People fear the unknown. But if you can find a way to present them a sort of think of all the gains you can make if you go with my campaign. That can also have a potentially major impact on your campaign and you don't have to rely as much on negative ads. So don't get too caught up in all the negativity, but don't just assume that positivity is what is necessary all the time. Negativity has its place, but negativity for its own sake is not solving anybody's problems. So it's all well and good to say that you hate negative campaigning. I hate a lot of it too, but it we're more responsive to it than we want to admit, and it does have its place. It just needs to be curtailed a bit, which is very hard to do. So think about those things the next time you see negative campaign ad, which will probably be the next five minutes because you can't go anywhere seemingly without a campaign ad being thrown in your face. But always remain vigilant, no matter what, in when it comes to politics. And that's gonna wrap it up for today's episode of Politics with Paul. As always, thank you so much for tuning in, for watching, for listening. Please like, share, comment, subscribe. My links are in the show notes, my other works like my five-day educational email course about how we can all be more effective at mitigating polarization and toxicity, some of the mistakes we make that accidentally make polarization worse, and how we can fix those mistakes, my book on Amazon about political independence, and my writings on medium.com, my other links, my LinkedIn profile, my Facebook page, my website, Paul Raider.org, and my email, Paul Raiderwrites at gmail.com. And that's gonna wrap things up for today. As always, once again, thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.