Latest / Politics By Faith w/Mike Slater / Pete Hegseth Makes UNPRECEDENTED Announcement
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to Politics by
- 0:06Faith.
- 0:06This is where we take the news of the day and then
- 0:08we bring it to the Bible so we can walk away with peace
- 0:11and perspective.
- 0:12There's new headlines every single day.
- 0:14But Ecclesiastes says it's not the new under the sun.
- 0:16So thanks for being here to get the true story.
- 0:18And by the end of the show today,
- 0:20I hope we will know a little bit more about
- 0:22justice.
- 0:24The story of the day,
- 0:25televised
- 0:26execution.
- 0:28Televised live streamed,
- 0:30but even that's a question
- 0:32because
- 0:33I don't know what the rules are even.
- 0:35I guess it's like Google allow this to be on YouTube.
- 0:38I don't know how this is gonna work.
- 0:39Here's
- 0:40what's going on.
- 0:41Nadal
- 0:41Hassan,
- 0:42he's a former
- 0:43Army major.
- 0:44He was an Army Medical Corps psychiatrist,
- 0:47and he was a,
- 0:48um,
- 0:49when he was a medical intern
- 0:51at Walter Reed,
- 0:52people talked about his behavior
- 0:53and how he's becoming increasingly
- 0:56anti-American.
- 0:58Fourth-year residents,
- 0:59they gave
- 1:00medical presentations,
- 1:02but he decided to give his,
- 1:04his,
- 1:04uh,
- 1:04presentation in front of doctors,
- 1:06uh,
- 1:06about the Koranic worldview
- 1:09and its implications for the US military.
- 1:13And he presented this argument that certain people
- 1:18can't be expected to live in harmony to Muslims,
- 1:21can't be expected to live in harmony with,
- 1:23with non-believers and Muslims should fight against
- 1:26non-believers.
- 1:28And then he said,
- 1:29made the argument that the military should allow Muslims
- 1:32to
- 1:33not have to serve like a conscientious objection
- 1:36to against serving
- 1:37in Iraq and Afghanistan.
- 1:39Now you may remember in,
- 1:41so there were,
- 1:41there were signs,
- 1:43it's almost always the case.
- 1:45These are almost never
- 1:47lone wolves.
- 1:47You hear about this lone wolf?
- 1:48No,
- 1:49they're mostly
- 1:50known wolves.
- 1:51This guy was on our radar too.
- 1:54You may remember in 2009,
- 1:56there was a shooting at a military recruitment office
- 1:58in Little Rock.
- 2:00And,
- 2:00uh,
- 2:01this guy,
- 2:01he killed a private and then injured another as well.
- 2:04He was a,
- 2:05a Muslim convert.
- 2:06His name was Carlos Bledsoe,
- 2:08but he changed his name to
- 2:09Abdul Kamen
- 2:12Mujaheed
- 2:13Muhammad.
- 2:14He went to Yemen to teach English.
- 2:17Came back,
- 2:19killed an American soldier.
- 2:21Nadal
- 2:22thought that was great.
- 2:24A colonel
- 2:25who worked with Nidal Hassan.
- 2:27He said he would make these outlandish statements about the war in Iraq
- 2:30and how the Muslims should stand up and fight against the aggressor.
- 2:33That was us.
- 2:33This is all while he was
- 2:35in the army.
- 2:38In the midst of all this,
- 2:40what we knew about him and the things he was saying,
- 2:42we
- 2:43promoted him
- 2:44to major.
- 2:46And then transferred him
- 2:48to Fort Hood.
- 2:50While he was at Fort Hood,
- 2:51he received poor performance reviews
- 2:53from supervisors.
- 2:54There was even investigation to him by the FBI
- 2:58because he was emailing
- 2:59with someone
- 3:00in,
- 3:02uh,
- 3:02somewhere in the middle of somewhere in Afghanistan or I,
- 3:04I forget exactly who it was and where it was,
- 3:07but,
- 3:07uh,
- 3:07the,
- 3:07the,
- 3:08the FBI determined that this correspondence was all medical
- 3:10related.
- 3:11Looking back at like,
- 3:12hm,
- 3:12boys,
- 3:13again.
- 3:14Known wolf
- 3:16So on October 5th,
- 3:182009,
- 3:19he went to work,
- 3:21Fort Hood.
- 3:22Shouted Allahu Akbar.
- 3:24And fired
- 3:26At unarmed soldiers,
- 3:28injured 10,
- 3:29excuse me,
- 3:30uh,
- 3:30killed
- 3:3110 men
- 3:32and 3 women.
- 3:34One of those women was pregnant.
- 3:36And then wounded 30 others.
- 3:39This was the worst terrorist attack
- 3:41on American soil since 9/11.
- 3:44The entire attack it lasted 10 minutes
- 3:46before he was shot by an army police officer.
- 3:51Just real quick on the shooting part,
- 3:53um,
- 3:53the,
- 3:54the,
- 3:54the,
- 3:54I took an army police officer.
- 3:55I remember when this happened,
- 3:57and one of the many topics that we talked about is what do you like,
- 4:00why are guys unarmed on these military bases?
- 4:03But
- 4:03if anyone were to be armed,
- 4:05be on a military base,
- 4:06like everyone's trained
- 4:07how do you,
- 4:07well,
- 4:08no,
- 4:08they weren't.
- 4:10Hassan said he switched sides
- 4:12and he regarded himself as a mujahideen
- 4:15waging jihad
- 4:17against the US military.
- 4:20In the trial,
- 4:21he had a defense attorney
- 4:22and he like screwed it all up and the whole thing,
- 4:24he made it seem like he wanted the death penalty.
- 4:27He ended up representing himself
- 4:29and he didn't do anything.
- 4:30He didn't call any witnesses.
- 4:31He,
- 4:31he didn't do any stuff.
- 4:33So in the end,
- 4:33a military jury.
- 4:35Found,
- 4:36um,
- 4:37it was comprised of 9 colonels,
- 4:383 lieutenant colonels,
- 4:40and 1 major.
- 4:41They convicted Hassan on all charges,
- 4:4313 murder charges,
- 4:4430 attempted murder charges.
- 4:46Now,
- 4:47one could imagine
- 4:48that he wanted to be put to death because he wanted to be a martyr.
- 4:52But the lead prosecutor in the case,
- 4:55when he was arguing for the death penalty.
- 4:57He said Hassan can never be a martyr
- 5:00because he has nothing to give.
- 5:03Do not be misled,
- 5:04do not be confused,
- 5:04do not be fooled.
- 5:05He's not giving his life.
- 5:07We are taking his life.
- 5:09This is not his gift to God,
- 5:11it's his debt to society.
- 5:14We will not now and will not ever,
- 5:16he will not now and not ever be a martyr.
- 5:20So the jury came back and recommended death.
- 5:23This was back in 2013,
- 5:24it's been 13 years.
- 5:26In 2014,
- 5:27he wrote to Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi,
- 5:29who was then the head of the Islamic State,
- 5:32that he wanted to be made a citizen of the Islamic State,
- 5:35and he ended his letter with SOA a soldier of Allah.
- 5:40And talked about how he wanted to be put to death.
- 5:42Which is great because his day is finally coming.
- 5:44Execution day is December 3rd
- 5:47at 1 o'clock,
- 5:48the exact same time he started killing.
- 5:51His,
- 5:51I hate to say this,
- 5:52his fellow soldiers.
- 5:55You may also remember
- 5:56when this happened,
- 5:57Barack Obama.
- 5:58Barack Obama,
- 5:59do you remember what he called this terrorist attack,
- 6:00Worst terrorist attack
- 6:02on American
- 6:03soil since 9/11?
- 6:0513 Americans killed,
- 6:0630,
- 6:0630 injured.
- 6:07Do you remember what he called it?
- 6:09He called it
- 6:10workplace violence.
- 6:13Workplace violence.
- 6:17This
- 6:19Naming at workplace odds was more
- 6:21than just
- 6:22uh refusing to admit who the enemy is
- 6:24or being careful not to hurt the feelings of Muslims.
- 6:28By calling it workplace violence,
- 6:30the families of those killed
- 6:32and the people who were injured were not entitled to combat related disability.
- 6:37So there was,
- 6:37there was more than just the.
- 6:40The,
- 6:40uh,
- 6:41you know,
- 6:41lingo
- 6:42of what to call it.
- 6:45Hassan
- 6:46As an American,
- 6:47he engaged in
- 6:49uh betrayal,
- 6:50uh treason.
- 6:51This was treason.
- 6:52It was a terrorist attack,
- 6:53treason.
- 6:55So the military
- 6:57then decided to
- 6:57put him to death and then decided
- 6:59that it was gonna be by means of
- 7:01firing squad.
- 7:04Now
- 7:05Here's where it gets
- 7:07even more interesting.
- 7:09On
- 7:10Thursday,
- 7:11last week Thursday,
- 7:12we were talking to the Breitbart 2nd Amendment correspondent,
- 7:14AWR Hawkins,
- 7:15who's awesome.
- 7:17And we talked about a bunch of things and at the end
- 7:19of our 30-minute conversation,
- 7:20I just,
- 7:21it's kind of like a passing thought.
- 7:23Uh,
- 7:24I said,
- 7:24hey,
- 7:24and this is in light of
- 7:26the botched lethal injection execution
- 7:29of Krista Pike in Tennessee,
- 7:31first woman
- 7:32to be executed in Tennessee in like 102 years,
- 7:34and it's like,
- 7:35it's like a horrific
- 7:36murderer,
- 7:38and,
- 7:38uh,
- 7:39they botched it,
- 7:39they screwed it up,
- 7:40they couldn't do it.
- 7:41Now she requested an all-female.
- 7:43Team,
- 7:44like,
- 7:44uh,
- 7:44execution team.
- 7:45I don't know if she got that.
- 7:45I it's unbelievable.
- 7:47Like they did,
- 7:47they couldn't do it.
- 7:47They couldn't figure out.
- 7:48Then they brought her to the hospital,
- 7:49which is crazy,
- 7:50and they saved her life,
- 7:52and then she just got released to the hospital.
- 7:53Anyway,
- 7:53so they botched that execution in Tennessee.
- 7:57So then,
- 7:57so then,
- 7:58then I hear like,
- 7:58oh,
- 7:58they wanna
- 7:59kill this guy by firing squad.
- 8:00So,
- 8:01oh,
- 8:01here's our 2nd Amendment correspondent.
- 8:02What,
- 8:02what do you think about
- 8:04killing someone
- 8:05by means of firing squad?
- 8:07And he said,
- 8:07yeah,
- 8:07it's great.
- 8:08Uh,
- 8:09but he,
- 8:09he said this is though when it's controversial.
- 8:11He said,
- 8:12uh,
- 8:12I think it should be.
- 8:14Live streamed
- 8:16But he,
- 8:17he didn't say last year.
- 8:17He said,
- 8:17I,
- 8:18I think,
- 8:18he said,
- 8:18I think it should be on pay per view.
- 8:21I think the execution should be on pay per view.
- 8:22It's AWR I think it should be on pay per view,
- 8:24and the money should go to the victims
- 8:25and their families.
- 8:28That was the end of the interview,
- 8:29I said goodbye.
- 8:30A couple of hours later,
- 8:31Pete Hegseth,
- 8:31the Secretary of War,
- 8:32comes out and says that this execution is gonna be live streamed.
- 8:35Anyone in the public can see it.
- 8:39So,
- 8:39we opened up the phones on this one,
- 8:41had a wonderful conversation.
- 8:42We did a 10-listener poll.
- 8:43Should the execution be
- 8:45live streamed?
- 8:46For the sake of this conversation,
- 8:47we went past the question of should he be put to death.
- 8:49That's a different conversation that I've changed my tune on relatively recently.
- 8:53Uh,
- 8:54so,
- 8:54so he is gonna be put to death.
- 8:55That's a done deal.
- 8:57Should it be live streamed for everyone to see?
- 9:00And we also looked past again,
- 9:01I kind of alluded to the technical problems with this,
- 9:03like,
- 9:04Who's gonna air that?
- 9:06YouTube,
- 9:07you can't air
- 9:08dead,
- 9:08you can't put dead people on TV.
- 9:10You can't show the image of dead people on TV.
- 9:12You can't,
- 9:12like YouTube has all these rules.
- 9:14You can't,
- 9:14I mean,
- 9:14I,
- 9:15I don't even know where they're gonna put it.
- 9:164chan.
- 9:17I don't know where you're gonna live stream something like this.
- 9:20Rumble,
- 9:20I guess,
- 9:20I don't,
- 9:21right?
- 9:22So,
- 9:23uh,
- 9:24putting that aside.
- 9:26Do you think it should be live streamed?
- 9:28Now,
- 9:28since Pete Hexhath said this,
- 9:30there's been some pushback.
- 9:31Trump came out after saying he
- 9:33was hooked with it.
- 9:34Now he's saying,
- 9:35uh,
- 9:35that he will make the ultimate decision if it will happen.
- 9:38There's been a handful of Republicans,
- 9:40uh,
- 9:40saying that we shouldn't do this.
- 9:42ABC and of course the media made a big deal about those,
- 9:44those 5 or so that,
- 9:45that I read about.
- 9:46ABC News found 2 of the victims of the terrorist attack.
- 9:49Alonzo Lunsford was a sergeant at Fort Hood.
- 9:51Hassan shot him 7 times,
- 9:53including in the head.
- 9:55And,
- 9:55and then he
- 9:56watched Hassan
- 9:57kill his colleagues and friends.
- 9:59He said he plans to attend the execution in person
- 10:02because he wants to lock eyes
- 10:04with Hassan.
- 10:05He said,
- 10:05I want him to be able to look at my eyes
- 10:08and to let him understand I won't be defeated.
- 10:10I can't be defeated.
- 10:12I'm no longer a victim,
- 10:13his victim.
- 10:14I am a survivor.
- 10:17And when asked about death by firing squad,
- 10:19so,
- 10:19so that's the first question.
- 10:20Should he be executed?
- 10:21Yes,
- 10:21and I will be there.
- 10:23Should it be by firing squad?
- 10:24He said,
- 10:24yeah,
- 10:24he shot us.
- 10:26Then he was asked,
- 10:27what do you think about live stream,
- 10:28and that's where
- 10:29he had a little more
- 10:30hesitation about it.
- 10:32Diane Ferguson,
- 10:32she was 21,
- 10:34she was shot 3 times,
- 10:35arm,
- 10:35shoulder,
- 10:35and thigh.
- 10:37And she was asked about live stream and making it public and she said,
- 10:39well,
- 10:40it's historically.
- 10:42Precedented
- 10:46Which of course is true,
- 10:47we'll get to that in a minute.
- 10:48The Atlantic
- 10:49then published a story,
- 10:51uh about the countries that,
- 10:53that still do public executions.
- 10:56Now,
- 10:57I imagine
- 10:58All countries did at one point,
- 11:01we did.
- 11:02But the only two that still do
- 11:04are Iran and Afghanistan.
- 11:06So of course,
- 11:06they're like,
- 11:06oh,
- 11:07we're just as bad as those two countries.
- 11:09This piece was written by,
- 11:10uh,
- 11:10Admiral McCraven,
- 11:12retired four-star general,
- 11:13former commander of Special Operations Command,
- 11:152011,
- 11:152014.
- 11:17He said,
- 11:17I teach a graduate class on national security decision making.
- 11:20I give my students a framework for thinking about how to make difficult decisions.
- 11:23The first question they have to answer before they can get to the right decision is,
- 11:27who are we as a nation?
- 11:30That's the big question.
- 11:31Who are we as a nation?
- 11:32I think we should ask the same question when we're deciding whether or not
- 11:35this should be live streamed.
- 11:36Who are we as a nation?
- 11:36That's a very good question.
- 11:39McCraven goes on,
- 11:40our values as a nation matter.
- 11:41It's not naive to think that we should have a sense
- 11:43of propriety when carrying out the harsh business of justice,
- 11:46to believe in our national sense of honor.
- 11:49So here,
- 11:50hey,
- 11:50let me just interrupt you.
- 11:53One could make the case.
- 11:55It is honorable
- 11:57to do this.
- 11:58So,
- 11:58the assumption is,
- 12:00this is me talking now,
- 12:01the assumption is
- 12:02that it is,
- 12:03um,
- 12:04it is dishonorable.
- 12:07Then who we are as a nation.
- 12:07Oh,
- 12:08we,
- 12:08we should,
- 12:09we could never do such a horrible thing.
- 12:12Well,
- 12:12maybe we are a nation that believes in justice.
- 12:15Now it should be swift justice,
- 12:16the swift
- 12:17that has,
- 12:18uh,
- 12:19that's,
- 12:19that's,
- 12:19it's set sail a long time ago,
- 12:21but we can at least have
- 12:22justice.
- 12:22And he says,
- 12:23well,
- 12:23you know,
- 12:23don't we believe in our national sense of honor,
- 12:25honor?
- 12:26Uh,
- 12:26maybe we haven't
- 12:28because we haven't been doing these in a,
- 12:29in a long time.
- 12:30Maybe a nation that has a sense of honor would have public executions,
- 12:34actually.
- 12:35And to expect our leaders to behave with dignity.
- 12:38Maybe this is the dignified thing to do.
- 12:41Integrity,
- 12:41civility,
- 12:42humility.
- 12:44Yeah,
- 12:44humility,
- 12:45understanding
- 12:46God's commands and how the state
- 12:49should treat
- 12:50people like this.
- 12:51That is humility.
- 12:54The the humility is understanding,
- 12:55well,
- 12:55like what,
- 12:56what does God say about justice?
- 12:58And what the penalty of justice should be,
- 13:01and who am I in that scenario.
- 13:04In that system,
- 13:05and we'll get to what the Bible says about it
- 13:07in just a second,
- 13:07but that is the humble thing.
- 13:09The assumption and the McCraven and all the liberals,
- 13:11whoever,
- 13:11they,
- 13:11they're,
- 13:12what they want you to think is that the humble thing is,
- 13:14oh,
- 13:15we'll just,
- 13:16well,
- 13:16that's,
- 13:16that's barbaric.
- 13:19Maybe not.
- 13:20He said these values build stronger,
- 13:22smarter,
- 13:22more humane
- 13:24societies.
- 13:24They engender good alliances,
- 13:26they drive,
- 13:26what does that have to do with any of this?
- 13:27They drive trust in businesses and higher education
- 13:30and they inspire our men and women in
- 13:32uniform.
- 13:32I don't,
- 13:32I don't know why any of the thing that McCraven
- 13:34said there means we shouldn't have a public execution.
- 13:39Now,
- 13:40There are some practical things to consider
- 13:42here.
- 13:43You may have a vision of what this looks like.
- 13:46Um,
- 13:48let me
- 13:48add a little.
- 13:50Data point to it.
- 13:52He's 56.
- 13:53I'm sure he doesn't look
- 13:55great.
- 13:56And he's paralyzed from the waist down.
- 14:00So,
- 14:00that kind of,
- 14:01if,
- 14:01if you think this would be a position of a thing of strength.
- 14:05He's gonna be so weak,
- 14:06almost pitiable.
- 14:08And frail,
- 14:09people may feel bad for him.
- 14:11I believe before they do the live stream,
- 14:13there should be a short video on what he did,
- 14:16so everyone knows exactly what happened.
- 14:18It doesn't have to be sensational in any way,
- 14:19just here,
- 14:20here's what happened.
- 14:21Just like I did in the opening,
- 14:23just so everyone knows,
- 14:24and they don't fall for,
- 14:26you know,
- 14:26his walking out off.
- 14:27They kind of did that with,
- 14:28um,
- 14:28Harvey Weinstein.
- 14:29You know,
- 14:29Harvey Weinstein looks awful now,
- 14:31right?
- 14:31Uh,
- 14:32he's like walking with a cane.
- 14:33He just looks terrible.
- 14:33You kind of like feel bad for the guy.
- 14:35Like,
- 14:35you don't,
- 14:35you don't want anyone feeling bad
- 14:37for Nadal Hassan.
- 14:40But if he comes out,
- 14:41you know,
- 14:41in a wheelchair,
- 14:42we wheel him out,
- 14:44paralyzed old man.
- 14:46He's only 56,
- 14:47but he's gonna look
- 14:48a lot worse than that.
- 14:49And I hope,
- 14:50I,
- 14:50I just wanna make sure that that doesn't
- 14:52backfire,
- 14:53if you will.
- 14:54Uh,
- 14:54this will be the first service member to be executed since 1961.
- 14:57There's a couple of different
- 14:58arguments about the last
- 15:00public execution.
- 15:01Um,
- 15:01I'm gonna land on 1936.
- 15:03There was a guy,
- 15:04a 70-year-old,
- 15:05there was a guy who,
- 15:06who,
- 15:06uh,
- 15:07raped a 70-year-old,
- 15:08uh,
- 15:09in Kentucky.
- 15:10Now.
- 15:11Phil Donahue,
- 15:13back in 1994,
- 15:14he said
- 15:15that
- 15:16Um,
- 15:17execution should be public.
- 15:18It should be broadcast.
- 15:20But he did it.
- 15:22He thought they should be broadcast so that people could see how barbaric it is,
- 15:26and then be against it.
- 15:28There's a website,
- 15:29a website called Showbiz 411,
- 15:31uh,
- 15:31talking about this.
- 15:32He said he advocated for the live execution of Timothy McVeigh,
- 15:34the Oklahoma City bomber.
- 15:36And now Pete Hegseth,
- 15:37a grotesque character,
- 15:39is going to let it happen.
- 15:40He's all for promoting violence.
- 15:43A firing squad,
- 15:44that's right,
- 15:44the most atrocious thing that could be shown on TV or streaming.
- 15:48It's atrocious.
- 15:50Has anyone watched TV lately?
- 15:53Hegseth,
- 15:53a dangerous clown
- 15:55who will be pilloried by historians,
- 15:56that's not true,
- 15:58told the website,
- 15:58we'll make sure people are able to watch it,
- 16:00that it's public because people need to understand
- 16:02that there's serious consequences for these
- 16:04types
- 16:05of things.
- 16:06Now,
- 16:07uh,
- 16:07so that's an interesting point about Phil Donahue,
- 16:09that he,
- 16:09that he,
- 16:10so maybe when people see this,
- 16:11they'll be
- 16:12more against the death penalty.
- 16:14Now,
- 16:14Erick Erickson has another practical,
- 16:16uh,
- 16:16thing.
- 16:17Uh,
- 16:18he says maybe this could be used,
- 16:19uh,
- 16:20the,
- 16:20the Nadal Hassan execution will,
- 16:21will be used to,
- 16:23uh,
- 16:23people,
- 16:23you know,
- 16:24terrorists around the world will celebrate his martyrdom,
- 16:26and it will be used to recruit new terrorists.
- 16:28He says it will be a recruiting bonanza.
- 16:30I disagree with that.
- 16:31Everything
- 16:33by the terrorist is a recruiting bonanza,
- 16:35a recruiting tool.
- 16:37The,
- 16:37the guy who would be the founder of the Muslim Brotherhood
- 16:40was radicalized when he was in,
- 16:41I believe,
- 16:41Colorado
- 16:42in like 1950.
- 16:45And he heard,
- 16:47Baby,
- 16:47it's cold outside.
- 16:50Yes,
- 16:50that's right,
- 16:51Muslim Brotherhood was inspired
- 16:52as a reaction to the song,
- 16:53Baby,
- 16:54It's Cold Outside,
- 16:55so
- 16:56whatever,
- 16:57we cannot live our life making decisions.
- 17:00Based on what we think the terrorists might not like.
- 17:04We have a history of public executions in America,
- 17:07uh,
- 17:07mixed thoughts from our founders.
- 17:09Uh,
- 17:09Benjamin Rush,
- 17:10uh,
- 17:10believed that public executions
- 17:12actually led to people having less of a respect for life,
- 17:15which then could lead to more murder.
- 17:18Um,
- 17:19Thomas Jefferson,
- 17:20these guys all wrote on this,
- 17:20by the way.
- 17:21Rush,
- 17:21Rush wrote an essay called An Inquiry into the
- 17:23Effects of Public Punishments upon Criminals and upon Society.
- 17:27Uh,
- 17:27it's a short little thing.
- 17:28I,
- 17:28I don't find any of his other arguments convincing.
- 17:30That,
- 17:30that's a pretty interesting argument.
- 17:31People value life less,
- 17:32therefore murder more.
- 17:34I don't know.
- 17:35His other arguments are not good.
- 17:36He said,
- 17:36uh,
- 17:37people may want to commit suicide,
- 17:38but they think that's a sin.
- 17:40So they'll murder someone
- 17:41in order to be executed.
- 17:44I guess
- 17:45it's like suicide by cop,
- 17:46I guess,
- 17:46kind of thing,
- 17:47maybe.
- 17:48I guess it's a slightly different.
- 17:49That's more of like someone who's like too cowardly to
- 17:52do it themselves.
- 17:52I don't know.
- 17:53Uh,
- 17:54he said some people don't like the death penalty,
- 17:56so they'll be less likely to convict someone.
- 18:00I don't know.
- 18:00I,
- 18:01I didn't find his argument.
- 18:01I love Benjamin Rush,
- 18:02but I didn't find those arguments very convincing.
- 18:03Thomas Jefferson wrote that he actually wrote a bill
- 18:05called,
- 18:06um,
- 18:07uh,
- 18:07proportioning Crimes and punishments.
- 18:09And he said the death penalty should only be used for treason and murder.
- 18:14Yeah,
- 18:14I think,
- 18:15I think we agree with that.
- 18:16I'd add rape
- 18:17to that list as well,
- 18:18but.
- 18:20Uh,
- 18:21so he wasn't against execution.
- 18:23He actually wrote in the bill that if you
- 18:27murder someone in a duel,
- 18:29you should be hanged.
- 18:31And if you were the challenger of the duel,
- 18:34and you won the duel,
- 18:35then not only should you be,
- 18:37so you started it,
- 18:38not only should you be hanged,
- 18:39he said your body should be
- 18:40gibbeted.
- 18:42This is a gibbeted body is a body that's on display,
- 18:45the corpse,
- 18:46the corpse is on display for a period of time for people to see
- 18:48the dead dangling corpse.
- 18:50This is something that's happened all over the world,
- 18:53and Thomas Jefferson was for that
- 18:55in Virginia.
- 18:57And then what about the founder of our country,
- 18:58George Washington,
- 18:59our,
- 18:59our,
- 18:59the father of America?
- 19:00He supported him.
- 19:02At least in the military,
- 19:02Thomas Hickney was a member of Washington's security guard,
- 19:06and he was convicted of mutiny
- 19:07and sedition,
- 19:08and,
- 19:08uh,
- 19:09George Washington ordered him hanged and then ordered 4 brigades to witness it.
- 19:12There are around 20,000 people who watched this public execution.
- 19:17Um
- 19:18He said,
- 19:19uh,
- 19:20he said he hopes that it will be,
- 19:21this is George Washington,
- 19:22he hopes it'll be a warning to every soldier in the army to avoid
- 19:25these crimes
- 19:27that are so disgraceful to the character of
- 19:28a soldier and pernicious to this country.
- 19:31There's another guy,
- 19:32Ebenezer Leffingwell.
- 19:34He kept,
- 19:35uh,
- 19:35retreating from the enemy.
- 19:37So Washington ordered him to be shot in the head.
- 19:39And he ordered soldiers
- 19:41to watch.
- 19:43Now people will say,
- 19:44um,
- 19:45no,
- 19:45that's military,
- 19:45so I don't,
- 19:46I don't know.
- 19:46I,
- 19:46I couldn't find any of his thoughts and I can look some more
- 19:49on his,
- 19:49uh,
- 19:50You know,
- 19:50among citizens,
- 19:52not just in the military,
- 19:53but,
- 19:54uh,
- 19:54I can't imagine the principle would be much different
- 19:56for those pernicious crimes.
- 19:57Now people will say,
- 19:58oh,
- 19:58but the fact the,
- 19:59uh,
- 19:59Constitution says there shouldn't be cruel and unusual punishment.
- 20:02That's interesting.
- 20:02It's in the 8th Amendment.
- 20:04Is firing squad cruel and unusual?
- 20:06I don't think it's cruel at all,
- 20:07but it's definitely not unusual,
- 20:08so it doesn't fit those standards.
- 20:11There was,
- 20:11uh,
- 20:12an ancient
- 20:13form of
- 20:13execution
- 20:14goes back to ancient Rome all the way through the 1600s in England.
- 20:18Uh,
- 20:18it was called poena
- 20:20culia,
- 20:21Latin for penalty of the sack.
- 20:24So this one,
- 20:24it was a murder,
- 20:25mostly,
- 20:26um,
- 20:26my understanding is a murderer,
- 20:27someone who murders like uh,
- 20:28uh,
- 20:28their mother or father,
- 20:30but the person was beaten
- 20:31until they're bleeding all over,
- 20:33then tied up,
- 20:34hands and,
- 20:34uh,
- 20:35arms,
- 20:35uh,
- 20:35arms and legs tied,
- 20:37and then thrown into a leather sack.
- 20:39And then thrown into the sack was a live serpent,
- 20:42rooster,
- 20:43monkey,
- 20:44and dog.
- 20:46And the sack was thrown in the back of a wagon
- 20:48and paraded through the town.
- 20:49Could you imagine the sounds?
- 20:53And then the sack was thrown into water and everyone drowned.
- 20:56I put that online and someone wrote back,
- 20:57poor dog.
- 21:00I believe though that is what our founders had in mind when they talked about,
- 21:03uh,
- 21:03cruel,
- 21:04unusual punishment.
- 21:05Notice they didn't say death,
- 21:06no death penalty.
- 21:07They could have said that,
- 21:07they could have said no death penalty in the 8th Amendment.
- 21:09They didn't do that.
- 21:09They knew the death penalty was
- 21:11proper.
- 21:12Of course there's gotta be a death penalty,
- 21:14we just wanna figure out the best way to use it,
- 21:16and we believe there shouldn't be any cruel and unusual
- 21:19punishments.
- 21:22Uh,
- 21:23I was wondering the reasons
- 21:24why we stopped public executions.
- 21:26Like,
- 21:26was it.
- 21:28Because,
- 21:29you know,
- 21:29genuinely people
- 21:31were appalled at the site and
- 21:33Uh,
- 21:34it wasn't a deterrent anymore.
- 21:35Maybe people,
- 21:35it was becoming too much of a party
- 21:37and not,
- 21:38not good for the soul of our nation.
- 21:41Or
- 21:42was it just another wrongheaded social justice
- 21:45reform forced on us by progressives like
- 21:48everything we see today in the criminal justice
- 21:49world like no cash bail and stuff like that
- 21:52and they were just wrong like like the left is wrong on so many
- 21:54other criminal justice related things today and maybe we should bring it back,
- 21:58see what happens.
- 22:00Someone called into the show and said,
- 22:01well,
- 22:01maybe we got rid of it because we thought we advanced as a society.
- 22:05Um,
- 22:06we haven't.
- 22:08We haven't advanced.
- 22:09It's time to bring it back.
- 22:11And again,
- 22:12people are like,
- 22:12well,
- 22:12it's not very civilized,
- 22:13or maybe is it?
- 22:15Is it the civilized thing to do?
- 22:20I'm always also curious what
- 22:22effect this would have on a society that sees fake violence all the time,
- 22:25just saturated constantly,
- 22:26fake violence in TVs and movies,
- 22:28just crazy stuff.
- 22:30Ever seen a Quentin Tarantino movie?
- 22:34It's blood everywhere,
- 22:35right?
- 22:36So,
- 22:37you know,
- 22:37and then we have,
- 22:38uh,
- 22:38you know,
- 22:39True crime documentaries,
- 22:40like every network drama is all about people getting shot and
- 22:43then crime shows and true crime is so popular right now.
- 22:45I don't think any of that stuff is good for the soul,
- 22:47but maybe uh
- 22:48Maybe,
- 22:49maybe people need like a
- 22:50just a refresh on,
- 22:52on what
- 22:54It's real,
- 22:55like,
- 22:55oh,
- 22:55here's real
- 22:56violence,
- 22:57right?
- 22:57Here,
- 22:58here's real,
- 22:58here's someone actually getting shot,
- 23:00and maybe they'll snap people out of
- 23:02like thinking that that's a satisfying thing,
- 23:04it's not,
- 23:05it's not,
- 23:05it shouldn't be satisfying.
- 23:09I think we could end if we do this,
- 23:10I think it could end with people valuing life
- 23:13more.
- 23:17All right,
- 23:18let's go to the,
- 23:18uh,
- 23:19let's go to the Bible.
- 23:20By the way,
- 23:21a lot of the people who are also making this argument that they're
- 23:23so appalled that Hegseth would even come up with such an idea.
- 23:26I wonder what they thought about
- 23:27the public assassination of Charlie Kirk.
- 23:30Cause I saw a lot of leftists
- 23:32making fun of that.
- 23:33I saw a lot of leftists.
- 23:35gleeful at the assassination of Charlie Kirk.
- 23:40And now they're gonna be like,
- 23:40oh,
- 23:41it's terrible that we would do this to to Nadal Hassan.
- 23:44Uh,
- 23:44we gotta go to the Bible.
- 23:45Uh,
- 23:46we're going a little long here.
- 23:47Let's get to it.
- 23:47Romans 12
- 23:49says,
- 23:49beloved,
- 23:50do not avenge yourselves,
- 23:51but rather give place to wrath.
- 23:53For it is written,
- 23:54Vengeance is mine,
- 23:55I will repay,
- 23:55says the Lord.
- 23:56Therefore,
- 23:57if your enemy is hungry,
- 23:58feed him.
- 23:58If he's thirsty,
- 23:59give him a drink,
- 23:59for in doing so you will heap coals
- 24:01of fire on his head.
- 24:02We did an episode
- 24:03on September 25th
- 24:05about that last part,
- 24:06heaping coals
- 24:07of fire on their head and what that meant.
- 24:08September 25th about Xi's visit
- 24:10to
- 24:11the White House.
- 24:12So that was a great episode if you wanna go back and check that one out.
- 24:15But the vengeance is mine part,
- 24:17uh,
- 24:17this is about you.
- 24:19This is about you.
- 24:21Uh,
- 24:21this is about the survivors
- 24:22of,
- 24:23you know,
- 24:23Nadal Hassan,
- 24:24uh,
- 24:24and the families of the people he did kill.
- 24:26They are not to go and try to kill Hassan themselves,
- 24:30but the Bible is very clear that the state has a role here.
- 24:33Romans 13:1,
- 24:34Let every person be subject to the governing authorities,
- 24:36for there's no authority except from God,
- 24:38and those that exist have been instituted by God.
- 24:40Therefore,
- 24:40whatever,
- 24:41whoever resists the authorities resist what God has appointed,
- 24:44and those who resist will incur judgment,
- 24:47for rulers are not a terror to good conduct,
- 24:48but to bad.
- 24:50Would you have no fear of the one who is in authority,
- 24:52then do what is good,
- 24:54and you will receive his approval,
- 24:55for he is God's servant for your good.
- 24:57But if you do wrong,
- 24:57be afraid,
- 24:59for he does not bear the sword in vain,
- 25:01for he is the servant of God,
- 25:02an avenger
- 25:03who carries out God's wrath on the wrongdoer.
- 25:06I think that's very clear,
- 25:08and it's pretty easy to understand.
- 25:09You,
- 25:10as an individual are told to turn the other cheek.
- 25:12There's even an argument that that.
- 25:14Really is only in relationship with other Christians.
- 25:16We're not gonna make that argument here necessarily,
- 25:19but it certainly
- 25:20doesn't mean that the state
- 25:22is just supposed to ignore
- 25:24crimes that people commit.
- 25:25That's crazy.
- 25:26Deuteronomy 25:2 says if there's a dispute between men
- 25:29and they come into court and the judge decides between them,
- 25:32acquitting the innocent and condemning the guilty.
- 25:35Then if the guilty man deserves to be beaten,
- 25:37the judge shall cause him to lie down to be beaten in
- 25:39his presence with a number of stripes in proportion to his offense.
- 25:4340 stripes may be given him,
- 25:44but not more,
- 25:46lest if one should go on to beat him with the more stripes than these,
- 25:49your brother will be degraded in your sight.
- 25:50I share that here because
- 25:52OK,
- 25:52we have a law and there's a punishment,
- 25:54there you go,
- 25:54and it has to be proportional.
- 25:56That's what that is,
- 25:57it's proportional punishment.
- 25:59It's not
- 26:01You know,
- 26:01you steal a candy bar and you get the death penalty,
- 26:03of course not.
- 26:04It's a proportional
- 26:06punishment
- 26:06to the crime
- 26:07you've committed.
- 26:10We really lost sight of justice
- 26:12in this country.
- 26:13Uh,
- 26:14we,
- 26:14most people have no idea what it really means,
- 26:16can't define it.
- 26:16It's been co-opted into social
- 26:19justice,
- 26:20but what about
- 26:20regular old justice?
- 26:23I believe part of
- 26:25biblically ordained
- 26:26order.
- 26:27Is
- 26:29um.
- 26:30That we have
- 26:32a government.
- 26:33And that with proper
- 26:35order and control and transparency
- 26:37can dispense the death penalty.
- 26:39That's my stance right now.
- 26:40Uh,
- 26:41I also say we live stream it.
- 26:43And whatever level of gruesome it is,
- 26:45it matches the crime,
- 26:47and it should be shocking to people.
- 26:50What he did was shocking.
- 26:52And people need to see reality.
- 26:53I think that'll be good.
- 26:55What do you think?
- 26:56What do you think about the live streaming
- 26:58of the
- 26:59execution of Nadal Hassan?
- 27:02Leave a comment on YouTube
- 27:03or wherever you're watching this,
- 27:04YouTube.com/apolitics by faith.
- 27:07Now,
- 27:07if I may,
- 27:07I'll end with the,
- 27:08the gospel,
- 27:08the ultimate justice and the ultimate law.
- 27:10These are the most important things.
- 27:12The law,
- 27:13uh,
- 27:13that,
- 27:13that God gave to the Jews,
- 27:15you have to follow all these rules.
- 27:17No one could,
- 27:17no one can,
- 27:18for breaking the law,
- 27:19you deserve,
- 27:20you deserve judgment
- 27:21of eternity in hell.
- 27:23That's the bad news.
- 27:24The good news is Jesus paid the consequence for you.
- 27:27He died on the cross,
- 27:28so now it's like you never sinned,
- 27:30you get to go to heaven instead.
- 27:32And now that we're all
- 27:33sanctified,
- 27:34or excuse me,
- 27:34now that we're all justified,
- 27:36we began,
- 27:37we begin a lifelong process of sanctification,
- 27:40where we keep God's commands out of love and gratitude,
- 27:42and it is a joy to do so.
- 27:45God's law reveals sin.
- 27:48And then
- 27:49Jesus.
- 27:51paid
- 27:51the price
- 27:52for our sin.
- 27:54He was obedient to God,
- 27:55to the cross,
- 27:56and we should be obedient to God as well.
- 27:59That's the good news.
- 28:01Slater Radio on Twitter and Instagram
- 28:03and uh please follow us on YouTube,
- 28:05youtube.com/apolitics by faith.
- 28:06Leave a comment.
- 28:07What do you think we should do
- 28:08with the live streaming of Nadal Hassan's execution?
- 28:12YouTube.com/apppolitics.com.
- 28:14Further work.