Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Free the Nipple! Breasts, Blue Laws, & the Bible Belt
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the
- 0:19truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand
- 0:23on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking, feels so much more happiness. Truth Usian
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Today
- 0:56we're talking about blue laws, also known as Sunday laws or Sunday closing laws.
- 1:04This happened in our not so recent past, and some of these laws
- 1:08remain on the books today. Here's the idea behind the blue law. Okay
- 1:15on the Lord's Day, which historically in this country at least has been considered
- 1:21Sunday, even though the Sabbath is actually Saturday. But okay, Sunday,
- 1:23the Lord's Day activities, certain specific things that you were doing well, those
- 1:30were forbidden. And of course this type of restriction usually roots back to religion
- 1:37and oh looky there's Christianity in the United States. So why are they called
- 1:44blue laws. Well, we can't really pin it down, but it is
- 1:48suspected that back in New Haven, Connecticut, a long, long, long
- 1:53time ago, they had a specific list of Sabbath restrictions and those restrictions were
- 2:00printed first on blue paper, so they were sort of known casually as the
- 2:05Blue Laws. That's a theory. We don't really know. Those Puritans back
- 2:09in the day, they apparently didn't think God could protect the Lord's Day,
- 2:15so they took it upon themselves to pass laws restricting what the public can do.
- 2:21And man, doesn't that sound familiar. A lot of retail stores were
- 2:25forced to keep their doors closed. Certainly, you couldn't gamble, you weren't
- 2:30supposed to drink. Travel was restricted in some places. They would tell you
- 2:37where you could and could not go, or how far you could go.
- 2:40Clothing was monitored. You can wear these things during the week, but uh,
- 2:46oh, too much skin or it's too tapered, showing too much of
- 2:51your shape. Well that's unholy. And the Lord's Day must be protected from
- 2:57shorts, I guess, and high skirts. By the way, And this
- 3:00is a quick digression, I'm guessing you've been reading about that guy in Monroe,
- 3:07North Carolina. Pastor Bobby Leonard totally in the hot seat last month.
- 3:14He is this, you know, I don't know, sixty seventy year old
- 3:16pastor a Bible Baptist tabernacle, and he does a sermon and he says that
- 3:24you know what, I'm gonna play it for you. It's just a short
- 3:29clip. Let me play you the clip of what he preached to his congregation.
- 3:36I used to say this, I haven't said this a long time.
- 3:38You're ready. I said, if you dress like it and you get raped
- 3:44and I'm on the jewelry, he's gonna go free. You don't like,
- 3:49do you? I'm right, though I can't hit you like I'm right because
- 3:54you know, a man's a man. This guy was preaching that you know
- 3:59his women today, well, they are causing the erections of susceptible men in
- 4:04the faith. These temptresses may just have it coming. So quote, if
- 4:12you dress like that and you get raped and I'm on the jury, he's
- 4:17going to go free because a man's a man. Oh, you can imagine
- 4:24the blowback on this. So he realizes that he's totally screwed up. I
- 4:30don't think he changed his mind. I think it's damage control. His solution
- 4:34was not to go and issue a personal and public apology to everybody on planet
- 4:41Earth for living in the year eleven. His tactic was to put a message
- 4:46on the Bible Baptist Tabernacle Marquis, the big church sign near the street.
- 4:51I am sorry for any hurt I was wrong, Pastor Leonard. That was
- 4:59his idea of an apology. Any doubt this guy would have implemented a Blue
- 5:04law against shorts on women. What else? Hunting was forbidden. Certain entertainments
- 5:15was certainly a no no. You couldn't do amateur sports, professional sports,
- 5:19stage shows and movies and that kind of thing right forbidden on the Lord's Day,
- 5:26which is weird to me. Shopping is therapeutic and for many RESTful sports
- 5:33therapeutic, and for many RESTful. Travel is for many therapeutic, RESTful,
- 5:41And yet God does not want this done Sundays Now, some of the Blue
- 5:46Laws applying to Sunday apparently were not rooted in religion. Back then, they
- 5:51were running the mail seven days a week, so Blue Laws shut that down
- 5:57on Sunday to give them a break to get at the maleman and male woman
- 6:01a day off. Some businesses were working their employees every freaking day of the
- 6:09week, giving them not a break, so a blue law would mandate they
- 6:13get at least Sunday off, give them a day of rest. And that
- 6:17may be one of the reasons that, at least back in the day,
- 6:20labor unions and trade unions were big supporters of blue laws, even though most
- 6:27of those laws have been repealed today, but not all. Not all blue
- 6:32laws, and they're not all limited to what you can and can do on
- 6:38a Sunday living quietly in our books. Still active in twenty twenty four are
- 6:46a bunch of old world, old school regulations that theoretically could be enforced.
- 6:53You could be fined or jailed if somebody out there took them seriously. And
- 6:58that's what today's show is. Now, if we're going to talk about him,
- 7:02let's get back to the genesis of the blue law, which apparently takes
- 7:08us back to Constantine. Back in three twenty one CE, the Emperor Constantine
- 7:15wrote these words quote, on the venerable day of the sun, let the
- 7:20magistrates and people residing in cities rest, and let all workshops be closed.
- 7:29Now. I think it's interesting because in his decree he says the venerable day
- 7:32of the Sun, it's s u n, the day of the Sun,
- 7:36not the son of God s N. Remember, after the ancient Babylonian started
- 7:44using the seven day week, the days of the week were named after gods,
- 7:48and Sunday was named after the pagan sun god. And that stuck.
- 7:55So Constantine was referring to a god that wasn't a god. Oh, he's
- 8:01now breaking the first commandment in the Book of Exodus and the Christian Bible.
- 8:07What are the other gods in the week? Monday is the moonsday, Tuesday,
- 8:16we know, Wednesday is Woden or odin'sday. Thursday is Thorsday, Friday
- 8:22I can't remember. Saturday is for Saturn, right, you get it.
- 8:26The days of the week referring to the names of non Christian gods, and
- 8:31in this Christians find no irony. That's just awesome, okay. The earliest
- 8:37Blue laws in this country were enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia in the
- 8:43Jamestown Colony of sixteen nineteen. There were seventy specific Blue laws. Morning and
- 8:48afternoon worship church was mandatory for everybody. You had to go every single Sunday,
- 8:56remember the Sabbath and keep it holy. In the United States in the
- 9:01nineteenth century, in some places, if you went to work, you could
- 9:05have been arrested. Back in nineteen sixty one, there was a Maryland department
- 9:13store and they decided they were going to leave the doors open on Sunday,
- 9:16open for business, everybody is welcome, and the state of Maryland fined the
- 9:24employees. So these employees of the store sued the state of Maryland, and
- 9:30the Supreme Court declared that states could do whatever they wanted, so as there
- 9:37are requirements for things like public health and safety, and welfare, morality,
- 9:43and even mandated leisure time, these fall under that umbrella. The Chief Justice
- 9:50at the time, Earl Warren, said that these reasonings weren't religious, they
- 9:54were just good sense. So find people all you want, and you know
- 10:01what's better for people than people do. It's no surprise that a whole lot
- 10:07of states still prohibit liquor stores from opening their doors on Sundays. Now.
- 10:11It's funny because somebody on my tennis team owns a liquor store, and I
- 10:16ask about the Sunday Blue law thing, and She's like, regardless of where
- 10:22it came from, I'm thankful that I get a day off. So maybe
- 10:26that falls back into the worker protection category. I don't know. Of course,
- 10:31now we've got alcohol in grocery stores, so you only have to drive
- 10:37past the liquor store. You can go to the grocery store. Oh,
- 10:39look, there it is on the shelf. Twenty one states allow grocery stores
- 10:45to sell the hard stuff and not just beer and wine. What about happy
- 10:50hour, those anticipated times when you get a discounted drink at the end of
- 10:56the long work day. It's still not legal on the books in Alaska,
- 11:01Indiana, Massachusetts, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, Utah, Vermont,
- 11:07happy hour is against the law. Of course, the restaurants have happy
- 11:13hour anyway, and I would love to see a census of how many Christians
- 11:18are knocking back a few beers after the day is done. The state of
- 11:24Massachusetts and Alaska prohibit the sale of alcohol on election days. And the reason
- 11:33was is that often they would take the saloon because everybody knew where it was,
- 11:37and it was I guess built to accommodate voting. The saloon would become
- 11:43the pole place the voting booth, and I guess they didn't want people getting
- 11:48wasted and then going to check a box. As soon as the polls closed,
- 11:56the bar was open. Utah has a law on the books prohibiting the
- 12:03sale of those mini bottles unless you're in a hotel or on a plane.
- 12:09Illegal to drink out of the minis. I guess if you're looking for the
- 12:13most liberated state when it comes to liquor, you would want to go to
- 12:16Nevada. You can buy alcohol twenty four seven in the state of Nevada,
- 12:22and the bars don't have to close at two in the morning. And the
- 12:26list for booze goes on and on. How much alcohol you can have in
- 12:31which drinks? Can you put food on the shelves next to the wine bottles?
- 12:37Are you allowed to transport liquor overstate lines to have it or to sell
- 12:43it? There are regulations on drinking games. By the way, there are
- 12:48some counties in the state of Florida right now that don't just prohibit the sale
- 12:52of alcohol on Sundays. You are forbidden by law to buy sex toys.
- 13:05It's on the books, you know. No strap ons and honey dust for
- 13:09you on the Lord's Day. Give it a few hours. When you wake
- 13:13up Monday, you can roll in there at you know, ten am,
- 13:18and you can pick up that body stocking that you wanted to wear to the
- 13:22orgy. Okay, that's Monday, not Sunday. You can't do it.
- 13:28Okay, We've done plenty about liquor. But I want to get into the
- 13:33weird stuff, like really weird, the stuff where you scratch your head and
- 13:37go, what's the context? What happened to make someone think we need to
- 13:41make an ordinance preventing this in the future, Because the Lord. I'm going
- 13:48to take a break and come back and do a laundry list of bizarre blue
- 13:54laws still on the books. We'll do it next. Still, I am
- 14:03hitting the road and doing a presentation called Seth Andrews Versus God, Who is
- 14:09the Better Intelligent Designer? It's a fun one. Orlando, Kansas City,
- 14:15Los Angeles, Little Rock, Denver, Sarnia, Ontario, Lexington, Kentucky,
- 14:20Saint Louis, Houston, Dallas. A lot of stuff coming up Seth
- 14:26Andrews dot Com slash events. We continue talking about blue laws, these strange
- 14:35morality clauses that somehow got overlooked and are still out there on the books today,
- 14:41and I guess theoretically enforcible. Let me start with Texas Penal Code section
- 14:50forty eight oh two. It is illegal to sell your internal organs, eyes,
- 15:00your kidney's, liver, lungs, skin, whatever. You are allowed
- 15:05to sell your blood and hair, but not the other stuff. This is
- 15:09a class A misdemeanor, and it also applies to anybody who wants to buy
- 15:16your internal organs. I've been trying to figure this one out. Are you
- 15:20preparing for death, like after I die you can have my stuff because I
- 15:26won't need it? Or is it just desperation? I can't pay the water
- 15:30bill? Here? Would you like a kidney? I don't know. I
- 15:33can't find the context for that law in Texas. Here's another one from that
- 15:37same state. This one hearkens back to the dust bowl. It is illegal
- 15:43to shoot buffalo from the second story room of a hotel. Was that a
- 15:50problem? Also in Texas? Did you know it's illegal to drive a car
- 15:58that doesn't have windshield wipers installed? Ironically, there is no law requiring your
- 16:04car to have a windshield, so I don't understand if you have wipers but
- 16:12no shield. I don't get that one. This one's in a county in
- 16:17Washington. I hope I'm saying it right. Scamania County, nineteen sixty nine,
- 16:21there was an ordinance passed making it illegal to kill Bigfoot. Well,
- 16:30I wouldn't want people to kill bigfoot anyway. Sure, legitimate zoological science says
- 16:37that they don't exist, but you and I know better. You and I
- 16:41know they're out there, and if you stumble upon a sasquatch, it's illegal
- 16:45to kill it, so don't. The Tennessee Constitution has a provision that says
- 16:52you are prevented from holding any public office if you've ever been in a duel,
- 17:00like a duel swords at dawn, you know, pistols at dawn,
- 17:03that kind of thing. Instant disqualification from politics. Here's one that was just
- 17:10only seven years ago repealed in South Carolina. If a man seduced a woman
- 17:17who was not married, and he seduced her by saying that he would eventually
- 17:22marry her, but he didn't have any intention to make her his wife,
- 17:27he could be arrested for lying to the woman. Same state, South Carolina,
- 17:36titled sixty three of the Juvenile Justice Code. It's unlawful for anybody under
- 17:42the age of eighteen to play pinball. I did a true story episode on
- 17:49this on my second podcast, where Off and On. In various places throughout
- 17:55the twentieth century, pinball was blamed for the downfall of today's youth. It's
- 18:03a distraction. Some called it gambling. Mayor LaGuardia in New York he did
- 18:07like a decade long war on pinball. It was like the Satanic panic with
- 18:15pinball, and that wasn't repealed in New York until the nineteen seventies. Apparently,
- 18:22the selling of babies used to be a problem in Pennsylvania. Article D
- 18:29Subchapter A, section four three zero five says, if you buy a baby
- 18:34or you sell a baby, it's a misdemeanor. It's a misdemeanor and not
- 18:41a felony. Wait, how valuable's the baby? Who set the penalty for
- 18:48that? Somebody who didn't like babies. I'm guessing if Yamhill, Oregon is
- 18:56serious about anything, it's apparently really serious about keeping fortune tellers out of their
- 19:03God fearing town. It is illegal to practice any occult arts and that is
- 19:10defined like this, fortune telling, astrology, Paul mystery, clairvoyance, mesmerism,
- 19:18spiritualism, and more. These are listed under the General Offenses page on
- 19:25the government websites. There's a Blue Law in New York. It made it
- 19:30illegal to walk around in public with a mask on unless you're doing a party.
- 19:36And I actually kind of agree with this one. But it was first
- 19:38passed in eighteen forty five, likely because of the Ku Klux Klan the KKK
- 19:45wearing masks and hoods, but political protesters wear masks in public. Today we've
- 19:52seen the white supremacists and other awful people who were hiding their identities in public
- 20:00under masks, So they, at least in New York are breaking the law.
- 20:04Not sure about them policies of other states. Here's another one that I
- 20:10totally truly support. This one came out in nineteen eleven in New Mexico.
- 20:15You are allowed to vote in elections in New Mexico if you've lived there for
- 20:22over one year, if you're not a felon, and if you are not
- 20:29an idiot. The original language said idiot. This was amended back in twenty
- 20:37ten for obvious reasons, and to be fair, the law was referring to
- 20:42people who had cognitive disabilities. They call them insane persons or idiots. But
- 20:49I think we should add the language back in. Not for those cognitively impaired,
- 20:56but I mean just for idiots, just idiots. We're not talking about
- 21:00mental health. I'm talking about people who constantly and unnecessarily do stupid shit and
- 21:07complicate things for the rest of us. I think we should just lock them
- 21:11out of the voting booth, which at this point in the United States,
- 21:15we may be talking about tens and tens of millions of people. I'm just
- 21:19fantasizing. I'm just fantasy the guy who says that women wearing shorts ought to
- 21:26be raped, or at least the rapist should get off scott free. No,
- 21:30now, I don't want that guy in the voting booth, thank you
- 21:34very much. Maybe you and I should get together and we just write some
- 21:40idiot laws, don't you. Let's just write idiot laws. Oh, somebody's
- 21:45swerving on the road. They're texting while driving. Lock them up. People
- 21:52who have decided that apparently nobody ever has to get off of an elevator,
- 21:56so after they hit the button and they're waiting, they just stand right there
- 22:00blocking the door. Oh yeah, that's an idiot law. That needs to
- 22:04be written. If you're doing dumb stuff on TikTok just to get views and
- 22:11hits and maybe become an influencer. Hey, Ricky, this will get us
- 22:17noticed. I'll bend over you, stick a bottle rocket up my ass and
- 22:22light the fuse. Make sure you're shooting vertical. Shoot that video vertical,
- 22:27gonna get famous. Oh yeah, there should be some sort of penalty for
- 22:33these people. I mean, punish the stupid. I think maybe the only
- 22:37way we defeat stupid. And maybe not even then, maybe we're just stuck
- 22:41with it. And speaking of fireworks, those people who apparently have leftover fireworks
- 22:51from the holidays, and so they just decide, just for kicks at a
- 22:53party, or they're just hanging out on the back porch and joint a beer,
- 22:57let's set off some mortar after ten thirty pm on a weeknight. That'll
- 23:03be fun. We're lying in bed, all of a sudden boom, the
- 23:10dogs flip out and start shaking. Hey, at least you were amused.
- 23:15Yeah, yeah, idiot ordinance enforcible. I think flat earthers. I think
- 23:23we should just build a camp for them, Just put them in a camp.
- 23:29Escape from New York, right, just build a wall, toss him
- 23:32over the wall. They can do all the flat earthy stuff they want to
- 23:34do, and the rest of us can evolve as a species. If you
- 23:41invest in crypto, I know the crypto bros Are going to come after if
- 23:48you are investing in crypto. Well, actually I wouldn't make that a law.
- 23:53I'll just let him lose all their money. Like, if you're going
- 23:56to invest in crypto, if you think crypto is survival, okay, knock
- 24:00yourself. That'll just be sort of a self penalizing action. Jefferson, Missouri.
- 24:07This is back to a few that are actually on the books. Jefferson,
- 24:10Missouri. Did you know it's illegal to have more than two garage sales
- 24:15at your house in one year? You can only have one garage sale a
- 24:18year. Until twenty fifteen, in the state of Minnesota, just two days
- 24:25of weekly bingo were allowed in nursing homes and retirement homes. You can only
- 24:32do bingo two days a week. Where did this law come from? Those
- 24:37parties must have been getting wild, right, ohya, what are they doing
- 24:41a bingo that somebody had to write an ordinance still on the books today.
- 24:47It's illegal to tease a skunk. In the state of Minnesota, you can't
- 24:52eat a hamburger on a Sunday in Saint Cloud. In Duluth, no animal
- 24:59is a allowed to sleep in a bakery. Here's one that has to be
- 25:07a free speech violation. Massachusetts Statute Chapter two six four, section nine says,
- 25:15if you screw up singing or playing the national anthem, the Star Spangled
- 25:22Banner, you change the words, you forget the words, you alter the
- 25:26notes, you don't do it right. One hundred dollars fine. Here's some
- 25:30refreshing, good sense sound of the state of Kentucky. It's against the law
- 25:36to use a snake in a church service. By the way, there are
- 25:44snake handling churches throughout the state of Kentucky, and not just there, Virginia,
- 25:48Tennessee and elsewhere. And if you don't know what the snake handling churches
- 25:52are, there is a verse in the Bible. You know what, let
- 25:57me look it up. They shall drink poison and die. Verse Mark sixteen,
- 26:07chapter eighteen was talking about people of faith who are able to do extraordinary
- 26:14things because God has protected them. The verse says they will pick up snakes
- 26:19with their hands, and when they drink deadly poison. It will not hurt
- 26:25them at all. And in southern Bible Belt states there are some backwater podunk
- 26:32churches where these dumbass pastors and their congregants think that God wants them to go
- 26:37out and find venomous snakes, and they mistreat these poor animals, and they
- 26:42bring them into the church service, and they're dancing and playing the tambourine,
- 26:47and they're throwing the snakes around and hanging them around their neck, and they're
- 26:51holding them above and they're doing all these things to show I ain't as scared
- 26:55a no snake. And of course at regular in people are killed at snake
- 27:03handling churches. I wrote a chapter in my book Sacred Cows about the whole
- 27:07snake handling church culture, with a laundry list of people who were bitten by
- 27:14a venomous snake refused medical attention because Jesus and died. That's just a gene
- 27:23pool thing, isn't it. We're just thinning the herd at that point.
- 27:27I'm not trying to be too dismissive, but I'm sorry, I have a
- 27:30hard time having sympathy for those people. I just do. In the state
- 27:37of Delaware. You're out of luck if you walk into a pond shop and
- 27:41try to sell your artificial limb. No outdoor sofas are allowed in the neighborhood
- 27:49of University Hill Boulder, Colorado. Apparently people kept putting their couches like an
- 27:57indoor recliner kind of thing. They do, put them outside and then just
- 28:02chill outdoors, and the whole place started to look like a big flea market.
- 28:07So they passed a law. Mobile Alabama outlawed silly string. Now,
- 28:17at first I did laugh at this one silly string. You've seen it.
- 28:19Google it if you don't know what silly string is. But I bet that
- 28:23this is about wildlife. Right. It's almost like you can't throw rice at
- 28:29the bride and groom after a wedding because the birds would eat the rice and
- 28:33then it would expand in their stomachs and kill the animals. I'm guessing this
- 28:37is probably an animal safety issue. Confetti is also prohibited in Mobile, Alabama
- 28:44and elsewhere. Okay, the whole last segment of the show is about American
- 28:52law and the nipple. We're gonna do it next. Hang on. In
- 29:10my book, Christianity made me talk like an idiot. I have this hypothetical
- 29:15scenario. Where's somebody like you or me. We are talking to a puritan
- 29:19religious person and we ask basic questions, and these are questions that few people
- 29:26seem to have asked themselves. So we're like, well, can a man
- 29:30go out topless in public? You mean shirtless? Yes, I mean shirtless?
- 29:37Can a man go out shirtless? Well? Yes? Yeah? What
- 29:41about a woman? Can she go out topless or shirtless? Absolutely not?
- 29:47Why not? It's obscene, it's inappropriate. Well where did that come from?
- 29:55Why is it inappropriate for the female? Well, she's got breast.
- 30:00Okay, So wait a minute. Let's say that I was maybe a little
- 30:04heavy, or you know, my something unique to my body. Let's say
- 30:08that I had pronounced breasts as a man. Let's say I had man boobs,
- 30:12I have moobs. If I go out in public, then is it
- 30:18obscene? No? No, it's I mean no, no, it's not
- 30:22obscene. You're a man, yes, but I have boobs. No,
- 30:29it's different. Well why is it different? Well, it's just different.
- 30:32It's different. I noticed that women can show some of the breast in public
- 30:38on g rated television or whatever. I mean, they show so well you
- 30:44can show a little bit of it, but you can't show too much.
- 30:47Yeah, well, how much is too much? Well do you know too
- 30:49much? You can't show too much? Well how much is that? I
- 30:53don't know. You just know it when you see it. But you can't
- 30:56show the nipple. Okay, so it's it's obscene or immoral to show the
- 31:03nipple? Yes? Why is that obscene? Well, men will see it
- 31:10and lust. All right, hang on, so they won't necessarily lust if
- 31:17they see another part of the brace. See it's this particular region. Well
- 31:22yeah, yeah, okay. Well what if, and this is assuming a
- 31:27heterosexual attraction, what if a man is turned on by the top part of
- 31:33the woman's breast that is allowed, which sort of spurs the imagination or whatever.
- 31:37Maybe they just get turned on by the maybe the neckline? What about
- 31:41that? Should that be covered? No? No? What about her eyes?
- 31:48He finds her eyes enchanting and he becomes aroused? Or what if it's
- 31:52legs? I mean, I don't know, let's just pick a body part.
- 31:56I'm not trying to be based here, but I'm trying to make a
- 31:57point. What if a rated or allowed part of the female is what gets
- 32:05them going? I mean, what do you do there? Well, you
- 32:07can't cover you know, I mean the neck and that's extreme. Well,
- 32:12hang on, that's causing lust, isn't it. It wasn't that your guideline?
- 32:19And back to the whole sexual identity thing. Can a woman show her
- 32:23breast or be topless in a locker room or you know, in a dressing
- 32:29room surrounded by other women? Well I guess that's okay. Yeah, what
- 32:35if women are in the room who are attracted to women? Would that not
- 32:39cause lust? YEA, well no, I mean that's not right. That's
- 32:45not right. That's not right. You can't you know, there's no And
- 32:51so they're starting to like vibrate, you know, because they've never been for
- 32:57who came up with these laws, who wrote the obscenity laws that targeted women
- 33:01in this way? If I was to go into photoshop and I pasted the
- 33:07male nipple over the female nipple and then I posted that photograph online or whatever,
- 33:14would that be okay? Or is that still obscene because it's a man's
- 33:16nipple and those are allowed? Are they not? And finally, even though
- 33:22we know the Bible talks about modesty and it hyper targets women, because a
- 33:27bunch of puritanical, thin skinned, apparently highly erect males wrote the Bible and
- 33:34they wanted to control women. Can you show me the verse in the Bible
- 33:37where it outlines which part of the body can be exposed and which cannot be
- 33:44exposed? And then these people just sort of leave, They get frustrated and
- 33:46walk out of the room. Well, you know, it's something I never
- 33:50thought about. I just assumed it growing up. They're not modestly dressed,
- 33:53and it was always leaning heavily toward the female, because of course women of
- 33:59the Harlots and the Jezebels and the sirens and the temptresses, and they control
- 34:04how men feel or react. Okay, that's really the thinking. It was
- 34:10a form of almost Islamic hijab covering of women. You know, the women
- 34:15must be covered preserve the mystery. More skin equals more sin. Okay.
- 34:23Well, I was trying to kind of find out where all of this nipple
- 34:27hysteria started, at least in the United States. I found this article on
- 34:32Yahoo Health. It says, if you ever want to feel like you're back
- 34:37in the dark ages of female equality, look no further than the law books
- 34:43of certain US states. In Arizona, a woman can be arrested for indecent
- 34:49exposure if she exposes the areola or nipple of her breast if someone else's present.
- 34:58Hiking in the forest in the nude is not a violation of the law.
- 35:01In Los Angeles, but a woman who exposes her quote private parts to
- 35:07another person can be found guilty of a misdemeanor for public indecency. Delaware,
- 35:13women can be arrested if they expose their breasts quote, under circumstances that she
- 35:20knows her conduct will likely cause a front or alarm. By the way,
- 35:25quick digression, I'm trying to think of what the law is at least in
- 35:30the state of Oklahoma. But talk about blue laws. The woman cannot apparently
- 35:37like a strip club or something, the woman cannot show the nipple unless it
- 35:42has a pasty on it. Now, the pasty is totally transparent. It's
- 35:46so the if the women have to paste that over the nibble, you still
- 35:51see the nipple, but it has a little transparent, plastic, sticky pasty
- 35:57on it, and apparently that makes it okay. In Oklahoma, you cannot
- 36:02serve alcohol in a bar where women are fully nude. So if they have
- 36:09they have a bottom of some they're wearing the bottom, but they're topless.
- 36:15There you can serve beer and all that other stuff. But if they're totally
- 36:17naked, no alcohol can be served. All. So we have morality,
- 36:23We have standards here at Oklahoma, dammit. Back to the article. Louisiana
- 36:29specifies that female breast nipples in any public place or a place open to the
- 36:35public view with the intent of arousing sexual desire, or which appeals to prurient
- 36:40interest or is patently offensive can get three years of jail time and a twenty
- 36:46five hundred dollars fine. God, I got to stop again. Hang on.
- 36:52Obscenity laws are some of the most ill defined and subjective laws ever implemented
- 36:58anywhere, because how do you define leud, how do you define indecent?
- 37:07And the idea is, in this country, the laws were written to prevent
- 37:10arousal in the most susceptible members of our society. So you have to present
- 37:20yourself in public in a way that isn't going to turn on the person who
- 37:24might most easily be turned on. How in the world do you even qualify
- 37:31and certainly enforce this obscenity comes from the Latin word ubsinis, meaning foul,
- 37:40repulsive, detestable. It's also linked back to another word define filth. And
- 37:47then we get into the discussions about whether or not it's just you know,
- 37:52base level leud nudity, or is it artistic nudity. You know, the
- 37:58artist paints the lovely shape of a body. Ah, that's artistic. That's
- 38:02allowable in polite society. Not like this. These laws differ depending on which
- 38:10state line you have driven over. So something that's obscene here is not obscene
- 38:15there. Totally subjective. What is obscene? Back to the article. These
- 38:23are just some of the many instances of legal gender inequality that compelled Lena Esco
- 38:30to write, direct, star, and produce her film Free the Nipple.
- 38:37She says, the first thing a child sees when it is born, the
- 38:40first thing it connects with, the first thing that nourishes it is a nipple.
- 38:46It's a boob, claims Esco when discussing the origins of her film and
- 38:52movement. The film is billed as a comedy, but perhaps best described as
- 38:57an activist how to guide. It tells the story of a group of young
- 39:01women who engage in public demonstrations of toplessness to call attention to the fact that
- 39:09not only do women continue to be arrested for topless ness despite its being legal
- 39:15in New York, but that women's bodies are subjected to different standards and rules
- 39:22than men. By the way, this was a movie shot without permits.
- 39:29They just went out with cameras in public and went topless and sort of shot
- 39:34reactions. Footnuh, it was actually illegal. This is just me talking now.
- 39:40It was actually illegal until the nineteen thirties for either men or women to
- 39:47show nipples in public, so men were at one time included in the band.
- 39:53Men were not happy about this, and so they protested. Back on
- 39:59Coney Island, they went out and did a demonstration shirtless to say you can't
- 40:06regulate my nipples. Nineteen thirty five, there were some male protesters in Atlantic
- 40:12City. They went to the beach shirtless. They got arrested. In nineteen
- 40:16thirty six, they legally got the right to show nipples in public in the
- 40:22state of New York, laying the foundation eventually for the same liberation for women,
- 40:30except that it's not. Women can still be charged with public indecency,
- 40:36disturbing the peace, or lewd behavior where toplessness is legal on the books.
- 40:42It's a kind of implied or or social blue law double standards, no question.
- 40:52There's a famous nineteen sixty two movie called Something's Got to Give starring Marilyn
- 40:58Monroe. Did you know that for that film she was required to cover her
- 41:06belly button. Meanwhile, the rest of the world is looking at us like
- 41:13we are twelve year old boys in a locker room, you know, going
- 41:16boobies right. Other cultures, people, regions around the world, Historically,
- 41:24you know, women have gone topless unless it's wintertime and they need to cover
- 41:30up for warmth other than that jewelry or something, but they're topless. We've
- 41:36seen that in India, in many parts of Africa, the South Pacific.
- 41:42It used to be that you saw almost everybody topless everywhere until what happened.
- 41:47Christian missionaries showed up because you know, these poor, rudderless, miserable,
- 41:53sad primitives sure need them. Some Jesus lucky them we have arrived. And
- 42:01when they get in and pretty much colonize and impose their own morality blue laws,
- 42:08more and more people felt compelled to cover up. And don't even get
- 42:14me started on Europe, they're not weird about nudity at all. It's the
- 42:19human body. Get over it, grow up everyday, life, film,
- 42:22television, whatever. Same goes with language too. Here we are censoring,
- 42:29we are blue lawing the words. Everybody knows that you are saying. Everybody
- 42:34knows what you have bleeped out or overdubbed. There is no doubt this is
- 42:39the F word or whatever. And look, I just centered myself the F
- 42:46word. It's the F word. It's like when I was a Christian in
- 42:52Christian school, we used to just stretch not to cuss, but we wanted
- 42:55to cuss, so we came up with all. I mean, you should
- 42:59have heard the shit that people said, son of a biscuit eater. Of
- 43:04course we had to say darn instead of damn, but everybody knew we were
- 43:08saying damn, gosh, darn instead of God, damn uh oh third commandment,
- 43:16gosh darn is okay, didn't say hell, but we said heck,
- 43:23oh fudge instead of shit. We said shucks. People actually said shucks.
- 43:32I knew somebody and he got this from Rush Limbaugh. But instead of saying
- 43:39bs for bullshit, he said barber Streisand that's just a bunch of barber stry
- 43:44sand right, God Bless America. That was considered an exclamation substitute for swear
- 43:51God Bless America. Oh did we know that we were walking talking punchlines?
- 44:00He did not Back to the Nipple, because I have it in the title
- 44:06of the show, and I guess I need to make sure there's plenty of
- 44:07nipple talk in the show Back to the Nipple. There's a big battle going
- 44:14on on social medium Meta meeting Facebook and Instagram. They are being petitioned to
- 44:21just freaking loosen up. A decade ago, breastfeeding mothers protested and they went
- 44:28to Facebook headquarters and did what they called a nurse in breastfeeding right there at
- 44:35the entrance of Facebook, saying why don't you guys just stop censoring and penalizing
- 44:40and striking all of the posts that have naked female bodies, especially from the
- 44:47waist up. Get over yourselves, it's the body. There's an oversight board
- 44:52for Meta apparently they have been making recommendations that Meta change its policy quote so
- 45:00it is governed by clear criteria that respect international human rights standards. There's another
- 45:08subjective and extremely nebulous definition. And before the free the nipple people before the
- 45:15nurse In about twenty years ago, there was another group doing the same thing,
- 45:21trying to kill these blue laws. They call themselves lactivists. Anyway,
- 45:27I guess the short version of this long discussion is that once again the United
- 45:32States is late to the party, but we might eventually arrive at the party
- 45:38if the Puritans who are running local government, state government, federal government,
- 45:46the Supreme Court, and the White House don't insist that we continue to live
- 45:52in the dark ages. It's astounding how often the people who call the shots
- 46:00and make the laws stand in contrast and contradiction to the attitudes and will of
- 46:05the general public. More and more, we're less puritan, more egalitarian,
- 46:10we're less weird about the body and about sexuality. I mean, gradually,
- 46:16we are evolving here at the grassroots level. While the people who supposedly represent
- 46:22us, they've got a big warehouse filled with chastity belts, and they would
- 46:29like to go door to door and distribute those to everybody and make the mandatory.
- 46:34I'd be curious to see how the culture looks in the years and decades
- 46:39ahead. We can take some lessons, I think from other parts of the
- 46:43world who've just gotten over it. You know, let's celebrate ourselves and let's
- 46:47just quit freaking out. Let's realize how much of these blue laws are rooted
- 46:52in obsolete, wrongheaded, conspiratorial, superstitious, patrin terrified mythologies. Anyway,
- 47:05that's just a quick look at Puritan America laws enforced just a few short decades
- 47:12ago, and apparently either somebody forgot to just erase them or vote against them,
- 47:19or maybe secretly they yearn for the day when it was illegal to drunk
- 47:25ski, to drink from a mini bottle, to sell your artificial leg,
- 47:31and to drive your windowless vehicle without wipers. Maybe they yearn for those days.
- 47:38I do not know. Thanks for being here. I will see you
- 47:44next week. Follow the Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive
- 47:49of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist
- 47:53logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought
- 47:59events and convents. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.