Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E069: A Random Walk Down the Timechain with Bob Burnett
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:27I say when we sell. All right.
- 0:33Welcome everyone back to the last trade.
- 0:36This week we have Bob Burnett. Bob, thanks for joining the
- 0:38show. How are you doing today?
- 0:41I'm doing well, I'm trying to stay dry and safe with a
- 0:45hurricane looming just off the coast of Florida.
- 0:49So what? What better way to spend time
- 0:53killing time than chatting with you guys?
- 0:55We appreciate you joining and this is the first like ninja
- 0:58launch kind of for for the last trade where you were blowing our
- 1:01minds behind the scenes. So we just just was like, let's
- 1:03just start the pod. Let's get it ripping.
- 1:05So appreciate you joining and excited to talk about some of
- 1:08the stuff you've been working on.
- 1:09Yeah, Bob, you got a lot going on over there.
- 1:11You, it's a, it's a question whether the water stops at your
- 1:14doorstep or 1 foot into your house.
- 1:18So there's some randomness that you're going to be dealing with
- 1:20over the next day or so. And then you were just showing
- 1:23us an unbelievably cool bit of randomness that you've been
- 1:26working on too. Yeah, well, I'm, I'm glad I was
- 1:29able to give you guys a sneak peek of that.
- 1:31And you know, we'll we'll obviously can go into that here,
- 1:36but I guess, you know, jumping in at that, I don't know.
- 1:40For those that don't know me, I guess just real quickly, I'm
- 1:43the, I'm the CEO of a company called Barefoot Mining.
- 1:47So we specialize in small to medium sized commercial mining,
- 1:52which I feel is a critical part of the infrastructure.
- 1:57And honestly the, the part of the infrastructure that gives us
- 2:01the greatest advantage too. And we can, we can talk about
- 2:04that more a bit later. I'm also on the board of
- 2:07directors at Ocean and an investor there.
- 2:11So we may touch on some of that. I'm also on the board of
- 2:16advisors of a company called M Fivers, which is a group where
- 2:20we are designing our own ASIC, so at the silicon level.
- 2:27And I'm also on the board of advisors at a company called
- 2:29Block Spaces, where we're developing a block space forward
- 2:33contract platform. So potentially depending on what
- 2:37you guys want to talk about, something that we can go into,
- 2:40but I'm also the CEO or chairman, I guess probably
- 2:44probably best call me the chairman.
- 2:46We just hired ACEO chairman of something called Chaos
- 2:49Enterprises, and the genesis of Chaos Enterprises was I, I
- 2:58started a few years ago objecting to the community,
- 3:04referring to mining rigs, mining systems, mining computers,
- 3:09mining servers, pick your choice as ASICS.
- 3:12That, that term really bothered me because as an engineer, I
- 3:17believe in specificity of I think language specificity is
- 3:22very important and terms, terms that get misused, especially in
- 3:29general can be very dangerous. In fact, I think that's
- 3:34something happening with ordinals right now, for
- 3:35instance. But again, we can talk about
- 3:38where I think that the term SAT has been abused and misused and
- 3:43it's creating confusion. But I was really concerned about
- 3:48ASIC because ASIC is a application specific integrated
- 3:52circuit. It refers to a chip and Asic's
- 3:56have been used for 30 years. I designed my first ASIC in the
- 4:00late 80s to control some battery circuitry on a laptop computer.
- 4:07But they're used in your car headlight control the the TV,
- 4:13you know, dimming when the lights go on.
- 4:15I mean all these sort of things are, are all ASIC controlled.
- 4:21But when we call the system in ASIC, so we have a ASICS in our
- 4:26world, right, that perform the hashing function, right.
- 4:30That's the, that's the guts of what happens in Bitcoin.
- 4:33But when we call the system in ASIC, we are saying that that
- 4:37system is now application specific.
- 4:41And one, I believe it's incorrect and confusing, but 2,
- 4:44I believe that by using that term in a consistent manner
- 4:50across the industry, what we're doing is we're giving tax
- 4:54authorities and regulators and bureaucrats a mechanism by which
- 4:58they can easily attack us. So if we say an S 19 sitting in
- 5:03a closet over in a in a certain spot is application specific, it
- 5:09makes that much easier for them to say, well, we are going to
- 5:12tax the power consumption of that unit because we don't like
- 5:17Bitcoin. I mean, that would be Elizabeth
- 5:19Warren's pipe dream, right? So, so I don't like Elizabeth
- 5:25Warren. I think there's a lot of evil
- 5:29that goes on and I want to fight that.
- 5:34So, you know, I started by trying to, I think, send a
- 5:38warning to the industry like we have to do this.
- 5:40But but then in the spring of 2023, the Biden administration
- 5:48did what I feared, which was they they proposed a 30% tax on
- 5:54energy consumption by Bitcoin miners.
- 5:59It got defeated. But by the way, it reappeared in
- 6:02the 2024 budget. But in that spring of 2023 when
- 6:05it happened, I said, OK, I need to prove to the world that a
- 6:10product like an S 19 is not application specific.
- 6:14And I, but it's kind of interesting, I said this
- 6:16publicly to many people and inside the technical community,
- 6:21I got ridiculed quite a bit. Several people said, you know,
- 6:26you're an idiot. These machines can only do one
- 6:28thing, you know, blah, blah, blah.
- 6:30And so I just, I was quiet. I started a skunkworks project
- 6:36because I knew what I could do with it, at least one other
- 6:39thing. And and that was to create proof
- 6:43of work based random numbers, meaning that I could create
- 6:46auditable and verifiable random numbers.
- 6:50And on the surface you might think, well, random numbers, who
- 6:54cares? But you find out when you think
- 6:56about it and you do a little research that random numbers
- 7:00permeate all over the place. Obviously they're they're,
- 7:04they're important in cryptography, they're important
- 7:07in online gambling, they're important in pharmaceutical
- 7:10research. There are all these different
- 7:12places where random numbers play a really important role in the
- 7:15world. And then when you dig deeper,
- 7:17what you find out is it's very difficult to generate a truly
- 7:22random number, especially a provable random number, because
- 7:28you can do things like everybody knows, like lotteries have been
- 7:31gained, casinos have been gained, military drafts have
- 7:37been gained. Like they're all these different
- 7:40things where people have manipulated randomness or it's
- 7:45just turns out that the method itself wasn't truly random.
- 7:50So while nature, like Jesse, you mentioned, you know, the
- 7:54hurricane, yeah, there's a whole bunch of randomness, but we
- 7:57can't really prove that randomness.
- 7:59There's no way to audit the randomness.
- 8:01Like, where will Hurricane Milton hit?
- 8:04We don't know. You know, what will the wind
- 8:06speed be when it makes landfall? We don't know.
- 8:09Those are those are random. But even to the degree we're
- 8:14random, if, if let's say we were going to make a bet about the
- 8:18wind speed at the moment that Hurricane Milton hits landfall
- 8:24or use that number as the seed of something else.
- 8:29The problem we have is we are reliant on third parties in that
- 8:36chain, right? So if, if, if so, if Jesse and I
- 8:39had a bet on what the wind speed was, Well, who's reporting the
- 8:44number? What equipment did they use to
- 8:46report the number? How can I audit and verify that
- 8:50the wind speed as measured at the moment?
- 8:52Like there's all these different things, right?
- 8:54So the seemingly random thing is turns out to be able to be
- 8:59highly manipulated. So what I did was I said, well,
- 9:04let's use the thing we learned from Bitcoin, which was proof of
- 9:07work with difficulty, right? And and apply it to the random
- 9:15number world. And so anybody listening, you
- 9:18can go to a website calledchaosengine.com and you
- 9:22can see the first incarnation of what we've done, and it's up on
- 9:27the screen for those watching. Now, and that's chaos caos.
- 9:32Yeah, chaosengine.com, correct. And obviously the word chaos
- 9:37comes from entropy. You know, I view, I view the
- 9:41proper way to look add a product like an S 19 is as an entropy
- 9:47engine. If I was, if I, I've kind of
- 9:50come to that realization, the best way to refer to that is it
- 9:53is an entropy engine. And you know, entropy, chaos and
- 9:58randomness are all they're not exactly the same thing, but they
- 10:02are intimately connected, right? And so that's where this term
- 10:08where the genesis of this website comes from in the name
- 10:13of the overall organization. And so as you look at the screen
- 10:17and you pull down, let's say on the numbers or decision making,
- 10:22excuse me, and you do a coin flip, sorry, decision making,
- 10:25coin flip. You see, this was the very first
- 10:27thing we did to prove that the that a product like an S19 could
- 10:33do something other than just my Bitcoin.
- 10:35What we did is we have a blockchain of coin flips that
- 10:40are linked to each other and feed each other just like one
- 10:42block in Bitcoin feeds another. We're using that same block
- 10:46construct but with a completely different data set.
- 10:49And when when you hit coin flip, what's happening is we have a
- 10:55certain difficulty that in this case it's two leading zeros.
- 11:00So we don't have a high difficulty on it.
- 11:01We just have 1 S 19 sitting behind this website right now
- 11:04because we don't have a lot of traffic on it, but we can very
- 11:07quickly generate the result of a coin flip.
- 11:10And we realized once we could do that and we proved that the
- 11:14equipment could do something else.
- 11:16We realized, well, hell, we can we can roll a dice, which you
- 11:20can you know, also also if you pull down on decision making,
- 11:25you can show that as well. And so and this one was done
- 11:32with three leading zeros. So we started to get this
- 11:38concept in place that that it was useful that we could prove
- 11:45this. And and I view it as what we've
- 11:47done is really created the third incarnation of proof of work.
- 11:51The first being practical application of proof of work,
- 11:55The first being Atom back with Hashcash, the second being
- 11:58Satoshi with Bitcoin, and this being the third which is
- 12:03auditable and verifiable random numbers.
- 12:07So fortunately we can't show you today, it's still in beta, but
- 12:11we have created now knowing that we can roll dice and flip coins,
- 12:18it means we can shuffle a deck of cards and we can do those
- 12:21things. So we have created now in beta,
- 12:25we have a group of beta users. It's called Chaos House and it
- 12:31is in a Bitcoin based online casino.
- 12:34We have blackjack, roulette, craps, slot machines, etcetera.
- 12:40And what makes our casino unique is that it is the first casino
- 12:47in the world where you can literally click a button, you
- 12:49play a blackjack hand let's say, and you lose and you go.
- 12:52I can't believe the dealer, the dealer you know, started with a
- 12:5712 and hit 4 cards and ended up with a 21 like and so.
- 13:02But you can click a button called an literally called an
- 13:05audit button on the screen and you can pull up and you can, you
- 13:09can actually see the blockchain of all the cards dealt in, for
- 13:15instance, the blackjack game. And you can if, if you want to
- 13:19put in the work, you can extract and see exactly how each of
- 13:23those cards was dealt. And so it becomes the world's
- 13:28first online casino where you can with confidence know that
- 13:36you're playing a fair game. In fact, it's so fair.
- 13:41I'll, I'll tell you this about it as well.
- 13:42It's unfortunate we we couldn't get my share working or I would
- 13:45have demoed it for everybody, but we let you decide if you
- 13:50want to be the house or you want to be a player.
- 13:52So it's that fair that that you know, if you, if you want, you
- 13:58can, you can play the house side.
- 14:01So, so there's, there's no, in other words, there's no
- 14:07motivation for the house to, to ever be corrupt because each
- 14:16user can come in and decide if they want to be a player or they
- 14:19want to be part of the house. In fact, you could be part of
- 14:22the house and the roulette game at the same time that you're a
- 14:25player on the blackjack game. Like we allow, we allow you to
- 14:28do that. You can kind of sit in the
- 14:30background, put some liquidity into, for instance, the roulette
- 14:33game and let that go and at the same time go over and play
- 14:37blackjack. And again, knowing all the time
- 14:41that you can audit, you can audit the results at any time.
- 14:48And then we have a, another website called Digital Horoscope
- 14:53dot AI. We've taken it kind of another
- 14:57level and we looked at kind of the whole, I guess I don't know
- 15:02if you call it the Mystic world, the esoteric world.
- 15:07To be honest, it's not something I particularly believe in, but
- 15:09it's an area where I know people get manipulated a lot.
- 15:13And So what we're doing is we're tapping into the randomness that
- 15:18we can get from this, the massive randomness, right?
- 15:23I think if you're, if you're a, a bitcoiner, you probably
- 15:26realize that the number set that we're dealing with, you know, 2
- 15:30to the 5th, 2 to the 56th is just this massive number.
- 15:36And so you know, what we're showing is, for instance, this
- 15:39is a tarot card reading. So we're using the same concept
- 15:43to shuffle a deck. I believe it's 78 cards and a
- 15:46tarot card deck, a past, present and future card.
- 15:51But once the result comes in, what we do is we've built a
- 15:54custom AI front end. So we take the results of those
- 15:58cards and whatever information we can get about the user and we
- 16:03feed that into an AI engine to create the reading.
- 16:06So it is what it is. I'm not making any claims about
- 16:12its accuracy, but what I can say is that if you want a tarot card
- 16:17reading, you'll get a genuine tarot card reading.
- 16:20The cards dealt are genuine and the reading is genuine with with
- 16:26no no reason or intent to be misleading or to manipulate
- 16:35somebody. So we have some fun things on
- 16:37this site like fork. You can get a digital fortune
- 16:41cookie. We have a magic 8 ball game.
- 16:43We've got horoscope settings, but at the kind of to get back
- 16:48to the the the main thing here at the center of all this is
- 16:54equipment that has traditionally only been used for Bitcoin
- 16:57mining. So now and what we'll, our plan
- 17:01is we will, as we bring this up, we will let Bitcoin miners
- 17:09direct their hash rate to us for this purpose.
- 17:14And then we'll kind of look like a pool.
- 17:18And then if, if, if we use them for the digital horoscope stuff
- 17:25or the casino, they're going to get paid something from that.
- 17:30But if, if we don't need their hash rate, then we'll direct it
- 17:33to, to, to Bitcoin. So what that does is that means
- 17:39that anybody that points their machine at this will not even
- 17:49know whether or not their machine is working on Bitcoin or
- 17:55working on on this. Now, I'm not trying to
- 17:57encourage, I want to be clear, I'm a bitcoiner, I'm a Bitcoin
- 17:59maxi. I'm not, I'm not trying to take
- 18:03and steal a whole bunch of the Bitcoin network to make this
- 18:05happen. But what I do want to do is give
- 18:08anybody that is in a position where they think they may be
- 18:11exposed to a tax authority or regulator.
- 18:16Now they have absolutely no idea what that machine is doing.
- 18:20And they have a very plausible and economically viable reason
- 18:24to say, hey, I, I, I might be running a casino.
- 18:27I might be helping do tarot card readings, or it might be mining
- 18:31Bitcoin. I don't know.
- 18:32You can't tax me. Bob, I'm going to jump in
- 18:37because you're kind of blowing our brains here.
- 18:38So there's a, there's a few thoughts or things that come to
- 18:42mind. One is I, I generally appreciate
- 18:44it since the very first time we chatted, your independent
- 18:47thinking. I think there's this is what
- 18:50makes individuals special in this world of, you know, you
- 18:53reference bringing it up as it's not an ASIC.
- 18:56You can break down Y based on your background and building.
- 18:59And then you got ridiculed a bit because because we have these
- 19:02tropes and Bitcoin and people stick to them and they don't
- 19:04ever think about like, well, why is it they're not your keys, not
- 19:07your coin. One is the one that we cook, we
- 19:08come to is everybody's believe this, But then what happens when
- 19:11somebody robs your house or hurricane hits?
- 19:12It's like, well, maybe I shouldn't have had all my keys
- 19:14in my house. And and so point being is just
- 19:18generally appreciate that because I think that's how very
- 19:21cool things building the world and somebody looks at it from a
- 19:24first principle, which is what you're doing here.
- 19:26And then to extend to the mind blowing side is like, you know,
- 19:31I don't like, I don't really gamble, but I appreciate that
- 19:34there's a big business of gambling online.
- 19:37And what's kind of blowing my mind is like a, you know, that
- 19:40if you've heard of nitrogen sports, they it's like a Bitcoin
- 19:43only on and off ramp for sports gambling.
- 19:45And I've always thought that's very interesting because it's
- 19:47like the bit bit Max version of you don't touch any Fiat.
- 19:50So they're just it's very it's very like anti fragile in the
- 19:54sense that they can always operate, they can always move
- 19:56around, but you take that and then you couple it with a
- 19:59Bitcoin native or quote UN quote auditable way to prove it.
- 20:03Now you're just you've built the best casino overnight that
- 20:06somebody can go online and be auditable and that's kind of
- 20:10it's kind of crazy. But then that goes across the
- 20:13board, like, you know, passwords and how you know the the what's
- 20:17the bit wardens of the world like they have to generate the
- 20:19randomness and we just trust that it's random.
- 20:22Yeah, 2 factor like that's like that's on our road map is to
- 20:26create 2 factor with the same technology that's on our road
- 20:29map. At Onramp, we believe that
- 20:31Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 20:35The hard part is securing it right There are shortcomings
- 20:39with keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 20:42up your own self custody arrangement.
- 20:44Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 20:47Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 20:50minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 20:53remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 20:57inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 20:59well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 21:02for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 21:05for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 21:08set up. For more information, check us
- 21:10out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah.
- 21:13And so anything about fantasy, even if I was just thinking
- 21:15about like fantasy football people do a draft or like, how
- 21:17do I know it was random that you just gave me this thing?
- 21:21But point being is like, I don't know if this is being too like
- 21:24hyperbolic or overzealous, but you would imagine if this is a
- 21:28construct that is easily verifiable for somebody to back
- 21:31into the the randomness, this becomes just an open standard
- 21:34for the Internet because you go and you're just like, why would
- 21:37you use a website that isn't standard?
- 21:39Isn't audible that the randomness was generated wasn't
- 21:42done by that because we just assumed that everything's random
- 21:45and we're perfectly fine with it and we know it's not and we know
- 21:47like, you know, the poker one comes to mind because I love
- 21:50playing hold'em and I never play online because you see all the
- 21:53stories of how the the house is like, you know, just like
- 21:57manipulated that. Sure, sure.
- 22:00Yeah, we do plant and tend to have APIs and there is a big
- 22:05commercial market for it too. You know, there, there are
- 22:07markets where somebody will say, hey, I need 6,000,000 random
- 22:12numbers between 1:00 and 4:00 quadrillion or something like
- 22:16that. Well, we'll, we'll be able to
- 22:18provide that and again, provide the proof of work behind the
- 22:21generation of all that. So there will be those
- 22:24commercial applications. And yeah, I hope, I hope that is
- 22:28the case. You know, we're we, we believe
- 22:31that not only casino gaming, but all types of online gaming or
- 22:35any, any type of gaming, right. If it's a, a first person
- 22:39shooter game, there is randomness within the games like
- 22:45they, they have to be right, you know, they, they have to say, is
- 22:49it raining or not? How hard is the wind blowing?
- 22:51Like if you're playing certain types of games.
- 22:54But that randomness is coming from within the game itself,
- 22:59first of all. And the algorithms and the
- 23:01techniques that they use always have a gap.
- 23:05Like there's always some degree of uncertainty about whatever
- 23:11random number. Now, in some cases, if you're, I
- 23:13don't know, playing a Mario Brothers game or something like
- 23:15that, who cares? But, but as soon as you're a
- 23:19serious gamer, whether you're playing for money or for, you
- 23:22know, in a, in a serious competition, I think you want to
- 23:25know that, that the randomness is really random and that you're
- 23:30not manipulated. And so, so anyway, I appreciate
- 23:34the kind words, Michael. And, and you know, I, I'm, I
- 23:38hope people understand, you know, what we're trying to
- 23:42accomplish. You know, we started out to as
- 23:45I, as I was, as I said, we started out from, it was
- 23:49somewhat of my like I, I need to prove that these do something
- 23:53else 'cause I want to beat the regulators to very quickly
- 23:56realizing, no really there is a market for this, that, that it's
- 23:59genuine. It genuinely can be a massive
- 24:03business in and of itself. Yeah, one could.
- 24:07Make the case at only 10 to 100 XS from here, because if we're
- 24:10living in an increasingly digital world, which we all
- 24:12would know we are, then you need to create randomness from like
- 24:16authentication tokens and from a from a listener perspective, the
- 24:21gravity is like the easiest example that's tangible is I
- 24:25forget and I know there was like a mix up.
- 24:27So I don't like completely I'll butcher this, but directionally
- 24:32because there was happening between foundation and cold card
- 24:35that cold card and they think the rod was going to kill me.
- 24:38If you listen to be like MK2, something happened with the
- 24:40randomness of rolling the dice that effectively I think it
- 24:44wasn't fully random in the way it was set up where funds were
- 24:47lost and they made a big stink. Foundation did, but point being
- 24:50is that like humans were very bad at creating randomness to
- 24:54the point of like the most visceral feeling or relationship
- 25:00to that is literally losing your Bitcoin because they were able
- 25:02to go and like cycle through addresses and sweep the funds
- 25:05because they didn't weren't able to create the the amount of
- 25:07randomness and entropy to create the private key that was needed.
- 25:12Yeah. So that's just like a small
- 25:13example, but it's one that's the most relatable today because we
- 25:16operate all day with encryption in in Bitcoin, but increasing
- 25:19world as digital is is increasingly encrypted and you
- 25:22need that randomness to exist. Yeah.
- 25:26Yeah, I know. I Yeah.
- 25:27Go ahead, Jackson. I was just going to say that I
- 25:30think Michael's excitement really stems from the fact that
- 25:33he does read his horoscope every morning and he just, he wants to
- 25:37pretend that he's excited about the other use cases.
- 25:39But exactly. But Bob, it's really
- 25:43fascinating, especially like from how you stumbled into it,
- 25:47not in a derogatory way, but I guess more so you mentioned the
- 25:51idea of having an S19 machine and the ability to tell a
- 25:57government or a regulator or whoever may be asking or
- 26:00infringing on your privacy that this could be doing many other
- 26:03things aside from mining Bitcoin.
- 26:05And that is really powerful just from a perspective of property
- 26:09rights and preserving that. But I also think it it, it
- 26:13sounds very compelling from an optionality as it relates to
- 26:15revenue of owning these machines as well, right?
- 26:18Because I'm sure we could talk about it during this podcast,
- 26:21but just how looking forward into the coming cycles fee
- 26:26markets will develop and thinking about the block reward
- 26:29and maybe there's going to be an increased demand for this type
- 26:34of monetization of these machines.
- 26:36And it's just really, I mean, there's, you can do an entire
- 26:39podcast on this topic alone because it's really, I've never
- 26:42heard anything like this before. So it's just it's really
- 26:45fascinating to get your perspectives on it.
- 26:49Yeah. I mean, we'll see.
- 26:50We'll see how economically viable it is.
- 26:53It's too early to tell. It depends on really the demand
- 26:56for it. I mean, I think it, I think it
- 26:59takes Vegas and puts it in any, anybody's browser potentially.
- 27:04Well, yeah, that's certainly the objective of that.
- 27:08And I, I will say that while we haven't worked out the whole
- 27:13model exactly that we are looking at for instance, as it
- 27:19pertains to the casino, we are looking at those that provide
- 27:23hash rate to back it as part of the house.
- 27:26So it's like providing liquidity to the house.
- 27:30So depending on how well the house is doing will determine
- 27:36the reward of the of the person contributing or the machine
- 27:41contributing hash. So, yeah, so.
- 27:46Yeah, it's a the Casino 1 and that's where is fascinating like
- 27:52because you change the dynamic of running a casino like in the
- 27:56sense of if you in my mind is if the back end is sound and it's
- 27:59random and then the front end is the consumer, the liquidity
- 28:04person coming. Well, they naturally do not want
- 28:06to be gained. So if a market forms around, you
- 28:10know, a non game version, you have more liquidity, more people
- 28:12coming, and then it becomes around the user experience of
- 28:16creating the best, you know, incentives pools, right?
- 28:22There's all these like interesting things you can do,
- 28:23but what's kind of just like mind bending for me is like it
- 28:25can all be done on Bitcoin. And then that effectively just
- 28:27becomes uncensored. You cannot like, ever stop
- 28:30anything like that because you can't stop the payment of of the
- 28:32flow of either direction. Yeah, that's how account
- 28:35creation takes place. Basically with Bitcoin, it's a
- 28:39it's a Bitcoin based casino as well, which maybe I can show you
- 28:45guys offline at the end of this, we can figure out a different
- 28:49way to share a screen and I'll show you people out there
- 28:52listening. Hopefully we'll have something
- 28:54soon that you'll all be able to look at.
- 28:56But yeah, I think it changes the game if you think about how
- 28:59much, how much effort goes in and how much overhead goes into
- 29:03the gaming industry to try to prove that it's fair or to
- 29:08regulate it or to manage it. And if you go, well, I don't
- 29:11have to do any of that. It in a lot of ways it does for
- 29:15gaining what Bitcoin did for money, right?
- 29:17You know, So what, what Bitcoin did for money was say, I don't
- 29:21have to trust all these other people, all these regulators,
- 29:24all these tools to make sure that nothing bad is happening.
- 29:31Go away with Bitcoin. Well, same thing with this.
- 29:33Like we, we can. And, and so I think it's
- 29:36fascinating that proof of work gets used again.
- 29:41And I'm, you know, and, and, you know, I think we've done
- 29:44something innovative, but I want to, you know, give full credit
- 29:49to Satoshi because I mean, I don't, I don't come up with this
- 29:52without, without Satoshi and understanding Bitcoin.
- 29:55I mean it it, you know, it's, it's truly standing on the
- 30:00shoulders of giants kind of thing like.
- 30:04Yeah, it, it one of the things that like, I, I think one of the
- 30:11reasons I, I thought that Bitcoin was a big deal was
- 30:14because a background in accounting and here's this thing
- 30:18that audits everything in the world every 10 minutes.
- 30:21Like, of course that's better. And this is another extension of
- 30:25that same sort of phenomenon of, of this technology makes it
- 30:29auditability and transparency a million times better than what's
- 30:34possible in the physical world. And, and so I have a few
- 30:38questions of like, how would you characterize what, what an S 19
- 30:42is? Then it is it, it's, so it's not
- 30:45an ASIC, is it that it's a, a number, a random number
- 30:49generator? Like what?
- 30:50What is the a better characterization of what that
- 30:55work is? I've I've somewhat settled on
- 30:59entropy engine as I think the best descriptor of of what it is
- 31:06and. And is, is that perfect entropy?
- 31:08Because it, so I may be mixing things up here, but I, I recall
- 31:13there there's something from, you know, Satoshi's coins about
- 31:16the extra knots being a little different.
- 31:18And I don't remember if that pattern has any bearing on the
- 31:23randomness of the nonce that's selected by that machine.
- 31:27Is that, am I conflating things or is it perfectly random what
- 31:31an S 19 spits out or does it matter?
- 31:34So you're. Yeah, well.
- 31:36There's a lot of elements that determine it.
- 31:38So, you know, first is and, and we we keep so this the seed,
- 31:48right? So the, what it is you're
- 31:51hashing right, is dependent on the previous block.
- 31:57So first of all, we are, we are taking a time stamp in there as
- 32:03well. You know, at the microsecond
- 32:05level, we have all these elements that sit within there.
- 32:09And so the the output and and then we have the difficulty
- 32:18level, of course, too, right. So, so we have all these things,
- 32:23I mean to it. It's it's my belief that we have
- 32:26created a as best as mankind can do to create an auditable and
- 32:36verifiable number. You know, we can't like we,
- 32:40there are certain things that I think we know as Bitcoiners and
- 32:44we've all probably learned a little bit about hashing like
- 32:47you can't prove that there aren't collisions, right, that
- 32:50two unique set of inputs don't create the same output.
- 32:55I don't think we have an example of it yet, but it's technically
- 33:01possible that that that could happen so.
- 33:04To sort of allowing for the the vanishingly small possibility of
- 33:08like ghosts in the code or something funny unexpected
- 33:11happening where the randomness is is being generated.
- 33:16Yeah, well, I mean, that's how that's how in the past a lot of
- 33:20that happened. Like there was a, there's a, a
- 33:22great story, not a great story, but there was a guy who wrote
- 33:26the algorithm for like Lotto numbers at one point.
- 33:33And of course he, he had a, a back door in that thing.
- 33:38And he could, he could on certain days like it, it wasn't
- 33:43every day, but on certain days he could, he could predict what
- 33:48numbers were going to be output. So he would go around the
- 33:51country to different friends and say, Hey, buy, buy this lottery
- 33:55ticket on this day. And, you know, he was smart
- 33:59enough to not do it himself, but you know, he had all these
- 34:01different people, but he eventually got uncovered and
- 34:03they found the back door in the, that stuff's impossible with
- 34:08what we're, what we're doing. And that's where the difficulty
- 34:11adjustment really kind of, you know, 'cause we're, we're going
- 34:15for a certain difficulty level too, which as we get more hash
- 34:19power, we'll get bigger and bigger.
- 34:21So the you could quote UN quote the quality of this.
- 34:24I mean I think the quality even at like that you guys saw in the
- 34:28demo, which is really just two or three leading zeros is pretty
- 34:32good. But we can increase the quality
- 34:34by simply right changing the difficulty level.
- 34:38And correct me if I'm wrong, but I mean the the sheer scale of
- 34:42hashing that's happening in a single machine, it's probably
- 34:45enough to run like every casino in the world, no problem.
- 34:50Well, it, well, it depends on how many people we have playing,
- 34:54you know, but I mean, we have, we have no, we'd have no if we
- 34:57had a couple 1000 people playing, we wouldn't need more
- 35:02than maybe two or three machines, so.
- 35:07The thing this reminds me of is a little bit of like open source
- 35:09software where again, still being early to the Internet, but
- 35:14the way it's like seems like it's shaking out is that open
- 35:17source open networks when and specific layer ground are bound
- 35:22like password managers. It's kind of a best practice
- 35:24that you're using open source because there's so many
- 35:26technical able to verify and then the market coalesces around
- 35:31a trusted, trusted software to use and you can't read the code,
- 35:34but somebody can and then they cry foul if they look at
- 35:40something it doesn't make sense. And so this kind of reminds me
- 35:42of that in the sense of you have these generators that are
- 35:47spinning for certain places on the Internet and people can back
- 35:50into it and prove that it's malicious or not.
- 35:53And then the market just starts to form around, oh, that's a
- 35:55trusted source to go and and do things to for or I won't like.
- 35:59That's how I can kind of see this shaking out.
- 36:03Yeah. I mean.
- 36:03We have to, we have to be honest and transparent because we're
- 36:09dead if we don't, right? I mean the, the, the moment
- 36:11somebody says, oh, no, this is manipulated.
- 36:14Now we're you. The algorithm says the card
- 36:20dealt should have been an 8 of clubs and you guys put up A10 of
- 36:24hearts. Well, we're done at that point,
- 36:26right? And we should be if that was
- 36:29ever the case. And so on that point, the way
- 36:33that you ensure that this thing isn't like running a number and
- 36:38it spits out, you know, 8 of clubs and then the house is
- 36:41like, let's try another card. But and then show that one.
- 36:45You would then see that the, the, the there is a card in the
- 36:50chain that wasn't dealt, that should have been dealt.
- 36:53Is is that how you? Would be, yeah.
- 36:55I mean the chain. Reviewing that.
- 36:57Yeah, I mean, and so the just like Bitcoin to be honest, in
- 37:04the early days, theoretically somebody could do the whole
- 37:10chain, right. But as we get further and
- 37:12further in and the chain gets bigger and bigger and bigger, it
- 37:15becomes harder and harder. So.
- 37:17Yeah. So I guess in that sense, you
- 37:19can have like a 51% attack on like, oh, let's let's go back to
- 37:24that prior nonce and then and then run again and have a fork
- 37:28here. And I guess that's something you
- 37:30got to solve for. And, and, you know, that's why I
- 37:33think like just we're still thinking through a lot of
- 37:38things. And I think what'll happen is
- 37:40that in the early days, until it establishes itself, I would
- 37:45recommend people come in and have fun with it and play for
- 37:49low stakes, you know, and, and I know that's, that's a terrible,
- 37:55it's terrible for business to a certain degree, but I think, you
- 38:00know, at some point it just becomes so big.
- 38:02And really, and because we're going to build this chain
- 38:05really, really quickly too. That's the other thing is that
- 38:09unlike Bitcoin, which is 144 blocks a day, ish, right?
- 38:14You know, well, we're adding blocks at a massive rate, you
- 38:19know, really, really quickly. So the chain, the chain, the
- 38:25chain will get to, I think this critical point where people can
- 38:28trust it more and more. Is it correct?
- 38:32Like theoretically you would want more hash power behind that
- 38:35because for a certain application you could reorganize
- 38:39that chain by going backwards with more hash rate right to
- 38:42change what you would want to manipulate in the in the the
- 38:45blocks. Yeah, and you would want it
- 38:47distributed hash rate, right? So not all owned by a single
- 38:51entity. Yeah.
- 38:52And you know, we obviously right now we own it all, but I'm, I'm
- 38:55not telling people to go play it yet, right.
- 38:57You know, so you know, our, our intention is that anybody can
- 39:01throw hash right at it. And you know, there are, there
- 39:08are places where we have vulnerabilities.
- 39:14I think they lessen with time as I said and we'll be transparent
- 39:18about what those are and but that the more participation we
- 39:23get the the safer it gets and it.
- 39:26And it seems like it could also be more profitable for hash rate
- 39:31to to be used for this sort of use case if they're, I think you
- 39:36mentioned that there's some sort of economics share with the the
- 39:40hash. Rate, yeah, it's possible, but
- 39:43it'll, it'll like anything. It's like in Bitcoin.
- 39:48I mean, it's how many people are playing like it'll, it'll really
- 39:51be a function of how many people are playing the game and
- 39:55generating hash. If too much hash rate comes in
- 39:59though. Yeah, it'll, it'll balance out
- 40:01anyway. It'll, it'll balance back out.
- 40:03So I and, and that's important to me because Bitcoin is more
- 40:07important to me than this. And so if, if for some reason
- 40:12the Bitcoin network started to weaken because of what we were
- 40:16doing, then I would say, well, we got to, we got to shut it
- 40:20down. But I, I just, I can't imagine
- 40:23that happening that, you know, we're not going to see 50 XA
- 40:28hashes flee the, the Bitcoin network and, and come over to
- 40:34the chaos thing quickly. Yeah, I see this as the
- 40:38opposite. It runs you like AI and the Co
- 40:40location happening, then you just end up with more robustness
- 40:43for where to put the hash depending on where the market's
- 40:46paying and the use case, right? Like I don't know what's better
- 40:51cuz printing that money than a casino.
- 40:53And so if that's starting to do, you can shift that hash, but
- 40:56then you can always move it, you know, depending where you need
- 40:58to. Yeah.
- 41:00Bob, do you have a like a threshold in mind of like if, if
- 41:04you get 1% of the hash rate is, is doing this application rather
- 41:12than just Bitcoin mining, that that becomes the sort of magic
- 41:16threshold for saying like, look, we're not, you know, it's not an
- 41:19ASIC. So, so regulators get it
- 41:21straight. This is a This is a entropy
- 41:24generator, and 1% of that entropy generation is being used
- 41:28for this totally different thing.
- 41:30Is that is there like a magic number in your head?
- 41:33I think it can be materially less than that.
- 41:36Because here's the thing. I mean, all these efforts are
- 41:40really stupid, right? Because I'm.
- 41:42I'm having this call with you on a MacBook.
- 41:46OK, I could be mining Bitcoin on this MacBook right now.
- 41:51I don't because it's not really economically viable, but I've,
- 41:58and what I view is if, if, if, if a government regulator came
- 42:03in and said, hey, anybody that runs mining software on any
- 42:08platform, whether it's something like an S19 or a traditional PC
- 42:13or a GPU thing, all these things have been part of our past,
- 42:16right? Well, we're going to tax, we're
- 42:20going to tax you based on that energy consumption.
- 42:23So while the only way, the only way to do that is first, I think
- 42:28severely violate my privacy by forcing me to disclose to the
- 42:32government what software I'm running.
- 42:37And I believe I'm just trying to to make it so that they have to
- 42:44look at an S 19 the same way as they look at the MacBook.
- 42:47That that, you know, what I've proved is I already and and
- 42:51there's a reason why I have 3 websites going at at first, not
- 42:54just one across wildly different applications.
- 42:59You know, one is kind of the chaos engines is really kind of
- 43:06the core generator. That's the core technology and
- 43:09that's the one that'll have the APIs for commercial purposes.
- 43:12So like if you were a pharmaceutical company or a
- 43:14financial services company running Monte Carlo analysis,
- 43:17anything I need a bunch of numbers, you'll be able to tap
- 43:21that API and get them from there.
- 43:23And then we have the horoscope stuff and the casino stuff.
- 43:27So, you know, 33 wildly different things all running off
- 43:33of the same machine and not really a way for anybody on the
- 43:39outside to know without, you know, I think a massive
- 43:43violation of, of, of privacy. So good luck, Elizabeth Warren.
- 43:53I love it, Jackson. Jackson had a whole list.
- 43:55We thought we were talking about centralization and datum and
- 43:57ocean mining and and now we're talking about Monte Carlo
- 44:01analysis and and casinos. Yeah.
- 44:04Well, we can go with those other.
- 44:05I mean, we can go wherever you guys want to go so it.
- 44:08I mean it, it my mind is still blown that like you've just
- 44:12shown here, that that an application of Bitcoin that I'd
- 44:16never thought of before is having a more perfect and
- 44:19audible form of randomness in the world and that is useful for
- 44:23every industry in various ways. That's awesome.
- 44:26Yeah, I, I, I echo that sentiment, Jesse.
- 44:29I love the idea of in a world where trust is declining and for
- 44:35for many reasons and many types of institutions, this could be a
- 44:39really compelling use case to maybe regain trust in terms of
- 44:44having this type of auditable and verifiable randomness.
- 44:48And yeah, I mean it. There's probably so many other
- 44:52use cases, Bob, that we could touch on.
- 44:55To Michael's point, I do want to get into some of the mining
- 44:59stuff as well, but if there's anything else like, you know,
- 45:01you really wanted to cover on this topic, we, we can before
- 45:04doing so. One more quip here, Bob.
- 45:07Ironically, I think you've found the one viable alternative use
- 45:12case for blockchain technology besides Bitcoin as money.
- 45:17Well, thank you. Thank you.
- 45:19I appreciate that. Yeah, sorry, I was on mute.
- 45:24But Bob, maybe, I mean I know you're involved in a lot of
- 45:28different businesses and pursuits these days, Barefoot
- 45:33being one of the businesses that we talked about in the last
- 45:36show. Could we explore the idea of
- 45:40your focus on small and medium sized mining and just the A, why
- 45:45do you focus on that and how do you view that as a
- 45:47differentiator for Barefoot versus other players in the
- 45:50space? And then the other piece of that
- 45:52as well would just be, why do you view that as so crucial to
- 45:57the Bitcoin network? And there's a lot of, I think,
- 45:59other questions I have top of mind as well, but let's start
- 46:02there. All right, OK.
- 46:04This may take a while. All right.
- 46:12So first I'll, I'll start with this, OK.
- 46:17I believe the most economically advantageous portion of mining
- 46:25will be in this space that I believe I can chase power in
- 46:32this size range, several 100 kilowatts to single digit
- 46:37megawatts. And that stranded energy exists
- 46:43in those pockets that can be free or close to free.
- 46:50And the large mining companies look at it and say, well, it's
- 46:53not worth our time to go after it.
- 46:59And so it it removes them from the competitive landscape.
- 47:06They almost all say, well, let's say like I'm doing a, I'm doing
- 47:10a 1.7 MW project right now. It's using anaerobic digestion
- 47:17from the excrement of cows from a dairy farm in Indiana.
- 47:26Our cost of production is let's just say well under $0.02 per
- 47:34kWh. Now, most companies would look
- 47:40at that type of opportunity any, any bigger company.
- 47:45So let's let's say the pub codes or those kind of and they just
- 47:48say 1.7 Wegmot. What am I going to do with that?
- 47:52Right? And, and in the middle of
- 47:54nowhere, I don't even have anything else close by, right?
- 47:58And I'll go along. Hey, I run the numbers.
- 48:01That's a pretty freaking good opportunity.
- 48:04And I may have to locate one or two bodies there, hire a couple
- 48:09people, but I can bring that operation up.
- 48:13And from ROI perspective, there's nothing better.
- 48:18It beats anything that that the big guys are working on now.
- 48:22I believe I can do that over and over and over and over again.
- 48:27Part of another group. We're buying our own stranded
- 48:29gas wells in Pennsylvania right now.
- 48:32And there's a lot of work with that.
- 48:35There is some risk with it, but you know, once we, once we buy
- 48:40the wells, it's our gas, it's free.
- 48:44I'm, I'm oversimplifying a little bit, but 'cause there are
- 48:48still costs of production, right?
- 48:50I mean, we have to run generators and there's
- 48:52maintenance on those generators and they're permits we have to
- 48:55get and standards we have to comply with.
- 48:57But, but again, we can beat anything on grid.
- 49:01So, so that's one reason that we do it from an economic
- 49:08perspective. There's a second reason, though.
- 49:12I don't have to compete for that power with anybody else.
- 49:18There's there's nobody else. The big guys trying to do big
- 49:23sites are now running straight into the AI world.
- 49:28They're running straight into the HPC world.
- 49:31They, they have to fight for those opportunities.
- 49:34And they're not, they're not infinite.
- 49:39They, they, they, they, they are finite, especially in
- 49:45jurisdictions that are friendly, that have the right cost
- 49:50structure, like they're, it's a very finite group that they're
- 49:54going after. And now they're competing with
- 49:56somebody else who's willing to pay more.
- 49:59Now some of the big guys are pivoting to that business, which
- 50:03I think is smart for them because I think they're going to
- 50:06find that that's a Better Business.
- 50:08And I hope they do frankly, 'cause I think they do a lot of
- 50:11damage to the Bitcoin network because they, we could go down
- 50:16that rabbit hole later too. But I think they over they
- 50:18overbuild and they're long, they're long amounts of time
- 50:24between capital deployment and starting hashing means that
- 50:31they're, they're almost always out of cycle in my opinion.
- 50:36So in other words, if I deploy capital to bring up A1 MW site,
- 50:40a natural gas site in I don't West Virginia, let's say
- 50:45identify the site, I raise the money.
- 50:49I'm probably operating in eight to 12 weeks from the point of
- 50:53capital deployment. So whatever, whatever market
- 50:56conditions were at the point that I made that business
- 51:00decision, I'm up and going inside those conditions.
- 51:07If, if I'm deploying $100 million on 100 MW site and it
- 51:14takes me 15 months, I, I tie up capital for really long periods
- 51:19of time and who knows what I come into, right?
- 51:23What is global hash rate? Then what is the price of
- 51:25Bitcoin? What's the fee market look like?
- 51:28I don't know any of those things.
- 51:29We can all speculate, we all do, of course, but they're coming up
- 51:33on these massive investments into a huge degree of
- 51:36uncertainty. And you know, they, there's this
- 51:42tendency in high growth businesses for people to
- 51:48underestimate what others are doing.
- 51:51So I saw this in the personal computer industry.
- 51:55For those that don't know, I came from the personal computer
- 51:57industry. So in the early 90s, we saw
- 52:00this, the personal computer market was starting to grow like
- 52:02crazy. So if we look at a year like
- 52:051995, it was a Seminole year in, in personal computing, we're
- 52:13starting to see just the early days of, you know, Internet
- 52:17adoption. AOL was hot.
- 52:20The CD-ROM was now a standard part of personal computers.
- 52:26The Pentium processor, which was considered very powerful at that
- 52:30time, was coming to the forefront.
- 52:32But most importantly, Windows 95 was coming out.
- 52:35And so in 1994, all of us in the personal computer industry knew
- 52:4095 was going to be a massive year.
- 52:43So you know, if I was at Gateway, so I'm going off the
- 52:47top of my head, these exact numbers are wrong, but I'm just
- 52:49talking, you know, conceptually. But you know, let's say we had
- 52:527% global market share at that point and we go well next year
- 52:56because all these cool things are happening, the markets going
- 52:58to grow 12%, but we're going to grow our market share from 7:00
- 53:03to 9:00. So, OK, So our forecast is you
- 53:08know for all this growth and we go off and set our supply chain
- 53:13and all our plans in action to capture all this.
- 53:17Well, guess what was happening at Dell, guess what was
- 53:20happening at Compaq is what happening at HP.
- 53:23Guess what happening at all these other, they were doing
- 53:25exactly the same thing. Everybody knew the market was
- 53:27going to grow and everybody thought they were going to grow
- 53:30their market share. Well, what end up happening?
- 53:35Well, market didn't grow quite as big as we all thought it
- 53:38would be and some gain share, some lost share.
- 53:43But what happened? A massive glut.
- 53:47I see a very analogous thing that seems to happen in mining,
- 53:55especially with the public miners and the public miners,
- 53:58they seem to be rewarded for growing, not not making money.
- 54:01They seem to be rewarded for growing, which baffles me to be
- 54:06honest. Like because if you look at I, I
- 54:09don't want to call out any specific company here today, but
- 54:14if you look at the, the public mining sector as a whole, it's
- 54:17been a catastrophe for quite a while.
- 54:20Like their financials are horrible, yet they keep making
- 54:24these offerings, whether it's convertible debt or new share
- 54:28issuance. And they get gobbled up.
- 54:31And that money often goes into expansion, which the market then
- 54:36rewards as soon as the they say, well, we're going to add another
- 54:39three extra hashes or two extra hashes in 12 months.
- 54:42And the market goes nuts and rewards them.
- 54:44And they do another offering. And we kind of have this
- 54:47feedback cycle that in my mind keeps rewarding companies that
- 54:52haven't yet shown operational excellence.
- 54:56And that's, that's bad because what it does do is the on the
- 54:58private side, we don't have that luxury.
- 55:02We don't have the luxury of operating with negative cash
- 55:05flow for any extended period of time.
- 55:07None of us do whether we're big or small on the private side,
- 55:11generally we don't have that opportunity, right.
- 55:14And so, so there's a, there's a possibility where what ends up
- 55:22happening is if this goes on and for an extended period of time
- 55:27where at the end of it, you have an overbuilt infrastructure with
- 55:33only the least efficient people left.
- 55:39I'm not saying that's what's going to happen, but there is
- 55:42there is that possibility that that that's what happens.
- 55:46Does your Bitcoin custody setup keep you up at night?
- 55:49Maybe you still have coins sitting on an exchange.
- 55:51Worried about hackers? Or maybe you've set up your own
- 55:54self custody but don't feel safe with your Bitcoin savings
- 55:56stashed on a little plastic device in your desk drawer?
- 56:00Gain Peace of Mind with Onramp and our multi institution
- 56:03custody solution. Here's how it works.
- 56:06Onramp creates a dedicated multi sig vault just for you. 3
- 56:10separate institutions each hold a key, Onramp bit go and coin
- 56:14cover, but none can move funds unilaterally.
- 56:18Instead, only you have control over your coins with on ramps
- 56:22multi institution custody. You'll sleep better at night
- 56:25knowing your Bitcoin is stored with best in class security on
- 56:28chain with fault tolerant multi sig.
- 56:31If you believe your Bitcoin is going to be worth a lot someday,
- 56:34don't jeopardize that future by exposing your coins to hackers
- 56:37on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks in the real world, or perhaps
- 56:41most importantly, the risk that you might screw something up
- 56:45with a highly technical self custody set up.
- 56:48Onramp's Multi Institution Custody eliminates single points
- 56:51of failure, reduces your personal attack surface and
- 56:54technical burden, and provides access to financial services
- 56:57that allow you to confidently secure your Bitcoin, including
- 57:01inheritance planning, insurance backed warranties for all
- 57:03balances and transactions, low cost trading and more.
- 57:08Bitcoin is a once in a species asset.
- 57:10Secure it right. Learn more at on
- 57:12rentbitcoin.com. So Bob, maybe just jumping in
- 57:16for a second, I think it's really important what you're
- 57:19describing because I don't think a lot of people think about the
- 57:22the mining industry from a public sector.
- 57:24They hear the big names and they don't really when you hear it
- 57:27broken down like that, it kind of makes sense.
- 57:29But I think what you're describing is a is effectively a
- 57:31product of loose money, whether it's on the traditional side.
- 57:35I've, I've been at the the Weworks of the world and was
- 57:38grow at all cost to get more money.
- 57:40We no block 5 went under because they didn't want to lose the
- 57:42annual recurring revenue and stop out the loans.
- 57:45And that's what cost cost them to be offsides from, you know,
- 57:48closing out positions on the lending capital.
- 57:51But then we experience this first hand similar to what
- 57:53you're describing on the custody side, because ultimately the
- 57:57market subsidizes almost all like Bitcoin companies in
- 58:01general. When you think about like the
- 58:02venture capital that comes in to grow at all costs and take
- 58:06either some kind of like market share or thought that you'll
- 58:08monetize in the future. And so there's this like fallacy
- 58:11built into Bitcoin that like custody should cost nothing.
- 58:15It's a bare asset, it's easy. But when you really think about
- 58:17it breaking down, it's like, well, there's only 21 million
- 58:19and we believe it can go to exposition.
- 58:21Somebody has to pay for that cost, whether somebody pays for
- 58:24it in the, in the security in their own home and guards or the
- 58:27custodian has to protect it. But this notion if you're using
- 58:30a company, they don't charge or this flat fee, well, somebody's
- 58:33paying for it. And ultimately to your point, at
- 58:35a certain time that runs out and then your counterparty may not
- 58:38be your counterparty because you have to get acquired or you go
- 58:41out of business. And these are just things that
- 58:43we experience day in and day out because we we charge for a
- 58:46product because it's we think it's best in class.
- 58:48And you have to pay the institutions to safeguard those
- 58:50cryptographic keys. But we see first hand you
- 58:54compete against somebody paying zero and zero is inorganic and
- 58:57it can't last forever. And so we just kind of hang,
- 59:00right? But so this will reminds me very
- 59:01similar. And I think there's probably
- 59:02little slivers across the board, whether it's in the traditional
- 59:05world or in Bitcoin, where different market specialists can
- 59:09see how this somebody trying to build the right way experiences
- 59:11this. And you just have to be very
- 59:13prudent, pragmatic about building in that environment.
- 59:16I think you're, you're nuts on when you said about the loose
- 59:20money. I agree with everything you
- 59:21said, but I think that's especially pertinent.
- 59:23And I'll, I'll just restate it a different way.
- 59:26I believe it is an infection of the Fiat world into Bitcoin.
- 59:31You know, I, I believe that and, and you know what I see
- 59:34sometimes I don't spend too much time on it, but I see people
- 59:38kind of support the public miners.
- 59:41You know, my guess is a lot of them are people heavily invested
- 59:43in the public miners, but they'll kind of cheer them on
- 59:46and say, oh, they're, they're company X is copying Sailor
- 59:51strategy. Say, well, no, they're not,
- 59:54they're not copying sailor strategy.
- 59:55Sailor Sailor has a a sound core business that generates positive
- 1:00:01cash flow and he is using his, his and and so.
- 1:00:07His treasury essentially has no exposure.
- 1:00:12Well, if if you're a company that is got negative cash flow
- 1:00:20and doesn't have a sound core business, you may be huddling,
- 1:00:24but that whole huddle stack is greatly exposed.
- 1:00:27In fact, it presents a threat to the network.
- 1:00:30And I will call out Core Scientific, at least the first
- 1:00:34incarnation of Core and Scientific, which did massive
- 1:00:36damage to the the Bitcoin ecosystem when when they had a
- 1:00:43big stack, they were losing bunches of money, they took on
- 1:00:47bunches of debt. And as they started to unwind,
- 1:00:51they had to sell massive amounts of Bitcoin into the market.
- 1:00:55This is a late 22, mid, mid to late 2022.
- 1:01:01And and it's my opinion they that that brand should be held
- 1:01:07in the same vein as FTX and Celsius and Voyager, that they
- 1:01:12did the same amount of damage and forced us into this extended
- 1:01:16bear market at the same level as those companies did.
- 1:01:21They took on a billion dollars of debt.
- 1:01:23They overbought equipment, they forced pricing very, very high.
- 1:01:26They locked out companies like mine from having access to
- 1:01:30equipment and they sold thousands and thousands of
- 1:01:33Bitcoin between the spring and their ultimate bankruptcy in
- 1:01:39November till they had no Bitcoin left.
- 1:01:41I don't remember off the top of my head, I think it was it was
- 1:01:45might even be well over 10,000 Bitcoin.
- 1:01:47Like they were just dump, they were dumping everything they're
- 1:01:49producing plus their stash. And the more they dumped, the
- 1:01:53more the market went negative, which forced the price down,
- 1:01:56which mean they had to sell more to cover it.
- 1:01:59And all of us were forced into the same thing.
- 1:02:02So, so anyway, I, I don't, I don't want to be doom and gloom
- 1:02:07here, but but I think that that those are things that we have to
- 1:02:12be cognizant of. So there was a question asked
- 1:02:15earlier and it kind of went on a tangent there.
- 1:02:17You know, I think companies like barefoot, whether it's Barefoot
- 1:02:20and there are, there are other good players that are, I think
- 1:02:23following a somewhat similar strategy to barefoot.
- 1:02:25Now I think we provide a very important part of the ecosystem
- 1:02:29and this leads to another thing, Michael, which you were leading
- 1:02:32to. So I have a very different view
- 1:02:34of the future of mining, but I'm going to give a speech in at La
- 1:02:39Bitcoin next next week. And I'll, I'll hit on some of
- 1:02:43this, but I'll preface it today. And what I'm going to say is
- 1:02:47controversial. I, I think we are on the cusp of
- 1:02:51seeing major financial institutions take over the
- 1:02:56prominent role in mining. So whether that's it may not be
- 1:03:04these names, but Citiblank and BlackRock and Deutsche Bank and
- 1:03:09Mitsui and like these types of companies in major markets, I
- 1:03:15believe will move heavy into mining.
- 1:03:19And the reason is it's not about mining Bitcoin and acquiring
- 1:03:24Bitcoin, it's about controlling block space that if we project
- 1:03:30what I'm going to say I think is true, the only question is the
- 1:03:33amount of time. So, so there's the, the network
- 1:03:38has a capacity of about 200 million transactions annually.
- 1:03:41That's it. So if major portions of the
- 1:03:46world are running on a Bitcoin economy, then as a financial
- 1:03:52institution, if you don't have access to control transactions
- 1:03:57within that economy, you're dead.
- 1:03:59It's existential. So if I was Citibank right now,
- 1:04:06if I was Bank of America, if I was Mitsui in Japan, I would get
- 1:04:10into mining and I would set a goal of probably having at least
- 1:04:141% of global hash rate and make sure that I can control roughly
- 1:04:17one block a day. It has nothing to do with the
- 1:04:20subsidy and the fees. They could give a crap.
- 1:04:24Bank of America has AIT budget of about $11 billion a year.
- 1:04:29That is the same size as the entire revenue of the Bitcoin
- 1:04:33mining industry last year and this year.
- 1:04:37So they're I just one bank, they don't give a crap.
- 1:04:41But, but if they lose customers, if they lose the ability to have
- 1:04:47control about when transactions occur and what the cost of those
- 1:04:51transactions are, they're dead. So, so I believe we'll see a
- 1:04:57radical change. I also believe we'll see nation
- 1:05:00states move heavily into mining for the same reason.
- 1:05:05And I'm not saying they don't want to build Bitcoin treasury
- 1:05:07and we, we hear a lot of people talking about that, But I, I
- 1:05:11think people are missing the main point.
- 1:05:12The main point is going to be about block space control.
- 1:05:15If I, if I was the president of Bolivia right now, what I would
- 1:05:20be doing is I would be building some mining operations of my
- 1:05:23own, number one, and #2 I would be putting sweetheart deals out
- 1:05:27to minors all over the world saying come to Bolivia, here's a
- 1:05:30sweetheart deal. The only caveat is you have to
- 1:05:33use the Bolivia pool. And in the Bolivia pool, the,
- 1:05:37the either the government or the central bank or one of those
- 1:05:41will be deciding what transactions go in those blocks.
- 1:05:45But I'm not saying I like this. I'm just telling you what I
- 1:05:47think is going to happen. And so, so I believe that those
- 1:05:54public companies, these big guys are gonna, some of them may be
- 1:05:58purchased, some of them may be subsumed or just kind of
- 1:06:01overtaken. And I believe that it's the
- 1:06:03small medium sized commercial miners and the plebs we need to
- 1:06:07maintain some level of control. I believe the ideal numbers,
- 1:06:11about 30% of the network that maintains the true spirit and
- 1:06:17ethos of Bitcoin so that at least let's just say 50 blocks a
- 1:06:23day are coming out with that ethos because otherwise Bitcoin
- 1:06:29won't die. But you know, you're going to
- 1:06:31see OFAC compliance, you're going to see, you're going to
- 1:06:33see completely different criteria for transaction
- 1:06:36selection. Bob, could you, could you
- 1:06:38explain? So we're talking about sovereign
- 1:06:42nations and financial institutions wanting to get
- 1:06:45involved in the mining space and predominantly you said not
- 1:06:49because of fees and revenues tied to that, but because of
- 1:06:52controlling block space. I think one piece of nuance that
- 1:06:56is often maybe overlooked as relates to mining is taking a
- 1:07:02step back and talking about block templates right before
- 1:07:05thinking about hashing. So could you maybe just describe
- 1:07:09what block templates are at a high level, You know, don't need
- 1:07:13to go into a ton of detail there, but then into that just,
- 1:07:17I think that's really ultimately what we're getting at, right?
- 1:07:20Like that's where having the control and the ability to
- 1:07:22determine what goes in blocks. Like how would these
- 1:07:25institutions think about constructing their own block
- 1:07:28templates and that and being able to get involved the network
- 1:07:31that way? Yeah.
- 1:07:33OK, great. Great question, Jackson.
- 1:07:39All right. So I think a lot of people out
- 1:07:41there think there is a mem pool. Let's start with that.
- 1:07:45There is not a mem pool. Every node has its own mem pool.
- 1:07:50OK, now they're broadcasting to each other, but there are
- 1:07:54essentially filters set up that decide what each node is going
- 1:07:59to have in its mem pool. Now, most people don't play with
- 1:08:02these settings. They're a little harder on a
- 1:08:04core node. If you use knots, it's a little
- 1:08:07easier, but regardless, it's there for you.
- 1:08:09You can decide what you want, you know?
- 1:08:12OP Return to be as an example. Those are all.
- 1:08:15Are you going to accept something that has an 80 byte
- 1:08:19opera turn field or not? So those are decisions that can
- 1:08:24make and that sits in your mem pool.
- 1:08:28Now if you're a real miner, then what you do is you create your
- 1:08:32own template. Most miners in the world today
- 1:08:36are hashers, OK? That means that they provide
- 1:08:41their hash rate to somebody else who creates the block and
- 1:08:45they're just providing the compute that goes against it.
- 1:08:48That was me, by the way, until two weeks ago.
- 1:08:50And we'll talk about why I'm no longer that I'm a real miner now
- 1:08:56again for the so. So what happens is in fact,
- 1:09:02I'll, I'll kind of jump to that. So what I do is if I want to be
- 1:09:08a miner, then I use a commands called get block template.
- 1:09:15And so I look into my mem pool and those transactions that I've
- 1:09:21picked and I can set my criteria then to build my block from the
- 1:09:27transactions that are in my mem pool.
- 1:09:29OK, that means let's say my mem pool has 150,000 transactions in
- 1:09:35it. I can maybe fit 4000 in.
- 1:09:39So what criteria will I use? Well an example might be if I
- 1:09:45have some of my own transactions, include those
- 1:09:48first at no fee or minimal fee. If I have friends and family and
- 1:09:55other people I can put those in too.
- 1:09:59Then I might say, let's say I'm feeling philanthropic, I can
- 1:10:03say, let me find the ones that have been sitting there the
- 1:10:07longest period of time and I'll fill those in.
- 1:10:10This is by the way, not the normal template is I'm just
- 1:10:12exemplifying that you can kind of put whatever criteria is it
- 1:10:16just when you hit 4 million weight units, which is usually
- 1:10:19about 4000 transactions, you're full.
- 1:10:23OK, then you start mining. Now, as you're mining or as
- 1:10:27you're hashing, you're trying to, you're trying to solve the
- 1:10:29block. If new transactions come into
- 1:10:33your mem pool every few seconds you go and you look and see if
- 1:10:37there's something there that should have priority over one
- 1:10:41that's there and you can swap it out.
- 1:10:43So the block, the block template that you've created isn't, is
- 1:10:48actually dynamic during the mining process.
- 1:10:51OK, so, so, so the, the block template control is, is
- 1:10:59paramount because it's, it's deciding what transactions
- 1:11:04you're going to try to mine and more importantly, which ones
- 1:11:06you're not. And you know, that's why I
- 1:11:11believe like these financial institutions.
- 1:11:13So like if I, if I was Citibank, what I would do is I would say,
- 1:11:19hey, I'd go to all my commercial customers and especially my
- 1:11:24prospects. And I would say, hey, if you
- 1:11:27bank with me, I will give you guaranteed access to, to base
- 1:11:35layer transactions within a 72 hour period and you will pay no
- 1:11:40more than 8 SAT's per V byte regardless of what the market is
- 1:11:45like. I don't care what I, what I care
- 1:11:47about is the banking relationship, right?
- 1:11:50I think people often think of miners and they think of the
- 1:11:53block reward and think, oh, miners are, are economically
- 1:11:57motivated. They're going to, they're going
- 1:11:58to pick the transactions that make them the most money and
- 1:12:02they're right. But what they're missing is what
- 1:12:04makes them the most money might not be the block reward.
- 1:12:08It might be, it might be that relationship.
- 1:12:11If I was American Express, I would, I would get into mining
- 1:12:16right now and I would go to all my high net worth people, all
- 1:12:20the people that have a credit score or a credit line over a
- 1:12:22certain level. And I would say good news, you
- 1:12:24get 6 base layer transactions a year for free.
- 1:12:29You just, you know, you, here's how you notify us that you want
- 1:12:32a transaction done and we'll, we'll guarantee you it.
- 1:12:36So I, I think that that's where the future is going.
- 1:12:43And like I said, it's a matter of time.
- 1:12:46And I think it's hard for probably most people to envision
- 1:12:48because they are used to a world.
- 1:12:51If you've been in Bitcoin for a while, for the last 15 years,
- 1:12:54you think of block space as just kind of a given.
- 1:12:56It's something that's there, it's almost always available,
- 1:13:00it's almost always free. But I, I'd say in essence, those
- 1:13:06days are over and a new world will emerge.
- 1:13:11Custody companies, you know, might, might, this might be
- 1:13:14important for custody companies. You may not mind, but you may,
- 1:13:18you may want to have a relationship with a minor that
- 1:13:21you can offer that same service to your clients.
- 1:13:25Like, hey, we'll, we'll, you know, we'll give you the ability
- 1:13:29to move anything into cold storage or from, you know, this
- 1:13:32fall to that fault or whatever for free within certain limits.
- 1:13:37I think companies like River and Swan will have to have those
- 1:13:41kind of relationships cuz a fold like you won't be able to do
- 1:13:46withdrawals. There's an interesting thing
- 1:13:49about the subsidy because I think like, I'll, I'll pose it
- 1:13:54as a question to you guys. Like when you think about the
- 1:13:56subsidy, how how do you define the subsidy and its purpose?
- 1:14:04A few birds with one stone, you know, I think it's how you go
- 1:14:07from zero to 21 million fairly. And I think it's also I think
- 1:14:12it's, I think the real genius of it is, is it's how you create
- 1:14:16increasing scarcity and therefore the savings technology
- 1:14:20phenomenon of Bitcoin where you store purchasing power and then
- 1:14:24because of increasing scarcity of supply issuance in the
- 1:14:27future, it grows in purchasing power over time.
- 1:14:29So I think, I think it is it just unbelievably clever way to
- 1:14:35solve several things that needed to happen it with an elegant
- 1:14:39little design. Yeah, I think of, I think we
- 1:14:42talked about it the last one, it's like it's most simplest
- 1:14:45form. It's the way to kick start the
- 1:14:47the system and then once the flywheels done the the you don't
- 1:14:51need television because the block should keep the the system
- 1:14:55running in it because of the transactions.
- 1:14:57Yeah. And I think part of, yeah, one
- 1:14:59of those, one of the outcomes of it is that in theory there
- 1:15:03should be a smooth transition from, you know, percent of block
- 1:15:07reward that is subsidy into fee based.
- 1:15:11You know, and you can sort of imagine over 100 years how that
- 1:15:14should you know, transition from 100% block subsidy value to 100%
- 1:15:21fee value. So I.
- 1:15:25I agree with all that. The, the reason I asked and I
- 1:15:28don't mean to put I, I, I agree with 100% of what you said.
- 1:15:31However, I got to add one other thing that I think is important,
- 1:15:34which is I think most of the time people think of the subsidy
- 1:15:38and they view it as it's important to the minor.
- 1:15:43OK, It's subsidized the mining function, right.
- 1:15:47But I think what gets missed is that it was subsidizing the
- 1:15:52users too. It was giving the users access
- 1:15:56to the most powerful digital network in the world for free,
- 1:16:03essentially on demand for 15 years.
- 1:16:06Yeah, So and, and I think that was both brilliant and a curse
- 1:16:11as well. And the brilliant part was, and
- 1:16:15this you hit this, Michael, I mean, it really facilitated
- 1:16:18adoption, right? It facilitated adoption and
- 1:16:20usage. But what it also did was it
- 1:16:24created bad behaviors and expectations for the long run.
- 1:16:29It's it's created people that have lots of small UTXOS.
- 1:16:35It's created this expectation that people will be able to
- 1:16:39access the base layer whenever they want.
- 1:16:42But the math, and we may have hit it up in the past, but it's
- 1:16:46worth repeating, there's only 53,000 blocks a year.
- 1:16:50There's only 200 million transactions a year.
- 1:16:53There are 8 billion people in the world.
- 1:16:56There are 330 million companies in the world.
- 1:16:59The math doesn't work. Not everybody can live on the
- 1:17:03base layer. If I want to give 10,000 SAT's
- 1:17:08to everybody in the world, I don't think I have that much.
- 1:17:11But let's say I did, I know I don't.
- 1:17:13If I did and each one was an independent transaction, it
- 1:17:18would take 40 years for the network to process that.
- 1:17:23So not everybody can live on the base layer.
- 1:17:27We, we are a privileged group, those of us that got in when we
- 1:17:30did because I'd say I'm the whole people that that have
- 1:17:35their Bitcoin and they're saving it on the base layer in Colt
- 1:17:41storage. It's wonderful.
- 1:17:45You're there whether you have a 10th of a Bitcoin or you have
- 1:17:471000 Bitcoin, that's wonderful. You have it there X number of
- 1:17:53years from now. I think sooner than later, your
- 1:17:57ability to move that and access that will start to get really
- 1:18:01constrained. The math doesn't work right.
- 1:18:04And so whether that's lightning or different custodial solutions
- 1:18:09or these type of relationships that I'm talking about, even
- 1:18:13though I don't like them, they become very important and we
- 1:18:17have to even be careful. In my opinion, this is going to
- 1:18:21be controversial when we say not your keys, not your Bitcoin,
- 1:18:25it's a true statement. But 8 billion people can't hold
- 1:18:29their keys, you know, So what do we do for them?
- 1:18:32How do we set the right expectation?
- 1:18:35How many people can hold their own keys?
- 1:18:37I don't, I don't know that number.
- 1:18:38I haven't done that math, but but how many can on a practical
- 1:18:41basis? Because only 200 million of them
- 1:18:44can either put more money into the base layer or take it out on
- 1:18:48an annual basis. I mean, I'm, I'm assuming, I
- 1:18:51mean, it's obviously you can have multiple inputs and
- 1:18:52multiple outputs. So you can you can multiply that
- 1:18:57number a little bit, but. Yeah, we, we struggle with that
- 1:19:00phrase at onramp and recently I've been reflecting on, on what
- 1:19:07its value really is because it's, it's been an incredible
- 1:19:11mantra to to adhere to very valuable for Bitcoin's 15 year
- 1:19:16history specifically because it was is intended.
- 1:19:19I, I think it gets to the core of like self custody versus
- 1:19:24third party custodian control of your coins.
- 1:19:28Like, you know, Mount Cox, Quadriga, FTX, they're all on
- 1:19:31one side of that equation. And, and you're much better off
- 1:19:35if you're choosing between those two to, to avoid FTX or Mount
- 1:19:39Cox. But looking forward, I mean, it,
- 1:19:43it doesn't scale and it, it, that mantra just doesn't really
- 1:19:47have a place in, in the realities of like mainstream
- 1:19:53adoption. And I feel like what, you know,
- 1:19:56what I think that mantra is really all about is you want to
- 1:20:00have control as much as you can of your coins.
- 1:20:06Yes, whether or not you hold your keys, you know, it's really
- 1:20:09about control and risk mitigation.
- 1:20:12Right. Among your possible options.
- 1:20:15So anyway, it's been interesting to be, you know, at on ramp and
- 1:20:19really reflecting on how not your keys, not your coins has
- 1:20:22been very true, very helpful to keep people off of exchanges,
- 1:20:30keep their coins off of exchanges because that's been
- 1:20:32the big risk. But that it it's value is kind
- 1:20:36of limited to that foil between third party custody and self
- 1:20:41custody. Yeah.
- 1:20:42It reminds me of it reminds me of ocean a little bit.
- 1:20:45Bob. Is this tied into what Jackson
- 1:20:48had asked about the, the construction and and kind of
- 1:20:52your involvement from these? I think there's a component of
- 1:20:55the the ability of investment and sitting on the board of
- 1:20:58recognizing that there can't be X number of mining poles
- 1:21:03concentration because of the block template that was like
- 1:21:06embedded into the financial institutions you mentioned.
- 1:21:09And this is something we looked at directionally of like, well,
- 1:21:11not everybody's going to hold their Bitcoin.
- 1:21:13It's not technically feasible. So then the opposite means that
- 1:21:15they're going to be X number of custodians and that's not good
- 1:21:17for Bitcoin. That means that like we're just
- 1:21:19naturally. So it's a very similar thing,
- 1:21:21but you can't, there's a middle ground of pushing it out to the
- 1:21:24edges and then there's some trust involved and then there's
- 1:21:27some verification involved. And that's as best as we've
- 1:21:29figured out so far. Yeah, but but the existing
- 1:21:32solutions do not make sense of having a centralized number of
- 1:21:35either a custodians or B people incorporated the block template,
- 1:21:39creating the block templates, because that's how you can
- 1:21:41censor transactions. And ultimately you kind of, you
- 1:21:43know, kills the value prop of a, you know, permissionless asset.
- 1:21:47So it's very similar like on different sides of the spectrum,
- 1:21:49but they kind of map directionally from a game theory
- 1:21:51perspective if you have to play within the confines and they're
- 1:21:54not perfect, but they're as the best that we have.
- 1:21:57Yeah. Real quick on that, Bob, just to
- 1:22:01piggyback from Michael's thoughts there.
- 1:22:04One thing that we've talked about a lot internally and a bit
- 1:22:07on the podcast is the idea of over 10% of the Bitcoin total,
- 1:22:12Bitcoin 21 million is custody with one entity, which is
- 1:22:15Coinbase. And not to pick on them
- 1:22:17specifically, but, and you know, that could be any business, but
- 1:22:21really the idea is just a decentralized asset should not
- 1:22:25be centralized as it relates to custody.
- 1:22:27And I know you're focused on, like Michael said, a similar
- 1:22:30idea with Ocean and addressing the centralization of mining
- 1:22:35pools specifically. I, I've been digging into it
- 1:22:39more recently. I didn't even, I knew it was
- 1:22:41centralized, but I didn't realize to what extent.
- 1:22:45And I, I looked in some into some of the data, you know, I
- 1:22:48looked into some of the research and podcasts that you've done
- 1:22:51recently and it's just remarkable how you know,
- 1:22:55everyone wants to talk about how bullish they are as it relates
- 1:22:58to Bitcoin, the asset. Like if you go on log into
- 1:23:02Twitter, almost every post or take is just about the number
- 1:23:06going up. And I find that frustrating
- 1:23:08being in the custody business because we have to have a
- 1:23:10realistic conversation about, well, how do you actually secure
- 1:23:13the asset from one trillion to five to 10 trillion?
- 1:23:17And I'd imagine that it's frustrating to you being in the
- 1:23:22mining space because a lot of people are just overlooking that
- 1:23:26Bitcoin mining pools are extremely centralized, and that
- 1:23:29poses a big threat to our ability to use it in a
- 1:23:32permissionless way. Yeah, it is.
- 1:23:35It is frustrating. It's a little disappointing
- 1:23:38sometimes. I think there's a certain
- 1:23:40apathy. I think all of us are on some
- 1:23:44sort of a journey, right? And I think how, how, how deep
- 1:23:50and broad we go in that journey is is up to us.
- 1:23:56I think there are a lot of people that stop at a certain
- 1:23:59point. They, they almost think they
- 1:24:04understand it enough or they just think it will magically
- 1:24:10take care of itself somehow. Some people think Bitcoin is
- 1:24:15perfect. I obviously I hold Bitcoin in
- 1:24:21high esteem. I believe it's divinely
- 1:24:23inspired. I believe it has to be taken
- 1:24:27care of though. I think we've been given a
- 1:24:30phenomenal gift, but, but it, it won't just live for the next
- 1:24:381000 years, which is what I, what I believe in.
- 1:24:40I, I, I speak on that sometimes. So, you know, I believe Bitcoin
- 1:24:43has money for 1000 years. What's only going to do that if
- 1:24:47we really take care of it. And we have to realize that
- 1:24:51naturally centralization, anything this powerful, anything
- 1:24:56worth this much will constantly be subject to centralization and
- 1:25:01it'll also be subject to attack. So we have to be on our guard at
- 1:25:08all times. That's why did the proof of work
- 1:25:11random number thing, right? I mean, there was one attack
- 1:25:13vector coming over there. Well, there's another attack
- 1:25:16vector you know, that we're trying to solve with Ocean,
- 1:25:19which was mining pool centralization, and even more
- 1:25:23specifically template centralization, because the
- 1:25:26template centralization is even worse than the mining pool
- 1:25:29centralization because it's obvious that a bit main LED
- 1:25:35group is a bit main LED initiative is controlling
- 1:25:42template creation, and it's also controlling the Coinbase
- 1:25:46distribution from the pools. Like different pools are sending
- 1:25:50the reward to the same place. You can see the templates
- 1:25:55created by several of these pools are virtually identical.
- 1:26:01Shouldn't be that way. So when we launched Ocean, we
- 1:26:04did it from the perspective like, hey, we got to, we got to
- 1:26:08have more pools. But, but number one thing is we
- 1:26:10got to have more template creators and a pool implemented
- 1:26:16properly can allow individual miners to create their own
- 1:26:20templates but still be part of the same pool.
- 1:26:23So that's the part that people missed that and and that's what
- 1:26:29we fixed with the datum announcement.
- 1:26:32I guess we're on the order of 10 days ago or so.
- 1:26:36And it was the number one reason when I aligned with Ocean, which
- 1:26:42was I think it was July, July of 2023 is when I first started
- 1:26:50meeting with the Ocean team. And I'm proud to say Barefoot
- 1:26:53was the very first company to commit hash rate back then.
- 1:26:57And I did it, I did it after the initial meeting.
- 1:27:01I said, when you guys are ready to go, I'm, I'm going to commit
- 1:27:04X amount of hash rate to you. I was the first miner to sign up
- 1:27:08for that. And, and by the way, we, you
- 1:27:12know, we, we did do that and we were blessed to actually mine
- 1:27:15the first ocean block. And that was back in I think
- 1:27:20December 1st ish was when the first ocean block happened.
- 1:27:24But the long term vision was to announce what we just announced
- 1:27:28which is called datum. So the way datum works is each
- 1:27:33miner in the pool can create their own template.
- 1:27:35However, we must we get the information about how to share
- 1:27:44the output of the template from ocean.
- 1:27:47So Ocean tells us that hey, if whatever block is being worked
- 1:27:52on, say Bob should get 1% and Jackson should get half a
- 1:27:56percent, Michael should get 3%, Jesse should get 10%, whatever,
- 1:28:01whatever those numbers are, we all will share that.
- 1:28:05But we create our own decisions about the template creation.
- 1:28:09And Ocean has been very controversial because some
- 1:28:14people view us as censorship. You know, anti spam, the whole
- 1:28:21whole thing with ordinals and inscriptions.
- 1:28:25Still fighting some of those battles.
- 1:28:26By the way. I was just on a call last night
- 1:28:28on a spaces last night talking about that.
- 1:28:31But what we do is we've said, hey, it's up to the miner
- 1:28:36Miners, A real miner creates their own template.
- 1:28:41OK, so you're not part of the Bitcoin network.
- 1:28:43So like to create my own template, I run a node and I
- 1:28:49have to put the parameters in for the template I want to
- 1:28:51create and then my hash rate is directed to it.
- 1:28:56And if I win, I simply have directed that block when it was
- 1:29:00constructed. I share it in the appropriate
- 1:29:03percentages offered by the pool. And if one of you guys want it,
- 1:29:09you have to share with me. So it brings pools back to what
- 1:29:13they should be, which is a revenue sharing, revenue
- 1:29:18stabilization tool. That's the purpose of a pool.
- 1:29:21The purpose of a pool is not to remove the function of being a
- 1:29:24minor. And I should also point out
- 1:29:27that, you know, we're not in a real controversial time right
- 1:29:29now, but those template creators usually signal like soft force
- 1:29:34activation, soft fork activations too.
- 1:29:37So if you're, if you're out there and you have hash power,
- 1:29:41do you want your pool to, to vote on this or do you want to
- 1:29:45do it yourself? I mean, I think the, the spirit
- 1:29:48of Bitcoin is for you to take an active role and voice your
- 1:29:52opinion. If you're not, I mean, in my
- 1:29:55mind, you're not, you're not fulfilling your obligation.
- 1:30:00You know, I, I basically have this, I call it the miner's
- 1:30:03creed and I don't have it in front of me, but I basically
- 1:30:05think it's a voluntary thing. But you know, it basically says
- 1:30:09that if you're, if you're a miner, I think you take on a
- 1:30:12responsibility to, to guard the network and, and preserve the
- 1:30:16integrity of the network. And you, you, you should make
- 1:30:24the ethos of Bitcoin and living within that ethos your priority.
- 1:30:28Like I take this job very, very seriously and what my company
- 1:30:31does very seriously. I would say the same thing.
- 1:30:33You guys are in custody. I think another really important
- 1:30:36thing, you guys should have the same, I would expect you to have
- 1:30:40the same thing. So when I see companies that
- 1:30:43behave outside of that, that call themselves miners when
- 1:30:47they're not miners because they're just hashers and they're
- 1:30:50constantly making decisions outside the ethos, I get, I get
- 1:30:54concerned. And I, I would say on the whole,
- 1:30:58I don't want to call out any specific company or any specific
- 1:31:02individual, but I would say the ETHO centric people, the people
- 1:31:06that really are doing this for the betterment of Bitcoin and
- 1:31:11the betterment of the world and fixing broken money are the
- 1:31:15plebs and the small and medium sized commercial miners.
- 1:31:20Bob, I know Jackson has to run shortly, but I think one thing
- 1:31:23that this has been such a great recap of talking about the
- 1:31:26market structure is this notion of fixed fee per share.
- 1:31:31And then what Ocean's doing and why the market aggregates around
- 1:31:35like it just to help the, the audience and us understand the
- 1:31:39incentive model and how it's kind of moved to centralization
- 1:31:42and this like notion of variance.
- 1:31:44And then the last part is just the, because I actually don't
- 1:31:48know this like from a, is it a proportion from the template?
- 1:31:51So whoever finds the block, is it a proportion of their hash
- 1:31:57that they're sending to like the ocean pool?
- 1:31:59Or is it the entire pool like how does that work from a block
- 1:32:03construction at ocean and and is it datum?
- 1:32:06Datum. OK, So what datum is essentially
- 1:32:12doing is it saying hey, if you want to be a miner and create
- 1:32:17your own templates. So if you if you connect to the
- 1:32:20ocean pool, you have two choices.
- 1:32:21There are still 4 standard templates created by the pool
- 1:32:26and you can pick one of them. Or you have a fifth choice which
- 1:32:33is you create your own template. If you create your own template
- 1:32:36you need to run a datum server. And what will happen if you run
- 1:32:42a datum server is the pool will communicate to you and say this
- 1:32:49is the split. This is the split of the hash
- 1:32:53rate of the network. OK, so here's a list like we
- 1:32:57have 660 participants roughly in the pool right now from a guy
- 1:33:03running a bit X to, you know, farms, right?
- 1:33:09All shapes and sizes, but they each get a slice and that slice
- 1:33:13is determined. I'm going to oversimplify based
- 1:33:16on the percentage of activity that they have contributed over
- 1:33:22the last eight blocks Ocean has mined.
- 1:33:25So it's not, it's not a current state, it's looking back for the
- 1:33:28last 8 blocks. How much, how much have you
- 1:33:31helped mine the last eight blocks?
- 1:33:36And so Ocean provides that. So me as a template creator, I
- 1:33:39get that. And I said, OK, this is the
- 1:33:41split. I have to put that information
- 1:33:44into the Coinbase transaction in the appropriate percentages.
- 1:33:49Then I can pick whatever transactions I want and I start
- 1:33:54hashing. If I think I have solved the
- 1:33:57block, I notify the pool, say I got it, they verify that I have
- 1:34:06adequately represented the the splits and then it gets
- 1:34:13presented to the network. So, and by the way, that's
- 1:34:18happening in like milliseconds, right?
- 1:34:20I mean, that's very a very quick process.
- 1:34:23So did that answer the question, Michael?
- 1:34:27Yes, I guess just a template of what's like what's what
- 1:34:33transactions are being filled. Is that by the person that found
- 1:34:36it and or is it just their purport they do the full
- 1:34:39template or they just do a proportion of like the hash that
- 1:34:42they provided and then everybody else that's participated is
- 1:34:44putting their proportion of the the transaction in that block?
- 1:34:49So, OK, so ocean, ocean. So a block just got mined.
- 1:34:53Let's just pretend, OK, block just got mined.
- 1:34:56Ocean's gonna snapshot then, Then the and and count up all of
- 1:35:04the work contributed by companies attached to its pool
- 1:35:10over the last eight blocks. And it will then come up with
- 1:35:15those percentages. Michael is 3% of Ocean.
- 1:35:18Jesse is a half a percent. Jackson's 4%.
- 1:35:22Bob's a 10th of a percent. Whatever those numbers are.
- 1:35:25OK, I must, if I'm going to create my own template, I must
- 1:35:30use those figures provided by Ocean.
- 1:35:36And so those percentages. So when I, if I solve a block,
- 1:35:41so we're hashing now I, I pick whatever transactions I want,
- 1:35:45including, by the way, I can fill the whole freaking thing
- 1:35:47with spam, even as as anti spam, you know, as ocean is, ocean
- 1:35:54will not reject anything as long as it's as long as it's a valid
- 1:36:00block, they will let me do whatever the hell I want.
- 1:36:03The caveat is I must have divided up the share of that
- 1:36:09block appropriately with all of my fellow pool members.
- 1:36:12Is that is that? Yep, that makes sense.
- 1:36:18OK. Yeah, yeah, well, Bob, I I do
- 1:36:22have to run the. The unfortunate thing is there's
- 1:36:26so much to unpack just with the work that you're doing if ocean
- 1:36:31barefoot chaos. I mean, there's, there's so much
- 1:36:34going on, so I'd love to just give a hand off to you as where
- 1:36:40people could just find more about the various projects you
- 1:36:43have and the best way to get in touch if, if they want to learn
- 1:36:47more, get connected with you directly.
- 1:36:49Yeah, thank you. So I'm on Twitter at Boomer
- 1:36:53under score BTC. So I guess that kind of is a a
- 1:36:56focal point for for all this stuff.
- 1:37:00Barefoot is at barefootmining.com,
- 1:37:03blockspaces.com. We didn't talk about it, but I
- 1:37:05have this block space forwards project that is coming along
- 1:37:08very well and it essentially is a way of selling future access
- 1:37:16to block space. And you know we view block space
- 1:37:20as a commodity that will be traded just like any other
- 1:37:23commodity, just like corn or apples.
- 1:37:29So you can see that there. Look for announcements coming
- 1:37:34soon from a project I have called M Fivers, where we have a
- 1:37:39top notch team developing our own ASIC, really an ASIC of the
- 1:37:42chip, like we're really designing our own.
- 1:37:46And we think we're doing some really innovative and creative
- 1:37:49things that will move the industry forward to new levels
- 1:37:55of efficiency. And more importantly, you could
- 1:37:57think of this as more of an Intel like company.
- 1:38:00Our desire is just to make chips, not to make systems.
- 1:38:04I, I believe that we're going to have a much healthier Bitcoin
- 1:38:09network if people can buy chips and anybody can design a system,
- 1:38:15any system they want based on our chips, much like anybody can
- 1:38:19buy a, an Intel CPU and build their own computer.
- 1:38:24And what am I missing? Oh, and then chaos, you can
- 1:38:30check out chaosengine.com for some of the random number stuff
- 1:38:35or digital horoscope dot AI. Those are, those are both like I
- 1:38:39sort of call them live betas right now.
- 1:38:42They're not finished products. So if, if something's a little
- 1:38:45buggy or a little funky, don't get upset with us yet.
- 1:38:49But we, we, we do encourage feedback.
- 1:38:53So if anybody sees it and wants to tell us how to do something
- 1:38:57better or add a feature or whatever, we we would, we would
- 1:39:00love to hear about it. Thanks so much for joining.
- 1:39:04Bob, this is, this was fantastic.
- 1:39:05We got to figure out how to do it on a, you know, quarterly or
- 1:39:08biennially cadence because there's a lot to unpack and
- 1:39:11it's, it was great. Well, thank you guys.
- 1:39:14Always a pleasure to talk to you, really.
- 1:39:16Cool. Thanks, Bob.
- 1:39:17Stay safe with the hurricane. Thank you.
- 1:39:19Will do. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:39:22week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:39:24valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:39:27rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:39:29All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:39:31notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:39:34reminder that on Ramp Media is for informational and
- 1:39:36entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:39:39investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:39:42your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:39:45Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:39:49one of our private Client advisors.