Latest / Consumerpedia / 72 - Finding a Real Estate Agent That's Right for You
Transcript
- 0:02Attention home buyers and sellers.
- 0:04Most real estate agents in the country are now doing business
- 0:06differently than they have in the past.
- 0:09In a nutshell, the way brokers are compensated has changed,
- 0:12making the true cost of residential real estate
- 0:14transactions more transparent and competitive.
- 0:18As a result, it's going to be confusing for brokers, buyers
- 0:21and sellers for a while until everyone understands the new
- 0:24rules. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 0:26Man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:30Welcome to Consumerpedia at checkbook.org.
- 0:33We're the nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid
- 0:36trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:39advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:42can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:46objective. Now here's the host of
- 0:48Consumerpedia America's consumer expert, the consumer man Herb
- 0:52Weisspaum. In this episode, a look at the
- 0:55new rules regarding real estate commissions, why they changed,
- 0:58and what it will mean to both buyers and sellers.
- 1:01Also, things everyone should know when you're hiring a real
- 1:04estate agent. We have two great guests to talk
- 1:07about this. Steve Robeck is a senior fellow
- 1:10at the Consumer Federation of America.
- 1:12He studied this issue for years and written numerous papers on
- 1:15the subject. Good to join you here.
- 1:17And Elise Clink, an expert on real estate and personal finance
- 1:20advice based in Chicago. Elise is an award-winning
- 1:22columnist and Blogger, talk show host and best selling book
- 1:25author, and an old friend. You can find
- 1:27heronline@thinkglink.com. Hey, it's nice to be here.
- 1:31So the changes we're talking about in this episode resulted
- 1:34from a class action lawsuit against the National Association
- 1:37of Realtors. As part of the settlement in
- 1:39this case, the NA are agreed that it's 1.5 million members
- 1:43would follow a new set of rules that governs how they get paid
- 1:46and who pays them when a house is sold.
- 1:48So, Steve, let's start with a little refresher course.
- 1:51How did things work before the new rules took effect?
- 1:54Well Herb, in the old system sellers compensated both their
- 1:57own agent and the buyers agent. So to list the property and the
- 2:01local MLS, sellers had to offer to pay the compensation of the
- 2:06buyer agent. The total compensation was
- 2:08usually 5 to 6% of the final sale price.
- 2:12Now on the other hand, most buyers didn't even sign a
- 2:15contract with their agent. If they ask about the agent's
- 2:19compensation, and I don't think most of them did, they were told
- 2:22the seller would pay it. So let's do the math.
- 2:24If I sold my house for $500,000 and I'd agreed to pay my agent a
- 2:286% Commission, I would owe $30,000 and my agent would split
- 2:32that with the buyer's agent. Well, that's correct.
- 2:34So why was that a problem? Do you believe that raised the
- 2:37prices? Buyers paid several.
- 2:38Problems. Most importantly, it allowed the
- 2:40industry to fix prices. Buyer agent compensation
- 2:44couldn't really be negotiated and that's a key reason that the
- 2:47rates are so high, 5 to 6% compared to 3/2, even 1 1/2% in
- 2:53most of Europe. Also, these rates for little
- 2:57relationship to the quality of the service that consumers
- 3:00received because all agents regardless of their confidence
- 3:04experience charge the same percentage and also all agents
- 3:08charge the same percentage regardless of the work that they
- 3:11did. A buyer agent that showed 20
- 3:13houses was paid basically the same Commission that a buyer
- 3:18agent who showed only one house. So buyer's agents use what are
- 3:21called multiple listing services or MLS's to find homes for sale.
- 3:25And under the new rules, National Association of Realtor
- 3:28members selling agents will no longer be able to advertise
- 3:31their Commission on listings. Elise, how is that going to make
- 3:34a difference and change things, hopefully for the better?
- 3:36Well, you know, the settlement is kind of interesting, Herb.
- 3:39You know, it was $418 million agreement that said brokers are
- 3:44not negotiating. They're supposed to negotiate
- 3:47all commissions. As I've written about in my many
- 3:49books, all commissions are negotiable, but they weren't
- 3:52negotiating it to Steve's point, things were more or less fixed
- 3:56or for some agents in some places they were fixed.
- 4:00The new rules are that the buyers must enter into a written
- 4:05agreement that guarantees how much they're going to compensate
- 4:08the agent ahead of time. And the seller continues to go
- 4:12into a listing agreement and they're supposed to now only be
- 4:15responsible for the half of the Commission that their seller's
- 4:18agent wants. So on the face of it, you think
- 4:21to yourself, well, it's the same amount of money.
- 4:23If the buyer's agent signs an agreement with the buyer and
- 4:26says you'll pay me two, two and a half, 3%, and the seller's
- 4:30agent signs an agreement that says you're going to pay the
- 4:32seller's agent two, 2, 1/2 or 3%.
- 4:35My perspective, which is probably a little different from
- 4:37Steve's, is in the real world, nothing is going to change.
- 4:41You're still going to end up paying between 5 and 6%.
- 4:44And since all the money came from the buyer anyway, it's just
- 4:47apportioned a little bit differently.
- 4:49So the fact that sellers, agents can't put in the multiple
- 4:52listing service, how they're going to share that Commission.
- 4:55Sellers don't have to force agents to do it.
- 4:58Buyers agents can now ask if they will be willing to share
- 5:02the Commission. I I guess in my real world
- 5:04perspective, I don't know how anything's going to change.
- 5:07Well, let let me provide a little different perspective on
- 5:10that. For the first time, buyers can
- 5:12really effectively negotiate down the Commission and they
- 5:15will be discouraged by buyer agents from doing so.
- 5:19The buyer agent will say, look, you don't have to worry about
- 5:21that. The seller will still pay.
- 5:23But if the buyers negotiate down the Commission, that would then
- 5:27allow them to negotiate on the sale price because the seller
- 5:31will have to pay the buyer agent less money.
- 5:34Everybody agrees that there's going to be no radical change in
- 5:37the near future, but many people, perhaps most, think that
- 5:41there will be slow changes over time.
- 5:43For the past several years, I've predicted that the rates would
- 5:46come down from an average of 5 to 6% eventually to three to 4%
- 5:51with much greater variation in the three to 4% with the really
- 5:55competent successful agents being able to charge more than
- 5:59the less experienced agents. And you can see this actually in
- 6:03New York City outside of a certain areas dominated by one
- 6:07of the many MLSS in New York City, the average rates are
- 6:11three to 4%. The thing is, Steve, and, and I
- 6:14know you've probably thought about this, I don't know any
- 6:16sellers who are willing to negotiate down even if they only
- 6:20have to pay 3% Commission or 2 1/2 percent Commission, which is
- 6:25kind of what they were responsible for anyway.
- 6:27In their minds. Sellers say, wow, I just
- 6:31pocketed that extra 3% and why would I negotiate it?
- 6:34On the buyer's side, you're now responsible for a Commission
- 6:37that you have to come up with out of pocket unless you can
- 6:41figure out a way to find finance it, which of course you and I
- 6:44will both agree, financing commissions is never a great
- 6:47idea. And so when buyers are really
- 6:49struggling to come up with down payments anyway, there's no
- 6:51guarantee the seller is going to come down on the purchase price
- 6:54simply because they're paying less in Commission.
- 6:56So I guess I'm unclear, maybe in the long run this will all sort
- 7:00out where buyers pay a little bit less and sellers pay a
- 7:03little bit less. But I don't know.
- 7:05As a person who's now selling a condo, I can just tell you in
- 7:08the real world, nothing has changed.
- 7:11Well, look, it's going to take a while for things to change and
- 7:14it's going to be more important for buyers now to use a really
- 7:17experienced buyer agent because if they can negotiate down, the
- 7:21buyers can negotiate down the buyer agent Commission, say 3 to
- 7:242%. A good buyer agent should be
- 7:28able to negotiate down the sale price and that will be a savings
- 7:31to them. In addition, as a result of all
- 7:34of this publicity and news coverage, sellers are now more
- 7:38aware that they can negotiate down the listing agents
- 7:42committee. We think that's going to come
- 7:44down too from the half to a full percentage point eventually.
- 7:48So we really stick by our prediction that eventually and
- 7:52it may take several years, the average commissions will come
- 7:55down by at least 1%, but probably closer to 2%.
- 8:00So we've had discount agency in the real estate world for quite
- 8:03a while now, at least 20 years. And there are companies out
- 8:07there like Redfin that charge, you know, one and three quarter
- 8:10percent. There were other kinds of
- 8:12companies that piecemeal the work that they would do for
- 8:15buyers and sellers. And at the end of the day, it's
- 8:17a complicated, perhaps overcomplicated process.
- 8:21You and I might agree on that, where buyers and sellers end up
- 8:24turning to people that they think are smart and competent.
- 8:27But when you go to the very best agents and the ones who are
- 8:30busiest, they're the ones who are least likely to say, yeah,
- 8:34I'll only charge you 2%, not 3%, because they feel like their
- 8:37time is worth whatever it is. And sometimes those agents are
- 8:41so successful because they do put so much into a deal.
- 8:45My mother was a top selling real estate agent in Chicago for
- 8:48many, many years. And she would say that, you
- 8:51know, over the face of it, if you do 30-40, fifty deals a
- 8:55year, which she was at that level, you know, there's maybe a
- 8:58handful, two or three that it's one offer.
- 9:01They fall in love with the first thing and then they do it and
- 9:04they close on that deal. Most of the deals, though, take
- 9:07a whole lot of time and effort and energy and there's extra
- 9:11expenses that go in that I don't think that buyers and sellers
- 9:14fully appreciate until they're in the process.
- 9:17And the expenses come for new technology.
- 9:20Like if you're going to stage virtually an apartment, for
- 9:23example, or a unit or a house, you know, somebody has to be
- 9:26paid for that technology. So I, I do think that there are
- 9:29complications and to the industry these days that the
- 9:33very best agents, I don't see them negotiating on price.
- 9:36It would be nice if they did. And I do think it's great that
- 9:39people are more aware that commissions are negotiable, but
- 9:43I'm not sure that that's going to work in all cases.
- 9:45Well, we agree that the best agents probably won't have to
- 9:48lower their Commission at all, but most agents are not
- 9:51experienced. Most of them are part time
- 9:53agents. I mean, the real marginal agents
- 9:55drain 25 to 30% of all the Commission income, so they are
- 10:00not going to be able to charge 3%.
- 10:02But to the whole issue of the discounters, the discounters
- 10:05have only a small portion of the market because they're
- 10:08discriminated against by the traditional agents.
- 10:11Take Redfin. Redfin with a lot of enthusiasm
- 10:14entered the marketplace nearly 15 years ago and was wanted to
- 10:17charge 2 1/2 or 3%. They could not make a go of it
- 10:21at that rate because the buyer agents would not show their
- 10:26properties. They had to compromise and offer
- 10:29a full 2 1/2 to 3% to the buyer agents.
- 10:32That's going to start to change now.
- 10:34I think one of the long term impacts of the settlement is
- 10:38going to be that it's going to empower the discount agents.
- 10:41You're going to see a lot more variation in the marketplace,
- 10:45particularly in compensation. You talked about all the
- 10:48different variables in terms of compensation.
- 10:50The price is eventually going to reflect those variables, the
- 10:54amount of effort that the agent put in, the confidence of the
- 10:57agent. So I think we can all agree that
- 10:59we'll see what happens down the road because there's a good
- 11:02chance that something will happen or nothing will happen
- 11:04and we'll do another podcast in two years and and figure it out.
- 11:06See, there are some who have warned that these changes are
- 11:08going to have a negative impact on the real estate market.
- 11:11Do you think it will? What do you mean by by negative
- 11:13impact? Certainly it's taking the
- 11:15industry a while to adjust to the changes.
- 11:19I just saw a headline in one of the industry trade press that
- 11:23used the term mass confusion. And one of the problems is that
- 11:27some of the agents are not willing to change.
- 11:30They're insisting buyer agents are insisting that listing
- 11:34agents guarantee a certain percentage, two and a half, 3%
- 11:38Commission, whereas much if not most of the industry is rolling
- 11:42with the punches and trying to adjust to the intent and the
- 11:48letter of the new rules and the desires and demands of the
- 11:53Department of Justice. So how is all this going to
- 11:56change things when I go looking for a real estate professional
- 11:58to sell my house or to help me find a new house?
- 12:00We're going to dig into that next.
- 12:02I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer man, and this is Consumerpedia,
- 12:05powered by checkbook.org. If you like what you hear, we
- 12:10hope you'll consider being a consumer PDS supporter by using
- 12:13the link at the bottom of the show notes to make a small
- 12:15contribution each month. This is consumer pedia.
- 12:20The new way of doing business created by the Commission rules
- 12:23will change the relationship in some ways between a seller and
- 12:26their agent, and this will mean disclosures and paperwork to
- 12:29sign. Elise, what is supposed to
- 12:31happen under these new rules? Well, the buyer's agent is
- 12:34supposed to present a disclosure and a contract basically to
- 12:38buyers that says, hey, I'm your buyer's agent, I owe you a
- 12:42fiduciary responsibility. That means I'm on your side.
- 12:46I'm paraphrasing here. This is not legal jargon.
- 12:48And for these things that I'm to do for you, you're going to owe
- 12:51me X and you guarantee that you will pay it or if the seller
- 12:56will not is basically what it says.
- 12:58On the seller side, they're already getting a listing
- 13:01agreement where the agent will put down the the list price and
- 13:04talk about all the different services they'll provide and the
- 13:07Commission. One of the dangers in this whole
- 13:10new scenario is that a seller might get tricked into signing a
- 13:15listing agreement that says they'll pay 6%, assuming that
- 13:19half of that is going to go over to the agent, whatever that
- 13:22number is, where the buyer is also signing an agreement
- 13:26agreeing that they will pay 2 1/2%.
- 13:28And I could imagine some scenarios where the total
- 13:31Commission is now 6 or 7 or 8% as opposed to something a little
- 13:36bit less. But the disclosure forms are the
- 13:38things that both the buyer and the seller now are going to be
- 13:41required to sign. Does it anywhere in this
- 13:44paperwork say, and these Commission rates are completely
- 13:47negotiable? Our consumers told this upfront
- 13:49in this document. Well, that's actually one
- 13:51exception to our criticism. Almost all the contracts that
- 13:55we've looked at, yes, in bold print or large print, say that
- 14:00this, the Commission, is negotiable.
- 14:02That's good. That's very good.
- 14:04Unfortunately, most of the contracts are not easily
- 14:08understandable. The law professor who worked
- 14:10with us in her analysis of the California forms, at least the
- 14:14early draft, said she could not understand parts of those
- 14:18contracts. This is a a law professor who
- 14:21teaches contracts couldn't understand them, so there's a
- 14:25lot of progress that needs to be made there.
- 14:27So, Elise, the president of the National Association of
- 14:30Realtors, Kevin Sears, said he is, quote, confident that his
- 14:33members are ready to embrace this evolution in the real
- 14:36estate industry. Do you think they are?
- 14:38I think that everybody wants them to be.
- 14:41I think that in the real world where we all Live Today, there's
- 14:44just a lot of confusion. I keep hearing and getting
- 14:47letters, emails from people who are, you know, buyers and
- 14:50sellers confused about what they have to sign.
- 14:52To Stevens Point, the contracts are opaque, difficult to parse.
- 14:56I'm married to a real estate attorney, and even when we were
- 15:00listing a condo recently, it was complicated.
- 15:03He understands and he does it every day.
- 15:04But I read it and I thought, I'm not quite sure what this says.
- 15:08And so when we guide buyers and sellers all over the country, we
- 15:11have to be very careful, you know, in saying ask questions,
- 15:15make sure you really understand what it is you're being asked to
- 15:19do and what you're on the hook for.
- 15:21If you don't understand that, then you could end up on the
- 15:24wrong side of things. Steve, what do you think?
- 15:26One of the issues that's going to come up when buyers are asked
- 15:30to sign these contracts that they don't understand and when
- 15:34it's explained to them that they are obligated to compensate
- 15:38their agent, despite any assurances the seller will pay,
- 15:41they're not going to do business with that agent, especially if
- 15:44the contract is not understandable.
- 15:47We've told the industry if they don't clean up those contracts,
- 15:50many buyers are not going to use buyer agents.
- 15:53And our whole system is going to evolve toward the British
- 15:57system. But there's essentially 1
- 15:59facilitator and the charges at the last survey, I saw 1.2%, not
- 16:055 .55 point 6%, which is the current charge in the US.
- 16:10So there's still some huge challenges that face the
- 16:14industry in particular, but also regulators and consumers.
- 16:18We are in the middle of change and there's a lot of confusion
- 16:22and there's a lot of resistance as well as acceptance of the new
- 16:25rules. Well, my fear is that people was
- 16:28they get handed this paperwork, are just going to sign it even
- 16:30though they don't understand it and they're just going to sign
- 16:33it. Well, The thing is, the agents
- 16:34are going to have to raise the issue of compensation and then
- 16:37they're going to take it more seriously than most consumers
- 16:40take contracts. You know, it's interesting, One
- 16:43of the things that came up in the condo we just listed was
- 16:46that the listing agent who we picked specifically for this
- 16:50offered us less than 6% and said that any excess money that comes
- 16:56in, if the buyer is going to just separately compensate the
- 16:58buyer's agent that they will return to us and reduce the
- 17:02Commission down to about, you know, whatever it was half of
- 17:05that. So 2 1/2%.
- 17:07And I think what is new and different is that that
- 17:10conversation happened before we signed the listing agreement.
- 17:13You know, Elise, that the experience you had with your
- 17:16listing agent who offered essentially a concession
- 17:18wouldn't have occurred in most cases three or four years ago.
- 17:22We did research and I was pretending that I was a home
- 17:26seller and contacted and had fairly long conversations with
- 17:29some 200 listing agents. About 3/4 of those listing
- 17:33agents said they would not negotiate the Commission at all.
- 17:37I think one of the impacts and it's going to take time to occur
- 17:42as a result of the settlement is that an increasing number of
- 17:45listing agents are going to be prepared to negotiate down the
- 17:49listing agreement, particularly in a dual agency situation.
- 17:53Before we leave this topic, two things to just recap.
- 17:56First of all, they're going to be a lot of confusing documents
- 17:59used. And the other thing, getting
- 18:01back, Steven, to that university, University of
- 18:02Buffalo professor, the law professor who studied some of
- 18:05the agreements out there, I read her paper and spoke to her.
- 18:07She concluded that some agents are already coming up with
- 18:10workarounds to go around the rules that are in place.
- 18:13So who's going to enforce this? I know the US Justice Department
- 18:16is said to have launched a formal inquiry into the
- 18:18California Association of Realtors contracts.
- 18:20Is it going to be up to the DOJ and maybe state attorney
- 18:23generals or maybe class action lawsuits to make sure that the
- 18:26agents follow the new rules? Well, the ML S S will actually
- 18:30have some responsibility, but really it's going to be up to
- 18:34the Department of Justice, but more importantly to private
- 18:38attorneys. Unfortunately, a lot of
- 18:40attorneys now, trial lawyers are sort of, you know, smell blood
- 18:43in the water. And they're going to be much
- 18:46more interested and willing to litigate in the future than they
- 18:49have been in the past. Up next, we're going to talk
- 18:51about how to hire a real estate professional, whether you're
- 18:54buying or selling. I'm Herb Weisbaum, and this is
- 18:57Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 19:01Consumer Pedia Fast Facts Slightly more than 4 million
- 19:05existing homes were sold in the US in 2023, according to the
- 19:09National Association of Realtors.
- 19:11That's down from 6.1 million in 2021.
- 19:15America continues to have a housing shortage.
- 19:18For more than a decade, population growth has exceeded
- 19:21the number of new homes built. In 2020, three 1.4 million new
- 19:25houses were built in the US, according to Statista.
- 19:29That's a nine percent decrease from 20, 22.
- 19:32The most expensive property sold in 2023 was the gigantic Bluff
- 19:36Top Complex on top of Paradise Cover in Malibu.
- 19:39It sold for more than $190 million in cash.
- 19:43The buyers? Beyoncé and Jay-Z.
- 19:46According to the Rob Report, it's the most paid for a home in
- 19:49California and the second priciest ever recorded
- 19:52nationwide. Steve, you recently wrote that
- 19:57the new rules provide both opportunities and risks for
- 20:00consumers. Your quote?
- 20:01Knowledgeable home buyers and sellers will be able to take
- 20:04advantage of the opportunities and avoid the risks.
- 20:07So let's make sure our listeners know what to do.
- 20:09The Consumer Federation of America has three suggestions to
- 20:12home sellers and home buyers about how to deal with a new
- 20:15residential real estate marketplace.
- 20:17Your first suggestion, Selecting a competent, honest agent is
- 20:20more important than ever, especially for buyers.
- 20:23It's the same rule, really, for selecting an auto mechanic.
- 20:26You won't know whether your car needs a new transmission or not.
- 20:29You have to have a mechanic who you trust and who's competent.
- 20:32Same thing for an agent. Now we know, according to
- 20:36industry studies, that a large percentage of this, nearly 2
- 20:40million agents are marginally competent.
- 20:43Some, according to the industry source, are even dishonest.
- 20:46So it's really important in this marketplace, it's become more
- 20:50complicated, particularly for buyers to find a competent
- 20:54agent. First of all, look for the
- 20:56brokers or associate brokers. They will almost always have
- 20:59more experience and more training than just an ordinary
- 21:02agent. Secondly, you can use the
- 21:05portals, the Zillow, realtor.com on homes.com to get information
- 21:11on agents that you are investigating.
- 21:13In particular, look at whether they're active and they've sold
- 21:17properties and also whether they've received favorable
- 21:20reviews from clients. So, you know, we have to be
- 21:23aware that most of those reviews were prompted by the agents
- 21:27themselves. And then perhaps just as
- 21:29important is, and this is a test as to whether the agent is going
- 21:33to level with you, asked to see the contract forms right up
- 21:37front and asked him about the compensation.
- 21:39Elise, you have any thoughts on that tip?
- 21:41It's really about years in business, how many homes they're
- 21:44representing. If you're looking in the suburbs
- 21:47for a single family house with a big backyard, you know, and the
- 21:50agent is only working in whatever city you're in and
- 21:53condos that are $500,000 more than you can spend, it's
- 21:57probably not a good match. You want somebody who's not only
- 22:00honest, which you're never going to really know until you're in
- 22:03the thick of it, but somebody who matches up with what you're
- 22:06actually looking to spend. And then you want to get into a
- 22:09relationship where you really feel like you're understanding
- 22:12what they're saying. Because to Steve's point, if
- 22:14there's a lot of gibberish going over your head, you're never
- 22:17going to get a straight answer and and really feel like you
- 22:20understand what you're signing. So before we move along to tip
- 22:222, how do you start the process? You know, we often recommend
- 22:25that if you're looking for a professional, you ask your
- 22:28neighbors who they used. Should you ask your neighbors
- 22:30who recently bought or sold a house?
- 22:32How do you like the person you use?
- 22:33You know, in my book, I recommend that people talk to at
- 22:36least three different agents from three different companies.
- 22:39All of the companies are going to have a different perspective
- 22:42and how they deal with you. And you'll get a sense from
- 22:44talking to a few people about the differences in behavior, the
- 22:48differences in the way that they handle sales or purchases.
- 22:52And yes, sure, of course ask friends and family members who
- 22:55they use. And to your point, very
- 22:57important thing to ask how was your experience?
- 23:01Because if somebody said it was just a meth, that isn't somebody
- 23:04that you want to work with. And yeah, so suggestion #2 from
- 23:08the Consumer Federation of America is read and evaluate
- 23:11buyer or seller contracts, often called agreements, especially
- 23:15blanks that are filled in. Well, a large number of the new
- 23:18contracts have been written by the industry.
- 23:21They're very difficult, if not impossible to understand and
- 23:24they contain anti consumer provisions.
- 23:26So that's why it's so important to right up front when you
- 23:30interview the agent to ask to see the contract that they use
- 23:35and try to discuss it with them. If they won't discuss it with
- 23:37you, you should not use that agent.
- 23:39And if you don't understand it, maybe they can help you.
- 23:42You know, most of the successful agents and brokers you know are
- 23:46honest and they're competent and you know by talking to them
- 23:49you'll get a sense as to whether they in fact are.
- 23:51But if you do not understand the contract and you can't get
- 23:55straight answers from the agent, do not not use that agent.
- 23:58Go find somebody else. Even if you can't understand the
- 24:01contracts, there's some red flags.
- 24:03If, for example, they're insisting on a mandatory
- 24:06arbitration, I'd be leery about signing that contract because
- 24:10that basically says you can't go to court.
- 24:12Essentially, practically, you can't go to court if you have a
- 24:15serious problem with the purchase or with the agent.
- 24:18Another red flag is if they ask you to approve dual agency in
- 24:22advance. So you're a seller, you're
- 24:25signing the contract with a listing agent, and the listing
- 24:29agent says, OK, if I find a buyer, you have to basically let
- 24:33me work as a dual agent. You lose your fiduciary
- 24:36representation. You want a fiduciary
- 24:39representative if you have an agent in a sale.
- 24:42And when a listing agent insists upon giving up that fiduciary
- 24:47relationship to you if they find a buyer, that's another red
- 24:50flag. Yeah, I agree with everything
- 24:52Steve has said. You know, again, a lot of places
- 24:55around the country do not not use real estate attorneys to
- 24:58help close deals. Midwest, upper Midwest, in the
- 25:02Northeast, they do. And again, married to a real
- 25:04estate attorney. So I say that up front.
- 25:06But I do think it's very helpful to have somebody you can call
- 25:11and say, can you please explain what this means?
- 25:14And anytime you're discouraged from seeking legal advice, I
- 25:18think it's a bad thing. And I it doesn't help clarify
- 25:21the situation. But Steve is exactly right.
- 25:24Ask the questions. Keep asking until you feel like
- 25:28you understand the answer well enough to be able to turn around
- 25:31and explain it to a 10 year old. Steve, I want to ask you about
- 25:34one specific tip you had in this section.
- 25:36I actually read your whole release.
- 25:37Some buyer agents will press buyers to sign this commitment
- 25:40before showing them a property, and a few dishonest listing
- 25:43agents at open houses may try to do so.
- 25:45Also. Increasingly, buyers agents will
- 25:48offer buyers the opportunity to sign touring agreements that do
- 25:51not require a financial commitment.
- 25:53Go through that a little bit if you would.
- 25:54Well, this is part of a new rule, the initiative, by the
- 25:58way, not of CFA or the Department of Justice, but the
- 26:01industry's own initiative. The timing of the signing of the
- 26:05buyer agent agreement is really controversial.
- 26:08And the industry has said that it's got to be signed before an
- 26:13agent shows you a house. And I've had many conversations
- 26:16with brokers about this say, look, that's too early.
- 26:19Essentially, when an agent shows you a house, they're auditioning
- 26:23for the job of being your fiduciary agent.
- 26:26So what Zillow did was, and they started talking to me about this
- 26:29over a year ago. They developed trade agreements
- 26:32which essentially you can sign and there for a very short
- 26:36period of time, maybe for one house, maybe for for one day,
- 26:39and they shouldn't be for any more than a week.
- 26:41You should feel free to sign those.
- 26:43And the only obligation that you'll have is if you're shown
- 26:47that house and you end up buying it through another agent, the
- 26:51first agent's going to come back and understandably ask for some
- 26:55compensation. OK, and finally, suggestion #3
- 26:59on finding a good real estate professional.
- 27:01Discuss and negotiate commissions and any other
- 27:04agreement. Compensation in dollar amounts,
- 27:07not percentages. Steve.
- 27:08No. You know, all of the litigation
- 27:10and brouhaha is essentially about fixed 5 to 6% rates.
- 27:14The good thing about the settlement, despite all of its
- 27:17imperfections, it really does not represent total uncoupling
- 27:21of the listing nation biology commissions.
- 27:23It's a partial uncoupling, but there are opportunities there
- 27:26and the big opportunity now is for the buyers to negotiate down
- 27:30the commission's. But what's critical is that you
- 27:33think about the compensation and you talk about the compensation
- 27:38in terms of dollars, not percentages.
- 27:40One of the reasons that I believe the industry's been able
- 27:43to charge 5 to 6% is 5 to 6% doesn't sound like very much.
- 27:48On the other hand, use the example earlier, $30,000 in
- 27:52Commission. That sounds like a lot.
- 27:54We think that if buyers and sellers start clunking to the
- 27:57agents in terms of dollars, not percentages, the agents will be
- 28:02more willing to negotiate and perhaps reduce their prices.
- 28:06I can't imagine anybody saying I'm willing to pay you 25,000
- 28:10but not 26 five. I just don't see that as being a
- 28:13way that people negotiate. I don't think buyers and sellers
- 28:16are comfortable with that. I think that's another reason
- 28:18why the percentages have been so strong.
- 28:21Also, there's this question. It's not the difference of
- 28:23buying a $200,000 house and $1,000,000 house where that
- 28:28percentage is going to be a very big thing.
- 28:30If you say, well, I'll pay you $5000, you know, if you help me
- 28:33buy a $200,000 house, OK, maybe that works, maybe it doesn't.
- 28:37But to say that for $1,000,000 house certainly wouldn't.
- 28:40There's just a different level that goes into that same thing
- 28:43on the seller's side. You know, when you start to
- 28:46unpack what seller's agents actually do, I do think that
- 28:50seller's agents should be willing to take a lot less
- 28:52unless they actually go to the house and do showings.
- 28:56A lot of times they just put lock boxes on and they let the
- 28:59buyer's agent go in and unlock the house and go through the
- 29:01house and turn on the lights and show the property.
- 29:04My feeling is your seller's agent isn't actually worth the
- 29:07money or very much of the money if that's how they're going to
- 29:09handle it. For me, it's a question of what
- 29:11are the services that are being provided and how do you make
- 29:14that work over a period of time in a very hot market where homes
- 29:18are staying on the market for maybe 20 minutes versus 6 to 9
- 29:23months. The amount of money that people
- 29:25are getting for that as as an agent would vary based on the
- 29:29time and the temperature, let's say, of the marketplace.
- 29:31So a lot of things have to go into consideration, I think,
- 29:36before you start having a real conversation about what
- 29:39compensation is appropriate. Well, you know, I think that if
- 29:42people start thinking and talking about this in terms of
- 29:45dollars, it's going to effectively change the whole
- 29:49marketplace culture. And we're talking about
- 29:51potentially very large sums of money here.
- 29:53You know, you bring the percentage down from 3 to 2%,
- 29:57you could easily save $5000 on a more expensive home, $10,000.
- 30:01So, and not everybody's going to do this, but to the extent that
- 30:05a significant minority and particularly people who are
- 30:09influencers do this, I think it's going to actually loosen up
- 30:14the pricing a bit overtime. I agree with Steve 100%, if you
- 30:18don't ask for a discount, you will never get a discount.
- 30:21So you might as well ask and then decide if that's the person
- 30:24you still want to have representing you at full price,
- 30:26or if there's somebody else who might be able to do almost as
- 30:29good a job for you for a little less.
- 30:31Yeah, I think that's good advice.
- 30:33Clearly, a lot of moving parts here and things are sure to
- 30:35change as time goes on. That's why I put a number of
- 30:38links in the show notes to help you dig deeper into all of this.
- 30:41I want to thank our guest, Steve Brobeck, a senior fellow at the
- 30:44Consumer Federation of America. You can find them on the web at
- 30:47consumerfed.org. Thank you, Steve, thank you.
- 30:51And real estate and personal finance expert Elise Glink.
- 30:54You can find her online at Think Glink dot com.
- 30:57It's always a pleasure, herb. Well, that's it for this edition
- 31:00of Consumer Pedia. We hope you'll rate this episode
- 31:03and follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen
- 31:07to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 31:09episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 31:13show is to follow us on Consumer Pedia on Facebook and Instagram
- 31:17and at my Consumer Pedia on Twitter.
- 31:19I'm Herb Weisbaum. Thanks for listening.
- 31:22Consumer Pedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 31:25We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 31:28smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 31:31help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 31:34ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 31:37If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 31:40Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 31:45Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and
- 31:48Washington DC. To get your free 30 day
- 31:51subscription, go to checkbook.org/consumerpedia.
- 31:55If you like what you've heard, we hope you'll become a
- 31:57supporter by using the link at the bottom of the show notes to
- 32:00make a small contribution each month.
- 32:02Consumerpedia. Empowering consumers to save
- 32:05money and make smarter choices.