Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Starboard Puts CarMax on Notice, Carvana Goes Hollywood, Lucid's CarPlay Win
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Thursday, March 12th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. Kyle Mounts here back with me today.
- 0:07Today, we're talking about putting CarMax on notice, Carvana going to Hollywood, and Lucid pushing, uh, some- Everywhere I go...
- 0:14kind of surprise over-the-air updates The people wanna know who I is and who I be But now we know it's possible That's why when they see me It's so wild. It's so wild. Now, now we know what's possible, right?
- 0:22Yes, I love that part of it. It's, it's gonna be so crazy. I'm so jealous that you got to hang out with Jamie Butters- It was awesome... on the show yesterday. Heck yeah. Whatever. California- I'm over that.
- 0:29Whatever, bro. [laughs] You'll get your chance. I'll try to go, and then you can have Jamie Butters as a co-host, and we'll just ask him who he likes more. [laughs] Oh, don't even start with me.
- 0:38Also, this is crazy, but I'm out in, uh, in St. Louis City, Utah, and, uh, I was visiting a dealer group here, and then got to stop by, and I was so mad.
- 0:49Our good friend Alex Lawrence, I just totally forgot that his store was, like, on my way to- Oh, no way... these other stores I was going to. So it's, it's like 10 minutes before closing. I rush into the store.
- 1:00I'm like, "Is Alex here?" He's not there. I'm so bummed. I didn't pre-plan it. So I got a selfie and made him all jealous, but, uh- You got to go... but it was cool to see. Look,
- 1:11one, go to my LinkedIn profile, this Genesis store that I was in yesterday. Oh, man. If you think that auto retail can't have dope- Can't have nice things... experiences, you're wrong.
- 1:19And then right after that, go check out EVauto and check out the dope experiences. Retail environments are here. Wow.
- 1:26I thought, when I saw that picture of the Genesis store, I thought you were posting pictures from the Genesis store we were in in Kazakhstan. No. No. No. But it was- This- It looked amazing.
- 1:35I mean, they got- It was unbelievable... they got a vibe. They got a vibe. Speaking of a vibe, we wanna thank our sponsors of the show today. iPacket, every vehicle was born with an MSRP.
- 1:44That was the manufacturer saying, "Here is the exact vehicle build." So iPacket brings value back to that moment with 100% OEM-verified build data of real options, real packages, the real window sticker.
- 1:57Then you layer in market comps like CPO, geography, model year, and validate the number intelligently because you started at the source. It's how modern dealerships win without racing to the bottom.
- 2:07Visit iPacket.us to learn more. How about that? IPacket.us. Start, start at the beginning. I love the fact- Oh, man... they were saying market comps in auto. It's like- Ah...
- 2:17it took us long enough to say the same thing that, that mortgages do, and we basically... Or that, uh, houses do, and we basically have a same run, you know? So- It, it really very, very much is. For saying it.
- 2:25Hey, we have, uh, an, an upcoming A So 2 Edge webinar on March 25th at 2:00 PM with Scott Trailer and Thuy Adamitis. How do you say her last name? Adam- Adamitis. Adamitis. Adamitis.
- 2:37I thought I said it right yesterday, but I always get jumbled up on that. They're our friends from MIA. We're talking about the three roles that AI should play in your dealership.
- 2:46Uh, they're great friends, so we always have a very lively conversation with them. Uh, you can sign up for the webinar at asotu.com. You can just get it. It's right there above the fold.
- 2:56Put your name, email address in so you can join us and be with us on March 25th at 2:00 PM. Do it now so you don't forget, right? It's two weeks away, so you'll forget. Yeah. Do it now. Also, buy your So 2 Con tickets.
- 3:06Also, buy your So 2 Con hotel because the hotels are already starting to rock and roll. Oh. [laughs] That's the real reason.
- 3:11And, uh, you wanna stay at the place that we're having the event, so- That's, that's the real reason to go... there you go. We're almost 60 days. Once we get inside that 60-day window, it gets- Ooh, it gets feisty...
- 3:19all bets are off. It gets all feisty. I've been spending, I've been spending all week writing handwritten invitations. It's been a lot of fun. I'm so obsessed with that. It's, it's- So obsessed.
- 3:25Hey, man, you're the human at a So 2 Con. You're the human. Like, what else, what else you gonna do? Just print type everything? No. Psh, don't print stuff. You can get it at asotucon.com. Let's get to some news.
- 3:34Activist investor, Starboard Value, that's the name of the activist investor, uh, they're turning up the heat on CarMax's new incoming CEO, arguing the used car giant has plenty of untapped potential, and they've got a $350 million stake to back up their opinion.
- 3:50[laughs] Starboard sent a letter to CEO Keith Barr calling out CarMax for falling short in pushing a streamlined online trade-in process and better digital conversion rates.
- 3:59The firm wants SG&A expenses capped at 70% to 75% of gross profit. They believe modest price cuts- Wow... of $100 to $300 per vehicle paired with real-time data-driven pricing could restore competitiveness.
- 4:12When did they learn so much about auto? Starboard is- They knew a lot about auto, apparently. Yeah. [laughs] I mean, who knew? Or, or they have ChatGPT.
- 4:18Starboard is nominating two board members, including its own CEO, Jeffrey Smith, to the board, signaling this is more than a suggestion.
- 4:25Analysts to truest agree there is room to improve, but warn that gaining ground on Carvana while cutting costs at the same time will not be easy.
- 4:33Morningstar analyst Dave Winston said, "If CarMax gets its flywheel moving again," Starboard talked, like talked, Starboard talked about, "then I think the stock would drastically be higher than it is today."
- 4:44Here's the thing.
- 4:45So what you're telling me is they're trying to solve the same problem that all the retail auto dealers are, that is trying to get life cycle marketing dialed in, where we get trade processes in through the service department, out through sales.
- 4:56I can't imagine being a CarMax where they don't really prioritize the service experience at all, and that is a- Yeah... very, very hard thing to keep that life cycle marketing going.
- 5:04You lose things to independents or to the franchise dealers. Um, but this is a signal, I think, to franchise dealers.
- 5:10It's like, hey, if you're looking at life cycle marketing, if you're trying to figure out how to streamline the on- online trade process, that's what the big players are trying to do as well.
- 5:18It is interesting to me that kind of a non-auto, uh, you know, personnel, uh, feels like they have a whole bunch to say about the pricing matrix and, and what the SG&A, uh, can be.
- 5:30Um, but the, the, the reality is, is Carvana is just picking up steam like crazy and CarMax has been a bit flatter down, and so they gotta do something.
- 5:38I mean, they think one, one to $300 per vehicle is gonna make a big difference. I don't know. I guess that's like- Maybe it will. You mean... I don't know. I don't think price sells cars. I think value sells cars. Oh.
- 5:50[laughs] Oh. Call us. Got 'em. Call us. Yeah. [laughs] Call your boys. Call your boys. We'll help you out.
- 5:55Uh, Carvana is taking the same-day delivery service to now the city of Los Angeles, and if you thought they were already moving fast, LA's about to find out what that really means.
- 6:04Carvana rolled out same-day veli- vehicle delivery service to the Los Angeles Metro area, letting eligible customers go from online checkout to driveway delivery in a matter of hours.
- 6:15Customers looking to sell can also get same-day pickup-Or drop off after completing their online appraisal, making the whole transaction, buy or sell, or both, happen in the same day. Wow.
- 6:26LA joins Sacramento, San Diego, Sacramento and San Diego, making California one of the most saturated same-day markets, with Carvana now operating service across 20 states nationwide with the same-day service.
- 6:38Senior director Jacqueline Hearns said, "The combination of our deep local infrastructure and growing logistics network allows us to go from online checkout to driveway delivery in hours."
- 6:48So, um, they're really turning up the heat there.
- 6:50When we had Patrick Abad on a couple weeks ago on your birthday, he was talking about all the things that we can learn from a Carvana, and all the things that digitally we've learned, the, the i- ideas around omni-channel.
- 7:00And this, uh, this is actually gonna be a consumer learning that's gonna happen.
- 7:04As they get market saturation, they're in 20 big cities, so you think about the number of people that have the opportunity to have this experience. It changes the level of expectation, right?
- 7:13We have these moments in any retail environment where the level of expectation just shifts, right? It's like table stakes go up, right?
- 7:21I, I remember back in the early 2010s when everyone was starting to do powertrain warranties for life. Well, well, now it's kinda like table stakes, right? There's all these table stakes things.
- 7:29The table stakes will be, how fast can I get that vehicle to my driveway and not have to leave my couch? And there won't be 100% of people that wanna do that.
- 7:38Uh, but you'll have a l- a growing ecosystem that kinda make that as a demand of expectation. So that's the note, is are you developing and planning toward this end for the subset of customers that you need to acquire?
- 7:49There you go. I mean, that's the, that's the bottom line with it. And learning from everything that's going on, even with the big play- players.
- 7:56We have more technology available inside, whether you're a single-point store or a group or whatever. You have so much technology available to you, and we're watching people really... I wouldn't say scrambling.
- 8:08Some are scrambling, but a lot are very thoughtfully pursuing the right tech stack, the right processes.
- 8:14Because all of this, these billion-dollar comp- You can do these things, or most of them, in your store, and a lot of times- Absolutely... better because you have more control over the experience.
- 8:24You have more control over, like you were saying, Kyle, over the value proposition and the value presentation of how you're selling the vehicle.
- 8:30And we just see dealers be successful with it all the time across the country, while other dealers are saying it's impossible. I think Brian, Brian Bensel calls it the "yeah, buts." He had a post on that today. Yeah.
- 8:40Now, I say, oh, 'cause he and, he and, uh- Yeah, but... Bernie Sisloski- You don't need that... were doing a presentation at NADA show, and we were saying what we're doing, and he's like, "And then the yeah, buts begin.
- 8:48Yeah, but what about this? Yeah, but what about that?" And- [laughs] It's a great post. You should go read it. Uh, speaking- That's a good, that's a good post... of things you should read, we're just listening to here.
- 8:55Segway time. We'll cover the whole thing. It's a pretty clean story. It's just an interesting one. It's clean. Lucid Motors is delivering some good news to Gravity SUV owners just in time for its Investor Day.
- 9:05After a rough few months of software headaches for Lucid owners, it's a welcome update. Lucid is pushing, get this, a software update to North American Gravity SUV owners Thursday that enables CarPlay and Android Auto.
- 9:18Uh, European and Middle East owners get it in late March.
- 9:21The features have been available on the Lucid Air sedan for some time, but the Gravity has had a rocky software rollout, significant enough that Lucid's interim CEO issued a public apology to owners.
- 9:31Uh, the update arrives on the same day as Lucid's Investor Day in New York City, where the company plans to discuss its upcoming midsize EV platform and its path to profitability? I lo- [laughs] Maybe. [laughs] Oh, man.
- 9:46So this is one of those things where I think we live in this world where now you can push features over the air, unlock features, get them.
- 9:52So it gives me a little bit of hope with all the decisions being made to cut out CarPlay and Android Auto for some reasons- Yeah... um, that like, hey, if you know you have- You can ship that right back in.
- 10:01Hey, if you know you can ship it right back in, it makes a lot more sense to see if you can do it this way. And if it's impacting things, you can be like, "Great news, we've added it." Great news.
- 10:10And if you already bought one- We're doing our quarterly recap-... we added it... for the stock people, and here we go. [laughs] Yeah, exactly. This, this'll get the, get things pumping.
- 10:16So again, we live in this new world where, uh, cars, software-defined vehicles, are going to just continue to be more of a thing, and I'm excited to see more software updates pushed that add new features and, you know, make, make things better.
- 10:29Keep your team aware of what your OEM is doing. Keep more competitive. Keep them what, aware of what your OEM is doing. Don't, don't hide them from all the OEM channels that you possibly can, 'cause they're gonna be...
- 10:37There's all these updates shipped. Oh, my gosh. And with used cars being a priority in so many dealerships, they've gotta have a pretty, pretty broad scope as to- Without a doubt... what's happening across brands.
- 10:47So find ways to keep your, keep your people informed. All right. Listen, everybody, have a great Thursday. Don't forget a couple things. Number one, you can go to asotu.com, subscribe for the webinar.
- 10:57But number two, go to asotocon.com. Get your tickets and your hotel before they're gone. [upbeat music] And leave it right. As- [upbeat music] And leave it right.
- 11:17As-