Latest / Sleepy Facts About History / Why Did George Washington Rotate Enslaved Workers Between Philadelphia and Mount Vernon? - Ona Judge, Hercules, and the Enslaved Workers of the Early Presidency | Sleepy Facts About History

Transcript

Why Did George Washington Rotate Enslaved Workers Between Philadelphia and Mount Vernon? - Ona Judge, Hercules, and the Enslaved Workers of the Early Presidency | Sleepy Facts About History · Sleepy Facts About History

0:00
Welcome to Sleepy Facts About History. When George
0:12
Washington moved into the President's house on
0:15
Market Street in Philadelphia, the new Republic's
0:18
executive residence became a working site of
0:21
both Republican government and chattel slavery.
0:24
While the public saw the President conducting
0:27
the nation's business, enslaved people were cooking
0:30
elaborate dinners, managing stables, and caring
0:34
for children in the same building. This episode
0:37
examines how early presidents from Washington
0:40
to Jackson maintained enslaved households in
0:43
northern cities, and later in the new capital
0:46
of Washington, D .C. It explores the deliberate
0:50
legal strategies used to evade Pennsylvania's
0:53
gradual abolition laws, including the forced
0:55
rotation of enslaved people back to plantations
0:58
before they could claim freedom. I wanted to
1:02
understand how the language of liberty and the
1:05
practice of slavery occupied the exact same rooms,
1:08
separated by floor and function rather than principle.
1:12
The assumption that working in a presidential
1:15
household was a relatively privileged form of
1:17
enslavement does not survive contact with the
1:20
historical evidence. Proximity to power conferred
1:24
no protection from sale, family separation, or
1:28
coercion. Through the stories of individuals
1:31
like Ona Judge, an enslaved woman who escaped
1:35
to new hampshire and was pursued for years by
1:37
federal agents and hercules the president's cook
1:41
who vanished into freedom we see the structural
1:44
contradiction at the heart of the early presidency
1:47
the executive residence was built and maintained
1:50
by people who were legally excluded from the
1:53
rights the new government proclaimed and their
1:55
resistance exposed a system built entirely on
1:58
force in the president's house on market street
2:05
the man who proclaimed liberty sat down to dinners
2:08
cooked by a man he owned and when that cook hercules
2:12
finally escaped the president of the united states
2:15
spent years using federal agents to hunt him
2:18
down in the spring of 1790 a house on market
2:23
street in philadelphia became the residence of
2:26
the president of the united states it was a handsome
2:30
building three stories of brick and stone with
2:34
public rooms on the first floor where guests
2:36
were received and private chambers above. What
2:41
the crowds who gathered to see George Washington
2:43
did not see, or perhaps chose not to see, was
2:47
the full layout of the place. The kitchen to
2:50
the rear was where an enslaved man named Hercules
2:53
prepared elaborate dinners. The stables were
2:57
where enslaved workers managed horses and carriages.
3:00
The upper floors or adjacent outbuildings were
3:03
where enslaved people slept at night after the
3:07
public rooms had emptied. The President's House,
3:11
as it was then called, was a working residence.
3:15
Republican government and chattel slavery occupied
3:18
not merely the same city or the same era, but
3:22
the same rooms. They were separated by floor
3:26
and function, not by principle. This is not a
3:29
story about what the early presidents believed
3:32
about slavery. It is a story about what they
3:35
did. It is a story about the people who cooked
3:39
their meals, cleaned their rooms, cared for their
3:42
children, drove their carriages, and served their
3:45
guests. Bees were people who were compelled to
3:48
do this work by law and by force. They were moved
3:52
hundreds of miles from their families when political
3:55
necessity required it. and some of them chose
3:59
to flee. The early presidency proclaimed liberty
4:02
in self -government. Its daily operation required
4:06
something else entirely. The assumption that
4:10
working in a presidential household was a relatively
4:12
privileged form of enslavement does not survive
4:15
contact with the evidence. Proximity to power
4:19
conferred no protection from sale, separation,
4:22
or coercion. The people who labored in these
4:26
rooms remained legally owned. and some of them
4:29
chose to escape. To understand how this worked,
4:33
we need to begin with the geography. When George
4:37
Washington took office in 1789, the federal government
4:41
sat in New York City. The following year, it
4:44
moved to Philadelphia, where it would remain
4:47
for 10 years while a permanent capital was built
4:49
on the Potomac. This meant that presidents from
4:53
the southern states had to maintain households
4:55
in northern cities where they conducted the nation's
4:57
business. Washington. jefferson madison monroe
5:02
and later jackson all faced this situation they
5:06
continued to hold enslaved people on their plantations
5:09
in virginia tennessee and elsewhere the president's
5:13
household was not a single place it was a moving
5:17
system of labor that shifted between capital
5:19
and plantation and the people who performed that
5:23
labor moved with it pennsylvania complicated
5:27
this arrangement in 1780 The state had passed
5:31
a gradual abolition law that freed children born
5:35
to enslaved mothers after they reached a certain
5:37
age. But it also contained a provision that would
5:41
become crucial. Any enslaved person brought into
5:45
the state and held for more than six months could
5:47
claim freedom. This was not immediate emancipation.
5:52
Adults remained enslaved. But the six -month
5:56
rule created a legal hazard for southern enslavers
5:59
who wished to maintain households in Philadelphia.
6:02
The solution, adopted by Washington and followed
6:05
by Jefferson and others, was rotation. Enslaved
6:09
people would be sent back to the plantation before
6:12
the six -month limit expired. Others would be
6:15
brought north to replace them. This was not a
6:19
casual arrangement. It was a deliberate legal
6:23
strategy. documented in washington's correspondence
6:26
and household accounts its purpose was to preserve
6:30
property in human beings while occupying the
6:32
highest office in a republic that spoke the language
6:35
of liberty it was also a physical recurring disruption
6:40
mount vernon sat approximately 140 miles south
6:44
of philadelphia enslaved people made that journey
6:48
by carriage or on foot they were sent back to
6:51
virginia as the deadline approached They were
6:54
replaced by others who then began their own six
6:57
-month countdown. Jefferson, during his vice
7:01
-presidency and presidency, followed the same
7:04
practice with enslaved people from Monticello.
7:07
The rotation was not a single journey, but a
7:10
pattern that structured the lives of enslaved
7:12
workers in the presidential household. It was
7:16
a moving plantation that relocated between capital
7:19
and plantation while maintaining the same coercive
7:22
structure. The analogy has its limits. The president's
7:27
house was an urban residence, not an isolated
7:29
plantation. Enslaved people in Philadelphia had
7:33
greater access to free black communities, information
7:37
networks, and escape routes than they would have
7:40
had in rural Virginia. But the coercive call
7:43
remained. The labor itself was domestic in the
7:47
full sense of that word. It encompassed everything
7:51
required to maintain a large household that was
7:54
also a site of public entertainment and political
7:57
negotiation. Enslaved people cooked elaborate
8:01
dinners for visiting dignitaries. They cleaned
8:04
rooms, washed linens, tended fires, cared for
8:08
children, managed stables, and served at table
8:11
in full view of the guests who came to petition
8:14
the president or observe the new government.
8:18
Hercules. An enslaved man owned by Washington
8:21
served as the principal cook in the Philadelphia
8:24
household. He was known for his skill. His work
8:29
was visible to the most powerful men in the nation,
8:32
but his status as property did not change. He
8:36
could not refuse the work. He could not leave.
8:41
He could not keep his wages if any were given.
8:44
The skill was his. The profit from it belonged
8:48
to another. The household contained a hierarchy,
8:53
but it was a hierarchy within enslavement, not
8:56
an escape from it. Some enslaved people worked
9:00
in closer proximity to the president's family.
9:02
Others performed the heavier labor of cleaning,
9:06
laundry, and stable work. All were subject to
9:10
the same legal regime. All could be sold, separated
9:15
from family, or moved at the enslaver's discretion.
9:19
The fact that some positions required more trust
9:22
or more visible skill did not transform the relationship
9:26
into something voluntary or reciprocal. It remained
9:29
coercion, organized around the needs of the household
9:33
and the political calculations of its head. Ona
9:37
Judge knew this from the inside. She was an enslaved
9:41
woman, born around 1773, who served as a personal
9:46
attendant to Martha Washington. in the Philadelphia
9:49
president's house. Her mother had been an enslaved
9:53
woman of African and English descent. Her father
9:57
was white, likely a man named Andrew Judge, who
10:01
was an indentured servant at Mount Vernon before
10:04
gaining his freedom. Honor was, by the law of
10:08
Virginia, enslaved for life. She was also, by
10:12
that same law, the property of the Washington's
10:15
estate. She was held in trust as part of Martha's
10:19
dower property. This meant that she could not
10:22
legally be freed by George Washington's will,
10:25
as she would revert to the Custis estate upon
10:27
Martha's death. In May 1796, Ona Judge made her
10:33
escape. She was 22 years old. The Washingtons
10:38
were eating dinner when she left the President's
10:41
house. She moved through the evening streets
10:44
of Philadelphia to the harbor. where she boarded
10:47
a ship bound for Portsmouth, New Hampshire. She
10:51
sailed north along the coast, leaving behind
10:53
her mother, her half -siblings, and the only
10:57
world she had known. She did not leave because
11:00
she was treated worse than other enslaved people.
11:03
She left because she was enslaved. She left because
11:08
she had learned that freedom was possible in
11:10
the North. And she left because she had been
11:13
told, falsely as it turned out, that she would
11:16
be given as a wedding gift. to Martha Washington's
11:18
granddaughter. That prospect meant separation
11:21
from her family and transfer to a new enslaver.
11:26
The Washingtons were furious. George Washington
11:30
did not treat her escape as a minor inconvenience.
11:34
He treated it as a theft of property and a personal
11:38
affront, and he used the powers of his office
11:41
to try to recover her. He instructed his secretary,
11:46
Tobias Lear, to contact Joseph Whipple, the federal
11:49
customs collector in Portsmouth, to arrange her
11:52
capture and return. Whipple located her, but
11:56
reported that she had agreed to return only if
11:59
she were freed. Washington refused that condition.
12:03
Washington then attempted to have her seized
12:05
by force. But Whipple warned that such an action
12:09
would provoke a public outcry in New Hampshire,
12:12
where sentiment against slavery was strong. For
12:17
years, Washington continued to seek her return
12:19
through agents and informers. He never succeeded.
12:25
Alma Judge lived in New Hampshire for the rest
12:28
of her life. She married a free black sailor
12:31
named Jack Staines. She had children. She lived
12:36
in poverty, as free black people in the North
12:39
often did, excluded from many forms of employment
12:42
and social advancement. In 1845 and again in
12:47
1847, she gave interviews to abolitionist newspapers
12:51
in which she described her escape and her reasons
12:54
for it. She was, by then, an elderly woman. She
12:59
made clear that she had not been driven away
13:01
by exceptional cruelty. She had been driven away
13:05
by the condition of enslavement itself, by the
13:08
threat of being given away, by the knowledge
13:11
that she could be moved and sold at another's
13:13
will. I am willing to work, she said, but I want
13:18
some of the privileges that other people have.
13:21
This was not a complaint about a particular enslaver.
13:25
It was a rejection of the system. Hercules, the
13:29
cook whose skill had graced the president's table,
13:32
made his own escape in 1797. He disappeared after
13:37
being returned to Mount Vernon from Philadelphia.
13:41
He vanished on Washington's 65th birthday. a
13:45
date that may have been chosen deliberately.
13:47
He was never captured. Washington pursued him
13:51
through advertisements and agents without success.
13:54
The man who had prepared meals for the most powerful
13:58
figures in the new nation chose freedom over
14:01
the kitchen where he had been compelled to work.
14:04
His skill had made him visible. His escape made
14:09
him, in the eyes of the law, a fugitive. These
14:13
escapes were not merely personal dramas. They
14:17
exposed the structural contradiction at the heart
14:19
of the presidential household. The president
14:22
of a republic that proclaimed liberty was using
14:25
the mechanisms of federal power to pursue human
14:28
beings who had taken that liberty for themselves.
14:31
The rotation system, the legal maneuvering, the
14:35
correspondence with federal officials, All of
14:38
this was necessary because the Republican household
14:41
required enslaved labor, and enslaved people
14:45
refused to accept it as permanent or natural.
14:49
The movement between plantation and capital was
14:52
itself a form of family separation. When Washington
14:56
or Jefferson or Madison brought enslaved people
14:59
to Philadelphia or later to Washington, D .C.,
15:02
they took them from spouses, children, parents,
15:05
and kin who remained on the plantation. The rotation
15:09
system meant that some enslaved people would
15:11
periodically return, but others were kept in
15:15
the North for extended periods. And the threat
15:18
of permanent transfer always existed. Orner Judge's
15:23
fear of being given to Martha Washington's granddaughter
15:26
was not abstract. Enslaved people in presidential
15:30
households were subject to the same transfers.
15:34
sales and separations that characterized enslavement
15:37
throughout the Atlantic world. Proximity to the
15:41
president did not protect them from this. In
15:44
some ways, it made them more vulnerable. They
15:48
were caught between the legal regimes of different
15:50
states and the political calculations of an enslaver
15:54
who could not afford public scandal but would
15:56
not relinquish property. The legal geography
16:00
of slavery shaped these households in ways that
16:02
the presidents understood precisely. Pennsylvania's
16:06
six -month rule was not a secret. It was discussed
16:10
in correspondence. It required planning, or the
16:15
rotation of enslaved people back to Mount Vernon
16:18
or Monticello or Montpelier before the deadline
16:21
was a logistical operation, documented in household
16:24
accounts and travel records. This was not a peripheral
16:28
matter. It was central to the functioning of
16:32
the executive residence. The president could
16:35
not maintain a household in Philadelphia without
16:37
addressing it, and the solution chosen was not
16:41
emancipation, but evasion. When the federal government
16:45
moved to Washington, D .C. in 1800, the legal
16:49
environment changed, but the dependence on enslaved
16:52
labor did not. The District of Columbia was created
16:56
from land ceded by Maryland and Virginia. Slavery
17:00
remained legal there until 1862. The new president's
17:05
house, later called the White House, was built
17:07
in significant part by enslaved laborers. Construction
17:12
began in 1792. The federal government did not
17:16
own enslaved people directly, but it hired them
17:20
from their enslavers, along with free white and
17:23
black workers, European immigrants, and skilled
17:26
craftsmen. Payroll records document payments
17:30
to enslavers for the labor of men who cut stone,
17:33
hauled materials, dug foundations, and performed
17:38
the heavy work of lifting and placing in the
17:40
heat and humidity of Chesapeake summers. The
17:44
names of some survive in the records. Most do
17:48
not. This was not unique to the White House.
17:53
Enslaved labor built much of the early capital.
17:56
But the president's house carried a particular
17:58
symbolic weight. It was to be the residence of
18:02
the head of state in a republic founded on principles
18:05
that its builders and early occupants did not
18:08
apply to the people who constructed and maintained
18:11
it. The contradiction was not hidden. It was
18:15
visible in the stone and mortar, in the kitchens
18:18
and stables, in the very fabric of the building.
18:22
and the enslaved workers on that site labored
18:25
under conditions distinct from their free counterparts.
18:28
They could not leave. They could not negotiate
18:32
their wages. They were hired out by their enslavers,
18:37
and they saw no profit from their own exertion.
18:42
James Madison's presidency brought this into
18:44
sharper focus through the experience of Paul
18:47
Jennings, born in 1799. Jennings was enslaved
18:52
from birth on Madison's plantation, Montpelier,
18:55
in Virginia. As a young boy, he was selected
18:59
to serve in the Madison household, and he accompanied
19:02
the president to Washington. He was present in
19:06
the White House during the War of 1812, when
19:09
British forces approached the city in August
19:12
1814. In his memoir, published in 1865, Jennings
19:18
described the hurried evacuation. the rescue
19:21
of Gilbert Stewart's portrait of George Washington,
19:24
and the burning of the building. He was, by his
19:27
own account, the person who physically helped
19:30
remove the portrait, cutting it from its frame
19:33
when there was no time to remove the frame itself.
19:37
Jennings' memoir is a rare document. It is a
19:41
testimony of an enslaved person who served in
19:43
the White House and later wrote about it, but
19:46
its rarity should not obscure what it confirms.
19:50
Jennings was not freed by James Madison. He was
19:54
not freed by Dolly Madison after her husband's
19:57
death. He purchased his freedom with financial
20:01
assistance from the Senator Daniel Webster, whom
20:04
Jennings had come to know through his work. He
20:07
then helped purchase the freedom of other members
20:10
of his family. His memoir is measured, precise,
20:14
and clear about the conditions of his service.
20:17
He describes the work, the household. The burning
20:21
of Washington. He does not dramatize. He does
20:26
not need to. The persistence of enslaved labor
20:30
in the White House continued through the antebellum
20:32
period. Andrew Jackson, the seventh president,
20:36
brought enslaved people from his Tennessee plantation,
20:40
the Hermitage, to serve in the presidential residence.
20:44
By the 1830s, the White House was a more established
20:47
institution than it had been in Washington's
20:50
or Madison's time. It had more settled protocols
20:53
and traditions. Yet its dependence on coerced
20:57
labor remained unchanged. Jackson's enslaved
21:01
household workers were part of a larger system
21:04
that extended through the capital and the nation.
21:07
It was a system that the presidency did not challenge
21:11
but accommodated and used. This was not a founding
21:14
era anomaly or a holdover from revolutionary
21:17
times. It was a continuing feature of the antebellum
21:22
presidency, evidence that the system had not
21:24
withered but persisted. What changed and what
21:28
did not is worth holding clearly. The early presidency
21:33
was a new institution, inventing itself as it
21:36
went. It had no established protocols, no settled
21:41
traditions. The decision to staff the presidential
21:45
household with enslaved labor was not forced
21:48
by necessity in any simple sense paid servants
21:52
were available free laborers built the white
21:55
house alongside enslaved ones the choice to use
21:59
enslaved people reflected the preferences the
22:03
property interests and the social assumptions
22:06
of the men who held the office it was a choice
22:10
made repeatedly that embedded slavery in the
22:13
daily operations of the executive branch the
22:17
rotation system The pursuit of fugitives, the
22:20
hiring of enslaved construction workers, the
22:23
presence of enslaved attendants in the president's
22:26
private quarters, all of this was documented,
22:30
known, and contested at the time. It was not
22:34
a secret that required later exposure. What required
22:38
later exposure, and what this examination attempts,
22:42
is the experience of the enslaved people themselves.
22:47
Their labor made the presidency possible. Their
22:50
resistance exposed its dependence on force. We
22:55
should be precise about what we know and what
22:57
we do not. The records are uneven. For Washington,
23:02
they are extensive. For Jefferson, plantation
23:05
records survive. For Madison, we have Jennings'
23:09
memoir and other sources. For Monroe and Jackson.
23:14
The documentation of enslaved household workers
23:17
is sparser. We know that enslaved people were
23:21
present. We know less about who they were, what
23:24
they experienced, and what became of them. This
23:28
is not accidental. The records were kept by enslavers,
23:32
not by the enslaved. They document property,
23:36
labor, and cost. They do not document interior
23:40
lives, family relationships, or the full range
23:43
of resistance and accommodation that characterized
23:46
enslavement. The escapes of Ona, Judge, and Hercules
23:51
are known because they were pursued, because
23:53
they gave testimony, because abolitionist newspapers
23:57
recorded their words. Most enslaved people and
24:01
presidential households did not escape, or did
24:04
not escape successfully, or did not leave records
24:07
if they did. Their experiences must be approached
24:10
through the structures we can document. These
24:14
include the legal regime, the household economy,
24:17
the patterns of movement and separation, and
24:21
the testimony of those who did speak. This is
24:24
incomplete. It is also necessary. The assumption
24:29
that working in a presidential household was
24:32
a relatively privileged form of enslavement does
24:35
not survive contact with the evidence. Privilege
24:39
in this context would require some meaningful
24:41
protection from sale, separation, or coercion.
24:45
It would require some access to self -determination.
24:49
It would require some recognition of family ties
24:52
as inviolable. None of this existed. Owner -judge
24:58
was not protected by her proximity to Martha
25:00
Washington. Hercules was not protected by his
25:03
culinary skill. Paul Jennings was not freed by
25:07
his service to a president. who was also a leading
25:10
intellectual of the founding generation what
25:14
protected them when protection came was their
25:17
own action it was the decision to flee to persist
25:21
to purchase freedom to testify the presidential
25:25
household was in this sense not exceptional but
25:29
exemplary it displayed with unusual clarity the
25:33
contradiction that ran through the early republic
25:36
the language of liberty and the practice of slavery
25:40
were not separate spheres that occasionally collided
25:43
they were intertwined in the daily functioning
25:46
of the nation's highest office the president
25:50
who received ambassadors and proclaimed policy
25:52
depended on people who were legally forbidden
25:55
to receive wages to leave his service to refuse
25:58
his commands or to keep their own children with
26:02
them this was not a failure to live up to ideals
26:06
that were otherwise realized It was the material
26:09
condition of the presidency itself. We can trace
26:13
this through the physical spaces. The President's
26:17
House in Philadelphia, where Washington and Adams
26:19
lived, had quarters for enslaved people on its
26:22
upper floors or in adjacent outbuildings. The
26:26
White House in Washington, rebuilt after 1814,
26:30
continued to contain spaces where enslaved workers
26:34
slept and worked. The plantations were connected
26:38
to these residences by the movement of human
26:41
beings. Mount Vernon, Monticello, Montpebia,
26:45
Highland, the Hermitage, all were linked to the
26:48
capital by people carried by carriage or forced
26:51
to walk, rotated to evade law, or kept in place
26:55
to serve political display. The system had a
26:59
geography, and that geography was marked by coercion.
27:04
The legal maneuvering deserves particular attention
27:06
because it reveals how consciously this was maintained.
27:10
Washington did not accidentally hold enslaved
27:13
people in Philadelphia. He consulted with attorneys.
27:17
He directed his secretary to manage the rotation.
27:21
He corresponded with federal officials about
27:24
the recovery of fugitives. When Orner Judge escaped,
27:28
he did not shrug and move on. He pursued her
27:31
for years. using the infrastructure of the government
27:34
he headed. This was not personal pettiness, though
27:38
it was personal. It was the systematic defense
27:41
of property rights in human beings by the chief
27:44
executive of a nation that had not yet found
27:47
a way to reconcile those rights with its founding
27:50
language. Madison's dependence on enslaved labor
27:54
extended through his presidency and beyond. Paul
27:58
Jennings' memoir describes a household that was,
28:01
by the standards of enslavers, relatively intimate.
28:05
Jennings knew the Madisons well. He served them
28:09
for decades, and he later helped free his own
28:13
family. But this intimacy did not translate into
28:17
freedom. Jennings purchased his freedom. He was
28:22
not granted it. The relationship remained one
28:25
of ownership until he ended it through his own
28:28
effort and the assistance of others. The construction
28:32
of the White House brings another dimension into
28:34
view. The federal government, in this project,
28:38
was not merely accommodating slavery, but actively
28:41
hiring it. Payments to enslavers for the labor
28:45
of their human property are recorded in the construction
28:49
accounts. This was public, not private. It was
28:54
done in the name of the nation, to build the
28:57
residence of its chief executive. The enslaved
29:00
workers who performed this labor were not household
29:03
servants in close proximity to Pala. They were
29:06
construction laborers, often nameless in the
29:09
records, performing the heavy work of building
29:12
in the heat and humidity of a Chesapeake summer.
29:16
Their labor was mixed with that of free workers,
29:19
white and black, European and American. But their
29:24
status was distinct. They could not leave. They
29:29
could not negotiate their wages. They were hired
29:32
out by their enslavers. And the profit went to
29:36
those enslavers, not to them. This mixing of
29:41
enslaved and free labor was characteristic of
29:43
the early republic's economy, not unique to the
29:46
White House. But the symbolic weight of the building
29:50
gave it a particular visibility. The residence
29:53
of the president, the visible center of the new
29:56
government, was being built in part by people
29:59
who were legally excluded from the rights that
30:01
government proclaimed. The contradiction was
30:05
not hidden in a field or a distant plantation.
30:08
It was in the capital, in the most prominent
30:11
construction project of the new nation. What
30:14
remains uncertain, and should be acknowledged,
30:17
is the full extent of this system across all
30:20
early presidential administrations. The documentation
30:23
is uneven. We know more about Washington's household
30:28
because his records were preserved and have been
30:30
studied intensively. We know about Ona Judge
30:34
because she escaped, was pursued, and later gave
30:37
interviews. We know about Paul Jennings because
30:40
he wrote a memoir. For many others, the records
30:44
are sparser. The enslaved people who served Monroe,
30:49
who worked in Jackson's White House, who built
30:52
and cleaned and cooked and were rotated or kept
30:55
in place, we know they were there. We know the
30:59
system required them. We cannot always name them
31:03
or trace their individual paths. This is not
31:07
a reason to generalize carelessly. It is a reason
31:11
to be precise about what the evidence shows and
31:13
what it does not. We can say with confidence
31:17
that enslaved labor was embedded in the early
31:19
presidency. We can say that it was maintained
31:22
through legal maneuvering and physical coercion.
31:25
We can say that it involved family separation
31:28
and the pursuit of fugitives. And we can say
31:33
that it continued from the temporary capitals
31:35
through the construction and occupation of the
31:38
White House. We cannot say that every enslaved
31:42
person in these households experienced identical
31:45
conditions. We cannot say that we have recovered
31:49
all their stories. The incompleteness is part
31:53
of the history. It reflects who kept records
31:57
and who did not, whose voices were preserved
31:59
and whose were silenced. The early presidency
32:03
proclaimed republican liberty while depending
32:05
on coerced labor. This was not a contradiction
32:09
that the presidents failed to notice. It was
32:12
one they managed through legal evasion, through
32:16
the rotation of human beings, through the pursuit
32:19
of those who escaped. The household was where
32:22
this management was most visible, most daily,
32:25
most intimate. The president, who returned to
32:29
his residence after conducting the nation's business,
32:32
found his meals cooked, his fires tended, his
32:36
children cared for by people who were there by
32:39
force, not by choice. Some of those people accepted
32:44
what they could not change. Some resisted in
32:47
ways visible to history. Most are lost to it,
32:51
their names unrecorded, their experiences inferred
32:55
from the structures that contained them. Ona
32:58
Judge died in New Hampshire in 1848, having lived
33:03
free for more than 50 years. She had been pursued
33:07
by the most powerful man in the nation and had
33:10
refused to return. Hercules disappeared into
33:13
the free black communities of the North, his
33:16
fate unknown. Paul Jennings lived to see emancipation,
33:20
wrote his memoir, and helped free his family.
33:25
Their stories are exceptional because they were
33:28
recorded. The system they escaped was ordinary
33:31
because it was everywhere, in the plantation,
33:34
in the capital, in the president's house itself.
33:37
The presidency that emerged from this period
33:40
was shaped by this dependence, not despite it.
33:44
The Executive Residence the protocols of household
33:48
service the very idea of what a president's domestic
33:52
life looked like these were formed in a context
33:56
where coerced labor was assumed organized and
34:00
legally protected the white house that visitors
34:04
tour today stands on foundations laid in part
34:07
by enslaved workers its early rooms were maintained
34:11
by enslaved people its early occupants pursued
34:15
those who fled This is not the only story of
34:20
the early presidency, but it is inseparable from
34:23
it. The Republican household and the enslaved
34:26
household were the same place. Understanding
34:30
this does not require us to condemn or to excuse.
34:34
It requires us to see clearly what was. And it
34:38
requires us to recognize that the liberty proclaimed
34:41
was, for many who heard it, a description of
34:44
a world that did not include them.