Latest / Chatter that Matters / Is Sports Fixed? Declan Hill
Transcript
- 0:08Sports, it lives in the worlds of not knowing.
- 0:13It's the uncertainty of the outcome, the unpredictability of
- 0:17the moment, the psychology of winning and
- 0:20losing. It's why we lean in when the clock gets
- 0:24tight. We love the hero's
- 0:27journey. Can the underdog win? Will there be another
- 0:31miracle on ice, or will the GOAT cement their legacy with an
- 0:35overtime winner in Game 7?
- 0:40That's the exchange we're willing to give with professional sports.
- 0:44We'll give you our undivided attention, our loyalty.
- 0:47We'll wear your merchandise as if it's tribal wear
- 0:51because you give us this emotional roller coaster. And what we get in return
- 0:55is the purest kind of drama, the kind that cannot be
- 0:58scripted. But over the last few years,
- 1:02that value exchange has been challenged by a new force.
- 1:06This is a massive problem, and they kind of know about it, and
- 1:10nobody wants to talk about it. Legal sports gambling, first
- 1:14supercharged by legislation and then by technology. We
- 1:18put a casino in everybody's pocket. And the new form of gambling is
- 1:21you're just pressing buttons. And sports gambling
- 1:25has grown exponentially. $170 billion
- 1:29alone last year was bet on legal sports sites. In the United
- 1:32States. When something gets that big, it becomes magnetic, pulls
- 1:36in more bettors, but also attracts more determined, more nefarious
- 1:40actors who want a slice of the action. Genuine surprise, I think, to most
- 1:43sports fans is the depth of corruption in
- 1:47sports. And how? They take the uncertainty
- 1:51of sports and create a certainty. They fix the action.
- 1:55They want the dopamine system in your body being
- 1:59turned on every few minutes. Now, the old image of fixing is the
- 2:03big, loud crime. We're going to buy an entire outcome, like the
- 2:07infamous 1919 Black Sox Scandal, where 8 players
- 2:10were accused of conspiring with gamblers to rig the World Series. And
- 2:14fixing still goes on, more than you know. We got a problem among
- 2:18our athletes, our coaches, our sports officials, our team owners in terms of
- 2:22their addiction to gambling. But there's also a new game that's being played,
- 2:25and it's called fixing a moment. A moment that most fans barely
- 2:29notice. But modern betting turns into a standalone market. A
- 2:33foul, a card, a first-inning run, a missed free throw,
- 2:37an early substitution. In a world of live betting and prop
- 2:40bets, the game is being atomized into thousands of tiny wagers.
- 2:44And that makes spot fixing the perfect crime because you can cash in
- 2:48without changing the headline. We're going to learn about what it means to fix a
- 2:52match and spot fixing. We're going to learn about how organized crime
- 2:55recruits. How it targets the vulnerable. How it turns the
- 2:59uncertainty of sport into the certainty of a bet. My guest
- 3:03today has made it his mission to pry into those
- 3:06cracks with courage and conviction, not from a safe
- 3:10distance, by going into the shadows to understand how this really works
- 3:13and who's profiting from it. And my prophecy that one of the major
- 3:17American sports leagues is going to have an existential crisis in the next 5 years.
- 3:21Dr. Declan Hill, is one of the world's leading investigators of
- 3:25corruption in sport and the author of The Fix. Being a
- 3:28professional athlete is a tough, tough game, and that's
- 3:32even before you get to the level of sports. This episode,
- 3:36I want him to answer two questions. First, is sport
- 3:40fixed? And if so, can it be fixed? And second,
- 3:43is sports gambling, as my guest has stated, the new opioid?
- 3:47And what does that mean for the collective psychology of a nation? When
- 3:51we lose more than we win. It is addictive. It's as
- 3:54addictive as tobacco or alcohol.
- 4:03Hi, it's Tony Chapman. Thank you for listening to Chatter That Matters presented
- 4:06by RBC. If you can, please subscribe to the podcast,
- 4:10and ratings and reviews, well, they're always welcome and they're always
- 4:13appreciated.
- 4:20Declan Hill, welcome to Chatter That Matters. Hey, thanks so much for having
- 4:23me. I'm really happy and honored to be here. Is sport fixed
- 4:27more than most fans know? Is this an anomaly or is this
- 4:31a reality in the way you present it in your book? I
- 4:35love sport. The reason why I've risked my life, the reason why I've
- 4:39dedicated so much passion in my career is that I want to preserve sport.
- 4:43I want to make sport what it should be, which is a
- 4:46vehicle for the ideals and morals and values of our
- 4:50young people. That glorious uncertainty, that drama, those
- 4:53life lessons that we can take. And it's really under threat and it's
- 4:57under threat by greed, by sheer
- 5:00unadulterated greed. Can that be fixed?
- 5:03Can we stop this? Yes, absolutely. It's some really simple stuff.
- 5:08Open our minds to this concept, how the fixes move from final
- 5:11outcome to these moments that happen within the game?
- 5:15Proposition bets are basically micro bets, and this is
- 5:19the plan of bookmakers is they don't want you
- 5:22going to the horse races and betting on
- 5:26just who's going to win the race. And an hour later or 20
- 5:30minutes later, there's another race and you bet on that. They want the dopamine
- 5:34system in your body being turned on every
- 5:37few minutes. So what they're doing is they're constructing a
- 5:41an environment to keep you on that high, win or lose,
- 5:45keep you on the high. So there's a series of micro bets that go on.
- 5:49Who's gonna win the next field goal? Is it the guy who's taking the next
- 5:52faceoff left-handed or right-handed? What's the number of all the
- 5:55players on this shift on a power play? Those kind of micro bets go
- 5:59on. And we're seeing more and more in Major League Baseball. We had a major
- 6:03scandal in, in the fall. In NBA, we had the John Tay
- 6:06Porter scandal with the Toronto Raptors. A minor player got embroiled with
- 6:10organized crime guys. Who said literally, we're going to come to
- 6:14Toronto and quote, fuck you over if you don't pay your money.
- 6:18So start fixing for us, start working for us. There's a major problem
- 6:22in NCAA. There is a massive, massive problem. What we're
- 6:25seeing is we're seeing the corruption of these microbets, and you're
- 6:29absolutely right, there is an endemic problem, but there's also just
- 6:33good old-fashioned match fixing of the results. And people aren't
- 6:36talking about that. Because the only
- 6:40way the sports leagues really
- 6:44sound the alarm is if the betting odds start to
- 6:47move. And that's like stock market insider trading
- 6:51in a penny stock, in a low-valued stock, you can
- 6:55quickly see if there's insider trading going on
- 6:58because there's just very little money, very little liquidity
- 7:03on those big bets on the big You know,
- 7:06who's going to win this game? It's really difficult to
- 7:10see in the odds movements. For example, you'll know from
- 7:14reading my book, I went inside a major Asian organized
- 7:17crime gang who fixes games at the World Cup of
- 7:21Soccer, and that's the biggest betting event in the world by
- 7:25leaps and bounds. Makes Super Bowl look like, you know, a Bush League.
- 7:28Every single one of those games in the World Cup, which we're having in
- 7:32America and Canada and Mexico this coming summer, there's at least
- 7:35$1 billion in every single game.
- 7:39Huge. You can't tell
- 7:42when it's that large what's happening just by looking at the
- 7:46betting market. You need inside intelligence, you need investigators looking at
- 7:50it. So when you're talking about a micro bet and the sudden swing,
- 7:54it raises people's suspicion because why would so many people be
- 7:57betting on whether you're going to be a left-handed or right-handed faceoff?
- 8:02But when it comes to the big game, it's impossible because there's so much cash
- 8:05flowing in. It's reality. Okay. There's so much liquidity
- 8:09on those games. And what you do if you're a fixer, and I'm sorry to
- 8:12give advice to, to, you know, any would-be fixers who are listening to us,
- 8:16is you don't bet like they did with the Chicago White Sox in
- 8:201919. You don't bet for the favorite to lose
- 8:24because then it's fairly obvious that there's something weird happening. You go
- 8:28to the underdogs and you say, guys, you're going to lose
- 8:32anyway. Why don't you lose with $50,000 in your pocket? And that's
- 8:35exactly what these NCAA alleged fixers
- 8:39did for years because the market just wasn't picking up
- 8:43on that stuff. Getting the players to fix was, seemed relatively
- 8:46obvious. They were just reaching out to them on Facebook or Snapchat or
- 8:50whatever. And these guys were saying, hey, sure, we'll do it. If I was a
- 8:53Hollywood scriptwriter, I'd say now that I've got that fly inside my web,
- 8:57I'm in control of the flight. Did that happen in fact that once that commitment
- 9:00was made, they knew that they had somebody they could count on time and time
- 9:03again? You take the reputation of somebody, you take them
- 9:07hostage. I'm a fixer and I fix some big major
- 9:10star. He's like, oh, I'll go to the cops. And I'll say, okay, well, just
- 9:13tell the media you were working for me. What do I care? It's no big
- 9:17deal for me. For you, it's everything. So why would you go to the
- 9:21cops? I've got your reputation now. I own you. But there's
- 9:24also the fact many professional athletes, the
- 9:28gambling addiction is rife in our sports
- 9:31community. Now professional athletes are facing an
- 9:35epidemic of gambling addiction and very, very few
- 9:38people are speaking about it. How does that happen? Because is it
- 9:42organized crime is getting smarter? Is it algorithms? Like
- 9:45what's making the web so enticing for these people to walk into?
- 9:49Or is it just, it was always there, but now the ease has just made
- 9:53it that much more apparent. There's two issues that are going on.
- 9:57One is, let's take a step back and talk about what gambling actually
- 10:00is. Now, when I think about gambling,
- 10:04I'm afraid that I think old school terms. I think about
- 10:08driving to a horse race, going to a
- 10:11casino, taking my money out. It might be a small
- 10:14interaction, might, but it's, it's a little human
- 10:18interaction with a teller, with a bookie, with a croupier.
- 10:22Even if I were to go illegal, I'd still need to have gone to a
- 10:25bar and met some guy, and he would see me
- 10:29once every month or so to settle up our score or whatever.
- 10:33But there's a human interaction. Much of that is old school.
- 10:37Much of that has gone out the window, and it's all on this. And for
- 10:40those of you who are listening, I'm now holding up my mobile phone. They're
- 10:44walking around with a casino in their pocket, and the new
- 10:48form of gambling is you're just pressing buttons,
- 10:52and it's called frictionless gambling. There's no human interaction. You're just
- 10:56tapping to get your dopamine constantly. It's as addictive
- 10:59as heroin. The second thing, everything that
- 11:03makes a professional or a top athlete good at what
- 11:07they do, drive to succeed, ultra
- 11:10competitiveness, incredible focus on
- 11:13overturning odds that nobody thought you could do. It makes them
- 11:17fantastic athletes and it makes them absolutely terrible
- 11:20gamblers. I know many, many of my professional
- 11:24contacts are professional gamblers, like guys that actually beat
- 11:27the bookmaker, and their personality is absolutely
- 11:31the opposite. They're ice cold, they're mathematical
- 11:35nerds. They're really driven to do their homework.
- 11:38And then you have a third factor, which is sports leagues have just
- 11:42gone straight into dancing with the devil. They have
- 11:45all this official sponsorship, all this official advertisement.
- 11:49So you have these poor athletes running into arenas
- 11:53named after bookmakers. Every time they turn on a TV, they're
- 11:57inundated with ads from gambling companies. So
- 12:00you've got a clear conflict of interest between a sports league
- 12:04that is basically doing business with bookmakers. They often
- 12:08have official sponsors. So this is a massive problem.
- 12:11And they kind of know about it and nobody wants to talk about it.
- 12:16And there's another prophecy that I would give, which is that one of the
- 12:19major American sports leagues is going to have an existential crisis in the
- 12:23next few years because of this issue. You've got a doctorate
- 12:27from Oxford, you're Canadian-born, you're one of the smartest guys in the world
- 12:31on this, yet you're willing to risk your life and go into the shadows. I
- 12:34mean, you've got to be a target. You've got to have a lot of people
- 12:36going, This is the last thing we want the world to know
- 12:40is just how corrupt the world of sports is.
- 12:43Yeah. And I find most of my pushback is actually from sports leagues and
- 12:47sports officials. Public, I mean, they're like, oh yes,
- 12:52Professor Hill, come and speak to us. But in reality,
- 12:56they're like a meatpacking plant producing
- 12:59toxic sausages. They do not want it discussed. They don't want to kill
- 13:03anyone. They don't, you know, they're not happy that it's going on, but much, much
- 13:06bigger to their issue is If the public knows how bad it is.
- 13:10What's happening now is the scandals are just becoming too big. You know, the
- 13:14FBI's getting involved, the Department of Justice is getting involved. I mean, if you
- 13:18look at that Eastern District Court of Pennsylvania's criminal
- 13:21indictment of the NCAA alleged fixers, we're
- 13:25talking dozens of the top tier 1 universities.
- 13:29They allegedly had fixed and corrupted a number of
- 13:33DePaul basketball players, and DePaul and
- 13:36Georgetown were playing. The fix was, okay guys,
- 13:40give us the first half, like just lose the first half below the
- 13:43spread. We're going to parlay that with another bet we have. We're going
- 13:47to make hundreds of thousands of bucks and then you can play any way you
- 13:50want in the second half. So they do that. They're literally
- 13:53texting the fixers and the fixers, alleged fixers, are
- 13:57saying, hey, this is a great job. Fantastic. Blah, blah, blah. Then those
- 14:01DePaul University guys who had played really badly deliberately
- 14:04in the first half, Just turn it on in the second half and they bring
- 14:08the game to one point. You go home at
- 14:12the end of that game and you're like, this is amazing. Like,
- 14:16what was the halftime like in the DePaul dressing room? It must be amazing.
- 14:20It must have inspired the guys. It must have made— but what you were actually
- 14:23watching was pure theater. You went inside an
- 14:27Asian fixing gang. You weren't a journalist looking from afar.
- 14:30You weren't using ChatGPT. I mean, you got under the ground.
- 14:34What did you see there in terms of level of sophistication? Like
- 14:38paint the picture. How do they bring people in? You know, they
- 14:42high-five. I mean, what's happening within it that they're in fact
- 14:45a sport within the sport? One, they are very
- 14:49intelligent. One of them used to work at MIT, so
- 14:53they understand the gambling market. They understand what's
- 14:56going on. Two, they're trustworthy
- 15:00in a way. They're honest criminals, which in that
- 15:04world is like gold dust. Often, and this
- 15:08is the thing that is a genuine surprise, I think, to most sports fans, is
- 15:11the depth of corruption in sports.
- 15:16We think as fans, I certainly did when I began this work,
- 15:19that all athletes were well paid, and my
- 15:23mind automatically went to the top 1% of the 1%ers in
- 15:27athletics. And that's actually not how it works. So many of them
- 15:30are badly paid. One or two games every
- 15:34World Cup, every FIFA World Cup are fixed. And the
- 15:37reason why that happens is so many of the teams at this
- 15:41big international sports tournament, the biggest in the world, don't pay the
- 15:45players. And most of those teams, they come from around the
- 15:49world, but most of the teams reliably are Sub-Saharan Africa. So
- 15:52that's Cameroon, Ghana, Nigeria, Ivory Coast, Senegal.
- 15:56Those type of teams. I'm not saying that each one of them fixes. I'm not
- 16:00saying that each one of the players fixes, but the corruption in African
- 16:04football is so endemic that any of our African listeners are
- 16:08going, yeah, finally somebody is saying it. Those teams,
- 16:11if they were run like Argentina, Germany, Italy, whatever,
- 16:15are capable of winning the World Cup, but they're betrayed
- 16:19frequently by corruption. They'll run onto the field,
- 16:23At this big tournament, the team beside them is getting
- 16:26paid and they're not. And the fixers have been working
- 16:30and building relationships for years
- 16:34with these players. Some of them were approached when they were in the under-17.
- 16:38They've got their coaches working for them. They're, they're, they really build
- 16:41an endemic system of trust. And it was the
- 16:45same thing with the alleged NCAA fixers. That
- 16:49work for 2 or 3 years in Chinese basketball and NCAA
- 16:52Tier 1 is when they say they're gonna pay you $10,000 or
- 16:56$30,000 in cash for underperforming, they do.
- 17:00I had a meeting a couple of years ago with one of them. My
- 17:04question was, what's stopping you? And they're like, nothing. Just keep it
- 17:08simple. Everybody gets 20% of their cash back.
- 17:12We're not being greedy. We're just keeping it going.
- 17:16You made a great comparison that those that have and those that have little. Does
- 17:20that also exist in professional sports where I see the star
- 17:24making $10, $15, $30 million a year?
- 17:27I'm going out to have the same dinner, I'm hanging around the same bus. I
- 17:30don't have that sense of cash flow. Is that part of the strategy
- 17:34recruiting or even the trainer or the coach that bring the people
- 17:38in that don't have the same sort of share of the riches?
- 17:42Recruitment is never a problem for these games. I have
- 17:46many very good contacts in the tennis world, and tennis
- 17:50match fixing is an endemic problem. To be fair to tennis,
- 17:53to be fair to the officials that now run tennis,
- 17:57since the 2016 exposé by the BBC and BuzzFeed,
- 18:01they've really taken a handle on this. But their essential
- 18:04problem in tennis is the top 50 men, male players,
- 18:08and the top 20 female players make gazillions of money in terms of
- 18:12sponsorship and prize money. And then once you get out of those
- 18:16top 50, top 20 players, you quickly just descend into
- 18:19a desperate situation in terms of money. So if you're on the tour,
- 18:23if you're ranked, I don't know, 200 or 300, you are struggling
- 18:27to make cash. And so quite often players will sell
- 18:31games and they'll make more money selling the game than they will
- 18:35ever when they're winning. So I remember
- 18:39one of my contacts inside a tennis match fixing gang said,
- 18:43look, we were fixing dozens of games a day and we
- 18:46had players phoning us saying, we want to work with you. What happens to the
- 18:50psychology of a player that, you know, my parents sacrificed everything,
- 18:54I made this my dream, I'm now in the top
- 18:57100 in the world starving, so I'm going to start compromising my
- 19:01integrity for cash. Is that slingshot
- 19:04inside even more dramatic because it was this
- 19:08dream that I chased, I got close to the top, but
- 19:12now within it, survival depends on me surrendering everything
- 19:16that I believed in. Being a professional athlete is a
- 19:19tough, tough game. And that's even before you get to the level
- 19:23of sports. First of all, to be top 100 at
- 19:27any sport in the world is incredibly competitive. You are looking at
- 19:31What you're eating, if you're going to bed 8 to 10 hours a day,
- 19:34you're constantly injured. You are making small sacrifices all the
- 19:38time. So for example, one of the match-fixing athletes that
- 19:42I talked to on the tennis circuit was fixing games where it didn't
- 19:46really matter for his points. He's due to play one of the
- 19:49majors in 2 weeks. He's got a torn hamstring, but at
- 19:53the beginning of the season, he signed contracts with a bunch of
- 19:57tournaments around the world to make sure that he keeps the points
- 20:01going, that he's still moving up the ranking. So here he is
- 20:04in a third-ranked tournament in San Luis de Potosí in the
- 20:08middle of Argentina, his hamstring's injured. He knows
- 20:12he has to go to the major tournament a couple of weeks. He flies to
- 20:16Argentina. He's got to pay that himself, is in an opening round where the
- 20:20player's, you know, not bad. And he thinks, well, if I lose
- 20:23to this guy, bet against myself, I'll get more money from
- 20:27doing that than I can if I win. I get back on the plane, I
- 20:31get back to my home country, I can take care of my hamstring, and I'd
- 20:34be ready for the majors in a couple of weeks. Rationally,
- 20:39it makes sense. Morally, we don't like to think about it. That's
- 20:43a lower-ranked tennis player. Let me drop 3 names
- 20:47at every single NBA basketball fan who's listening to us.
- 20:51This is going, yeah, mate, you're right on that. Utah
- 20:54Jazz, Sacramento and Washington.
- 20:58Tell me at this point in the NBA season, do you
- 21:01really think that they're trying? I think the players want to
- 21:05try. I look at the record of those 3 particular teams,
- 21:09like many other NBA basketball players, I'm like, they're tanking
- 21:13to win the draft lottery so they can
- 21:17rebuild. And that's not the players, that's an official
- 21:20decision that at some point someone has said, this is what we're
- 21:24going to try to do. So to me, that undercuts the entire
- 21:27integrity of the sports league. I might be
- 21:31wrong. Maybe those 3 teams are
- 21:35really trying their best and they're losing part of their
- 21:38season is all coincidence, but I find it difficult
- 21:42to believe that. And I know millions of NBA basketball fans are
- 21:46looking at that going, guys, you're just tanking. I would
- 21:50pose the question, what is the difference between tanking and fixing? And if you are
- 21:53on a tanking team, if you're an athlete or a coach or whatever,
- 21:57and, and you know your team's going to tank, why wouldn't you bet
- 22:00against yourself? That is the standard of integrity that the
- 22:04sports leagues have brought in. And so this is why I go back
- 22:08to my statement, my prophecy that one of the major American sports
- 22:12leagues is going to have an existential crisis in the next 5 years. The
- 22:15athlete that gets embroiled in this, is this become
- 22:18addictive, is addictive to them? As what sports and
- 22:22winning was in terms of the purity of the sport, saying
- 22:26my game plan now is no longer just X, Y, Z,
- 22:29it's about making sure that the fix is paid. There's a
- 22:33whole range of athletes and psychology
- 22:37of athletes. There are some athletes who would
- 22:40never fix whatever you throw in front of them. There are
- 22:44a few who are just in criminals and they openly
- 22:48boast about that in that little circle. They're saying, oh, I bought myself a condo.
- 22:51I bought myself a sports car. I got another condo, all from the results of
- 22:55my fixing. I would never be able to get that if I played honestly. There
- 22:58are other sports athletes who was a Japanese player in
- 23:02the Australian soccer league. His mother no longer speaks to him. I think she's being
- 23:06harsh on the guy because he hadn't been paid for 6 months.
- 23:10His wife had just had a baby. And somebody said, I'll give you
- 23:13$10,000 if you take a yellow card. $10,000
- 23:18in cash. Where would you stand on that one?
- 23:21You've got a baby. You haven't been paid in 6 months. You know, the
- 23:25international perspective of that particular fix. He's a
- 23:29Japanese player playing in Australia. Colombian fellow
- 23:33is making a couple hundred thousand on the Asian gambling market. It's
- 23:36an international international global
- 23:40phenomenon of sports match-fixing now.
- 23:44We come back, Declan and I talk about the realities
- 23:48of a society getting addicted to gambling and what it
- 23:52can lead to, including suicide. And then he offers some
- 23:55advice to parents, advice that truly matters.
- 24:02Hi, it's Tony Chapman. And a big thank you to RBC for sponsoring
- 24:06Chatter That Matters. Speaking of matters, I have a question for you. You're
- 24:09checking on your family, your health, even your car. When was the last time
- 24:13you did a check-in on your finances? Well, RBC
- 24:17Check-In is a virtual experience with no obligation. I got
- 24:20answers to all of my money questions, big and small, and I now have a
- 24:24plan for my future. Book a check-in at rbc.com/check-in.
- 24:37Why don't they just do this? It's so simple. Why? You know, this isn't
- 24:41complicated to protect 90% of sport 90% of the time.
- 24:45Why have sports leagues and sports officials allowed this problem?
- 24:50My guest today is Declan Hill. He's earned his PhD at Oxford,
- 24:54world renowned, highly respected investigative journalist, and like many
- 24:57of us, he loves sports in its purest form, but he was astonished to find
- 25:01out how much of it is fixed. The other side of
- 25:05the coin toss is what sports gambling is doing to individual
- 25:08and our collective psychology. When something fun becomes addictive,
- 25:12when a bit of fun money lost suddenly becomes my house money's
- 25:16lost. I've been anti-sports gambling since it arrived.
- 25:20And if it's legal where you live, I encourage you to go to your government
- 25:23sites and see the effort they're making to encourage people to
- 25:27gamble. Cash incentives, lessons, even
- 25:31stories of people who've become famous as sports gamblers.
- 25:34And this is all happening at a time when people feel they're already pushed to
- 25:38their back feet, struggling with the unaffordability of life, the
- 25:41uncertainty of the job market. And they start thinking maybe that
- 25:45sports gambling is their Hail Mary to get them out of their current
- 25:49situation. And Declan, you've gone even further. You've called
- 25:53sports gambling the new opiate. It is
- 25:56addictive. It's as addictive as tobacco or alcohol,
- 25:59and you don't allow tobacco or alcohol to be sold
- 26:03in primary schools. And what we've allowed in Ontario is
- 26:07unregulated sports gambling. They pretend that,
- 26:11oh, there's some regulation. Oh yes, we're going to
- 26:14make changes. We're going to stop gambling advertisements before
- 26:189 o'clock. But really, it's just unregulated.
- 26:22The bookmakers came in and they bought out many of the regulators. They said, come
- 26:25and work for us. So many of the guys quit their jobs
- 26:29in the government of Ontario, quote, regulation things, and just started working for
- 26:33the bookmakers for 2 or 3 times their money. They talk about self-regulating
- 26:36market, which is about as— makes as much sense as an NFL football game
- 26:40to be self— oh, we're going to get rid of the referees. We're just going
- 26:43to allow everybody to run around and ref themselves. It just doesn't work. We
- 26:47need proper regulation. There are products
- 26:51out there in the gambling market very much like Joe Camel
- 26:54in the tobacco days back in the '80s and '90s, where
- 26:58for our younger viewers and listeners, the tobacco industry before they got properly
- 27:02regulated was designing icons, was
- 27:06designing narratives in their advertisement that were dog
- 27:09whistles to 14-year-olds and 12-year-old boys.
- 27:13And girls, quite frankly, that were trying to hook them early
- 27:17to bring them in. The same thing is happening with sports gambling.
- 27:21The UK Gambling Council, which has many
- 27:24problems, many issues, but it's light years ahead
- 27:28of what we've got in Canada, estimates that there's well over
- 27:3155,000 teenage pathological
- 27:35gamblers. The bookmakers agree with that figure.
- 27:39So just think about that. That is the largest stadium in Ontario
- 27:42packed with 15, 16-year-olds who aren't just
- 27:46trying gambling, are pathologically addicted. They've ruined their
- 27:50brain structure that early age, and they're— most of them are going to be
- 27:53gamblers for the rest of their lives. Let's look at what it's done to
- 27:57the rest of society. There's a fantastic paper out of
- 28:00California by academic colleagues looking at the rate of
- 28:04foreclosures. House foreclosures, and
- 28:08car repossession. And it's up to 50%
- 28:12higher in states that have got legalized
- 28:15sports gambling. The general population is losing
- 28:19their homes, are losing their cars, are being hit
- 28:23because this kind of conversation, Tony, between you and me and
- 28:27our listeners and our viewers is simply not happening. Legalized
- 28:31sports gambling. Present me a positive side to it. Look,
- 28:34just regulate it. Let's put some just basic regulation
- 28:38in there in the same way that
- 28:42alcohol is regulated. People still want to buy booze. They'll still
- 28:46want to have a drink with their buddies, whatever. Okay, fair enough. You go to
- 28:49a bar, it's X distance from a high school,
- 28:53you have to show ID, et cetera, et cetera. You got some basic
- 28:56regulations and people can do addictive behaviors, then there'll be a
- 29:00certain cost in society. But we've decided as a society,
- 29:04we've decided as a community, we're willing to put up with that because we want
- 29:07this necessary freedom. What is one regulation that
- 29:11we could do that is so breathtakingly easy,
- 29:14it's going to stun people? We could make match fixing
- 29:19in Canada illegal. At this moment, it's not
- 29:22illegal. It's not criminal. And I've had conversations
- 29:26with match fixers who have actually immigrated to Canada
- 29:30so that they can go around fixing games. Take half an hour,
- 29:3415 minutes, change the criminal code, add one paragraph saying if you
- 29:37change a part or the entirety of a sports event to
- 29:41benefit from sports gambling, you're going to jail.
- 29:45There's lots of other regulation that gets into the technicalities
- 29:49of sports gambling, but just that shows you how bad
- 29:53the regulation or the lack of regulation is in the Canadian market. You know, there's
- 29:57so many areas that we could explore. A quick one for me that when I
- 30:00read your book and saw some of your interviews, how much is sports
- 30:04gambling and money laundering? Is there an intersection between the two? It's so
- 30:07intertwined. It's unbelievable. Look, again,
- 30:11I'm hoping this isn't a class for criminals here, but if you want to
- 30:15money launder, sports gambling is the easiest thing in the world.
- 30:19Just bet both sides of the sport event. So let's say I've
- 30:22taken a bunch of cash in my cocaine empire in Vaughan or
- 30:26wherever the mob is working these days. I go to a legal bookmaker
- 30:30in Ontario, I go to a legal bookmaker in Quebec, and I bet
- 30:34the Canadiens, the Habs and the Leafs are going to play a game. And
- 30:38so in Quebec, I bet on the Leafs,
- 30:42and in Toronto, I bet on the Canadiens.
- 30:45Somebody's going to win. I'm going to lose one bet, but I'm going to win
- 30:49the other one. At worst, I'll have to pay an offshoot of 10,
- 30:5215%, but the cash comes in and I say to the tax guys, oh,
- 30:56I've just won this bet. You just washed your cash. It's so easy.
- 31:00I want to get very granular because I have to believe a lot of
- 31:03parents out listening to this are becoming deeply concerned
- 31:07about their child. Is there anything you've
- 31:11observed that parents should be thinking about to
- 31:14one, raise awareness that this isn't just an isolated event.
- 31:18This could be a path towards addiction. And two, is there anything they
- 31:22should be doing to hopefully create some kind of
- 31:25moat around it before they become the next Phil Mickelson where
- 31:29the, the next bet seems to be all I care about? Teens,
- 31:33males, females, women have a slightly more proclivity to
- 31:37becoming addicted to casinos. Young boys, men have
- 31:41much more at this moment, it's changing, but in this moment are much more
- 31:45inclined to sports gambling addiction. It's built into a number
- 31:48of the esports that they're playing, the, the concept of a loot box.
- 31:52And frankly, there's a whole series of people I would describe as
- 31:56dodgy celebrities who are now
- 32:00advertising sports gambling, including some current NHL
- 32:03hockey players. Of course, a young boy or a young
- 32:07teenager's gonna be looking at his heroes and his heroes are saying, Hey, it's okay
- 32:11if you gamble on sports, it's fine, it's great. They're walking
- 32:14into addiction. Just imagine alcohol and
- 32:18tobacco companies were allowed to do those same kind of things. You're
- 32:22not allowed to use tobacco. You're not allowed to link tobacco and
- 32:25sports anymore. There's a massive break. You just can't do that.
- 32:29You can't use a celebrity athlete to push a particular type of
- 32:33alcohol or a particular type of marijuana. Sports gambling now is the
- 32:37same thing. So I urge, I beg
- 32:40parents, please have a conversation. Your teenagers are
- 32:44smart. And once they understand that it's addictive, they can
- 32:48start making decisions for themselves. My concern is you'll hear back, mom and
- 32:51dad, I know what I'm doing. I'm only spending a few bucks. I earned the
- 32:55money. I, you know, I pack bags at the local grocery store.
- 32:59It's just fun money. How does a parent counter that?
- 33:02Because The parent that worries that joint leads to
- 33:06heroin and often are very dramatic about how
- 33:09easy that gateway is. You have to have a certain past personality, but I think
- 33:13with sports gambling, the gateway seems to be
- 33:16easier for me to go from one-off experimentation to,
- 33:20as you said, releasing this constant sense of dopamine in my brain
- 33:23because it's like I'm playing a video game. There are two facts that
- 33:27are useful for parents to know. One is the concept of
- 33:31bankrupt or ban, and that is how the algorithms
- 33:34work. Now, there is no way any sports
- 33:38gambler who's successful will be able to beat the bookmaker.
- 33:42The algorithm turns them down and eventually bans
- 33:46them. This comes from the best sports bettors in the world. They formed an
- 33:49organization protesting the algorithms on
- 33:53quote, legal sports. If we beat you guys,
- 33:58you don't encourage us to keep betting with you. You gradually turn the
- 34:02amount that we can bet from 1,000 down to 100, down to 10, and then
- 34:05you shut our accounts down. Conversely, if we're losing, you
- 34:09open that volume up. So the more you lose, the more welcome
- 34:13you are, the more you become a VIP, the more you get these little special
- 34:16bonus offers or whatever. There's no way that anyone is going to win
- 34:20now in a North American legal sports book.
- 34:24Two, I beg, I urge, I
- 34:28implore parents who, before they have this conversation, go to
- 34:32the site gamblingwithlives.org,
- 34:35gamblingwithlives.org. And I pray
- 34:40in all seriousness with, with complete sincerity that
- 34:43none of our listeners ever has to join that group.
- 34:47Because that is a group of parents in the UK whose children have
- 34:51committed suicide because of gambling addiction. And
- 34:54on that site, they have a number of resources
- 34:58to have exactly these kind of honest conversations with their children.
- 35:02And it breaks your heart. The problem with gambling
- 35:06addiction is unlike many of the other addictions that we've been speaking about this morning,
- 35:101 in 5 addicts, ideates,
- 35:14thinks about suicide with gambling addiction. It is a
- 35:18desperately dangerous form of addiction. Let's put
- 35:21aside sports integrity. Let's put aside everything else that we spoke about. If there are
- 35:25parents listening, go to that site gamblingwithlives.org
- 35:29and begin to have these conversations, or simply
- 35:32show your children, here's a website, just take a look at it so they
- 35:36understand the dangers of what they're getting into. When I look at our
- 35:39society today and we spend so much time typing and pushing things
- 35:43in the cloud. We know we're no longer the blacksmith fixing Steve's
- 35:47horse. We're no longer creating pottery, and we've lost that
- 35:50tactile element. Do you think that what social media has
- 35:54done, what sports gambling sites has done, is making people
- 35:57feel they still have purpose and pursuit, that there's an outcome, there's a win
- 36:01or a loss, my decisions matter versus most of the
- 36:05stuff I do nowadays just gets lost in the cloud. At the end of the
- 36:09day, somebody says, you have a good day's work? I guess so. As
- 36:12opposed to going, yeah, I shoot Johnny's horse and they don't have to put it
- 36:15down. Is that part of the psychology of social media and sports gambling
- 36:19that we prey on now? Is that we do need purpose in life? And if
- 36:23so, as the future of unwork arises and
- 36:27there's more and more AI taking away our tasks, are we even more
- 36:31vulnerable as a society to create this fabricated sense
- 36:34of The hero's journey. I'm going after something. It's a
- 36:38win or lose, risk reward, fight or flight. Does that not even
- 36:42feed more into our desire as humans to still feel like we're valuable?
- 36:46To be remembered, that narrative as you described with the hero
- 36:50against the system is the one that the bookmakers will promote and
- 36:54push. You know sports, you can make money. I strongly
- 36:57urge you to know that is a completely false narrative in sports
- 37:01gambling. You're never going to be able to make money on that ban
- 37:05or bankrupt model that they have. Two, I'll share an
- 37:08anecdote with you. It's got an end sampling of about 2 or 3, but I
- 37:11was recently as a professor, I had to go to a high school and
- 37:15there was a bunch of parents there thinking about how to
- 37:19educate their children. And there were 2 prominent senior
- 37:23executives on these big AI and
- 37:26computer companies. They were
- 37:30absolutely adamant that they wanted no screen time
- 37:33for their children. And I'm watching this going, you know what
- 37:37you're peddling. You know the famous
- 37:41story about Mark Zuckerberg where he sends all his kids, they have
- 37:45no screen time. The people that are manufacturing this world,
- 37:49they don't want it for their own children. So why should we?
- 37:53Have our own children doing this as well. I could honestly speak to you all
- 37:56day. You have passion, you have pursuit. And I always end with my 3 takeaways.
- 38:00I love that what you said very early on, I love sport and
- 38:04I want to preserve it. And I think that is a noble cause because I
- 38:08love sport and I'm sickened and saddened. The
- 38:12uncertainty, the outcome, the unscripted drama
- 38:15that I'm watching in fact could be very scripted. Script it. And what
- 38:19you really opened my eyes to, it's not just this sort of
- 38:23spot moments within the thing, but it's in fact taking
- 38:26advantage of people that already feel they're going to be losers and being rewarded for
- 38:30it. The second one is I love the way you use memes. I
- 38:34love words and you talk about reputation hostage taking,
- 38:37frictionless gambling. And I'm not saying that you're claiming these as your words, but you
- 38:41have an incredible way to frame a
- 38:45and then allow us both sides. And I congratulate you for that because
- 38:48most of the people that I've talked to or interview, whether it's my
- 38:52podcast or when I'm doing radio, I'm only gonna stick in this lane because
- 38:56that's what I'm known for. And when you say, you know what, I don't blame
- 38:59that gambler who had just had a baby, has no
- 39:02income, I don't blame them for doing it. It just shows you that
- 39:06how vulnerable we are as a society to be taken hostage
- 39:10by people that want to prey on our insecurities, our
- 39:13uncertainties, and sometimes our need for validation.
- 39:17And the final thing is that I really appreciate is your courage,
- 39:21because it's easy to write about this. It's easy to have a Substack
- 39:25on it, but you've gone down these wells, you've looked around,
- 39:28you've talked to people. To me, when I read your book, when I listened
- 39:32to your interviews, we all have biases, But I think you keep
- 39:36your biases in check more than many because you're open-minded
- 39:40enough to realize having different points of view
- 39:43allows us to get a better view on what really is going on. So for
- 39:46all of that and more, you've just been an absolutely delightful
- 39:50guest. You got my dopamine going and I didn't have to bet on it.
- 39:54You put it brilliantly and eloquently.
- 39:58Once again, a special thanks to RBC for supporting Chatter That Matters.
- 40:02It's Tony Chapman. Thanks for listening, and let's chat soon.