Latest / Soccer Down Here / Multi-Club Ownership in Soccer- "The Who and Why"- Jason Stephens on SDH AM 8.26.25
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: And as always time to catch up with our friend
- 0:02Jason Stevens find out what in the wide world of
- 0:04sports is going on as we learn our master's class
- 0:07when it comes to MCOs and the multi club model
- 0:10and all of that, so we can become better watchers
- 0:15of the entire landscape when it comes to owning soccer
- 0:18clubs here in the present day. Jason has always thanks
- 0:21for dropping by and giving the education.
- 0:23Speaker 2: I appreciate, I appreciate. I'm still welcome back after last week.
- 0:28Speaker 1: Please, it is always a red carpet for you, especially
- 0:32when it comes to everything going on that we need
- 0:34to know about this week. When it comes to the
- 0:38multi club ownership model, I know that we wanted to
- 0:41get into the why and the motives and the motivations,
- 0:46and I know that there are a couple of different
- 0:48directions that you wanted to go here. Where did you
- 0:51want to start first?
- 0:52Speaker 3: Yeah, I think if we.
- 0:53Speaker 2: Look at it, I mean, when we see multi club ownership,
- 0:56there are several groups behind this.
- 1:00Speaker 3: So I three fought we would break it down into three.
- 1:02Speaker 2: Groups, so the state fund groups, the private equity model,
- 1:06and then the wealthy individuals.
- 1:08Speaker 3: So if we look at the motives for those three groups.
- 1:12Speaker 2: I think that may provide a bit of a better
- 1:14understanding for all these MgO is going forward.
- 1:17Speaker 1: All right, So if we go motive state fund, what
- 1:21are we staring at here?
- 1:22Speaker 2: Well, first of all, let's look at it from a
- 1:26state fund is more of a long term position. There's
- 1:29an element of geo politics, the soft power and sports
- 1:33washing connected. You could say it's image and reputation management.
- 1:37It's about international relations. Clubs have become a tool for
- 1:42the global influence from them, but ultimately the sports teams
- 1:46are serving as a cultural bridge between nations. We've got
- 1:50particularly typically, we've got about four state funds that will
- 1:53vy and follow our own level of competitive advantage within
- 1:56the MTO. So we've got Gutsar, which is in the
- 2:01build up to the World Cup. Ever since twenty ten
- 2:03when it was awarded the World Cup, it went straight
- 2:05out and bought PSG and then we had this long
- 2:10decade of then covering up.
- 2:12Speaker 3: Humans rights abuses.
- 2:15Speaker 2: They were trying to normalize state involvement, which reduces I
- 2:19suppose in their eyes by grabbing hold of the club
- 2:22it was reducing their international scrutiny. The other side of it,
- 2:26you've got Doha being taken to the mini region as
- 2:29a business hub for sports, which was acting as a
- 2:32form of cultural integration.
- 2:34Speaker 3: So we've seen guitar.
- 2:36Speaker 2: They went out, yes, they started investing in PSG. Then
- 2:41they started undertaking a lot of sponsorships, two big brands.
- 2:44They sponsored Barcelona for a while, and they went out
- 2:47and sponsored into Miami, and then they got involved in
- 2:52all sorts of different sports as well.
- 2:56Speaker 1: So then you look at you look at Steve Fine
- 3:00and let me ask it this way, with state funds
- 3:05and their ownership, how much would you just when you
- 3:10look at it today, how much of having them at
- 3:14the big table with all of the other owners is
- 3:17because of all of the stuff that you've discussed, all
- 3:19of the sports washing, all of the negative press that
- 3:22could come along with it when it comes to their
- 3:24individual countries that they're attached to. How much of it
- 3:27today is yeah, okay, we know that part, but we
- 3:31need to focus more on the economics for survival of
- 3:34either the club or the entity that that club is in.
- 3:37How much of this is just kind of taking the
- 3:40bad with the good.
- 3:41Speaker 2: I guess you could say, yeah, I'm going to get
- 3:43a couple of examples. So if we look focus from
- 3:46Saudi Arabia. I mean they listened a couple of years ago.
- 3:50They decided that there was going to invest twenty billion
- 3:53pound as part of their Vision twenty thirty, which was
- 3:56basically transforming their economy, coming away for reliability of oil
- 4:02and using sport as a vehicle for that to happen. Now,
- 4:05what they looked at was their population and realized that
- 4:08sixty five percent of their population was under the age
- 4:11of thirty five and they were heavily influenced in football
- 4:15and sport. So Saudi have taken the decision to use
- 4:18sport as a vehicle to help generate relations inside the
- 4:22country as well as the international side of things. But
- 4:27through the scale which they've done, it's caused controversy. Obviously
- 4:32them potentially buying the World Cup twenty thirty, solding proleague,
- 4:37buying players for extortion of fees, paying them extortion at wages,
- 4:42and then you've got them in want to go back
- 4:44to buying the World Cup. How they did it was
- 4:46they went into the smaller feefa regions fee for countries
- 4:50member associations as we call them, and they started to
- 4:54create partnerships financial partnerships in return for their votes.
- 5:00Speaker 3: For me.
- 5:00Speaker 2: I would say that's a bit of what we call
- 5:02a lightning rod effect for attention, and the world has
- 5:05certainly been focused on Saudi Arabia since that strategy began.
- 5:10We don't forget the sports strategy goes beyond football. It's
- 5:14lived golf, is boxing, his WWE, it's junior tennis.
- 5:18Speaker 3: It goes on and on, and then.
- 5:20Speaker 2: You've got Abby Darby UAE, which is you could say
- 5:24it's like a positive branding for their international reputation, but
- 5:28they have a big emphasis on community development and local
- 5:31regeneration investment. If we look at the Manchester City Reflection Club,
- 5:36what you've got over there is that England's government itself
- 5:41as basically hasn't got the investment to be able to
- 5:46help develop and keep the northeast Northwest up to the
- 5:51standards of the South. So you've got another political agenda
- 5:54here where you've got a nation company in which is
- 5:57helping them the wider infrastructure to help develop those areas,
- 6:00Saudi with the northeast and Aby Darby with the northwest.
- 6:04In return, they've got access to two of the biggest
- 6:06clubs in the Premier League. Obviously the biggest league in there,
- 6:11so you know they're going to be patient. There's going
- 6:13to be capital benefits long term, and I'm going to
- 6:17say this is probably you know, a decade long strategy
- 6:20rather than a than wirying about quarterly profit margins.
- 6:23Speaker 1: You know, private equity motives and I know that in
- 6:29our discussions with some of the other multi the multi
- 6:34club owners. Obviously you look at someone like John Texter
- 6:37who has ties to areas management and massive interest rates
- 6:41that are attached to it. But motives when it comes
- 6:44to private equity, is it Is it something that is
- 6:47as easy as to sit there and say we see
- 6:50this as an investment or we see a distressed asset
- 6:54that we want to capitalize on and assimilate it eventually.
- 6:57Is it almost like like the board from start Track
- 7:00when it comes to adding things and just making yourself bigger.
- 7:03What's the motive for private equity here?
- 7:05Speaker 2: Yeah, well, I think it's like football is distressed assets,
- 7:09undervalued assets, under developed assets. And I sort of touched
- 7:14upon it last week where it's private equity. When they
- 7:17compare the American sports model to the European sports model,
- 7:21A lot of experts believe that the football because of
- 7:23the global popularity in the size and you compare it
- 7:27to the NFL and the big five leagues in America.
- 7:30That football in Europe is forty percent developed, there's another
- 7:35sixty percent margin for it to grow. So private equity
- 7:38believes has got the expertise in terms of not just
- 7:40its financial leverage, but also it's experience with technology and
- 7:44commercial powers links to help those clubs to develop their
- 7:49values and revenues. So, I mean you're looking at enhanced
- 7:54financial returns on a one on an annual basis, and
- 7:58then you're probably looking at, you know, increased asset values
- 8:03once they come up with their exit strategies, et cetera.
- 8:07I mean, some of these private action guys are quite smart.
- 8:10So he is a little bit of a strategic position
- 8:12for future industry consolidation, et cetera. You know, when we
- 8:15look at the Club World Cup and we're seeing mimers already,
- 8:18that competition originally penciled in for every four years, is
- 8:22potentially going to change through every two years after twenty
- 8:25twenty nine. And we saw the amount of money involved
- 8:28in that competition. So now it's going to offer clubs
- 8:32in the smaller regions an opportunity to take part in
- 8:35that competition on a regular basis. You've got the Super
- 8:37League that's still not dead, as I mentioned last week,
- 8:40so private actually get involved with that. And then we've got,
- 8:44like you said, new competitions. We've already seen relevant sports
- 8:48in America that they've now got the rights to bring
- 8:52in league matches from LaLiga. So you're going to see
- 8:56Villa al versus Barcelonia on your shows in December, and
- 8:59they been trying for a couple of years now, but
- 9:02the governance bridges have been smoothed out and there's no
- 9:05laws stopping leagues now from playing those games overseas. So again,
- 9:10when you look at you know a unique opportunity, you
- 9:15can say that you've got an alternative asset class development.
- 9:19You know, a high percentage of clubs don't own their
- 9:23own stadia or training facilities, or you can say that
- 9:26the infrastructure they've got needs re generation because the demands
- 9:31of the modern fan have changed in recent years and
- 9:34the way that we use our stadiums have definitely changed.
- 9:36So you can see that there's loads and loads of
- 9:38opportunity there, but ultimately what's going to offer in a
- 9:41few years sign there's premium valuations. And you know, but
- 9:46the big thing is I want to get on too,
- 9:47is like there's definitely a private equity collective approach, and
- 9:50what we're seeing them is they drive up the league's
- 9:52values and the competition rights. Now, if you've got ten
- 9:56clubs and you've got different private actuity groups or in
- 9:59one in each up, then they can all drive the
- 10:01value of connectively, increase the sponsorship, increase the broadcasting nights,
- 10:05et cetera. And I sort of say, is the USA
- 10:08a full state fund because of all the private action
- 10:11groups from America that are really actively in the European
- 10:14game at the moment I mentioned Tours, Area's Apollo and
- 10:17just getting involved. You've got clearly bank Capital, Red Bird,
- 10:21oak Tree, twenty sixth North, You've got all these groups,
- 10:23et cetera.
- 10:24Speaker 3: And there's probably another twenty or Thirsty on top of that.
- 10:26Speaker 1: You know, on there, how much of the market equity
- 10:32interest is to get a quick turn on an investment,
- 10:37and because I mean, look, there have been some things
- 10:41out there where you wonder why they're investing in a
- 10:45particular individual or a particular or a particular ownership group
- 10:50because of the idea that that ownership group really is
- 10:55carrying a lot of debt load, and the market equity
- 10:58fund comes in and sits there and tries to keep
- 11:01that corporation that has the negative debt load running to
- 11:07continue to have that product that they represent still moving.
- 11:11I mean, why why do you invest in something that
- 11:14is a net massive negative when it comes to a
- 11:17bottom line.
- 11:19Speaker 3: Yeah, it's a bit. It's it's a bit like mortgages.
- 11:23Speaker 2: Right, when you own your mortgage and you know the
- 11:26amount of interest that we pay on our mortgage over
- 11:28the twenty five year period, et cetera. The quainctent near
- 11:31enough double the price that we paid for the house.
- 11:34And the reason we do that is because we know
- 11:36that the asset will gain a capital value along the way.
- 11:40So I think a lot of private equity is relying
- 11:42on the club valuations to increase at the same rates
- 11:47of interest or.
- 11:48Speaker 3: Not more so when they do come to exit.
- 11:51Speaker 2: Yes, at the moment, it is just cost cost cost,
- 11:54but once they exit, they get that money back tenfold.
- 11:57I mean the other side is is that what are
- 11:58the exit strategies?
- 11:59Speaker 3: Right?
- 12:00Speaker 2: There's multiple pathways, and what we see is that you
- 12:04know you can exit either partially.
- 12:06Speaker 3: So we saw that with Ripswich when they.
- 12:08Speaker 2: Brought in bright Path, they bought them in for one
- 12:11hundred and six million, which was paid for what they
- 12:14paid for the club in the first place, and they
- 12:16still had sixty percent of the asset. And then you've
- 12:18got people like Man United or the Glaciers et cetera.
- 12:21They had any of us come in and they paid
- 12:23one points on two five billion for twenty five percent
- 12:26of the club right and given away the football operations.
- 12:30You know, for the Glaziers, that's perfect night because they've
- 12:32got the brand value, the commercial money coming in, that's
- 12:35what they really want. Leave that responsibility or the pitch
- 12:37to somebody else. So that's quite as a builder out
- 12:40of private excellent looking at going okay, I'm I'm not
- 12:43too sure this is going to work, you know.
- 12:45Speaker 3: Profitable in the end.
- 12:46Speaker 2: But is there another motive with Jim Madcliffe when we
- 12:50come up to individual orders.
- 12:52Speaker 3: Is that crossing over?
- 12:53Speaker 2: But we've also seen there's groups now forming where they
- 12:56only want like a minority stake in the commercial operations.
- 13:00So they're looking at thirty percent states and clubs that
- 13:02don't want nothing to do with the football operations. They
- 13:05just want to help drive up the revenues in the commercial,
- 13:08maximize their social media output and then try and generate.
- 13:11Speaker 3: The revenues and the value that way.
- 13:14Speaker 1: You know, our friend Jason Stevens, a consultant over in
- 13:17England for the Beautiful Game, hanging out with us here
- 13:20for our continued education when it comes to multi club ownerships.
- 13:24Third one is the individual and the individuals seem to
- 13:29be drifting away into the other two that we've been
- 13:33talking about. But motives for the individual idea of doing
- 13:37an MCO.
- 13:39Speaker 3: Yeah, I think you know.
- 13:40Speaker 2: The motives that we've just can overlap with the groups
- 13:43that we've just said. So if we look at the
- 13:45local owners for example, are they passion, are they purpose?
- 13:50Speaker 3: Are they profile?
- 13:51Speaker 2: And what we mean by purpose is that they feel
- 13:54it's like a community responsibility in social contribution through their
- 13:58various company entities, et cetera. That they feel they need
- 14:02to keep that club active and thriving in the community.
- 14:07You could say it's a profile for them where it
- 14:09provides like instant global recognition and access to probably elite
- 14:14social circles. I mean, the funny thing is when we
- 14:17go back to two thousand and five, Enroment and Bravivich
- 14:19coming to Chelsea. He was the first guy that was
- 14:22like from an outside of company in millions of pounds,
- 14:25just splashing them. And then he was also quite secretive
- 14:29in his profile. He didn't want people to know who
- 14:31he was. He was very very rarely did he do
- 14:33an interview, very rarely did he get himself exposed publicly.
- 14:38But it was that sort of I suppose bas football
- 14:41business was starting to evolve when people wanted to know
- 14:43who you're in as well and where he was reluctance
- 14:46to actually meet them halfway to interview. People started to
- 14:49then dig deeper into who are these guys? But it
- 14:51actually bought like an unkn well I would say, where
- 14:55it was unwelcomed at the time, but a spotlight, an
- 14:58element of fame showed this light on this guy that
- 15:01had this strategy of the way he was managing clubs,
- 15:04firing owner as if they weren't successful, making success because
- 15:07they were winning titles trophies every year. And Chelsea are still,
- 15:12if you come back to two thousand and five, twenty years,
- 15:14the most successful club in English football in terms of
- 15:16the amount of trophies they've actually won over that period,
- 15:19and you know that sort of profile. I wouldn't s
- 15:22advised that that was like an ignition for other private
- 15:26equity owners that got in there.
- 15:28Speaker 3: But then you've got obviously.
- 15:29Speaker 2: Relate back to state backed entities. It's about positioning, it's
- 15:33about power to portfolio diversification, et cetera.
- 15:37Speaker 3: And then private equity. What is it about?
- 15:40Speaker 2: Is it about profit? Is it about platform creation or
- 15:42player development? You know, player development is proving to be
- 15:46another model for where you know you can generate revenue
- 15:50streams from and you know the MCO groups are really
- 15:53really good at that.
- 15:54Speaker 3: I mean, you know, I just quickly go into this.
- 15:56Speaker 2: We look at four MCO groups, right the City Football
- 15:59Group now in the last three seasons they've generated six
- 16:03hundred million from their academy Chelsea two hundred and seventeen million,
- 16:08you have, not including this transfer windom as well. And
- 16:12then you've got Red Red Ball Group in the last
- 16:14three years generated over four hundred million, maybe.
- 16:17Speaker 3: A little bit surprising you guys.
- 16:19Speaker 2: Eagle Football Group has generated over two hundred and twenty
- 16:22five million and has also had a very busy summer
- 16:24as well. So we've got four different types of groups there.
- 16:27You've got state back fund, you've got private equity, and
- 16:29you've got wealthy.
- 16:30Speaker 3: Owners, and they're all generating.
- 16:32Speaker 2: They're creating a model which can generate vast quantities for
- 16:35player development.
- 16:37Speaker 1: Random question to wrap up this week. Yep, if you
- 16:41and this this is the this is the question that's
- 16:45kind of based on the Thiago Almada transaction. And I'm sure,
- 16:50and it's happened in the past with other groups and
- 16:51so on and so on. So if a club purchases
- 16:55a player and they have still yet to pay for
- 16:59the player, but they sell him on, how are they
- 17:03able to do that?
- 17:04Speaker 3: Then?
- 17:04Speaker 1: The machinations of the whole thing where you know, if
- 17:08if I if I pick up a player from a
- 17:11club and I still haven't paid the full amount on
- 17:15a player, and I sell him on and I still
- 17:18haven't paid you know, I still haven't paid the first guy,
- 17:21but I'm moving him on to a third guy. How
- 17:23is that transaction still allowed to happen if you haven't
- 17:26paid your if you haven't paid your debt to club
- 17:29number one, and you're moving him to club number three,
- 17:31how does this work?
- 17:32Speaker 3: Yeah?
- 17:33Speaker 2: Well, yeah, so the way that there's two sides to
- 17:35the financial accounting in football, Okay, you've got the player
- 17:39transfer and then you've got how you buy it. Okay,
- 17:42So for example, let's just look at like Declan Rice.
- 17:45For example, he went to Chelsea a couple of years
- 17:47so he went to Arsenal a couple of years ago.
- 17:49Speaker 3: The fee was one hundred and four million.
- 17:51Speaker 2: Now west Ham wanted that money paid up within twelve pounths.
- 17:56So Arsenal had to go to a creditor to give
- 17:59him that money up front, and they had to pay
- 18:02three installments, thirty straight away, thirty at Christmas, thirty before
- 18:06the window closed in the summer. Now on their accounts,
- 18:09because of the length of the contract, they can spread
- 18:12that out over five years. So with the creditor they go, look,
- 18:15we just pay you back over the five year the
- 18:17left of the contract. We don't necessarily have to pay
- 18:20you back in that one year that west Ham demanded
- 18:23that money. However, if you move that player on to
- 18:26another club, that club does have to settle that full
- 18:29transfer and has to settle that you cannot have ongoing
- 18:33transfer fees. Now that may happen in some leagues, but
- 18:36I know in the Premier League that car you have
- 18:38to close that transfer down.
- 18:39Speaker 3: Before you move it on again.
- 18:42Speaker 2: Now, there may be some loopholes in terms of the
- 18:45creditors and debtors that you can you know, just say,
- 18:49for example, Saint gil decle and Mice moves on to say,
- 18:54for example, my team Liverpool, he moves on to Liverpool
- 18:56as me wish for thinking. He moves on to Liverpool
- 18:59in the next couple of for next year. But he
- 19:01still got two years left on the debt. So Arsenal
- 19:04would say, right, he's got forty million left on that payment.
- 19:08So but the creditors, he may still have another sixty
- 19:11to seventy million, because it depends how they structured that
- 19:13deal with them. And again without fully answering that one.
- 19:18But there was a great example with Killian and Bape
- 19:20when he went to Monico a couple of years ago.
- 19:23Now he went for over one hundred and eighty million,
- 19:25but the way that they structured that deal was that
- 19:28they paid Monico the minimum amount in years one in
- 19:31year two so they could comply with PSR, and then
- 19:34when he got to year three, they gave him a
- 19:36bigger chunk in year four. Then they gave the majority
- 19:39of it in year five. But by the time he
- 19:41got to year five of his contract, they renegotiate the
- 19:44terms of the deal, and then they were able to
- 19:48leverage the payments for their own part over another five years,
- 19:51but for Monico that had to pay it all back.
- 19:54Speaker 3: In that time. A very creative and complicated.
- 19:58Speaker 1: Yeah, yes, and that was why that's why we bring
- 20:00you in to have these kinds of discussions about the
- 20:04creative aspects of all of this and how it now
- 20:07is coming together where you have groups of three different groups,
- 20:10three different subsets doing things kind of the same ways.
- 20:14It's just where the individuals are and where the money
- 20:17goes and how it is operated. Because I'm still false
- 20:21value and false revenue to me last week that was
- 20:23what blew my mind. I'm like, absolutely, yeah, that's the
- 20:26best way that I could phrase stuff like that. But
- 20:28now that I have those two terms in my head,
- 20:30I'm now keeping an eye on all of that stuff.
- 20:33What topic do you want to tackle next time?
- 20:35Speaker 2: Well, let's pick up a couple of MCOs, right, and
- 20:38let's have a look at them in more data, and
- 20:40we'll have a look at how private equity is actually
- 20:43work in those MCOs. There's some interesting sides through it.
- 20:51Working on an article at the moment when I'm just
- 20:54analyzing the private equity links within League one the frenually
- 20:59and it's actually quite scary when you see a couple
- 21:01of the American groups behind the Elliott Management and then
- 21:06you've got Redbird Capital. How they're working together, one lending
- 21:10then other one money to buy the club. Who's got control.
- 21:13It's a quite an interesting one. They've managed to map
- 21:16all the investigators. They can't determine it.
- 21:19Speaker 3: We've got things to look at them.
- 21:21Speaker 1: Wet looking forward to it. As always. I love these conversations.
- 21:24It's a great education and we can't thank you for
- 21:27being a part of everything here at SDH to educate
- 21:30us all on what's going on, especially where all the
- 21:32money's being hidden, where it's going, who's got it, who
- 21:35doesn't have it, where the interest rates are, what they're
- 21:37looking for, all these kinds of things. Jason, my friend.
- 21:39Great to see you again. We'll catch up with you
- 21:40next time.
- 21:41Speaker 3: Yeah, I appreciate it. Thank you,