Latest / Destiny Community Podcast / DCP Firing Range Ep. 62 - Let Bungie Cook! - Bungie Interview w/ Eric Smith & Mercules
Transcript
- 0:00There we go. Hello everyone, Thank you very much for joining us,
- 0:02and welcome to Firing Range, a podcast to talk about all things Destiny,
- 0:06weapons, abilities, loadouns, and the Sandbox at large. And tonight,
- 0:11grab a chaperone and consider yourself Amanda Holiday, because we've got a lineup so
- 0:15explosive you're going to get blown away. Boo. Allow me to introduce our
- 0:21two guests for tonight, gameplay feature lead at Bungee, Eric Smith. Eric,
- 0:27thank you very much for joining us, Thank you for having me,
- 0:30happy to be here. Quick little intro on who you are and what you
- 0:34do with Bungee. Sure, my name is Eric Smith. I'm game feature
- 0:39lead on Destiny two at Bungee, so working on things like you know,
- 0:44abilities, player movement, really anything that has to do with the way the
- 0:51feels to play the game. Great, And moving on to our other guest
- 0:57for this evening, former host of the show hashtag not Bitter, Associate weapons
- 1:03designer Mercules Merk. How you doing, buddy, Hello, glad to glad
- 1:08to be back. It's always fun joining you guys for some for some chatting
- 1:12about Destiny from from the other side of the from the other side of the
- 1:15Great Divide, I guess oh you damn right. Um. For people who
- 1:19might be new to the community or to the show, quick little intro on
- 1:23who you aren't what you do with Bungee. So my name is Mercules.
- 1:29I am an associate weapons designer. So basically what I do is I work
- 1:33on the weapons team to do the PvP and PVEE balance weapons. We build
- 1:37new legendary weapons, we build weapon perks, or build exotic weapons. Stuff
- 1:41like that. So very nice, and before we dive in, we just
- 1:46want to very quickly make a finger too clear and set expectations for you wonderful
- 1:53viewers and listeners at home. As mentioned, the guests tonight here from Bungee
- 1:59are from the Weapons and Abilities team. Okay, Therefore, there are certain
- 2:06topics that we, even though I'm sure we would all love to get into,
- 2:09we won't be able to because they are not able to comment on them,
- 2:14things like why'd your nerve stompies? I mean I would I would love
- 2:19to have that discussion if they are not here for that Weapons and Abilities team.
- 2:23These gentlemen are not here from the Armor team, nor can they talk
- 2:28about where dedicated servers Murk fixed the game fix the gamework not a question,
- 2:35but you know exactly what I'm what I'm saying. So again we're here to
- 2:40talk about weapons and abilities, and we appreciate them for coming on the show
- 2:45and giving us their time. You know who us other slubs are, and
- 2:49you don't care. We're on the clock. We have limited times, So
- 2:51why don't we go ahead and just shut up and dive right in? Cammy,
- 2:55Would you like to open the master document and maybe start rolling out?
- 3:00Yeah, I can start one. Two. I'll start with the aerial abilities
- 3:04one. So regarding those, often find that I'm fighting the map ceiling barrier
- 3:08and or the ground landing ampullans, you know, more than I'm fighting my
- 3:14opponents. So with the AA system existing and aerial build crafting trade offs and
- 3:20now the architect death prevention now existing, is there a realistic chance that maps
- 3:24in anti air systems can be given more attention in the future. Yeah,
- 3:31So this is a good question, you know, kind of on that topic
- 3:38of like it not necessarily being gameplay related, Like I can't really speak to
- 3:45so whether or not map changes are realistic for that because PPP maps aren't the
- 3:50responsibility of the gameplay team. That said, the general feel of combat is
- 3:54the gameplay team responsibility, So like, if those fearing with combat like it
- 4:00is something we can discuss with them. That said, I do know making
- 4:04map changes is not cheap, so okay, realistically, like I mean,
- 4:10I guess I can't speculate on whether or not the world our team has the
- 4:14bandwidth for that sort of thing. Um as for like the ground landing aim
- 4:18punch that is there for balance and immersion, we don't have any plans to
- 4:24change it. So that's that. Okay, we want to move on to
- 4:30someone else with a different question or have Mikey fire. I mean, we
- 4:32got more ability questions, Um, we can just do maybe a few if
- 4:36Murk doesn't mind sitting tied for a minute. I mean, we have no
- 4:39real organized format here. We've got questions that have been approved, but you
- 4:46know, yeah, yeah, keep it, keep it going. We're we
- 4:47got Eric warm, We're gonna We're gonna keep rolling here. So the next
- 4:51one is about the slide augmented melee abilities, and I know one of them
- 4:56is going to be added with Strand Titan, so it can be strong,
- 5:00but sometimes I prefer to use my standard ability melee during a slide, and
- 5:04unfortunately the keybind options don't allow for that separation. Another example is Acrobat Dodge
- 5:11and Frenzied Blade can be activated instantly to a side direction on controller, but
- 5:15not on M and K. On mouse and keyboard, it prioritizes the direction
- 5:19of the camera and I feel like there's some delay with mouse and keyboard on
- 5:25these abilities that makes it not really intuitive to use. And then another one
- 5:29with frenzy blade is used the ability melee, then your neutral melee back to
- 5:33back, it'll do a double ability melee. There's a couple more examples I
- 5:38could go into, But are all these changes something I should expect to be
- 5:42more intuitive in the future on both devices? You know, it's something we
- 5:47can look into, and yeah, you know your issue that is noted.
- 5:55I think you know, we do like to make quality of life changes when
- 5:59we can, but as with everything, we've got to prioritize it against other
- 6:02features that we're building and not I think for the directional lunge abilities and mouse
- 6:09keyboard like generally those abilities rely on like the speed and responsiveness of the mouse,
- 6:15aiming to be able to change direction instead of working off the players throttle.
- 6:19This is just how it's set up an engine we can it's we want
- 6:27to keep that consistent. But yeah, it's something we can maybe look at.
- 6:32I think making it making a toggle for the control our options might be
- 6:38possible. But it is a significant amount of work. That sounds incredible because
- 6:42there are some classes whereas the night and day difference of the ability. Sure,
- 6:46you know again, I'm not promising anything at all, because of course,
- 6:48of course it is. It is a significant amount of work for engineering
- 6:53teams, for UI teams, we've got to prioritize that against all sorts of
- 6:57other features. My thought was, I don't want to ask, then maybe
- 7:00it'll never happen. So that's true. You know, it can't hurt to
- 7:03ask so quick quick interjection, Now who who sets it? No? That
- 7:10was me? But go for it? Oh I'm sorry, no, you
- 7:12please go. No. I was going to go into a rant about we
- 7:15like how game development is hard, you know what I'm talking about, and
- 7:20still like this like where game development is hard. First off, I've heard
- 7:25that we have a long wish list of things we want to fix, but
- 7:30realistically it's hard to get to the things that aren't near the top of the
- 7:34list in terms of priority. We see we hear the sort of feedback we
- 7:40see, the Reddit post, the Folkus feedback posts, the Twitter threads,
- 7:44the YouTube videos, and we generally sympathize with all of this stuff, and
- 7:48a lot of times we added to our wish lists of things we want to
- 7:51do. But like, the truth of the matter is, our time and
- 7:55resources are limited. We've got to be selective about what we spend our time
- 7:59doing. That paired with the fact that when a new season launches, where
- 8:05we've already basically wrapped up the season after that, so like trying to shift
- 8:13gears back to a previous release takes a lot of resources away from our upcoming
- 8:18release. And some of these changes like this, like might seem easy to
- 8:24make on paper, especially it feels like it's changing one number, it's like
- 8:30a damage thing, but that often has cascading effects, like in a vacuum.
- 8:35Those changes are increasing a damage value or a range value seem like it
- 8:39might be fine, but then you combine it with you know, the other
- 8:43forty million moving parts in the game, and it can create unforeseen challenges.
- 8:48So even like simple changes, they need to test pass from a test team
- 8:52to make sure the low risk test passes aren't free that sort of thing.
- 8:58I'm said, I'm really glad I shut up and let you finish that tangent,
- 9:03my friend. At one time, any change is like steering a cruise
- 9:07ship or something like a very large ship. Just takes a lot of time
- 9:11and resources. Yeah, that's absolutely true. Okay, Um, I'm gonna
- 9:16jump in here real quick with a quick pivot to a Murk question. I
- 9:20love the Cammey questions. I feel like we need to fort Yeah, you
- 9:28know exactly where I'm going with this. Let's let's start with some questions that
- 9:31are probably on the tips of most people's tongues. So I get our handsome
- 9:35friend Murk to talk about SMGs. Here's a question that we have written down.
- 9:41Um, seems very likely that the weapons team knew that the Immortal was
- 9:45a beast on paper, and yet it was released into the wild. Anyway,
- 9:50How did how did things play out that way? And why did it
- 9:54take a full season to reel it in when we all knew it would go
- 9:58super hard? Yeah, this is actually a really good question. Was one
- 10:01that I was hoping that we'd get to because I think it's an interesting insight
- 10:05in like the way game development works to understand how something like this happens,
- 10:09right, And like we meeting the weapons seem actually did like a little bit
- 10:13of like a post mortem of like Immortal shifts and this was the result,
- 10:16and you know, how do we avoid something like this happening in the future,
- 10:20Right, And like, I know, it's pretty easy to say in
- 10:22retrospect, like wow, Immortal was you know, superpower crept and really strong,
- 10:28but it was actually like a little bit deeper than that. Right.
- 10:30There were like three main things that caused Immortal to happen. Basically. The
- 10:33first was we were releasing a Trials SMG when we had already released a Trials
- 10:39SMG, right, and the previous Trials SMG is pretty much unequivally like one
- 10:45of the best SMGs we've ever put into the game. Right. In addition
- 10:48to that, we had also just released the KLOSSMG, which is another aggressive
- 10:52SMG, And prior to that, we had borrowed Time, which, although
- 10:56it was like locked behind Gambit and like having super massive perk pools, is
- 11:00also incredibly strong. Right, So when we were working on this from a
- 11:03design standpoint, we kind of got a little bit carried away with the like
- 11:05it has to compete with shire As. It has to be better than Chelos
- 11:09and borrowed time, right, and we made sure to try to give it
- 11:13trade offs. So like Shiras does outrange a mortal, even with everything loaded
- 11:18up on a mortal, Shiras still outranges it. But the difference in range
- 11:22wasn't really enough because a mortal is more forgiving and has a faster ttk.
- 11:28Right, So we should have and now you see whe're we're using the range
- 11:31by ten, right, So like, really that should have been where it
- 11:33was at to begin with, right, Like we shouldn't have given it as
- 11:35much range as it had. We made sure to keep it Undershires, but
- 11:37it wasn't far enough Undershiras, so it became a solved equation, right,
- 11:41Like nobody was going to take Shiras over Immortal when you know, you were
- 11:46sacrificing a half meter of range, but you were getting you know, a
- 11:48tenth of a second faster ttk and more forgiveness on crits. So we kind
- 11:52of got a little bit, you know, carried away with the We've got
- 11:54to make sure it stacks up versus the other super powerful atoms that already exist
- 11:58in the sandbox. Or other eyes. It's not a worthy Trials reward,
- 12:01right, So that's problem one. Problem two is we totally underestimated the effect
- 12:07the target lock bug was going to have on its effectiveness. There's a number
- 12:09of reasons for this, but before ship, we discovered that target lock was
- 12:13bugged on guns with a rate of fire above a certain value, right,
- 12:18But we didn't fully understand like what was causing the issue and what effect the
- 12:22issue was having, right, So we made a change for target lock that
- 12:26was going to ship in the mid season patch. But what we really should
- 12:31have done is we should have understood that I was going to have a much
- 12:33larger effect on the effectiveness of the weapon and the forgiveness of the weapon,
- 12:35and we should have pulled that forward into a sooner patch or into you launch
- 12:39for lightfall, right, But we didn't. We eventually did end up pulling
- 12:41it forward, right like we pulled it out of the mid season patch.
- 12:43We pulled it forward a couple of weeks, and that actually had a pretty
- 12:46noted effect on the effectiveness of Immortal. Not necessarily usage of it, but
- 12:52the effectiveness of it dropped pretty significantly after target lock got nerved. And the
- 12:56third thing is is a lot of times we're okay with shipping weapons at our
- 13:00power crept as long as their path acquisition is challenging. Right, Like examples
- 13:03that this would be raid weapons, you know, dungeon weapons, trials weapons,
- 13:09stuff like that, like weapons that you really have to go into the
- 13:11endgame to get. Like we're okay shipping them a little bit stronger, a
- 13:15little bit power crept. On the raid side, we usually do it PDE
- 13:18focus. On the trial side, we do a PvP focus, right,
- 13:24We based on experience, Like we thought Trials is gonna be a much larger
- 13:28barrier to entry for the gun than it was. Like, I don't think
- 13:31anybody expected half a million players to play Trials like week one, a lot
- 13:35of people and just totally blow it up and to instantly flood the ecosystem with
- 13:39like God rules, right, Like we've been making trials more and more generous.
- 13:43Not we, but the you know Bungee in general, the rewards team
- 13:46has been making Trials more and more generous as time has gone on, and
- 13:50you know the population has made it to where like Exalted Truth, you still
- 13:54just don't see a ton of it, right, Like God rules of Exalted
- 13:56Truth they're still locked behind you know, going balls and farming the flawsable and
- 14:01stuff like that. So we kind of overestimated how much of a barrier to
- 14:03jury trials is going to be for like getting a perfect role of that gun.
- 14:09And then the first two weeks just like blew it all out of the
- 14:11water and totally flooded the sandbox with just like perfect roles of that weapon.
- 14:16So it was those three things in general that like allowed it to ship the
- 14:18way it did. So it was you know, missed estimations on our part
- 14:22and stuff like that, and like we were okay with the gun going out
- 14:24strong, not as strong as it did ship with target lock, but with
- 14:28target lock fixed. We were okay with it going out that strong if the
- 14:31only people who were going to be able to have it were like the super
- 14:33dedicated PvP players who were you know, working really really hard to get that
- 14:37weapon. But it ended up not playing out that way. The second part
- 14:41of the question, which is why did it take so long to balance again,
- 14:45there's a couple of things, like mostly because the usage and effectivest peaked
- 14:48at the beginning of the season and it's been trending downwards again. Effectiveness and
- 14:54usage, right, like, not just usage. We're gonna talk about that
- 14:56with some other questions later. People loved to mem the usage and balancing based
- 15:01on usage, right, But ironically a mortal is an example of like the
- 15:05biggest sin of the gun and its current state is actually its usage, right,
- 15:11Like, it has a huge amount of kills because it has a huge
- 15:13amount of usage. When you actually look at the effectiveness of the weapon,
- 15:16it is out of band. And that's why we're addressing it, right that
- 15:20we're reducing the range, and also we're nerving all aggressive SMGs in season twenty
- 15:24one. So I'm not saying it's not out of band. It is.
- 15:28But in order for us to like pull a fix forward a significant amount of
- 15:33time, something has to be like seriously, seriously out of band where it's
- 15:37like jeopardizing the sandbox as a whole, right, And so examples of that
- 15:39would be like hard light, that's when we hot fix stuff, right,
- 15:43hard light, special AMMA, linear fusion rifles, DMT, right, Like,
- 15:46there have been times where we have hot fix something because it is legitmate
- 15:48jeopardizing in the sandbox. And like a good example of that is DMT had
- 15:52less than half the usage of a Mortal but was getting nearly as many kills
- 15:56on a given weekend. Right, the effectiveness of DMT was almost twice as
- 16:00high as the effectiveness of Immortal was. So in general, right A Mortal
- 16:04promotes an aggressive play style, but there are counters to it. You can
- 16:07play range, you can use fusions, you can use woven mail to reduce
- 16:11the effectiveness of it, and hitting target lock did substantially drop the guns effectiveness,
- 16:17like massively dropped out effective the weapon was. Right, So it's super
- 16:21super annoying to hear, like like every single game forever, and we totally
- 16:26understand and sympathize with that, but it's not just like overtly oppressive the way
- 16:30something like hard Light was. And so, you know, with the usage
- 16:33and effectiveness trending down week over week over week, players figured out how to
- 16:38play around it a little bit better on certain maps. It was nice to
- 16:41see that, but you know, we didn't feel like it was a high
- 16:44enough priority to you know, potentially make a risky decision and pull a change
- 16:47forward that could have cascading ripple effects and make stuff worse, right as opposed
- 16:51to fix in something. So we had to fix in place for season twenty
- 16:53one, and we're going to shift that fix and we think it's going to
- 16:56have, you know, a substantial effect on on the weapons and we'll see.
- 17:03Let's talk about that real quick. Um, So we got the immortal
- 17:07changes right, which are the is cutting what the range back by ten I
- 17:11believe, and then and then the ag frame changes as a whole, which
- 17:17is changing the so the damage is tweaking in a way that the krip damage
- 17:22is going from twenty eight twenty one point eight right now on one kryp shot
- 17:26to just twenty one in season twenty one. I don't know if a lot
- 17:33of people would read a numeric change like that and really feel the weight of
- 17:37the change like we do. We feel that the that change is going to
- 17:42be enough to curb the really excessive agframe SMG usage being seen in PvP right
- 17:48now. Well, we're also dropping the body shot damage from fifteen to fourteen,
- 17:52right, so, like body shot damage is getting decreased, that's why
- 17:56we're increasing the precision multiplier. But precision damages going down, right, So
- 18:00it's losing damage flat across the board, almost a point of damage on both
- 18:04body shots and krits. And yeah, I mean, it's gonna make a
- 18:07difference, right, because you're going to go from a point six seven TTK
- 18:11to a TTK and the mid point sevens, right, which is it might
- 18:15not sound like a lot, but one tenth of a second is a huge
- 18:18difference in terms of weapon effectiveness. Right. It's going to put it a
- 18:22lot more in line with where precision SMGs are because it's a lot more in
- 18:26line with the range of precision SMGs, and it's going to kind of separate
- 18:30it from lightweights and adaptives, which kill a little bit faster but are less
- 18:34range. So it's gonna make a difference. It's also going to make it
- 18:37less forgiving, right, So it's going to be more krit dependent, and
- 18:41it's gonna you know, like, is it going to dumpster aggressive SMGs?
- 18:45I definitely don't think so, Like that's not the intent. The intent is
- 18:48not to be like, oh, never use an aggressive SMG again. They're
- 18:51awful, right, right, And people don't like that we are hitting the
- 18:55entire aggressive SMG subfamily at one time. But the truth of the matter was,
- 19:00aggressives have always been super lethal, but they've been held in check by
- 19:03like really poor stat packages. Right. If you think of cold front or
- 19:06you think of harsh truths. You know, like with the exception of Iklos,
- 19:10SMGs and a couple of exotics, aggressives have always had really poor stat
- 19:12packages to kind of offset the high lethality that they offered. But they were
- 19:18seeing they were just not seeing any success anywhere, right, right, except
- 19:22for bar time, which again you know, cracked but ridiculously hard to farm.
- 19:26So what we started doing with Icholos is we started saying, okay,
- 19:29well, like, what if we gave them better stats, are people going
- 19:30to use them? The answers, yes, they are. So now we
- 19:33have to walk back that lethality to a place where the gun feels good to
- 19:37use and isn't overtly lethal, right, because like you tried the hyper lethal
- 19:41but bad stats. So now we're kind of flipping around a little bit and
- 19:44we're like, let's give them better stats and make them less lethal. Right,
- 19:47So we're trying to find the place where aggressives can can live. So
- 19:49in the future you should expect more aggressives that are in line with like the
- 19:53Kolos Immortal, even the title you know, is not great stat wise,
- 19:57but like got some pretty good perk options, right, Like you should expect
- 20:00aggressives in the future to be more in line with that. So that's why
- 20:03we're bringing the entire subfamily down in terms of its effectiveness. You know it's
- 20:11gonna it's a start, but I think the honest, like the honest truth
- 20:14is, like the bigger change for SMG's as a whole is going to be
- 20:17the zoom and like damage fall off stuff that's coming in season twenty two.
- 20:21Like, I think that's going to be like more of a clamp on the
- 20:27effectiveness of those weapons. I really want to jump back to Eric in a
- 20:32minute, but just because you brought that up, we'll do a nice little
- 20:36round sort of round added end on that, merc rant I guess before we
- 20:41jump over to another ability question for Eric, because one of our questions that
- 20:45we had lined up was that, you know, y'all had mentioned a potential
- 20:48future adjustment to range finder and zoom across the board. We got a little
- 20:52bit of a sneak peek of that today in the Wednesday twelve what are we
- 20:56calling it the the Bungee block This Wednesday at Bungee, What information can you
- 21:03share about the future zoom changes so season twenty two is when we should expect
- 21:10that and like give a layman's what's it going to look like? What's it
- 21:12going to feel like? Yeah? And why are we doing it? We're
- 21:17actually really excited about this change. The only reason we couldn't do it sooner
- 21:21as we actually had to build some new tech to allow us to do it.
- 21:22So we had to get engineering support to basically build the technology to allow
- 21:26us to break this stuff out. But like, the foundation is that zoom
- 21:32is one of the most powerful stats in the sandbox. It does a lot
- 21:36of stuff. When you increase the zoom of a weapon it currently in live
- 21:41in the game you're playing, it increases the damage fall off distance, so
- 21:44your damage falloff starts farther away and it ends farther away. It increases the
- 21:48autoam fall off distance. Your autoam is effective for longer distances. It increases
- 21:52your accuracy, it decreases your recoil right, and then there are supposed to
- 21:56be some tradeoffs that come along with it, And the tradeoffs are that it
- 21:59narrows your field of view and it narrows your amosis cone a little bit.
- 22:03Right. The field of view thing has almost like no effect outside of like
- 22:07pretty high values, So that is a negligible decrease. The narrowing of the
- 22:12amosis cone is somewhat more effective. I know certain people like Drew You've preferred
- 22:15not to play with rangefinder before because of the narrowing of the amessis cone and
- 22:18the effect that it has on the weapon. Right, But we were so
- 22:22hesitant to do anything to zoom because zoom is very integral to how a weapon
- 22:26feels, and if you just straight up decouple zoom from all of those things,
- 22:30you can make weapons end up feeling really bad. And so we didn't
- 22:33want to do that. So we came up with a solution where we were
- 22:34only going to break out one part of that step. We were going to
- 22:37pull it away, so damage fall off is now no longer affected by zoom
- 22:42at all. So zoom continues to effect, it continues to affect recoil reduction,
- 22:51it continues to increase accuracy, but it is not going to push out
- 22:56damage fall off distance anymore. And instead, what we're going to do is
- 23:00we're going to give fixed damage fall off scalers to every type of weapon when
- 23:04they go ads. Right, So SMGs, for example, are going to
- 23:08have a fixed damage fall off scaler of one point four times. It doesn't
- 23:11matter what your zoom value is. When you go ads, your damage fall
- 23:15off is going to be multiplied by one point four, right, And we're
- 23:18going to set those values. We're going to fix those values for every type
- 23:22of weapon across the board, right. And what it allows us to do,
- 23:26and the best part of this is it allows us to make like hard
- 23:30range brackets for weapon effectiveness. Whereas right now, because zoom can push out
- 23:33damage fall off, you can end up with a rapid fire pulse rifle that's
- 23:37effective at fifty five meters, or you can end up with antiopen SMG which
- 23:41is effective at you know, twenty seven meters, or you can end up
- 23:45with all these weird combinations of guns where they're like pushing outside of their effectiveness
- 23:48windows and they're bleeding into the effectiveness of other weapons. And not only do
- 23:53they invalidate every weapon that then doesn't have that same zoom value, but they
- 23:57invalidate you know, for example, high zoom SMGs. We're invalidating auto rifles
- 24:03like seven twenty auto rifles for a long time. So what we've done in
- 24:07this first pass is we've kind of defined our ranges right where short range is
- 24:11going to be, you know, zero to twenty three and a half meters
- 24:15and zero to eight meters is really more like shotgun in melee range than it
- 24:18is like weapon range or primary weapon range. And then mid range is going
- 24:23to be twenty three and a half meters to forty meters, and then long
- 24:26range is going to be outside of forty meters. And because we're able to
- 24:30bracket all these weapons now really strongly, we can start using zoom to kind
- 24:34of manipulate weapon fuel and differentiate weapons without necessarily saying, hey, we're going
- 24:38to give this rapid fire pulse rifle twenty zoom. All of a sudden,
- 24:42it's the rangiest pulse rifle in the game. Right right, It's not going
- 24:45to work like that anymore. And Drew, I know you're gonna be happy
- 24:48with this. We're pushing BXR Battler back up to twenty zoom because we're able
- 24:51to make this change. So I knew that was something that he was going
- 24:53to Like, that's just like a lot of moving pieces and a lot of
- 24:59work, like you're doing a custom job on almost like every weapon archetype sub
- 25:03archetype in the game. That is, we literally built a calculator that takes
- 25:08every weapon in the game and it's current range values and it's possible range values
- 25:12with zoom, and then we built another calculator that like translates all those down
- 25:18into what we found to be like the more appropriate ranges for everything. Right.
- 25:22So in addition to doing this, like we know that there are some
- 25:26weapons that only compete in the sandbox because they have abnormal zoom values, right,
- 25:30or there are some weapons that feel bad because they don't have abnormal zoom
- 25:33values. So like we're also doing a range you know, damage fall off
- 25:37start rebalance on a bunch of different weapon types to kind of move them around
- 25:41a little bit so they don't get left behind. Because like, imagine if
- 25:44we just took damage fall off away from range finder and we didn't do anything
- 25:47to hand cannons, right, like, all of a sudden, all the
- 25:49best hand cans in the game would be less rangey and they wouldn't compete with
- 25:52pulse rifles and stuff like that. Or you know, imagine if we did
- 25:56this to SMG's, well, all the low range SMGs that we're relying on
- 26:02range finder just to be usable, would all of a sudden not be very
- 26:04good at you. So we're going to be you know, we're gonna be
- 26:07taking a look at every single archetype of weapon in the game, making sure
- 26:11that they have a place that they you know, that their range values make
- 26:15sense. And then yeah, we're going to be giving them all the fixed
- 26:18ads scalers. So I'm actually like, really really super excited about this change.
- 26:21I think from a player perspective, it's gonna feel it's gonna feel really
- 26:26readable, it's gonna feel really good, and I think it's going to create
- 26:30like better engagement windows where there's less of like I literally can't compete with this
- 26:36thing at this distance, you know, like high impact pulse rifles for example,
- 26:40where outside of forty meters, you're like, if I'm not using a
- 26:42scout, I can't touch this person and it feels really bad. And so
- 26:48the ability to clamp those distances means that like we should hopefully alleviate a lot
- 26:52of those issues. Okay, I'm going to before we jump back over to
- 26:57Eric one sentence answer going to be the doctor Malcolm to your John Hammond.
- 27:03That sounds really complicated, great but complicated. Is there any chance that things
- 27:08will go horribly wrong. This sounds like a really big change. Our raptor
- 27:11is going to break out of the fence and kill people. No, I
- 27:15mean we didn't want to move things a huge amount. So everything is going
- 27:19to be very similar to where it is in Live right now. There's not
- 27:22going to be like a huge sweeping change where you're like, I'm used to
- 27:26pulse rifles working at you know, fifty meters and now they only work at
- 27:29twenty meters. Right, It's not it's not going to be anything like that.
- 27:32Like we're not totally picking things up and moving them around. We're just
- 27:37taking the outer edges and like compressing them a little bit or in some cases
- 27:41expanding them. And like rangefinder even like we pulled the damage fall off obviously
- 27:47out of zoom. All rangefinder does as a perk is increased zoom. So
- 27:49rangefinders a perk now is still going to do the other things. And people
- 27:52are like, oh, you're nerfing rangefinder. It's like, well, let
- 27:55me phrase rangefinder in a different way for you. What rangefinder now does is
- 27:57it increases stability, it increases amosis fall off distance, and it increases accuracy.
- 28:03Right, So like, let me phrase it like that instead of saying
- 28:06it just increases zoom, because what was actually the truth is that Ranchfinder was
- 28:08a super super super OPI park up until this point, and now it's kind
- 28:14of like in band as far as a left column park goes good stuff.
- 28:18That was more than one sentence, by the way, but I'm I'm gonna
- 28:21let you get away with it because one there at all. Yeah, just
- 28:26one bread So Mark's since it's on a scaler, would that mean that at
- 28:33the point of fall off, would it hold it a little bit longer like
- 28:37the damage? Does that make sense? So it will depend on what the
- 28:41weapon had before, Right, So if you were a high like if you
- 28:45were an abnormally high zoom and your damage is going to fall off faster now
- 28:48than it would before. If you were a you know, a lower zoom
- 28:56weapon, you're going to get the benefit on both sides. So it kind
- 28:59of is going to depend on what the what the gun was before. And
- 29:02that's part of clamping everything into a range band, right, is like we
- 29:06are pushing damage fall off start out a little bit in some cases, but
- 29:11in some cases we're not pushing damage falloff end out at the same time.
- 29:15Right, So you're going to hold full damage for longer, but once it
- 29:18starts falling off, it's going to fall off faster. And there's certain weapons
- 29:21that are going to, you know, experience that more than others. Side
- 29:23arms and SMGs, for example, are going to experience that more than others
- 29:26because we don't want them operating outside of their range band, right, Like
- 29:30you don't want side arms hitting at twenty meters. You don't want SMGs hitting
- 29:33it twenty five, twenty six, twenty eight meters, right like, you
- 29:36don't want that. So they're going to become less effective much more quickly now
- 29:40once they hit that value, whereas other weapons like auto rifles for example,
- 29:45are going to now hold those values longer. Right, So auto rifles might
- 29:48hit damage fall off, but the damage is going to fall off pretty slowly.
- 29:52So they're going to maintain some usefulness outside. And we kind of divided
- 29:55that up by like rifle class versus like you know, handheld class. So
- 30:00hand cannon's got a little bit of both because like you know, I felt
- 30:03like they needed it, So handcan's got a little buff on both ends.
- 30:06But Okay, that was all really good. I appreciate that, Drew.
- 30:10I'm looking over the document right now, you have a fair amount of ability
- 30:15questions. Eric's been very patient. Appreciate that Drew. Once you comb through,
- 30:21give give Eric something. Sure, let's poke's brain a little bit here.
- 30:26Yeah, I think this is a good one to start with. I
- 30:29think the Titan barricade has gained a lot of popularity and recognition for its strength.
- 30:36It's able to act as effective cover for peak shooting, like popping in
- 30:40and out of cover for shooting, taking space and applying pressure with safety obviously
- 30:45not being able to get shot and even just peak into lanes without any risk.
- 30:48And this is a lot more apparent and things like let's say elimunition game
- 30:52modes, but not limited to that against snipers. I think a lot of
- 30:56players right now feel it's a bit too frequent or maybe difficult countercurrently taking a
- 31:02little too long to shoot down, or maybe even grenades not acting on the
- 31:07same cool down window as it, or like frequent enough to match them.
- 31:11I wanted to know just in general, like what are your thoughts on the
- 31:14barricades current strength or is there any plans around that or changes or yeah,
- 31:22yeah, barricades good. I agree. I think we want it to be
- 31:27good, but it does also need to be balanced, you know, barricade.
- 31:34We did nerf the barricade cool down by around thirty three in lightfall,
- 31:41though we are willing to look at other options if we still feel like it's
- 31:44too good, including barricade health, which hasn't been touched in a while.
- 31:52Barricades currently take more damage from Special Ammo. How do y'all feel about that?
- 31:56Like as a counter to like, I I'm sorry, Oh, it's
- 32:06all good. It's also she piercing, Uh Ammo will do it too,
- 32:12But like I mean, don't get me wrong, I love that Special Ammo
- 32:16you know does extra damage to a barricade, but I usually like to conserve
- 32:21it for um people. Um sure, yeah, I think that it's good
- 32:29that there are sinks like that for Special Ammo at times, and like there
- 32:31are times where like I know, Cam can kind of attest to this one
- 32:35we're playing, Like I always just say, like just just do just dumped
- 32:37the special, Like who cares, Like we're gonna lose if you if you
- 32:39don't do it. Just just dump the Special. But you'll find that,
- 32:43like there are some players will that will know you're going to do that,
- 32:45So let's say, for example, like shotguns are very very frequently used.
- 32:50If someone knows that I'm going to challenge and I'm going to pop their barricade,
- 32:52they know to like that there's a window of time that I can't shoot
- 32:57now that they're just going to challenge me, and I've already had to put
- 33:00myself in the danger in order to do that. So that like that seems
- 33:04like part of the weird thing to tackle. For snipers, it's a little
- 33:08bit more practical, I guess, because obviously you have range fusions. I
- 33:13think are fusions are probably the most practical because you can set at mid range
- 33:15a little bit, you can maybe play your own a little bit of cover
- 33:17and threaten it. But at that point sometimes they're just going to get away
- 33:22from the danger. So it feels like I'm happy that there's like sinks I'm
- 33:25gonna call like special weapons sinks or special amo sinks and things I give you
- 33:30that option for like right now, it just feels like you're they're either getting
- 33:34out of the danger or like you put yourself in the danger and they're given
- 33:37a chance to capitalize on you for something that feels like it should be like
- 33:42I'm countering this. I'm using this to conscious like I'm wasting this economy to
- 33:47have an advantage. Yeah, that's fair. It's a hard one with barricades
- 33:54because it has the titan. It feels really bad to pop your barricade in
- 33:59it have it just disappear immediately. You know what we can do about it?
- 34:06You know, maybe maybe health is a lever there. I think we
- 34:09talked about this concept of class envy a lot. We want hunters to be
- 34:15like, why do they get a barricade, why do they get a dodge?
- 34:20Why do they get a risk? You know what I'm saying. So,
- 34:21like, I understand where it comes from, and it's it's by design
- 34:25a little bit. But yeah, if those attributes are not balanced correctly,
- 34:34it makes problems. Yeah, well we'll see how it's feeling. It's funny
- 34:39because like every time we shift a bunch of things around into a new season,
- 34:45even if we didn't directly touch that thing, there are other things that
- 34:49are affecting the entire ecosystem of the sandbox. So we will absolutely keep an
- 34:54eye on it here in season twenty one. UM on the subject of I'm
- 35:00sorry, Drew g you have a follow up there I feel like we might
- 35:02be the same place. But I was gonna say, would you mind if
- 35:06I piggyback with a is this about question? No? No, I was
- 35:10gonna ask about or objective game modes, but yours is more. Well,
- 35:15we can do yours and then and then roll into mine. Sure, yeah,
- 35:17go for it. Okay, So I was gonna say, you mentioned
- 35:21that, like, you know, class envy and that like that's kind of
- 35:23like a thing, and I definitely respect that A big reason I ask where
- 35:29the Barrica is. I'm someone that I love objective modes, and they're starting
- 35:31to become more prevalent, like with the introduction of like the Trials changes I
- 35:36believe, and objectives are becoming more of a of a factor in Destiny PvP,
- 35:40which I love. But a common pain point or criticism of objective game
- 35:45modes are those abilities like the Titan barricade, maybe riffs. I know a
- 35:52lot of people talk about while of Radiance or World have done. And I
- 35:54guess I just wanted to then I'll ask if you wanted to elaborate or ask
- 35:58about your thoughts on those abilities in objective game modes. Yeah, and like
- 36:05and maybe what or any sort of opportunities there are for balancing around those game
- 36:10modes. Yeah, that's it's a complex question because you know, we really
- 36:16like having objective modes in the game on the gameplay team, but we do
- 36:22need to consider the entire game when making balance changes, so it's unlikely for
- 36:28us to make sweeping decisions based on one or two modes, especially if those
- 36:34most are time limited. I think there are certainly opportunities for targeted changes where
- 36:39they make sense, but we don't want to make changes that are going to
- 36:44cause the player experience where the game feel of those abilities to suffer in other
- 36:49parts of the game. So you know, instead of nurfing ward and well
- 36:54outright across the game, we'd rather consider, like what can we give players
- 37:00to deal with an enemy ward well when they see one. I think we
- 37:04have ways to go there as far as making accessible options that you didn't necessarily
- 37:13like pre plan for, right, and this going back to like the the
- 37:19barricade or the ward thing, Like we've tried things where we create certain weapon
- 37:28perks or whatever to like do more damage to those things, but like the
- 37:32problem is that we also don't want to require players to jump into their inventories.
- 37:38These switching weapons like as soon as they see something like that, right,
- 37:43because it's just not realistic. I think, uh, special AMMO because
- 37:51it's generally something that players have unless they're running double primary, like, is
- 37:55something that is universal enough to be a solid counter. But saying yeah,
- 38:02you need this certain ability or this certain weapon park to like deal with with
- 38:08a board or a well isn't a great solution. So we're still thinking about
- 38:15that. I was gonna say, as long as we were on the topic
- 38:19of barricades, Cammy, I couldn't help but notice that you and I have
- 38:22a near identical question about the changes coming to fragment slots on aspect, that's
- 38:30a great pivot point you want you want to roll into that one there?
- 38:34Yeah, real quick though, I want to just add to Drew's initial question
- 38:37on the Titan barricade and just remind that to me, it is just how
- 38:43much Titans could throw a barricade, and if it costs sniper AMMO or a
- 38:46grenade, it just leads the economy, so it's almost always the right choice.
- 38:52Okay, now I'll move on. Okay, So it's been announced that
- 38:55the minimum fragment slots are being an increased to two on aspects are previously only
- 39:00allowed one. Many of the aspects were pretty strong in PvP. It's like
- 39:05Trappers, Ambush, Shattered Eye, Bastion, leaving their counterparts as viable options
- 39:10mainly for their extra fragment slot. So any thoughts on how increasing the fragment
- 39:15slots on most aspects may affect balancing and player choice. Yeah, so increasing
- 39:23fragment slots will absolutely affect player choice of aspects, but we also want to
- 39:31give players as many build crafting opportunities as possible. Having one fragment slot,
- 39:38we just feel like it generally feels bad, so we'd like to avoid it
- 39:42where possible. Fragment slots are part of the overall value proposition of an aspect
- 39:49when you look at it, what am I going to quip? I'm going
- 39:51to quip this one? Am I going to quip that one? And if
- 39:54that value is too high because of the fragment slots, we can look at
- 39:58the functionality of the aspect itself and bring it in line. And we still
- 40:04want the option of granting only one slot as a balance lever. We're actually
- 40:08considering giving one fragment slots to one of the season twenty two strand aspects that
- 40:14we're working on because the aspect is bretty spicy. Um, can we know
- 40:20which one? Nope? Um, but it's it's gonna be cool. We
- 40:27don't think giving yeah players like one more fragment slot is generally gonna cross cost
- 40:32too much power creep. So we'll be looking at the usage data to make
- 40:37sure we don't have any dead aspects if if you know, so for the
- 40:43mars, like for the most part, like if for example, like if
- 40:47Bashion in season twenty one, people are like, whoa two fragment slots,
- 40:52Like I wasn't crazy enough to like I should have been using that already,
- 40:55but I'm gonna use it now. Like, so the play is maybe if
- 41:00we see the usage numbers like skyrocketing for an aspect that just got that buff,
- 41:05the plays maybe to like maybe reevaluate what the aspect does rather than being
- 41:08like, let's take back that extra fragment slot that we just gave them.
- 41:15Excuse me, Yeah, I'd prefer that, okay, but it's hard to
- 41:20say until we actually you know, across that bridge. I think looking at
- 41:28Baston in particular, like it already has a significant barricade cool down penalty.
- 41:34We don't think it's potency is like wildly out of band. I think it's
- 41:37easy. Use is pretty high, and it's you know, augmenting something you're
- 41:42doing all the time anyway, which is is casting barricade. So um,
- 41:47it's definitely when we're gonna keep in our eye on, our eye on.
- 41:50But I think right now at ten resilience you're getting like one bastion barricade a
- 41:54minute. So we'll see. All right, all right, Uh, let's
- 42:04see here, Mark, Let's talk about a underused under the radar exotic weapon
- 42:14that some people probably have never heard before nor have ever seen in PvP called
- 42:20le Monarch. Let's talk about that boat for a minute, shall we?
- 42:23Uh? What are what are the weapons? Teams thoughts on the Monarch's current
- 42:30viability in PvP? Is it is it? Do you all think it's not
- 42:36spicy? Too spicy? It's you know, it feels it feels a little
- 42:40weak. We've got a buff coming for it in season twenty two to just
- 42:44allow it to one shot, you know, natively all the time. Now,
- 42:47it's uh, in all seriousness, we do believe that Lemon's Lemon's time
- 42:51is fast approaching, really Okay, Yeah, we've got a change checked in
- 42:54for it right now that we feel pretty good about. Actually, um,
- 42:59it moves the damn image in the draw time profile to match or not not
- 43:01to match exactly, but to be closer to that of a lightweight though,
- 43:05because I'm sure some of you guys are know as it actually has the lightweight
- 43:07intrinsic like secretly on it. So we're gonna shift the draw time is going
- 43:14to be a little bit faster, but the damage is going to come down,
- 43:16you know, pretty substantially to match what lightweights do currently. And then
- 43:21we're also going to reduce the duration of the burn that it applies to players.
- 43:24Right now, it's a three second burn and we're we're looking at reducing
- 43:28that down to about a second and a half. So between those two things,
- 43:32we've been play testing it a good bit and doing less chunk damage upfront
- 43:37and having the DT burn off faster has made a pretty significant improvement and how
- 43:43it feels to play against La Monarch without necessarily like crushing La Monarch and making
- 43:51it feel awful to use. And in PVEE, the feedback that we've gotten
- 43:54as the draw time actually makes it feel better to use, and we buffed
- 43:58the damage of time damage in PVEE so that it's not losing you know,
- 44:02damage overall. So I think the DPS is actually coming up in PvE UM
- 44:07and in PvP. Yeah, the goal was still. It still feels good
- 44:09to use, but it doesn't feel nearly as bad to play against. I'm
- 44:15just I'm just soaking in the information. I'm basking and I exceeded any expectation
- 44:20I had. I was good. That was a good answer. That was
- 44:22a banger. Yeah, wow, Okay, cool, um are there?
- 44:29I guess this kind of similar question. Are there any other weapons in the
- 44:32sandbox that the team might be quote keeping an eye on for you know,
- 44:38future tweakage? Yeah, Jack Smith, the class always like the ifr on
- 44:45is turned upon vacts and I'm just waiting for for a reason. I think
- 44:50the acquisition of that weapon is you know, challenging, and that's probably what's
- 44:53kept it down. But you know, as the community likes to point out
- 44:58to us, usage doesn't equal strength, and that gun is ridiculously ridiculously strong.
- 45:01Apparently it's by the usage being low, So we're keep an eye on
- 45:05that. A couple of new ones that have come up especially with like the
- 45:08some of the changes that came in seven hundred or Crimson has like risen dramatically.
- 45:14That gun was always pretty strong, but some usage issues with it kind
- 45:19of kept it low, like in terms of how difficult it actually was to
- 45:22use it, like high field of view and stuff. But I think people
- 45:23are figuring out how to play around that, and it's effectiveness is has always
- 45:29been high, but it's it's usage is rising to match that as well.
- 45:31Um So Crimson is something we're keeping an eye on. You know. I
- 45:37don't want to say this because I know it's gonna hurt cool guys feelings,
- 45:39But like we're we've we've were given a side eye to cloud strike right now.
- 45:44I don't think that there's anything wrong with it. I'm just saying I
- 45:46don't think there's anything wrong with it. It's just sometimes you can't even deny
- 45:50that that lightning strike feels just a little bit free, doesn't it. Hey,
- 45:53dude, it's because y'all shifted more of the way y'all did. People
- 45:59had to put it many. We don't have any change We don't have any
- 46:04change plan for cloud Strike. I think it's one of those weapons that just
- 46:07like is a super fun power fantasy and feels great to use. So like,
- 46:10we don't have anything, you know, we don't have anything uh plan
- 46:14for it. We don't plan a nerve it or anything but plan it is
- 46:15just something we're keeping an eye on, right Like if you see a sniper
- 46:19that's like top ten on a cauldron trials, right, like, you got
- 46:22to ask some questions about what's going on ever there. So you know we're
- 46:27we're keeping an eye on it. But as far as buffs go, uh,
- 46:30we've always got an eye on exotics that are underperforming. I think black
- 46:34talent is something that we're looking at. Buffing um lightweight shotguns right now are
- 46:37underperforming a little bit. And PvP, Uh, those like two little horizontal
- 46:43pellets are you know, you have a tendency to really only hit one or
- 46:45the other. You can't really hit both. So we're looking at pulling those
- 46:47two horizontal pellets in to make the spread a little bit tighter so they're a
- 46:52little bit more effective in PvP. So we've got we've got a good bit
- 46:54of stuff we're looking at buffing as well. It's not it's not all nerves.
- 47:00I really wanted to get back to Eric, but question, is there
- 47:04anything else that you any other guns murk on the table, not not that
- 47:07we're going to share today. I don't. I mean we have some other
- 47:12like you guys have some specific questions that you want to ask. I think
- 47:15no time to explain is probably on the brain. But we'll we'll cross average
- 47:17when we get right now. I don't know, I don't like that.
- 47:20Let's move past that. Let's get back to back to Eric. There,
- 47:23cool guy, hit him, hit him, hit him up? Sure?
- 47:25Um okay, kind of a two part question here. Um, we have
- 47:30auto Melee coming soon. Um. And for a number of reasons. You
- 47:34know that you know, on the technical standpoint, kind of prevents overstampling.
- 47:37You know, your Melee is going to be as fast as a little RPM
- 47:40for melee. It's also for um, what's the word I'm looking for?
- 47:46Um? I guess just easier accessibility. Right. So it's a cool feature.
- 47:51And on the other side with the Melee system, for a while,
- 47:55we've had some like frequent instances of teleporting and rubber banding for the character models.
- 48:01That's you. Well, it's tied to a lunge most of the time,
- 48:05but it can happen without the lunge and even with your super you have
- 48:08instances where the melee isn't registering on targets and that can be super frustrating.
- 48:14So can you give any details as to why that's happening. Yeah, so
- 48:21this really is a better question for a gameplay engineer. But what I can
- 48:25say is that melee networking is hard. We can't really account for every network
- 48:35situation. On the design side, we would like to try to try some
- 48:39things to kind of mitigate rubber banding. In season twenty one, we're making
- 48:44changes to some of the extended lunge range perks, like Knockout an Afidian aspect.
- 48:51In the future, I could see a world where you just don't extend
- 48:54Lunde range to try to improve this. You know, if I was gonna
- 49:01armchair engineer this, i'd say, you know, players in Destiny move really
- 49:07quickly, and there's a lot of prediction going on in like networking player positions
- 49:15to all the clients. So when those melee registration issues generally happen, it's
- 49:22when clients don't agree on the positioning of the players, and it usually happens
- 49:25when players are moving very quickly. High school players are more likely to be
- 49:30moving quickly and notice it as well. I think it's something we are continuing
- 49:38to look at, but again, non an engineer, so I can't say
- 49:43how how realistic it is. That's for automanly. Yet we're really excited to
- 49:46get that into the game, primarily as an accessibility option for players who can't
- 49:53spam buttons, you know, yeah, quickly and that sort of thing.
- 49:58I My ears were burning there. You mentioned a key word that appears multiple
- 50:04times in the document, and that word is knockout. Drew, you had
- 50:08a question for Eric on knockout, did you not? Yeah? Just beforehand
- 50:15followed there's a few comments about Eric being a little quiet. I just tweaked
- 50:19it. I just tweaked his volume up. Yeah, sorry about that,
- 50:22folks. We did some audio testing before, but you know, not always
- 50:28perfect in podcast land. So hopefully people can hear Eric a little bit better
- 50:30now. If his volumes are better, let me know in the chat,
- 50:34and if not, I will continue to raise him. Thank you, Drew.
- 50:37Yeah, no, Wurris so m Stryker Titan's knockouts, as you said,
- 50:43being nerf to, which is pretty great. But as far as I'm
- 50:46aware, and I could be incorrect on this. I believe it last for
- 50:50multiple males on a timer where I think please correct me if I'm wrong.
- 50:54Previously to Ark three point zero, it hadn't. Is there any reason for
- 51:00this or are Do you have any thoughts on how this may be lending to
- 51:04its current strength, any thoughts on its current strength in general and what you
- 51:08hope to see from the nerve. Yeah, so we initially made that change
- 51:15to put on a timer and ARC three point zero because Stryker's performance fell off
- 51:20a cliff after the thirtieth anniversary release. At that point we had changed Knockout
- 51:28to consume on melee kill, but prior to that thirtieth release, it could
- 51:31be refreshed like infinitely, and the timers intended to be a middle ground between
- 51:37the two versions of it. Essentially that said, yeah, we've looked at
- 51:44the data. Knockout is significantly overperforming in preseason twenty one. So in season
- 51:51twenty one we're reducing its lunch range. In lightfall, we reduced the player
- 51:55damage, and we're going to continue to monitor it. We don't want to
- 52:00nerve it into the ground because you know, the striker subclass is about that
- 52:06melee damage. So it's important that we retain the identity, but I agree
- 52:09it can be frustrating to deal with. I mean, you got a couple
- 52:16more ability questions we could we can just keep rolling through them, Drew,
- 52:22if you got more sure? Sure? Why not? I don't think I
- 52:29have any more that are directly related to that. But you can just jump
- 52:31the vun abilities. Um. I'm curious to hear what your thoughts are on
- 52:37the current power level of Blink, not including astrocite, and do you think
- 52:42there's any room for improvements? Like personally, I recently completely fell in love
- 52:46with astrocite blink because of the increased distance, but I don't know, I
- 52:52really can't stand the standard Blink distance without it. Yeah, Blink is a
- 53:00difficult one to balance. We talk about it a lot. You know,
- 53:04first, it has unlimited up time, being a jump ability. On the
- 53:08one hand, we want it to feel good for the user. Making it
- 53:12travel fire makes it hard for opposing players to track, though, especially on
- 53:16controller. If we made it travel the astrocite distance by default, we probably
- 53:22need to give opposing players more time to reacquire the target something I don't know.
- 53:32Maybe in that case we increase the time it takes for the blinking Borlock
- 53:37to get back into weapon Ready, which hurts the game feel of it.
- 53:43So it's it's in a tough place to balance. I think right now,
- 53:47putting that power to bamboozle and break ankles of opponents behind an exotic slot that
- 53:54feels like a fair trade off. But if you could do that for free,
- 54:00I think it would feel frustrating to play against because you'd see it how
- 54:04over the place that said, you know, we think there's room for improvement
- 54:09for the base blink. Oh, but it's suggestions if y'all got any like,
- 54:14you know, outside of just give it, give it astrocyte by people.
- 54:19M. Yeah, I'm not sure. Honestly, I'm like gonna be
- 54:22so super honest. I just played Warlock for that, but I really want
- 54:24to play it on Hunter. That's why you know, I don't want the
- 54:29standard blink, but I'm not sure. I'm not really sure what you would
- 54:31do to it, because I feel like the weapon Ready speed is opens as
- 54:37much as I'd love it, I would love faster ready speed, but that
- 54:40is can of worms that you open up to, like how you engage with
- 54:45stuff, and it's like, isn't that what it used years and years and
- 54:47years ago. What's up? Isn't that what it used to be like back
- 54:51in the day when blink was used very heavily, it was you could you
- 54:53could ready your weapons barely quickly out of blink and it was like very strong.
- 54:57So it got turned into what it is today, I guess. Yeah,
- 55:02So that's why I like, I asked a little bit about the distance
- 55:06because I'm like, I don't really, at least personally, I don't know
- 55:12what are the levers you work around with that. Currently there's there's a small
- 55:16cool down for back to back blinks, and then you wait, um,
- 55:21what if there was an option to just hold button to do like the Astra
- 55:25site, just one blank and then have does that make sense? So one
- 55:30blank, then have a cool down essentially, but have like a more Astracite
- 55:36esque blink. That's interesting. I think it would be important to like offer
- 55:43both options. Well, I don't know. Players don't use blink for jumping
- 55:49puzzles anyway, They just swap off of it, So true, Yeah,
- 55:52you would be surprised they used the carry momentum out of sword skin hard mode.
- 55:59Most people I do, I know it, but yeah, um,
- 56:04I've I found a question here for for Eric that I think is a good
- 56:07one here. Um, we've done versions of this podcast I'm turning into a
- 56:10man where we've had a Bungee dev's on the show. So we've asked this
- 56:16question before, but it's a question I like bringing up again because the game
- 56:22changes, the sandbox changes. What do you currently think is the most out
- 56:30of all the subclasses in the game. What is the like the picture perfect
- 56:35of balance for either PVEE, PvP, your pick. You kind of look
- 56:39at it and you point to it on the wall. That's the gold standard
- 56:43that we're trying to hit for all classes. We want that to be the
- 56:45epitome of balanced and good game play loop right. Yeah, that is a
- 56:54tough question because there's so many ways you can judge, aside whether it's like
- 57:04the fun factor or the minimax factor, how good it is a single target
- 57:09DNA, how goods that had clear um ppe pp I think I think it
- 57:22just it changes over time, right, Like different subclasses are better different activities
- 57:27and different skill levels with different control methods, and then you have artifact mods
- 57:31that can turn everything on its head for a season. I think data wise
- 57:37and loopwise, like I you know, void Walker is one that comes to
- 57:46mind for me, I think, um, you know, it's generally in
- 57:50the middle of the pack in terms of wind rate in that sort of thing.
- 57:57So it's it's actually balanced by the data as well for me. You
- 58:01know, I think all three Strand subclasses are shockingly balanced in the term in
- 58:08terms of like data and like how how they came out of the gate.
- 58:14It's because you know, it's really always hard to tell during development because our
- 58:20playtest don't necessarily represent the same conditions as the live game in terms of things
- 58:24like you know, skill disparity, build crafting, cheese and all the sort
- 58:30of stuff. But you know, Strand didn't didn't really break anything too hard,
- 58:37which has been cool. Strand feels good, feels great. I really
- 58:42enjoy using it um in PV and stuff. Uh quick quick follow up question,
- 58:49where would you pvpu? And if you know Cosmo leaped through the window
- 58:53to tackle you don't have to answer, But like PvP scale, where where
- 58:57is striker in the in where are you think it is right now? And
- 59:01how balanced it feels against everything else? It's hot, It's like it's too
- 59:09good tbh, And you know the season twenty one changes, so in a
- 59:14week we'll see how it is. We don't get data in until at least
- 59:20a week after lunch, and even then it takes players time to adjust,
- 59:27takes players time to unlock new weapons and artifact moths and everything, so it's
- 59:32kind of hard to see. But I think, for me, anecdotally and
- 59:37actually looking at the data, Striker is the best subclass in the game.
- 59:44I said, it's true. Yeah, it's um, it's it's pretty,
- 59:50it's I would feel just I can only speak for me. I can only
- 59:52speak for me, but it's it's very abundant. And I know we've already
- 59:59kind of spoke about how Meleei's can feel, and you know, yeah,
- 1:00:05I've just I've seen some ridiculous things. Man. You know, Titans flying
- 1:00:08at you from like twenty meters away. It's like, good Lord's got teleport
- 1:00:13knockouted into oblivion. It's just m and I don't want the people at home
- 1:00:16to think that, you know, we're we're anti Titan. I try to
- 1:00:20play I'm kind of like Cammy. I try to play all three a lot,
- 1:00:22you know what I mean. It is very fun, but yeah,
- 1:00:25I am just of course, curious just to hear what Eric's thoughts are on
- 1:00:29the on a placement of one very popular or subclass right now. So I
- 1:00:34appreciate that answer. Eric, Mark not done with you, buddy. Let's
- 1:00:43do a quick one. This is we're gonna we'll go back into more important
- 1:00:46things. I gotta know, and people have been asking me, and I
- 1:00:49don't want to. I don't want to test it, So I'm just gonna
- 1:00:51ask you. Um, I can't even believe I'm asking this does counterbalance?
- 1:00:55Do you know on a shotgun? Counterbalance on a shotgun? Can you look
- 1:00:59into the camera and say, doesn't do anything on a shotgun. We looked
- 1:01:02at the data today just in case there was some like weird thing on it
- 1:01:07that was filtered to only affect shotguns, kind of balunce. I mean it
- 1:01:09changes the recoal direction. But we were looking at we were like, why
- 1:01:13do we even allow people to put some shotguns? It was like, yeah,
- 1:01:19it doesn't do anything on shotguns. I mean it changes the recoal direction.
- 1:01:22Right, So if you had like a rapid fire shotgun, that was
- 1:01:23like when you were holding down the trigger trying to dps a boss or something
- 1:01:29or a bubble and it was like shooting off to the right. You could
- 1:01:31fix that with a counterbalance mod, but now it doesn't do anything that would
- 1:01:37actually be effective in PvP on the shotguns. So you literally checked to day.
- 1:01:40Yeah, so it's not like a situation with bad juju. Can I
- 1:01:44tell you how god damn fucking funny that is bad ju jus using like auto
- 1:01:47rifle recoil, what is well, what is it? Handing of it?
- 1:01:51Like, yeah, I mean different, different, like subfamilies of guns sometimes
- 1:01:55have different requal Right, so like precision hand hands have different recoild than one
- 1:02:00forty hand cans, which have different recoil than one eighty hand cannons, right,
- 1:02:04like they all are affected by stability. But the same thing with auto
- 1:02:07rifles, the same thing with the poles rifle as well. So like just
- 1:02:08something having a different recoil is not necessarily indicative of being a bug. But
- 1:02:13like as we discovered with the Klos SMG, like every once in a while,
- 1:02:15there's some you know, weird leftover stuff in there from a time long
- 1:02:20since past that is causing issues. And so if we get you know,
- 1:02:23player reports about something feeling weird a lot of times, will you know,
- 1:02:27put a pin in it, and then when we get some time, we'll
- 1:02:29go back and we'll look at the data just to make sure. And bad
- 1:02:30juju is just one of those things fair enough, So we're like ninety percent
- 1:02:36positive that there's not like a bad jujue situation going on counterbalance shotguns anything like
- 1:02:43that. Perks. Perks are a lot easier, Like an individual perk is
- 1:02:45a lot easier to look at that an entire exact weapon, right or an
- 1:02:47entire legendary weapon. So yeah, like the individual perk data is usually contained
- 1:02:52only in a single place, So yeah, we looked at the perk data
- 1:02:54to day. There's nothing special about counterbalance on shotguns shout out ill physics,
- 1:03:00So like like Outbreak has that too correct? Yeah, I believe Outbreak does,
- 1:03:06and it actually benefits Outbreak in it's case, But yeah, I mean
- 1:03:08I haven't. I would have to look at the data on that, so
- 1:03:10I don't want to give an example. But my guess off the top of
- 1:03:13my head is that's using a different auto rifle recoil pattern, and so an
- 1:03:16Outbreak's case, it helps it and heard it so it does not it.
- 1:03:23I haven't heard of Rodeo in a long time, it's Yeah, that's why
- 1:03:28it feels kind of cool, kind of good. Yeah, So it might
- 1:03:30be that, like you know, maybe Outbreak has seven twenty AAR recoil or
- 1:03:35something. This is not real, right, giving you like a hypothetical example.
- 1:03:37I'm not this is not what it actually is, but I'm just saying
- 1:03:38like, in general, maybe it's like that, like one of them has
- 1:03:42seven twenty and the other one has like three sixty AAR, and so one
- 1:03:45of them feels worse than the other one feels better. Thank you for that.
- 1:03:49Moving on to non meme related questions, Um, let's talk about Let's
- 1:03:52talk about glades because their usage numbers, not that I'm complaining, are kind
- 1:04:00of in the basement right now. I think last time I checked in Trials,
- 1:04:02they were like blow power weapons and stuff like that, which is and
- 1:04:08then you know, we see that we have a Trials specific glave coming down
- 1:04:13the pipe, which is just interesting. What are the what is the role
- 1:04:19of glaves in the current PvP Landscaped? Is it hitting the goal? Is
- 1:04:25it's what's going on there? So the role of glaves, and I think
- 1:04:29I can open by saying like, no, it's not really hitting the goal.
- 1:04:31Of where I wanted them to be. It did for a little bit,
- 1:04:33and it got real scary, and so we nerve them before anybody caught
- 1:04:36on. Really, Like I think Drew and I actually made out a conversation
- 1:04:40about this, but like we're like, oh, no, someone knows how
- 1:04:43to use a glave. They're like actually unstoppable and it's horrifying, right,
- 1:04:46And so glaves ride this really really fine line of like bad, bad,
- 1:04:53bad, literally the most oppressive thing to exist, right, And so we're
- 1:04:57trying to keep them underneath that bar okay, where they become so incredibly frustrated
- 1:05:01to play against that they just wreck PvP. And so we're like, you
- 1:05:03know, gradually, you know, poking at them, and you know,
- 1:05:08we fixed their projectile hit registration, and we've we're noodling on some ideas right
- 1:05:13now of potentially ways we can change Glaze. But like the overall fantasy and
- 1:05:15the role for the Glade, it's like, have you seen the movie three
- 1:05:17hundred, All those guys like bunch up and they've got their shields in front
- 1:05:20of them, they've got like the spear poking around the side, right,
- 1:05:24and yeah, and like the way I think about it is a lot like
- 1:05:27if you've played Rainbow six Vegas like the Riot Shield, You've got the Riot
- 1:05:30Shield up in front of you and like the Deagle around the side, and
- 1:05:31like you can't move very fast, but you can protect yourself and people who
- 1:05:34are behind you, and you can still do some damage. You know.
- 1:05:39It's like that's kind of like the type of fantasy I think that we think
- 1:05:42about on the team of what we want the Glaze to be is like you've
- 1:05:45got the shield up in front of you, you can still deal some damage,
- 1:05:47but you can protect yourself and the people around you. Originally, the
- 1:05:53shield had a lot higher damage resistance and it was too effective and PvP you
- 1:05:58could really tank some ridiculous stuff and that felt pretty bad. But I think
- 1:06:03maybe we brought the shield down a little bit too much when we made the
- 1:06:06change. Now it kind of feels like you're increasing your hip box size for
- 1:06:10not and like the reward really isn't there anymore. Um So, like I
- 1:06:14said, we're we're noodling on a bunch of stuff. We're thinking about ways
- 1:06:16we can change glaves, but like the last thing we want to do is
- 1:06:19introduce a glave meta into the game. So Unfortunately you have to air on
- 1:06:23one side or the other, and we're air side of being conservative and like
- 1:06:27slowly moving them upwards, and you know, we've we've talked about ways to
- 1:06:30change the projectile and ways to change the gameplay and stuff like that. So
- 1:06:33well, well we'll definitely you know, do something to them. But in
- 1:06:35the meantime, for the people who do like glaves, you know, there
- 1:06:39is you know, there's a place style. They were all about encouraging different
- 1:06:43weapon play styles and PvP, right, Like, it's not it's not a
- 1:06:45fun game if ten out of the twelve people in a match are using the
- 1:06:47exact same thing, doing the exact same thing, right, Variety is the
- 1:06:50spice of life, so fair enough, So you think that like I would
- 1:06:57agree with you by the way that I don't want to wake up tomorrow more.
- 1:07:00And you're like, oh, it's glave meta. It sounds awful,
- 1:07:01but like it's it's a delicate balance because you want to, you know,
- 1:07:04make the thirteen glave users out. They're happy with whatever they're you know,
- 1:07:10bringing into the game. So we're feeling like fairly good about that. That
- 1:07:14slow, not too harsh climb for the the new glave coming in season twenty
- 1:07:19one. Yeah, well, I mean it's like, what are you know,
- 1:07:21we haven't had a glave that's like, this is a PDP glave,
- 1:07:25right, Like, we haven't ever had that. We've had glaves that exist
- 1:07:28and people use them in PvP, but this is like a PDP glave and
- 1:07:31it's got great stats and strong perks, so you know, you never know,
- 1:07:36maybe people pick it up and they're like, oh damn, Like I
- 1:07:38can actually use this thing pretty effectively, Like this is pretty fun. Like
- 1:07:42I hope that people don't pick it up and then we end up with glaves
- 1:07:45in the top ten of trials. But you know, well, well we'll
- 1:07:48see, right, Like we're always keeping an eye on everything, the same
- 1:07:50way we're looking at underutilized exotics and stuff like that to buff them. Where
- 1:07:55you were looking at underutilized ARC types of weapons and things like that and looking
- 1:07:59for waste doing it better. In the Weapons blog today we talked about like
- 1:08:01we're doing a sword balanced pass as well in the future, So that's all
- 1:08:05that. That's all grav lance too. Yeah, Revision zero the Heavy Burst
- 1:08:11ended up being a nice little beta test for for buffing grave lance. I
- 1:08:15said that. When we were working on a revision zero, we were like,
- 1:08:18what would we do if we wanted to make grave lance meta, And
- 1:08:21it was like, let's do that for the heavy burst, right, So
- 1:08:25it's like the balance, you know, the faster rate of fire, the
- 1:08:28balance damage. And then that went out and like people enjoy using it feels
- 1:08:30good to use, but it's not breaking anything. So we were like,
- 1:08:32all right, this is probably a safe place for graviton lance to go into.
- 1:08:35And graviton lance is, you know, a slightly different beast, like
- 1:08:40the damage is still split between the two bullets differently, but it's got the
- 1:08:43same rate of fire and the same overall damage profile. So do you think
- 1:08:47you've gotten into a place where I'm really excited about that change but can't wait
- 1:08:50wait for all of it. Do you think it's gonna potentially meta? Will
- 1:08:56there be a world with an astocross YouTube thumbnail meta mark graviton lands. I
- 1:09:01mean it's hard for a gun with a point eight seven second time to kill
- 1:09:06that requires that amount of bullets to hit to be like flat out meta if
- 1:09:15it's not like just directly better than a lot of other stuff, right,
- 1:09:18So there are things that can kill you faster than graviton lands at similar ranges.
- 1:09:24Right, there are things that can kill you in the same speed as
- 1:09:26graviton lance without requiring you to hit as many bullets. Right, So I
- 1:09:32think we aired on the side of it being strong and you know, shipping
- 1:09:39potentially hot. Like it feels really good to use, and it wouldn't surprise
- 1:09:45me to see it, you know, make an appearance up there. But
- 1:09:46I don't know that we're going to re enter the world of D two year
- 1:09:50one where graviton lands and might a multitool were you know the meta options?
- 1:09:57Okay, all right, the Golden Age? Yes, yeah, so I
- 1:10:03mean think sometimes hockey heavy rounds on revision zero, right, and like do
- 1:10:06you feel like that's meta, Like definitely not. It kills it the same,
- 1:10:12Yeah, it kills at the same speech as you know, hockey heavy
- 1:10:15rounds. But it you know, it's got other benefits to it, right,
- 1:10:18Like the amesist is super high, stability is super high. There's other
- 1:10:21stuff that still not have as much drop off. Okay, that's right there,
- 1:10:28that's the boon to use it. Right before we go back to Eric
- 1:10:33there, Drew, you got a couple more weapon questions anyone you want to
- 1:10:36throw at Merck while we've got him on the mic. Cool, I know
- 1:10:40you have a weapon question too. Was that already kind of answered in our
- 1:10:44talk about correct Yeah, okay, just double checking decoupling of fall off?
- 1:10:50Sure, sure, Drew, what do what do we? Well can brought
- 1:10:57up no time. Oh. For a lot of players, especially experienced players,
- 1:11:00I think the high impact pulses are typically considered the best weapons in the
- 1:11:05game, well aside from SMGs. That's obviously due to a lot of things
- 1:11:11like the lethality or potential lethality damage, perse perverse and a consistent three shot
- 1:11:17kill. So it's got like the two tap potential, consistent three tap and
- 1:11:20just like good damage. I wanted to know what your current thoughts are on
- 1:11:25high impact pulses, and then, of course, because no time to explain,
- 1:11:30leads the charge of the high impact pulses and continues to you know,
- 1:11:34be a really strong, really potent weapon even after being nerved. Um,
- 1:11:41I want to know what your thoughts were on that and he plans around those
- 1:11:44or yeah, yeah, I mean I think on mouse and keyboard specifically,
- 1:11:48ease of use is too high for the three forties. The amount of lethality
- 1:11:53they provide the risk reward model is off, but that's on mouse and keyboard,
- 1:11:59and like, it's important to keep in mind that we do have,
- 1:12:01you know, as much as we try to blend them, like the metas
- 1:12:04end up being a little bit separate between the input devices. Right. And
- 1:12:08so for an example that actually pulled these stats today on no Time on mouse
- 1:12:12and keyboard, No Time to explain, is thirty five percent of all pulse
- 1:12:15rifle kills on controller it is twelve percent, Right, So it is almost
- 1:12:20three times you know, netting three times more kills on mouse and keyboard than
- 1:12:26it is on controller. Right, Like, the difference in effectiveness between the
- 1:12:30two input devices like cannot be overstated because people are as like, oh,
- 1:12:32well, why don't you just dumpster no Time And it's like, well,
- 1:12:35because it's actually balanced pretty well on controller comparatively, right, Like at the
- 1:12:39risk reward model. I'm not saying it's perfect, but the risk reward model
- 1:12:42is in a much healthier place, right to the point that no Time is
- 1:12:45not even the most used you know pulse rifle on controller. Right, We've
- 1:12:49got autumn wind that's well above it. It's like, you know, on
- 1:12:53par in some lobbies with some guns that I'm surprised to even show up up
- 1:12:58there, right, But like BXR is still above it, Autumn Winn is
- 1:13:00still above it, right. So there are options on controller, but that
- 1:13:03doesn't excuse the fact that on mouse and keyboard, yeah, it's too hot,
- 1:13:06right, So when we look at balancing it, we have to try
- 1:13:09to figure out a way to balance it where we can tone down the effectiveness
- 1:13:12on mouse and keyboard without really hitting it, you know, unnecessarily hard on
- 1:13:17the other input device, where it's you know, already not the most popular
- 1:13:21pick, and it already is kind of risky to use because you're going to
- 1:13:25be hitting the three burst more than you hit the two burst, and a
- 1:13:27lot of other pulse rifles three versts faster, you know. So what I
- 1:13:30would say is what we're gonna do for sure, is we're gonna bring no
- 1:13:32time to explain specifically, We're gonna bring the range down like a fair amount.
- 1:13:38It's no longer going to be a weapon where you can sit forty plus
- 1:13:41meters away and and just plink of people and like build up those charges.
- 1:13:44It's just not going to be effective at that You're not going to hit.
- 1:13:46You're not going to hit your shots. In play tests, it's it's been
- 1:13:51it's been pretty noticeable. Actually, there's been a number of times where we've
- 1:13:55had players to be like, man, I would have two bursted that person
- 1:13:57in live and like, you just didn't, right. It just doesn't do
- 1:14:00enough damage. They're like right on the cusp with not being able to burst
- 1:14:01even with six grids, So you just don't, right, And I think
- 1:14:04that's going to be a good change. We're also doing going to cross the
- 1:14:08board change to pulse rifles, but specifically it's going to affect high impacts the
- 1:14:12most. We're reducing the autoam cone at low amosis values pretty substantially the size
- 1:14:17of the autoam cone, right, So that's going to affect all pulse rifles,
- 1:14:21but the lower the amosis stat is, the more it's going to affect
- 1:14:25it. And specifically, high impact pulse rifles have the lowest amosis stats by
- 1:14:29default, so they're going to hit. They're going to be hit by far
- 1:14:31the hardest, and it's definitely a very noticeable feeling. What happens right now
- 1:14:36is like your gun recoils upwards, but the amosis cone is big enough that
- 1:14:42even while it's recoil outwards, it's still pulling the bullets to the head,
- 1:14:44and it's not going to do that nearly as effectively. Now, if you
- 1:14:46recoil too high without manual recoil control, the last SHOT's going to go over
- 1:14:49the head right or it's going to miss. So that's going to be a
- 1:14:53pretty big change. I think that's going to reduce their easy of use a
- 1:14:55good bit. It should affect mousing keyboard more than it affects controller because controller
- 1:15:00has radical friction to fall back on. So they're losing a part of amosists,
- 1:15:04but not all of it, whereas mouse and Keyboard is losing pretty much
- 1:15:08all the aim assists. So in play tests that we've done, it's definitely
- 1:15:11noticeable on both input devices, but it's more noticeable on mouse and keyboard,
- 1:15:14which is good. That's what we're shooting for to like address the elephant in
- 1:15:17the room of like why don't we make them six krits. It's because we've
- 1:15:21looked at that change and because mouse and Keyboard has an inherent like twenty percent
- 1:15:26accuracy bonus that's like baked into it, mouse and keyboard is hitting six krits
- 1:15:30far more often than controller is. So what that change did is it made
- 1:15:34them unusable on controller and had very little effect on their effectness on mouse and
- 1:15:39keyboard, which is actually where they're the problem. So like that is a
- 1:15:43change, and we actually have like a change waiting in the wings where it
- 1:15:46will give them a resiliency gate to six krits. So I think if you're
- 1:15:50at five resilience or above, it will require six krits. And like that
- 1:15:54felt a little bit more fair, and it basically gave players the option of
- 1:15:57being, like, I really don't like being killed by this dude with the
- 1:15:59high impact pulse. I'm going to build into resilience and make it harder for
- 1:16:02him to kill me. Right, So that felt a little bit more fair.
- 1:16:04We're not going to ship that change just yet, but we like we
- 1:16:08have it ready and waiting. But what we're gonna do is we're gonna again
- 1:16:11reduce the range of no time to explain, probably mid season twenty one.
- 1:16:15We're going to reduce the amosis cone, but the auto MD cone at low
- 1:16:18values for all pulse rifles also probably mid season twenty one, and then in
- 1:16:23season twenty two, the range the damage fall off and zoom decoupling. High
- 1:16:29impact pulses are for the most part at eighteen zoom, and the base value
- 1:16:32for pulse rifles is going to be seventeen their ADS damage fall off scaler.
- 1:16:38So that's going to clamp the effective range of high impact pulses a lot more,
- 1:16:43right, and so it's going to kind of squeeze them into where the
- 1:16:45higher end of pulse rifle range is going to be like forty meters now,
- 1:16:48and they're going to maintain some effectiveness outside of that, but you're not going
- 1:16:53to be experiencing these pulse rifles being super effective in the high forty fifty meter
- 1:16:57ranges anymore. Because that was a really detailed answer. Yeah, that sounds
- 1:17:02like, oh, like really good stuff. I think though, like especially
- 1:17:04I want to mention it earlier with the coupling of the zoom and like range
- 1:17:09stuff. It sounds like ranges as a whole seemed like they're going to be
- 1:17:13a lot more like digestible defined and like readable, like you know, complain
- 1:17:18about like you know, like even pulse is being so rangy, you know,
- 1:17:20people sitting back and gonot and I feel like, if that's like the
- 1:17:24standard that you're going for, that they're gonna be coming down a little bit.
- 1:17:26That's probably a good thing. Yeah, we're right now. The way
- 1:17:30things are kind of staggered is like in live auto rifles have this like huge
- 1:17:34rage window that's basically only based on zoom, Like they're actually ranged at means
- 1:17:38very little and the only thing that matters is their zoom value. And so
- 1:17:41you've got auto rifles with twenty zoom that are hitting forty meters right, and
- 1:17:45then you've got auto rifles with sixteen zoom that can barely hit like twenty five
- 1:17:47meters, And so there's this huge disparity amongst auto rifles and hand cannons.
- 1:17:53You've got handcns with rangefinder that are hurting thirty six thirty seven meters and handcans
- 1:17:57without that can barely even hit thirty, you know, three or third before.
- 1:18:00So what has happened is like zoom is so powerful, but the only
- 1:18:04way you can get it is be gifted it as part of the stat package
- 1:18:08of the gun when we ship it or have range finder, and that's it,
- 1:18:11right, So by decoupling damage fall off from zoom and making range itself
- 1:18:15the stat the way you can get it. There's so much more ways to
- 1:18:18get range the stat there's a ton of different perks, there's a ton of
- 1:18:23different you know, STAT allocations, masterworks, mods, stuff like that.
- 1:18:26Like there's way more ways to give a player control over the ranges that they
- 1:18:29want to engage in. And then the second thing is, like we wanted
- 1:18:31to rain in these outliers high zoom SMG's, high zoom side arms, even
- 1:18:36high zoom pulse rifles, they are treading too deep into their neighboring weapons engagement
- 1:18:42ranges, and it's making them hard to counter with weapons that should be able
- 1:18:45to fight aginstant. Like you should be able to fight against a pulse rifle
- 1:18:47with a hand cannon and the pulse rifle might outrange you by a little bit,
- 1:18:53but it shouldn't be fully effective while it's also outranging you by ten meters,
- 1:18:57right, Like that's not a fair value proposition there. So the way
- 1:19:00we're looking at doing it is like auto rifles, hand cannons, pulse rifles
- 1:19:03are all going to basically share the same effective ranges, and then their performance
- 1:19:11outside of those effective ranges is going to kind of, you know, dictate
- 1:19:13the differences in feel between the guns. But they're not going to be fully
- 1:19:16effective once they leave those ranges. Right, So, you know, hand
- 1:19:19cannons, aggressive handcanns will be able to hit forty meters, pulse rifles will
- 1:19:24be able to hit forty meters, even high range auto rifles will be able
- 1:19:27to hit forty meters. And then once you leave that window, they're all
- 1:19:30going to start degrading in their experience. Right, So what it should do
- 1:19:34is it should offer the ability for you to like choose, pick your mid
- 1:19:38range poison. How do you want to play the mid range? And if
- 1:19:42you pick the wrong answer, someone's not going to be able to sit ten
- 1:19:45meters further away from you and you do absolutely nothing with them while they too
- 1:19:47burst you. So just to clarify those so, like the how they deal
- 1:19:55with exiting that range is what makes them feel different, just to be clear.
- 1:20:00Yeah, So, like say you have, you know, one hundred
- 1:20:04zoom aggressive hand cannon, one hundred zoom high impact auto rifle, and one
- 1:20:09hundred zoom high impact polese rifle. Right at forty meters, they will all
- 1:20:13still deal full damage. Right at forty one meters, they will all be
- 1:20:16in damage. Fall off. The hand cannon is going to drop off the
- 1:20:21most like the harshest right. As a handheld weapon, the auto rifle will
- 1:20:27drop off the next harshest and then the pulse rifle will drop off the least
- 1:20:30harsh right. Does that make sense yep. This is really difficult, by
- 1:20:40the way, because every time we get either one of you, Eric or
- 1:20:44Murk going on a roll, I just want you to keep talking forever.
- 1:20:49I also want to go back and forth to make sure everyone gets time to
- 1:20:54share information and talk about season twenty one. It's just it's really rough.
- 1:21:00I could I could listen to both of you rant for over an hour.
- 1:21:03Thank you. That was was really It's very thorough. Mark Drew. Do
- 1:21:09you have any um any additional questions for Eric? I know we're we're not
- 1:21:14yet through with this document, but the clock keeps on ticking here. I
- 1:21:18have a very burning, burning question for abilities, and it's that I feel
- 1:21:24like there's a lot of plenty I'll say, of exotics that drastically increase ability
- 1:21:30up time here we go through either rewarding energy or strongly decreasing cool downs in
- 1:21:38certain scenarios. The things that I think of is young Ahamkara spine is like
- 1:21:42a hot one. I know, these are exotics, but just as an
- 1:21:44example, Caliban's hand. You know, when you place the knife it,
- 1:21:47your regen goes crazy and it feels like more are joining them too, like
- 1:21:51with a recent exotic. And I know this is in your area, but
- 1:21:54with the recent exotic buffs there's like you know, Atherist I believe is getting
- 1:21:59some sort of a increase strength strength or something like that. Yeah, I
- 1:22:04wanted to know what your thoughts are on how these exotics impact the ability economy
- 1:22:11and how do you balance or manage ability up time and meaningfulness with those exotics
- 1:22:15existing, because you know, we do get changes, like somewhat recently where
- 1:22:20the new Tier ten is now the old tier eight. Um. So yeah,
- 1:22:27yeah, so with the new Tier ten being the old tier eight,
- 1:22:30you know, we're still looking at ways to holistically balance the ability energy economy
- 1:22:38to make sure it doesn't feel like abilities are spammable. I think like the
- 1:22:44exotic Armor questions specifically is probably better for the Armor team, But I can't
- 1:22:48talk about kind of the ability energy economy in general. You know, wrangling
- 1:22:57the energy economy is a full time job essentially. You know, we're giving
- 1:23:03players ability energy from so many sources there's fragments aspects, armor mods, armor
- 1:23:10perks, weapon perks, artifact mods, activity modifiers, orbs of power,
- 1:23:15and you know, on their own, each of these might be a small
- 1:23:20amount, but in a game that's all about build crafting, it gets out
- 1:23:25of hand real quick. So with all those potential sources, we tend to
- 1:23:30give small amounts. But when we give small amounts, the feedback as always
- 1:23:34doesn't feel like it does anything, or you know, us using something without
- 1:23:41using everything else doesn't feel worth equipping, right, So designers tend to increase
- 1:23:50the amount until the player can feel it, which leads to high ability up
- 1:23:55time. I think this is especially prevalent with the exotics, because they're just
- 1:24:00such like a centerpiece of your build, and it feels like when you equip
- 1:24:04them, it should just do something extreme exotic, right. Um, But
- 1:24:13you know, because those player expectations for ability energy are I like, I'd
- 1:24:17prefer that we're going to move away from granting ability energy and towards other things.
- 1:24:25But uh yeah, I don't envy the armor teams like trying to create
- 1:24:32chasable items and like interface with all of our weapons and abilities, because it's
- 1:24:38a it's really hard to be in that sweet spot where it's like it augments
- 1:24:44a base ability, but doesn't you know, blow it off a chart as
- 1:24:47far as like how how powerful it is. So I think as we continue
- 1:24:54to rework exotics, we probably will want to look at that ability energy regeneration
- 1:25:00see if it's appropriate to shift the value of an exotic away from ability energy
- 1:25:03into something else. But again that if you get the armor team on here,
- 1:25:10you should you should ask their all the other teams. I'm sorry,
- 1:25:17go ahead, you talk a little bit. I mean, because it was
- 1:25:19an exciting change. Um, grapple was strand you know, it was a
- 1:25:26two and a half minimum delay to like a point two, So I think
- 1:25:30that's really cool. And then the Hunter melee the changes to it. Yeah,
- 1:25:36so those changes are coming in seven to ten in on Tuesday. Um,
- 1:25:44so with the Grapple one, you're mostly going to see the reduction in
- 1:25:50the in the activation suppression, like on the Hunter when they're using their aspect
- 1:25:57that gives them the two grenade charges. Initially, we were scared of grapple
- 1:26:02and how much distance it let you cover, so we wanted to like put
- 1:26:06in a cool down between uses. Essentially, Um, you know, Grapple
- 1:26:13has proven fairly safe for the game, Like it's not absolutely breaking a ton
- 1:26:21of like aspirational content, so we are going to try reducing that that suppression
- 1:26:30between it so you can be more Spider Man. You can you know,
- 1:26:34flip flip twice in a row. All of that UM and and and play
- 1:26:40tests, its felt really good to do that, so we're excited to get
- 1:26:43that in the Hunter Melee. UM is getting a lot more powerful. Like
- 1:26:50Hunter Melee is interesting because you know, I see a lot of feedback that
- 1:26:55it's weak and against single targets. That is true, and I think it
- 1:27:03has like it's it's original designs to have this role where like it is used
- 1:27:09on groups of enemies to damage all of them and to sever them, which
- 1:27:15reduces their outgoing damage output. Right, So it's more like a utility tool
- 1:27:19than a damage tool. But and and if you know, if I throw
- 1:27:24it at a group before, like not a lot of melees can have that
- 1:27:28sort of damage output. But it's not single target damage output, so it
- 1:27:30feels weak. So we want it to feel good, So we're pumping up
- 1:27:35the damage versus PDE enemies. We're increasing the range of it as well,
- 1:27:41making it a bit more catchable. I think there's still some work to do
- 1:27:46here, like the way the audio works in our game, like the mix
- 1:27:56is dependent on whether you're facing something or not. So when I throw at
- 1:28:00the dart, and if I'm not looking at the dart, like I'm not
- 1:28:01going to hear it is easily that sort of thing. Yeah, there's still
- 1:28:06some challenges, but I do think Strand Hunter is going to be in a
- 1:28:12pretty good spot come Tuesday. So you I did a good job on the
- 1:28:15Hunter melee. You can look at the bottom left of the screen and see
- 1:28:18it flash green for when you have to press the button to get it back.
- 1:28:24Yep. And now the dart's gonna return slightly slower, which is gonna
- 1:28:30extend that window that you have to catch it, and extend the window that
- 1:28:34that icon turns green as well. You're welcome. Paul Tassili claims that Strand
- 1:28:42Hunters can't catch the melee, call him a man out, Eric. Is
- 1:28:46there anything more? I'm hijacking your question, Drew. Is there anything more
- 1:28:50you can tell us about the upcoming Strand aspects that are coming down the pipe?
- 1:28:56Yeah, we're super excited to get these aspects out um give players more
- 1:29:02build crafting options. It always feels bad when you got two aspects to choose
- 1:29:08from, so it's like you have this kind of static build. So now
- 1:29:12that we're gonna have three aspects for all of the classes, we'll see some
- 1:29:15more variety there. You can't expect to see some video of these aspects in
- 1:29:21action very soon. How soon, you know, maybe maybe maybe tomorrow,
- 1:29:30maybe not, but I think, uh yeah, the aspects like fantasy wise,
- 1:29:41I'll go through them. The Titan called the Flachette Storm. It's about
- 1:29:46being an offensive powerhouse, violently weaving these sharp projectiles and you know, flinging
- 1:29:54them at distant enemies. So it's about that berserk or fantasy see. But
- 1:30:00it's also about giving Titans a ranged melee option that can deal a high damage
- 1:30:03at mid range. So excited to see what players do with that. The
- 1:30:09Warlock aspect, the Wanderer, it's about expanding the minion master fantasy for the
- 1:30:16brood Weaver and weaving tangles into this semi sentient creature and throwing it out.
- 1:30:25They have like a cool performance and nice tracking, and then they stick to
- 1:30:30enemies and kind of swell up and explode into this suspending detonation. So that's
- 1:30:39about giving the warlock more access to suspend, giving them a tangle augment aspect,
- 1:30:44which we want all the classes to have eventually excited about that one.
- 1:30:48And then the hunter aspect is about weaving a clone that can pull your enemies.
- 1:30:56And this one it's real special about deception, about survivability. Uh,
- 1:31:03you know, we've never let players create an object that can draw combatant agro.
- 1:31:10So it feels really fresh to the game in that regard. H In
- 1:31:15PvP, Uh, the clone will ping the radar, so you can use
- 1:31:20it for that really. Okay, So it is like a decoy, but
- 1:31:29it's like it's not like it is a hologram or like looks just like a
- 1:31:34hunter or like moves at all. Right, it's it's it stays in you
- 1:31:39weave it into this kind of action pose um. So so the object itself
- 1:31:44isn't and it's not it's not like your whatever pose you're in, right,
- 1:31:48but it is like an action oriented pose um, And it isn't necessarily meant
- 1:31:55to fool enemies into looking like an enemy player because it is made of strand.
- 1:32:00We got to retain that, you know, strand aesthetic looking like this
- 1:32:06woven creature, but it does look a bit like a Strand Hunter in Super
- 1:32:12And in addition, um, when you aim at an enemy clone, it
- 1:32:17does bring up the nameplate in the health bar, which can whist can full
- 1:32:23of people into you know, wasting a rocket or a nova bomb on it
- 1:32:27for something for those twitchy players who would just you know blasted on site essentially.
- 1:32:32Um, but yeah, I'm really excited about all of them. Um,
- 1:32:40I'll leave it there. All that is kind amazing. I'm to wear
- 1:32:45some bright green shaders. Think you think you won't be fooled by the clone,
- 1:32:51but like because it pings the radar, and because when you come around
- 1:32:55the corner, it's got the name plate over it, and like your redical
- 1:32:58turns red, and you know the amount of times that people have wasted supers
- 1:33:02on it or abilities on it, or like my personal least favorite is like
- 1:33:06I've got heavy Emma, and I like run around the corner, jump of
- 1:33:10a deer to fire rocket at a clan and just like totally burn the heavy
- 1:33:14Emmo. Like it's it's actually a super super useful tool and it's really really
- 1:33:17fun. I'd like the stasis turns. Can you pull like momentum more off
- 1:33:21of it if you get to kill with ace. That's a good question.
- 1:33:26That is a good question. Off the top of my head. I'm not
- 1:33:30sure. I think we try to get rid of any sort of like cheese
- 1:33:33straps because you can't actually shoot it yourself when you When I create this thing,
- 1:33:40if I want to remote detonate it, I can just shoot it.
- 1:33:43It's going to explode into threadlings, so I can use it in that sort
- 1:33:47of way. I do think, yeah, I do think it's kind of
- 1:33:51fool players at first, but it's going to be something that players learn over
- 1:33:56time, so it'll probably get less effective in PvP time, but that radar
- 1:34:00manipulation will always be effective. Quick quick, piggyback on the Strand talk the
- 1:34:10new or not the new? The added extra changes to the Warlock, the
- 1:34:15Strand Warlock with you know, being the Minion Master and all that stuff.
- 1:34:19Do we feel like the season twenty one changes are going to kind of significantly
- 1:34:24elevate because I love threadlings. I think they're really fun um. I just
- 1:34:27kind of wish they were like stronger. I guess in PVEE content sometimes it
- 1:34:30just feels like it's like a fun fantasy, but it's not really wildly as
- 1:34:35effective as maybe I want it to be. You know that's fair. Yeah,
- 1:34:42well, you know we're looking at threadlings. There's I'd love to make
- 1:34:45threadlings more effective and smarter as well. But again, this is what I'm
- 1:34:50saying about, like, we don't want to rush changes in and then realize
- 1:34:57that they blow something up. So sure, well, I wish we could
- 1:35:00get those changes in the season twenty one. We're gonna put them in season
- 1:35:05twenty two or season twenty three and test them essentially for a longer period of
- 1:35:13time before we're satisfied with it. Sure, thank you for that. We
- 1:35:20promised these guys we would not keep them super long. It's really cool that
- 1:35:29they've given us their time. We're basically seconds away from the time limit that
- 1:35:35we set for ourselves. Last minute, boys, Are there any final short
- 1:35:43burning questions that you wanted to hit Eric or murk with or counterpoint murck Eric.
- 1:35:48Was there anything that you really wanted, anything that you're very excited to
- 1:35:53share that maybe we haven't touched on yet that you want to just kind of
- 1:35:58throw out there? Come on, Mark, I mean, there are a
- 1:36:06couple of there a couple of questions, but they're not short though I'll get
- 1:36:14end up ranting for like ten minutes. I don't think I can do that
- 1:36:16to anybody out nother day boy wants to sit here for any longer than that.
- 1:36:18So it was about the like, why don't we balance stuff until usage
- 1:36:23spikes? I think Drew had that question right, and like I've already talked
- 1:36:28a little bit, I think about how far ahead we're working right, Like
- 1:36:30we're balancing two seasons in ahead, Like Season twenty one hasn't even shipped yet
- 1:36:33and we're like literally finishing up season twenty two right now, so we're like
- 1:36:39two full seasons ahead of the live game. So usually what happens is like
- 1:36:42we preemptively make changes based off what we see and experience in the game,
- 1:36:45and then if something starts to become an issue, we move those changes forward,
- 1:36:50like you know, backwards in time basically, like we pulled them out
- 1:36:54of season twenty two and we put them in a season twenty one mid season
- 1:36:57patch, right, So that that usually means that we have like about a
- 1:37:00month and a half lead time on balancing something. So if something is a
- 1:37:02problem that season launch, then usually in the mid season we can address it.
- 1:37:06Or if something becomes a problem in the mid season, then like and
- 1:37:10this is weapons team exclusively that I'm talking about here, not the rest of
- 1:37:14the game, right, Weapons, that's the cadence we work on. So
- 1:37:17that's what we can do. And on rare occasions we can hot fix stuff
- 1:37:21reactively, like super rare occasions LFRS recently DMT because those are potentially like catastrophic
- 1:37:30issues and they have to be fixed immediately, right, So on rare occasions
- 1:37:33we can do that. But the big question is, like why don't we
- 1:37:36preemptively balance things more often? Is because we've talked about this before. But
- 1:37:41there's the net fun equation, right, and the net fun of a gun
- 1:37:45that is low usage but high effectiveness is generally still positive, right, Like
- 1:37:53every so if you get killed by cloud Strike once in ten games, that's
- 1:37:57like barely a blip on your radar as a player as far as like an
- 1:38:00agative emotion goes. But for the player who's getting in the kill with Cloud
- 1:38:02Strike, every kill they get is like a little endorphin rush and like a
- 1:38:06little happy moment and gameplay, right, And so you know, positive sentiment
- 1:38:12about using a gun is like pretty much a linear curve, like every kill
- 1:38:15you get gives you like a little happy bump, whereas on the negative side,
- 1:38:19being killed by it is much more of like an exponential curve, where
- 1:38:24the more it happens, the more annoying it is to get killed by something,
- 1:38:28you know. You know, it's like kind of an example that even
- 1:38:30that effective. Yeah, so it's one of those things where like why do
- 1:38:34we wait? And it's because, like, well, if a gun is
- 1:38:39effective, but very few people are using it, it could also be that
- 1:38:42the people who are using it are just really good players, right, And
- 1:38:44what happens is as usage increases, effectiveness a lot of times normalizes, like
- 1:38:47effectiveness comes down, right, As more people pick up the weapon, more
- 1:38:51varieties of skill pick up the weapon, affectiveness starts to decrease, right,
- 1:38:56And so it turns out like, oh, it wasn't really the weapon that
- 1:38:58was too strong necessarily, it's that the people who we're using it, we're
- 1:39:00all really good players who are very adept with the weapon. So there's a
- 1:39:03multitude of reasons why we wait for usage to start rising a bit before we
- 1:39:09you know, before we hit things. And it's not like everything's greated on
- 1:39:12the same scale, Like we nerved lfrs when they were like two percent usage
- 1:39:15or something like that, right, which is not very high even for a
- 1:39:17special weapon. So it's a sliding scale for everything. And we don't balance
- 1:39:23based purely off of usage. I've said this a bunch of times, but
- 1:39:25like, if we did balance based off usage, we'd be nerfing rows right
- 1:39:29now, right, And like we're not going to do that. In fact,
- 1:39:30we're buffing rows when the you know, the damage fall off stuff comes
- 1:39:33out in season twenty two. So like, we don't balance based just off
- 1:39:38usage. We haven't really ever done that. I know that that's a funny
- 1:39:41thing to meme on, but like it's way way more about effectiveness, and
- 1:39:45that gives us our targets, and that gives us the things to look at,
- 1:39:48and then when they start to become a problem and people start to experience
- 1:39:51too much of them, and that net fun equation kind of flips over,
- 1:39:55that's when we say, Okay, now's the time, right, And so
- 1:39:59I hope that answers that qu it does Eric? Can I figureback off that
- 1:40:04question with the fun one? Sure? Okay, humber me here, what
- 1:40:11is the one weapon? Or ability in the sandbox. That is like your
- 1:40:14fun fact or your dopamine hit, if you can think of that off the
- 1:40:16top of your head. I mean this revision is zero for me, right,
- 1:40:19like I built that gun. Yeah it actually it actually comes into There
- 1:40:25was a question here about like think of like new exotics, right, and
- 1:40:29like some of the time, you know the some of the time the guidelines
- 1:40:31are more rigid, like hey, we need an exotic that does this to
- 1:40:33match the theme of the season or the event or whatever, and some of
- 1:40:36the times it's more free form. But for a revision zero, they were
- 1:40:40like, hey, we need a gun to go with this story, and
- 1:40:43it has to be able to change week to week, and we wanted to
- 1:40:45be craftable. And I was like reached into my bag of files and was
- 1:40:48like, well, lucky here, I've got this idea for a craftable exotic
- 1:40:53that I've been working on for a while. So that fits in nicely.
- 1:40:55And they're like, well, we need to make it feel a little bit
- 1:40:57more exotic, so I just craftable And I was like, you know what
- 1:40:59I wish I could do? I could snipe, like like in the Halo,
- 1:41:01right, like hip fire accuracy in air accuracy, like I want to
- 1:41:05be able to snipe like I'm in Halo. And so that's where Revision zero
- 1:41:09came out. And I've got like seven thousand PvP kills on my Revision zero
- 1:41:12right now, and you know I'm getting yeah, and I'm getting like four
- 1:41:15yeah, exactly. You know I have more than double that in like she'll
- 1:41:17play test, but you know I'm getting like, you know, four or
- 1:41:20five headshots a game. I hip fire half of them like it's you know,
- 1:41:26it's a freaking blast. So you'll laugh at me, Marke. Whenever
- 1:41:29I have the perk up in trials, I have to tell my teammates nobody
- 1:41:31move, don't even look at I have to use this, I think on
- 1:41:38the ability side for me, like h right now, nothing beats the strand
- 1:41:43loop of I don't want to tangle, grappling to it, you know,
- 1:41:45diving out of it. Um that has the highest fun factor for me.
- 1:41:49But there's a lot of them. Like for me, Gunpowder Gamble is a
- 1:41:56great one, uh Sam done. One of our gameplay designers made that one.
- 1:42:00Our Dirt designed it. Consecration is always a fun one and everything explode
- 1:42:09joint sure M Yeah, I mean I think abilities are all about fun.
- 1:42:15You know, we could make just explosive ball that flies out and tweets things,
- 1:42:23but like it's all about the feel and the camera shake and the feedback
- 1:42:28and the sound and everything. Didn't you already make something like that though Fusion
- 1:42:31Grenades, Starfire Protocol, throw the ball. Hey, you know you got
- 1:42:36to have those two. See its variety is a spice of life. I
- 1:42:42feel hum any open. Anything that you wanted to mention or tease Eric about
- 1:42:49season twenty one that we that we didn't manage to get to that you want
- 1:42:54to just kind of get out there before we wrap things up. I don't
- 1:42:57want to. I don't want to spoil it, but season twenty one is
- 1:43:00gonna be crazy. Though. I'm super excited for people to play it and
- 1:43:04see it. We're excited to get our hands on it. And you know,
- 1:43:11you know, if you're listening at home, I got like I got
- 1:43:15twelve extra minutes out of him. Right, you just give the mic to
- 1:43:16Murk. Lord knows what happens. My man's gonna run with it. We
- 1:43:19appreciate him. We really appreciate you guys taking time out of your day to
- 1:43:25get on the show. We know you don't have to. I don't think
- 1:43:28anyone's putting a gun to your head. But we just really appreciate the you
- 1:43:32know, the open lines of communication with Bungee. It's just really fun to
- 1:43:39get to hear from you all about stuff coming down the pipe, and we
- 1:43:42just really appreciate you both. Thank you. This was a lot of fun.
- 1:43:47Hope to be back. I'd love to have you back. Away was
- 1:43:51always a blast. Right, I've been on the show enough times now at
- 1:43:56this point it feels like coming home and you're a grandfather or now, because
- 1:44:00I mean, you know, your Revision zero was your kid, and now
- 1:44:02Revision zero is being the model for Graviton Lances your kids having a kid,
- 1:44:08right, it's a grandpa unless Graviton Lands ends up actually becoming like Super Meta,
- 1:44:14in which case not very proudly kids running wild. Yeah, send that
- 1:44:18kid back to school. All right. Um, we're not going to go
- 1:44:21around the table and just you know, you know where to find us.
- 1:44:24But again, thank you so much for joining us on the show. We
- 1:44:27all appreciate you very much. We're not going to host anybody, none of
- 1:44:30that offline stuff. We're just gonna end the show. So um, Thank
- 1:44:33you very much for joining us at home. We appreciate all of you.
- 1:44:35We will see you next time. Take care,