Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Winter's Bone (2010): The Specificity of Place
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting here in a nook of my attic room,
- 0:34a window between us looking out onto my backyard.
- 0:39It's a drizzly spring day. But the grass is green
- 0:42and growing, and the two large silver maples
- 0:45are covered with burgeoning leaves. If you come
- 0:49to visit me in a few more weeks, my backyard
- 0:51will be bright and verdant and alive, finally
- 0:55basking in the miracle of spring. But if you
- 0:59hadn't watched it grow, if you hadn't seen that
- 1:02miracle happen, it wouldn't particularly stand
- 1:06out to you. It doesn't look that different from
- 1:09the backyards we expect from Americana, the kind
- 1:13you might see recreated on a set for a sitcom
- 1:16or in a picture book. A grass lawn, a few trees,
- 1:20a swing set. We have this picture of a typical
- 1:25American home, one that includes maple trees
- 1:28and squirrels and twittering birds, one with
- 1:32seasons, snow days, falling leaves. April showers.
- 1:38I know, because it's a myth I grew up with. I
- 1:44spent my childhood in a very different part of
- 1:47the United States, in the Sonoran Desert of Tucson,
- 1:51Arizona, a place with very distinct flora and
- 1:54fauna, unfortunately lumped with the American
- 1:58exemption of out west, a place you might picture
- 2:02as flat, beige, empty except for some scrub brush
- 2:07and maybe a lone cactus. I grew up in the shadow
- 2:12of mountains, playing in a jungle of a front
- 2:15yard filled with mesquite and palo verde trees,
- 2:19creosote bushes, beds of aloe, an array of cactuses,
- 2:25beryl, cholla, prickly pear, and yes, saguaros.
- 2:31That's what that lone cactus is called in your
- 2:34mind's image of out west. It's the tall, ridged
- 2:38cactus with one or two curved arms. You've probably
- 2:42seen it on a logo or a t -shirt or a silly cartoon,
- 2:46perhaps wearing sunglasses. It's ripe for anthropomorphism.
- 2:52There's even a muppet. And you might be surprised
- 2:55to know that it only grows. in the Sonoran Desert,
- 2:59in southern Arizona, and a strip of western Mexico
- 3:03down to the Gulf of California. That's because
- 3:06Arizona was a common place to film westerns.
- 3:11There was even a film studio built in 1940 called
- 3:15Old Tucson, a backlot of sorts, a folly of a
- 3:18western town. It served as a filming location
- 3:21for the original 310 to Yuma, Rio Bravo, and
- 3:26McClintock. But Only one of those films takes
- 3:29place in Arizona, and possibly not even in the
- 3:33Sonoran Desert. Still, it's the picture in your
- 3:36head. A misplaced plant which, unless you know,
- 3:41you assume grows throughout Texas and New Mexico,
- 3:45Utah and Colorado. And because of the saguaro's
- 3:50connection to Out West, it shows up in illustrated
- 3:54and animated form when you want to communicate.
- 3:57desert. But these depictions are usually so off.
- 4:03There's little understanding of how large mature
- 4:07saguaros are, 15 to 20 feet tall, or that they
- 4:11don't grow arms until they're between 75 to 100
- 4:15years of age. A couple of years ago, my husband
- 4:19played the game Horizon Zero Dawn, and it hurt
- 4:22my soul to see four to five foot tall saguaros
- 4:27with seven arms in the ruins of southern Utah.
- 4:30If you have lived in a place, if you know that
- 4:34place, you understand when it is portrayed falsely
- 4:38and when it is portrayed authentically. And that's
- 4:43why I'd like to talk today about a film set in
- 4:47an entirely different place and culture, 2010's
- 4:51Winter's Bone, directed by Debra Granik. It tells
- 4:56the story of 17 -year -old Ree Dolly, who lives
- 5:00in the Ozarks of Missouri with her two younger
- 5:02siblings and her mother who is nearly catatonic
- 5:05for an unexplained reason, likely a combination
- 5:08of mental illness and trauma. Rhi, a high school
- 5:13dropout, is the sole caretaker for her family.
- 5:17One day, the local sheriff shows up on her front
- 5:20doorstep looking for her estranged father. He
- 5:24was arrested for cooking meth and put up his
- 5:27house and property as bail. If he does not show
- 5:31up to court, in one week, Rhi and her vulnerable
- 5:35family will be evicted from their home. Rhi must
- 5:39travel through the backwoods of rural Missouri
- 5:41into the depths of a criminal network in order
- 5:45to find her father and protect her way of life.
- 5:49You probably haven't seen this movie, and that's
- 5:52okay. It was nominated for two Oscars, including
- 5:57Best Picture, but it probably wouldn't have been
- 6:00nominated if the pool hadn't been expanded beyond
- 6:03five. It's one of those jewels of independent
- 6:07cinema. It debuted at the Sundance Film Festival
- 6:11and won the Grand Jury Prize for Dramatic Film,
- 6:14going on to have a small debut in four theaters
- 6:17in New York and Los Angeles, later playing in
- 6:20a smattering of heartland cities, where it did
- 6:24fairly well for its size. Even so, it became
- 6:28the lowest -grossing Best Picture nominee since
- 6:311983, and one that few people, if any, talk about.
- 6:38It's mostly remembered for its star. This film
- 6:42was the breakthrough role for Jennifer Lawrence.
- 6:45She received her first nomination for Best Actress
- 6:49as the quiet but tenacious Rhi, trudging her
- 6:52way to answers, pushing further and further into
- 6:56danger, knowing to give up means losing everything.
- 7:01It's certainly the part that won her the role
- 7:04of Katniss in The Hunger Games. Of the two characters,
- 7:08Lawrence once said something to the effect of
- 7:10Katniss runs, but Rhi walks, which is a fairly
- 7:15good comparison of their characters. I remember
- 7:18reading the coverage of the 2011 Oscars. Rhi
- 7:23is a country girl in the winter, dressing largely
- 7:26in sweatshirts, thick coats, and work boots.
- 7:31She wears little to no makeup, and her blonde
- 7:33hair is often tucked under a beanie or pulled
- 7:36back. So reporters were surprised when her actress
- 7:40showed up on the red carpet in a slinky, bright
- 7:43red dress, and it was Jennifer Lawrence. It was
- 7:47almost funny to watch them discover that she
- 7:50cleaned up so well. I watched this movie for
- 7:54the first time in college, on a laptop in a study
- 7:58carrel while making flashcards. I was still fairly
- 8:02new to independent cinema. You see, when I was
- 8:05in middle school, my family moved from the Sonoran
- 8:09Desert across the country to a tiny town on the
- 8:12outskirts of Appalachia, though deep enough that
- 8:16we learned the local pronunciation, Appalachia.
- 8:20It was far too small to have a movie theater.
- 8:23Two larger towns nearby did, cycling through
- 8:26blockbusters. Mid -budget films would make their
- 8:30appearance, but only for the requisite two weeks.
- 8:33We'd never been an opening weekend kind of family,
- 8:36preferring to wait for movies to come to the
- 8:39cheap theaters, but we had to learn very quickly.
- 8:42If you don't see a movie in the opening two weeks,
- 8:46you might not be able to see it in theaters at
- 8:48all. Very occasionally, we'd drive to the nearest
- 8:53city to watch a smaller film, but that required
- 8:56a day trip. and so it didn't happen much. So
- 9:00my exploration of independent cinema was largely
- 9:03through the internet. I'm indebted to Yahoo!
- 9:06Movies and Rotten Tomatoes for showing their
- 9:09reviews of indies, and I became well -versed
- 9:12at reading about movies I knew I may never see.
- 9:16I also explored libraries, and while our local
- 9:20collections were very small, The library at my
- 9:23small liberal arts university had an excellent
- 9:26collection of old and new cinema and made sure
- 9:30to acquire Best Picture nominees when possible,
- 9:32which is how I ended up watching Winter's Bone
- 9:36on a laptop. I knew a little about the story
- 9:39from what I'd read and the clips I'd seen of
- 9:42Lawrence's performance at the Oscars. I knew
- 9:45it was a crime film. and possibly even that it
- 9:48was what the author of the source material called
- 9:51a country noir, but I was not expecting the experience
- 9:56of watching this film. The opening shot of this
- 10:02movie is of a field obscured by bare trees. In
- 10:07this field is a collection of abandoned vehicles,
- 10:10cars, trucks, an RV, and a school bus. I was
- 10:17taken aback. I paused the movie to check where
- 10:20it was shot on IMDb. It was indeed filmed in
- 10:25Missouri. But it looked like the land where my
- 10:29family lived. And that site, a field of abandoned
- 10:34vehicles, was so specific, and exactly the sort
- 10:38of thing movies set in the boonies do not portray,
- 10:42that I felt unnerved. Especially the school bus.
- 10:47It isn't a junkyard. It's just a field. The next
- 10:54shot shows Ree's siblings playing outside, jumping
- 10:57on a trampoline without a net. Next to them are
- 11:01pieces of plastic kitty furniture, a bench, and
- 11:05a plastic kitchen. Not the kind of toy you find
- 11:10outside houses, but inside. And then you see
- 11:16them sitting on a couch on the front porch, not
- 11:19a patio chair, an upholstered couch. If you had
- 11:25asked me to articulate the specifics of an authentic
- 11:28portrayal of the communities near my parents'
- 11:31home, I could not have identified these things.
- 11:35But I recognized them immediately. I have never
- 11:40in my life seen plastic kiddie kitchens outside
- 11:43or a full -on couch on somebody's front porch,
- 11:46except in Appalachia. Then Rhi takes her siblings
- 11:52to school, and I again had to stop the film,
- 11:55flashcards abandoned. The hallways of this school
- 11:59look exactly the same as my high school. One
- 12:05corridor in particular, near the gym in this
- 12:07film location, is exactly the same in architecture
- 12:11as a hallway I walked every day of my high school
- 12:15career. And the gym itself is a dead ringer for
- 12:19my middle school gym. On the loudspeaker is an
- 12:23announcement for a meeting of the Future Career
- 12:26and Community Leaders of America, the FCCLA.
- 12:30an organization I have only ever heard of in
- 12:34the context of my high school and this film,
- 12:37one whose members were, for lack of a better
- 12:41turn of phrase, the people who stayed. They had
- 12:46no intention of going to college or leaving for
- 12:50a higher -paying job. They planned to stay, living
- 12:54maybe a mile or two from where they grew up.
- 12:59Shortly after, in the film, Rhi goes to visit
- 13:02her friend Gail. Gail is probably 17 or 18. Gail
- 13:08is also married, with a baby. I knew quite a
- 13:12few people who married after high school graduation,
- 13:15and at least one classmate married at 17. It
- 13:19was legal if your parents agreed to it. My junior
- 13:22year of high school, at least 1 % of the student
- 13:26body was pregnant. This was normal. This was
- 13:31ordinary. This is not what I expected to see
- 13:36as the backdrop to this story, its assumed setting.
- 13:41It was unnerving in a way that's difficult to
- 13:44describe. Exposing, uncomfortable, incredibly
- 13:50specific, and unexpected for two distinct reasons.
- 13:58First, the Ozarks are not a part of Appalachia.
- 14:02Not all rural America is the same or has the
- 14:07same culture. The university where I sat and
- 14:10watched this film is in a tiny town only slightly
- 14:14larger than where I attended high school, but
- 14:17it is in the Midwest. That is not a location
- 14:21signifier only. During the westward expansion
- 14:26of white settlers in the U .S., European immigrants
- 14:30tended to settle on land that reminded them of
- 14:33home. There's a reason Minnesota is connected
- 14:36with a specific accent. It was largely settled
- 14:39by Scandinavians. Who else would flock to those
- 14:43kinds of winters? It felt like home. Large portions
- 14:47of the Midwest were settled by German immigrants,
- 14:50who found the prairies and forests similar to
- 14:53German plains. They built a very practical culture
- 14:57with hearty food. A fixture of potlucks in my
- 15:01college town was homemade egg noodles, and every
- 15:05local restaurant featured fried pork tenderloin,
- 15:08which is literally just schnitzel. The Appalachian
- 15:14Mountains are an old mountain range, tracing
- 15:17its roots far, far back to what is known as the
- 15:21Central Pangean Mountains, a range that existed
- 15:25before continental drift occurred. The remnants
- 15:29of these mountains also include both Ireland
- 15:33and Britain. So when the Scotch -Irish, a group
- 15:38of people composed of Scottish Presbyterians
- 15:40who relocated to Northern Ireland and, far later,
- 15:45fled economic hardship, came to the American
- 15:48colonies in the 18th century, they found mountains
- 15:52that look like home. Mountains that, unbeknownst
- 15:58to them, were the same as home. What I didn't
- 16:03know when watching Winter's Bone, and what I
- 16:05do know now, is that later, as westward expansion
- 16:09pushed Native peoples out of their land, and
- 16:13white settlers moved in behind, the Ozarks were
- 16:17first settled by descendants of these Scotch
- 16:20-Irish people, seeding Appalachian culture again
- 16:24in the mountains. So the culture in this film
- 16:29shares deep connections with the town my family
- 16:32lived in, far more than where I went to college.
- 16:38Appalachian culture is old and complex. It places
- 16:44a great value on family networks, a holdover
- 16:47from its Scottish roots, where clans are reborn
- 16:51into kin. One of my friends from high school
- 16:55often refers to her hometown as having nobility,
- 16:59old, deeply rooted families whose names show
- 17:03up again and again. In Winter's Bone, This kind
- 17:08of family network is Ree's one connection to
- 17:11navigating the criminal underworld safely. You
- 17:15and me is kin, she says. Ain't that supposed
- 17:19to mean something? Appalachia is full of a community
- 17:24that takes care of its own. I remember a kid
- 17:28in high school getting into a bad car accident.
- 17:31Someone placed a cardboard can next to the lunch
- 17:34line in the cafeteria, asking for donations to
- 17:37help with medical bills. It was assumed that
- 17:41we, his classmates, would help take care of him.
- 17:46In Winter's Bone, Ri and her brother watch their
- 17:49neighbors skin a deer in a time where they're
- 17:52struggling to feed themselves. He wonders if
- 17:55they should ask for some food. Ri takes his chin
- 17:59in her hand and says, Never ask for what ought
- 18:03to be offered. Community support is a cultural
- 18:07assumption. Appalachia is a place with a deep
- 18:12musical tradition. Folk songs and folk instruments.
- 18:16In sixth grade music class, we learned to play
- 18:19the dulcimer, getting quizzed on Down in the
- 18:22Valley. Our district had retained a good music
- 18:26program, and every time a performance of our
- 18:28string ensemble was lagging, we pulled out some
- 18:31bluegrass fiddling and slap bass, and all the
- 18:34smiles appeared in the audience. In Winter's
- 18:37Bone, music accompanies the few joyful scenes
- 18:41of this story. A gathering for a grandma's birthday.
- 18:45The finale of a strumming banjo. It also opens
- 18:49the film. an a cappella version of the Missouri
- 18:53Waltz setting our scene. But these things, these
- 18:57signifiers, are all the more unexpected when
- 19:01you consider my second reason for surprise at
- 19:04the experience of watching this film. That mountain
- 19:08people are very often poorly represented in the
- 19:11media as cartoons and caricatures, idiot clowns
- 19:17or ignorant villains. This was especially true
- 19:21in the early 2000s. While there were conversations
- 19:25throughout the 90s into the millennium about
- 19:27cultural sensitivity towards other races and
- 19:30people groups, hillbillies remained ripe for
- 19:35entertainment value. So many reality TV shows
- 19:39thrived off this image of poor, fat, dumb country
- 19:43people. Movies, too. While every TV procedural
- 19:48got to have a special episode in Appalachia where
- 19:52bigoted, inbred racists killed some poor sweet
- 19:56girl, these images were everywhere. I think it's
- 20:02easy to forget how vulnerable mountain people
- 20:05are. These are the poorest areas in the country.
- 20:10They have tied themselves to a place they love.
- 20:14these mountains that are home. And employment
- 20:18is complicated. The land is how they survive,
- 20:22and for a while they did so by exploiting that
- 20:25land through coal mining and logging. But those
- 20:29are dangerous professions, one that put bodies
- 20:32in harm's way. Some get by by farming, although
- 20:36the land isn't valuable for large commercial
- 20:39farms. And others have found alternate ways of
- 20:43living. outside the law. Moonshining was historically
- 20:48an option, and during Prohibition it kept quite
- 20:51a few families fed. So it should be no surprise
- 20:54that producing illegal substances is still a
- 20:57thriving industry, not to mention life is hard,
- 21:02and many people with hard lives find unhealthy
- 21:06ways to escape. I want to be clear. Appalachians
- 21:13aren't I don't think Winter's Bone thinks they
- 21:18are either, even if it is a crime drama transposing
- 21:23the noir genre to a rural setting. It isn't the
- 21:27crime that felt familiar to me, but the haunted
- 21:32look in these characters' eyes. I have seen people
- 21:37like every character in this movie while filling
- 21:41up my car at a gas station. or shopping for groceries
- 21:44at Walmart. And it felt bizarre to watch a movie
- 21:49that understood how vulnerable this community
- 21:52is. Even the characters that are violent criminals
- 21:56elicit compassion in their continual collapse
- 22:00into terrible cycles. And what struck me then
- 22:05on my first watch And what continues to strike
- 22:08me now is that this movie was made by outsiders.
- 22:13Deborah Granik is from Massachusetts. She went
- 22:17to Brandeis University and got her master's from
- 22:20Tisch. On that DVD was a commentary with her
- 22:24and the cinematographer Michael McDonough. He's
- 22:27a Brit. This is not their community. This is
- 22:32not their place. But they weren't content with
- 22:37a stereotype, with a saguaro in Utah. They researched
- 22:42the Ozarks. They visited homes, observed how
- 22:46people dressed and talked and decorated their
- 22:49front porches. They cast locally, and it mattered
- 22:53to them that Jennifer Lawrence was from Kentucky,
- 22:56even if it was the western half. When I try to
- 23:02explain Appalachia to other people, There isn't
- 23:05much media I feel I can hand over as an accurate
- 23:08representation. There are a lot of four -foot
- 23:12-tall saguaros, stories about poor people wearing
- 23:16a full face of makeup in their too -clean cars
- 23:19and their nice new jackets, talking loudly about
- 23:22a popular political issue for New York and Los
- 23:26Angeles so those audiences will feel sympathy
- 23:29for them. There aren't many stories that feel
- 23:33right. that show people I recognized, that are
- 23:38honest about what's good about the culture of
- 23:41hill people, and truthful about the vulnerabilities
- 23:44and the spirals that continue to bring suffering.
- 23:47But if you want to know what the setting of Appalachia
- 23:50feels like, what it looks like, what it sounds
- 23:54like, Winter's Bone, a crime noir jewel of independent
- 23:59cinema, is a surprisingly good place to start.
- 24:03And maybe, if other filmmakers are as attentive
- 24:07as Deborah Granik, our picture of America will
- 24:11begin to look a lot less like my backyard and
- 24:14more like the beautiful, complicated place it
- 24:18actually is. Thanks for coming.