Latest / No Way Out / From Battlefield to Pen: Military Insights, Strategy, and Creative Transformation with Austin Caroe
Transcript
- 0:21Mark McGrath: So we'll have a lot of fun with this conversation, but I guess we should get started by saying the views of our guests do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the United States Army.
- 0:32Mark McGrath: Is that fair?
- 0:33Austin Caroe: That is fair and that is correct.
- 0:34Austin Caroe: I am here speaking for myself, not speaking for the Army.
- 0:37Austin Caroe: The Army does not officially endorse no Way Out, although they should, but they don't.
- 0:43Mark McGrath: Well, we haven't been invited yet to be on the Army's podcast, the official Army podcast.
- 0:49Ponch Rivera: Well, the Air Force is talking to us.
- 0:50Ponch Rivera: That's true, the Air Force is talking to us.
- 0:52Ponch Rivera: Do they have an official?
- 0:54Mark McGrath: Army podcast.
- 0:55Mark McGrath: I mean they must.
- 0:56Mark McGrath: It's probably, I don't know, do they?
- 1:02Mark McGrath: I don't know?
- 1:03Mark McGrath: I mean there's certainly plenty of Army veterans.
- 1:07Austin Caroe: I know JRTC has their own official podcast and NTC has their own official podcast where they talk about lessons learned through different rotations and things like that.
- 1:16Austin Caroe: But again, I don't even.
- 1:17Austin Caroe: I think those are official and units have podcasts too, and so it is what it is.
- 1:23Austin Caroe: I don't know if there's an official Army podcast.
- 1:30Mark McGrath: Well, if they're out there, have punch and I put a word for us to get uh punch and I on the talk about oodle loop, so the army could restore itself with uh the theories of john boyd, there's a soldier for life podcast.
- 1:38Ponch Rivera: It looks like it's done by the army okay I don't know what that's about?
- 1:42Austin Caroe: well, it's probably about transitioning soldiers to the private sector out of the Army.
- 1:47Ponch Rivera: That's what the Soldier for.
- 1:48Austin Caroe: Life program is yeah.
- 1:49Ponch Rivera: My Army benefits, how to transition out, how to pay your taxes, because you're going to have to pay taxes when you leave for a lot more.
- 1:56Mark McGrath: I should tell.
- 1:57Ponch Rivera: No, your retirement's not worth a million dollars.
- 1:59Mark McGrath: I should disclose Austin.
- 2:01Mark McGrath: I am the son of a retired Army officer.
- 2:03Mark McGrath: I was born at Fort Knox, lived at Fort Benning, lived in Grafenwoehr.
- 2:06Mark McGrath: So I've done the uh.
- 2:08Mark McGrath: It chased me right into the Marine Corps.
- 2:09Mark McGrath: So yeah, but um you do know, I was a government employee for the army?
- 2:15Ponch Rivera: right, I was a government employee for the army, oh.
- 2:18Austin Caroe: I didn't know that.
- 2:18Austin Caroe: I knew you were a pilot.
- 2:20Austin Caroe: I didn't know you were an.
- 2:20Austin Caroe: I was the army.
- 2:21Ponch Rivera: So I, I, I was a GS uh army guy in um cool Institute cart for 16 months.
- 2:28Ponch Rivera: Yeah, I had to get out.
- 2:29Austin Caroe: Okay, that's as long as you can stand it.
- 2:33Mark McGrath: They had to bring in some Navy and say it's my army story.
- 2:35Mark McGrath: Yeah, so now I'm minding my own business one day and I'm thumbing through sub stack I don't know, maybe over a year ago and there's this great Substack called the Distro and we're speaking with the author.
- 2:46Mark McGrath: Here we are all these months later.
- 2:49Mark McGrath: I love your stuff.
- 2:51Mark McGrath: What started it all for you?
- 2:54Mark McGrath: How do you figure out?
- 2:56Mark McGrath: One day I'm like I'm in the army and I'm just going to start writing about stuff.
- 3:02Austin Caroe: So with a lot of things it was kind of a COVID project.
- 3:04Austin Caroe: So you know, with a lot of things it was kind of a COVID project.
- 3:38Austin Caroe: So we were kind of opening myself up intellectually.
- 3:40Austin Caroe: I was reading a lot of Nassim Taleb he was very influential in my thinking.
- 3:44Austin Caroe: I came across John Boyd, of course, Yanir Bar-Yam, some of the other complexity writers, that book Chaos who wrote that Anyway, that's the main book on chaos that everybody reads, just sort of the popular book.
- 3:57Austin Caroe: So I was kind of immersing myself intellectually in these different types of things.
- 4:02Austin Caroe: And then, as I was reading, I was like man, we kind of did a lot of this stuff while I was in command.
- 4:06Austin Caroe: This describes a lot of sort of my philosophy about things and how we went about stuff, and so I was just writing a lot of different essays and ideas and jotting things down.
- 4:16Austin Caroe: I didn't publish them, I didn't really do anything with them, but I had dozens of Google documents of started essays, half-finished essays, completed essays.
- 4:27Austin Caroe: And then we withdrew from Afghanistan and I was very upset.
- 4:33Austin Caroe: I deployed there three times.
- 4:35Austin Caroe: I had lost friends there, A lot of soldiers I knew had gotten hurt, and so for a lot of service members it was a very emotional time for me and I sat down and wrote a really long essay about not really long I mean, it was maybe 5,000 words or so about Afghanistan and why I thought it had collapsed and the things that had gone wrong.
- 4:58Austin Caroe: And I was researching different newsletter things.
- 5:02Austin Caroe: I had one newsletter service that I was using but I wasn't really sending out very much stuff.
- 5:06Austin Caroe: So I found Substack and I was like, oh, this sounds great.
- 5:15Austin Caroe: So I brought over my email list from the other newsletter I had and I added a bunch of people.
- 5:17Austin Caroe: I texted people hey, do you want to get on this?
- 5:18Austin Caroe: And so I added a bunch of people.
- 5:19Austin Caroe: And then I sent out this essay on Afghanistan and it went relatively viral, Like you know.
- 5:25Austin Caroe: It got shared a lot.
- 5:26Austin Caroe: It got shared so much that it made it to my I had just gotten to ILE, to intermediate level education, to the command and general staff college, and this essay had made it to my instructors, and which was which was good and bad, because some people I had some instructors reach out to me being like, hey, this is amazing, I want you to do a, get a second master's, a master's in military arts and science, where you have to write a thesis.
- 5:55Austin Caroe: I want to be your thesis advisor.
- 5:56Austin Caroe: I had other people basically being like, well, this is a crock of crap and this is nonsense.
- 6:02Austin Caroe: So it was pretty polarizing, Even though I didn't lay blame on any specific person.
- 6:07Austin Caroe: I tried to talk about structures and what I thought had gone wrong.
- 6:10Austin Caroe: And you can still find that essay.
- 6:12Austin Caroe: It's still up.
- 6:12Austin Caroe: I've actually published one or two, I think one follow-up where I went through the Special Inspector General for Afghan Reconstruction.
- 6:19Austin Caroe: I went through their report and basically copied and pasted from their report, inter top, inter interwoven, with what I had written, basically being like see, I told you so, like this is.
- 6:30Austin Caroe: This wasn't me just shooting my mouth off like the inspector general said the exact same thing.
- 6:35Mark McGrath: So that went relatively viral and I was like man, I I think I have like a platform, I think I can do this writing thing pretty well, give us a taste of, give us, give us some of the patterns that you were observing, that they ended up affirming in that report.
- 6:48Mark McGrath: What are some of the things that you were seeing and tuned in on?
- 6:52Austin Caroe: So the two main things are nobody was in charge and there was no strategy.
- 6:56Austin Caroe: You know people tried to disagree with that.
- 6:58Ponch Rivera: That sounds like every business in America right now, every Fortune 20.
- 7:05Austin Caroe: And so at the end of the essay I had, I was like, hey, look, if you want to do these types of things again, if you want to fight a small conflict like this, there's probably different ways that you could go about it.
- 7:10Austin Caroe: But one thing is put one person in charge and be like, hey, you are the czar, you get to make all the decisions and success or failure is on your shoulders alone.
- 7:21Austin Caroe: You don't get to do this.
- 7:21Austin Caroe: Hey, you come in for 18 months high five.
- 7:24Austin Caroe: The next guy.
- 7:24Austin Caroe: That guy comes in, blames all the last guy for all the things that are wrong, but says, oh, but I can do it differently.
- 7:30Austin Caroe: And then when they leave they play with all the metrics and say, oh, we did such a good job, look at me, I'm amazing.
- 7:36Austin Caroe: And then you just repeat that cycle for 20 years.
- 7:38Austin Caroe: But again, you can't lay the blame on any one individual if you do that and the SIGAR report basically says the same thing where it's like, hey, this constant turnover seriously hampered the effort, and then the lack of strategy.
- 7:49Austin Caroe: One of the stories I tell in my essay is on my second deployment.
- 7:54Austin Caroe: I was at Headquarters Resolute Support, which is the four-star NATO headquarters, and I was a liaison there, and I had a colonel sit me down and be like, well, you see, captain there, and I had a colonel sit me down and be like, well, you see, captain, here in Afghanistan we've only been fighting nine to 12 months at a time, just fighting season after fighting season, and that's really what we've been doing.
- 8:14Austin Caroe: But we have now decided that we need a five to 10 year plan for Afghanistan and, mind you, this is in 2016.
- 8:21Austin Caroe: And it's like oh, so now you guys have decided that we need a five to 10 year plan, and that was what the sustainable security strategy was, if anybody wants to.
- 8:29Austin Caroe: So I was like are you guys kidding me?
- 8:32Austin Caroe: And then the SIGAR report said the same thing.
- 8:33Austin Caroe: It said the United States continually struggled to redefine what it was actually doing, what its strategic objectives were, who its enemies were, who its allies were.
- 8:42Austin Caroe: It's all in there.
- 8:43Austin Caroe: I mean, it's not.
- 8:44Austin Caroe: I would say if you get too far into the details of Afghanistan, you are missing the point.
- 8:49Austin Caroe: The big strokes, the big, simple explanations are the best explanations, like the New York Times sorry, I'm really going off on a rant.
- 8:55Austin Caroe: The New York Times is going off on this, like well, the real reason we lost is because they supported people like General Rozek, who was really bad, and people, people hated him and they didn't win the hearts and minds and blah, blah, blah.
- 9:11Austin Caroe: I'm like guys, I'm not saying that's wrong, but that's not why we lost.
- 9:13Austin Caroe: We beat ourselves.
- 9:13Austin Caroe: That's what it comes down to.
- 9:14Mark McGrath: So anyway, there you go.
- 9:15Mark McGrath: Which one, so that one, what's the title of that one?
- 9:19Mark McGrath: So we want to make sure that we link to that.
- 9:29Austin Caroe: So there's one that's called Afghanistanghanistan, which is the first one, and then the second one is called.
- 9:31Austin Caroe: I'll send it to you.
- 9:31Austin Caroe: I have to look it up, I think it's.
- 9:32Austin Caroe: Yeah, it's like looking back or retrospective or something like that.
- 9:33Mark McGrath: So I'll send those to you, that way you can link it.
- 9:35Mark McGrath: So punch and I, being gen xers from the knees, you know, were in in, at least in my high school days.
- 9:42Mark McGrath: Everybody wanted to live, live in Seattle and go follow, like Alice in Chains and Pearl Jam.
- 9:46Mark McGrath: So I look at your titles and, like those albums, they all have one word, like you, just have like a one word title.
- 9:51Austin Caroe: One word yeah.
- 9:52Mark McGrath: Which is great.
- 9:53Austin Caroe: That's right.
- 9:53Mark McGrath: It's like a lot of grunge bands.
- 9:55Austin Caroe: Yeah, you know I did that as a forcing function to stay away from, to prevent myself from doing any clickbait, because you know I could make a whole bunch of different.
- 10:04Austin Caroe: I can't stand the clickbaity things like here's five ways to improve your leadership and so I tried to stay away from that by just sticking to the single word.
- 10:11Austin Caroe: I will usually, if I have a guest post, I'll work with the, the, the author on the guest post, what the title is going to be, and usually it's multi-words, so if it's not just me writing, then sometimes there'll be a.
- 10:22Austin Caroe: It'll be a little bit more explanatory in what the title is.
- 10:25Ponch Rivera: Hey Austin, I'm curious as to how, yadir Bar-Yam you also had Nassim Taleb, his book on anti-fragile how the thinking on complexity influenced your thoughts on Afghanistan.
- 10:39Ponch Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 10:41Ponch Rivera: Like entropy I know Tlaib talks about that sometimes Anti-fragile, which is nothing more than resilience under another name.
- 10:49Austin Caroe: So let's see, do I have maybe I didn't bring it in here I have Bar-Yim's book Making Things Work, which is funny because that book is written, I think, in 2004.
- 11:01Austin Caroe: It's published in 2004, 2005.
- 11:03Austin Caroe: He goes over the US approach to Afghanistan in there.
- 11:07Austin Caroe: That's one of the very first chapters, if you remember.
- 11:09Austin Caroe: Have you guys read this book?
- 11:11Ponch Rivera: No, but I met him.
- 11:12Ponch Rivera: I'll make a connection here a little bit.
- 11:17Austin Caroe: Oh sweet.
- 11:18Austin Caroe: So he writes about Afghanistan in there, but it's a 2004 perspective and, if you remember, in 2004, it's still very unclear as to what's happening.
- 11:27Austin Caroe: But our structure is very complex.
- 11:30Austin Caroe: Our command structure is very complex.
- 11:31Austin Caroe: One of the things he says in the book and it's been maybe a year or two since I've read it is that the complexity of the organism has to match the complexity of the environment, which I think is true.
- 11:47Austin Caroe: But if you remember the, I would love to talk to him kind of about this, because something changed in our approach to Afghanistan.
- 11:51Austin Caroe: It became, I think, two, we started putting too many resources in.
- 11:55Austin Caroe: That's another thing.
- 11:56Austin Caroe: The Inspector General report goes over.
- 11:58Austin Caroe: A lot is we flooded it with resources, mostly with just money.
- 12:01Austin Caroe: We just throw money at things, and that wasn't something that we were doing in the early days.
- 12:07Austin Caroe: But there wasn't.
- 12:08Austin Caroe: You know, I wasn't thinking a lot about complexity when I wrote.
- 12:12Austin Caroe: I was just thinking about kind of obvious things and I think and you don't want to be too, I don't know the right way to put it here it wasn't something that I was really thinking about was complexity.
- 12:22Austin Caroe: It was really like what I had seen because I had served at every echelon.
- 12:26Austin Caroe: I'd served at the platoon leader level fighting against the bad guys, going on patrol every day, hitting IEDs, recovering vehicles, seeing sort of the futility in that I had participated in big battalion movement to contact operations which were completely fruitless.
- 12:42Austin Caroe: I felt like you know what I always tell people when I was a platoon leader is like it feels like we're an elephant in a hornet's nest, which is like we just can't, we're just not matched for this.
- 12:50Austin Caroe: You know, we're not equipped to do, we're not fighting the way that we need to be fighting to win.
- 12:54Austin Caroe: So I saw it at the tactical level.
- 12:56Austin Caroe: I saw it at the operational level when I was on the brigade staff, seeing all the different battalions working together.
- 13:01Austin Caroe: I saw it at the regional level, at the TAC South level when I was on that staff, and I saw it at the four-star level, at the highest level in the theater.
- 13:11Austin Caroe: I used all that experience and put that together to be like this is what I think happened Were you doing any?
- 13:21Mark McGrath: tribal engagement, or was it more kinetic stuff with what you were doing?
- 13:27Austin Caroe: It was mostly kinetic, it wasn't super, it's hard to explain.
- 13:30Austin Caroe: It wasn't really like tribal where we were.
- 13:32Austin Caroe: I mean it was right, but it was mostly dealing with individuals.
- 13:34Austin Caroe: I actually learned a lot about, because I'm just curious, naturally.
- 13:39Austin Caroe: So I learned a lot about the poppy trade when I was there.
- 13:42Austin Caroe: So I sat down and I would talk to different poppy farmers about how the poppy trade work, and I could go off on a whole thing about how the poppy trade works, but it you know, and those poppies those are only for bagels and cakes, right?
- 13:54Mark McGrath: The poppy has no use for that, correct, it's just for bagels and everything bagels.
- 14:01Mark McGrath: Yeah, exactly Right, and we can't eat too many poppy seed bagels, otherwise we'll pop hot on a drug test.
- 14:07Mark McGrath: Well, tell I mean, unpack that a little more.
- 14:08Mark McGrath: So tell I mean tell us more about the interactions with the, with the poppy farmers, though, like what you know, what were the things that caught your attention to learn about the?
- 14:15Mark McGrath: Learn about that, give us, give us some more on that I was.
- 14:18Austin Caroe: I've always been interested in economics and mark you and I have talked a little bit about austrian economics and was just very interested in, like, how does the supply chain work?
- 14:25Austin Caroe: You know, are these farmers like, are they bad guys?
- 14:28Austin Caroe: Obviously, you know they're not.
- 14:29Austin Caroe: They really just want to make their money.
- 14:31Austin Caroe: But basically I won't go into too many details, but the basic structure is the poppy farmer owns the field and grows the poppy and then people come in from outside, like people come in from the cities and from everywhere else and they buy a piece of the field from the farmer and then they are the ones that harvest the poppy for him, so he grows it.
- 14:53Austin Caroe: But other people come in, they pay for a part of the field, then they harvest it and then they take it and sell it to somebody else, who sells it to somebody else, who sells it to somebody else who eventually gets it across the border, gets it to a processing station and then it gets exported from there.
- 15:06Austin Caroe: So yeah, that's those those are.
- 15:08Austin Caroe: Those are pretty, but it was very interesting talking to them.
- 15:10Austin Caroe: I really love I actually really loved the Afghan people.
- 15:14Austin Caroe: They were very hospitable, they were very accommodating, a lot like where I am right now, in El Paso and Las Cruces, where I was in Afghanistan.
- 15:27Austin Caroe: It looks very similar, so I really love the topography and you know I'm still optimistic about Afghanistan, believe it or not.
- 15:31Austin Caroe: You know Vietnam is a huge tourist destination for people from the United States.
- 16:35Austin Caroe: Today, People love going to Vietnam and you know we're not that far removed from the Vietnam War and I have similar hopes for Afghanistan and that I would love to go skiing in the Hindu Kush with my grandchildren someday and I I am optimistic.
- 16:49Austin Caroe: I think that there's a good chance that that's going to happen.
- 16:52Mark McGrath: Interesting and you did.
- 16:54Mark McGrath: You did three trips like from basically was it like your platoon commander days to up all the way up through company command.
- 17:02Austin Caroe: Yeah, I kind of bounced back and forth.
- 17:03Austin Caroe: So, yeah, I was there as a platoon leader and then I got to serve on the staff for a little bit there and then, uh, so I was in two different platoons.
- 17:10Austin Caroe: My second deployment is where I was at the four-star headquarters, um, and then my third deployment is when I came back as a company commander.
- 17:17Mark McGrath: When you were in the four-star headquarters, were you in ops or plans where we would?
- 17:21Austin Caroe: So I was a liaison officer from TAC South under General Agudo and then under General Henry, representing the TAC South staff, which was a division level staff or a one star or two, one two star level staff to a four star staff and that was an amazing experience.
- 17:37Austin Caroe: It was really great.
- 17:38Austin Caroe: You really learned a lot about staffing and how the Army works and how that war was being being run.
- 17:46Mark McGrath: Yeah, it was great.
- 17:47Mark McGrath: It was a great experience.
- 17:48Mark McGrath: That's interesting, all right, well, let's uh, let's depart afghanistan and get to some of the uh, theoretical stuff that you, uh, that you work on.
- 17:56Mark McGrath: Uh, I'll cover, cover a couple of things, of course.
- 17:59Mark McGrath: The one that caught my attention was Kriegsspiel.
- 18:03Mark McGrath: You're doing Kriegsspiel chess and you used the term Fingerspitzengefühl in it.
- 18:12Mark McGrath: I did.
- 18:13Mark McGrath: I had not been familiar with Kriegsspiel chess.
- 18:17Mark McGrath: Conceptually, it sounds fascinating.
- 18:19Mark McGrath: Why don't you walk us through Kriegspiel Chess so?
- 18:22Austin Caroe: Kriegspiel.
- 18:23Austin Caroe: Chess is a fascinating game.
- 18:25Austin Caroe: I've been playing this game since before I could remember.
- 18:29Austin Caroe: Chess has always been a big thing in my family.
- 18:31Austin Caroe: Some of my earliest memories are playing chess with my grandfather, who I loved and admired, and he was an amazing chess player and a great Kriegspiel player.
- 18:40Austin Caroe: So Kriegspiel is where you cannot see your opponent's pieces.
- 18:45Austin Caroe: Now it's not just blind chess necessarily, where you know if you watch videos of Grandmasters they'll do this thing where they'll be blindfolded and then they'll be playing against four people and they'll call out the moves.
- 18:58Austin Caroe: They'll be like all right, you know pawn to c4, and then the Grandmaster, who's blindfolded, will then call out his move.
- 19:05Austin Caroe: You know a pawn d4, or whatever it is, and it's not that you cannot see your opponent's pieces and you don't know what your opponent is doing.
- 19:12Austin Caroe: So usually the players are back-to-back and then there's a referee, and so white will just move.
- 19:17Austin Caroe: So white starts, right, so they'll move, and then the referee will simply announce white has moved, it's black's move.
- 19:23Austin Caroe: Black has no idea what piece white has moved, but black must now make a move, and so black then moves, seeing so the referee.
- 19:33Austin Caroe: There is that girl in the middle and she's going to walk back and move her master board.
- 19:38Austin Caroe: So the master board keeps track of the uh of the game and then she's going to walk over to the other person.
- 19:53Austin Caroe: This is a very inefficient way to play, if you ask me.
- 19:57Austin Caroe: Back to back is is far superior, and so the referee has to be very good and there's many different ways you can play creeksfield.
- 20:05Austin Caroe: There's probably there's at least 100 different variations and house rules and things like that.
- 20:09Austin Caroe: But the way that my family has always played is a super esoteric.
- 20:14Austin Caroe: But it's a variation on what are called the cincinnati rules and it's sort of for maximum uncertainty.
- 20:22Austin Caroe: So, to give you an idea, it's like well, what happens if you make an illegal move?
- 20:25Austin Caroe: Well, illegal moves and errors are actually a huge part of the game because that's how you do reconnaissance.
- 20:31Austin Caroe: So if you can imagine that you put your bishop on one corner of the board and then move your bishop from that corner of the board to the other corner of the board, the referee is going to tell you that's no for three or no for two, and that means that there are two or so.
- 20:45Austin Caroe: Let's say he says no for three, that means there's three pieces between you and the square you want to move to.
- 20:50Austin Caroe: So now you're going back and like, well, what could?
- 20:53Austin Caroe: What?
- 20:53Austin Caroe: Three pieces could there be?
- 20:55Austin Caroe: You know what?
- 20:55Austin Caroe: What makes sense for there to be there?
- 20:57Austin Caroe: And then you might move back again.
- 20:59Austin Caroe: You'd be like, okay, well, there's no for three, where's the no for two?
- 21:01Austin Caroe: So you can find out where the different pieces are.
- 21:04Austin Caroe: So there's a lot of reconnaissance involved in the game.
- 21:06Austin Caroe: So you want to make mistakes, you want to make illegal moves because it gives you more information.
- 21:11Austin Caroe: But with all that reconnaissance there's also risk, because what happens if you try to move your bishop to the other end of the board and the referee says white has moved, it's now black's move?
- 21:20Austin Caroe: Well, you've now put your bishop in a very precarious position.
- 21:24Austin Caroe: You've essentially wasted a move and you haven't gotten any information other than there's no pieces there.
- 21:29Austin Caroe: So I guess you have that piece of information.
- 21:30Austin Caroe: So it's this game of maximum as much uncertainty as you can put into the chessboard.
- 21:35Austin Caroe: It's very fun.
- 21:36Austin Caroe: It's a great spectator sport, because spectators can see the master board and so it's very fun for them to try to figure out.
- 21:42Austin Caroe: And you can be very good at figuring out where your opponent's pieces are.
- 21:46Ponch Rivera: So, austin, on that, so are you trying to develop a mental map of where the pieces are?
- 21:51Ponch Rivera: I mean, that's what you're doing, okay, but you can't physically move the pieces that are in front of you, right?
- 21:57Ponch Rivera: You can't move the white pieces if you're on black in front of you to build that map, correct?
- 22:01Ponch Rivera: Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:02Austin Caroe: Oh, build that map correct.
- 22:02Austin Caroe: Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:03Austin Caroe: Oh, you can't Okay.
- 22:04Ponch Rivera: Okay, so you're actually you're trying to map the external environment with your if you put a boundary around you and your board.
- 22:10Ponch Rivera: It's kind of like the game of Battleship.
- 22:12Ponch Rivera: You know when you play that when you're a kid, same thing type of thing where you can't see what's going on on that side, but essentially what you're trying to.
- 22:17Ponch Rivera: So there's a lot of uncertainty in this game.
- 22:47Austin Caroe: But where it gets interesting and that's sort of mildly interesting on its own.
- 22:50Austin Caroe: It's actually hard to get chess players to play Kriegspiel because it's just so different.
- 22:53Austin Caroe: It's like a completely different game.
- 22:54Austin Caroe: Moves that make sense in chess don't make sense in Kriegspiel, and vice versa.
- 22:58Austin Caroe: But what when you start talking about AI?
- 23:10Austin Caroe: Because AI, as we know, are chess engines.
- 23:11Austin Caroe: They're about a thousand ELO points better than the best humans.
- 23:13Austin Caroe: And to give you an idea of what a thousand ELO points looks like, that's about the difference between someone who's like pretty good at their chess club compared to Magnus Carlsen or one of the greatest chess players of all time.
- 23:22Austin Caroe: It's not even close.
- 23:23Austin Caroe: It would be like you know a guy who's a regional boxer going up against you know the greatest boxers of all time.
- 23:31Austin Caroe: I mean, it's just not, it's not close.
- 23:33Austin Caroe: So chess engines are unbeatable.
- 23:35Austin Caroe: No human can beat a chess engine, because the way chess engines work is they simple.
- 23:41Austin Caroe: I'm simplifying it hugely here, but the way chess engines work is, from any position that you give them, they will simulate something like a million games or 10 million games and they'll say, hey, out of simulating these 10 million games, this move leads most often to a victory or to a draw or to the least worst position.
- 23:59Austin Caroe: So it's just playing the probabilities.
- 24:02Austin Caroe: It's saying, hey, between the available moves, this one most often leads to a victory or to a draw or whatever the best outcome, all right.
- 24:09Austin Caroe: Well, how are you going to do that in Kriegspiel when you don't know where your opponent's pieces are, you don't know what pieces have been captured, and the moves that don't make sense, like weird bishop moves or weird rook moves, which make absolutely no sense, make perfect sense in Kriegswil because you're trying to get information about the battlefield.
- 24:28Austin Caroe: Okay, so I went and did a bunch of research and I found this guy, Paolo Siancarini, who's at the University of Bologna, who probably has created the best Kriegswil programs, and it turns out that you can actually build a pretty good chess engine for Kriegspiel.
- 24:46Austin Caroe: But here's what's interesting about it In his paper he has three different approaches.
- 24:51Austin Caroe: The approach that turned out to be the best approach for the computer was not to simulate the game all the way to the end, was not to even try to guess where all the pieces was.
- 25:01Austin Caroe: It was just saying what is the next right move, for all the pieces was.
- 25:06Austin Caroe: It was just saying what is the next right move like what is the next move?
- 25:08Austin Caroe: That's not gonna, that's not gonna cause catastrophe for me, or that's gonna protect my pieces which remind me a lot of you know, dave snowden has that.
- 25:13Austin Caroe: A lot in complexity and uncertainty do the next right thing?
- 25:16Austin Caroe: Um, and so the computer is essentially mimicking what it's trying to mimic what humans do under uncertainty.
- 25:24Austin Caroe: But it turns out that even the best creeksville engines can't beat the best humans at creeksville.
- 25:30Ponch Rivera: Yeah, not yet, so I want to at least I want to pack this some more because you brought up this note and complicated and complex.
- 25:35Ponch Rivera: When you so, we'll I'll uh, bring up some manny duke in here as well.
- 25:39Ponch Rivera: So she wrote a book, several books actually.
- 25:40Ponch Rivera: One of the things she talks about is the difference between, you know, complicated and complex, if you will.
- 25:46Ponch Rivera: So when you're playing a game of chess, it contains no hidden pieces.
- 25:50Ponch Rivera: Both players can see all the pieces all the time.
- 25:53Ponch Rivera: They can't randomly appear or disappear.
- 25:55Ponch Rivera: Outcomes correlate more tightly with decision quality.
- 25:57Ponch Rivera: So if you're a subject matter you know, based on your expertise, so that outcome is very connected to the decision qualities.
- 26:04Ponch Rivera: Right there, it's a well defined form of computation.
- 26:07Ponch Rivera: And then the next thing is I think Kriegsfield, the way you're playing at chess is probably more like some people talk about Go I like poker as another analogy.
- 26:15Ponch Rivera: But you have valuable information remains hidden, right, it's hidden.
- 26:19Ponch Rivera: You have incomplete information and you're making decisions under conditions of uncertainty over time, right, so this is important.
- 26:26Ponch Rivera: Now we talk about developing a strategy in a complex environment.
- 26:29Ponch Rivera: Information and you're making decisions under conditions of uncertainty over time, right, so this is important.
- 26:32Ponch Rivera: Now we talk about developing a strategy in a complex environment.
- 26:33Ponch Rivera: It's an adaptive strategy, meaning it's changing based off the landscape.
- 26:35Ponch Rivera: And that map that you're building, or that chessboard that you're building in front of you, has incomplete information, right.
- 26:40Ponch Rivera: You don't know what piece is where.
- 26:41Ponch Rivera: You just know that there's something in a spot, potentially, where you don't know.
- 26:44Ponch Rivera: And this is that difference between the complicated and complex and what we're.
- 26:49Ponch Rivera: I think the best thing you can take away from this conversation, if you're a business leader, is your strategy has to build with two things build around a map that you you know the map is not the terrain.
- 26:59Ponch Rivera: You have to build a map of the external environment, and you do that from multiple perspectives, right.
- 27:01Ponch Rivera: In this case, the game you're playing has one perspective.
- 27:02Ponch Rivera: That's in perspective.
- 27:03Ponch Rivera: You have to build a map of the external environment, and you do that from multiple perspectives, right.
- 27:05Ponch Rivera: In this case, the game you're playing has one perspective and that's the perspective of the chess player, right?
- 27:10Ponch Rivera: Or the creature-fueled chess player.
- 27:12Ponch Rivera: The next thing you have to do.
- 27:14Ponch Rivera: Your strategy is not a five-year strategy.
- 27:16Ponch Rivera: It is an adaptive strategy based off information that's coming in and you have to build your next move, your next right move, based off the information you have right.
- 27:25Ponch Rivera: So it goes back to that idea of probe sense respond.
- 27:29Ponch Rivera: In the complex domain you probe, which you said earlier, is done through illegal moves, if I understand it correctly.
- 27:35Ponch Rivera: Sometimes that's right.
- 27:37Austin Caroe: Yeah, yeah, and we'll come back to this.
- 27:38Austin Caroe: But, yes, keep going.
- 27:39Austin Caroe: Yes, exactly right.
- 27:41Ponch Rivera: So I think this is why this is very important in this whole conversation about no way out the world of reorientation, strategy, mapping, creating a mental model.
- 27:51Ponch Rivera: When we do our simulations for teamwork, we want them to build a mental model, or a shared mental model, and I know some people don't like that term.
- 27:59Ponch Rivera: Build a fucking map.
- 28:00Ponch Rivera: That's what we're trying to ask you to do.
- 28:01Ponch Rivera: Build a common map that you have, a common operational picture that you can all work on together and then you execute that over time.
- 28:08Ponch Rivera: In industry, in businesses, they do not do this, they do not map, they refuse to map, and they hire McKinsey, they hire somebody in to give them a five-year plan or a five-year, 10-year strategy.
- 28:18Ponch Rivera: That is just a bunch of word, a bunch of mumbo jumbo.
- 28:22Ponch Rivera: This is the most important thing you should take away from this conversation up to this point is you have to build a map of the external environment, otherwise you're going to get your ass kicked.
- 28:32Ponch Rivera: And that all maps are wrong.
- 28:34Austin Caroe: Right, all maps are wrong, some are useful Exactly and see, and that's the see.
- 28:39Austin Caroe: That's the very most.
- 28:40Austin Caroe: One of the most important things in Creek Spill is when you're building your map, you are constantly adjusting it because you know it's wrong, it can't possibly be right, and so you're always updating where you think your opponent's pieces are based on new information.
- 28:53Austin Caroe: And one of the things that is a little bit different from Kriegspiel and you can actually remedy this but one of the things that's different from Kriegspiel, which keeps it technically from being chaotic is that it's not, it's not sensitive to, it's not that sensitive to initial conditions.
- 29:07Austin Caroe: I mean, I guess it kind of is.
- 29:09Austin Caroe: Well, actually, I guess it is, um, because you know exactly where your opponent's pieces are to start.
- 29:15Austin Caroe: But what would do you know what?
- 29:16Austin Caroe: Uh, uh, have you heard of?
- 29:18Austin Caroe: Uh, fisher random chess or chess?
- 29:20Austin Caroe: I think it's called chess, maybe chess 360, is that what they call it?
- 29:21Austin Caroe: Yeah, I imagine you start with an unknown starting point, so the the pieces are arranged on the back row.
- 29:23Austin Caroe: The pieces are arranged randomly, I think it's called maybe Chess 360.
- 29:24Ponch Rivera: Is that what they call it?
- 29:24Austin Caroe: I imagine you start with an unknown starting point.
- 29:25Austin Caroe: So the pieces are arranged on the back row, the pieces are arranged randomly.
- 29:29Austin Caroe: So if you were to come by, if you really wanted to say, but kind of, the point of what I was saying about Kriegspiel is, people love to talk about AI and the importance of AI, and, yes, ai is going to be very important, but AI doesn't actually know the future man.
- 29:43Austin Caroe: Until you can show me that a computer can consistently beat the best humans at Kriegsville chess consistently and with the level of dominance that they have in regular chess, I'm not going to buy into AI dominance.
- 29:56Austin Caroe: Ai is our overlord type arguments.
- 30:00Austin Caroe: I think that AI and humans are going to be working together where we both do the things that we're good at.
- 30:06Austin Caroe: And one of the thinkers I really like, whose book I have several books I have here is Gerd Gigerenzer, who's talked a lot about human intuition versus big data and how simple models that humans can use in many cases outperform complex models that require big data.
- 30:22Austin Caroe: So anyway, that's kind of the big takeaway.
- 30:24Austin Caroe: But if you really wanted to maximize uncertainty in Creekspiel, you'd play Creekspiel Fisher Random Chess, where the starting pieces are the back row, is completely different, so you don't even know where the starting pieces are.
- 30:34Austin Caroe: So that would be really neat.
- 30:35Austin Caroe: But I love what you said about business leaders and building a map of the environment, knowing that that map is wrong, but it's something that you can constantly adjust off of.
- 30:46Ponch Rivera: Yeah, and your point about the AI being insufficient or not having the interoceptive or intuition or finger-spitzing of fuel that humans have is critical.
- 30:53Ponch Rivera: So my view is and going back to the Kenevan framework, in a complex domain, that's really a good domain for humans.
- 31:00Ponch Rivera: I mean, if you think about what's happening with AI right now, large language models probably are in the clear domain.
- 31:05Ponch Rivera: Maybe the agentic AI is going to be a little bit in the complicated domain.
- 31:09Ponch Rivera: Humans still do quite well there, but in the complex domain which you just pointed out, humans will continue to I hate to say, dominate, but that's going to be our strength and the reason for that is because we're updating our generative model of the external world, which LLMs cannot do at the moment.
- 31:25Ponch Rivera: Right, and the current AI?
- 31:27Ponch Rivera: When you think about it, it's a linear OODA loop approach.
- 31:31Ponch Rivera: It's the bad OODA loop applied to the clear and complicated domain.
- 31:34Ponch Rivera: It doesn't work in the complex domain.
- 31:38Ponch Rivera: The only thing that works in the complex domain right now is an active approach to understanding, perception and action, which is really what the OODA loop does.
- 31:43Ponch Rivera: It tells us how living systems defy entropy, and that's what you know when I brought up the connection back to Yanir Bar-Yam and to Nassim Taleb.
- 31:51Ponch Rivera: You know, I think Taleb's writing a book about entropy right now and that whole thing is starting to merge.
- 31:55Ponch Rivera: In fact, in a recent Joe Rogan podcast I think it was Thomas Campbell kind of out there, but he talked about the importance of avoiding entropy, which is exactly what you're trying to do in the complex domain which, when you're playing a game of critical chess is, you're trying to avoid that early demise, right.
- 32:10Ponch Rivera: So I think there's tremendous.
- 32:12Ponch Rivera: I love this conversation because you've given us a nice way to explain to organizations, using the way you play chess, to explain what the actual external world looks like, what they're dealing with.
- 32:23Ponch Rivera: So thank you very much for bringing that up, that's awesome.
- 32:26Mark McGrath: Yeah, the mapping is important.
- 32:28Mark McGrath: Like the, I was going to say that the mapping is important and the gaming is important too, because you start to go through scenarios and have those types of discussions and challenging your assumptions, right yeah?
- 32:41Austin Caroe: So that segue is not, unless you guys have another.
- 32:43Austin Caroe: I have a good segue into another thing that I've written about.
- 32:46Austin Caroe: Unless you guys want to continue on this topic, do it.
- 32:48Austin Caroe: So I love what you said about the map there, because two of the my early essays, which are quite foundational, I think to kind of everything that I've written about Our pair of essays, one called Fredericksburg and one is called Stakeholder of essays one called Fredericksburg and one is called Stakeholder and remind me to bring it back to the map and the importance of maps and mapping the environment.
- 33:10Austin Caroe: Don't let me forget that part.
- 33:11Austin Caroe: Okay, so I'll kind of start out with a story.
- 33:15Austin Caroe: There's a guy named Major Brian Eckhart.
- 33:17Austin Caroe: In World War II he's a British intelligence officer.
- 33:21Austin Caroe: They're getting ready to conduct Operation Market Garden where they're going to drop a bunch of paratroopers, essentially behind German lines, and then punch through with armor to link up with those paratroopers.
- 33:31Austin Caroe: So the paratroopers will seize bridges and then the armor will punch through and link up with them.
- 33:36Austin Caroe: Well, major Urquhart doesn't have a very good feeling about this operation and he uses some hole to get a special reconnaissance flight over the drop zones and hundreds of pictures come back and he comes through these pictures.
- 33:52Austin Caroe: And you know, this is this is something ai would have been great at.
- 33:54Austin Caroe: Hey, ai go through these pictures and find tanks for me, you know.
- 33:58Austin Caroe: But so he has to spend hours going through these, uh, these grainy black and white photos.
- 34:02Austin Caroe: But he finds five pictures which definitively show that there are Panzers on the drop zone.
- 34:10Austin Caroe: And he jumps in his Jeep, he runs to the headquarters where General Browning, the commander, is located, and he says Sir, there are Panzers on the drop zone.
- 34:20Austin Caroe: We have to stop, we have to cancel the operation.
- 34:22Austin Caroe: And General Browning looks through the pictures and he says well, I wouldn't trouble myself with these, they're probably not serviceable anyway.
- 34:29Austin Caroe: And so he was smoking the copium.
- 34:32Austin Caroe: But why did he do that?
- 34:33Austin Caroe: Why was General Browning so against this idea that there might be panzers on the drop zone that the entire operation has to be changed?
- 34:43Austin Caroe: Well, because that unit, the army at that time, was suffering from something I called the objective Fredericksburg problem, which is when you confuse the plan, the making of a plan, with what the plan is actually supposed to accomplish.
- 35:01Austin Caroe: It became the case that the plan, operation Market Garden, was more important than the objectives the plan was supposed to achieve.
- 35:10Austin Caroe: They had to protect that plan.
- 35:12Austin Caroe: They had to keep it safe.
- 35:15Austin Caroe: They had to set up defenses around it.
- 35:17Austin Caroe: They had to repel invaders.
- 35:18Austin Caroe: They had to advance that plan forward, to take more terrain with just the plan.
- 35:23Austin Caroe: And other people knew this too.
- 35:25Austin Caroe: Eisenhower knew of that intelligence.
- 35:27Austin Caroe: They tried to convince Monty not to do the operation.
- 35:30Austin Caroe: And they went ahead and did it anyway.
- 35:31Austin Caroe: And what did they do with Major Brian Urquhart?
- 35:33Austin Caroe: Well, they sent a psychiatric doctor to him and they said clearly, you're suffering from too much stress and go home.
- 35:41Austin Caroe: And he begged.
- 35:43Austin Caroe: He was like no, no, no, no, you have to.
- 35:45Austin Caroe: Just let me go.
- 35:45Austin Caroe: Like I'll go, I'll just send me.
- 35:47Austin Caroe: Like this isn't fair.
- 35:47Austin Caroe: They didn't even give the intelligence.
- 35:50Austin Caroe: They hit the intelligence from the guys, from the paratroopers.
- 35:53Austin Caroe: They didn't even know what they were jumping into.
- 35:55Austin Caroe: It wasn't even like hey, maybe there might be some tanks.
- 36:06Austin Caroe: And again, because they had to protect the plan, the plan had to be protected.
- 36:08Austin Caroe: Yeah, and so that's something I call the objective problem.
- 36:09Austin Caroe: And you see this in army units and other units all the time, where you spend all this time and energy making a plan.
- 36:13Austin Caroe: There's so much staff work and there's so many powerpoint slides and there's excel spreadsheets and some people do gantt charts, and there's all this effort that goes into making the plan.
- 36:22Austin Caroe: Somebody, you know, you get the end of the planning process and somebody points out well, hey, if the enemy just just does this very simple and obvious thing, then the whole plan is going to fall apart.
- 36:29Austin Caroe: And then what does everybody do?
- 36:30Austin Caroe: Well, here's 10 reasons why they won't do that.
- 36:33Ponch Rivera: So here's something for you.
- 36:35Ponch Rivera: What's happening there is within a system, within a planning system, includes all kinds of agents in there.
- 36:41Ponch Rivera: They're trying to minimize free energy, expected free energy, all right.
- 36:45Ponch Rivera: So expected free energy is internal to the system and it's in the planning process.
- 36:48Ponch Rivera: One way to minimize that is to hide valuable information, suppress it, right, and that's exactly what you're doing.
- 36:53Ponch Rivera: And to your point about the desired outcome, when you're trying to minimize variational free energy, when your actions actually interact with the external world, that's what matters more than anything, right?
- 37:04Ponch Rivera: So you want to make sure you know.
- 37:06Ponch Rivera: This is why you have red teams, this is why we do red teaming, this is, you know, premortems and all that.
- 37:10Ponch Rivera: This is why psychological safety exists.
- 37:13Ponch Rivera: This is why removing fear in an organization exists.
- 37:14Ponch Rivera: This is why weak signal detection is so important.
- 37:16Ponch Rivera: But even in today's world, ego, the ego of the organization, the ego of the plan, kind of dominates man and that ego needs to be relaxed in order to have greater access to information within the system that says that's out there, Right?
- 37:33Ponch Rivera: So I think there's an interesting connection to what's going on in neuroscience and EFE and VFE.
- 37:40Ponch Rivera: Sorry, mark, go ahead.
- 37:41Mark McGrath: Yeah, no, I think too, because I've certainly experienced this too.
- 37:44Mark McGrath: Sorry, mark, go ahead.
- 37:45Mark McGrath: Yeah, no, I think too, because I've certainly experienced this too.
- 37:47Mark McGrath: Like when you question a plan and you challenge it, everybody thinks you're nuts, everybody thinks you're not a team player, everybody thinks that you're, in this case, a psychiatric evaluation.
- 37:57Mark McGrath: It made me think of the book the Psychology of Military Incompetence by Norman Dixon.
- 38:01Mark McGrath: I don't know if you're familiar with that book.
- 38:03Austin Caroe: Yep, yeah, I brought a bunch of books we might discuss, but yes, I have that book on my shelf.
- 38:08Mark McGrath: It's a great book, I guess, when I think of a commander basically shitting on insights from a junior commander because it's inconsistent with the plan.
- 38:18Mark McGrath: As we know, planning is priceless.
- 38:20Mark McGrath: The plan is absolutely useless.
- 38:22Mark McGrath: I mean, we literally just had General Petraeus come on and tell us don't do that, what this guy did to his subordinate.
- 38:29Mark McGrath: General Petraeus actually told us don't do that.
- 38:31Mark McGrath: You need to get insights and perspectives from all channels to cover blind spots.
- 38:36Mark McGrath: And I remember, even in the early 2000s where your PowerPoint became the most important thing in the function of a hella board assault in Hawaii, you know, with your Marines and whatever.
- 38:50Mark McGrath: None of that mattered.
- 38:51Mark McGrath: Like man you could have used some animations on that PowerPoint.
- 38:55Mark McGrath: I mean, the colonel sat there and he was not entertained by your PowerPoint.
- 38:59Mark McGrath: Nobody wants to talk about, like the actual, what has to happen to the enemy, like what actually?
- 39:04Ponch Rivera: has to.
- 39:04Ponch Rivera: Yeah, can you change puppy to small dog?
- 39:06Austin Caroe: Yeah, change change fire to configuration.
- 39:11Austin Caroe: So, yeah, I think what you said there, ponch, is interesting.
- 39:15Austin Caroe: I know you guys are all into the free energy and I'm reading through Ocinga's book right now.
- 39:19Austin Caroe: Mark's a great mentor and he sends me stuff to read all the time, but I'm reading through Ocinga's book right now and I think that I'm sure all that stuff is correct.
- 39:27Austin Caroe: I have absolutely no doubt that that is correct.
- 39:29Austin Caroe: The audience that I'm writing for yeah, there, it is right there.
- 39:32Austin Caroe: I've got my copy actually sitting out there.
- 39:39Austin Caroe: I was just reading it, so I try to.
- 39:40Austin Caroe: I think that the conceptual reason why that happens is correct.
- 39:41Austin Caroe: From in dumb infantryman language, what's happening is everyone's just putting so much energy into the plan, like there's so much time and effort invested into it, that people just don't want to see anything happen to it.
- 39:52Austin Caroe: They don't want to have to restart everything, even if everybody knows it's wrong.
- 39:56Austin Caroe: They pretend that it's not, because it's like, well, whatever it's training, or it's this, or I don't have to go on the mission, so whatever it'll, it'll be fine.
- 40:01Austin Caroe: So the way that I think to get around that and what you guys said is very interesting, because it's basically like, well, just don't, don't do that.
- 40:10Austin Caroe: You can't just not do it.
- 40:12Austin Caroe: There are inescapable parts of organizations and how they're structured that it's almost like there's no way out of some of these problems, and so you have to structure some of your processes differently to ensure that these types of things don't happen.
- 40:28Austin Caroe: And one of the things and bringing it back to the map, one of the ways that I think that many units can overcome the objective Fredericksburg problem is that plans need to be made for whatever echelon you're at.
- 40:41Austin Caroe: If you're at the battalion echelon, the battalion plan should be made or should emerge through a collaboration between the company commanders and the brigade plan should emerge through the interactions of the battalion commanders.
- 40:57Austin Caroe: And so let me explain what that looks like, and I call this the stakeholder planning process.
- 41:02Austin Caroe: Now, I don't want to replace MDMP.
- 41:05Austin Caroe: The stakeholder planning process is not a replacement for the military decision-making process.
- 41:10Austin Caroe: You have to have the military decision-making process for a variety of reasons.
- 41:13Austin Caroe: I know you guys probably completely disagree and you're like throw it out.
- 41:16Austin Caroe: I know Don Vandergriff is kind of like that.
- 41:20Austin Caroe: But you have to have it for a variety of reasons.
- 41:22Austin Caroe: But the most important part, what do you start with when you're doing the stakeholder planning process for a tactical problem is you start with the terrain model.
- 41:29Austin Caroe: So you model the terrain and you have the G2, the intelligence officer get on the terrain model and say this is what we anticipate, this is what we currently see the enemy doing, this is what we anticipate the enemy is going to do.
- 41:40Austin Caroe: And then you put the company commanders on the terrain model while the battalion staff is just watching and observing.
- 41:47Austin Caroe: Maybe they have some ideas.
- 41:48Austin Caroe: But the battalion commanders say, hey, look, given what the enemy is doing, what about this?
- 42:09Austin Caroe: What have we tried this?
- 42:10Austin Caroe: Hey, I'll go down here.
- 42:11Austin Caroe: What if you went up there?
- 42:11Austin Caroe: Actually, I think you input, but he has to to what Ponch?
- 42:15Austin Caroe: To your point, he's got to put his ego aside and just let the company commanders kind of do their thing and gently guide them.
- 42:20Austin Caroe: By the way, this is how I did my company live fire planning when I was a company commander.
- 42:26Austin Caroe: Now, part of this just comes to that.
- 42:28Austin Caroe: I'm just insanely lazy and I don't consider myself a very good tactician and I thought my platoon leaders were quite good.
- 42:34Austin Caroe: So I told my platoon leaders hey, y'all plan the live fire Like you guys make the tactical plan, not the training element.
- 42:39Austin Caroe: This was like the tactical plan.
- 42:40Austin Caroe: You guys make the tactical plan.
- 42:43Austin Caroe: Here's the terrain model, here's all the things.
- 42:44Austin Caroe: Just come get me when you're ready.
- 42:46Austin Caroe: I didn't even watch them, you know, they came, they got me, they briefed me, I made some adjustments, I made some adjustments, they tried again.
- 42:51Austin Caroe: But if you do this it turns out you don't even have to write down the operations order, you don't have to make slides, you don't have to write anything down.
- 42:57Austin Caroe: Imagine that, except for maybe some notes, you know, maybe you capture the plan on like two pages, you know, of just kind of the general outline.
- 43:04Austin Caroe: Or maybe you publish a timeline.
- 43:06Austin Caroe: You know you publish some tools that people can use, but you're not like you know mission statement.
- 43:15Austin Caroe: You know this Italian will see.
- 43:16Ponch Rivera: I want to make a connection here.
- 43:17Ponch Rivera: This is very important for for business leaders.
- 43:19Ponch Rivera: So in the flow system, we put in their value first.
- 43:21Ponch Rivera: You know, customer first, value delivery those that are closest to the customer should be the ones doing the planning process.
- 43:27Ponch Rivera: They know the customer, they know the terrain right.
- 43:29Ponch Rivera: That's that's key there, Not the people in the ivory tower, not the people that are 15 years removed from the tactical side.
- 43:34Ponch Rivera: But that's not what we do in organizations.
- 43:36Ponch Rivera: They flip it around and then they hand the plan off for somebody else to go execute.
- 43:39Ponch Rivera: This is not what you want in your organization.
- 43:42Ponch Rivera: What Austin just described is exactly what you need to do in your organization and, yes, it takes time to do it.
- 43:47Ponch Rivera: Yeah, you have to take people off the line to go do this, but what you get in return is unbelievable.
- 43:56Ponch Rivera: You get high-performing teams right, because in order to be a high-performing team, you need a shared and valued goal, right?
- 43:59Ponch Rivera: So one way to create value for your leaders is to invite them to participate in the planning process.
- 44:07Ponch Rivera: So that's important.
- 44:09Ponch Rivera: On MDMP, my view on it is it's a good practice.
- 44:12Ponch Rivera: Are there better?
- 44:13Ponch Rivera: Yes, but it's still a good practice, meaning if you have a good practice that's shared across an organization.
- 44:18Ponch Rivera: Go with it right.
- 44:19Ponch Rivera: So again, I just want to make that connection for organizations.
- 44:22Ponch Rivera: They may be hearing that this is only going to be valid for military operations.
- 44:25Ponch Rivera: No, no, no.
- 44:26Ponch Rivera: This is exactly what you need to do in your organization Build a map, invite those that are closest to the customer to do the plan, use red teaming techniques, use an effective planning process, a good planning process For all.
- 44:38Ponch Rivera: I meant you know, for all intents and purposes, use the MDMP.
- 44:41Ponch Rivera: You know you'll get somewhere better and faster.
- 44:45Austin Caroe: Absolutely so.
- 44:46Austin Caroe: A couple of things on this.
- 44:47Austin Caroe: One is, you know, we say this all the time we have this trope of like, well, plans are useless, but planning is everything, because you know, when you plan, you learn.
- 44:55Austin Caroe: And that's true.
- 44:56Austin Caroe: It's not that plans are useless, you know.
- 44:57Austin Caroe: I think they're probably more valuable than that.
- 44:59Austin Caroe: But the point is, who is doing the learning?
- 45:02Austin Caroe: If the battalion staff is doing all the planning, then they're doing all the learning.
- 45:08Austin Caroe: And now, rather than firsthand learning, the company commanders of the next echelon down that receives the plan is now just receiving all that stuff secondhand, with a bunch of shortcuts and truncations and things like that.
- 45:20Austin Caroe: So you really want the people that are executing to actually do the planning for it, which seems obvious, but we miss that all the time.
- 45:28Austin Caroe: Another thing is we also mistake this for mission command, where it's like company commander, your mission is to seize bush hill.
- 45:34Austin Caroe: Now, I'm not going to tell you how to seize bush hill, because I'm executing mission command.
- 45:38Austin Caroe: But you know you take bush hill however you want, but you have to take bush hill.
- 45:41Austin Caroe: The my, my, the way I look at it is.
- 45:45Austin Caroe: Well, why is the company, why doesn't the company commander have a say in what objective he's actually doing.
- 45:49Austin Caroe: And I would say, if you're, if you're really executing mission command, that company commander is going to get a say in that plan and not a veto.
- 45:55Austin Caroe: Okay, because if you make the plan and then give it to the company commanders and say, well, do you have any input?
- 46:01Austin Caroe: Well, now we're just back at the objective Fredericksburg problem, where it's like, well, yeah, hey, sir, attacking Bush Hill is really not a good idea, and it's like, well, actually, it's fine, we'll give you some extra artillery.
- 46:09Austin Caroe: And you know, go get them Tiger, so they'll just go right around you and they'll overcome your objections.
- 46:14Austin Caroe: So that's a lot of problems with top-down guidance, bottom-up refinement.
- 46:18Austin Caroe: That's a lot of the problem there is.
- 46:19Austin Caroe: Well, you know, everyone hears the top-down guidance, but you're fighting gravity and institutional inertia when you're trying to do bottom-up refinement.
- 46:27Austin Caroe: And I have another great example of that on D-Day for the obstacle clearance plan, this like super esoteric, but they knew the obstacle clearance plan wasn't going to work and they were so delusional that they were like, well, the bombers, some of the bombs on the beaches will fall short and that'll help clear the obstacles.
- 46:41Austin Caroe: It was total coke, I mean, it was horrible.
- 46:43Austin Caroe: So, anyway, if you ever get a chance read.
- 46:47Austin Caroe: The best book on D-Day is Omaha Beach, a Flawed Victory by, I think, adrian Lewis.
- 46:50Austin Caroe: It's one of my favorite books, but Stakeholder talks about that my essay, stakeholder, and then.
- 46:55Austin Caroe: So another key thing with Stakeholder is well, shoot, which way was I going to go with this now?
- 47:06Austin Caroe: Yeah, so we talked about why we plan and learning.
- 47:08Austin Caroe: So, anyway, those are kind of the key things.
- 47:08Austin Caroe: If I think of the other thing, I'll share it, but yeah, those are key points.
- 47:10Ponch Rivera: Yeah, on the point about planning we talk about planning is continuous, it's fractal, it's an anticipatory decision-making process that helps teams deal with VUCA so you can adapt to an external environment.
- 47:21Ponch Rivera: And I think a lot of people don't understand.
- 47:23Ponch Rivera: You know plans are important.
- 47:25Ponch Rivera: Plans should be developed with maps, with a strategy.
- 47:28Ponch Rivera: Your strategy should be that mental tapestry that changes with the more you learn about the external environment, so it's an emergent thing.
- 47:35Ponch Rivera: And then the planning approach for teams and this is where we get into team science that you need a shared I'll call it a mental model again approach to planning.
- 47:46Ponch Rivera: Mdmp gives us that.
- 47:47Ponch Rivera: Is there a better one out there?
- 47:48Ponch Rivera: The answer is yeah.
- 47:49Ponch Rivera: I believe there are better approaches than MDMP.
- 47:51Ponch Rivera: But if your opponents aren't using them, you know, then you're okay.
- 47:55Ponch Rivera: But that doesn't mean and this is why in the Kenevan framework it's called a good practice, it's never called a best practice.
- 48:03Ponch Rivera: Mdmp is not a best practice.
- 48:05Ponch Rivera: It's a good practice, but I guarantee you the three of us can come up with better planning process that will crush the MDMP right.
- 48:11Austin Caroe: So that makes it a gooder practice, sure that will crush the MDMP right, so that makes it a gooder practice?
- 48:16Austin Caroe: Sure, well, it depends on again, and you want to match the tools to the problem you're trying to solve.
- 48:19Austin Caroe: Mdmp is great if you're trying to resource allocation.
- 48:23Austin Caroe: In fact, you probably can't find a better.
- 48:27Austin Caroe: I'm sure you could, but it's hard to find a better tool for resource allocation than MDMP because it's very scientific.
- 48:33Austin Caroe: We've come up with different ideas.
- 48:35Austin Caroe: We'll do a lot of research, we'll compare them and we'll figure out which is the best way to go.
- 48:40Austin Caroe: But I want to go back to one of the things that you said about.
- 48:42Austin Caroe: Yes, it's time consuming to bring in leaders and things like that.
- 48:45Austin Caroe: What I found was by constantly bringing in my subordinates to do the planning when we were time constrained or when I had to just make a decision because we didn't have time to go back and do planning.
- 48:58Austin Caroe: There was an enormous level of trust because they had participated in the planning.
- 49:04Austin Caroe: They knew that I cared about them and they understood my judgment and how I thought and how I went about making decisions.
- 49:10Austin Caroe: I had to make a plan.
- 49:11Austin Caroe: I don't have time to get everybody together.
- 49:13Austin Caroe: The platoons are all spread out.
- 49:15Austin Caroe: We've got to do this attack in four hours.
- 49:17Austin Caroe: I don't have time to bring the platoon leaders in and do this whole thing.
- 49:19Austin Caroe: Hey, I'm going to sit down and do the best I can.
- 49:21Austin Caroe: I'm gonna make a plan and I'm putting it out over the radio and we're and then we're rocking, doing things like this.
- 49:26Austin Caroe: Than just the immediate result that you'll get when you try to accomplish it, you'll get those long-term results of building mutual trust inside of that organization, which again is a key part of mission command is mutual trust.
- 49:47Ponch Rivera: Austin.
- 49:47Ponch Rivera: I have a question.
- 49:49Ponch Rivera: We have a client that's focused on quality right now.
- 49:51Ponch Rivera: Let me ask you this we have a client that's focused on quality right now.
- 49:54Ponch Rivera: Let me ask you this when you do this type of work, when you bring in those leaders that are closest to the front lines the customers in this case can you talk a little bit about the quality of deliverables?
- 50:00Ponch Rivera: I mean, did you notice anything different by doing it this way?
- 50:04Austin Caroe: Yeah, I mean so just in terms of output.
- 50:07Austin Caroe: My OER, my officer evaluation report, says this my company did the best out of all the other companies.
- 50:13Austin Caroe: So we finished the live fire lane in like five zero minutes and 50 minutes, where other units were taking 90 minutes, two hours, to complete the entire lane.
- 50:24Austin Caroe: So the output, the immediate like, the results that we achieved in the immediate term by doing this were just unmatched and you can't match that.
- 50:33Austin Caroe: But when it comes to like quality, are they trying to produce a product?
- 50:36Austin Caroe: Is it a product or is it a service that they're trying to work on?
- 50:40Austin Caroe: It's a product.
- 50:40Ponch Rivera: But I'm curious.
- 50:41Ponch Rivera: I mean, it's kind of hard to match the services that we delivered in the military to higher quality but higher quality decision-making, anything that you saw.
- 50:48Austin Caroe: So I would say, and one of the things that I've written about, I actually have an essay called Quality which talks about how there's someone named Christopher Alexander, which I don't know if you've talked about him on the podcast before.
- 51:01Austin Caroe: I know Moose has read him.
- 51:05Austin Caroe: I can't remember.
- 51:06Austin Caroe: I don't think we Boyd doesn't have him on the reading, on his reading list, right?
- 51:09Austin Caroe: It's not his lettering, you know, john.
- 51:10Mark McGrath: Robb did.
- 51:11Mark McGrath: It wasn't Boyd, it was John Robb that first turned actually not first turned me on, but one of the things that jumped off the page Because years ago I had studied.
- 51:20Mark McGrath: I was taking little kids to Disney.
- 51:23Mark McGrath: I thought to make the most out of this.
- 51:25Mark McGrath: I really got to try to understand how this place ticks, because it's just unbelievable.
- 51:29Mark McGrath: And one of the things that Disney had studied was the Garden City movement, and Christopher Alexander wrote two books, the timeless way of building and in a pattern language, and Rob had those on his global.
- 51:42Mark McGrath: This was years ago, but yeah, those are.
- 51:44Mark McGrath: Those books are phenomenal, highly readable.
- 51:47Mark McGrath: Um, totally, yeah, we were.
- 51:52Mark McGrath: We were talking about that.
- 52:06Austin Caroe: Maybe I don't know, maybe a few months ago, you and I were talking about this book because I want to learn more about flow.
- 52:10Austin Caroe: When I was in command, I decided early on, you know, I'm going to put my ego aside and I'm just going to do what feels natural and I'm just going to try to be genuine and authentic.
- 52:21Austin Caroe: I'm not going to do anything I don't really want to do and I'm not going to do anything because other people have done it, because I think I'm expected to do it.
- 52:28Austin Caroe: I'm just going to do the things that I think make sense to me and my entire command.
- 52:32Austin Caroe: I just felt like I was.
- 52:33Austin Caroe: I had all this.
- 52:34Austin Caroe: I was very energetic and I was very focused.
- 52:36Austin Caroe: I was able to do all these things.
- 52:37Austin Caroe: So a lot of the things that I sort of naturally discovered by accident and just sort of focusing on this idea of just doing the things that felt right.
- 52:45Austin Caroe: When I look back then I realized, hey, this is a lot.
- 52:48Austin Caroe: There's a lot of what I did that's inside of this stuff, and one of those was Timeless Way of Building.
- 52:53Austin Caroe: But in Timeless Way of Building and to give people an idea, christopher Alexander is an architect and one of the things that he was reacting against was modern architecture sort of brutalist architecture and mass-produced things that were mass-produced and things that were sort of put together in factories and then assembled.
- 53:12Austin Caroe: It wasn't beautiful, it wasn't bringing beauty into the world.
- 53:14Austin Caroe: He was also against architects making grand plans because they wanted to get their names in architecture magazines.
- 53:20Austin Caroe: It was all about looking good to their peers, and so what Christopher Alexander did, his idea, was like no, there's something in the process itself which brings about beauty in the world.
- 53:32Austin Caroe: It's how the building is constructed, in conjunction with the people that will use it in harmony with its environment.
- 53:40Mark McGrath: The quality without a name.
- 53:42Mark McGrath: Isn't that what he?
- 53:42Austin Caroe: calls it.
- 53:44Mark McGrath: The quality without a name.
- 53:45Austin Caroe: That is exactly right.
- 53:46Austin Caroe: That is the quality without a name, and so this book's been very influential in a lot of tech spaces and software design and things like that.
- 53:53Austin Caroe: But we have to remember that that quality is brought about because of the collaboration.
- 53:58Austin Caroe: But you're also sometimes you do things just because they feel right, and this is, you know, apple.
- 54:03Austin Caroe: There's probably a lot of stories with Apple here where I know it doesn't make sense internally.
- 54:07Austin Caroe: I know that internally it would be more efficient to connect this wire this way or whatever, but it's not aesthetically pleasing.
- 54:14Austin Caroe: So make it look like this on the inside, where no one's going to see, and that quality just emerges.
- 54:22Austin Caroe: It's not something that you can build in ahead of time.
- 54:23Austin Caroe: So kind of to your point, ponch, that's what I would think is.
- 54:25Austin Caroe: If you want to build something that's of high quality, that's bringing beauty and improving the world, it's in the process that you use to create the thing.
- 54:35Ponch Rivera: Christopher Alexander's work has been used quite a bit in the agile space and pattern language We've talked about quite a bit and to me, pattern language, when I learned about it it reminded me of the things you learned in aviation of plan brief, execute, debrief and human factors, interaction pieces those repeatable things that build teams.
- 54:49Ponch Rivera: So you're talking about flow.
- 54:52Ponch Rivera: My first experience in taking like heavy project management lessons from MBAs right into military war fighting failed and I recognized this immediately.
- 55:00Ponch Rivera: You know, I was like I knew Gantt charts.
- 55:01Ponch Rivera: I knew these amazing things.
- 55:02Ponch Rivera: I could do all kinds of things.
- 55:03Ponch Rivera: I'm leading a large team in the Air and Space Operations Center and they're all aviators, mostly aviation background, and I'm trying to do this thing, design this amazing scheme of maneuver and all that.
- 55:13Ponch Rivera: And I recognized man, this isn't going to work and I had to fall back on the patterns that I knew and the patterns everybody else knew, which was those contact points and plan brief, execute, debrief, using mission command and using the knowledge that.
- 55:26Ponch Rivera: Hey look, we all know crew resource management, we know how to communicate, we know it's closed loop communication.
- 55:32Ponch Rivera: We know these things, let's execute on that.
- 55:34Ponch Rivera: We got the patterns back in there and that's when I recognized.
- 55:37Ponch Rivera: All the shit that you learn from project management is useless unless you know how to do those things.
- 55:42Ponch Rivera: So those patterns that's where they're getting at.
- 55:44Ponch Rivera: What I saw in the agile space is they talk about these patterns but they excluded the science of teams.
- 55:49Ponch Rivera: Right, and they go.
- 55:50Ponch Rivera: That's only for the military and we don't need to do that.
- 56:06Ponch Rivera: It'll naturally emerge.
- 56:07Ponch Rivera: Well, self-organization isn't about just letting random shit and things happen.
- 56:12Ponch Rivera: You got to have the patterns in there and team faster Flow within a high-performing team is just that workflows from one person to another.
- 56:17Ponch Rivera: I think it's the number one characteristics of a high-performing team and delivering value.
- 56:24Ponch Rivera: The pattern stuff that I learned from the agile community, from Christopher Alexander, is exactly what we were doing in fighter aviation.
- 56:31Ponch Rivera: It's the team science stuff.
- 56:34Ponch Rivera: It's how do you plan, how do you communicate, how do you execute, how do you create situational awareness, how do you build adaptability, and mission command came into that.
- 56:41Ponch Rivera: So thank you for bringing that up.
- 56:43Ponch Rivera: I haven't, you know, looked back at pattern language in a long time, but that's what the agile community was trying to do and where they failed.
- 56:56Austin Caroe: They absolutely failed on this and they went with let's just let everybody figure this out on their own, Like, eh, it's not going to work that way, I've seen you ranting against Agile on LinkedIn recently.
- 57:05Mark McGrath: I said oh I, I'm sorry, go ahead, moose.
- 57:06Mark McGrath: Oh no, no Ponch.
- 57:09Ponch Rivera: He was saying how he loves your rants on Agile on LinkedIn.
- 57:10Ponch Rivera: I don't try to rant on it.
- 57:11Ponch Rivera: I've been in the community for a long time.
- 57:13Ponch Rivera: I saw the problem.
- 57:14Ponch Rivera: We created a flow system around.
- 57:16Ponch Rivera: Hey look, it's team science.
- 57:18Ponch Rivera: It's an exactive practice from the complex domain.
- 57:22Ponch Rivera: You borrow from some other place.
- 57:23Ponch Rivera: You take MDMP and you apply it.
- 57:25Ponch Rivera: That may work out for you.
- 57:27Ponch Rivera: You take crew resource management.
- 57:28Ponch Rivera: You apply it, modify it, exact it over.
- 57:31Ponch Rivera: It's that simple.
- 57:32Ponch Rivera: You just look at who's doing great work around the world and go how do they do that?
- 57:36Ponch Rivera: Don't do it the other way.
- 57:38Ponch Rivera: Where you find people that remember in a complex environment, separating decisions from outcomes is important, right.
- 57:43Ponch Rivera: So you can have a great outcome in a complex environment, regardless of how your internal processes are, and what we generally get are people that have those lucky outcomes write books about how fucking awesome they are Right and people.
- 58:01Austin Caroe: Well, it's like Dave.
- 58:01Mark McGrath: Dave Snowden always rails against a lean startup for doing that Right, Because it's like well, we're just going to, you know, survivorship bias.
- 58:05Austin Caroe: We'll just find the winners.
- 58:06Austin Caroe: I will find we'll find all the things that are common to them and be like these are the things you should do, yeah.
- 58:11Ponch Rivera: And that goes back to when I think you brought it up early on.
- 58:13Ponch Rivera: Hey, we're going to write a story about the seven leadership lessons from watching I don't know.
- 58:18Ponch Rivera: Pick a stupid movie over the weekend, sure yeah.
- 58:22Austin Caroe: It's interesting that you.
- 58:23Mark McGrath: Oh sorry, go ahead, moose.
- 58:24Mark McGrath: I was going to say just to close the loop on Chris Alexander.
- 58:27Mark McGrath: I'm sad the report that two years ago, yeah, issue with him, but just didn't.
- 58:33Mark McGrath: I was reminded of the.
- 58:35Mark McGrath: Of the books there was three, you know, timeless way of building pattern language and then the oregon experiment, which were all, uh, connected.
- 58:41Mark McGrath: And then I I remember how beautifully designed these books are, that you could read it in less than an hour.
- 58:48Mark McGrath: It's a 552 page book but you could read it in less than an hour because he has all the summer, he has all the the, he has all the chapter heads or the titles, the subtitle, everything was compressed in the front, so there were two paths to read it and I thought, boy, what a standard for designing a book.
- 59:03Mark McGrath: I mean, it's like even in the design of the actual book and we remember it all these years later.
- 59:09Mark McGrath: So, yeah, definitely on our list.
- 59:11Austin Caroe: No, it's true.
- 59:12Austin Caroe: And another book that's kind of written that way is the Systems Bible by John Gall, which is absolutely fabulous book and that's one of the for officers that are progressing in their careers.
- 59:23Austin Caroe: It's like my number one recommended book for them to read is the Systems Bible, because it's almost like he wrote it about the Army, but obviously he's writing it about any large organization, but it's kind of written that way too, where big laws and important things are written in all caps and inside the book.
- 59:39Austin Caroe: One of the things that and kind of going back to what Panch was saying about the flow system and how you work with teams and build teamwork and stuff like that One of the essays I wrote was called Causation, which is about these leadership studies that are done by Inc and Google has one and Microsoft did one.
- 59:57Austin Caroe: That's like we looked at all of our teams and they all share these traits you know they all have.
- 1:00:01Austin Caroe: They provide structure and clarity and meaning and their impact and psychological safety and you know all these, all these things.
- 1:00:07Austin Caroe: And you know it's funny because if you're, if you're struggling as a leader and you don't really know, like what you're doing, how does this help you?
- 1:00:15Austin Caroe: If you're a football coach and someone were to come along and be like well, we've looked at all the best football teams and it turns out they all have really good offense and really good defense.
- 1:00:23Ponch Rivera: They play four quarters.
- 1:00:24Mark McGrath: Yeah, they've got uniforms and everything.
- 1:00:28Austin Caroe: Exactly and it's like well, how does this help me again?
- 1:00:32Ponch Rivera: Well, let me point out something.
- 1:00:33Ponch Rivera: That's how Scrum came about.
- 1:00:34Ponch Rivera: All right, okay, we looked at this thing and they plan, they brief, they do this thing, they debrief, right, and you're like that's called a team lifecycle and 14 pages, and you got to go through a two-day course to go.
- 1:00:46Ponch Rivera: All teams have to learn how to plan.
- 1:00:48Ponch Rivera: It's actually what you put in that matters, right, which they don't teach you.
- 1:00:59Austin Caroe: No, what you put in that matters right, which they don't teach you, no, exactly right.
- 1:01:01Austin Caroe: And so one of the things, you know, one of the things that inspired my writing was these super fluffy LinkedIn articles about you know, about this type of stuff, and I was like, can I just give people some concrete things, like the stakeholder planning process, like build a terrain model, put the commanders on the terrain model, brief them the plan, all right.
- 1:01:16Austin Caroe: Now like, and not exactly, it's not, not super prescriptive, not step-by-step, not, not here's a handbook, but here are some techniques, here's some ways to think about how you can do, how you can accomplish these things.
- 1:01:28Austin Caroe: And one of those concepts that I came up with is called fail seeding, which it seems.
- 1:01:34Austin Caroe: It's one of these things that all my ideas, I feel like are super boring and banal, until you really start to explore them and unpack them and it's like, ok, maybe there's actually something here.
- 1:01:41Austin Caroe: Fail seeding is just failure and succeeding.
- 1:01:44Austin Caroe: You put those words together, you get fail seeding.
- 1:01:46Austin Caroe: And so, to back up where this idea kind of sparked from, I was at Fort Benning, now called Fort Moore, for the, I guess, the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Aydarang.
- 1:01:57Austin Caroe: It must have been the 50th.
- 1:02:02Mark McGrath: Yeah, we were soldiers once in Young Battle, that's right.
- 1:02:04Austin Caroe: We were soldiers once in Young Battle.
- 1:02:05Austin Caroe: So the 1-7 and 2-7 Cav soldiers, the veterans, came and talked to us Super impactful.
- 1:02:14Austin Caroe: So how, Moore's guys, Savage and all these other guys get up there and they're like rah, rah, we were the best and we were hand selected and we kicked ass and dah, dah, dah, dah, dah.
- 1:02:24Austin Caroe: And everybody remembers those guys because of the movie.
- 1:02:29Austin Caroe: We were soldiers once and yet.
- 1:02:30Austin Caroe: But if you read the book, there's another battalion in there that everyone's kind of forgotten about and that's the battalion I think it was, because two seven was at was at, uh, LZ Albany.
- 1:02:40Mark McGrath: It was the group that was at LZ Albany.
- 1:02:44Austin Caroe: Yeah, I think that was one seven cav.
- 1:02:45Austin Caroe: That was their sister battalion.
- 1:02:47Austin Caroe: Everybody forgets about one seven.
- 1:02:48Austin Caroe: So one seven was a hodgepodge.
- 1:02:51Austin Caroe: It wasn't hand-selected and trained by Hal Moore.
- 1:03:08Austin Caroe: There was a bunch of hodgepodge logistics officers leading infantry platoons.
- 1:03:11Austin Caroe: They're on their the swagger of Hal Moore's guys.
- 1:03:15Austin Caroe: They don't come across as victorious warriors, they come across as people that are still struggling with this defeat, and just them.
- 1:03:21Austin Caroe: The way that they spoke about this was I'm getting emotional just thinking about it.
- 1:03:25Austin Caroe: I mean it was terrifying.
- 1:03:26Austin Caroe: They were talking about how they're just pinned down.
- 1:03:28Austin Caroe: He's a lieutenant, he's a captain, he's pinned down by fire and he like, wow, this is really bad.
- 1:03:33Austin Caroe: I hope some lieutenant colonel comes by and tells me what to do.
- 1:03:36Austin Caroe: I hope some major comes by and gives me some orders.
- 1:03:40Austin Caroe: And these guys just didn't feel empowered to be like start attacking into the ambush, like to start fighting.
- 1:03:47Austin Caroe: They're just laying there pinned down because they didn't.
- 1:03:50Austin Caroe: They did not feel empowered to do things.
- 1:03:52Austin Caroe: They were like someone is going to.
- 1:03:53Austin Caroe: They were like someone is going to come and rescue me, someone is going to come and tell me what to do.
- 1:03:56Austin Caroe: And right there, as I was sitting, I was like never in my military career.
- 1:04:00Austin Caroe: Will someone who works for me be in a position like that and wait for me to come and save them?
- 1:04:06Austin Caroe: Period?
- 1:04:07Austin Caroe: It's not going to happen and I'll do anything I can to prevent that, because you just can't do that as a leader.
- 1:04:13Austin Caroe: You can't do that to your people.
- 1:04:14Austin Caroe: That's learned helplessness.
- 1:04:16Austin Caroe: And so fast forward maybe a year or two and I'm a company commander and I'm like on day three and my battalion commander's on like day two, and we get an email from the battalion executive officer who was the second in command for the battalion.
- 1:04:30Austin Caroe: He sends us an email and he's like hey, the battalion commander, you know, next week or whenever, he's going to come, walk through your motor pool, come look at your vehicles and your containers and stuff like that.
- 1:04:40Austin Caroe: So you know, make sure your stuff's squared away All right.
- 1:04:42Austin Caroe: Now 99% of army company commanders are going to get an email like that and they're going to immediately start issuing directives and saying here's when the pre-inspection is and this is what I want to see.
- 1:04:54Austin Caroe: And da, da, da, da.
- 1:04:54Austin Caroe: And they're going to start prioritizing that inspection because they want to look good to that battalion commander.
- 1:05:00Austin Caroe: And I said, well, I was like I'm not, I don't want to do that.
- 1:05:03Austin Caroe: I'm not going to do that.
- 1:05:04Austin Caroe: So I told the XO, I forwarded him the email.
- 1:05:07Austin Caroe: I'm like, hey, the battalion commander's coming, just make sure it's all squared away and if there's any questions I can help you.
- 1:05:13Austin Caroe: Like I know exactly what to do.
- 1:05:14Austin Caroe: I know exactly what it's supposed to look like.
- 1:05:16Austin Caroe: So if you need help you can come to me.
- 1:05:18Austin Caroe: But like this is on you, all right.
- 1:05:20Austin Caroe: Well, the battalion commander comes down.
- 1:05:22Austin Caroe: I didn't even check, I didn't do a pre-inspection, I didn't do anything.
- 1:05:24Austin Caroe: And I could tell the XO was brand new, going to go very well, but I was fine.
- 1:05:30Austin Caroe: I was like you know what, whatever we screw it up, we screw it up.
- 1:05:35Austin Caroe: Battalion commander comes down, the vehicles don't work, we have no paperwork for anything, we can't even open the containers because no one has the keys and it's just like a disaster.
- 1:05:43Austin Caroe: It's as bad as you could possibly.
- 1:05:45Austin Caroe: It could not possibly have gotten worse.
- 1:05:47Austin Caroe: So the battalion commander just looks at me and is like Captain Carew, just looks at me and is like Captain Corot, this inspection was an abomination.
- 1:05:57Austin Caroe: You fail and I'm very disappointed.
- 1:05:57Austin Caroe: You guys need to do better.
- 1:05:58Austin Caroe: And I was kind of happy and I was like again, I felt like I was in flow, I felt like I was kind of on drugs and I was like, yes, sir, I understand, we'll do better next time.
- 1:06:05Austin Caroe: I'm sorry, we did not do so well.
- 1:06:09Austin Caroe: And I saw the second in command, the XO, just out of the corner of my eye.
- 1:06:12Austin Caroe: His mouth just drops open because what commander, confidently, is like well, sorry, but we'll do better next time.
- 1:06:18Austin Caroe: And sorry, I know, I'm going on and on here my XO comes into my office tears in his eyes and he's just like sir, I'm so sorry I let you down.
- 1:06:27Austin Caroe: And I was like hey, buddy, it's fine.
- 1:06:32Austin Caroe: We're a light infantry company.
- 1:06:33Austin Caroe: We're not deploying anytime soon.
- 1:06:34Austin Caroe: Our vehicles aren't pacing items.
- 1:06:35Austin Caroe: Here's what you need to understand.
- 1:06:36Austin Caroe: I'm not out here trying to save you.
- 1:06:38Austin Caroe: I'm not out here trying to save you.
- 1:06:39Austin Caroe: If I give you something to do, if you need help, I'm always here to help you.
- 1:06:43Austin Caroe: Whatever help you need, I'll give you help.
- 1:06:45Austin Caroe: I'll give you coaching, I'll give you advice, you something.
- 1:06:49Austin Caroe: It's on you, man.
- 1:06:50Austin Caroe: If the company fails because of the things you did or didn't do, it's on you.
- 1:07:00Austin Caroe: We're in this together.
- 1:07:01Austin Caroe: Ultimately, I'll take responsibility.
- 1:07:01Austin Caroe: I took responsibility for the failure on that inspection, but if we fail, it's because of you.
- 1:07:03Austin Caroe: I did that with everybody on everything, basically, where I was just like, hey guys, it's on you, I'm not coming to save you, I don't care if we look bad as an organization, I'm not going to save you.
- 1:07:11Austin Caroe: If we look bad as an organization, I'm not going to save you.
- 1:07:14Austin Caroe: And that, maybe more than anything, empowered my leaders to act, to do the things that they knew were right and to not lean on me to come and rescue them, which I see all the time in the military.
- 1:07:27Austin Caroe: When you have a strong, confident commander, they will prevent their organizations from failing because they are afraid that they personally will look bad, and so they will intervene and they will hobble their organizations because they don't empower their people, because they're afraid to fail.
- 1:07:39Mark McGrath: Yeah, totally makes sense to me.
- 1:07:40Mark McGrath: It goes back to the lessons of Norman Dixon and the psychology of military incompetence.
- 1:07:45Mark McGrath: I wish a lot of those things you're describing I get it.
- 1:07:47Mark McGrath: I keep thinking back to that book and I always say I wish I would have been given that book as a midshipman and naval rotc, that that should be required reading for incoming officers, to read that book and understand it like, like no exaggeration.
- 1:08:01Mark McGrath: And what's funny is that book was written in 1976 and I had asked one of boyd's acolytes I'd asked gi wilson about it if, if boyd had ever discussed that book because you know it was contemporary to him he, him, he would have had access to it and he said he remembered Boyd talking about it, although it's not on the bibliography of the things that are in the archives.
- 1:08:22Mark McGrath: But as you read it, though you would say I'm sure Boyd read this book, because he addressed everything in it on the things that have negative influences on a commander's point.
- 1:08:35Mark McGrath: And then, if you recall Norman Dixon, he was a foot soldier in World War II.
- 1:08:40Mark McGrath: I mean, he'd been down the business end before he had gone in to study psychology and get all his professional training, but he had lived this firsthand as a foot soldier.
- 1:08:49Mark McGrath: Sure, now what's interesting about that book as a foot soldier?
- 1:08:51Austin Caroe: Sure, now what's interesting about that book, and maybe why Boyd didn't talk about it so much is.
- 1:08:55Austin Caroe: The Freudian analysis is probably wrong in most of the cases, although the description of the pathologies is correct.
- 1:09:05Mark McGrath: The Freudian analysis of.
- 1:09:06Mark McGrath: There's like 14 of them, you know.
- 1:09:10Austin Caroe: That's right.
- 1:09:11Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:09:12Austin Caroe: The diagnosis of like, he accurately identifies problems, but when he's like well, you see, it's the british boarding school background that put these men on, or put these little boys on.
- 1:09:24Austin Caroe: You know strict, you know schedules for going to the bathroom, you know they made them super constipated and so this attack to sacrifice hundreds of thousands of soldiers was really a psychological release related to constipation.
- 1:09:38Austin Caroe: It's like okay, maybe, maybe not.
- 1:09:41Austin Caroe: There was a, there was a lot.
- 1:09:42Austin Caroe: Yeah, there was a.
- 1:09:43Austin Caroe: There's a lot of stuff like that in that book.
- 1:09:45Austin Caroe: And so I think and I think he accurately describes the, the authoritarian personality traits, but I don't know if he really gets to the root cause of a lot of them.
- 1:09:55Mark McGrath: Huh, all right, let's close with this.
- 1:09:58Mark McGrath: Your most shared article has a very catchy name Laziness, oh laziness.
- 1:10:06Austin Caroe: Yeah, I mean this is something that I really like to talk about.
- 1:10:08Austin Caroe: For some reason, this one you know this was kind of almost a throwaway one for me when I was writing it, but you know I've already kind of talked a little bit of how I'm personally like quite lazy, and there's a.
- 1:10:18Austin Caroe: There's a quote that gets thrown around a lot from Kurt von Hammerstein where he's like I divide my officers into you know what is it like?
- 1:10:27Austin Caroe: Lazy and intelligent, proactive and intelligent, lazy and stupid, proactive and stupid.
- 1:10:33Austin Caroe: And he basically is like well, the people who are, you know, the lazy and stupid, that's like 80% of the army, so that's most soldiers there's.
- 1:10:41Austin Caroe: You know, people who are intelligent and very proactive, put them on the general staff.
- 1:10:46Austin Caroe: They're going to do great, but people who are lazy and lazy and intelligent, those are the people that need to be at the highest levels of command and people.
- 1:10:56Austin Caroe: This is a pretty common thing.
- 1:10:57Austin Caroe: People talk about this a lot, but when you really look into it, like why is laziness so?
- 1:11:02Austin Caroe: Why is that?
- 1:11:03Austin Caroe: You know, why is that the case?
- 1:11:04Austin Caroe: And so the essay is really an exploration of why is it that laziness is important and is it always important?
- 1:11:10Austin Caroe: And so there's a lot we could go into, but basically what it comes down to is laziness is about preventing harm at scale.
- 1:11:20Austin Caroe: The higher you go up in the chain of command or the larger your network, the bigger the thing that you're working with, the more consequential your decisions are, the less you should be doing.
- 1:11:30Austin Caroe: The less you should be doing Because every single thing that you do is going to have huge ripple effects, second and third order effects.
- 1:11:38Austin Caroe: And I give the example in the essay of you know a two-star general, let's say he's in charge of an army post and traffic accidents have increased dramatically recently and he's like well, this is unacceptable, we can't have all these traffic accidents.
- 1:11:49Austin Caroe: You know staff go and tell me what to do and they say well, we really think we should have a safety stand down day.
- 1:11:55Austin Caroe: Well, they do the safety stand down day and that has all these.
- 1:11:59Austin Caroe: You know, training gets canceled.
- 1:12:01Austin Caroe: I tell a story about private snuffy.
- 1:12:02Austin Caroe: His leave gets canceled so he can't go propose to his girlfriend that he was going to do.
- 1:12:07Austin Caroe: So you know, he gets, he starts drinking and there's all these effects because we, we did everything to do the safety stand down day and um, and that's just what the problem is traffic accidents actually go down after the safety stand down day, and so this tricks everyone to the thinking well, safety stand down days make accidents go down, so we should do this once a quarter.
- 1:12:31Austin Caroe: And so it's just this huge whiplash effect where it's like, well, no, the safety stand on day didn't have anything to do with it.
- 1:12:36Austin Caroe: Traffic accidents was probably just random fluctuation or something to do with traffic patterns or weather.
- 1:12:41Austin Caroe: It's all the different things that could have caused the spike.
- 1:12:43Austin Caroe: I mean, it's just regression to the mean.
- 1:12:44Austin Caroe: But we get confused and say, well, this thing that we did cause this other thing.
- 1:12:49Austin Caroe: Most things are very overdetermined, they don't have one or two causes, and so we get tricked because we do one thing and then we get a result.
- 1:12:58Austin Caroe: The result is good, and so we think that what we did is what caused that.
- 1:13:01Austin Caroe: And I would challenge that and say that that's not always the case.
- 1:13:05Austin Caroe: When you're lazy, you're looking not to do things but to undo things.
- 1:13:09Austin Caroe: You're like well, can we just not do this meeting?
- 1:13:13Austin Caroe: You know, one of the things that and this is sacrilegious.
- 1:13:20Austin Caroe: So this is, you know, just between, just between us is when I was a company commander, I didn't have a training meeting, which is, again, that won't mean anything to people that aren't in the army.
- 1:13:25Austin Caroe: But not having a training meeting as a company commander, like purposely being like I'm not doing that, um is is basically going into church, and being like, uh, that is basically going into church and being like you know, jesus wasn't crucified or something like that Completely sacrilegious.
- 1:13:37Austin Caroe: And I'm not saying tall company commanders don't have a training meeting, I'm just saying it wasn't.
- 1:13:40Austin Caroe: I didn't need one because I was lazy and I was like I don't want to do meetings.
- 1:13:43Austin Caroe: I hate meetings.
- 1:13:44Austin Caroe: They're dumb, and when you look to undo things or not do things, you're not looking for changes.
- 1:13:58Austin Caroe: You're looking for changes in the environment, but you don't want to change the environment for the most part, or you want it to improve.
- 1:14:01Austin Caroe: So you, instead of adding something, you can just take something away, and if you don't get a degradation, not necessarily you see an improvement, but if things don't get worse, then it's probably fine, and so you can just like sort.
- 1:14:10Austin Caroe: It's like jenga, right, where you slowly just take out one thing at a time and be like well, can I just not do that?
- 1:14:15Austin Caroe: And I do this all the time on staff work, where you know, when I was a liaison, there was this huge long email that they wanted me to write, but I knew no one read it, so I just stopped sending it.
- 1:14:25Austin Caroe: No one ever said anything and so and no one ever used that information for anything Like it wasn't nested with anything, so I just stopped, and so that's kind of what laziness is about.
- 1:14:35Austin Caroe: It's about do less and build excess capacity, and I have a whole nother essay about the importance of building excess capacity and why, when it feels like you're wasting manpower, you're not.
- 1:14:45Austin Caroe: There's a whole great story from the mythical man month.
- 1:14:47Austin Caroe: I'm guessing you're familiar with that.
- 1:14:49Austin Caroe: Yeah, oh, yeah, yep.
- 1:14:50Austin Caroe: So anyway, yeah, that's.
- 1:14:52Austin Caroe: That's what laziness is.
- 1:14:53Ponch Rivera: There's a couple other connections here.
- 1:14:55Ponch Rivera: Uh, daniel kahneman writes about.
- 1:14:56Ponch Rivera: Laziness is built deep into our nature.
- 1:14:58Ponch Rivera: You know we talk about two percent of our body weight burn and twenty percent of our energy we take.
- 1:15:01Ponch Rivera: You also look at zips law uh, the principle of least effort.
- 1:15:04Ponch Rivera: So if you ever look into the, the power laws, you'll, you'll see the same thing in there.
- 1:15:08Ponch Rivera: Here it's it's natural.
- 1:15:10Ponch Rivera: You get into system one and system two.
- 1:15:11Ponch Rivera: System two takes more energy, so it's easier just to use heuristics and just make shit up and go than it is to slow down.
- 1:15:17Ponch Rivera: And this goes back to what we were talking about with bringing people off the line to slow down a little bit.
- 1:15:21Ponch Rivera: That's actually what you're trying to do is build up, focus on system two thinking and bring it back into system one over the long run.
- 1:15:27Ponch Rivera: But yeah, I'm with you on all this stuff.
- 1:15:29Ponch Rivera: It's again laziness is.
- 1:15:31Ponch Rivera: By the way, that image you have on your laziness article cracked me up.
- 1:15:34Ponch Rivera: Man.
- 1:15:34Ponch Rivera: Yeah, that's a good one.
- 1:15:36Mark McGrath: That's what every Marine is thinking.
- 1:15:37Mark McGrath: Where'd you find that anyway?
- 1:15:38Austin Caroe: I just, you know Googled, you know army lazy, or you know sleeping.
- 1:15:42Mark McGrath: There you go.
- 1:15:43Mark McGrath: I really like that.
- 1:15:43Austin Caroe: So, yeah, there's a couple funny there have left.
- 1:15:49Austin Caroe: We've been going for a while, almost an hour and a half, yeah I got a punch right here yeah, we're gonna put it well.
- 1:15:53Mark McGrath: Yeah, we'll put a pin in it and we'll uh, we'll call it a day.
- 1:15:56Mark McGrath: We're gonna send everybody to the distro which is phenomenal, and they can read for themselves some of the amazing things that you've written.
- 1:16:05Mark McGrath: And then I was gonna say thanks for uh, thanks for coming on.
- 1:16:09Mark McGrath: I'm.
- 1:16:09Mark McGrath: I guess the next, maybe the next time we get, you can give us your debrief of the Osinga book.
- 1:16:14Austin Caroe: Yeah, yeah, for sure, yeah, no.
- 1:16:17Austin Caroe: Thank you so much for having me on.
- 1:16:18Austin Caroe: People can check out the distrosubstackcom.
- 1:16:20Austin Caroe: I also have a YouTube channel where I have some videos.
- 1:16:23Austin Caroe: I've got a whole thing about Ranger School on there, a bunch of different videos covering Darby phase.
- 1:16:27Austin Caroe: I'd like to do more work, obviously, but you know, but I've got a day job so I can only do so much.
- 1:16:32Austin Caroe: But thank you so much for having me on.
- 1:16:35Mark McGrath: And we want to remind everybody about that day job that your views are your views.
- 1:16:39Mark McGrath: The views that you share with us are yours and yours alone, not that of the United States.
- 1:16:44Mark McGrath: Exactly right, all right, thanks, austin.
- 1:16:47Mark McGrath: Thanks, guys.