Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Is Digital Ministry the Church’s New Narthex? A Conversation with Rev. Joseph Wolyniak
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, I'm talking with
- 0:03Pastor Joseph Woliniak. He's a really close friend of
- 0:08mine, and we're talking about the Narthex project, which is
- 0:10something that we're both working on together.
- 0:13You'll hear more in the conversation, but it's about
- 0:16digital ministry and connecting with those who are spiritual but
- 0:20not religious, and all the things we're learning as we go
- 0:22through this project. It's skews in a bunch of other
- 0:25directions, but it's a really awesome conversation just about
- 0:29story telling and why it matters to show up as people of faith in
- 0:35the places where we can. It's just great.
- 0:37I can't wait to share it with you.
- 0:39Here we go. Welcome to the Together for Good
- 0:41podcast, a podcast created by Bethany Lutheran Church in
- 0:45Cherry Hills Village, Co and hosted by me, Pastor Nate
- 0:49Pricinger and Together for Good. Our goal is to provide
- 0:52practical, engaging content that supports you without
- 0:55expectations. Whether you're feeling
- 0:58disconnected from traditional religion or simply exploring
- 1:01what faith means in your life, we are here to walk alongside
- 1:04you. No matter where you are on your
- 1:07journey of faith, we're glad you're here.
- 1:09Welcome to Together for good. Well, I'm here with my very best
- 1:14friend in the whole wide world, Joseph Maleniak.
- 1:16How are you, Joe? Great to see you man.
- 1:19Great to see you as always. Joe is an Episcopal priest at
- 1:24Christchurch, Denver, but you live in Seattle and we're going
- 1:28to get into how this all works out, etcetera.
- 1:31Joe is the mastermind. And what is, are you executive
- 1:34director of the Narthex project? Is that your technical term?
- 1:38No, at the Guru. The guru of the narthex project,
- 1:42which is this Lily grant that Joe wrote and received.
- 1:45I'm going to give you let you talk more details and but just
- 1:48for the Bethany people here, Bethany is one of the sub
- 1:51grantees that was kind of a part of this.
- 1:53So we want to talk about the narthex grant today.
- 1:56Joe, give us like just start at the beginning kind of talk about
- 1:59how this is structured, how it works, just to give our, our
- 2:02listener an understanding of what we're talking about.
- 2:06First of all, I thought we were talking about how the Nuggets
- 2:08didn't make too many trades of the trade deadline.
- 2:11They didn't do anything at the trade.
- 2:12Deadline thought we were going to be talking about the buyout
- 2:15market. OK, OK, this I'll suddenly
- 2:17pivot. How to fix the NBA All Star
- 2:19game? I guess that's our next
- 2:23conversation. So the narthex developing
- 2:26digital capacity for the analogue church.
- 2:29I have to say that we may have written the grant and received
- 2:32the funds, but we were very, very much inspired by you, Nate,
- 2:36and what you all are doing at Bethany and just trying to keep
- 2:39up with the Lutheran Jones's down the street.
- 2:43But if we take a step back and go to the pandemic, the joke
- 2:48that I like to to say is that Episcopalians discover the
- 2:51Internet in the pandemic, even if it was the AOL dial up
- 2:53version, that there's of course many, many dark things and and
- 2:59difficult things of the pandemic.
- 3:00But if necessity is the mother of invention, your church, my
- 3:05church. Many mainline churches had to
- 3:08pivot into online engagement overnight in the pandemic.
- 3:12I'll never forget us having to live stream our first service,
- 3:16the first service we ever live streamed to Christchurch, Denver
- 3:19with my mobile phone. Even if it looked like The Blair
- 3:22Witch Project and all the the shaky craziness and quickly
- 3:27pivoting up from there to online live streaming and Zoom Bible
- 3:32studies. And I was really worried for our
- 3:35congregation that we weren't going to be able to make that
- 3:39pivot to online engagement. Our church, like many mainline
- 3:42churches, is full of of folks that are over the age of 55 and
- 3:47may have varying levels of technological ability.
- 3:51But we were able to make this pivot as a congregation and
- 3:54start connecting as a community doing Bible studies, worship,
- 3:58prayer online. And this gave us an opportunity
- 4:00to say, how could we continue to do this?
- 4:03Learn from other peers, including you, Bethany Lutheran
- 4:07and other mainline leaders, and different congregations across
- 4:10the country, and ask how to do this better as we try to engage
- 4:15folks beyond the walls of our church.
- 4:18So with that then in terms of writing up the grant itself,
- 4:22like thank you for that, gives us a real understanding of sort
- 4:24of the impetus behind it. And I think you're right that a
- 4:27ton of congregations were all of a sudden looking at themselves
- 4:30in March 2020 being like, what do we do now?
- 4:33Side note, if you look back at our YouTube channel from those
- 4:37days, we were recording and live streaming, but we had these like
- 4:41security cameras that we were using.
- 4:43So it looks like a 1995 home video and I love it.
- 4:46And I'm so grateful for the people that gave money so that
- 4:50we could improve the quality of our live stream.
- 4:54It's really funny. But with with this developing
- 4:57the digital, digital capacity, I'm also remembering and I know
- 5:02you and I have talked that part of this is not just about
- 5:05helping the mainline denominations get up to code,
- 5:09but more also how can we be reaching out and connecting with
- 5:13an audience that's not here, correct.
- 5:15Like that's kind of part of how the grant was written.
- 5:18That's exactly right. It's built into the name itself.
- 5:21I mean, so for those of your listeners who don't speak Greek,
- 5:24the narthex itself is a Greek architectural term.
- 5:28For traditional churches, there would be this space between the
- 5:32street and the sanctuary, sort of a transition place as you're
- 5:36walking into the church or as you're walking out from the
- 5:40church. And we meant it in that bi
- 5:41directional idea that this is sort of a gathering space and A
- 5:46and a place of encounter for for those of us who inhabit the
- 5:50church and those who are on the outside of the church, what we
- 5:54would in the Pew language called the ever growing ranks of the
- 5:59nuns, duns and spiritual but not religious.
- 6:02Again, your listeners I'm sure know they're friends and family
- 6:06that are in any of those categories that would consider
- 6:10themselves not religious or they perhaps were religious at some
- 6:15point and have disaffiliated walked away from institutional
- 6:18or organized Christianity or religion generally.
- 6:21And maybe in that category of still having a spirituality or a
- 6:25sense of God or some some transcendent being or beings,
- 6:30but but not identifying with the traditional religious
- 6:33institutions. So the whole goal of this
- 6:36project is not just to do the in reach stuff, which we did really
- 6:39well in the pandemic, but how can we push ourselves in that
- 6:44evangelical mission that is a part of our baptism and a part
- 6:48of the Great Commission to go and share the good news and and
- 6:52the highways in the hedges, as the old hymn goes.
- 6:55Let, I want to dig into this Joe, because I, we, you and I
- 6:58have talked about all of these themes in various ways, but I'm
- 7:01also kind of curious we're, we're two years in now, just
- 7:05about right through this whole project.
- 7:08And yeah, Christchurch, Denver was the one that received the
- 7:12grant and then there's 5 sub grantees.
- 7:15Do I have that correct? Trying digital ministry in
- 7:18various mainline ways. And here's what I'm wondering
- 7:22about and would love your knee jerk reaction too.
- 7:26And I and I haven't asked you this before because we're too
- 7:29busy talking about the Nuggets, but do you think that digital
- 7:35space is where the church can connect with the nuns and the
- 7:40duns and the spiritually spiritual but not religious?
- 7:43Is that actually a, I don't know, like what analogy we want
- 7:47to use, but like a a good space for that or is it is it too
- 7:53gnarly over there for the church to make any head rub?
- 7:55I'm. Going to put the question back
- 7:58to you, but I'm going to start with teaching in a classroom at
- 8:04Seattle University. So you mentioned that I live in
- 8:07Seattle and I'm still a remote member of the pastoral staff at
- 8:11Christchurch Denver. But having lived in Seattle now,
- 8:14I started teaching as an affiliate faculty at our local
- 8:17Jesuit Catholic school, within which 98% of the students that
- 8:23I've had to date, so about 150 students, 98% of them are in
- 8:28that none done spiritual, but not religious, atheistic,
- 8:31agnostic category. And they know for me shockingly
- 8:37little about Christianity, even though they're attending a
- 8:40Jesuit Catholic school. I had a student the other day
- 8:44right on a midterm that they didn't know that Jesus wasn't an
- 8:47American. And that took me back.
- 8:52But if not, if I were honest, you know, there's a part of me
- 8:56that said if I went to your average person at Bethany
- 8:59Lutheran and I said quick, when and where was Siddhartha
- 9:03Gautama, the first Buddha born, they probably wouldn't be able
- 9:08to say, oh, in the 6th or 7th century BC and Numbini in Nepal,
- 9:14right? I'm really glad you didn't ask
- 9:16me that question through this. Yeah, great.
- 9:20Back to the Nuggets buyout market, but we're we are
- 9:24inhabiting an ever increasingly post Christian context or in
- 9:29certain parts of the country like here in the Pacific
- 9:31Northwest. It was never really a religious
- 9:34context. So but the I think the hunger
- 9:39for spirituality or a friend transcendence is there in all of
- 9:44us and the place that most of us, especially younger digital
- 9:50natives go to find the answers to the questions we're asking in
- 9:54life for everything. How do we change some something
- 9:57mechanical in our car to how we raise our kids to what is the
- 10:01meaning and purpose of life is online?
- 10:05So I don't know that there is a quick and easy correlation
- 10:12between some of the content that you have been posting and the
- 10:15amazing reels and the podcast to young people all of a sudden
- 10:19showing up in our church. But I do think that this is a
- 10:22space that we are going to have to occupy if we want any chance
- 10:26for people discovering us. What it another one of our
- 10:30colleagues in this pilot cohort of churches, the way that he put
- 10:34it, and AME Zion, pastor in Philadelphia, said we're kind of
- 10:39a Yellow Pages church in a digital age.
- 10:41So how do we as the church inhabit this digital space?
- 10:45But can I put the question back to you?
- 10:47I mean, you've been experimenting and we've been
- 10:49trying to learn from you at Bethany Lutheran through your
- 10:52podcasting, through the online content that you all have been
- 10:54creating. What have you found in terms of
- 10:58this ability to reach those you're trying to reach beyond
- 11:01the walls of your church? No.
- 11:03And so I, I'll, I'll give you my, my honest kind of reflection
- 11:06of all of it too, is it's not yet like you said, I don't think
- 11:10directly resulting in a huge surge in membership or even
- 11:16worship attendance. No.
- 11:18And you rooted all of this in our baptismal covenant in that
- 11:25work called to share the good news.
- 11:29And it doesn't ever say anywhere in there that and there should
- 11:32be results. And so that's also part of how
- 11:35I've been constantly approaching is like, I'm going to
- 11:37continually put out pieces of information, you know, like
- 11:42resources and prayers and Bible verses and etcetera, etcetera,
- 11:47in hopes that the person scrolling through might stop and
- 11:51finally hear something that speaks to their soul in a
- 11:54meaningful way. And that's hard some days to to
- 11:59for that to be enough because we are programmed to be so results
- 12:03oriented. But my call has always been
- 12:08about being faithful and not being successful.
- 12:10And I have to remind myself of that again and again.
- 12:13The other piece too, though, what I always, I think part of
- 12:15my hesitation and worry is that this can easily also become just
- 12:22trying to play the secular game with Christian pieces.
- 12:30And that's something I'm very averse to as well that like I
- 12:33don't want to do gimmicks and I don't want to do like just
- 12:37trying to play along with whatever is hot and exciting
- 12:40right now in an effort to like bait and switch someone and be
- 12:44like, oh, shoot, like I stumbled upon Christianity.
- 12:48And that's a really fine line. I don't, I don't know if you
- 12:51have, I'm sure I know you have a reaction to that.
- 12:54But like, how do you, how do you discern that kind of fine line
- 12:57between like, are we just sort of like trying to entertain
- 13:01people, which shouldn't be what we're doing, or are we actually
- 13:06doing evangelistic gospel work? How do you discern that?
- 13:11Yeah, I think it's pretty easy for me because I am
- 13:13constitutionally incapable of doing anything hot or exciting,
- 13:17as you know, so. As evidenced by your hat.
- 13:24So, yeah, I'm not, I'm not going to struggle with that, but it is
- 13:26a really good question. I mean, I think that always the
- 13:29the form forms, right? So we have to be thinking about
- 13:33how as we try to inhabit these online spaces, we talked about
- 13:37social media, in particular, the the very form of social media
- 13:41itself is forming us as we try to inhabit those those spaces,
- 13:47both in terms of what we're doing is content creators for
- 13:51the platforms themselves and and the kinds of content that we're
- 13:56putting out there and consuming. And so we're go back to your
- 13:59word of faithfulness. That is the challenge for us is
- 14:02how do we faithfully inhabit those spaces and to the the
- 14:07question of, you know, numbers and and success versus
- 14:13faithfulness. That is always the question for
- 14:16us as Christians. I mean, I want to be prudent
- 14:19with our use of these technologies.
- 14:21I want to be doing this if nobody's engaging these
- 14:25resources, but I do of course, think of Jesus himself who is
- 14:30able to to go person to person and the grand strategy for the
- 14:35the new in breaking Kingdom with 12 small faithful followers and
- 14:40starting with them and sending them out to proclaim the good
- 14:43news. You know, we're talking pastor
- 14:46to pastor here, but I'm, I'm really aware that the, the call
- 14:52of good news is not just for us. And we're trying to talk about
- 14:56how can our churches inhabit these online spaces as
- 15:00institutions. But the bigger challenge for us
- 15:03may be to help the everyday person in our pews think about
- 15:08inhabiting their own social media presence or their own
- 15:11online platforms to share truly good news, the good news of
- 15:16Jesus and not just the good news of Rome.
- 15:19Because our social media feeds are completely dominated by bad
- 15:24news #1 and if I go back to those students in the classroom,
- 15:30what they, they tell me that they see about Christianity is
- 15:34not particularly good to them. So it think it's incumbent upon
- 15:39all of us, not just pastors, not just churches as institutions,
- 15:42but all of us as followers of Jesus, to be thinking about the
- 15:46ways in which we inhabit ourselves online.
- 15:49And are we sharing the good news you were just talking about?
- 15:53And is that the good news of Jesus?
- 15:54Or is it the the good news the you angelion of Rome?
- 15:59It's really funny. I don't know if you ever saw
- 16:01this trend, but there was a whole trend about a year ago on
- 16:04social media where you would just ask a random person, like,
- 16:08when's the last time you thought about the Roman Empire?
- 16:10And then for whatever reason, it was that like men think about
- 16:13the Roman Empire way more than women.
- 16:17And yet, yeah, like, that was my answer because I had our social
- 16:21media person at the time asked me that question.
- 16:23I'm like, like probably about every six weeks, you know, like
- 16:26it seems like it comes up in my preaching or something.
- 16:29Anyways, I just think that's funny.
- 16:30But it's a good example of, yeah, like the can we be 11 in
- 16:37the online space just by showing up, just by putting something
- 16:41out there that's that's more positive.
- 16:44But what? And even deeper than that,
- 16:46right? Like, 'cause that's the other
- 16:47thing. I don't want to just get into
- 16:48positive pop psychology. Like I, I really believe the
- 16:51gospel is something so much more important and transformational
- 16:55than that, that hopefully people are starting to discover.
- 16:59And, and here's my question I'll put back to you.
- 17:04Do you ever wonder, could that time be spent better just
- 17:11getting a small group of people together like Jesus did, and
- 17:14really pouring into them in those ways?
- 17:19Absolutely. I mean.
- 17:20Let's say that. The whole impetus behind the
- 17:23this project, and I know that you share this and I'd love to
- 17:25hear you reflect on this too, is that online is not a means.
- 17:32It is a means it's not an end to itself, right.
- 17:35We're, we're not simply trying to create an online church or
- 17:40online community. Those things can be great.
- 17:43There's a, there's a space for online community, especially for
- 17:45those who maybe in particular life circumstances or they're,
- 17:49they're homebound or hospital bound or something like that
- 17:52where they, they really need online community.
- 17:56But for the vast majority of folks, the real place of
- 18:00encounter is always going to be incarnational.
- 18:02It's like with real people offline.
- 18:05But the vast majority of people, again, if we're talking about
- 18:08the institutional church, they're first experience of a
- 18:12church is not going to be suddenly showing up at Bethany
- 18:15Lutheran at 10:00 on Sunday morning.
- 18:18First, they're going to scroll, they're going to check out the
- 18:22website, they're going to ask questions, they may even DM or
- 18:28e-mail the congregation to. They're going to kind of kick
- 18:31the tires of of the church right before they ever show up on
- 18:34Sunday morning. Listen to your sermon.
- 18:36They're going to watch, see how you present yourself online.
- 18:40So the whole goal is to how to for the institutional church to
- 18:44think about being thoughtful about how we're presenting
- 18:47ourselves online in ways that are Invitational to those who
- 18:52don't know what the word Lutheran or Episcopalian mean or
- 18:57may ever increasingly not know what the word Christian means.
- 19:01But again, I put it in the broader register for for all of
- 19:05us to be thinking about the ways in which we inhabit ourselves
- 19:09online will be quick to say, oh, you all have to go see this
- 19:12amazing film that just came out. You got to go check out this new
- 19:17restaurant that is in Cherry Creek.
- 19:20It's just absolutely amazing. But are we as quick to talk
- 19:24about the amazing things that are happening in our church or
- 19:28in our own hearts or lives or families?
- 19:32We get really shy about faith. We'll be really quick to talk
- 19:35about politics, but are we as ready to share the good news of
- 19:41Jesus Christ? No.
- 19:43There's just something so awkward about it for most
- 19:45people, and yet I think the digital space can make it so
- 19:51much more easy and manageable. One of the things that I've been
- 19:56wanting to do is to create a class, just like an after church
- 20:01class for my people at Bethany about digital evangelism.
- 20:06And, and digital tithing, so to speak, because you really can do
- 20:10that. And, and it's really easy.
- 20:12Like people don't realize it, but like when you click like on
- 20:15the post, that tells the algorithm that more people
- 20:19should see this. Like that alone is really
- 20:21helpful that that is a gift to your church.
- 20:24And what's even bigger gets if is when you click that share
- 20:27button, because that also like makes the algorithm sparkle and
- 20:30light up. And it means that now everyone
- 20:32on your feed gets to see this thing that you've shared.
- 20:36And so there's like just a whole, there's a whole ethos
- 20:39that we're missing out on that there.
- 20:42There's a whole way of being in an online space that would be so
- 20:46beneficial to your congregation that I don't think people
- 20:48normally consider or think about.
- 20:51And part of that I, I, part of that too is just sort of the
- 20:56current state of the online spaces.
- 20:59I feel like maybe 15 years ago it was a lot safer, just like,
- 21:02oh, hey, but now most people just sort of lurk online, except
- 21:06for the folks that get really angry in the comments.
- 21:08And I, I'm rambling, but you like just touched on something
- 21:13that I've been wanting to do, but not found time for because
- 21:16I, because I do think I really like this vision of teaching,
- 21:20like through engaging in digital ministry, we're also discipling
- 21:25people in the congregation about how to inhabit those spaces.
- 21:30Fair. OK, well, So what have you
- 21:34learned through this process, like being a part of this grant
- 21:39at Christchurch? Are there any insights or big
- 21:41aha moments that you've kind of had in the last two years as a
- 21:45result of this project? Oh man, how many hours do we
- 21:50have? So say for us as a congregation,
- 21:53one of the things was taking a long hard look in the mirror,
- 21:57which is not always fun. One of that, one of the things
- 22:01for us was to realize almost all of our communications was prior
- 22:06to starting this grant internal, we were just talking to
- 22:09ourselves. Everything in the e-mail,
- 22:13everything on our website was just talking to ourselves about
- 22:16ourselves. When the next event is going to
- 22:18come up what resources we have This gave us an opportunity to
- 22:22really step back and as you know in the in our processor of
- 22:27imagine who might we be trying to reach in our neighborhood
- 22:32that is not currently a part of our church and we can playfully
- 22:35call this the 8O21-O initiative. As I told you I do nothing hot
- 22:39hip or exciting. This is a back to the 90s
- 22:42reference, although you're 90s Bethany Saved by the Bell video
- 22:46set. The oh, thank you.
- 22:48I'm so glad you saw it. Very important.
- 22:50So, you know, this question of like, how can we try to build
- 22:57the church for those who don't exist yet and build an online
- 23:01space for those who are not currently a part of our church?
- 23:05And this has just continued to challenge me personally to think
- 23:11about the those nuns and duns and why are they not in church.
- 23:16And I could come up with a very long list of things that I've
- 23:19heard people that are have been hurt, people who are bored,
- 23:24people who have felt unseen, people who feel like they can't
- 23:29really reconcile some of the the arcane stuff we do in these
- 23:33religious traditions with their real everyday lives.
- 23:39It's a very long list, but how can we, in the spirit of Jesus's
- 23:45own teaching, to leave the 99 to go find the one?
- 23:50Maybe it's a little bit flipped now.
- 23:52It's some kind of like leaving the 10 to go find the 99,000,
- 23:55given the decline of the mainline church.
- 23:59But how can we invert our usual gravitational pull, which is
- 24:05always toward the gathered church and back out to being the
- 24:09scattered church in our everyday lives?
- 24:12But I'm curious for you, too. I mean, you've not to keep
- 24:17teething your home horn, but you've been a point of
- 24:20inspiration for me, both personally and pastorally.
- 24:22And your congregation has done this a lot.
- 24:24What have you all learned along the way?
- 24:27I mean. I think, I think a lot of us,
- 24:31I've sort of confessed to it just through the questions I'm
- 24:34asking is that there was definitely a mindset of if, if
- 24:38you post it, they will come and just kind of reframing that for
- 24:43everyone. And, and it, it speaks so much
- 24:46to the human souls predicament of always believing we found the
- 24:50quick fix and there is no quick fix.
- 24:53There's just Jesus. Like that's, that's the most
- 24:57important thing that I continually learn.
- 25:01But but also, I mean, within that just learning, I mean, I've
- 25:06learned a lot about what works online and what doesn't and just
- 25:12in terms of the importance of storytelling.
- 25:14And you know, you mentioned the silly 1990s staff video that we
- 25:19did. And yet that was really, it
- 25:23really speaks to like, hey, like let's show other people that we
- 25:27don't take ourselves too seriously.
- 25:29And if you look on our website, that's the kind of the way we
- 25:31frame it on our staff pages, it says, like, we do really serious
- 25:34work, but we don't take ourselves too seriously.
- 25:36And that's important because it really is true about who we are.
- 25:40And it's something we want other people to know about us because
- 25:43they have the mindset of the church being especially a
- 25:46Lutheran Church, right? Like old and stodgy and set in
- 25:48their ways and very, you know, European sitting in rows and
- 25:54Robert's Rules of Order, whatever have you.
- 25:59And we want to show that there's more to us than that because
- 26:01that's also what we think makes us great.
- 26:03Like storytelling is so, so important in the digital space,
- 26:07but also just as a church community, who are you?
- 26:11And be proud of that and be willing to tell other people
- 26:14about it. That's the quick one that comes
- 26:18to mind in terms of the key learning.
- 26:22And I guess I'll leave it at that for now, but but it's what
- 26:26I want to say to that too. It's a key learning and it is so
- 26:32neat to see that that is such a part of what it means to be a
- 26:36faith community. And it always has been.
- 26:39I, I love to think about one of Jesus like core characteristics
- 26:45or identities is as a storyteller.
- 26:49And I don't think we talked about that a lot.
- 26:51Like I, I would never limit it to that, but that he spoke in
- 26:54parables. And what is that like?
- 26:56What is that trying to show us about how to be a human being?
- 26:59And, and what is that showing us about the character of God that
- 27:02when God was in human form, God told stories.
- 27:06And how can we as the gathered community of Christ?
- 27:10Yeah, tell, tell the stories of this place.
- 27:12And, and, and you know, when I see all these connections like
- 27:14this, what we do at baptism, it's like we're going to bless
- 27:16the water, but we're going to bless the water by telling you
- 27:18and recounting all the stories of the time that God used water
- 27:22to save God's people. And it's like, hey, look, the
- 27:25story is still happening today with this baby, right?
- 27:29It's so beautiful when you start to unpack it.
- 27:32And that's just, I mean, that's the key learning too, is that
- 27:36there's nothing new. It seems new and fresh and
- 27:39creative. And it is so deeply rooted in
- 27:42who we are and what we're trying to do.
- 27:46I don't know reactions to any of that because you always have an
- 27:50opinion about everything, which is why I like you.
- 27:52But where do you resonate with storytelling?
- 27:56Did I commit any grave heresies with that whole rant?
- 28:00No. Absolutely not.
- 28:03You didn't know no heresies and absolutely resonate with this
- 28:06storytelling piece, which I want to come back to you for.
- 28:10Again, our average person in the pews that this isn't just like
- 28:13our our institutional church organizational communications
- 28:17plan. But maybe we should think about
- 28:19this your everyday baptized person that yeah, evangelism is
- 28:23hard. Like none of us took an
- 28:25apologetics or evangelism one O 1 class, right?
- 28:29And we, we feel like we don't want to talk about religion and
- 28:32politics because those are the two no go zones, although we do
- 28:35seem to be willing to talk a lot about politics online, just not
- 28:39religion. But our real fear around
- 28:42religion is that, oh, if we get into that and somebody asks us a
- 28:46question, am I going to be positioned to, to answer that?
- 28:49I don't, I don't know. Now I got to back away.
- 28:51But maybe storytelling is the place to begin for all of us
- 28:55that you don't have to come up with the, the argument that's
- 28:59going to bring somebody into faith.
- 29:00In fact, it's not actually an argument.
- 29:03It's just about telling stories of where you've encountered God
- 29:07in your life for the story of the difference faith has made to
- 29:11you in this topsy turvy, noisy, turbulent world that going back
- 29:17to your own story and what the difference Jesus has made in
- 29:22your life. If I can circle back to to one
- 29:26of the stories that Jesus himself told of the parable of
- 29:29this, this sower and this idea of the one to one correspondence
- 29:33that if I post a reel, if I post something online, then it's
- 29:36going to lead to somebody coming to faith and starting
- 29:40worshipping with us in the church.
- 29:42Jesus told this story of the the sower goes out and throws the
- 29:46seed and it's really this the story of profligate grace.
- 29:50It is not a very precise or measured way of planting seeds.
- 29:56And I know nothing about seed planting because I come from
- 29:59Detroit, but but this is not precise and measured out.
- 30:05And if I plant the seed and water just under the right
- 30:07conditions, but it is just throwing stuff out there to see
- 30:11what happens. And sometimes the seed falls on
- 30:13hard soil. Sometimes a bird comes in and
- 30:16just distracts before the seed can really take root.
- 30:20And other times it does take root.
- 30:22And that's been the way that I am trying to think about all of
- 30:25this digital storytelling, digital gospel sharing work is
- 30:30it is just trying to cast stuff out there and see what might
- 30:35land with people. And maybe it doesn't lead to a
- 30:38one to one correspondence that this real means this person
- 30:41started worshipping with us. But maybe that's also not the
- 30:44point. It is to just share a profligate
- 30:47grace story of God's work and the world.
- 30:51And maybe that is a word of encouragement to people in a
- 30:55world that desperately needs hope, I think.
- 30:58About one of my, my best friend growing up, he was going through
- 31:03a really hard time and I just, I, I didn't really know how to
- 31:08help him. Like, OK, like I just pray when
- 31:11things are hard. And that's all I told him.
- 31:14And it started this whole new thread of conversation with us.
- 31:18And like, then he would start, he slept over every Saturday
- 31:22night, like, for the rest of that those two years that before
- 31:26we went off to college so that we could all go to church
- 31:28together. And yeah.
- 31:30And he's still, like, very, very much a person of faith today.
- 31:34And it was just because I was willing enough and I trusted him
- 31:39enough. Like, we had a good enough
- 31:40friendship where I could just, like, listen, like, I'm just
- 31:42going to tell you what works for me.
- 31:45But I hear that exactly what you're saying.
- 31:46Like, sometimes that's all that it really takes.
- 31:51Do you have a story, though, from your own life about why
- 31:56this matters for you? I mean, I know you have many,
- 32:00but I'm going to put you on the spot and ask you to maybe tell
- 32:03us one. Yeah, I've heard, again, tons of
- 32:11younger people. I'm going to go back to the
- 32:13classroom and the I start my class at Seattle University
- 32:21every quarter asking students what their image of Jesus is and
- 32:25where they've gotten it from. And what emerges is an American
- 32:32Jesus that is muscular, violent, mean, exclusionary, so on and so
- 32:37forth. And I asked, where'd you pick up
- 32:40that image? And all of them will say social
- 32:43media, TikTok, Instagram, Twitter, 100% that I don't
- 32:50really know anything about Christian envy.
- 32:52But if I did have an impression of who Jesus was or what he
- 32:57taught, or what his followers look like as they try to walk in
- 33:01his footsteps, this is what I've seen online.
- 33:06So this is, in my mind, what we're up against.
- 33:09It is as much a deconstructing task as it is a reconstructing
- 33:14task. First of all, we have, there's a
- 33:17aspect of this where we have to say this is not what Jesus is or
- 33:21was or ever taught. But can I introduce you to the
- 33:26Jesus, reintroduce you to the Jesus that I know, this
- 33:31embodiment of God's love, mercy and grace in the world.
- 33:37I've also heard counter stories of people saying, you know what
- 33:41did change my mind? This little piece of content
- 33:44where I saw everyday people faithfully following the
- 33:49teachings of Jesus and trying to put them into practice in their
- 33:51lives. And while I might not be
- 33:52convinced or I'm not going to become a Christian tomorrow, I
- 33:57did see this and it made me think maybe there are people out
- 34:00there who are trying to live out their faith in ways that do
- 34:05resonate with me. So then, then again, I think for
- 34:11the everyday person in in your pews or in my pews that live
- 34:16busy lives, work 9 to 5 jobs, raising kids, what can they do
- 34:25to share the hope that is within them?
- 34:29As the New Testament says, How about for you?
- 34:34Is there a story that sticks out to you and your own personal
- 34:39life or your pastoral ministry? About sharing the hope that is
- 34:47within me, I really like that you drew us to that line in
- 34:51particular. I mean, that's really good.
- 34:55So what I'll say just in terms of why this stuff all matters is
- 35:03just because it has always been so poignant for my own being.
- 35:11Like, like my study of theology and this, the more I dig into
- 35:17it, the more the pieces just seem to fit together.
- 35:20And not all the time. I'm currently so attuned to
- 35:24looking at people and being able to kind of recognize the the
- 35:31trauma that informs their current state of being.
- 35:35And I feel like it's so prevalent and, and not in like
- 35:38some mystical sense, but I can just kind of tell it's like, oh
- 35:41wow, like you are so in need of attention right now because I
- 35:48bet like growing up, nobody paid you any attention or you were
- 35:52the kid that was bullied. Or like I've just developed this
- 35:55whole new aspect of compassion for kind of seeing people's
- 35:59stories or seeing the story that might live behind the current
- 36:04super annoying way folks present.
- 36:09And that makes me care so much about trying to help be a part
- 36:17of the healing of humanity in these like deep soul level ways,
- 36:22which is what the gospel is so much about for me.
- 36:25Is that we right, Like we're all in this messy human predicament
- 36:29and we have these stories from our life about why things got
- 36:32messed up and why we ended up going through the world in a
- 36:36certain way. But it comes from this place of
- 36:39woundedness. I know people like to hate on
- 36:42the story of original sin. But I but I see.
- 36:46That too, of just like the way, like there's something beautiful
- 36:49about that story thing like, yeah, every single person has
- 36:52this woundedness within them that they're just trying to
- 36:55figure out. And for us to have a a system of
- 37:00faith that is deeply connected to these incredible depths of
- 37:06the human experience. Is there something I really want
- 37:11other people to know about? Because I think it matters and I
- 37:15think it's important and I think it really could help.
- 37:18And I know, I mean, I know it from my own life.
- 37:21Yeah. I've, I've been able to because
- 37:23of my faith, like help put different pieces in their
- 37:27correct spot, more or less. And I know, and I don't want to
- 37:31put you on the spot, but I'm like, this is part of what why
- 37:33we connect so much is because I know you have similar
- 37:35experiences and a similar level of passion for the gospel and
- 37:40what it does to an individual. Amen.
- 37:45You know, I again, to bring this back to the classroom, this is
- 37:48something that we've talked a lot, a lot about among with this
- 37:51undergraduate students that especially in the social media
- 37:55age, it is so easy to hate because what we experience
- 37:59online are often flattened caricatures.
- 38:02They're avatars of ourselves there.
- 38:06There I mean, and it's a series of zeros and ones like let's say
- 38:09what it is, that's what digital anything is.
- 38:12Is it 0101 switch on switch off? Yeah, the whole the whole design
- 38:15is to keep us on these devices as long as we possibly can.
- 38:18And what's a great way to do it? By stocking that anger emotion,
- 38:22right. And if you're angry, then you're
- 38:23going to stay online, stay engaged.
- 38:25And so hatred and anger are great ways for social media
- 38:29companies to to monetize your presence on mine online.
- 38:33And I'll talk to the students about the the radical message of
- 38:36Jesus and Howard Thurman, who was a sort of the spiritual
- 38:42guide behind the civil rights movement, wrote a really
- 38:44important book called Jesus and the disinherited 1949 and the
- 38:48pre civil rights era Jim Crow S amid segregation and talked
- 38:53about hatred being so natural and easy for us.
- 38:58Helpful to an extent because hatred allows us to distinguish
- 39:02ourselves from others online to say, I hate this thing and I'm
- 39:05not that it's it helps us to identify, to do identity
- 39:09formation. But he says it can become a
- 39:12problem And it can just seep into every aspect of our being.
- 39:16And that's so often those hatreds are rooted in the very
- 39:20hurts that you're talking about. And herein lies the hope of the
- 39:24gospel as the teaching of Jesus to learn to love your enemies,
- 39:29that none of us, Thurman says. And getting this from Jesus
- 39:33himself is reducible to the worst thing that we've said or
- 39:37done. And to see every person as a
- 39:41child of God created in God's image and likeness.
- 39:44And we'll talk with students, they say they hate this.
- 39:48They hate this teaching. This is a really hard teaching.
- 39:51And I will admit I am a lifelong practitioner who is still in
- 39:58process of like hatred is still very easy for me, but.
- 40:03But how can we learn to? To see people as more than the
- 40:08worst parts of themselves that they present online or in the
- 40:12real world? To see those hurts and pains
- 40:14that we all carry, those original sins or wounds that all
- 40:18of us have. And to see the gospel as a
- 40:22meeting place where we can be a part of the ministry of
- 40:26reconciliation that we've been given.
- 40:31What I love about you bringing up what got me so excited too.
- 40:36The other piece to the love your enemy aspect is that it forces
- 40:41you to also have to confront the enemy within because right like
- 40:48so often times the person that annoys you the most is the one
- 40:53who's doing the things that you know you do but never want to
- 40:56admit to, right? Like and but that's why it
- 40:59annoys you. Talk to my wife before those.
- 41:03But but that's why it annoys you so much is because, but, but you
- 41:06never like, it's very hard to put that piece together.
- 41:09It's like, Oh my gosh, I can't stand that person until you like
- 41:12zoom out and you're like, Oh my gosh, like they are maybe just
- 41:15like this terrible part of myself turned up to 11.
- 41:18And that's why it unsettles us so much is because like this is
- 41:22the the subconscious part of ourselves, the we're just trying
- 41:24to push away and ignore and wish away that it wasn't there.
- 41:29But if you have to love your enemy, it, it creates this
- 41:32incredible space too, where you now have to, to, to face down
- 41:37the demon inside that you've been trying to ignore and say
- 41:39isn't there because you're going to love the person who presents
- 41:43that so strongly and inherently. You're learning to love yourself
- 41:47more deeply as well at the same time, which is I love that you
- 41:52brought that up. I didn't know the whole Howard
- 41:54Thurman aspect of it, but it is part of, I think, the brilliance
- 41:58of the gospel message because lots of people say like, yeah,
- 42:01love, love your neighbor, you know, love others, treat others
- 42:05the way you want to be treated. But love your enemy is so
- 42:08distinctly radical. And we just kind of brushed off
- 42:12because we know Jesus said it. And it's like, you know, it's a
- 42:15nice little sound bite. But if you like, sit with that
- 42:18and meditate on it and really think about the implications.
- 42:21It is still to this day so unsettling and groundbreaking
- 42:25and crazy. This, this is the genius of
- 42:28Jesus. And not only is it an idea, but
- 42:30it was a practice for him that if we look at his 12 disciples,
- 42:34among the 12 disciples are Simon the Zealot and Matthew the tax
- 42:39collector. Matthew, the tax collector who
- 42:42shut down his own Jewish people to to collect money and then
- 42:46lined his own pockets to give taxes to the occupying force,
- 42:51the Roman Empire. And Simon the Zealot.
- 42:54You could also translate that Simon the Patriot who wanted to
- 42:58by any means necessary overthrow the Roman Empire, including
- 43:03violence. They tried.
- 43:05And Jesus selects both of these diametrically opposed
- 43:10individuals and asks them to be a part of this new human family,
- 43:13this new Kingdom that he is building that is in breaking
- 43:17with his presence. So to bring it back to to
- 43:20online, you know, part of it may not be posting the meme that's
- 43:25going to bring somebody to faith.
- 43:27Well, I have some good ones so. I know you do.
- 43:30It is thinking about how we inhabit ourselves in those
- 43:37places, how we engage with folks online when their views may be
- 43:42diametrically opposed to us. Whether that is because they irk
- 43:46us and that they are whatever part of us that are turned up to
- 43:5011, or if they are truly the embodiment of something that we
- 43:54just cannot wrap our minds around.
- 43:59How do we love our enemies in online conversation?
- 44:02Is a an aspect of discipleship for our digital age?
- 44:06Yeah, and and it's it's a great place to kind of tie this all
- 44:11off too, because it it shows that piece that you're talking
- 44:15about. Like, can we learn how to show
- 44:18up as people of faith in these online spaces, not just seeing
- 44:25the other as the one who needs to be destroyed and and also not
- 44:30just looking for the content that will make me feel
- 44:34self-righteous and smug and right.
- 44:38But how can we show up in this as someone who will love their
- 44:42enemy in those spaces, as hard and difficult as that is cool.
- 44:49Anything to add before we sign off?
- 44:52One more note on that front. I was listening to a pastor the
- 44:55other day, just to make this really practical.
- 44:57I was talking about some his own involvement in some of the
- 45:01demonstrations in Minneapolis around the ice activity there,
- 45:07and there's a quote that really stuck out to me that the goal
- 45:11was not to March against, but to March towards.
- 45:15That to me is the gospel in the nutshell, whether we're doing
- 45:19that in our offline everyday lives or in online spaces.
- 45:23That the goal here is not to March against somebody, but to
- 45:27March towards them with that ready, a defense of the hope
- 45:31that is within us with the good news of the gospel of Jesus.
- 45:35And if that's all we accomplish in this narthex project, maybe
- 45:39we will have done some good in the end.
- 45:42Thanks for that. That's a perfect way to end it,
- 45:45Joe. Thanks for taking the time.
- 45:47Love talking with you. You should move back to Denver.
- 45:50Have I said this? We could do this all the time.
- 45:56I miss you a lot. I love you and your family.
- 45:58Thanks for being a part of this. And you, dear listener, and
- 46:02thanks for listening. Share this with family and
- 46:04friends who might need to hear it.
- 46:05As always, stay in peace. Thank you for listening to the
- 46:08Together for Good podcast. If you'd like more resources for
- 46:11your walk of faith, please visit our website bethany-denver.org
- 46:16or download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect in
- 46:20your phone's App Store.